00:00:51.780So it fits right in with all of your other podcasts listening,
00:00:54.940Everything is there in one place. So if that is understandably something that has been keeping you
00:01:00.960from subscribing, that excuse is now gone. So head to culturestudypod.substack.com,
00:01:08.420sign up to be a paid subscriber, and then you can follow the instructions to get that special,
00:01:13.380exclusive paid feed in your favorite podcast app. All right. Thank you. On with the show.
00:01:19.520okay i want you to take a second close your eyes and when you think of the cheerleaders
00:01:26.160who's the one cheerleader whose face comes into your mind and can you just0.93
00:01:32.600that was gonna be my tf and can you describe their face sorry i jumped right in um dark brunette0.88
00:01:41.420hair i believe blue eyes really welcoming face only the only type of face that like a southern
00:01:48.000Christian family could raise that's like heart-shaped it's heart-shaped right that's like
00:01:53.840the right word for that like Reese Witherspoon yes oh that's so interesting I'd never even
00:01:59.280connected those two but yes the voice that comes out of her body matches with that face
00:02:04.760Sam who do you think of I think of and help me with the name the one who's about to go into her
00:02:11.760fourth or fifth year is the daughter of a Cowboys cheerleader Victoria Victoria and no matter what0.52
00:02:17.880she does and no matter how hard she tries the mean coaches kind of just haze her and never give
00:02:25.220her any shine yeah and she is having to walk through and suffer through a multitude of maladies
00:02:31.280and neuroses trying to make it work and it just never works for her it breaks my heart and i go
00:02:38.200to sleep thinking about her after i watch that show that poor baby
00:02:41.260this is the culture study podcast and i'm ann helen peterson i'm sam sanders and i'm zach
00:02:52.740safford and we are the hosts of vibe check today we are talking about the netflix show
00:02:57.380america's sweethearts dallas cowboys cheerleaders which i think of as just like the dallas cowboys
00:03:03.520cheerleaders show that's how i've been talking about it in shorthand we're trying to make this
00:03:07.700episode welcoming to people who have not seen the show, but know a few things about what a
00:03:14.720cheerleader for a football team, for a professional football team is, right? And the placement of the
00:03:20.640Dallas Cowboys cheerleaders in particular in the American zeitgeist. So can either of you,
00:03:26.180this is a huge challenge. I'll give you a present. I don't know, like, I'll give you some of the 60
00:03:30.900degree weather that we have here right now. If you can summarize what the show is about.
00:03:37.080America's Sweethearts follows the journey of one crop of Dallas Cowboy cheerleaders for one season, from auditions to the end of the football season.
00:03:50.300you see many different types of women some returning cheerleaders some doing it for the
00:03:57.160first time ever but in watching their journey you begin to understand over the course of the
00:04:03.120seven or eight episodes that the dallas cowboy cheerleaders is a beautiful smiling heavily made
00:04:13.220up cult that's my description of this show i yes it is a cult there's like a cult-like behavior to0.99
00:04:22.880this entity that is the dallas cowboys themselves and how these women do speak of working their
00:04:29.140jobs as if they are part of a religion that has to be respected and that they have to fit within
00:04:34.680in order to to survive in it so it does feel like a cult in many ways um yeah can i read the
00:04:40.840description of a DCC so my dear friend Caitlin Dickerson who covers immigration uh she took
00:04:49.060some time to write about this show for the Atlantic because she was obsessed with it as a
00:04:53.200former high school cheerleader and she paused the show when they show the handbook and they show the
00:04:59.740on the screen the page of the handbook that has the mission statement for what a DCC is can I just
00:05:05.640read it and it'll tell you everything you want to know. It says, quote, what am I? I am a little
00:05:11.420thing with a big meaning. I help everybody. I unlock doors, open hearts, do away with prejudices.
00:05:19.420I create friendship and goodwill. I inspire respect and confidence. Everybody loves me.
00:05:26.740I bore nobody. I violate no law. I cost nothing. Many have praised me. None have condemned me.
00:05:35.640i am pleasing to everyone i am useful every moment of the day oh my god i whoa i wow that
00:05:49.240that's a dystopian handbook like that's like yes yeah they i was listening to this um and i don't
00:05:58.640want to get this wrong i was listening to a podcast this morning before we all talked
00:06:01.420it's a podcast hosted by janine amapola and she had claire walford on who was a dallas cheerleader
00:06:07.520in the show and in it she's talked a lot about that mission statement and said whenever i walked
00:06:13.060into the locker room and felt myself being too critical of my body feeling too critical of like
00:06:17.260all the stress i was feeling from the dallas cheerleaders um i would say well who can i serve
00:06:23.120to make me forget about this and she was like they're being forced to go take care of someone
00:06:28.020else instead of taking care of themselves which is just so dark they say the last line i am useful
00:06:34.460every moment of the day yeah oh well they're useful because they have to have jobs outside
00:06:41.340of this other job in order to make a living wage and they can't like start dating the football
00:06:49.320players because fraternization is strictly prohibited then why join this team that would0.96
00:06:54.160be my whole reason for this like i'm marrying rich like what so yeah yeah i mean i it also
00:07:00.880seems to borrow so heavily from evangelical culture in terms of like the place of the woman in the
00:07:06.200home and like oh if you're if you're questioning your faithfulness in some way who do you go serve
00:07:12.500right like how do you serve god in that moment how do you serve the dallas cowboys and the greater
00:07:17.320world in that moment and usually at least as we see in the show that means like you go to a home
00:07:22.580for for the elderly or i don't know you sign an autograph while the the men involved have to
00:07:30.880hold the football so that they don't accidentally touch you in an appropriate way
00:07:35.360don't tempt your christian brothers yeah well and there's so much of it that feels so churchy
00:07:41.200because it's all so top down you know the two let's call them head coaches leaders of the team
00:07:46.600these are older women who were cheerleaders back in the day they embody the patriarchy is wonderfully0.94
00:07:54.080dressed heavily made up older women but they embody it and what i notice about the way that0.98
00:07:59.060they do things you know nothing is ever an assault on anyone's character they just euphemistically
00:08:07.700tell you they don't like you and they can't stand you by saying i don't know if those high kicks
00:08:13.020were high enough or i don't know if you were looking happy enough today there's this roundabout
00:08:18.120bless your heart way of in grouping and out grouping without ever saying it and that is so
00:08:24.480church that is so church the pastor's never going to say i just don't like you they're going to find
00:08:30.500some rule to say that you violated and that's how you know yeah you're too short yeah like that
00:08:36.480poor girl who gets cut for being like how tall i think she was probably like five two or something1.00
00:08:42.640like that which is usually prized in most types of cheerleading but not in this one but like with1.00
00:08:47.960but like so like with victoria this was the one who keeps trying it keeps trying and she never
00:08:52.400kind of makes it they do all these things to tell her they find her annoying without saying they
00:08:58.800find her annoying yeah that's all their feedback and they just mask it in this other language the
00:09:04.140masking of the real feedback the masking of how you feel that is so church to me that's so cult
00:09:09.340to me oh oh 100 and like we learn over the course of the show that like she has gone through so much
00:09:19.380and has been a main figure in like the previous dallas cowboys cheerleader shows but here she is
00:09:26.080trying to figure out her way we're not going to do any spoilers into like is she going to try out
00:09:30.460for another year is she going to make it this year like what's going on what how would you describe0.78
00:09:34.800her look her look is in every way begging for acceptance she's begging for these coaches to
00:09:41.040love her she's begging for the crowds to love her and all of her beauty and energy and light
00:09:47.460is hidden behind that anxiety it breaks my heart uh yes and also can we this won't spoil anything
00:09:54.820but her interview set up in her bedroom how was that bed the entire width of the room and what
00:10:00.900type of bed is it like it also it like blocks her shelving there's like a lot of questions i have
00:10:05.100around design there too the maison sun the maison sun like the like the way that they shoot all of
00:10:12.580these different characters you can tell like it's not a villain edit right it's a sympathy edit
00:10:17.320almost like the way that the way that her um bed becomes the entire room and she looks surrounded
00:10:24.260by like stuffed animals almost right like incredibly childlike and she's living in her
00:10:30.600mom's home like we get that message as well well and it's funny that you speak to this sympathetic
00:10:36.460edit all of the reviews of this show compare these filmmakers work to previous shows they've done
00:10:43.120like cheer and what's the junior college football one was it last chance you which one is it yeah
00:10:49.020yeah and they this show has gotten these creatives their worst reviews ever because
00:10:54.420critics think that they sympathize too much with the subjects and I see it wow I see it
00:11:00.980that I like that I like that because I sympathize with them too these poor things yes these poor
00:11:08.240underpaid women we should sympathize with them like what are we doing yeah but it's also like
00:11:13.900very you know I grew up in the south like Sam I grew up in Tennessee watching the show felt like0.85
00:11:18.920a really problematic warm blanket for me because it reminded me of all the passive aggressive ways0.98
00:11:24.180the white women in my life would speak to me in this like loving and caring way but it was all1.00
00:11:29.260about controlling my my body controlling my role in our community controlling how i operated inside
00:11:35.840the church that we're a part of it was never really about me but the the things they were
00:11:40.460saying were about me but no one was willing to just fess up and be like i have this feeling about
00:11:44.040you and this is why you should change or whatever it's all masked in god religion the organization
00:11:48.780all these things which makes you feel kind of gaslit the whole time and these women all feel
00:11:53.480like they're super gaslit through this whole process well and you know they use a voice i
00:11:58.240think reese actually uses it more than anyone else but you can see it in the coaches as well
00:12:02.680and even in um charlotte jones the daughter christian baby girl it's christian baby christian
00:12:07.800funny voice right and we just we just recorded an episode uh with a former trad wife who does
00:12:14.440this incredible breakdown of fundy baby voice about how it's how you get what you want while
00:12:21.180still like being pleasing to everyone right so you incorporate this idea that like i'm not going
00:12:27.180to piss off any dudes but i'm going to wield my power get what i want yeah through this like be
00:12:34.060sweet right okay this is a good this is a good jumping off point to start our question so this
00:12:40.980first one comes from Allison. The show Cheer gave me the sense that cheerleaders are really
00:12:47.620athletes. America's Sweethearts talked about the athleticism of the women a ton, but I never really
00:12:52.680saw it displayed in a way that made sense. Like, why are these incredibly talented dancers, gymnasts,1.00
00:12:58.500etc., so enamored with being a cheerleader for this football team? Future career prospects,
00:13:03.240clout, or something else? I don't get it. Wow. Like, why is an orthodontist invested
00:13:09.680in becoming a Dallas Cowboys cheerleader?
00:45:58.600Now that I know, I'm worried about them and asking more questions about other kind of effective labor that you see pop up around really wealthy industries.
00:46:08.020Because I just, like many people, just I'm like, oh, everyone's getting paid.
00:46:13.960You know, one thing I was thinking about and they don't address, at least in this season in any capacity, is similar to Bama Rush.0.99
00:46:20.340I wonder if someone came in and had like a huge influencer following and was like making TikToks of the process if they would be wary of her because she has too much power.0.99
00:46:34.780Even in like an interview I was listening to today, one of the cheerleaders said she was asked on this season of the show to have a first date filmed.
00:46:42.820and the interviewer was like that would be so awkward to have a guy get a camera on him for
00:46:47.780the first date and her concern was that the guy may not be dcc approved enough to be on camera
00:46:55.100it wasn't about like her own desires or love but it was about the brand identity of the cowboys
00:46:59.760and does he fit into it and that just tells you everything about what about the like hallmark
00:47:05.260movie fiance that's engaged to the woman who just finished off her final year do you remember this
00:47:12.000guy oh yes yes the actor the he was an actor he's an actor and he's been in a couple hallmark movies
00:47:17.480and like moved to dallas for her yeah he quit his career now they're moving to la
00:47:22.560so that he can chase his dreams and she's like i it's now his time to have his dreams fulfilled
00:47:28.160like i had mine and i was like i'll never be married because i'll be god damn if i take a
00:47:34.160year off myself this guy is like i will be on this show i am thrilled to be on this show whereas
00:47:56.840This is again about passion work and this comes from Kelly.0.95
00:47:59.340After watching the docuseries, I perceive DCC as a pseudo-cult devoted to upholding a particular kind of outdated feminine ideal.
00:48:10.600My question is, is there a masculine equivalent?
00:48:15.040In what context do men compete for a demanding job that pays very little in exchange for belonging to an in-group that grants them a coveted status?
00:48:25.240If there isn't one, why doesn't this kind of thing appeal to men the way it does to women?
00:48:33.440I love this question. And two things jump to mind immediately. The first, the only equivalent I can
00:48:38.640think of in the most like literal way are the Chippendales dancers. Those men make a similar
00:48:43.900salary. They're objectified in similar ways. They're kind of cultish. They have a very interesting0.78
00:48:48.720cultural experience that has been documented in that Hulu show, which wasn't that terrible,0.95
00:48:53.800but i enjoyed it and that's like the first one that comes to mind of like bodied gendered obsessed
00:48:58.640people but the one that really is floating underneath the surface for me that feels very
00:49:02.700similar in a surprising way are rupaul's drag race i was gonna say drag i was gonna say drag
00:49:08.900drag yes well sam why do you think drag because i have my thoughts so drag is extremely demanding
00:49:16.360not just physically but like as an expense it's very expensive to get the makeup right get the
00:49:21.180clothing right you're constantly traveling you may not get paid and for the most part most drag
00:49:27.060queens don't get rich doing it it's a side job but if you get it right you are beloved in every
00:49:34.000bar you walk into you're a part of a fraternity slash sorority you have friends for life and
00:49:39.440memories for life i think drag is a is a big one because like even though we see the successes
00:49:44.600from rupaul's drag race that is like less than one percent right yeah less than one percent i
00:49:50.040also think in response to this question like is there a matching equivalent it's actually football
00:49:54.440most football players don't make it most football players don't make the nfl and those that do get
00:50:00.720two or three seasons and they're injured for life i know so many kids that i grew up with playing0.75
00:50:05.640football thinking they were going to make it they didn't they fucked up their bodies and now they
00:50:11.120have a job that is tied in no way to football but they would do it all again yeah it was legible0.66
00:50:17.320glory to them right yeah yeah i mean i think it also back to what we were talking about in the
00:50:24.720beginning too there are ways in which people who are denied power in our society they take what
00:50:31.480they can get yes right so like what is a place where you feel the most power that you can feel
00:50:37.520is it on the drag stage is it on the like on the sideline as a cheerleader where do you get that
00:50:43.700power and you will do it whatever the cost might be because it is like your one chance to feel like
00:50:50.120a powerful white guy yeah and i think and this is a thing that i felt the entirety of watching this
00:50:56.960show this like inherent trait within all of us whether we admit to it or not we all actually
00:51:04.000at least some of our lives we love to be part of systems and structures that tell us exactly what
00:51:11.280to do there's something comforting and affirming about being in a system like the cowboys cheerleaders
00:51:18.180or professional football or high school football where there are scripts and there are roles and
00:51:22.300you do it and you can see someone who's done this before and then you do it too i was in marching0.63
00:51:27.240band so i was like the queer hanger-on to the football industrial complex because the band
00:51:32.920kids were always just inherently queer coded but even that was a script they tell you how to do it0.55
00:51:38.580you see how to do it and they teach you and the time of my life when i felt the most connected0.86
00:51:45.320to other people ever was probably high school marching band these systems and structures give
00:51:51.500us something they give us belonging which means a lot yeah yeah i mean i the reason i wanted to
00:51:57.240be a cheerleader like most of it was that i wouldn't have to decide what to wear to school
00:52:01.880two to three days of the week that's real because you wear one of your cheerleading uniforms
00:52:06.480or your like hideous warm-ups that were like made out of like you know balloon material
00:52:13.020it's just so gross purple and gold but yeah like that especially in times when you feel like you1.00
00:52:20.620don't know what's next in your life right so that might be high school for these women like the0.63
00:52:25.760period post-college or in your early 20s like that is an incredible transitional period especially
00:52:30.940when there are these expectations in a place like texas around when you should be getting
00:52:36.380married and like what your relationship with your boyfriend should be like and all that sort of
00:52:40.780thing there is some structure where it's like the high kicks are always the high kicks the splits
00:52:44.940are always the splits that's it right do it right like you know exactly what you're doing on a
00:52:51.260saturday you have no free time yes because you're always practicing or doing your hair or maintaining
00:52:56.940your body in some other way and it doesn't give you a lot of time to be sad or to think about the
00:53:03.240world around you so this is church too this is church yeah and yeah the bow on all of this is
00:53:08.760the reason why it keeps you so busy and keeps you so focused on the community is that if you were to
00:53:12.260take a moment to break free like victoria is about to do hopefully you would then want to
00:53:16.860dismantle the whole thing so they have to keep you busy yes and that's why dcc remains to be
00:53:22.100a very beautiful cult yes yes well that's the word that's the engine right there that's the0.56