Culture Study Podcast - July 26, 2026


BONUS EPISODE: The 'Woke' Little House on the Prairie... Kinda Works??? [preview]

How to Fall in Love with a City The Case For Quitting

Episode Stats


Length

10 minutes

Words per minute

157.12

Word count

1,709

Sentence count

65

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 Hi, everyone. Welcome to a bonus episode of the Culture Study Podcast. I am your host,
00:00:05.660 Anne Helen Peterson, and I have two co-hosts with me here today. First is Margaret H. Willison,
00:00:12.740 the Culture Study Librarian, currently neck deep in Andy Cohen memoirs for our next issue of
00:00:22.160 Zeitgeist Syllabus. And we are additionally joined by my dear friend from college and also
00:00:29.480 Vastly more impressive person, Catherine Van Arendam.
00:00:33.160 Catherine, do you want to tell them why you matter?
00:00:35.900 I can't imagine mattering more than being one of your longtime closest friends.
00:00:41.740 But I am a culture writer at Vulture.com, which is part of New York Magazine.
00:00:51.020 And oh, and I have a podcast.
00:00:52.660 Actually, I have a new podcast that I do with my friend Alan Sepinwall, who is a longtime TV critic.
00:00:59.880 It's called TV is Good.
00:01:01.620 So those are places where you can go and find me and all of the things that I do.
00:01:07.020 I always am afraid to admit that I don't listen to a lot of podcasts, but that is a podcast that I would really, really like to listen to because I admire your work so much.
00:01:16.160 I admire Alan's work so much like that.
00:01:18.840 And I like hearing about TV, especially when it's not just dudes talking about TV, which is hard to find.
00:01:24.280 Only 50% dudes.
00:01:26.000 It's a great ratio.
00:01:27.480 It's an unusual ratio.
00:01:28.660 And it's a fun podcast also because Alan and I have a, I think, a really good Venn diagram of TV taste where there are some things that overlap perfectly and some things that are completely opposite.
00:01:43.960 And so sometimes it's just us being like, yes, of course, this is the best thing we've ever seen.
00:01:48.200 But then also it's like me attempting to explain what Love Island is to him and him just being deeply, deeply baffled.
00:01:55.860 But he then also has this incredible long encyclopedic memory.
00:02:00.500 So I'm really looking forward to an upcoming episode where he is going to explain to me something called Mrs. Columbo, which I have no familiarity with, but I'm very excited to learn.
00:02:14.000 that sounds like some incredible gen x nonsense yeah uh today we're talking about the netflix
00:02:22.580 adaptation of little house on the prairie which came out by the time this episode comes out it
00:02:28.760 will have been released about a week and a half two weeks ago it's already doing very well on the
00:02:34.580 platform which a lot of premiere seasons do very well on netflix and then drop off and are never
00:02:40.800 heard from again but that's another conversation uh we're gonna start by discussing a little bit
00:02:47.720 of our little house positionality because katherine does this in her review of the
00:02:54.020 series katherine actually was the person who saw screeners and then texted margaret who texted me
00:03:00.300 to say uh the new little house is actually pretty good yeah yeah yeah i think it was something like
00:03:06.720 The new little house whips was made in the text that I got.
00:03:10.480 And I was like, well, I'm.
00:03:11.500 And I was dubious.
00:03:12.800 I was so dubious.
00:03:14.360 Of course.
00:03:15.740 How could you not be deeply, deeply concerned about the words like there's a new little house on the prairie?
00:03:23.420 If you weren't deeply concerned about there being a new little house on the prairie and its quality, you might be disappointed by this one.
00:03:31.900 Yes.
00:03:32.200 Right.
00:03:32.760 Because its positionality is very interesting.
00:03:35.280 But Catherine, what's your relationship with Little House on the Prairie?
00:03:39.640 So as I wrote about in the essay that I did for New York Magazine, I grew up having these
00:03:47.720 books read out loud to me by my mother.
00:03:51.660 It was, it would probably have been 1993, 1994 when she was reading them.
00:03:57.580 And she read most of the series out loud to me and to my younger sister.
00:04:04.380 And I remember loving them very, very much. I grew up in southwest Michigan, so it was not exactly this area of the country, but it was certainly familiar to me to sort of big rural open spaces and how easy it is to be very, very far away from anything else.
00:04:24.180 And I was an American girl, kid also, so there was a lot of overlapping interest in the kind of material culture of the 19th century and rural 19th century places, 100% spoons.
00:04:43.280 And so I loved hearing these books get read aloud.
00:04:50.940 I was obsessed with, you know, all of their descriptions of digging wells and building doors and how much ribbons cost.
00:04:59.960 And my experience was that my mom argued back to these books all the time.
00:05:08.820 she was um as fascinated as i was by the descriptions but she was also as she would
00:05:16.180 read she would be like why is pa doing this what is he thinking why would they ever be so far from
00:05:21.560 town that makes no sense how are they going to survive i remember the descriptions of how pa
00:05:28.700 could um encircle ma's waist with his two hands and her being like oh and i was like
00:05:35.620 ridiculous diet culture just like yes right there yes and i remember being and corsets i remember
00:05:45.680 that was like a long thing about corsets that she went off on and and so my whole i mean it's like a
00:05:53.560 obnoxious way of saying this but my experience of these books was dialectical from the beginning
00:05:58.740 right yes my mom read them as well although this is like so funny to me my dad popped in and read
00:06:10.040 farmer boy oh wow funny yeah i was like did he also read you little men no we did not that was
00:06:20.100 like the only book that i think my dad read to me in full like sometimes he would read you know the
00:06:25.040 chapters of whatever books we were on but all the responsibility was ceded to my dad
00:06:30.740 which is such a weird like people don't talk about it really like there are all these like
00:06:36.820 these um canon and non-canon books actually within this larger series like what my mom actually the
00:06:44.580 first time I can remember someone saying essentially that something was non-canon is
00:06:49.180 her talking about the books that were released posthumously that were um written by laura
00:06:57.380 about their life after the fact and my mom's like it doesn't really fit she didn't really
00:07:02.780 you don't know if she wanted it to be published it's not really up to the same quality you
00:07:07.280 shouldn't read it um i don't remember her as many interjections from her but she was so
00:07:14.340 so into interjections like she made me watch mtv with her that was the only way i could watch mtv
00:07:20.800 and i have like such a vivid memory of watching counting crows video for mr jones and they have
00:07:27.220 like a flamenco girl in the back because there's that that lyric and my mom's like do you see what
00:07:32.400 they're doing that's objectifying or like with little mermaid she's like why do you think she 0.99
00:07:38.880 loses her voice so i actually i i'll have to have a discussion with her about whether she did this
00:07:48.740 but i do love this the way that the books to kids just feel like oh my gosh they're having so much
00:07:54.660 fun and if you revisit them as adults you're like pa was a dilettante like like he could not
00:08:03.520 Gabriel Bronson Alcott.
00:08:05.240 Yes.
00:08:05.780 Oh, my God.
00:08:08.480 Yeah.
00:08:08.780 Bronson Alcott had had, like, a little bit more get-up-and-go energy, you know?
00:08:12.320 Yeah, Bronson was committed.
00:08:14.040 Like, Pa could not stick it out, and he was just perpetually being, like...
00:08:18.560 Bronson was rooted.
00:08:19.920 Bronson wasn't necessarily committed.
00:08:21.640 Fair enough.
00:08:22.420 Fair enough.
00:08:23.400 Margaret, did you read these as a kid?
00:08:25.220 So, no, I did not read these as a kid.
00:08:27.060 Or, I should say, I think I probably read Little House in the Big Woods when I was very
00:08:31.820 small and the only thing i remember is the description of making like maple candy by like
00:08:37.960 extracting the syrup and putting it in the snow and i mean like that's the kind of thing it's like
00:08:41.960 of course that's the detail i remember because that's what these books are in so many ways uh
00:08:47.800 and then i read little house on the prairie as an adult for my children's literature classes in
00:08:54.120 library school and i was like both i was like wow i 100 see the appeal of this narrative and
00:09:02.200 these books like they're really really well written really well crafted and then also
00:09:08.520 i understand why people have so many problems with them yes yes and it's so interesting to
00:09:16.220 watch this series um are we like what is our policy on spoilers here I mean I think I think
00:09:25.980 we could talk about spoilers because it's not like there's anything out for a minute you know
00:09:31.460 the books have been a hundred years yes so it's like I read this and I knew I when when at the
00:09:40.440 end of this season they are forced to pack up and leave independence and move on to yet another 0.97
00:09:47.140 homestead i it wasn't a complete surprise to me but i was also like what the fuck yeah 0.88
00:09:54.820 i'm so team uh ma's sister eliza being like come home have your baby in a civilized place 0.97
00:10:06.220 where a doctor will be able to reach you 1.00
00:10:08.520 and not stopped by a snowstorm
00:10:10.020 you have community why are you moving
00:10:12.600 to this place
00:10:13.340 so the show
00:10:16.640 was announced
00:10:17.780 I don't know like a while ago
00:10:20.700 and there were
00:10:22.720 there was pre-discourse
00:10:24.460 about how it was going to be woke
00:10:26.880 and Megyn Kelly I believe
00:10:28.580 said like if you ruin
00:10:30.380 Little House on the Prairie I'm gonna like
00:10:32.580 ruin your life
00:10:33.660 yes yes yes yes
00:10:36.640 Okay, we're going to pause here.
00:10:38.060 If you want to hear the rest of this bonus episode, go to patreon.com slash culture study
00:10:43.120 to become a paid subscriber.
00:10:44.720 Super easy.
00:10:45.700 You can do it for the month.
00:10:46.520 You can do it for the year.
00:10:47.480 You can add on to your newsletter subscription.
00:10:49.800 Just do it and you can hear this whole fantastic conversation.