00:00:00.000Welcome to Bitchy History, the American History podcast that would absolutely be banned by Moms1.00
00:00:04.620for Liberty, especially after today's episode. Here we are at episode 11 of Bitchy History,
00:00:14.960and today is not only the second of two Pride episodes, but it's also a very special episode
00:00:19.500because it's the first time we've had a guest on the show. Today we're joined by Amanda Tempson
00:00:23.300from YesterQueers to talk specifically about the history of drag in the United States.
00:00:27.720Amanda, I'll let you introduce yourself before we get started.
00:00:30.780I didn't know I was going to be your first guest. That's so exciting.
00:00:34.360Brand new. First one. Never done it before on this show.
00:00:37.420Amazing. That explains a lot about all the things that just happened.
00:00:41.980The homophobic recording video that we had to deal with today. Yeah.
00:00:45.940Just a moderate amount of technical homophobia.
00:00:49.020Anyway, my name is Amanda. I am a writer and a television producer and an avocational public historian.
00:00:56.060of queer history, which means I don't have a degree in queer history, but I know a lot about
00:01:00.540it and I spend a lot of time educating about it. Yeah. And you know what? You do not have to have
00:01:05.540a degree in history. I do not gatekeep. I don't gatekeep. True. It's true. But you do have to know
00:01:11.140how to do research and check your sources. Yes. You do need to do that and be able to accept
00:01:17.300when you're wrong and somebody corrects you, which as we have found, avocational male historians on
00:01:24.060tiktok can't do that they they have no interest in being corrected apparently but that's a story
00:01:28.320for a different podcast i'm just glad the party city helmet is optional because i don't think i
00:01:32.840would look good in that yeah i'm not sure i could pull that off i really don't i think so
00:01:36.960so we're talking specifically about the history of drag in the united states it's not a art form
00:01:43.580that is solely an american art form obviously but we do have a very strong presence of it in our
00:01:49.340history and in our culture here in the United States, everything up from its origins to, you
00:01:55.180know, RuPaul's Drag Race, right? It's a big thing here. And so what exactly is drag, if you could
00:02:01.760explain it to us? So drag is both an art form and a political statement. It's the act of highlighting
00:02:09.700or exaggerating traditionally feminine or masculine features as a means of both celebrating and
00:02:16.700subverting gender expression it's not just men wearing dresses um it is in fact distinct from
00:02:23.640cross-dressing mostly because of the community and performance components of drag cross-dressing
00:02:30.300is usually something that's done um alone for an individual to sort of explore their gender
00:02:36.060expression whereas drag is usually done as part of a community or part of a performance
00:02:41.140right yeah there's it's obviously it's a big dramatic there's a lot of pageantry to drag
00:02:46.860whereas if cross-dressing is done by yourself that's by yourself or if it's done to pass like
00:02:51.680like a woman trying to to join the military by dressing up like a man or something it's a very
00:02:56.840different thing you're you don't want to draw attention to the fact that you're not the the
00:03:00.960right gender right yeah and cross-dressing is not um cross-dressing is not generally performative
00:03:08.040You know, drag is done for the experience of other people as part of a community, as part of a performance for an audience or for other members of the community.
00:03:20.900Whereas, you know, cross-dressing is an individual choice for a variety of reasons, which is a whole different episode that hopefully you'll invite me back for.
00:03:27.980Yeah, I am. I have another set of notes set up for that.
00:03:30.940So we'll do another episode on that maybe next month.
00:03:42.220So we've talked a lot about this already.
00:03:45.560You know, we were meeting on Zoom about this episode.
00:03:48.880And, you know, you were telling me some of the stuff I definitely did not know about the history of kind of the origins of drag, where it got its start here in the U.S.
00:03:57.040So if you could kind of go into that a little bit, because this is definitely this is why I brought you on, because this is not my area at all, honestly.
00:04:03.020So I love the history of drag is actually fascinating.
00:04:06.260So, of course, it has its roots in theatrical traditions all around the world.
00:04:11.200So ancient Greece, Shakespearean theater, kabuki theater, you see a lot of male performers playing female roles.
00:04:19.620But drag in the U.S. actually has its roots in Washington, D.C. in the late 1800s with the first queen of drag,
00:04:27.420who is a formerly enslaved man named William Dorsey Swan, who held parties that were then just called drags.
00:04:34.040Now we would call them drag balls, which were like big, fancy parties where he and all of his friends, most of whom were also formerly enslaved men, would wear their finest women's clothes.
00:04:45.600So it's really, you know, like almost everything that is awesome and amazing in culture in the U.S., it is rooted in the black experience in the United States and specifically in the experience of formerly enslaved men in the nation's capital right after the Civil War.
00:05:02.920Yeah. And I think that's a really interesting thing that so many of the things that have caused these sort of culture freak outs, these these, you know, all this anger had always has been stuff that with its root in African-American culture, like the anger about jazz when it came out as you know, as devil music, the anger about rock and roll.
00:05:24.580It was all related to this, you know, these tensions of race.
00:05:28.640And so it's interesting that we're facing off against, you know, issues with drag now.0.80
00:05:33.760And it all dates back to the same stuff.
00:05:36.000Everything is kind of wrapped up in this racial tension.
00:05:47.920Not that I think that like the Tennessee drag ban or whatever, the people who wrote it have any idea what the history of drag is.
00:05:54.080I don't think they've done any research on this. They just kind of instinctually hate it because
00:05:58.940they hate everything fun. I mean, yeah, basically. Well, they hate everything fun and they hate
00:06:04.500everything that is even a little bit subversive to this really rigid set of sort of, you know,
00:06:14.000Christian American values of like, what is a man and what is a woman and how do those two things
00:06:19.420or how did those two genders interact and like anything that doesn't fall into those neat little0.91
00:06:24.320boxes is like they can't make sense of it and they hate it and it is therefore must be perverse and0.77
00:06:28.540destroying all of our children so yeah exactly yeah and we have we've been dealing with this
00:06:33.080for a long time there is this very strict enforcement through the law of these sort of
00:06:40.180you know heteronormative standards uh in america for all that we'd like to talk about you know
00:06:45.180america being about freedom it really has not been a huge for whom exactly freedom for who
00:06:52.920exactly um well i made this point several times on the show in the last few episodes about the
00:06:58.100puritans where the puritans were not here for freedom in a general sense they were here for
00:07:02.400their freedom uh totally okay with creating a theocratic you know uh situation in government
00:07:09.600as long as they were the ones creating the rules.
00:07:12.480And so really, that's, honestly, it is very American, right?
00:07:16.380That's a very American idea to control people and make them do what you want.
00:07:20.740I want everyone to have the freedom to be exactly like me.
00:07:23.280That word does not mean what you think it means.
00:07:25.860Right. I don't think you understand the concept at all.
00:07:29.500But sort of what's interesting about drag in the U.S.,
00:07:33.400especially in the late 1800s, early 1900s.
00:07:36.120So William Bercy Swan, you know, he was he was one of the first really like queer activists in the U.S.
00:07:46.560and one of the first to really go up against the the police and the sort of like governing restrictions around men gathering.
00:07:59.840And, you know, in his case, it was sort of like a two pronged problem. Right.
00:08:03.600There was a bunch of black men gathering, which was, you know, frightening to people in Washington, D.C., and it was a bunch of black men gathering wearing dresses, which was the thing they just sort of couldn't get their heads around.1.00
00:08:12.860Yeah. You know, so he was really among the first who just kind of pressed those boundaries.1.00
00:08:21.580But what's interesting is that drag was not necessarily seen as a particularly perverse or weird thing up until like sort of right after World War One.
00:08:35.600Like, certainly, like, there were, you know, laws that I know we're going to talk about, about, like, cross-dressing and stuff, and William Dorsey Swan ended up being arrested a couple of times for running a disorderly house, which is they thought he was running a brothel instead of throwing a party.
00:08:51.760But before World War I, the highest paid actor in the country was a female impersonator, who we would now call a drag queen, named Julian L. Tinge, and he was a white man.
00:09:03.520a white man no um or so you know but like female impersonation was very very popular um during the
00:09:14.620height of vaudeville um you know drag kind of made its way like from washington dc up the eastern
00:09:20.180seaboard into new york um it was a huge part of the harlem renaissance so like many things it you
00:09:28.280know it wasn't it wasn't much of an issue until people started to decide that it was and then1.00
00:09:33.680suddenly it was this you know huge perverse oh my god the children problem of course yeah
00:09:39.840familiar yeah sounds pretty familiar uh i just keep finding that nothing is new nothing is new
00:09:47.360everything sounds uh you know like something that happened 100 years ago uh yeah which
00:09:53.140which I find comforting because I can look back and be like okay we've been through this before
00:09:58.680here's how we got through it so we can get through it but on the other hand I'm like
00:10:03.060could we solve a new problem like still still not keep rehashing the same problem it would be nice
00:10:11.460it would be uh theoretically nice if we could just move past this and move on to something else but
00:10:16.280no no they're not going to let us do that until I guess enough people die off in the older
00:10:21.420generations but even then that doesn't really stop it right i mean yeah you mentioned that0.82
00:10:26.320you were mentioning some of the the there was you know cross-dressing laws and like you said
00:10:31.540they didn't really apply to drag to to drag performers uh in any real meaningful way because
00:10:37.040when you're on stage right when you're doing something that is a performance it's different
00:10:42.080than living your life wearing the wrong the wrong clothing uh for your you know quote unquote gender
00:10:48.440yeah uh but they did have a lot of impact on you know on the queer community in a general sense
00:10:55.480which of course the drag community was a big part of uh even even if you have you know straight drag
00:11:01.300queens or or drag kings which does happen on occasion um and was much more prevalent at the
00:11:07.760beginning of the century of course yeah you know there are there is this is my like forever pet
00:11:13.760peeve there is a photo so if you google william dorsey swan you will get a photo that is attached
00:11:19.620to every single article about him and it is not him it is a performer named um i think john brown
00:11:27.920or i'm sorry john gregory or jack gregory anyway it's a performer in a vaudeville duo in paris and
00:11:34.760there are like promo shots and not only is that performer not william dorsey swan he's straight
00:11:40.600that is a straight man as far as we know he had a wife and there is no historical evidence that
00:11:47.840he was anything other than straight um and so it's like it's sort of like a double um it's like
00:11:54.860a double insult to call that william dorsey swan like right it's not him and the reason we know
00:12:00.120it's not him is because after william dorsey swan died the um police in his town burned his house to
00:12:06.840the ground burned every single thing he owned that tracks completely this is why we have no
00:12:14.360photos of william dorsey swan uh also this man that they keep attaching to all of these stories
00:12:20.900about him is a straight female impersonator in the vaudeville scene in the early 1900s
00:12:27.240right yes it's kind of crazy there's a lot of insults going on there yeah yeah and that's why
00:12:32.900just like this is the problem with google right where you google it and this picture comes up and
00:12:36.460it's like right it's even attached to articles from like more reputable news sources and if you
00:12:42.020read the teeny tiny caption of the photo it'll say something like you know vaudeville performer
00:12:46.540in paris in 1903 but like if the article is about william dorsey swan and there's a picture of black
00:12:51.060man in dress like people are going to make that assumption right and if somebody writes like a
00:12:55.040blog post about him and they just pull that picture without doing any research because people do that
00:12:59.260or make a tiktok or something like that the picture just you know it self-propagates the
00:13:04.000the myth right weird little like i have a couple of those sticking points about queer history where
00:13:09.460i'm just like oh it annoys me it's annoying it really is it's so annoying especially when
00:13:15.080like you said the cops burned all the pictures and so we don't have any any real you know
00:13:19.780evidence of his life which uh you know it's always a firm reminder for viewer for listeners uh this
00:13:26.420this podcast very much does ascribe to a cap like it's just there's no there's no good things coming
00:13:31.720out of that area of the world. I'm sorry. There is a wonderful, wonderful, wonderful scholar
00:13:38.360named Channing Gerard Joseph, and he is the reason that we know as much as we do about William Dorsey
00:13:44.840Swan. He has a book in the works called House of Swan that's supposed to come out, I think,
00:13:49.400sometime soon that I cannot wait to get my paws on to read the whole thing. That would be amazing.
00:13:55.180yeah he he is the man who really did this deep dive and found out so much of this information
00:14:01.720to be able to sort of place him in drag history and really not just in drag history but at the
00:14:07.040at the beginning he is our our very first queen of drag that's amazing that's amazing i'm excited
00:14:13.400to read that too i'll definitely uh put up a link to it when it comes out on my website so people
00:14:17.960can uh people can think it got delayed by the pandemic it was supposed to come out a couple
00:14:21.220years ago and every so often i'm just like is that out yet the pandemic was hard you're trying
00:14:25.580to work on a book and then you get stuck in your house and you just don't want to work on your book
00:14:29.420then right now now because you have all this time you don't want to get it done yeah i don't know
00:14:33.860anything about that meredith no idea i've never i've never done that before my master's thesis
00:14:38.820wasn't like that at all that never happened uh but yeah so i just wanted to get i want to talk
00:14:44.540a little bit about cross-dressing laws specifically because of how it affected the queer community in
00:14:48.640this and just because you know there's a lot of similarities what's going on today with anti-drag
00:14:55.240bills and things like that there's a lot of similarities even though they weren't specifically
00:14:58.280targeting drag queens then they're being used now for the same purpose so yeah cross-dressing has a
00:15:03.560very long history in american america as well we're definitely going to be doing an episode on
00:15:07.440that uh in the future because there's just so many cool stories about cross-dressing in american
00:15:12.700history um but the laws that governed crossdressing had this huge impact on everyone uh the oldest one
00:15:20.100that we have in america was a uh something called a masquerade law which was passed in 1845 in new
00:15:25.380york it specifically said that it was a crime to have your face painted discolored covered or
00:15:31.200concealed or be otherwise disguised while in a road or public highway that was that was what it
00:15:36.640was which is a very weird law um the state is bizarrely specific it is right so the state
00:15:42.900originally intended the law only to punish rural farmers because they had taken to dressing up as
00:15:48.060native americans to fight tax collectors uh so there's a lot to unpack with that law a lot
00:15:54.420not the least of which is the fact that the most recent usage of this law
00:16:00.140uh was in 2011 they actually used it to arrest occupy wall street uh protesters who were masks
00:16:07.860yeah they were still using it uh it was i think that all of those arrests got overturned by the
00:16:14.400judge the judge was like are you freaking kidding me no we're not using this um so yeah but then
00:16:20.060then in 1848 ohio columbus ohio specifically passes another one which is a law forbidding
00:16:25.700a person from appearing in public in a dress not belonging to his or her sex. So that kind of
00:16:31.800starts this watershed moment in America, where suddenly throughout the 1850s, we start to see
00:16:37.940just a wave of these laws being passed. And there's a Susan Stryker, who's an associate
00:16:44.360professor of gender and women's studies at the University of Arizona, wrote about this,
00:16:48.880has written about this extensively. And she said that these laws represented a new development0.96
00:16:53.620specific to gender presentation so it was this issue that comes up where uh people are angry
00:17:01.000that things aren't heteronormative right this is what is it what does it you say uh that i said
00:17:05.660oh the heteros are upseteros yeah exactly that needs to be on a shirt it does uh they were very
00:17:10.800it's gotta be a shirt anyway and then there's another book which i recommend which is arresting
00:17:18.740dressed by claire sears and she writes about all of these cross-dressing laws in there and i think
00:17:24.360one of the most interesting things she says is that it's not really about clothing that it's
00:17:29.620being passed to police indecency it's a morality law and has these these wide impacts she says the
00:17:37.140law made anyone who didn't fit into the narrow definitions of what a man or woman should look
00:17:41.500like they had to be extra vigilant uh she notes even one time where a someone was arrested because
00:17:47.980they were suspected as being a male cross-dresser they were taken into police custody and they were
00:17:53.340uh basically strip searched they were you know stripped off uh and then they realized that this
00:17:58.360was in fact a biological woman and you dropped the charges um they sent her home with a certificate
00:18:04.840verifying her sex so she could show her papers for her arrest what's you're too many you know
00:18:12.420What is absolutely hilarious is, like, nothing about that even is new to the end of the 19th century. Like, the very first case of people in authority not knowing what to do about gender nonconformity comes from the Virginia colony in the 1600s, the middle of the 1600s.
00:18:30.000there's a person in the virginia colony named both thomas and thomasine hall who dressed
00:18:35.920alternately in men's clothes and women's clothes alternately did the work of men and women
00:18:39.620nobody could figure out thomas slash thomasine's gender including thomasine themselves like
00:18:48.220they did not have a strong position on what their gender was and the first envy i love it
00:18:55.680Well, it's now, so they were hauled in, same thing, to be, like, examined by a panel of people to figure out what gender this person was.
00:19:03.960We now understand that this person was probably intersex because they exhibited the physical sexual characteristics of both genders.
00:19:13.300But they could not figure out what to do with this person.0.72
00:19:16.720So what they finally decided was that Thomas slash Thomasine had to wear the clothing of both genders all the time.
00:19:23.520so like a skirt and a shirt or whatever like had to wear like a dress but like a men's hat
00:19:29.220like because they just couldn't figure out what to do and the and they had no way to um to parse
00:19:37.180this person who didn't really fit in either box because of how gender at all the like
00:19:42.080laws and like work and everything so they don't know what they were like you just always have
00:19:46.400to dress as both genders all the time just so you don't confuse people i feel like it's more
00:19:52.100confusing but that that's you know that's a very very strict heteronormative gender-based roles
00:19:58.480during that period of time and it causes a lot of problems for somebody to to go against those
00:20:03.480uh at all you know it's it's going to cause a major problem and of course like everything else
00:20:09.260in the u.s the reason this whole thing came to a head is because um thomas slash thomasine was
00:20:14.960working on under an indentured contract and the person who owned the plantation she was indentured
00:20:21.940to wanted to sell their contract um but the person buying the contract would not complete the
00:20:28.560transaction until they were certain of the gender of the indentured indentured servant they were
00:20:36.220purchasing essentially i have questions that are bad questions that i'm not going to ask about why
00:20:41.880cared so much but i'm just gonna ostensibly i mean not to give white men any quarter here but
00:20:49.020But ostensibly, the reason it was important is because they wanted to know which set of jobs to assign this indentured servant to.
00:20:56.660Like, is this a field person or like a housework person?
00:21:00.760God forbid they just figure out what job they're good at and let them do it.
00:21:07.960Obviously, whatever physical characteristics you were born with determines what you're good at.
00:21:12.560Right. Of course. That's exactly how it works. Always.
00:21:14.980anyway so all that to say people in authority have never had a clue how people who are gender
00:21:24.040non-conforming right and it's instead of just letting them be and let people you know live
00:21:29.160the way they want to live dress the way they want to dress they have to get themselves involved they
00:21:32.720always do it's just you know if it doesn't fit my narrow worldview of what society should look like
00:21:38.720then you know just you're gonna have to be forced into the into this narrow worldview
00:21:44.300uh or we're gonna send you to jail it was one of the one of the stories of a woman who was
00:21:49.080arrested multiple times that claire sears talks to talks about with cross-dressing she was uh in
00:21:54.980in the 1870s she's arrested more than 20 times for wearing male attire uh and they you know keep
00:22:00.840sending her to jail keep sending her to court all of this stuff and one time when she's in court she
00:22:05.120just says you can send me to jail as often as you please but you can never make me wear women's
00:22:09.160clothing again which i you know i love that for her i love that she's like no we're not doing this
00:22:13.900uh but again they just went after her continuously trying to make sure that she would not be uh you
00:22:20.400know allowed to live her life the way she wanted to live it which is there's a there's a long
00:22:25.580history um especially of butch lesbians and trans women in this same situation being arrested0.78
00:22:32.560multiple times and they're just like cool keep arresting me i don't care and again the authorities0.97
00:22:37.460have no idea what to do because like that's their one go-to move is we're going to arrest you and0.68
00:22:41.460fine you and or imprison you and they're like great cool sure I think with women and during1.00
00:22:47.960that time period it's a uniquely bad opportunity bad attempt to stop them because women's lives1.00
00:22:53.240already sucked so like what are you gonna do make it worse by sending me to jail where I don't have1.00
00:22:59.120to like see my husband or deal with men like you're gonna send me to a woman's workhouse0.99
00:23:04.180okay like about that but yeah probably not the women's work houses were awful like they were0.98
00:23:13.500terrible places but my point being like if your life already sucks then you might as it's like
00:23:18.640well whatever sure yeah it's also it's it reminds me a little bit of the and again this was like0.93
00:23:23.880clearly a position of privilege like were you in a position where you could repeatedly be arrested
00:23:27.640and imprisoned for a few days and that wouldn't you know destroy your life um but it reminds me
00:23:32.580a little bit of like sumptuary laws during, um, uh, in Elizabethan England, like there's a giant
00:23:39.520fine for wearing purple velvet, but people who are rich enough still just paid the fine, you know?
00:23:44.240Well, I remember somebody saying once, you know, that, uh, when the punishment for a crime is,
00:23:49.820is paying a fine, then really it's just a, it's just a punishment for poor people, right? It's
00:23:53.680only poor people from doing it. Uh, you know, if you, if you, you know, have to pay a ticket for
00:23:58.440double parking, well, okay, I can, I can afford the ticket. It doesn't bother me. So I'm just
00:24:03.640going to call. I live in Los Angeles and I have definitely on occasion been like,
00:24:08.200is it worth it to me to maybe get a ticket for parking here? Is that like, is that a reasonable
00:24:14.520potential expense as opposed to circling for 20 more minutes to find a place to park?
00:24:19.040What's my, what's, how much is my time worth? Let's see. Like, we'll see if I've got a good
00:24:24.580podcast on or a good, uh, or a good audio book, then I'll just keep circling. It's fine. Yeah.
00:24:30.740Also helps that I, I, I physically cannot, uh, parallel park. So I'm, I'm a stereotype. I can't
00:24:37.600parallel park at all. So if I can't find a parking spot that will allow me to pull in,
00:24:43.460I just don't park. I just leave. It's amazing. I have in fact stood up someone on a date once
00:24:50.680simply because the place she invited me to only had parallel parking possibly the most femme thing0.86
00:24:57.060you've ever done i'm just gonna put that i was like it's all parallel parking i can't i didn't
00:25:02.260really stand her up i did text her why i left but still anyway you had mentioned earlier that swan
00:25:10.060got uh arrested a couple times for running a disorderly house right yes uh so what what is
00:25:16.160that exactly? So running a disorderly house was the, you know, sort of 19th, early 20th century
00:25:23.040way of saying being a madam or running a brothel. And so the thing that was sort of interesting
00:25:28.960about Swan in particular is that what he was doing in holding these drag balls really kind of
00:25:37.920walked a line in terms of legality. Like it was not legal for this many men to wear dresses and
00:25:44.260be social. But there also weren't really great laws around it. You know, it's sort of a little
00:25:52.000bit difficult to prosecute. So they decided that charging Swan with running a disorderly house
00:25:59.780would like get him out of the business essentially of throwing these drags. You know, and it did
00:26:06.480because this is the American justice system at work, folks, by the way. So he was arrested early
00:26:12.960in the morning on january 1st i think 1896 because he had had a new year's eve drag his trial
00:26:20.800was on january 3rd and it only lasted a few hours because by the end of january 3rd he had been
00:26:28.100convicted and sentenced to 300 days in jail wow yeah uh and the and i had to look up this quote
00:26:36.580from the judge because it just the I think the naked hatred that the judge exhibited during his
00:26:45.780trial is very applicable to the naked hatred that we're seeing now against drag performers all over
00:26:53.800the country because when he was sentenced the judge said to him I would like to send you where
00:26:59.020you would never again see a man's face and would then like to rid the city of other disreputable1.00
00:27:03.480persons of the same kind you know what it sounds like that judge sounds like he would have gotten1.00
00:27:09.360along really well with michael knowles you know they would have they would have they would have
00:27:13.520had drinks they would have loved each other uh yeah in a gay way i don't know um and the thing
00:27:20.280that's sort of interesting about swan too is he served three months and then he started petitioning
00:27:25.660the president, Grover Cleveland at the time for clemency. And he was the first American ever to
00:27:35.680take specific legal steps to try to defend his right to gather with other queer people. Like he
00:27:45.000was the first one to fall into the system and then fight back against the idea of suppression and
00:27:53.160police violence and all of that and he had a remarkably um a remarkably big support network
00:28:01.840in washington dc um right i mean it didn't work the like the the president never even saw it and
00:28:11.820the u.s attorney um referred to swan as having been convicted of the most horrible and disgusting
00:28:20.020offenses known to law so disgusting that it could not be named um so like sounds about right it
00:28:27.400didn't work um you know so cleveland was like due to the character of your friends we think we're
00:28:32.840gonna leave you in jail um but he tried like he was the first one to really like raise public
00:28:39.760awareness and really try to fight back against this system and that you know that's like the
00:28:47.380thing that's interesting about drag is that like yes it's a performance and it's fun and it's campy
00:28:54.380but it also has an enormous political element because of this claiming of space and claiming
00:29:02.100of community um you know as we move into um the 20th century in particular um especially as we
00:29:11.220move like into the like the post-World War II years um when people are sort of trying to
00:29:18.980queer people are sort of trying to figure out new ways to be in community um actually especially
00:29:23.760men returning from the war who had all of these intense experiences while they were overseas both0.91
00:29:30.220with their fellow soldiers or with um you know sex workers in Europe and they're just men queer men0.66
00:29:36.840learned a lot about themselves during World War II and then they came back to the states and sort
00:29:40.640have had to try and figure out how to be in community again, um, or new ways to be in
00:29:44.800community, I guess I should say that wasn't just being in the closet again. Right. And, you know,
00:29:50.620so as, as drag rose up, you know, through the fifties and sixties, um, I feel like we have to
00:29:58.300do a whole other episode on like, like drag houses and how that whole culture evolved.
00:30:04.640Yeah. But it really became this place that was both art and performance and entertainment and community and political activism and this, you know, subversion of norms and this really powerful way to say this is who we are and we're not going anywhere.
00:30:27.880Yeah. And because it is such an inherently public performative, you know, form of art, right? For a very long time, you know, queer people were in the closet, even if they, you know, had, you know, Boston marriages or things like that, where you had two women living together or two men, you know, living together, they kept it to themselves.
00:30:50.400it was within between their relationship maybe their family maybe their friends but they were
00:30:54.780not making a spectacle of it because they there were laws and and there were social problems that
00:31:01.380would come with that uh and so you know you have you know historians who are like oh they were
00:31:05.720best friends you know they lived together their whole lives and they were best friends i'm like
00:31:12.200their dog was named sappho buddy they weren't best friends uh but uh you know this is a situation
00:31:18.480Right. So they have been hiding themselves, hiding their identity for so long in order to get by.
00:31:24.080And then you just have, you know, late 1800s, you just have these people who are like, hmm, we're just going to be very publicly queer and very publicly go against, you know, gender roles and and completely throw the system into into disarray and chaos.
00:31:41.900and, you know, we're going to be public about it, which is going to change everything about how the
00:31:48.500queer community, you know, live their lives at that point, basically. Yeah. And, you know, drag,0.87
00:31:54.360drag also is a thing that sort of, you know, it's, it started among formerly enslaved Black men in
00:32:03.200the U.S. It moved through the Harlem Renaissance, you know, and by the time you get to like the
00:32:08.00060s it had really been co-opted by largely white gay men because drag kings are obviously a thing
00:32:16.400but they didn't really start to rise to prominence as far as i understand it until like the 80s is
00:32:21.260when you start to really see drag kings so largely we're talking about white men um and the like the
00:32:27.940whole system of you know drag houses and all of that came out of the racism of drag balls in the
00:32:34.620sixties in New York city because there was drag queen named Crystal LaBeja who was, um, you know,
00:32:40.640at the time drag was not as, um, exaggerated as it is now. Like now when you think of drag queens,
00:32:46.940you think of like divine and you think of like, you know, big hair and lots of glitter and, you
00:32:52.240know, colorful eye makeup and eyelashes for days and all of that. Drag was not like that in the0.93
00:32:57.320sixties. It was much more about, it was much more like a, like a, like a Miss America pageant.
00:33:02.520so it was a little bit more about passing although I'm hesitant to say that because
00:33:08.780none like they weren't trying to be women but the beauty standards they were trying to meet
00:33:13.360in these pageants were the beauty standards applied to white cisgendered women so less0.98
00:33:19.180exaggerated they weren't trying to over exaggerate the the yeah they were I mean the 60s were an
00:33:24.400exaggerated time like we've all seen beehives so like you know they were that exaggerated yeah
00:33:29.020Um, but they were incredibly racist. A lot of them were being judged by very white beauty standards, um, which gave drag queens, uh, black drag queens and drag queens of color, um, pretty much no shot. Um, and Crystal LaBeja was, um, a Latina drag queen who had actually managed to make it pretty deep into the, um, mostly white, um, you know, drag competition space.1.00
00:33:55.220and um you know there she was in this competition and there's a great documentary about it and and
00:34:03.020like she came in fourth and a woman who was still in the top three or a drag queen i should say who
00:34:08.740was still in the top three like hadn't even bothered to wear a wig and like like it's perfectly1.00
00:34:13.660made a perfectly pretty woman but like no like just not even on crystal's level at all she just0.98
00:34:20.320snapped she walked right off the stage and and just and like and it's amazing because there was
00:34:25.340a documentary crew there at the time um and captured her whole like she is the reason that
00:34:31.000drag queens read people now like anytime you see a drag queen read someone that is all inspired by
00:34:36.920crystal labaja um yeah but the roasting of people i mean just i mean it just it's amazing uh but
00:34:46.140she founded the first drag house with, um, you know, with another friend, she became the first
00:34:51.940drag mother. And it was sort of a, the drag houses serve two purposes. One was to reclaim drag from
00:34:58.640the white people who were destroying it. Honestly was to bring drag back to, they called it uptown0.93
00:35:03.840drag. So back up to Harlem and to those neighborhoods that were largely populated by
00:35:08.800black people and other people of color. Um, and it was also to form families, right? Like they're
00:35:15.100literally drag families and the drag mothers were um were there to be mentors not just in the art
00:35:21.160of drag but you know every lost queer kid who showed up and you know had been um either kicked
00:35:28.420out of or had chosen to leave their family of origin you know whatever um and it became this
00:35:34.520really really powerful social network um that all sprung out of the drag community yeah to have
00:35:41.440these people who have a space to go when you've been kicked out or a space to go where you can
00:35:46.560express yourself and not feel you know feel like a like a freak or feel you know bad about who you
00:35:53.340are uh that's again a huge powerful thing in the organizing of the queer community in into you know
00:36:01.040the the queer civil rights movement of the you know the 70s and 80s uh it's a major major player
00:36:07.580in that really we have uh we have drag queens to thank for a lot of you know the advancements in
00:36:14.140uh in queer culture yeah i mean and just in culture in general so the other thing that
00:36:18.500happened with the formation of um drag houses is it really changed like a quote-unquote uptown drag
00:36:25.560really changed the face of drag because that's when you start to see all of these drag balls
00:36:30.700that have all kinds of wild categories right you know like formerly they were again very much like
00:36:37.400Miss America you know pageants so they had like a limited number of categories um but once they0.81
00:36:42.880start dividing themselves up into drag houses and doing these like sort of huge and elaborate balls
00:36:47.640um it really upped the performance aspect of drag because it was no longer just
00:36:54.460walking across the stage you know like certainly there was walking up and down a an aisle but there
00:36:59.940was also um all kinds of elaborate you know performance that got added to it and pretty
00:37:07.000much everything that was cool in the 80s or 90s started in drag houses like i have i'm doing an
00:37:13.420episode on yester queers next week about willie ninja and the house of ninja who's the reason we
00:37:17.300have voguing like he is the father of voguing um so all of that is yeah is all tied into this
00:37:25.400definitely it's not just uh one second there's a train going by so i have to cut this part of
00:37:33.720the audio so you know uh yeah so uh yeah i mean we're yeah there's a lot to thank them for a lot
00:37:40.060too and it's one of the big reasons why i mean not just for civil rights reasons but it's one
00:37:44.800of the reasons why we need to be you know organizing behind these movements now to keep
00:37:50.460you know keep drag queens safe keep trans people safe all of these people have had such a huge
00:37:55.880impact on our society uh not the drag and trans same thing but there is like a certain element
00:38:02.360of this of of both that are coming into what's going on with the culture war right now but
00:38:07.140I mean drag the history of drag in a lot of ways is the history of or at least the foundation of
00:38:15.660queer culture in the United States like you cannot separate those two things no you know
00:38:21.820certainly queer culture is much you know wider and broader and more complex than just drag
00:38:28.560but it is one of the cornerstones of everything that makes up American queer culture today in
00:38:37.0202023. And I think it's easy for people even in the queer community to dismiss it as just sort of
00:38:43.880like silly and frivolous, you know, just sort of like fun. And sure, it's all of those things,0.76
00:38:51.220but also um it is connected to this very um this very deep and important part of our history
00:39:01.580you know and there's also like there just isn't one there's just not one kind of drag or like one
00:39:06.940way to do drag you know there's like there's drag story hours there's the sisters of perpetual
00:39:12.220indulgence who are the drag nuns who do enormous amounts of good works they do and they're
00:39:19.120absolutely just hysterical and the nicest people you'll ever meet every time i've ever had any1.00
00:39:23.860interaction with them i'm like they're just so nice piss off the catholic church so you know0.56
00:39:29.300all good i love that you know there's just lots there's lots of ways to do drag and be drag and
00:39:35.460understand drag and i think one of the things that frustrates me the most about you know the way
00:39:43.240conservatives and you know Christo fascists in this country fascists talk about drag like it's
00:39:52.060clear that they just don't have a clue what it is at all and I'm not sure they would care if they
00:39:57.400did but like could you at least try try maybe go to a performance I don't know just at least watch
00:40:06.420the birdcage for god's sakes yes just try one thing just try one thing oh yeah we were talking
00:40:12.100a little bit about like the post-World War II period earlier before we got like we kind of
00:40:15.880skipped forward into the 60s and 70s which is totally not a problem uh we just you know we
00:40:20.480backtracked to go back into things but yeah uh I think it's really because you said that you know
00:40:25.940after World War II we start to get more people who are experimenting with drag but also because
00:40:30.660it is the post-war period there's even more pushback against people uh you know experimenting
00:40:36.740with anything that's not a strictly you know white Anglo-Saxon Protestant you know
00:40:41.640wasp family unit right and so we start to see a lot more i i would i hesitate to say a lot more0.91
00:40:49.620violence against the drag queens and queer community because there certainly was violence
00:40:54.540before but it is more focused i think after after world war ii uh this particular uh rusty brown
00:41:02.200as a a woman who was interviewed for a uh for a project on queer history and she was talking about
00:41:08.740the fact that uh she originally started dressing as a man uh because she lost her job at during
00:41:14.780world war ii uh at the end of the war she lost her position as a machinist and so she began
00:41:19.980disguising herself as a man so that she could get a job again uh and then after that she does go on0.92
00:41:25.580to become a drag king this is you know she's one of the earliest drag drag kings of that era and0.98
00:41:30.840and she mentioned in her interview where she talks about what they call the three article rule1.00
00:41:35.980which was that people were arrested for not wearing at least three pieces of of gender
00:41:43.140appropriate attire basically uh this was not a rule that actually existed there's no law on the
00:41:49.180books about it uh seems like it maybe it was more of a term that was used by the gay community as
00:41:53.720sort of a a general warning like oh don't you know don't break the three article rule um but this
00:42:00.760becomes a major problem right so it's it's not at this point now it's not just about people who
00:42:07.020are cross-dressing not just about drag queens uh it's about anybody who chooses to dress
00:42:11.420any differently than what their gender is expected to dress as and i just think like i don't wear
00:42:17.120skirts i don't wear dresses i would have done very poorly in this this time period uh and i
00:42:22.300mentioned earlier about the woman who had to have her papers right she had to have this report from
00:42:26.500the police and a very similar thing happened in 1968 this man martin boyce is on his way to a
00:42:32.580halloween party uh and he's dressed as oscar wilde which okay cool it's a cool outfit i love it it's
00:42:38.340great but cop famously a man oscar wilde right it's great great choice but a cop actually collars
00:42:44.580him and says hey your costume is too feminine which first of all it's oscar wilde i don't
00:42:49.180understand but whatever whatever i don't know what the costume looked like boyce has an argument
00:42:55.540with the cop and he again it's a papers thing right he pulls out the receipt he's carrying the
00:43:00.760receipt for the costume from a unisex store uh basically to prove that he is not wearing
00:43:06.920something that doesn't fit his gender and it's crazy that he had to have papers for this uh but
00:43:13.240the thing that really gets me about it is that the police officer then turns to a gang of angry young
00:43:19.880men and says he's all yours and the cop leaves because he legally can't do anything about it
00:43:26.180but he's going to allow a gang to beat this man up luckily apparently the gang was not very invested
00:43:32.460in uh like in queer bashing that particular night uh and they let voice go but it was a very common
00:43:39.520thing during this period of time which is of course what's going to lead us to you know the
00:43:43.340stonewall uprising uh this harassment over gender norms and things like that and voice actually was
00:43:48.800at stonewall as well so it's kind of a neat you know full store full circle story for him where
00:43:54.520he had this harassment happen and then he's there at the moment uh which you know kind of explodes0.88
00:44:00.120into the into the gay rights movement uh but it is just such a dangerous thing and honestly we0.53
00:44:08.540have seen discussions about carrying your papers right we've seen discussions about this uh going0.91
00:44:15.020on with you know current drag bands current uh current you know transgender bands things like
00:44:21.760that in america where they're talking about like oh well you know you just carry proof that you've
00:44:25.660had your surgery why should i have to carry proof i shouldn't have to give you my papers
00:44:30.760what kind of fascist state is this i think that's so fascinating and i think there's a lot of
00:44:37.400parallels between america after world war ii and where america is right now because basically what
00:44:43.300happened after world war ii is um you know we had a several year span where most of the men in the
00:44:51.240country were someplace else um and a lot of them who were in europe were either having experiences
00:44:57.720with their fellow soldiers because that's what happens when you're lonely and think you're going
00:45:01.640to die every other minute or they were having um experiences with european sex workers they were
00:45:08.280being exposed to European ideas about sex and sexuality. So you have all a huge chunk of
00:45:15.380American men overseas somewhere fighting a war, but also learning a lot about themselves and
00:45:20.800their likes and then desires and like the world, you know, at large. And then you have a bunch of
00:45:27.060women and girls who are suddenly pulled out of their sort of like support positions and put into
00:45:33.560jobs as, you know, factory workers and machinists and car mechanics and all kinds of things. So
00:45:39.160they are suddenly, um, you know, pulled out of this stereotypical behavior pattern. And then
00:45:47.440the war ends and, you know, everyone who wasn't killed comes home and all the women are expected0.83
00:45:52.580to go back into the kitchen or back to being, you know, secretaries or, you know, nurses or0.96
00:45:57.100whatever and so it wasn't just the queer community I think that they were trying to um reign in it0.96
00:46:03.680was everybody it was like all right we have those weird four years and I'm glad everyone did what1.00
00:46:07.720they had to do but like okay women back in the kitchen men back to stoicism you know and back to0.89
00:46:13.000the normal you know day to day of what things are supposed to be like yeah it's like it all just got
00:46:18.680a little too crazy let's just dial it back um and in some ways I think that is very parallel to
00:46:25.280what's going on now. Um, you know, like I'm Gen X, I am, you know, almost 46 years old. So I,
00:46:32.860um, I watched the generations coming up behind me who have a very different understanding of
00:46:38.960gender and sexuality and, you know, the ways in which people interact, which I think is wonderful.0.59
00:46:45.300Um, but it is terrifying to people who want this country to run on the, you know, straight, narrow Christian tracks that they've been trying to keep, quote unquote, keep it on, um, you know, for decades.
00:47:05.640And so I think we're in a similar place now where it's like,
00:47:10.540So we just got to really, you know, reel it back in.
00:47:13.920And it's like, it's not, you can't, you can't put toothpaste back in a tube.
00:47:17.540That's not, it's not, it's not going to happen.
00:47:19.400We're not going to suddenly stop living our lives or stop doing the thing,
00:47:23.000you know, stop expressing ourselves or things like that. Yeah.
00:47:25.760And trans people and drag queens are two such obvious targets because like a0.97
00:47:32.120drag queen, you can spot a drag queen at 50 yards, right?0.95
00:47:35.240like big hair big boobs glitter drag queen yeah um you know and i don't think that that's true of0.88
00:47:41.060trans people although people always like to say well i can tell no you can't you really can't0.96
00:47:45.340literally cannot um but they feel like an obvious target well yeah and that's a really unfortunate
00:47:52.180thing which i'm gonna have to do a whole episode at some point on just trans trans issues at some
00:47:56.500point uh not that it's really my area to talk about but trans history would be a really interesting
00:48:00.620bring another guest that also is not my area yeah we'll find somebody somebody else um somebody
00:48:07.120will be somebody will be available for it at some point uh but yeah it's a very unfortunate thing
00:48:13.900especially since there are elements of the queer community which are not supportive of transgender
00:48:19.760people which i i don't understand turfy lgb people like i don't get it doesn't make any sense to me
00:48:27.380again like whole other episode i understand how and why turfs came to be i do not understand how
00:48:35.240they continue to proliferate here in 2023 yeah and i it's very difficult for me to understand
00:48:40.280specifically turfs who are also queer like it just seems so counter to the idea of like look
00:48:46.060you're you've been oppressed you know what this is like why would you perpetuate that uh but
00:48:51.960There's lots of people who, you know, have been, who have multiple intersecting identities. And, you know, it's this like, it's this pernicious desire to be as close as possible to like, the ruling majority intersection of identities, right? Like to be as close as possible in this country to being a straight, white, cisgendered man, you know?0.71
00:49:15.420Um, so that it's just, it's, oh, it's just pernicious, but yeah, it's the, uh, as much0.99
00:49:22.940as we have to, you know, offload in order to maintain our proximity to, you know, what
00:49:29.320we view to be like the ultimate power, um, power dynamic in this country, which is, it's