Bitchy History - February 25, 2024


General Harriet Tubman and the Civil War


Episode Stats


Length

16 minutes

Words per minute

174.41

Word count

2,951

Sentence count

113


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
00:00:00.000 welcome back to bitchy history yes we have a new intro again let me know what you think of it i
00:00:28.760 I take constructive criticism, no matter what my commenters on TikTok might claim to the contrary.
00:00:33.640 This is the 33rd episode of this show. Can you believe that?
00:00:36.600 I mean, it would be more, but teaching takes a lot of time when you actually give a shit about your students and the education they get from you.
00:00:42.760 Go figure.
00:00:43.460 But anyway, last week in my Intro to American History class, I was lecturing on the Civil War and the self-emancipation thesis,
00:00:50.740 which Civil War historian James McPherson describes this way in his article, Who Freed the Slaves.
00:00:55.940 The self-emancipation thesis embodies an important truth.
00:00:59.700 By coming into Union lines, by withdrawing their labor from Confederate owners,
00:01:03.540 by working for the Union army and fighting as soldiers in it,
00:01:06.640 slaves did play an active part in achieving their own freedom,
00:01:09.780 and for that matter, in preserving the Union.
00:01:12.100 Like workers, immigrants, women, and other so-called non-elites,
00:01:15.940 the slaves were neither passive victims nor pawns of powerful white males
00:01:19.600 who loomed so large in our traditional image of the past.
00:01:22.140 They, too, made a history that historians have finally discovered.
00:01:25.940 This concept might seem a little deep for an intro-level American history class,
00:01:30.220 but I always come prepared with historical illustrations
00:01:32.720 on these more theoretical discussions of historical nuance.
00:01:36.740 In the case of the self-emancipation thesis, my example is Harriet Tubman,
00:01:40.660 and as ever, the blind spots in my students' previous education on American history
00:01:44.860 hit me with full force as I was once more met with stares of shock
00:01:48.880 from students who definitely didn't know Harriet the way I know her.
00:01:52.460 One student on the way out of class actually stopped and told me
00:01:55.600 that she'd had three classes where the Civil War was taught,
00:01:58.680 and this was the first time she'd heard this information about Tubman,
00:02:01.920 which is why today's episode is on this very information.
00:02:05.780 Education on Harriet, at least for my students,
00:02:08.240 seems to begin with her escape from slavery and end with the Underground Railroad,
00:02:12.460 and those are, in themselves, admirable and heroic stories,
00:02:16.280 but it's also not where her story ended.
00:02:19.220 Born into slavery in 1822 in Maryland, Harriet was one of nine children.
00:02:23.860 She escaped to the North in 1849.
00:02:26.360 On a side note, because she was enslaved in Maryland, had she still been enslaved at the
00:02:30.960 time of the war, she would not have been freed by the Emancipation Proclamation, which only
00:02:35.920 freed slaves within states in rebellion against the United States.
00:02:40.560 Maryland was one of four slave states, including Delaware, Kentucky, and Missouri, which did
00:02:45.120 not secede from the Union.
00:02:46.900 When you think about it, this is one of the more ridiculous parts of the Emancipation
00:02:50.560 Proclamation.
00:02:51.680 Lincoln's Secretary of State, William Seward, who would have a very close relationship with Harriet Tubman in the following years,
00:02:58.000 sarcastically summed up the issue this way,
00:03:00.260 We show our sympathy with slavery by emancipating slaves where we cannot reach them and holding them in bondage where we can set them free.
00:03:09.120 But Harriet, like so many of the enslaved, didn't wait for the war.
00:03:13.200 She escaped to freedom 13 years before the Emancipation Proclamation would tie the issue of slavery directly to the Union's cause for fighting.
00:03:21.100 But Harriet wasn't satisfied with simply escaping slavery and starting her new life in Philadelphia.
00:03:26.640 For the next several years, she would risk her life and freedom going back to Maryland at least 13 times to help guide other slaves,
00:03:33.440 many of them her own friends and family, to freedom as a conductor for the Underground Railroad.
00:03:38.380 All in all, she rescued around 70 people on those trips,
00:03:41.940 though later numbers by her biographer, Sarah Bradford, would inflate those numbers to 19 trips and over 300 people.
00:03:48.620 Of her work, it is said that Tubman had this to say
00:03:51.840 I was the conductor of the Underground Railroad for eight years
00:03:55.200 And I can say what most conductors can't say
00:03:57.500 I never ran my train off the track
00:03:59.600 And I never lost a passenger
00:04:01.120 John Brown and Harriet Tubman met for the first time
00:04:04.340 In April of 1858 in St. Catharines
00:04:06.880 On the Canadian side of Niagara Falls
00:04:08.980 Brown, awestruck at meeting Tubman
00:04:11.540 Dubbed her General Tubman
00:04:13.500 And referred to her as one of the best and bravest persons on the planet
00:04:17.660 Abolitionist Wendell Phillips wrote,
00:04:19.500 The last time I ever saw John Brown was under my own roof, as he brought Harriet Tubman to me, saying,
00:04:24.900 Mr. Phillips, I bring you one of the best and bravest persons on this continent, General Tubman, as we call her.
00:04:31.260 In 1859, Tubman would play a key role in helping Brown plan his famous, but ill-fated, raid on Harper's Ferry.
00:04:37.820 She used her geographical knowledge of the Mid-Atlantic region and helped raise funds in Boston for the raid.
00:04:43.780 Brown's raid on Harper's Ferry was a failure, but ultimately an important moment in building tensions between the North and South.
00:04:50.080 Tubman said, after Brown's death, that he had done more in dying than a hundred men would in living.
00:04:55.920 A count of 70 freed souls and her aid on the Harper's Ferry raid would be more than enough to give her general credentials in my book.
00:05:02.460 But when the Civil War begins in 1860, her work on the Underground Railroad shifted into something that gave Brown's nickname for her even more literal a meaning.
00:05:11.500 Her involvement with the Civil War started out in the more traditional role that women tended to play in military camps, as a nurse and a cook.
00:05:19.040 In early 1862, Tubman traveled to South Carolina to provide badly needed nursing care for African American soldiers and civilians.
00:05:26.620 However, soon she also began serving as a spy and a scout behind Confederate lines.
00:05:31.020 She recruited escaped slaves to act as river pilots, spies, and scouts as well.
00:05:35.520 This group of spies were able to undermine the Confederates, liberate many enslaved African Americans,
00:05:40.860 and destroy goods and the property of plantation owners and the Confederate Army as well.
00:05:45.800 Dressed as a field hand, she led scouting and spying missions to identify and map the locations of Confederate mines, supply areas, and troops.
00:05:54.220 Tubman delivered the information all to Union Colonel James Montgomery,
00:05:58.060 commander of the 2nd South Carolina Volunteer Infantry, to support military operational planning.
00:06:03.480 It was with Colonel Montgomery that one of the largest successes of Tubman's career came on June 1, 1863.
00:06:10.980 This one mission destroyed millions of dollars of Confederate property, freed more than 700 slaves,
00:06:16.980 and made Harriet Tubman the first woman to lead an armed military operation in the United States.
00:06:22.420 This was the raid on the Combahee River Ferry.
00:06:25.260 The Combahee River is a short river in the southern Lowcountry region of South Carolina.
00:06:30.180 It bordered and supplied the water for some of the largest and most productive rice plantations in the state.
00:06:36.000 Or it did until the Union soldiers torched them all with Harriet Tubman's help.
00:06:40.740 Union Colonel James Montgomery was an abolitionist who really put his money where his mouth was on the topic.
00:06:46.380 He was well known during the Civil War for liberating slaves during his raids,
00:06:49.880 as well as burning and looting the goods and properties of the pro-slavery populations he encountered.
00:06:55.200 Montgomery was authorized to raise a regiment of African-American infantry in January of 1863
00:07:00.420 that would become the 2nd South Carolina Volunteer Infantry Regiment,
00:07:04.580 which would accompany Tubman and himself on this raid.
00:07:07.800 June 2nd, 1863, at around 3 o'clock in the morning,
00:07:11.500 two ships, the Harriet A. Weed and the USS John Adams,
00:07:15.040 arrived at the mouth of the Combahee River at Fields Point.
00:07:18.320 Small detachments of the 2nd South Carolina Regiment were sent to drive off Confederate soldiers,
00:07:22.900 while the other two ships continued upriver to Nichols Plantation, where the gunboat Harriet A. Weed anchored.
00:07:29.320 Carrying the remainder of the 2nd South Carolina Infantry and Tubman, the USS John Adams went upriver to the Combahee Ferry.
00:07:36.820 Here I will read from Sarah Bradford's biography of Harriet Tubman.
00:07:41.360 The word was passed that these were Lincoln's gunboats come to set them free.
00:07:45.940 In vain, then, the drivers used their whips in their efforts to hurry the poor creatures back to their quarters.
00:07:50.880 they all turned and ran for the gunboats they came down every road across every field just as they
00:07:56.620 had left their work and their cabins women with children clinging around their necks hanging to
00:08:01.400 their dresses running behind all making at full speed for lincoln's gunboats i never see such a
00:08:07.520 sight said harriet we laughed and laughed and laughed here you'd see a woman with a pail on
00:08:12.000 her head rice smoking in it just as she'd taken it from the fire young one hanging on behind one
00:08:17.720 around her forehead to hold on, another digging in the rice pot, eating while they ran. Hold of
00:08:23.000 her dress, two or three more. Down her back, a bag with a pig in it. One woman brought two pigs,
00:08:28.260 a white one and a black one. We took them all on board, naming the white pig Beauregard and the
00:08:33.100 black pig Jeff Davis. And so they came pouring down to the gunboats. When they stood on the shore
00:08:38.280 and the small boats put out to take them off, they only wanted to get in at once. After the boats
00:08:42.860 were crowded, they would hold on to them so they would not leave the shore. The oarsmen would beat
00:08:47.300 them on their hands, but they would not let go. They were afraid the gunboats would go off and
00:08:51.560 leave them and all wanted to make sure of one of these arcs of refuge. At length, Colonel Montgomery
00:08:57.340 shouted from the upper deck above the clamor of appealing tones, Moses, you'll have to give them
00:09:02.480 a song. Then Harriet lifted up her voice and sang. The song Harriet sang, according to Bradford's
00:09:08.580 biography, was a few bars of a popular Yankee song known as Uncle Sam's Farm, of which I am
00:09:14.140 providing a recording, because I'm sure as hell not going to try to sing it.
00:09:44.140 away. Oh, come to this country and have no fear of harm. Our Uncle Sam is rich enough to give us
00:09:53.080 all a farm. Somewhere between 700 to 800 slaves were freed on this one raid. Numbers differed
00:10:00.720 slightly depending upon the source. In addition, houses and barns and railroad bridges were burned,
00:10:06.260 railroad tracks were torn up, torpedoes destroyed, and many of the freed African Americans would join
00:10:11.380 the Union Army as well. Of the raid, newspapers had quite a lot to say. For instance, in the
00:10:17.120 pro-Union Commonwealth newspaper, they said,
00:10:41.380 receiving a scratch. It was a glorious consummation. The colonel was followed by a speech from the
00:10:46.300 black woman who led the raid and under whose inspiration it originated and conducted. For
00:10:51.340 sound sense and real native eloquence, her address would do honor to any man, and it created a great
00:10:56.580 sensation. That's pretty good coverage. I mean, it would have been nice if they had named the woman
00:11:00.820 in question, but still, for its day, pretty progressive. The pro-Confederacy Charleston
00:11:06.420 Mercury had a slightly different take, spending most of their article recounting all of the
00:11:11.360 goods burned or looted and naming all of the poor poor plantation owners who'd been wronged by the
00:11:16.560 bad bad union. You can tell how sympathetic I feel to their terrible plight. The raid was enormously
00:11:23.100 successful and the union would go on to adopt the tactics used for future operations. The Combahee
00:11:29.200 Ferry raid proved the value of black troops in combat and demonstrated Harriet Tubman's
00:11:33.720 intelligence and bravery. Reporting on the raid to Secretary of War Edwin Stanton, a union general
00:11:39.040 said this this is the only military command in american history wherein a woman black or white
00:11:44.920 led the raid and under whose inspiration it was originated and conducted it's unfortunate that
00:11:50.540 despite her many years of service and incalculably beneficial work for the union tubman would not be
00:11:56.300 recognized for her military service ever during her lifetime many people worked to petition the
00:12:02.120 government on her behalf including secretary of state william seward who bradford said exerted
00:12:07.620 himself in every possible way to procure her a pension. Bradford sums up the situation far more
00:12:13.320 eloquently than I could. It is a shame to our government that such a valuable helper as this
00:12:18.440 woman was not allowed pay or pension, but even was obliged to support herself during those days
00:12:23.720 of incessant toil. Officers and men were paid, indeed many enlisted from no patriotic motive,
00:12:29.740 but because they were insured a support which they could not procure for themselves at home.
00:12:33.620 But this woman sacrificed everything and left her nearest and dearest and risked her life hundreds of times for the cause of the Union without one cent of recompense.
00:12:43.560 She returned at last to her little home to find a scene of desolation, her little place about to be sold to satisfy a mortgage, and herself without the means to redeem it.
00:12:52.980 Bradford's biography of Tubman's life, published in 1869, would bring Tubman around $12,000 in funds,
00:12:59.280 and many of her friends and supporters from the days of her abolition work would raise funds to
00:13:03.920 support her as well. In 1874, Representatives Clinton McDougal of New York and Jerry Hazleton
00:13:10.020 of Wisconsin introduced a bill to pay Tubman a $2,000 lump sum for services rendered by her to
00:13:16.720 the Union Army as scout, nurse, and spy, but it was defeated in Senate. The Dependent and Disability
00:13:22.920 Pension Act of 1890 made Tubman eligible for a pension after her second husband, Nelson Davis,
00:13:28.620 a Civil War veteran, died of tuberculosis on October 14, 1888. In 1895, Tubman was granted
00:13:36.220 a monthly widow's pension of $8 a month. In December of 1897, New York Congressman Serena
00:13:42.360 Payne introduced a bill to grant Tubman a soldier's monthly pension of $25 a month.
00:13:47.640 Congress received documents and letters to report Tubman's claim on her work as a soldier,
00:13:52.120 but despite the vouching of people like Brigadier General Rufus Saxton and others,
00:13:56.340 some members objected to a woman being paid a full soldier's pension, because of course they
00:14:01.840 fucking did. One has to wonder how much any of them actually did during the war.
00:14:07.540 One of the members of the committee who blocked Tubman's $25 pension was W. Jasper Talbert of
00:14:12.640 South Carolina, so you can imagine his reasons for doing so. In February of 1899, Congress approved
00:14:19.940 a compromise amount of $20 per month, which was actually $8 a month for the widow's pension and
00:14:25.660 twelve dollars for her service as a nurse, but they refused to acknowledge her service as a scout
00:14:30.560 and a spy, and let's face it, a military officer. Surrounded by friends and family members, she died
00:14:36.920 of pneumonia on March 10, 1913, was buried with semi-military honors at Fort Hill Cemetery in
00:14:44.280 Auburn, New York, where she had lived with her family on land purchased from the Secretary of
00:14:48.820 State Seward family in 1859. She never did what she did for the accolades, as far as I can tell,
00:14:55.660 which is really why she deserved far better than what the country she fought for gave her.
00:15:01.000 In 2023, the Army Surgeon General and Army Chaplain Corps hosted a ceremony in Washington to honor her.
00:15:07.520 And earlier this year in Philadelphia, a statue of Tubman titled
00:15:10.900 A Higher Power, The Call of a Freedom Fighter was approved by the Philadelphia Art Commission to be placed outside City Hall.
00:15:18.300 Artist Alvin Petty said that it was inspired by this very raid on the Combahee Ferry
00:15:22.580 and will be larger than life, standing 15 feet tall,
00:15:26.100 a timely reminder of the struggles faced to truly make this country
00:15:29.500 something approximating a land of the free.
00:15:32.160 Because yes, Nikki Haley, there is systemic racism in America,
00:15:36.080 and there always has been.
00:15:38.020 I'll close here with a letter to Harriet written by Frederick Douglass.
00:15:42.440 Most that I have done and suffered in the service of our cause has been in public,
00:15:47.060 and I have received much encouragement at every step of the way.
00:15:50.000 you on the other hand have labored in a private way i have wrought it in the day you in the night
00:15:56.020 i have had the applause of the crowd and the satisfaction that comes of being approved by
00:16:00.540 the multitude while the most that you have done has been witnessed by a few trembling scarred and
00:16:05.360 foot sore bond men and women whom you have led out of the house of bondage and whose heartfelt god
00:16:10.820 bless you has been your only reward the midnight sky and the silent stars have been witnesses of
00:16:16.480 your devotion to freedom and of your heroism much that you have done would seem improbable to those
00:16:21.680 who do not know you as i know you your friend frederick douglas thank you for tuning in to
00:16:27.380 hear me bitch about history if you're loving the show don't forget to subscribe and make sure to
00:16:31.140 visit bitchy history.com to sign up for the newsletter the newsletter offers extra resources
00:16:35.540 on the topics covered in all of our episodes as well as on the topics covered in my videos on
00:16:40.180 tiktok supporting the podcast is really easy spread the word to your friends grab some fabulous
00:16:44.800 bitchy history merch off our website or consider becoming a paid subscriber your support means the
00:16:49.480 world to us history history history history history what a bitch right