A Bit Fruity with Matt Bernstein - August 01, 2024


The Kamalafication of BRAT

Topics
Hawk Tuah: From Harmless Meme to Right Wing Symbol Transvestigating (with Contrapoints)

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 10 minutes

Words per minute

193.6

Word count

13,587

Sentence count

222

Harmful content

Misogyny

27

sentences flagged

Toxicity

53

sentences flagged

Hate speech

25

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 So my intro question for you is, do you think that Kamala Harris would allow herself to be filmed doing cocaine with Charlie XCX to secure the youth vote?
00:00:12.200 I don't know if you remember when she was asked about her, all the convictions for like marijuana offenses.
00:00:18.500 And they were like, have you smoked weed?
00:00:20.020 And she was like, well, yes.
00:00:22.140 Well, yes.
00:00:22.680 She was like, well, yes.
00:00:24.320 Well, yes.
00:00:24.780 So I think in answer to that, yes.
00:00:30.000 hello hello and welcome back to a bit fruity i'm matt bernstein and i'm so happy that you're here
00:00:38.320 on july 27th 2024 brat summer as we knew it was declared over when buddy carter a republican
00:00:46.480 member of the united states house of representatives whose personal policy positions include wanting to
00:00:51.760 outlaw gay marriage outlaw abortion with no exceptions for rape or incest ban trans people 0.64
00:00:56.700 from the military and eliminate affordable healthcare, tweeted, am I doing the hashtag 0.79
00:01:02.600 brat thing right? With a photo of a chartreuse square and with a blurry text in the middle that
00:01:10.560 said, middlemen are driving up the cost of prescription drugs. Buddy Carter, no, you are
00:01:16.800 not doing the brat thing right. In fact, you couldn't. How the fuck did we get here? Who the
00:01:22.060 fuck is buddy carter and what is brat summer what is this garish shade of chartreuse that defines 0.98
00:01:29.200 pop culture right now and why is kamala harris using it to appeal to young voters how did the 0.99
00:01:35.440 image of an experimental pop artist beloved by gay people everywhere from bushwick to williamsburg
00:01:41.240 become that was funny i thought that was fun i loved thank you thank you how did the image of
00:01:46.020 an experimental pop artist beloved by gay people everywhere from bushwick to williamsburg become
00:01:52.020 key to the U.S. presidential race? Today, we will try to answer all of those questions without 1.00
00:01:57.920 drinking bleach, at least until we stop recording. Before we begin today's episode, if you would like
00:02:03.840 to support the show or you would like some extra episodes of it, we are over on Patreon. The link
00:02:10.020 for that will be in the bio. This summer, I have been working on a multi-part series, revisiting
00:02:16.840 the bi-sister 2019 beauty guru homophobia heterosexual trickery vitamin gummy scandal. 0.85
00:02:24.900 None of those words were in the Bible. 0.52
00:02:26.620 And we also just put out a brand new bonus episode taking a look at what went wrong with
00:02:32.920 what Rolling Stone is calling the worst comeback single of all time, Katy Perry's
00:02:37.620 Woman's World.
00:02:38.960 The link for the Patreon is in the bio.
00:02:41.080 If you'd like to support, we'll be over there.
00:02:43.420 and if you would like to sink your teeth into what the hell is going on with brat summer then uh
00:02:48.500 hang out strap in we have some things to unpack there is no one who i would rather help me unpack
00:02:54.440 this topic with then welcome back to the show friend of the podcast maya so excited to be back
00:03:01.140 maya is in my apartment today so we're doing this together we have two camera angles to make it look
00:03:06.600 a little more chic but we are in fact sitting right next to each other right next to each other
00:03:10.400 I could get into your camera right now.
00:03:13.140 We both have green nails, too.
00:03:15.100 We're both feeling very Brat Summer. 0.77
00:03:17.700 Very Brat Summer. 0.80
00:03:18.180 We're celebrating the final breaths of Brat Summer.
00:03:21.540 The final gasp.
00:03:22.780 The death rattle.
00:03:23.920 The death rattle of Brat Summer.
00:03:26.200 So I'm Maia.
00:03:27.220 I have a YouTube channel called Broye Deschanel, where I do film analysis, video essays.
00:03:33.200 And then I also have a podcast called Rehash, which I co-host with my best friend, Hannah.
00:03:38.000 And it's all about internet phenomena.
00:03:40.400 And if you like this podcast, you would love Maia's podcast, Rehash. 0.89
00:03:45.400 She does such a great job of unpacking these like pop political topics online.
00:03:51.620 And I am so happy that we're going to sit and talk about this very jarring thing that has happened to one of my favorite albums of the year.
00:04:01.480 What do they do to my son?
00:04:03.500 If you have listened to the beginning of this podcast episode and you are like, I have no idea what you are talking about. 0.98
00:04:09.760 We're going to be talking about a lot of things in this podcast and a lot of wild shit that
00:04:13.500 has gone down at the intersection of pop culture and American politics, but I want to establish 0.65
00:04:20.160 the basics.
00:04:21.000 I want to meet everyone where they're at.
00:04:22.320 And so, Maya, can you explain, first of all, what is Brat?
00:04:25.840 What is Brat the album or what is Brat the lifestyle?
00:04:28.800 I guess both.
00:04:30.040 We have to discuss both.
00:04:31.120 So Brat the album is Charlie XCX's most recent album.
00:04:34.400 Charlie XCX, for those who don't know, is a pop artist who's kind of came up through the underground scene, I would say.
00:04:42.340 Yeah.
00:04:42.560 She's been around for quite a while.
00:04:43.800 I think I was in high school when she first came out in around the 2013, 2014 era.
00:04:49.040 She's always been kind of a cool girl.
00:04:51.420 And I would say over the years, she's had a very incremental growth in her audience.
00:04:55.940 She's had a lot of international success.
00:04:58.280 I think she did a song with Iggy Azalea back in the day that also kind of brought her a bit more.
00:05:02.760 I'm so fancy.
00:05:03.440 Yeah, I'm so fancy.
00:05:04.400 personally one of my least favorite songs of hers but totally but it uh that also kind of
00:05:09.560 brought her into mainstream attention most recently she came up with this album called
00:05:13.100 brat which had one of the most impressive guerrilla marketing campaigns i've ever
00:05:17.080 witnessed honestly yeah um i remember i learned about it because i went to a party at a bar next
00:05:22.480 to my house it was like some sort of event that these people i knew were throwing it was very
00:05:27.400 intimate and all over the bar were these stickers that said brat on them like chartreuse colored
00:05:33.300 stickers and rattle them uh and i was like what is this and they're like charlie xcx's team reached
00:05:38.260 out to us and we're like hey we hear you're throwing an event in toronto do you want these
00:05:41.940 stickers to give out i think it's notable to begin with charlie xcx is british yes and she's had a
00:05:47.840 wild splash in american politics over the last few weeks but she's not american and like you said
00:05:53.900 she's been around for basically a decade and what's interesting is that even though she's had
00:05:58.380 so many moments of mainstream success like she had a song in the Barbie soundtrack she has always
00:06:05.380 I think been most cherished by the like queer underground I think she continues to like she
00:06:12.080 loves the underground as much as the underground loves her when this stuff hit like you know CNN
00:06:16.460 and stuff they were talking about Charlie XCX like she had this death grip over Gen Z which
00:06:21.860 she kind of does but they were talking about her like as if she was a famous icon like Beyonce
00:06:27.400 or like lady gaga or taylor swift and like she doesn't she's never at any point had nearly the
00:06:33.780 same like popularity or cultural ubiquity as any of those people yeah i would say she's niche
00:06:39.200 she's definitely niche and she's always kind of maintained an edge i would say totally in a way
00:06:43.400 that i think is really alluring to a lot of young people especially among gen z so i think when brad
00:06:49.040 came out it kind of felt like the anthem for these like kind of cool underground people but then i
00:06:54.960 think it just like exploded from there it was like felt like kryptonite almost for some reason
00:06:58.960 describe brats album cover it's like a chartreuse square and it has in like very lo-fi kind of a
00:07:06.440 like pixelated font just says brat it's very simple it's very like windows xp yeah yeah yeah
00:07:12.220 yeah what's interesting is when this album cover first came out i remember online people were like
00:07:18.140 angry like angry in a very serious way about the fact that this was like a very lo-fi album cover
00:07:24.560 you know and i remember like charlie was going back and forth with her fans online and she was
00:07:28.920 like i don't know why you expect that artists faces must always be on their album cover or
00:07:32.920 whatever and there was like a weird back and forth happening but people were really upset about it
00:07:36.680 and it's interesting because the album cover clearly has become like i mean it became a meme
00:07:40.820 it became like one of the most iconic and central parts of the marketing of the album
00:07:44.740 people would really yeah repurpose it for other things and kind of put their own names on it
00:07:50.040 different corporations like publications were using it as a marketing tool as well yeah it kind
00:07:54.600 of became like the people's princess of marketing it's kind of the people's princess of albums
00:08:00.460 really or at least it was yeah i guess you can't really be the people's princess of albums once
00:08:06.100 you're like co-opted by like a major political party oh i want to say before we move on i actually
00:08:11.000 met charlie xcx once maybe this isn't a story it's just not an interesting story i met her and she
00:08:16.360 was really sweet is the point i've heard she's very nice i also know people who have met her
00:08:20.400 she's kind of just like around she's kind of an accessible person i think that's actually
00:08:25.260 really important again you think of these major pop stars and while some of them build like
00:08:30.860 extremely successful parasocial relationships with their audience like taylor swift none of
00:08:36.260 those people ever feel accessible like they're up here whereas like charlie xcx like part of her
00:08:40.640 album rollout was like she was doing these like club performances there was um brick wall here
00:08:46.240 in new york that they turned into like the brat wall that always had like messaging relating to
00:08:50.000 brat and remixes that were coming out like she like went to the brat wall and like met a ton
00:08:55.020 of her fans there and it was the ultimate campaign like it truly was incredible we have to talk about
00:09:00.120 brat summer but of course because brat is more than just an album it's a lifestyle i just love
00:09:05.480 that every summer we come up with a new term for us having our like messy era there's like a new
00:09:10.940 term every year it kind of means the same thing every time every summer is basically about like
00:09:15.280 being hot and having sex and like partying but we find new ways to dress we find new ways to do it
00:09:20.740 yeah so i think brats generally kind of oscillates between these songs about being it can even happen
00:09:26.860 within a single song but like you know being a party girl going out doing drugs being messy
00:09:31.680 having kind of indie sleeves vibes like having makeup and ripped tights kind of energy and then
00:09:37.300 also tank top with no bra tank top with no bra oscillating between that and then like kind of
00:09:42.600 really introspective poignant takes on being a woman in your mid to late 20s and early 30s
00:09:48.860 and kind of reckoning with like the biological clock and reckoning with just getting older in
00:09:54.820 general body image stuff that I think really resonated with people but it's couched within
00:09:59.340 these songs that are kind of like club hits almost right the amount of times I've heard 0.98
00:10:03.680 360 or Von Dutch played on a night out is is crazy I know and I lose my shit every time 0.75
00:10:08.540 i was like at the club a few weeks ago with my friend tyler and von dutch came on and we were 0.91
00:10:13.680 just like i was like i don't care like if i like sweat through my like filled in eyebrows like i 0.88
00:10:18.180 don't care i'm just gonna like fucking ball out to the sun yes i think that essence of like a brat 0.98
00:10:22.840 you're maybe cocky maybe a little mean you're like hot you like sweat through your makeup on a hot 0.99
00:10:29.700 summer day and you like the sidewalk on the street is your catwalk kind of thing but then also
00:10:34.260 you are like a vulnerable insecure person and you're using these kind of like edgy hot curl
00:10:42.780 aesthetics to cover up for that and you're aware of that it's a little bit epi stonem dare i say
00:10:48.000 is that skins yeah she's she was like a tumblr icon right yeah tumblr icon i guess indie it's 1.00
00:10:53.300 just such an indie sleaze thing epi stonem kind of coming home in her like makeup and her messed 0.52
00:10:57.300 up hair totally but then being this kind of like tragic figure i think there's also like really
00:11:02.180 uplifting notes like there's a song called girl so confusing which is about feeling in competition
00:11:08.380 with other women who might also like be your peers it's song she did uh in reference to lord
00:11:15.000 right so then lord and charlie made a remix together where they were like let's work it out 1.00
00:11:19.620 on the remix and then they basically like used their respective verses in the remix to describe
00:11:24.840 how like they didn't know that the other one was feeling that way and they were so caught up in
00:11:28.720 their own insecurities and their own paranoias about themselves and the world that they didn't
00:11:33.320 realize that they had like projected this image of like infallibility onto the women around them
00:11:38.120 and then at the end of the song they're like we ride for each other and it's like there's a lot
00:11:42.040 of like a lot of introspection and a lot of universality but in very like yeah very specific
00:11:47.780 ways like that feels like such a feels like kind of a universal experience with womanhood and just
00:11:52.160 like the competition amongst women and and like this kind of guard we all have up when we first
00:11:57.000 meet each other like it's yeah it's very interesting it's definitely a break the internet
00:12:00.740 moment right and so brat summer is about just like embodying all of these themes on the album
00:12:06.040 it's about being vulnerable it's about being hot it's about doing cocaine also which i'm not you
00:12:11.540 know don't do drugs youtube we're demonetized don't do drugs right don't do drugs but also
00:12:19.120 that is what brats that's what it's about that's what i saw this tweet from someone i think i sent
00:12:24.120 to you and it was like does kamala harris know that like brat summer is about doing coke and
00:12:28.720 wanting to kill yourself yeah i saw that now before we talk about how brat summer enters the
00:12:34.020 world of kamala harris and problematize it a bit i want to talk about how kamala harris i think 0.77
00:12:39.740 she's become the meme candidate i think in many ways memes are like the language of young people
00:12:45.900 and i think politicians make a conscious effort oftentimes to meme themselves in ways that will
00:12:53.000 endear themselves to young people but it doesn't work usually and with kamala harris it has worked
00:12:58.800 so well and we're going to talk about why that is but i want to make reference to some of the memes
00:13:04.000 that have even before she announced that she is essentially the democratic nominee for president
00:13:09.240 right now she she became really endeared to like this the very online very young portion of voters
00:13:15.600 by like being herself in these kooky ways so do you know the wheels on the bus no don't remember 0.99
00:13:20.860 it she literally kamala harris is just always i mean as a high profile politician she's always 1.00
00:13:25.520 being filmed and she just like i mean she's been memed into like kind of the coked out aunt in a 1.00
00:13:30.960 way people make people make a lot of jokes about like she is on the craziest pharmaceutical cocktail
00:13:35.820 known to man yeah she's on some zans for sure and yeah the wheels on the bus one was a viral video
00:13:41.820 where she's just she sees a bus on the curb like in front of the curb in front of her and she goes
00:13:46.640 the wheels on the bus go round and round and it's not in tune with how the wheels on the bus song
00:13:56.420 the wheels on the song is the wheels on the bus go round and round and she sings the wheels on
00:14:02.520 the bus go round and round and it's one of the most rudimentary songs of humanity like if there's
00:14:07.880 some like row row row your boat like it's a song that's just ingrained within us from age three so
00:14:12.440 it's crazy well and it's also just like there were there weren't children around like the thing that
00:14:18.040 inspired her to do that was seeing the bus in front of her like she really is a kooky individual
00:14:23.560 she's got jouissance for sure like she's she's got a she's got a joie de vivre a what a joie de 0.98
00:14:29.880 vivre me doing the french accent a lust for life oh yeah she's got energy she she totally has a 0.99
00:14:36.760 lust for life yeah yeah totally has a lust love her or hate her she the woman has a lust for life
00:14:41.060 do you know the venn diagram meme yeah essentially kamala harris and another in some other public
00:14:47.320 appearance said that she loves venn diagrams and she went into great detail explaining why
00:14:53.220 specifically she loves the venn diagram what it does for her well so the funny thing is though
00:14:58.160 i watched that i was preparing for this episode and i watched that video and she doesn't actually
00:15:02.580 say why she loves venn diagrams she just describes what a venn diagram is she's like i love venn
00:15:10.180 diagrams you know you get those two circles and the part in the middle right i love venn diagrams
00:15:15.340 i really do i love venn diagrams it's just something about those three circles and
00:15:23.100 the analysis about where there is the intersection right yeah i see people that you agree with me
00:15:28.900 right so okay so i asked my team i brought props that yes that's what a venn diagram is she loves
00:15:35.480 she'd be like I love lawns you know you have the the grass and and you know you water it and
00:15:42.700 lawns you know it's like she's just describing things yeah and it's the most like benign I mean
00:15:50.240 it's it's a diagram it's a type of diagram yeah she's giving like glass of scotch barbiturate
00:15:55.620 2 p.m 2 p.m kind of energy and I I kind of like yeah it's so hard not to find it so funny and I
00:16:03.540 think the lens of that for so long during biden's presidency especially in the months leading up to
00:16:09.040 this past couple months was that like oh here's joe biden he's got dementia he never knows what
00:16:14.620 he's saying but then and then kamala was kind of paired with that as like and then he has his crazy
00:16:19.720 vp who does a lot of drugs you know so they were kind of this pair to be kind of like mocked we're
00:16:25.640 going to again problematize all of this like this is not an episode about worshiping kamala as a
00:16:33.060 camp icon we're gonna discuss her i think in a hopefully nuanced way as a politician but
00:16:39.600 it is worth noting like she would be america's i think first kooky president it goes a long way
00:16:46.360 to have personality i think that is the most fundamental aspect of american politics
00:16:51.700 unfortunately is personality yeah which is the problem yes which is the crux of this episode
00:16:56.700 but we're getting ahead of ourselves i'm not done talking about kamala memes do you know
00:17:00.360 unburdened by what has been wait you just described this to me three seconds ago unburdened okay okay
00:17:05.040 okay you you tell you what yeah so this is really interesting a lot of the memes that have really
00:17:09.840 been successful for her have surfaced from one twitter account which is a republican run twitter
00:17:16.480 account it's it's like an official rnc account and it's called rnc research and what this account
00:17:23.760 does over and over again is publish these videos of her doing things that the people running that
00:17:31.400 account Republicans think are like cringy or weird and what they don't realize is that it's really
00:17:38.080 like camp and funny and so multiple times they have done this where they're like can you believe
00:17:43.780 Kamala said this and then everyone like kind of the liberal and the left internet will both be
00:17:49.960 like this is fucking hilarious and so it to the extent that i am like okay i think the rnc research
00:17:56.140 research twitter account is a psyop that's my conspiracy theory i think it's like a liberal 0.91
00:18:01.100 psyop but anyway they posted this four minute compilation of her from like a hundred different
00:18:07.120 speeches that she's done she she uses this line what can be unburdened by what has been i can
00:18:13.460 imagine what can be and be unburdened by what has been you know what can be unburdened by what has
00:18:20.940 been there are those who are unable to see what can be um but there are many more who are able to
00:18:28.860 see what can be unburdened by what has been and it's it's just like i mean they're trying to be
00:18:34.460 like it makes no sense she obviously thinks this is an extraordinarily hard-hitting line that she's
00:18:39.120 said it in a hundred different speeches and it's just kind of not but that is what's so funny and
00:18:43.740 she does her politician hands when she does it where she does her like roundabout hand and she's
00:18:48.260 like don't you see and it's just it's like drunk auntie giving sage advice kind of vibe and you're 0.90
00:18:52.960 like yes yes the wisdom totally drunk auntie giving sage wisdom yeah yes and then perhaps
00:18:58.240 the most famous meme is the coconut tree meme take it away i believe it was a press conference
00:19:04.260 where she's telling a story that her mom used to tell her she kind of does this crazy laugh where
00:19:11.280 she's like then she's like you think you just fell out of a coconut tree and then she and then
00:19:17.580 she all of a sudden gets extremely serious and she's like we exist in the context what is it
00:19:23.560 you exist in the context of all in which you live and what came before you and she's like doing her
00:19:30.240 politician hands my mother used to she would give us a hard time sometimes and she would say to us
00:19:35.140 i don't know what's wrong with you young people you think you just fell out of a coconut tree
00:19:40.080 you exist in the context of all in which you live and what came before you and she it's just the
00:19:50.480 switch up from the crazy laugh to the immediate seriousness and like somber tone that's so funny
00:19:56.820 and it's just like when you take any clip out of context if you're walking let's say you hear
00:20:01.160 someone walking by you on the street anything they say will be so funny but so something about
00:20:07.020 the out of contextness of it also just amplified the like ridiculousness of the statement i think
00:20:11.800 if you listen to the speech in full it makes sense within the context of what she's saying
00:20:15.340 but the way she delivers it and like the the concept of the coconut tree and it just it's
00:20:20.700 just so kooky and strange i was at the gym the other day and i you know there were there like
00:20:26.500 the stationary bikes and i get on one and the two guys on the stationary bikes next to me i just hear
00:20:30.640 one go to the other one you think you just fell out of a coconut tree kamala harris fans are
00:20:34.620 describing themselves as coconut pilled and i do think this is just such a seismic shift because
00:20:39.060 like democrats have struggled for so long to appeal i mean since obama really like joe biden
00:20:45.240 has struggled so much to appeal to young people because there's nothing about him that was ever
00:20:49.260 naturally appealing to young people he's out of touch with the issues that we care about but also
00:20:53.740 just like on a personality level it's like what no amount of like gen z democratic strategists
00:20:59.520 huddling around biden which they did every day for years could ever make him like cool yeah to
00:21:05.220 young people and so the fact that kamala could do this like organically it makes sense that the
00:21:10.760 people around kamala would try to capture this and seize on it there's been a lot of discourse
00:21:15.220 like leftists like just on the left about the idea that like the democrats kind of need their
00:21:20.200 own Trump not ideologically but just in the sense that like Trump was someone who was able to
00:21:25.740 galvanize a group of disenfranchised people right and he used populism to do it he used these like
00:21:31.460 horrible world views yeah to do so and he I think what's so important about to remind ourselves of
00:21:38.440 is that we live in a society of spectacle and like the most important things in that society
00:21:42.760 are images and their icons and like narratives and stories and I feel like Trump what was so
00:21:48.440 effective about his campaign and what people really underestimated was the power of the image
00:21:53.240 like he had the really simple hat he had these really simple slogans and i'm not saying oh
00:21:58.060 everyone should go be a populist that's not at all what i'm saying but i think what the democrats
00:22:02.380 have kind of failed to capture is this this like the simplicity of those things and the power of
00:22:07.900 those things and i think biden especially was someone who just really came to symbolize how
00:22:13.060 forgettable the democrats became and especially the these like establishment democrats
00:22:18.220 uh like i can't even remember his slogan all i can think of is we did it joe which was kamala's
00:22:24.060 slogan like that was literally the i also can't remember his slogan but you're right yeah that's
00:22:28.960 like the most like memorable kind of like slogany thing that came out of that campaign and it was
00:22:32.680 kamala again being herself at the end of a run lean in it joe it was again it was like the drunk
00:22:38.560 aunt at like exactly yeah and i think you know even thinking about trump getting shot recently
00:22:42.960 the second that image of him was taken by that associated i think it was an associated press
00:22:48.100 photographer everyone was like oh it's done it's done because that image of him with the ear is
00:22:53.720 like way too powerful the fist it's an innate thing for him trump trump understands the power
00:23:00.620 of an image of course and i think the reason he does is because i get we can talk about this more
00:23:04.860 of it like american politics has always been political theater like american democracy is
00:23:09.200 political theater it's all about personality it's all about the image it's all about the narrative
00:23:13.160 And so politicians are celebrities by way of that, like by virtue of that being a thing in this like mediatized society.
00:23:19.640 But Trump especially was already a celebrity.
00:23:22.080 Like he knows how to appeal to people in these in these ways.
00:23:25.780 And like that's kind of what he had, not to give him too much credit.
00:23:28.940 But even in the months leading up to this election, people were kind of like, Trump's kind of funny, which is not something I ever want to indulge.
00:23:35.540 But it's like that that was a thing that even people on the left started kind of admitting.
00:23:38.960 And it's like the Democrats just like they just didn't have that.
00:23:42.520 ever since obama played basketball i feel like after that no one was ever to recreate was ever
00:23:47.320 able to recreate that not only did democrats fail to have any sort of like there was never any cult
00:23:52.960 of personality and like to be clear i think cult of personality is bad and it's bad and i think
00:23:57.360 that i think the fact that american politics is like you said theater is bad and we're going to
00:24:03.540 get into all of that but that is what it is here and it is what you have to champion if you want
00:24:09.200 to win and Democrats could never do it and I think Democrats just became viewed as like the like 0.93
00:24:14.480 boring party that's always just like slapping you on your wrist and being like we suck but you have
00:24:18.800 to vote for us because we're not the other guy yeah the lesser of two evils yes and it's like 0.94
00:24:23.180 you just can't campaign like you can't run a successful campaign as the lesser of two evils
00:24:28.300 forever you have to give people something to vote for and not just someone to vote against
00:24:31.860 I'm just remembering when like even Hillary went on Broad City and instead of that being good for
00:24:37.340 her campaign it was just bad for broad city something about them like the most recent like
00:24:41.720 democratic candidates just felt so disingenuous and so like hollow yeah in a way that like yeah
00:24:46.380 trump kind of speaking his mind and being for the people and being this like populist person
00:24:50.480 worked and i think that's something that the democrats can no longer take for granted
00:24:53.960 totally you know who should be president put this on record monica lewinski
00:24:57.880 i would like to take a quick quick break from the show to give a shout out to the sponsor of
00:25:06.080 today's episode, Rocket Money. Something that I spend a lot of time thinking and getting frustrated
00:25:11.680 about lately is how with the amount of streaming services we now have to pay for for TV shows every
00:25:17.600 month, we've basically just looped back around to paying for cable packages. Why are we doing that?
00:25:23.960 What's going on? That is a problem that is much bigger than me, but a consequence of that problem
00:25:28.720 is that all of us are paying for a lot more in subscription services every month than we realize.
00:25:34.140 Most Americans think they're paying around $62 per month in subscription services, when the real number, on average, is closer to $300.
00:25:43.200 Rocket Money is a personal finance app that helps find and cancel unwanted subscriptions, monitors your spending, and helps lower your bills so you can grow your savings.
00:25:52.560 After signing up, Rocket Money will highlight everything that you're spending money on every month, some of which you may have forgotten about, and help you cancel the things you don't want anymore with just a few clicks.
00:26:01.820 Rocket Money has helped its over 5 million users save an average of $740 a year when they use all of the app's features.
00:26:09.760 Stop spending money on things you don't use and get your finances correct with Rocket Money.
00:26:14.800 If you'd like to try it out, feel free to go to rocketmoney.com slash fruity.
00:26:19.880 That's rocketmoney.com slash fruity.
00:26:23.240 Now let's get back to the show. 1.00
00:26:25.080 so where does the world of brat summer charlie xcx cocaine hot vulnerable girls enter the campaign
00:26:35.780 of kamala harris well i've constructed a little timeline and we are going to walk through it
00:26:41.500 bit by bit and uh provide commentary as we see fit oh poet didn't know it on july 3rd 2024
00:26:49.860 Ryan Long a senior at the University of Delaware with no you know substantial social media following
00:26:57.840 or life in politics post a video on Twitter captioned why did I stay up till 3 a.m. making
00:27:04.340 a Von Dutch brat coconut tree edit featuring Kamala Harris and why can't I stop watching it
00:27:10.140 on repeat and this video which I will play a tiny snippet of because I don't want to get copyright
00:27:15.420 claimed is videos of Kamala Harris when she's talking about falling out of the coconut tree
00:27:21.160 and other clips of her like dancing and being kooky edited into the Addison Rae remix of
00:27:28.300 Von Dutch it's like it's like the word vomit coming out it literally every episode I reach
00:27:36.200 a place where it's like none of these words are in the bible but truly none of these words are
00:27:40.020 explain this to to like to a victorian child and dead they're dead dead at the dead before
00:27:46.440 the sentence comes to a close dead on sight you think you just fell out of a coconut tree
00:27:52.880 you exist in the context of all in which you live and what came before this goes totally viral it
00:28:04.780 like catches fire on twitter i think first of all i think memes are an art form and i think
00:28:09.120 especially i guess all memes are homemade but especially when like like edits like this and
00:28:12.960 i just view this as like a dada art piece yeah a little avant-garde it feels like like nonsensical
00:28:20.280 digital art that is like a product of total political disillusionment by young people
00:28:25.620 we're returning to random core i think like what we're thinking about the dadaists and like that
00:28:30.940 entire art movement i think it was born of people feeling fatigued and feeling disenfranchised and
00:28:36.180 feeling nihilistic the absurdity kind of comes out of that yeah and I think what we see with
00:28:41.240 memes in this like irony poison culture is just that like people are feeling nihilistic and
00:28:45.660 they're feeling disenfranchised they're feeling tired and like even seeing these memes about
00:28:49.520 Kamala like I was at a place for a lot for like the past few years where I was like I don't care
00:28:54.080 I don't want to hear about politics I don't want to think about it I was a poli sci major like
00:28:58.780 this is not this shouldn't be happening with me I feel like I had always been really invested but
00:29:02.940 I just yeah it's like after all of these years it's just like we're just tired and so I think
00:29:06.900 being able to find a bit of joy and a bit of humor out of these like absurdist videos and memes and
00:29:13.400 this like ridiculous sense of humor like I can't stop laughing at Kamala I think she's so funny
00:29:17.880 like I and like I am critical of her but it's it's hard not to find joy in those memes you spend so
00:29:24.080 many years in this place of like total political disillusionment I think especially for young
00:29:28.100 people like we've never been excited I mean we had Bernie Sanders but that didn't work in the
00:29:33.920 sense that he didn't win and so it's like what you said I just feel like videos like this that
00:29:38.320 keep going viral are a product like that's like my artistic analysis of what's going on here like I 0.97
00:29:44.420 think it's a product of like disillusionment and just like throwing our hands up and throwing shit 0.66
00:29:48.420 at the wall yeah there's something that felt even less absurd about the memes about Bernie back in
00:29:52.500 the day where you know like the meme that's like I am once again asking and oh yeah I am once again
00:29:56.880 or the picture of bernie sitting on the chair in the middle of nowhere like they felt even less
00:30:00.800 absurd and more just like endeared towards bernie than these do which is like none of these are
00:30:04.760 necessarily endeared towards kamala although she is getting a lot of love on twitter but more i
00:30:10.760 don't know this kind of content feels a bit more just like whatever well right and it's i mean and
00:30:15.940 that's why i wanted to talk about what the album was about and what the themes of the album are
00:30:19.580 about like we joked like kamala has admitted to having smoked weed but like nothing about like
00:30:24.740 brat has any real material or like meaningful association with Kamala Harris there's no
00:30:32.220 connection there other than the one that's been forged through memes yeah like my girl was a
00:30:37.060 district attorney and then she was a attorney general and then she's like she she's not out
00:30:42.300 here partying in Bushwick with her mascara running down her face she's not yet she's
00:30:48.340 prosecuting we have 90 days left of this campaign I'm telling you it's not too late for her to do
00:30:52.740 coke and bushwick she might just she might just hey dnc i have ideas for you you're gonna get
00:31:01.100 demonetized so hard i was demonetized in the first six seconds when i asked if you thought 0.75
00:31:05.260 kamala would do coke you can only bleep out coke sorry to say it again coke this is why i have
00:31:10.740 patreon on the afternoon of july 21st uh three weeks after this meme is released into the wild
00:31:20.720 Biden, too much fanfare, withdraws from the presidential campaign.
00:31:25.260 He endorses Kamala as his predecessor within an hour,
00:31:28.980 and almost immediately it becomes clear that she will replace him as the Democratic nominee,
00:31:33.820 which is where we are now.
00:31:34.960 That evening, Charlie XCX totally shakes the table when she tweets,
00:31:40.960 something which has now been viewed on Twitter 53 million times, 1.00
00:31:45.500 Kamala is brat. 1.00
00:31:47.940 It's like Kamala is brat. 0.96
00:31:50.100 Kamala is brat is his capitalized yeah this was like immediately controversial I think it's been 0.68
00:31:56.440 quote tweeted like 30,000 times with everyone either being like oh my god like Charlie like 0.84
00:32:02.120 I can't believe you're endorsing Kamala and like saying she's brat and then other people were like
00:32:05.880 what are you doing like why are you bratifying Kamala Harris did you have any hot takes when
00:32:12.600 this happened like I just have very complicated feelings about everything right now like I'm not 1.00
00:32:17.340 really landed in one place I think just seeing Charlie XCX do it because she has this edge
00:32:22.080 her promoting this establishment democrat which I feel like has been really like not on vogue
00:32:28.760 over the past few years like it's been really uncool to be a lib it's been kind of uncool to
00:32:33.180 be like pro democrat for someone as cool as Charlie to do that felt kind of like like it's
00:32:39.820 more it was more just kind of like concern for her brand because I was like what's going on
00:32:43.540 It did feel off brand for her to to like lend her image and like lend the meme that's come out of this album to like a major American presidential candidate.
00:32:53.340 Again, she's British. So there's which adds another layer of just like, what are you, Ariana, what are you doing here?
00:32:58.460 What's up, girl? I mean, America has a very strong cultural power over the world.
00:33:01.640 So I like in Canada, we're completely invested. Why? Like, why do I know any of this? You know what I mean?
00:33:06.280 yeah my is my is canadian which is also part of why i'm happy that you're here because you can 0.90
00:33:12.440 add some perspective from someone who's like living outside of the slush over here oh yes
00:33:18.180 yes within a couple hours of charlie xcx tweeting that the biden hq twitter account which is the
00:33:25.640 twitter account that managed official communications coming out of the biden administration switched
00:33:30.660 over to kamala hq and they switched over the imagery on the twitter account and the banner
00:33:36.780 for the twitter account said kamala hq in the brat font on the brat chartreuse background this
00:33:43.780 is marketing that's coming from the kamala harris campaign and i remember seeing this and honestly 0.64
00:33:49.220 at first i was fucking gagged i was like whoa whoa whoa it's so crazy for people who are working 0.54
00:33:56.620 on a presidential campaign for the mainstream candidate to like acknowledge a meme like this 0.96
00:34:02.200 especially because so much of like the brat stuff is it literally is just about like feeling crazy
00:34:08.240 and doing drugs yeah and so for them to like approximate it i was like i was like a little
00:34:13.240 kamala brat pilled for a moment i think part of like why almost this kind of worked there's i have
00:34:18.540 many reasons to why this works but part of it i'm just i'm thinking now is that so much of brat
00:34:23.540 like a lot of it was charlie xcx's fans and like people loving the album a lot of it like we were
00:34:28.900 saying at the beginning of the episode was about marketing and i think the brat logo getting taken
00:34:34.380 and reappropriated so many times by its corporations by all these different people
00:34:38.700 kind of made it like it kind of extricated it from its context like abstracted it and so i think that
00:34:44.020 made it so like it lended itself so easily to something being kind of co-opted by a political
00:34:50.000 campaign because it had kind of had no meaning after a while soon after the kamala hq instagram
00:34:55.960 was set up and they one of the first things they published was the green brat square with text that
00:35:02.700 said welcome to kamala hq so this was the point of no return when kamala hq started using the
00:35:10.060 chartreuse brat imagery as their own marketing like there was no going back this is when it
00:35:15.060 picked up by the mainstream media and i want to watch a clip with you of them talking about this
00:35:22.420 on cnn and like a bunch of cnn news anchors like trying to understand what the hell is going on
00:35:27.620 here kamala harris appears to be leaning into this this is the singer charlie xcx uh tweeted
00:35:33.700 last night kamala is brats uh and this is in reference to her album it's called brat kamala
00:35:39.380 has branded her kamala hq twitter page with the same aesthetic of the album that's another gen z
00:35:44.020 So, first of all, just for my producer, Elizabeth Stewart,
00:35:48.020 who will spit out her coffee as I say this, 1.00
00:35:51.020 I am supposed to say, that's brat.
00:35:54.020 And for those who don't or not in the know the way I am,
00:35:58.020 that is a cool thing. It has a color, chartreuse.
00:36:03.020 But I have brought some notes
00:36:05.020 because I knew you would want a definition.
00:36:08.020 Okay, here we go. Charlie XCX, who I do know,
00:36:13.020 know, quote, Brett, you're just that girl who is a little messy and likes to party and maybe says 0.96
00:36:23.000 some dumb things sometimes, end quote. So it's the idea that we're all kind of 0.94
00:36:29.440 Brett and Vice President Harris is Brett. I don't know if you're Brett. I think you aspire to be
00:36:35.260 Brett. You don't have to become Brett. You have to try. You can work at it. I will aspire to be
00:36:41.640 they were talking about this on fox news and a fox news anchor said that brat is very dangerous
00:36:48.960 to republicans and they've essentially turned her into a meme which has inherently given her a fan 0.99
00:36:55.580 base for the first time in her career and it's quickly changing the public's perception of her
00:37:00.160 and this is very dangerous for republicans and it needs to be taken seriously that same day july 23rd
00:37:06.120 The deeply unpopular mayor of New York City, Mayor Eric Adams, who has the lowest approval rating of any New York City mayor in history, according to the New York Times, who has been accused of sexual assault, who is known for his tough on crime stance and for having been a cop for a really long time and his inhumane policies towards homeless people, including legally not allowing them to sleep on the subway. 0.94
00:37:32.220 Eric Adams tweets brat summer shaking hands emoji with the summer of responsibility on July 24th one day later as I open the episode with Buddy Carter the Republican House of Representative guy representing Georgia's first district tweets his own brat meme and asks am I doing brat right and so I saw this and I was like who the fuck is Buddy Carter and so I googled his policy positions and he's basically anti human rights for everybody except straight cis white men. 0.90
00:38:02.220 and pro-gun and like got an A from the NRA. 0.97
00:38:06.040 He's like a total Trump stan.
00:38:07.600 Like he voted against certifying the 2020 election
00:38:09.900 after January 6th.
00:38:12.080 And so it was just like, okay,
00:38:14.600 we've absolutely lost the plot here.
00:38:16.980 Like how did this beloved by, you know,
00:38:21.600 queer and women who kind of like appreciate
00:38:24.240 the underground music scene,
00:38:25.960 how does this iconic album,
00:38:28.160 which is an incredible critically acclaimed album,
00:38:30.700 How does it get in the hands of like a pro-gun, anti-affordable healthcare, anti-LGBT, anti-abortion, 66-year-old white dude, Georgia Republican politician?
00:38:41.840 Like, what is going on?
00:38:43.380 What has happened here?
00:38:44.900 Here's my theory about memes and about this kind of internet culture is I think that it has to travel from the bottom up and not the other way around.
00:38:55.260 and what I mean by that is I think that memes are like I really believe in the internet a lot 0.93
00:39:03.520 of people are like you know like the internet's dumb and social media makes you dumb and like 0.89
00:39:07.520 it's all like you know right rot your brain and like I think that memes are a community-based 0.97
00:39:13.080 art form I think that it's a democratic and like I think it's like an inherently democratic and
00:39:18.680 accessible art form and i think once they have been co-opted from the community of you know
00:39:27.160 everyday social media users by the wealthy and powerful that's when they lose their shine like
00:39:32.640 when we watched that first kamala brat video you and i and anyone listening to the podcast when we
00:39:38.960 watched it just now but also when we watched it on twitter for the first time at the beginning of
00:39:42.940 July it was so funny and so sporadic and it made no sense we were just like experiencing this like
00:39:51.100 absurdist both political and pop cultural drama like reach its peak through like you know random
00:39:57.520 Twitter videos and it was it was just funny and we could all laugh together to me the moment that 0.67
00:40:02.200 it was doomed was also kind of the height of its popularity which is when Kamala HQ decided to make
00:40:10.200 to use the brat banner on their social media and it wasn't even them using the banner it was that
00:40:14.700 they acknowledged it it worked because they weren't breaking the fourth wall do you know
00:40:20.040 what i mean it was like totally community based yeah and then once people at the top start
00:40:25.840 manufacturing it back down then it's manufactured then you're receiving this like watered down
00:40:31.400 version of it that was created by a focus group in in a boardroom in washington dc yeah i think
00:40:36.760 so much of it is PR. Like I'm saying, like politicians are celebrities in, within North
00:40:41.760 American democracy. That's just kind of, that's, that's how it is. And I think there was like a
00:40:46.660 viral tweet that went around being like Kamala, when, when the Brad stuff first started coming
00:40:50.180 out, they were like, and Kamala was endorsed. Someone was like, uh, Kamala shouldn't acknowledge
00:40:55.360 the memes because that's going to take the power away. Something I've learned about Kamala Harris 0.98
00:40:59.500 throughout just like knowing about her as a, as a politician, but also in like researching for 0.99
00:41:03.560 this episode is that she was someone who was actually really averse to like narrativizing
00:41:09.680 herself oh it's something that like i i was listening to some uh podcasts where people were
00:41:14.900 like why doesn't she address like the south asian side of herself why doesn't she talk about her
00:41:18.820 relationship to her father it's like she's actually been kind of against that i think just as like a
00:41:22.900 former da and as an attorney general like that's not really something that she was kind of in touch
00:41:27.220 with because that's not something you do to get into those positions and she was kind of uncomfortable
00:41:31.820 with that in 2020 and that's something that didn't really work for her and it's something
00:41:35.620 that you kind of need as a president is to be or as a candidate is to be able to narrativize yourself
00:41:39.420 and so it didn't work for her in 2020 um she didn't really know how to deal with her like 0.95
00:41:44.480 prosecutor label people are like extremely critical of that you know the idea of her being
00:41:48.420 a progressive prosecutor just doesn't make any sense like right all that stuff so now when we 0.97
00:41:52.720 get to now i think kamala harris on her own has like gotten in control of the narrative and she's
00:41:57.720 kind of she is kind of like embracing the prosecutor position because trump is a criminal
00:42:01.560 kind of vibes yeah and for liberals it like totally that works really well i'm the i'm the
00:42:06.420 cop and he's the felon yeah and like that doesn't work for the left it's not working for the left
00:42:10.240 but she's not she doesn't she needs to appeal to like the comparatively much larger group of like 0.93
00:42:15.760 center liberals which that narrative works really well exactly and so to have her personality kind
00:42:21.340 of come through to gen z in this really organic grassroots way was kind of the perfect way for
00:42:27.200 her to galvanize these, what is the Democrats disenfranchised group, which is Gen Z and which
00:42:32.040 is young people. The thing about the memes is she was never trying to have a moment. Like you think
00:42:37.360 about like the wheels on the bus go round and round or like the Venn diagrams. It's like those
00:42:42.020 were not moments where she was trying to be funny. She was just literally zoning out and being
00:42:46.560 herself. Molly Roberts wrote in the Washington Post, the so-called coconut pilling of the populace
00:42:53.520 was until recently organic no one well no one that we know of paid a tiktok user to produce a
00:43:00.040 remix of harris's goofiest moments to tracks from charlie xcx's blockbuster album brat now democratic
00:43:06.580 surrogates are proclaiming their own coconut pilledness and posting pictures of themselves
00:43:11.220 climbing palms the campaign itself on a twitter account rebranded from president biden to harris
00:43:16.980 has traded out dark brandon for kamala hq on a lime green brat background who can blame them
00:43:23.320 the content is that good but there's a risk in trying to force something whose appeal comes
00:43:27.980 precisely from the reality that is unforced you might lose the magic do you remember dark brandon
00:43:33.980 this is in my blackout era where i was like no i won't hear it you're also fully not american
00:43:39.320 like you don't have to understand these failed means unfortunately like it's shoved it's shoved
00:43:44.020 down our throats anyways as canadians we know about it anyways i think canadians know more
00:43:48.380 about american politics than they do about canadian politics wow because cultural hegemony
00:43:52.280 It's just America's strong culture.
00:43:55.400 I was watching the American women's gymnastics team effort this morning where they won gold.
00:44:00.200 And it's like, I'm like, Simone Biles is the only thing any other country should know from America. 0.99
00:44:03.980 All the other shit we should keep under wraps. 0.99
00:44:05.640 We love her. 1.00
00:44:08.220 So Dark Brandon was.
00:44:12.600 I like already hate it.
00:44:14.160 I already hate it.
00:44:15.060 basically there was a thing that trump supporters started doing a few years ago where they would
00:44:23.700 chant at their maga rallies and the trump rallies and whatever they would chant like 1.00
00:44:27.680 let's go brandon and it was for some reason coded to mean fuck joe biden it was so stupid it was so 1.00
00:44:33.300 stupid everyone who participated in this was dumb but sorry so this let's go brandon thing is 0.99
00:44:40.520 totally taking off in like maga circles and the democratic establishment and the people around 1.00
00:44:46.380 biden are like okay we need to make you look cool which as everyone in america knows is an extremely
00:44:52.920 difficult thing to do for a senile old white centrist man like literally geriatric and i
00:45:01.780 commend everyone who like was at task with making him seem cool because that you know i don't think
00:45:08.140 they ever successfully did it but that is not a job that i envy die his hair pink yeah we should
00:45:15.760 have we should have made if we had made joe a blue hair lib yeah make him a cat girl
00:45:20.940 i had to stop doing this yeah like what if what if we made oh my god a neon girl
00:45:26.460 we made we made we made joe biden young cat like yeah if only hadn't if only hadn't dropped out
00:45:33.540 joe biden come back here um so they were like gonna take a sound bite out of that and cancel
00:45:38.880 you so hard on twitter do it i don't care anymore i have nothing to live for so they were like let's
00:45:46.380 take this let's go brandon thing and turn it on its head and they attempted that and so basically
00:45:51.940 what they made is this meme which i'm gonna show you like what is it can you describe what you're
00:45:59.060 looking at wait what would you describe this art style as i guess it's kind of like pop art yeah
00:46:02.900 it's kind of like a pop art stencil version of joe biden and then he has evil uh red eyes it
00:46:10.620 looks like the thumbnail of a video i did about the barbie movie except it's joe biden right it
00:46:15.540 has like laser eyes laser eyes like hypnosis eyes right and so they called this the dark
00:46:23.040 brandon meme i don't know like this is joe biden but like as like a super villain like it was kind
00:46:29.700 of i don't know they were branding him as like some like kind of like sinister like cartoon
00:46:33.660 does this do anything for you maya so this is supposed to make him look good that yes the
00:46:38.840 democrats made this to like make him look cool do you think he looks cool like it would be cool if
00:46:47.320 like i didn't know it was joe biden but i also would not but it is i would have no idea what's
00:46:54.220 going on yeah so the dark brandon they basically were just like you know trying to rehabilitate
00:46:59.640 his image as this frail octogenarian and this is what they came up with and it resonated with
00:47:07.060 no one with no one and so but you know again it's just this like this is what happens when a meme
00:47:14.860 is created by a focus group again top down versus bottom up the culture youth culture internet
00:47:21.240 culture meme culture it has to be it has to start with the community it has to start with people
00:47:27.540 yeah it feels like the memes are such a emblem of like the free net you know what i mean totally
00:47:33.340 kind of like the wild west yeah the web and to to have like an actual corporate entity well it's
00:47:39.360 interesting because one of my friends actually described kamala and brat this whole kamala
00:47:44.660 ex-brat phenomenon as being like manufactured consent which i thought like i really spent a
00:47:49.620 lot of time thinking about this manufactured consent in the way that like oh this is being
00:47:53.700 manufactured to us to basically get us to be on board with kamala but then it's like but like
00:47:58.700 propaganda like propaganda but like the thing with manufactured consent is that it is top down
00:48:02.800 and coming from corporations whereas the kamala brad stuff was coming from the bottom uh this
00:48:07.960 is manufactured consent the other meme the other kind of manufactured dnc meme that i had here
00:48:14.780 was pokemon go to the polls do you know pokemon go to the polls of course can we uh can we can
00:48:21.100 we whip it out real quick yeah hillary was making a campaign speech in 2016 which was
00:48:26.900 famously the summer of pokemon go exploding in popularity and taking over the world for a brief
00:48:32.840 moment but you know what i will say one of my best friends one of my best friends is like
00:48:37.620 not only still playing pokemon go but he like travels to pokemon go meets and he's like ranked
00:48:42.700 nationally or something oh good for him and so i i do want to make the point that there is still a
00:48:47.340 large swath of people who are like competitively continuing to play pokemon go maybe hillary
00:48:52.600 clinton is in that group i don't know can you imagine okay here i'll pull it up i don't know
00:48:57.540 who created pokemon go but i'm trying to figure out how we get them to have pokemon go to the polls
00:49:08.480 it's so it never gets easier to watch it's the issue with it is that like the the grammar
00:49:23.840 it's just something about is not flowing well but that's the whole thing right is it's not
00:49:28.900 flowing like that was written for her and you can tell yeah yeah she's confused as hell
00:49:33.780 pokemon go to the polls i'm trying to get them to pokemon go to the polls stiff and wrong stiff
00:49:40.680 and wrong i want to talk a little bit about the intersection of fandom and politics i think that
00:49:47.560 fandom has for a long time to your point about like political theater it's it's had a place in
00:49:52.420 american politics but it's had a particular resurgence in a brand new way with donald trump
00:49:59.780 The thing with fandom is that people's relationship to the politicians who are public servants, right, that they're voting for, starts to resemble the way that, like, again, a gay person in Brooklyn might love Charlie XCX or a 12-year-old girl in the mid-2010s might have loved One Direction.
00:50:16.680 It's when voting, which is political strategy, becomes hero worship.
00:50:23.140 Do you know where the word stan came from?
00:50:26.440 Well, Eminem, of course.
00:50:27.720 Yeah, do you want to explain?
00:50:28.660 he has a song called stan yes and it's about a stalker i can't remember if he actually
00:50:34.460 completely fabricated him or if it was it was inspired by one of his own fans yeah but
00:50:38.900 essentially he he wrote this rap song about a crazed fan who essentially becomes so obsessive
00:50:44.140 with eminem that he murders his wife and children drives them off the bridge yeah i think is what
00:50:49.360 and kills himself and kills himself and it's like it the song is supposed to be kind of like
00:50:53.740 cautionary tale about fandom and obsession when we talk about people stanning politicians i think
00:51:01.640 january 6th was like standing like politician standom brought to its like natural conclusion
00:51:08.520 which is just like doing this like wildly self-destructive like like extremely illegal
00:51:13.660 you think about the people who have like gone to jail for january 6th someone was murdered on
00:51:16.880 january 6th like it's it's like political standom to its most disturbing and also logical conclusion
00:51:23.200 and it's like that was stand to Eminem like those were literally Donald Trump's stands yeah and I
00:51:30.020 think I think that it's incredibly if you use the right rhetoric you use the right us versus them
00:51:36.200 driven politics and ideology like you can very easily like it's I think Trump went to show how
00:51:42.060 easily you can suck people in with that and how easily people can be brainwashed by that kind of
00:51:47.540 rhetoric and I think like I'm I'm quite frankly terrified to know what would happen if he lost
00:51:52.960 given what happened with with january 6th i think it's extremely if he lost this election i'd be
00:51:58.260 extremely scared to see what would happen oh the election that's about to happen the election
00:52:01.320 that's about to happen because i'm scared imagine what they're going to think with this one yeah
00:52:04.900 well his grip over the people who love him has certainly not loosened totally and it's cultish
00:52:09.820 yeah and i think it's just like an extension of political theater in general and i think that's
00:52:13.780 like the danger of it i find like i find north american democracy extremely centered upon like
00:52:19.120 sensationalism and emotionality and like i find a lot of voters and like myself included but like
00:52:25.240 very unconcerned with the issues and policy proposals like we don't have people talking
00:52:30.400 on twitter about policy or like the nitty-gritty of you know like project 2025 or trump's agenda
00:52:36.380 or like kamala's like kamala's policies like we don't like no one's talking about what she's
00:52:40.180 going to propose and it's like it's all centered instead around personality and this like worship
00:52:45.380 and basically creating idols out of these people.
00:52:48.600 I think over the last couple of years,
00:52:50.060 this has been something that the right
00:52:51.780 has had a lot more success with,
00:52:53.740 of like building these like big personalities,
00:52:56.060 both in media, you know,
00:52:57.580 the Tucker Carlson's of the world.
00:52:59.160 Elon Musk is ultimately a right-wing personality.
00:53:02.340 Donald Trump, obviously.
00:53:04.220 I think like on the left, like again,
00:53:06.460 Bernie Sanders had that.
00:53:08.880 He had a really personality driven kind of,
00:53:11.840 it was also populist.
00:53:13.080 And what I found so refreshing and beautiful about Bernie, though, was that he had a really compelling way of actually getting people to think about specific issues.
00:53:21.940 And I think I think like more than ever and more than any other politician that he was he was up against.
00:53:26.940 And I think that was the appeal of him.
00:53:28.500 And that's what that's what drew me to him specifically, but then still managed to have this really distinctive look, distinctive voice, distinctive personality.
00:53:35.940 And he had these very kind of casual ways of delivering that information.
00:53:40.260 i think maybe because he was a lifelong he's talking about like he's dead i think maybe
00:53:44.560 because he's a lifelong politician like he he had that ability but um but yeah it was very
00:53:48.500 compelling and i think you don't usually get that kind of balance from democrats from democrats
00:53:53.220 especially yeah well and but and the thing is like republicans and conservatives you're saying
00:53:58.740 like oh people only you know it becomes all about their personalities and not their policies and
00:54:03.280 it's like i'm not saying that like democrats work entirely for the people all the time like at the
00:54:08.380 end of the day like these are all part of like an elite class of politicians who answer to people
00:54:13.360 that aren't always us they answer to the oligarchy quite frankly but also like republicans in
00:54:20.360 particular like they need this personality driven almost psychosis that they have over their i would
00:54:27.840 say like voter base but it literally becomes fan base but they need that personality stuff because
00:54:32.280 anyone who starts reading the actual policies that they're proposing it's like these aren't for
00:54:37.900 working people yeah of course like trump's whole thing is that he's proposing stuff that's actually
00:54:43.040 completely at odds with the well-being of his voter base you know like who tend to be lower
00:54:48.720 income like white people it's sad it's sad he needs people to buy into his personality because
00:54:55.300 like there's nothing to buy into with the policies i mean like we could talk about project 2025 and
00:55:00.220 like all that stuff but it's just like it's it's not good for anyone like whether you if you're
00:55:04.860 listening to this podcast you've never agreed with the single thing i said if you are just like
00:55:07.940 not in the 0.0001 like the policies that these people put forward are not for you and like we
00:55:14.960 don't have to get into the details of it but if you're listening to this podcast you don't know
00:55:18.780 what project 2025 is it was a transition plan proposed by a famous right-wing think tank
00:55:25.200 signed off by tons and tons of people who worked in the trump administration during his first term
00:55:30.540 And essentially, it's like an extremist proposal that will have outrageously devastating effects for every single person in this country, other than a very small few.
00:55:42.040 So I highly recommend looking into it. 0.99
00:55:44.200 I looked into it recently and it kind of lit a fire under my own ass. 0.99
00:55:47.160 Yeah. 1.00
00:55:47.640 Because it's scary.
00:55:49.180 It's crazy.
00:55:50.260 Yeah.
00:55:50.720 It's crazy.
00:55:52.080 But so back to standing politicians, right?
00:55:53.900 People in America tend to understand, especially like anyone left of center, knows that Trump's base stands him.
00:56:01.800 What's interesting, though, and what people talk about way less often, is the way that self-identifying liberal people can do that.
00:56:10.320 Do you know what blue MAGA is?
00:56:12.400 Not fully, no.
00:56:13.760 Okay, so blue MAGA, this is something that I talk about a lot.
00:56:17.060 blue maga they're basically people who are they tend to be like centrist liberal democrats who
00:56:23.620 have taken this like maga like obsession but like towards democrats who these were the people who
00:56:31.080 were like ride or die like biden people you know these were all the people who were like no biden
00:56:35.700 who shouldn't drop out like he's our candidate and like okay these are the people who like they
00:56:41.620 when the dark brandon meme was pushed on us they were like yeah hell yeah dark brandon like
00:56:46.980 biden's a boss i i've gotta meet these people in person because i i'm like that sounds like
00:56:51.760 a unicorn to me but also there's just like a lot of people online you know it's like
00:56:55.320 hashtag blue wave hashtag resist libs like on twitter they're known as resist libs but it's
00:57:00.260 basically people who have this like fandom like obsession and inability to criticize politicians
00:57:05.600 the way that trump supporters are towards trump no i am going to mention it there's this page
00:57:09.940 on online there it's like very popular on like facebook but it's called occupied democrats
00:57:15.460 but it's basically it's one of these huge pages that's just like they they're liberal but they
00:57:22.540 treat american politics like it's team sports and like i'm on the blue team and you're on the red
00:57:28.860 team and the goal is for the blue guys to win and it's like no the goal for any of this should be
00:57:32.520 to make people's lives better it's just so revealing of like the failure of north american
00:57:37.720 democracy in general and like especially american democracy with a two-party system and obviously
00:57:42.580 people vote third party but it's like you really have the two and they're pitted against each other
00:57:47.780 they're us versus them even when they are sometimes they're quite often aligned at least like
00:57:52.320 fiscally and with regards to foreign affairs they're quite similar and it's just it is a team
00:57:56.820 sport if you add that to the pageantry in the theater it's like it is basically like sports
00:58:01.080 and it's like should we be indulging that or should we should we be trying to change that
00:58:05.060 When Biden withdrew from the campaign and was replaced with Kamala, something that so many Trump supporters I saw saying online was like, wow, you guys are just like, you know, going coconuts for Kamala right away.
00:58:16.360 And like, you're just going to let Biden go like that.
00:58:18.500 And it's like, yeah, you know, I don't think people who are engaging with politics from like an intelligent place should be like wanting to like marry themselves symbolically to any single politician.
00:58:31.380 Trump has built this like cult like base. And when people behave that way towards a Democrat candidate, like towards Joe Biden or, you know, whoever Democrat, like I don't think anybody should be doing that. I don't think any of this stuff should be personality driven. We should not we should be focusing on these people's policies, like you said, like we should be pushing them in the direction that we want them to go politically, like in favor of, you know, bettering people's lives. Like we should not be doing this. Like, I don't I don't think we need posters of these people in our rooms.
00:58:59.820 No, of course not.
00:59:00.920 I mean, and that's something Stalin would have loved, you know?
00:59:03.140 Like, it's like, yeah, we shouldn't.
00:59:04.560 That shouldn't be something that's, like, characteristic of democracy.
00:59:07.920 Democracy is about the people.
00:59:09.200 And I feel like we always forget that.
00:59:10.820 I think so much of it gets lost in, like, the fervor and the us versus them and, like, this party being, like, he's lying, she's lying, everybody's lying.
00:59:17.240 And it's, like, we get so caught up in this us versus them stuff that, like, we have so little time to sit down and really envision, like, what this person would be doing on a day-to-day basis in office.
00:59:27.260 are they charismatic enough to really engage with other leaders from other countries are they strong
00:59:32.560 enough to lead a team on a day-to-day basis within the oval office like are they do they have these
00:59:36.880 leadership skills that are important rather than like who is this person what are all their scandals
00:59:41.660 like all of this stuff it's like that's not really what i'm interested in like i want to know what
00:59:46.200 kind of person they're going to be on the job because it's a job and i think we just forget
00:59:50.000 that because it's so mediatized because of the spectacle like it's so weird that the president
00:59:54.960 for so long had to have like a nuclear family unit who cares crazy i mean even still kamala's 0.96
01:00:00.760 getting so much shit for like not having biological children of course because it's a bad narrative 0.53
01:00:05.120 it doesn't fit with the narrative of like american the american ideal i guess yeah and 1.00
01:00:09.600 it's misogynistic of course but it's like jd vance is a fucking pig yeah fuck that guy 1.00
01:00:14.500 like i just that's just not what i'm interested in in politicians and i think we just we so often 1.00
01:00:20.280 forget that we forget that this this is all actually about us not them not these two people
01:00:25.320 yelling at each other on a stage like it's a joke it just becomes a joke after a while returning this
01:00:30.800 to the what i'm calling the comma-ification of brat i have conflicting feelings about this at
01:00:36.840 the end of the day on one hand i think that nobody our age has ever been excited about
01:00:42.840 a presidential nominee i say my age because i was too young to really understand what was going on
01:00:48.440 when obama oh i was big on obama me 12 years old i was like i was riding hard for obama because it
01:00:57.120 was exciting at the time you know but like but i'm i mean i'm a couple years younger than you
01:01:01.060 and like everybody younger than me and i'm 25 there's a lot of people younger than me who are
01:01:05.280 voting and who all they've ever known are like hillary trump and biden what's there to get
01:01:11.160 excited about there as a young person and so like i think it's good ultimately like if if brat if
01:01:17.940 kamala brat gets young people excited about like voting which i think is a net good then i think
01:01:24.920 that's great political momentum is something that you need to win but right like my concern with it 0.67
01:01:32.280 is that when she gets reduced to the like cool aunt like brat coconut head girl like we run 1.00
01:01:39.400 the risk of forgetting that she is a fallible powerful public servant who must be held 1.00
01:01:46.980 accountable at every term and who must be pushed on some of the issues that she still needs to
01:01:51.460 prove herself on it really does speak to like the myopia of the internet in general and just people
01:01:55.860 people just forgetting you know it's just like a collective amnesia one month ago maybe two
01:02:01.300 months ago kamala harris was crazy coked out aunt who everyone was kind of it was kind of
01:02:06.360 derogatory like they were kind of mocking her and now we're all like ah my girl kamala and it's
01:02:12.080 take that out. We're all like, wait, that was perfect. I feel like I just made myself cringe
01:02:18.280 so hard. Everyone's like, yes, Kamala, mama. I think we're in this kind of, and I think young
01:02:25.600 people especially are just in this mode where it's like, yeah, for as long as they've been
01:02:29.140 voting, it's been a thing where, oh, they're forced to choose between the lesser of two evils,
01:02:33.740 but like you got to choose one. And I think a lot of people are just very fatigued with that.
01:02:37.560 You know, you look at Project 2025. If you think about all the people that are going to be harmed
01:02:41.140 by Trump's policies and by his reign. It's like, it's going to be more people. So you kind of end
01:02:47.360 up having to do this utilitarian kind of calculation where it's like, who is going to be most harmed in
01:02:52.060 this? Who is going to be immediately harmed by this? How can I as a voter protect at least one
01:02:56.320 more person? That personally is to me how I approach voting. It's tiring being in a crisis
01:03:01.040 where you can't just be excited about the person you're voting for and be like, hooray, I'm putting
01:03:05.360 all my backing in them and I'm going to feel so represented by them. I don't think any young
01:03:09.560 people have ever felt that well and the truth is though i think to a certain extent if you are you
01:03:15.460 know to left i don't think you're ever gonna feel that in american politics i think like to aspire
01:03:20.700 and to get close to achieving the office of the president like you're an imperialist like you're
01:03:26.300 the empire and this is why i just feel like no politician should ever be stand because i think
01:03:31.880 that they all inherently like this is my hot take like i think there will never be a perfect
01:03:36.520 candidate. I don't think there's ever going to be close to a perfect candidate. I think every
01:03:40.080 person who probably ever runs for president will have done like pretty awful shit. And I still think 0.99
01:03:45.440 that we should get out and vote. And that's, I mean, that's my take, right? Is like, I'll say
01:03:50.100 like, I'm voting for Kamala. I hope that because she is the only person right now who can be Donald
01:03:56.440 Trump, I hope that people will also get out and vote for Kamala. And that being said, like, I think
01:04:01.040 that Kamala is someone that you should vote for and then protest against every time she falls short. 0.54
01:04:05.240 and i think that she's like not our friend i think she's not a girly i think she's not
01:04:10.780 coked out brat mom coconut head falling out of a coconut tree like i i just i think she's a public 0.67
01:04:17.020 servant and that's i'm not speaking for my i'm not speaking for anyone but like that's like my 0.68
01:04:22.420 personal ethos around all of this that's the other truth that i hold right like on one hand i think
01:04:26.980 that like if the memes get you excited look i don't want to be like the annoying lefty who's
01:04:31.280 always smacking you on the wrist for laughing like i think excitement's you know political like
01:04:35.880 it's fun it's fun we should and we should have a moment to laugh especially when you know the the
01:04:40.900 senile old old guy isn't our only choice anymore but that being said like i think we should probably
01:04:46.600 dial back our feelings about like kamala being a girl that we're gonna go out and party with
01:04:50.400 because like she's not she's very well could be the president of the united states yeah i'll also
01:04:56.500 speak for myself and no one else and not matt i think like i went from being incredibly nihilistic
01:05:02.120 about this election i'm not a voter i can't vote for this but like whatever happens in american
01:05:06.060 politics will gravely affect us in canada we're extremely codependent uh with the u.s and so we
01:05:12.400 have a huge vested interest in it it's really hard not being able to have a say but i went from being
01:05:17.300 completely nihilistic about this election to kind of honestly without realizing it unconsciously
01:05:22.100 becoming a bit optimistic and i think that just comes from i think it comes from a renewed energy
01:05:27.280 that kamala is bringing just like the happiness that biden is is gone and i think also just that
01:05:33.320 you know kamala has shown throughout her history that she's someone who can be pushed further in
01:05:37.480 either direction that's just what i've observed of her and i think over the past few years she's
01:05:42.460 been pushed further and further and further to the left she's someone who will just do whatever
01:05:45.680 is currently popular and i think that she has the capacity to be pushed even further and that
01:05:52.380 is the optimism that i'm carrying with me throughout this these next couple months i think
01:05:57.060 the brat spell over kamala harris's campaign kind of broke for the young online left when
01:06:05.560 recently after netanyahu disgracefully spoke in front of u.s congress and kamala in fairness and
01:06:14.020 a lot of Democrats did boycott his speech. But there were tons of protests around D.C. when
01:06:20.360 Netanyahu visited. Kamala released this statement that basically smeared all of the protesters as
01:06:27.140 anti-Semitic, which like certainly anti-Semitism has occurred at these protests. And, you know,
01:06:33.280 if I say that if I don't include that disclaimer, then someone's going to send me a screenshot of
01:06:37.340 some zoomed in photo from a protest that had an anti-Semitic symbol somewhere. And so I'm
01:06:41.420 acknowledging that I'm sure that it did exist. But as we all know, we've been so many months
01:06:47.760 into this issue. And we know that smearing all protests against the atrocities committed by
01:06:54.220 Israel as anti-Semitic has been a way to squash the entire movement. And so Kamala Harris wrote
01:07:02.160 a letter essentially doing this, and it went over really poorly online. But I think I saw a lot of
01:07:08.200 people being like well that's brat summer for you and i do think that that was like a necessary
01:07:15.160 like i think the spell had to be broken there was only so long that like this like fun 365 party
01:07:23.020 could be co-opted by the democratic party by any sort of like major politician before we have to
01:07:30.940 all come back down to earth and be like again these are public servants who need to be protested
01:07:35.980 when they do something that is not in favor of the people.
01:07:39.560 And so as we wrap this up,
01:07:41.340 I want to read a tweet from Claire Schaefer.
01:07:44.380 She wrote,
01:07:45.340 I could be totally wrong, 0.79
01:07:46.680 but all I see in the Kamala memes is Gen Z nihilism
01:07:49.900 over a lack of choice in the political system,
01:07:52.640 not sincere standing of a politician.
01:07:55.500 The former is also worthy of critique,
01:07:57.380 but let's not conflate it with the latter.
01:08:00.140 And I think that if we're thinking about the camps of people
01:08:02.640 who were laughing at those memes or sharing them,
01:08:05.040 And I think there is definitely a nihilistic camp to that.
01:08:07.720 Who felt seen or at least a sense of release.
01:08:10.020 And I think we want to like, I don't know, I want to like give everybody grace who thought these were funny. 0.94
01:08:14.720 Because to be clear, they are very fucking funny. 0.89
01:08:18.420 Like they're very funny. 0.99
01:08:19.920 And they're hilarious.
01:08:21.320 It's knowing when to temper ironic love towards a politician on Twitter with like actual stand-up.
01:08:29.620 I guess what I'm trying to say is I think it's fine if you're falling out of a coconut tree. 0.99
01:08:33.500 just remember that brat is about doing coke and wanting to kill yourself 0.96
01:08:38.560 touche got nothing to say to that my uh thank you so much for coming to my apartment and doing this 0.83
01:08:49.660 with me thank you so much for having me if you guys want to know the review matt's apartment's
01:08:53.540 gorgeous oh but it is an old building and the ac sucks and so if you could hear the ac we've had
01:09:01.280 up blasting because that is the only choice i have in this heat and if you can't hear the ac
01:09:06.760 then that means i've done some really good work in final cut pro for those watching on youtube
01:09:12.060 if you see a glint across my cheek no just know that it's sweat
01:09:17.100 maya where can people find more from you people can find me on youtube at broie de chanel
01:09:25.460 and you can find me on twitter at broie de chanel and you can find me on instagram
01:09:29.620 and listen to our podcast rehash it is so fucking good oh yeah if you want extra episodes of a bit
01:09:38.200 fruity you can find those on patreon if you made it this far we're living through a really weird 0.58
01:09:43.120 time in america and i just want to give everyone my love and solidarity and we're all watching this
01:09:51.120 unfold together with amazement and um i love you i do you know get out there and vote don't stand
01:09:58.240 and we are all unburdened by what has been and let's go and all that came before us
01:10:04.340 let's all get really fucking unburdened i love you and until next time stay fruity 0.90