For The Wild - June 07, 2018


TOM GOLDTOOTH on Climate Change Capitalism ⧸80

Topics
RON FINLEY on Cultivating the Garden of the Mind ⧸79 JACINDA MACK on the Planetary Cost of Luxury ⧸81

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 1 minute

Words per minute

127.28

Word count

7,807

Sentence count

368

Harmful content

Toxicity

3

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 Hey For the Wild community, it's Ayanna here speaking to you from the Spirit Weavers gathering
00:00:04.800 where we are screening our film When Old Growth Ends about old growth logging in the Tongass
00:00:10.920 National Forest and I wanted to share a few updates before our conversation with Tom Goldtooth.
00:00:16.720 We're calling out for land partners to plant trees and implement our biodiversity enhancement test
00:00:22.180 plots. If you're a land steward and are interested in this prospect email us at engage at for the
00:00:28.720 wild.world and ask about our land partnership for our 1 million redwoods project we're also
00:00:35.420 expanding our research team and we're on the lookout for people with backgrounds in forestry
00:00:40.880 and mycology so again email us at engage at for the wild.world to be on our research team for the
00:00:47.880 1 million redwoods project and lastly we are open to sponsorships so if you or your business would
00:00:54.060 like to sponsor this podcast and help us spread these messages, again, email us at
00:00:59.320 engageitforthewild.world. All right, now on to the show.
00:01:11.040 It's part of our prophecies, for one thing. Some of our people have been told that a time will come
00:01:17.400 when these children of the colonizers,
00:01:20.980 these people who come as the settlers, 0.93
00:01:23.760 that they're going to start waking up
00:01:25.420 and see those things that we've always been saying.
00:01:39.040 The silence is broken by somebody crying,
00:01:43.600 trying to be heard, never a word.
00:01:46.560 Always the attitude, sort out your own, always alone
00:01:51.880 Wishing for something the world is denying
00:01:55.760 Out in the wilderness somebody's crying
00:02:00.920 Somebody wishing for something to happen
00:02:14.220 Wishing to tell, wishing to help
00:02:17.660 Someone was listening, someone who cared, never despaired
00:02:23.360 Someone to lean on and someone to trust
00:02:28.000 Who needs your assistance and finds your disguise
00:02:32.020 Hello and welcome to For the Wild podcast. I'm Ayanna Young. Today we are speaking with Tom
00:02:48.920 Goldtooth. Since the late 1980s, Tom, member of Diné and Dakota Nations, has been involved with
00:02:56.080 environmental-related issues and programs working within tribal governments in developing
00:03:01.220 indigenous-based environmental protection infrastructures. He works with indigenous
00:03:06.680 peoples worldwide. As executive director of Indigenous Environmental Network since 1996,
00:03:13.240 Tom is known as one of the environmental justice movement grassroots leaders in North America,
00:03:18.960 addressing toxics in health, mining, energy, climate, water, globalization, sustainable
00:03:26.180 development and Indigenous rights issues. He is one of the founders of the Durban Group for Climate
00:03:31.820 Justice, co-founder of Climate Justice Now, co-founder of the U.S.-based Environmental
00:03:37.360 Justice Climate Change Initiative, and a member of the International Indigenous Peoples Forum on
00:03:43.020 Climate Change that operates as the Indigenous Caucus within the United Nations Framework
00:03:48.700 Convention on Climate Change. Tom is a policy advisor to Indigenous communities on environmental
00:03:54.640 protection, and more recently on climate policy focusing on mitigation, adaptation, and concerns
00:04:00.880 of false solutions. He was also awarded the Gandhi Peace Award in 2015.
00:04:08.180 Wow, Tom, what a gift it is to welcome you on the show today. Thank you so much for joining us.
00:04:14.000 Thank you, Ayanna. I'm glad to be on the call. And it's a warm day where I'm from right now in
00:04:22.300 northern minnesota we have not even have a spring we went straight from a long winter almost like
00:04:30.340 right into summer definitely all over where i've been traveling and talking to people it's very
00:04:37.500 warm out there in north america oh my goodness it is it was breaking 90s yesterday here in northern
00:04:46.960 California, and it's still May, so we're all feeling the heat. I just want to jump right into
00:04:54.760 this topic of red, and your work on behalf of Earth and Sky has reverberated through networks
00:05:03.580 locally, nationally, and internationally, and you are so well-versed in the ways colonization
00:05:10.500 unduringly attempts to exploit, commodify, and privatize the sacredness of life.
00:05:18.520 And in this phase of great planetary shifts, we see the beast of global capitalism unraveling.
00:05:25.860 Yet instead of letting itself die, it literally grasps for carbon as the new commodity.
00:05:33.020 With the UN, the international NGOs, and institutions such as World Bank
00:05:37.280 championing market-based carbon trading regimes, such as REDD, a program, which is reducing
00:05:43.240 emissions from deforestation and forest degradation. And you and IEN have been loud
00:05:49.460 in your opposition to REDD, not only for its failure to address the root sources of climate
00:05:55.320 change, but also as a scheme to precipitate one of the largest land grabs in colonial history.
00:06:02.320 So, Tom, would you help us understand the mechanisms of red, how it works, and also explain why you have compared it to the doctrine of discovery for its use of dishonest justifications to dispossess indigenous peoples of their lands and cultures?
00:06:20.720 Well, you asked me to talk about something that I'm really passionate about.
00:06:26.420 I remember when I first got into this work, there are some friends of mine who are older than me.
00:06:35.200 I guess in a way, you know, one would call them my uncle, my aunties.
00:06:42.220 I've always had older friends, even when growing up.
00:06:47.040 And, of course, like in relationship, I would normally call someone my uncle or grandpa.
00:06:54.340 But somehow for me, it was more on a friendship and they opened that door with me, you know.
00:07:00.540 So that's why I say I have some other friends who say, who told me, Tom, in this work that you're doing with this organization, working on environment, remember it's spiritual work.
00:07:16.360 because our relationship, no matter what tribe,
00:07:21.000 we have a spiritual relationship to our Mother Earth,
00:07:24.780 to our Grandmother Earth,
00:07:26.020 and also the creation of life,
00:07:29.320 including the sky, Father Sky, the universe.
00:07:34.100 So those are things that definitely I was raised with
00:07:38.000 in understanding that relationship that I have
00:07:41.840 as I walk on Mother Earth.
00:07:43.700 It's always been a foundation of who I am and what I talk about.
00:07:51.460 So it was a good reminder when they said, you know, don't forget of that work that you do is spiritual work.
00:08:00.180 The second piece that I was told is also watch out if you come upon an issue that's really hard to translate into language.
00:08:10.100 And this moment came about, I would say, about 15 years ago, when there was a lot of policy work in this country, but internationally, where it seemed like instead of the countries of the North, like the United States and Canada and Europe and the UK,
00:08:36.340 Instead of cutting back on carbon dioxide and greenhouse gases, they actually started to look at alternatives.
00:08:48.560 Instead of cutting back, they created a market system called carbon offsets, carbon credits, going carbon neutral, carbon trading, payment for environmental services.
00:09:03.320 this is an area that I really needed to study.
00:09:08.580 So looking at it, studying it, talking to elders,
00:09:13.420 even having ceremonies, consulting with other folks
00:09:17.000 about what is this all about.
00:09:20.500 And at the end of that analysis,
00:09:23.680 I really had to speak out against it
00:09:27.700 because it was a violation of the sacred, bottom line.
00:09:31.040 It involves a market system of trading air.
00:09:36.360 In this case, carbon or methane and other greenhouse gases.
00:09:41.820 A trading mechanism to where if you trade anything in a trading system in this world, whether it's a Wall Street type trading system, you have to determine whose property right that is.
00:09:55.280 You can't trade anything until you determine the property right.
00:09:58.380 in this situation, we have an economic regime where you have to privatize the air and create
00:10:07.540 a trading mechanism. It is a form of privatization. That's something that is very critical to us
00:10:14.740 is that the world has come to this time and place to work. This is one of the major solutions
00:10:21.220 of the United States and Canada and other countries of the north to mitigate climate
00:10:27.020 change that we're in. Another moment that I always reflect on is a gathering that was held by
00:10:33.740 an indigenous president of Bolivia, Evo Morales, who is still the president.
00:10:41.620 And he was so frustrated participating in the UN climate meetings when he also was trained to
00:10:48.680 integrating the issues around indigenous cosmology. It was in 2009 in Copenhagen,
00:10:57.920 and there was a strong resistance against these false solutions. IEN was very critical in that
00:11:04.560 area, and we were mobilizing other NGOs, non-government organizations, to speak out
00:11:11.660 against these, that they're false solutions. They're not really mitigating climate, and actually
00:11:16.120 They're giving polluters the right to continue to pollute.
00:11:20.200 Evo Morales left Copenhagen at that UN climate meeting and said, we're going to have our own meeting.
00:11:27.720 He's going to invite world leaders.
00:11:29.400 He's going to invite the farmers, the peasants, the people who struggle for water rights, indigenous peoples, people from throughout the world to have their own World People's Conference on Climate Change and the Rights of Mother Earth.
00:11:44.500 that was in Cuchabamba, April 22nd, 2010.
00:11:51.140 And it was really, man, it was a really good meeting.
00:11:55.560 It was a lot of critical analysis about where we're at.
00:12:00.100 But something that really struck out at me,
00:12:02.460 and I found another stronger base there of people who thought like I did.
00:12:09.520 And out of that meeting came a universal declaration on rights of Mother Earth.
00:12:14.500 But why I mention this is that it talks about that we have to come together as people and nations of this earth and that we have to challenge the decision makers to reevaluate the relationship to the sacredness of Mother Earth, acknowledge that she is a source of life and that we get our nourishment from her.
00:12:37.480 Everything comes from her. And recognize that capitalist system, along with everything that it represents, exploitation, abuse, contamination, commodification, and part of the problem of climate change, that we have to address this reality.
00:12:56.580 And that really was the hook for me to better understand where we're at, because if we as indigenous peoples, as well as non-indigenous people, lose our understanding about what those original instructions are that were given to us by the creator, then we're in the danger of becoming like dominant society.
00:13:22.580 And that's the critical area, is that we have a dominant system that views Mother Earth as an object, the same way that many of us are addressing the issues of objectification of women.
00:13:41.980 We have an economic system and politics and policies, including property rights, that objectifies that sacredness of our Mother Earth.
00:13:54.760 So it's linked up. It's related to this broader frame of financialization of nature. It creates a new commodity of nature by turning that sacredness of our Mother Earth's carbon cycling and Mother Earth's life cycling capacity into property to be bought and sold in a global market.
00:14:17.680 That's what red is, reducing admission from deforestation and degradation, selling the carbon that's in the trees.
00:14:26.680 And who is it that buys that carbon?
00:14:28.760 Who is it that's trading that carbon?
00:14:31.060 It's the polluters.
00:14:32.300 It's Chevron, oil.
00:14:35.020 It's Shell.
00:14:36.560 It's Phillips Conoco.
00:14:38.400 It's the very polluters that are creating climate change but also toxic contamination in this world.
00:14:45.060 It gives them a free ride. They use carbon as a sponge. And the carbon credits that they buy are cheaper in the global south. So in a way, what's happening is that they are buying the trees in the south. It's their trees. They have bought carbon.
00:15:02.320 And now we are experiencing human rights violations from all over the global South, Indonesia, Africa, Latin America, where these forested regions where indigenous peoples live, now they don't have access to the trees because those are protected trees.
00:15:23.140 It is a catch-22 because we do support the conservation of trees. There's so much illegal logging that's going on in the South.
00:15:32.320 But out of what's happening here, using trees as part of a trading system with no really clear and strong mechanism for reporting, verification and monitoring, it ends up potentially, and we've seen this already, this international Ponzi scam of climate capitalism.
00:15:54.840 Wow. Thank you, Tom, for unpacking this really disgusting false solution. And it seems that
00:16:06.660 the REDD program seems to avail the longstanding colonizer strategy of divide and conquer.
00:16:14.540 And I'm wondering how you've seen communities fissure when grants from the World Bank or
00:16:21.100 NGO rhetoric begin shaping indigenous delegations? It is one of the problems and we want to talk
00:16:28.360 about that at our Protecting Mother Earth Conference and a lot of these policies that are
00:16:34.200 you know that we're struggling with especially when you link money to it and we want to come
00:16:40.520 together to address this issue because what is that foundation that holds us together as
00:16:47.420 indigenous peoples aboriginal first nation people not only of north america canada and u.s what we
00:16:54.260 call turtle island but of the world there's a lot of division the sacred hoop is really
00:17:02.260 not completely broken the sacred hoop needs to be mended and and healed because a lot of these
00:17:11.400 initiatives, whether it's mining, the differences between saying no to mining, that there's no such
00:17:18.120 things as sustainable mining, but yet there's such a push from financial institutions like the World
00:17:24.660 Bank who say, yes, there is sustainable mining. We'll give you money to go development around
00:17:30.540 sustainable mining. But when we consult with our traditional people, there's really concern and
00:17:38.220 lack of trust in the concepts of sustainable mining. Does that really exist? So the other
00:17:44.740 area that we've been talking about is this area of commodification of the sacred, privatization
00:17:51.340 of nature, financialization of life itself. That's the number one solution for mitigating
00:17:59.400 climate change. And we know, like what I briefly talked about, it's not a real solution, but it's
00:18:06.300 being pushed by some of the well-financed large green groups in this country, U.S., as well as
00:18:14.100 throughout the world. We call them the large non-governmental organizations, NGOs, the well-funded,
00:18:23.100 and they're pushing this fault solution agenda along with World Bank, which is sourcing up
00:18:29.760 Indigenous organizations to support REDD. REDD is, again, is part of this carbon trading,
00:18:37.360 carbon offsets. There's other related initiatives like payment for environmental services
00:18:43.380 compensating people under this regime. So money talks, especially when you're dealing with our
00:18:51.420 people that haven't had money, or they're fighting other issues and they need resources.
00:18:58.340 So we've been battling with this as how do we create the necessary resources to do community-based training
00:19:06.000 and make those available in different languages, whether it's the indigenous languages of Brazil or in Ecuador
00:19:14.280 or other areas of the global south where tropical forests are.
00:19:21.060 That's where these initiatives are being implemented.
00:19:24.420 And also domestically in the U.S. and Canada, they're being implemented in forested areas in the north as well.
00:19:32.540 Red structure, but similar.
00:19:34.960 And so there is that division that's happening.
00:19:38.600 We find that as we work with tribes and indigenous communities who are looking at participating in red,
00:19:48.180 it, we ask them a simple question. Where does the money come from that they're promising to pay you?
00:19:55.640 And they say, because globally, they say, the World Bank, about time the World Bank has given
00:20:00.740 us money, you know, are in California, they say, well, it's coming from the state of California.
00:20:09.300 And we say, no, that money is coming from the polluting industry. That's given them a way out
00:20:16.920 In a form of greenwash, they're not cutting back admissions in Richmond, California, or Martinez, California.
00:20:25.460 They are increasing admissions.
00:20:28.500 And what gives them cover is that they say, we have purchased carbon credits to conserve trees.
00:20:36.880 And try to tell that to local community people who have respiratory illnesses.
00:20:42.500 They're dying.
00:20:43.800 There's cancer clusters around a lot of these polluting facilities that are greenwashing.
00:20:49.720 And then the other issue is that the numbers don't add up.
00:20:53.900 Europe was a good example of that in their admissions trading.
00:20:57.180 We have a new publication, a new report that we just put together along with the Climate Justice Alliance called Carbon Pricing, a critical perspective for community resistance.
00:21:09.420 And it speaks out to this issue.
00:21:11.360 Do carbon trading regimes threaten cultural genocide on a scale we have never seen before?
00:21:20.140 Well, not only genocide against our people, it's a form of ecocide against nature, against
00:21:28.380 Mother Earth. It's as if these policies are liquidating the sacredness of what we as
00:21:36.400 indigenous people understand in our relationship with Mother Earth. She's in liquidation. It's all
00:21:43.100 about money. And not only is it red and the trading of carbon in the trees, but now agriculture.
00:21:52.300 In the UN system, they are even proposing what we call climate-smart agriculture,
00:21:57.120 which means that it involves genetically engineered seeds for agriculture and crops
00:22:04.740 that are climate friendly and it also involves not turning the soil so that you sequester the
00:22:13.120 carbon in the soil again who buys carbon in the soil who makes that investment
00:22:20.000 around climate smart agriculture again it's the polluters now it's also mining companies
00:22:28.500 It's pension funds. There's big money and investments around what I'm talking about.
00:22:37.400 And it involves also biological offsets, conservation offsets.
00:22:42.960 So this is really concerning because on an international scale, it's also coming out of the international realm.
00:22:51.580 It's a whole financial system that is not transparent.
00:22:56.240 The bottom line, at the end of the day, at the 11th hour, it's not our people or even non-Native people that have rights to the land is going to be in corporate hands.
00:23:08.360 So it's ethoside.
00:23:10.280 Genocide, yes, but cultural, it involves our culture as well.
00:23:14.980 And again, genocide piece comes in to where it's not a solution to climate change.
00:23:22.400 We have melting ice territories of our Inupiat and our people in the polar regions of the north.
00:23:29.880 The ice is melting.
00:23:31.460 The permafrost in Alaska is thawing out.
00:23:36.520 Housing is shifting.
00:23:38.360 There's going to be more erosion along the coastlines.
00:23:41.720 And it's not that easy just to relocate Native Indigenous peoples from a village,
00:23:47.420 from our territories, and relocate to another area.
00:23:50.980 it involves land exchange that have to be negotiated in many of our areas here in northern
00:23:58.220 minnesota in the great lakes our people are always very cautious and looking with both eyes
00:24:06.120 whether or not there's going to be a good fishing season our maple syrup maybe it's going to be just
00:24:13.640 Briefly, the sap that's going to be running for a week are ricin, the wild rice, the piscine or the manomen, the medicine food.
00:24:24.800 You know, some of the, depending on the seasons, some of these lakes are drying out, even here in the Great Lakes.
00:24:31.740 So we're always watching precipitation.
00:24:34.880 Again, if you look at the weather, in our Navajo tradition, there's male rain and female rain.
00:24:40.840 You get a lot of male rain these days that when it rains throughout different parts of the country, it comes down really hard, fast, and it runs right off the land and goes into the rivers and causes floods and washouts, things like that.
00:24:56.740 When it's more gentle, it soaks in into the ground.
00:25:00.500 So these are things that affect our right to hunt, our rights to gathering, our medicines and our foods, the right to plant and our agriculture.
00:25:12.580 So this is all part of the link to our health and our well-being.
00:25:30.500 I sit still
00:25:51.420 The blank mind I crave
00:26:00.500 I sit still, the blank mind I crave, I sit still, the blank mind I crave. 1.00
00:26:25.000 You're a coward 0.99
00:26:31.000 I sit still 1.00
00:26:36.000 The blank mind I crave
00:26:40.000 You don't know how to be kind
00:26:46.000 I sit still
00:26:51.000 The blank mind I grave
00:26:54.540 When all I asked for was a lie
00:27:06.120 Red is clearly reaping egregious violations 0.97
00:27:14.200 to the rights of indigenous peoples and the earth, 0.63
00:27:17.540 particularly in the global south,
00:27:19.020 like you've been explaining to us. But I also know that here in California, as well as in Alaska,
00:27:26.040 carbon offset programs have actually been welcomed by some indigenous nations. For example, the
00:27:31.500 Chugash willingly sold their coal rights to a conservation investment management company,
00:27:35.840 who then retired those rights to the local native conservancy land trust, leaving the Chugash to
00:27:42.160 manage their ancestral territory for carbon stocks. I know situations in Alaska are particularly messy,
00:27:48.400 as the Native communities are navigating the wake of ANSCA, the Alaska Native Claim Settlement Act.
00:27:54.820 But I just wanted to bring this to the table to illuminate more of the complexity surrounding this issue
00:28:01.560 and probe if you think there is ever a situation in which carbon trading can be beneficial for a community's well-being.
00:28:10.480 Good question. I appreciate you asking that.
00:28:13.900 It goes to the core of whether or not these economic measures would be able to affect the amount of greenhouse gases that go into the environment.
00:28:30.000 That's the critical part that we really have to look at.
00:28:33.620 For our network, you know, we are advocating that we need to take action, action quicker to move away from a fossil fuel economy.
00:28:45.680 Mother Earth just cannot absorb any more carbon.
00:28:49.340 That's why we've been bringing attention to science organizations that have said that if we're going to really turn this planet around and reducing the amount of concentration of greenhouse gases, that we have to keep at least 80% of fossil fuel reserves under the soil, beneath the ocean floor.
00:29:13.280 And we have to start banning any new exploration and exportation of oil, car sands, oil, gas, shale, or fracking, coal, and even the link to other extreme energy that are not solutions like uranium mining and transportation infrastructures, pipelines, going across Mother Earth.
00:29:39.600 tanker traffic taking frac oil or car sands oil overseas from the Pacific Ocean.
00:29:47.820 And the question is, how do we achieve 100% clean renewable energy by 2030 or no later
00:29:56.860 than 2050 without any dependence on nuclear power?
00:30:01.000 We're in that critical stage right now.
00:30:04.100 And any participation in this market system is a contradiction of that need of where we need to go.
00:30:14.740 And I have been in discussions with policymakers and debates around this issue of can we reform market systems?
00:30:28.480 Can we make them work?
00:30:30.120 People have told me, Tom, we hear you.
00:30:32.880 there's a lot of problems and risk with carbon trading and offsets.
00:30:38.520 You know, work with us so we can make it work.
00:30:41.260 But I'm not sure if we can make it work.
00:30:43.940 Since when has commodification of life and capitalism worked on the behalf of our people,
00:30:52.560 especially we are trying to get our traditional knowledge recognized?
00:30:57.360 They even want to commodify traditional knowledge.
00:31:00.600 So we're at a time really at this crossroad that I've been told to watch out for for a couple of decades.
00:31:06.920 We are there right now.
00:31:08.360 And the temptation is there to try to get us to compromise our position and negotiate in a way that allows this black snake to go across not only our land, but in the minds of our people.
00:31:24.560 okay one more question about red because it's such a huge topic to cover i think about red and
00:31:34.600 other carbon offset programs and how they operate under the premise that without intervention from
00:31:40.340 a developed country quote developing countries as they call it will inevitably cut down their
00:31:46.340 forests and extract their resources anyways part of me wants you to debunk this myth and then the
00:31:53.520 other part of me asks but it's almost a self-fulfilling prophecy as life-sustaining cultures
00:32:00.320 have no reason to do so until imperialist intervention prohibits them from gathering
00:32:05.740 hunting and tending their traditional territories so in one way i feel like this is a myth that
00:32:11.020 they're going to do it anyways these communities but then a lot of times these communities are
00:32:15.920 pushed into a corner when capitalism comes and really wrecks havoc in their area
00:32:23.240 Right. Our Indigenous Environmental Network is really concerned about all these points that we've been talking about.
00:32:33.500 It's that, you know, we're committed to looking for real solutions.
00:32:38.680 And we have seen that in areas that dissipate in red.
00:32:44.460 And we have to understand a lot of the red projects are just starting up.
00:32:49.620 But also in some of these areas, eventually, deforestation may take place, and they just replant the trees in afforestation, and it's still part of a market system.
00:33:06.280 So is it a way to preserve and conserve trees?
00:33:10.820 There are already laws in the Global South that address illegal logging.
00:33:15.560 So where are the pressure points outside of a market system that puts the pressure on government, whether national or subnational?
00:33:26.460 Brazil, for example, or Ecuador, or the Congo in Africa, can get real solutions to preserve the trees.
00:33:36.260 And those dialogues have not taken place.
00:33:38.880 In areas of Africa, there already are human rights violations perpetuated by the national governments against tribal peoples in the remote areas of the forests.
00:33:51.320 There's big money in forests now in these carbon trading mechanisms.
00:33:55.520 We already are seeing violations of the human rights of forests in the communities that are going to be removed from their traditional homelands.
00:34:04.960 because those trees are now part of a market system.
00:34:09.640 We're seeing that now.
00:34:11.300 Plantations and parks, national forest parks, social bosques in Ecuador, 0.76
00:34:20.000 where there's already violence, where Indigenous peoples are standing up and saying,
00:34:24.940 no, we never gave away our rights to have access to our forests.
00:34:29.900 It is some serious critical questions that we do need to ask ourselves.
00:34:34.960 and look for real solutions to conserve and protect our trees.
00:34:39.480 Forest management in the North, in California, is a big issue.
00:34:43.520 Many of the tribes I talk to don't know where the money comes from.
00:34:48.200 And that's where I believe that we continue to speak the truth,
00:34:52.660 and we start continuing to have trainings and workshops
00:34:56.920 and get together as Indigenous peoples,
00:35:00.000 like at our Protecting Mother Earth gatherings,
00:35:02.600 to have space to be able to share the information we have to bring experts and scientists and
00:35:10.600 economists in native and non-native who have researched this topic of red and make them
00:35:17.720 available to our people because our people aren't hearing from them they're hearing from the other
00:35:23.220 side that are promoting it that's something that is very critical where we're at but it's linked
00:35:29.180 to energy you know it's linked to an economic system that we're dependent on a fossil fuel
00:35:35.500 economy it's all linked i don't think that the system as i call it matrix i don't think the
00:35:42.940 matrix really wants to wean ourselves away from fossil fuels it's thinking of every excuse
00:35:49.420 every greenwash tactics to continue to dig and extract earn um every toxic pollution
00:35:57.900 every oil from the ground, every fossil fuel until we run out. And it's all about funding.
00:36:05.260 And if it can convince us to use a market system like we've been talking about, it will do that.
00:36:12.380 We'll even promote technologies like cloud seeding and these other genetic engineering
00:36:19.920 tactics. They are doing that already. We're going to talk about that at the Protecting
00:36:24.400 Mother Earth Conference as well. Thank you so much, Tom, for walking us through the complexities
00:36:31.380 of red and carbon trading. I think that the majority of people don't understand
00:36:38.120 all of the hidden loopholes that are tied within it, but they just see it as a solution. But really,
00:36:46.260 it is such a detrimental false solution. So I'm so appreciative of the time you've taken
00:36:52.180 to spread the word about this you know no doubt money is a primary vector for the cannibalistic
00:37:00.340 sickness of dominant society but i wonder where we find ourselves now in order to protect land
00:37:07.560 and life ways in order to ensure our voices are heard we rely on money and ultimately it seems
00:37:14.380 that all money is dirty and tethered to some type of resource extraction so i'd like to know what
00:37:21.340 do you think about that and do you think there is a way to funnel money to good causes with
00:37:27.100 integrity and yeah i guess like are there righteous funding initiatives that you believe in well there
00:37:34.620 are there are funding mechanisms out there i call it clean money yeah i've been in debates where
00:37:41.840 people say all money is not clean at some point, but as compared to where the polluters
00:37:50.640 are putting their money into a false solution like climate change, let's just say that's dirty money.
00:38:00.400 We've been advocating for governments and communities to participate in conservation
00:38:07.920 measures that are outside of a market system. And you'll see some of that language and some
00:38:13.980 of the negotiation at the United Nations climate meetings, non-carbon and non-market. I believe
00:38:22.200 that that's where we need to go. And we need to create a political will. Generally, in my
00:38:30.140 assessment, people of the world and people right here in River City in the United States,
00:38:37.920 aren't well-versed on economics.
00:38:41.700 The public education system has failed us.
00:38:45.040 I've been to Mumbai, for an example, in India.
00:38:47.460 I have been into the slum areas,
00:38:50.080 and I have engaged on this discussion of economics
00:38:53.600 and economic justice.
00:38:55.960 And they get it.
00:38:57.420 They understand it.
00:38:58.660 But here in America,
00:39:00.120 it's difficult to find people where I can engage
00:39:03.700 in talking about economics and capitalism,
00:39:06.180 and especially, you know, where do we go if we want to make an economic change?
00:39:12.960 Where do we go? How do we get there?
00:39:15.160 So as we understand an extractive economy, that's something we really need to analyze.
00:39:21.240 And that's one thing we're going to introduce as far as these different concepts.
00:39:27.260 You know, it's not going to just take four days, but we're going to give the tools for people to think
00:39:33.280 and to be critical thinkers as indigenous peoples you know many of us been in the public school
00:39:39.860 systems we've been raised in a society doesn't value who we are our traditional knowledge our
00:39:46.500 identity our language many of us are part of that seventh generation part of that seventh to the
00:39:54.720 eighth fire our children now are part of that generation that are going to make and change
00:40:01.980 But that also means being critical thinkers of where we are and where we're going, and to really look at this danger of capitalism and economic system that creates money.
00:40:15.360 You know, what is our model of growth?
00:40:18.940 How do we evaluate that for us as indigenous people?
00:40:23.500 So what we've been advocating is decolonization process for us as indigenous peoples.
00:40:30.400 to ask ourselves about establishing our own policies on our own indigenous-based index
00:40:39.060 for living well that creates and establishes standards for meaningful work, a livable wage.
00:40:47.580 What is that for our reservations? What does it create a sustainable community?
00:40:53.560 Is there other models for housing, building our homes, energy-efficient homes,
00:40:58.980 rather than these government-subsidized homes that leak in the middle of winter?
00:41:03.960 What's our agriculture and what's food sovereignty to create our own food?
00:41:08.380 And this is all linked together, renewable energy.
00:41:12.420 How do we rebuild our communities based upon our original instructions
00:41:17.620 and also looking at the future generations,
00:41:20.840 the seven generations to be able to take them into account?
00:41:24.660 So this is part of the challenge that we have.
00:41:26.900 And it is going to be a challenge because a lot of our Native nations, whether it's in Canada or the U.S., we are dependent on federalism.
00:41:36.780 We're dependent on the money that comes down.
00:41:39.940 We send our children.
00:41:41.540 We send them to college and universities who come back and they wanted a good job.
00:41:46.540 So we do recognize that the economy is very important.
00:41:51.520 What kind of economy are we going to build as Native people?
00:41:55.160 We're small islands of people in a broader, dominant economic system of America.
00:42:02.560 And we know a lot of problems with the economic system is that it perpetuates unlimited growth.
00:42:09.880 It's barely hanging on.
00:42:11.980 It's depleted a lot of the fish in the oceans.
00:42:15.600 And this is part of that problem that at least we're recognizing in our circles of people that we're working with.
00:42:22.980 and a lot of them do come from frontline communities.
00:42:26.160 We have to change the way that we are operating,
00:42:29.680 again, and recognize the sacredness of our Mother Earth
00:42:33.920 and our Father Sky and live in peace and harmony
00:42:37.420 with Mother Earth, not treat her violently
00:42:41.100 like you see on the news stations every day
00:42:44.420 or throughout the world.
00:42:46.220 It's like society of the world is at war with Mother Earth
00:42:50.240 and always exploiting her, degrading her, looting her, privatizing her.
00:42:58.420 If there's an economic system we can develop and we can't do that alone, 0.99
00:43:03.240 and that's something we are doing, we're mobilizing with non-Indigenous people,
00:43:08.020 people of color, for example, people from the global south,
00:43:12.620 small farmers, the peasants. 1.00
00:43:14.860 We're going to change the system, and I believe we can do that.
00:43:18.580 It takes education, popular education, and beginning to speak up as indigenous people about that responsibilities that all of humanity has to protect that sacred female principle of creative principle of Mother Earth.
00:43:35.720 that's beautiful tom and as we've been talking about the economic system i've been thinking
00:43:42.560 as well as about the legal system and i'm reflecting on how colonizer legal systems
00:43:49.040 have foundationally enabled the destruction of the planet these environmental laws and
00:43:54.380 regulations have never sought to protect nature only to legalize exploitation and while corporations
00:44:02.120 are granted personhood by law, water, soil, forests, etc., are considered property. And
00:44:09.040 although there are glimpses of this transforming with countries such as Bolivia and Ecuador and
00:44:13.880 New Zealand adopting the Declaration of the Rights of Mother Nature, stemming from a movement that
00:44:19.720 you've been vital to. So I want to ask, how do you see the legal recognition of the rights of nature
00:44:26.240 challenging and shifting the prevailing paradigms that uphold violent and disharmonic ways of being.
00:44:34.260 It's part of our prophecies, for one thing. Some of our people have been told that a time will come
00:44:40.720 when these children of the colonizers, these people who come as the settlers, that they're
00:44:47.580 going to start waking up and see those things that we've always been saying. That's coming about.
00:44:53.420 Some lawyers, some social change people, they're starting to come about throughout the world, and they formed an alliance on the rights of nature.
00:45:04.980 Of course, I initially was very cautious in that, and what is the agenda of these descendants of settlers?
00:45:13.440 As I checked it out and a number of us were evaluating at work with these people, we felt that it was consistent with at least with those prophecies that we have.
00:45:26.000 And there's other people I know who have talked about the doctrines of discovery.
00:45:31.360 And even back then, in the colonization of the U.S. and of their Americas, there were international laws at the time.
00:45:39.900 So the question I'm sure that was asked, how can colonizers, the countries that are coming here to the U.S. and throughout the Americas,
00:45:49.620 how can they come and invade and colonize our territories legally under international law?
00:45:58.160 It needs the church, basically and very simplistic, it needs the church to say that we are not civilized.
00:46:04.660 we are pagans and that's part of that process doctrines of discovery manifest destiny so one
00:46:14.140 of the challenges that we look at in our decolonization process is to call question
00:46:20.420 to the concepts of dominion dominion it's the same thing with the man says i have dominion over my
00:46:28.220 wife the same thing man says they have dominion over mother earth and that's a concept that's a
00:46:37.180 principle that we have to change we got to really work together to reevaluating our relationship as
00:46:45.440 humanity to the sacredness of mother earth and how we walk upon her that's where we're at that's why
00:46:53.060 for continuing to look throughout the world about the struggles of indigenous peoples
00:46:59.440 like the Maori people who have fought for the recognition of the river over in New Zealand.
00:47:06.880 And it's important for them to look at that.
00:47:10.780 And they've been fighting for it for a long time.
00:47:14.320 And now New Zealand has finally recognized the personality of that river.
00:47:19.940 And I was just there.
00:47:21.740 I went over there.
00:47:23.060 We're looking at that. It's progress. It's the first step.
00:47:27.020 It's something that we're continuing to promote throughout the world.
00:47:31.320 It's this new system of what we call systems change, not climate change, where it moves away from this framework of privatization and looking at Mother Earth as a property right.
00:47:47.740 It's very critical to us.
00:47:49.580 I was brave, I was brave.
00:48:19.580 when we were talking earlier about reservations and basically where you were describing a just
00:48:41.040 transition for native folks and you mentioned renewable energy and i really question renewable
00:48:48.360 energy more and more all the time. For example, I truthfully don't see solar panels as part of
00:48:54.860 a regenerative culture, especially after my interview with Jacinda Mack, a native woman
00:48:59.800 from British Columbia who's dealing with mining disasters. And somewhere, a sacred mountain is
00:49:05.740 demolished, waters are polluted, humans and more than humans inflicted upon to maintain the rare
00:49:12.240 minerals they require. You know, not to mention the energy expended from the mining itself,
00:49:16.800 the assembly, the transport, the installation, the upkeep, so on and so forth. So renewable energy
00:49:22.600 as it's unfolding now is not clean, nor does it question systems of oppression or our infrastructure
00:49:28.700 with limitless growth. So I'd like to ask your opinion on our collective capacity for a just
00:49:36.480 transition. And do you have any stories you'd be willing to share of communities who are embodying
00:49:42.200 a just transition and regenerative way forward with unique integrity.
00:49:47.400 Yeah, we're right in the middle of developing our Indigenous-based Just Transition Initiative.
00:49:53.920 And part of what we've been advocating for that I mentioned on this interview is the need for us
00:50:01.680 as Indigenous peoples to really have that critical analysis with the question of where are we going
00:50:08.240 for the next generation? Where are we going in 2050 when there's going to be an evaluation of
00:50:16.860 whether or not these climate policies that are being implemented at the national and international
00:50:24.220 level have really worked? Our youth now will be elders in 2050. What's the evaluation mechanisms
00:50:33.520 and the indicators that will be used at that time.
00:50:36.880 Are we as Native Indigenous people going to be in seven generations?
00:50:41.940 Those are critical questions that we are asking.
00:50:45.240 And we want to engage our leadership, both grassroots, women, youth, and elected governments
00:50:52.120 about this question.
00:50:54.580 How do we build alignment?
00:50:56.460 Where are we going as far as building a just transition and transformation to a better world?
00:51:02.600 Those are questions that we have to ask ourselves, and it does look at the concern we have not only within our territories, where some of our Native nations are invested in mineral extraction, who are invested in fossil fuel development, but we also have to challenge the dominant society to be part of this transition.
00:51:31.000 We have in the United States policies that really create too much waste.
00:51:37.460 We have policies that encourage continued consumption at levels that are not sustainable.
00:51:46.280 Our dependence on energy is something that we really need to look at in this country and Canada as well, these big cities.
00:51:55.780 If we're going to be pushing for wind turbines or photovoltaic solar, at scale to meet current needs being expressed by an addicted society to energy is not sustainable.
00:52:12.360 So we really need to reevaluate what is our needs energy-wise.
00:52:17.320 What is the concepts of energy democracy when we look at not only our energy, true energy needs, but also how do we as communities have more control on the energy that we produce or do we participate in a colonial federal electrical grid line system?
00:52:39.700 You know, what is a microgrid system? Those are things that we are advocating for as Indigenous Environmental Network. When it comes to just transition, definitely those are areas, again, that we're lifting up this decolonization process.
00:52:56.520 that does look at our physical, our psychological,
00:53:02.060 our emotional, our spiritual strategies
00:53:04.860 because that always has been a factor
00:53:08.080 as we look about where we are going
00:53:10.720 is our body, our mind, our heart, and our spirit
00:53:14.000 as it relates to where we've been
00:53:16.240 with trauma, colonization,
00:53:18.940 but also going through the healing process.
00:53:22.280 So this is kind of, again, where we're at.
00:53:24.420 Just transition has to have its foundation in our original instructions, those spiritual teachings that have been left to us by our ancestors, and leave enough of that information and knowledge for our future generations to recognize, again, that vital life cycle of Mother Earth.
00:53:46.260 That should be the core of where we go and how we build our communities.
00:53:50.400 How does it impact our Mother Earth, our water of life, our air, our trees? 0.63
00:53:57.040 It does bring up some of these questions that this other movement by non-Native people within the Rights of Nature movement are asking. 0.67
00:54:06.680 Do trees have standing?
00:54:08.760 Those are critical questions that they are asking that really jumped out at me on that question of do trees have standing?
00:54:16.260 Looking at if white folks can develop their own laws, like in Pennsylvania, I mentioned that earlier, where they have laws that they recognize the rights of nature.
00:54:27.580 I think I remember a couple of their communities through their ordinances, and including the city of Philadelphia, passed an ordinance that recognized the ecosystem and the natural community as having legal right to exist and to be healthy and to flourish.
00:54:46.260 And that, you know, the community, the people have that authority to enforce and defend those rights.
00:54:54.180 That's not much different than those instructions I've been raised on, that we are guardians, we are caretakers, that when Mother Earth cannot speak for herself, we are there to speak for her.
00:55:08.900 I remember Roberta Blackboat made an intervention in Geneva, that statement, talking about the earth bundles of the mountain area.
00:55:19.600 Most people in the world don't know how to listen to nature.
00:55:23.460 They don't know how to listen to the earth.
00:55:25.900 And it's our people that have to do that. 1.00
00:55:28.260 So, again, we're going to talk about these at the Protecting Mother Earth Conference coming up June 28th through July 1st in the territories of the Nisqually Nation.
00:55:38.900 the people in Washington state. Yes, I'm so grateful that you're putting on this
00:55:46.000 conference to give space to these issues for people, indigenous people to come together and
00:55:53.000 really sit with one another. And like you said, have people and lawyers and those who are up to
00:56:01.580 date with the laws and and the regulations and and how we can learn and educate ourselves and
00:56:09.160 and so i i really am so excited about protecting mother earth conference and one more question tom
00:56:14.900 before we end this incredible conversation you've mentioned a few times in the interview about
00:56:20.740 this time and perhaps the cosmology or the proverbs behind it and i so respect your connection to
00:56:28.360 spirit and i'm interested by what lessons your cosmology gleans from this particular time
00:56:37.000 of great unraveling and great change and if there's anything you feel called to say about
00:56:42.620 where humanity stands right now or for the carrying capacity of earth in your belief system
00:56:48.820 you know a couple years ago i i was talking to orrin lyons a faith keeper
00:56:54.920 one of the Aga people over in the Great Lakes, the Iroquois Confederacy, he told me that they
00:57:01.040 have prophecies in the Mohawk people. Trees will start dying from the top down. And he related that
00:57:08.160 to where we're at with climate change because they started to raise this issue up in the late 1970s
00:57:15.080 as far as climate and prophecy. For us as IEN and my role, I've been there as a knowledge holder as
00:57:24.400 well. And I remember a statement that we said at a circle of wisdom keepers, including elected
00:57:33.440 tribal leaders and grassroots and spiritual leaders. In 1998, that was the foundation of
00:57:40.540 our work here on climate. And we said that indigenous prophecy now meets what we have
00:57:47.900 known and believe. You also now know the earth is out of balance. The plants are disappearing. 0.89
00:57:53.640 The animals are dying, and the very weather, rain, wind, fire itself, reacts against the actions of the human being.
00:58:02.860 For the future of the children, for the health of our Mother Earth, Father Sky, and the rest of creation.
00:58:09.580 We call upon the people of the world to hold your leaders accountable.
00:58:13.420 That's what the elders and our youth and women and our elected leaders and grassroots said in 1998 at our Circles of Wisdom gathering to talk about our native homelands.
00:58:26.580 And it was a climate workshop that was held in Albuquerque.
00:58:29.840 It was there that was a foundation of recognizing that prophecy of where we're at and why we need to do what we're doing.
00:58:38.140 Just transition is part of that foundation.
00:58:41.060 transition is inevitable. Justice is not. That's why we have to fight for the justice.
00:58:47.940 And so we will get there and lifting up those good way of thinking, lifting up our original
00:58:54.160 instructions and those teachings of respecting ourselves, our clan systems, our family systems,
00:59:00.440 and our Native nations. We always say to the rest of the world, don't just put it on our shoulders.
00:59:06.960 we need the people of the world to come together to learn about what's going on here and we're
00:59:13.700 going to talk about that very soon wonderful thank you so much tom for this the time that
00:59:20.240 you've spent with all of us diving into such complex issues and we support you and ian and
00:59:28.040 indigenous rising and protecting mother earth conference thank you for all that you do and
00:59:33.800 we will keep supporting and really believing in your leadership and those that you work with.
00:59:41.920 Thank you very much for this opportunity.
01:00:03.800 Thank you so much for listening to For the Wild podcast.
01:00:09.980 I'm Ayanna Young.
01:00:11.920 And our music today was by Elia Natalia Schwein.
01:00:15.880 Our theme music is Silence Returns by Bo and Like a River from Kate Wolf.
01:00:20.160 I'd like to thank our incredible podcast team, our producer and editor, Andrew Storrs,
01:00:26.200 research director, Madison Magulski, media director, Molly Lee Bove,
01:00:30.040 and research assistant, Francesca Glassbell.
01:00:33.340 Questions for this episode were crafted by Madison Migulski, Francesca Glaspell, and myself.
01:00:39.300 If you want to learn more about our other projects, including the Tongass National Forest Campaign to end old-growth logging,
01:00:45.100 the One Million Redwoods Project, and be attuned to other updates, sign up for our newsletter on our website at forthewild.world.
01:00:52.340 Also, rate us on iTunes if you haven't already.
01:00:54.900 Alright, thanks so much, and until next week.
01:01:02.680 Smells doors and windows, closed against the day.
01:01:09.340 Sweet smell of the pines, tall western cedar, drifting on the wind, through the mountains like a river.