For The Wild - January 13, 2021


CAROL RUCKDESCHEL on Keeping Cumberland Island Wild ⧸217

Topics
OLÚFÉMI O. TÁÍWÒ on Climate Colonialism and Reparations ⧸216 TOM BUTLER on the Complexities of Large-Scale Conservation ⧸218

Episode Stats


Length

55 minutes

Words per minute

131.4

Word count

7,312

Sentence count

248

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

4

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 For the Wild podcast is brought to you in part by the Calliopeia Foundation and listeners like you.
00:00:05.720 Calliopeia supports projects interweaving spirituality, culture, and ecology.
00:00:11.160 We are grateful for their support and the support of grassroots contributions from listeners.
00:00:16.020 To learn more about the Calliopeia Foundation, visit calliopeia.org.
00:00:20.720 To make a donation to For the Wild, visit forthewild.world slash donate or support us through Patreon.
00:00:30.000 Hey, For the Wild community, Ayana here.
00:00:33.140 We're putting out a special invitation to all musicians who enjoy For the Wild's programming and would like to contribute.
00:00:39.860 If you're a record label or a musician, we'd love to work with you to showcase your music on the program.
00:00:46.060 If you think your music is a good fit, or you're even interested in creating something special for the show,
00:00:51.560 you can submit your tracks at forthewild.world slash submit dash your dash tracks.
00:01:00.000 Hello and welcome to For the Wild podcast. I'm Ayanna Young. Today I'm speaking with
00:01:18.420 Carol Ructichel, a biologist, naturalist, environmental activist, and author.
00:01:24.260 We depend on wild areas. We depend on the earth and its ecosystems, plants. I mean, just for survival, for our physical survival as well.
00:01:38.280 Carol shot the hooch with President Jimmy Carter, documented new species of lizards in the North Georgia mountains, and discovered that sea turtles were dying by the tens of thousands along the Georgia coast.
00:01:51.020 She has lived on Cumberland Island for over 40 years and was instrumental in the establishment of the Cumberland Island National Seashore and its ensuing wilderness designation.
00:02:02.720 Ruck de Shell has fought a lifelong battle with families like the Carnegies, Rockefellers, and Candlers, who thought of Cumberland Island as their personal playground and summer retreat.
00:02:12.760 well hello carol thank you so much for joining us today for those of the long time for the wild
00:02:26.520 listeners when it was called unlearn and rewild we did an interview with an author who wrote a
00:02:32.120 book about you so it's pretty incredible to now be speaking to you directly and i'm really looking
00:02:38.500 forward to diving into a conversation together well i look forward to being part of it really
00:02:46.520 flattered that that uh you you cared about a place like cumberland island absolutely yeah
00:02:55.100 it's a small wilderness but it's uh you know on the east coast we don't have too much
00:03:02.440 left. Right. So it makes it that much more important. Yes. Well, I'd like to introduce
00:03:11.460 listeners to Cumberland Island and why it is such an important place. And I wonder if you could
00:03:17.660 share with us the sounds, smells and experiences of Cumberland so listeners can ground themselves
00:03:24.600 in the islands, flora and fauna. And I know this small island is home to over 20 distinct
00:03:30.600 ecological communities, from salt marshes and maritime forests to coastal beaches.
00:03:36.640 So perhaps you could transport us to an area you are the fondest of.
00:03:42.760 I'm particularly fond of freshwater wetlands, as counterintuitive as it may seem,
00:03:51.160 being right there on the ocean. Usually with biologists, there's pretty much a division in
00:03:58.680 marine and terrestrial or freshwater. So even though I've been on the island and worked with
00:04:06.260 marine animals, the sea turtles and dead marine animals, my fondness is really for the freshwater
00:04:12.760 outlands of the island. But for most people, of course, it would be the rhythmic churn of the
00:04:20.960 ocean and lapping against the shore and the shorebirds screaming.
00:04:26.960 But inland, it's just as beautiful with the frogs singing and a lot of water, freshwater
00:04:37.140 birds and alligators and turtles.
00:04:43.120 And so that those are those are my favorite places.
00:04:48.800 Sounds amazing.
00:04:50.960 And yeah, because of Cumberland's incredible biological diversity, it is home to many rare
00:04:58.820 and endangered kin. Bobcats and coyotes roam on the land, bald eagles, American oyster catchers,
00:05:06.960 piping plovers, and least turns soar above. And the waters hold American alligators,
00:05:13.900 green sea turtles, and right whales, many of which are endangered. So having spent the last 40 years
00:05:20.920 on the island. I wonder if you could share some stories of kinship you've experienced with the
00:05:26.140 wildlife. Well, I'm not really a people person, so it just seems natural or comes natural that I form
00:05:36.860 more lasting impressions with the animals of the island. Yes, alligators are particular
00:05:46.360 favorites of mine as are sea turtles the bobcats were introduced the ones that are there now they
00:05:55.440 had died out on all the islands but the park reintroduced or introduced bobcats and also a
00:06:04.860 lot of new things like the coyotes and armadillos and things that appeared after i came so it's a
00:06:11.300 It's never ever changing, which makes it never at all moment over there.
00:06:16.400 Just when you think you got all the players lined up and you can really look at the ecology,
00:06:21.120 there's a new one arrives and throws everything into a spin again.
00:06:25.520 Got to plug in a new member.
00:06:28.360 So that's kept it interesting.
00:06:31.980 Yeah.
00:06:32.880 And what is the, you know, with all of this biodiversity, I wonder what the topography is like.
00:06:39.340 Like, you know, how does the island shift from different ecotones?
00:06:45.140 And, yeah, if you could just kind of take us through a visualization of what you see there and, yeah, the smells and how it feels.
00:06:58.240 Sure.
00:06:59.340 The island was not just made in one fell swoop.
00:07:05.000 So it was made over a long period of time.
00:07:08.980 And so there are differing, the topography is significant in places.
00:07:16.340 There are pretty serious hills in the middle, which were, of course, at one time dunes.
00:07:24.000 And then less so in the middle, in the older portions, where it's leveled off and they farm the land, which there's not too much sign of that left.
00:07:36.160 I mean, indirectly for an ecologist, there is because of the vegetation.
00:07:41.320 But but for the average person, there are trees on what world fields now.
00:07:47.160 And then the wetlands, of course, the newer, some newer additions along the paralleling the beach are freshwater sloughs in between ridges.
00:07:59.160 And there are several of those, I mean, side by side, which make sloughs and hold fresh water and are very exciting, much younger topography than the old hills and flatland in the middle.
00:08:14.040 And then on the other side of the island, the west side, where we've got the salt marsh.
00:08:19.320 And that's a vast level plain for the most part, of course, as everybody knows.
00:08:24.900 but and a totally different ecosystem than than any others so it's it's it's really it's an
00:08:32.800 exciting place if you're a biologist because you have your choices of so many different habitat
00:08:38.540 types yeah it sounds absolutely magical and you've spent most of your life gathering research
00:08:48.380 on sea turtles across the island spending time with thousands of leatherback green and loggerhead
00:08:54.500 turtles, all of which are endangered. And their potential extinction feels especially important
00:09:00.400 to mention because these kin are some of the oldest animal species on the planet,
00:09:05.380 dating back over 200 million years. Yet it has only taken a few decades for us to
00:09:11.880 decimate their populations. How is sea turtle nesting faring currently on the island?
00:09:18.080 yes it's really it's really been a pleasure seeing the numbers of nests go up when I first
00:09:28.760 came I don't think a single nest survived I mean I'd see them and mark them and go out and every 1.00
00:09:35.140 day they were all gone and that was because the island was overrun with hogs and there was I'd 1.00
00:09:42.280 say there was not a square yard inland that wasn't rooted up by hogs they were just everywhere 1.00
00:09:48.320 and of course the the island people couldn't well they would never tried to control them but still
00:09:55.700 populations of course especially on islands cycle quite a bit and at times of high hog populations
00:10:03.640 I mean they were very very abundant so they they put a lot of pressure on the sea turtles and that
00:10:12.560 was true on on most of our barrier our Georgia barrier islands and with the park since the park
00:10:20.360 service has come they've since got a person that that who's one of his primary duties is just to
00:10:27.960 to keep the hogs under control so they don't do that eat all the nests and they certainly don't
00:10:33.620 They've been, that attempt has been very successful.
00:10:38.380 And the conservation, other conservation of just, besides getting rid of the hogs or controlling the hogs, apparently you can't get rid of them. 0.51
00:10:49.260 But controlling them has been, I would guess, the most important thing for the sea turtles on all the Georgia islands.
00:10:58.620 Well, it's good to hear that you're seeing more nesting. And yeah, I'm thinking about that it was in 1976, you moved into your home on Cumberland Island, that you rebuilt with scavenged wood, and have since led a life that has led you to be profiled as, quote, the wildest woman in the United States.
00:11:25.440 And I'd like to ask you about this notion of wildness or perhaps your ethos of wild and what this has meant to you, especially growing up during a time when gender norms for women were incredibly rigid.
00:11:39.640 So can you speak to the importance of reinstating our feralness, especially in a society that attempts to breed the love of the wild out of us from a very early age?
00:11:50.900 yes and i yes and no uh by by that i mean i can certainly speak to it because i've always
00:12:02.820 said i'm i mean i know about feminism and all that and i've never felt like i really understood
00:12:11.840 that and and i think part of the reason was is that that i kind of didn't walk on the main path
00:12:18.200 I was off in the woods always. So I never really ran into any obstacles that say you can't do this
00:12:26.100 because I tried to do what I tried to do was away from everybody. So nobody there was nobody
00:12:31.940 stopping me or trying to stop me or I had no real model. I just knew what I loved. And so I just
00:12:41.060 went and did what i what i pleased um unlike people that have to fight to do if i wanted to
00:12:47.920 be a telephone lineman for example i know i would i know at that time i would have run into trouble
00:12:53.740 now maybe people have cleared the way and you could do a woman could do that but when i did it
00:12:59.320 all i wanted to do was get away from people and get out in the woods and why because it was just
00:13:05.260 I really I really can't explain why it was just that there was never any other way because I
00:13:11.760 didn't kind of didn't fit into to what I saw as the norm of of our society at least at that time
00:13:22.720 much better now yeah I can relate to some of those pieces and I'm wondering yeah if you
00:13:32.920 i'm just thinking about um the gender dynamics coming of age in the 50s and 60s and the
00:13:41.560 independence you found in rebuking dominant culture's expectations like so you were you
00:13:47.900 know i'm trying to imagine you back then when you're moving to cumberland island and saying
00:13:53.380 you know i'm going and um just the the courage that that may have taken at that point
00:14:00.520 oh yeah well I was terribly excited and I'd been there I'd been there with one of my professors
00:14:07.060 a couple times and I and so I knew it from one aspect and I always thought I'd end up in the
00:14:15.440 mountains where it's cool and the hills and everything and that was just sort of a without
00:14:21.260 thinking where I was going I mean I figured I'd end up there and then when the when the thought
00:14:27.760 of the going to Cumberland it was like oh well am I sure I can handle this you know being on an
00:14:34.220 island and in the hot and I was thinking I'd be up in the mountains and but after visiting at a
00:14:41.960 time or two of course I fell in love with it and I realized it's every bit as wild and there's every
00:14:47.200 bit as much to learn there as there is anywhere and that's that's the kind of thing that keeps
00:14:52.980 me going is just learning new things about any kind of natural things, about natural systems.
00:15:01.580 Yeah, many stories have been told about your lifestyle on Cumberland. And what this leads
00:15:08.080 me to really think about is how the love of land and place changes you. It can call you into a
00:15:15.220 certain type of fearlessness or remembrance that there are ways of being that exist outside of how
00:15:22.400 we are instructed to live. And I know many listeners probably struggle with the mentality
00:15:27.820 of feeling stuck within their rigid, industrialized lifestyle. But the life you've carved out on
00:15:34.980 Cumberland is a testament to the reality that you can create something else. So what initially
00:15:40.800 attracted you to Cumberland and how have you created this fruitful life within the margins?
00:15:46.400 i guess the main thing that attracted me to it was it became available and and i saw a job i
00:15:57.280 could take a job there and move there and have a place to live and i had to work but work is not an
00:16:03.020 issue i'm happy to work and and so it was just it was just wonderful and and it turned out it was
00:16:11.260 for three years and that was adequate time for me to realize that yes there are enough questions
00:16:18.280 here to be answered to keep me happy the rest of my life and basically that's what it was about
00:16:23.180 I mean besides loving the place and the and the wildness of it I mean it's far from pristine wild
00:16:30.000 it's just there aren't many people and that's that's what I found very pleasant
00:16:35.720 being here with you is like keeping my eyes open in the salty wind on the prowl of a fast boat
00:16:47.200 saying wide awake letting worlds and hearts break
00:16:53.100 stagging through my fields with the radio wall
00:16:56.640 well this city makes me crazy it's a midden heap full bones
00:17:05.340 and harsh opinions
00:17:06.480 all the money and the shame
00:17:08.560 and the pulsing
00:17:11.840 airless metro
00:17:12.860 burns under these streets
00:17:15.260 like so many ravaged arteries
00:17:17.760 and veins
00:17:18.840 ancient monuments
00:17:24.140 to a terrifying god
00:17:26.240 you fought a bar fight
00:17:27.740 beneath a glowing cathedral
00:17:29.520 oh the altitudes
00:17:34.320 and angles, gilded angels
00:17:36.400 tombs, heads rolling, panties
00:17:38.180 flashing in the dense and sweaty 0.98
00:17:40.600 bra.
00:17:42.080 Being here with you is like keeping
00:17:44.280 my eyes open in the salty
00:17:46.260 wind on the prowl of a fast
00:17:48.400 bone.
00:17:52.080 Staying
00:17:52.680 wide awake, letting worlds
00:17:54.240 and hearts break, staggering through my
00:17:56.500 field to the radio wall.
00:18:04.320 in 1955 the national park service recognized cumberland island as one of the most significant
00:18:22.060 natural areas in the u.s and by 1972 cumberland island was designated as cumberland island national
00:18:29.920 seashore, a unit of the National Park Service. But in preparing for our conversation, I was
00:18:36.220 reminded that only 5% of the United States is protected wilderness, and only 2.7% of that is
00:18:44.480 located in the contiguous United States. The rest is up in Alaska, which is a painful reminder
00:18:51.160 of how little wilderness remains and why it is so vital for us to stand for wild places across
00:18:58.200 this country. So currently, how much of Cumberland is protected under wilderness designation,
00:19:04.680 and what are the shortcomings of that designation?
00:19:10.400 Well, well over half of the island was initially congressionally designated as wilderness.
00:19:18.280 Unfortunately, local special interest groups removed some of that so that they could drive
00:19:27.640 commercial tours and things like that which is pretty sad for the general public for that to
00:19:34.320 happen and for anybody to kind of unilaterally do that but it happened nevertheless as we know
00:19:41.480 things happen and uh so the north end the beach and the main road was taken out of wilderness
00:19:50.160 so people could drive commercial tours around the island.
00:19:55.200 It happened in a really deceitful way.
00:20:00.740 It was a rider tacked on to an omnibus bill in 204
00:20:06.500 by a local congressman, which had been bought and paid for.
00:20:11.740 So that's what happened.
00:20:14.220 Now, the only good thing there is that I've been told
00:20:18.200 I'm not really a political person, too political, but I've been told that changing an act of Congress is not hard if you just want to totally repeal it.
00:20:29.420 But if you want to change it, then that presents a problem.
00:20:32.400 But if you want to repeal it, all you need is congressmen to introduce it, if they would support that.
00:20:37.800 So we're all hoping that we can get the wilderness put back together and taken away from special interests.
00:20:44.240 and then it'll be intact again and the beach will all be back in and in the north end and the main
00:20:51.420 road which would make for a much better longer term preservation as it is now it's it's just
00:20:58.300 yeah well it's been a mockery of wilderness truly so that's kind of sad but right now there's also
00:21:08.260 So, or maybe, maybe, I mean, the chances of changing it are looking better and better,
00:21:13.440 let's put it that way, of getting it back, putting it back together.
00:21:18.540 Well, that's good to hear.
00:21:20.000 And, you know, I was reading something about this, quote, potential wilderness.
00:21:25.120 And what does that mean for a place like Cumberland?
00:21:29.180 Well, I think all wildernesses, when they're established, go through that.
00:21:33.520 there are areas with non-conforming use like such as retained rights and things like that
00:21:39.960 um that that they just what all that means is when goes back all goes back to the the original
00:21:48.520 owner the government then it can then it can be wilderness but it also takes another act of
00:21:53.220 congress to put it in wilderness that's what i've been told so even though there may be a few places
00:22:00.060 that could be put back in it may be i don't know the reasoning behind it but i was always put off
00:22:06.400 when i ask about it that's the park service about it oh yeah so complex and nuanced land
00:22:14.960 designations and management and um yeah yeah don't get me started
00:22:20.540 i i hear that um you know you had mentioned something about tourism just a moment ago and
00:22:29.600 Cumberland has long had a history of being the playgrounds for wealthy families like the
00:22:35.100 Carnegies, Rockefellers, and Candlers, and currently the Carnegie family owns a commercial
00:22:40.620 hotel called the Greyfield Inn, where guests can stay and be driven around the island's wilderness.
00:22:46.920 And I mention this because tourism is still peddled as an alternative to extractive industry,
00:22:52.800 but Cumberland proves to be another example of the inherent exploitation that takes place
00:22:58.580 when people seek to make the wild profitable.
00:23:02.340 So can you speak to what occurred on Cumberland
00:23:04.500 when private interest sought to fragment designated wilderness
00:23:08.100 for the purpose of allowing vehicle tours?
00:23:11.060 And how was this one of the most substantial removals
00:23:14.440 and fragmentation of wilderness in U.S. history?
00:23:18.680 Well, it's really sad, and it probably comes, well, maybe not.
00:23:22.700 Y'all are more used to how we being our society, our culture works nowadays with big money running everything and more so every year, it seems like.
00:23:35.880 But that's what's happened to Cumberland.
00:23:37.600 I mean, it's pretty shocking to see the concessions made, the concessions that were for the American people, and then now they're made to other people for other reasons to make money.
00:23:54.580 And that's really disheartening.
00:23:56.780 I mean, I don't know how to fight that kind of thing.
00:23:59.660 I know those people.
00:24:01.140 And individually, they're mostly very nice people.
00:24:03.980 and and but but it's just um i don't know and and and i'm not rich so i i can't see it from
00:24:12.480 their standpoint i think that's what it would take but but i understand that it that it's
00:24:18.400 fact i've accepted that it's it's definitely fact that they uh influence the management of
00:24:25.220 Cumberland Island and yeah so maybe you could also explain how the tourism is impacting the
00:24:37.920 wilderness and yeah kind of give us a visual of this fragmentation because I think for many of
00:24:44.300 us growing up with national parks there's roads and honestly national forests and national you
00:24:51.420 know all sorts of public land and blm there's roads cutting through dirt roads roads for atvs
00:24:57.740 um so i'd really be interested to hear i guess it's kind of a two-part two-parter one about
00:25:04.240 this fragmentation of wilderness and how that disrupts a place and then we could kind of get
00:25:09.740 into the impacts of tourism and they're not necessarily one in the same well it's particularly
00:25:17.280 important on Cumberland because there's one road going from north to south that it's called the
00:25:24.000 main road and it's there are other side roads that were trails or were maintained when there
00:25:31.560 were old fields or people were running hog traps or whatever that are just there there's no pavement
00:25:39.900 over there understand so they're all dirt roads but the main road there's so much traffic now
00:25:45.160 that it's graded half the way by the by by by a big machine the park service has um because there's
00:25:53.220 a lot of traffic on the south end between where the visitors come over and especially plum orchard
00:25:59.600 big house about midway um but the the main road was taken out of wilderness obviously so they
00:26:08.820 could drive their commercial tours and as i explained that goes right up north south to north
00:26:16.260 on the main divides the island in two pieces so really there's a there's a cumberland island
00:26:22.240 wilderness west cumberland island wilderness east and then they took out the whole north end
00:26:28.300 because there's a little church up there and unfortunately that's the only
00:26:33.000 possible destination for most people because most people aren't interested in
00:26:38.980 in just a little view or a salt marsh or looking at bird they want to see something
00:26:45.080 human connected and so a little church and a little settlement up there that was
00:26:50.600 designed by by folks to uh help the hotel that was operating up there in the turn of the century
00:27:00.680 So you have that.
00:27:02.080 And then the commercial tours that now can go from the south end up to the north end, drive around the north end, and go out.
00:27:10.580 The nice way back is on the beach so people can see the beach.
00:27:15.280 And so then they had to take the beach out of wilderness.
00:27:17.860 So you can see the big circuit, the driving circuit.
00:27:22.080 That's particularly devastating for the wilderness.
00:27:24.740 And also in the legislation that removed those areas, they mandated that the park run bus tours to the north end.
00:27:38.120 And those now, they've been shut down because of COVID, but they will resume.
00:27:45.640 And that's devastating for somebody hiking up there.
00:27:49.160 And also taking the road out of wilderness allows bicycles to be up there.
00:27:54.200 So people have buses driving by them, bicyclists riding, and I've heard so many complaints.
00:28:02.640 I mean, it's really, it shatters people's experience to be passed by a bike or a bus.
00:28:09.220 There are also island people that have the right to drive there because they're going and coming, but they rarely do it.
00:28:15.500 It's like, I try to explain to people, it's like in your neighborhoods, you don't drive all the roads.
00:28:19.920 You have your little road to get to the grocery store or wherever you're going, and that's about it.
00:28:24.200 And that's how it is on the island. Most island people aren't driving up and down the island all the time.
00:28:29.720 You know, they'd rather not because of fuel.
00:28:33.620 And the bus tours going up twice a day is that that's pretty devastating.
00:28:38.900 yeah it's so important for us especially us as listeners to consider the impact of visiting places
00:28:48.280 and how we can connect to the wild that is left and also take care of these places it's
00:28:58.880 a conundrum you know it's um it's really challenging to interact and engage and not
00:29:05.860 disrupt even more and yeah I definitely don't have the answers for that at the moment and maybe
00:29:13.640 there never fully will be um it's so hard because we live such industrialized technologically
00:29:24.460 forward lives at this point especially in the United States so it's like when we're engaging
00:29:31.820 or interacting with these places we're not doing so in a really gentle way you know we're using
00:29:39.680 machines that are cars we're we're bringing in so much with us and so i i think that also makes
00:29:48.560 things challenging all of our modern needs as humans and how much we carry with us into these
00:29:57.040 places and leave behind because of that so um yeah and just our needs for access and it's it's
00:30:05.540 complicated it's really complicated yeah it's but and it's particularly sad that if if the
00:30:14.820 administering agency is not tuned or supportive of wilderness it's even worse for example
00:30:21.580 I had people come and tell me that they were camped at the northernmost campground on Cumberland Island, and it was dark, and somebody came up with a flashlight and warned them that there was a particularly heavy rainstorm coming and would they be all right.
00:30:39.920 Now, they were in the wilderness camping, understand. And somebody drove up and hiked in to tell them that. And they were really offended. And rightly so. I mean, they said, of course not. We're going to stay. And it was just a heavy rainstorm.
00:30:54.500 But that sort of thing, I don't know. I mean, I don't know how to fight that kind of thing. People that go and have experiences like that just need to advertise those experiences for other people. And so the Park Service will take heed and realize that people really do want to be alone. I mean, that should be a God-given right.
00:31:20.520 we all need it i think some of us more than others
00:31:27.060 yeah i do think there is a need for quiet and reflection and some of us um you know have
00:31:40.900 more access to it than others as well and and um how we're able to find that
00:31:47.260 source of connection even when we don't get to be in the wilderness I think is going to be
00:31:53.720 one of our deep inquiries as we move deeper and deeper into the Anthropocene and climate change
00:32:00.980 and who knows what else is coming for us so yeah this this deep inquiry of finding that type of
00:32:07.280 quiet spaciousness in an increasingly noisy world yeah yes and then the two things about
00:32:16.980 wilderness that people always ask about you know why is it significant and all that like you're
00:32:23.980 just saying it's so important to our well-being our physical mental well-being to know it's there
00:32:29.740 but but it is physical and mental in other words those people that were passed by buses and bicycles
00:32:36.380 when they presumed they were hiking in wilderness which they were it's just that it was on each side
00:32:41.880 of the road and it's not the road um we're devastated and their experience ruin but also
00:32:49.120 physically um we we depend on wild areas we depend on the earth and and its ecosystems plants i mean
00:33:01.340 just for survival for our physical survival as well and that seems to be forgotten because we
00:33:07.960 cause of artificial fertilizer, and that means we can make hundreds of thousands of more people
00:33:14.500 than the earth would normally sustain, and that sort of thing. We forget that it is physical
00:33:21.560 as well as mental or spiritual or whatever you call it, I think.
00:33:37.960 guitar solo
00:34:07.940 Your drunken limbs must just be aching
00:34:16.740 And you twist it up this way you planned
00:34:26.820 You're branching off, breaking your back
00:34:37.940 And man, oh man, the things you've seen, you've seen, embers flying on the tree.
00:34:57.460 Well, yeah, threats have long loomed over the island, ranging from development to extraction.
00:35:05.540 but currently you're facing a battle against the development of Spaceport Camden.
00:35:11.240 Can you begin by explaining what Spaceport Camden is and what threat it poses?
00:35:17.660 What is the risk of exploding rockets in terms of all inhabitants of Cumberland?
00:35:25.640 Well, I've gone through many NEPA reviews and comments on various aspects of things in the island and everything,
00:35:34.860 But the one for the spaceport, which is immediately opposite the north end of the island on the mainland with intervening salt marsh.
00:35:46.580 And then, of course, rockets will have to go over the salt marsh and waterways and then over the island to be even over the ocean.
00:35:56.100 That was was I don't know how to put it.
00:36:01.440 It's just that I could hardly understand it.
00:36:03.620 In other words, in that first environmental impact statement they did for the rocket launch, they just said, oh, campers, oh, yes, that would be a problem.
00:36:16.940 OK, we'll just call them authorized people and they can stay.
00:36:21.040 Oh, somebody living on Cumberland, the rockets, which, of course, are going to go directly over my house.
00:36:26.220 um oh well we can't it's illegal see they know that to to say i have to leave every time they
00:36:33.800 shoot a rocket because this is for a private enterprise enterprise and that would be a taking
00:36:39.960 and you can't just take somebody's property for that so they can't make me leave and so they just
00:36:46.240 would call me an authorized person which to me meant i was sacrificial i it was fine they could
00:36:53.500 do without me? And how that got by are NEPA people. But even worse now, and maybe I'm getting
00:37:03.500 this too confusing, but even now, NEPA has been emasculated so that they don't even have to have
00:37:12.020 public input. For example, back when that big, big four-inch, five-inch EIS statement came out,
00:37:20.740 they were going to use medium to large size rockets that's what they were planning to launch
00:37:28.680 and they had a certain failure rate this and everything which was apparently acceptable to
00:37:35.200 most people but now since they received so much that brought so much controversy that they
00:37:41.520 they've decided to go only with smaller rockets which have my understanding a 10 times greater
00:37:48.140 failure rate. Well, would you rather have more small ones or one big one? I guess that's what
00:37:56.080 it amounts to. But now the bad thing is they do not have to have any public input on that change
00:38:03.980 because of something the present political administration put in NEPA, just emasculated
00:38:11.660 NEPA, which is the Environmental Protection Act. So we're really, we, meaning the U.S. public,
00:38:20.300 really in a bad situation here. And not being political, I can't suggest a way out except for
00:38:28.480 people to get involved and learn about what's going on. And of course, there's a good website,
00:38:35.960 No Rockets Over Wilderness, which I will explain all the details of that.
00:38:43.840 And it just seems preposterous, and yet it's real.
00:38:48.640 It's like reading something in science fiction.
00:38:52.000 To me, especially because I'm right directly in the line of fire or under the line of fire.
00:38:57.880 But also, one more little tidbit is that less than eight miles to the south of where we're launching these rockets, and in other words, you can stand on the shore and see where they're going to launch and look down and see big buildings, and that's where we store nuclear warheads from Kings Bay Naval Submarine Base.
00:39:19.360 so there's just not a lot that adds up for me i'm a kind of common sense type person
00:39:25.640 and and have trouble when things are so illogical i just really really don't know how to even think
00:39:33.400 about it it's yeah yeah but but the answer is is for people to get involved i mean i've been
00:39:45.920 screaming so long that I'm stale you know they don't want to hear they just look at me and go
00:39:50.140 oh no here she comes again so you really need need fresh people new people uh out beating drums
00:39:59.720 absolutely I I'm all for that and oh yeah the NEPA process being gutted is
00:40:08.640 part of me wants to say it's shocking but it's not with how this country is governed but it's
00:40:18.320 something that we all really need to be concerned about and need to look into because it's taking
00:40:27.460 away our voice when it comes to managing our land and you know it's a huge deal for those of us
00:40:39.060 honestly for everybody but especially for those of us who love the land and don't want to see
00:40:44.440 more disruption and resource extraction and poisoning and stealing of the last bits of fresh
00:40:50.480 water for more extraction for what you know for 99 cent store crap like for what what are we doing
00:40:57.260 this for it's insane just thinking about the the chain of what all of this resource extraction and 0.75
00:41:04.500 all of this development leads to it just leads to more crap that we throw away in landfills halfway
00:41:10.280 around the world it's not for anything valuable and um and so it's yeah it's it's just it's
00:41:19.080 killing the earth to create trash i mean it's really insane so um yes it is but but but you
00:41:28.820 know the root of it all the elephant in the room that no one will speak of is why and it's because
00:41:35.840 we can because we have artificial fertilizers because we can feed more and more and more
00:41:41.980 and sustainability is not in much many of our vocabularies any longer it's growth growth growth
00:41:49.060 and that's not sustainable I hate to use the same word but it's not I mean we just can't keep doing
00:41:54.540 it we can't we're not they're not meant we're like rats in a cage it's an addiction it's a
00:42:00.300 it's been done it's been tested and you just can only put so many rats in a cage and the planet's
00:42:05.880 a cage well I think there's an addiction to growth and consumption and um and yeah breaking
00:42:16.540 that addiction and and realizing that this addiction is creating spiritual bankruptcy
00:42:22.680 in us and that this is a really a question about um a spiritual reckoning of coming back
00:42:31.060 home uh to ourselves and to this earth and and yeah but anyways i'm i could go down this
00:42:39.700 existential rabbit hole for hours um but i do want to get back to this spaceport camden and
00:42:45.340 It seems like supporters of Spaceport Camden argue that the project would bring in hundreds
00:42:51.720 of high-paying aerospace jobs to rural Georgia, which is somewhat of a fallacy seeing as other
00:42:57.800 projects have been unable to procure these results. But regardless, this highlights the
00:43:04.300 intricacies and increasing threat rural wilderness faces as the capitalist economy continues to
00:43:10.220 decline. So I'd just like to explore this topic with you a bit further in terms of
00:43:15.600 what bolstering rural economies means for wilderness preservation and how you define
00:43:21.880 true natural resources. Oh, wow. Well,
00:43:28.340 uh it's for for one well i know that there's a you stop it carol okay um sorry um it's it's it's
00:43:46.020 very true that that the the mainland opposite cumberland is fairly undeveloped it's there's
00:43:56.060 the one the place opposite the south end is becoming more and more developed getting houses
00:44:02.220 in other words the view from the island looking toward the mainland used to be just natural and
00:44:07.740 and it's no longer that if you see houses well camden county and most georgia counties put
00:44:15.640 very little value on any on any natural features they just don't see the value why do people want
00:44:24.340 to come to Camden County right now, it's because it's not so highly developed. And yet it's only
00:44:31.000 natural, according to our culture today, the people that work there in the Chamber of Commerce
00:44:36.940 and all that want more and more and more development for more and more and more people.
00:44:43.540 But they're missing the big part of it. They don't realize why people come to Cumberland even.
00:44:49.080 I mean, they keep wanting to raise the limit of people that can come to the island, the park does. And that will ruin everything. Just like the opposite land, opposite it, the park should be fighting, and I think they are against the spaceport, because it's going to, not because so much of the few jobs it's going to create, which I understand is simply a few jobs.
00:45:19.080 It's because we don't need that kind of development, if you will.
00:45:25.760 I mean, not only is it a threat to our nuclear resources, for crying out loud, but to the island and the whole area.
00:45:35.440 We've just got to get a better appreciation for undeveloped land.
00:45:44.560 And maybe that's what you mean by wilderness.
00:45:46.700 Of course, it's not wilderness over there.
00:45:48.580 There used to be big signs along the place where they've got the, where they're going to develop the spaceport or propose to develop it, saying, what did it say, danger, unexploded ordnance.
00:46:02.500 Well, whoa, what does that mean?
00:46:04.560 Well, the big Dow Chemical and other companies, I can't think of the other one, glycol, there are hazardous chemicals.
00:46:15.300 It's a it's a hazmat site over there and munitions all over there under the ground in places.
00:46:22.720 And yet that's where we're going to put this.
00:46:25.580 And how are they going to and they're not no proposal to clean it up that I've ever heard of.
00:46:30.500 So what does that mean to the waterways?
00:46:33.560 And on it, they're just so very many questions that that are unanswered.
00:46:41.160 And it's just in this big push to presumably bring more money into Camden County, which may or may not happen if everything went right.
00:46:52.900 So far, everything's gone wrong.
00:46:54.420 And we, me, a taxpayer, they're paying, we're paying the bills.
00:47:01.180 What, eight million, seven or eight million they've already spent trying to do this and nothing's been done?
00:47:09.160 I don't know.
00:47:11.160 Crazy flame burning through the night
00:47:32.040 A desert rider falling down from thirst
00:47:41.160 What passion must be keeping him alive?
00:47:49.100 The sand is humming hymns in the great white wind.
00:47:56.140 The sand is humming hymns in the great white wind.
00:48:03.880 He lays his bridle upon the dunes.
00:48:11.160 For a truism might fly from the horse's mouth
00:48:17.300 Does he love really, really and true?
00:48:27.560 Really, really and true?
00:48:32.040 Well, in 2018, the Federal Aviation Administration received over 15,000 public comments opposing
00:48:43.240 the project, yet the FAA decided to move forward with the project without any additional opportunity
00:48:48.640 for public comment. I understand that the FAA will issue its final decision for the launch site in
00:48:54.500 March of 2021, just a few months away. So for listeners who recognize the incredible importance
00:49:00.660 of this decision, what can they do? Without a public comment period, what can be done?
00:49:07.740 Well, they can go to that site I told you about, No Rockets Over Wilderness, that website,
00:49:13.300 and there's a place there to easily send letters and things like that and become familiar with
00:49:21.660 what's going on, that's about the best thing. I mean, until they come out with an EEA, I guess,
00:49:31.520 environmental assessment, even then, that doesn't mean anything, because there's no public comment
00:49:37.140 will be allowed, but unless there can be something done between now and then, who knows? I don't know.
00:49:44.180 I'm not that political to know whether anything could be or not.
00:49:50.160 Write to our senators, write to Georgia.
00:49:53.480 Georgia, the state supports it, of course.
00:49:57.520 I mean, Georgia's known to be a red state, but enough letters could change people's opinion.
00:50:09.240 Absolutely, yeah.
00:50:10.600 Yeah. Well, Carol, I hope this conversation has reminded our listeners that there are folks whose
00:50:17.540 homes are entire ecosystems and the launching of rockets across the island of Cumberland is no
00:50:24.320 different than if someone were to launch rockets within one's bedroom. So as we come to a close,
00:50:29.800 I'd like to ask you about what you've witnessed and the trends you've noticed because you've
00:50:36.580 committed yourself to one small bioregion since the 70s. What do you wish others would take stock
00:50:43.360 of or just any reflections you wish to close with? Yeah, I've thought a lot about it because
00:50:51.680 I've fought for what I thought was right in protecting the island for so long. And I don't
00:50:58.420 feel like I made much progress. And why? Okay, I asked myself, why is that? And partially, I think
00:51:07.540 it's because of a shifting baseline. And by that, I mean, one group of public officials,
00:51:18.540 Park Service are running Cumberland now, another group for them, and so on back. But every time
00:51:25.440 one new group comes in they take stock of things and that's their baseline so it it just by natural
00:51:35.540 over time that facilitates ecological degradation because they're you're always starting from a
00:51:43.960 lesser point a lesser point a lesser point i mean at one time there were x number of cars now there
00:51:50.980 are xx number of cars at one time there were no bicycles now there's bicycles everywhere
00:51:56.160 uh and and so on and and the people just accept that the new people coming in because that's the
00:52:03.900 way it is so that's a big danger and what that means is that the public has always got to keep
00:52:11.640 try to keep tabs on what's going on and don't consider what they see as locked in stone they
00:52:19.040 can change it if they will write letters. Mostly if you have a good time and you leave, you don't
00:52:24.740 think about, you know, anything. But if you have a bad, bad time, you'll write a letter. Well, it's
00:52:29.740 also good to say, wow, I walked all the way to the north end of Cumberland and I didn't see a vehicle.
00:52:35.180 Thank you, Park Service. Something like that. A positive to try to reinforce it because they don't
00:52:42.020 hear the positive side of things. I mean, they have done a lot of good things right now. There's
00:52:48.180 still a lot of bad things lined up to be done, such as fire management and feral animals, but
00:52:54.180 they've done a lot of good things. They did round up the cattle that were on the island.
00:53:00.420 So, but again, it's the public that is going to have to keep tabs on whatever agency it is,
00:53:08.220 because just by nature, the government agencies do not like wilderness. And that's Fish and
00:53:16.200 wildlife that's forest service blm and national park service so the public has really got to hold
00:53:23.460 them responsible without that without that i mean all the groups can do a lot but they they don't
00:53:32.800 they're nothing like the public if there's a public outcry
00:53:36.920 which makes what you're doing so important i think
00:53:41.720 thank you yeah well this has been a really just yeah i'm just thinking so much about this place
00:53:53.440 and it's been so wonderful to spend this time with you and put myself across the country and
00:54:00.280 into a whole other ecosystem and land that is in need of care like all of the places that
00:54:08.720 so many of us who are listening love and to be allies with one another as we fight for these
00:54:16.000 places feels important so carol thank you so much for this time that we've spent together
00:54:22.160 and i will be keeping up and keeping tabs on what's happening at cumberland
00:54:28.520 thank you ayanna i really appreciate it i think you're doing a wonderful thing
00:54:38.720 Thank you for listening to another episode of For the Wild podcast.
00:54:51.380 The music you heard today was by Eliza Edens, Kizia Nagata, Lauren Alegre, and I, Good Friend.
00:54:59.520 For the Wild is created by Ayanna Young, Erica Ekrem, Francesca Glaspell, and Melanie Younger.
00:55:08.720 Thank you.