Under the Influence (with Jo Piazza) - July 20, 2025


Sunday Nice Things: Unladylike

Topics
Content Creation Is a Business. Grace Atwood Treats It Like One. The Italian Lady Assassins, Spies, and Couriers Who Fought the Nazis

Episode Stats


Length

46 minutes

Words per minute

176.1

Word count

8,166

Sentence count

357

Harmful content

Misogyny

68

sentences flagged

Toxicity

33

sentences flagged

Hate speech

46

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 Joe here on the road from the book tour for Everyone is Lying to. It's a lot. It's a lot.
00:00:05.800 And it's also so nice to be alone in a hotel room with no children. I'm just gonna say that
00:00:10.540 because it is, it is incredibly pleasurable. Truly, truly. Today I'm dropping one of my
00:00:16.760 favorite podcasts into your feed for you to listen to. And I am actually a guest on this podcast.
00:00:21.920 So yeah, it's a lot of me. If you're totally sick of me, maybe give it a skip. Listen to
00:00:26.140 something else from them. The show is called Unladylike, which is what people call me on a
00:00:33.000 fairly regular basis. Host Kristen Conger is a national treasure. She dissects the myths,
00:00:39.660 messes, and media that is shaping modern womanhood. She's a delight, and so is the show. I think you're
00:00:46.620 going to love it. Unladylike. If you like this episode, I'm going to drop all the episodes
00:00:50.520 right in the show notes so that you can listen to all of them. Enjoy.
00:00:56.140 I have somehow become the world's leading expert on Trad Wives, which was completely 0.83
00:01:02.020 unexpected, but I'll take it.
00:01:04.920 hello and ladies trads chads i am kristen conger and i do have some quick housekeeping not to be
00:01:30.420 two on the nose uh skip ahead one minute if you've ever left a one-star podcast review along
00:01:36.460 the lines of the house spent the first minute promoting herself and i hate her voice and i
00:01:41.580 could care less yeah just pop ahead i'm gonna take a minute and catch up with y'all this is
00:01:49.420 a bonus episode i'm so excited to bring it to you all um but also thank you to everyone who
00:01:56.120 listened to this spring's gender war games mini series i hope you all enjoyed that as much as i
00:02:04.420 did getting to talk to all of our genius guests on that one now if you have not listened in a long
00:02:12.060 time you might not know i stopped making unladylike as a weekly free feed podcast at the end of last
00:02:19.740 year. I'm a one person production team. I just had to create space for myself and also for
00:02:30.200 trying new feminist approaches to things like Conspiracy She Wrote podcast out now available 1.00
00:02:38.320 to listen everywhere. And also a limited podcast series that will be coming to the Unladylike feed 0.98
00:02:45.000 that I'm going to be announcing soon so I am still making podcasts and any readers listening
00:02:51.400 I've also been writing more and occasionally infographing in the newsletter unladylike.substack.com
00:02:58.900 I've been posting more videos over at unladylike media on instagram and tiktok
00:03:04.840 so here I am algorithms dear god monetize me
00:03:09.500 and speaking of which i you know i could probably learn a thing or three in that regard
00:03:16.700 from trad wives the reason for the season our dazzling guest joe piazza is as hilarious as
00:03:26.660 she is insightful and only she could bring us the trad wife murder thriller slash book of the summer
00:03:33.280 everyone is lying to you. And I am not exaggerating when I tell you it hooked me on page one.
00:03:41.260 Jo is the best-selling author of The Sicilian Inheritance, We Are Not Like Them, and six
00:03:46.340 other titles. She also hosts the podcast Under the Influence with Jo Piazza. And really,
00:03:53.060 she just might be the world's leading expert on Trout Wives.
00:03:57.200 It's been about two years that I've been interviewing tradwives and former tradwives and really immersing myself in this world.
00:04:06.100 And honestly, I got to tell you that when I started writing this novel, it did start as a satire.
00:04:11.160 And I did not think nor and I absolutely did not hope I hoped against it that this would be our reality come summer 25 when it came out. 0.88
00:04:21.980 But I think that Trad Wives and what they represent are influencing politics in a more dangerous way than ever. 0.97
00:04:29.760 So I'm very excited for Everyone is Lying to you to just dismantle that and break open people's brains. 1.00
00:04:36.580 Joe, I'm so excited that you mentioned the political influence because I definitely have questions on that.
00:04:43.520 But before we go further, your new novel, Everyone is Lying to You, it is Trad Wives meets Gone Girl.
00:04:51.260 it is a perfect summer read why though this story now yeah i mean i i feel like i'm just giving
00:04:59.240 america what it wants and needs uh right now um i mean everyone is lying to you you describe it
00:05:04.600 perfectly it's gone girl meets trad wives it's a delicious addicting murder mystery but about
00:05:12.220 all of the lies that were being told on social media about all of these picture perfect women 0.99
00:05:17.900 that we look at them. And I feel like normies like me feel so much shame and guilt because I'm
00:05:22.660 like, why can't I grow a beautiful garden and homestead and run barefoot through a field with
00:05:29.820 my 19 children and look so perfect and incredible and amazing all the time? And the fact is they're
00:05:35.100 not. They're lying to you. Everyone is lying to you. This lifestyle is a massive fantasy that
00:05:42.120 they're selling to you on social media so they can sell you crap, to be honest. They're like, 0.99
00:05:46.660 I'm going to sell you $120 egg carrying bucket for your chickens. And they don't show the work
00:05:55.740 or the labor of the chickens either, which drives me so crazy because having chickens is not easy
00:06:00.340 and having chickens is not clean. It is messy. You do not want to run barefoot through those
00:06:04.240 chicken coops like they do on their Instagram reels. That's gross. And so, yeah, so that's why
00:06:10.080 I felt like this really hits right now because I have so many friends who are progressive,
00:06:17.220 like just like liberal moms, right? Who are like, I can't stop watching conservative homesteading
00:06:22.480 content. And I'm like, I get it. I mean, the fantasy looks great. And I wanted to puncture
00:06:28.740 that fantasy. And I do like to be clear about one thing though. I'm not skewering trad wives
00:06:36.180 themselves. And I would never judge or skewer any choice that a woman made willingly. What gets
00:06:44.260 skewered in this book are the lies, the deception, the showing people picture perfect worlds when
00:06:52.020 the reality behind the facade is clearly not perfect. And also shitty men. I mean, a lot of 1.00
00:06:58.380 shitty men get murdered in this book. And I think that that is also what we want and need this 0.98
00:07:02.540 summer while we're on the beach or ignoring our children at the public pool. I will say nothing
00:07:07.240 like scrolling through the ballerina farm feed and seeing cameos of the husband makes me want to 0.65
00:07:13.340 murder. Yeah, well, it's like the husband's in all of these feeds. And I mean, I've, like I said,
00:07:21.260 I've interviewed so many trad wives and former trad wives and aspiring trad wives because, you
00:07:27.240 know, there's absolutely an aspirational pipeline there right now. But the husbands are always kind
00:07:32.860 of a cipher. Like you only, and I write this in the book, I'm like, you only ever see them like
00:07:36.400 far off in a field, in profile. They're never really doing anything. They're never really
00:07:42.280 doing any work. And a lot of these tradwives are preaching the idea of women submitting to their 1.00
00:07:47.860 husbands. And they say things like, I'm just a housewife. I'm just a mom. When in reality,
00:07:53.220 They're making hundreds of thousands, if not millions of dollars off these accounts.
00:07:57.560 They're a boss. 1.00
00:07:58.500 They're actually the new girl boss. 1.00
00:08:00.300 And they're just stripping away all of the labor and all of the work behind that. 1.00
00:08:04.360 I know so many trad wives whose husbands now work for them, who are preaching submission 0.96
00:08:08.680 to your man, that a man is the only breadwinner in the family.
00:08:12.320 And yet their husbands quit their jobs or got laid off from their jobs, like so many
00:08:16.080 men right now.
00:08:16.760 And they're being supported by their wives.
00:08:19.120 But again, everyone is lying to you.
00:08:21.300 it's not just a clever title for a fun book. Well, and I was going to ask how you did approach
00:08:26.880 writing the men, because like you said, the trad husbands are often, you know, they're not nearly
00:08:35.120 as present in the feeds. Yeah, yeah. In reality, they're not. And so the men were actually the
00:08:42.140 hardest to write, which is shocking, because they're often the least complex characters in
00:08:47.720 books. But because I really had to create them from scratch, I had to think about, I'm like,
00:08:54.300 what is feeding this very conservative, quote unquote, traditional idea of masculinity these
00:09:02.020 days? Where is that coming from? What are their values? And then ultimately, how do they feel
00:09:08.500 when their wives do become the breadwinners in the family, which I think is like the best pun
00:09:13.340 when I think about how much sourdough content I get served. I'm like, I just love making that 0.80
00:09:19.580 correlation. But how do they feel? Are they jealous? Is there an undercurrent of hatred
00:09:27.160 for their wives? And so all of these tensions come to a head to create this thriller. And when
00:09:33.500 I started really thinking about the world, I was like, of course, there's going to be dead bodies.
00:09:37.560 like this is this is just the natural progression of this
00:09:41.820 how did you go about though even approaching trad wives to interview it's really interesting
00:09:51.600 for me because I've been covering the internet and social media for five years now which is
00:09:56.680 shocking to me but it's true because I know that I started doing it when I had my first daughter
00:10:02.600 and she didn't sleep. She was a terrible, colicky baby. She was the worst. And all I could do all
00:10:08.020 night, every night was just rock her with one appendage free, which was my thumb. And I would
00:10:13.440 scroll Instagram and I'd be served influencers. And I became obsessed with this world and this
00:10:20.220 business. And I started under the influence to report on it and try to dissect it and figure it
00:10:24.340 out. I'd been a celebrity reporter for a long time and also a political reporter. So this is
00:10:30.020 actually probably my Venn intersection right now of what I'm doing. And I realized that influencers
00:10:36.000 were the new celebrities, right? I mean, more people are paying attention to them, to these
00:10:40.460 strangers on screens in the palms of our hands that are watching most Netflix shows. And they
00:10:47.160 have a lot more power over how they influence culture. And so because I did a deep dive that
00:10:54.300 was very, I would say, objective reporting into the world of influencers, Trad Wives have been
00:10:59.780 very excited to talk to me, to open up their world. Again, I don't judge women. I want to 0.97
00:11:07.120 understand them better. And I'm trying to put all of that out there, warts and all. We have
00:11:14.380 many trad wife influencers in this book. Our main character, Rebecca, is one. And we show 0.59
00:11:21.480 just how hard she works. We do show the truth behind creating this kind of media,
00:11:26.840 but she is never taken down she is she's actually she's really like shown for who she truly is
00:11:33.780 and i think in the interviews that these women have given me that's what they want they want
00:11:38.880 to be seen they want to be seen for their labor because they don't show it in their feeds
00:11:43.880 but at the same time this is where it starts to feel so contradictory though of like
00:11:49.720 they want to be seen and yet they also want to say not all of hashtag not all trad wives but
00:11:58.060 you know hashtag not all trad wives but the ethos like you mentioned earlier is that they are living
00:12:05.120 a lifestyle that is free of what they might call careerism girl boss feminism paid labor
00:12:13.480 but I think it's that the fact that two things can be true at a time right that you can want
00:12:19.880 your brand to present as one way and still your ego can be hungry for some kind of recognition
00:12:25.800 you're saying trad wives are human too I'm I am I am telling you trad wives they're just like us
00:12:35.140 this just in that's just in Bonnie Fuller and Us Weekly circa 2005 would totally agree with us
00:12:42.160 Is there a taxonomy of trad wives? Because one thing I loved is all of the different iterations of not just trad wives, but the mom fluencing world. And I was wondering if there was almost like a taxonomy of it all.
00:12:58.660 Oh, my God, girl, I could create you a whole taxonomy of the influencer world. I really could
00:13:04.680 at this point. You know, our main character, Rebecca, is really complicated. And, you know,
00:13:11.540 while I drew on a lot of real life inspiration, she's completely fictional. And I've just spent
00:13:17.700 so much time with different kinds of influencers that she kind of came together as, you know,
00:13:24.260 a combination of a lot of different women. But there's different subgroups of child-wife 0.99
00:13:28.960 influencers. You have the kind of domestic goddesses ones who are often a little bit more 1.00
00:13:35.720 suburban, who are giving definitely more Martha Stewart vibes, which I think is crazy to say, 1.00
00:13:41.660 because Martha Stewart is like the biggest, bossiest babe out there, right? Like the biggest 1.00
00:13:46.520 boss babe there is. But at the same time, it's more like domestic goddess. Look at me in my
00:13:50.620 beautiful, suburban, all-white marble kitchen, right? And then you have the homesteading
00:13:58.560 like kind of hobby farm influencers who, I mean, they definitely have to come from generational
00:14:04.640 wealth because it is hard to succeed at either homesteading or hobby farming unless you come
00:14:11.540 from money. There's a reason that farmers are typically subsidized by the American government,
00:14:14.920 even though, you know, that is not a thing we talk about nearly enough. And so they're out there
00:14:20.000 doing kind of prairie core, like Laura Ingalls Wilder, fantasy homesteading, even though we all
00:14:26.400 know very well that life was incredibly hard and miserable for women on the prairie. I did a whole
00:14:33.900 podcast called Wilder on Laura Ingalls Wilder and her legacy. And Ma Ingalls was unhappy.
00:14:40.360 Yeah. Okay. Ma Ingalls worked her ass off and her life was miserable. So anyone aspiring to
00:14:45.740 Ma Ingalls lifestyle right now needs to re-read those books. And then you have the ones that
00:14:50.720 are somewhere in between that they, you know, they probably do live in like suburban or ex-urban
00:14:57.900 America. And yet they're like, I'm going to be a hen fluencer. I'm going to have some chickens
00:15:02.420 and I'm going to get real big on the internet with these chickens. But like the biggest thing
00:15:08.620 that links them together is this idea that a woman's place and that her purpose is inside the
00:15:16.220 home and women should not be in the traditional workforce or that women will be unhappy in the
00:15:21.640 traditional workforce. And I think that that is what is so appealing to so many of us and to so
00:15:26.820 many young women because the workforce and America failed us as women and mothers. We were told to
00:15:33.500 lean in. We were told to be girl bosses. And then trying to be a grown ass woman, raising children,
00:15:39.880 having it all in corporate America was impossible and sucked balls for us. Okay. And so looking at 1.00
00:15:46.300 like these women who have quote unquote checked out, we're like, that is a fantasy I could get 0.99
00:15:50.000 behind. That seems nice and lovely, even though again, everyone is lying to you because you can't
00:15:54.900 have that without generational wealth, without a government safety net, you know, without the
00:16:00.300 support of a massive village. And yet, and yet, and yet, it looks really pretty on Instagram.
00:16:18.280 Do tradwives ever talk about money? No, no, they don't. They don't. Tradwives act as though money
00:16:26.200 just appears that it's something that just or not even that it just appears that it's something 0.77
00:16:31.700 almost dirty to talk about because it's so much about self-reliance and pulling yourself up by
00:16:38.960 the bootstraps they act as though all of this is just happening by their sheer virtue of hard
00:16:46.320 work um and no I mean one of the things I've always found fascinating about you know the
00:16:52.420 Ballerina Farm account and the brand. And I'm always very careful to like, I'm like, it's not
00:16:56.380 her as Ballerina Farm. Like this is a media brand. The whole Ballerina Farm umbrella is that for a
00:17:02.780 long time, and even now they're not open about it. They didn't talk about how the husband behind
00:17:08.980 the brand is a jet blue heir, how they come from so much generational wealth to make this kind of
00:17:14.340 lifestyle available to them when it's not available to the majority of people. I've also, I break down
00:17:20.080 the economics of Tradwifery, I talk to young women all the time who are like, yeah, I would love just 1.00
00:17:25.920 to raise chickens and my heirloom tomatoes and take care of kids and not have to go to a job. 0.98
00:17:31.860 And I'm like, okay, the average man in America makes about $65,000 a year. The average household
00:17:36.500 spends about $74,000 a year. How do you think you're going to do this? Do you think you're
00:17:41.620 just the magic 1% that's going to go find a rich man who is going to finance this lifestyle for
00:17:46.120 you because you're not um again it's all a fantasy everyone is lying to you everyone like you know 0.93
00:17:51.540 most households need two people in them to be self-sufficient and the trad wives are working
00:17:57.160 they're making money oftentimes more than their husbands the economics of it all is so fascinating
00:18:01.400 to me too because i found myself the other week um i was on tiktok and i think it was the first
00:18:10.300 time i watched some trad wife content and i was like no i get what you're saying and you are not
00:18:17.420 i don't entirely disagree we just have a totally opposite framing on the issue she was talking
00:18:23.600 about uh like she was essentially saying what you were saying like it is unaffordable to
00:18:29.200 live a single breadwinner multiple children kind of family today and fuck that and i think 1.00
00:18:38.580 And fuck that. And fuck that. And I think that that is what is most dangerous about a lot of these accounts, because there's a nugget of truth in all of them. Yeah. Right. Like, there is a nugget of truth in the fact that feminism in a lot of ways did fail us. 1.00
00:18:52.920 I do when I when I say that, I want to add that feminism did so much good as well and that the world didn't catch up with us that, you know, corporate America did not fulfill its promises that that there's no government safety net for women.
00:19:09.800 And there were a lot of things feminism wasn't able to do. We did indeed figure out ways to raise our daughters the way we raised our sons. But as Gloria Steinem has said so often, we did not figure out enough ways to raise our sons like our daughters. Men didn't catch up. Men are indeed a big part of this problem. And I think that has to be called out on a regular basis. 0.99
00:19:30.860 i also do not think that feminism expanded the tent enough um you know it did feel like for a 1.00
00:19:38.600 long time there was one way to be a feminist it's like you work outside the home you like 1.00
00:19:43.620 you're earning the money like you're you're the only ambition for a feminist is to have a job 1.00
00:19:50.020 outside of the home and i don't think that is fair either because stay-at-home moms are like 1.00
00:19:53.800 some of the biggest boss babes i fucking know they're the ceos of their household okay and yet 1.00
00:19:57.760 I do think that a lot of traditional feminists looked down on them for a long time. And that 1.00
00:20:01.640 has caused them to check out of the movement and be like, feminism failed me. You didn't include me 1.00
00:20:06.080 in that. We didn't make enough room for people who make choices other than corporate America.
00:20:11.320 That sucks. And so there's this nugget of truth in everything that they say. And so like,
00:20:16.700 because of that nugget, you're drawn in and you're like, okay, okay, I'll hear out the rest
00:20:21.560 of your argument. And then all of a sudden you're down the slippery slope and you own a fucking 1.00
00:20:26.140 hen house. The homeschooling is like my favorite part of all of this because like there's some 0.99
00:20:33.760 people who love homeschooling. I think those people are women who were probably meant to be
00:20:37.780 teachers, right? But like that is a small percentage. And like so many of these homesteading
00:20:42.260 accounts don't show the labor and the nitty gritty of how hard this actually is. And especially the
00:20:46.620 ones that have money, they're all just hiring tutors anyway. And then the most of the homeschool
00:20:49.940 accounts, this is the problem, are trying to sell me their homeschooling materials. And the other
00:20:54.340 thing that doesn't get brought up a lot is a lot of these families that are homeschooling their
00:20:58.280 kids are living in rural areas where there just aren't enough schools or very very poorly funded
00:21:05.600 schools right because the government is not public funding enough public education so they actually 1.00
00:21:10.460 can't send their kids to school like this isn't a choice what are trad wives selling in terms of 0.99
00:21:16.840 both like the product categories and also philosophically also the dream yeah you mean
00:21:22.980 the dream that they're selling yeah both the things both the things well i mean those and
00:21:25.740 those are two different things right like they are gap like they're capturing our attention
00:21:30.280 and because we do currently live in an attention economy attention is absolutely currency they're
00:21:36.320 capturing our attention with this fantasy they're selling the dream of an easier softer existence
00:21:44.840 again and anyone that's ever spent any time home with kids that's not soft that's not easy like
00:21:49.380 that is such hard work and the fact that they're like making this appear so beautiful and appealing
00:21:54.060 and aspirational that's the first lie right there I like spending time with my kids for a very set
00:21:59.260 prescribed amount of time they are not here right now and that is a very nice thing for me uh they're
00:22:04.700 also selling that it's just like it's a better life to live outside of the city in the countryside
00:22:10.700 in a farming community wouldn't you be so much happier and they're capitalizing on the fact that
00:22:16.580 the grass is always greener for everybody, right? If you're unhappy with your morning subway commute,
00:22:21.100 you're going to be like, God damn it. I wish that I just like lived in the country in this small 0.96
00:22:25.940 town, like in Gilmore Girls, where I could just like walk to the inn that I own and the diner and
00:22:30.700 have all these people pop up. If you live in a small town, you're like, God damn it. I just 0.99
00:22:34.920 wish I could live in a city and live the life of Carrie Bradshaw and also not have to drive my car
00:22:40.240 an hour to get groceries. And so like, they're really, they're selling the idea that the grass
00:22:44.480 is always greener. But then the things they're selling you are also highly specific. They're
00:22:49.140 selling you courses on how to homestead when most of them are probably not actually successful
00:22:53.220 homesteaders. They're selling you so many supplements. Like the Maha Trad Wife continuum
00:22:59.100 is really intense. And they've also used a lot of Trad Wife content to suck in former country 0.98
00:23:06.760 liberals and to bring them over to the Maha camp. So lots and lots of supplements. And then
00:23:13.900 stuff just like stuff all day long like an egg apron a basket a hat dresses linen pajamas
00:23:23.060 really ugly patchwork jeans like they're just like they are like they're selling you products
00:23:29.960 galore through trying to sell you a false nostalgia for a lifestyle that never really
00:23:34.600 existed for any woman and apparently we're buying and we're buying we're a hundred percent buying i
00:23:40.960 get sucked in. I have bought things from influencers before. I have ordered high protein
00:23:45.520 flour. I'm telling you, it's not bad, but it's not any better than the high protein flour that
00:23:53.600 I have got at Costco. Okay. I think that's the Bob's Red Mill or whatever. But like, yes, we do
00:24:00.000 get easily sucked in. Also, the ones that are like the real grifters that get me are the ones
00:24:05.560 who are selling you the pyramid scheme of how to make money online they're essentially trying to
00:24:11.800 teach you how to be an influencer and they're an influencer who sells courses on being an
00:24:16.780 influencer so I mean it's just a massive MLM pyramid scheme at this point what you're describing
00:24:22.520 reminds me of like uh sort of the feminized parallel to the manosphere grift because like
00:24:33.240 Andrew Tate like the way that a lot of the ways that he makes his money a lot of these influence
00:24:37.540 manosphere influencers make their money is through selling bullshit courses on like becoming a
00:24:44.500 crypto king or whatever it is how to become an influencer and it's fascinating that we are seeing 0.94
00:24:52.360 just these two at either end of a hyper gender binary pole totally opposite but similar lies
00:25:00.320 being sold but but the same but the same that's the thing I mean I Emily Amick and I talk about
00:25:05.100 this all the time we call it being pink pilled it's the same thing as the manosphere it's just
00:25:10.140 they're using influential outreach to reach women in their pain points in the same way that Andrew
00:25:16.240 Tate and this like toxic brosphere reached men with their pain points you know but the male pain
00:25:21.240 points are like do not feel like you are you know like that you're confident enough like you know
00:25:28.200 Are you lonely? Do you not have a community of other men? Do you not feel masculine enough?
00:25:33.060 Let us show you how to be a man in the world. I love my Andrew Tate voice, by the way. I think
00:25:38.160 it should probably be a little bit more British and a little bit more like slangy. But in the
00:25:43.780 same exact way, the trad wife accounts and the traditional influencers and the mahas are like,
00:25:49.800 aren't you so unhappy with work and burnout? And aren't you so tired? And we can just sell you a
00:25:56.940 better way to live and a better kind of community they're the exact same thing just from opposite
00:26:02.280 sides of the gender spectrum i know that's the only thing that's the only thing you can say you 1.00
00:26:12.400 could just sigh going back to sort of the feminist failure of it all do you think that all of the 1.00
00:26:21.120 sort of feminist discourse and hot takes, has that kind of inadvertently just made them more 1.00
00:26:30.320 mainstream? Does that make sense? Fuel, yeah, fuel the fire. I mean, one of the things we know
00:26:36.440 is that social media algorithms love controversy, you know, so the second that those algorithms
00:26:42.680 sniff out controversy, they're going to elevate the accounts that are causing it. So, you know,
00:26:48.100 by creating those rifts online, they're only making more people see those accounts and we
00:26:53.240 know that they can be very aspirational. So yes, there's that. And then yes, also it's going back
00:26:58.800 to what we talked about before of not widening the tent. And that's why I'm so careful to say
00:27:04.420 that a trad wife is not a stay at home mom. Okay. Because I do think a lot of stay at home moms
00:27:08.640 felt attacked by feminists attacking trad wives. I know people have said it to me and I'm like,
00:27:12.640 no, no, no, no, no, that's not what I believed. You know, I am very concerned about women preaching 1.00
00:27:20.640 the idea of submission to a man, that a man is a plan, that women should be checking out of the 1.00
00:27:26.340 workforce, that women, you know, should aspire only to an MRS degree and give up birth control 0.95
00:27:32.600 and have as many babies as possible. What we need to talk about is choice, like how women can have
00:27:39.200 the options and the choices in order to be ambitious in all parts of their life if you know
00:27:45.560 you want to be ambitious as a mother you should be able to do that if you want to be ambitious
00:27:50.500 as a career woman you should be able to do that if you want a hybrid of the two you should be able 1.00
00:27:55.060 to do that you know my issue with trad wives is their political leanings that are trying to strip 1.00
00:28:00.620 agency and rights away from women that's my biggest issue but I do think feminists you know 1.00
00:28:06.240 have gone about this in the wrong way um and in attacking trad wives have attacked stay-at-home
00:28:11.880 moms as well if that makes sense it does and i also think that there's an opportunity to
00:28:17.720 address the inherent like contradiction hypocrisy whatever you want to call it of
00:28:26.240 the right also getting so spun out about crises of masculinity and you know men are not okay
00:28:35.160 and at the same time they are uplifting an idea that says um hey women if you want to be
00:28:42.040 economically secure you just find a rich man and it's like well aren't you just like further 0.93
00:28:46.740 fucking with like the pressure that men already feel and like the i don't know oh yeah like it
00:28:53.420 oh yeah absolutely absolutely i mean there is a crisis of men and i i also think that 0.98
00:28:58.200 in many ways the left and progressives have ignored that you know they've made it hard to
00:29:02.380 talk about because they're like, oh, we're not going to feel sorry for men. And I'm like, look,
00:29:06.380 I get it. Like we've had it harder. You can always have, you know, a trauma tragedy Olympics to be
00:29:12.820 like, it's been fucking worse for us. We get it. Okay. But like a lot of men are fucked. Okay. 0.95
00:29:18.940 They do feel left behind. They're worse at making friends and building community than we are. So
00:29:23.260 they don't have anyone to talk to about this. Like I look at my own husband who was like a,
00:29:27.560 like a wonderful feminist supportive man. And he's like all fucked up in the head over like, 0.99
00:29:32.380 the world right now and the fact that he's not currently the breadwinner and how does he reconcile 0.98
00:29:36.620 that fact even though he's super supportive of me and my career right like like we don't live in a
00:29:42.200 culture that has supported men we don't live in a culture that supports anyone okay and so again
00:29:48.440 you know one of the things that I hear from a lot of young women who are telling me they've leaned
00:29:53.140 into this kind of traditional lifestyle because they've been pink-pilled on Instagram is that 0.89
00:29:58.800 they're like you feminists seem so angry all the time and like these trad wives they just seem so 1.00
00:30:04.420 happy and that's when I pull out the like phrase everyone is lying to you like nothing that you see 1.00
00:30:10.280 on the internet is the truth or reality but their branding is better okay like yes feminists are
00:30:16.780 angry because there's a lot to be angry about this is deserved anger but at the same time I don't 0.83
00:30:22.480 think we show nearly enough that the ability to have choices and options has made us really happy
00:30:28.240 And I mean, that's why I try to say things like as often as I can. I'm like, my happiness is
00:30:32.380 probably a nine out of 10 right now. Like I'm like, and I would like, I'm deducting a point
00:30:36.620 because I hate marketing my book so much. And like, that is just like consuming my life right
00:30:41.220 now. But I have all of the things I ever wanted in life. I'm a bestselling author. I have a
00:30:47.000 husband who's great. I have three gorgeous kids, all of whom I had after the age of 37, because
00:30:52.940 of like essentially I had access to corporate health care for my entire life, access to birth
00:30:58.880 control to decide when I would have a child and the ability to have an abortion when I got pregnant
00:31:04.300 at 16. I have my life because I had all of these things that make women's choices and options
00:31:11.660 better. And I don't think that the left emphasizes that enough. It's like you can live what the life
00:31:16.360 you want. You can have the things, but we're the ones fighting for those values for you girls.
00:31:21.160 right well and and it's like when the left has done some messaging around choice it's also though 1.00
00:31:30.000 so easy for that to quickly just spin into this choice feminism of like well anything a woman 1.00
00:31:36.840 chooses is feminism right so therefore right and that's like a word that's like a word salad right 1.00
00:31:43.440 it's always a word salad and i don't think they walk that walk is the thing because they do like 0.95
00:31:48.500 many, many women often look down. They're like, oh, you're just going to raise babies. It's the 1.00
00:31:54.820 just that is almost always there. And they look down on women who choose anything except for this
00:32:01.280 one very rigid path, which is so hard. I mean, my God, I don't work in an office. Thank the Lord
00:32:07.520 anymore. Okay. I get to work for myself. But when I was working in magazines and for tech companies,
00:32:14.340 The women above me had kids. 0.60
00:32:15.940 I didn't have kids yet. 1.00
00:32:17.420 And they're struggling to leave the office at 6, not because they still had work to do. 1.00
00:32:20.880 They're the most efficient bitches on the planet, but because it was the FaceTime. 1.00
00:32:25.040 Like if they left first, you know, they were looked down upon. 1.00
00:32:28.840 6 o'clock, someone had to get their kids at 3.30 from school.
00:32:33.140 Dinner is usually at 6.30 for small kids.
00:32:35.560 Like they were missing their kids' entire lives.
00:32:37.620 And again, not because they weren't as productive, but just because like corporate America wasn't
00:32:40.840 set up to accommodate mothers.
00:32:43.200 still isn't corporate america and also even just american homes too well american homes too i mean
00:32:50.440 when we were living in san francisco um the public school district your schools were assigned by
00:32:58.060 lottery and they could you could be assigned anywhere in the city so like literally miles
00:33:03.560 from your house and there was no bus system so a parent or you'd have to pay someone very very well
00:33:11.500 to be getting your kid to school if you were a person who had to get to a job at nine o'clock.
00:33:16.420 Like nothing was like set up to accommodate the two things unless you were outsourcing a lot of
00:33:22.180 this care. I mean, we moved back to Philadelphia mostly, probably for a lot of reasons because I
00:33:28.160 had help. It's so much more affordable. They can go to a public school that is literally four
00:33:32.400 blocks from our house and like all of our kids can go there until eighth grade. But like that
00:33:38.160 is not the way in most of america the world is not set up for for parents or really just set up
00:33:43.140 to like take care of anyone at this point and now like enter trad wives and it's like well the answer
00:33:48.900 is just give up and revert back the answer is give up the answer is give like the answer is make i
00:33:56.460 mean it's it's very mega coded it's make america great again but again they're like when is the
00:34:02.580 again? Is the again back in the prairie days? Is the again back in the 1950s when every woman was
00:34:09.920 fucking miserable? I love cosplay of 1950s America because I would like everyone to watch 1.00
00:34:19.480 Betty Draper on Madman. Betty Draper is the saddest character that's ever been on television.
00:34:25.540 uh my grandmother was a very tratty trad wife in the 50s mostly because she was fucking rich 0.97
00:34:33.200 okay like again like you could only live that life if you were already very wealthy and so like 0.98
00:34:39.680 they were pretty rich and she was a child wife and she was miserable until my grandfather died
00:34:45.000 okay like hated her life uh and so like that's the reality that we're not seeing but again the
00:34:51.820 pictures look pretty and the reels look pretty and when you're like a mom juggling all of the
00:34:56.700 things and like trying to make it work and also working 19 jobs like so many of us do right now
00:35:01.520 you look at someone just sitting in a field with their kids and you're like that does look nice
00:35:07.520 although we're up here in the mountains right now and I've been sitting in a field with my kids
00:35:12.220 a lot and it's so itchy I'm so itchy right now that like I love outdoors and I love the mountains
00:35:20.680 But like my whole body is a mosquito bite. 1.00
00:35:32.280 What kind of, we touched on this earlier, what kind of political influence do you think that trad wives possess? 1.00
00:35:41.640 Oh, I mean, it's very right and MAGA coded. 0.97
00:35:45.040 I mean, honestly, and also very evangelical Christian, very Mormon.
00:35:48.780 And we do know that the early mom influencers and still a very large majority of mom influencers
00:35:55.620 come from the Mormon faith because, you know, Mormonism has been, you know, very big on
00:36:01.440 first it was journaling, then early blogging.
00:36:04.020 It's like spread the word through sharing your life through this content.
00:36:07.820 And so that's why most of the early mom influencers were young Mormon women.
00:36:13.360 And so there is a hard right political influence. We also know that Turning Point USA, Charlie Kirk's organization, has funded a lot of trad wife influencers, has funded a lot of trad wife messaging. Peter Thiel is currently funding or did fund. I'm not sure if he's still doing it. I want to make sure I get it right.
00:36:33.960 evie magazine the the right-leaning cosmo which is now pushing ditch the pill and pronatalism 0.94
00:36:40.680 um and also that women's sole purpose is to be in the home uh we know that a lot of this is right 0.70
00:36:48.740 coded and maga coded but they're very good at they're often very good at hiding their politics 0.99
00:36:53.920 um and that and that's the thing i mean the left again is wearing our politics like
00:36:58.360 on our sleeves and on our t-shirts all of the time uh whereas they're hiding theirs and it's
00:37:03.940 a lot more subversive. You know, it's you're going to dive into an article about why these
00:37:08.840 celebrities are choosing to go off birth control, which was a legit headline that Evie magazine just 1.00
00:37:14.380 ran and be like, oh, my gosh, like all these other women are doing it. Maybe I should think about 0.99
00:37:19.240 this. And then, you know, the slippery slope from there is a lot of women start thinking birth 0.99
00:37:24.740 control doesn't matter. And then it makes it a lot easier for our government to ban birth control 0.66
00:37:29.060 because no one's fighting for it anymore. I mean, that's the path here. That's the goal.
00:37:32.900 charlie kirk said it uh you know you change the culture you win the war and they've been working
00:37:39.300 for 10 years to change the culture and especially through influencers because they knew they didn't
00:37:44.520 have hollywood for a long time so like we have to build our own celebrities and they did it and
00:37:48.960 it's working and we've seen it we saw it with the men with the joe rogan bro sphere and now we're
00:37:54.820 seeing it with the women with the trad wives with the maha influencers with women like alex clark
00:38:00.580 like you know these are huge influencers their content gets millions of views a day
00:38:05.880 and I don't think we're paying nearly enough attention to it why aren't we paying enough
00:38:10.320 attention to it hubris I really think it is hubris I think you know it gets dismissed as
00:38:18.060 fringe or fluffy and again because it's women who are moms and who are wives who are showing
00:38:26.160 these beautiful pictures who are doing it and we're like oh my god no one's paying and by we 0.84
00:38:29.960 I mean, feminism at large, the left at large, no one's paying attention to any of that.
00:38:34.320 And the fact is, people are.
00:38:35.740 The fact is, young girls are going off of birth control now, largely because they've
00:38:40.620 seen a lot of these wellness accounts and things like what Evie Magazine is pushing.
00:38:46.880 Or they see accounts like Ballerina Farm with her many, many, many children.
00:38:52.580 And they're like, oh, I should just have a bunch of, I can have it all.
00:38:56.340 look like you know this this is so beautiful and idyllic why don't i just have nine children
00:39:01.600 meanwhile i've got three children and it's so many children so many and it's not just a thing
00:39:06.680 of you know ditch your birth control and have children but do that when you are young when
00:39:13.120 you are in your early 20s totally totally like go i mean literally at turning point usa's young
00:39:21.520 leadership conference last week, a young girl got up and said to Charlie Kirk, should I go to
00:39:26.340 college? And he was like, only if you want to get your MRS degree. And I saw that clip and the crowd
00:39:33.940 was like, interestingly, I think there is an argument to bring back the MRS degree
00:39:40.160 and no, seriously. And just be clear. That's why you're going to college, right? Don't lie to
00:39:47.060 yourself. Like, don't like, oh, I'm going, I'm studying sociology. No, you're not. We know why
00:39:50.580 here and that's okay actually and that's a really good reason to go to college actually
00:39:55.800 especially an sec school they're like yay um and again the danger in that that like we just have
00:40:05.100 to dig into so much of it it's like a man is just not the plan girl like okay if you want an MRS
00:40:11.220 degree and you want to have kids cool can you have a discussion where he's giving you a salary
00:40:15.400 every month and you're putting it away in a 401k or you're buying like investment properties just
00:40:20.280 for you in your name so you have financial independence if and when he leaves you or dies.
00:40:26.260 Like, come on. It is just like, it makes no sense to me. And when I've interviewed former
00:40:32.360 trad wives, they're like, I was fucked. Like, actually fucked when he left me. I had no money. 1.00
00:40:39.580 I had no resume. I had no way to support my family, who he's no longer interested in because
00:40:44.560 he's found a younger model. Man is just never the plan. And that's part of the reason that I write
00:40:52.160 the books that I do. My goal is always to write a fun book. Everyone is Lying to is a delicious
00:40:58.080 beach read. Sicilian Inheritance was like an escapist fun, again, easy, great read. But both
00:41:07.220 of them, there's no man that is the plan. There's no knight in shining armor. The women rescue
00:41:13.460 themselves and they rescue each other, which is what mirrors real life. And those are the kinds 1.00
00:41:18.180 of things we should be showing. A friend of mine recently asked me a question I will pose now to
00:41:23.840 you. Is there anything good about trad wife culture? Yeah, no, I mean, and I think one of 1.00
00:41:34.100 the things that I learned about influencing early on when I started doing the Under the Influence
00:41:37.840 podcast is just how awesome it has been for women to be able to create their own businesses 0.91
00:41:44.380 through the democratization of social media, right? Like women are running their own media 0.99
00:41:48.860 companies. They are able to create their own schedules where they can care for children 1.00
00:41:53.240 and also build a brand and also make their own money. That is great. What Trad Wives have also
00:42:00.040 done in a lot of cases is, you know, get us talking about all of the things that women do 1.00
00:42:07.340 do in the home again. Like it's now cool to be someone who cooks and gardens and cares for a 1.00
00:42:14.140 household. They've done a lot for that kind of branding. And that's great. And again, because
00:42:18.460 women should have choices and options and be able to be ambitious about any of the things that we 1.00
00:42:24.080 want to be ambitious about. Those are good things. The problem really becomes when it gets coded in 1.00
00:42:31.140 ways that make women care less about their rights. Because if women want all of these like beautiful 1.00
00:42:36.400 things and these lifestyle options, we have to have a very basic set of rights. And that's what 1.00
00:42:42.240 the right is switching is, you know, getting rid of right now. Is it too late for cultural 0.93
00:42:48.760 intervention from the law? No, no, absolutely not. I don't think so. I mean, I talk about this
00:42:54.780 all of the time. I think we just have to see what they're doing. I think that we can build
00:42:59.660 machines to build it better. You know, we do need to make the things that the left
00:43:04.980 supports women to do seem more aspirational. And again, I mean, that is why I talk about the
00:43:12.140 fact I'm like, I have a perfect fucking, a near perfect fucking life because of birth control. 0.99
00:43:16.860 Okay. Like, did I like it all the time? No. But like, did I also get to build a career and now 0.99
00:43:22.380 have like three children after the age of 35 with the person I was meant to instead of some like 1.00
00:43:27.680 douchebag that I had sex with after fashion week one night. Okay. So like, I think that's the kind 0.98
00:43:33.540 of talk we have to be having. The left also just like suffered so much from all of our cancel
00:43:38.020 culture bullshit in the past three years where it's just like if anytime anyone said anything, 0.99
00:43:43.580 were getting attacked. And so we stopped talking, we stopped having real talk about these kinds of 0.96
00:43:49.020 things, because we all got scared. And the right took advantage of that, frankly. So no, I think
00:43:55.240 we can absolutely come back from this, we have to get a lot more comfortable with different
00:43:59.180 viewpoints with like having nuanced conversations with letting people speak their minds a little bit 1.00
00:44:05.360 more and have a more welcoming tent to what it means to be a feminist and also just better 1.00
00:44:10.240 branding that our policies are what make women's lives better have any of the trad wives you
00:44:14.300 interviewed read it yeah a couple of them did and they really liked it they're like this is a fun
00:44:20.000 book it's fun read you know trad wife approved yeah trad i should put a stamp on it that says
00:44:25.440 trad wife approved a beautiful artisanal handmade stamp though totally but also like probably not
00:44:31.400 jd vance approved so i'm and i'm like oh my god i would love if turning point banned me like that
00:44:36.060 would be the most fun ever so i keep sending jd vance and like charlie kirk copies of the book
00:44:41.360 okay and ladies now you get to treat yourself to everyone is lying to you anywhere books are sold
00:44:53.740 follow joe on instagram at joe piazza author listen to under the influence with joe piazza
00:45:00.680 uh, well, Patreon supporters, y'all are getting an exclusive deep dive into the far-right trad
00:45:08.260 wife marriage and also how all of it compares to non-trad momfluencers. If you would like to
00:45:16.140 support me, my work, Unladylike Media, please head over to patreon.com slash unladylikemedia.
00:45:23.200 become a subscriber five dollars a month is such a huge support and if you have ideas requests
00:45:31.400 collaborations that you want to throw my way hello at unladylike.co thank you all i love you take care
00:45:39.800 goodbye what is the most unladylike thing about you if we're describing ladylike in the way that 0.78
00:45:50.360 the trads do I would say it's the fact that I make more than four times my husband like I mean 1.00
00:45:56.780 and that's and that's a hard thing too I mean Nick and I have had to negotiate what that looks like
00:46:01.300 and like how he feels about that and I don't think it's a forever thing but it is a fact that you
00:46:06.860 know a lot of men are being laid off from jobs and so right now yeah the most unladylike thing
00:46:12.160 about me is that I am the breadwinner in my family and my husband is the full-time caregiver and I
00:46:18.480 wish that we didn't consider it unladylike amen