00:00:00.000melody the first thing you said to me is that you've been getting a lot of tiktoks for tubal
00:00:06.000legation yeah and also uh moving to ireland in addition to just like all of the other
00:00:14.860processing uh welcome to the first culture study podcast post-election i'm very glad that we didn't
00:00:23.320have anything come out last week nothing would have felt appropriate no but we are happy to be
00:00:28.960here. And actually, this is a perfect episode that I think this is the sort of nuance that I
00:00:34.980always crave when talking about something as complicated as gender in sports. And this is
00:00:40.900the sort of nuance that I think a lot of people really reject. And I just I love this episode.
00:00:46.980It's fantastic. And I'm really grateful for all of our listeners who are also willing to
00:00:53.300lean into the complication. So we're really happy you're here.
00:00:58.960OK, women's sports have never been more popular. And there's also like endless, seemingly endless public hand-wringing and outright panic about who should be able to participate in women's sports. So, Rose, are these two things connected?
00:01:14.700yes yeah yeah absolutely absolutely i think that you know if you can ignore women's sports because
00:01:22.980there's no money in it there's no fame in it there's no cultural power in it then it doesn't
00:01:27.360matter who competes but as soon as that stops being the case and as soon as you have women
00:01:32.680athletes female athletes being incredibly culturally powerful and relevant and rich
00:01:37.400and have all these brand deals and moving the culture forward all of a sudden it really matters
00:01:43.620who gets to compete and who doesn't. Right. Well, and this actually, I was thinking about
00:01:48.680the Olympics and how very few people outside of when it's Olympics time care about people who
00:01:55.800participate in so many different types of sports. And then suddenly, when the Olympics come into
00:02:04.080the foreground, and it's an opportunity for celebrity, like it's just this time when you can
00:02:10.720actually be someone in the public eye and wield some power, then suddenly we care about who's
00:02:16.960competing in, say, women's boxing. It is amazing how many people are experts in women's boxing.
00:02:23.000I just had no idea. There were so many women's boxing experts out there. It's just truly0.73
00:02:30.320incredible to me. This is the Culture Study Podcast, and I'm Anne Helen Peterson.
00:02:40.320I'm Rose Eveleth, the host of Tested, the podcast.
00:02:43.860Different podcast, not this podcast, different one.
00:02:46.320This is a great tee-up for us to talk about Tested, which came out in July alongside the Olympics.
00:02:53.480So how were you thinking in terms of, like, I want to create this podcast?
00:03:03.220I would love to say that this was, like, totally planned out and extremely strategic.
00:03:07.040um what is the truth is that I have been working on this series for 10 years I pitched it for eight
00:03:14.400years wow I pitched it 26 places until the CBC Canadian Broadcast Company said yes and then NPR
00:03:22.640eventually came on and that didn't happen until October of last year and then it was like oh
00:03:29.580well I guess we're doing this for the Olympics like it's it is good timing right it is the right
00:03:34.580perfect time to do it but it was sort of all of a sudden it went from me spending years you know
00:03:39.920funding this on my own spending all of my savings to make like try and make this to oh my god we
00:03:46.160have six months basically to make a huge documentary podcast series that would normally take 12 months
00:03:52.180to make um but it just like there was no universe in which we were putting this out after it had to
00:03:57.340be like you know right when the olympics were happening and so um i think you know it is it
00:04:02.260It was good timing and also stressful timing for me personally.
00:04:07.080So just for listeners who aren't familiar, because I know we have a lot of listeners who have listened to the show and love it.
00:04:13.500Can you sketch out what the show is and also what made you think that this could be a show and would be a show that would be important 10 years ago?
00:04:24.480Yeah, so Tested is about the sort of past, present and future of so-called gender verification policies in elite sports.
00:04:30.540And those are policies that basically say that there is some test that we have to do
00:04:34.980to make sure that the women competing in women's sports are really female or really women.
00:04:39.840And there's been this very long history of trying to find this test.
00:04:43.240It goes all the way back to the very beginning of women's competition in the Olympics.
00:04:46.920And for me, I think being able to trace that long history really puts today's conversation
00:08:32.020and the founder of the modern olympics pierre de couvertin was appalled by this this idea that
00:08:38.060women would want to do this thing in part because the olympics were founded largely as a way to
00:08:43.480encourage a certain kind of manliness right a certain kind of masculine athleticism and those0.99
00:08:49.980two words are sort of synonyms right like this idea of athleticism was not something that women0.60
00:08:53.940were supposed to aspire to you know in any way and so of course as as is always the case immediately
00:09:01.620women are saying hey I actually want to do that too and in fact I'm kind of good at it and I would
00:09:06.120like to compete and there's a long sort of and really fascinating back and forth that happens
00:09:11.420about how to include women in the Olympics whether to include women in the Olympics there are two
00:09:15.820books that I highly recommend one is by Michael Waters called The Other Olympians and the other
00:09:20.420is Maggie Merton's book Better Faster Stronger which sort of both sort of trace in some ways the
00:09:25.040early history of women's inclusion in sports and eventually they do win the ability to compete
00:09:31.220first they get you know the ladylike sports tennis which is very funny to me to consider
00:09:35.160that ladylike because at the time they were wearing corsets and they were literally taking
00:09:38.240off their corsets after these matches and bleed like they're bloody because they're playing tennis0.93
00:09:42.820in a corset so like they do it that's like this feminine like delicate thing that people are doing0.92
00:09:48.140is wild but eventually 1928 they get to compete on the track and this is just absolutely horrifying0.79
00:09:56.860to the men who are watching because when you run really hard your face makes weird shapes you look
00:10:03.040like you're exerting yourself you're doing all these physical things that to the men of the time
00:10:06.940many of them were just disgusting and they were fairly vocal about how disgusting they found it
00:10:12.520um and so that just felt so like it was so antithetical to what they believed real woman-ness
00:10:19.140and like femininity was that they sort of freaked out a little bit yeah yeah no and I think even
00:10:25.320just like articulating that very like basic coding that athleticism is masculine. And if you are
00:10:34.580athletic in some capacity, and if your body is good at being athletic, if your body is built in
00:10:40.440a way that codes it as athletic, then you are also masculine. And of course, this intersects
00:10:45.160with all these understandings about whiteness and race and all sorts of things. But that basic
00:10:51.460understanding guides so much of our thinking and it's so like it's just it's so wild to me that
00:10:59.020you're like oh like of course like all of this panic is rooted in this thing that like is not
00:11:04.620it it's all cultural like it's all understandings that we have mapped onto bodies there's nothing
00:11:12.100fixed about it totally totally and it is I mean it's also so interesting to to go back and read
00:11:18.660this and and you you know these men are not subtle right they're not trying to be you know
00:11:23.920like oh well of course we support with them they're like this is gross like this is disgusting to me0.94
00:11:28.240like they just they talk they think it's ugly they they like talk about it right in this way that is
00:11:32.620very you know unabashed right because of that was the dominant thought right in in the sort of
00:11:38.620powers that be and the other thing that's probably worth noting is that these men who are in charge
00:11:42.260of the olympics um for many years particularly the beginning these are the ultimate aristocrats
00:11:46.940These are, like, kings and princes and barons and, like, titled nobility people who have, even for their own time, a fairly regressive idea about what gender roles might look like.
00:11:58.160And those are the people that are creating the Olympics.
00:12:04.920There's just so many directions I could take this.
00:12:06.800But I think that we're going to cover a lot of the different ways that we could go with this.
00:12:10.920We're going to cover this as we answer listener questions.
00:12:15.960This comes from Jennifer, and Melody's going to read it for us.
00:12:19.680Regarding gender issues in sports, what's up with the transphobia and panic?
00:12:24.420At the end of the day, it regards a very small population.
00:12:27.920When people are trying to ban an assigned male at birth kid who has transitioned to being a girl from running cross country in South Dakota,
00:12:34.880a whole state of people are focused on keeping one up to a handful of children from competing.
00:25:55.280And so if you're going to draw a line and you're going to say, okay, we have a women's category because otherwise y'all will just never win and never be able to be competitive, then you have to enforce that boundary, right?0.92
00:26:05.500And you have to police that boundary.0.67
00:26:07.560And that is sort of the underlying argument here that they make around why it is that there's no point.