Under the Influence (with Jo Piazza) - November 06, 2023


Protecting Boys From Toxic Social Media with Peggy Orenstein

Topics
Don't Spy On Your Kids' Phones with Dr. Devorah Heitner Are Trad Wives Happier Than You?

Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

179.95

Word count

7,639

Sentence count

358

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

29

sentences flagged

Hate speech

19

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 Hello. Happy Monday. When was the last time that you thought about the Roman Empire?
00:00:13.820 Really? I literally never think about it. But according to TikTok, men apparently do
00:00:20.200 all the time. This is old news by now, but whatever. I don't abide by your TikTok rules. 0.76
00:00:29.160 What's old is new, because I just learned about it.
00:00:32.340 Apparently, a month ago, this thing went viral on TikTok,
00:00:36.680 where women recorded interactions with their husbands or boyfriends,
00:00:40.500 in which they asked them how often they thought about the Roman Empire.
00:00:44.940 Based on their answers, men think about it constantly. Constantly.
00:00:48.840 And the men in these response videos are so serious.
00:00:53.480 They're deadly serious, as if, why would you even ask that?
00:00:57.100 don't you realize I'm constantly in the gladiator ring in my head? And why is that a strange thing?
00:01:03.080 Why is that not normal? They also seem shocked that their partners are shocked about what a huge
00:01:09.280 part the Roman Empire plays in their interior lives. This trend was a big thing. The hashtag 0.99
00:01:15.840 Roman Empire has nearly a billion views. A billion. A billion people are talking about this.
00:01:22.980 I mean, frankly, I think that's a little sad. It is. Just don't we have anything better to
00:01:29.020 talk about these days? But apparently I'm going to talk about it today.
00:01:32.340 I want to know what does this say about men? What does this say about our culture? And what
00:01:37.820 does it say about the Roman Empire? To figure it out, I called up the author, journalist,
00:01:43.620 and cultural critic Peggy Orenstein. She writes and thinks a lot about both the politics of
00:01:49.620 everyday life and gender. She's the author of many, many books. Her most recent, Unraveling,
00:01:57.220 is a delight. You should order it right away. I also love Cinderella Ate My Daughter as the
00:02:04.400 mother of a girl who owns way too many princess dresses, and the books Girls and Sex and Boys 0.99
00:02:10.560 and Sex. Peggy and I started out our conversation. By the way, I just emailed her and was literally, 0.97
00:02:16.640 I don't know her. And I was literally like, hey, can we shoot the shit about the Roman Empire? 0.99
00:02:21.360 And she wrote back right away and said, yeah, we can shoot the shit. Awesome. I love that I can do 1.00
00:02:25.920 that. Anyway, we started out our conversation dissecting this Roman Empire thing. Why do men
00:02:32.080 think about it all the time? And also, why did it become such a sensation on TikTok? Does it have to
00:02:37.060 do with the gladiators, the brutality, a desperation for a different kind of time? But then Peggy and
00:02:43.620 I got into so, so much more. We got into all of these things that were actually way more
00:02:48.660 interesting to me than the Roman Empire. That were actually way more interesting to me than
00:02:53.620 the Roman Empire. We started chatting about rigid masculinity and the kinds of crazy masculinity,
00:02:59.880 I don't want to say toxic, we're going to say rigid here, that boys might encounter on social
00:03:04.240 media on a daily basis. There's so much that young men and young boys can find on social media
00:03:10.380 that is absolutely terrifying. The stuff that is being served to young men is extreme and
00:03:17.640 misogynistic, and frankly, so much of our parenting job of parenting young men is now to manage the
00:03:24.160 media that they are being shown. And it's hard, because our kids are way ahead of the curve when
00:03:30.360 it comes to this. As the mom of a son, this conversation freaked me out. But it also brought
00:03:37.700 me hope. Because knowledge is power, and if we know what is out there, then we can at least make
00:03:43.440 a plan for how to help our kids work through it. I have to tell you that I haven't thought about
00:03:55.420 the Roman Empire since the show Rome. I was just in Rome, and I still wasn't focusing
00:04:01.600 on the masculinity of the Roman Empire.
00:04:05.980 I was very into the gelato, mostly.
00:04:08.540 Yeah.
00:04:09.060 Mostly, right?
00:04:10.240 Yeah.
00:04:10.800 Gelato and pasta.
00:04:13.880 I'm having you on to talk about the Roman Empire
00:04:16.000 because social media went wild for this idea
00:04:20.180 that men are obsessed with the Roman Empire,
00:04:25.220 that it may be the ultimate height of masculinity. 0.99
00:04:29.180 and i feel like you are probably one of the best people to just shoot the shit with about that 0.97
00:04:36.420 well i don't know um yeah i mean you know i thought i got contacted by the new york times 0.95
00:04:42.240 to comment on that i was like i have no idea what you're talking about right so i had to like google
00:04:47.280 it no hegi i saw it when you wrote something on your social media that said you had never
00:04:53.860 heard about it yet. I didn't hear about it. I missed this whole TikTok craze about is your
00:05:00.840 husband obsessed with the Roman Empire? Probably. I know you blink and you miss a TikTok, right?
00:05:05.320 The thing was, for those who missed it, on social media that people, young women mostly, but
00:05:11.460 not exclusively, were asking their male partners or friends how often they thought about the Roman
00:05:18.620 Empire and then recording their own response, the woman's response, at the answer because they were
00:05:23.480 but done that so often it was like all the time. But I have to say, I did a little straw poll of
00:05:31.140 the men in my life who were, of course, it's social media. So I thought, this is not social
00:05:35.980 science, right? That's social media. I love that you just said that social media is not social
00:05:42.180 science. Yeah, no, it's really not. I definitely like I asked my niece to ask her husband and she
00:05:47.320 was like oh and he was i they're about 30 and he he she was like oh my god he said he thinks that
00:05:53.840 the roman empire multiple times a week i had no idea but then i like i asked my husband and he
00:05:58.040 said never um and and it was like everything in between i will say the one commonality and it
00:06:04.780 didn't it didn't coordinate to age um it didn't coordinate to like relative feminism or like
00:06:13.160 egalitarian attitudes necessarily um i will say that the men of color all said never
00:06:19.820 and i think that's significant yes i think it's a white thing to the extent it's a thing it's a
00:06:26.660 white thing yeah i think it's a white it's i think it's a white man thing i haven't asked
00:06:30.820 my husband yet i'm going to ask him live on this podcast because i like him he might say never he
00:06:37.680 He may say never, but I like to ambush him.
00:06:40.440 I do.
00:06:42.200 I'm sure he really appreciates that.
00:06:44.460 You know what?
00:06:44.860 He knows who he married.
00:06:46.220 He does.
00:06:47.200 I know.
00:06:47.460 Yeah.
00:06:48.180 They do.
00:06:48.600 They do.
00:06:49.120 They do.
00:06:49.700 They really do.
00:06:51.160 Why, for the men that said, yes, as far as this is a phenomenon that some white men do
00:06:57.820 tend to think about the Roman Empire every day, why do you think this is?
00:07:02.040 As someone who has covered and reported on masculinity in culture for so long.
00:07:08.280 I mean, at first I felt like it was a really, like, sinister kind of thing.
00:07:15.680 Because you've got this ultimate masculinity.
00:07:17.160 They're looking at, like, would I survive the arena?
00:07:21.380 I mean, one guy was saying to me, like, football is basically the Roman Empire.
00:07:24.900 You know, you're sending these guys in to get pounded and watching it and cheering them on.
00:07:30.080 That's basically the Roman Empire.
00:07:32.040 And I thought, yeah, that kind of is, I guess.
00:07:34.680 Huh, that is a contemporary version of that, or boxing, or these things like that.
00:07:39.020 MMA, I don't disagree.
00:07:40.560 My husband is from Wisconsin, and he remembers very well growing up.
00:07:49.760 A family friend of theirs, the dad was a judge, and every Sunday when football came on, he'd be playing at this house, and this guy would say,
00:07:59.340 all the humans need their gladiators yep and that that is i mean that's that's that's what sports
00:08:07.200 are we're watching men men fight in a cage so i get that i feel that real hard one of my friends
00:08:13.860 from college said well i think of it every time i see a straight road i think a roman road i don't
00:08:18.920 know what that is but apparently that's a thing i mean and then my and then one of my dear friends
00:08:24.340 said well i think of it all the time he said i think about it i mean he was like i emailed him
00:08:28.180 I said, how often do you think about women? And within 30 seconds, I got an email with it
00:08:30.900 all the time. I was like, really? Okay. And he's like, you know, he's like an older guy. He's,
00:08:37.680 you know, I was like, what? Why? Why? And he said, well, as a child, I was obsessed the way
00:08:43.600 you are with superheroes and things like that. And then he said, I'm less obsessed now, but I
00:08:49.380 just think about like, you know, what would it have, I don't know. I couldn't, but it's so wonderful
00:08:54.040 And then on the most, on that sinister end, I looked up, I just thought, I wonder, I wonder if there's an Andrew Tate component to this.
00:09:03.200 You know who he is, right?
00:09:04.680 No, I don't know who Andrew Tate is.
00:09:06.240 So Andrew Tate, that's because you have daughters and you're a woman.
00:09:08.960 Andrew Tate is like the really, he is this internet phenomenon who convinces, who talks about like masculinity as this sort of, you know, men must be, like the worst kind of fragile, rigid masculinity that he's trying to convince young boys about.
00:09:31.320 and he's it's been a it's a it's terrible thing and um and he's super popular with teen boys
00:09:39.000 and young men um he's like the masculinity version of white supremacy oh he was arrested he was in
00:09:45.900 jail yeah i know i see the look on your face you're going oh oh because i'm looking him up
00:09:50.280 and his net worth is something like 700 million dollars yeah yeah it's very he's very bad very
00:09:57.160 very very bad and um and and it's something you know that you have to if you have if you had older
00:10:03.060 kids you would be talking about it hopefully with them girls too because they need to know
00:10:08.960 what's going on with this guy and what how the influence he might be having on boys so he has
00:10:14.220 a tremendous influence on a fairly significant segment of boys and it's just on a whim looked
00:10:20.380 up andrew tate roman empire and yeah it turns out he loves the roman empire for you know you
00:10:27.100 And because these boys who watch him or listen to him, they don't know anything.
00:10:31.000 They're uneducated.
00:10:32.340 So he's saying, like, the Roman Empire was the pinnacle of men being men and being in control. 1.00
00:10:38.960 And once they, you know, the cycle is they get in control and then they get lax and then they become pussies. 0.99
00:10:45.200 And then somebody comes and takes them over. 1.00
00:10:46.680 And that's why it fell, because men became pussies. 0.99
00:10:49.440 And that was, I mean, that's his language, not mine. 0.99
00:10:51.780 And that. 0.98
00:10:52.360 Yeah, I figured.
00:10:53.580 Yeah.
00:10:53.840 Yeah.
00:10:54.000 So that is, so there was also a, I don't like to really use the phrase toxic masculinity, but in this case, I think it fits that there was a toxic masculinity piece of it, not for, you know, men like my nephew or my friend or my brother, but that is definitely a piece of it for a cohort of younger men, I think.
00:11:16.240 now now i'm really i'm about to go deep down an andrew tate rabbit hole which will probably
00:11:22.560 make me feel gross and oozy later on but we started this conversation to talk about the
00:11:30.580 roman empire but i do have to talk about this really quick now that it's it's you've brought 0.77
00:11:34.580 it onto my radar i did not even realize that this was such a thing on tiktok bombarding these young
00:11:42.340 men with these kinds of misogynistic videos. I do. I also I also have a son. I have a six year
00:11:47.220 old son. And this is terrifying. Yeah. And he was he was charged in Romania with rape and human
00:11:53.160 trafficking. And yet he continues to have this really intense hold on a lot of boys and young
00:12:02.460 men. And so it really is something because, you know, like anything with media, they watch it.
00:12:07.520 You know, at first they watch it because they think it's like funny or weird. But those ideas
00:12:11.500 get into their heads and of course it's something that uh with for parents because you know we look
00:12:17.100 at that stuff and go like well that's ridiculous but it becomes not ridiculous to them you know
00:12:24.200 it becomes part of their world and those and you know there's a lot of research i talked about this
00:12:28.860 in boys and sex about how um when you embed false facts in stories people's first response and this
00:12:36.720 is not specific to boys. This is just humanity. And this tells us a lot about like fake news and
00:12:42.720 what's happened on the internet. Your first response is to go, oh, that's not true. But then
00:12:47.020 over time, even if it's not told to you again, like they did these experiments with college
00:12:51.540 students where they put false facts into stories, like exercise is bad for you, like something 1.00
00:12:57.020 that stupid, right? And they go, well, of course that's not true. And then they ask them two weeks 0.99
00:13:01.080 later after they've read the story and they're like, yeah, you know, I heard something that
00:13:04.700 exercise is bad for you and it actually becomes more it those false beliefs become strengthened
00:13:09.000 over time after they're told things so if you are if a boy is sitting and watching Andrew Tate
00:13:16.180 because he thinks it's you know hilarious as boys will say when something you know and I have a whole
00:13:21.260 a whole deconstruction of the word hilarious and what it means in boys lives but they watch it
00:13:28.460 because they think it's funny or it's hilarious or it's goofy but they will there it starts to
00:13:32.840 implant beliefs. And that's not to say that there are going to be horrible, misogynist rapists or 0.98
00:13:36.560 anything like that, but it starts to skew who they are in the world. And we have to really,
00:13:41.100 you know, it's a world that the online world, so much of the online world wants them to be
00:13:46.020 super polarized, wants them to be extreme, wants them to be, you know, misogynist. And you have to
00:13:54.200 constantly sort of like upstep that and talk to them about that and work with that.
00:13:57.800 yes i and this hamster tate he's not an obscure personality just for i feel like oh god no not
00:14:06.340 of my a lot of my listeners probably haven't heard about him either because his videos been watched
00:14:11.180 11.6 billion times yeah no it's not a little thing i'm not talking about some weird corner
00:14:18.480 dusty corner of the dark web or something this guy's mainstream and this is boys really because
00:14:25.600 he makes you feel better about yourself and when you're a young man and you're like insecure like
00:14:32.540 oh we all are when we're young you know it gives you sort of like some tools he he's supportive
00:14:38.140 he and then slowly it flips into this like really deep misogyny we are going to take a quick break
00:14:47.700 here when we get back we are going even further into this andrew tate rabbit hole and more
00:14:53.760 terrifying things that boys and young men are being shown on social media. I didn't know that
00:14:59.120 this is where the episode was going, but I'm really glad we went there. Happy about it. Be right back.
00:15:05.380 i feel bad for young men for a lot of reasons but they want to be
00:15:21.960 encouraged and led and they want role models yeah i really try to avoid the phrase toxic
00:15:28.720 masculinity because i think it puts boys in a defensive crouch and i don't want them to think
00:15:33.380 that who they are like their their their personhood is toxic and so I try to use words like rigid
00:15:39.080 masculinity or fragile masculinity or you know conventional masculine like words that are less
00:15:45.500 loaded um some of the boys like when I was writing boys it's like some of them use that phrase
00:15:50.620 because that phrase obviously is in the culture and they all know it um but but I and and I'm
00:15:54.940 often you know people say like that I use it but I actually I actually try to not use that because
00:16:00.820 I feel like when I talk to boys, it was so interesting talking to boys, honestly, Joe, they they because, first of all, they would say people would say to me, like, how did you get boys to talk to you like that?
00:16:14.220 I'd say, I asked, you know, because really, nobody asks them. And if you ask them, they actually talked more sort of emotionally and deeply in some ways than girls did, because they never had the opportunity. And they were so, and I would say like, you know, what, tell me, you know, when I would ask them to, like, what was the question I would ask?
00:16:41.160 what's the ideal guy
00:16:43.580 you know it was like they were channeling
00:16:45.800 1955 they would immediately
00:16:47.800 go into this like you know 0.93
00:16:49.540 athletic and sexual conquest
00:16:51.360 and you know rich and all these
00:16:53.840 things and they really wanted
00:16:55.780 alternatives and they really wanted
00:16:58.040 ways that they could be a
00:16:59.720 fuller person especially around emotional
00:17:01.680 suppression they were so
00:17:03.220 they were really in pain
00:17:08.000 around
00:17:09.000 um emotional around the ways that they would always say that what they had learned by the
00:17:15.340 time they were really the age of your son what they had learned was um that they were allowed
00:17:20.000 two emotions happiness and anger and when that's it after a while you really become incapable as
00:17:28.700 we you know a lot of us adult women can attest to in some of our relationships with men they don't
00:17:33.880 have a big emotional range anymore because they have lost it it has it has become it has gone
00:17:38.540 away because they didn't practice it. They didn't learn it. Their brains don't wire that way. So
00:17:42.220 what I would say the best thing you can do with your little boys is to name emotion, as broad a
00:17:50.100 range of emotions with them as you can. So it seems like you're feeling frustrated. It seems
00:17:55.880 like you're really sad about that. It seems like you're very confused. It seems like you're feeling
00:17:58.900 a lot of joy around, like the whole range of emotions so that they don't just go to happy
00:18:03.860 when they're happy and everything else, anger. Because anger's, you know, that's where it starts
00:18:10.180 with boys. We don't want them to be acting that anger, that constant anger out. But if sad goes
00:18:15.000 to anger, if frustrated goes to anger, if confused goes to anger, if everything goes to anger,
00:18:20.340 you can see why that can become a dangerous situation. So it's really important as mothers,
00:18:25.160 but also as much as possible men in their lives to really like pinpoint emotions so that they can
00:18:31.180 name the emotions in themselves and that allows them to hang on to them when they get as they get
00:18:34.780 older such that's such good advice we we just went through something where my son who has a lot
00:18:43.400 of wonderful emotions but he's been clashing with his dad because they're very similar they have
00:18:49.800 very similar brilliant fascinating brains and he started writing him notes that say i hate you
00:18:57.840 daddy i'm leaving them all over the house interesting really in creative places i mean
00:19:04.240 there was one on the toilet seat there's one under like under his side of the covers over there uh
00:19:10.600 but he and i had a talk about it and i said you don't hate daddy you feel you feel things for
00:19:17.000 daddy you know and i think that you're annoyed with daddy a lot of the time and he said he's like
00:19:22.320 but i can't spell annoyed
00:19:24.680 so it's really funny okay okay we can work with this so i wrote him a spelling guide for
00:19:38.380 other ways to tell his father he's unhappy with him i'm annoyed with you i'm confused by you
00:19:46.760 i'm sad um and now he's using a lot more a lot more verbs isn't that great i mean
00:19:53.640 right for his vocabulary but also that's exactly what i'm talking about you because hate is anger
00:19:58.860 right and usually under hate is not usually a primary emotion there's usually something
00:20:04.160 underneath that there's hurt there's sadness there's pain there's something else so how do
00:20:07.660 you help i mean i think that works for girls too but girls aren't discouraged from um learning what
00:20:15.840 the range of their emotions are in the same way i mean they may it may be that they don't for
00:20:20.120 whatever reason, but it's not considered part of their gender identity to cut themselves off
00:20:25.160 from feeling. I always say that girls, boys, girls, the work with girls was about learning
00:20:30.140 about how girls cut themselves off from their body. And the work with boys, although it was 0.95
00:20:35.040 also about sex and all of that, but it was really fundamentally about how boys cut themselves off
00:20:39.060 from their heart. Oh, see, I haven't, this is one of your books that I haven't read yet.
00:20:44.540 And now I need to. Now I'm ordering it on Amazon right now.
00:20:47.580 Well, I mean, I'm not saying that you should, but, you know, obviously, of course, of course, but I don't think they're ever too young.
00:20:56.780 Yeah. Yeah. It is true that, you know, around those issues of, you know, development of emotion, other things that are going to eventually scaffold into being about their relationships with a partner, both emotional and sexual, are things that we plant the seeds of when they're very, very young.
00:21:16.000 whether it you know how we talk about their bodies or it's how we allow them to express emotion or
00:21:21.300 how we teach them to behave with others on the playground you know all these things are going
00:21:26.800 to they're going to bring into their human relationships and you can't really just start
00:21:30.700 talking about the issues that you know that become that when they're first of all once they hit
00:21:36.820 puberty it's really hard to talk to them anyway like entering into those conversations that you
00:21:40.380 know 13 14 15 good luck with that not that you can't if your children are already that age but
00:21:45.120 it's it's just a lot harder whereas if you are already talking about like you know emotions when
00:21:51.200 they're little if you get those you know there's all these there's great books on um sexuality for
00:21:56.780 you know for four-year-olds that are are wonderful um Roby Harris's books are wonderful sex is a
00:22:02.340 funny word it's wonderful they're on my website which is my name but you know there's to have
00:22:06.460 those books in the home and to have those conversations sort of neutrally when they're
00:22:12.000 when they're little, I mean, I can remember my daughter loves when I talked about her like this,
00:22:15.820 I'll tell you. But I can remember, you know, like when she was seven, we were sitting at dinner and
00:22:21.600 all of a sudden she was like eating and all of a sudden the fork like paused halfway to her mouth
00:22:26.280 and she kind of looked up, you know, into space and she said, well, I know it takes a sperm and
00:22:33.900 an egg to make a baby, but how does the sperm get into the uterus? And my husband like gave me
00:22:41.920 this look like and i i without because i was i knew i had prepared for this moment already we
00:22:48.140 had planted the seeds even up to that point and i without missing me i said you know honey that is
00:22:52.160 such a good question after dinner let's read your book and we can look at that part and you know and
00:22:58.020 we had the ruby harris book and we looked at the part and they had you know and and and it just
00:23:01.980 helped us with no and then of course then what happened was she had she had a friend who had
00:23:07.100 two moms oh yeah and she was so she was she was like what about gideon and you're like different
00:23:15.480 different science it's like well you know they uh gideon's moms had a helper um who who gave them
00:23:23.520 some sperm and she said how and i said well you know they went to the doctor's office well how
00:23:29.160 did the doctor get and i was like okay let's have a cookie that's enough of this conversation today
00:23:33.860 i love it yes we we haven't got into the sex conversations but what what being ready for it
00:23:43.440 but being ready for it being ready for it but having the books like those roby harris books
00:23:47.580 they have just lovely little cartoons and they're not and they're appropriate they're age appropriate
00:23:51.940 and you know so that you're never making it something that feels you know dirty or taboo or
00:23:58.260 unspeakable when they're little. And then as they get older and things do become more complicated
00:24:04.080 and all the things start happening, they know that they can come to you for somebody who they
00:24:14.880 can talk to, who will not be judgmental, who has already shown openness. Because man, it gets
00:24:20.420 harder. I know. Everyone keeps telling me that. I'm ready. I'm preparing for it. I'm really glad
00:24:27.640 about the turn this conversation has taken,
00:24:30.100 because now I'm fascinated.
00:24:31.820 I feel like there's a lot that I don't know
00:24:33.300 about what boys are seeing on social media
00:24:36.560 and the rigid masculinity.
00:24:39.780 Besides Andrew Tate,
00:24:41.380 is this very prevalent, this world, for young men?
00:24:46.460 Yes.
00:24:46.880 I mean, I don't want to scare you too much.
00:24:51.360 I really think that as much,
00:24:53.120 if in a community of parents
00:24:54.360 is you can keep your child from that as long as possible and then once they are gonna i mean it's
00:25:01.820 a drag because you know they need to be online to do their school work and all these different
00:25:06.100 things so you know our our tool of our work or our academic life has merged with the tool of
00:25:11.680 our entertainment um and and that's tricky for all of us right for all of us um but for kids i
00:25:19.460 think you know what i'm finding out i'm doing a project right now and we don't have to go here
00:25:26.780 because that's going to scare you even more but i'm doing a project right now and young people
00:25:31.100 in pornography and um the a lot of there i mean there's the whole point you know there's the whole
00:25:39.100 like porno and all that but a lot of what they find initially is more like on youtube or social
00:25:45.580 media. And so it's really, it's, I think, hard for us because we didn't grow up with it in the same
00:25:54.740 way. But to be aware that these, you know, the algorithms, they take them down these rabbit
00:26:01.060 holes and they'll keep feeding them and feeding them and feeding them more extreme material.
00:26:05.300 And there just needs to be a lot of conversation, as much, you know, blocking or minimizing as you
00:26:13.820 can do um for little for younger kids um i think it's really important um because the stuff that
00:26:19.820 is going out to boys uh is is extreme um it's massage it's really misogynist um and and it can
00:26:28.940 feel initially empowering um so i i just i i really i feel like for our generation of parents
00:26:40.140 and you're even a generation of parents behind me because my daughter is you know in college now but
00:26:44.460 um that we didn't we were completely unprepared for how much of our parenting job was managing
00:26:53.280 media you know I mean I think that has become like an enormous part of our parenting job
00:27:00.720 and something that we that that's hard to do because they're kind of ahead of us on that curve
00:27:05.620 um but we it makes it all that it's like why i i just was um some of some reporter in the pacific
00:27:14.380 northwest called me because some sheriff had gone into the public library and seen a book called um
00:27:23.920 like deal with it i think it was called it was a book on female puberty from 1999 uh decided it
00:27:33.340 was obscene checked it out the library and not brought it back as a as a and some other book
00:27:39.100 too and it was like first of all i was like okay the books from 1999 has been there since 1999
00:27:44.280 why is he suddenly doing this and why and like it's completely outdated anyway i would pull that
00:27:51.340 book from the library for different reasons because you know social media hadn't even happened
00:27:54.780 um so what is you know like it's not even helpful um but and i'm not sure kids go to
00:28:03.880 the library anymore because they're all you know like like who but but and and and all of that i
00:28:08.580 mean the the book banning thing is part of this national coordinated effort and this guy whether
00:28:11.920 he is actively part of that effort or passively just you know himself consumes the media that
00:28:18.480 gives him that idea ends up being part of the effort but the but the larger issue was i was
00:28:24.320 like, you think that you, by taking some sex ed book out of the library, you're stopping kids
00:28:31.000 from encountering this information because guess what? They've got a phone in their pocket and
00:28:37.800 that phone is putting them in touch with so much that, I mean, you think if you don't talk about
00:28:44.320 your child about sex, they're not going to find out about it or they're going to find out about
00:28:48.300 it in some like natural, healthy way or, you know, figure it out. That's not going to happen.
00:28:55.000 The way that they're going to find out about it is online and you don't have a choice. And that's
00:28:59.360 the same thing with boys and masculinity and emotion, all that stuff. They are finding out
00:29:04.160 such massive misinformation about so many things online that so much of our job as parents is to
00:29:09.080 counterbalance that at this point and to make sure that we're inculcating them with positive values,
00:29:14.060 with love, with kindness, with caring, with real human. I mean, I think I like most of that negative
00:29:19.740 stuff on the internet. It's about undermining our humanity. And, you know, it's not, whether it's
00:29:27.400 the masculinity stuff, the sex stuff, whatever it is, it's all about undermining humanity and
00:29:32.640 human connection and compassion and listening to others and all the things that are so
00:29:39.260 important to us. So just reinforcing those things constantly in our kids' lives becomes a big part
00:29:45.700 of the task. You can't get rid of all the stuff online. It's whack-a-mole. But you can keep
00:29:51.320 really strongly reinforcing your values and reminding them and educating them that what
00:29:57.440 they see online is there to sell them things, whether it's an idea or a product.
00:30:04.920 Time for a quick break. When we get back, we'll talk about finding positive role models for young
00:30:10.280 boys online. Are there positive role models for young boys and like an influence for good that
00:30:30.860 is say the opposite of the andrew tates yeah i mean i think they're you know you can find those
00:30:35.520 all over you can find those online as well i mean there's some like there's some great ted talks
00:30:38.960 like justin baldini you know um do you know him no you're telling no you're giving me so much
00:30:44.400 so much he he is the guy did you ever watch oh shoot what's that called um kane the virgin yes
00:30:51.920 yes well he's the the guy on jane the virgin okay he's actually a white guy but he's the guy 0.76
00:30:58.700 who plays the Latino guy. He is actually, of all things, he's Baha'i. And apparently Baha'i has
00:31:05.480 really evolved ideas about masculinity. Who knew? And so he did this like beautiful, he did this 0.99
00:31:11.060 whole, he does a lot on masculinity. I think he has a book coming out on positive generative
00:31:17.140 masculinity. There's some wonderful TED Talks for older boys. I don't know as much for younger boys,
00:31:22.760 but there should be more like picture books and stuff. I feel like there's a number of
00:31:26.500 things out there. You just have to be, it's the same as with girls, you know, to find, I mean, 1.00
00:31:31.540 there's actually, it's easier with girls. You can find more feminist stuff more easily. There's sort 1.00
00:31:34.740 of more of a, both a balance and a contradiction in the way that girls grow up. I think one thing 0.89
00:31:39.160 that social media actually can give us in a positive way, if we let it, is helping your
00:31:45.800 child establish boundaries. And by learning to establish them with us as parents, that helps
00:31:49.740 them establish them in other areas of their social media life as well. So it's really important to be
00:31:54.720 able to help them and let them do that and to ask them you know to say when as you know what even
00:32:00.420 when they're little i think you know you can say like can i and they can and they can say for
00:32:05.800 whatever reason they feel like does it matter no say yes or no yeah exactly yeah we went we got
00:32:12.900 into so we got into so many better topics than the roman empire today i know you said you wanted 0.96
00:32:19.240 to shoot the shit so i thought let's just do it let's just talk about what we're talking about 0.99
00:32:23.040 Oh, shit. And it was such good shit shooting. I loved it. I loved this conversation. I'm so happy that you came on, Peggy. Thank you so much. 1.00
00:32:30.420 This was super fun. Still, I'd like people to get Unraveling, even though we didn't talk about it.
00:32:34.620 No, well, hey, look, no, as we end this conversation, tell me, tell the audience, because they love books. They love buying books. Tell us about Unraveling.
00:32:44.540 so unraveling was i you know like everybody i i had been like traveling around the boys and sex
00:32:50.940 had just come out and um lockdown happened life stopped terror set in all i could do i was a
00:32:57.540 knitter all i could do is knit and talk to my mom who was dead so it was interesting that i spent the
00:33:02.060 whole day talking to her um oh wow so you're knitting you were knitting and talking to your
00:33:05.760 dead mom yeah um because um yeah and and but but i realized at a certain point that and that kept
00:33:13.760 me calm. And I realized, even though my mom was not a calm person, but I realized that what I
00:33:18.500 was doing, what I wanted was to talk to her. This thing that was in defiance of all laws of nature,
00:33:25.820 I wanted to talk to her and for her to be my age and for me to be my age too. And so I was like
00:33:31.800 taking both sides of this. And my mom had taught me to knit. That was why it was relevant. And in
00:33:38.000 the book, there's this whole theme she learned from her mom because so many women learn from
00:33:42.160 their moms. And I started breathing in SLSHM. And it became one big theme of this book. It's like
00:33:49.960 what we learned from our moms, what we didn't learn, what we wish we learned, what we're sorry
00:33:53.880 we learned, what we pass on to our daughters, what we do. I never taught my daughter to knit
00:33:58.140 because I knit in a weird way. And I didn't want her to learn the way I learned. And I thought,
00:34:03.000 well, that's a metaphor for the things that we don't want to pass along to our daughters that
00:34:07.240 we learned that we want to stop with us um so that's a big thing but in the course of doing
00:34:12.680 this thing um that i decided to do is everybody else was off baking sourdough i thought i know
00:34:17.000 i'll learn to shear a sheep um because that's normal um yeah and i did this whole i don't know
00:34:23.120 i had some like and this is back to the roman empire the thing i think about all the time
00:34:27.400 every day laura engelswalder i think about laura engelswalder all the time all the time
00:34:32.960 in ways that are good in ways that are bad in ways that she's problematic in ways that
00:34:37.180 cheese, you know, all these different things. And one of them was like, OK, I'm stuck in Little
00:34:41.900 House on the Prairie now because I've gone off on the covered wagon in COVID land and I can't
00:34:47.380 be in touch with anybody anymore. And I'm going to learn how to do a Laura Ingalls Wilder thing.
00:34:52.280 And I learned to shear sheep and process. And I did this whole thing. But it became so much about
00:34:57.280 more than that. And that's why I think, I mean, you don't have to be a person, although I think
00:35:01.240 a lot of us do do handcraft. And as women, it's a really important thing. And craft ties into
00:35:08.180 witchcraft. And like, there's all these resonance to it. But it just became a lot for me about
00:35:15.060 confronting transition in my life as a woman. And my dad was dying. My mom was dead. My daughter
00:35:24.100 was leaving for college. I was in kind of disarray. That's why it's called unraveling.
00:35:29.800 you know the world was falling apart around me it was also about learning to like we think
00:35:35.320 we think about our food so much now you know so consciously and eco-consciously but we don't
00:35:40.040 think about our clothes like why don't we think about our clothing the way we think about our
00:35:42.780 food so a lot of it became about looking at the environmental impact of our clothing it became
00:35:47.820 about thinking about what creativity means in both like personal ways and larger ways
00:35:52.220 it became about all this history and lore and why like I said why the Greeks don't see blue
00:35:57.080 and all this stuff so it was like all this stuff that ended up being in this book that was so much
00:36:01.980 more than like a book is a braid and there's the part that you more but more than three strands
00:36:06.880 there's the part that you know which was that I was going to do this project and then there was
00:36:10.840 all the strands that I just didn't know and and all that ended up being like so much not I want
00:36:16.860 to say more interesting but more surprising and not even more surprising just different and
00:36:22.120 relevant and women's work and even the history. What did women do, Joe, when Trump was elected 1.00
00:36:30.100 president? We knit. We made pussy hats out of yarn. And there is a reason for that. There's a 0.95
00:36:38.140 reason that the first thing that women did was pick up knitting needles historically and culturally 1.00
00:36:43.920 and across, you know, across economics and across ethnicities. Our handcraft has been a way 0.98
00:36:52.280 that women, traditional handcraft, has expressed both dissent and patriotism politically and
00:36:57.780 continues to be. Craftivism is a really big thing. And that, learning that whole history
00:37:04.200 of women's labor was incredible. So there's like all these aspects of this book that were just
00:37:08.620 super fun and interesting and kept me from complete despair during the year of lockdown.
00:37:13.920 Peggy, I have a great, I have a great plan for getting Unraveled into more hands.
00:37:25.420 Have you listened to our other podcast, Wilder, yet?
00:37:30.700 Oh, I have. Wait, do you do Wilder? Is that you?
00:37:34.900 Glynnis McNichol is the host of Wilder, and I created it with her. So I'm the executive producer of it.
00:37:40.580 Oh, my God. I haven't. I got it. You want to know why I haven't?
00:37:44.780 Yeah.
00:37:45.420 I'm so jealous that you thought of that idea that I have not been able to bring myself to listen to it because I can't believe I didn't think of it.
00:37:53.120 I know.
00:37:53.680 It's such a good idea. I hear it's so brilliant and I'm going to listen to it.
00:37:57.980 I just wrote a piece which got my editor at The New York Times. Sometimes he just sits on things and then.
00:38:05.120 I know. They always do.
00:38:06.220 I love my editor, but sometimes, and then it's too late for me to sell it elsewhere. And I wrote a piece on the Roman Empire. Yeah, you said that post. And so I wrote why I think about Laura Ingles Wilder all the time. And he sat on it. And now I don't know what to do about it.
00:38:27.020 But it was pivoting off of men think about the Roman Empire.
00:38:33.640 Was there something that women think about?
00:38:35.760 It turns out it's Laura Ingalls Wilder.
00:38:37.460 Like with all due respect to the Austenite and the Louisa May Alcott people, no shade.
00:38:41.640 But it's Laura Ingalls Wilder.
00:38:43.040 And Anne of King Gables, there's all those ladies, but not me.
00:38:45.460 No, it's Laura.
00:38:46.920 And it's Laura for Glynnis too, which she's been talking about Laura Ingalls Wilder.
00:38:52.340 We've been friends for almost 20 years.
00:38:54.900 I've been talking about her for as long as I've known her.
00:38:58.000 It's her obsession.
00:38:59.340 We've driven across the country several times, and she would take me to the homesteads off the beaten path every time.
00:39:07.120 And so I was finally like, you're going to have to do a podcast on this.
00:39:09.960 I'll produce it.
00:39:10.920 Why aren't you my friend?
00:39:12.340 And why didn't you say this to me?
00:39:13.960 I know.
00:39:14.560 Joe.
00:39:15.360 I'm sorry. 0.99
00:39:15.940 Damn it. 0.98
00:39:16.540 No, but it's up. 1.00
00:39:16.960 I failed.
00:39:17.280 I failed, Joe.
00:39:17.760 My grandfather grew up on a homestead.
00:39:21.420 Oh, my God.
00:39:21.900 So I and my other my other great grandfather was a lumberjack, which is weird.
00:39:28.880 You know, I'm Jewish and it's kind of a weird background.
00:39:30.760 Not really. It's not weird if you're from where I'm from, but it's not Hester Street.
00:39:34.560 And but my my grandfather grew up on the homestead in North Dakota.
00:39:38.860 I grew up on those stories of raising the barns and picking the wild cherries and choke cherries and breaking the horses and then everybody dying and the crops all being leveled by hail.
00:39:49.320 hail like all the awful too like all of it the grasshoppers yeah yeah in my grandfather's case
00:39:56.240 it was hail um and because the dakotas is a terrible place to do that stuff terrible and
00:40:01.620 and so i felt this kindred to laura in part because i i felt like i was not that far away from
00:40:09.180 her um growing up with these stories in my life and then we had a butter churn in the kitchen
00:40:17.520 growing up, which my mom would not let me actually use, but I would sit there and pretend to churn
00:40:23.280 my butter. And, you know, I think we all boiled the maple syrup and poured it into the snow and
00:40:27.960 lost all the maple syrup. And, you know, all the things we had, my mom liked, we had a wagon from
00:40:35.140 a horse and buggy in the den. So I would sit on it and pretend to take my horses, you know, and
00:40:41.460 go in my covered wagon. Oh, my gosh. Yeah. I mean, I had a whole Laura life going on. So, yeah.
00:40:54.140 We went to a lot of places today. We started out with the Roman Empire,
00:40:59.300 made it to rigid and terrifying masculinity. And on that front, I'm sorry. I'm really sorry
00:41:04.740 about subjecting all of you to this man, Andrew Tate, this man who is now in my feed. And it is
00:41:11.400 some of the worst shit that I have ever seen. I hate that he's online. I hate that young boys 1.00
00:41:17.540 are watching him online. I hate everything about it. I do. I do. But at least we know. Now we know.
00:41:27.620 And then this episode did go in a happier place. We talked about sheep shearing and knitting,
00:41:32.100 which was nice. That was good for me. And as always, all points led to Laura Ingalls Wilder.
00:41:39.300 because, yes, my takeaway is that Laura Ingalls Wilder is the Roman Empire for most women.
00:41:46.640 It is. I really want to see Peggy's story about that.
00:41:49.840 Go buy her book Unraveling and all her other books, Girls and Sex, Boys and Sex, and Cinderella Ape My Daughter. 0.99
00:41:56.200 Peggy is a treasure, and I am so grateful that she responded to my email and said she would shoot the shit with me. 0.99
00:42:02.520 That is all we've got for today. 0.99
00:42:05.080 Go shear a sheep, or learn to knit, or send Andrew Tate some hate mail. 0.96
00:42:09.300 he deserves it he's probably gonna fucking dox me right now isn't he also as always my friends 0.94
00:42:15.440 pre-order the sicilian inheritance pre-order it and send it to andrew tate because he seems like 0.96
00:42:20.880 the kind of dude who could really use some strong kick-ass women characters in his life
00:42:24.700 love you all talk soon 1.00