For The Wild - May 12, 2021


TERRY TEMPEST WILLIAMS on Sacred Rage and the Battle for Public Lands ⌠ENCORE⌡ ⧸233

Topics
GOPAL DAYANENI on the Exploitation of Soil and Story ⧸232 BANI AMOR on Tourism and the Colonial Project ⧸234

Episode Stats


Length

56 minutes

Words per minute

141.19

Word count

7,945

Sentence count

358

Harmful content

Hate speech

1

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 For the Wild is brought to you in part by the Calliopeia Foundation.
00:00:04.900 We are grateful for their continued support and the support of grassroots contributions
00:00:09.780 from listeners like you.
00:00:11.800 Learn more at calliopeia.org.
00:00:14.640 To make a donation, visit forthewild.world slash donate or find us on Patreon.
00:00:21.120 If you'd like to support us in other ways, consider sharing our episodes through social
00:00:25.480 media or leaving us a review wherever you listen to the podcast.
00:00:30.760 Welcome to For the Wild podcast. I'm Ayanna Young. This week we are rebroadcasting our
00:00:37.260 interview with Terry Tempest-Williams, initially broadcasted in October of 2017. In this evergreen
00:00:45.120 episode, Terry and I discuss public lands and the power of sacred rage. We hope you
00:00:51.100 enjoy this special Encore episode.
00:00:53.000 I asked him, how do you stave off despair? And he said, surround yourself with people you love
00:01:01.120 and seek out wild places. And then he turned to me and said, we lose nothing by loving.
00:01:10.460 I believe that. Terry is an American author, conservationist, and activist.
00:01:16.460 Her work ranges from issues of ecology and wilderness preservation, to women's health,
00:01:21.760 to exploring our relationship to culture and nature.
00:01:25.760 Williams is the author of Refuge,
00:01:27.660 An Unnatural History of Family and Place,
00:01:30.620 An Unspoken Hunger, Stories from the Field,
00:01:33.860 Desert Quartet, Leap, Red,
00:01:37.360 Patience and Passion in the Desert,
00:01:39.660 and The Open Space of Democracy.
00:01:42.540 She divides her time between Wilson, Wyoming,
00:01:44.960 and Castle Valley, Utah,
00:01:46.600 where her husband, Brooke, is field coordinator
00:01:48.620 for the Southern Utah Wilderness Alliance.
00:01:51.760 Wow, goodness. Thank you so much, Terri, for joining us today.
00:01:56.000 It's a pleasure, Ayanna. Thank you so much for having me.
00:01:59.640 Terri, I wanted to start off by again thanking you, but specifically for your work as an artist, a writer, and an activist, and how you have taken political measures personally to protect public wildlands.
00:02:13.800 And I think it's absolutely critical right now that we all learn from each other about how to stand up for these public lands and to think up to, I think, 21 national monuments are a threat right now.
00:02:28.400 And Trump appears hellbent on dismantling public lands to the full extent as he is able.
00:02:34.860 The largest among the monuments under threat is Bare Ears, which many predict will be the next Standing Rock if this goes forward.
00:02:42.340 So I'm wondering if you could talk a bit about this latest chapter of the assault on public lands and why this has got to be stopped and how we can find those fissures of opportunity to creatively resist and safeguard these last intact treasures.
00:03:01.920 It renders me speechless because I still can't wrap my arms around what's happening.
00:03:07.200 But I think it's important to take a long view, both backwards and forwards.
00:03:13.360 You know, in a sense, this is nothing new.
00:03:17.140 For the past three decades, we've been fighting for our public lands, especially in the interior
00:03:22.860 west, in Utah, particularly, whether it's the Sagebrush Rebellion that we saw in the
00:03:30.680 70s and 80s, whether it was the forest wars that we saw in the 90s, this is just a reoccurring
00:03:40.740 theme and incarnation of the desire for the extractive industry to privatize our public
00:03:49.620 lands. And the thing that makes this incarnation so frightening is we have a president who not
00:03:57.620 only doesn't care about these public lands, I doubt he's ever set foot in them. And in that
00:04:03.420 sense, people like Orrin Hatch and Rob Bishop and Chaffetz, who are Utah's delegation, have
00:04:11.780 exorbitant sway. And then you have someone as weak as Interior Secretary Zinke, who pretends that
00:04:18.620 he's in the likelihood or in the same fabric as Theodore Roosevelt, and nothing could be farther
00:04:24.960 from the truth. He rides in on his first day in Washington on a horse. In fact, he lives in a
00:04:31.860 gated community in Santa Barbara. So I think we have to put things in perspective. In terms of
00:04:37.760 the monuments, again, this is tailored for Utah. The parameters of these 27 monuments that are under
00:04:46.200 review begin in 1996, and they end in 2016. This was tailored and fashioned by Orrin Hatch.
00:04:56.080 It begins with Grand Staircase Escalante National Monument in 1996, and it ends with
00:05:01.680 Bears Ears. He's never gotten over the fact that these lands were protected. And, you know,
00:05:06.380 these are acts of revenge and pettiness and nastiness, all at the pleasure and profit of
00:05:14.820 the oil and gas industries. So that's sort of my take on the background. I also think it's really
00:05:22.100 important for our listeners to actually hear these names, because there's power in names.
00:05:29.200 And just to contemplate where these are, and what states they belong to. And in fact,
00:05:36.900 they belong to all of us. Our public lands are our public commons. So these are monuments with
00:05:44.600 over 100,000 acres, and in many cases, several million. Basement Range, Nevada, Bears Ears, Utah,
00:05:55.440 Berryessa Snow Mountain, California, Canyons of the Ancients, Colorado, Carrizo Plain, California,
00:06:04.480 Cascade Siskiyou, Oregon, Craters of the Moon, Idaho. That was established in 1924. It's just
00:06:13.640 hard to imagine. Giant Sequoia, California. Gold Butte, Nevada. Grand Canyon Parishant, Arizona.
00:06:21.800 Grand Staircase Escalante, Utah. Hanford Reach, Washington. Ironwood Forest, Arizona. Mojave
00:06:31.180 Trails, California. Oregon Mountains Desert Peaks, New Mexico. Rio Grande del Norte, New Mexico.
00:06:39.240 Santa Snow, California, San Gabriel Mountains, California, Sonoran Desert, Arizona, Upper Missouri River Breaks, Montana, Vermilion Cliffs, Arizona, and we can add Katahdin Woods and Waters in Maine.
00:06:55.800 So that's the list. And for those of us who know and love these places, it's more than a heartbreak. It's a tragedy.
00:07:06.520 But what's interesting to note is that over a million citizens have sent in their comments already and have said, we do not want these monuments rescinded or reduced. We want them protected.
00:07:18.480 So the question remains, will these open spaces of democracy remain open?
00:07:25.940 that was so powerful terry to hear you speak the names and the locations of the monuments thank you
00:07:35.240 for speaking the names aloud and i just felt chills all over my body imagining i've been to
00:07:43.180 many of those incredible gifts that i feel that they are on this planet for us to care for and
00:07:50.200 steward and be inspired by and be fed by so thank you again for that and i want to also question
00:07:58.180 how can we find those fissures of opportunity to creatively resist and safeguard these last
00:08:05.380 intact treasures and i know that you and tim to christopher and many others have found those
00:08:11.660 fissures and i'd like to speak on that for a bit and any ideas that are swirling in your head for
00:08:17.300 those people in the audience who want to take a grandstand. You know, I'm not sure the grandstand
00:08:24.780 is what is needed. I think that small, deliberate, focused acts within our own communities and the
00:08:31.680 places we call home, in many ways, are the most powerful, Ayanna. And, you know, going back to
00:08:37.720 Bear's years, it's been such a potent experience for conservationists in Utah and really around
00:08:45.160 the country because what we've been able to witness and learn from and be inspired by
00:08:51.080 have been the tribes and the tribal leadership that has come forward through the five intertribal
00:08:59.880 commissions that has led the way for Bears Ears National Monument and that President Obama responded
00:09:06.700 to, as did Sally Jewell in 2016. You have the Navajo, you have the Hopi, Zuni, and the two
00:09:15.340 Ute nations who have come together and said, you know, these lands are sacred. These are the lands
00:09:21.780 of our homecoming. These are the lands where the bones of our ancestors are buried. And in those
00:09:28.400 canyons that rise upward like praying hands, we can still hear the voices of our ancestors
00:09:34.220 singing through the wind.
00:09:36.740 This is where their ceremonies take place.
00:09:39.140 This is where they gather their medicines.
00:09:41.760 And, you know, over 100,000 different artifacts
00:09:44.700 are buried there, exposed, hidden in the alcoves.
00:09:50.780 There is a painted language that resides
00:09:53.980 on the walls in petroglyphs and pictographs.
00:09:57.900 So it is a powerful country.
00:10:00.940 The tribes have led the way.
00:10:02.220 The fact that Secretary Zinke showed up for four days, let's give him five, do you know how long he spent with the tribal members?
00:10:14.700 He spent one hour in a room without windows in Salt Lake City.
00:10:21.580 He and his entourage with Orrin Hatch, Rob Bishop, county commissioners from San Juan County, arrived at the airport in Blanding.
00:10:31.000 They were met by another county commissioner who had five horses and five white hats ready to go.
00:10:37.060 The hats that read, make San Juan County great again.
00:10:40.900 Who do you think he listened to?
00:10:42.760 And after being there for four days, he came out and said, it's too big.
00:10:47.380 It's too big for protection.
00:10:49.460 It's too big for the tribes. 0.53
00:10:51.180 Too big for the community of the wild, the animals, the plants.
00:10:56.940 But it's certainly not too big for the oil and gas industry.
00:11:01.000 that has its claim there. So I just wanted to go back to your original question of what's at stake.
00:11:08.080 So what can we do? I think that each of us, with the gifts that are ours,
00:11:14.840 in the places we call home, need to stretch, expand, and deepen our engagement. You know,
00:11:24.100 so often we think, who is our leader? We're looking for one person, when in fact, I think
00:11:29.700 in the 21st century, it's not about one person or one grand gesture, but I think it's about
00:11:35.940 community and all of us working together, again, with the gifts that are ours, each in our own
00:11:43.080 time, each in our own way. To me, that is the way forward.
00:11:50.020 I agree with that, Terry, that if we're using our own gifts and passions locally, we have
00:11:57.780 a lot of power in that way. I want to start directing the conversation from the monuments
00:12:04.240 to some of the other issues that have plagued the Southwest, which is the relationship between
00:12:12.040 environmentalists and ranchers. And you wrote something to the effect of, quote, a sense of
00:12:17.220 place leads to an ethic of place, end quote. And the ranching community clings to an ethic of
00:12:24.780 autonomy an ethic of self and as they grab for more and more public land but without a knowledge
00:12:32.560 of ecology and the ethics of stewardship the short-term gains are finite and it seems we are
00:12:41.000 now reaching that limit would you agree that ranchers versus environmentalist battle is now
00:12:48.620 verging on obsolescence as climate pulls the rug from under ranchers with land degradation,
00:12:56.620 water shortages, and economic breakdown, etc., outweighing the tepid threat environmentalist
00:13:03.400 had posed in the past. You know, I actually don't agree with that, Iona. I think it's too simple.
00:13:10.420 You know, I don't think it's fair to label all ranchers in the form of the Bundys.
00:13:19.040 You know, we saw their standoff, that family, that clan at Malheur National Wildlife Refuge.
00:13:26.540 And some of them have been sentenced.
00:13:28.940 Some of them have not.
00:13:30.660 One of them was killed.
00:13:32.480 You know, it was a terrible situation.
00:13:34.440 And we all were very aware of the injustices.
00:13:37.120 I mean, we're talking cowboys. And I mean that in the most rogue sense. And, you know, if those had been Native people, if those had been environmentalists, if those had been Black people, Brown people, we know that it would have a very different outcome. So there's that. And I think they're on the extreme.
00:13:54.480 I know so many ranchers and farmers who love public lands, who pay their fees, who are really trying to work with land trusts and easements to be good stewards.
00:14:08.780 So I think it's complicated.
00:14:11.140 You know, certainly there are those that aren't the best stewards, but I just, I don't see them as the enemy.
00:14:17.320 I really don't.
00:14:18.140 I think what we have to do in our communities is work together.
00:14:21.940 I think environmentalists, conservationists, ranchers, farmers, and I would even argue developers and the different agencies, the Park Service, the BLM, the Forest Service, we all have to come together and really say, what is a sustainable vision?
00:14:37.440 And that takes time.
00:14:39.120 It takes affection and commitment.
00:14:41.840 It has ground rules where we may agree to disagree.
00:14:45.260 And there are some things maybe we won't compromise on.
00:14:48.960 But that's the process that I'm interested in seeing.
00:14:52.500 There's also the issue of tourism.
00:14:55.780 And Abby was a great advocate talking about industrial tourism.
00:15:00.300 And anyone that has been to Yellowstone National Park or Arches or Zion in Utah understand what that is.
00:15:07.240 Yosemite, Grand Canyon, we're loving our parks to death.
00:15:11.180 Why? I would argue because the need is greater than it's ever been.
00:15:15.380 Certainly there are more of us.
00:15:16.560 So I think it's this mosaic. And how do we really look at all the pieces and create a whole? That's, to me, the real issue, especially as you suggest, with climate change, with drought, with all of the compounding issues that are facing us at this moment in time.
00:15:34.820 Yes, I think coming together and this mosaic framework that you speak about is really the only way forward in so many ways.
00:15:46.040 And I absolutely agree that there's no simple way forward, but many voices need to be at the table and not just the people in power and the government, but local people, tribes, ranchers, environmentalists.
00:16:04.440 so that there can be face-to-face conversations to bring everybody's gifts and understandings
00:16:10.920 and experiences so that we can move forward. Because with climate change and industrial
00:16:18.380 tourism and the list goes on and on, we are losing the resilience of these places that we love.
00:16:25.200 And I'm wondering, speaking of that, how has the ecological health of the Great Basin fared
00:16:32.160 within the web of extraction and development.
00:16:35.960 And where does her resilience lie that we can get behind
00:16:40.520 as we face climate extremes and other stressors brought on by humanity?
00:16:45.900 It's such a good question.
00:16:47.520 And, you know, I'm not a biologist and I'm not a scientist.
00:16:51.140 You know, when I think about the Great Basin,
00:16:54.540 you know, what I really think about are all of the nerve gas that's buried out there.
00:16:59.540 I think about the munitions that are buried out of there and the kind of surreal tanks that are out there in army maneuvers.
00:17:09.160 You know, certainly in Utah, we're facing drought. Great Salt Lake is at its all time low.
00:17:13.760 The birds are not there in the numbers that they used to be.
00:17:16.500 Pelicans are taking a huge hit because of predation that hasn't been there for decades because Gunnison Island, which is their nesting area, has been an island.
00:17:27.640 It's not an island anymore. So you've got coyotes, you know, crossing the lake bed and ravaging the
00:17:35.000 nests. And then you have the juvenile pelicans that are then flying prematurely, but can't make
00:17:40.180 it to freshwater where their parents are. And so last time I was out at Great Salt Lake, I counted
00:17:45.780 over 60 dead juvenile pelicans. And I couldn't imagine what had happened. And talking to the
00:17:51.560 Division of Wildlife Resources learned this is the situation. So stress is the right word.
00:17:57.640 The Colorado Plateau, that's another story.
00:18:00.720 You know, if we had a raven's point of view, an aerial view, it looks like an exposed nervous system with all the infrastructure, the roads, the pads, the oil and gas rigs, the flares at night.
00:18:12.280 It's a heartbreak.
00:18:13.440 You know, you go into the Uinta Basin and it's worse.
00:18:17.080 You see fracking, infant mortality rate has skyrocketed because of fracking, water poisoned in states like Wyoming.
00:18:26.640 again, it's connecting the dots. It's not just one community. But when you start looking at the
00:18:32.820 collective in the interior West, I can't believe what I'm seeing just in my lifetime. Again, I think
00:18:40.500 it's why public lands matter so much, Ayana. They're breathing spaces in a society that is
00:18:47.620 increasingly holding its breath. So I do think we have to fight for these lands. And I'm so
00:18:53.760 encouraged in that this is front and center of a new conversation. There's people in the East
00:19:01.460 that have no knowledge of what public lands are because it's privatized in the East. They don't
00:19:06.560 exist. Same with the Midwest. They've been plowed under. So I think people are finally coming
00:19:12.220 to understand that we have a great heritage. These are not just public lands, but there are
00:19:19.140 public stories, our natural histories, and our cultural histories.
00:19:23.320 And that's very, very powerful to the identities of Americans.
00:19:49.140 Long ago, before the stars were made
00:20:02.120 Oh, I met you in that meadow
00:20:09.300 Oh, we saw it only by you
00:20:17.480 The American Southwest has inspired and moved many people
00:20:31.980 as it's home to the pinyon pine and the juniper forest
00:20:36.660 that have inched their way to old growth almost in slow motion.
00:20:43.060 You know, a 60-foot juniper can be hundreds of years old
00:20:45.760 and support an ensemble of over 450 plant species and i believe that the first wholesale assault on
00:20:54.680 the great basin ecosystems was by the charcoal industry which peaked in the late 1800s forests
00:21:00.760 were gobbled up whole clear cut and since the land has been slowly healing and regrowing
00:21:07.180 till more recently than the blm and the forest service made the claim that this new growth is
00:21:12.480 invading greater sage grass habitat and wetlands and thus a new wave of destruction has come into
00:21:18.300 the basin you know in the meantime the lowly handsaw has been trumped by more imaginative
00:21:24.240 means of destruction and i am horrified and was horrified to learn that the most common way these
00:21:32.840 ecosystems are clear today is by stretching a battleship anchor chain between two enormous
00:21:39.480 earth movers and tearing up anything that protrudes from the earth's surface so i'm wondering how is
00:21:45.740 this abomination justified and are you aware of any other strokes of brilliance in this field of
00:21:53.180 ecocide you know i remember it must have been in the late 80s early 90s in moab when ken slight
00:22:02.000 alias seldom seen of edward abbey's monkey wrench gang where many of us stood in front of those bold
00:22:09.400 dozers that were going to do exactly what you're speaking of that chaining and you know again I
00:22:14.960 just am rendered speechless it's it's the flavor of the day in terms of management and I think
00:22:22.240 you know what concerns me most is I just again I can't even find the words it's it's not one thing
00:22:30.700 but it's all of the things and I just keep thinking as a child there was so much sage
00:22:38.020 it put me to sleep you know you drive and you drive and you drive and the tallest you know
00:22:43.320 tree or plant on the horizon was sage you know and then you'd see the magnificent juniper twisted
00:22:49.600 and gnarled shaped by the wind or the beautiful pinions that would yield those wonderful nuts
00:22:54.820 that we would gather as children and now just what you're saying the sagebrush steps is an
00:23:01.420 endangered ecosystem and here we have an administration that wants to undo the protections
00:23:07.480 that were a collaborative means of conservation management, you know, through the state government,
00:23:14.420 through the federal government, through conservation, the tribes, and local communities
00:23:19.680 to protect the sage-grouse. Now they want to undo all of that. Why? A few years ago, someone in
00:23:25.220 Washington, D.C., a ludicrous question, but they said, who do you think is the most powerful person
00:23:30.040 in the West right now who has the most influence? And I said, the sage-grouse. And they laughed and
00:23:37.160 they said, no, no, I'm serious. And I said, so am I, because the sage grass has been the only
00:23:41.920 species, the only individual between the health of the land and the absolute abject rapacious
00:23:50.060 appetite of the fossil fuel industry. You take out the sage grass and it's open field development.
00:23:58.240 So those are some of my concerns. And again, just what you're saying, you know, add drought to that,
00:24:03.060 add development to that, add climate to that, add cows to that, alongside, you know, these kind of
00:24:09.860 antiquated practices of chaining. And, you know, you've really got an abused landscape.
00:24:16.200 When I think about the abused landscape that you're speaking of, and I connect it to the
00:24:21.880 abused landscapes of the Pacific Northwest forest, the temperate rainforest, the old growth that's
00:24:28.420 being slaughtered there down to the amazon up to the boreal we are in a time of mass extinctions
00:24:37.000 and in your talk of bioneers you spoke of the need for connectivity of wildness for evolution
00:24:45.560 and resilience to continue and you said this quote that has chilled me since i heard it
00:24:53.260 And it was that, quote, death is one thing, but an end to birth is something else, end quote.
00:25:01.520 So can you speak of the end of biological evolution and how deep into the unraveling process do you believe we're in?
00:25:14.160 And I mean, can we even know from our vantage?
00:25:16.420 you know that quote is from the great conservation biologist michael suway and that was a revelation
00:25:24.620 to me too we talk about the end of species but rarely do we talk about the beginning of new
00:25:29.380 species or the evolutionary process and that's what he's talking about and you know i want to
00:25:35.100 say to you ayana um how much i appreciate your courage because we're talking about really hard
00:25:41.740 things and you know i think it's in our nature to want to be hopeful to want to be optimistic
00:25:47.860 but i think unless we really face the reality of where we are at this moment in time in call it
00:25:55.020 the anthropocene where human beings do have this extraordinary press on the planet right now
00:26:00.220 then we really can't go forward with the courage and the open eyes and open heart that is going to
00:26:08.220 be required to make the necessary changes. Honestly, I've taken hope out of my vocabulary.
00:26:16.900 It's not that I'm not hopeful. It's that I don't think it's helpful. And rather than hope, I choose
00:26:22.440 to think about faith. I have tremendous faith in our capacity to change. I have tremendous faith
00:26:28.360 in the power of consciousness. I have tremendous faith in the works of people to make very quick
00:26:36.280 changes. But we're up against a capitalistic society, not just the United States, but China
00:26:45.880 and every other country that wants the same kind of lifestyle that we have. So when Donald Trump
00:26:52.320 says that the G20 gathering, you know, Western civilization is at risk, he's right, but not in
00:26:59.220 a way that he thinks, you know, and he said our lifestyle is at risk. He's right, but not for the
00:27:05.260 reasons. If we want to survive as a species in fellowship with other species, we are going to
00:27:12.120 have to shift our point of view and become more empathetic, become more unselfish. Think about
00:27:20.500 what sacrifice means in a spiritual sense and what the spiritual implications are of climate
00:27:27.280 change. But we're still in the stage of denial. We're in denial of death. We're in denial of
00:27:33.680 where we find ourselves now and that there is a real world and it is really
00:27:37.900 dying right now. And what concerns me most are those that have no voice.
00:27:42.440 And those are the birds. Those are the plants. Those are the
00:27:45.840 moths. Those are the elephants. All of the creatures among us who are
00:27:49.980 struggling. And that's what I'm concerned about.
00:27:53.880 So how do we come together? You know, how do we take
00:27:58.040 on one hand all that modernity has given us?
00:28:01.920 And how do we take, on the other hand, a spiritual reality that we must begin to embrace, that we are not the only species that lives and breathes and loves and grieves on this planet?
00:28:15.100 And how do we bring these two hands together in prayer?
00:28:18.340 I'm not talking about religion. I'm talking about a spiritual consciousness that I think we are going to have to embrace if we are going to evolve to a species that dares to love, even in the face of death, even in the face of mass extinction, even in the face of our own complicity.
00:28:38.000 that was so beautiful terry and it has been feelings that i have felt so many times whether
00:28:45.500 it's seeing this collective denial that i myself was grown and conditioned into breaking away from
00:28:53.720 that and then learning how to not shy away from the truth because i felt very early on when i
00:29:01.800 started to awaken to the realities of the world that for me to love the world that meant i had
00:29:07.000 to understand what was happening and not shy away from the pain because the earth and the all
00:29:13.980 creatures are feeling this pain at least I believe that and I wanted to actually show up in a
00:29:18.800 relationship that I could hold not just my own pain but the pain of the other species as well
00:29:25.780 and so I think it's almost this intense gift to learn to love in the face of collapse and how
00:29:34.680 passionate and alive I believe humans can feel when we start really awakening to these realities
00:29:42.620 and being present with them and I think about this biological cessation that you were mentioning
00:29:51.820 earlier and the end of birth is something else and I certainly think that this cast a new light
00:30:00.240 on the human experiment and now you know not only have we seen a slowing or a ceasing of biological
00:30:08.020 evolution but a deep regression in cultural evolution and so i'm wondering how are wild
00:30:16.660 spaces and wilderness fundamental to our creativity as a species and to our sense of
00:30:24.780 direction amid the confusion? It's such a great question. You know, I think of a story
00:30:31.520 not long ago. I was talking with a young woman who grew up in the Western Everglades in Florida,
00:30:38.700 and she said, you know, we used to have two seasons in the Everglades. And as a child,
00:30:44.540 I looked forward to both. We had the dry season and we had the rainy season. And in both,
00:30:49.620 you know there were gifts now we have only the wet season and she said what am i supposed to do
00:30:58.240 terry as i watch my own home ground flood and i know that in the not so distant future the
00:31:06.580 everglades which is my identity with these long-legged birds you know how am i to grieve
00:31:13.920 you know how am i to move forward knowing what is going to be lost and i really didn't have an
00:31:19.060 answer for her. All I could say was to bear witness is not a passive act, but an act of
00:31:26.400 conscience and consequence. And to have the strength not to avert our gaze, as you said,
00:31:34.680 to not look away. In the same way when those of us who have been with loved ones who are in the
00:31:40.500 process of dying. We don't walk away and we stay and we hold them and we listen to them and we cry
00:31:49.340 with them. And we know this is the process of life that we are in. Half of my family is gone
00:31:55.540 and I've had the privilege of being with them in those dying moments. It's not easy, but it is
00:32:01.860 about being present and the gift of the consciousness of knowing we are finite. I have no
00:32:09.800 doubt that the earth will survive us but it will be a changed earth and it's not without its sorrow
00:32:16.720 you know i'm reading this terrific book maybe you've read it staying with the trouble by donna
00:32:22.520 harroway and she talks about the importance of multi-species justice and how our task as human
00:32:28.740 beings right now is to make trouble and i love that you know whether it's direct action whether
00:32:35.160 it's buying oil and gas leases, whether it's committing civil disobedience, whether it's
00:32:40.740 holding prayers, as so many did, and also offer support and presence at Standing Rock,
00:32:49.840 you know, what may be asked of us with bear's ears, to really look at this kinship that
00:32:55.900 is ours and how we are redefining family.
00:32:58.440 And I know for me, my sense of family is not just exclusive to my own species, not at all. You know, when I hear the hermit thrush singing in the morning and at night, even between intervals of thunder, that is my kin, that is my voice too.
00:33:17.920 i just imagined thunder being kin and my heart picked up a beat i wanted to read a quote that
00:33:28.300 i had written down from you quote cynicism thrives in air-conditioned rooms like any true place the
00:33:36.140 desert is a risk end quote and elsewhere you write quote desert strategies are useful in times of
00:33:45.140 drought, pull your resources inward. When water is scarce, find moisture and seeds. To stay strong
00:33:53.660 and supple, send a taproot down deep. Run when required, hide when necessary. When hot,
00:34:01.840 go underground. Do not fear darkness. It's where one comes alive." And it's just reminding me of
00:34:12.040 what we were talking about with not shying away from the darkness and this fear of death and as
00:34:21.240 desertification is becoming an undeniable pattern of civilization this advice if taken literally
00:34:28.340 could be life-saving for a lot of people you know i do suspect however that there is a more
00:34:35.020 metaphorical layer under these words like most of us do fear darkness and the end of cheap energy
00:34:42.940 and life as we know it our screens going dark and civilization gives us the option to
00:34:49.420 burrow in our comfort zones but in the wild fear and risk make you think fast and act fast and
00:34:59.200 with courage. So what would be the upshot if we all learned to embrace risk-taking and fear as
00:35:09.540 creative forces? I love that. You know, who knows? I mean, that's the thing. You know, each landscape,
00:35:17.420 each ecotone, each ecosystem, you know, I view them as our teachers. And the key word for me is
00:35:26.820 is being humble which has its root in hummus earth and being teachable you know we think we
00:35:35.240 know so much we think we we have these brains and it's true we do but I think more than that
00:35:43.480 we're still animals and we still are part of something so much larger than ourselves and to
00:35:49.380 remember that you know the desert is not a void it is my unknowing and I think it's that unknowing
00:35:56.560 that puts us on equal ground with other species, and that's a beautiful thing, and the world is so
00:36:03.740 beautiful, and every day I set for myself some encounter with wildness, whether it's a praying
00:36:10.960 mantis in Manhattan, whether it's, you know, hearing the wingbeats of ravens in Castle Valley
00:36:17.000 where we live, or, you know, watching bison in the Lamar Valley, or the grunion rum, you know,
00:36:24.020 those flashing scales coming up with the tide on the pacific coast i mean it's just it's endless
00:36:31.120 spring peepers you know in the northeast i mean the indiana dunes i mean we are so blessed by
00:36:38.200 these wild spaces and i've come to really cherish how beauty is its own form of resistance to have
00:36:46.780 a living knowledge of beauty and wildness and that sense of humility that sense of fear that
00:36:52.680 you speak of and darkness, where we're on our edge and we can use our night vision.
00:37:22.680 Thank you.
00:37:52.680 i'd like to read another quote quote our fear of being touched removes us from a sensate world
00:38:08.380 the distant self becomes the detached self who no longer believes in anything
00:38:13.980 end quote when you look around a crowded street and see how alienated people have become from one
00:38:21.340 another and from their own selves through hyper consumption of empty products. And you see how
00:38:30.120 we have no command of our autonomy. It's beyond choosing between products or careers or religions
00:38:37.600 or politicians. So could you speak about the illusion of choice in modern society and give
00:38:47.240 some advice to the huge contingency of millennials who don't believe the myth of progress and seek
00:38:54.320 a radically different reality? You tell me. I'm so interested in the millennials and I,
00:39:02.220 you know, I know my students and I love them so much. And in so many ways, they're so much
00:39:06.760 farther ahead than I am. So I turn to you because I think you're speaking a different vocabulary.
00:39:13.200 And I think you're, on so many levels, so much braver than certainly my generation.
00:39:18.900 How old are you, Ayanna?
00:39:21.120 Well, I am turning 30 in a matter of days.
00:39:25.080 I mean, to me, your wisdom, you know, your beautiful ambition to talk about these ideas
00:39:31.120 and to have this forum, I mean, I am just in awe of you.
00:39:35.700 And this is what I'm seeing with your generation.
00:39:39.100 And that's why, you know, I bow to you.
00:39:41.260 I mean, you are my teachers, and I am so aware of what I don't know.
00:39:46.780 You know, in many ways, I think my generation's task is to get out of the way so that you can flourish.
00:39:52.980 And, you know, what I see is that you are holding this pragmatic vision.
00:39:58.660 I see you as pragmatic visionaries.
00:40:01.560 So talk to me, you know, talk to me.
00:40:04.700 What are you seeing?
00:40:06.300 What is it that you want to create?
00:40:08.360 well personally i am married to the temperate rainforests and my vision is to serve
00:40:19.360 the land in whatever way they direct me and so far that direction has been in the form of a
00:40:28.660 native species nursery to enhance biodiversity to sequester carbon and help with climate mitigation
00:40:35.960 So I see this interplay between the philosophical wanderings and this cultural shift that can happen in meetings and celebrations in combination with tangible restoration of land, in combination with tangible conservation of land.
00:40:56.620 And I think that I am very lucky, very privileged to even be able to consider these things because I think a lot of people, whether they don't have the privilege or they're just stuck in the conditioning of this dominant lie of abundance that isn't true abundance or these choices, if you do these choices, this will bring you fulfillment.
00:41:23.720 but the fulfillment that the dominant culture is selling us is all about really narcissism
00:41:31.540 and i have never found that just serving the self is fulfilling at all and so i think that
00:41:37.200 is this large lie held over many people's heads to just focus on the self or the nuclear family
00:41:45.180 and to have these certain steps certain chapters in your life that you get to this whether it's
00:41:51.040 the white picket fence and the two kids or whatever it is but it doesn't make sense in the
00:41:56.720 reality that we're facing and not to say that we can't have families but it's more than that and
00:42:02.820 what we're facing is monumental and so it's this monumental challenge of creativity at the same
00:42:09.840 time how are we going to step up to the task that we are being handed in a way that is in love and
00:42:17.100 in rapture and in passion and focused and clear and intelligent and you know one thing that i've
00:42:24.780 really been learning a lot lately with building this native species nursery is even if you do
00:42:30.280 have good intentions even if you want to make all of the best choices and the most integrity
00:42:35.860 the system that we are in does not make eco quote eco-friendly choices affordable convenient easy
00:42:44.720 it's just amazing even just to grow trees how challenging it is to make decisions that are not
00:42:51.000 hurting another land somewhere else so I've been thinking about this question a lot just
00:42:57.080 what are our choices at this point and how do we not get stuck and so how I move through the
00:43:04.720 Anthropocene is falling more deeply in love every day with what is still here and with what I can
00:43:13.640 imagine coming back if we support and tenderly care for the land and I think about the word
00:43:22.680 wildness and I know it's come up a lot you know in your writing and I think I mean it's for the
00:43:27.760 wild so I very much connected to that word but I've heard from some people the word wildness
00:43:35.100 can be construed into a lot of different meanings I've heard from some other people I've had in the
00:43:40.980 podcast like oh well the wildness is this term used from colonialist or people that aren't
00:43:48.860 familiar with the land and so it's separating if something's wild that means we're not wild and
00:43:53.660 and wild is something that you don't touch or humans don't touch but then i think about tending
00:43:58.900 the wild there's a book about california native people and how they were able to steward the land
00:44:03.560 and actually enhanced biodiversity.
00:44:06.220 And so I wanted to talk to you about your connection to the word wild
00:44:11.660 and your connection and your definition of what you feel when you hear that word.
00:44:19.380 First of all, I just want to thank you because I just think you have shared such wisdom.
00:44:24.880 And again, practical and visionary.
00:44:29.400 And I just so honor what you're doing.
00:44:32.040 And this is what I'm talking about. I think what you know we need to hear. And I will talk about wildness and wilderness. But, you know, I have a question just to follow up after listening to what you have just so beautifully articulated in terms of your own life's work. Do you feel angry?
00:44:51.720 i call it sacred rage and yes i feel angry i feel i my blood boils but i take that anger and it it
00:45:06.100 honestly just turns into this passionate love because it i don't know if this is what a mother
00:45:13.380 bear feels like but but yeah I feel angry and but the anger is so much energy and that energy
00:45:20.840 can be used to just push something forward so I'm not upset when I feel that well I don't know
00:45:27.740 if upset's the correct word but it doesn't get me down it just fuels my fire I feel the same way
00:45:34.600 and I too call it sacred rage you know how many times as women have we been told calm down you
00:45:41.940 know, you're irrational, you're angry, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. And I just want to, I am
00:45:46.340 angry. I'm furious, you know, and over the winter, especially with the election and knowing what was
00:45:52.900 coming down, I thought, okay, I've got to get a grip. Everyone says I'm just, I've got too much
00:45:57.480 fire. I'm too angry. And then I thought with a name like Tempest, I'm hopeless. So I went and
00:46:01.500 ordered, I swear, 12 books on anger, you know, dance of anger, anger and compassion, love your
00:46:07.380 enemies. I mean, you should see my library. And I started reading them with my red pencil and
00:46:13.140 really being studious about it. I got so angry at what I was reading. I just thought, okay, stop.
00:46:18.460 And I do think anger is a focused force. And I do think if we can take our anger and channel it
00:46:25.440 into something powerful and direct, it does, and it can become sacred rage and sacred acts
00:46:32.620 of resistance. And I also feel that, you know, there is fire in the wild, in forests, you know,
00:46:40.440 in the desert, it's a hot fire that roars and it's fast, you know, in grasslands. And I think
00:46:46.460 there's a real purpose for that in the same way that there's a purpose for water. It's all elemental,
00:46:51.000 you know, water seeping into every crack and cranny, you know, to where it has the power to
00:46:57.980 cracked stone. So again, all these elements around us that give us clues. You know, you asked me,
00:47:05.820 what is my definition of wilderness or wildness? And it's Thoreau's 200th anniversary this year.
00:47:13.360 And of course, in Wildness is the preservation of the world, he writes. And I understand,
00:47:18.800 you know, the critics who say that, you know, wilderness has become irrelevant before it's
00:47:23.560 become resolved. And wilderness is a political term, a colonial term. But I also think it's a
00:47:28.960 limitation of language. And when I think about wild country, big country, the country that we
00:47:35.060 still have in the West and in our forests and deserts and mountains and meadows and wetlands
00:47:41.800 and oceans and seashores and rivers, to me, this is the taproot of consciousness. It is where we
00:47:49.360 have evolved and it is where we are continuing to evolve and we cannot separate ourselves from it
00:47:55.720 and i think that's the key it isn't something outside of of human beings it's inside us as well
00:48:03.460 and i think it's this convergence of the inner and outer wilderness that that is so crucial right now
00:48:09.940 to make peace with and yes there's the protected wilderness and yes we can find wildness everywhere
00:48:18.160 But I think it's seeing the world whole, even wholly, and fighting for the remaining land that is there and the animals and the ecosystems that are, as you said, stressed and suffering in the same way that we are.
00:48:32.700 I heard the most beautiful story. May I share it?
00:48:36.320 Please, yes.
00:48:38.820 There's a biologist named Sue Beatty, and she's the chief botanist in Yosemite National Park.
00:48:47.120 I met her last year in the centennial of the National Park Service and I was so moved by her
00:48:54.520 story as you know the Mariposa Grove has been under restoration for the last five years I think
00:49:01.020 it's to open this year this summer anyway she told me this incredible story and this is how I
00:49:06.840 remember it that you know one day she was on patrol she was walking through the Mariposa Grove as she
00:49:13.180 always does, loving the big trees, thousands of years old, talk about elders. And she heard
00:49:18.880 something and she stopped. And what came into her heart was that the trees were stressed,
00:49:26.480 that the trees were suffering, that they were in fact speaking to her. You know, how do you take
00:49:32.440 that instinct, that intuition, that feeling, and translate it into science as a botanist charged
00:49:39.860 with the help and wealth of a particular national park, the Mariposa Grove, really the first public
00:49:47.560 lands we had protected by Abraham Lincoln after the worst battle in the Civil War. 1864, he created
00:49:56.000 the Yosemite Land Act to protect Yosemite Valley and the Mariposa Grove. Well, she went back with
00:50:03.160 her team and they did science, they did research, they did their statistics, they did their analysis
00:50:09.040 and looked at the mariposa grove and its health of the big trees, sequoias.
00:50:14.800 And in fact, they were suffering, not just from drought,
00:50:17.760 but from having their roots trampled to death by asphalt, by trams, trolleys, by cars,
00:50:26.220 by millions of visitors' feet for decades over time.
00:50:31.560 So what could relieve that stress?
00:50:34.480 What could alleviate the suffering of these giant trees, these elders?
00:50:40.660 She thought, what if this sacred grove of trees thousands of years old, what if it no longer was a place of entertainment, but a place of contemplation?
00:50:59.500 what if it was no longer about recreation but restoration and so with the superintendent
00:51:10.380 and with supporters of the mariposa grove it was agreed that over time the asphalt would be removed
00:51:20.580 There would no longer be the buses, the trolleys, entertainment, noise, unconscious, walking, but rather soft earth would be reinstated, the roots would be freed, new paths would be made, and it would become a place of solitude, contemplation, restoration, reverence.
00:51:46.160 and that is what is happening so that now the mariposa grove is a breathing space
00:51:53.920 and that the trees will be able to heal don't you love that i do love that and i think it's
00:52:03.540 such an important understanding that land is not there just for our recreation or for our
00:52:14.020 resource extraction as humans or for anything but it's also a relationship and when you kept saying
00:52:20.300 that the trees were elders I thought about grandparents and you know an elder needs a
00:52:27.280 rest every now and then and if an elder was being chatted with 24 hours a day and questions and
00:52:32.860 made to do this that and the other they would get exhausted and maybe ill even from that so
00:52:38.280 being able to put this kinship this well this relational understanding of land and how we can
00:52:47.680 interact in a way that is loving and considerate and respectful and not just about our needs but
00:52:55.580 about the land's needs is such a huge shift exactly and you know we keep thinking what can
00:53:03.960 one person do? Well, Sue Beatty did a lot. And it goes back to that idea. Again, what do we do?
00:53:11.460 What's our gift? What's my gift? What's your gift? How do we deepen it? How do we listen?
00:53:17.080 How do we take it to the next level? Sue Beatty, a botanist, listened. She listened to the trees
00:53:23.600 and it made all the difference. And she shifted. I mean, it's like a chiropractic shift.
00:53:29.860 that to me is what is required
00:53:31.920 so that again each of us
00:53:33.900 in our own way with the gifts that are ours
00:53:36.180 can make an enormous difference
00:53:38.220 in the places we call home
00:53:39.980 that truly is where my faith
00:53:42.360 lies and
00:53:43.940 you know that to me is the challenge
00:53:46.140 it's not the big grand gestures
00:53:48.080 although hers was
00:53:49.360 but these small moments
00:53:52.020 where we stop, we pause
00:53:54.520 we listen, we contemplate
00:53:56.900 and then we
00:53:58.520 reimagine
00:53:59.860 It goes back to what you were saying, acts of the imagination that loom large as we make these shifts, recognizing, as you said, that our institutions are no longer working for us.
00:54:14.420 The notion of the nuclear family is a myth, but how do we expand our sense of family, expand our sense of community to both human and wild?
00:54:24.700 And if we take care of that in our own sphere and circle of reference, then the earth will be held.
00:54:32.420 And we will be transformed in the process.
00:54:34.820 I really believe that.
00:54:36.340 You know, when I was in school in biology, you know, the big no-no was anthropomorphism.
00:54:43.480 But then now I'm thinking, you know, how arrogant to assume that we're the only animals that can feel or think or dream or grieve.
00:54:51.600 We know that isn't true.
00:54:52.980 Thank you, Terry. Thank you for your exquisite words and walking your prayer and leading by example and courageously using your knowledge and privilege and your gifts to protect these places that hold us all. Thank you.
00:55:18.100 and thank you for your wisdom and happy birthday you know and i just i remember um doug peacock at
00:55:26.620 a low moment i i just love him so much he's you know george washington hey duke the inspiration
00:55:33.220 for at abby's monkey wrench game the the character who blew up glenn canyon dam i asked him how do
00:55:39.460 you stave off despair and he said surround yourself with people you love and seek out
00:55:47.340 wild places. And then he turned to me and said, we lose nothing by loving. I believe that.
00:56:00.780 Thank you for listening to For the Wild podcast. The music you heard today was by Buffalo Rose,
00:56:06.760 Kendra Swanson, and Aviva LaFey. This episode of For the Wild was created by Ayanna Young,
00:56:12.700 reach out Madison Migulski and Molly Lebov.