00:00:00.000Welcome to Bitchy History, the American History podcast that would like to remind you that we have Thanksgiving dinners to thank for the creation of Tucker Carlson's family wealth, and that's enough of a reason to have a problem with this holiday.
00:00:17.100Before we get started with the show today, there's a couple of new features on the podcast website that you might want to check out.
00:00:22.620The first is that the website now has a new URL.
00:00:25.940Rather than typing in all of that podpage.com backslash nonsense,1.00
00:00:30.260just type in bitchyhistory.com and you'll get to the site.0.99
00:00:33.580You know, when I bought that URL, the hosting company tried to warn me off of it1.00
00:00:37.440because it might potentially offend someone.
00:01:18.700Welcome to episode 9 of Bitchy History, where we will finally talk about the history of the quote-unquote first Thanksgiving.
00:01:25.880And I put heavy emphasis on the quotes here because it was neither the first celebratory meal of gratitude between Europeans and natives,
00:01:33.340and by European standards, it also wasn't a Thanksgiving at all.
00:01:37.100But we'll get into how the modern-day view of this event came about later in this episode.
00:01:41.420As I mentioned in episode 7 when I first introduced the concept of the Puritans and their journey to America to this show, most of us grew up with a very child-friendly view of the first Thanksgiving.
00:01:52.980Squanto helped the Pilgrims grow their crops, and in return, the Pilgrims expressed their gratitude by extending an invitation to Squanto's tribe to join their festivities on the first Thanksgiving.
00:02:03.960Nope, sorry, it didn't happen that way.
00:02:06.400And as we got older, some of us learned a much darker version of the story about the Pilgrims and the Natives.
00:02:12.360We learned of murder and war and oppression, and that became the grim, dark version of the first Thanksgiving.
00:02:18.100Kind of like what would happen if you set the writing team from Riverdale loose on Charlie Brown's Thanksgiving special.
00:02:24.400But seriously, though, how did Archie Comics go from this...
00:15:12.720That question being, how did three paragraphs of
00:15:15.880we had a great harvest and ate a big meal get turned into a national holiday,
00:15:19.980which is part of a nationalistic mythology of America's past?
00:15:23.620First, I think it's important to explain what I meant at the beginning of the episode
00:15:27.140when I said that this was not actually a Thanksgiving by the standards of the pilgrims.
00:15:31.900A Thanksgiving would have included fasting and prayer and would have been religious in nature.
00:15:36.360The events in 1621 were celebratory, not necessarily religious.
00:15:40.520This was a party, a harvest feast which had little to do with religion,
00:15:44.080at least as far as anything with the pilgrims had little to do with religion.
00:15:47.980Later, actual thanksgivings involving religious prayer and fasting to give thanks to God
00:15:53.100would be recorded by the colonists, notably in 1637 and 1676, both of which occurred after bloody
00:16:00.260victories in which they defeated natives in battle, such as the end of King Philip's war in 1676,
00:16:05.780which involved the Plymouth men mounting the head of Metacomet, or King Philip, above their town on
00:16:11.440a pike where it remained for two decades, while his dismembered and unburied body decomposed.
00:16:17.360Understandably, that makes for a less heartwarming story for children to perform pageants about at
00:16:21.640school. We also know that this wasn't the first time that a friendly feast was celebrated between
00:16:26.380European colonists and native tribes. For instance, in 1565, nearly 60 years before the Plymouth Feast,
00:16:32.960a Spanish fleet came ashore and planted a cross on the beach to christen the new settlement of
00:16:37.320St. Augustine in what is now Florida. To celebrate the arrival, 800 Spanish settlers shared a feast
00:16:43.420with the native tribe. I mean, look, European colonists and explorers have been arriving in
00:16:48.040the New World since 1492. It beggars belief that anyone could think that it wasn't until 1621 that
00:16:54.780some of them bothered to sit down and have a meal with each other. The colonists weren't usually
00:16:59.240nice to the natives, but there had been semi-friendly relations from time to time between
00:17:03.740Columbus and the Mayflower. So this was neither the first feast nor an actual Thanksgiving, but
00:17:09.060how did we get from the truth to what we learn in our November lessons in second grade? On October
00:17:14.1403rd 1789 george washington issued his thanksgiving proclamation designating for the people of the
00:17:19.860united states a day of public thanksgiving to be held on thursday the 26th day of november
00:17:24.940marking the first national celebration of the holiday in 1841 the reverend alexander young
00:17:31.100explicitly linked three things in his book chronicles of the pilgrim fathers of the colony
00:17:35.560of plymouth the 1621 rejoicing the tradition of autumn harvest festivals and the name thanksgiving
00:17:41.880in a one-line footnote. The line, this was the first Thanksgiving, the great festival of New
00:17:47.820England. But we would not have an actual official national holiday for Thanksgiving until 1863,
00:17:53.380when President Abraham Lincoln called for an annual celebration to be held on the final
00:17:57.760Thursday of November. And it wasn't until this post-Civil War period that we began to see what
00:18:02.940we would now consider to be modern Thanksgiving rituals beginning to take shape. For instance,
00:18:08.340football and thanksgiving 13 years after the institution of the national holiday the first
00:18:13.460football game played on thanksgiving was the intercollegiate football association championship
00:18:18.500in 1876 the game and the holiday became so connected that by 1893 the new york herald
00:18:24.620called thanksgiving the official holiday for watching football the nfl played its first game
00:18:29.760on thanksgiving in 1920 for those of you that care it was yale versus princeton yale won two to zero
00:18:36.000I hate that I know this fact, because I hate football.
00:18:39.700Don't come for me about this, because you will not convince me to like this sport,
00:18:43.420and it will be a waste of time for both of us.
00:18:45.860I just think it's rather odd that a nation that prides itself on its virility
00:18:49.420should feel compelled to strap on 40 pounds of protective gear just in order to play rugby.
00:18:54.180Then there's another Thanksgiving tradition, pardoning the turkey,
00:18:57.260which is an extremely weird tradition no matter how you look at it, to be honest.
00:19:01.460It's often stated that President Lincoln's 1863 clemency to a turkey
00:19:05.580recorded in an 1865 dispatch by a White House reporter, was the origin for the pardoning
00:19:10.960ceremony. A few other instances of this would pop up during the Kennedy, Nixon, and Carter
00:19:15.980presidencies, but it wouldn't be until 1981 that the practice would become the norm under President
00:19:21.040Reagan. The turkey ceremony also became a source of satire and humor for reporters.
00:19:26.820The tradition of a harmonious Pilgrim Wampanoag feast would come in the 19th century as well,
00:19:31.780alongside a desperate attempt to find an acceptable national creation tale.
00:19:36.600Carla Pastana, in her 1993 article, The Quaker Executions as Myth in History, puts it this way,
00:19:43.040the pilgrims who established the inconsequential settlement of Plymouth Plantation won pride of
00:19:47.940place in the national creation tale during the 19th century, primarily because they were not
00:19:52.780implicated in the acts of religious persecution and could be admired as uncompromised advocates
00:19:57.820of liberty. The more significant Puritans of Massachusetts Bay left a more conflicted legacy,
00:20:03.480one that Americans grapple with to this day. Because as you'll remember from episode 7,
00:20:09.000Puritans were hypocrites who actually weren't big on religious freedom at all, or any freedom for
00:20:13.900that matter, which presented a major problem to the nationalistic identity of America as a country
00:20:19.420founded on the ideology of liberty. In the article Monumental Mobility, The Memory Work of Massasoit,
00:20:25.580The authors point out that the holiday myth of the first Thanksgiving began to spread as anti-immigration sentiments in the late 19th century were looking for a hero to present as the perfect national founders.
00:20:37.100And they found the Pilgrims to be the perfect archetype for their mythology.
00:20:40.740White, Protestant, Democratic, and blessed with an American character that was centered on family, work, individualism, freedom, and faith.
00:20:48.640I would personally argue that that is a terrible interpretation of everything that the Pilgrims and Puritans stood for.
00:20:54.480But when it's propaganda, facts don't matter.
00:20:57.780And it was propaganda, plain and simple.
00:21:00.220But if you've made it through nine episodes of this show, that shouldn't exactly be a big surprise by now.