00:05:43.660It's always perceivable no matter what else is going on.
00:05:47.380So what I try and do and what Radical Joy for Hard Times, my organization tries to do,
00:05:53.140It is to find that life and beauty and spirit and vitality that is still struggling to be known beneath all of that stuff that covers it up.
00:06:06.620I was thinking when this country was colonized in the 1700s, 1800s, during the westward expansion, that clearing forest was the first thing that people did.
00:06:18.100The forest represented the unknown danger, the ugly darkness, the realm of predators and witches, whereas open space was bright and sunny and provided pasture for animals.
00:06:28.300and more closely resembled the savannas humanity evolved in with long views since vision and not
00:06:35.360smell is our most primary sense to think of a pristine forest as ugly is difficult to imagine
00:06:42.440so what do you think has changed for us to now look at a clear cut and see a terrible crime
00:06:48.360and an emptiness where there was once a perfect ensemble of life is there a gradual consciousness
00:06:54.600shift going on where we can see things differently than a few hundred years ago?
00:06:59.400Well, first of all, I don't think that everybody necessarily perceives the clear cut as being
00:07:05.940ugly these days. I think a few people do, probably not enough people. And I also think that in a
00:07:14.120sense, I can understand what the colonists were going through. They came from a place that was
00:09:45.040Perhaps I'm supposed to join an organization and fix it or clean it up, and I don't necessarily know how to do that or want to do it or I don't have time.
00:09:52.420And then the other thing is, what do I do once I get there?
00:09:58.220I don't want to feel those bad feelings.
00:10:00.800So our suggestion is, and what we did when we went to the clear cut, is first of all, we just got out of the car and sat there and took it in and said, what is here?
00:10:11.320When we do go to these places, especially people who are very conscientious environmentalists or restorationists or conservationists, the tendency is, okay, I have to do something.
00:10:26.960but the very first thing to do is go and say what's here how am i affected by this
00:10:33.260what do i notice and so when we were in the clear cut that there were just four of us that went up
00:10:40.900together and i guess it was about 10 years ago and every day we would go out alone and we would
00:10:47.400spend the day from like nine in the morning to four three or four in the afternoon sitting or
00:10:52.580walking alone in the clear cut and just being there and watching it and reflecting on it and
00:10:57.660seeing what came up for us and seeing what we noticed. So being present and taking it in and
00:11:03.980acknowledging both what's around us and our own responses to it without having to feel that we
00:11:10.900have to do anything. That's the key point. When I set out with this idea that we were going to go
00:11:16.540spend a week in a clear cut I thought that I would just feel grief and despair the entire time
00:11:23.100and that it turned out would sort of come in and out but I also got enthralled with a lot of things
00:11:30.960like I remember when I was first there on the first day and I was sitting on this enormous
00:11:36.560tree stump the trees there because where you camp you camp in an old growth forest it's very
00:11:42.740primitive, but it's gorgeous. The trees are 800 or 900 years old. So this clear cut, which was
00:11:48.520quarter mile up the hill and down the road, I was sitting on a huge stump and I realized it was so
00:11:55.480big that I could lie down on it and almost my whole body could stretch out in this stump. And
00:12:01.580there was something marvelous about that. And then I immediately thought, you know, this is 900 year
00:12:06.980old tree that's been cut down. How can I possibly find anything to be excited about in this
00:12:11.360experience. But I was, you know, there was something amazing about being able to lie down
00:12:17.240on a stump. And then I would think about the people who had cut the forest, and I would wonder if they
00:12:24.260felt any grief or any reluctance to take down these huge, magnificent, venerable trees. And
00:12:31.700then there was a day when I was sitting there and maybe 15 feet in front of me came a mother bear
00:12:39.160and two little cubs just sort of dancing over all this debris from the tree limbs.
00:12:44.020And there was one member of our group who saw the clear-cut forest as like a metaphor,
00:12:51.420a living symbol of what she began to call her devastated youth.
00:12:58.140And so she was making altars on all the trees.
00:13:00.860One man just practiced patience sitting on one stump.
00:13:04.900And as he did that, he realized he was in a marriage back in the U.S. that was having a lot of difficulties.
00:13:12.040He realized that his tendency was always to sort of run away from the confrontations with his wife and that he needed to be as willing to sit with what was uncomfortable in his marriage as he was becoming sitting with the discomfort of being in a clear-cut forest in British Columbia.
00:13:31.100So it was really vast and complex what unfolded over those days.
00:13:36.200It was a place where everything was legal.
00:15:31.100you know i was imagining that when you go to these damaged landscapes and even when i visited
00:15:39.020them myself a lot of other personal wounds come up and i'm interested in how they play into each
00:15:46.860other you know they're a mirror for each other and i'm just wondering if you see the healing
00:15:52.140of our wounds tied to the healing of earth wounds how you see that interface it's a great question
00:15:59.860Well, before I started doing this work with Wounded Places, I guided vision quests for many years and still do occasionally.
00:16:07.760And it was always interesting to me that every now and then people would find and be captivated by places that were somehow like not beautiful and wild,
00:16:19.460like a grove of dying aspens or an old mine shaft in Colorado or dead trees that have been struck by lightning.
00:16:28.540Very often we're just like beings calling to people to spend time with them.
00:16:35.260And there's something about seeing that nature can be wounded and struggle to survive and still be long in its landscape.
00:16:48.800You know, a dead tree is not kicked out of its landscape.
00:16:55.580And in fact, there's an amazing story. I did a program with three or four other people called Facing the Mystery, and it was for people with life-altering illnesses. And several of the people didn't live very long after that program. Some of them were in wheelchairs.
00:17:12.520and there was one woman we did it in Colorado and then we didn't we weren't in the wilderness we
00:17:17.880would just go to a park every day and those who could would go off on their own and those
00:17:22.400who were in wheelchairs would be taken to a spot where they wanted to be and then we'd come back0.86
00:17:27.220and get them and this one woman was looking at two trees side by side and one of them they're
00:17:34.660both ponderosa pines I think one of them was beautiful and green and lush and healthy and0.99
00:17:40.940the other one was dead no needles on it sort of knobby fungus things all over the tree and she
00:17:48.160looked at the dead tree and she said that's me i'm i'm dead i don't belong anymore and then she
00:17:54.820noticed a magpie flying around in the sky overhead and she imagined that it was looking for a place
00:18:02.060to land and she just said to herself well it's going to land on the healthy tree because
00:18:06.440who wouldn't who wouldn't choose that tree but instead the magpie landed in the dead tree
00:18:11.920and it was like this transcendent moment for her she suddenly felt as if she had received
00:18:19.960a blessing a message that no matter how wounded you feel that you are you can be sought out by
00:18:26.420something that's beautiful and winged and so for her it was a like that dead tree in comparison
00:18:34.680of the healthy tree was confirmation of her own lack but then when the bird landed in it it was
00:18:41.580confirmation of how she is part of something higher and beautiful and winged so the the way
00:18:49.840a person can respond to a wounded place is so varied i mean you could you might see it as a
00:18:56.120reflection of yourself you might see like this woman did when we were in the clear cut that by
00:19:01.220making altars for places on the stumps, making altars for people or groups of people, you give
00:19:08.640a healing to yourself as you give a healing to the land. It's infinite messages. So what's important
00:19:15.080about all of these is the willingness of the people involved to recognize that they are having
00:19:22.960a response to this place. It's not just like sitting and looking. It's being constantly aware
00:19:29.200that we have a relationship, a vibrant, flexible, malleable relationship with what calls to us
00:19:36.120and being willing to learn from that. Two things came up for me. One was absolutely, yes, we have
00:19:43.880to start with that emotional connection and attachment to wounded places, healthy places,
00:19:49.660you know, just the land in general. And until we find that emotional belonging with the earth,
00:19:54.880we can't really go any further but you know then the flip side of that is that in modern western
00:20:02.520culture especially here in the u.s there's a major fixation on self my wounds my life my this my that
00:20:11.880and i'm wondering do you think it can be a hindrance to allow personal wounds to take over
00:20:19.240the experience. You know, if you're visiting a sick friend, you want to sit with their illness
00:20:25.400and not dwell on your problems. So I'm wondering, do you think we have to let go of our own self
00:20:32.440and just be there for the wounded places? I think you're really right on the right track,
00:20:37.760and I really agree with you. And in fact, one of the things that I have sometimes thought about,
00:20:44.300I'm not a psychologist, but I've been very interested in eco-psychology, which is the idea that people cannot be truly healthy when they're living in an unhealthy environment.
00:20:56.460But, you know, and it's much more complex than that.
00:20:59.440But it's and there's some wonderful work that's being done with it.
00:21:02.920However, like you, I have wondered, is it going to be all about healing the human?
00:21:07.980If we have a person going to therapy and saying, I'm upset because all of the beautiful orchards in California in the Napa Valley are being changed into vineyards, and then it becomes only about me and not about what I can do to give honor and respect to the land, then there's something wrong.
00:21:29.340You know, then it's like I'm only going to use nature as a mirror and I'm not going to I'm not going to say, OK, I'm going to heal myself and then I'm going to go off and do something else again.
00:21:40.120It's like we have to broaden our perspective and recognize that we have a reciprocal relationship.
00:21:47.420And I think that's where eco-psychology needs to focus on, because I think if people are brought into awareness that seeing their wounds in nature and then healing their own wounds is one thing, and it's important, and it could be the first step, but I don't think you go through all those steps and then you're done.
00:22:07.040but that there has to be some sort of reciprocity, some sort of going to the natural world and saying,
00:22:13.760I'm weeping for you. I'm weeping because the Animus River is running orange. I'm weeping
00:22:19.120because the skies of California are filled with smoke and the land is drying up. And it's not
00:22:25.500about me. It's not only about me. And I know you know Joanna Macy and her work. And I remember
00:22:31.900when I was first reading Joanna Macy like 20 years ago, I read that she had gone to her
00:22:38.300therapist and said, I worry about the poverty and I worry about nuclear war and I worry about
00:22:45.180the desecration of the land. And her therapist said, well, it's really about your family. And
00:22:50.320once you get that resolved, you won't have these concerns anymore. And she insisted, no, that's not
00:22:55.380right he's worried about larger things so i think there is a line and i also like i mean i want to
00:23:02.440sort of reiterate what i touched on a few seconds ago that i don't think it's like okay i have to
00:23:07.980fix myself first and then i'll turn to the land you know that i don't think that's right i think
00:23:12.800they can be done in you know step by step like you don't only take a hundred left steps with
00:23:19.360your left foot and then you catch up with your right foot so left right left right left right
00:23:23.700We take care of ourselves, we take care of the land.
00:23:26.520We take care of ourselves, we take care of the land.
00:23:29.240Yeah, and speaking from my own personal experience,
00:23:33.900I realized that the more I focused on the land rather than myself,
00:23:39.020my own healing just followed without trying or even being aware of it in the moment.
00:23:44.380You know, there is a power in that connection and relationship.
00:23:47.820and i feel that all the psychological illness and dissatisfaction of life you know of this
00:38:55.840But I also have gotten into the habit of just making, I'll make a bird and I'll stop wherever I'm struck by something that's going on, no matter what it is, whether it's a factory farm or a trashed beach, you know, it's just like giving a gift to the land for something that's going on with them.
00:39:15.980And I think maybe instead of telling you about my own experiences, just to mention some of the ones that have been really touching that people have done with Radical Joy for Hard Times.
00:39:28.800There was a woman, for example, in Jerusalem who wanted to do an earth exchange for people who were in a hospital waiting to get bone marrow transplants, and they don't allow any plants inside the hospital rooms because it has to be extremely sterile to get people ready for this surgery or these treatments.
00:39:50.340And so this woman made little mobiles up on the roof, and then she dangled them off the side of the roof into the windows of the patients.
00:40:00.400And so they could choose a mobile, and then she would tie those to the roof so they had this little beauty outside their window.
00:40:06.740And, oh, gosh, there's so many people.
00:40:09.900There's a group of young kids in Chicago, and every year they lead their own Earth Exchange with their friends.
00:40:44.780when you're there out of whatever's in front
00:40:47.240of you. And I think that's the magic of it. I think it's a practice that will become increasingly
00:40:54.020meaningful to people. Many predict we are headed for increasingly hard times. How do you see your
00:41:01.400work evolving with the times? Yeah, I don't have a very optimistic attitude about the future
00:41:07.340because global warming is here and its effects are going to be unknown and they're going to be
00:41:16.640profound. And meanwhile, we are not taking care of what we already have that's beautiful and
00:41:23.000valuable in the Arctic, as you say, in forests, in farmlands, all over the world, the natural world
00:41:31.740is disappearing. And water is becoming scarce, and it's becoming polluted. So what are we going
00:41:38.720to do? Frankly, I know a couple of people who are planning to move to the Canada wilderness and hide
00:41:45.360out with their kids and try and escape all this stuff. But is that really what we want to do?
00:41:50.820We can't all run away and escape. It's like all the rich people when Hurricane Katrina hit New
00:41:58.160Orleans, they got to go away, but the people who didn't have the means to leave had to stay there
00:42:02.800and face the calamity that was all around them. I think we have an ethical responsibility to stay
00:42:09.540and take care of where we are not to put ourselves in danger but to but to take care of what we are
00:42:16.360where we are and to join with other people in the community and say how are we going to take
00:42:23.140care of this place how are we going to muster together through the hard times how are we going
00:42:28.960to make this place beautiful even as it's damaged even as it's not what we remember it as how are
00:42:35.760we going to keep loving it are we going to keep ignoring it or are we going to find ways of
00:42:40.580continuing to love it and remember it and thank it and give it offerings so how radical joy will
00:42:46.120unfold our vision is that we wrote this in our mission statement back in 2009 when we founded
00:42:54.160the organization that our vision is that no place on earth is orphaned from the people who love it
00:43:00.600So that every place would be loved and cared for. So that's our vision. And maybe that'll come to pass. And then radical joy for hard times wouldn't even be necessary anymore because the practices of making beauty for places that you love that are damaged is so much ingrained in people's lives and their outlooks that it's just a habit.
00:43:24.860i agree we need to stand for the places we live and love as an ethical imperative but also
00:43:33.200practically speaking there really aren't any places to run to human impact is practically
00:43:39.040everywhere and our pollution and nuclear haze reaches into the most pristine places
00:43:44.460of course there are places that will be lifeboats for people and other species
00:43:49.180but the earth is a swirling ball of connectivity
00:43:53.180so if we turn our backs to this environmental assault
00:46:02.800Jung had the idea that you could communicate with different aspects of your psyche.
00:46:09.680And he did that beautifully with his own self.
00:46:12.740And to me, through work that I've done with guided imagery and training to lead the wilderness rites of passage or vision quests,
00:46:22.720I just started applying that idea of active imagination to the natural world and encouraging people to go out.
00:46:32.260And in fact, I do it on every single program I do, whether it's an indoor program, an outdoor program, a half hour program, you know, I don't do half hour programs, but two week program, a weekend program, go out onto the land and find a being, I call it a being, that's calling to you and spend some time with it and talk to it.
00:46:52.060You know, and you can see people going off and going, well, this isn't going to work for me.
00:46:59.600And, you know, and by calling to you, I mean something as simple as what are you noticing when you go out for a walk?
00:47:05.580It's not like a tree is necessarily going to be saying, come to me, come to me.
00:47:10.740I have a message for you, although it might.
00:47:13.520But when anybody goes out on a simple walk where they don't have a goal or an intention, they notice certain things.
00:47:20.540So when you notice something, stop, pay attention and then have a conversation with it. And people get really, people always, always, always, always come back with the most amazing stories about things that have happened when they spend time with whatever, a tree, a mountain, you know, a piece of coyote shit.0.98
00:47:42.940it opens them up to the possibility of dialogue with something other than a human being sitting
00:47:51.320right in front of them you know or in in technology in some way and it's very very profound and i don't
00:47:59.300know how it works i don't know i don't know what the reason for it is but i know that i know that
00:48:05.360it does work and i know that it opens people up to a way of being in a relationship with
00:48:12.280the world around them in a way that you just, once you've opened up in that simple way,
00:48:17.420you just simply can't go back and think, you know, I'm me and I'm sentient and everything else that's
00:48:22.780not human, is it? I see what you're doing as a kind of psychological prepping for a regenerative
00:48:28.600society. And I also feel the urgency to intervene in the assault on nature and the extinction
00:48:34.680crisis in a direct material way. I'd like to ask, is the psychological work in your view
00:48:41.120a partner with direct on-the-ground activism, or a prerequisite, or an alternative, or what?
00:48:48.300I think they can work really beautifully hand-in-hand. And I've had many conversations
00:48:53.740with activists about this. And some activists who are really engaged in litigating, lobbying,
00:49:01.940protesting, educating, doing really important work, their reaction sometimes is, well, I don't
00:49:08.380have time to talk to the earth i don't have time to give it off you know that's not that's not
00:49:12.840relevant but really it is you know it's very relevant and i think we need all different forms
00:49:19.180of paying attention and so for example if a group of activists is working together say to to save a
00:49:26.880canyon there would not be any reason why they couldn't get together in a circle once a week
00:49:31.940and talk about their feelings about what they're doing there wouldn't be any reason why they
00:49:36.120couldn't go to that canyon that they're trying to protect and spend a little quiet time in it
00:49:40.680and come back and share with one another what they noticed and make some kind of a simple act
00:49:46.420of beauty it's like because a lot of activists spend so much time being angry being in a fighting
00:49:53.440mode being on technology and not being out in the places that they work so hard to save yes you know
00:50:00.440it could work in harmony. And my hope also is that by doing simple things like these earth
00:50:08.780exchanges, these simple practices, people will realize, and it's happened in many, many instances
00:50:14.580I know of, that people realize that they do want to get more engaged in these places because
00:50:20.720they've allowed themselves to open up to their deep feelings of love for places. And they want
00:50:28.340to get involved. They want to take care of the places then in more ways. So they do become
00:50:32.920activists. They start taking kids on walks. There's lots of different ways for people to
00:50:40.540get involved. There's different ways that we need to be in consciousness, mindfulness about what's
00:50:48.400going on around us. And one of them is changing consciousness. And one of them is taking steps
00:50:54.220to stop the things that are further harming the earth.
00:52:16.260I only now work with a quest for young people every other year in California with the School of Lost Borders.
00:52:24.720But I think that my focus, and we talked about this a bit earlier, is that, okay, so after you've gained insight for yourself and your world, then what?
00:52:37.140How do we give back, I guess you could say, although I haven't really articulated it this way.
00:52:41.900How do you give back and thank all those beings that gave you all that insight?
00:52:46.260on your fast how do you thank them what if you spent four days in a land that's suffering drought
00:52:53.560how are you going to thank that place are you just going to go away and be grateful that you
00:52:58.880got a lot of profound messages about the drought in your own life or are you going to get something
00:53:03.500back to that land and thank it and give it offerings and maybe go and help educate people
00:53:37.760Well, when I was writing about the Navajo and Hopi, I wrote a bunch of articles from 1986 to 91 about a land dispute where several thousand traditional Navajos were being moved off land that had been redrawn so that it would be Hopi land.
00:53:55.320One of the things that I loved about being there was walking or driving around with Navajo people and the stories that they would tell about their land.
00:54:07.080It was like all of history was living and alive when you would walk or drive around that land with one of those people.
00:54:15.600They would tell a story about how a mountain got its name, or this is where somebody's son was followed by a bobcat when he was coming home from school, or this is where somebody used to play as a little girl, or this is where there's a sacred spring that was revealed to somebody's grandmother by a porcupine.
00:54:35.180It would be like these stories would just emerge from the land.
00:54:41.160And it made me think about how land was alive in my own life.
00:54:46.780And I just loved the humor of the Navajo people, the accessibility that they had to their emotions and their grief about having to leave that land.
00:54:55.320And in a way, that was influential to me, too, because I was aware that so many people came to that land, Native, I mean, white people.
00:55:03.080And a lot of people from Europe, especially Germany, would come because they were drawn to working with the Navajo and helping them.
00:55:10.260And I thought, is it only Native people that can cry for their land?
00:55:14.000We seem to think that white people aren't allowed to cry for their land, but that can't be right.
00:55:18.800Interestingly enough, right before I did my own first fast, I did an interview with Lakota.0.88
00:55:24.740No, he wasn't Lakota. He was a Yankton Sioux activist and writer, amazing writer named Fine Deloria.
00:55:29.540And at the end of the conversation, he said to me, you white people need to go out there and find your own traditions. So I realized he was right, you know, that we needed to find our own ways of being with the land and working with the land. And shortly after that, I found out about white people being able to go on vision quests and then started working with Animus Valley Institute for several years.
00:55:53.420so Trebi what's next for you and where can people go to stay in the loop and perhaps join in the
00:55:59.940work well I want to thank you first for your amazing questions this has just been a fabulous
00:56:05.220conversation thank you so much for the time you've taken to speak with us thank you my website is
00:56:12.540radicaljoyforhardtimes.org and I just finished writing a new book I just finished it yesterday
00:56:19.940in fact oh wow i know it's called aphrodite at the landfill and it's about making beauty for
00:56:27.980for wounded places so i'm excited about that i'm not sure when it'll be coming out yet but
00:56:34.080before too long i hope and i'm really focused on trying to understand the ways that people are
00:56:42.700responding to calamity and disaster and threats to the world around them, and how to be resilient
00:56:52.240and creative and generous in those times. Because I've learned in my own life that it's not just
00:56:59.860radical joy for hard times on the earth, but if I can bring a spirit of openness, generosity, beauty,