For The Wild - March 01, 2018


PETER WOHLLEBEN on the Hidden Life of Trees ⧸67

Topics
MIRIAM HORN on Conserving Common Ground in America's Divided Heartland ⧸66 ADRIENNE MAREE BROWN on Emergent Strategy ⧸68

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 7 minutes

Words per minute

138.56

Word count

9,413

Sentence count

375

Harmful content

Misogyny

1

sentences flagged

Toxicity

5

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 If you value this content and want to support us in continuing this work,
00:00:05.840 please go over to our website and make a contribution.
00:00:11.420 Also, consider rating us on iTunes so that we can keep growing this community and network
00:00:16.680 towards Earth Regeneration. And if you're a musician and would like your music played on the
00:00:22.380 show, go to our website and upload your work. We're excited to take a listen.
00:00:30.000 The silence is broken by somebody crying
00:00:37.800 Trying to be heard, never a word
00:00:41.260 Always the attitude, sort out your own
00:00:44.820 Always alone
00:00:46.600 Wishing for something the world is denying
00:00:50.480 Out in the wilderness somebody's crying
00:00:55.640 Somebody wishing for something to happen
00:01:08.960 Wishing to tell, wishing to help
00:01:12.380 Someone was listening, someone who cared
00:01:16.200 Never despaired
00:01:18.040 Someone to lean on and someone to trust
00:01:22.720 Who needs your assistance and finds your disguise?
00:01:35.840 Hello and welcome to For the Wild podcast. I'm Ayanna Young.
00:01:41.140 Today we are speaking with Peter Wollnben.
00:01:44.480 Peter spent over 20 years working in the Forestry Commission in Germany
00:01:48.660 before leaving to put his ideas of ecology into practice.
00:01:52.720 He now runs an environmentally friendly woodland in the Eiffel Mountains in Germany, where
00:01:59.100 he is working for the return of primeval forest.
00:02:02.920 He also runs a nature academy, where he leads guided tours and seminars.
00:02:08.860 He is the author of numerous books about nature, including The Hidden Life of Trees, a New
00:02:14.160 York Times bestseller, and The Inner Life of Animals.
00:02:18.720 Peter will also be speaking at the Geography of Hope Conference this March in Point Reyes, California.
00:02:24.960 The theme this year is Finding Resilience in Nature in Perilous Times.
00:02:30.420 Well, welcome to the show, Peter. I'm so excited to speak to you now and also meet you in Point Reyes in March.
00:02:37.660 Yeah, thank you very much, Ayanna. I'm really proud to be part of your show.
00:02:41.200 this topic the hidden life of trees and forestry and your work is so dear to my heart as
00:02:48.480 I myself am a forest dweller and a restoration ecologist and spend the majority of my life
00:02:56.820 amongst these incredible beings and reading your book was so enlightening to learn about all of
00:03:04.260 these complexities that are so often left out of the dominant narrative of forest.
00:03:11.920 I mean, certain things come to mind, like how from a tree dying shortly after their life partner
00:03:17.580 passes to trees nursing their sick neighbors or trees ultrasonically scream when they're thirsty
00:03:24.480 or warn one another of predatory insects. It's just, it's so enlivening to be reminded that
00:03:32.620 there are beings on this earth who still know how to look after one another and have done so even
00:03:39.040 through so many planetary shifts. These lessons of the forest are the lessons I think humanity needs
00:03:47.300 to know most right now. Peter, you've studied forestry and worked for a long time as a commercial
00:03:53.120 forester before you began stewarding your woodland in the way you do today. And I'm wondering what
00:03:59.640 are some crucial moments for you during your commercial forestry career that caused you to
00:04:05.580 shift your life and your perspective in this way? First thing was when we felt an old dead
00:04:13.160 beech tree, which I thought was just worth firewood. And after I felt all the woodworkers
00:04:23.180 have felled this old tree, and it was transported for firewood.
00:04:28.920 But afterwards, I felt sorry for the insects, for the fungi, which were living in this old
00:04:36.440 tree.
00:04:37.420 And then I began to think about what I'm really doing to this forest.
00:04:42.320 Or shortly after that, I felt a sick tree in March.
00:04:49.000 And when they felt the tree afterwards, there were a mess, a mess of water running out of the stump as if the tree were bleeding.
00:04:59.260 And I thought, what are you doing to this wonderful ecosystem?
00:05:05.000 And then I began to think about what I really wanted to be as a little child.
00:05:09.680 As a little child, I want to be someone who protect nature.
00:05:13.680 And when I was, let's say, 12 or 13, I realized that you can study something like this.
00:05:23.140 And, yeah, when I became 19, I heard about forestry and I thought, ah, a forestry is something like a tree keeper.
00:05:32.360 And that should match to my dreams about nature.
00:05:35.620 And after leaving university and beginning to work in a sense, like I described it a little earlier, then I realized, no, a forester is not a tree keeper.
00:05:48.540 A forester is a tree butcher and is a timber producer.
00:05:52.580 It's OK, but it's not what I've dreamed of.
00:05:56.340 And so I'm really happy that the book on trees was so successful because with the money we earned, we founded a nature academy.
00:06:09.060 And in this academy, I can now work as someone I dreamed of when I was six years old.
00:06:17.460 I loved how you explained that you wanted to be a tree protector, but that a forester was a tree butcher.
00:06:23.420 And I'd never thought of it in those words.
00:06:26.340 And immediately the moment you spoke of your academy, I wanted to be there with you and learning.
00:06:33.680 And I would just love to hear about your beloved woodland.
00:06:38.960 Our ecosystem is in a very bad mood because we have here in Germany, we don't have any single square meter of primal forest left.
00:06:48.180 Our primal forest has been a beach forest, a beach forest from a very stable ecosystem.
00:06:56.340 because they can control their own temperature, create their own microclimate and are very stable
00:07:04.100 over thousands of years. But in the last centuries in Germany, most forests, real forests have been
00:07:11.620 gone. Now we have plantations, spruce plantations, pine plantations, oak plantations and so on.
00:07:17.780 and the people are used to it
00:07:20.480 and say, ah, that
00:07:21.960 are forests. And when we get
00:07:24.460 visitors
00:07:26.540 from other countries, they say, no,
00:07:28.660 you don't have forests, you have plantations.
00:07:31.160 We have not
00:07:31.880 real primeval forests because all forests
00:07:34.520 have been managed, but from old
00:07:36.260 beach forests, even managed forests,
00:07:38.520 we just have three per mil
00:07:40.240 left of the whole
00:07:42.100 woodland. So
00:07:43.720 we have damaged our forests
00:07:46.580 here in Germany, and we are really good in giving advice to Brazil or Indonesia to protect
00:07:53.400 the rainforest there.
00:07:55.360 But I think it's perhaps five to noon here in Germany for the forest, and it's a lot
00:08:02.580 of work to do.
00:08:03.760 But the real forest we should have here, those beach forests, where there are just a few
00:08:09.020 remnants here in our area, they are so wonderful.
00:08:12.640 Because when you come in those old forests, it's like going in a cathedral of, let's say, silver-gray stems, which are very tall.
00:08:25.100 The trees can become as old as 500 years.
00:08:27.680 That's not that old that your redwoods can become.
00:08:32.240 But 500 years, we don't have any forests where we have trees of that age here in Germany left.
00:08:37.760 So I really try hard to work on restore such forests and undisturbed
00:08:44.520 beach forests.
00:08:45.520 You can observe all those wonderful things that the trees are caring for each
00:08:50.080 other, that they are caring for their offspring, that they are caring for old
00:08:57.200 stumps, that they work together.
00:08:59.440 And the less you touch such a forest, the healthier it is.
00:09:03.720 And that brought my thought to the point that we should use just a little wood, a little timber, just as much as we really need.
00:09:14.960 And in most cases, when you think about paper, when you print your emails, for example, in most cases, it's not necessary.
00:09:22.260 In some cases, it's okay to use wood, for example, for furniture or good books.
00:09:30.400 But in many cases, we wouldn't need that big amount of timber.
00:09:36.180 And yeah, that's a complex task for us to do.
00:09:40.640 But when you see those untouched old beech tree forests, then everyone knows instantly that's worth it.
00:09:48.300 So the native forests of your region are primarily deciduous, yet the commercially managed ones are planted with non-native conifers.
00:09:59.920 How would you say they differ in terms of health, biodiversity, and what happens when one of the coniferous plantations is left alone and succession is left to unfold naturally?
00:10:12.340 I think nature doesn't have any problems with restoring the ecosystem.
00:10:19.740 The problem is, if you're far away from the natural state,
00:10:24.160 the stronger will be the reaction of nature to bring back the old system.
00:10:28.740 For example, when you have such a conifer, let's say a spruce plantation,
00:10:32.820 in Germany, those plantations are very endangered by storms and insects.
00:10:37.700 57 percent of the timber is gained through catastrophes through storm falls or insect
00:10:46.380 attacks so it's not really good to to work or to calculate with such plantations so it's really
00:10:53.260 not a good business even if you won't think about the ecologic distractions you make with
00:11:00.700 such a management but yeah we have every winter we have storms here in germany and every time
00:11:07.420 you really hear about fallen trees and streets which are which are not able to pass because of
00:11:14.540 such a dream trees which were fallen such streets so we have problems problems problems and our
00:11:23.340 Or animals which are living in woodlands, they couldn't even live in such plantations.
00:11:30.640 For example, little mites or insects or birds, which are used to live in broadleaf trees like beech or oak,
00:11:40.920 they are not able to feed on needles of spruce or pine.
00:11:45.800 So you find in such artificial ecosystems, you find other animals, which in our case, spruce and pine are trees from the taiga, from the northern woodland in Sweden, Norway, Russia.
00:12:00.840 And you find in such plantations birds or insects like special ants, which live in such taiga forests.
00:12:08.040 And so we have here in Germany, in many cases, an artificial taiga, which has nothing to do with our wonderful beech tree forest.
00:12:18.860 I'm not against conifers, where they belong.
00:12:23.200 When we look at northern Sweden, we have wonderful primewal forest with spruce and pine and other species.
00:12:30.000 But here in Germany, we used to have beech trees, oaks, acer and other trees.
00:12:35.780 And they are, in many cases, almost gone.
00:12:39.980 I want to read a quote from your book that just fascinated me regarding this topic.
00:12:45.180 And it was, quote,
00:12:46.320 However, reforestation programs introduce spruce and pines to areas where they are not native,
00:12:52.100 and the newcomers experience substantial problems in their new habitats.
00:12:57.020 Usually they are brought to low elevations that are too warm and dry for conifers to thrive.
00:13:01.680 As a result, the area is dustier. They are easier prey for bark beetles. At this point, frantic scent males begin to swirl around in the canopy. The trees are screaming for help and activating their arsenal of chemical defenses. You absorb all of this with every breath of the forest you take into your lungs.
00:13:21.140 consider this threatened forests are inherently unstable and therefore they are not appropriate
00:13:27.420 places for human beings to live there is a scientific observation that speaks to this
00:13:33.060 the blood pressure of forest visitors rises when they are under conifers whereas it calms down and
00:13:38.900 falls in stands of oaks and you know you go on to explain just this relationship with the forest
00:13:47.540 with humans in the forest when we go into these non-native forests that are not natural and
00:13:54.980 they're not meant to be like that the ecosystem the weather does not support that type of forest
00:14:00.600 community and that was so incredible to think about when I've been into tree plantations
00:14:06.880 versus an old growth forest and how I do feel the difference and I actually really understood that
00:14:14.440 while reading your book, the scientific backing of that, and then your take on it. I just wanted
00:14:18.920 to bring that into this conversation because I think it's so fascinating to understand all the
00:14:23.840 dynamics that are left out of the story, the dominant story at least, when we learn about
00:14:31.040 what happens with reforestation in this way. That's a really good topic because it shows that
00:14:39.000 we are still part of the forests. And many people living in
00:14:43.440 cities think, perhaps we have lost connection with nature. But
00:14:47.700 you can't lose connection with nature because it's in your body
00:14:52.140 you're in your genes. When you look at evolution, then we know
00:14:57.300 that at minimum, since one million years, mankind is
00:15:01.020 making fire. And for making fire, you need timber and for
00:15:05.240 timber, you need trees, you need a forest. So for example, brain
00:15:08.880 development. For brain development, we need cooked food. We
00:15:13.620 need fire. We need fire. So our brain is a result of forest
00:15:18.660 tree energy, let's say like this. So we are strongly
00:15:23.100 connected since 1 million years with forests. And it's no
00:15:27.940 wonder that our, our body, our instincts react on good or bad
00:15:33.300 forests, good or bad ecosystems, good or bad places to
00:15:37.080 settle. And therefore, what you describe when you when you feel
00:15:42.180 joy or happiness, while you're walking through a native forest,
00:15:46.080 or vice versa, when you're walking through a plantation
00:15:49.060 that this these feelings are missing. That's exactly what
00:15:54.060 your your body and your instincts are saying. And some
00:15:58.740 people, for example, when they when they enter our old beech
00:16:01.920 tree forest. I've heard that several times. They said to me, don't call me crazy, but
00:16:08.160 it's like feeling, it feels like coming home. And that's exactly the point. A good, stable
00:16:16.260 forest, and that can be a redwood forest at the west coast of North America, that can
00:16:21.920 be a beet tree forest at the east coast of North America or in Europe, that can be a
00:16:27.020 spruce forest in northern Scandinavia, and all in those
00:16:31.880 forests, you have good feelings, you have lower blood pressure,
00:16:37.760 your whole body and your mind are in a good mood. And when you
00:16:42.900 go through a plantation, your body feels instinctively that
00:16:46.620 this is a catastrophe to nature and, and what your body, how
00:16:52.420 your body reacts, that's exactly the reaction of the whole
00:16:55.340 nature and the nature is trying to bring in a better balance.
00:16:59.660 And that means at first that those plantations will be eaten
00:17:04.160 by bark beetles, by other insects, by fungi, which destroy
00:17:08.300 trees. And in the first decades, maybe such forests or
00:17:12.680 plantations look very ugly. But afterwards, in just one tree
00:17:17.660 generation, and that may be 500 years, this forest will change
00:17:22.520 in the real forest.
00:17:25.340 Thank you.
00:17:55.340 I'd like to talk about the social relationships of trees, and through your book and through
00:18:02.080 others' work and scientific findings, it's showing that not only do trees not act selfishly
00:18:09.360 or purely competitively, but they're also very social.
00:18:14.820 They're social beings, and in The Hidden Life of Trees, you detail kinship that seems to
00:18:21.240 extend beyond single species.
00:18:23.700 Susan Simard from the University of British Columbia, whom you reference, noticed that Douglas furs suffered when their paper birch neighbors were removed.
00:18:33.200 The shaded Doug furs were receiving a great deal of carbon from birch through the mycorrhizae, and that this relationship flipped when the season changed and the birch shed their leaves.
00:18:45.320 I would love if you could speak about the social nature of trees and resource sharing.
00:18:51.000 Perhaps you could give us an example of unique tree relationships from your woodland.
00:18:56.100 Perhaps in general, real forest trees, not all trees are real forest trees.
00:19:01.740 Some trees like to live on their own because there are trees of the savannah of grasslands
00:19:06.580 and there are usually no neighboring trees.
00:19:09.780 So there are some trees like willows or some birch tree species or apple trees, cherry trees,
00:19:17.180 which used to live on their own.
00:19:19.180 But in general, for most woodlands with the tree species like Douglas fir or sequoia or in our region, beech trees, oaks, acer and so on, they used to live in family bands.
00:19:33.420 And there's a very good reason for that.
00:19:37.860 A single tree knows instinctively, I'm not a forest.
00:19:41.340 And just as a forest, you can cool down together on a hot summer day.
00:19:45.300 For example, trees are sweating together.
00:19:49.180 big beet tree is consuming as much as 500 liters of water per day and that means that the the air
00:19:57.980 gets very humid much cooler we have here um discoveries from the university of aachen they
00:20:06.380 found out that the different the temperature difference from managed which tree forest to
00:20:12.140 unmanaged tree forest is three degrees celsius in summertime and two conifer plantations
00:20:19.980 much more so the trees can cool down together can create their own climate and when we think about
00:20:26.780 climate change what climate change does to ecosystems then i would say the damage would
00:20:32.300 be not that big when we wouldn't manage that intensive forest because every tree you cut
00:20:40.140 you fell, cause a damage because you have a gap in the canopy,
00:20:45.700 there comes some sunlight in, the air gets warmer, the air gets
00:20:49.500 drier, and that's stress for the trees. So they try to close that
00:20:54.500 gap. But perhaps the next time the forester comes again, and the
00:20:57.700 next tree will be felled and not just one, but thousands and
00:21:01.500 thousands. So the whole ecosystem is warming up. And when we
00:21:06.300 we have on top the human made climate change, then we will see many forests die as we see
00:21:11.760 them now dying in North America, for example, the lodgepole pine forests, which are attacked
00:21:18.260 by the bark beetles. I think that's a mixture of many problems, but most of them human made.
00:21:24.600 So trees are used to climate change because trees can become very old. When we look at
00:21:30.780 Europe, for example, the last thousand years, we have had very warm times, we have had the
00:21:36.720 Little Ice Age and the Middle Ages, I think the last very cold period was in the 1800s.
00:21:44.720 So a tree which can become 500 or even 1000 years old has to stand climate changes, but
00:21:52.100 it's only able to stand those changes together as a community.
00:21:56.840 And it's not only the climate, but it's also when a tree gets weak, for example, or gets sick, it gets support from other trees.
00:22:05.460 We have here in my forest a tree which was really very heavily damaged.
00:22:11.200 And everyone would have said that tree is not able to survive.
00:22:14.520 and but it's like a wonder because this tree has got support from the surround trees through the
00:22:22.540 roots through the fungi network with sugar solutions and other nutritions this tree became
00:22:28.680 strong again and perhaps and that's just a guess the next time when the neighboring one of the
00:22:34.420 neighboring trees gets weak he can support this tree so they together they build a very stable
00:22:41.080 ecosystem, or you can say they built a stable family band
00:22:45.320 because trees, they know exactly who is standing beside it.
00:22:50.400 For example, with the root chips, they can detect,
00:22:53.820 ah, this is an oak.
00:22:55.040 I will support an oak.
00:22:56.340 I will support other beech trees.
00:22:58.480 So they connect just with beech trees or even when it gets
00:23:04.280 to their own seedlings, they can detect whether a seedling
00:23:08.800 is their own or not.
00:23:09.940 And with their own seedlings, they will connect stronger.
00:23:13.880 They get more support.
00:23:16.020 So, yeah, you can even say mother trees are caring for their children.
00:23:21.080 Now, some people say, ah, that's much, much too much human terms.
00:23:25.960 And trees are much more different than using words like this.
00:23:30.340 But I think nature has some principles which are working really good.
00:23:35.680 And that is for having a good social system.
00:23:38.020 When you support each other, all together can become much, much older.
00:23:41.860 And that system works on trees, that works on antelopes, that works on humans.
00:23:47.140 And we see it nowadays.
00:23:48.660 And that's perhaps a little bit ironic where we see we had a good system, a worldwide system, a little bit breaking apart.
00:23:57.880 And I hope we see those political situations.
00:24:01.560 If trees could talk to us, they would say, stand together, don't make that nonsense.
00:24:08.020 there's a fascinating section in your book titled tree school that tells of trees ability to learn
00:24:15.880 from their elders as well as from their own mistakes and experience and you go on to explain
00:24:22.060 how when trees are planted in isolation either in a park or in a land foreign to them they don't
00:24:29.160 fare as well and they often suffer because they lack the community guidance in their youth i would
00:24:34.960 just love if you wanted to elaborate a bit on this and you know what lessons are these isolated
00:24:39.800 trees deprived of when they grow up bereft of family and their communities all trees like to
00:24:47.660 grow fast and eat as much as they can and trees are creating food by photosynthesis with their
00:24:56.400 leaves and therefore they need to have as much light as possible that's exactly the point everyone
00:25:03.080 who grows fast in young years won't become very old. That's a
00:25:07.280 biological principle which you can find in many species. So,
00:25:12.280 trees are interested in becoming very old because it takes a lot
00:25:16.000 of time to grow up and to become a tall tree, become the tallest
00:25:20.480 tree to be on top of the forest and then to reproduce that takes
00:25:24.800 hundreds of years and so it's very important to become as old
00:25:28.760 as possible to to use this advantage as long as possible and therefore you need a very slow youth
00:25:35.820 grow and that means that the mother trees bring a deep shadow on the little trees just three
00:25:42.540 percentage of the sunlight comes down to the little ones and that's not enough to live and
00:25:49.180 therefore the mother trees connect with the little ones over the roots and pump sugar solution to the
00:25:56.340 little ones, you may even say they suckle their children over
00:26:01.260 hundreds of years, we have 100 year old beach tree, little
00:26:05.580 beach tree, it's just one meter in height and as thick as my
00:26:10.260 little finger. So this tree has to wait perhaps one or two
00:26:16.260 centuries more to become an old tree to be allowed to become an
00:26:19.440 old tree. And yeah, that's in cities totally different when
00:26:25.860 you have a tree which is planted near a street then this tree gets the full sunlight it's like
00:26:32.240 a street kit this tree is allowed to do whatever it wants so it it feeds as much as possible
00:26:38.580 sugar because it can make with all the crown with all the canopy photosynthesis in the full
00:26:45.100 sunlight it grows very fast and we love trees which are fast growing because we are impatient
00:26:51.820 We are a short-living creature compared to trees.
00:26:55.500 So we want to see efforts, results during our lifetime.
00:27:00.040 For example, when you plant a tree in your garden, you won't wait for 20 or 30 years
00:27:04.860 to see the tree growing very slow, but you want to harvest apples or cherries.
00:27:12.320 You want to have something like a garden furniture, which gives shadow.
00:27:16.860 So we plant big trees, plant trees which grow very fast.
00:27:21.820 these trees altogether can become very old.
00:27:25.000 That's not so important for us, and it's okay to do so,
00:27:27.840 because our garden, that's our home range, and there are we first.
00:27:33.320 But just to explain, trees in cities or in gardens,
00:27:37.940 they won't become older in general than 200 or 300 years.
00:27:42.940 There are perhaps some exceptions, but most trees won't become much older.
00:27:47.940 And we all think, wow, what an old tree.
00:27:50.620 And in reality, that's a young tree, a young dying.
00:27:54.180 Another example, trees have similar behaviors like we have.
00:27:59.160 For example, they need to sleep at night.
00:28:02.120 And the science in this point is just at the beginning.
00:28:05.080 There's a team of Finnish and Austrian researchers, which they found out that trees let hang their branches at nighttime, just a little bit.
00:28:14.040 And with sunlight, they something like stand up.
00:28:17.900 What for? They don't know because that's a typical phenomenon in science. You have answered one question and then you have 10 new ones. But they know that trees have to sleep. And when in the streets you have streetlights near a tree and the light is burning the whole night, then the tree is not able to sleep. And those trees will die earlier.
00:28:47.900 Thank you.
00:29:17.900 I'd love to also ask you,
00:29:42.900 how has your understanding of forest as familial communities shaped the way you steward and manage your woodland
00:29:50.460 compared to the ways in which commercial forest management is incompatible with the social structure of forest trees?
00:30:00.880 First, we have to realize you can't manage a forest without disturbing or damaging it.
00:30:07.380 And we always try to live in a good balance with nature and in harmony.
00:30:15.180 And we like to have something like a certificate which is saying, okay, you're allowed to do so because you don't do any harm to anyone.
00:30:26.900 That's not possible.
00:30:27.880 Every living being does harm to everyone else because it needs space, which another could take and so on.
00:30:37.380 So for me, the main question is, how could we manage a forest without harming it too much or with harming it lesser than we do it now?
00:30:49.000 And the first thing is, when we realize that we can't manage a forest, manage a forest means cutting trees, we can't cut trees and protect them, the trees dead afterwards.
00:31:04.740 So the question is, we should have protected areas where trees can live their life and can live in family bands undisturbed for centuries.
00:31:16.380 That's very important for me to have big enough areas where trees are allowed to do so.
00:31:22.120 And then the rest of the forest, we should manage as close as possible to nature.
00:31:26.700 And that means that we should use the tree species of the special area where the woodlands are, which we manage.
00:31:34.180 In your case, that would be Douglas fir, hemlock and other species.
00:31:40.600 And in our case here, it would be beech and oak and haze and ash and so on.
00:31:46.760 And the second is the trees should live as long as possible.
00:31:53.280 And in Germany, the average age of trees is 77. That's nothing
00:31:58.860 that are not real trees that are tree babies. That's the average
00:32:02.520 age of trees in Germany. So I think they should grow older,
00:32:06.900 and they should become older, we should live them, although they
00:32:10.620 will live in managed forests and family bands. And when we
00:32:14.160 harvest them, not with big machines, we have all over the
00:32:19.620 world the same technique with big harvesters that are machines
00:32:24.060 which cut trees and cut them into pieces, cut off the
00:32:27.420 branches and make them ready for transport. And those machines
00:32:31.500 are very heavy, they weight up to 50 tons, and they compress
00:32:35.820 the soil. And then we don't have any oxygen left in the soil.
00:32:40.260 We don't have the capacity of water storage goes from 100%
00:32:45.360 down to 5%. And it's very important for the trees to have
00:32:48.840 this stored water in the ground because on hot summer days when
00:32:52.800 there's no rain and a big tree needs 500 liters per day, then
00:32:57.280 those 500 liters have to come from anywhere. And when the soil
00:33:01.600 is dry, then the tree will become weak and sick and perhaps
00:33:06.080 die someday. So when the damages when you drive with a big
00:33:10.600 machine in such a forest, this damage, according to scientists,
00:33:14.320 will be restored perhaps after the next ice age or recover after the next ice age.
00:33:21.720 There's nothing you can do to restore such soil.
00:33:25.920 So it's a pity and a shame to go with such big machines over the woodland floor, over the soil.
00:33:35.100 So we are using horses.
00:33:37.140 We are using horses.
00:33:38.320 The work was horses in the woods.
00:33:41.660 That's a tradition made since 6,000 years, and it's still working today.
00:33:48.260 And it's when you calculate it incomplete, when you calculate the damage you're doing to the soil,
00:33:55.100 when you calculate the machine costs and so on, then you find out that the horses are cheaper.
00:34:00.280 They are cheaper, and many horses say, ah, we don't have that many horses to do all the work.
00:34:06.180 No, there's no demand, and therefore we don't have many horses.
00:34:09.460 And the most horse keepers of those, we say something like tracking horses, those horse keepers, there are just a few and they say we would love to have more jobs for doing such work, but there's no demand.
00:34:24.400 And that's what we are doing and what we are practicing in our academy. We're not making guided tours and things like that, but also seminars for woodland owners, which like to change the practice of management.
00:34:39.460 I myself have been really struggling with the idea of machinery use, even in restoration work, say for creating swales or to bring coarse woody debris into streams for salmon habitat complexity.
00:34:52.100 And I've actually operated machines myself this last summer while building the native species nursery. And I see the soil compaction and destruction that is inevitable with machines. And it did feel almost spiritually disrespectful when compared to techniques that use slow human animal strength.
00:35:13.060 And so I wonder do machines have some use in reforestation or restoration work but hearing you speak it reminds me that it's not worth it even though there is this intense feeling of urgency and the machine has been invented and it's been conditioned in our mind that machines are fast and efficient.
00:35:37.900 And now with so much damage happening on Earth, this feeling of we must use machines because they will be faster and we can't possibly protect and conserve and restore all of this land in a timely way without the use of machines.
00:35:55.080 So I definitely feel that struggle in myself. And this other topic that I've been really
00:36:02.340 questioning right now is forest thinning. There's also this dogmatic notion of thinning in forest
00:36:08.820 management as there is with machines and restoration. And it's believed in a common
00:36:15.800 practice that cutting intermittent trees opens up light in the canopy, letting the remaining
00:36:20.960 trees grow more vigorously and with a more straight structure, which is then of course
00:36:26.360 more profitable. Yet this idea is rooted in an understanding of trees as individualistically
00:36:32.540 competitive. And you thoroughly dispel this in your book, describing how thinning can actually
00:36:38.020 do more harm than good. And you've also now explained to us how fast growing trees don't
00:36:43.900 actually live the longest and they may not even be the healthiest. So would you tell us how you've
00:36:49.680 learned about the effects of thinning on forest communities and how does this widely accepted
00:36:55.280 notion lack an appreciation for the cooperative and communal reality of forest as we're dealing
00:37:01.720 with so many plantation forests so many second third growth forests that are extremely
00:37:08.280 overgrown in so many senses and also a fire danger what do we do in place of commercial
00:37:18.220 thinning is there another option that you see that's more beneficial in the long run for a
00:37:24.080 healthy ecosystem to begin with there over your last question about the fire um yeah i think um
00:37:31.880 the ecosystem is away from nature the higher is the fire danger you can see that in portugal for
00:37:38.160 example they used to have oak forest in former times and nowadays they have many conifer forest
00:37:45.460 forest and also eucalyptus forest. And now they are the most endangered country in Europe
00:37:52.460 concerning fire, wood fire, because of those plantations, because it's like gasoline, the
00:38:01.840 leaves on the ground. So when someone lights a cigarette and throw it away, the whole forest
00:38:09.140 is burning instantly, whereas the old oak forest was not able to burn.
00:38:16.020 You can try to light a beech or oak tree, a living tree, it's not possible.
00:38:22.980 So I think forestry is causing many problems where foresters say,
00:38:29.100 ah, that's a problem of nature, that's a problem of climate change.
00:38:32.760 There are problems of nature, there are problems of climate change,
00:38:35.560 but they wouldn't be that strong without forest trees. So to come to another topic, you mentioned
00:38:44.680 that the trees, we were told that trees compete in the forest, and that when we
00:38:51.880 thin a forest, there's more space for the other trees to grow faster. Yes, those trees are growing
00:38:57.400 faster, but they shouldn't. Because fast growing trees won't become very old. That's perhaps
00:39:03.480 you can compare it to the industrial animal keeping. Pigs 0.94
00:39:07.480 are forced in those industries, you can say,
00:39:11.480 to grow in five or six months, ready for
00:39:15.480 slaughter. And when you put such
00:39:19.480 pigs out of the stables and bring them 0.75
00:39:23.480 to an animal keeper, we have here some people
00:39:27.480 who care for pigs like that, they won't become much older than
00:39:31.480 one year because the body is exhausted from fast growing their
00:39:36.160 lungs, their heart and whatsoever. It's it's so so
00:39:40.420 stressed from this fast growing process that those pigs are not
00:39:44.260 able to live very much longer. So you have the same problems with 0.82
00:39:48.860 such plantations. First, when you plant a tree, the roots are
00:39:53.680 damaged. It's like opening your your body and put your gut out,
00:39:59.380 For example, the roots are not used to see sunlight and you take them out of the tree nursery, put them in a new soil, you compress the soil, then you squeeze the roots, perhaps you cut, you even cut the roots.
00:40:13.900 And you know that the root tips, there are brain-like structures with brain-like processes going on.
00:40:19.120 And when you cut those tips, the roots will restore, but not in the same quality.
00:40:24.720 So the roots are damaged.
00:40:26.100 The trees are not rooting very deep anymore after planting.
00:40:29.380 That's a general thing.
00:40:32.780 And afterwards, they grow very fast, too fast, they get exhausted.
00:40:39.280 So they are not able to defend very good against bark beetle attacks.
00:40:44.780 And they are not very socialized.
00:40:47.200 But we can see that, for example, that old stumps, they, in most cases, they don't get
00:40:52.780 support from surrounding trees when this old stump is in a plantation because planted trees
00:40:58.740 won't connect that good
00:41:00.080 and that quality like trees
00:41:02.580 in a natural forest
00:41:04.500 so plantations
00:41:06.200 are full of weak
00:41:08.420 but good looking trees
00:41:10.200 good looking to the industry and we have
00:41:12.340 learned that when the forest
00:41:14.580 industry say hey that's a good tree
00:41:16.500 but in reality it's a weak tree
00:41:18.700 it's a tree which
00:41:20.620 is much too
00:41:22.240 tall for this age
00:41:24.760 and this tree is
00:41:26.580 endangered by
00:41:28.400 fire, it's endangered by insects, it's endangered by hot summer days. And when then such a big
00:41:36.440 plantation becomes problems, then most people say, ah, that's nature. But I say, no, that's forestry.
00:41:45.160 So what can we do as restorationists, as holistic managers, to deal with the problems left in the
00:41:55.320 wake of these plantation forests first it's necessary to see what is the main problem the
00:42:03.660 main problem is that we don't want to lose time but the question is is it really important for
00:42:10.800 nature to make this restoration in one decade or two decades that nature has time we don't have
00:42:17.980 time we want to see results that's on one hand on the other hand we are destroying nature in a speed
00:42:24.520 that it's necessary to hurry up a little bit
00:42:28.320 and I can understand that
00:42:29.540 and it's also good for us to see results
00:42:32.440 because it's a good motivation
00:42:33.720 and so I would make a combination
00:42:36.480 I would perhaps plant here and there trees
00:42:40.380 and that's more for us than for nature
00:42:43.840 because we can see a little forest
00:42:46.000 we can see results
00:42:47.080 and it's good to see results
00:42:48.860 on the other hand
00:42:49.980 it's letting nature doing the job
00:42:53.860 for example when we have here our spruce plantations and we want to change them we say okay
00:43:00.260 the fastest thing would be to plant little beech trees but as i said when you plant a tree you
00:43:06.500 damage it so it come a big tree but not a healthy tree and we want to have healthy trees so we try
00:43:11.940 to work with the nature and that means that we make big boxes wooden boxes in the forest
00:43:19.380 Therein we put in acorns and beech nuts, and then the birds like Scrap Jays, that's a ravenbird,
00:43:28.100 it comes and it's picking up those seeds and storing them around in the forest floor as a
00:43:35.860 winter depot. And this Scrap Jay always wants to be on the safe side. It just needs, let's say,
00:43:42.980 say, 1,500 beech nuts, but it's storing around about 10,000, yeah, want to be on the safe
00:43:50.980 side. So that means that 8,500 beech nuts are able to become seedlings in the next spring.
00:43:58.500 And seedlings with an intact root system, they were seeded in a natural way, and that
00:44:03.880 with just a little cost. For example, when we plant a beech tree that costs one euro,
00:44:09.120 let's say $1. And we need for a square kilometer, let's say I
00:44:15.420 think 2 million seedlings to have something like, okay,
00:44:20.340 forest, it's not a very good forest, but it's okay with 2
00:44:23.580 million plants. So that costs $2 million. And when we let do the
00:44:27.820 birds, the job costs for a square kilometer, perhaps, let's
00:44:31.500 say $200 to just $200. And the bird is happy to do the job
00:44:36.420 because it gets enough to feed.
00:44:38.420 So that's exactly the method I would recommend.
00:44:42.280 Let nature do the job.
00:44:43.580 And if you want to try to show the direction
00:44:46.060 or to speed up a little bit this process,
00:44:48.820 then it's good to offer those birds seeds of the trees
00:44:52.860 you want to restore.
00:44:54.160 Or if it are seeds which are not eaten by birds
00:44:58.880 or other animals which bring it out in the nature,
00:45:02.520 Then you can bring yourself the seeds in the forest and bring them aground.
00:45:09.060 And the second best is to plant here and there a group of trees.
00:45:13.080 But it would always be best to plant groups and not single trees.
00:45:17.200 To have little hotspots where the development is a little bit faster.
00:45:22.180 And that is an advantage even for the seeded trees.
00:45:26.800 Because then we have shadow in the forest.
00:45:29.640 We have less wind in the forest.
00:45:31.480 That means that we have a more humid microclimate.
00:45:36.220 So that's perhaps the best thing would be a combination.
00:45:39.220 And then all are happy in the nature and the people who are so good in bringing back nature.
00:45:46.940 That was so helpful to hear, especially as I'm setting up this native species nursery
00:45:52.740 and have put so much thought and care into strategy behind how to reforest damaged landscapes,
00:46:01.120 whether that's been clear-cut land or burned areas and a lot of times especially in California,
00:46:10.060 Oregon, and Washington with all of the land use change areas where there used to be oak savannas
00:46:15.240 have been taken over by doug fir which actually is invasive in those areas and then places that
00:46:23.420 used to have redwood have been taken over by hardwood such as oaks and madrones because the
00:46:29.180 redwood isn't able to spread as quickly as these other hardwoods in the sun. And so there's this
00:46:36.040 complexity to reforestation. And it's not just as simple as walking out and planting a million
00:46:43.600 trees, which in and of itself is not simple. So to hear your thoughts with the birds and
00:46:50.160 the biodiversity, which I'm very committed to when replanting, it's not just planting
00:46:56.140 the one conifer that is what's been conditioned as the valuable tree, but how do we replant
00:47:04.440 biodiversity along with understanding that these trees need shade and they need each other and they
00:47:10.740 need the whole community and also being aware of the compaction to the soil. It's just a lot to
00:47:16.660 take into consideration and I think also with you bringing up this deep understanding of the
00:47:24.220 time frame of us humans and then the time frame of nature and the forest and how different those
00:47:30.660 are and how we need to take that into consideration when we're thinking about how to be the best earth
00:47:36.260 stewards we can be and the other thing that came up for me as you were speaking was the thinning
00:47:43.580 and even how one may think that thinning is beneficial for forest health and fire safety
00:47:52.640 it not always is that case and we really need to think about this more fully not just thinning but
00:48:01.140 then selective logging and how so much of the time when trees are selectively logged the trees that
00:48:09.400 are chosen are consistently the quote desirable timber trees with a certain structure that's
00:48:18.540 straight and I think about well are we not removing certain trees and usually the oldest trees
00:48:26.360 from the gene pool if we were to selectively log what do you feel is the best way to go about that
00:48:34.940 when selecting certain trees and how to basically honorably harvest trees if that were the case for
00:48:45.820 communities that still rely on logging for their economy yeah i would work without big machines
00:48:55.860 that means in in every case where the machines are not able to drive on roads on dirt roads i would
00:49:05.800 choose to do it with with horses and i would like to fell if a tree should be felled with woodworkers
00:49:14.280 That's good for jobs, and that's good for the forest, and that's also good for the money, because you earn much more money with a healthy forest.
00:49:24.080 And when it gets to the thinning, to be honest, it wouldn't make any sense if we would choose trees we couldn't use for planks, for example, just choosing trees because it's less worth for the forest.
00:49:40.120 And we don't know how much a tree is worth for a forest.
00:49:43.360 So it's always okay when you manage a forest to take out what we really need.
00:49:49.180 And therefore, because our needs are sometimes a contradiction to the needs of a forest, we need those protected areas and in between some little areas, perhaps just 50 yards or so in diameter.
00:50:02.780 And in this area, the trees are allowed to grow and to keep their complete genes because if you thin a forest in the first years, the foresters take out the trees which are not straight and have too thick branches or other things.
00:50:21.940 And that means that they are bringing them, they are breeding the trees to a type which is not really wild.
00:50:34.980 It's a domesticated tree species afterwards with just a few wild genes left.
00:50:40.340 And there are some very important things missing.
00:50:43.380 For example, a wild tree is able to withstand storms much better than a domesticated tree because it's able to move back and forth without breaking.
00:50:55.460 So without breaking and the domesticated tree with good stem for forest industry, which is very straight and where the fibers inside are straight too without drilling, those trees break much easily in heavy storms.
00:51:14.380 So it's always good to have those little spots inside with wild trees, with the complete genes.
00:51:21.540 And over the pollination in spring, they mix their genes with the genes of the managed forest.
00:51:29.340 And so you keep the wild gene reservoir of those forests.
00:51:34.240 That's the method we are doing.
00:51:36.060 And so, according to the moment, according to our knowledge of the day, we say that's the best compromise for managing forests because we are also important as humans and it's okay to take out what we need out of the forest, but it's perhaps a better balance than it is now.
00:51:57.000 And what's very important for me to say, when we protect nature, for example, what's wonderful, I love what you told about the restoration of forest and former woodlands, what you're doing, that's really a great job.
00:52:10.300 And what we should know is that over a long time frame, the next ice age will come, will destroy that wonderful forest, a new forest will be built, and that's coming and going like it was ever in the whole time the Earth is in our universe.
00:52:31.980 But nowadays we have the problems and that are our problems when you protect the forest or when you store a forest or plant new trees, then you protect the people, the human species, because nature protection is in first the protection of ourself.
00:52:53.000 And I think it's very important to be aware of that.
00:52:56.660 So there is no distance.
00:52:58.620 Here is nature and there are we.
00:53:01.080 We are working against each other.
00:53:03.860 No, we are one system.
00:53:05.720 And when you protect our system, we protect ourselves.
00:53:26.660 Each eye, ooh, that I'll rest my every burn, ooh, till all doubts and fears
00:53:46.580 I would love to now turn the conversation towards forest and climate
00:54:14.700 and how this relationship is much more expansive than the sequestration of carbon.
00:54:22.000 Forests are the reason precipitation even reaches the landlocked interior of continents
00:54:27.740 through the cyclical creation of clouds as water is intercepted, evaporated, and transpires as it moves inland.
00:54:36.460 So could you share with us what you know of this phenomenon and help us understand why coastal forests are essential in this life-giving system?
00:54:48.580 Yeah, that's a research, I think, from Russian scientists, which found in the Amazon region more and more heavy droughts in the last decades.
00:55:01.340 And they asked, why? Is it because of the climate change?
00:55:05.740 I think the climate change is nowadays the easiest explanation, but in this special case, they found out that forests are working like a water pump.
00:55:18.060 Within a range of, let's say, 300 or 400 miles from the coast, the clouds are losing the rain and then disappear.
00:55:27.460 So after the German edition, it's 600 kilometers, I think it's around about 400 miles.
00:55:35.740 After 400 miles, usually in the continents, you have a desert because there are no clouds anymore.
00:55:43.700 They have lost their rain in those 400 miles trip from the coast to the inland, and afterwards you have a desert.
00:55:51.700 But if you have a forest in this region, then the rain falls in.
00:55:56.400 The humidity is gassing out, is forming new clouds.
00:56:00.240 the clouds are shifting into deeper into the country and raining again and when there's another
00:56:06.840 forest going deeper into the continents and there's another forest and so on so the the water
00:56:12.500 is handed deeper and deeper into the continents by trees and the russian researchers found out that
00:56:19.840 even 2 000 miles away from the coast you have the same humidity the same rainfall amount like at the
00:56:28.560 coast. But when you destroy the coastal forest, you destroy the
00:56:33.480 main water pump, which is responsible for the first part
00:56:36.640 of the chain. When you destroy it, then it's logical that the
00:56:40.980 rest behind gets drier and drier. And that's the reason why
00:56:45.480 many regions get more deserted gets drier, because we have
00:56:51.080 destroyed so many forests, whether it is in the United
00:56:54.960 States or Canada or Europe there when you when you look at
00:56:58.000 the time shift films where how the forest disappeared in the
00:57:03.360 last two centuries in the northern hemisphere, then it's
00:57:07.440 no surprise that the inner of the continents gets drier and
00:57:11.600 drier. Therefore, it's very important to bring the forest
00:57:14.920 back. And therefore, I can say just again, it's wonderful to
00:57:21.200 hear from you that you're planting trees and working on
00:57:24.360 the restoration of woodlands forests are more than habitat more than just biodiversity it's more than
00:57:34.020 carbon sequestration they also call in the rain and for us here in california and honestly all
00:57:43.120 up and down the west coast drought is a major concern for many people and so when we continue
00:57:50.740 to log our forest and then plant with agriculture or develop suburbs, which then pump water out of
00:57:59.060 these aquifers that are then not recharged by forest, we're getting ourselves into this
00:58:05.980 water management issues and water scarcity. And I know this is really happening all over the globe,
00:58:12.340 whether that's in China, South America. So I think this concept of forest as water pump is so
00:58:19.200 deeply important as we look to the future for human survival and survival of biodiversity and
00:58:26.820 our other kin. So I was also so fascinated to learn that you have initiated a living gravestone
00:58:34.480 project, which preserves a stretch of forest by selling burial plots with trees as living
00:58:40.460 gravestones, not only as it lets the trees live out their lives fully, ensuring they won't be cut
00:58:47.420 down but also instills a sense of regeneration and earth-based ceremony into human death
00:58:54.700 and as our dominant culture has been so dissociated from death and fears and it sterilizes death
00:59:02.000 i hope to see and be a part of more initiatives such as this in my lifetime
00:59:07.760 and i'd love to hear your thoughts on what projects like this can bring to communities
00:59:13.040 that's it's really a lovely project for many reasons at first i thought okay i had to get
00:59:21.980 an idea how to protect an old beech tree forest which should be clear-cutted by the forest
00:59:27.520 authorities and i thought okay we we need a rescue plan and then there came up the idea in
00:59:35.040 switzerland that to to bury the urns of people in forest and i thought okay that would be a perfect
00:59:42.280 idea. And we planned the project, we made the project. And
00:59:46.940 afterwards, I realized that's even better, because it's it's
00:59:52.600 brings back the real sense that that we belong to nature, that
00:59:56.500 we are a part of the nature. And after dying, our body will go
01:00:01.060 back to nature without being a environmental problem, which many
01:00:06.460 people think about nowadays, because of the medicine and what
01:00:09.400 your life or nuclear body. That's no problem when the body is
01:00:13.300 burned and the urn is brought into the root system of an
01:00:19.300 old beech tree because it's most of your remaining ash is
01:00:24.760 calcium. It's not bad for the tree and it's vice versa. And it
01:00:30.220 shows that your body is going to be something new afterwards in
01:00:35.080 in form of timber or leaves
01:00:37.080 that shows for me
01:00:38.860 even better that we are
01:00:40.840 not evil to the forest
01:00:43.140 we are part of the forest
01:00:44.580 with 7.6
01:00:48.000 billion people on this
01:00:49.300 little globe, it's a little bit
01:00:51.280 too much but that's no problem
01:00:53.060 we individually can solve
01:00:54.880 so I think it's better to
01:00:57.240 live in harmony with the forest
01:00:59.120 to do the things we can
01:01:01.180 do, we are not able to solve all problems
01:01:03.400 and we shouldn't think too much about this
01:01:06.980 but we should think about problems we can solve
01:01:09.500 like your restoration projects
01:01:12.000 that is burying people in the forest have living headstones
01:01:15.460 it's much easier to people to handle the death
01:01:18.780 we see it in every case a tragedy
01:01:21.540 to lose a family member but when you're in the forest
01:01:24.320 and it feels you see the nature
01:01:27.960 and you are aware of that
01:01:31.100 your beloved family member is part of this wonderful system
01:01:34.980 while living and also being dead.
01:01:37.420 So the circle closes and what your soul is doing.
01:01:42.840 That's not the question in this case.
01:01:46.040 But I think for many families, it's a good feeling to know
01:01:50.360 that their beloved family member is resting in such a peaceful environment.
01:01:56.600 And so for us, it's a wonderful combination
01:02:00.100 because those family members buried in this forest,
01:02:03.400 they protect with their urn the tree which they are buried at.
01:02:08.880 So it's even able to protect forests after having died.
01:02:13.800 So, yeah, it sounds perhaps a little bit crazy,
01:02:16.580 and most foresters, which I spoke about before making this project, 0.85
01:02:22.020 say, ah, you crazy guy, now you're a corona and not a forester anymore.
01:02:26.880 And I say, okay, I love to talk with people, to help people in this very sad situation. 0.95
01:02:34.140 It's for me a better job than cutting old mother trees and selling them to China, for example.
01:02:41.780 What a beautiful solution for so many of our disconnections.
01:02:47.640 I really love that.
01:02:49.180 And I hope that this burial forest can continue to spread throughout the world.
01:02:54.460 so for our last and bonus question i heard you speak in an interview about how recent research
01:03:02.100 is uncovering that plant roots emit and respond to sound and in reflection you said something
01:03:08.600 along the lines of with every answer 10 new questions arise and there's just so much truth
01:03:14.820 to that and embracing all that we cannot make sense of and perhaps we'll never be able to
01:03:21.080 what do you think of this sound that's coming from the roots and what is your intuition about
01:03:28.460 what is being communicated we know that that there are a lot of things going on and that trees
01:03:36.440 have perhaps more ways to communicate than we have let's say it again the main problem is that
01:03:43.060 trees are so much slower than we are the electrical signal the tree tissue is traveling as much as
01:03:50.000 one centimeter per second
01:03:51.980 our body from
01:03:54.060 head to feet it needs just two
01:03:56.060 milliseconds that's thousands
01:03:58.140 times faster
01:03:59.660 so that's the main
01:04:01.320 difficulty for us
01:04:04.000 to detect to research
01:04:05.880 trees but
01:04:07.140 to come to your question
01:04:09.060 it's a new research from
01:04:11.840 Australia that trees for example
01:04:13.900 are not
01:04:14.840 just able to hear
01:04:17.980 each other but for example
01:04:19.640 to detect where water is flowing in the underground by hearing it. And they tried to, they made an
01:04:26.280 experiment and one sound came from a computer and in some tubes which were brought into the earth
01:04:34.920 and in the soil and near the other tube there was real water flowing and the trees were able to hear
01:04:41.240 the real water and bring the roots in this direction. So the trees don't have ears. And
01:04:49.000 some scientists in Germany say, ah, that's not scientifically not correct. But I think
01:04:55.400 when we are dealing with sound detection, and it doesn't matter if being has ears or whatsoever,
01:05:02.600 but for me, it's more important if it is able to hear sound waves and trees are definitely able
01:05:07.880 to hear sound waves they are able to hear each other and they are able to hear for example that's
01:05:13.240 just one uh detection uh they are able to hear water flowing in the underground water is very
01:05:19.400 important for trees so they are able to orientate and that's another advantage which trees have
01:05:27.800 just incredible peter i'm so grateful for your life's work and your relationship with the forest
01:05:37.000 and how much you have dedicated to understanding them, protecting them, and teaching others how we
01:05:44.640 can be better stewards. So I thank you so much for that and for the time you've spent with us
01:05:51.080 and for the Wild podcast. And I'm so looking forward to meeting you in person in March. And I
01:05:56.900 have so many other questions that I can't wait to ask you when I meet you, because it is a really
01:06:04.820 foundational moment for us here on cougar mountain which is this land that a number of us are setting
01:06:12.460 up this nursery on so just know that you have been fundamental in our learning and our and the
01:06:20.700 way that we move forward with our reforestation project and we'll be in touch yeah thank you
01:06:27.760 i'm really looking forward to our meeting in march because i'm yeah i love to talk to people
01:06:35.120 which are are so uh hard working on on bringing back nature it's it's really good to have a
01:06:41.120 network and it's it's it's really time and necessary to make it in these days perfect
01:06:47.440 Thank you.
01:06:48.980 Me too.
01:06:50.420 Thank you very much and bye-bye.
01:06:52.080 Bye-bye, Peter.
01:06:52.680 Bye.
01:07:08.460 All the music you heard today was by Eola with This Is The World, Future Hymns, and How Far Am I From Canon.
01:07:17.440 Our theme music is Like a River by Kate Wolfe and Silence Returns by Bo.
01:07:23.140 I'd like to thank our incredible podcast team, our producers, March Young and Andrew Storrs,
01:07:30.580 Research Director, Madison Magulski, Media Director, Molly Lee Bove,
01:07:35.740 and all the other soulmates here at For the Wild.
01:07:38.980 Our podcast relies on your donations, so please head over to forthewild.world and make a contribution
01:07:45.240 to help us continue keeping the show going.
01:07:48.740 And while you're there,
01:07:50.180 check out our new podcast study guides
01:07:52.040 and let us know what you think.
01:07:54.580 Thank you, and until next time.