00:00:38.460and I've spent my life exploring how other people survive what should have destroyed them.
00:00:43.680I'm Elizabeth Smart, and these are The Survivor Files.
00:00:47.300Every week, I'm with survivors who live through the unthinkable,
00:00:51.020abducted, stalked, controlled, and nearly silenced.
00:00:54.640These are stories about what it takes to make it out alive.
00:00:58.680Listen to The Survivor Files with Elizabeth Smart on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:01:06.800Amazon is the largest online retailer in the entire world.
00:01:10.880So Amazon's business decisions really matter because they can set the tone for the entire retail space.
00:01:16.060And this week, Amazon announced they were building out their own super cheap fast fashion retail site where items will ship directly from China to the United States to compete with the suspiciously low cost Chinese online retail giant Xi'an.
00:01:31.360Now, Xi'an is a huge and not to mention not super ethical player in the retail space.
00:01:37.140After a disastrous Shein influencer brand trip, I spoke to Aja Barber, author of Consumed, Colonialism, Climate Change, and Consumerism, about the cycle of fast fashion, Shein, and how it's doing real harm to all of us.
00:01:54.380All of a sudden, everyone's an expert because a brand has flown you first class to tour their facilities.
00:03:46.360And there's another thread to this web too, influencers.
00:03:49.840The people who go on social media and chill for brands online for profit.
00:03:55.280So, given all this, all of this harm, can influencers, many of whom talk a big game about causes like supporting women or championing the environment,
00:04:04.440can they ethically hype up fast fashion retailers?
00:04:08.380Last week, after a disastrous Shein brand trip, the internet answered with a resounding and loud, no.
00:05:26.300I was kind of a bit like, but how do they get these prices so low?
00:05:31.220Like just constantly asking myself that, even though like there were times where I couldn't afford anything different.
00:05:38.320but I still had to ask the question, especially as a curious person and as someone who likes to
00:05:45.880do crafts and knit and sew. But the other part of it was I found that people really did not like
00:05:54.200having this conversation. Consumerism, it has its claws in us. And I noticed in some spaces that you
00:06:01.840and I were in together like people could be as lefty and right on and righteous about every topic
00:06:10.300under the sun but if I were like hey guys I think maybe we shouldn't be shopping at forever 21
00:06:17.180because I think they're exploiting people it would be like you you know fart it in the pool everyone
00:06:24.640would start like throwing like tomatoes at you and get really mad and be super defensive and I was
00:06:31.640like, oh, okay, consumerism has us in like a death grip. And so I started to just notice that
00:06:40.600there was a lot of inconsistency within people's behavior in this conversation. Like,
00:06:47.260yeah, support all women, super feminist, right on women, but also like, let's not buy sweatshop0.95
00:06:53.880clothing, boo. And so I kind of just was always in spaces where I would sort of like test the
00:07:00.940waters for the conversation. And I kind of feel like I've been talking about this for like 10
00:07:07.560years now. I've been thinking about it for 10 years now. And it's kind of like jumping into
00:07:12.440a jump rope, like a double Dutch jump rope. Like you're going like this, you're waiting for the
00:07:16.900moment. So you test the water and you're like, nope, they're not ready. And then there just
00:07:20.820became a moment where it was like, okay, I think people are ready to have this conversation now.
00:07:25.600And I don't know if it's a mixture of us realizing that, like, climate change is coming for us all and, like, these systems are aiding in it and no one's going to be safe, or whether it was people actually starting to realize that, like, these systems aren't good for us.
00:07:43.240All they're doing is creating billionaires and oppression.
00:07:46.060But it finally feels like folks have come around.
00:07:50.280From following you and other folks who create content about sustainability, people do have these very strong, sometimes pretty weird defensive reactions when you talk about what you talk about.
00:08:04.860Like I've seen people say like, oh, this is really classist because some people can only afford to shop fast fashion or this is really fat phobic because maybe this brand is the only size this person can find to fit them.
00:08:18.040Why do you think that is? And how do we how do you have these conversations in a way where folks can actually hear and like take in what you're saying without jumping to that defensive point?
00:08:28.840um i just feel like i have been repeating the same thing for a hundred years no i'm just kidding
00:08:39.080it is just really saying like the same thing and one of the first things i realized that people
00:08:45.340were deeply hypocritical about is we're having a conversation about poverty but like folks do not
00:08:52.080want to include the garment workers and the people that make the clothing in that conversation0.94
00:08:56.160that is deeply hypocritical. And that is tied to a weird colonialist idea that we think that if
00:09:04.840somebody lives over there, they should be okay with being poor. That's because you also hear it
00:09:11.020when people say things like, well, that's a good job in that country. And I always sort of push
00:09:16.200back a little and go, okay, well, do you want to do that job? And they're like, no. And then I'm
00:09:22.180like okay why not and they're like well well well and then they start getting backed into a corner
00:09:28.140and super defensive but what i want people to do is like recognize that like they're playing a part
00:09:35.240in these colonialist ideas as we're all talking about like decolonize this and that you know what
00:09:40.780i mean like um there was a time period where everybody was sort of talking about colonialism
00:09:46.400and how it shows up today but the mere idea that you think someone in the global south
00:09:51.220wouldn't want to make the same nice wages we do for the same sort of work that we used to do in
00:09:56.820our country, that's a colonialist idea. The idea that you think that someone should be
00:10:01.760grateful for a crappy job in an unsafe factory with bad wages, that's a colonialist idea.
00:10:09.420And then at the end of this system, because it is a linear system, production, usage,
00:10:17.760end of life, we also have a colonialist idea that somebody in the global South wants our scraps
00:10:24.180because a lot of the clothing that we buy today isn't the same quality that it was 20 years ago
00:10:30.700because that's how you push billions of garments on your consumers by like really making sure that
00:10:37.600the quality is not great. So people are constantly buying, but also people are buying for a lot more
00:10:43.680reasons than that. But we buy 20 times more clothing than we bought in 1990. And that means
00:10:53.080that there's a lot more waste and a lot more stuff being donated. And because we're buying
00:10:59.220such large quantities of clothes, a lot of what is being donated ends up in the global South,
00:11:06.200usually in parts of Africa being someone else's problem. So for instance, within the book
00:11:14.320Consumed, I write about Cantamante Market in Accra, Ghana, and they receive 15 million items
00:11:20.840of clothing every week from the global north. Now, obviously, this market is not going to be
00:11:28.000able to resell 15 million items, which means 60% of what arrives in Ghana is waste. And when it1.00
00:11:35.960becomes waste it ends up everywhere it's not supposed to be so the municipal dump has filled
00:11:42.840up 10 years ahead of schedule uh the dump catches on fire because of all the clothing waste which
00:11:49.780also like a lot of that stuff we're putting on our body and you should see how it's not decomposing
00:11:56.320you know um it ends up on the beach the beach there is incredibly polluted from the clothing
00:12:03.040waste, it ends up in neighborhoods. And so what we've created is a system of waste colonialism,
00:12:09.500but we have tricked ourselves into saying that like, oh, somebody in Africa is really going to0.51
00:12:15.600be really happy with this t-shirt with the twisted seam that I don't want to wear anymore because I1.00
00:12:21.700know it's not good, but they're poor so they can have it. You know what I mean? So like from start
00:12:27.180to finish, this system completely craps on non-white people. Your clothing is either is made1.00
00:12:35.620by a non-white person in the global South, usually, and someone who's impoverished. And then at the0.96
00:12:42.640end of its life, we just dump it right back in the global South on someone else. And that is why it0.94
00:12:47.480is a racist system. And that is why when people say like, oh, it's, it's classist that you should
00:12:53.960criticize this. I think they're just sort of dodging an actual conversation where we should
00:13:00.200talk about what our place is in this. Now, there will always be people who can't make different
00:13:07.960decisions, right? Like the Shein trousers are the ones that they need for work, and those are the
00:13:13.340trousers they need for work. Fine. That's not the vast majority of us. And when you look at
00:13:19.420the profit margins that fast fashion is pulling in, if all the poor people on the planet put all
00:13:28.820of their money together, they couldn't create these profit margins. These massive inflated
00:13:35.120billion dollar profit margins that the fast fashion industry is pulling in annually is created with
00:13:42.620money from customers who are over-consuming and buying often. And the people that can do that
00:13:49.600are middle and upper class people. So let's talk about that because, I mean, by now you probably
00:13:57.060are sick of thinking about it, talking about it, being asked about it. I will never get sick of
00:14:01.660asking about it, talking about it until we stick it to these corporations. I just want to get them.
00:14:08.460So, like, no, I'm not tired of it. I will talk about it until the cows come home because I want these billionaires to pay for what they've done.
00:14:16.800Don't worry. Aja and I talk all about that disastrous Shein brand trip after a quick break.
00:14:38.460check availability bell connection is everything run a business and not thinking about podcasting
00:14:44.420think again more americans listen to podcasts than ad-supported streaming music from spotify
00:14:49.580and pandora and as the number one podcaster iheart's twice as large as the next two combined
00:14:54.500so whatever your customers listen to they'll hear your message plus only iheart can extend
00:14:59.320your message to audiences across broadcast radio think podcasting can help your business
00:15:03.720Think iHeart. Streaming, radio, and podcasting. Let us show you at iHeartAdvertising.com.
00:15:12.280If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
00:15:18.200This is Prose Society, the weekly podcast that's part book club, part group chat for thought daughters,
00:15:24.620pop culture obsessives, and anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:15:30.680I'm Eli Rallo, and every week we're connecting the dots between books, the internet, and the conversations everyone can't stop having.
00:15:37.780I'm going to have to look up this story. I'm obsessed. I'm obsessed.
00:15:41.360From best-selling authors and your favorite book talk creators to the latest pop culture moments, nothing is off the table.
00:15:47.320It's like if you can hide some real messages inside compelling characters, then that is a Trojan horse.
00:15:54.780Whether you're looking for literary deep dives, smart pop culture conversations, or a community of readers who love to think a little too much, you're in the right place.
00:16:04.400Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:16:28.080Xi'an flew a handful of influencers to Guangzhou, China, to tour one of Xi'an's factories and to visit its innovation center.
00:16:35.400It's well-lit, clean, and it actually looks like a pretty okay place to work.
00:16:39.480The influencers speak to workers about rumors of their mistreatment,
00:16:43.100and the workers say, oh no, we are being well-paid and enjoy easy commutes.
00:16:47.220It all seems pretty rosy, much like that suspiciously cheap crop top, maybe a little too rosy.
00:16:54.900And that's because they were probably not actually talking to employees representative of the typical employee experience at Shein, nor were they in a typical representative factory.
00:17:05.280Garment experts spotted pretty quickly that the facility the influencers were touring couldn't possibly be where Shein makes the clothes they sell.
00:17:12.000But that didn't keep these influencers from making glowing, positive content about what they saw and Xi'an's practices.
00:17:19.200One influencer, Danny DMC, their videos were particularly rage-baity, and I'm not even totally sure why.
00:17:27.640Maybe it's the way Danny refers to themselves as, quote,
00:17:30.400an investigative journalist and an independent thinker who gets all the facts
00:17:34.200and doesn't fall for negative Western propaganda about Xi'an like the rest of us sheep.
00:17:38.740Okay, Danny didn't really say that, but the gist was pretty clear.
00:17:42.720Though, in subsequent videos, where Danny walks back their partnership with She-En,
00:17:47.620they say they were paid very well by She-En,
00:17:50.240and at other times they say no one is paying them to say these positive things about the company.
00:17:54.980There was just something about Danny's video that was just kind of smug, easy to hate,
00:26:36.620It's about the ethical responsibilities that this company is skirting.
00:26:42.340And so I wonder, how do we make sense of wanting influencers to be paid for their labor,
00:26:50.520but also wanting them to do so in a way that is not contributing to harm?
00:26:56.560Because I felt like there was no way to square that circle.
00:27:00.500And I was like, influencing is not for me, because to make any real money, you basically have to chill for things that are not values aligned, which just didn't make any sense. And so I don't even really know what I'm asking, but how can we square that circle?
00:27:13.780Well, I think, yeah, I get a little bit worried that too many people want to be influencers because people want to be famous, regardless of what they do. And that's the issue. And then it sort of became like, oh, you can only have a platform if you like, speak on, you know, certain topics, or you have like, what's your niche issue that you care about?
00:27:42.500and then I thought oh god let's get ready for some real like empty dialogue you know what I
00:27:47.940mean like everybody's got like a everyone's got a cause you know and it's just like a lot of people
00:27:53.520I'm like you can just admit you just want to be famous you don't have to be like oh yeah and I'm
00:27:59.260like you know I'm a mental health person or whatever mental health is a big one like it's
00:28:04.060so annoying where it's like you know just be it's okay to want just want to be famous and have a
00:28:09.080platform you don't you don't need to opine publicly every everybody wants to have like a
00:28:14.440cause so that they can be like i'm deep and it's like maybe we don't all need to have this because
00:28:19.900we're having a lot of shallow conversations now um but at the end of the day i don't think the
00:28:26.160world needs as many influencers as we have i don't think that it's really an occupation that
00:28:34.440Like I read some survey and I don't remember where, but it was like one out of seven school children who's like asked about what they want to be when they grow up, says they want to be an influencer.
00:28:45.840And I'm like, no, yeah, you know, I think this idea of wanting to be famous just for being famous is it's quite weird, to be honest.
00:28:58.900for me, I've always seen platforms as a way to open doors to things that I've always wanted to
00:29:05.620do. So like, I have always wanted to write, but like, you know, I told my parents, oh, I want to
00:29:10.760write. And they were like, yeah, good luck with that. There's so many black women writers out
00:29:14.900there that are being celebrated in our society. This was like, you know, 20 years ago. So I wasn't
00:29:19.680encouraged to go into this path. And so I kind of saw having a platform as a way of achieving the
00:29:26.960things that I wanted to do career wise. And I think we really have to question like, who are
00:29:33.880we following and why? You know, like, I guess we shouldn't be that surprised that people want
00:29:39.860platforms just to be famous in a world where like, no one can stop talking about the Kardashians.
00:29:46.880You know, I think it's really indicative of our society. But at the end of the day, I just think
00:29:52.620maybe we just need fewer people wanting to like
00:29:57.800go after this sort of work because at the end of the day we're we're propping up something that I
00:30:06.920don't necessarily think is great like there could be a lot of great things achieved from online
00:30:12.040spaces but if people if everybody wants to have a cause and everybody claims to care about
00:30:20.340the same stuff, like, oh, I don't want to oppress women, then what are we doing in this
00:30:25.240conversation? You know, how did we get to this place? And I think we also need to understand
00:30:30.120that like, influencing is a fairly young occupation. It's been, what, around for like 20
00:30:37.460years or so. So like my generation had the ability to shape this occupation and to something that
00:30:45.740could be great. And we've just found ourselves in the same capitalist hellscape where the
00:30:51.060corporations have everyone under their thumb. And so I really think that influencers need to think
00:30:58.180about like, what is it that we're trying to achieve? And like, maybe if we get with the
00:31:03.400winning team and all start to maybe organize a little bit, not only can we fight for better
00:31:09.320for ourselves, but we can transform industries. Fast fashion wouldn't sell without people willing
00:31:15.500to sell it but we need to really get with the winning team about like what that looks like and
00:31:22.920what those sorts of sacrifice look like if we want everyone to be paid like at one point in time
00:31:27.860people were sort of kicking around this idea of an influencer union in the UK and when asked about it
00:31:33.680I was just like no because I'm the daughter of a union president ex-union president but
00:31:41.480your union has to recognize other unions. You have to have a code of ethics. And if the majority of
00:31:50.060the, if the majority of the sponsors of the people within this union are brands that bust
00:32:01.160unions, then what are we doing? You can't unionize while not recognizing other people's unions.
00:32:08.420That's not how that works. And so like we're at a crossroads where people really need to like figure out what sits right with their morals.
00:32:18.280And I'm never going to say that like influencing is easy because it isn't.
00:32:23.000I think that content creators can be incredibly skilled, but it is still an occupation that is like, you know, you're not cleaning gutters.
00:32:34.820You know what I mean? Like, you're not you're you're not like, you know, like there's a lot of other occupations you could do. It doesn't have to be the one where like, you know, that the highs are high and the lows are low, you know, and so people people need to get right with their ethics here.
00:32:53.480And what that's really going to look like is folks sitting stuff out.
00:32:58.080Like we're all looking at the, the writer's guild strike and I'm like right on like union
00:33:03.520strong, you know, just like power to the workers, you know, like we're all watching this go
00:33:08.780down, but like people don't realize what solidarity should look like across the board, you know?
00:33:15.320So if you are like an influencer and you don't want to like oppress people and sell things
00:33:23.000that oppress people, then you need to actually figure out what that's going to look like for
00:33:27.220you. If the only thing you can think of is, oh, I got to take money from like these horrible brands,
00:33:33.280then like maybe this isn't the thing that you should be going for. The reality is I knew that
00:33:38.880I couldn't do that. And so I diversified and I, you know, started doing Patreon long before
00:33:47.160the lockdown, which served me well. I wanted to write books. I wanted to do a lot of different
00:33:52.400things, but I did not ever want to take money to say on my grid that like some big box brand
00:34:00.100was not oppressing people when I know the majority of them are.
00:34:58.380If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
00:35:04.340This is Prose Society, the weekly podcast that's part book club, part group chat for thought daughters,
00:35:10.740pop culture obsessives, and anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:35:16.780I'm Eli Rallo, and every week we're connecting the dots between books, the internet, and the conversations everyone can't stop having.
00:35:23.900I'm going to have to look up this story. I'm obsessed. I'm obsessed.
00:35:27.420From best-selling authors and your favorite book talk creators to the latest pop culture moments, nothing is off the table.
00:35:33.440It's like if you can hide some real messages inside compelling characters, then that is a Trojan horse.
00:35:40.900Whether you're looking for literary deep dives, smart pop culture conversations, or a community of readers who love to think a little too much, you're in the right place.
00:35:50.500Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:42:59.800but I will say the experience of reading your book was,
00:43:02.480there's a there's a bright side to it I guess is what I'm saying like like everything that you
00:43:08.100just said is correct and scary and seems really big but the reality is is that we can make small
00:43:14.240changes like we don't have to wait for corporations to be better we don't have like we can make small
00:43:20.240changes like in the pandemic I've talked about this on the show I got a little bit like addicted
00:43:24.880to buying cheap crap I didn't need just for like a boost because I was feeling a lot of people did
00:43:30.000Yeah. And I had to take a step back and be like, what am I doing here? Like the amount of boxes outside of my apartment was like embarrassing to me. And when I started really thinking about my consumption habits and how social media was part of it and really undoing and unpacking some of that, it really changed my relationship to my home because I didn't have my closets were not filled to the brim with crap I didn't need.
00:43:53.980my physical presentation because so much of those clothes were garbage. Like, I found this tie-dye
00:44:02.520fucking two-piece sweatsuit that I bought on Amazon, and I was like, why did I buy this?0.99
00:44:08.240This looks ridiculous, and it looks ridiculous on me. When you stop consuming and then you1.00
00:44:13.980actually focus on acquiring things that you like, that feel good, that are designed, that are like
00:44:20.140made well I not the company made well but made space well uh make me clear about that like my
00:44:28.660dad gave me this leather jacket that he used to wear in the 70s that I've now been like oiling
00:44:34.440and taking very good care of and it's like I have a new sense of pride and love for the things that
00:44:39.680I that I really value and then when I put them on my body I I feel better it's really it's this
00:44:46.580sounds hippy-dippy and all of that, and it sounds like it sounds, but it really has been
00:44:50.500transformative. You're completely right about that. The truth of the matter is, I think we view
00:44:56.040slowing down our consumption cycles as like, oh, it's going to be so boring, and I'm going to hate
00:45:02.600it, and it's going to be terrible. And I can say my wardrobe is 400% better than it was when I was
00:45:09.300buying fast fashion because I really think about the things I bring into my closet. Not only do I
00:45:17.340think about it, but getting away from fast fashion forces you to actually figure out your style,
00:45:23.540your personal style, because we all think that we're being freed by fast fashion. But if anything,
00:45:29.820you're just getting a ton of trends pushed at you. You think you have free will in this,
00:45:34.800But in actuality, the things that are being sold to you have been picked out for you by
00:59:41.240If your bookshelf and your For You page
00:59:43.520are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
00:59:46.540Pro Society is a weekly podcast that's part book club, part group chat for anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:59:55.260Each week, we're connecting the dots between books, the internet, and pop culture with your favorite writers, book talk creators, and plenty of overthought opinions.