00:00:00.000Hey y'all, Jo here and welcome to Under the Influence. Today's episode is yet another grab
00:00:11.460bag of sorts where we are going to talk about all things Olympics, what the heck happened to
00:00:17.280everyone's early influencer favorite Love Taza, and my friend Allie Hoff Kasich's wonderful frothy
00:00:23.840and fun new novel, Too Blessed Distress. Allie's here to talk to me about all of it,
00:00:29.560including my latest favorite ridiculous conspiracy theory.
00:00:38.480Hello, Allie. Thanks for being on today to talk about one of my favorite subjects,
00:00:43.980the reason this podcast exists, influencers.
00:00:48.640Sometimes you just have to go back to what made you fall in love with it in the first place,
00:00:53.200and I'm so glad that I can help you do that today. Well, we have a couple things I've really
00:00:58.520been wanting to dive into about influencer culture, but the first thing I want to ask you is
00:01:04.220who was your gateway influencer? Oh, that's such a good question. So can it be a blogger?
00:01:12.620Does it have to be a social media influencer? I think that blogger is separate. So you can say
00:01:19.160blogger but then tell me the social media one too okay i guess this person who was my my entryway i
00:01:27.080i ended up following her on social media so i think it works my um my my entree into influencer
00:01:34.500world was love taza naomi davis do you know my god mine too yeah yes and then i i really was
00:01:42.960attached to her on her blog, but she probably was one of my first non-friend or family member
00:01:49.320Instagram follows as well. So I think it counts on both fronts. It does. It does. And that's the
00:01:54.680question. And I'm curious for our audience to ask themselves, who was the person you followed
00:01:59.500on Instagram, the first person that you followed who wasn't a friend or family member and who
00:02:04.300wasn't like distinctly a celebrity, but was just another seemingly normal person, but you didn't
00:02:10.540know who they were yes yes and i i am still heartbroken that we do not know where taza is
00:02:17.480we don't know where taza is it haunts me does it haunt you joe because i it's maybe one of
00:02:23.300my roman empires i think about it several times a month um like where did she go what happened to
00:02:31.100her i know her book kind of tanked but is that really why she went off the grid i have a lot
00:02:36.580of questions. I have a lot of questions too. And I mean, maybe we should get into that because I'll
00:02:41.700bet a lot, I'll bet you it was a lot of people's gateway. Let's just explain to the audience who
00:02:47.060and what Love Taza was. Yes. So should I, I can share my perspective. I stumbled on her when I
00:02:54.240was working as a publishing assistant in New York City. And at the time I was commuting like hours
00:03:01.600a day. I was living at home and taking the bus because I'd graduated early from college and like
00:03:06.180didn't know anybody who I could live with. So I was just endlessly on the bus and I was sleeping
00:03:12.440in my childhood bedroom and it was all very unglamorous. But then at the same time, I was
00:03:16.300spending my days in New York, which had always been my dream. And I came across Taza, who was
00:03:20.820probably only several years older than I was at the time. She had graduated from Juilliard.
00:03:26.780She was Mormon, as so many influencers were and are, as we know. And she was married to the love
00:03:34.900of her life. She had this blog called The Rockstar Diaries, which was really about documenting her
00:03:40.340early married life with Josh, who went by Ties and Fries online. And Taza was his nickname for
00:03:47.220her. And I think I just was really swept into it because I felt like she was living the New York
00:03:52.140life that I hoped that I would get to live once I stopped doing this nightmarish commute. And
00:03:58.800she blogged for at least a decade and she became super successful i mean it started as these like
00:04:05.700polaroids of the two of them sleeping in a tent on their on the floor of their studio apartment in
00:04:12.300harlem and we kind of followed their life over all these years i think they had five kids they moved
00:04:18.980to washington dc until the into this beautiful townhouse they ended up like renovating a gorgeous
00:04:24.660apartment in New York when they moved back. She had a line at Target like her brand really blew
00:04:30.220up. And then she went away. And then she just disappeared. And so many of the things that you
00:04:37.820just said really resonate with me, because I do think that for a certain generation of young
00:04:44.120women, watching people like Naomi Davis, the human behind the Love Taza blog and then Instagram
00:04:52.340was kind of similar to my experience watching sex in the city so like i watched the original
00:04:59.420episodes of sex in the city when i was in high school and college and i'm like this is gonna be
00:05:04.460my new york city life and then weirdly it was actually to be honest i mean i was actually a
00:05:09.360gossip columnist it was strange but i i feel like for the generation that came up right below me
00:05:16.860these early influencers and bloggers were giving people a glimpse into what life in the big city
00:05:24.320could look like and it was it was very voyeuristic it felt very real and she went from just being
00:05:30.760oh my gosh we're like this young couple struggling in the city to I mean then going full-blown mom
00:05:38.460influencer five kids and and I just want to reiterate the fact also a Juilliard trained
00:05:45.660ex-ballerina turned wife and mother it's like oh my god that's that's super familiar
00:05:52.100yes isn't that interesting how that seems to have played itself out all over again
00:05:57.640with somebody else that we know very well in 2026 yeah fascinating right um I mean what
00:06:03.780what if Naomi Davis just turned into Hannah Nealman like what what what if that's what0.74
00:06:08.700happened that would be such a great story if she just maybe she's just wearing a wig and
00:06:14.340I mean, I've lost track of how many kids Hannah Nealman has, but I think you could probably make an argument that they just added a couple more while they've been offline, and now Josh is a farmer.
00:06:24.500I think he was a banker before, but he seemed quite capable.
00:06:35.840Really, it's a hobby farm. And frankly, as we well know, apparently he's not very capable because their raw milk just tested positive for E. coli.
00:06:45.900And I will tell you, I don't think that that would happen under Josh Davis's watch. I think that Josh Davis would be more on top of it than that.
00:06:52.020So if there's any argument against this theory of yours, which I do genuinely like, it's that Josh Davis seems a little bit more careful, maybe, than Daniel Nealman.
00:07:22.100I mean, you can just say the craziest things online these days.
00:07:26.320I'm actually going to the Ballerina Farm outpost.
00:07:31.040I'm doing an event in Utah, a book event at a wonderful woman-owned bookstore called Folklore, which is in the town where the Ballerina Farm brand is based.
00:07:43.580And I guess I won't have the experience of having raw milk products because they've been pulled from the shelves, but I'm going to buy everything else.
00:07:53.040I will be paying close attention to your social media while you are on this trip, because this sounds like it is ripe for fantastic content and lots of anecdotes.
00:08:02.680I mean, I'm just here to sell books, girl.
00:08:09.240I will chug Ballerina Farm hydration powder.
00:08:13.280I will like one knee chug it while I'm in the middle of the store until I'm dragged out kicking and screaming, telling people to order the Parisian heist.
00:09:24.960And Taz's aesthetic at the time was so whimsical.
00:09:30.500I mean, it sort of evolved over the years.
00:09:33.280But at the beginning, I was so drawn to just like the colorful way that she lived her life.
00:09:38.640And I think that it created its own fantasy.
00:09:42.060Like just the lipstick and the bright pops of color they had in their apartment.
00:09:46.280Like she was doing some world building there and creating something almost fantastical in a grounded setting that made it seem possible for all of us to have a little bit of magic.
00:10:00.740And I think that the most effective influencers do exactly that.
00:10:06.180And she did sort of weave her belief system into her blogging here and there in a way
00:10:14.800that almost like added to that because we would hear about these like conferences that
00:14:12.060I think it would be so fun if we went on, what if we went on like a road trip to find her?
00:14:16.580I mean, that could be a whole documentary called Finding Taza, which, I mean, all right, look, it's not the worst idea.
00:14:24.200Creepy, creepy, voyeuristic, stalkery, wrong, wrong, but good content.
00:14:30.580Somewhere she is just out in the world, presumably Phoenix, like raising all of these kids and maybe living a life beyond the fact that she really was like this.
00:14:41.160massive first impact on the blogging scene I have also spoken to a lot of people who say that
00:14:46.220she was the entry point and to then kind of just retreat into oblivion it's not like she is doing
00:14:52.280some other work that we're aware of like she's just living a life and if that's what she wants
00:14:58.180then that's great but um it is so strange like it was very abrupt there was no farewell post
00:15:03.420I think maybe her Instagram is now wiped like I don't even think you can look her up anymore
00:15:08.380I hope she's well Taza if you're listening we're thinking of you and we hope she's she's clearly a
00:15:15.760massive under the influence fan obviously uh she's been listening from the beginning I mean it does
00:15:21.100remind me a little bit of when Rick Moranis dropped out of Hollywood uh because his wife passed and
00:15:25.940so Rick Moranis one of the greatest comedic actors of the 80s uh left Hollywood to raise his children
00:15:32.220I mean that's you know Taza is just the Rick Moranis of the influencing world I think that's
00:15:37.300probably what she was aiming for the whole time. A hundred percent. All right, let's take a quick1.00
00:15:42.640break. And when we get back, I want to talk about the specific influencer rabbit holes
00:15:47.240that you went down when you were researching your book to Blessed Distress.
00:16:00.880Okay, we are back. You've got a book coming out. I blurbed it. I'm doing your launch event with you.
00:16:05.880you did a lot of research for this book, but you also like you're a person who enjoys following
00:16:10.600influencer culture. What specific rabbit holes did you go down that you can tell us about so
00:16:16.140we don't go down them? Yes, please don't, because I have already given these people way more of my
00:16:21.400time and attention than I would like to admit. So it all happened during peak lockdown during
00:16:26.580COVID as Taza was driving her family from New York to Phoenix, I guess. I was stuck in the house like
00:16:32.520everybody else, not driving to Phoenix and spending a lot of time on my phone. And at some
00:16:37.580point I saw a video, I couldn't tell you who made it, but I remember that it was about your virginity
00:16:44.020and why it's so important to maintain your purity. But it was a video featuring this gorgeous young
00:16:50.060woman who at the same time was promoting like what she was wearing and her makeup. And I just thought
00:16:55.460it was so interesting because it was so divorced from any of my own personal experience. And as
00:17:01.140of course, we know more now, the algorithm then did its algorithm thing because I watched the
00:17:06.120whole video and was just kind of like intrigued. And I started getting served so many videos in
00:17:12.560this vein, talking about subjects like saving yourself for marriage, like modest fashion,
00:17:21.300like dating a godly man who would lead you and help you make the smart decision about
00:17:27.940finding church and finding community like anything you can think of but through this very specific
00:17:33.320white evangelical lens and I was most intrigued by the fact that even as somebody who does not
00:17:40.340consider herself to be religious like I was kind of taken in by it um and even as somebody who
00:17:46.500like fundamentally disagrees to so many of the underlying beliefs of these people I was still
00:17:52.880taken in by it. And I thought that that was concerning because I am an adult woman who
00:17:58.780likes to think that she's pretty informed and educated. And I don't want to be somebody who
00:18:03.820can be swayed or convinced by somebody online who has a great message packaged in cute fonts and
00:18:10.960sparkles, but I was. And so I took it upon myself to really focus on learning more about this
00:18:17.960community and trying to figure out what about it was working um as a tool to grab eyes and spread
00:18:25.080messages and i i really don't want to tell you like how much time i spent um watching these videos
00:18:33.420listening to these podcasts my algorithm will never be the same joe at this point all that i get are
00:18:39.080like golden retriever videos and modest is hottest content like that's it um and i weirdly am still
00:18:47.940kind of interested in what goes on with these people, which I sort of hate to admit, but
00:18:53.720I spent a lot of time with them researching. And I'm happy to share a couple of the big names that
00:18:58.640I came across. But big picture, I would just say like it's everything from sisters who have
00:19:05.520online ministries together where they talk about their former porn addictions and how they beat
00:19:11.940them and also about home birth because of course, to couples that were trying to do this together
00:19:17.300and who were barely hiding their extremely toxic, abusive dynamics.
00:20:10.020And at the beginning, most of their videos were just these like sit down face to camera videos talking about godly marriage, talking about their journey.
00:20:19.940Morgan did have sex before she married Paul, but of course he decided that he would forgive her and allow her to bring her sins into their marriage, which she was redeemed.
00:20:28.960So she talked about that story quite a bit.
00:20:30.800And they talked a lot about what it looked like for them to be a modern Christian couple.
00:20:36.380their motto for a long time was about having hope about being free and they had a really big
00:20:44.660following they had tons of patreon followers they did youtube lives all the time where people would
00:20:50.000chime in and i don't quite know how this works but i guess you can like send creators money
00:20:55.200while they're doing a youtube lives they did that a lot they never had other jobs um so there's
00:21:03.240always been a lot of speculation about like maybe one of them has rich family members that are
00:21:08.480paying for all of this but they very confidently were talking about how this was a full-time
00:21:12.740ministry at a certain point they started talking a lot about their fertility struggles which is
00:21:18.780its own rabbit hole in the christian space because their big strong feelings about a lot of the
00:21:26.200treatments that many of us find to be quite mainstream at this point so they were they were
00:21:30.440resistant to things like IVF because of their religious beliefs. They really commodified that
00:21:35.220for a long time. And then they had two children. She, of course, wanted to have an all-natural
00:21:41.180home birth and ended up waiting way too long to go to the hospital. Almost died. Had to have an
00:21:47.400emergency C-section. Got pregnant again, like, immediately. And her one joy after having her0.98
00:21:54.880two children was getting out of the house to play pickleball and it was through her that paul
00:22:01.220discovered that he also loved pickleball and he is now pursuing a pickleball career and one of my
00:22:08.000favorite things to see on reddit is because i don't follow them or watch their videos myself
00:22:12.340i just turned to my friends at reddit to see what they post but he posts like training montages as
00:22:17.660if he is rocky um of himself like like basically giving like a bird bath in a drinking fountain
00:22:25.160to cool himself off because he's training so vigorously for pickleball um and then at the
00:22:31.080same time like split screen style his wife is at home like trying to raise godly men as she talks
00:22:37.300about um and it's so it's just so uh disjointed because they have all of this language about like
00:22:43.920what it means to be a supportive family and a supportive couple when that's so clearly not
00:22:48.440what's going on. And she gets so mad in the comments because people will mention that it
00:22:55.440really seems like Paul is completely ignoring her, ignoring their children. And she is not shy about
00:23:01.720taking on people in the comments, which seems very ungodly to me, but it definitely makes for
00:23:07.820interesting viewing, just as somebody who eats this stuff up. And I could really watch the
00:23:15.640Paul and Morgan show for hours. It's pretty juicy stuff. Also, fun fact, she threw up at their
00:23:23.040wedding. I mean, I threw up after my wedding, but I'll bet we did it for different reasons.
00:23:29.500I think so, too. She claims that she was just hungry, but the internet has different thoughts
00:23:35.160about why she quite literally ran off the altar to go vomit oh wow she ran off the altar to go puke
00:23:42.080to go herb yeah wow there's a lot there's a lot there i did my best to summarize it but uh they
00:23:48.220they really like started in this like preaching vibe and instead they've tried to pivot not so
00:23:55.960gracefully into like more of a family vlogging pickleball vlogging situation with very judgmental
00:24:03.800Christian undertones. And I think they probably should have stayed in their lane. That seems to1.00
00:24:08.920be where they were making better inroads. And a lot of it now is just random outbursts about how
00:24:16.600women shouldn't wear leggings to the gym and how all of the videos carried at Walmart are
00:24:22.060blasphemous. But what I'm taking away from this is that pickleball influencers are also a thing.0.82
00:24:28.440They are. And you should probably do an episode about it.
00:24:30.860All right, fine. Done. Will you come back? Will you talk to me about Pickleball influencers?
00:24:35.820I will talk about Pickleball Paul and how much I hate him for as much as you would like me to.
00:24:41.940It's amazing because I tried to get into Pickleball. One of my first substacks was
00:24:45.560about me trying to get into Pickleball and buying a whole outfit to get into Pickleball.
00:24:48.960We bought a set that we set up maybe twice that just lives in our basement now. For some reason,
00:24:56.560it just never caught on for us. I think it was too much work for Nick and I. We're like,
00:25:00.260You have to go set up a court. And also the kids were littler when we tried to do it. So we're like, what do we do with the kids? Now we can, I guess, just take them to the playground. Maybe I'll try pickleball again. Maybe I'll do my deep dive into the pickleball influencing world. And that will influence me to come back, come back to the sport.
00:25:19.840That's what they're trying to do. They want you to see how much fun they're having. And maybe you'll decide to go pro like Paul.
00:25:27.880I did tell my kids the other day because we were on the chairlift skiing and Charlie said to me, you're too old to be in the Olympics.
00:25:37.100And I said, I'm going to take up curling.
00:25:40.660And not that I think curling is easy, but it is a sport that you can be older and do.
00:25:46.400Because I think like one of the top curlers is like a 55-year-old personal injury lawyer.
00:25:50.000And so I told him, I'm like, don't you bully me, because next thing you know, your mom is going to the next Olympics in France as a curler.
00:33:53.920He is, he's definitely in it pretty hard with the toddler thing right now, but they're very sweet moments that I think balance that out in a nice way.
00:34:07.800You know, all kids are difficult, right, in their own way, and they're all sweet in their own way.
00:34:12.520Toddlers are difficult because they're still so dumb, and there's like a gazillion ways for them to kill themselves on everything and everywhere all the time.
00:34:20.260the thing with three is that all of a sudden they realize that they're their own person0.99
00:34:25.980they have ideas their ideas are are completely irrational but they want them enforced and so
00:34:33.320they will just fight you on everything um and that that part of it is exhausting i don't think
00:34:40.100that ends till five okay so i have some time i should buckle down totally totally but and just
00:34:47.380prepare for it finish book two and then and then you know just prepare just prepare to be screamed
00:34:53.100at all the time i'm just screamed at all of the time these days i'm getting used to that especially
00:34:58.360in the car there's just a lot of screaming in the car i'm like i know you you said you said it once
00:35:03.180i heard it the first time we don't need to say it over and over and over again at increasing volume
00:35:07.700between point a and point b but that seems to be what we're doing so i think i just like i'm just
00:35:14.340going to keep writing and hopefully getting better at tuning out to The Screaming. And like you,
00:35:20.700I hope that my books continue to get better and maybe my parenting will get better too.
00:35:25.340I love that for you. I'm so excited for your book to come into the world. Will you tell
00:35:29.880everyone where they can find you online? Yes, you can find me on Instagram at
00:35:33.720Allie Hoff Cossack. That's A-L-L-I-H-O-F-F-K-O-S-I-K. You can also find me at
00:35:39.560AllieHopCossack.com. I am also a podcast person. You can find links to my shows there along with
00:35:44.600my sub stack. And I would love for you to come say hi. You can pre-order my book, Too Blessed
00:35:48.860Distressed, or order it after March 3rd, wherever books are sold. And I hope you love it.