00:00:00.000Hello and welcome to Vulgar History. My name is Anne Foster and this is my feminist women's1.00
00:00:17.680history comedy podcast and you might notice an improvement or maybe just like a change or
00:00:23.140difference in the audio quality and that is I watched a tutorial on how to use my microphone
00:00:27.880and I think I'm talking into the correct part of it now. So hopefully you're able to hear me a bit
00:00:33.080better because this is a one-woman operation and I'm figuring this out as I go along. So welcome
00:00:39.560to the podcast. This is the fifth episode of the podcast and the first one since I've been iTunes
00:00:46.240official. So welcome to all the new fans who came to me from iTunes and, you know, shout out to all
00:00:52.280the fans who've been there since day one as I figure out what the hell I'm doing. So this is
00:00:57.260a podcast where I look at the stories of women from history, and then we score them at the end0.73
00:01:01.940based on their, the four categories, which are scandalousness, scheminess, significance. And
00:01:08.520then we give them a bonus for how, how much sexism might have impacted the things that happened to
00:01:13.480them. It's a fun ride. Welcome aboard. So the first episodes that we've done of the show,
00:01:19.240the first four episodes, we did one royal, two noble women, and one woman with connections
00:01:27.220to royalty. So in terms of women's history, and the women's history that we're looking at on this
00:01:34.720podcast so far, similar to what I have personally studied, is that of European, Western European
00:01:42.740Australian women. As per the quote by Laurel Fletcher Ulrich that inspired this season,
00:01:49.060well-behaved women seldom make history. And I dive into that in some previous episodes. So if1.00
00:01:54.740you've caught up to that, awesome. Or if not, briefly, basically what she was talking about
00:01:59.720in an essay when she said that instantly iconic phrase is basically the only time that women pop0.98
00:02:07.620up in records are when perhaps when they get married, because there would be often documentation0.92
00:02:14.560about that when they died, maybe when they had children, even when they were royal, sometimes
00:02:19.040you don't get all of those things. And even then you might not get anything more than that. The
00:02:24.840only women who you hear more about are people who, I guess, for lack of a better term, misbehaved.0.99
00:02:31.360So people who somehow stepped outside of the status quo and what was expected of them in0.98
00:02:35.620society. And that's who we know about. And there are so many, I'm sure, amazing, cool women who
00:02:40.740were well-behaved and we just don't know what they were up to. And that sucks. And
00:02:44.980hopefully we can look at their stories somehow once time travel is invented and we can go back
00:02:50.340and learn their stories. But until then, the ones that I'm personally choosing to look at for this
00:02:55.140podcast are the women who, especially for the season, quote unquote, misbehaved. And so we've0.85
00:03:00.360looked at people with connections to the nobility, to the royalty. And today's topic is a woman who
00:03:07.340had no connections to either. She was an absolutely standard issue, peasant woman.1.00
00:03:15.140And what happened in her life is why we know about her. And this is so messed up.0.99
00:03:21.340here we go so we're looking at the story of mary toft who i'll give a little content warning just
00:03:31.100because we're going to get into this is vulgar history in the name of the topic of the of the
00:03:36.300show you see that i'm going to maybe say some some vulgar things i might have a swear word here then
00:03:41.600um all the podcasts so far that i've uploaded actually i've had to put the explicit filter on
00:03:46.640So this is like, prepare yourselves. But also today, we're going to be like, not shying away
00:03:51.120from the gynecological details of some absolutely horrific stuff that involved vis-a-vis dead animal0.99
00:03:58.420parts inside of her vagina. So just content warning, that's not for everybody. And we're0.92
00:04:04.420going to be talking about that a lot for the next like, meh, 45 minutes. So here we go.
00:04:09.740This story begins with the parents, whose names are Jane and John Denyer. They were
00:04:15.580so when we say like working class like or even high class or lower class like basically
00:04:22.080this is the year 1703 is when mary was born and so it was a sort of situation where you've got
00:04:28.640sort of like your nobility your aristocracy you've got your royals and then you've kind of got
00:04:34.100like really poor people like homeless level people and then you've kind of got like the working poor
00:04:40.940and that's kind of what they were more than like working class i'd say they were like the working
00:04:45.620poor so john and jane denier they had five children overall all together and their oldest was a girl
00:04:53.200named mary so she was born mary denier and she was baptized february 21st 1703 and like a lot of
00:05:02.760people not just women not just working poor people but just like anyone in general even like royals
00:05:10.300people whose every action you'd think would be written down like no one really knows much about
00:05:14.520what she got up to because no one really wrote down a lot of what anyone was getting up to because
00:05:18.260everyone was too busy working the fields etc but when she was 17 years old Mary Denier married a
00:05:24.840man or a boy she was 17 and her husband was 18 year old Joshua Toft and so this is young to be
00:05:33.400married even then even though there's sort of this sort of misconception slash myth that people got
00:05:40.200married when they were like 12 or whatever back then. And I mean, like, yeah, betrothals happened
00:05:44.040between rich people. But for a 17 year old girl to marry an 18 year old boy, probably either they
00:05:50.740were in love, or she was pregnant, or one or the other, or both. So basically, they got married in
00:05:57.820the year 1720. And Joshua Toft's family becomes important. So we're gonna dive a little bit into
00:06:04.980who they were and what that whole situation was. So Joshua Toft was the sixth of 12 children
00:06:12.400and his family, the Tofts were better off than Mary's family, the Deniers. So they had been0.97
00:06:19.160working for several centuries, like literally hundreds of years as clothiers. And this is the
00:06:26.360sort of thing like we're seeing these days with people talking about like, you know, agriculture
00:06:30.160industry or like coal mining or things where it's like, this was a thing of family occupation
00:06:35.420business that people did for a really, really long time, but then sort of industrial change
00:06:40.720and times change and the weather and whatever makes it less tenable as a career choice.
00:06:46.360And so for them, their choice of being clothiers was not doing super well by the year 1720,
00:06:53.120which is when Joshua married his friend, Mary.
00:06:55.580So a clothier, in this sense, basically means somebody who is in charge of sort of a fabric slash clothing making organization. So the clothier would be people, the head bosses, they would sort of employ people who would shear the sheep, they would employ the people that would like turn that into wool, they would hire the people who made that wool into fabric, like it's a whole sort of fashion empire situation.
00:07:22.640But basically, the Tofts had been, they had sort of made their fortune and their reputation through the successful clothiary business. But by 1720, they were sort of more on the shearing sheep level of work than the like overseeing an entire company level, but they still called themselves clothiers on census documents. So that's still kind of how they presented themselves.
00:07:45.460So like the Toft family had a good pedigree, but they weren't especially financially well off. And especially Joshua being the sixth of 12 children, there wasn't a lot of money for him personally to inherit or to have.
00:08:02.560though he himself worked in the family clothier business as well. So Mary and Joshua's first
00:08:09.860child was a daughter named Mary, which is just a thing that people used to do that I wouldn't
00:08:15.180mind seeing come back again, which is that daughters were given the same names as their
00:08:20.000mothers. I think it's cute. So Mary Toft had a daughter, also called Mary Toft, who was born
00:08:26.120sometime around when they were married, probably around 17, let's say 21. And then in 1723,
00:08:32.760Mary gave birth to a second child, a daughter whose name was Anne. Amazing name. I'm also in
00:08:37.980favor of people being called Anne, but this Anne unfortunately died of smallpox, aged around four
00:08:43.520months, which is awful. And then the next year, they had a son whose name was James. So it's 1724.
00:08:51.660before mary has been married for four years so she's 21 years old mother of three she and james
00:08:59.200were renting a home from a farmer and as this is like not a weird arrangement this is just like
00:09:06.000what what was up so they rented a home from a farmer and as a condition of living there they
00:09:11.020worked for the farmer in his fields so this meant that during her three pregnancies and then also
00:09:20.040like postpartum, like just after having had the babies, she would be not just working in the
00:09:26.460fields, but also basically walking, commuting to the fields. And it was basically something like
00:09:31.840a two hour walk there, two hour walk back. The work was very physical work. And that was just
00:09:38.180what the situation of her life was. So Mary worked in the fields more than her husband did,
00:09:43.440because he also had to dedicate some of his time to being a clothier. He was a journeyman
00:09:50.380clothier, which is like one step up of an apprentice, I think. So he was sort of like
00:09:56.020on this career path, but there weren't very many jobs for clothiers. So he was basically a poorly
00:10:01.920paid laborer slash working on the farmland of the place where they were renting slash his wife was
00:10:08.640also working on that same farmland. And that is what is going on in their lives. So just to set
00:10:15.140the scene. So by the time they were both 25 years old, they were the parents of two small children,
00:10:21.720one of whom had recently just died. They're both working, physically demanding low paying jobs in
00:10:27.040a community where the Tofts used to be wealthy, but now weren't anymore. And Mary was pregnant
00:10:33.340again. So as far as they knew, there's going to be one more mouth to feed. Any minute now,0.95
00:10:39.060more money would be fantastic and also less backbreaking work and also her getting to put
00:10:45.520her feet up, but that's not going to happen. So in August 1726, so again, Mary is 25 years old.
00:10:55.780Yes. 25-ish years old. She has a miscarriage. So this story, as I mentioned at the beginning,
00:11:03.020in the content warning has a lot of gynecological information involved in it. And a lot of it is0.66
00:11:10.120self-reported gynecological information from Mary Toft, who was a woman living in the early
00:11:15.9001700s, which was a time when even the doctors didn't know what was going on in terms of a
00:11:22.740uterus, a cervix. So she's just sort of like saying, here's what it felt like to me. So what
00:11:29.020she later described this miscarriage as was she described passing an object as big as her arm
00:11:34.620and then experiencing a flooding, quote unquote, that lasted about a week. So we can assume some
00:11:42.340cramps were happening. We can assume bleeding was happening. The other women who she worked with in
00:11:48.340the fields likely would have covered for her because she couldn't do this whole job she was1.00
00:11:53.580doing. She couldn't commute there. But what was unusual to her and others about this was that0.96
00:11:59.760her miscarriage didn't look like a baby. It looked like an object. And they all thought it looked
00:12:08.480quote unquote monstrous. So Mary Tuft went back to work as soon as she could. But then three weeks
00:12:16.760later, while she was working in the field, she experienced further flooding. This is the word
00:12:21.620that she used herself to describe what's happening. So I'm guessing bleeding, cramping situations and
00:12:26.620great pain. So this was some sort of, it was like a two part miscarriage situation, perhaps. And
00:12:35.160this is where I'm just going to say that I off the record consulted with a woman who I know who is a
00:12:41.760obstetrician slash gynecologist just to say like, here's what Mary Toft was saying. What do you
00:12:48.120think this was and so she said again totally just like you know in those magazine articles where
00:12:53.780it's like the body language expert is like oh here's what this means when this person put her
00:12:58.980arm like this in the picture it's like this person didn't actually is not the psychologist of these
00:13:03.340people so the woman who I consulted I just gave her here's Mary Toft's recounting what do you
00:13:08.260think this was and so what she suggested based on sort of the description of the miscarriage
00:13:14.040and what it looked like, the miscarriage situation, might have been an incomplete
00:13:19.900molar pregnancy, M-O-L-A-R. So this is what happens when a non-viable fertilized egg implants
00:13:26.680in the uterus. So totally unpleasant, awful, traumatizing thing to happen to her.
00:13:32.380But at this point, her in-laws, the Toft family, thought like, well, what if this was a monster
00:13:39.520And then we could get rich by saying, Mary Toph just gave birth to a monster.
00:19:12.300And so she took the quote unquote monster to a surgeon slash midwife who lived nearby so he could tell them what was going on.
00:19:20.460And the surgeon slash midwife is a man named John Howard.
00:19:25.960and to his credit he was like this seems unlikely like thank you so much for bringing me this um
00:19:33.740perhaps skinned vivisected cat carcass with eel inside of it and saying that it came out of a0.91
00:19:40.720vagina but that is just like pretty hard for me to believe but not just because that's like of0.59
00:19:46.120course it's hard for them to believe that's impossible but his reasoning was like there's0.80
00:19:49.320not a head on this and i guess they had cut the head off of the cat body i'm just looking at my
00:19:54.660cat it's like little cat ancestors so yeah he was like if mary had actually given birth to this
00:20:01.760monster there would be head on it but there's not a head on this ergo this woman didn't give birth
00:20:06.640to this monster but he was like so i'll just come over to the house and see what's going on
00:20:10.700because you know given birth maybe the head is there i don't know what he was thinking this
00:20:14.780whole situation gets like super weird like even weirder so john howard came by and by the time
00:20:22.920he got there, Mary just happened to be going in quote unquote, going into labor again. Um,
00:20:28.820her mother-in-law and delivered more dead cat bits, which I guess were from the same cat or
00:20:34.800a different cat. Like, does it matter? I don't know. So John Howard was like, Hmm, like you
00:20:40.440witnessed this happening or he witnessed Mary screaming. And then someone being like, look,
00:20:46.220this cat just came out of her or whatever, but there still wasn't a cat head or a cat tail.
00:20:51.160and he's like great i see that she may have just given birth to this monster situation but again
00:20:57.860without a head i just can't get on board so somehow uh margaret and ann toft had lost track
00:21:06.620of the cat head and there wasn't another one nearby or whatever so they decided to go for
00:21:12.120rabbit bits because there were rabbits were easier to come by than cats and so they just1.00
00:21:17.400wanted to stuff some dead animal up inside of Mary's vagina because this whole thing is a1.00
00:21:23.340nightmare. So pause, side note on rabbits in general, which is just to say that there was0.99
00:21:32.520a lot of rabbits all over England at this time. Maybe there are still, I don't know. I don't live
00:21:36.620there, but hundreds of years before. So medieval lords, like back in the day, in the day, medieval
00:21:42.480lords had built uh sort of little rabbit warrens to raise rabbits for meat and fur so the medieval
00:21:49.060lords could have the meat and the fur for their fancy medieval lord outfits and meals etc but
00:21:55.080rabbits cannot be tamed so they escaped from these enclosures and became basically pests
00:21:59.780to the working poor to lower status people to the farmers etc so just rabbits the whole peter
00:22:06.380rabbit situation the rabbits would come into people's farms eat all their lettuce etc so
00:22:11.340So rabbits were all over the place, making them the easiest thing for the Tofts to acquire.
00:22:17.580But also the rabbits had this sort of political implication as they were sort of seen as symbolic of the carelessness of the upper classes.
00:22:24.600So this is where the whole situation takes on a sort of political context that Margaret and Anne may or may not have consciously thought about.
00:22:35.440But that becomes part of the story as well, because this is just getting wilder.0.97
00:22:39.540It's, I know we've already had an eel in a headless cat inside a woman's vagina and a0.89
00:22:47.600doctor being like, but with no head did this happen, but this is going to get weirder.0.96
00:28:01.540and armies scattered like bones in the dust.
00:28:04.700Now the survivors claw to what's left of a broken world, praying the darkness chooses someone else tonight.
00:28:12.620But in the shadow dark, the darkness always wins.
00:28:16.900This is old school adventuring at its most cruel.
00:28:20.400Your torch ticks down in real time, and when that flame dies, something else rises to finish the job.
00:28:26.300This is a brutal rules light nightmare with a story that emerges organically based on the decisions that the characters make.
00:28:33.820This is what it felt like to play RPGs in the 80s, and man, it is so good to be back.
00:28:38.620Join the Glass Cannon podcast as we plunge into the shadow dark every Thursday night at 8 p.m. Eastern on youtube.com slash the glass cannon with the podcast version dropping the next day.
00:28:49.300See what everybody's talking about and join us in the dark.
00:28:56.700Welcome to the realms of peril and glory.
00:29:01.960Explore the mechanically magical vistas of Vale,
00:29:06.360the paranormal mysteries of liminal London,
00:29:15.220Be awed by our incredible guests from familiar shows like Oxventure and No Rolls Barred.
00:29:22.840Search realms of peril and glory to find out more.
00:29:26.120The world of Sonic the Hedgehog has been thrust into a not-so-dark, not-so-stormy, hard-boiled detective story that probably nobody saw coming.
00:29:42.100Follow Sonic and the Intrepid Chaotix Detective Agency as they take on their biggest case yet.
00:29:48.920This high-flying, action-packed adventure will take them across the world, fighting for every quill they can fight.
00:30:14.020All will be revealed in Sonic the Hedgehog Presents The Chaotix Case Files.
00:30:20.840Listen now, wherever you get your podcasts.0.93
00:30:26.120and we're back so the fact that she mary toft was having these rabbit parts put inside of her0.99
00:30:38.500vagina and then john howard repeatedly delivering them it's incredible she didn't die from this0.99
00:30:44.220which spoiler she doesn't so he was delivering the pointy claws of dead rabbits from her vagina0.99
00:30:52.180like so it wasn't like a whole rabbit all up all at once it was like parts at a time and so over0.96
00:30:58.320the course of like a day she would quote unquote deliver a whole rabbit with her mother and sister
00:31:04.680mother-in-law and sister-in-law the ones like helping to slide the bits up inside of her but0.82
00:31:09.480mary was the one who had to like spread her legs and deliver these rabbit parts so basically at
00:31:16.760this point, John Howard was spending so much time with her and her like rabbit birth situation that
00:31:22.800he entirely moved his entire medical practice so he could be with her 24 hours a day because one
00:31:28.480never knew when a new rabbit part might need to be delivered. And he was the doctor that delivered
00:31:32.740the rabbit babies. So by the end of November, 1726, Mary Toft had given birth to, did you hear
00:31:40.380my little quotes quote-unquote given birth to 12 complete rabbits piece by piece from her vagina1.00
00:31:49.060they like the pieces were put up the pieces were removed 12 rabbits so sometimes she had to keep0.85
00:31:57.800rabbit bits up inside of her for days or even weeks so john howard wouldn't see them being put
00:32:02.620inside and again the fact she didn't die of a blood infection is really speaks to the resiliency
00:32:09.060of her immune system. So while this was all going on, so John Howard was like, this is great. I'm
00:32:14.620the man who delivered the rabbits, but they weren't getting as famous as he wanted. Or as
00:32:19.140the Tofts had obviously also wanted. Mary, again, I don't think this was what she wanted for herself,
00:32:25.680but she would get some of the money as well. Basically they're like, we just, how do we take
00:32:29.520this to the next level? Which is like, oh my God, like what is the next level of this? So we'll find
00:32:36.360So what happened is John Howard wrote letters to every rich and important person he knew, hoping for more publicity, which would bring him more money and glory. And to be prepared, he pickled all the rabbit bits that he delivered. And he offered to like take his little jars of pickled rabbit bits. He could bring them to your dinner party. He could bring them to your soiree. He could bring them to your medical lecture and he could talk about it.
00:33:00.620So basically, he was blabbing about this so much that basically, eventually, a small notice came up in a newspaper in London, saying like, this woman's been giving birth to rabbits, like, isn't that weird? And that newspaper article gained the attention of some men who served the king. Some of the courtiers of the king at this time was King George, the first.
00:33:24.020And one of the people who noticed this or who heard about it from the newspaper article was the king's personal physician, which is a man named Nathaniel St. Andre. And so now this takes this whole story takes its next mega twist moment, courtesy of the king and St. Andre.
00:33:42.720So first of all, a note on King George I. So he was the grandnephew, so not the grandson, but the grandnephew of Queen Anne I, as played by Olivia Colman in The Favourite. So if you remember from The Favourite, also a movie with a lot of rabbits in it, also related to fertility.
00:34:01.000so the queen anne the first had given birth to so many children and sadly none of them survived
00:34:08.880childhood she had a huge number of miscarriages as well so basically she was the queen and no one
00:34:14.420knew who would inherit from her because she did not have any surviving children so basically
00:34:20.100because she died without any living heirs and she was protestant and nobody wanted a catholic to
00:34:25.440inherit. They just sort of looked at her family tree to figure, like, who is the next closely
00:34:31.000related to her Protestant person? And that was George. So the thing about George is he was
00:34:38.060German, and he never learned how to speak English, despite being the king of Britain.
00:34:44.740And he spent most of his reign, like, literally living in Germany, not even in England.
00:34:51.260all of which to say when it came time for george the first to hire a personal physician to be his
00:34:57.900doctor in england he was like well as long as the doctor speaks german that's fine so as his doctor
00:35:04.000he chose nathaniel saint andre who was from switzerland who spoke german and who's also
00:35:10.640a terrible doctor slash even worse person slash okay so we'll get into it so nathaniel saint andre
00:35:19.420had a long history of odd behavior. If you, there's not time in here to get into all of the
00:35:26.080Nathaniel St. Andre of it, but his story involves like wife stealing. His story involves poisoning.
00:35:32.600His story involves like, was he even really a doctor? Like he was just a messy bitch who lived1.00
00:35:36.860for drama, Nathaniel St. Andre. So he happened to find himself caught up in weird scandals a lot1.00
00:35:43.300more than basically anybody else because he loved scandal. He loved drama. And if there was a scandal
00:35:49.160happening, he would like fling himself into the middle of it because he was desperate to keep his
00:35:53.580name in the newspapers as this like famous eccentric genius. So he just really wanted to
00:35:59.580be associated with anything dramatic. John Howard just wanted money, basically. And Mary Toft is
00:36:06.980just like this person in the middle of all these other people's wild ambitions, which is such a0.98
00:36:11.760common, I mean, not this story, not the rabbit vagina situation of it all. But it's such a common0.82
00:36:18.380thing of like a bunch of men are just really ambitious about something and they see a way
00:36:23.300to get power and the way to do it is just by using a woman like to a different extent this is sort of
00:36:29.040the story of uh the beginning of queen elizabeth the first sis reign but anyway mary toft is having0.99
00:36:37.680i mean she's suffering she's physically suffering like having rabbits pulled out of your vagina1.00
00:36:45.100every day. Having to put in and then pull out the pointy bits. Like she just had a miscarriage. Like1.00
00:36:52.620anyway, so she's just like, she didn't want this. She didn't want this, but more and more people
00:37:00.620around her are just like counting on her to keep doing this so that they will get rich or more0.52
00:37:05.920powerful or whatever. So basically the story of her rabbit births by now had gotten so locally
00:37:13.020famous that, you know, there wasn't paparazzi or whatever, but basically she couldn't stay in her
00:37:17.100little house that they were renting from the farmer, who was also her boss. So she's moved
00:37:21.900to a bigger town. John Howard came along with her to live in this town where she just continued.
00:37:27.220And, you know, hopefully her mother-in-law and sister-in-law came along too, so they could like1.00
00:37:31.520procure rabbit carcasses and shove them up inside of her. Actually, the person who was procuring1.00
00:37:37.600the rabbit carcassus was her husband, Joshua. Remember him from back before the story got so
00:37:43.900distressing. So he's basically running around buying dead baby rabbits from whatever, I don't
00:37:50.100know, rabbit vendors there are. And he was not being discreet whatsoever. Like later, the rabbit
00:37:56.220vendors would be like, he would come up and say stuff like, yeah, I need to buy some rabbits for1.00
00:38:00.040my wife. Like, do you have any dead rabbits? It'd be great if they were dead baby rabbits.1.00
00:38:04.540my wife needs dead baby rabbits no reason so it was not a smooth operation oceans 11 it is not
00:38:14.420so nathaniel saint andre was like i'm into this and so he swept up in town just in time
00:38:20.480to personally witness mary's 15th rabbit birth so nathaniel saint andre horrible person0.95
00:38:28.860messy bitch who lived for drama technically the king's personal physician in england but also just0.95
00:38:35.300like also a terrible doctor so he personally helped her deliver one of these rabbits and then1.00
00:38:42.580he ran off to autopsy it to see like what's going on you know like is this some sort of human fetus
00:38:47.840that looks like a rabbit like what's the deal and so it's at this point that one of the things he
00:38:52.960did was he took the lungs of the rabbit put them in water and they floated and the reason he did
00:39:00.200that was to see like if they floated that means that those lungs had breathed air and so the
00:39:05.360rabbit seemed to have been born dead but like if the lungs had air in them that means the rabbit
00:39:11.180at some point breathed which means it probably didn't grow inside of matoft's uterus but he was
00:39:18.940not ready to to debunk this he was there to support it basically so he just like didn't really
00:39:25.720get too concerned about that like i guess there's just air inside of her uterus like why not there's
00:39:30.700already rabbits growing there so and just after this autopsy he went over he was called back to
00:39:35.800her side again and witnessed the birth of another rabbit carcass and so now he also not just
00:39:43.040autopsying the the rabbit bits but he also examined her whole vaginal area did a little
00:39:51.020peeking around seeing what's up he's like let's just see if there's any more rabbit parts
00:39:56.000hiding up inside here and he's like nope i don't see anything in there so i guess0.99
00:40:00.640i guess you're not secretly putting rabbit parts inside your vagina and then he left0.99
00:40:05.240but then he came back and he delivered another dead rabbit and he was like oh my god i looked0.99
00:40:10.620inside her vagina there's no rabbit parts there then she delivered a rabbit so like i am convinced0.94
00:40:16.220but also he went in there like ready to be convinced he didn't require much convincing1.00
00:40:21.300and then also later like as much as one can love a detail in a story as profoundly fucked up as
00:40:27.920this story i love this detail which is in her later deposition mary explained that like when0.98
00:40:34.020he looked up inside her vagina there were rabbit parts there there literally were he just didn't
00:40:38.960know what he was doing or what he was looking at vis-a-vis a woman's vaginal canal. So like he was0.98
00:40:46.540just such a useless and unqualified doctor that he didn't notice a rabbit carcass inside the vagina1.00
00:40:51.760of a woman whose vagina he was inspecting to see if there was a rabbit in it. So basically poor her1.00
00:40:59.620and Nathaniel St. Andre sucks and and guess what story gets weirder. So by now the king was kind0.98
00:41:07.060of like, even from Germany was like, what's going on? This all seems a little weird. And he was
00:41:12.780like, I kind of know Nathaniel St. Andre, messy bitch who lives for drama. So let's just like get1.00
00:41:18.140like a objective third opinion on the situation. So he sent his other personal physician who is
00:41:27.340named Syracchius Ahlers. I'm going to call him Ahlers. Ahlers was the official royal doctor of0.55
00:41:35.080the German royal family, which is the one that George cared more about. So he chose like an0.52
00:41:39.060actual good doctor for there. Allers was, came into this whole thing, thank God, skeptical of
00:41:46.640the whole situation. He showed up basically like, Mary Toft, I don't believe you've given birth to
00:41:51.02015 rabbits. Prove me wrong. So from moment one, like he was not impressed with the whole clown
00:41:57.080car that was this whole scheme. So for instance, when he arrived, he showed up and Nathaniel
00:42:02.380it, Andrea was like, oh, look, this rabbit skin, she just gave birth to this. You just missed it.
00:42:08.900And Ollers was like, I don't think so because there's no blood or fluid on this rabbit skin
00:42:15.260whatsoever. There's literally no way this was just born out of either a human woman0.99
00:42:19.580or a female rabbit. Also, he was just like looking in the room. He's like, oh, and also Mary Toph
00:42:26.240doesn't look pregnant at all. I feel like she's literally wearing a corset right now. And she's1.00
00:42:31.220also walking around, like holding her knees together, like she's trying to make something1.00
00:42:34.660not fall out of her vagina. So it's all just like a little suspicious. And Mary's like,0.99
00:42:40.560oh no, I'm going into labor. And Allers was like, okay, I'm going to take care of this situation.
00:42:47.260And despite him being skeptical, which made me sort of side with him a little bit,
00:42:52.700turns out he didn't know what he was doing at all vis-a-vis childbirth delivery. He was a doctor,
00:42:57.440but he was not a obstetrician, nor was he a gynecologist. So he reached his hand up inside
00:43:03.040of Mary to like help her give birth. But what he did is he accidentally shoved the rabbit
00:43:06.900higher up into her vagina, which is just like, oh, so Mary screamed in probably absolute genuine0.98
00:43:15.560pain. And John Howard was like, I got this. But so while John Howard, John Howard delivered the0.96
00:43:23.460new rabbit carcass. Allers sneakily stole some of the rabbit bits and he like went off into his
00:43:28.720room. And then even though he was supposed to stay in town for three more days, he pretended that he
00:43:33.760had a headache and then he secretly left town with him. So again, he shoved the rabbit further
00:43:40.520up the vagina, but I like Allers for his sneakiness here. So basically he just like0.98
00:43:44.960crapped out of town. I picture him climbing out a window. He probably didn't, but he might have.
00:43:48.720so in london he took the rabbit bits and he did further testing where he found that a the rabbits
00:43:56.320had had their muscles cut from their bones with sharp knives not something that could have happened
00:44:00.000in utero and b the rabbits had pellets in their bums with corn and wheat and grass in them meaning
00:44:07.060that the rabbits had eaten corn and wheat and grass meaning they had not just been born so
00:44:11.540similar to what nathanael c andre had found with the floating lungs like these had been
00:44:15.760alive rabbits who were then killed and then put inside of Mary. They did not gestate inside of
00:44:22.960her. So he had absolute proof now, as much as one could have, you know, CSI 1726, he had proof that
00:44:30.660this was a hoax. So at this point, we picture Mary herself, just whatever the 18th century
00:44:37.440equivalent of holding frozen peas to your vulva would be, just like trying to make herself not
00:44:44.900hurt as much as she was obviously hurting both psychologically and physically but nobody else0.89
00:44:52.160nobody nobody cared about her because what happened next is that allers john howard and0.72
00:44:56.900saint andre have basically a dick swinging contest about which of them was the smartest doctor
00:45:01.620which basically was all three men kept like one would write a letter to the editors of the0.80
00:45:05.680newspaper being like mary toft is a hoaxer and then one of them would write a letter being like0.97
00:45:09.780no allers is a hypocrite and then one would write a letter being like no no saint andre's a messy1.00
00:45:13.900bitch who lives for drama and like nathanian andre probably sent that one so just a war of words but1.00
00:45:19.460not even about her just between them about like who's the smartest and best doctor throughout all1.00
00:45:24.240of this anne toft kept shoving rabbit bits into her daughter-in-law john howard kept delivering
00:45:29.140them and finally just to settle this all the king commanded an obstetrician like thank god
00:45:36.680named sir richard manningham like sir like he was a knight like he was such a trusted obstetrician0.83
00:45:43.240he was a knight of it to go and visit mary toft and figure out literally what the fuck was going0.94
00:45:47.860on sir richard manningham goes to see mary and he's like so i don't see a rabbit inside her0.99
00:45:56.340vagina her cervix seems closed as per usual for a person not actively giving birth to anything
00:46:04.100um but then just after he left the room john howard was like oh i just just after you left
00:46:08.980to look. She gave birth to these membranes. I guess you must not have noticed them when you
00:46:13.740were examining her. And Manningham looked at the membranes, which were clearly bits of a bladder
00:46:19.600from a pig that smelled like pig urine. And he was like, I think this is a pig's bladder. Can you0.98
00:46:26.760bring me like a pig's bladder to compare it to? And then someone did that because there's a pig's0.99
00:46:33.020letter around. I don't know. And he's like, yeah, this is clearly a pig's butter. This is hashtag
00:46:38.980a hoax. And Mary just started crying. Like, honestly, of course she did. And so the men,
00:46:47.480the man doctors all agreed to bring Mary back to London for further examinations, which like,1.00
00:46:52.800can't we just not have any more hands on her vagina ever again? Apparently not. So on to London.1.00
00:47:01.160now at this point what happens is saint andre wanted her next rabbit birth to happen publicly
00:47:08.900like in a theater you know like those theaters like in um what's called the nick was that what
00:47:13.880it's called the show but like the oldie time doctors where you like or like in frankenstein
00:47:17.980and stuff where like a doctor's in the middle of an auditorium and there's all medical students
00:47:21.820watching so saint andre wanted her to do that with everybody watching so that he could get fame
00:47:27.200and glory but what happened when they got to London is Mary was for the first time no one
00:47:33.140thought of this before was put under basically round-the-clock surveillance so there's no0.97
00:47:37.020opportunity for anyone to bring her a rabbit to put inside of her vagina so she didn't go into1.00
00:47:42.520birth so she couldn't have it happen in auditorium anyway but also just like I hope she just like1.00
00:47:47.960went in the room whatever it was like a jail room a hotel room and just like squeezed her legs
00:47:54.020together and just was grateful that her in-laws weren't there to do this to her again but she was
00:47:59.960also at this point legitimately sick because obviously because no kidding because she probably0.99
00:48:05.440had like a thousand various internal infections from all the hands they probably had gross pointy0.98
00:48:12.100nails also the rabbit bits the skulls like of course she was sick basically she started having0.97
00:48:18.900fits and the doctors were like oh these fits kind of look like she's going into labor but they were
00:48:22.300probably involuntary convulsions from various serious infections she was having and then a man
00:48:28.900was caught trying to smuggle a dead rabbit into her room and he when he was caught they were like
00:48:33.820why are you delivering this rabbit into her room and he was like because her sister-in-law Margaret
00:48:37.840paid me to do that and the jig was up because he was not good at rabbit sneaking. Margaret Toft
00:48:45.620the sister-in-law was brought in for questioning and she was like okay yes I hired that guy to1.00
00:48:50.020sneak the dead rabbit into mary toff's room but not for vagina reasons it was because she likes1.00
00:48:55.340to eat rabbits it was a special treat for her to eat a raw rabbit and they were like sure so then0.80
00:49:03.560they went to talk to mary and she was like yes is if that's what she said then that's true the
00:49:08.500rabbit was just for me to eat so for two days they interrogated mary trying to get her to admit
00:49:13.540to the hoax and she wouldn't give in and she wouldn't give in because of family loyalty and
00:49:18.240like I don't know delusional blood infection brain but eventually Manningham was like okay
00:49:25.800so if this is true if you gave birth to whatever it is at this point 17 rabbits that means that0.98
00:49:31.100there's something really fucked up inside of your like innards so we just need to like literally0.99
00:49:36.600vivisect you now like cut you open in a surgical manner and look at your insides and Mary was like0.99
00:49:42.520okay please don't do that it's a hoax so december 7th 1726 mary dictated her confession and this is
00:49:53.160where we got a lot of the information from about the whole scenario because she came clean so the
00:49:58.900first first round confession version one she claimed that she'd met a strange woman on the1.00
00:50:04.360road who had suggested that she should put rabbits in her vaginas pretend to give birth to them0.97
00:50:09.120because that would be a way for her to never want as long as you live like aka would make her rich1.00
00:50:14.840and they're like really a strange woman on the road told you this and then you just did it like
00:50:19.540that's okay like a little unbelievable and mary toft was like okay version two it wasn't a strange
00:50:26.660woman on the road it was in fact my in-law's idea it was my mother-in-law and my sister-in-law and
00:50:32.840she also said that john howard was in on the scheme as well and she was steadfast in all of
00:50:36.920her confessions and she herself was innocent in all of this. She didn't want to do this. Like who,
00:50:42.200who would ever have wanted to do this? Of course she didn't want to do this. So she was basically
00:50:45.580blaming other people, which is like, you know, people might do that when they confess, but for
00:50:49.400her, it's like, I believe her based on every reason in the world. But based on this confession,
00:50:56.920Mary was officially charged with a crime of being a notorious and vile cheat, which was a crime
00:51:03.380back then in that place in time so she was put into prison and crowds would like mob outside0.96
00:51:10.460just like desperate to see the rabbit queen and during this time period she had a portrait painted1.00
00:51:17.260of herself which is like people like mary toft like aside from the whole rabbit vagina scenario
00:51:24.140like she would have never probably had a portrait painted so it's kind of this is where it's like1.00
00:51:28.120well-behaved women don't make history like we heard about mary toft because of this scheme0.99
00:51:31.440She only really got her portrait done because of the scheme. And so from that, we kind of see what1.00
00:51:35.980she looks like, which is just sort of like a pleasant looking person. Of course, in the portrait,
00:51:39.840he painted her holding a live rabbit in her lap because, you know, that's what the crowds would
00:51:45.460have wanted to see or whatever. So she was only in jail for three months. She was discharged
00:51:50.380mostly because the crime of being notorious and a vile cheat isn't easy to prosecute because it's
00:51:56.080kind of not a thing. But during the three months in jail, her health issues improved, partially
00:52:01.200because she wasn't having dead animal bits and unwashed men's hands forced into her vagina0.97
00:52:05.280on a daily basis so feeling better bounced back she returned back to her husband and her two1.00
00:52:12.000children and her in-laws which must have been so awkward because they are nightmare horrible people
00:52:17.860and got her in the situation in the first place and about a year after um mary toft now age 26
00:52:25.600although it feels like she's aged 100 years in this experience. She gave birth to another daughter
00:52:32.020who she named Elizabeth. From then on, writers and newspapers and like, you know, cartoonists
00:52:38.100and things would still continue to bring up the story, especially because of the whole rabbit
00:52:41.180political angle. But Mary herself fades from public record almost entirely until she died in 1763.
00:52:49.520so when she died her husband had died first because the parish register recorded her as
00:52:55.720Mary Toft comma widow they noted after her name as well that she was the imposterous rabbit breeder0.88
00:53:02.560and although poor women from where she grew up weren't ever written about in London newspapers0.63
00:53:09.040when they died her obituary was actually published in the London newspapers alongside those of0.95
00:53:13.560aristocrats because she was still so famous for this whole fucked up situation. So a couple of0.95
00:53:21.120things I want to mention. First of all, there's a new biography coming out of Mary Toft. I'm really
00:53:26.560excited about it. It's called The Imposterous Rabbit Breeder. It's coming out in early 2020,
00:53:32.060and it's written by a researcher, historian named Karen Harvey. And the thing that I'm really
00:53:37.380excited about with this book is that she's really making the book about Mary Toft, not about all the
00:53:42.380men and doctors who were around her. In researching this whole situation, there was a really great
00:53:47.640essay by the author of this book, Karen Harvey, that I read. All of my references are all put
00:53:55.420a link to them in the show notes. But basically, I'm really excited to read this book. Karen Harvey's
00:53:58.660point of view is really compelling. And she really puts a really person first spin on a story that's
00:54:05.880become sort of a myth at this point. Also just came out, I haven't read it yet. But there's a
00:54:11.780fiction historical fiction novel written by dexter palmer called mary toft or the rabbit queen
00:54:17.360which seems like the main characters in it are the men doctors and there's certainly a lot of
00:54:23.140drama to be cleaned from imagining what they were up to i read a lot of things to research this i'll
00:54:29.060put the research notes um i'll link to those in the post i won't say them all out but just know
00:54:34.380that there's a lot of interesting stuff out there discussing this topic including um the lore
00:54:40.520podcast episode number 45 first impressions which talks a bit about the myth around this
00:54:47.020whole situation and now it's the part in every episode of vulgar history where we score this
00:54:53.000and this is a weird one because it's like mary toft i feel i've read about her a lot and i feel
00:54:59.880like i know her and i feel like she didn't want this she wasn't like if we were scoring nathaniel
00:55:04.840saint andre like he would get whatever high scores because he was all about the scheminess
00:55:10.360but mary toft i feel like was not in it for herself so the first category is a scandaliciousness
00:55:18.080and this is where even though she did she may or may not have wanted to do this like1.00
00:55:23.980like whatever it wound up being i think 17 rabbits like giving birth them from her vagina1.00
00:55:31.220the like months long conspiracy of it. It got up to the king. She was sent to jail. Like0.98
00:55:37.240the scandalousness is pretty high here. I think I'm going to give her a seven for
00:55:45.240scandalousness, partially because she didn't do it on purpose. Like it wasn't necessarily her idea,
00:55:51.340but it's just, I mean, it's a juicy, juicy scandal. Her scheminess, her personal scheminess,
00:55:57.140I think was not super high, which is to her credit, really. Again, we're not scoring her
00:56:02.480in-laws for them, much higher score, because they were the ones who came up with this. But
00:56:06.700that being said, Mary Toft stuck with it. She pretended to give birth to all these things.
00:56:11.300She stuck to her story. She didn't give up for two days of questioning. I'm going to give her
00:56:16.480a scheminess of four. The next category is the significance, which is like, had you heard of her
00:56:23.900before this i'm guessing for a lot of you not because it's not a super famous story even if
00:56:31.660you've heard about the woman who gave birth to rabbits you may not know her name the significance
00:56:36.640of it she didn't like it fucked up the career of nathaniel st andre but like that would have
00:56:41.920happened anyway because that was just how he lived his life the significance i'm gonna give her0.76
00:56:47.540the significance i mean i'm gonna give her two two for significance because you know it's being
00:56:55.380revisited we're talking about it here it's not it's more significant than if it hadn't have
00:56:59.860happened but it didn't change the course of world history the final category is where we give her
00:57:04.920bonus points based on how much sexism played a part in this situation and i'm going to give her1.00
00:57:11.020an eight for that because she was I could even go higher because she was so helpless in this1.00
00:57:19.500situation like her in-laws like regardless of fact they were women doing this to her like she1.00
00:57:25.300was stuck in a situation where she was so helpless when the male doctors came in like she had no say
00:57:31.300in anything that was going on she was just a victim of everybody oh you know what no I'm1.00
00:57:36.600going to give her a seven, a seven for sexism. So it gives her a total of 14, 15, 18, 20. This gives0.98
00:57:43.340her a score of 20, which is tied with Caroline of Brunswick, which I think is respectable,
00:57:51.640but they're tied with the smallest amount right now, the two of them. So yeah, that was, I think,
00:57:59.340officially the most fucked up story I've told on this podcast yet. My name is Anne Foster,0.98
00:58:03.540and this is the vulgar history podcast so there's a bunch of of places where you can follow me oh
00:58:10.240oh but i need to mention so i've been doing a thing where for each episode of this podcast
00:58:16.420i'm putting a new item in the vulgar history store on teespring and i was like what what could sum up
00:58:23.860mary toft's whole life experience in the form of a magnet or a shirt or whatever and basically
00:58:30.600there were some contemporaneous political cartoons that were drawn of her situation one of which was
00:58:36.800by an artist called William Hogarth and it's basically a picture of her it's like a line
00:58:42.240black and white line drawing of her like pretending to give birth well like one of her in-laws is next
00:58:48.020to her looking like oh no what's happening and there's just like all men around her they're all
00:58:52.040just like we're all men and it's just like is a nightmare and so I just took a black and white0.98
00:58:57.780picture and I overlaid it in red font, the phrase, fuck everything. And I feel like that just kind of0.97
00:59:04.540says it all. You can find that at teespring.com slash vulgar history. It's one of the things you
00:59:13.600can get there. What do we have? We have that as a mug. We have it as a t-shirt, lots of different
00:59:18.060things. Great for Christmas presents, but also you can find the podcast on Twitter. We're on
00:59:25.420Instagram, just like a vulgar history. The podcast itself is now on iTunes and basically nearly all
00:59:33.000of the various podcast sources. So you can find it there. And now I get to say to subscribe and
00:59:39.180to rate and review because that would make me feel really good. And if you want to support me
00:59:44.940financially to help me with things like I bought the thing for the microphone so that my peas don't
00:59:50.920pop. I had the time to read about how to use the microphone and talk into the right part of it.
00:59:56.040If you want to support me financially, I have a Patreon, which is patreon.com
00:59:59.760slash Anne Foster Writer. So yeah, I guess I'll talk to you all next time. Have a good one,
01:00:06.840everybody. Vulgar History is hosted, written, and researched by Anne Foster and edited by Christina