00:00:00.080This podcast is brought to you in part by support from our partner, the Calliopeia Foundation.
00:00:06.820Calliopeia envisions a future grounded in compassion, respect, dignity, reverence for nature, and care for each other and the earth.
00:00:16.160Other organizations they support include the Rocky Mountain Seed Alliance and Led to Life.
00:00:21.940To learn more about Calliopeia's mission, visit calliopeia.org.
00:00:27.140Hey for the wild community, Ayana here.
00:00:30.100In this week's episode, we'll be speaking with activist Elsa Sebastian from Last Stands
00:00:34.480about the current threats facing the Tongass National Forest in southeast Alaska.
00:00:39.940Since we spoke, there have been a few key updates that I'd like to share before we begin.
00:00:44.480One of the largest threats at this time is Trump's plan to rescind the roadless rule
00:00:48.680in the Tongass and open 9.2 million acres of protected land back up to logging and resource
00:00:55.200extraction. Just yesterday, the Forest Service announced that on Friday, October 18th, they will
00:01:01.880finally publish the draft environmental impact statement for the roadless rule exemption being
00:01:06.940proposed. The release will open a 60-day period for public review and comment, and for those of
00:01:13.580us who are U.S. citizens, we have the right and responsibility to weigh in on this important
00:01:18.740decision that will determine the future of the Tongass, one of the most precious living libraries
00:01:24.040left on this earth. We'll share more at the end of this episode, so stay tuned, and in the meantime,
00:01:29.920visit our website at forthewild.world and learn how you can make a public comment.
00:01:35.000We will also continue to share updates and ways that you can take action on the podcast
00:01:38.980and across our social media channels. Now on to the show.
00:01:47.100It is incredibly important that people engage with this comment process, especially as we're
00:01:52.520seeing the Trump administration work to try to weaken this type of process. Today we are speaking
00:01:59.860with Elsa Sebastian. Elsa grew up in the fishing village of Point Baker on northern Prince of Wales
00:02:05.620Island. For most of her 20s, Elsa captained a commercial salmon troller fishing the wild
00:02:11.100coastline of southeast Alaska. These days, Elsa deckhands on a drift gill netter in Bristol Bay
00:02:16.880and spends her winters working in conservation, most recently as executive director of Lynn
00:02:22.380Canal Conservation. Elsa loves wildlife and spent several years working with Alaska Whale Foundation
00:02:28.680to establish a remote field station on Baranoff Island, now serving as chair of the Alaska Whale
00:02:33.860Foundation Board of Directors. Elsa founded the Last Stands Project in 2017 to learn more about
00:02:40.480what remains of the world's largest coastal temperate rainforest, the Tongass. Since founding
00:02:45.720the project, she's bushwhacked and beachwalked through hundreds of miles of forest and coastline
00:02:50.480and sail to threatened last stand of old growth on her home island of Prince of Wales.
00:02:56.000Elsa is a 100-ton licensed captain and adventures from a 38-foot catch sailboat, the Murelit.
00:03:03.820Elsa, this is so wonderful to speak with you today.
00:03:06.900I just admire you so much and really hold you in my heart often.
00:03:12.320So thank you for making the time to be on For the Wild podcast.
00:03:16.640Thank you. I've been looking forward to this for a few months now.
00:03:19.180Yes, yes. I know. I love how our meeting has collided and now we're finally both being able to speak, both in Alaska, although not together, which next year that will have to change at some point.
00:03:32.120So I'd like to ground our conversation today by giving our listeners some historical context and background information on roadless rule.
00:03:39.920Passed in 2001 by the Clinton administration, the roadless rule prohibits further road construction and timber harvest in inventoried roadless areas.
00:03:48.740Roughly one third of all national forest system lands were approximately 58.5 million acres across the country.
00:03:56.480The rule is considered one of the country's most successful conservation measures,
00:04:00.820passing with tremendous public participation.
00:04:03.920Since its passing, however, the rule has faced a series of appeals and injunctions,
00:04:09.960And in Alaska, the rule currently faces renewed threats under the Trump administration's
00:04:15.360rollback of public lands conservation, the largest in American history, actually.
00:04:21.200So to jump in, why is roadless rule so important to uphold and protect?
00:04:25.780What is at stake in Alaska and in the 22 million acres of the Tongass and the Chugash National Forest that would be reopened to road development and logging?
00:04:35.360Yeah, thank you so much for that history.
00:04:40.400So the Tongass is the largest forest in Alaska, and it's also the only forest where we really have an active timber industry.
00:04:51.600The Forest Service likes to say that this rule change is to try to improve access for
00:04:58.240rural communities in Alaska so we can have access to things like, you know, hydropower.
00:05:05.020But actually, because this rule change is only impacting the Tongass, it's pretty obvious
00:05:09.240to see that this is about the timber industry.
00:05:13.540This is about opening up more acreage of old growth forest to be clear cut.
00:05:19.340so you had mentioned the tongas is our nation's largest forest it's 17 million acres in southeast
00:05:27.120alaska it wraps around 11 000 miles of coastline and remains one of the most pristine and productive
00:05:33.640estuaries on the planet now the tongas is also home to one of the largest remaining areas of
00:05:39.360ancient old growth temperate rainforest of cedar spruce and hemlock just to name a few
00:05:44.520some of these trees over a thousand years old, as well as countless plant and wildlife species,
00:05:50.600including the endangered marbled murrelit, bald eagles, Sitka black-tailed deer,
00:05:55.300and five species of Pacific salmon. So I'd love if you could tell us more about the dynamic
00:06:00.980relationships and ecological threads that weave between these plant and animal communities,
00:06:06.180and why is it so critical that these habitats and wildlife corridors remain undeveloped
00:06:11.180and intact to support the web of life beyond the Tongass?
00:06:14.500One of the things that this project has taught me is quite a bit about what is left in the Tongass
00:06:22.780and why it's important to protect what is left. The timber industry in the Tongass has been
00:06:29.620active at an industrial scale since the 50s. And since then, so many of the low-lying
00:06:37.960valleys and sort of easy pathways for animals have been cut. And so when I started this project,
00:06:46.480I had this idea that I was going to hike through threatened lands and I would only hike through
00:06:52.520old growth forest. What I found when I actually started planning my routes and getting out into
00:06:59.140the field is that the most obvious corridors for wildlife have often already been cut. So
00:07:06.620what that means is that the wildlife has to work harder to move between intact wild places and
00:07:14.000often has to use logging roads and so the areas that are left unroaded are absolutely essential
00:07:21.520to provide connectivity for wild animals and without it we're going to see these unique
00:07:29.200island ecosystems degraded to a point where they will no longer have an intact ecological
00:07:35.600character. And so protecting these roadless areas is absolutely critical to ensure that the Tongass0.95
00:07:44.280remains unfragmented in the places where it still expresses its most wild character.
00:07:51.800I've experienced the roadless areas in the Tongass, and it's beyond explanation to me
00:07:58.600that we need to protect these roadless areas because roads are the beginning to the end for
00:08:05.280species, for intact ecosystems. And it became that much more clear just being on the ground here.
00:08:12.560Now, the history of land management and resistance to industrial extraction is a much longer story
00:08:19.160than the present day debate over roadless rule. From one of your field journal entries, I recall
00:08:24.480that you spent your 10th birthday on an Amtrak train traveling with your family to Washington,
00:08:29.640D.C. to lobby for the inclusion of the Tongass and the roadless rule. So speaking from your0.91
00:08:35.380experience growing up on Prince of Wales Island and immersed in this culture of activism from
00:08:40.260such a young age, could you give us a sense of the arc of resistance and the shifting stakes
00:08:46.080in the Tongass? How has this movement and your relationship to it as an organizer and advocate
00:08:51.820for this land changed through the years? I think that this project and my advocacy within the last
00:08:59.820few years has had me thinking a lot about how people settle places and how their relationship
00:09:07.640changes with those places throughout generations. So my parents moved to Alaska in the 70s and both
00:09:17.200of them were coming from essentially the suburbs. My dad grew up in Ohio and my mom was from
00:09:23.900Oakland. And they came to Alaska and for them, it was paradise. It was a place where there was
00:09:33.420wildness and abundance beyond what they ever imagined. So when they moved to Alaska and
00:09:40.360started a family, I think for them to watch the timber industry, which was really at its peak,
00:09:47.200when they were starting their family, it was such an attack on what they had found. And this thing
00:09:53.820that they had found, as I said, was beyond what they could have ever imagined. And so their
00:10:01.200response to that violent attack was very passionate. And it really, in many ways,
00:10:08.640was what they needed to do and what felt necessary in that moment. But it wasn't informed by
00:10:15.480a long history on the land. So growing up in a family that was engaged in environmental activism,
00:10:23.800I was just aware of how divisive environmental conflict is in rural places and how it tears
00:10:32.720people apart, the impact that it has on rural communities in terms of, you know, really
00:10:39.540impacting friendships, impacting the potential for communities to grow and flourish, because
00:10:46.120there's just so much emotion that is ingrained in the conflict. And so as a second generation
00:10:56.540environmental activist, I feel that my journey has been a bit more complicated than that,
00:11:02.680But it's still a young journey. I think it'll take, you know, generations of living in the Tongass to really be able to speak for it in an informed way. And so I hope that my future ancestors are able to carry this work forward.
00:11:21.360but when I grew up in on Prince of Wales the timber industry was was very visible I remember
00:11:30.040looking out the window from our log cabin living room and seeing you know these huge ships just
00:11:37.080loaded with you know freshly fallen trees moving by headed to wherever and as a child like that
00:11:43.780that was really hard to process what I was actually seeing and I think I didn't really
00:11:48.460I didn't really have the capacity to understand what was happening to the land that I was growing
00:11:54.300up on. As a child and for much of my life, the land really showed me beauty almost exclusively.
00:12:03.340And sometimes that beauty was woven in pretty fierce colors of the storms and the darkness and
00:12:10.400sort of the intensity of where the land meets the sea and the sharp edges of the coast. But I think
00:12:17.640most of all the land took care of us and it was just so abundant in that, in giving us the venison
00:12:24.180and the berries and the birdsong and the tranquility. And so I saw the forest as being
00:12:30.840abundant and beautiful. And the realities of what the timber industry, you know, with all of the
00:12:40.300force of government subsidy behind it was doing to my home island and also, you know, all of
00:12:46.560the rainforest islands in Southeast Alaska that have those big stands of trees.
00:12:51.720So I think in some ways for me, I, you know, I started the last stands project when I was 27
00:12:58.840and it really feels like a coming of age project. I think at a certain point, if you're going to live
00:13:06.700somewhere with dignity and intentionality, you just have to take the blinders off and see
00:13:13.940around you. And for me, when I first started this project, you know, I had my huge backpack and I
00:13:19.880was going to hike across the last stands of untouched ancient old growth on Prince of Wales.
00:13:25.900And I started to look at the forest in a different way to actually understand what the human history
00:13:31.780of industrial extraction has been. And when I did that, I realized, you know, for the first time
00:13:39.320that the hillsides around my home were covered in scars and those scars were old clear cuts.
00:13:49.140And even though those areas were green and looked recovered from the shore,
00:13:53.860when you look at an old clear cut, it's a green canopy. But what you don't understand when you
00:14:01.320see that green is that underneath that top layer of the top of the canopy, those old clear cuts
00:14:08.100are really like dead zones. There's no understory growth or life. And so I think that, you know,
00:14:14.500as an activist, when I started this, it was, you know, as a 10 year old, I went back to
00:14:21.140Washington, DC to lobby for the roadless rule. At that time, you know, my parents were just
00:14:28.060telling me to speak for the value of our lifestyle, because they recognized that our lifestyle was
00:14:34.620under attack. So I was just speaking to these people who are making these decisions and trying
00:14:41.960to tell them as a 10-year-old why I cared about salmon and why I liked being able to play in the
00:14:49.740forest. But now as an adult, I think that I've finally come to a place where I can start to
00:14:59.000meet the forest with a more honest approach of seeing and understanding. And it's been,
00:15:09.560in some ways, sort of a painful transition because those realities are really hard to bear.
00:15:19.520I was visualizing you as a young child playing in the forest and going to Washington, D.C., and
00:15:25.540I love hearing your stories. So thank you for sharing those personal pieces of your life with
00:15:31.060us. I was actually just looking for this quote that you once wrote, quote, there are not anonymous
00:15:37.960lands. These are lands with long histories, rich webs of life and value that extends far beyond
00:15:44.640stumpage, end quote. And I'm wondering why have you chosen to tell the story of the Tongass in
00:15:50.640the way that you have, beyond traditional data and scientific methodologies, but instead through
00:15:56.400written word, drawings, photography, social media, and compelling narratives. And maybe a second part
00:16:03.360to that is beyond the measurable scientific findings, it seems that so much of what you're
00:16:09.120trying to give voice to in this project cannot be captured or quantified in the data. So I also
00:16:14.980wonder how you share these important messages with the court's lobbyist or those who may not
00:16:19.900necessarily see value beyond the numbers. Yeah. Trying to figure out how to do that has been
00:16:27.320at the heart of this journey. And I think that's in part why this project continues for me when
00:16:34.560whenever I have open space in my life, I feel myself drawn back to the forest and drawn back
00:16:41.780to this sort of intense interdisciplinary way of trying to experience a place. And it's
00:16:49.080interdisciplinary because of the people that I journey with. So I think that ground truthing
00:16:55.660for me is a way to engage with public lands as fully as we can and try to democratize
00:17:07.560the sort of information that is shared with the public about their lands. So the Tongass is
00:17:14.960held in common between all of us who are citizens of the United States. And for me,
00:17:23.360ground truthing is a way to bring a human and a non-expert perspective to the table.
00:17:30.320Spending time on the land gives somebody authority to speak for what is valuable there.
00:17:36.080And what I've found actually is that a lot of times the folks who are in management roles
00:17:42.960don't actually understand what is truly in the forest beyond the colors that they're looking at
00:17:50.820on the map. And we've actually had an experience with the Last Sands Project where we talked to
00:17:57.720a ranger at a local Forest Service office about an area that we were planning to walk through.
00:18:05.040And we were concerned about that area because it did have a heavy past with timber extraction,
00:18:11.440And we knew that it was just going to be this, you know, chopped up matrix of broken lands.
00:18:16.800And we wanted to find a path that would take us through some of the old growth that was left there.
00:18:22.320And this ranger who is the local manager for the forest pointed to areas on the map that were designated old growth reserve and told us that, you know, that's where the big trees would be.
00:18:36.560And so we went there and we had to walk on logging roads to get there.
00:18:40.540and when we got there we realized that what he had sent us to were actually very old clear cuts
00:18:48.680so clear cuts that had happened before the forest service started taking good notes basically
00:18:54.600so that was really interesting just realizing that just because something is designated in
00:19:01.880a certain way on on the map doesn't mean that you know that that accepted reality is going to hold
00:19:07.100up when you're in the forest itself. So yeah, that idea of ground truthing as a citizen of
00:19:15.740this democracy to be in the land and to confirm whether or not what we've been told is true,
00:19:23.360which is a definition that I'm sort of pulling from Terry Tempest Williams and some of the work
00:19:28.500that she's done in the arctic i think that is a critical foundation of this project i think what
00:19:37.280i've started to realize on a more personal level is that we need to we need to have stories to
00:19:44.040explain the urgency of these issues and we need to have stories that will fuel us as conservationists
00:19:54.380and keep us going even when that advocacy work feels futile.
00:20:00.500Stories can come from experiences that we create for ourselves.
00:20:05.620And I think that for many people in our generation,
00:20:09.600we're starting to realize that we live in a culture
00:20:13.380that is devoid of the sort of ritual that we need
00:20:16.740to find a more reverent relationship with nature.
00:20:19.500so you know we have to sort of start out in this fledgling way to try to create our own rituals and
00:20:26.820and yet there's so much to pull from and I think the idea of walking and pilgrimage is something
00:20:34.160that has been really inspiring for me on this project I mean it's the most ancient way to be
00:20:40.720an awareness of a landscape in a humble way and if you do enough of it you sort of find a rhythm
00:20:49.480So for me, this moving through the dense rainforest, it really is bushwhacking. I mean, it's not like we're moving in slow motion through glorious stands of huge old trees. So much of it is just like crawling on hands and knees through dense thickets of berry bushes and pokey devil's club.
00:21:09.680But when you do it enough, you're really opening yourself up to joy as well. And there's so much that I'm still processing from this work, but I feel like this sort of joy that comes from spending a lot of time in a place that is threatened with the hope of protecting it is what motivates you to tell stories about the place and work for it.
00:21:37.920You know, and I plan to work for these, you know, stands of old growth for the rest of my life. And I know that I'll have to.
00:21:44.180stories are powerful and they have been for us humans probably since the very beginning
00:21:51.880and i don't think that data alone is going to support us in protecting these places i think
00:22:01.740it's important to an extent to be able to ramble off oh the carbon sequestration information and
00:22:07.240that of course we're going through a massive extinction and those things are important but
00:22:12.000I'm really with you in the way that you see where the power lies to shift people's perspective.
00:22:20.880Yeah. And that point of, you know, data is a really good one. And I think we're in an
00:22:26.280interesting time because I feel that people who understand that things aren't going the way they
00:22:34.220should be, who, you know, feel a hole in their hearts are often told that, you know, data is
00:22:42.800the sort of root of those problems. You know, we're at a time where we're, you know, questioning
00:22:47.740science. That's not what this project is about. You know, we're absolutely not questioning science.
00:22:54.580I think what I'm trying to do and sort of find my way through as a local advocate for these places
00:23:02.920is to just be a more whole and fierce defender by having connection to, you know, each of these
00:23:13.580stands of force that are threatened. And I think that, you know, when you put yourself out there
00:23:19.900in that way, it makes it work a lot more painful. I'm fully anticipating that some of these areas
00:23:27.820that I've visited on Prince of Wales will be logged not just within my lifetime but within
00:23:33.560the next 10 years and so when I hear about that I'm going to be you know imagining that gorgeous
00:23:41.300cedar tree that I stumbled upon after hours of thrashing around in thickets of berry bushes
00:23:48.120you know stepping out and like coming to that gentle flowing creek and seeing this enormous
00:23:54.080tree that just holds so much space and so much silence and, you know, seeing around it the beds
00:24:00.120of deer and just the ways that like seeing through the forest, the ways that the animals and, you
00:24:06.940know, the things that are living in the forest appreciate the presence of that tree. When that
00:24:11.540place is threatened, I am going to feel that so deeply. And I think that in some ways that feels
00:24:21.560really scary. I mean, when you forge these personal connections with places, what you're
00:24:27.840doing is you're opening yourself up for heartbreak. But I also think that it allows me to speak in a
00:24:35.920more informed way about what's actually on the ground. And one of the environmental writers that
00:24:41.780resonates most with me is Wendell Berry. And I think the reason that I feel such a strong affinity
00:24:49.800for him is because he also is working to love a place that has been hit hard by industry.
00:24:58.820And when I say working, I really do mean that. I think that it takes effort to open yourself up
00:25:06.200to love places that have been hurt. So some of the things that Wendell Berry is dealing with
00:25:11.460and thinking about as he writes and as he finds an environmental ethic for Appalachia is
00:25:19.260the impact of industrial agriculture and coal mining and boom economies and the poverty that
00:25:25.180follows in the wake of those booms. And where I'm from, Prince of Wales has also been hit hard
00:25:32.100by industrial extraction. And we're dealing with the same after effect of boom and bust
00:25:39.220industry. And that's why Prince of Wales is called the Sacrifice Zone. And it's interesting
00:25:45.580to relate this to Wendell Berry because he's writing about industrial agriculture. And that's
00:25:51.480a huge part of the problem for the Tongass and all forests within our national forest system
00:25:57.760is that they're being managed under the Department of Agriculture. You know, the Forest Service
00:26:03.500is part of the Department of Agriculture. And so that's part of the reason why we're letting
00:26:10.440ancient forests that have been thousands of years in the growing to be managed as if they're crops
00:26:17.920of lettuce. So these foresters that are working within the system of management are experts,
00:26:26.860but they're experts in a sort of quantitative system that I think will always be deferential
00:26:37.680to the needs of the timber industry because the outputs of timber are easily measured
00:26:44.160and the successful managers of Southeast Alaska are the ones that are able to show the productivity
00:26:52.820of the land as it's measured through, you know, millions of board feet of old growth trees.
00:26:59.760So the kind of value that a citizen of Southeast Alaska, you know, someone that lives in the
00:27:07.300Tongass is trying to speak to, you know, when they're pushing back against these policies
00:27:13.540is a lot harder to quantify. I mean, we're talking about a lot of times what we're talking about
00:27:20.160something that's more spiritual and we're talking about our need for beauty. We're talking about our
00:27:27.360need to continue to live in a way that our parents have made for us. And in the case of many people
00:27:36.960in Southeast Alaska who are indigenous to the land it's thousands of years of ancestors who
00:27:43.960have made that way and that unfortunately is not something that expert culture is very good at
00:27:53.980and I think that this project the idea of ground truthing is for me at least like a way to
00:28:03.660really strengthen my local knowledge and my love of this area that will continually
00:28:12.240be under attack by a management system that exists to quantify productivity of the land.
00:28:33.660We'll place our records in these dark hours.
00:28:37.800Our love is unprotected like the ocean waves pouring over my feet.
00:28:44.880It reaches my knees and for a moment I am lost in the sway.
00:28:55.520And we're dancing all night in your reading room
00:29:03.860And your books are talking to us and the music too
00:29:34.180Like cigarettes more left as an evening dew
00:29:40.280We could paint it over a thousand times
00:29:47.160But it would still be the same shade of highway blue0.92
00:29:52.820you had mentioned that prince of wales where you grew up is the sacrifice zone of the boom
00:30:06.880and bust of logging it's also i've read it being called ground zero for old growth logging i think
00:30:12.520that was actually what drew me to go to prince of wales island was seeing that on a i think it was
00:30:17.820an article title. And I'm just curious how this economic conflict plays out in your community
00:30:25.640of Prince of Wales. How did the logging boom through the second half of the 20th century
00:30:30.800not only drastically impact the forest and watershed ecosystems, but also sow the seeds
00:30:36.580of social division and cultural toxicity? And how do you go about navigating the complexity
00:30:41.960intentions that are rooted in these issues as an advocate, an activist, and a neighbor?
00:30:48.780Well, I feel often that I am well prepared to be an advocate for conservation in Southeast Alaska
00:30:59.060because of my relationship with salmon. I've spent every summer of my life
00:31:05.740working in the commercial salmon fishing industry in one way or the other.
00:31:10.920I grew up on my family's fishing boat, would spend three to four months of the year with my family on our tiny 42-foot wooden fishing boat, catching salmon and making our livelihood.
00:31:25.040And in my early 20s, I started running my own boat and fishing solo, and I did that for about five years.
00:31:33.800And I think that was really important work for me and continues to be because I understand how you can have a really powerful, meaningful relationship with a creature or a living thing that you're taking the life from.
00:31:58.220And I also understand how significant that sort of work is to maintaining connections between family. It's an important thing in my family that I'm still a fisherman, because I can call my parents and ask them how their fishing season is going. And we can have like a really vital back and forth about the work that we do. And that's an important thing to me.
00:32:22.560But what I've started to realize is that, you know, the story of commercial fishing in Southeast Alaska and of logging are really actually close.
00:32:34.980When the commercial fishing industry started in Southeast Alaska, people used to catch these, you know, big hundred pound king salmon, like pretty frequently.
00:32:43.880And I've never even seen a fish that big.
00:32:46.780The size of those big king salmon has been gradually declining over the last 80 years.
00:32:56.100And the big fish that my father caught when he first started fishing here are twice the size of the big fish that I catch now.
00:33:04.580And I think that there's sadness in watching that sort of change.
00:33:09.260And it feels really basic to want to try to hold things as they are, to not want to accept that reality that, you know, humans have had an impact. The reason why there aren't those big fish anymore is because that genetic line has been removed in large part because of commercial fishermen.
00:33:29.760and of course you know commercial salmon fishing is a lot different than logging old growth trees
00:33:37.240because these big trees that were falling are you know sometimes you know 500 600 700 even
00:33:43.800you know a thousand years old so that cycle of return is is a very long one and it's really hard
00:33:51.180to to correct the wrong that has been done but I guess what I feel is important to me as a
00:33:58.700conservationist. And what allows me to work in communities without feeling too much anger is
00:34:04.480recognizing that these sort of industries are often the way that people are finding their
00:34:11.040identity and finding their connection to their family. And a lot of communities on Prince of
00:34:18.260Wales were founded, well, white settler communities were founded on the timber industry.
00:34:26.380and those communities are dying out because for one, they were never built with the sort of
00:34:34.780stability or care that most communities are. I mean, they were boom towns. People came because
00:34:41.080there were jobs and some of those people really fell in love with the lifestyle and wanted to
00:34:45.520stay. So coming to realize that and realizing the commonality that I have with those people
00:34:53.000who are working in the timber industry is definitely, it's one of the painful parts of
00:34:59.900this work. I think as a second generation advocate for the Tongass, it's not natural for me
00:35:08.080to demonize the other side. What is wrong is that very few people are actually making money
00:35:17.200off of falling these ancient trees what is wrong is that when we clear-cut forests
00:35:24.720and send you know 50 to 80 percent of those trees overseas we're stripping the land that we live on
00:35:35.260of its value and we're doing that for the next 200 years because an old growth forest won't
00:35:43.700be able to carve out its, you know, vital existence on those lands for at least another
00:35:50.340200 years. When I advocate for stopping the timber industry at an industrial scale,
00:35:55.840I'm doing that in part because I want to see people continue to live on Prince of Wales
00:36:02.820and continue to have the opportunity to have relationship with big old trees. And sometimes
00:36:08.980that relationship, you know, involves taking the life of that tree and using it for something.
00:36:13.700And, you know, from like an economic perspective, those big old growth trees are like money in the bank for local communities.
00:36:23.520But we can't just think about them in terms of their immediate economic value because that is stripping land of its abundance and its, you know, potential to support future generations.
00:36:36.180and actually being able to communicate that in an effective way and a way that can make a difference
00:36:44.040with policy is very challenging, especially now when we're in a time where we're seeing
00:36:50.460the NEPA process being undermined. People are being removed from management decisions
00:36:58.220and they're being removed so a very few can make a quick buck that's pretty tragic and i don't
00:37:06.180think that's what anybody wants in southeast alaska thank you for sharing some of the
00:37:13.880complexities with us and how you have come to find a type of reckoning with this really painful
00:37:22.720issue in your home and i so appreciate the work that you have done on yourself and perhaps the
00:37:30.000salmon and the forest have done on you to be able to hold the complexity so gracefully now i want to
00:37:36.720talk a little bit more about the economic issues surrounding this old growth logging and in january
00:37:42.720in 2018 just to give some context the state of alaska sent a petition to the usda requesting
00:37:49.640that these areas be exempt from the roadless rule. And since then, they have jointly signed
00:37:54.580a memorandum of understanding announcing their intention to create an Alaska state-specific
00:38:00.020version of the rule that would reopen to logging and road building. Based on my research for this
00:38:06.240episode, it seems that the state and logging industry's opposition to the rule is largely
00:38:11.040mounted on this economic claim that road construction, further development, and resource
00:38:16.420extraction is economically beneficial to Alaskans. So as somebody who works in the fishing industry,
00:38:22.600like you've told us, if you could paint a more comprehensive picture for us of these many
00:38:28.460economic issues at play in the debate around the rule, I just want you to speak to those people
00:38:34.160who say, but what about jobs? What about the economy? We need this. Or people from the outside
00:38:41.440who think that they should support this exemption to the roadless rule because they believe that
00:38:46.900it's actually going to be supporting people. Yeah. The economic rationale for the timber
00:38:52.560industry in Southeast Alaska is incredibly frustrating to have to continually address
00:38:58.680because the timber industry in Southeast Alaska has feasted off of subsidies for pretty much
00:39:09.240since its industrial formation. And in reality, you know, tourism and commercial fishing
00:39:17.260provides about 25% of the jobs in Southeast Alaska, and logging provides less than 1%.
00:39:25.620And so the numbers are there, you know, tourism and commercial fishing,
00:39:30.360Those industries are reliant on the Tongass to be this beautiful, incredibly rich place, not just visually, but down to the watersheds as well that support salmon that commercial fishermen are absolutely reliant on.
00:39:51.740But that's not really where the argument is at, really. As we were talking about before, I mean, this really is a cultural thing.
00:39:59.860There's a few people in Southeast Alaska who are making a lot of money off the timber industry, and they're able to sort of play that cultural card to influence politicians who want to work to support their livelihood.
00:40:22.400But what's really sad is that the timber industry, as it is, has a very short future. So Prince of Wales, where I'm from, has the last mill that is cutting trees on an industrial scale in Southeast.
00:40:39.420And so that means that a lot of the policy changes that are put forward to try to encourage growth in the timber industry in Southeast Alaska are done almost exclusively for the benefit of that one mill.
00:40:56.480So when the Forest Service and the Trump administration and the state of Alaska continue to manage the Tongass National Forest for clear-cut logging, they are justifying that decision based on the fact that there is a mill that is still doing that logging and operating locally.
00:41:18.320the sort of depressing side of that and and the the reason why there's urgency i think in this
00:41:27.160moment is that that mill viking mill refuses to transition to a second growth industry so a second
00:41:37.980growth industry would be an industry where they were cutting trees that have grown up on the scars
00:41:47.180of clear cuts from you know the past 50 years they refuse to do that their machinery is
00:41:56.000so big that it can only process old growth trees and when that mill shuts down the family that's
00:42:07.420running the mill they'll be fine the folks who won't be fine are you know those 40 workers which
00:42:14.280That's how many workers Viking claim work at their mill. But in fact, there's probably only another, you know, maybe 15 years of old growth timber left on Prince of Wales.
00:42:29.400and if we open up these roadless areas maybe there's more but we're really looking at this
00:42:36.700mill shutting down within most likely the next like 10 or 20 years because there just aren't
00:42:44.200enough old growth trees left to make the industry profitable for a mill that's operating at that
00:42:49.660size and so it really comes down to now will we make the decision to actually gracefully transition
00:42:57.940the Tongass, away from clear-cut logging? Will we take care of the people who work at that mill
00:43:03.940and provide them other jobs? Or will we just let this go as every other boom and bust community
00:43:09.600will go if it's allowed? Take the last of what stands. People lose their jobs. They leave town
00:43:18.620because there's nothing left. And if we allow Viking Mill to continue to cut trees on Prince
00:43:24.940of Wales, there will be nothing left because the forest is an essential part of the reason why
00:43:32.600people live on Prince of Wales. It provides us with venison. Sitka black-tailed deer are essential
00:43:39.860to people who live a subsistence lifestyle, and most people do. It provides us with the sort of
00:43:46.460watersheds that can support the return of salmon. And it also supplies us with what is arguably
00:43:53.340still the most abundant opportunity in Southeast Alaska, which is these big, beautiful trees
00:43:59.220that we can make refined products out of, that we can build economies around.
00:44:07.080The question is, is whether or not those economies are going to be economies that can be,
00:44:12.460you know, tended and passed through generations, or whether they're just going to be a boom
00:44:17.440and bust economy that takes what it can get, takes the money and then leaves.
00:44:21.420And so the economic argument that the timber industry utilizes is so incredibly weak.
00:44:34.160The only reason why this industry exists is because of government subsidies.
00:44:40.700It is so expensive to cut trees in Southeast Alaska.
00:44:49.140dollars, that money is given to the timber industry by the U.S. Forest Service. They literally take
00:44:55.680that off the price tag of these timber sales because they, you know, somehow justify that it
00:45:02.960will provide future economic opportunity to these places. So the timber industry is able to operate
00:45:12.380because of those subsidies and that's the reason why we have like 2,500 miles of logging roads on
00:45:21.220an island that's only 135 miles long and when the only mill that's operating on the island
00:45:29.280has made it abundantly clear that as soon as the old growth is gone they're going to pack up shop
00:45:35.980and retreat down to their parent corporation in Washington it's obvious to the people who live
00:45:41.340there, who, who want to live there, who want to see there continue to be vital communities
00:45:46.580that, you know, the US Forest Service's justification for providing subsidies for
00:45:52.960logging roads is a lie. If, if there's no timber industry present that wants to harvest second
00:46:00.400growth, then those roads that, you know, we've been paying to build are a one-off. They're a
00:46:07.040one-off for very few people who are making profit off of this beautiful rainforest that is held in
00:46:14.740common by the people of the United States. God damn it. And beyond that, I look around in the0.99
00:46:24.520commercial fishing industry and I see that the young people who are investing in the industry
00:46:29.880are doing it in an incredibly thoughtful way you know they've recognized that no longer do we live
00:46:37.640in a time where there's just raw abundance there's more people living in the tongas national forest
00:46:44.160than there ever have been and you know we're pretty hungry for resources so the pop the
00:46:51.400populations of wild salmon aren't what they used to be and i see you know young fishermen responding
00:46:57.560to that in a really smart way, which is this realization that this action of structuring
00:47:03.940their business so they're able to catch less and make more money off of it.
00:47:09.120And that means that they're, you know, creating value-added products.
00:47:13.740You know, they're putting it in a jar, they're, you know, filleting it themselves and creating
00:47:18.880direct markets that make sense for them.
00:47:21.620I think that it's 79% of the salmon that are harvested commercially in Southeast Alaska are coming from streams on the Tongass. Those salmon are reliant on those big old growth trees to hold that together.
00:47:34.700and also um tourism is uh significant um people want to visit this place because it has
00:47:43.660a sort of raw beauty it has in this you know this lushness this life it has so many things living
00:47:51.180in it has the hugest bears it has you know hump humpback whales that the connection between land
00:47:56.720and sea is is visible and you can experience it even if you only are you know coming in
00:48:03.500and staying for a few days or a week. And so those two industries that are so valuable and
00:48:11.180are reliant on the Tongass make up 25% of the economic resource in Southeast Alaska
00:48:20.520and the timber industry is less than 1%.
00:50:22.440as I got off the plane when a phone call came in. And this is what they said. You've got to go
00:50:31.660home. You've got to go home. I really want to focus now back on the roadless rule.
00:50:43.480And over the years, allied government and corporate entities have chipped away at the
00:50:48.140integrity of legislation and protections for the Tongass, largely by disregarding or barring public
00:50:54.600input and denying citizens their right to information. The Forest Service is opening up
00:50:59.940a period for public input this summer or potentially in the next few weeks even on Alaska
00:51:05.460state-specific rulemaking, but this commentary period will likely come during the busiest fishing
00:51:11.420season, guiding season, or at the end of it if it's coming in a couple weeks, which essentially
00:51:16.420obstructs due process and citizen input, particularly from those who make a living
00:51:21.060from the state's natural resources, thus most impacted by the ruling, which is just crazy
00:51:26.640making to know that. Now, public participation was instrumental in the passing of roadless rule
00:51:31.740back in 2001, with more than 600 public hearings around the nation, 1.6 million public comments,
00:51:38.320and 95% supporting strong roadless protection. So what, if anything, has changed in this case?
00:51:45.000Has there been maybe less public participation and consensus around this issue? Or has the opposition put more barriers in place to try and force through this legislation? And yeah, maybe also speak to just the importance of making the comment when it does open potentially in a few weeks.
00:52:03.960Yeah. So the roadless rule was very popular when the Clinton administration started to plan it and heard from the people and was able to finalize the rule in 2001.
00:52:18.420And the state of Alaska has pushed back on the rules since the beginning, you know, because of this sort of adherence to the timber industry and the will of the timber industry, even as that industry is becoming such a small part of our economy.
00:52:37.440and last fall when the U.S. Forest Service was scoping this rule change
00:52:43.980and they were traveling to communities in Southeast Alaska,
01:06:55.280You can do so today through Southeast Alaska Conservation Council or SEAC's online portal.
01:07:01.800Their plan is to flood the U.S. Forest Service on Saturday, October 19th, as soon as the comment period opens, with all of the comments that they have collected so far.
01:07:11.660Thereafter, every comment made through their website will go directly to the U.S. Forest Service.
01:07:16.640The deadline is December 17th, 2019 at midnight Alaska time.
01:07:21.260visit seac.org or our website for the wild.world to find the full link
01:07:28.600second please consider making a donation to lost stands fundraising campaign and support the team
01:07:35.400in bringing stories of the tongas to life through their beautiful art and film projects visit go
01:07:41.080fund me and search tongas lost stands to stay up to date and informed about issues in the tongas
01:07:47.340check out the following organizations and follow them on social media
01:07:51.380audubon alaska southeast alaska conservation council sitka conservation society women's
01:07:58.360earth and climate action network and earth justice lastly one of the most important
01:08:03.360things you can do is spread the word and share this information and episode with your friends
01:08:08.020families neighbors anyone who cares about the future of our public lands we'll need as many
01:08:14.020people as possible to step up and stop this legislation from passing. As always, you can
01:08:19.660visit our website at forthewild.world or click on the details tab of this episode for links and more
01:08:25.680information. Thank you for listening to another episode of For the Wild podcast. I'm Ayanna Young.
01:08:33.780The music you heard today was from Aaron Durant. I'd like to thank our magical team,
01:08:39.020Aidan McRae, Andrew Storrs, Carter Lou McElroy, Erica Ekrem, Aaron Wise,
01:08:46.120Francesca Glaspell, Hannah Wilton, Melanie Younger, and Suzanne Dollywall.