00:00:00.000For the Wild podcast is brought to you in part by the Calliopeia Foundation and listeners like you.
00:00:05.720Calliopeia supports projects interweaving spirituality, culture, and ecology.
00:00:11.160We are grateful for their support and the support of grassroots contributions from listeners.
00:00:16.020To learn more about the Calliopeia Foundation, visit calliopeia.org.
00:00:20.720To make a donation to For the Wild, visit forthewild.world slash donate or support us through Patreon.
00:00:30.000Hello and welcome to For the Wild podcast. I'm Ayanna Young. Today I'm speaking with Dr. Kutcha
00:00:39.120Risling-Baldy. We have to take a moment to kind of think about the ways in which we've not been
00:00:44.700able to learn how to imagine futures together beyond resource extraction. Dr. Kutcha Risling-Balding
00:00:53.980is an associate professor and department chair of Native American Studies at Humboldt State
00:00:58.580University. She received her PhD in Native American Studies with a designated emphasis
00:01:04.220in feminist theory and research from the University of California, Davis, and her MFA in creative
00:01:09.940writing and literary research from San Diego State University. She also has her BA in psychology
00:01:15.960from Stanford University. Her research focuses on California Indians, indigenous feminisms,0.94
00:01:22.600social and environmental justice, and decolonization. Her first book, We Are Dancing for You,
00:01:28.580Native Feminisms and the Revitalization of Women's Coming-of-Age Ceremonies
00:01:32.720Addresses Gender Inequality and Gender Violence Within Native Communities.
00:01:37.660Dr. Risling Baldi is Hupa, Yurok, and Kauruk,
00:01:41.740an enrolled member of the Hupa Valley Tribe in Northern California.
00:01:45.780In 2007, she co-founded the Native Women's Collective,
00:01:48.760a non-profit organization that supports the continued revitalization of Native American art and culture.
00:01:58.580Well, Katja, thank you so much for joining us today. I'm really looking forward to this
00:02:04.560conversation and just had such an inspiring research session, getting to know you a bit
00:02:11.600through your work in preparation for this. Yeah, thank you so much for inviting me.
00:02:17.180So I'd like to start off by talking about the land back movement. In the past couple of years,
00:02:22.680we've seen a cultural narrative shift around land ownership, settler relations, stolen land,
00:02:29.400and with more and more people attaching themselves to the language of land back,
00:02:34.440which is great, but it does feel like the shift loses some of its momentum and application,
00:02:40.160in part because I think settlers remain overwhelmed and perhaps unwilling to fully
00:02:44.900commit to the work of mapping out what land return looks like. So I'm wondering if you
00:02:50.360could speak to the reality of who actually owns the majority of land in this country,
00:02:54.900individuals or the state. And then what are some examples of how Land Back unfolds under
00:03:00.380United States legal governance? I love talking about Land Back because I think that it's a
00:03:07.520movement that sort of inspires what we could do. To me, it's like a really inspirational movement.
00:03:14.780It kind of says, like, how do we think beyond what we're currently living under, right? Like
00:03:19.820this settler colonial system, the system of capitalism and exploitation, and instead think0.69
00:03:25.600about what the future is going to look like. And I think if you would have asked people
00:03:30.38010 years ago, how can we even imagine that happening? People would have had a very different
00:03:36.820answer than now, because I have seen land return happen in my lifetime. I have been fortunate
00:03:44.160enough to be you know a witness to it and also to be a part of seeing that happen in my own
00:03:49.800communities so I I love this like conversation like starting this conversation and I always know
00:03:56.500that when I do start it it's very it can be very kind of scary for people at first you know because
00:04:01.460they've never really been approached with like oh what would it look like if we returned land to
00:04:04.940indigenous peoples but the more you talk about it the more it starts to become oh how exciting
00:04:09.980is land return? How exciting is land return? And what could that help us to sort of imagine this
00:04:15.980world to look like next? In the United States, we can talk specifically about the United States
00:04:20.920because things are so very different if you're talking about other countries, other spaces. But
00:04:25.920in the US, the primary land ownership is by private landowners. So about 60% of land is
00:04:32.620owned by private landowners. And then about 30% of land is owned by the federal government. So the
00:04:39.780federal government is the second largest land holder in the United States. And private land
00:04:45.540owners is anybody that owns land privately. And so that could be made up of several millions of
00:04:51.540people, really. But the federal government owns 30% of the land that is in the United States.
00:04:57.300And then the rest is sort of a mixture of state governments and then tribal governments. Tribal
00:05:03.960governments own about like 2.5% of the land in the United States. So, you know, a significantly0.99
00:05:11.140smaller portion. And when you think about like land ownership in general, you also sort of,
00:05:17.120if you do research on it, you kind of start to realize that there's a very large racial
00:05:21.780disparity in who owns land through private land ownership. And so the five largest land owners
00:05:27.800in America are all white and they own more rural land in the United States than all of Black America0.62
00:05:35.000combined. So if you're looking at like Black land ownership, the five largest landowners in America0.99
00:05:40.500own more land than all of the Black ownership of land in the United States. It's generally
00:05:47.520white Americans who own land. So you have about 98% of land ownership is owned by white Americans.
00:05:55.140And so you see a great racial disparity when it is white Americans to own 90% of U.S. land that is in land ownership. So of the 60% that's owned by private ownership, 98% of that is white Americans versus every other group in the United States.
00:06:11.260And I think that that's something that when people start to learn about that, they get very surprised that there's such a large racial disparity when it comes to land ownership.
00:06:22.240And it actually becomes like a really interesting conversation because then you start to see that lends itself to how we understand like wealth disparity in the United States as well.
00:06:31.400It's primarily white families who are significantly wealthier than all other racial and ethnic groups combined.
00:06:38.180So if you take all ethnic groups and combine where their wealth is in their families and you add them all together, it does not meet the same as white families who have generally a net worth that is much more than all of those families combined.
00:06:55.480And then you also look at how then that lends itself to what land ownership looks like within your own communities. When you break down land ownership in the United States, what you'll notice is that the eastern part of the United States kind of blending into what we call now the Midwest is primarily dotted with federal land ownership.
00:07:19.500And so you see very sparse areas that are owned federally because, you know, the federal government's the second largest landowner.
00:07:26.440But when you get to the West and the Southwest, the land of the West and the Southwest is primarily owned by the federal government.
00:07:34.540And so what you'll see is that there are some places where the federal government is the largest landholder in the state.
00:07:41.620In the Midwest and East Coast, that's not usually the case.
00:07:44.280Usually it's private landowners that are the primary owners of the land in the state.
00:07:48.760But on the West Coast, it's primarily the federal government.
00:07:51.760And in California, 45 percent, I think, 45 percent of the state is owned by the federal government.
00:07:58.900In Nevada, it's like 80 percent of the state is owned by the federal government.
00:08:02.540So a lot of this really does have to do pretty significantly with history, like the history of the region and the area.
00:08:09.880And then also the availability of natural resources and resource extraction industry, and then the availability of what we now call like, you know, the wilderness or state and national parks and forest land. And you see a kind of big disparity between federal government ownership of land on the west of the United States versus the east and Midwest.
00:08:31.220I want to mention for listeners one specific example where the city of Eureka returned the island of Tuluat to the Wiyat.
00:08:40.320And I'm wondering if you could share about this example and how this return initiated a new chapter in Wiyat's living history.
00:08:49.000Yes, I mean, and this is actually particularly important to me because it's, you know, it's the it's the place where I live.
00:08:53.760So I am joining you today from Humboldt County in what the WIAT refer to as like Baduwat, the Baduwat region, which is very near the Mad River, what's currently called McKinleyville, but it's very near what the WIAT called Gigi or Eureka, California.
00:09:09.760And so this whole region where Humboldt State is, which is where I teach, that's all on WIAT land.
00:09:15.820And WIAT land spans a really large portion of what we currently call Humboldt County.
00:09:21.920And in the centers, the city centers of Humboldt County, primarily Eureka, but also Arcata,
00:09:27.400McKinleyville, sort of like the places where many of the people live, are right in the0.99
00:09:32.920And the Wiat worked for, you know, close to two decades, like over 20 years on the return0.88
00:09:39.260of Tuluat Island, which is the center of the world for them.1.00
00:09:43.220It's the place where the world came into being.
00:09:46.660and it's really significant to how they celebrate and renew the world each time that they do world
00:09:52.720renewal ceremonies. And in our area, you know, it was pretty well known by us as Native people,
00:09:58.600even though I don't think it's like standard practice to teach about Tuluat in the way that
00:10:02.860maybe we grew up learning about it. But it was the site of a really horrific massacre in the 1800s
00:10:09.720during the gold rush when we had a massive influx of people to this region who were really just here
00:10:15.260to try to get as much gold as possible. And they thought of Native people really as in the way
00:10:19.740of that. And they didn't really want to set up, you know, like relationships with Native peoples
00:10:26.280and governance structures. They wanted to get whatever they could from the land, from the gold0.87
00:10:31.100and from the people. So you see these moments of them passing laws to legalize slavery of Native0.86
00:10:37.160people, passing laws they can legalize militias that would rise up against Native people and0.85
00:10:42.340commit massacres and kidnap primarily women and children. And Jack Norton, who wrote a really
00:10:47.980great book called Genocide in Northwest California, he really talks about how in Humboldt County,
00:10:53.660it was a marauding horde of people. And he refers to them as a marauding horde. And he just says,
00:10:59.540you know, the violence introduced during this area was in this area during this period of time
00:11:04.280was really horrific. And you almost cannot, you can't tell a story that will tell you about just
00:11:09.840how awful it was. And so you're talking about indigenous peoples having to navigate this period0.98
00:11:16.260of time when really everybody is working together through law, through policy, through militias to0.97
00:11:23.780try to get rid of us, to genocide us. It was nothing. I mean, it was an attempted genocide
00:11:29.320of our people. And then in this region with the WIAT, they had to navigate just sort of the
00:11:34.660ever-changing policies of the state and county government about where they could and could not
00:11:40.080be. So you're looking at Tuluat as a place that they thought of as very important. And they were
00:11:46.120doing a world renewal ceremony in the 1800s. And they, because of that, many of their men would
00:11:54.400stay off the island while primarily women, children, and elders would be on the island
00:11:58.680during this ceremony and a group of people came together from like a Humboldt County citizenry
00:12:06.120and they went to the island to massacre everybody there and they killed primarily women children and
00:12:13.200elders one of the things that a historian Tony Platt talks about is that they used very like
00:12:19.940he calls them quiet weapons things like hatchets and knives and came in the dead of night to kill
00:12:26.860everyone. And it's a really, it's a horrific and sad story about these people who were trying to
00:12:34.340perform a ceremony that would balance the earth for everyone and help the earth for everyone.
00:12:41.140And then they were attacked in this way. And after the island was emptied out because of this
00:12:47.500massacre, you see people coming in and purchasing it and selling off pieces of it. And it becomes
00:12:54.080sort of like private property, but also city property. And I think that one thing that I
00:12:58.560always try to point out to people is like, after that period of time, a lot of people started
00:13:02.980referring to this island as Indian Island. And like colloquially in this region, especially,
00:13:08.540they will sometimes call it Indian Island. And I really made a point like with myself and
00:13:14.640my students and people that I talked to to say that I try not to refer to it as Indian Island.
00:13:19.420Although if you look up different things, many people will talk about it that way.0.99
00:13:23.040But it was only given that name after they, you know, attempted this massacre of Wiat people. Then they started referring to it as Indian Island. And instead, it's Tuluat. Like, that's the name of the space, you know, that the Wiat have known for, you know, for time immemorial.
00:13:41.820And so Tuluat, I think, is a really important name to sort of reclaim and make sure that that's what we call it.
00:13:49.620And there's so many beautiful and amazing stories around Tuluat that what I tell people is it'd be easy to tell that story as if it was a story of like the end of Wiat peoples or the tragedy by how we remember them or how we know them.
00:14:06.380And for a long time, I think most people would say that what they know about the Wiyat is that they experienced this great tragedy, this attempted massacre of all of their peoples on Indian Island.
00:14:16.260But now the story is very different. And I think that that's important for us to remember because, you know, 150 years later, the Wiyat returned and they did a world renewal ceremony there and they made a point to be able to be in that space.
00:14:30.460And then they worked for 20 plus years to have the island returned. And it started with their tribal leader at the time, Cheryl Seidner, just sort of starting to say to people, I'm going to get my island back. Now it's time. It's time for us to get Tuluat back.
00:14:46.720And people told her, people told all of them, I think, that that wouldn't be possible, that that was like a pipe dream, that that was from that would take so long. And they just kept saying, no, like, this is what needs to happen. This is what's right. So they just made it happen.
00:15:02.680And I keep telling people like, you know, you're talking about people who came together and started doing like bake sales and selling T-shirts, trying to just get people to donate to them so that they could buy portions of the of the island that were for sale.
00:15:18.840And then they started saying out loud to people, we need to get this island back.
00:15:22.640And what would that look like and how would that work?
00:15:24.940And you have the Eureka City Council working with them to make that happen.
00:15:28.500And yes, it took, you know, over 20 years to make that happen.0.84
00:15:32.680But from start to finish, what I've learned from speaking with the Wiyot peoples and listening to them tell this story is to them, they were signing up for however long it took to get the island back.
00:15:46.180They were like, if it took 20 years, if it took 30 years, we weren't going to stop working for the return of this place that is the center of the world that we need to make the world healthy again and that we need so that we can carry on the ceremonies that we have.
00:16:00.560um and i think that that type of approach which says you know this is our space our land our
00:16:07.520our future and we're going to work as long as it takes to make these things happen because we know
00:16:12.700that this is what needs to happen so that this whole world can be a better place that's the
00:16:17.200story that we should tell about native people sometimes we focus a lot on telling the story
00:16:21.780of california indian genocide and you see like the best-selling books about california indians
00:16:27.440tend to be about our genocide. But I think the stories of our resurgence and our revitalization,
00:16:32.860our land return, our movements, those are the stories that I want people to know about us. And
00:16:37.600those should be the stories that are the bestsellers about us because we're doing that
00:16:41.840good work right now. Yeah, just as we've seen a popularization of land acknowledgements in the
00:16:49.260past couple of years, I've also noticed that traditional ecological knowledge has become
00:16:53.980much more of a buzzword. And I can't help be reminded of earlier moments in history where
00:16:59.900settlers were really interested in indigenous culture as a means to secure their own hobbies,
00:17:06.540livelihoods, and even culture, but weren't willing to engage with indigenous sovereignty.
00:17:11.600Another example that you've written about is the hypocrisy of California implementing controlled
00:17:16.680burns and acknowledging indigenous practices as a way to save, quote, the state without addressing
00:17:22.760the California tribes that still don't have access to their land. So it would appear that
00:17:28.380settlers just want to be able to import the ideas and practices that we think will give us a shot
00:17:36.300at life on this earth, but we want to do so without having to learn about rematriation.1.00
00:17:42.600So I'm wondering if you could speak to the reality that you can't uproot indigenous
00:17:46.360sovereignty as something that exists siloed from traditional ecological knowledge.
00:17:50.780sure i mean i think that um we're always talking about like what are we going to do now right like
00:17:57.340what is it going to look like as we start to really face uh what's happening with climate
00:18:03.180change what's happening with like environmental justice issues what's happening with racial
00:18:06.920justice issues uh what are we going to do like what what are what are the solutions look like
00:18:11.640and i think that for far too long we've been creating solutions um especially to these larger
00:18:16.780problems of like, what do we do with climate change without Indigenous knowledges? And have
00:18:22.440been taking for really for granted that Indigenous knowledges are going to be the response that we0.79
00:18:27.520need to have. I've been reading articles talking about how like, you know, Indigenous knowledges
00:18:31.920are not a backup plan anymore. They are the plan. And the things that we've been fighting for and
00:18:37.580maintaining and pursuing for the last 50 years really are the ways that need to happen in order
00:18:44.820to move forward. And what I think that also means is that we as Indigenous nations need to be
00:18:53.060centered in how we enact that knowledge and what that looks like, because it can't happen
00:18:59.340in a vacuum, in a silo. It's like a totalizing experience of what this space is supposed to
00:19:08.240look like. So if you talk about cultural burning, for instance, some of the people that have some0.90
00:19:13.400of the most intimate knowledge of the forests and the ways in which they're supposed to be managed,
00:19:18.500especially in our region, also have no access to forest land, because even though they are
00:19:23.940tribal nations recognized by the United States, the land in which they now have doesn't include
00:19:30.600forest land. So when they want to go and gather or interact with or even propose cultural burning,
00:19:37.320they have to navigate several federal government agencies to make that happen. And a lot of the
00:19:41.660times that's based on a lot of education because you still have people who don't know that like
00:19:46.380cultural burning is one of the only things I think that's really going to address this issue of like
00:19:50.840why our forest fires burn so hot or why they're so damaging or why it is that they pop up every0.91
00:19:56.940couple years in a way that really sort of like destroys rather than protects like the region
00:20:02.680that they're in and you start to see people saying well what's the answer to this and people are like
00:20:07.380it's cultural burning. If we had been burning consistently, we would not be having these same
00:20:12.060problems. And what you're seeing is that the policies that were set forth by the federal
00:20:16.160government that primarily focused on fire suppression in order to maintain, and really
00:20:22.720that was about like capitalism and profit, because it's really focused on how do we make more
00:20:28.160trees or more things that we could use so that we could take it out of the area and we can sell it.
00:20:33.980But it's also really based on this idea that somehow this is supposed to be wilderness and what people were seeing was like untouched land.
00:20:42.000And wilderness is a concept that really was used to erase Native people from lands.
00:20:46.500And most of the wilderness that we know today, especially in California, is Native lands where Native people were living when that quote unquote wilderness was created.
00:20:55.940So when they became national parks or state parks, Native people were actually living in there.
00:20:59.960And so anything that you're thinking about when you think about wilderness, what you're actually thinking about is native lands that they tended to, that they took care of, and much of that was done with cultural burning.
00:21:08.380So when people start talking about bringing cultural burning back, what they don't tend to acknowledge is, yes, inviting indigenous peoples from that area to come in and tell you and inform you and help you to do that cultural burning is really necessary.
00:21:22.400But it's also really insulting because you're acting as if that land is not their land that they have knowledge of. And you're being okay with the fact that they're being kept out of it legally and often physically and often like spiritually and socially.
00:21:39.300they can't connect with that forest land in the same way because it belongs to the National Park
00:21:45.200Service or to the State Park Service because it's part of wilderness areas or protected in some way
00:21:50.840by the federal government or even the state government laws. And so I'm thinking in particular
00:21:55.320in our area about like the Kaduk tribe. They are a tribe who was significantly impacted by the gold
00:22:00.960rush. Horrific things happened in that area to remove them from their lands and push them into
00:22:07.620various areas. And then they made a treaty with the federal government, with the United States
00:22:12.420at a point in the 1800s when they were making treaties in California. And because of pushback
00:22:17.820from the citizenry of California, those treaties were never ratified. And so suddenly you go from
00:22:23.020tribal nations in California being guaranteed certain lands that they negotiated, that they
00:22:28.600made sure they would have until the end of time that they agreed to, to maintain a relationship
00:22:35.080of nation to nationhood with the United States. And these treaties were unratified. And then they
00:22:40.480were put under an injunction of secrecy so that nobody knew about it. And then the Native people
00:22:47.740in California were never informed of this. And so what you suddenly see is like just pandemonium
00:22:52.600and chaos because of what happened with these treaties, which are still in existence. You can
00:22:56.280actually go, the Smithsonian, the National Museum of American Indian did an exhibit on the treaties
00:23:01.980a couple years back, and actually brought them out from where they had been kept in storage,
00:23:07.640so you could see that these were real documents signed by Native people and the federal government
00:23:13.340of the United States. And so what they have now are two areas of land that they live on,
00:23:19.300that they're a part of, but they don't have a large reservation, and they don't have any forest
00:23:24.480land in their control. Yet they still continue to outreach and work so closely with forest managers
00:23:30.660and the forest area. And so they make requests about cultural burning. They make requests
00:23:36.280constantly about saying, we want to take care of this area. And they are consistently,
00:23:41.100there's so many roadblocks to making that happen. And a lot of people coming at them through
00:23:45.800suspicion of like, why do you want to be in charge of this? Or what does this mean?
00:23:49.600Or like, how do we make this happen? And so to me, it's like, people want the benefits,
00:23:55.020they want the knowledge, they want to be able to invite indigenous peoples in, come here and give,
00:23:58.840And we will extract from you this knowledge of what to do in this area so that we can keep it healthy and safe. But start talking to them about how like, well, then look at the Karuk who don't have the same type of access to land and don't have the same type of ownership of land. How are you working to uphold their sovereignty, self-determination? And how are you working to push back and say they need to be the ones who also have access to, who own this area?0.99
00:24:25.320And if you're not working in partnership in that way, then what you're really doing is kind of saying that you're OK with this unequal treatment of tribal peoples, where they are really important to how we're going to build our futures in a way that we can all breathe, that we can all not have periods of time where the air is so thick with smoke that we can't even go outside so that we can protect our future peoples and families and areas.
00:24:55.320even our water supply and resources because fire is really you know attached to water and you're
00:25:01.620okay with letting them do all of that but the idea of having a conversation about what that means for
00:25:05.720their sovereignty and what that means for their own land ownership isn't okay then to me that's
00:25:10.300such an unequal relationship that it um it behooves people pointing out like this is not okay
00:25:16.460like we also have to uphold what they need if we're going to ask them for that type of work
00:26:16.580Yeah, I see this a lot in my on-the-ground work.
00:26:44.320And it's so complex. And yeah, it's just another form of extraction and really manipulation as well. And I'm thinking about California's gold rush again. And then I think about Canada's current gold rush and the interviews I've done with Nuskamata up in British Columbia and just all the extractive industries that continue to plunder the earth to uphold a violent lifestyle.
00:27:11.780And I do wonder, what will it take for us to recognize that California's gold rush was a precautionary tale?0.99
00:27:20.120And despite living amongst the consequences every day, you know, this current dominant culture continues to replicate the same abuses.
00:27:29.200So what do you think is required to break this psychosis?
00:27:35.080um i think that i actually think physically when people start to see land being returned it kind
00:27:40.940of changes their their approach to tribal nations when they're starting to go like oh you guys could
00:27:46.980actually have land returned and then you know it could work in a very different way how we understand
00:27:50.940like the placement of land or the idea of what land is what in this region so i do think like
00:27:56.520working toward land return to indigenous peoples is really important uh because it demonstrates
00:28:01.540for people sort of the reality of how physically ownership can change or even like the physicality
00:28:07.180of like where you go to do certain industry or where you where you can sort of have certain
00:28:12.980lands under like that are open for certain things or not um so I would say land return but that's
00:28:17.940my answer to everything like everybody's always asking me like what's the answer to this and I
00:28:22.080always say land return just give it back and then uh we'll have a totally different conversation
00:28:26.000after that, I promise. But the other thing I'll say is, we have to take a moment to kind of think
00:28:31.940about the ways in which we've not been able to, to learn how to imagine futures together beyond
00:28:38.840resource extraction. And, you know, we view like the ways in which we do things in this world as
00:28:45.440like kind of inevitable. And then also, that it's not possible to do something else. And all the
00:28:51.240time people will say to me, like, that's a really good dream that you have, right? Where I'm like,
00:28:56.280oh, someday we won't actually need any fossil fuels. And then they're like, that's a really
00:29:00.420good dream you have, but that's impossible. That's impossible. But what I tell people now is like,
00:29:05.440you know, I think we have to stop thinking about things as impossible. What we have to do is say
00:29:09.760out loud what we want the world to be. In indigenous contexts, we say nothing can become
00:29:15.880until you speak it into being and you, you first have to tell a story about it. You have to open
00:29:21.520up people's imaginations to what that could look like. Um, I've been doing a lot of like really
00:29:27.740good research and talks where you hear, you hear from people that like, uh, there was a speaker
00:29:32.960who I heard one time talking about how it's easier for people to imagine like what they're
00:29:37.760going to do in a zombie apocalypse. Uh, they'll have like plans and they'll be like, when the
00:29:42.480zombies come, I'll do this, right? They can do that, but they can't imagine a world post-capitalism
00:29:47.480and they can't imagine a world like post-settler colonialism. And they can't imagine a world
00:29:52.720post-patriarchy because we don't get a lot of like books or movies or things that are like,
00:29:57.140this is what the world looks like once we've taken apart settler colonialism and we've started to
00:30:01.680look at what this could look like when we're not building pipelines, right? When we're not
00:30:06.000extracting resources, when the dams come down, like we have a hard time thinking about that post.
00:30:12.480But we have to start to be the people that say out loud when the dams come down, after the dams come down, because we have to know it's possible.0.95
00:30:22.080And the thing I know in my life right now is when people, when the Wiyot went to the city and they were like, we're going to get this island back, however long it takes.0.93
00:30:33.780When they started talking to people about it, people kept telling them it was impossible.0.97
00:30:37.640and then it happened. And I always say to people, I have seen an impossible thing happen in my
00:30:44.180lifetime. So I've seen the impossible become possible in my own lifetime. So I know that
00:30:50.620it starts with being open with yourself to like have that conversation and to say out loud
00:30:56.140the things that you want to see happen. And so I feel like that's my job lately is I go and
00:31:01.280I'll do talks and I'll stand up in front of rooms and I'll be like, give all the land back and all
00:31:06.060the baskets and all the remains and all that because that to me is where we're where we're
00:31:10.680going with this and then people will be like oh that's impossible and I was like well I'm going
00:31:14.160to keep saying it because I feel like at a point it starts to become more possible because we're
00:31:18.620just speaking it out loud and I see that as like a movement toward allowing us the space to have
00:31:25.980conversations about what that could look like because all the times I start talking about like
00:31:30.660land return, for instance, uh, people want all the answers about how that's going to look. So
00:31:36.460they'll, they'll start asking me like real kind of like nitty gritty questions about like, well,
00:31:41.540how's that going to work on a functional level of property taxes within like cities, states,
00:31:46.480and counties. And I just, I just started to laugh and I'm like, you know, that's going to take some
00:31:50.720work to do. You're right. But let's start by giving the land back and then we can answer all
00:31:54.480those questions and see how it works. Like, I, I kind of want to tell people like it doesn't have
00:32:00.020to be all perfect before you make something happen what you have to start doing is talking about it
00:32:05.020and then you figure out how to make that happen and anybody that's returned land which we've done
00:32:10.840a report which shows like what land return looks like throughout California it looks different for
00:32:15.940everybody because I think that's part of like the imaginatory process and I do think that in Native
00:32:22.020American Studies, especially, we're doing so much work to retell the stories. We call it rewriting
00:32:30.360history, so that people can start to see that imaginatively in history, there's always been
00:32:37.880a different view that shows you that there was something else happening and going on,
00:32:41.900and you need to see it. You need to know that story so that you can imagine something different
00:32:46.760now. I think of the work of my colleague, Caitlin Reed, and she's really doing amazing research
00:32:53.960on how she's understanding the current movement and what they call the green rush in Humboldt
00:33:03.140County with the cannabis industry. And she's saying, you know, it's talked about as like the
00:33:08.000green rush. And she's really looking at the fact that it's repetitive of the gold rush in terms of
00:33:13.640the same types of focus on resource extraction uh who's actually making money sort of like what
00:33:20.300happens to the land in this region and the question becomes when when will we learn our lesson
00:33:25.820and one thing that i told her when she was interviewing me as part of that research is like
00:33:30.880well we've been rushing like humboldt county has been rushing since the very beginning like we
00:33:35.240rushed like they rushed the gold trying to think that was going to be the thing they rushed minerals
00:33:39.780they rushed in the timber industry they rushed in the fishing industry it's never been good for the1.00
00:33:46.280region and there has to be something else and through all of that it was always indigenous1.00
00:33:50.840people saying this is not the answer to how you're supposed to live here like this is not the answer
00:33:57.980to how we're supposed to be in this space and they and we have maintained our ceremonies our
00:34:02.820connections to land, our histories, our knowledges, our sciences. And we keep doing it, knowing that
00:34:10.420this is going to be the answer to how we're going to move forward. And I think we've seen that world.
00:34:16.960I think we've dreamed that world for thousands of years. So I don't think we're going to stop
00:34:22.400until we can chip away and see how we can make that happen.
00:34:25.300you write quote my contention is that through this in-depth analysis of cultural revitalization
00:34:35.960as decolonizing praxis we see how native nations are able to challenge settler colonialism through
00:34:42.520native feminisms and build revitalization movements that not only imagine decolonized0.74
00:34:48.000alternatives but also acknowledge that these alternatives did have always and will always0.89
00:34:54.140exist, end quote. And that last sentence, I think, really is saying that cultural revitalization
00:35:02.220is anti-apocalyptic, and revitalization is done in collaboration with the past, present,
00:35:08.620and future all at once, always. So I'd love if you could speak a bit about what cultural
00:35:14.640revitalization has taught you about living well post-apocalypse. I mean, I think it's taught me
00:35:20.940a couple of things. One is that the answers that we're seeking can be found within our own cultural
00:35:27.840teachings and cultural knowledge. I think we were some of the best philosophers and many of our
00:35:35.500oldest stories are providing for us guidance to be able to build futures and saying like,
00:35:42.200we're going to be here for you in multiple and various ways. And so here's a story to kind of
00:35:48.380help guide you through that and I think it teaches us that like the power of those things
00:35:55.120so that we don't feel um like we're starting brand new uh but acknowledging that like this
00:36:04.080is a very old knowledge that has been time tested and has managed to be passed through
00:36:13.840generations after generations so there's something very powerful about that but that it is also so
00:36:20.100adaptable and um challenging to our current situation uh i i look to the old stories a lot
00:36:29.480and i'll say you know let's start with our language let's start with our stories to see
00:36:33.280what's the guidance that's supposed to be provided to us about how we live in this world
00:36:38.800And I think it helps us so that we don't feel like we're making it up brand new, but that it's coming from a base of knowledge that we've carried with us.
00:36:48.960I also think when you're talking about post-apocalypse, there's something very powerful about us being able to do this revitalization now.
00:36:58.480So when you think about the effort and energy that went into the peoples who were living through the apocalypse, right, who were living through the genocide to make sure that we would have this, whether that was like a person saying, you know, I'm going through this, but I have a song, I'm going to pass that song on and make sure that happens.
00:37:20.920or I know one part of it, you know, or I'll carry these words forward. Whether that was people
00:37:27.080saying, I'm going to sit with this anthropologist or this ethnographer, and I'm going to tell them
00:37:31.240everything I know about the women's ceremony. Those are moments where you start to see that
00:37:35.860what we're doing now is such an important honoring of the effort and strength that it
00:37:43.380took for them to be able to do that and and and and also i think um a demonstration that they're
00:37:51.220envisioning that they're saying out loud someday someone's going to do this dance again and we need
00:37:57.640them to have this information made it happen like they had to start by saying that it was possible
00:38:02.740that someday somebody would do this again and they said it and they brought it into being
00:38:08.540because then now we're doing it so they were not wrong and they were making sure that you know
00:38:14.280people could make it possible by saying aloud someday it would happen and when I would interview
00:38:19.960the women who were involved in this revitalization a lot of them talked about how like
00:38:24.580you know every generation somebody shared something somebody did a demonstration somebody
00:38:30.020sang a song somebody did something and they just kept saying someday somebody's going to do this
00:38:34.920dance again someday we're going to do it again so now i'm going to share this part they just said
00:38:39.880it out loud um and according to like the the medicine woman i interviewed she talked about how
00:38:45.720when they finally were open to it and they said okay we want to do it once they said we want to
00:38:52.020do it she said all we had to do is scratch the surface we just had to say we wanted it and then
00:38:56.800so many things came to us elders started to remember things that they had forgotten people
00:39:02.660started to have dreams that reminded them of something that they might not have remembered
00:39:07.200otherwise. Songs came to people. So I think that those are the things that people should understand
00:39:13.160is like, it was slightly bigger than us. But I think it also showed that those efforts and
00:39:18.740moments of what happens in time of great upheaval, where you're like, I'm going to believe that
00:39:23.600there's a better future after this, I'm going to believe that there's going to be a moment of
00:39:28.140resurgence and revitalization, that it mattered because that's what helped to make it possible
00:39:34.040for us to be able to do it because they never stopped bringing it up. They never stopped saying
00:39:38.460it. They never stopped speaking about it. They never stopped. They never pretended like it was
00:39:43.660gone forever. To them, it was always a part of their cultural imagination. It was waiting for
00:39:48.780the right time for it to happen again. And I think that that's a really beautiful thing for us to be
00:39:54.040a part of now. Because when I start talking about what the future could look like, and I'm saying,
00:39:58.860let's speak into being the things that we want. I'm telling you, for my elders and ancestors,
00:40:04.620I am the living being of the things that they wanted. We are doing the things that they spoke
00:40:09.820into being now. So what are we going to speak into being and make happen in the future?
00:41:19.580Indigenous Peoples and the Politics of Water
00:41:22.540with Melanie Yazzie. And you write, so too, do we both maintain indigenous feminist integrity
00:41:29.820towards the love of all good relatives of the earth and the cosmos who caretake the future?
00:41:35.640In closing, we leave you, our new relative, with this. Indigenous people are good at making1.00
00:41:41.880relatives. It's what we do. It's who we are. Our relatives are our source of strength. We are not
00:41:48.340And so I'd like to ask you about indigenous feminism in terms of emboldening kinship and0.98
00:42:17.200respect. And for many folks, the concept of feminism in their communities has been appropriated
00:42:23.700and commodified and just really hollowed out, which has caused a lot of injury. So I'm wondering
00:42:29.920how has Indigenous feminism in Native communities remained devoted to respect and relationality
00:42:35.860while actually chipping away at the gender binary, not solidifying it?
00:42:40.440I think that what indigenous feminism is really important and is really building off of and a part of a lot of women of color feminisms, you know, like you're talking about black feminism, you're talking about Asian feminism, you're talking about the feminisms that are sort of pushing back against a feminism that would sort of uphold white supremacy.
00:43:02.460And I think it's I always it's really important for me to point out to people, people will sometimes give the label white feminism and they'll say, like, you know, what I'm really what I'm really what I'm really not on board with is white feminism.
00:43:16.920And I always say like any feminism that upholds white supremacy or that upholds like racial injustice or that in any way sort of doesn't center intersectionality, doesn't center like the voices of the least marginalized is just not feminism.
00:43:34.920So I wouldn't even call that feminism at all, because feminism is about looking at how we understand what equality actually is. And for us, I think doing this work, we're really talking about how we uplift, center, and push forward the most marginalized of voices, so that we understand that gender equity and equality is what we're talking about, and that we have experienced that.
00:44:01.620I think what Indigenous feminisms adds to this conversation is that in the time before colonization, you are talking about cultures that were truly enacting, theorizing, and living Indigenous feminisms, that were living in a way that said gender equity is about the ability of peoples to be able to live in a space where they are treated in a way that upholds dignity, respect, and relationship.
00:44:31.620And whether that manifests itself as various genders or manifests itself as various gender identities, that doesn't play into how we understand what relationality is and the relationship that we exist in with each other.
00:44:50.480And we know that time. We have stories about it. We talk about it. We see it enacted through our ceremonial practices. So we know that that can exist.
00:45:03.420So for anybody to come in and say a society that exists where all genders are equal is a utopia, a utopic vision that could never possibly be, because a lot of the times we get told through our own ways in which we learn about history or the ways in which we learn about politics or culture or society, what they call social science, right?0.85
00:45:25.320people sort of take for granted they kind of say like patriarchy is natural and sort of like a0.83
00:45:29.940patriarchal role of how we understand the world is the natural way of being and then you see these
00:45:35.280kind of moments throughout even like the ways in which we understand like science or the or you
00:45:41.240know the animal kingdom or whatever where people are like see we can normalize this idea of like
00:45:47.580patriarchy and inequality of genders through all these ways that we view the world but indigenous
00:45:52.700feminism reminds you that actually when you are in relationship with the world through an
00:45:57.760indigenous lens, you are in that relationship in a way that values the equity of gender and all
00:46:05.900beings. And that it's a very different way of approaching. It's not extractive. It's not
00:46:13.100exploitive. And it really values people and demonstrates that when we exist in relationship,
00:46:20.620we make very different decisions. And it also then says, and there is a way that this can exist
00:46:27.260because we have lived it. We have seen it. It was the way that many of our cultures were
00:46:35.000organized. And then you see then what happens with the change with gender violence, with sort
00:46:41.120of the introduction of like the ways in which people approach gender specifically. The attempted
00:46:46.680genocide, I mean, this is actually really important work that's been done by Debra Miranda
00:46:51.180here in California, where she talks about the attempted specific targeting for a genocide
00:46:57.400of people of different genders. So people who sort of lived in art, who are a part of our
00:47:04.980communities, who, you know, don't fit the male female binary of gender, were really targeted0.63
00:47:12.220for genocide especially in the Spanish mission system and so you start to see that all coming
00:47:17.940in at the same time and so now we're intervening again because I think I don't I it's really hard
00:47:25.740to hear from people when you start talking about this and they go well that's a utopic vision of1.00
00:47:29.440society I'll say you know prior to colonization many of the work that's being done by indigenous1.00
00:47:34.480feminists show that there are there are many indigenous cultures that did not have rape1.00
00:47:40.860Rape is not something that existed.1.00
00:47:43.160It doesn't mean that we didn't have like any instances ever in the 10,000 years minimum
00:55:16.080But we, we are the people 150 years from then.
00:55:19.620So we're like, hey, that wasn't a good idea.
00:55:22.120like we really shouldn't we shouldn't pour mercury in the water because now we have a bunch of water
00:55:27.000that we can't fish from or use and i mean we like as in everybody in that part of california
00:55:32.160so when we're thinking about our decision making process we need to realize like when we make
00:55:37.420decisions and go and we can take all the oil out of the ground right now and we can build this thing
00:55:42.680here because like whatever it's only going to matter 150 years from now it's really not that
00:55:47.400far away it's like like we that's us that's like us in the future so we have to kind of start
00:55:53.520thinking about ourselves as like connected generation to generation uh and with Andrew
00:55:58.820Jackson me I have like a personal hope that at some point when someone mentions Andrew Jackson
00:56:05.620everybody just rolls their eyes and it's just like yeah that guy uh it was not a good decision
00:56:12.400maker and also we need to be very clear about what we can do to prevent that from happening
00:56:17.060again because there are still laws on the books that allow that to happen so like the law that
00:56:24.360was passed so that he could invade some states because he was mad at them they wouldn't participate
00:56:29.260in these tariffs that doesn't get taken off the books right so like we have some work to do if we
00:56:34.760want to make sure that like we're not repeating the same things and then we have to remind ourselves
00:56:40.160like we're in the midst of it um we're the ones that need to be the loudest and we have all the
00:56:46.220we like we have all the ability to be the loudest about what's happening so like we should speak up
00:56:52.020and we should not sort of say oh this is just like you know acceptable and happening right now
00:56:57.940we need to speak up all the time because we we hold people responsible from history and we're
00:57:03.380like why didn't they speak up why didn't they fight but we're in the midst of history right
00:57:07.480now how are we speaking up how are we fighting how are we pushing back um and i will say there
00:57:13.800was one other thing that happened with Donald Trump that just like, I actively think he's like
00:57:18.440trying to, he's really trying to find a way to tell us that he is Andrew Jackson. Sometimes I
00:57:25.200think he like maybe like did some kind of weird, you know, like Illuminati thing. And he like took
00:57:31.960in the essence of Andrew Jackson or whatever. But one of the things he did, like, I guess when he
00:57:37.100met with Justin Trudeau, when Justin Trudeau was like, you know, the prime minister of Canada came
00:57:41.680down to visit and he was like they were meeting he said something to him that was like oh nice to
00:57:48.020meet you but we don't really like you do we because of the war we don't like you very much
00:57:52.800and Justin Trudeau said that he was just like what are you talking and he goes are you talking
00:57:56.880about the war of 1812 like is that what you're talking about with me right now and everybody
00:58:01.440thought it was like a haha funny moment but uh you know who was in the war of 1812 Andrew Jackson
00:58:07.300So I was just like, see this man, he he's got some type of tie to this idea of like, to him, that's like the moment of American history that we're just like, plowing through and, you know, doing whatever we want, passing laws and taking control.
00:58:24.760And because we have continued to venerate Jackson, instead of making him the laughing stock that he should be, we're now answering for that today.
00:58:36.200If we would have laughed at Jackson the way we should have, if we would have said that that was an aberration and also completely unacceptable, maybe it would have been different.
00:58:46.800But we turned around and made him into some kind of like folk hero president. And now what we're seeing is that people venerate him in a way that says it's a good thing that he tried to, you know, really destroy everything that would have, that like uplifted what was happening at the time with like the people on the ground.
00:59:09.280um but i think i mean i think when you're in indigenous studies and when you're from like
00:59:15.560uh spaces where you're really thinking about like with native interventions and philosophies what
00:59:21.740you start to realize is like the whole system from the beginning was kind of set up so that
00:59:26.580it could uphold itself and white supremacy and we've been navigating it and dealing with it
00:59:33.860But it's never going to be a system that truly empowers our country to become, I think, the vision of what it could have been had we had the right kinds of interventions at the beginning.
00:59:48.180So maybe what we can do now is work for, like, is dismantle and disrupt and then decolonize and then reimagine what it's supposed to look like.
01:00:03.860Yes. Oh, well, Katja, thank you so much for joining me today. And before we come to a close, I'd just like to invite you to share any closing sentiments you want to share with listeners or ways to support your work on the Native Women's Collective.
01:00:19.620I think I always encourage people to follow me on Twitter and then follow everybody I follow on Twitter and uplift Indigenous voices.
01:00:29.060Think about how you can have Indigenous voices be at the center of the things that you're talking about, or you can invite Indigenous peoples to tell those stories.
01:00:37.200The work I do with the Native Women's Collective is on the revitalization of Native arts and cultures.
01:00:42.180And we're very clear at how we work in Native communities to empower people to be able to reconnect and have a resurgence of our cultures and the things that we do.
01:00:57.460And I think that it's a pretty powerful way of supporting, especially young people, as we work toward what decolonized futures look like.
01:01:05.300So if people want to look us up, we're at nativewomenscollective.org.
01:01:09.240we have a special project that's going on with my book right now where you can buy a copy of the
01:01:14.480book through our site and then if you donate the amount of money it takes we will take that
01:01:20.360donation and use it to purchase a book and send it to we send it to rehabilitation centers tribal
01:01:27.460libraries and women and men's prisons in California so we're starting with California
01:01:34.940But we want to get the book to places where people might normally not get a copy of it and really sending it to the various places where people, especially like with the women's and men's prisons, like where people are incarcerated, because we want them to have the opportunity to read this story about community and sort of the empowerment that's happening.
01:01:53.600and often they don't get you know books in their library so we will donate a copy of the book to
01:01:59.820the various places that we have on our list if people want to donate there it's one project that
01:02:06.060we're doing to try to get the book out there and then we have several other projects that we're
01:02:09.740doing which you can learn more about but it's really about connecting with community and making
01:02:14.300sure that our community is cared for especially in times like this where we can find ways to
01:02:19.460reconnect with our cultures so that we can move forward in really good ways.
01:02:29.540Thank you for listening to another episode of For the Wild podcast. The music you heard today
01:02:35.580was by Aisha Badru, Holy Rivers, and Teresa Anderson. For the Wild is created by Ayanna
01:02:42.280Young, Erica Ekrem, Francesca Glaspell, and Melanie Younger.