For The Wild - July 21, 2021


Dr. MICHAEL LUJAN BEVACQUA on Guåhan’s Sovereignty Amidst Climate Change ⧸243

Topics
STEFANIE BRENDL on Being Humbled by Sharks ⧸242 PRENTIS HEMPHILL on Choosing Belonging ⧸244

Episode Stats


Length

55 minutes

Words per minute

140.31

Word count

7,845

Sentence count

328

Harmful content

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 For the Wild is brought to you in part by the Calliopeia Foundation, who support reconnecting
00:00:05.720 ecology, culture, and spirituality. We are grateful for their continued support and the
00:00:11.340 support of grassroots contributions from listeners like you. Learn more at calliopeia.org.
00:00:17.720 To make a donation, visit forthewild.world slash donate, or find us on Patreon. If you'd like to
00:00:24.720 support us in other ways, consider sharing our episodes through social media or leaving
00:00:29.820 us a review wherever you listen to the podcast. Hey, for the wild community, it's Ayanna here.
00:00:36.260 We are getting so close to reaching our goal of 2,000 Patreon subscribers per month.
00:00:42.060 If you'd like to be a part of keeping this podcast going, head over to Patreon and sign up
00:00:47.080 or donate through our website. We really need y'all to continue producing this work. Thanks so much.
00:00:52.900 hello and welcome to for the wild podcast i'm ayana young today i'm speaking with dr michael
00:01:06.060 luhan bavakwa whenever you have a an empire whenever you have sort of a something like this
00:01:14.480 if there's something that they don't want to think about or don't want to deal with
00:01:18.540 It gets pushed out to the furthest reaches.
00:01:22.600 This is something we've seen empires do since time immemorial.
00:01:26.520 Dr. Michael Lujan Bavakwa taught Guam history and Chamorro language at the University of Guam for 10 years
00:01:34.300 and helped found its Chamorro Studies program, the only one of its kind in the world.
00:01:40.100 With his brother Jack, they run a creative collective called The Guam Bus,
00:01:44.460 which publishes Chamorro language books, comics, and learning materials.
00:01:49.920 He is the co-chair for the community group Independent Guahan,
00:01:53.900 which is dedicated to educating the island of Guam on the possibilities
00:01:57.840 should it decolonize and become a sovereign, independent country.
00:02:02.580 He is a member of the Cabeza and Bidut clans on Guam.
00:02:06.940 thank you so much for joining us today from guam i'm really looking forward to
00:02:17.780 having this conversation together and you too thank you so much for having me ayana
00:02:23.600 yes well i'd like to start our conversation by recognizing guahan's incredibly layered history
00:02:34.360 as well as Chamorro history that predates this colonial narrative by thousands of years.
00:02:41.160 And there really are so many different ways to ask this question.
00:02:45.640 And to some extent, it feels like framing Guahan in one way or another really does a disservice to its complexity.
00:02:54.960 But I'd like to share a passage from Militarization and Resistance from Guahan,
00:03:00.140 protecting and defending pagat written by you and tiara naputi quote while the pacific ocean
00:03:09.040 is a huge swath covering almost half of the globe it is perceived as populated with small islands
00:03:15.660 and small island peoples and thus imagined as a place meant to be traversed by imperial and world
00:03:21.880 powers rather than a site from which we can understand the structure of colonial power
00:03:27.920 The smallness of the islands and peoples of the Pacific make them ideal as anthropological
00:03:33.720 laboratories, but not as sites for understanding the structure of American sovereignty.
00:03:39.660 In the Pacific, we find stolen lands aplenty, stolen kingdoms, islands transformed into
00:03:45.940 fortresses, bodies and lands poisoned through military testing, and an array of colonial
00:03:52.060 bodies shipped off to war. In the Pacific, we see that militarism and colonialism are not exceptional
00:03:59.960 facets of American existence, but structures that are constitutive and essential to the
00:04:06.040 historical and contemporary production of American power." And yeah, so I wonder if you can ground
00:04:17.300 listeners, in the history of Guahan and how it really challenges conventional definitions?
00:04:24.300 Or why is it vital to center Guahan's story and current developments, both in terms of
00:04:30.000 indigenous culture and scholarship, as well as a manifestation of U.S. empire?
00:04:36.600 Thank you for that question. I think when looking at the story of Guahan,
00:04:41.780 One, Guam has the distinction of being the first place colonized in the Pacific by Europeans.
00:04:49.860 When Magellan, we're 500 years from the anniversary of Magellan, sailing across the Pacific and
00:04:56.020 finding Guam as he crosses.
00:04:59.400 That sort of, that leads to what later becomes hundreds of years of Spanish colonization.
00:05:05.700 At the start of the 20th century, there's a change in powers and the United States takes
00:05:10.640 Guam for its sort of strategic military needs. And what we see now is that Guam in the 21st
00:05:18.180 century, Guam is one of the last formal colonies left in the world, where much of the world has
00:05:24.340 decolonized, where many former colonies have sort of moved through a process where they now sit
00:05:30.940 beside those who once colonized them in international forums, in negotiation at the United
00:05:36.920 nations, Guam remains one of those places that is still a colony, sort of a remnant of the old way
00:05:45.080 of doing things, the way of doing things that everyone is supposed to agree that shouldn't
00:05:50.580 exist in the world anymore. And so you can see that in a number of different ways. But Chamorros
00:05:56.060 on Guam feel it the strongest because we have the longest history of that colonization. If you live 1.00
00:06:02.860 on Guam today, you're a resident of Guam, you cannot vote for president of the United States.
00:06:09.300 You don't have electoral college vote. You elect a single non-voting delegate to the U.S. Congress.
00:06:16.220 But despite this, all federal laws apply to Guam. And the federal government can dictate and mandate
00:06:23.800 whatever they want for Guam, despite Guam and other territories being left out of the democratic
00:06:30.000 discussion about the course of the United States in general, but also what will happen to the
00:06:37.080 island itself. And so the U.S. took Guam because of its strategic value. In 1898, it was because
00:06:45.480 U.S. ships, you know, they were coaling ships. And so you needed all these points across the
00:06:52.600 Pacific to fill ships. But eventually, that strategic value has changed to not just a
00:06:59.740 link in a chain, but now it's also a point in, I guess, as one former military officer
00:07:06.660 called it, a cloud of islands so that Guam and other islands and Micronesia around it
00:07:13.640 are the points from which the U.S. can project force into Asia, but they're also a buffer
00:07:20.160 so that they become something that can sort of muffle or deter any force projection back
00:07:28.320 across to the United States. And so this puts Guam in a strange position because on a daily basis,
00:07:37.780 the American flag flies over the island. People are U.S. citizens on the island.
00:07:44.080 And the educational system is very Americanized. We are an extension of U.S. Netflix. So we see
00:07:52.200 what's trending and what's number one in the United States. And we watch alongside people
00:07:55.700 in the United States. But on a daily basis, we don't know whether we are included in the United
00:08:02.000 States so that when Joe Biden or Donald Trump talks about America, is he including Guam in that?
00:08:11.160 Or is Guam just what many military commanders refer to it, the tip of America's spear? Is Guam
00:08:19.500 a strategic asset? Is Guam something that is not a part of America but exists apart from America
00:08:27.140 and its purpose is to be wielded, to be sharpened, and so on? And that's why when talking about
00:08:35.900 militarization, Guam is an island which is just over 200 square miles, but it is almost one-third
00:08:43.220 U.S. military bases. And so if you come to Guam, you drive around, if you go in the northern part,
00:08:50.940 most of the northern part of the island, there's military fences that go for miles because there's
00:08:56.580 a large air force base, Anderson Air Force Base up there. When you come to the middle of the
00:09:02.100 island, you'll find an army base. You'll find missile defense sort of positions there. When
00:09:08.200 you go to the south, you'll find Navy-based Guam. You'll find a huge naval magazine where they store
00:09:13.840 weapons. And so when we're talking about sort of U.S. militarization and Guam sort of telling you
00:09:22.360 something about the United States, this is something that I always find is interesting.
00:09:26.740 Whenever you have an empire, whenever you have sort of something like this, if there's something
00:09:34.360 that they don't want to think about or don't want to deal with, it gets pushed out to the
00:09:40.080 furthest reaches. This is something we've seen empires do since time immemorial. Whether it's
00:09:45.680 a discussion about government corruption, well, government corruption, it exists in the fringes,
00:09:50.060 it doesn't exist in the center. But for Guam, we see it with military. Guam becomes a hyper
00:09:57.220 militarized place, a place in which sort of all of the things about American power, American
00:10:03.640 dominance, American strategic military needs, we see it all manifest in just a small island on the
00:10:10.600 edge of Asia. And so if you want to understand the United States, you want to understand sort of
00:10:19.020 its story and you want to learn some of its secrets, some of the things that the United
00:10:23.040 States doesn't really talk about and doesn't want people to know about, you can definitely look to
00:10:28.960 Guam. And you'll find a lot of stories which may seem familiar because you've heard them in the
00:10:34.500 context of treatment of Native Americans. They may sound familiar because you've heard them in the
00:10:39.340 context of the way that the United States treats other countries. But that's one of the important
00:10:45.460 things about why people in the United States should know about the island, should know about
00:10:49.660 Guahan, because it can reflect back. It can reflect back and tell you really important things
00:10:58.280 Because even just this past year, with all the conversation, or the previous year, with so many conversations around racial justice, it's so important.
00:11:09.640 But one thing that needs to be part of that, though, is what does the United States do with its territories?
00:11:17.860 Because it still has a number of territories.
00:11:21.040 And so I wait for that conversation to happen because the Chamorro voice, the indigenous people's voice in the island, has long not been heard within the United States.
00:11:34.420 and that as we push and as we protest sometimes we really wait for the united states to live up
00:11:42.040 to some of their professed values uh their ideals and really give the people of guam and especially
00:11:49.360 the chmur people a chance to to sort of govern themselves to determine their destiny and so um
00:11:56.840 that was that was quite a bit i'm so sorry no it was so important to hear and i
00:12:03.980 i'm really just sitting with yeah just sitting with the fact that guahan in so many ways doesn't
00:12:12.900 get to be in so many of the conversations happening um in the lower 48 and this place
00:12:21.840 that so many people forget exists but really explains the united states as empire and as a
00:12:30.340 violent empire. And so I really appreciate you taking us there. And I'd like to jump into
00:12:36.440 conversation on the efforts to decolonize Guahan, not metaphorically, but truly working to dismantle
00:12:43.980 American colonialism and instill strong self-governance. And I think for quite some
00:12:49.920 time, the term decolonization became a popular slogan and then was really abstracted outward
00:12:58.060 word to a point where it lost meaning for many. But from what I understand, the people of Guahan
00:13:04.100 are actively looking at what a decolonized future might look like. However, you know, I also imagine
00:13:10.700 that there's a lot of complexity there because of the island's liminal nature and allegiance to the
00:13:17.600 United States. So is there resistance to decolonization on the island? And how are you
00:13:24.480 all working to make decolonization a rational pursuit for the majority?
00:13:30.680 So decolonization used to be a dirty word in Guam. And part of this was because of the feelings of
00:13:39.720 sort of loyalty and sort of a debt, like a debt of loyalty that many Chamorros felt
00:13:45.680 because of World War II in the island. For 32 months, the Japanese occupied Guam.
00:13:53.020 And this was a violent occupation. Towards the end, the Japanese massacred many Chamorros as the United States was bombing the island and preparing to reinvade it.
00:14:02.780 And so this experience fundamentally changed the way Chamorro saw the United States. Prior to the war, they saw the U.S. as offering great opportunities, but they also saw the United States as a racist country because the U.S. brought segregation into the island.
00:14:19.480 segregated schools, segregated bars. And so Chamorros lived on one side of the fence and
00:14:25.720 white Americans lived on the other. And then, but, and the United States proposed itself as 0.75
00:14:34.460 the greatest country in the world. Its democracy was the most fantastic, but it didn't allow that
00:14:40.600 democracy to exist in Guam. But what happens in the war is that there's a contrasting of
00:14:46.820 colonialisms, a contrasting of colonizers. And so when confronted with the brutality of the
00:14:52.740 Japanese, Chamorros choose sort of the more lazier, sort of less in your face colonization 0.96
00:14:59.740 of the Americans. And they start to feel a debt to the United States for kicking out the Japanese, 1.00
00:15:06.000 for expelling them and bringing a sense of peace to the island. And so because of that, 0.98
00:15:12.060 for the longest time, while much of the world was decolonizing, Guam was not. And people in Guam
00:15:18.940 were resistant to that. But what happens in the 1970s is that the islands around Guam, many of
00:15:27.800 which in Micronesia were under the Japanese in World War II, they get the chance to negotiate
00:15:35.100 a new political status.
00:15:36.880 They get the chance to decolonize
00:15:38.320 with the United States.
00:15:41.140 But Guam as an unincorporated territory,
00:15:44.940 a strategic possession,
00:15:47.120 is denied that right.
00:15:50.300 So you have people from Palau,
00:15:53.620 the Marshall Islands,
00:15:55.100 the Federated States of Micronesia,
00:15:56.640 and the Commonwealth of the Northern Marianas.
00:15:58.980 They get to sit with the State Department
00:16:00.880 and talk about what they want
00:16:02.040 for their political future.
00:16:03.600 And they get to vote.
00:16:05.100 in plebiscites. But Guam, because it's deemed too strategically valuable to the United States,
00:16:11.440 is denied the chance. And this then leads to especially the political leaders in Guam feeling
00:16:19.140 like it was being left out. That while the rest of the Pacific and the world was moving on,
00:16:26.220 Guam was stuck. And that while even our neighbors in the Pacific and Micronesia
00:16:31.580 are able to make deals with Taiwan, with mainland China, with Japan, while they're able to negotiate
00:16:38.780 and work with them as partners. Guam has denied that. And so there has also been a very strong
00:16:48.120 movement for justice around this issue. And for some people, it is an issue of land.
00:16:54.120 When I mentioned that Chamorros were patriotic, called patriotism to the United States after World
00:16:59.760 War II, the United States immediately took advantage of that patriotism. In the wake of
00:17:06.200 sort of the Japanese occupation, the United States started to condemn thousands of acres of land
00:17:12.940 around the island, pushing out families, bulldozing farms, literally showing up in a farm and forcing
00:17:20.460 people to sign papers saying that they were willing to give it up to the United States.
00:17:24.420 And that Guam went from being a self-sustaining sort of agricultural island where the people lived closely connected to the land, where within, by 1949, you had thousands of Chamorro families who had no land because the United States had bulldozed their farms, pushed them off them, and basically created the military bases that the island has now.
00:17:49.600 And so for some people, this is an issue of justice.
00:17:52.960 We remember those things that the United States has done, and we remember sort of how for decades they banned our language in schools, similar to the experience of Native Americans in boarding schools.
00:18:07.640 When the United States came in, they banned the language so that you could be punished for speaking your own language in schools and in public places.
00:18:17.480 And so we remember these things. And we remember, most of all, we remember that the United States is not the beginning and it should not be the end of the Chamorro people or of Guam and Guam's existence.
00:18:32.420 The Chamorro people, they are the sort of, the Chamorro people, we inherit the legacy of the first navigation into the Pacific.
00:18:42.480 The Marianas Islands that Guam is the southernmost part of, we were the first islands documented, settled in the Pacific, close to 4,000 years ago.
00:18:53.800 And so our history in this place goes far beyond the red, white, and blue flag that was planted on the island in 1898.
00:19:00.680 And so what we've seen more and more in recent years, as Chamorros have undergone a cultural renaissance, trying to contend with colonialism, with the way it has suppressed parts of our culture, the way that it has tried to suppress our language, the way that it has displaced the people from their lands.
00:19:20.100 part of that is not it doesn't remain a cultural conversation part of it then becomes a political
00:19:26.260 conversation about the rights of the Chamorro people about how the Chamorro people have been
00:19:31.940 treated and what is the best path moving forward for them for me this is something that I've
00:19:38.260 experienced in teaching students is that if you teach them the language if you teach them
00:19:46.480 their history, if you share the stories of their village with them, if you connect them to places
00:19:54.120 that they feel that have been long lost to sort of this history and this continuing story of
00:20:00.420 colonization, you increase the chances that they will see it as something of value and you increase
00:20:07.280 the chances that they will then feel that they are obligated to protect it. Because it's one thing
00:20:13.880 if you deprive people of their language and their lands and their culture, it's easy for them to
00:20:19.000 feel apathetic about the world because they don't feel tied to anything. But in terms of
00:20:24.520 decolonization, we've seen that as we have worked to try to preserve and revitalize the language,
00:20:31.300 as more people protest about the military bases and their uses, we see more and more,
00:20:37.360 especially young people, feeling like they need to take a stand, asking the question of
00:20:43.360 why wasn't I taught my language?
00:20:46.580 You know, why is it that my family doesn't have land anymore?
00:20:50.500 You know, why is it that so much of our history has been lost?
00:20:54.940 And so it's been beautiful to see.
00:20:57.780 It's been beautiful to see so many people connect that to decolonization,
00:21:02.580 connect it to the idea that Guam needs to leave this status of being a territory,
00:21:07.720 that we need to move to something where we join the rest of the world.
00:21:13.360 We'll be right back.
00:21:43.360 I will not obey
00:21:45.800 Give us the minds of your children to learn
00:21:52.000 The substance of books we have not yet burned
00:21:55.560 But can they read the skies for rain
00:21:59.060 What can one say
00:22:02.540 I will not obey
00:22:05.300 Soon our tyrants will feel our impatience
00:22:11.480 We choose to create our own combinations
00:22:14.780 Who is always willing to agree
00:22:17.720 And what can one say?
00:22:20.600 I will not obey
00:22:22.120 I appreciate what you're bringing up for us to sit with and chew on
00:22:36.060 And yeah, I'm also thinking about the importance of decolonization and self-governance in context
00:22:44.700 to climate change, especially in terms of islands throughout Oceania.
00:22:49.540 You know, I don't want to sound apocalyptic, but the reality is that typhoons are set to
00:22:56.160 increase and sea level is expected to rise by three feet in the next century.
00:23:01.440 And so I understand that perhaps many people feel that the process of decolonization is one of great risk where individuals are willingly abandoning a system in order to fend for themselves without the benefits of the so-called United States.
00:23:17.280 but you know the united states and really the whole world is not what it once was and in terms
00:23:24.940 of the united states it doesn't even care for its own states when they suffer climate emergencies
00:23:31.020 so who is to say that it will care for territories can you speak to self-governance amidst changing
00:23:38.160 systems worlds and whether or not you think that pursuing greater autonomy should be motivated by
00:23:45.120 climate collapse. I strongly believe that the issue of climate change, environmental sort of
00:23:51.620 preservation, all of those sorts of issues, they really are tied to your level of sovereignty.
00:23:59.740 I mean, during the Trump administration, we saw this as being a territory of the United States.
00:24:06.000 We don't get to speak for ourselves in the world. And so this is one thing that has been frustrating
00:24:14.020 in recent years. When I talk to people about this, I always say that you can see this in terms of
00:24:20.000 Leonardo DiCaprio. Leonardo DiCaprio, he went to Palau, an island to the south of us, which has
00:24:27.920 become sort of an environmental champion in the Pacific and around the world. They've banned
00:24:33.840 commercial fishing. They've created a shark sanctuary. Every tourist that comes to the
00:24:42.240 island has to pay a green fee that they use to then protect sort of their their their net and so
00:24:49.940 on so a few years ago leonardo dicaprio he went to he went to palau he took selfies with the
00:24:57.500 president he hung out and he barbecued on the beach with the president and he came to guam too
00:25:03.240 but he just went visited the airport and changed planes in guam and part of that is because
00:25:11.020 Palau and other islands in the Pacific get to go to these meetings, international meetings here
00:25:18.040 in Europe. Pacific Island nations have been some of the strongest voices about the need to do more
00:25:24.460 because as you mentioned, it's life or death. Some islands in the Pacific have already started to
00:25:32.160 create their emergency escape plans, working with partner nations to purchase or to set aside land
00:25:40.760 so that when their islands begin to disappear or become uninhabitable,
00:25:44.840 they can move to those higher islands to keep sustaining themselves.
00:25:53.220 And Guam is completely absent in those conversations
00:25:56.280 because at those meetings where the president of Palau
00:26:00.620 gets to hang out with Leonardo DiCaprio, Mark Ruffalo,
00:26:05.060 or Emmanuel Macron, or anybody else, Guam doesn't get to go to those.
00:26:10.760 Instead, the State Department of the United States speaks, and we don't get a voice in that.
00:26:19.280 And so under the Trump administration, it was really frustrating because climate change
00:26:23.420 is becoming more and more sort of obvious, its impacts more and more sort of more and more
00:26:31.600 undeniable. But the United States was moving backwards on the issue. And other countries
00:26:38.220 were decrying that, but in Guam, we are stuck. We go along with the ride. We are not a canoe
00:26:46.440 that sails beside the United States. We are not a people who ride on the ship of the United
00:26:52.540 States. We are a boat which is tied to the United States and dragged along. And so whichever
00:27:00.600 way America goes, we have to go with it. And so this has, yeah, this is one of those frustrating
00:27:07.320 things, is that we want to work and we want to organize with other countries. We want to be able
00:27:14.380 to, we want to help make that case for more to be done around climate change. But we can't even
00:27:22.180 get into the door. There's different bodies for Pacific Island nations, and Guam can't even join
00:27:30.580 those because Guam is not an independent country. Guam is sometimes allowed observer status where
00:27:37.460 we get to sit and watch while other countries in the Pacific meet and talk about their fates,
00:27:43.520 but Guam doesn't get to participate. So this is the problem, is that that lack of self-governance
00:27:53.460 on a daily basis, many people may not be able to feel it or may not realize it because kind of you
00:27:59.120 just move from one day to the next and sort of the American flag flies over the island and
00:28:04.560 everything must be okay, right? But when you really think about the issues that matter,
00:28:12.340 the lack of sovereignty is perilous. The lack of sovereignty means that while other island nations
00:28:21.140 are making important decisions about what's going to happen to them and how they need to take a
00:28:26.720 stand. We don't get to. While other islands, I mean, this was something that we felt prominently
00:28:33.580 during the COVID pandemic, was that around us, the Pacific and Micronesia became like a model
00:28:41.460 for COVID-free sort of existence, because all these islands in Micronesia remained COVID-free
00:28:48.940 for months and months and months. And even when there was a case, it was quickly isolated
00:28:56.320 and the island wasn't impacted directly.
00:29:01.300 But on Guam, because we are a transit hub,
00:29:06.220 because we are a U.S. destination,
00:29:10.260 and because we don't have the ability to close off our island,
00:29:13.920 because that's the U.S. federal government that gets to decide that,
00:29:17.580 even when we were worried and we saw our island brothers and sisters
00:29:22.100 closing themselves off to protect themselves, Guam couldn't.
00:29:26.320 and so this lack of the ability to self-govern you can feel it in so many ways and it's unfortunate
00:29:34.920 because as these issues such as climate change become more and more real that ability not to
00:29:40.900 even be part of the conversation it just becomes so much more problematic it just you know for me
00:29:46.480 it becomes much more harrowing that that we cannot stand beside other pacific island nations
00:29:52.560 and speak with a louder voice about the need for the large countries to do more to stop this issue.
00:30:02.320 Yeah, I'd now like to ask you about the potential creation of a new constitution for Guam.
00:30:08.980 And I welcome you to share some more general information on this because I don't want to
00:30:15.140 misrepresent anything. But in an article entitled, Guam can learn from U.S. Virgin Islands
00:30:21.380 constitution attempts you write quote the creation of a constitution is a powerful exercise of a
00:30:28.460 community trying to create a document that enshrines not only their hopes but their worries
00:30:34.080 and fears it's a blueprint meant to also provide tools for how they can potentially protect and
00:30:39.940 defend themselves from threats internal external and colonial end quote and i know for many just
00:30:47.920 the term constitution evokes a very colonial understanding, suggesting that we move within
00:30:55.780 colonizer courts or allow our relationships to be defined by colonial understanding. But part of me
00:31:03.340 wants to think about constitutions as a sort of necessary passageway into agreement and
00:31:09.940 relationship as it provides a clear articulation of boundaries. So I'd really love to hear you
00:31:17.340 talk about this process a bit more in terms of the shortcomings, opportunities, and importances?
00:31:26.820 No, it's a very good question, because since the 1970s, Guam and the U.S. Virgin Islands
00:31:34.100 have been empowered by the U.S. government to create constitutions. But this is a very
00:31:41.680 misleading sort of thing because they have been empowered to create constitutions but the rules
00:31:49.400 and the limitations on the constitutions are that your government has to follow the format of the
00:31:55.400 United States. It cannot conflict with any part of the United States federal law and it cannot
00:32:03.160 acknowledge your own sovereignty. Your constitution has to acknowledge the sovereignty of the United
00:32:08.460 States over you. And so even if you just think about what the Constitution of the United States
00:32:15.180 was supposed to represent for the framers and for the United States,
00:32:20.660 the Constitution that the U.S. Congress wants Guam and the Virgin Islands to make
00:32:25.500 is nothing like that. This would just be like cutting and pasting the U.S. Constitution
00:32:32.760 and then just changing out one or two words here or there.
00:32:38.060 And so for the Virgin Islands, it's been a frustrating experience for them
00:32:42.660 because they've tried to do this at least five times.
00:32:46.960 And part of the issue, though, is that when they create a document,
00:32:53.060 then the last time that they did it, they created something, for example,
00:32:56.800 they wanted to put restrictions on who could like stronger time restrictions on who could
00:33:04.800 serve in public office in the Virgin Islands because the Virgin Islands has an issue where
00:33:09.700 people move down there and then they get residency and then they like run for office even though they
00:33:16.360 don't have strong connections to the community there yet and so they wanted to put in something
00:33:21.500 where you had to have lived on the island for like seven years or 10 years. And they put longer
00:33:29.240 residency periods like that, longer than any other place in the United States. And the Department of
00:33:35.360 Justice said that that's unconstitutional. But for the people of the Virgin Islands, it was an issue
00:33:41.320 where, but we want to make sure that the people who represent us, that they are actually connected
00:33:47.860 to the community. They're not just people who have a summer home in the islands or a winter home in
00:33:52.140 the islands. So we want to make it so that they have to actually live here for a long enough
00:33:59.400 period to be connected to the community before they're eligible to represent it. And the Department
00:34:05.840 of Justice said, no, it's unconstitutional. And there was other things too that they took out
00:34:10.540 and they said, if you want to pass this constitution, take out all these things.
00:34:14.260 and so that's part of the problem with doing a constitution while you are still a territory
00:34:21.100 is that like for guam there's a couple issues that i always talk about in relation to this
00:34:26.540 you know and one of them is the military build-up the united states has been destroying
00:34:34.100 jungle areas it has been desecrating areas with historic human remains cultural artifacts
00:34:42.580 There's a lot of stuff happening on the island.
00:34:45.400 The people of Guam who are against this feel powerless that we can do anything about it
00:34:50.080 because we are in territory.
00:34:52.960 And so if somebody says, well, we should have a constitution, one of the things that you
00:34:58.240 couldn't put into this constitution is that you couldn't put anything to affect the military.
00:35:06.880 So you couldn't put anything that says that the people of Guam have sovereign control
00:35:11.760 over their resources, because then the United States would say, well, wait a second, you
00:35:16.940 don't actually have that.
00:35:18.940 We have sovereign control over your resources.
00:35:22.380 You couldn't say anything like that.
00:35:23.740 You cannot, you cannot, historic sites are protected in this way or that way, because
00:35:29.100 the federal government would say, no, that's, you can't do that, because that would infringe
00:35:32.600 on our ability to build firing ranges or build bases.
00:35:35.720 You can't do anything like that, because if you're a territory, the Constitution is not about you expressing what you want or what you're afraid of or what you hope for to protect what's valuable to you.
00:35:50.480 If you're a territory and you do a Constitution, it's all about just mirroring and copying the colonizer.
00:35:58.700 And it's all about just creating something for their comfort, creating something so they can argue that you are no longer a colony, because that was the original push for constitutions for the territories, was that the United States wanted to remove Guam from the list of United Nations recognized colonies in the world.
00:36:24.080 So they thought that if the people of Guam created the constitution, then they could get support to have Guam removed as an official colony. But people on Guam saw through that and voted against the constitution.
00:36:37.480 But in a wider discussion about this, I think that one thing that's unfortunate is that for people in the United States and Guam to some extent, as you said, our sense of a constitution is very limited by the U.S. Constitution, which is a fine document in some ways.
00:36:59.300 But when we look across the world, you can see constitutions in which the environment is protected. You can see constitutions in which people have rights as workers. In other constitutions, you see traditional leadership enshrined, right?
00:37:19.620 you see all sorts of things, all sorts of ways in which different people take this document and
00:37:25.900 then they make it reflect who they are, not reflect who the colonizer is or was, but that you put what
00:37:33.920 you want from the world, what you want for the future, what you want to protect, you put that
00:37:39.080 in that document. And so that's why, you know, for me, undergoing a process of writing a constitution
00:37:47.620 will be so important for Guam, but not as a territory.
00:37:51.740 But when we have that freedom to gather as a community
00:37:54.600 and then talk about how we can protect what matters to us,
00:37:58.640 what makes this island special.
00:38:00.200 And it can be a place where, of course,
00:38:01.940 all ethnicities are respected,
00:38:04.040 but how could we also ensure
00:38:05.840 that the Chamorro connection to the island is protected,
00:38:11.140 that it's not erased and it's not lost.
00:38:17.620 A crazy flame burning through the night
00:38:34.000 A desert rider falling down from thirst
00:38:40.980 What passion must be keeping him alive
00:38:48.540 The sand is humming hymns in the great white wind
00:38:56.320 The sand is humming hymns in the great white wind 0.99
00:39:03.960 Something that I've been thinking about with the colonization and militarization of Guahan
00:39:19.060 is the cost of militarization. And I'm wondering if, you know, broadly we can talk about the
00:39:26.820 economic cost in terms of something like the war on terror, which has costed the United States
00:39:33.440 over $5 trillion since 2001. But I also wonder about the cost of militarization in terms of
00:39:42.480 livelihoods and just ways of being in this world, not through war alone, but in terms of global
00:39:50.120 defense plans and the creation of military bases across the Pacific. As Guahan is considered one
00:39:56.940 of the most important bases in the world by both U.S. defense and military experts. I'm wondering
00:40:03.920 if you could speak to what militarizing Guam costs. Militarizing Guam definitely, it brings
00:40:12.240 money into the island. It's one of the reasons why their community often feels that increasing
00:40:18.900 the US military presence is important because there's construction jobs. There's some taxes
00:40:27.180 that are paid as part of that. More military stationed on the island means potentially more
00:40:32.260 people spending money on the island. And so the economic benefit to Guam is something that a lot
00:40:39.820 of people will always champion when they're talking about why the military, it's good to
00:40:44.540 have them here and why we should have more of them here. But to your larger point, one of the
00:40:50.140 reasons why it's tricky, though, to think of the military as sort of an economic partner,
00:40:57.040 an economic boost on WOM, is because the military is ultimately something which its course,
00:41:04.000 its direction, its priorities are not something that are negotiated with WOM or talked about
00:41:09.100 with Guam or its government. These are things that are decided in Washington, D.C. These are
00:41:15.580 things that are decided without really Guam being a part of that. And so that's why over the past
00:41:24.220 15 years, for example, there's been key moments where the military said that they were going to
00:41:30.160 bring in, let's say, thousands of Marines from Okinawa. And then, so this happened about the
00:41:36.340 time that Barack Obama was elected president. They said the military buildup is going to bring
00:41:41.360 all this money into the island, all these new bodies, all these new bodies into the island.
00:41:48.580 And so sort of the richer class on Guam started to invest. They started to buy up properties,
00:41:54.980 create condo units. They started to try to get more franchises from the U.S. to bring to the
00:42:01.320 Island. Even Walmart was talking about moving into Guam at that point because of all this
00:42:06.580 speculation about the booming economy once the military buildup is going. But then what happened
00:42:13.160 is that in the US Congress, two senators, one of them was the late John McCain, basically looked
00:42:20.760 at this and said, no, this is a waste of money. Come up with a plan for what you're doing in Guam
00:42:26.540 in the Pacific and then maybe we'll give you funding. And so then for several years, the
00:42:31.080 buildup didn't happen because the military didn't have a plan. They were just sort of
00:42:35.100 proposing all these projects. And so all of these people that were banking on that then sort of lost
00:42:42.580 money, invested in things that didn't happen. More recently, one of the strangest and most
00:42:49.440 bewildering things, because if an empire is large enough, then eventually you can see the empire
00:42:55.260 sort of eat itself in a certain way was that while people in the United States were protesting
00:43:02.340 the building of the border wall, Trump's border wall, in Guam, one of the things that happened
00:43:09.980 is that in order to get the money to build his border wall, Donald Trump proposed taking the
00:43:17.060 money away for the military construction on Guam. And he actually did that. He delayed
00:43:25.020 construction by a year because he took the money that was meant for the construction of barracks,
00:43:31.360 Marine Corps barracks and Marine Corps facilities on Guam. He stole it and decided to use it for
00:43:37.380 building his, and so it was one of those interesting moments where in the short term,
00:43:44.640 you know, so I think, so me personally, of course, I was against any border wall,
00:43:49.980 Trump's border wall. But on the other hand, if sort of if the empire extends long enough,
00:43:55.980 then the lines of progressive, liberal, colonial, decolonial, they start to shift
00:44:01.800 a great deal. And so in Guam, being in support of Trump's border wall and Trump's border wall
00:44:09.500 happening would mean that the military buildup might not happen. And so that's one of the ways
00:44:17.000 which you can see sort of the complexity of these sorts of things. But one thing that's unfortunate
00:44:24.120 though is that this militarized prioritization of money, it causes so many problems across the
00:44:33.880 United States. And it also causes problems in Guam, where there's always money for sort of
00:44:41.000 military projects in Guam. There's not necessarily money for other types of projects in Guam.
00:44:47.000 but across the United States, it's the same thing. Military budgets always go up. There's always
00:44:53.180 fancier weapons, bombs to make. There's always more things to spend military money on while the
00:45:01.460 infrastructure of the United States, you know, sort of declines, while education has so many
00:45:07.320 problems, while, you know, the economy has so many problems. And so I think this is one of those
00:45:13.820 things where the United States may not think of itself as a militaristic country, a country that
00:45:20.780 is sort of determined by military values that prioritizes the military over everything else.
00:45:27.740 Your average person in the United States may not see itself in that way, but Guam provides a
00:45:33.780 reflection that absolutely, if your country spends more of its budget on the military than on
00:45:41.940 everything else. It means you are a militarized country. You may not feel it if you live in
00:45:49.800 Washington State or in South Carolina or in Texas, because for you there, like a military base,
00:45:58.960 there may be sort of one around you somewhere. But in Guam, you definitely feel it.
00:46:05.380 Because in Guam, every time there's news about a new Chinese missile, you feel it.
00:46:11.940 because you are America and Asia. Every time there's North Korean threats in the Pacific,
00:46:18.260 you feel it because you are the tip of America's sphere. We feel it because we live sort of that 0.71
00:46:24.980 reality, that militarized reality, where Guam has one of the highest rates of military enlistment
00:46:31.380 and also one of the highest rates of military sort of usage, where just one third of the land
00:46:38.900 for military facilities. And so I definitely think that in order to, if you want to sort of
00:46:46.100 understand one of the big contradictions and problems within the United States, look to a
00:46:51.200 territory like Guam, and you'll get sort of just an inkling, an inkling of that poor prioritization.
00:47:00.100 Yeah, I think it's so important for us who want to understand this empire of the United States to look to Guahan and study the history.
00:47:17.940 And, yeah, I mean, we've covered some really expansive topics, and, you know, they're all threading the importance of identity, affirmation, and I'm really thinking about community beyond colonial structures.
00:47:36.540 And as we close, I'd like to ask you what you see as the next steps for Guahan in the pursuit of becoming sovereign once again, and how will resistance and political projects continue forward?
00:47:51.760 Thank you for that. And so one of the organizations that I'm part of, Independent Wahan,
00:47:58.820 we've been doing community education for about four years now, and about sort of decolonization,
00:48:06.560 the need to change our status. And as part of our efforts, we've reignited and revived a number of
00:48:13.900 things. We've pushed into different territories, into sort of outreach territories. One of the
00:48:20.880 things that we've done recently, but we need to really build upon is that we started to go back
00:48:28.220 to the United Nations to tell Guam's story. Is that every October, even though Guam is not
00:48:34.240 represented at the United Nations, every October, people from Guam can go and give a speech about,
00:48:42.080 a short speech about the state of the territory, what is happening there. And so we sort of
00:48:48.740 revived that practice, which hadn't been actively done for a while. But we did that because we felt
00:48:54.780 the need, especially after threats from North Korea, possible threats from China, that we felt
00:49:01.820 that we needed to get our voice out there because the feelings and the needs and the fears of the
00:49:08.280 people in Guam were being lost in sort of American militaristic narratives. And so one thing that we
00:49:16.080 need to do, and we've started, and this year will be sort of the year that hopefully we can
00:49:23.180 make it happen, is that we need a comprehensive educational campaign for the island.
00:49:30.420 And so next month, two studies are going to be released. One of them is a governance study,
00:49:38.520 and it will show all of the ways in which Guam is deficient as a self-governing entity.
00:49:45.120 So all the ways in which Guam, as a self-governing entity, you have these types of controls, you can do these types of things.
00:49:52.140 The study will show all the ways that we don't have that.
00:49:55.460 And we'll also have another study which will identify the possibilities for three different political status options.
00:50:03.540 Statehood, seeking to become integrated into the United States.
00:50:07.920 Free association, becoming an independent but freely associated country with the United States.
00:50:13.200 And finally, independence. And so from those studies, there'll be social media campaigns breaking down pieces of it for the public.
00:50:24.340 But I think more than anything, as sort of the pandemic in these times of crisis, we have to remind ourselves that being a territory, you know, means that you don't have the basic control over your community that you need in order to navigate what life will throw at you.
00:50:46.500 And sometimes it's easy to ignore this, but in the pandemic, this was so obvious as the island sort of became a COVID hotspot because we could not close it off.
00:50:58.360 At one point, there was a military, U.S. military aircraft carrier that was ported on the island.
00:51:04.600 And some people felt that we should have the ability to say no, that you shouldn't port here because you will bring the coronavirus into the island.
00:51:12.160 We found that other countries around us, even in Asia, we couldn't ask them for help because we are a territory. The United States gives us. But we couldn't connect directly with any of them to seek their assistance or their help.
00:51:29.160 And so I think what remains to be done here is to really make that case for people to understand that this issue of status affects everything in your lives.
00:51:41.160 It affects the cost of things on the shelves. It affects your ability to connect with the culture and the history of the island.
00:51:48.160 It affects the fear that we have every day of whether bombers or missiles from North Korea or China are going to hit us.
00:51:57.420 And beyond that, beyond that, though, within the United States, because one of the biggest problems we face is one of ignorance and apathy.
00:52:07.460 The federal government likes Guam the way it is.
00:52:12.260 Guam is not a problem that they look to solve because the military likes Guam the way it is.
00:52:19.180 The military sometimes calls Guam their playground.
00:52:23.900 WOM and the Marianas Islands are their playground because they can do types of training and testing
00:52:30.200 there, and they don't got to ask anybody's permission, whereas in other countries,
00:52:35.420 they have to ask for permission. And so fighting against that, and one of the ways that we can do
00:52:42.900 it is if the United States, because of all the activism and community sort of uproar last year
00:52:49.020 around racial injustice and the need to deal with it if somehow the United States can also find a
00:52:54.720 way to deal with its territories. And I don't mean that the United States should just give people in
00:53:02.140 the territories the right to vote, but what justice would look like for me is that after
00:53:07.840 a hundred years of the United States not listening to Guam and not caring what the Chamorro people
00:53:14.260 had to say, after hundreds of years of the Spanish not caring and not listening. The real 0.90
00:53:20.860 answer to how to fix this is that the United States needs to listen. That the United States
00:53:27.240 needs to listen to what the people of Puerto Rico want. It needs to listen to what the people
00:53:32.040 of Guam want. It needs to listen to what the people in the Virgin Islands want. And that's
00:53:37.740 how you can get some justice in terms of the people the for the people in the territories
00:53:43.620 is don't tell them what to do don't give them extend your constitution to them just be quiet
00:53:53.040 and listen and ask them what they want because part of the problem is that you've never asked
00:53:59.660 them what they want thank you so much michael this has been yeah oh no problem it's yeah it's
00:54:11.140 really transported me and
00:54:13.280 yeah i'm just there's so many thoughts swirling around empire and how much there is to know and
00:54:24.860 just for me personally like these lapses in my own understanding and this conversation really
00:54:32.260 filled in a lot of blanks and was really helpful to think about colonization and decolonization
00:54:38.460 in general and to look at guahan in a sense as a as a space to learn from in these wider
00:54:48.620 conversations so i i really appreciate your time today no problem no problem i look forward
00:54:54.740 to hearing it too
00:54:56.540 and sharing it.
00:54:58.420 Thank you.
00:55:06.220 Thank you for listening
00:55:07.420 to another episode
00:55:08.500 of For the Wild podcast.
00:55:10.720 The music you heard today
00:55:11.960 was by Fabian Almasan Trio,
00:55:14.140 Dumpster Full of Dragons,
00:55:15.500 and I, Good Friend.
00:55:17.120 For the Wild is created
00:55:18.120 by Ayanna Young,
00:55:19.560 Erica Ekrem,
00:55:20.440 and Francesca Glaspell.
00:55:24.740 Thank you.