There Are No Girls on the Internet - September 08, 2023


Elon doubles down on antisemitism; Grindr forces LGBTQ staff back to the office; Your car knows your sex life; Something is rotten at Rotten Tomatoes – NEWS ROUNDUP

Topics
Black women’s entrepreneurship is under attack - STUFF MOM NEVER TOLD YOU Ashton Kutcher and the anti-trafficking grift

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 15 minutes

Words per minute

183.41

Word count

13,926

Sentence count

543

Harmful content

Misogyny

5

sentences flagged

Toxicity

24

sentences flagged

Hate speech

16

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 This is an iHeart Podcast.
00:00:02.580 Guaranteed human.
00:00:05.140 Get Bell Pure Fiber Internet with Crave, Netflix, and Disney Plus
00:00:08.720 from $94 a month.
00:00:10.160 Price guaranteed for two years on Internet
00:00:12.040 with a two-year term and auto-pay credit.
00:00:14.400 Visit bell.ca for details and to check availability.
00:00:17.180 Bell. Connection is everything.
00:00:19.620 Run a business and not thinking about podcasting?
00:00:21.880 Think again.
00:00:22.520 More Americans listen to podcasts
00:00:23.980 than ad-supported streaming music from Spotify and Pandora.
00:00:26.680 And as the number one podcaster,
00:00:28.060 iHeart's twice as large as the next two combined.
00:00:30.820 Learn how podcasting can help your business.
00:00:32.640 Call 844-844-IHEART.
00:00:34.920 If your bookshelf and your For You page
00:00:36.860 are equally important to your personality,
00:00:39.100 welcome home.
00:00:40.700 Pro Society is a weekly podcast
00:00:42.560 that's part book club, part group chat
00:00:44.480 for anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice
00:00:46.180 and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:00:48.920 Each week, we're connecting the dots
00:00:50.360 between books, the internet, and pop culture
00:00:52.460 with your favorite writers, book talk creators,
00:00:54.980 and plenty of overthought opinions.
00:00:57.080 Yeah, I'm obsessed. I'm obsessed.
00:00:59.020 Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:01:09.060 There Are No Girls on the Internet is a production of iHeartRadio and Unbossed Creative.
00:01:17.180 I'm Bridget Todd, and this is There Are No Girls on the Internet.
00:01:22.660 I am here with my fantastic producer, Joey.
00:01:25.360 Joey, how are you? How was your holiday?
00:01:28.100 Hi, Bridget. I'm doing good. My holiday was nice. It's nice to have, you know, a couple days on.
00:01:32.960 Yeah, did you do anything fun?
00:01:34.720 Um, what did I do this weekend? Yeah, actually, I did a drag performance for the first time.
00:01:42.560 Oh my god!
00:01:44.460 Yeah, I feel like I've been wanting to do it for a bit, and then my friend, I had like a birthday party over the weekend.
00:01:50.260 It was like, I want my friends to do drag performances, so I was like, all right, sure.
00:01:55.360 Why not? Yeah, it was super fun. I totally, totally won't do that again. So it made my
00:02:01.720 drag debut. Oh, my God. I hope to many more. Also, happy birthday. Oh, no, it was my friend's 0.99
00:02:08.420 birthday. Oh, friend's birthday. Got it. Well, happy birthday to your friend. Well, let's get
00:02:13.840 into some of these news stories that folks might have missed on the internet this week. So first
00:02:18.860 of all, we have to start with a little bit of an update, which is an update on our enemy of the pod
00:02:24.700 professional litigate, that's right, Edward Blum, the one-man wrecking ball against diversity.
00:02:31.120 This week on the podcast, I did a deep dive on the show Stuff Mom Never Told You into Edward
00:02:35.920 Blum's legal challenge that he is bringing against the Black venture capital firm Fearless Fund for
00:02:41.020 giving out grants and money and support for Black women entrepreneurs. After Blum successfully
00:02:46.700 brought a legal challenge that gutted the Voting Rights Act and affirmative action, well, Blum is
00:02:52.440 also challenging diversity fellowship programs for people of color, LGBTQ folks, and people
00:02:57.440 with disabilities at law firms. And it looks like that challenge might have been somewhat successful,
00:03:02.780 at least with one law firm, because the law firm Morrison & Forrester has removed language
00:03:07.660 specifying that their fellowship is only open to Black, Hispanic, Native American, or LGBTQ
00:03:12.840 applicants, according to a flyer from the program's website. Now, the flyer has been altered to say
00:03:18.980 that applicants need to, quote, bring a diverse perspective to the firm as a result of your
00:03:23.980 adaptability, cultural fluency, resilience, and life experiences. So luckily, it doesn't sound
00:03:30.060 like they are completely abandoning the diversity part of their fellowship program outright,
00:03:34.460 but that they're probably changing the wording, probably because they're hoping to avoid a big
00:03:39.940 legal challenge or legal battle with Blum and just want to be able to focus on, like, doing
00:03:44.740 their work. The fellowship is called the Keith Wetmore 1L Fellowship for Excellence, Diversity,
00:03:50.580 and Inclusion, and it supported law students from historically underrepresented groups in
00:03:54.520 the legal industry. It was also a recruitment tool to help diversify law firms, which folks
00:03:59.060 probably know are notoriously not very diverse. The fellowship consists of a paid summer associate
00:04:03.800 position, which in law firms can often lead to a full-time job that pay in the six figures after
00:04:08.560 graduation, and a $50,000 stipend. So way to go, Edward Blum. I hope the fact that this law
00:04:14.600 firm had to amend their fellowship program is to your liking. I hope it makes you feel good. I hope
00:04:20.240 you will leave these people alone. I hope you will let them just do their jobs. And we will keep y'all
00:04:24.620 updated on how these cases progress. It's so messed up and it's so like obviously messed up
00:04:30.320 that it's, I don't even know like what to say at this point. Well, I often feel like I think
00:04:36.140 that you might feel now where I don't even know what to say. I think that Blum is someone who
00:04:42.100 will not rest until a very small subsection of people, him and people who look like him,
00:04:50.360 are making all the decisions for everyone, are the ones who are getting everything. I think that's
00:04:55.140 what he wants. And so when I hear about the challenges that he is taking on, it's hard for me
00:05:01.840 to even really know what to say. And in the episode of Stuff Mom Never Told You that I did
00:05:07.420 this week something that really comes up for me after doing all that that research into blum and
00:05:12.200 his motivations and the people that he's that he's suing are that these are people who are
00:05:16.720 really have work to do right like they are trying to write societal wrongs they are trying to make
00:05:24.300 landscapes more equitable and that is real work and so i can understand why this legal firm is
00:05:30.300 just like you know if tweaking our our website language is gonna maybe make this guy go away
00:05:36.480 let's do it but they shouldn't have to do that they should be able to focus on what it is that 0.52
00:05:41.320 they are trying to accomplish with their work and so yeah i i blum remains an enemy of the show
00:05:48.080 we will keep folks posted on his next moves hopefully they won't include continuing to go
00:05:55.440 at go after marginalized people and the institutions that support us i think that's
00:06:00.840 interesting i feel like i remember for a while there are all these stories that were coming out
00:06:05.600 about like people that would like fake being native american scholarship or like there were
00:06:11.520 a couple like really big cases of like people that were like claiming to be like transracial
00:06:15.660 or something like i don't it's it's interesting that this is happening after i feel like we had
00:06:20.580 a big conversation about there was a big sort of media frenzy around that um i don't know it's just
00:06:25.660 like it's the same sort of attacking all of these programs from like different angles which i yeah
00:06:32.220 this whole thing is so weird. It's so weird. Blum is such a weird guy. If folks are interested in
00:06:38.040 more about him, his background, his motivation, check out this week's episode with me on Stuff
00:06:43.720 Mom Never Told You because it is a doozy. So speaking of supporting or not supporting
00:06:50.500 marginalized people, we got to talk about what's going on at Grindr. Folks probably know there
00:06:55.160 have been a flurry of big companies making remote workers come back to the office like Google and
00:07:00.960 ironically, Zoom, you know, Zoom makes the tech that we all use to work remotely, but apparently
00:07:06.780 won't let their staff work remotely using the tech that they build. I don't know. It's kind of a
00:07:12.160 weird sitch. But employees who work at the dating app Grindr are being forced to come back to work
00:07:18.200 in person. And now staff is saying that that mandate, that policy has really dealt a blow
00:07:24.180 to Grindr's unique queer-friendly workplace culture, which employees say was a rarity in
00:07:28.900 tech. This is all from Wired, which did a really great deep dive into what's going on. Since many
00:07:34.160 of Grindr's employees are LGBTQ, in-person work policies means having to give up access to support 1.00
00:07:40.500 systems and support networks and sometimes medical care networks that you've established during a
00:07:45.280 time where folks are seeing waves of anti-LGBTQ violence and threats across the country. Wired
00:07:51.220 talked to one trans employee that they call Robin, who said that the mandate forced a choice between
00:07:56.160 a job they loved and a support system that includes trusted doctors who provide their
00:08:00.560 transgender medical care. Robin ultimately chose to leave the company, but said that initially
00:08:05.620 coming to work at Grindr was, quote, a blast of fresh air compared to other jobs in the tech
00:08:10.740 industry. I felt normal. I didn't feel like one queer person or the most noticeable queer person
00:08:15.960 at a company. It was what I was always looking for, and now that is gone. Robin is actually
00:08:20.780 not alone, because none of the eight openly trans employees who worked at Grindr chose to relocate
00:08:25.860 And the trans staffer that they spoke to said that it's really indicative of the cuts and how they are impacting more marginalized staff the most.
00:08:33.440 Robin says, demanding that LGBTQ plus people move for their job in this political environment conflicts with so much of Grindr's mission that it's close to its users, that it's part of the community.
00:08:44.180 This all started last month when Grindr abruptly gave its all remote staff two weeks to pledge to work from an office two days a week starting in October or lose their jobs come August 31st.
00:08:55.500 82 out of the 178 employees, that's 46% of the staff, were let go after rejecting that mandate,
00:09:02.480 according to the Grindr Union, which went public two weeks before the ultimatum.
00:09:06.820 The policy would have forced many of them to relocate to L.A., Chicago, or San Francisco.
00:09:12.180 Now, this is all happening against the backdrop of Grindr's recent unionization.
00:09:16.320 The Communications Workers of America, which now represents employees of Grindr,
00:09:20.300 filed two unfair labor practice charges with the U.S. National Labor Relations Board against
00:09:24.880 Grindr, accusing the company of unlawfully suppressing discussion of working conditions
00:09:28.900 and company chats, and through an agreement that terminated employees were offered in
00:09:32.780 exchange for severance pay. Now, Grindr does say that this abrupt back-to-office plan has
00:09:39.700 nothing to do with the recent unionization. That is just a huge coincidence, according to Grindr's
00:09:45.580 higher-ups. However, the staff says that the cuts disproportionately impacted union supporters.
00:09:51.860 Nine out of the 11 union organizing committee members were forced out.
00:09:55.520 Staff is also worried about how this will ultimately impact the site. Obviously,
00:10:00.100 for dating apps and hookup apps, privacy concerns are heightened. Privacy is important on any app
00:10:06.520 or any platform, but especially an app where you're meeting people, you're having intimate
00:10:10.580 conversations, photos are being exchanged, you're meeting up, that kind of thing.
00:10:13.860 The exodus has raised concerns among the remaining staff about Grindr's functionality as an app,
00:10:20.000 recalling Elon Musk's employee purge at Twitter and the ensuing glitchy chaos.
00:10:24.960 So this really does seem to be part of a larger pattern playing out within tech companies.
00:10:29.840 I know that this came up on one of our previous newscasts, but Ben Collins at NBC calls this CEO contagion,
00:10:35.960 where there's this vibe of tech CEOs like cleaning house, firing everybody, laying everybody off
00:10:42.020 without real meaningful regard for how it will impact the platforms that they run
00:10:46.880 and could ultimately make those platforms worse.
00:10:50.520 Yeah. And like, obviously, like this case is particularly sensitive since so much of the
00:10:55.840 employees there are like LGBTQ plus identifying. Honestly, I'm surprised not all of them. 0.55
00:11:02.500 But, um, yeah, like, I feel like this is part of a pad. I don't know, like, like, my job, they're starting to like open up the offices again and encourage people like come back into the office. And I technically the office I work for is in a different state than I live in. So like, I'm crossing my fingers hoping and they're not gonna like mandate that anytime soon. But it is so weird. It's been three years where we've been working remotely and things have been going pretty smoothly. It's definitely.
00:11:28.080 yeah like like you said at the end there like it is this whole like CEO contagion about
00:11:33.820 not really sure what the I mean I guess the motivation is to get people to like
00:11:37.980 whatever I don't know I don't understand this whole push all of a sudden and it just seems
00:11:43.020 like it's gonna end with a lot of chaos um but yeah also yeah Grindr with the privacy thing
00:11:49.740 that's scary that's I mean that's a hookup app like that isn't especially like any dating app
00:11:54.860 I'd be worried about Grindr especially. It's not the kind of app where I would feel comfortable
00:12:00.560 showing up if they arbitrarily and haphazardly gutted the privacy and security staff. And it
00:12:09.440 sounds like that's what, according to this Wired piece, that's what some of the staff are worried
00:12:13.580 about, that if they just make these massive cuts to the workforce in mass, it's going to be that
00:12:20.920 much harder to ensure a safe and secure platform. And when you're dealing with a hookup app,
00:12:26.260 your people on that app really need to be able to feel like they're on a safe and secure platform.
00:12:33.060 Oh, yeah. I feel like this is just like a good example of like rainbow capitalism, 1.00
00:12:36.660 still capitalism. Rainbow CEOs are still CEOs. They're still going to put their own interests 0.84
00:12:41.700 first. And yeah, that's just that's that's messed up. I don't know a ton about Grindr
00:12:46.520 like as an organization i know like a couple years back there was some sort of like discussion
00:12:51.700 about like how trans people's experiences on the app were and stuff like that so again it's like
00:12:57.580 the if if you know what they're like the eight openly trans employees like decided not to
00:13:03.960 relocate i mean how is that going to affect the the app like not having any trans people on the
00:13:08.940 team of your or maybe losing all the trans people on your team that just it doesn't seem like it's
00:13:13.840 Yeah, that's such a good point. And the trans employee that Wired spoke to, I mean, I don't know what's going on at Grindr, but it does sound like if one demographic is just like no longer represented at your workforce, management really has to ask how equitable were these layoffs, how equitable was this rollout if it completely got rid of an entire subsection of your workforce in that way. 0.99
00:13:43.340 It just seems to me like obviously something's going on there. I think that the staffer that they talked to who said that these cuts are impacting the more marginalized staff more, it seems obvious that that's the case. And so I'm curious how it's going to work out.
00:13:57.940 But I feel for staff who, like, if in the piece they talk about how this was rolled out very abruptly and how for the last few months, staff who worked remotely were like, are we going to have to come back to the office?
00:14:13.520 And management was like, no, you'll be fine.
00:14:15.260 No, we're not.
00:14:15.700 We have no plans to make that change.
00:14:17.040 And then coincidentally, after the unionization was successful, now this is like abruptly rolled out.
00:14:24.140 And so, yeah, it just seems like a situation where management is really going out of their way to roll out this policy in the most abrupt, chaotic way possible, possibly in retaliation for unionization, question mark.
00:14:37.520 I don't know. But, you know, that timing does seem awful coincidental to me.
00:14:46.180 Let's take a quick break.
00:14:54.140 Bell Pure Fiber Internet with Crave, Netflix, and Disney Plus from $94 a month.
00:14:58.680 Price guaranteed for two years on internet with a two-year term and auto pay credit.
00:15:02.920 Visit bell.ca for details and to check availability.
00:15:05.700 Bell. Connection is everything.
00:15:08.220 Run a business and not thinking about podcasting?
00:15:10.900 Think again.
00:15:11.860 More Americans listen to podcasts than ad-supported streaming music from Spotify and Pandora.
00:15:16.180 And as the number one podcaster, iHeart's twice as large as the next two combined.
00:15:20.760 So whatever your customers listen to, they'll hear your message.
00:15:23.420 Plus, only iHeart can extend your message to audiences across broadcast radio.
00:15:27.920 Think podcasting can help your business?
00:15:29.800 Think iHeart.
00:15:30.820 Streaming, radio, and podcasting.
00:15:32.900 Call 844-844-IHEART to get started.
00:15:36.060 That's 844-844-IHEART.
00:15:38.540 When I was 14 years old, I was kidnapped and held captive for nine months.
00:15:44.380 I survived, and I've spent my life exploring how other people survive what should have destroyed them.
00:15:50.900 I'm Elizabeth Smart, and these are The Survivor Files.
00:15:54.500 I just remember this low, taunting voice next to my ear saying, 0.96
00:15:59.940 shut up, don't say anything.
00:16:02.700 Every week, I'm with survivors who live through the unthinkable. 0.98
00:16:07.120 I knew if he woke up, without a doubt, he was going to hurt me.
00:16:11.580 I started feeling that there was someone at the end of my bed, and I just started screaming.
00:16:18.660 They are abducted, stalked, controlled, and nearly silenced.
00:16:23.120 But these aren't stories about what's taken from them.
00:16:26.540 They're stories about what it takes to make it out alive.
00:16:30.180 Listen to The Survivor Files with Elizabeth Smart on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:16:44.040 And we're back.
00:16:45.020 so i do want to balance the scales a little bit you know we talk a lot about corporations doing
00:16:53.780 the wrong thing when it comes to supporting marginalized staff so it is nice to be able
00:16:57.760 to report on a company doing something kind of good going in the opposite direction indeed the
00:17:03.080 online job search company is offering ten thousand dollars to trans employees or immediate family
00:17:08.060 members if they need to move to escape laws restricting trans health care so them reports
00:17:13.180 that they've actually been doing this policy since July after employees expressed concern
00:17:17.620 over anti-LGBTQ plus legislation in Texas and Florida, but they're only now making this policy
00:17:22.560 public. The relocation monies are being treated as a stipend, and Indeed is also covering any taxes
00:17:27.520 on that money, which is pretty important. Indeed has already provided that support to at least one
00:17:31.860 worker, a senior content creator who moved from Texas to Colorado not long after Indeed announced
00:17:36.460 the initiative. As soon as I found out that I was getting the money, it was very much like a weight
00:17:40.360 had been lifted, the employee told Bloomberg.
00:17:42.700 FEM reports that Indeed is not alone.
00:17:44.660 This is actually a slow trend of companies offering this kind of support to staff.
00:17:48.220 Financial software company Intuit offers relocation money, and even the Air Force
00:17:52.440 announced that they would help trans service members and their families relocate if they
00:17:55.960 are stationed in states with discriminatory laws. 0.91
00:17:59.000 Obviously, as you were saying earlier, Joey, I don't like the idea of like, oh, now trans 0.94
00:18:05.700 folks can join the military industrial complex too. 1.00
00:18:09.340 But, you know, it is what it is. You got to take what you can get. And I guess I feel like, I don't know, it is a bummer that we live in a reality where this kind of policy is necessary, but that is the reality that we live in.
00:18:26.780 And even though I obviously think this is great, everybody deserves to live in a place where they can have access to whatever medical care they need. And everybody deserves to live places where policies are not hostile to their very existence. And so I am really happy that people have access to this relocation support. But it shouldn't be a luxury just for people who have like good office jobs. It should really be for everybody. That should be the bottom bare minimum that people can expect.
00:18:54.940 right i think that's the one thing that kind of concerns me about this because i remember seeing
00:19:00.180 this article that or an article about it and being it was the same thing i was like wow that's
00:19:03.920 really cool i don't know maybe i'm just like a skeptic but i was sort of like this seems
00:19:08.740 i feel like a are they going to actually do this or are they just saying they are so it's good to
00:19:13.220 hear that i guess they've they've done it at one case now but i feel like what that the people that
00:19:18.780 i'm more worried about is like like who is that who is this open to because again like if you're
00:19:24.080 working like a service job in like texas or florida um where you're not making a lot of
00:19:30.720 money you're like living paycheck to paycheck i mean you're probably going to be the one in the
00:19:33.820 most danger of living under these policies and and how they're going to affect you like is that
00:19:39.560 covered in it um which is not to say again like obviously i had my little office not office job
00:19:46.460 because i don't have an office right now like it's important that everybody gets that kind of
00:19:51.460 respect and help. But yeah, it's, I don't know. I am cautiously optimistic about this. I think
00:19:58.620 it's good to see that like a company is doing something at least. Yeah, your concern is
00:20:04.120 definitely well founded. I want to say it was Netflix. I'll have to look it up. But so when
00:20:09.180 Netflix rolled out this very generous unlimited parental leave program, they got so much good
00:20:14.240 press, lots of applause. However, they had one big problem because that program was only for
00:20:19.360 full-time staff. It did not include part-time staff. It did not include folks who were working
00:20:24.180 in their DVD distribution centers. So this was back when Netflix still had those DVDs in the
00:20:30.520 sleeves they would send out. And so, yeah, I'm with you, Joey. Whenever I see policies like this,
00:20:37.700 I hope that it's just not for like, oh, for our office workers, as people like to say on the
00:20:43.000 internet, people who have the email jobs, quote unquote, but I hope it's truly for everybody
00:20:47.920 who works there not just a certain subsection of people who get access to this i like the the email
00:20:53.920 jobs because i feel like i've been having a hard time different like who again back to the other
00:20:57.500 story like i don't work in an office i actually visited the iHeart office for the first time
00:21:02.960 uh the one in atlanta yeah no the one in there's one in new york okay i haven't invented the
00:21:08.480 atlanta one yet um but i was like that this is the first time since i was like interning that
00:21:13.780 i've been inside of an office um but yeah i it's again yeah i i good friend indeed i'm glad to hear
00:21:23.440 this i hope they follow through with it i guess you know we keep an eye on the story see what
00:21:29.140 happens yeah yeah the air force thing too i'm a little that i don't know it's whenever the military
00:21:37.720 comes up it's so complicated because there is a whole history of like there's a lot of trans people
00:21:43.540 who have been in the military or are in the military just kind of and and again like because
00:21:51.380 i remember when this all this happened with like the trump administration banning trans people from
00:21:55.700 the military there was discussion about like access to like benefits and stuff and all that's
00:22:01.860 important that being said i'm not willing to i don't know i i'm always gonna sort of take a step
00:22:11.700 back I think when it comes to military stuff it doesn't yeah I don't know I don't know where this
00:22:15.440 is going Joey Pat hates the troops no just kidding so important question for you do you drive a car
00:22:24.540 you live in New York you probably don't but do you I mean I don't I like I have my driver's
00:22:31.300 license I have driven um I like drove my family's car when I was home but yeah currently do not own
00:22:38.480 a car. Don't really have a reason to. Well, that's actually good news for you, because if you drive
00:22:44.820 a newer car, I have some bad news, which is that your car is probably spying on you. In addition
00:22:49.900 to collecting data about you, like normal car data, like whether you drive too fast or if you
00:22:55.540 wear your seatbelt or whatever, your car might actually know who you have sex with. This is
00:23:00.160 according to a new report from Mozilla. Just full quick disclosure, I do host Mozilla's podcast,
00:23:06.340 IRL about AI and ethics. I just wanted to say that. So Mozilla's Privacy Not Included project
00:23:12.100 found that every major car brand fails to adhere to the most basic privacy and security standards
00:23:17.920 in their new internet-connected models. All 25 of the car brands that Mozilla examines
00:23:23.360 failed their test. Mozilla found that major car brands collect data about their drivers,
00:23:27.980 including race, facial expressions, weight, health information, and where you drive.
00:23:32.060 Now, all of that might seem like pretty reasonable information for your car to collect about you.
00:23:38.080 But this is really wild.
00:23:39.680 Some of the cars tested collected data that you would not expect your car to be able to collect about you, including details about your sexual activity, race, and immigration status.
00:23:48.800 According to Mozilla, Kia's privacy policy reserves the right to monitor, quote, your sex life.
00:23:55.280 I don't know about you, but I don't know how I feel about my car knowing about my sex life.
00:23:59.680 Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa.
00:24:00.960 Yeah, wait.
00:24:01.600 Like, do they explain how they do this?
00:24:04.480 I mean, I'm sure you're going to get into it, but, like, are there, like, cameras in the car that areβ€”this is soβ€”that's so freaky.
00:24:09.960 That is soβ€”I have so many questions.
00:24:11.760 So that's a really good question.
00:24:12.800 According to the report, a lot of these newer cars have come enabled with, like, cameras in them, with, like, microphones in them.
00:24:21.660 They have, like, hands-free technology where you can talk to the cars, and so the cars have microphones, and they can hear conversations happening in there.
00:24:28.760 And so, yeah, I think that we don't usually think of a car as collecting information about
00:24:36.800 us as we're driving, but that's what's happening.
00:24:40.220 That's so, that's so freaky. 1.00
00:24:41.800 I just, okay, I'm always really behind on my TV show that I just watched the new Black
00:24:45.720 Mirror, like the first episode with, what's her face, Alexis from Schitt's Creek and everything.
00:24:51.080 And I, that was so freaky.
00:24:53.300 I just, I'm thinking of this because I'm like, no, there's so many things that are just,
00:24:56.920 Yeah, but that's, oh my God.
00:24:59.960 That was my favorite episode of the new season.
00:25:02.260 It was good.
00:25:02.820 I reference it quite a bit.
00:25:05.280 So Jen Calderider, Program Director of Privacy Not Included,
00:25:08.760 shares your disbelief of that this is happening.
00:25:12.500 Jen says, many people think of their car as a private space,
00:25:15.660 somewhere to call your doctor,
00:25:16.860 have a personal conversation with your kid on the way to school,
00:25:19.500 cry your eyes out after a breakup.
00:25:21.080 Oh boy, have I been there.
00:25:22.360 Or drive places that you might not want the world to know about.
00:25:25.060 but that perception no longer matches reality all new cars today are privacy nightmares on wheels
00:25:31.020 that collect huge amounts of personal information okay one thing that I do I love just like you
00:25:38.560 know every once in a while you just gotta like scream and like I'll go like if I'm have access
00:25:43.320 to a car like if my mom I've ever heard it's how it's like sometimes I'll just like sit in the car
00:25:46.620 like scream and I'm like oh my god they were now I'm like going over all the yeah well how new is
00:25:53.160 your parents car i think it's about seven years old so like 2016 2017 okay you might be okay you
00:26:00.940 might be okay if this this whole thing makes me happy i mean i i barely drive i don't i think i
00:26:07.400 probably drive like once a month but my car is a like 15 year old clunker so it makes me kind of
00:26:14.880 happy it doesn't i still have to do the thing where you plug in like a bluetooth receiver into
00:26:21.380 the aux court to like listen to music on my phone if I want to like listen to something that's not
00:26:26.600 the radio so it is very janky it is very old school doesn't have gps doesn't have anything
00:26:30.880 but as janky as it is at least I don't have to worry about my car listening to me talk to my
00:26:37.260 doctor on the phone or like have an argument with my partner I'd be like oh looks like she's
00:26:42.520 arguing about finances let's send her some ads about car refinancing or whatever I feel like
00:26:49.920 there's always you always have such emotional conversations in cars too I don't know if it's
00:26:55.120 I don't know if you do this too but like I feel like I've had a lot of very especially like as a
00:26:59.900 teenager a lot like it would be like a friend would be dropping me off or I'd be having like
00:27:04.540 a really dramatic conversation with my parents or something and it's just I don't know that's yeah
00:27:09.820 well I think you're right I do I don't even know how to put this I spent a summer living in LA and
00:27:16.580 And so when I was in L.A., I had a car and I probably had it was it was a tough summer for me.
00:27:21.720 And I probably had most of my intimate moments like where I was questioning myself or having tough conversations with friends and family in the car.
00:27:30.780 Like the car is feels like an intimate space. It feels like a private space.
00:27:34.580 How many times have you taken a long drive and done or said things that you would that you thought were just between you and, you know, just you and your God.
00:27:45.620 The idea that the car is listening, the car is collecting that information, the car is using it to serve you targeted ads, these conversations and these moments that were happening in a place that felt so private and so intimate and so sacred, it's just not a good situation.
00:28:03.900 Mozilla said that a number of car brands say that it is the driver's responsibility to let passengers know about their car's privacy policies, which, you know, because that's a totally normal conversation that you have when somebody gets in your car, when you get into a car.
00:28:18.260 It's a totally normal thing to be like, oh, let me just quickly brief you on my car's privacy policy so that you're aware of them.
00:28:24.100 That is an absurd standard to have to opt people into.
00:28:27.900 That's an absurd way to handle people having to opt into this.
00:28:31.100 Or, you know, when you get into an Uber or a taxi cab, like, how is that handled? And even beyond that, that doesn't really help because these policies are always inscrutable in the first place.
00:28:42.160 So if it is your responsibility as a driver or the owner of this car to tell people about the privacy policy that you didn't set up when somebody gets into your car, how can you do that if they're written in such a way that it's intentionally inscrutable to the point where you can't even summarize what the policies are?
00:28:59.700 like one of the car brands they talked about had 12 different privacy policies so how the hell are
00:29:04.940 you meant to be letting somebody know about your car's privacy policies if you can't even understand
00:29:09.560 them yeah it almost feels like letting somebody into your house and being like oh sorry by the
00:29:15.320 way if you like talk about x things there's like a little i don't know which i guess some people
00:29:21.100 have like alexis and stuff now so i don't who knows what that's doing but yeah man there's just
00:29:29.220 There's no privacy anymore.
00:29:31.520 It's scary.
00:29:33.440 Not even in the ride.
00:29:40.120 Let's take a quick break.
00:29:47.720 Get Bell Pure Fiber Internet with Crave, Netflix, and Disney Plus from $94 a month.
00:29:52.740 Price guaranteed for two years on internet with a two-year term and auto-pay credit.
00:29:56.800 Visit bell.ca for details and to check availability.
00:29:59.900 Bell. Connection is everything.
00:30:02.340 Run a business and not thinking about podcasting?
00:30:05.080 Think again.
00:30:06.060 More Americans listen to podcasts than ad-supported streaming music from Spotify and Pandora.
00:30:10.600 And as the number one podcaster, iHeart's twice as large as the next two combined.
00:30:14.880 So whatever your customers listen to, they'll hear your message.
00:30:17.860 Plus, only iHeart can extend your message to audiences across broadcast radio.
00:30:22.080 Think podcasting can help your business?
00:30:23.560 Think iHeart.
00:30:24.980 Streaming, radio, and podcasting.
00:30:27.080 Call 844-844-IHEART to get started.
00:30:30.220 That's 844-844-IHEART.
00:30:32.680 If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
00:30:38.600 This is Prose Society, the weekly podcast that's part book club, part group chat for thought daughters,
00:30:45.020 pop culture obsessives, and anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:30:51.060 I'm Eli Rallo, and every week we're connecting the dots between books, the internet, and the conversations everyone can't stop having.
00:30:58.180 I'm going to have to look up this story. I'm obsessed. I'm obsessed.
00:31:01.760 From best-selling authors and your favorite book talk creators to the latest pop culture moments, nothing is off the table.
00:31:07.700 It's like if you can hide some real messages inside compelling characters, then that is a Trojan horse.
00:31:15.180 Whether you're looking for literary deep dives, smart pop culture conversations, or a community of readers who love to think a little too much, you're in the right place.
00:31:24.800 Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:31:30.860 See you between the pages.
00:31:38.160 And we're back.
00:31:39.040 okay so this is a story happening in your neck of the woods joey because short-term rentals like
00:31:47.960 airbnb and verbo are basically over in new york city thanks to new regulations so last week new
00:31:54.160 rules said that rentals shorter than 30 days are not allowed unless the hosts register with the
00:31:59.720 city hosts must also commit to being physically present in the home during the duration of the
00:32:04.460 rental, sharing the living quarters with their guests. More than two guests at a time are not
00:32:09.200 allowed. So in effect, kind of barring families from doing short-term rentals like Airbnb in New
00:32:15.000 York City. So that was last week. Well, this week that went into effect and The Guardian reports
00:32:19.400 that not many hosts were able to comply with registering with the city. So Airbnb is not
00:32:24.820 allowed to process those rentals. Very few hosts had successfully registered and New York City
00:32:29.540 says that it approved just under 300 of the more 3,800 applications received. Now, housing advocates
00:32:36.440 say that the apartments were basically being used as hotels, which is a big problem in a city like
00:32:41.020 New York, where there is very much, you know, as I'm sure you know, an active housing crisis.
00:32:46.640 Oh, yeah. Airbnb does not get enough crap for like, the way that they have contributed to the 0.54
00:32:52.140 housing crisis in so many major cities, like all over the world. I like, I remember talking to 0.97
00:32:57.720 like somebody who lived in like florence and italy that it was like the same situation they
00:33:02.460 were talking about how like and that that's like a huge tourist city and and part of the reason
00:33:07.360 that it's impossible to have like an apartment there now is just airbnb has gotten so many
00:33:10.980 apartments new york same thing um does concern me a little because i do think i have a friend
00:33:16.280 who's staying in new york next week who has an airbnb so i probably should check in with her
00:33:19.780 check in on your friend yeah yeah but i i mean i am glad that's that they're they're cracking
00:33:25.420 down on that because it's out of control. I completely agree. Airbnb is fighting these
00:33:31.020 new rules in court, arguing that they are essentially a ban on Airbnb and that they
00:33:35.560 would hurt visitors looking for affordable accommodations. So I should say Airbnb,
00:33:40.480 I have a little bit of firsthand knowledge. And I'll say this, they are very good at this kind
00:33:46.860 of thing. So I honestly would not be surprised if this policy was short-lived in New York City.
00:33:52.580 I hope it's not short-lived, but I would not be surprised because Airbnb is very good at this kind of thing.
00:33:58.080 So here's a little bit about what you can probably expect.
00:34:00.840 You can expect to see them really highlighting the local people who they say are just like local community members making extra income by welcoming in travelers on a budget into their spare bedrooms.
00:34:12.640 You know, it's all like Nana and Pop Pop who just want to make their lasagna for somebody from out of town.
00:34:18.660 Like, definitely they're going to make that or try to make that the face of, like, who is being hurt by this Airbnb crackdown.
00:34:27.380 So they're not going to tell you about the company or the wealthy landlord who has bought up multiple properties that would be available housing and has turned them into hotels for people they probably will never even meet.
00:34:42.040 No, they will not tell you about that.
00:34:43.500 They will definitely be trotting out, like, Nana and Pop Pop and telling you how this is, like, hurting your, like, local community members.
00:34:51.200 Again, I can tell you from personal experience that Airbnb hires what they call community organizers to help create what I would argue is, like, an astroturfed movement specifically to represent their corporate interests, but then make that seem like a completely grassroots collection of just, like, concerned community members sticking up for their communities.
00:35:11.840 yeah and i again like even though i'm complaining about airbnb i've stayed in airbnbs a couple
00:35:18.520 times and i think honestly most especially if it's like me and my friends traveling where we're like
00:35:24.420 on a tight budget a lot of times like it's a it's a company that we're reaching out to it's not
00:35:28.920 like locals or whatever they're they're trying to like position themselves as i it is very weird
00:35:36.960 because also i remember like when airbnb was first like becoming a thing that was how they
00:35:40.660 were marketing themselves it was like it's a you know same sort of like uber where it was like
00:35:46.360 just sharing rides you're sharing living space for the you know week or whatever but it's that
00:35:53.340 yeah the whole community organizers thing too that's so vile just to especially like i don't
00:35:59.160 know if you're looking at like again if you're looking at like a job site and you see community
00:36:02.500 organizer i think you're expecting a very very different job than working for airbnb oh yes uh
00:36:09.280 I completely, completely agree.
00:36:12.220 I don't want to say anything that's, I don't want to say anything wrong.
00:36:14.780 I'll just say that I used to work for an organization that provided free or low-cost
00:36:19.180 digital training for progressive organizers, real organizers.
00:36:22.900 And we did that.
00:36:23.900 It was usually a network of volunteers, and that was done out of the desire to build social
00:36:29.460 change, to build up the left's, you know, muscle in order to create social change.
00:36:35.780 And imagine my surprise when some of those folks took that training that was given, you know, from the goodwill of our time and labor to Airbnb to do, quote, community organizing.
00:36:52.900 So, yeah, I guess I'll just leave it there.
00:36:58.320 It was a surprising turn of events.
00:37:01.200 Folks were not thrilled that that happened.
00:37:03.600 But yeah, so Airbnb is so good at this. I got to give props where props are due. If you were not a savvy person and you were looking at the people who are probably opposing this legislation in New York, you would think this is just community members who are speaking out.
00:37:23.900 But Airbnb, they're really good at that. They really know what they're doing. And yeah, I should say, like, the same as you, I don't, it's not like I don't use Airbnb, but I try to use it sparingly. And I try to just be very aware, like, it would be, it's one of those things where it would be nice if I could be like,
00:37:49.060 oh, I'm just staying with like somebody who has a spare bedroom in their house. And like,
00:37:53.240 you know, this is just like, she's getting extra money. I'm getting to eat the fresh baked cookies
00:37:57.540 that she's making me. This is all great. But that's not what it is in 2023. What it is in
00:38:01.360 2023 is like, generally somebody who is running Airbnbs as a business, it is usually not their,
00:38:07.020 their, their home that they're letting you into. It is like, maybe at best it is their vacation
00:38:12.340 home or something like that. But generally it's a business. And so I just wish that we could,
00:38:16.120 we could talk about it in reality and not in this way that it's just like a fantasy again i think
00:38:22.760 that you're right that it started that way my very first time ever staying in an airbnb this
00:38:27.700 was like when the company first got started i was staying on somebody's couch in the house that they
00:38:32.320 lived in with their family and it very much was like i'm just crashing here uh but that certainly
00:38:37.160 isn't what it's like in a meaningful way in 2023 yeah i think there was there was like one time when
00:38:44.140 i was i was in amsterdam with some friends and we were like staying at somebody's apartment that
00:38:50.560 it was like there's it actually was like a spare bedroom and they were super nice and like you know
00:38:56.440 gave us recommendations of places to go and stuff but yeah it's i don't know the last like airbnb
00:39:01.560 that i've stayed in again it was uh i'm i didn't book it a friend and i'm not sure what the situation
00:39:05.920 was but like there was an ant infestation in the house it was terrible i it was terrible experience
00:39:12.060 So I'm still mad at Airbnb about that experience anyways.
00:39:18.400 Are you one of those people who is like, oh, it's hotels all day.
00:39:21.680 I'll never stay in an Airbnb if I don't have to.
00:39:24.700 I try to.
00:39:26.340 Like, I don't do as much traveling now, just kind of at this point in my life.
00:39:32.820 But I like usually if I am, I'm going to visit people.
00:39:35.600 So I'll go like crash at their place.
00:39:37.180 But yeah, I usually like try to go for a hotel.
00:39:41.300 you know they're gonna clean you know they're gonna clean the room every day it's like nice
00:39:45.280 i like that that's the nice part about traveling and you don't like the thing that gets me about
00:39:51.160 airbnbs and this there's been a whole if folks haven't seen there's been a whole back and forth
00:39:55.540 of like airbnbs versus hotels one of the things is like with airbnbs there was a time where their
00:40:00.600 fees were just out of control where you'd be paying like a cleaning fee but also get a list
00:40:05.460 of chores to do so you'd be like why am i paying this cleaning fee if i'm doing the laundry and
00:40:09.140 like meant to be sweeping up yeah yeah exactly I was like I don't know maybe
00:40:16.000 if I'm on vacation I want to be in a hotel I don't want to be doing any of the work
00:40:22.340 totally fair okay so why don't you ask me what our favorite person is up to these days
00:40:31.740 All right. So, Bridget, oh, I know where this is going.
00:40:38.380 I bet you can already tell.
00:40:40.060 Yeah. I have a lot of thoughts on this.
00:40:42.660 Anyways, what's Elon up to now?
00:40:45.520 Well, I spent my Labor Day on vacation at the beach.
00:40:50.280 Elon Musk spent his Labor Day being very anti-Semitic.
00:40:54.160 He spent this week fighting with the head of the Anti-Defamation League
00:40:56.940 because the ADL is basically telling the truth to advertisers
00:41:00.420 about the rise of anti-Semitic hate speech on the platform since Elon Musk took over.
00:41:05.340 Musk accused the ADL of being, quote,
00:41:07.600 the biggest generators of anti-Semitism on Twitter
00:41:10.200 and threatened a $4 billion lawsuit against them
00:41:12.860 saying that they were scaring away advertisers.
00:41:15.780 So it should be said that per Twitter's own metrics, their own API,
00:41:21.000 the use of anti-Semitic hate speech has risen since Elon Musk took over.
00:41:25.760 It's just a fact.
00:41:26.940 But you don't have to have access to that data, nor do you have to be the head of the ADL to see that this is true.
00:41:33.140 All you have to do is follow Elon Musk on Twitter and see the kinds of things he tweets and the kinds of tweets that he engages with.
00:41:39.480 Elon's brand of anti-Semitism, I would say, like previously was sort of loosely coded.
00:41:44.720 He would use like George Soros or the ADL or like people who control the media, like pretty big dog whistle, as a stand in to denigrate Jewish people.
00:41:56.440 So this is not new for him at all. This has been a longstanding pattern of behavior with Musk. But I think that more recently, his anti-Semitism has gotten more overt, engaging with tweets that straight up attack Jewish people as a whole.
00:42:11.180 He replied with an exclamation point to this tweet that purported to show that, like, he replied to a tweet from a white supremacist that purported to show a poll showing that Jewish people hated free speech.
00:42:24.040 So I would argue that he is someone who has always trafficked in anti-Semitism, but it's especially concerning that it seems to be getting more and more overt and less and less coded.
00:42:35.660 yeah i mean as a jew who controls the media i'm i'm so excited at this podcast yeah obviously
00:42:46.420 it's you know oh god i'm so glad we're talking about this story i have so many 0.72
00:42:51.420 thoughts on this so like first things first i will say upright adl not necessarily a good
00:42:59.620 organization um their platform their their idea what they market themselves on which again is like
00:43:07.460 an anti-hate speech fighting anti-semitism fighting bigotry um there's a lot of criticisms
00:43:15.700 of the organization itself they've done a lot of things in the past they've designated um
00:43:21.700 certain groups as being anti-semitic that weren't anti-semitic they were more just sort of like
00:43:26.580 critical of israel or anti-zionist which is not the same thing as anti-semitism that is a very
00:43:31.780 valid political opinion um again i i'm not a fan of the adl they are i disagree with the organization 0.91
00:43:39.480 uh fundamentally on a lot of things i think they've actually done a lot of shit that's been
00:43:44.400 sort of like detrimental to a lot of anti-racist anti anti-bigotry even like anti-anti-semitism
00:43:50.880 sort of movements um that being said like the criticism is clearly like this is this is a
00:43:59.300 situation where they're going after this organization for being a jewish organization
00:44:03.520 for being a group that speaks out against anti-semitism um i recently it was it was
00:44:09.240 probably like a month or two ago the the ceo of the adl jonathan greenblatt said in an interview
00:44:14.840 he compared he said that elon musk is like the henry ford of our generation which also is really
00:44:20.440 ironic because Henry Ford was like notoriously anti-semitic so I was like I don't know like
00:44:25.880 like if somebody called somebody like the Henry Ford of something to me I would be like 0.99
00:44:30.680 okay so they're a piece of shit like I don't know anyways he meant it as a compliment so I think 0.98
00:44:36.600 this is a good example of like again so-called like human rights organizations if you're gonna 0.99
00:44:44.340 like use your time and your energy and your platform to like cheer on people who have this
00:44:51.460 history of going against other marginalized groups that aren't your own like they're gonna come after
00:44:57.260 you too like you're just setting your like I don't know like that they're not gonna save you
00:45:01.320 surprise I just this whole situation there's again it's so messed up because you know you
00:45:08.300 know that meme that's like the worst person you know made a great point I feel like it's a version
00:45:14.040 about where it's like i can't believe i'm defending the adl of all things like i but yeah it's it's
00:45:22.400 like nobody again i might disagree with some of their platform but nobody should be attacked for
00:45:30.460 just being a jewish organization and also the whole idea of like the adl contributing being
00:45:35.180 the most anti-semitic i don't that that is so weird that is so weird yeah there are like i mean
00:45:41.120 i i it's it's complicated and i appreciate the nuance that you're bringing to it elon must
00:45:46.480 saying that the adl is the most is spreading the most anti-semitism there are people on the
00:45:50.620 platform who tweet swastikas like there are people on the platform who like so that's just like not
00:45:57.160 true and it's so funny that you're saying this um the critic mark lamont hill who mark lamont hill
00:46:03.920 like he is someone who has been very open about the fact that he feels like he was like personally
00:46:08.240 attacked by the adl and he even even he was like yeah and again this is just my opinion but i'm
00:46:13.660 jewish i was you know very involved in a lot of jewish activist spaces around when that was
00:46:18.200 happening like he was attacked but yeah and yet even he this week was like elon musk what elon
00:46:25.680 musk is doing with the adl is anti-semitic and it's not like he was like i am someone who was 0.94
00:46:31.560 attacked by them and even i can say like what's happening is really fucked up and so it is it is 0.65
00:46:36.640 this very interesting moment in time I guess where and honestly the ADL when it comes to this 0.90
00:46:43.160 Elon Musk situation they didn't really have to do anything to to like get Elon Musk to go off on
00:46:49.860 this string of anti-semitic behavior and comments like I don't know if he is trying to oh is it
00:46:56.220 didn't he like compare George Soros to like Magneto or he sure did he sure did which also
00:47:03.060 i'm a big x-men fan like i love magnino like excuse you excuse you like no no no no you're
00:47:10.680 like that's a favorable comparison actually yeah like this is this has been an ongoing thing he's
00:47:16.420 said a lot of anti-smatic stuff and yeah and to be clear like i think i think we did an episode
00:47:21.700 about this it might have been on the page but regardless like it's one thing to be critical
00:47:27.760 of like like Soros is a very wealthy well-connected you know influential person in politics it's one
00:47:34.720 thing to be like oh I am critical of George Soros's policies of xyz or like his positions on xyz it's
00:47:41.580 quite another to compare him to Magneto like that is and so like if you like I think that with Musk
00:47:47.320 he's really good he previously he was like good at staying like keeping it coded keeping it a dog
00:47:56.220 whistle. And the fact that now he's like, no, it's just open. Like, it just signals to me that
00:48:01.740 there's been a shift and a change. And it really concerns me for the state of Twitter. I don't
00:48:08.140 remember, Joey, are you still on the platform? Is it a platform that you engage on? I have an
00:48:14.440 account. I don't use it a ton anymore. But like, I'm still on it. And I'm hanging on. I'm trying to
00:48:21.120 see how long till the website collapses on itself. But it's been such a shit show lately. 0.99
00:48:28.380 Like it hasn't been fun to be on the platform. So it does seem like we've hit a new moment with 0.99
00:48:33.780 Twitter where folks are just really starting to see just what you said, that it's just not fun.
00:48:40.200 It's not pleasant. Civil society groups are pushing to get advertisers to stop spending money
00:48:44.560 advertising on Twitter. I actually did a pretty personal deep dive into my own relationship with
00:48:49.880 Twitter, on Patreon, where I heard from folks who similarly are feeling a little bit weird
00:48:54.740 about our relationship with the platform in this specific moment, but who also feel it as a deep
00:49:00.180 loss. Roe, who gave me permission to share this, wrote, I keep having this conversation with myself.
00:49:06.860 I only keep it because of the community connections that will be lost if I leave,
00:49:10.360 but so many are already gone. I run a mutual aid meal delivery in my city, and one weekend,
00:49:15.240 we had extra food. While I was delivering, I pulled over and tried to reach a single mom.
00:49:19.460 I know only through Twitter to offer to drop by.
00:49:22.360 She's left the platform and I have no means to contact her now.
00:49:25.740 Twitter was so important when Ottawa was overrun by the freedom, in quotes, convoy last year.
00:49:31.280 I don't know where we could share information at the same scale now.
00:49:34.560 So the too long didn't read is that I stay on Twitter out of fear
00:49:37.280 and I'm incredibly resentful that an awful man broke a critical resource for my community.
00:49:43.200 And boy, Ro, did I identify with that.
00:49:46.600 That is exactly how I am feeling.
00:49:48.760 I'm really wrestling with a lot of that same stuff of like this used to be a resource that
00:49:54.760 was good it wasn't perfect it had its problems if folks want to I will talk all day about some of
00:49:59.820 the issues I had with pre-Musk Twitter but something about this week just I was like this
00:50:04.940 is just not fun it's not pleasant I don't enjoy showing up here the example that I gave on the
00:50:10.540 Patreon was I was having a conversation with somebody about um Bravo's Real Housewives of
00:50:16.040 Atlanta. And I don't know if you watch the show, but like this season hasn't been great. And
00:50:20.720 somebody was like, oh, who would be a great, if you were doing a cast, a casting, who would you
00:50:24.920 cast? And somebody was like, T Madison, who is this black trans woman, like blogger and content
00:50:30.440 creator. I was like, oh my God, T Madison would be amazing. Why didn't that occur to me? Like,
00:50:33.900 she's so funny. She's so good at like clapping back, blah, blah, blah. Love T Madison. And it
00:50:38.440 didn't take long until people with blue check marks were intentionally misgendering T Madison,
00:50:45.000 calling, like, deadnaming T. Madison, and this was just, like, a fun conversation about a
00:50:52.060 television show, and it's, like, that's, it's not pleasant to show up to a platform and try to have
00:50:58.120 a, like, fun, light conversation, and then next thing you know, you're, like, someone is intentionally
00:51:04.800 deadnaming and misgendering somebody. It's no longer against Twitter's terms of service to do
00:51:10.160 that, because that was one of the things that Elon Musk, one of the policies that he changed
00:51:14.160 but the first thing that he did and you know the whole conversation turned into people being like 0.96
00:51:20.520 this is fucked up don't do this and then people being like saying transphobic things and it's like 0.99
00:51:25.560 we can't even have a conversation about bravo housewives without this nonsense it is just not 0.99
00:51:30.940 good it doesn't feel good it doesn't feel fun and i don't feel good knowing that i am supporting
00:51:36.120 elon musk and helping to make the platform look like it's still viable by showing up there yeah
00:51:42.440 I I agree with that and I I feel like especially what what Ro had said just feeling resentful
00:51:48.800 that again feeling resentful that this man like broke Twitter and sort of almost feeling like
00:51:54.940 like I feel like at this point I'm kind of staying on out of spite like I'm sort of like no like
00:51:59.760 you can't scare me away like nope we're staying here but yeah it's I it then it's but then yeah
00:52:05.640 the other side he's like it's it's not usable anymore I not seeing my friends posts I'm yeah
00:52:11.140 seeing a lot of just blue checkmark stuff um i also yeah like twitter was especially during like
00:52:18.100 the height of the pandemic when stuff was on lockdown like that was how i was staying connected
00:52:21.900 to people um i was still in college at the beginning of the pandemic and and like we were
00:52:28.000 using twitter to like get mutual aid to people and help people like get information that like
00:52:33.480 the school was not telling us get information that's how i was able to get like my vaccination
00:52:37.800 appointment when that was first happening.
00:52:39.620 I was crazy trying to get like my vaccine in New York.
00:52:43.800 It's such a it has become such an important tool.
00:52:47.480 And it's just it's so sad to like see this happening.
00:52:51.160 It is sad.
00:52:52.320 I should mention while all of this was going down, Twitter's CEO, maybe CEO, Linda
00:52:59.020 Yaccarino, while Elon Musk was like engaging with anti-Semitism and all of that, she was
00:53:05.000 busy tweeting.
00:53:05.880 Did somebody say sports?
00:53:07.800 After a huge Labor Day weekend, X video views continue to surge above last year.
00:53:13.600 So while Linda Yaccarino, as supposedly the CEO of Twitter, was saying all of this stuff about how Twitter is now advertiser friendly, brand friendly, blah, blah, blah.
00:53:23.380 My question for Linda Iaccarino is, how does Elon Musk tweeting all of this anti-Semitic nonsense square with her publicly stated intention to make Twitter a place where brands want to show up and want to spend money in advertising?
00:53:38.780 I'm curious, like, if I were the CEO of a company and my head of engineering was tweeting like this, I might have something to say about it, but not Linda.
00:53:49.680 I'm so curious what's going on there.
00:53:51.200 so yeah if if folks want to know my thoughts on the should i stay or should i go of it all
00:53:58.480 please check out our patreon and i also would love to hear where folks are at with twitter
00:54:02.760 like are you still there have you left are you what are the vibes like for you let me know i
00:54:07.840 would love to know more after a quick break
00:54:21.200 Get Bell Pure Fiber Internet with Crave, Netflix, and Disney Plus from $94 a month.
00:54:26.680 Price guaranteed for two years on Internet with a two-year term and auto pay credit.
00:54:30.940 Visit bell.ca for details and to check availability.
00:54:33.700 Bell. Connection is everything.
00:54:36.140 Run a business and not thinking about podcasting? Think again.
00:54:39.900 More Americans listen to podcasts than ad-supported streaming music from Spotify and Pandora.
00:54:44.320 And as the number one podcaster, iHeart's twice as large as the next two combined.
00:54:48.660 So whatever your customers listen to, they'll hear your message.
00:54:52.020 Plus, only iHeart can extend your message to audiences across broadcast radio.
00:54:56.340 Think podcasting can help your business?
00:54:58.280 Think iHeart.
00:54:59.320 Streaming, radio, and podcasting.
00:55:01.500 Let us show you at iHeartAdvertising.com.
00:55:04.080 That's iHeartAdvertising.com.
00:55:06.440 If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
00:55:12.380 This is Prose Society, the weekly podcast that's part book club,
00:55:16.760 part group chat for thought daughters, pop culture obsessives,
00:55:20.160 and anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:55:24.860 I'm Eli Rallo, and every week we're connecting the dots between books,
00:55:28.540 the internet, and the conversations everyone can't stop having.
00:55:31.800 I'm going to have to look up this story. I'm obsessed, so obsessed.
00:55:35.540 From best-selling authors and your favorite book talk creators to the latest pop culture moments,
00:55:40.400 nothing is off the table.
00:55:41.500 It's like if you can hide some real messages inside compelling characters, then that is a Trojan horse.
00:55:49.380 Whether you're looking for literary deep dives, smart pop culture conversations, or a community of readers who love to think a little too much, you're in the right place.
00:55:58.560 Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:56:04.600 See you between the pages.
00:56:11.500 So let's get right back into it.
00:56:14.820 Okay, so this last story is really just like a story tailor-made for me.
00:56:20.100 So hopefully it is interesting to others as well, because I was like very invested.
00:56:24.300 And that is that something is rotten over at Rotten Tomatoes.
00:56:28.180 So Rotten Tomatoes is a movie criticism aggregate platform.
00:56:32.540 They have a thing called the Tomatometer, which aggregates critics' reviews of movies and gives a percentage score.
00:56:38.640 The tomato meter may be the most important metric in entertainment, yet it is also erratic, reductive, and easily hacked.
00:56:45.900 This is from a very interesting report on Vulture.
00:56:49.100 So Vulture reports that back in 2018, a movie called Ophelia, which was meant to be kind of a feminist retelling of Hamlet starring Daisy Ridley, was getting not super great reviews from critics.
00:57:00.500 meaning that its aggregate score on Rotten Tomatoes was a dismal 46%,
00:57:05.140 which is not good, especially for a prestige film
00:57:08.120 they were trying to sort of like find a studio home for
00:57:11.140 and kind of thought maybe might have some award season buzz.
00:57:15.040 The film was rotten on Rotten Tomatoes,
00:57:17.860 which means that it scored below 60%.
00:57:19.940 Bunker 15, a movie publicity firm,
00:57:23.040 recruited a bunch of smaller, obscure, often self-published critics
00:57:26.780 who are nevertheless part of the pool tracked by Rotten Tomatoes.
00:57:30.500 Bunker 15 paid these critics $50 or more to write reviews.
00:57:35.360 These payments are typically not disclosed,
00:57:37.620 and Rotten Tomatoes says that it prohibits reviewing based on a financial incentive.
00:57:41.280 So Bunker 15 told Vulture a lot of stuff.
00:57:44.520 Like, I would read the article if you want the whole thing,
00:57:46.780 but essentially what Bunker 15 told Vulture was pretty much an obvious code for
00:57:51.220 we don't tell them to write good reviews,
00:57:55.200 but we pay them to write reviews so that we can raise the Rotten Tomatoes score,
00:57:59.840 and it's really nice that those reviews are good reviews so like essentially we pay them they write
00:58:05.320 good reviews if they didn't like the film they don't write a review and that's how we're able
00:58:09.140 to get the Rotten Tomatoes score up I'm not surprised by this I feel like there's been so
00:58:14.080 many weird especially like you know we've talked about review bombing on the show and that's become 0.96
00:58:18.440 such a prevalent thing whenever you know there's a movie about anybody that's not a straight white
00:58:24.240 man and uh like Rotten Tomatoes maybe there's like a theme with this I feel like it was the
00:58:30.460 same thing where with Airbnb where it was like kind of cool when it first like was a thing and
00:58:34.420 it was like you know the people's kind of method of reviewing movies and it was like but but then
00:58:40.580 it's so quickly like now I don't even look at it I don't like I see especially like like I'll like
00:58:45.420 if whenever the for a movie I want to see like the Rotten Tomatoes stuff will come out but like
00:58:49.440 and I'll like I'll look at it but it's not like like I always take it with a grain of salt now
00:58:52.600 because i don't know there have been some movies that were rated great that i did not enjoy and
00:58:58.560 there were other movies and the opposite happened like i didn't get a good review and i thought it
00:59:01.740 was fun and it just maybe wasn't you know not for everybody but it's still fun so it's so
00:59:08.440 interesting to hear you say this i might be like a little pollyanna-ish like this vulture piece
00:59:14.740 blew like blew the lid right off this thing for me because i probably spend more time browsing
00:59:21.860 Rotten Tomatoes than any other site.
00:59:24.920 I'm a movie person.
00:59:26.060 I love film.
00:59:27.120 I love cinema.
00:59:27.820 It is my first love.
00:59:29.180 And I guess it should have occurred to me that Rotten Tomatoes could be hacked, could
00:59:33.460 be bought, could be bombed, could be artificially inflated or deflated.
00:59:39.220 It just, I don't know.
00:59:41.240 I think I'm usually pretty skeptical about tech, but I wonder if I let my pure love of
00:59:46.800 movies blind me to the truth that was right in front of my face.
00:59:51.860 Nah, I mean, I get that. I also, like, I'm a big fan of, like, I love movies. I'm a big movie person. But I feel like my opinion, too, my view is always, I think, ultimately, like, it's subjective. Everybody's got their own interests and opinions and stuff. And I think, you know, it is hard to, like, universally. I don't know. But yeah, I think it's just seeing all these incidences of review bombing. I'm not surprised.
01:00:20.460 But the thing that does surprise me is the fact that it's like,
01:00:22.960 because I feel like there's usually the official tomato meat
01:00:25.020 and then there's the fan one.
01:00:26.380 And yeah, it's interesting.
01:00:29.380 So this article is saying that it's affecting the official tomato meat area?
01:00:32.880 Yeah, so that's a great question.
01:00:34.120 So basically, the official critic... 0.91
01:00:36.680 So for folks who don't spend all their time on fucking Rotten Tomatoes like I do, 0.64
01:00:40.740 it has two different tracks. 0.78
01:00:43.320 There is the audience score and the critic score.
01:00:46.540 And the critic score is the one that really matters.
01:00:48.340 And so to answer your question, Joey, yes, the critic score can be gamified.
01:00:53.580 Here's how it works.
01:00:54.780 The scores can sort of be hacked by studios.
01:00:58.260 When a studio is prepping the release of a new title, it will screen the film for critics in advance.
01:01:03.140 It's a film publicist's job to organize these screenings and invite the writers they think will respond most positively.
01:01:08.840 Then that publicist will set the movie's review embargo in part so that its initial tomato meter score is as high as possible at the moment when it can have the maximal benefits for word of mouth and early ticket sales.
01:01:20.960 They really rely on fan sites.
01:01:23.560 So even though like traditional critics are probably less likely to write a glowing review for like a superhero movie, studios can generally count on somebody who is a big fan of that franchise to write a positive review.
01:01:36.220 And even if they write that positive review on, like, a self-published fan site or, like, a Medium page, that can sometimes still count toward the Rotten Tomatoes aggregate critics review.
01:01:46.560 So it doesn't seem like it's really that hard to gamify those critics' scores.
01:01:51.740 And it really, like, people listening might be like, why are you telling me this? Why does this matter?
01:01:56.040 Well, it matters because Rotten Tomatoes is actually kind of a big deal.
01:01:59.780 It can really make or break a film's release.
01:02:02.160 If you watched one of my favorite shows on HBO Max, The Other Two, there's a whole plot line about how powerful Rotten Tomatoes is on shaping how a film is perceived.
01:02:11.300 Studios are so scared about Rotten Tomatoes' tomato meter score that they actually work with a company called Screen Engine ASI, which attempts to forecast scores.
01:02:21.540 One publicist spoke to Vulture and said,
01:02:23.120 I put in our original business plan that we should not do films that score less than 80.
01:02:27.880 Rotten Tomatoes is the only public stamp of approval that says this is out of immense
01:02:31.780 quality and all critics agree.
01:02:34.360 But like, not necessarily.
01:02:36.040 And so if studios and publicists are using this as a stamp of approval, but it's also
01:02:41.520 easily hacked and easily gamified, it seems like a little bit of a scam.
01:02:46.840 Anyway, the whole piece is definitely worth a read.
01:02:49.380 i thought that not focusing on films that score less than an 80 i feel like that's so concerning
01:02:55.120 because people i think because the film industry is it's like an industry and it is this very like
01:03:00.020 hyper capitalized like it is still like art it is still art that's very accessible to people
01:03:05.460 too and that's the reason like film has such an important place and like i don't know i i have a
01:03:12.140 lot of feelings about the film industry but i i feel like yeah like there's plenty of movies that
01:03:16.360 like i love that have like 70s or like even yeah even in like the 50s or 60s all the like cult
01:03:22.480 classic films that like like if studios are only focusing on movies that score over 80
01:03:30.680 we're not gonna get so much of like the culture around film or the culture that that the film
01:03:38.600 industry produces yeah the thing i think it's the same thing with like all the netflix stuff
01:03:43.440 with all these like tv shows that are getting canceled um there's been a lot of things you know
01:03:49.940 like we're in the middle of the writer's strike for a reason there's like all these movies that
01:03:54.160 are getting shelved there's like tv shows that are getting canceled after one season because it
01:03:58.340 it's film is an art form and it's like these companies are trying to take that aspect away
01:04:05.520 and the creative aspect away and that's just like concerning overall i i mean i'm almost like
01:04:12.400 tearing up here when you talk about this because it film is something that i take very seriously
01:04:16.960 art and culture and film it's like the thing that saved me and it's really important and it feels
01:04:22.960 like we're losing it this is a little bit of a longer read but i want to read this quote that
01:04:27.440 richard linklater one of my favorite directors uh said so he was asked in an interview about
01:04:31.380 what what he thinks about the current state of american movie making and he said it's a little
01:04:36.620 bit long so bear with me he said it feels like it's gone with the wind or gone with the algorithm
01:04:42.440 Sometimes I'll talk with some of my contemporaries who I came up with during the 90s and we'll go, oh, my God, we could never get that done today.
01:04:49.420 So on the one hand, selfishly, you think, I guess I was born at the right time.
01:04:52.700 I was able to participate in what always feels like the last good era for filmmaking.
01:04:57.240 And then you hope for a better day.
01:04:58.980 But man, the way distribution has fallen off, sadly, it's mostly just the audience.
01:05:03.440 Is there a new generation that really values cinema anymore?
01:05:06.260 That's the dark thought.
01:05:07.800 I have a film society, and I run into so many young, cinema-loving kids who actually have the Criterion channel, and they watch all kinds of amazing movies, but I know that culturally, that's the exception.
01:05:17.460 I fear that there's not enough of a critical mass in the culture to sustain what was, but who knows?
01:05:22.400 I don't think I have any deeper analysis than anyone else would, and it's not in my nature to make huge statements about whether it's all over.
01:05:28.940 I just feel we're all treading water and hoping we don't drown. Challenging times are certainly here.
01:05:33.980 With a changing culture and a changing technology,
01:05:36.280 it's hard to see cinema slipping back into the prominence it once held.
01:05:39.600 I think we could feel it coming when they started calling films content.
01:05:42.900 But that's what happens when you let tech people take over your industry.
01:05:45.960 It's hard to imagine indie cinema in particular having the cultural relevance that it did.
01:05:49.900 It's hard to imagine the whole culture is going to be on the same page about anything,
01:05:53.260 much less filmmaking.
01:05:54.500 We can be so self-absorbed and say it's just about cinema,
01:05:57.140 but it's really all of our modern cultural life.
01:06:00.220 You could say the same things about reading books.
01:06:01.860 A lot of young people can't really read a book because they're just on their phones.
01:06:05.240 Some really intelligent, passionate, good citizens just don't have the same need for
01:06:09.000 literature and movies anymore.
01:06:10.620 It doesn't occupy the same space in the brain.
01:06:12.920 I think that's just how we've given over our lives, largely, to this thing that depletes
01:06:16.860 the need for curating and filling ourselves up with meaning from art and fictional worlds.
01:06:21.460 That need has been filled up with, let's face it, advanced delivery system for advertising.
01:06:25.780 It's sad, but what can you do?
01:06:27.380 I also don't want to go through life thinking our best days are behind us.
01:06:30.420 That's just not productive.
01:06:31.240 So in your own area, you just have to persist and do what you can on behalf of the things that you believe in. You have to believe that everything can change and things can go back to being a little bit better. Isn't that what we all want for everything these days, from democracy on down? Can't we just go back to things being a little better?
01:06:46.660 And boy, did that answer really punch me in the gut because I feel like that's where we're at, where these things that were just purely good, movies are good, culture is good, art is good, music is good.
01:07:03.720 we are losing that and we're losing the kind of collective cultural understanding that those
01:07:13.460 things have value and that they're not just content to fill streamers and content to put
01:07:18.980 advertising on that they that they are inherently valued they're what make us us right like when
01:07:24.820 all of us are dead that's those are the things that people are gonna watch and read and listen
01:07:29.960 to and consume to understand what we were in 2023 and it's really sad to me the idea that
01:07:37.860 as a culture collectively we might not hold that as a value that long that cultural longevity we
01:07:44.240 might be losing that it really it really it hurts yeah i think i feel like the same way i think it
01:07:52.080 is really concerning to see what's happening the one thing i do kind of disagree with with that
01:07:57.400 quote i think the kind of lens of like oh people just don't want these kind of movies don't want
01:08:03.020 these kind of like indie really like more artistic movies anymore i think that's that i'm a little
01:08:10.300 bit more cautious of i don't think it's necessarily that people don't want it i think so much of it
01:08:14.620 just has to do with the fact that like the way that the film industry has acted in the past like
01:08:20.020 decade it has kind of given people like the the it's become so much more centralized um there's
01:08:29.040 been so much more emphasis on like you know a lot of like special effects and cgi and stuff that
01:08:35.280 isn't even particularly good coming from a lot of these studios but like and i mean i think this
01:08:40.860 whole idea of like these film franchises has become such a bigger thing culturally um but a
01:08:45.380 lot of that is because that is what these production companies have like sort of engineered
01:08:50.340 the film industry to look like to look like and again like I brought up the writer's strike
01:08:54.620 earlier it's the fact that the the power the monetary power is so centralized right now and
01:09:01.120 the people that are the ones making this art aren't getting compensated aren't able to live
01:09:07.000 their lives yeah I think it's just the the one thing that I think kind of gives me hope in this
01:09:13.100 sort of situation is the fact that i i think we are reaching a point where like all these superhero
01:09:18.360 movies keep flopping because people have gotten really sick of it because again like i love
01:09:22.620 superhero movies i think they're fun they're always gonna be a thing in american culture but
01:09:26.300 like we're all kind of sick of the of the like avengers thing like they kind of did their big
01:09:31.340 thing and it's like we're ready for the next thing i feel like lately there's been like a
01:09:35.620 couple more that have sort of like i remember okay everything everywhere all at once when that came
01:09:39.820 now because I had a I loved that movie so much I know lots of people love that movie and I remember
01:09:45.080 talking to a friend about it and they were just like I felt so like like it felt new it was the
01:09:50.560 first thing that I watched in a while that felt like new and original and I feel like I'm seeing
01:09:55.060 a little bit more of that and like I don't know I saw like bottoms last weekend oh my god how was
01:10:02.360 it wait I'm seeing it I'm seeing it tomorrow is it good it's so good okay okay okay I'm so excited
01:10:07.800 that is like one of my new favorite movies again solidarity with the writers trying
01:10:12.420 solidarity with the actors like I know they're not doing promotion right now so I don't want to
01:10:16.240 be like but but it's an amazing movie I totally recommend people go see it but even like with
01:10:23.060 that I remember seeing a tweet from somebody about it where they were like here's the budget
01:10:26.380 and here's what it made and it's opening weekend and it was less than the budget but I was like
01:10:29.860 okay but that's just opening weekend like and also it opened to only a couple theaters this
01:10:34.640 isn't like a marvel movie where they're trying like there was that whole thing for a while where
01:10:38.660 like disney kept trying to like one up it's like most money made for a movie and there was like a
01:10:44.240 whole thing it was between like the avengers and like avatar for a while and like i don't care like
01:10:49.860 it was one of those things i was sort of like they paid billions of dollars why are they still
01:10:54.120 trying to make more money just to be just for like a pr stunt um so i think again i think the
01:11:00.720 issue is less like people don't want this stuff i think people do i think people always will
01:11:05.960 yes there's the argument that like with you know tiktok and twitch streamers there's all this much
01:11:10.880 more like packaged targeted content out there again like the whole using the word content versus
01:11:17.600 film um which i i agree with that i think calling it content feels a little weird but um yeah but
01:11:24.760 but at the same time i think you know people like art people want art that's like a part of humanity
01:11:30.520 that has existed forever and yeah again I am hopeful I do think like the fact that like 824
01:11:36.780 has kind of taken off in its popularity like as much as I don't like film Twitter as a whole I
01:11:44.200 think the fact that like film Twitter and Letterboxd and all these things are sort of like
01:11:47.660 becoming a bigger thing I think it just shows that like there's still people interested in this
01:11:51.540 there's still people that want to see this it's just the industry's fucked like honestly it's yeah
01:11:57.400 i i'm hoping for the best but yeah we'll see what happens oh my gosh i love everything that 0.57
01:12:06.520 you just said first of all i i think i i'm i'm like an a24 stan i'm probably i'm probably the
01:12:14.220 person on film twitter that you're like god you're so annoying i'm into like i'm worse
01:12:19.300 it is the thing where i'm like i'm part of the problem and i yes
01:12:23.880 yeah i'm the problem it's me yeah exactly but this is so hopeful this is such a hopeful
01:12:33.120 note to end on like support the writer's strike as much as i like as much harm as these like 0.95
01:12:40.360 billionaire streamer hollywood ceo bastards have given us the fact that they robbed us of a bottoms
01:12:48.300 press tour i will never forgive them but they're like a couple of videos i did before the before 0.95
01:12:53.760 the strike were just like beautiful but yeah again and i i go see bottoms the way to support
01:12:59.820 the strike is to show these executives that people want these movies that people want this
01:13:04.160 creativity go see bottoms fantastic film that is a great place to end you have your assignment for
01:13:10.480 the weekend folks go see bottoms joey thank you so much for being here i really appreciate it
01:13:15.000 of course and thanks so much to all of you for listening we will talk to you very soon
01:13:23.760 if you're looking for ways to support the show
01:13:27.820 check out our merch store at tangody.com
01:13:30.260 slash store
01:13:31.000 got a story about an interesting thing in tech
01:13:34.000 or just want to say hi
01:13:35.000 you can reach us at hello at tangody.com
01:13:37.420 you can also find transcripts for today's episode at tangody.com 1.00
01:13:40.580 There Are No Girls on the Internet
01:13:42.080 was created by me, Bridget Todd
01:13:43.460 it's a production of iHeartRadio and Unbossed Creative
01:13:45.960 edited by Joey Pat
01:13:47.660 Jonathan Strickland is our executive producer
01:13:50.140 Tari Harrison is our producer and sound engineer
01:13:53.200 Michael Amato is our contributing producer.
01:13:55.240 I'm your host, Bridget Todd.
01:13:56.700 If you want to help us grow, rate and review us on Apple Podcasts.
01:14:00.040 For more podcasts from iHeartRadio, check out the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:14:11.120 If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
01:14:16.800 Pro Society is a weekly podcast that's part book club, part group chat for anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
01:14:25.460 Each week, we're connecting the dots between books, the internet, and pop culture with your favorite writers, book talk creators, and plenty of overthought opinions.
01:14:33.700 Yeah, I'm obsessed. I'm obsessed.
01:14:35.480 Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:14:40.860 I survived nine months in captivity, and I've spent my life exploring how other people survive
01:14:48.180 what should have destroyed them. I'm Elizabeth Smart, and these are The Survivor Files.
01:14:53.760 Every week, I'm with survivors who live through the unthinkable, abducted, stalked, controlled,
01:14:59.580 and nearly silenced. These are stories about what it takes to make it out alive.
01:15:04.780 Listen to The Survivor Files with Elizabeth Smart on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:15:13.100 New school year, same beautiful mess. 0.99
01:15:16.440 Good Mom's Bad Choices is back to talk back-to-school realness. 1.00
01:15:20.820 The guilt, the giggles, and the choices no other show is brave enough to admit. 0.97
01:15:25.460 Mom life is calling and I have my last motherfucking volleyball tournament of Irie's Club Team Volleyball. 0.97
01:15:31.900 and I can't wait for this to be over 0.98
01:15:35.280 because I don't like participating
01:15:39.500 and having to drive far distances.
01:15:41.740 Shout out to the moms and my mom who made it happen. 1.00
01:15:44.940 Listen to Good Moms Bad Choices
01:15:46.200 from the Black Effect Podcast Network
01:15:47.780 on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts,
01:15:50.320 or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:15:52.440 This is an iHeart Podcast.
01:15:54.920 Guaranteed human.