For The Wild - November 30, 2022


THENMOZHI SOUNDARARAJAN on Annihilating Caste Systems ⧸314

Topics
SLOW STUDY: We Will Dance with Mountains Preview TIFFANY LETHABO KING on The Black Shoals [with brontë velez], Part One ⧸315

Episode Stats


Length

57 minutes

Words per minute

141.92

Word count

8,198

Sentence count

232

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

1

sentences flagged

Hate speech

18

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.200 Hello and welcome to For the Wild podcast. I'm Ayanna Young. Today I'm speaking with
00:00:07.500 Thanmari Sondararajan. It's not accidental to me that we see a rise of polarization
00:00:14.540 and anti-democratic forces at a time when the earth itself is unstable because of our actions
00:00:22.120 around climate catastrophe. So in many ways for us to come back into the alignment with the law
00:00:29.420 of life. We have to choose life, which means choosing each other, choosing to slow down,
00:00:35.920 and to try to heal in our relationships with each other. Fenmarie Sandorarojin is an elite
00:00:43.720 American civil rights artist, organizer, and theorist who has worked with organizations 0.93
00:00:49.080 around the world to address the urgent issues of racial, caste, and gender equity. Her intersectional
00:00:56.280 cross-pollinating work helps to create a more generous, global, expansive, and inclusive
00:01:02.460 definition of South Asian identity, along with safe spaces from which to honor the stories of
00:01:09.040 these communities. She was also an inaugural fellow of the Robert Rauschenberg Artist as
00:01:15.640 Activist, Atlantic Foundation for Racial Equity, and is a current fellow at Stanford Center for
00:01:22.420 South Asian Studies. She is also the author of the new book, Trauma of Caste, by North Atlantic Books.
00:01:31.120 Well, Fenmuri, thank you so much for joining us on this rainy and frozen day where we both are.
00:01:40.100 I'm really looking forward to diving into this tender and complex conversation with you.
00:01:48.720 So looking forward to it, and thank you for having me.
00:01:51.700 I just want to say in preparation for this interview, I was really, yeah, moved by so much of your writing. And when I was thinking of how to start this off, I was like, where do I begin? There's so many quotes that I could pull from. And so I guess I'll just have to be patient knowing that we'll get to explore a number of things together.
00:02:15.920 but I thought we could start off with reading, I wanted to read a quote from your Slate interview
00:02:21.660 titled, Silicon Valley has a caste problem. Quote, the best way to think about it, caste,
00:02:29.280 is as a system of exclusion based on birth that goes back thousands of years. Its initial origins
00:02:36.060 are an ancient Vedic society, but it came strongly into force in India during the Mughal era,
00:02:42.500 which began in 16th century, and then in the British Raj, Brahmins were at the top,
00:02:48.400 deletes at the bottom. It started in scripture, and just like race, it's based on a social myth,
00:02:55.740 where some people at the top said that other people at the bottom are less worthy,
00:03:00.500 and therefore set up structures that excluded them from many institutions in society, end quote.
00:03:06.540 I found this really important to understand the history of the caste system and how we
00:03:14.900 are replaying that system in the United States today.
00:03:18.700 And something that really stood out to me about this quote as well is this idea of a
00:03:24.060 social myth.
00:03:25.940 And so I'd like to just maybe start off in a type of general way where you could describe
00:03:32.620 to us the history of this caste system and how you see it being remade over and over again
00:03:41.400 into our current society? Well, caste is, you know, one of the oldest systems of exclusion
00:03:48.960 in the world. And it's almost, you know, it is as large as the system of race, but we don't talk
00:03:58.040 about it on a global level, despite the fact that one in four people live in a society defined by
00:04:05.160 caste. So I think it's important that we slow our nervous systems down and think about the
00:04:13.240 staggering scale of the consequences of a system like caste. Because under caste, you know, it's
00:04:22.800 again, built it on a social fiction, similar to the way that white supremacy is where people at
00:04:28.740 the top basically created this whole, you know, social myth of how people should be divided. And
00:04:34.880 in the context of race, you know, it's about skin color. In the context of caste, it's about purity
00:04:41.140 and pollution and the family that you're born into. So when you live in a society defined by
00:04:47.220 caste, you're born into a family and that family has an assigned caste that defines its profession
00:04:54.680 and that profession has a level of purity. So if you're a priest, you're at the top
00:04:59.440 and then it goes downward. It's like, there's priests, there's rulers, there's merchants,
00:05:05.060 there's peasants, and then there's people who are the outcasts, which are the untouchables like me.
00:05:10.240 So, you know, depending on what your status is that you're born into, it determines the whole
00:05:16.020 of your life, from where you worship, who you marry, what side of a town that you live on,
00:05:22.340 and your proximity to structural violence and structural exclusion. And the data around caste
00:05:31.220 is very stark. You know, there's a crime against caste-depressed people every 19 minutes. And,
00:05:38.800 you know, the average age of mortality for Dalit women or caste-depressed women is 39,
00:05:43.760 because of how many combined exclusionary points that we face so you know I think that the thing
00:05:52.880 that really strikes me as so profound about caste is that it is so large it impacts so many people
00:05:59.440 but it's not as visible in our global discourse as we try to look at the ways that we deal with
00:06:05.360 historical harms the way that it's been that it's being babbled for right now around the conversation
00:06:11.280 about race. And so the work I'd hoped to do with the trauma of caste was to not only help
00:06:18.620 create a global conversation about what caste is, but also understand that when we find it
00:06:25.180 in regions outside of South Asia, like the United States or the UK or Australia, anywhere that we've
00:06:31.360 seen immigrants of South Asian countries have gone, the reason why these communities
00:06:39.640 replicated is because of the intergenerational historical nature of trauma that caste begets
00:06:46.940 in our body. And that oftentimes when communities replicate systems of exclusion, even when we have
00:06:53.740 no reason to, you know, because again, caste is like predicated on dominant caste people being
00:06:58.540 in power. They're not in power in these foreign countries. So then why are we talking about caste?
00:07:05.720 Why are we seeing significant caste discrimination in American institutions?
00:07:10.100 And it comes back to the mindless way that we recreate patterns of violence with each 0.65
00:07:15.800 other.
00:07:16.700 And that's really what, you know, for people who already are part of the conversation with
00:07:22.320 caste, the data will not be new.
00:07:25.060 But what will be new is thinking about caste with the lens of, you know, trauma and also
00:07:30.460 how frameworks like understanding caste as a soul wound can help us understand how we embody
00:07:37.460 systems of exclusion. And whether you're privileged or oppressed, we all carry this
00:07:43.980 burden. And it's been a training in our nervous system that really is the biggest impediment for
00:07:50.100 us to being collaborators on equity. I'm wondering, how is abolishing caste
00:07:56.760 depended upon abolishing other forms of oppression?
00:08:01.260 Well, I think it may even be new for some of your listeners to first know about caste,
00:08:07.100 and then that there is a movement to annihilate or to abolish caste. And the thing to know is that
00:08:14.700 under the caste system, not only has there been punishing systemic exclusion and violence,
00:08:21.500 there was also literal slavery. And that's why many caste-depressed people use terms like
00:08:27.860 abolition or annihilate the system altogether because of how much degradation and dehumanization
00:08:34.320 we faced. But also the term abolition really connects us to other struggles against slavery
00:08:40.280 and other oppressed peoples. So solidarity is not a transaction. It's in fact an enterprise,
00:08:47.640 shared and mutual solidarity and you know in many ways you know as someone who was cast depressed
00:08:55.660 my personal journey to being able to feel to find my path towards dignity and rehumanization
00:09:05.120 was being held by other movements and other leaders who were in their own journeys for
00:09:11.620 dignity and reclamation and black and black internationalism has been one of the the north
00:09:17.900 stars for many oppressed peoples around the world because in trying to out-organize white supremacy
00:09:25.040 uh black liberation leaders reached out to oppress movements around the world to find shared
00:09:31.600 resistance shared community and mutual language for our freedom so in many ways you know the book
00:09:40.820 is an artifact to that, because much of the language that I had to construct to talk about
00:09:46.340 cast with the lens of intergenerational trauma, and even how we might consider thinking about
00:09:52.460 healing, those things could only be done if I use language that came from other oppressed peoples.
00:10:00.420 And so, you know, we share analysis, we share, you know, we share meals, and we also share potential power building because of the fact that our freedoms are intertwined with each other.
00:10:15.980 There is no freedom for one community if any of the other communities are still languishing in oppression. And that's why I think that caste abolition is really linked to so many other racial justice struggles, because the same people oppress us within the South Asian community are the same South Asians who would actually work against racial solidarity in other contexts.
00:10:41.540 So being able to learn about each other's struggles and creating mutual liberatory discourse is a key part of our process.
00:10:50.760 And thinking about the relationship between caste and ideas of punishment, and I'm wondering, how is the idea of, quote, worthiness often weaponized and used as justification for punishment from, you know, the prison system to access to resources to educational opportunities and so on?
00:11:15.660 So I think one thing that is really important to think about is that as people are getting
00:11:21.840 familiar with the caste system, there's also a very key carceral logic that's at the heart
00:11:27.800 of caste.
00:11:29.240 That's really a place where I think that there's a lot of momentum that I think that we need
00:11:35.440 to be able to have more learning around.
00:11:39.180 And, you know, for people that are unfamiliar about what I'm speaking about, the carceral
00:11:44.140 logic and caste is actually related to reincarnation because the idea is is that
00:11:50.540 people were born into a caste oppressed background or a dulled background because they did something
00:11:57.880 bad in another life you know maybe they were a murderist or a rapist or a thief and therefore 0.96
00:12:04.280 because they did something that was bad in another life they deserve to be oppressed and excluded
00:12:10.160 because that's their sentence in this life that was the the logic that came out of certain
00:12:16.280 scriptures in the initial you know you know development of caste and so what that has meant
00:12:24.380 is that there's always an understanding that Dalits should accept the conditions of their 0.81
00:12:29.560 subjugation because they deserved it and I always rankled around that and I was someone who was born
00:12:36.880 I'm both Hindu and Christian, and now I'm Buddhist, but, you know, when we know that caste, you know, exists across so many South Asian faiths, it is so challenging to see that people are telling Dalit people not to organize for their own equitable conditions. 0.99
00:12:58.080 And that's what I'm really, you know, not comfortable with in terms of seeing what's happening in terms of our community.
00:13:07.800 And that's a big part of why I've spoken out about this carceral logic, because we don't want systems that punish.
00:13:15.620 We don't want systems that dehumanize.
00:13:17.960 And we want to be able to hold grace and connection and community with each other.
00:13:24.360 So these are all things that I think are super helpful to be able to think about as we move forward and think about how we, you know, want to heal from systems of carceralization.
00:13:38.520 yeah gosh there's so much here and there's so much in your work that I
00:13:44.820 am trying to wrap my head around there's a quote from your book the trauma of caste and you write
00:13:52.460 quote caste trauma is generally reduced to the discussion of the consequences to only delete
00:13:59.560 people yet the suffering the caste causes is not limited to those of us born at the bottom
00:14:05.700 never discussed are the networks of privilege that benefit from caste and the ways that the
00:14:11.500 dominant caste psyche also is defined by suffering end quote and i'm wondering about this topic that
00:14:23.600 i've thought you know or discussed on the podcast a lot around white supremacy or supremacist culture
00:14:30.520 in general, it's like everybody is actually suffering under this type of belief system.
00:14:37.400 Now, of course, some people have it much more comfortable and have privileges that make life
00:14:45.200 convenient and easier in many ways. But I think even on a spiritual level, the type of
00:14:52.900 disconnection and spiritual bankruptcy that either caste systems or white supremacy leaves for all of
00:15:03.880 us is extremely detrimental. And I think that's really manifested in how we see what's happening
00:15:11.560 to the world, to the earth, to the land. Poisoned water, poisoned air will eventually impact all of
00:15:19.360 us like even those at the top can't run forever and so i just wanted to open up this thought
00:15:27.460 process with you and and uh maybe you could speak to this quote that i recited of yours and take us
00:15:36.640 a bit into this these ideas so what is really profound to me about even in my own writing
00:15:46.960 journey for this book as someone who's advocated on the issue of caste for almost 20 years was how
00:15:54.680 much I was still dehumanized and not embodied about my own pain about caste and that might seem
00:16:03.600 strange for your audience but you know I think many oppressed people in order to survive in
00:16:10.760 very violent societies they go to the cerebral you know and they're troubleshooting about how
00:16:16.900 to get to from point a to point b whether if it's the hustle of their work or lifting their family
00:16:22.240 out of poverty you know whatever whatever these situations are um they are doing they're focused
00:16:29.920 on the practical and the material but not about the pain that lingers in your body about what
00:16:36.160 you're seeing and so much of what i wrote there was about first giving permission for
00:16:43.800 cast oppressed people and really all oppressed people to slow down enough to be embodied about
00:16:49.860 the container of grief that they might carry related to the system of exclusion that they're
00:16:56.000 navigating. And certainly for me, I just, I was not doing that. I was really just shoving it down
00:17:04.320 and trying to really just be focused on the work that needed to happen. And I was getting health
00:17:10.000 problems from it. I was getting high blood pressure. I was getting, um, you know, panic
00:17:15.320 attacks. And I also was moving so quick. I couldn't acknowledge how much violence that
00:17:24.140 you're exposed to as a caste depressed person. So there's a piece in that quote, that's about
00:17:29.000 first allowing caste depressed and oppressed people to, to humanize by being embodied around
00:17:36.820 our pain. Because the world may not recognize it, but if we can't even begin that journey to a global
00:17:43.640 conversation, if we don't embody ourselves first. But additionally, there's a call for accountability
00:17:51.320 and a calling in for people of privilege to know that there is a wound, there's a part of this
00:17:58.620 wound that you also carry because you can't other another without losing some part of your humanity
00:18:07.320 so whether you're witnessing atrocity or you're staying silent in the face of the slur or maybe
00:18:13.620 you're an active contributor to discrimination or bigotry each time you take down another human
00:18:20.460 you actually take down a part of yourself and you have to close yourself off from the web of life
00:18:27.960 in order to do that. And that's a profound wound as well. And we don't talk about it because it's
00:18:35.300 much easier to focus on the consequences of caste and not the origins of caste and the people who
00:18:42.540 benefit. So there's a political logic for looking at who benefits. But if we're also using the lens
00:18:49.320 of healing, we want all of us to come back into the family of humanity. And that's really part of
00:18:55.360 the negotiation around this conversation. And then second, I think that the other piece of this,
00:19:03.080 which is what you spoke to, is that there's an interconnectedness that we have as humans with
00:19:09.620 other species and the earth. And I think what systems of exclusion do well is to silo us off
00:19:17.560 from each other and the earth and I think in times of deep polarization we see ourselves
00:19:25.780 leaning into trauma worlds made up of filter bubbles of a hellish landscape where no one
00:19:34.700 can be trusted but a few and that there are you know projections of what we're assuming
00:19:42.160 about other communities. And the reality is, is when someone is in a trauma bubble,
00:19:48.840 you're not going to be able to get through to them through direct attack. You have to deescalate
00:19:55.700 their nervous system. You have to actually work to re-regulate their nervous system to be in
00:20:01.140 relationship with you again, in a relationship of trust enough so that they deescalate their
00:20:05.960 nervous system. And the ways that you do that have to be not just with each other, but you do that
00:20:11.500 with nature and you do that with other species these are all ways that we're connected to the
00:20:17.280 web of life and so it's not accidental to me that we see a rise of polarization and anti-democratic
00:20:25.040 forces at a time when the earth itself is unstable because of our actions around climate catastrophe
00:20:32.460 so in many ways for us to come back into the alignment with the law of life we have to choose
00:20:40.300 life, which means choosing each other, choosing to slow down, and to try to heal in our relationships
00:20:47.480 with each other.
00:21:10.300 Take a look around you
00:21:18.900 Just as there's sun in me
00:21:23.060 You won't find you'll never be free
00:21:27.400 Until you let it all go
00:21:30.800 What gives with the misgames
00:21:36.400 You gotta live
00:21:38.120 My thoughts have run
00:21:43.520 So far beyond my way
00:21:46.840 So to you I say
00:21:49.620 Hey, hey, hey, hey, hey
00:21:52.960 Be not divided
00:21:56.160 From this pain
00:21:59.380 No words to say
00:22:03.720 I'll sing hymns of light of ocean
00:22:12.540 Yeah, yeah, I really am seeing the connection
00:22:23.160 that you're speaking to with healing and slowing down
00:22:27.120 and the nervous system and realizing there's not some
00:22:32.660 10-step intellectual solution like I think it's important that we understand the history and we
00:22:40.280 we can intellectually grapple with the harms being done but so much of the work is this
00:22:49.980 somatic psychological healing and I really see that in so many ways I guess I'm just interested
00:23:01.020 to hear your insight into the ways that caste has been brought into structures of extraction
00:23:07.600 and even been intertwined into systems of colonialism, because I'd say for our listeners
00:23:14.480 and on the podcast, you know, we speak so much about colonialism and structures of extraction,
00:23:19.800 but not so much caste. And I think it would be really helpful, I know, for me to understand how
00:23:26.540 all of these things fit together? Well, I think what's important to know is that, you know,
00:23:33.900 caste is one of the oldest systems of exclusion in the world. It has its origin in the BC era.
00:23:40.700 And, and it's been a continuous thread in understanding the dynamics of power, you know,
00:23:49.120 from that time period to present and you know uh the way to understand it and how i kind of look at
00:23:57.000 it is that before a single english person you know set a boot on the ground in india there were
00:24:02.720 already centuries of exploitation of caste oppressed people across the subcontinent so it
00:24:08.580 is its own uh system of exclusion that needs to be addressed and you know colonialism just bought
00:24:15.900 another layer to the intersectional kind of violence that occurred for caste-depressed
00:24:22.280 people, both as people who experienced subjugation at the hands of dominant caste people, and
00:24:29.300 also the ways that the caste system was manipulated by colonial masters.
00:24:35.480 And, you know, for the English, they certainly saw caste as an efficient way to organize
00:24:40.580 a few to control the many.
00:24:42.180 and in fact they used the blueprint of caste as the architecture for apartheid in South Africa
00:24:49.400 because they saw how efficient it was to have the few to control the many and to kind of put these
00:24:54.640 little gradations of classes of people to be pitted against each other so that they never
00:25:00.480 achieve solidarity to take down the actual fundamental you know powers that be at the top
00:25:06.180 So, you know, I think that, you know, again, it's really important to understand that do we need to decolonize? Yes. And in the context of South Asians, in order to decolonize, we must first de-Brahmanize.
00:25:21.180 Brahmanize. And what that means is, is that, you know, the caste system has an animating ideology 1.00
00:25:28.440 called Brahmanism. And just like we wouldn't talk about anti-Blackness without talking about
00:25:35.360 white supremacy, Brahmanism is that ideology that set that framework in motion. And for people that 0.78
00:25:42.640 want to dig in, like, why that name? Where did that come from? Well, in the caste system, you know,
00:25:47.120 as I mentioned earlier, there's a pyramid where you have a priestly caste at the top called
00:25:52.660 Brahmins that basically structured the scriptures to allow for the categorization of the other
00:25:58.940 communities. So under Brahmins, you have the rulers that were Shatriyas, you have the merchants that
00:26:05.360 were Vaishyas, you have the peasants that were the Shidra caste. And then outside of that whole 0.86
00:26:11.380 system, you have people that are untouchable, because they were seen as spiritually defiling
00:26:16.900 to other people. And because they were spiritually defiling, they shouldn't be touched. That's why
00:26:22.320 we were, you know, called untouchable. But of course, that's, you know, ludicrous and extremely 0.87
00:26:27.820 offensive. And so we use other terms like Dalit, or Ambedkarite, or, you know, Bahujan. And, you
00:26:35.560 know, it's basically everyone chooses their own name as a way to free themselves from this
00:26:39.240 construct. And then you have South Asian indigenous people who are also outside of the system. So they
00:26:44.900 might call themselves tribal or advasi or their tribe names so brahmanism set up this entire
00:26:52.080 framework like this and we see its ideology stretching way beyond its origins into many
00:26:59.760 aspects of south asian society and to even other communities of faith practice today so you use
00:27:07.080 brahmanism interchangeably the way that you might use white supremacy to understand dominant
00:27:13.340 thinking when it comes to systems of exclusion in our in our region and so for me it's very
00:27:20.280 important that yes we acknowledge the pain of colonization but we can't really solve you know
00:27:28.260 what got harmed in colonization if we don't look at the first wound which is the caste soul wound
00:27:34.760 and so you know decolonizing requires us first to examine where we might de-brahmanize
00:27:40.580 i want to explore a bit about something that you bring up again in your slate interview
00:27:48.980 titled silicon valley has a caste problem and and you say quote in the united states we have a very
00:27:56.040 north american understanding of race as long as we've got a diverse workforce and we're challenging
00:28:02.240 white supremacy we think we've got all of our boxes checked but the reality is that these are
00:28:08.800 American companies working in a global context. North American models of race aren't going to
00:28:14.560 cover all the issues of inequity. Think about Google, Microsoft, Twitter, Meta. Their largest
00:28:21.000 market isn't the United States. It's in India, end quote. I really was moved by this quote because
00:28:30.900 You know, I can admit for myself, it's easy to get wrapped up in whether it's like a local mental framework or a national framework where, you know, like, I don't know if it's called American exceptionalism, but definitely this thought around, you know, being in the United States and thinking about, you know, seeing it through a lens of being here.
00:28:57.920 But reading that quote, it really expanded my thought process around how other places like India are interfacing with these large multinational corporations that are truly trying to control us.
00:29:15.560 And so I just wanted to open up this question to you, or this thought process with you about other, you know, I don't know if I'm trying to think like there's, you know, definitely a question around frameworks of discrimination.
00:29:32.700 But I also think talking about big tech and discrimination when it comes to other countries who have bigger markets than ours, it's something that I can honestly say I haven't even really been aware of.
00:29:48.820 Well, I think there's kind of like two ways to really think about the way our minds might be opened around this. So the first is that because of American dominance in the global economy, we've never really had to step out of the comfort zone of thinking about our definitions for race are not the only definitions for exclusion in the world.
00:30:16.640 and in fact we have so many ways that different communities around the world are thinking about
00:30:23.460 decolonizing and also experiencing you know rapid conversations around the shifts of power
00:30:32.060 around the lines of race but in their own logic you know so whether we're talking about countries
00:30:38.960 like Brazil or the different countries in the African continent or in Asia, the conversation
00:30:50.580 about equity looks really different because it's not about necessarily a white dominant class.
00:30:57.820 It could be and is oftentimes about dominant gatekeepers that come from historical legacies
00:31:05.500 of trauma in that region. So we have to really be specific about the manifestations of historical
00:31:14.580 violence that we're trying to remedy with policies that are focused on DEI and equity.
00:31:21.700 And an American framework is not a one-size-fits-all because of how complicated those
00:31:27.180 colonial and local histories are. And the issue of caste is a really good example of that because
00:31:34.280 it has both an American discourse and a discourse in the region. So in the American discourse is
00:31:41.360 that the IT industry, because of the high amount of South Asians that it hires, has a great deal
00:31:50.720 of caste discrimination happening in American borders, which means it's subject to civil rights
00:31:57.060 law and labor law here in a way that really needs to be addressed. And then I think outside
00:32:04.260 Outside of that, what we have is outside of the United States is when American companies do business in other global contexts, our legal laws here are not going to be robust enough to understand the systemic discrimination there.
00:32:20.720 And that's why we need to have global policies that kind of speak to keeping all of the workers and all of the users safe to the same standards.
00:32:31.600 And that seems like that would be obvious and logical, but it's actually not been the
00:32:36.900 business practices of many of these companies.
00:32:39.900 So, you know, they, you know, they either have inconsistent policies where casts are
00:32:45.120 not listed in HR policies outside of South Asia, but, you know, they have to do it in
00:32:51.240 South Asia because it's a protected category there in many of the countries, or refusing
00:32:56.100 to acknowledge that it's happening in the United States, even though there are significant
00:33:00.180 caste-depressed tech workers that are raising their appropriate civil and labor rights around
00:33:05.080 these issues and are concerned about it. So it's a very complicated landscape that Americans need 0.69
00:33:15.080 to quickly become familiar with because we cannot afford a vision of justice that ends at our
00:33:22.700 borders, especially when our companies are multinational. The flows of our capital are
00:33:28.020 multinational. And we have billionaires that are American citizens that are destabilizing
00:33:33.740 democracies through their tech and their, you know, across the world. And, you know, I think
00:33:41.100 about, you know, Twitter, which has been in the news because of Elon Musk's takeover, and 90%
00:33:47.220 of the India team was laid off. And this is in one of their largest markets and one in which
00:33:53.400 dangerous genocidal hate speech is the norm. If there are so many people in human rights and
00:33:59.800 academic research and legal compliance and moderation that are fired, how will you stop
00:34:06.040 and address the duty of care companies like Twitter and Meta have around the human rights
00:34:14.260 crisis that's happening there? So it's really important that we expand our notion of equity
00:34:20.920 and justice and get familiar with these global conversations because they're already impacting
00:34:26.500 us here. We're already seeing the impact of what happens with biased tech, like biased companies
00:34:33.380 create biased tech. And when we have people that are not adhering to the law, we find that they
00:34:40.880 will skirt accountability for tech that creates harm in all of our communities. Thank you for
00:34:49.020 opening our eyes or many of our eyes to this it's um it's heavy and so important to understand
00:35:00.320 how insidious these systems and corporations and big tech are to so many of us around the world
00:35:10.920 oh goodness um yeah there's of course more to talk about with big tech I mean there's so much here
00:35:22.000 definitely thinking about investigating the many uh horrific ways big tech acts as a mediator for
00:35:32.140 global issues of power you know just that seems really frightening and like holding us back from
00:35:41.600 actually healing or being able to find a way through some of these really intense issues
00:35:50.180 i i think that we have the reins of power in our hands and we've surrendered control
00:35:58.180 because we think we're really limited to only being users, but we are in fact citizens.
00:36:04.900 You know, we actually have the rule of law and we are seeing people with money behave
00:36:10.040 as if they don't have any accountability to anyone else.
00:36:13.900 And to me, I think these conversations about these tech companies, it's not just about
00:36:19.420 one feature.
00:36:20.800 It's not just about one act.
00:36:23.500 it's actually a battle of futures. Because, you know, the the model that many of the billionaires
00:36:30.800 have is that they view the earth as a husk. You know, everything, you know, especially if you
00:36:35.500 take someone like Elon Musk, and, you know, the movements that, you know, he comes out of,
00:36:41.120 they really do believe that the earth is meant to be a husk for us. And our only purpose and only
00:36:47.240 way that we survive as a species is if we burn all of our resources and get to Mars and start
00:36:53.300 to colonize the stars, you know, and using again, that term colonization, you know, and, and I think
00:36:59.600 that there are alternative futures, I think that, you know, in this time of great climate catastrophe,
00:37:04.740 we can use this as a moment of reexamination, and consider, is there another way for us to return
00:37:12.280 back to balance, because the earth, you know, in its own, if it didn't have humans as the, you know,
00:37:18.380 the apex predator here, you know, generally tends towards balance between the different species that
00:37:25.320 are here. We are the ones that are causing the great kind of catastrophe here. So I think if we
00:37:32.980 can, you know, think about things like the great turning that, you know, that, you know, we've,
00:37:39.100 we've heard in other circles, and use this moment of the just transition to think about ways that we
00:37:45.720 calibrate our relationships with each other. And tech is certainly part of it. Tech is just a tool.
00:37:51.760 And we do not have to adhere to the visions of these billionaire titans that don't know how to
00:37:58.500 run companies, don't know how to run democracy, but they just have a ton of capital and are
00:38:03.400 anti-democratic in their engagements. And I think remembering that we have the rule of law,
00:38:09.180 remembering that we have the ability to vote, remembering that we have the ability to bring
00:38:13.840 litigation and support people towards that process, I think is to, to accountability and
00:38:22.260 also towards love is something that we still have in our power. And, and I think that sometimes
00:38:28.620 people get in despair because they see the division of these very rich people and they're
00:38:33.700 like, how can I compete with that? You know? And, and I think that the love of millions of people
00:38:39.980 is as strong as, you know, the money of like one billionaire, you know, and to be able to
00:38:47.600 return back to love, to return back to humanity. I think that means everything.
00:39:00.120 Sister, you are not too far for holding. I need your strength to carry.
00:39:09.980 on sister you are not too far for holding i need your strength to carry on
00:39:24.660 and our bodies are bound like the vines on the side of a house somewhere deep in the heart of
00:39:31.700 the earth bodies are bound like the vines on the side of a house somewhere deep in the heart of the
00:39:38.340 earth sister you are not too far for holding i need your strike to carry on
00:39:50.600 that's really beautiful and thank you for empowering some of us again because i
00:40:01.920 think with big tech it can feel really overwhelming with these issues of control and power within a
00:40:13.600 rapidly growing and often unregulated space that's technology it can be like oh my gosh how do we even
00:40:20.340 stop this monster and thanks for giving us some some ideas of how to move forward and
00:40:29.040 And I want to jump to another topic, and I want to read a quote from your book, The Trauma of Kast, where you detail the experience of Kast saying, quote, you're not even allowed the consultation of spiritual practice, some kind of relationship with the higher power, because you are considered spiritually defiling before God, end quote.
00:40:53.480 gosh and it's just such an intense you know thing to take in it's like thinking through
00:41:02.100 the complex relationship between caste and religion and I'm wondering if you could provide
00:41:07.360 some more depth on that relationship and the spiritual struggles that come with it
00:41:12.580 you know I think writing those words were very hard for me to write too
00:41:17.280 because I had to confront the totality of some of the pain that I had as someone who is a survivor
00:41:24.520 of religious abuse. And even to say it out loud was, you know, it was kind of like a bell rang
00:41:31.100 in my soul because all of the pieces of what I had been running from, I had to hold and really
00:41:38.720 just say, this happened to me. And it happens to millions of Dalit people. Because again, I think 0.67
00:41:45.400 the the problem with caste is that it is a system of exclusion that has its roots in religious
00:41:53.260 communities so it's not just that you're excluded from society it's that you're actually excluded
00:42:00.420 from the divine and you know that is a very profound thing because you know for other people
00:42:06.940 like when you decide that you want to become a seeker you might go out to the stars and look up
00:42:12.020 and wonder about your place in the universe and think deeply about, you know, who am I,
00:42:18.320 where do I belong and what do I believe? And that practice, that ability to have freedom to do that
00:42:26.380 is really denied to Dalits because we are from jump thought to be spiritually polluting
00:42:32.860 and othered. And the path to becoming part of a community feels so deeply pained. It's not an
00:42:42.780 easy one to reclaim your divinity. And in fact, you have to fight tooth and nail, you have to
00:42:48.480 fight centuries of conditioning, you have to fight, you know, societal programming that tells
00:42:53.760 you that you don't have a right to this, to actually surrender and say, I absolutely do,
00:43:00.460 because all of us are divine and that again was a much easier thing to say than it was to actually
00:43:10.300 practice in my real life because I really always felt ashamed and never felt good enough to be part
00:43:17.680 of spiritual communities and it's part of the reasons why I was a seeker and I would read
00:43:23.580 every religious text and I would go to different community gatherings to see if I could find a 1.00
00:43:29.260 political home and a religious home but I always felt othered because of that core caste soul wound 0.85
00:43:37.480 and I had to I had to love myself and I had to really really be kind to acknowledging how deep
00:43:49.140 this pain was in me and give myself space to self-examine and once I was witnessed both by
00:43:57.440 myself and other people, I could then feel like I could make my choice about returning to a
00:44:05.820 spiritual practice that was on my terms. And, you know, you don't have to be Dalit to understand 0.79
00:44:11.920 this experience because there are many survivors of religious abuse. But the path towards
00:44:18.300 surrendering to a mystery or a divinity that's greater than yours is so hard when you've been
00:44:24.500 wounded in this way and the trust has been broken and for me what really helped me heal was a
00:44:31.100 connection to the earth a connection to you know to life and um and to see the divine in everyday
00:44:39.620 things as well as in grand mysterious things you know you see the divine in the blooming of a flower
00:44:47.500 just as you would in like a grand religious spectacle of an institution you know it's about
00:44:53.700 that interconnectedness to that, that larger sense of who we can be as a species, as an earth
00:45:00.980 connected to the rest of the universe. And, and I had to give myself permission to take up space
00:45:09.580 spiritually. And that was also part of my healing, you know, and so to talk about this in this way
00:45:15.560 was to give words to an experience that many Dalits don't talk about because the wound is so
00:45:21.820 intimate and it's so shameful. But my hope in talking about this was really to create space
00:45:28.120 for people to consider that the divine belongs to everyone and to democratize access and to
00:45:35.120 give space to people who have never been able to hold how horrific this kind of wounding is
00:45:42.560 to be witnessed and to heal. Thank you for sharing that with us.
00:45:52.820 Cornel West, who wrote the afterword for your book, writes in his book, Race Matters, quote,
00:46:00.180 In these downbeat times, we need as much hope and courage as we do vision and analysis.
00:46:06.260 We must assent the best of each other, even as we point out the vicious effects of our racial divide and consequences of our maldistribution of wealth and power.
00:46:17.960 We simply cannot enter the 21st century at each other's throats, even as we acknowledge the weighty forces of racism, patriarchy, economic inequality, homophobia, and ecological abuse on our necks.
00:46:31.820 We are at a crucial crossroad in the history of this nation, and we either hang together by combating these forces that divide and degrade us, or we hang separately.
00:46:42.540 End quote.
00:46:43.000 thinking about dr west work in conversation with yours i'm wondering what is at the heart
00:46:51.260 for these searches for justice and solidarity what worlds could solidarity build
00:46:58.120 well you know one of the things that um i've always admired about professor west is the way
00:47:06.600 that he leads with love. And he has a quote where he talks about love is what justice looks like in
00:47:13.520 public. And I think about that a lot when you think about solidarity, because for me,
00:47:20.540 solidarity isn't like a big political, you know, concept outside of yourself. It's actually
00:47:28.280 embodied in the relationality you have with someone about shared liberation. And, you know,
00:47:35.120 I always think about his mentorship because you know when I met him like I was like so eager and
00:47:40.860 I just wanted to be witnessed I wanted someone who understood how big this problem was and would
00:47:47.060 would see me as a person because I spent years like not getting support and I always remember
00:47:53.880 that first meeting I was so nervous and I wondered like is this gonna you know do you think he'll
00:47:58.720 only give me five minutes and I was ready to rush in and just kind of make my peace and hopefully
00:48:03.500 it would work and you know Professor West gave me so much time and so much empathetic witness
00:48:11.480 and he he had like piles of paper of work he needed to do he had people outside the door
00:48:19.480 waiting for him and when we talked it was like we were the only two people in that room because of
00:48:26.180 the power of how deep his black internationalism is, and his empathetic witness was in holding
00:48:33.580 space for another oppressed person. And I'm not the only Dalit leader that he has mentored. And
00:48:39.880 I think that this is what is profound about shared solidarities is that because of our love for each
00:48:46.520 other, we view like an injury to to another as an injury as if it happened to us. And, you know,
00:48:56.060 if I have a plate of rice, I want to give half of it to my, you know, to my collaborator and my
00:49:01.380 colleague, because I how can I eat when I know that they're hungry, you know, that shared sense
00:49:06.900 of survival, it actually is a counter to the capitalist notion of individual survival of the
00:49:15.600 fittest when actually there's as many stories in nature of collaborative species survival as there
00:49:22.460 is of competition and and I think that solidaries between oppressed people are an example of that
00:49:29.080 and another friendship which I think is really another example of that is you know my friendship
00:49:35.620 with Toronto Burke and we both came up as you know gender-based violence organizers who you know
00:49:42.320 worked on issues related to sexual violence with Black and Dalit communities. And when we were in
00:49:48.800 our 20s and didn't know where our lives were going to land, you know, we just always dreamed 1.00
00:49:53.400 of a world where Black and Dalit young girls and women could be free and could live without the
00:50:02.360 violence both inside and outside of our community. And those dreams are the freedom dreams that
00:50:08.700 actually lay the path for solidarities like this because we just always think about ways that our
00:50:14.360 movements and our lives might intersect and when we know that someone is in the point of struggle
00:50:19.260 you know we always just offer that friendly ear that you know tactful suggestion that opening to
00:50:25.860 a colleague you know whatever it is to kind of help leverage our collective resources that's
00:50:32.800 really the power of what I've been so, so grateful to witness and also contribute to with many other
00:50:41.560 leaders and movements. So it's, it's a process, I think, that really is, is thoughtful and takes
00:50:47.900 time to really consider, but I'm just really grateful to see develop, you know, in many
00:50:53.800 different ways, you know. This has been such a beautiful conversation. I've really appreciated
00:51:00.380 your time and there's something i wanted to close us out with in the appendix of your book
00:51:07.780 you introduce readers to cast abolitionist ancestors who've inspired you and i'd love
00:51:13.820 if you could share a bit about one of these ancestors with our listeners well i think one
00:51:20.460 ancestor and there's many in there to really learn deeply from uh but one that i really love
00:51:27.640 is Dr. Ambedkar. And, you know, he was like the equivalent of our Malcolm X and Martin Luther
00:51:34.280 King. But he's, you know, a once in a generation, you know, figure because he did it all. You know,
00:51:43.580 he was an economist, he was a historian, he was a scholar, he was a lawyer. He was one of the first
00:51:51.900 Indians to go to school abroad and went to Columbia University in the United States and
00:51:59.240 the London School of Economics. And his mind was worked in all of these dimensions because he was
00:52:05.920 basically creating a critical theory for the liberation of caste-oppressed people. And it was
00:52:12.660 also, he was coming up during the time of the consideration of what it would be like to have a
00:52:18.520 free and independent India because he grew up in colonial India. So his learnings really
00:52:24.120 informed an activism that had many different phases as he was trying different tactics to
00:52:31.020 free Dalit people. So in his first wave, he was an independence movement leader. And then he went
00:52:38.220 on to become the architect of the Indian constitution, which is the first legal document
00:52:45.100 in South Asia to have a Dalit author. So it has a weight beyond India because many other South
00:52:51.140 Asian republics used it as a blueprint for their work. And then also, you know, he helped to set
00:52:57.500 up the first reserve bank of India. He also fought, you know, tremendously for women's rights
00:53:03.780 and his battles to free, you know, all women from, you know, restrictive and conservative religious
00:53:10.160 codes, set the framework for many of the civil rights laws that protect women from land property
00:53:19.260 to discrimination. And then also he, very much like the civil rights movements in the United
00:53:27.060 States, led significant battles to desegregate key institutions across India. And this would be,
00:53:36.320 he led desegregation marshes against temples that wouldn't allow Dalits to enter, around roadways 0.83
00:53:42.760 where Dalits were not allowed to walk, into water tanks where Dalits were not allowed to even drink 0.77
00:53:48.740 water. And, you know, throughout this time, he's also writing and sharing his work through many,
00:53:55.900 many different kinds of books. And, and, you know, in his final act, he converted to Buddhism,
00:54:02.200 because he he said that though I was born a Hindu I don't want to die one and he he demonstrated
00:54:08.780 what it meant to choose in the face of Brahmanism and and I think that that was a very profound
00:54:15.940 thing to observe because when he converted hundreds of thousands of people converted with him
00:54:21.940 in Nagpur Maharashtra and you know it was the largest conversion in world history and you know
00:54:31.060 when I think of his figure and I think about his history the thing that I am so inspired by
00:54:36.200 is that there was no domain that he did not feel that was his as a Dalit to enter and in fact 0.97
00:54:43.100 all of life experience he was going to consume and consume greatly in a way to be able to to bring 0.90
00:54:50.360 Dalits to the seat of at the table as fellow humans and his Buddhist engagement and the way 0.99
00:54:57.640 that he navigated entering religious practice as a socially engaged Buddhist was also very deeply
00:55:06.000 inspiring to me. So he's a figure that I really would like to lift up for people, because
00:55:11.900 fundamentally, we are having this conversation about caste, not because we just want to talk
00:55:17.040 about the problem, but also because we want to heal. And if I can leave anything with your
00:55:23.120 audience members to think about, it's that systems of exclusion are not permanent. They are only
00:55:31.200 lasting as long as we hold on and have attachment to that suffering. And so if we are willing to let
00:55:37.760 go and step through the doorway of our discomfort to be able to welcome new ways of interacting with
00:55:46.420 each other, many things are possible. And that's the pathway towards healing. And I think it's
00:55:53.360 just a really profound thing to be able to see how that really manifested through Dr. Embedkar's
00:56:00.980 career. And now through the millions of people that in his name, continue to take forward the
00:56:08.620 commitment to annihilate caste and be caste abolitionists. So his name and his work and
00:56:15.820 the many ancestors, and I think about my own grandparents and people who come from my lineage,
00:56:21.840 you know, we're all artifacts as Dalit people of a thousand generations of love.
00:56:26.920 And so if we can build this movement on love and healing, we have so much that we can win
00:56:31.980 and so much that we can travel towards as we work with other people
00:56:36.420 to heal the earth and heal each other then marie thank you so much i've really
00:56:42.800 enjoyed and been moved by this conversation and just really appreciate all the love and care and
00:56:50.820 effort you've put into helping us heal i really appreciate that and you know just want to thank
00:56:59.080 you for holding space and in our movements we always give a salutation of justice as we end
00:57:04.900 and begin a conversation.
00:57:06.800 And we use the terms J-Beam and J-Savitri,
00:57:10.480 which invoke both Dr. Ambedkar
00:57:13.080 and another ancestor, Savitri Bhai Pule.
00:57:16.280 So I would leave your listeners with that ending
00:57:18.720 and knowing that we are now beloved community
00:57:21.020 with each other and look forward to keep buildings.
00:57:24.080 For J-Beam and J-Savitri, everyone.
00:57:28.420 Thank you for listening to For the Wild podcast.
00:57:31.320 The music you heard today was by Justin Cromer,
00:57:34.900 Tay Martin, and June West, For the Wild is created by Ayanna Young, Erica Ekrem,
00:57:43.440 Francesca Glassbell, and Julia Jackson.