00:07:28.740and they don't actually realize what that means for them.
00:07:31.020I mean, even just right now with the conversation
00:07:33.100about the public service jobs being cut, you know,
00:07:36.300people without the unions who are coming out and speaking about what this means for Canadians,
00:07:41.340that translation kind of has to happen. So in the context of these acronyms and numbers
00:07:48.340that you saw with wage, can you tell me a little bit more about what that initial cut would have
00:07:54.540meant? And even what the, there is still a reduction. So like what that could also look
00:07:59.540like still as it stands. Absolutely. You know, I think, and you hit the nail on the head with
00:08:06.000you know it's just a percentage it's just a number and people don't understand the material impact
00:08:11.440and so you know local women's organizations and lgbtq organizations they have been like chronically
00:08:16.960underfunded for decades right like they're underfunded and they're dealing with these
00:08:20.400massive crises and they're putting it all they're leaving it all on the ice as i like to say so that
00:08:25.440is you know shelter workers who are going above and beyond to do everything they can to help a
00:08:30.880women fleeing violence get the care and support they need to you know stand up and live healthy
00:08:36.400lives and get you know back to contributing to our economy and so if these cuts had come through
00:08:42.240that lifeline funding that has been channeled by women and gender equality into our sectors
00:08:47.520it would have disappeared overnight and we would have seen organizations suddenly with a funding
00:08:52.480gap that no one else is stepping into address you know it's not like there's provincial governments
00:08:57.680lining up to spend more on women's services right now and so you would have seen local organizations
00:09:03.120struggle to do their jobs right like demand is increasing because the gender-based violence
00:09:07.440pandemic is ongoing and we've got governments rolling back on rights and then to have these
00:09:12.320organizations be placed in an even more financially untenable position uh would have had a devastating
00:09:18.000impact across the country and so there's there's the services piece and that is where we've really
00:09:22.640focused our argument because those services are what matter most in making this economy in this
00:09:26.880country work for everybody but then there's also what happens when you gut a department and make
00:09:32.880it a shell of itself you know we rely on wage to help inform the rest of government's work
00:09:39.280on gender equality to make sure when they're announcing programs that they actually think
00:09:42.720for at least a hot second about how those programs might impact women girls and queer people
00:09:48.160if you take that away if you reduce their capacity to provide that advice and that guidance
00:09:52.880you are risking a budget and a government that thinks about men and men only and doesn't factor
00:10:00.840in the realities that are different for women and queer people across this country yeah and
00:10:06.000i i think that that's something that has been a broader critique that we've heard several times
00:10:12.040about mark carney i mean uh there i i didn't actually like prepare any quotes from this or
00:10:18.480that i can pull up because i'm just going rogue a little here but um you know we we heard uh we saw
00:10:24.880in practice when he was dealing with uh journalists in the election campaign and to this day that he
00:10:30.480tends to lose his temper a little bit more quickly with female journalists and it's not just me
00:10:35.040pointing that out chantelle a bear also said this and you know um there is the additional factor
00:10:41.440that there were these murmurs and i heard this from my government sources too that it was a bit
00:10:46.080bit of a boys club in the prime minister's office. And then we also saw how petty he was towards
00:10:52.620Karina Gould, which came out of the Steve Marr article in McLean. So I guess this feels like a
00:11:01.660prime example of the way that unconscious bias results in real proactive issues for
00:11:09.860marginalized groups. I don't know if you can speak to that a little bit. Do you think that
00:11:14.560that's a fair analysis or what are your thoughts? My hope is that that's not the case, right? Like
00:11:19.960it's still early days. You're still trying to figure out like who is this PM and what is he
00:11:23.800all about? But you know, right after the budget, I was in the lockup on Parliament Hill. And so
00:11:29.680we got to like see the budget a little bit more, embargoed copy before it was live. And then right
00:11:34.880after I was debriefing with a bunch of our pals in the career and feminist space. And I won't
00:11:38.760attribute who said this because they deserve to speak for themselves. But one of the first
00:11:42.760comments that I heard was, oh, this is a man's budget. This is a budget for the boys. It's a
00:11:49.220budget with big military spending, with all of these cuts to help the tech bros make their next
00:11:56.220billion. And it's not really thinking about everything else. And so I think that does
00:12:01.580contribute to an aura of concern that maybe this PM doesn't understand the importance of gender
00:12:07.700equity. And maybe he thinks it's a nice to have. Yes, it is nice to have a government that does
00:12:12.260what Trudeau did, which is like trot out feminism for props and symbolism. And I care about the
00:12:18.500moral and social right that is investing in these programs and services. But if you've got woman0.98
00:12:24.920shelters, the economy won't work in the way that it's meant to, because you will have less folks1.00
00:12:29.340able to get jobs, able to be supported. Canadians rely on those services. And so at the end of the
00:12:35.860day, I'm hopeful that our read so far on Kearney isn't accurate. And I am like, you know, a little
00:12:43.240bit appeased or made hopeful because we know that part of why we got these investments in the wage
00:12:49.720budget was actually because of feminist liberal MPs and gals around the cabinet table who helped1.00
00:12:56.000articulate the critical investment that this needed to be. But it's still a bit of a mixed bag.
00:13:02.360And I'm not really convinced or sure where PM Carney himself stands on these issues.
00:13:07.840Yeah. You know, jumping off of that, I did want to ask you in a more broad sense, because, you know, I think as someone who's very involved in political organizing, you talk to a lot of unions, you talk to a lot of folks who have overlapping, but maybe their wheelhouse is on a different part of the intersections of, you know, injustice in our world.
00:13:29.600So I did want to ask you about like, whether you have any thoughts of the direction the government seems to be heading in based on this budget. Personally, I found it to be a pretty big red flag that they're telling people we have to make sacrifices while they're also paying for all of these investments with cuts to public services, to the public service, to programs through, you know, not increasing their funding in the years to come.
00:13:59.600which, you know, results in a slowdown.
00:14:02.780But then also they're getting rid of, you know,
00:14:06.120the capital gains increase that was canceled.
00:16:04.680in working class Canadians, investing in public services
00:16:09.320and things like childcare and mental health services,
00:16:12.000those lead to a stronger and more prosperous economy.
00:16:15.280And in particular, an economy that works for everyone,
00:16:18.780not just people who look like Mark Carney does.
00:16:21.380Yeah. And I think that it feels extra egregious because of the fact that we just all jealously watched as New York elected Zoran Mamdani and saw that, like, these kinds of politics aren't just electable.
00:16:36.380They are very popular. And the thing that I keep coming back to from that is that, you know, I think that the reason why we're seeing such a rise in this right wing populism is because those populist leaders are correctly diagnosing the issues that we're facing right now with respect to broadening income inequality.
00:16:55.000You know, in Canada, it is the worst it has been since Stats Canada, Statistics Canada, started keeping track of income inequality in our country.
00:17:05.640So, you know, there is an issue in our economy that maybe gets missed with these macroeconomic indicators like when you consider those big economic indicators that are always referenced by our leaders, you know,
00:17:21.460which lead people like Christopher Freeland to call what we're experiencing a vibe session
00:17:26.100when the reality is yes the very rich are doing very well but working class people are struggling
00:17:32.580more than ever and I think that just to bring this full circle the conservatives are correctly
00:17:37.480diagnosing that issue just the solutions that they're offering are kind of snake oil because
00:17:42.240they are trickled down like policies that time and time again prove to be ineffective so I guess I
00:17:48.680I just feel extra frustrated seeing a budget like this that offers these timid, outdated solutions to an issue when we know that there are other options.
00:17:58.700And we just saw that through Zoran Mamdani.
00:18:02.260And I'm just kind of rambling now, but I did want to ask you, in light of all of this, like this budget was a factor in conservatives crossing the floor to the liberals.
00:18:16.940and they still call themselves red Tories in this floor crossing. So what do you make of
00:18:24.700the state of our politics from that lens? And I guess in a sense, like, do you think we can
00:18:31.080learn any lessons from the Zoran of it all? Oh, we have so many lessons that we desperately need
00:18:37.840to learn from Zoran. And I would say like, as a progressive, you know, I think we are lacking
00:18:42.160the strong like counter note to what is like a liberal Tory same old story kind of energy right
00:18:48.320like so much of the conversation in Ottawa has been you know Mark Carney is a liberal but his
00:18:54.240budget is for conservatives and his approach is conservatism and I think that that's a big
00:19:00.260challenge because everyone is terrified of this Pierre Polyev guy right like we don't like him
00:19:05.560We're worried about his, you know, obsession with identity politics and cultural war distractions.
00:19:13.160And we are very worried about a PM who will joke or make comments about how, you know, political opponents need to be jailed or investigated by their RCMP.
00:19:22.120I've seen, you know, him going off around recent Supreme Court decisions.
00:19:26.920I grew up in a family where we thought that conservatives believed in the rule of law and respected the courts.
00:19:32.300And so we're seeing this like scorched earth, I'm going to burn it down, get angry and channel that rage energy coming from Polyev. And then we're not really seeing that same like populist, in a good way in this context, like populist left wing response.
00:19:47.420And I think, you know, the NDP leadership race is underway, and there are some candidates there that are bringing that energy, and I'm excited to see where that goes.
00:19:54.880But in that gap, in that moment, there's not really a strong third option, and the first two options seem very similar.
00:20:04.160Now, when it comes to, you know, Polyev, I think that he is starting to see more and more the price of a politic built on rage and with little substance underneath it.
00:20:13.940And I deeply enjoy seeing some of the hypocrisies that emerged through, you know, conservatives branding themselves as the everyday man's guardian or defender.
00:20:23.940You know, I think it was after the budget was dropped, as is done almost every year, there was like a party in downtown Ottawa where a bunch of liberals went and celebrated.
00:20:34.220And they got criticized by, you know, Melissa Lansman for their like out of touch champagne politics, blah, blah, blah.
00:20:40.020And I'm just sitting there being like, wait, so like a former law or a Walmart lobbyist is lecturing Canadians about affordability.
00:20:47.380How much money does she make? How much money has she made?
00:20:50.700When is the last time she had to worry about paying her bills or putting food on the table?
00:20:54.800I would love for rich people to stop trying to pretend that they are anything other than rich people and to stop trying to pretend that they are the ones in touch with the working class when that is the furthest thing from the truth.
00:21:04.260yeah well and also sorry just like as a personal aside i was in the press gallery for seven years
00:21:11.120that party's an annual tradition and you can criticize it but i can tell you conservatives
00:21:15.880went to it when i was on the hill so it's just i find it kind of ludicrous that because of the
00:21:22.120populist sort of scorched earth politics that they're embracing that all of a sudden they're
00:21:27.320pretending it's super weird to do this kind of thing when like i've had wine with michelle
00:21:32.140Rempelgarner in the CTV offices. So, you know, it's just maybe that is a problem. But it's just
00:21:39.840so ludicrous to see this shift where they pretend that this wasn't exactly what they did just years
00:21:45.240ago before they decided to pretend to be something else. Yeah, I did want to ask you about that from
00:21:53.120Polyev because that is sort of the flip side of this. I mean, there's the elements of what this
00:21:58.040Floor Crossing tells us about the liberals and their style of governance and their policies and
00:22:02.560why it might appeal to someone who is more of a red Tory. But there's also what it tells us about
00:22:07.460Poliev. I mean, for years, he has been going on these like culture war issues, attacking the
00:22:13.900vulnerable and just like, you know, talking about things that it's so funny. I actually noticed that
00:22:19.620when Poliev went quiet for a bit after he lost his seat, some of you can correct me if I'm wrong,
00:22:26.060because I'm saying this as a cis woman, but like I saw a bit of a die down in at least the political
00:22:33.740conversation about trans rights. People moved on to other stuff when there wasn't Polyev directing
00:22:39.820their rage as like clearly in that direction. It still existed. Absolutely. There's still plenty
00:22:45.440of transphobia, but then he came back and he started sending emails and he started, you know,
00:22:51.860getting loud again and some of the first stuff he did was attacking trans folks and it just ramped
00:22:56.820up again and so i i guess i wanted to ask you like do you think that that's also part of why we're
00:23:02.420seeing this floor crossing is because he's leaning into these weirdo culture war issues that normal
00:23:07.700people don't actually care about unless they're disinformed into caring about them absolutely you
00:23:14.260know i think i think that a lot of like more centrist conservatives are in a really tough
00:23:20.180situation because like they they are conservatives right and like their belief in uh and their
00:23:26.340support for the conservative party is is often something that has mattered to them throughout
00:23:30.100their lives but i think they've also like lost the fight for the soul of the conservative party
00:23:34.500uh and i think many are wondering is there any way to to win back momentum again uh when we look
00:23:40.900at you know aaron o'toole the past leader of the conservatives and compare him with polyev
00:23:46.180i see a leader there who could you know flirt with centrists and maybe even bring over some
00:23:51.220progressives versus polyev who seems to be more focused on firing up his base than in doing
00:23:57.380anything else and so i think for those conservatives who are more center of the road who are looking
00:24:02.420at carney and recognizing that this guy was first appointed under harper uh that this guy
00:24:08.180is in many ways again like aligned with their fiscal beliefs and if they're pissed that their
00:24:14.180leaders scorched earth culture war politics it's a pretty strong case to say what if you went over
00:24:20.260the to the other eye or like cross that aisle um and helped govern instead of just being part of
00:24:25.780a party that wants to burn things down all around them yeah yeah totally um and and that really is
00:24:34.260the the reality of the kinds of politics that we are seeing polyev embrace is that that burning
00:24:40.980everything down because what are you left with when you convince people to hate each other to
00:24:46.180this degree right and i wanted to ask you on that topic because it's something that i personally
00:24:51.220grapple with too when i'm you know on social media and trying to i i think there's a lot of power in
00:24:58.340the conversations that we have in the public square and those influence how people think
00:25:03.380as i just demonstrated with the situation where polyev started sending out fundraising emails or
00:25:09.060you know sending out tweets about trans folks and all of a sudden there were more conversations
00:25:13.860vilifying trans folks so um sometimes like i try to provide a counter voice or hit back at some of
00:25:22.580this but i wondered what you think about how like where the line is when it comes to further
00:25:31.300inflaming these divisions versus helping to counter them because if i like for me i think oh
00:25:38.980if a trans kid is seeing all of this hate hopefully they see a positive supportive post
00:25:44.580and that kind of gives them that little boost that they need to to hang on but what if that propels
00:25:51.540a ton of hate in response to it that then other trans kids see when they might not have seen the
00:25:56.420hate in the first place so i guess that's sort of my question to you is where is that line
00:26:02.180and i think i think that's a lot of where we we feel stuck and i i know i often do is like you
00:26:07.140know when polyev or danielle smith are coming for trans people and they're using all this
00:26:11.380misinformation like how much do we engage and directly refute and what i would say is a few
00:26:17.140things first like social media has broken our brains already um and we need to learn to engage
00:26:22.420in other spaces right like the the ecosystem is so polarized that it's hard to have real
00:26:27.300conversations anymore i think the like degree of character assassination and personal attacks you
00:26:32.260and i both receive is indicative of that and the efforts to like frame us as these like scary
00:26:38.580radicals or conspiracy theorists and i'm just like y'all like yes the far right has done
00:26:44.580a good case study on character assassination by coming for us
00:26:52.420they just froze for me but oh there you go you're back okay the last thing i heard from you was that
00:27:02.980the right did a good case study and character assassination through us which is absolutely true
00:27:07.940so please carry on and so i guess like what i would say yeah like first again in-person
00:27:14.900conversations and i think rejecting the frame that they're placing on the table right like
00:27:19.220they want you to believe that it is either protect the rights of parents or the rights
00:27:25.380of trans kids well how about if instead we built schools where every kid could be themselves and
00:27:29.860we welcomed the involvement of parents in their child's education what if we believed in freedom
00:27:35.860without the exceptions of freedom when it comes to trans people but when it came to all people
00:27:40.900and so i think we need to respond when it's happening in the moment we need to be out there
00:27:44.980and providing that counterpoint but then in our everyday work we need to be having these
00:27:50.540conversations and doing so on our terms because when we seed space to them and they define the
00:27:56.060conversation well they've already focus grouped the slogans they're using and they boxed us into
00:28:00.760a corner and so let's reject that corner let's rise above and let's come back to what every
00:28:06.260canadian believes in a country where freedom is for everyone where we believe in rights and we
00:28:11.700want governments telling us how to live or what we can do with our bodies yeah yeah absolutely
00:28:16.500that's i think that's a a great uh little lesson and how to handle this trash um you know and i
00:28:24.660think one thing i always think about and uh i i've seen you make this point as well is just
00:28:30.340the ways in which um all of our rights are intertwined and i i think that we keep getting
00:28:36.660more and more evidence of this of how you know as we see lawmakers come for trans folks rights
00:28:44.580there will be uh cisgendered folks who don't uh care or if anything will like actively join in on
00:28:53.460this but then next thing you know these policies bleed into policing how those cisgendered women1.00
00:28:59.300present like a bathroom ban is going to uh necessitate for enforcement a enforcement1.00
00:29:07.540of femininity so if if you are peeing and your hair is too short even if you're a cisgendered
00:29:15.460woman there is a very good chance that your expression of femininity and how you choose
00:29:20.660to live as a cis woman will be it'll be policed because in order to not face harassment while
00:29:28.020going pee, you have to present as feminine as possible. And so these are sort of the ways in
00:29:34.360which these policies that start by absolutely abusing and vilifying trans folks, they also
00:29:40.000bleed into other communities. So even if you don't care about other people, at least if you can care
00:29:44.940about yourself, you know, maybe that'll give you the juice you need to, to fight these things. But
00:29:50.760I guess I wanted to ask you like, about this interrelated nature of human rights and how you
00:29:56.820see and experience this in the work that you're doing so I like to think about this in two angles
00:30:02.940first is exactly what you alluded to like the social environment they target trans people and
00:30:07.980like turn us into a boogeyman to make an example of us as like bad gender performance and what that
00:30:14.100leads to is a world where like the butch lesbian is going to be mistreated the gender non-conforming
00:30:18.520tomboy like this whole resurgence of a like social conservatism right like and we're seeing it when1.00
00:30:25.860comes to like has feminism gone too far and like trad wives and incels like all of that really is
00:30:32.500like the resurgence of a social conservative politic that should be worrying to anybody who
00:30:36.580wants to like look however they want to look sleep with who they want to sleep with and live
00:30:40.580like maybe alternative lifestyles so there's there's a piece there and a piece where the like
00:30:46.100rage and um like polarization that is fuel that is being fueled here will make it harder for folks
00:30:52.020of all kinds right like if if you can create an environment where it's permissible to demonize
00:30:56.660trans people who the hell do you think conservatives are going to go after next it's going to be
00:31:00.820newcomers it's going to be a bring back of the cultural or the barbaric cultural practices tip
00:31:05.540line kind of energy and so there's a huge component and concern in the social space
00:31:11.540and then the second place is the erosion of checks and balances on government power
00:31:16.500and this is where i'm really like this is where i think we see the biggest departure from what
00:31:21.380conservatives used to be they used to be the ones that didn't want the government telling you what
00:31:26.180you could or couldn't do with their bodies or with your bodies and now in alberta we have premier
00:31:30.980danielle smith mandating sex checks on women and girls so they can play the right sports0.72
00:31:35.540we have a politician in your family doctor's office violating the sacrosanct relationship
00:31:40.580between a patient and their physician and we have a concerted effort to weaken the notwithstanding
00:31:46.820the charter of rights and freedoms now i understand why that clause exists that allows you to suspend
00:31:52.580for a period of up to five years equality rights and other components like that that clause was
00:31:57.540negotiated for a reason but it was not meant to be used flippantly or irresponsibly you know in
00:32:03.140saskatchewan premier mo actually invoked the clause uh prior to a court ruling because he was so scared
00:32:10.180that a that the courts would say hey you're harming vulnerable children that he didn't even
00:32:14.980want them to be able to consider the case in alberta we're seeing the use of the notwithstanding
00:32:20.900clause to try to force teachers back to work meanwhile parents are struggling with larger
00:32:25.860and larger class sizes that aren't giving the kids their kids the support and services that they
00:32:31.060deserve and so there's the social battle that we need to make sure we are fighting tooth and nail
00:32:36.980and then there's also the erosion of rights and freedoms of checks and balances on government
00:32:42.260power i don't want to live in a country where politicians are able to erroneously override
00:32:49.060our court system if we have to do that i want it to be done in a manner that is cautious that is
00:32:55.460aware of the risk and the danger and it is grounded in genuine concern but and i hate to bring in the
00:33:01.780like supreme court ruling in terms of uh the pedophilia strike down of mandatory minimums
00:33:07.700But it is very important. It's a great conservative opportunity to go off about Trudeau and about
00:33:13.700Carney. But what happens when you say, actually, we are going to violate or potentially violate
00:33:21.140the freedom and rights of some in order to serve a angry political narrative? That's a terrifying
00:33:28.020precedence. Absolutely. Actually, I'm really glad that you brought up the notwithstanding clause,
00:33:32.980because that was something I wanted to to talk about here because it is really for the so Faye
00:33:39.300kind of already did a great job just quickly explaining it you can tell that like she does
00:33:43.660this all the time hey she like drops a a big fancy word that no one understands quickly defines it
00:33:49.880doesn't even like break a sweat while making her point but for those of you who didn't pick it up
00:33:55.960from Fay, the notwithstanding clause is a clause in our charter that allows governments to pause
00:34:04.080or override or violate certain charter rights. Not all of them. There's some exceptions that
00:34:11.140this can't apply to, but there are rights that can be overridden or ignored for a period of five
00:34:16.740years while enforcing a law. And this is what was used in, and it's being fought in the courts,
00:34:23.520But the Saskatchewan, you know, basically forcing forcibly outing kids to their parents.
00:34:30.560There's it's being used in Alberta. It's being used with the Quebec religious symbols law.
00:34:38.980So what we're seeing time and time again and now, you know, in Alberta with respect to the teacher strike.
00:34:44.320So what we're seeing is that every time this is used and the original framers, you can see this on the Library of Parliament website,
00:34:50.480intended this to be a safety valve that is rarely used and not used for controversial issues.
00:34:59.920But I have to say, I was a little bit optimistic because I find it hard to think of a situation in
00:35:03.980which overriding someone's charter rights wouldn't be controversial. But it is supposed to be this
00:35:08.660very scarcely used. But what we're seeing time and time and time again is conservative governments
00:35:14.240use this clause to violate marginalized people and vulnerable people's rights. It's being used
00:35:21.880to violate trans folks' rights. It's being used to violate the rights of religious minorities,
00:35:26.780and it's being used to violate the rights of workers. So it is fundamentally being used to
00:35:31.740regress our politics. And I guess I wanted to ask you about, as we're seeing this trend,
00:35:37.800how concerned are you about the future of trans rights in this country, particularly as we are
00:35:42.420seeing a shift towards you know conservative governments keep winning in these provincial
00:35:46.340elections and they are the ones who are continually enacting and using the notwithstanding clause
00:35:52.020that's just a fact so what what are your thoughts on that so i think you know first like one of the
00:35:58.820the concepts that upheld or upholds the notwithstanding clause is the idea of parliamentary
00:36:04.580supremacy right it's the idea that like the will of the people as uh conveyed or administered
00:36:09.380through their elected representatives should be above anything and everything. And that makes a
00:36:14.920lot of sense in a healthy liberal democracy. But the idea was that governments would have to pay
00:36:20.400a political price if they were being irresponsible in their use of that clause. And that's why you
00:36:24.780see a five-year limit, right? So that at some stage, that government's going to have to go
00:36:28.860back to the electorate to get a new mandate. I think what that clause didn't factor in was a
00:36:35.000politics of polarization, an era of misinformation, and a loss of, I think, like a loss of some of
00:36:43.640the like foundational understandings that, you know, generations past understood to be core to
00:36:49.040a healthy democracy. So, you know, we got a whole lot of rage. And so it makes it so much tougher
00:36:53.880to have real conversations. Now, I think when it comes to, you know, the future of trans rights
00:37:00.040and what happens when we have the flippant use of the notwithstanding clause it is of course like
00:37:05.240the deepest cause for concern uh because if we don't have the one check and balance on government
00:37:10.440power i.e the court system uh that we have relied on in the past how do we make sure that we protect
00:37:17.320the rights of vulnerable people now my like diamond in the rough is as follows you know um
00:37:23.560we've always had governments come in for the rights of our communities it's only in the last few
00:37:28.040like years or decade or two where we've seen like not hostile governments and we've also had
00:37:34.360periods of backlash time and time again in the 70s the 80s the 90s there's always these windows
00:37:40.440uh and guess what we've done on each of those occasions we have organized we've advocated and
00:37:45.480we've won the public over to our side and we have built progress uh in the midst of those rollbacks
00:37:51.480and so i think my world is really scared right now and my heart is breaking for the trans kids
00:37:56.440in Saskatchewan and in Alberta, and they deserve so much better than this. But at the same time,
00:38:02.200I am confident that as this politics of rage continues, more and more Canadians will wake up
00:38:08.600to the poison pill that they're being offered by Kira Polyev. More and more people will become
00:38:13.960inoculated against this politic of anger, but it requires us offering a politic of hope instead.
00:38:20.520A politic that believes in a Canada where freedom includes everyone, and where we actually lift our
00:38:25.560neighbors up when they're going through tough times even if their families look different from
00:38:29.640our own and i'm really hopeful i'm placing all of my i'm betting placing all my bets on this concept
00:38:37.720that we can overcome anger and like we can see a shared humanity and it starts by connecting
00:38:44.280through shared values and a vision of what we want i want a generational
00:38:48.520change in canadian society that actually delivers for everyday canadians not just some of us
00:38:55.560Yes. Thank you. And you know what? I think that that is what was so powerful about and why the world was watching the election in New York City, because that was what Zoran Mamdani represented.
00:39:13.400it. He had all of these policies that, you know, also like progressive or seemingly progressive
00:39:20.220or democratic establishment politicians have disavowed as way too radical, you won't be able
00:39:28.220to get elected on that, yada, yada. And he just said, no, we're going to have hope. We're going
00:39:32.700to push. We're going to do this. And he proved that hope can win. And also voters across the
00:39:39.040United States proved that as Trump is doing these increasingly anti-democratic actions and attacking
00:39:45.800people's neighbors, rounding them up in the streets, people are not okay with that. And they
00:39:50.840will use the tools at their disposal to push back. I just think it's so inspiring. And you
00:39:58.800are like Zoran in the sense that you are someone who doesn't give up, who keeps organizing in the
00:40:05.320face of fear. So many attacks were levied at him. He was, you know, painted with every kind of
00:40:10.760racist attack that they could pull out of their, you know, pockets. Everything was tried and
00:40:17.720thrown at him. And he was relentless. He didn't give up. And you are the same way. You keep
00:40:22.640organizing in the face of fear. And I wanted to ask you, you know, and you kind of already just
00:40:28.060said it but what do you like how do you keep going and what do you say to people who look at all of
00:40:37.020this and are struggling to find that energy to pick up and to keep going and to be relentless
00:40:43.740in the face of these attacks and to you know hold on to hope how do you do that
00:40:51.420well first thank you comparison to zorwan is like terrifying i'm gonna like
00:40:54.460sorry i think i'm like i'm not complaining yeah i think you know there's there's a couple things
00:41:03.580the foundation is i think recognizing how much progress we've made and who's benefited from it
00:41:08.780right like i refuse to go backwards because i know what backwards looked like it looked like a world
00:41:13.980where you know matthew shepherd was murdered in america simply for being gay it looks like a world
00:41:19.820where trans people before me were forced out of their homes and made to live in hostile environments
00:41:26.940and just suffer so deeply simply for being themselves i am reminded that it is we are
00:41:33.740stronger now than we have ever been before we are movements that have changed the fabric of
00:41:40.860civilization in such incredible ways and i am made hopeful because i see the kids that are benefiting
00:41:47.820from that progress today and we told them that they deserve the freedom to be themselves and
00:41:53.180now we have to fight like hell to defend that freedom and i refuse to let that be a broken
00:41:57.820promise i refuse to let this world go back to the one that taught my generation to hate ourselves
00:42:04.780and that we deserved and had to hide who we are i think canada is ready for all that my community
00:42:10.700has to offer and i think canada will benefit from accepting us because our acceptance will lead to
00:42:16.300a world where everyone is more free from the patriarchy colonialism racism classist
00:42:21.980bullshit that we have been sold by centrists and conservatives for generations yeah well
00:42:28.620faye that was all the questions that i had prepared i do have some more stuff i would throw
00:42:34.700at you but i want to also give the audience a chance to get some questions in if they have any
00:42:40.540so um if you guys have anything you want to ask faye or myself please feel free to put that in
00:42:45.740in the chat now. And while I give you a minute to do that, Faye, can you tell people who have
00:42:50.680listened to you for the last 45 minutes and have felt that hope and excitement where they can keep
00:42:57.120up with both you and your work? Absolutely. So on Twitter, which we refuse to call by anything else
00:43:03.880and that yes, I have not been chased off of yet. You can find me at Faye Johnstone. I love a good
00:43:09.680pun. So my Instagram is at fading away because like she disappears sometimes. And if you want
00:43:15.560support my organization's work you can go to momentumcanada.net and have no doubt we are going
00:43:21.720to continue making noise at this current uh federal government but also we're soon going to be
00:43:27.480tapping back in in a big way in alberta uh where the government is looking like it's going to
00:43:32.120introduce the notwithstanding clause within the month and so stay tuned because we're going to
00:43:37.160have to get real angry and encourage all of y'all to do the same to protect the rights and freedoms
00:43:41.960of trans kids and their families. Yeah. Awesome. Thank you so much, Faye. And just so you know,
00:43:47.520that is Faye F-A-E. So that in the pun fading away is F-A-E. So we do have one super chat here
00:43:54.640that I'm going to pull up. Nicholas Chopp says, speaking of social media, have you two heard of
00:43:59.900the North Sky Project, a Canadian LGBT branch of Blue Sky? It's still in the works, but hopefully
00:44:04.760it can detoxify some social media. So I don't know what your reaction is to that, Faye, and what you
00:44:09.280think of these alternative social medias that are popping up um whether you think they'll work
00:44:13.700whether you think they are powerful or if they're gonna turn into just little community spaces that
00:44:19.820might not move the needle the way some other social media platforms can but can at least be
00:44:23.380a source of support what are your thoughts on them i think i'm twofold first like it's the same
00:44:28.720reason i'm still on x is kind of the same reason that i'm like not always jumping into the new like
00:44:35.080lefty social media place and that is i don't want to cede space i think that there is a risk we
00:44:39.800already have an echo chamber on the left we don't like to admit it but we do and i want to make sure
00:44:44.120that we are engaging beyond that space um but at the same time oh my god i am so excited the concept
00:44:49.400of a social media platform where i can actually be a human being and not worry that everything
00:44:53.000that i say or do is going to be taken out of context and turned into a like far right attack
00:44:57.640and so i'm like stay on the platforms and fight for that space while protecting yourself as you
00:45:03.400do it but also find those other spaces that can be more community-based and can be safer for you
00:45:10.840because i think those help us stay present in the global arena as well yeah yeah um i i totally
00:45:18.680agree i it's a bit of a controversial position apparently like i hear see from some of my peers
00:45:23.880that i choose to stay on twitter but i honestly just the if the decision makers didn't stay on
00:45:30.920there, I would leave. But the fact that so many who are making the decisions in the newsrooms of
00:45:36.580Canada, the biggest newsrooms and the biggest halls of power in terms of politics are continuing to
00:45:42.340scroll on that hell site means that if all of us just remove ourselves who provide a different
00:45:48.380perspective on these issues, they might become convinced that these loudest voices that are in
00:45:55.080fact minority voices that are in fact agitating in bad faith a lot of the time are the reality
00:46:01.500of Canadian society. So I feel the need to counter that because of the fact that these
00:46:07.420individuals who have so much power in our society refuse to learn that lesson. There was another
00:46:15.820question here. Someone wanted to know, are there any strong advocates of the LGBTQIA community who
00:46:21.140running for office that you know of um i don't know if you have any names off at the top of your
00:46:25.380head or folks who are getting into politics that you're excited about or folks who are already in
00:46:29.780politics that you're excited about that people can follow or look to as a north star perhaps uh
00:46:35.140what are your thoughts on that any names oh this one is easy um so actually i mean some of it is
00:46:40.180like there's not many i don't think there's any election currently underway on a provincial or
00:46:44.100federal level. But Lane Treasurer was just re-elected, is a non-binary Yukon NDP MLA up in
00:46:52.520the territories, and they are a badass and a source of hope for me. But then we also got folks
00:46:58.080like Logan Oxenham in Manitoba, the first openly trans man in provincial elected office. We've got
00:47:06.620folks like Janice Irwin, who is doing so much good for the gays and everybody else, making us all
00:47:13.300fall in love um and feel like butch envy out in alberta and so i think we have these champions
00:47:20.020i think there's a lot of them across different parties um and my invitation is i think we again
00:47:26.100i hate social media despite being a doom stroller myself my invitation is like that's actually
00:47:32.020organized to support their campaigns uh now more than ever it's great to share our hot takes on
00:47:36.820socials but we need to show up and knock on doors to help get good gays that they selected into
00:47:41.220office. Yeah. So that was the only other question that I saw. Oh, you know what? Sorry. I caught1.00
00:47:47.680another one here. I was going to be greedy and ask you another one of mine, but I'm going to
00:47:51.900throw this one at you. And then if no other one comes through, I'll throw you one last one from
00:47:55.160me. But someone says, Canadian here, how do either of you navigate social media to fight the good
00:48:00.540fight without being exhausted by the toxicity of certain media? What do you, how do you do this,
00:48:06.380say i think you know a lot of it i mean the shitty thing i would say is that you become
00:48:12.460hardened to it like it rolls off of you when you've been like broken and jaded about it enough
00:48:16.660times like there were moments when yes it broke me three years ago uh now i'm really good at
00:48:22.320blocking people and i'm really good at ignoring what's happening on my socials and i manage it by
00:48:27.300going back into community i joke that i have been to more drag shows and gay clubs than ever before
00:48:33.380since I came into this role because it's powerful to realize that these are just trolls on socials
00:48:38.420and that like community is thriving in our own spaces without them. And so like hang out in
00:48:45.380community, ignore the haters and like have fun because fun is one of the things that will keep
00:48:51.200our movements going. Totally. I completely agree. It's the same thing with me. Like I know it's such
00:48:56.800a thing to say, go touch grass, et cetera. But like really each blade of grass is, I feel like
00:49:05.160symbolically touching grass is like each blade of grass is another member of your community. And
00:49:09.680just like reacquainting yourself with that community, reminding yourself that the internet
00:49:13.600is not real. Like it is real in the sense that it has offline impact, but the voices that you see
00:49:19.560on there aren't necessarily reflective of how broader society as a whole thinks. There are
00:49:25.160going to be the loudest, awful voices on there. But you have to remember that the average person
00:49:30.100you run into in the street, first of all, a lot of those people who will say that to you online
00:49:33.020wouldn't even say that to your face in person. But like, the average person you run into either
00:49:37.740doesn't care, or I like to think hopefully are kind. And so I have those moments where I surround
00:49:42.920myself by that proverbial grass. And that reminds me that there are a lot of good people in this
00:49:47.680world. And I think that with things like the election of Zoran, we saw that if those people
00:49:51.900all come together and care that they can really win something because the um the politics of hate
00:49:58.460is very mobilizing and those politics have been mobilized for years while a lot of people felt
00:50:03.820apathetic because they weren't being offered exciting positive solutions but i think that
00:50:08.780what we're seeing now is a lot of folks building momentum building those positive solutions and
00:50:14.300I'm hopeful that as more people get involved and start to express the care that they do feel inside, that we'll start to see a shift in the narrative.
00:50:25.980But that actually leads me to the thing I wanted to talk about with you, Faye, because you mentioned earlier, and I think it's so interesting, like you and I have dealt with these really intense attacks on our character.
00:50:38.120and I wanted to ask you whether you feel as though that is something because I personally
00:50:44.500have a lot of feelings about this but I wonder about how those character assassinations have
00:50:50.060been effective in slowing progressive movements because you know if they make all of they being
00:50:57.100these sort of loud haters on social media and stuff when they watch us like hawks using what's
00:51:02.920referred to as like the gamer gate model but I won't get into all that right now
00:51:06.320When you're watched like a hawk by someone who dislikes you for you, for your opinions, but then anytime you make a mistake or do anything that they can conceive as being problematic, they will amplify it and pretend that that's the thing they care about when it's actually you as an individual and what you represent in your politics.
00:51:24.640But then our media isn't really taught to look for intent or to look to differentiate between good faith outrage and bad faith outrage.
00:51:36.920And so what ends up happening is they'll both sides those issues or they'll view you as controversial as a result and say, oh, when there's smoke, there's fire, yada, yada.
00:51:45.580So I wanted to know, like, is that something that you've encountered? And what lessons do you think our media and our society needs to learn about not participating in these character assassinations and smears as a result of, you know, these bad faith attacks?
00:52:03.940I think it's one of the like, I think I like to read it first as like a demonstration of success. Like we're clearly doing something effectively if they're like this invested in coming after us.
00:52:13.660like the funniest thing for me is that like my profile would be so much smaller if the far right
00:52:19.340wasn't obsessed with me like the fact that they go out of their way to like smack around anything
00:52:24.300that i'm involved in like babes like i don't think about y'all but they have like dozens of photos
00:52:29.260of both of us saved on their phones and i'm just like oh it's so weird um you're so normal wow
00:52:36.460people just do that right they just like save pictures of folks uh it's not creepy by any means
00:52:42.220um but i i think for me i like to rest on the fact that like they've created this whole like
00:52:47.020false persona of who i am and then people meet me and have a conversation with me and they realize
00:52:53.260that i'm like pretty much just like another human who wants to chat and that actually works in our
00:52:58.620favor when they frame us as unreasonable and we are as reasonable as i know us to be they look
00:53:04.700like extremists and they look like assholes and idiots and so i think that their character
00:53:10.940assassination strategies will eventually and are already starting to blow back on them we saw what's
00:53:15.980wrong he just like ran into it and kept going and then those folks over there looked unhinged when
00:53:21.340he just brushed off their criticism as the bad faith attacks that it were that they were and
00:53:27.100so i think there's a lot there um but i also think the risk is the overton window shifting
00:53:33.180right so i think we see if we don't you know respond with the politics of hope and goodness
00:53:39.580i think there is a risk that those narratives coming from certain segments of the far right
00:53:43.980filter more into mainstream media and then it gets harder for those of us who are in like
00:53:48.460unofficial spokespeople roles uh to get booked on those shows whereas on the right wing they're not
00:53:55.020bringing the like centrist anti-trans person who has like feelings and questions i want to chat
00:54:00.140with that person uh they're throwing up the unhinged i want to like criminalize and loathe
00:54:05.020of those transes. And so we need to make sure that we are wary of that and building our own
00:54:11.360movements and the power of our own response so that they can't shut us out of the public hands
00:54:16.060square. Totally. Yeah. I always think of that Cardi B quote where she was like, she was accepting
00:54:22.700an award or something. And she was like, and shout out to my haters because you're commenting
00:54:27.480on my stuff and blowing it up and you made me famous. So it is sort of a byproduct, but it is
00:54:34.080true that um i i think that a difficulty with as i mentioned the media is that they they can't it's
00:54:40.800difficult to differentiate intent or determine intent and differentiate between good faith and
00:54:45.520bad faith and as a result of that we end up with situations where they'll have these sort of
00:54:50.720radical people on air from the right um but then they'll also feel as though we are you and i are
00:54:57.360like loco because of the bad faith attacks that we get and then they're surprised when they actually
00:55:03.760see this in person which then kind of brings us full circle to the power of showing up in person
00:55:08.960and having community because i think that also helps to remove the false branding that people
00:55:14.000like you and i get because of the relentless character assassinations which are really
00:55:19.440evidence of our strength um so faye thank you so much for coming on the show today i really
00:55:25.360appreciate your time um is there anything that uh you didn't get the chance to touch on that you
00:55:31.680you want to say we've got like a minute left so I figured I'd give you the floor if you have
00:55:35.280anything else you want to mention I think just like I mean first like a thank you to you for
00:55:40.140creating a space and a platform where we can have these conversations because I think it is like
00:55:44.660the counter note that the world needs in an era of doom and gloom and then for everyone else
00:55:50.840watching I would say just like remember that it is scary uh but fear is what they want you to feel
00:55:57.380and hope is a choice. It's not always an easy choice when the world is on fire,
00:56:02.140but progressive change has always happened when good people tap in. And when we tap in,
00:56:07.380in unity, in a belief in a better future, nobody can stop us. We've always been outgunned. The
00:56:13.420rich have always had more money than we do, but we have won and we will keep winning as long as
00:56:18.400we keep hoping and showing up to make good things happen. Thank you so much, Faye. I think that's a
00:56:23.880great note to end things on. I really appreciate your time today and hopefully I can badger you
00:56:28.100to come back soon. Oh, absolutely. Thanks so much, Rachel.
00:56:37.800Thank you for listening to this week's episode of Bubble Pop. I'm Rachel Gilmore,
00:56:42.220your least favorite person's least favorite journalist. If you enjoyed this episode,
00:56:45.820consider subscribing on YouTube, Patreon, Substack, or wherever you like to listen.
00:56:50.400You can also find me on TikTok, Instagram, Twitch, and Blue Sky.
00:56:54.660I'd like to give a special thank you to Hans Vivian Wenzel for making the incredibly groovy