Missing Witches - January 25, 2024


WF Dr. Marion Gibson - It Almost Feels Like They Are Waiting There For You

Topics
MW Rx.35 - Writing Love On The Ceiling MW Rx. 36 - Handle With Care

Episode Stats


Length

49 minutes

Words per minute

186.48

Word count

9,289

Sentence count

240

Harmful content

Misogyny

7

sentences flagged

Toxicity

11

sentences flagged

Hate speech

22

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 The Missing Witches podcast is brought to you by The Missing Witches Coven.
00:00:03.940 Come find out more at missingwitches.com. 1.00
00:00:06.900 You aren't being a proper woman, therefore you must be a witch. 1.00
00:00:13.000 You must be a witch. 1.00
00:00:16.860 Welcome, listeners. 0.98
00:00:18.640 Welcome, friends.
00:00:20.280 Welcome, coven mates.
00:00:22.080 Welcome, mountains of snow.
00:00:26.020 Kids with a racking cough.
00:00:27.800 Home for five days in a row. 0.72
00:00:29.400 sleepy brains. Welcome all of us surviving as best we can under terrorizing conditions of
00:00:37.640 late-stage capital. And also welcome to all of our hopes and joys and excitements and just
00:00:43.760 the real delight and honor that personally I feel here today in getting to meet someone who comes
00:00:50.400 with such a life of research into something that I care so much about and I'm so excited to get to
00:00:56.100 learn about from the source. And I'm really thankful Dr. Marion Gibson. Marion is here.
00:01:02.020 I'm really thankful for this book. I've dog-eared Witchcraft, A History in 13 Trials,
00:01:07.200 which I think according to a recent Instagram meme, it means that I'm chaotic evil.
00:01:14.020 I wrote all over it and folded all the pages. But you can also feel reading this book,
00:01:19.400 the like hundred other books that are behind it. So I really feel the presence of all of that work
00:01:25.520 in all that labor and I'm really thankful for it so thank you so much for being here how are you
00:01:29.960 oh I'm very well it's a pleasure to be here and I'm so pleased that you've written in it
00:01:34.860 I like to write in books too because it's like having a conversation with the author and having
00:01:39.600 a conversation with yourself about what you found in there and oh I must look this up or
00:01:44.060 or really like this bit yeah I love that good me too I feel like also when I encounter those
00:01:50.540 books later I know how much I love them if I really docked them up yes the more folded down
00:01:56.800 leaves it has and the more little bits of marginal note it has the more you think oh that that book
00:02:03.160 meant something to me yes and I love that I love that and I love that that you've done it with
00:02:07.320 with my book thank you yes I have there is so much research here I wonder if you could situate this
00:02:13.840 book some of the research that went into telling these specific stories and also within your your
00:02:20.520 life's work so folks can get a better idea of what that's been like yes there is a lot of research
00:02:26.280 in it yeah and this is why I'm now so tired yes I'm not going to deny that there is so I've been
00:02:33.940 interested in the history of witches for about 30 years now which feels like a very long time when
00:02:39.820 you say it like that doesn't it but actually I started being interested when I was an undergraduate
00:02:46.200 at university and that was because somebody gave me a kind of early modern newspaper basically a
00:02:53.200 pamphlet about a witch trial and I was just so fascinated by this thing and I still am really
00:02:59.700 you know I still go back to that first sense of excitement of encountering these stories and
00:03:05.060 and it still works for me I'm still excited about them and I was excited because it was about women
00:03:12.360 primarily. And I found that really interesting because, of course, you know, sources from the
00:03:17.440 16th, 17th century are often not primarily about women. Or if they are, they're about them in ways
00:03:24.120 that we now find problematic, like stories of witchcraft. So I was interested in what those
00:03:29.660 women were saying about their lives, the women who'd been accused and the women who'd done the
00:03:34.460 accusing of them, because, of course, not all the accusers were men by any means. It's quite common
00:03:39.480 for women to accuse one another, as I expect you guys know. So I was really interested from that 1.00
00:03:44.780 point of view, and it's all kind of spun out from there. But this book, it really was a lot of work.
00:03:50.240 I mean, it's seven centuries of research, and I learned a lot during the course of it. I spent a
00:03:56.240 lot of time in libraries and also a lot of time in archives, in record offices, going through old
00:04:03.260 documents, which is something that I absolutely love to do, but isn't particularly easy. And I
00:04:08.300 tried to put as much in as possible because what I wanted to do was make it as detailed as possible
00:04:14.220 and try wherever I could to really foreground the story of the accused person and try to put them
00:04:20.540 at the centre of it and where I could to find words that they'd actually spoken or if I couldn't
00:04:26.280 find that then at least details of their lives you know stuff they might have seen on a daily basis
00:04:31.100 stuff they might have thought about try and work out exactly where they lived and what that might
00:04:36.000 have felt like for them so it was all about it was the nitty-gritty stuff and that does mean a
00:04:40.580 lot of digging but I really wanted to do that to put them at the center of their story if you see
00:04:45.820 what I mean yeah I absolutely do and I think that's something you can really feel in the book
00:04:50.660 and it really feels so I mean some of it is so sad and so traumatic to read but it also really
00:04:58.000 does feel like oh finally like I wanted to see who these people were like even if I can't get
00:05:03.800 more concrete data just to put them in the perspective that you did what was it like what
00:05:08.320 was the town like what were the social economic strings that were being pulled what what was the
00:05:13.680 racial background of the people involved it gives us more insight i think especially when you bring
00:05:18.380 that conversation into today where that words or the phrase witch hunt is getting slapped around by
00:05:25.400 everybody i wondered from the perspective of these trials could you think out loud about
00:05:32.640 who witches are who witches were and maybe outside of the perspective of persecution who were they
00:05:40.500 and i know you have another book kind of specifically about that but yeah well yeah
00:05:45.660 well yes yes i do but i think it's a question that's always worth keeping asking ourselves
00:05:50.440 and one of the things i learned during this but you know i'm a historian i basically look at the
00:05:54.120 past but I wanted in this book to bring it up to date because like you I was increasingly noticing
00:05:59.180 that people were talking about witch hunt they they were actually believing that other people
00:06:03.960 might be doing magic and I thought that was really interesting you know the world was kind of on the
00:06:08.480 one hand being re-enchanted which is nice and good and on the other hand people were using the word
00:06:13.680 witch as a hammer to beat each other which is bad so I wanted to bring it up to date and I learned 0.95
00:06:19.720 a lot about what I thought a witch was because of that really I mean I'd always thought okay so
00:06:25.880 they're primarily women we we know from from the period of the witch hunt really the 15th to 18th
00:06:31.640 century or something like that you know when there are lots of witch trials we know that there are
00:06:37.300 about 75 percent of those accused are women and in some cases it's much higher it's 90 percent is
00:06:44.060 100 percent but in others it's much less and in some jurisdictions men are the majority but they
00:06:49.420 are a fairly small number of jurisdictions so I was thinking right they're women that is primarily
00:06:54.800 a story about the lives of women although not exclusively and then as you go on beyond that
00:06:59.860 you think well what kind of women are they so they're quite often women who have stood out in
00:07:04.980 their community in some way either for good reasons in their own terms or bad reasons
00:07:09.680 so you maybe they've had quarrels with neighbours or maybe they've been accused of something like
00:07:16.220 heresy some sort of religious crime or maybe they've been accused of some sort of social
00:07:21.380 crime as it was then considered you know perhaps they have an illegitimate child and the church is
00:07:26.200 upset with them or perhaps they've had a history of various sexual partners which appears lurid
00:07:34.300 to the people around who you know imagine that they're going to spend their whole lives in a
00:07:38.720 monogamous relationship and once they're married that's it and that's how they think about
00:07:43.740 themselves so anybody outside of that they think oh well you know this person is deviant this is
00:07:48.560 very bad so I was kind of looking for those sort of women who done something a bit different
00:07:53.480 with their lives and who stood out and their neighbours could see them and then beyond that 0.99
00:07:58.600 I was thinking what else are their economic circumstances quite a lot of them are poor women
00:08:03.040 so they're they're women who are struggling on the margins of society but there are also 0.99
00:08:09.160 rich women which I think nicely makes the point that wait a minute this is about women
00:08:13.020 isn't it it's not just about economics it's not just about all the things that historians will
00:08:18.260 often tell you that that witchcraft accusations are about it's about women can we pay attention
00:08:24.020 to that so I thought all those things were important things to draw out and then of course
00:08:29.020 I started looking around the world you know I really started my research in Britain which isn't
00:08:34.200 very racially diverse in the early modern period but of course as I started to look at more modern
00:08:39.700 times. And then I moved across the Atlantic to look at the early American trials, whether that's
00:08:45.440 in Virginia in the 1620s or Salem in the 1690s. Then I started thinking about race. I started
00:08:51.560 thinking about Native American people and African American people. And then I looked, you know,
00:08:57.320 in other places in Europe to see what I could see in terms of that sort of diversity. So one of the
00:09:03.500 chapters looks at Northern Norway, which is something I really hadn't considered before I
00:09:07.660 started writing this book and there I found colonists, settlers, people coming up from the
00:09:13.220 south in conflict with the people of the Arctic Circle. So the witch is also sometimes somebody
00:09:19.080 who stands out in other ways. Maybe she looks different from the people around her. Maybe her
00:09:24.040 language is different. Maybe she has different religious beliefs, different practices. So those
00:09:29.480 are the sort of people that the book is about. People who get noticed for the wrong reasons and
00:09:35.680 that are persecuted and victimized and scapegoated because of that. And as you move into modern
00:09:40.260 times, you can see they are often the same kind of people. Of course, their circumstances are
00:09:45.480 different, but I think you can still count them as witches. And the people in the book are people
00:09:50.300 who've on the whole been accused of some sort of magical crime. And that in my book, literally in
00:09:55.800 my book, makes them witches too. So I wanted to trace that throughout history, that sense that
00:10:01.500 we're dealing with marginalized people
00:10:03.760 who are in trouble with the society around them.
00:10:08.180 And it has something to do with the changing idea of magic, right?
00:10:12.080 Like you talk about this right in the very beginning.
00:10:15.260 Can you think out loud about that too?
00:10:17.300 Because some of the people are, they're reading how milk churns
00:10:21.960 or they do have these folk magical practices,
00:10:24.380 but something changes in the moment that makes that kind of magic dangerous.
00:10:29.820 Yeah, they do.
00:10:30.340 And I think people have always believed in that sort of magic.
00:10:33.200 You know, there's quite a lot of evidence from prehistory that people are blending ideas of what we might now think of as religion and what we might now think of as magic.
00:10:41.400 And this is the same for people.
00:10:42.980 So this kind of basic human thing is, I think, is one of the ways we think about the world.
00:10:48.240 But come the religious upheavals in the Christian church in Western Europe and North America in the 16th and 17th century, that all gets very difficult for people to think about.
00:10:58.800 so they start accusing each other you know christians start accusing each other of heresy
00:11:04.220 protestant catholic other groups splitting off from those two two big separating churches and
00:11:10.780 then they start looking for people who they think are outside of that and the whole thing just gets
00:11:15.500 more and more problematic and magic gets drawn into this religious debate because people start
00:11:21.600 thinking well i'm not really sure if this person is on is on god's side or the devil's side and one
00:11:27.260 of the ways that I might work out that they're on the devil's side is looking to see if they
00:11:31.660 practice any kind of magic so do they maybe do magical healing do they do they say prayers in
00:11:37.820 places that I'd really prefer them not to say prayers in are they the sort of person who I
00:11:42.180 don't think should be saying prayers or preaching or standing up and speaking about religious matters 1.00
00:11:48.000 you know are they are they a woman quite often but are they also maybe a poorer man or somebody
00:11:54.260 who's unqualified in the terms of the church at the time. So I wanted to look at that way that
00:12:00.000 over time magic had become associated with the devil and demonized. And then in modern times,
00:12:05.980 even though, you know, now we often think of ourselves being more enlightened and more
00:12:09.760 accepting and tolerant and all of these kind of things, very often you will find that people who
00:12:15.120 are in all those groups that I talked about earlier, find themselves being accused of some
00:12:19.800 sort of crime which has a magical aspect to it so later on in the book I talk about a woman who's
00:12:25.680 a spiritualist medium and how she's accused and dragged off to court and I talk about faith healers
00:12:32.340 in Pennsylvania in the 1920s and then I bring it right up to date and I talk about Stormy Daniels
00:12:38.700 who has been you know is a pagan and has been accused of witchcraft in quite straightforward
00:12:43.560 terms as part of the general debate around her role in modern American politics. So I've tried
00:12:51.260 to find examples throughout history of where magic has been regarded as a bad thing rather
00:12:56.900 than a good thing, which I think is how it might have been regarded in the very earliest of human
00:13:02.780 societies. And what do you think about
00:13:07.220 trust these days, right? I want to read a little piece because I want to hear you talk more about
00:13:14.740 the relationship between witch hunting and colonialism. You identify these different
00:13:19.240 moments where the Sami indigenous woman, and you give her a different name, Tituba Tatave,
00:13:25.240 than I had seen before, but really identifying these moments where, and you know, we've seen it
00:13:30.360 in Colombia and in the Philippines, where inquisition or witch hunt is really used as part
00:13:35.900 of a colonizing endeavor. Can you talk about, I love this quote. I'm going to read your writing
00:13:41.540 at you. That's okay. So you wrote, scholars have recently suggested that the earlier transatlantic
00:13:46.340 trade in enslaved people was seen by its victims as a type of witchcraft, just as they had previously
00:13:51.500 imagined witches metaphorically consuming happiness, fertility, and wealth. So some
00:13:55.620 enslaved people described themselves as victims of witches who they thought would literally eat
00:14:00.300 them in Barbados or Boston. Together with redefinition by incoming Christians, this new 0.86
00:14:06.120 conception of witchcraft as slavery may have destabilized traditional beliefs. A study published
00:14:12.000 in 2020 claims in Africa and North and South America, representatives of ethnic groups that
00:14:16.260 are more severely raided during the Atlantic slave trade era are more likely to believe in witchcraft.
00:14:21.400 This hypothesis doesn't explain everything about contemporary African witchcraft trials,
00:14:25.000 but it points to links between colonial violence and a legacy of social mistrust.
00:14:30.300 trust broken down. I have like seven more paragraphs outlined and realizing it's a really
00:14:34.860 long thing to read. But would you think out loud about that? I think that was one of the things
00:14:38.840 that I found most interesting because somebody who writes about early stuff, some of the more
00:14:44.140 recent witchcraft accusations. So for example, the ones that I write about across South Africa
00:14:48.720 were the ones I knew least about. So I went chasing other scholars had to say about why they
00:14:54.680 thought witchcraft belief was so prevalent there and why people were so violently persecuted I
00:15:01.220 mean hundreds of people are being killed as witches across southern Africa but also in other parts of
00:15:06.360 the world parts of India Nepal parts of Indonesia and I wanted to think about that we spend a lot
00:15:13.160 of time telling ourselves how rational we are today and how we would never do that and all those
00:15:18.220 kind of things but it turns out they're not really true so I thought it was important to look at that
00:15:22.720 and to look back at the long history of people exploiting other people
00:15:27.520 and see what kind of place the idea of witchcraft had in that.
00:15:32.260 And what that report by those scholars that I cited in the chapter argued
00:15:36.360 was that it's the exploitation which turns into enslavement
00:15:41.800 and turns into the transatlantic trade in enslaved people
00:15:44.960 is inherently connected to ideas of magic
00:15:47.900 because the people who were enslaved already lived in a magical world,
00:15:52.280 you know as lots of people did in that period and lots of our own ancestors in Europe and North
00:15:57.360 America did too they perceived what was being done to them as some kind of magical exploitation
00:16:03.280 because they couldn't think of another way to to explain it you know their whole world was being
00:16:08.760 dismantled their culture was being destroyed they themselves had been captured and dragged away to
00:16:14.180 a place which was utterly strange to them and they had enormous trouble making sense of it some of
00:16:20.020 took with them their magical practices as a way of trying to make sense of that world. There's
00:16:25.540 quite a lot of interesting archaeological evidence about what kind of things they did.
00:16:29.920 So I wanted to think about the ways that they thought of the world as magical,
00:16:34.140 and they thought of the colonists as witches, which is a really interesting juxtaposition,
00:16:38.760 isn't it? But at the same time, those who were colonising their world often were involved in
00:16:44.160 missionary activities too, so were trying to Christianise them. The way that those people
00:16:48.800 thought about the indigenous folks that they were exploiting as witches and use the idea of
00:16:54.340 witchcraft accusation against them. It's really complicated because the people, the indigenous
00:17:00.100 people who are living there are very often people who believe in witchcraft and accuse others of
00:17:04.840 witchcraft. Yet the colonizers still manage to find a way to make the witch trial count against
00:17:11.400 them. Whether it's saying, oh, you know, you superstitious people, you're accusing each other
00:17:15.460 witchcraft. This is bad. Therefore, we must civilize you and take your country from you and
00:17:19.640 colonize it. Or they're saying, oh, well, actually, you know, you are practicing witchcraft. This is
00:17:24.920 very bad. We must take your country away from you and colonize it. So witchcraft gets very much 1.00
00:17:30.660 mixed up in discourses of colonization, it seems to me. And I thought it was really important to
00:17:36.140 talk about that because, again, it's something that we see a lot in the world today. And it
00:17:40.840 helps to explain why witchcraft accusations are so common in parts of africa india indonesia and
00:17:47.180 so on i want to know what you think about so as someone who i have a witch podcast i'm really
00:17:53.360 interested in the word and in the identity you know gives me power and i'm interested in the
00:17:59.260 history and the sort of intersection between politics and art and grounding in a spirituality
00:18:03.300 after not really having any and just in the community it gives me but i fear that you know
00:18:09.340 the other pieces of that, that like entertaining, exploring ideas around the unknown makes us more
00:18:15.380 vulnerable to conspiracy theories or that building a community, embracing ideas of witchcraft
00:18:20.760 somehow makes it more dangerous for people who are being accused of witchcraft because we're
00:18:25.220 somehow giving validation to the idea that witches are real. And, you know, you've done all this
00:18:30.320 research right at the intersection of this question, the way that this word gets used against
00:18:34.640 people in this sort of flip-floppy, violent way. What do you think about that these days?
00:18:40.680 Yeah, that's really interesting. And it's a really insightful thing to say that, you know, by
00:18:45.840 ourselves believing in magic and witchcraft, are we in some way saying, oh, well, you know,
00:18:51.200 the witch trials of the past are fine. And the witch trials of people in contemporary Africa 0.60
00:18:55.400 is fine because, yes, they actually are witches. So there we go. It's really difficult to think 0.97
00:19:01.160 about, isn't it? And when you look back at the history of people arguing against witch trials,
00:19:06.860 some of the first people to do so were 18th century folks who looked at the history of
00:19:13.480 the past and said, well, that's just superstition, isn't it? You know, we're radical lawyers of the
00:19:17.920 18th century. We're French revolutionaries. We're going to stop believing in religion altogether,
00:19:23.020 not just witchcraft, but everything. The idea of a supernatural world, the idea of
00:19:27.880 supernatural beings, you know, just throw out the angels and the fairies and the spirits of the 0.90
00:19:33.540 past and God and the devil and demons and all of it. Just get rid of all of it, because that's the 1.00
00:19:38.860 only way the world is going to be safe for people and they won't be accused of witchcraft anymore.
00:19:44.120 And I think that's a really powerful thing to say. You know, it kind of appeals to me, that level of,
00:19:49.220 right, blank slate, let's just start here and let's only believe in things that we can verify
00:19:53.880 with our own eyes etc or let's reframe the world in ways that we think well it will exclude certain
00:20:00.860 things but we don't mind losing those things if it means we also lose witch trials I think that's
00:20:06.160 a really powerful thing for people to have thought but I think that what it does is is often it does
00:20:12.940 strip the world of that sense of of well magic I suppose you know the beyond the fantastical
00:20:21.260 and you see at the same time as people are trying to desacralize the world in that way in the 18th
00:20:27.760 century get the rise of stuff like gothic literature so you get all the ghosts and the
00:20:32.360 angels and the demons and the witches all kind of creeping back in through the back door and you
00:20:36.980 know they bring with them stuff like vampires and all the kind of figures that we actually really
00:20:43.340 like to think about i think there is something intrinsic in the human mind that wants all of
00:20:48.140 that stuff and you know who am i who am i or anyone to deny it to people if that's the way
00:20:54.620 you see the world then great that's fine it seems to me the key thing is you know this is part of
00:21:00.640 modern wiccans creed isn't it and and which is creed you know depending how people identify
00:21:06.660 themselves it's about not harming people so it in a sense it doesn't matter to me as a historian or
00:21:13.460 as a person what people believe in so long as they do it in a way which is tolerant and careful
00:21:19.980 and avoids causing harm I think there's a lot to be said for re-enchanting the world because quite
00:21:26.620 often it can bring back the idea of a connection between people that idea of community that you've
00:21:33.040 talked about getting together to create a world together when it can bring back a connection with
00:21:39.000 the natural world, which can also seem haunted and empowered and spiritual in its own way.
00:21:46.080 And I think those are really good things.
00:21:47.780 Yeah, I mean, throughout my career, I've kind of struggled with the same sort of ideas,
00:21:52.460 which means very different things to different people.
00:21:55.900 It can mean a hapless victim of lunatic aggressors, or it can mean empowered spiritual person, priestess or goddess.
00:22:07.520 It can mean all those kind of things.
00:22:10.160 So I've got more comfortable over the years, I suppose,
00:22:13.200 trying to see those things in tension with each other
00:22:17.120 and in balance with each other.
00:22:18.780 But I think witch trials happen when they get out of balance
00:22:21.180 and when people start weaponising them.
00:22:23.580 That's where the danger lies for me.
00:22:27.420 And do you always feel like, well, I guess there's an assumption
00:22:31.360 in my question, do you feel like first that there is this sort
00:22:34.660 of rise in interest in witchcraft and studying witchcraft
00:22:37.460 I think there is. And if you do, do you think that that is related? Like, I feel like sometimes the question of witches and witch hunting and whether there's magic, the unknown in science, that it's tangled right up in the complexity of this moment.
00:22:51.760 to think about witches isn't really this fringe story anymore because we're right in this in the
00:22:57.600 heart of this moment of like is is an enchanted world possible like is is is a is a liberated
00:23:04.080 world possible or are we just fucking doomed you know what I mean it feels like really urgent to
00:23:10.740 engage with it somehow yeah I think that's right I think your assumption is absolutely right people
00:23:15.740 are more interested in witches now witches are having a moment um and I think they have been
00:23:21.220 since at least the 1990s and probably before actually you know you could also look back to
00:23:26.220 the particularly the feminist movements of the 70s and 80s when people started being interested
00:23:31.940 in reclaiming the idea of witchcraft in modern times although the book also looks back to
00:23:36.260 Victorian people who were interested in that too so I do think it's been going off quite a long time
00:23:41.200 but I think since the 1990s it's really been hotting up if you like and people have become
00:23:46.680 more interested in what the which means and that is partly because of that idea of trying to
00:23:52.480 re-sacralize the world so that ultimately you don't blow it up or destroy it in other ways
00:23:57.720 I think you're right that does feel pretty urgent doesn't it but also people have become interested
00:24:04.040 in it maybe in just the past five or six years really as we've seen increasing misogyny in the
00:24:09.040 world and and we've started to think well I've started to think that some of these problems
00:24:13.400 just haven't gone away we haven't changed things as much as we maybe thought we had or thought that
00:24:18.020 we should have done and words like witch do retain a relevance therefore it must at one time surely
00:24:24.260 have seemed that witch was a word you would only use about the past but actually now here people
00:24:29.140 are being accused of witchcraft in the present and people are still finding the idea of the witch
00:24:32.920 powerful so yeah I think there's a really interesting and quite lengthy cultural moment
00:24:38.560 happening around the witch I don't know how it's going to turn out no and as you say you talked
00:24:43.500 about conspiracy theory earlier it's the intersections between ideas of magic and
00:24:48.560 witchcraft and ideas of conspiracy theory really interesting aren't they because conspiracy theory
00:24:53.700 often leads us at least in my view into places where we really don't want to go
00:24:58.780 where you know we end up in this kind of post-truth world and anything goes and people can
00:25:04.920 make up any kind of awful libel against other people and find ways to force it upon them and
00:25:12.720 that you know that's a bad thing so is it possible to be too magical is it possible to re-enchant the
00:25:18.800 world too much so that we've moved away from the 18th century lawyers and their insistence on
00:25:24.420 provability and we've moved towards it doesn't matter if you can prove it or not it could be
00:25:28.780 true anyway i don't know i don't know i feel i feel enmeshed in it the same as you do but i do
00:25:35.800 think the witch is a really powerful way of talking about that because the witch is right
00:25:40.080 at the center of that long history of humans trying to work out how the world works what
00:25:45.260 are places within it how we're supposed to relate to each other is that is there a world beyond is
00:25:51.140 there a supernatural world you know the witch helps us think about all of that and i think
00:25:55.380 that's really quite important to have that discussion totally and you make me think i mean
00:26:00.500 the invention of the witch by historians sort of wanders this line between like really great history
00:26:07.820 and you know as you i think really kind of lovingly point out like an invention that used
00:26:14.560 history in a way that was quite creative that sort of helped us get to a sexually liberated
00:26:20.180 gender, you know, defiance of norms, way of thinking about witchcraft, but that that history
00:26:26.120 was kind of fuzzy, like the Michelets or Doreen Valiente or Margaret Murray. Can you talk about
00:26:33.100 that way of doing history that's sort of problematic, but sort of gifted us some stuff?
00:26:37.760 Yeah, I totally can. That's something I've developed increased tolerance for. You know,
00:26:41.960 when I first started out doing history, I was just like, no, these people are wrong.
00:26:45.900 we're not discussing that that's just wrong it didn't happen like that history wasn't like that
00:26:51.000 you know the 16th century women were most likely not nature loving goddess worshiping pagans but
00:26:57.580 the idea that they might have been is super powerful isn't it and I gradually came to have
00:27:03.580 much more tolerance for that idea because I could see that the historians like people like
00:27:08.320 Jean Michelet who were putting it forward really had their hearts in the right place and I thought
00:27:13.600 that went rather a long way towards my feeling warmer to them so the first time I read Michelet's
00:27:19.840 book you know I was going through I think I may even have written in the margins I don't know I
00:27:25.000 had a cheap 70s paperback that I've still got I may even have written no every now and again
00:27:31.160 in the margin no you know I'm really sorry but no they were not empowered pagan priestesses I wish
00:27:37.140 they had have been but they weren't they were just medieval women who were struggling with a church
00:27:42.120 that wanted to silence them but then you know once you start thinking well yeah they were
00:27:46.360 struggling with a church that wanted to silence them what if somebody in the 19th century
00:27:50.660 wanted to reinvent them as pagan priestesses who am I to stop him so yeah I think the ways of
00:27:58.540 thinking about the history of witchcraft need to be more open actually and I think we've kind of 0.58
00:28:03.860 there's a phrase throwing the baby out with the bathwater I don't know if you have that
00:28:07.820 But we have that, that, you know, you've thrown away the precious thing in an attempt to rid
00:28:12.280 yourself of the, you know, less good thing. And I kind of feel that historians have sometimes got a
00:28:19.040 bit too interested in stuff like, you know, the economics of history or stuff about, you know,
00:28:25.660 social relationships and class and so on. And they perhaps noticed a little bit less,
00:28:30.960 look, these are women. Look, they might have unusual religious views. We sometimes don't 1.00
00:28:35.740 know, but sometimes it's quite clear that we did have some heretical views. Maybe they weren't
00:28:40.880 pagans, not in the modern sense, but what about all that folklore that they knew? What about the
00:28:46.360 stories that they told each other? It's worth listening to see if you can find those things,
00:28:51.500 isn't it? And so I think it's important to pay attention to the Michalés and the Valientes.
00:28:58.100 And even if you will end up thinking, I really don't think history was like that,
00:29:03.520 it's always very nice to play the game of what if it was and to see the difference they've made to
00:29:09.360 the modern world which is perhaps even more important than interpreting the past it's the
00:29:13.020 difference you make now so yeah i i do like those sorts of writers even though at the start of my
00:29:18.620 career i really didn't i i love that answer so much and i i was on mute but you made me laugh
00:29:23.860 so hard when you said you've increased your tolerance for them which is a good thing right
00:29:29.000 If you write about witches, surely you should become more tolerant over time.
00:29:35.280 I really love that.
00:29:36.360 And I do love thinking about, I'll interrupt myself to say we have members of our coven here who are witches, practitioners, academics, artists from all different kinds of perspectives and worldviews.
00:29:52.320 I will invite folks, if you do want to ask a question or just engage in this conversation, I'm going to make sure we have time for that.
00:30:01.960 But I wanted to ask, you know, when we're thinking about these stories, you know, like women of the 16th century, what did they really believe?
00:30:12.960 How can we really know?
00:30:13.920 Or even going further back, right?
00:30:15.560 talking about colonization from the perspective even of Roman colonization, you know, burning
00:30:21.700 sacred groves. What were these like longer memories that people maybe in the country were
00:30:27.860 holding on to? As a researcher, what do you suggest? What are some practices of, often I ask
00:30:36.020 people for like a ritual or something they're doing right now, but I'm going to ask you for
00:30:39.280 a research practice instead. What's a research practice you suggest for us when we go looking
00:30:44.500 for these stories especially stories that exceed the archives women's stories the stories of
00:30:50.120 colonized enslaved people there's a lot of places where we don't make it into the archives how can
00:30:57.220 we connect to those stories yeah that's a great question and you know it pushes me in a direction
00:31:03.540 that I've been going for some time which is seeing the practice of researching history as being an
00:31:10.980 emotional one actually you know having emotional engagement it does have elements of ritual
00:31:16.140 that the pleasing aspects of historical research the going through the catalogs the
00:31:21.560 the going to special places to do the research the immense privilege of being able to touch
00:31:26.760 the original record and find names in them that you recognize you know that's it's it's kind of
00:31:33.760 a church and therefore it's kind of a ritual so I yeah I hear you when you say hang on this is kind
00:31:42.120 of like the moment when you ask somebody about ritual the things that I do I suppose would be
00:31:47.940 try and go to the places where the people lived if you possibly can there's any way you can get
00:31:52.640 to any of them and walk around in them and and try to see what they see you try to feel what they
00:31:58.540 felt you know is it cold there is it hot there what if you shut your eyes what can you hear
00:32:02.980 what do you smell there what do you know from the records that they might have smelled there
00:32:07.420 in the past or seen there in the past you know if you shut your eyes can you imagine what that
00:32:11.620 might have looked like what does the landscape look like how do you feel there is it a flat
00:32:16.460 landscape where you feel exposed is it a hilly landscape you know what's going on in it is the
00:32:21.560 sea there is it is it a big open plain what is it so I found those kind of things really useful
00:32:27.660 And sort of walking around as far as you possibly can in the footsteps of the accused people or their accusers, I think, is really interesting.
00:32:37.700 It's certainly something I've done in a previous book called The Witches of St. Joseph that I wrote.
00:32:42.060 I went on this kind of 11-mile trudge.
00:32:45.560 I didn't dignify it by saying it was a hike or, you know, a trail.
00:32:50.440 It was a trudge around muddy lanes in Essex County in England.
00:32:57.660 And I tired myself and I allowed myself to feel kind of vulnerable.
00:33:04.080 You know, I was staying in a kind of glamping place and it was cold.
00:33:08.000 It was January just before the pandemic, which, of course, we didn't know was coming.
00:33:12.340 And so I tried to feel the way they might have felt, these women who were accused of
00:33:16.420 witchcraft subsequently.
00:33:17.980 And they'd gone around from house to house, farm to farm, begging for charity, you know,
00:33:22.200 often been turned away, often had crosswords for the householders and something terrible
00:33:27.140 happened to the householder and they thought aha you know it's that person who came to the door she
00:33:31.560 cursed me that's what it is but I thought it was important to do it was important to slip in the
00:33:36.080 mud and it was important to have sore feet and it was important to be hungrier than I really wanted
00:33:39.920 to be and tired than I really wanted to be and just think about what those people might have felt
00:33:45.260 like so I do all of those things and also I do feel that records lead you where they want you
00:33:51.400 to go and that's something that I think a lot of historians feel most of them don't talk about
00:33:56.440 because it sounds kind of magical doesn't it but they do you know you find things because it almost
00:34:02.760 feels like they are waiting there for you they are waiting to be found some stories want to be told
00:34:07.780 some stories maybe don't want to be told and those are the harder ones to get out of the archive
00:34:13.240 but I do feel that and I just feel I just feel I feel so happy when I find the story of one of
00:34:20.700 these people and I trace them and I care about them I think caring about history is really
00:34:25.540 important and I increasingly less trouble about saying it you know when you're in a kind of early
00:34:30.980 career academic you don't say all that stuff necessarily because you want people to think
00:34:35.700 of you as a kind of 18th century lawyer figure who is rational and focused and orderly and has
00:34:40.900 a strategy and all of those things but the older I get the more I think no you know what that isn't
00:34:45.800 how I do things I kind of putter towards things you know feeling about them so it's guided by
00:34:52.540 emotion it's guided by something that might be instinct or might be experience who is to say
00:34:57.600 it feels kind of magical so it does it there is there is an element of ritual I think in
00:35:02.900 historical research and if people want to follow that and go after a figure that they feel some
00:35:08.320 empathy with in history and try to research their story by going to the place that they lived or
00:35:14.160 doing the things that they did I think that's all brilliant I do think people outside of
00:35:19.360 academic institutions could do really good history in that way I feel emotional hearing you say that
00:35:24.660 many of the stories in your book made me very emotional because I I'm especially the first one
00:35:29.980 like Helena you know because it's such a it's such a wrench you know I'm so proud of her and of her
00:35:36.980 community but to know that that is the kernel story behind her her prosecutor behind so much
00:35:44.900 of what comes next it's really really bittersweet are are there moments in the book that were really
00:35:52.400 emotional to discover yes absolutely yeah I think Helena's story so the first trial you know set in
00:36:00.420 1485 in in Austria where this this woman Helena is accused of witchcraft but she fights back I think
00:36:09.140 that was a real turning point in writing the book and I wanted to start the book there because it's
00:36:12.940 a surprise isn't it we often think of witches as hapless people who were victimized you know were
00:36:18.780 forced into confession and that's absolutely true of many of them they were not able to do anything
00:36:24.220 to save themselves but this woman did and I really did find that quite inspiring yeah she she you
00:36:30.920 know she shouted at her persecutor she stood up in court she went and got herself a lawyer she was
00:36:35.700 lucky in various ways you know she had access to the the level of education the level of religious
00:36:41.820 education the the money that allowed her to do that she had some support from her community
00:36:46.880 but she did it she's great so I love that moment and you know and there are sadder ones too the
00:36:53.160 one that's really engaging me at the moment is chapter five which is about Bess Clark a disabled
00:36:59.760 single mother from Essex in the 1640s who gets caught up in the the big witch hunt in eastern
00:37:06.040 England led by this chap the witch finder general Matthew Hopkins and I'm still working on that
00:37:11.440 actually, I'm still looking at other stories from that group of people. Because in the end, 0.97
00:37:16.660 there are a couple of hundred people who are accused across those eastern counties.
00:37:20.720 And most of their stories haven't been told. People haven't looked in the archives for those
00:37:24.720 women because they don't tend to look in the archives for the stories of poor women because
00:37:30.240 they think they're not going to find anything. You know, so they don't look. But I would like 1.00
00:37:36.260 to find more of those stories because I feel so sorry for people like Bess who was one of the
00:37:42.500 people who couldn't do anything to save herself. She was in the wrong time at the wrong place and
00:37:48.260 she was unable to save herself and we should feel upset about it because if we don't feel upset
00:37:53.320 about things like that that happen in history then we feel less upset about things like that
00:37:57.720 that happen now and of course we should feel engaged with those things that happen now it
00:38:02.200 seems to me well yeah and especially in a in a current moment i mean here in in north america
00:38:08.920 where the the attack on women's rights with people's bodily autonomy is so virulent it's the 0.95
00:38:15.440 same it's the same shit it's quite heartbreaking and i think really important to tell these 0.97
00:38:21.800 histories i think so i i think if we look back at the history of persecution we can see a lot 0.99
00:38:29.380 of analogies with the way that contemporary politics deals with groups who are not able
00:38:33.840 to defend themselves. So I think that history can tell us a lot. We don't always learn from it,
00:38:39.220 which is a very sad thing. We do keep repeating this stuff where we scapegoat and persecute each
00:38:45.100 other. But at least we can tell the stories. At least good people can reflect upon them and
00:38:49.760 hopefully feel a sense that this has happened before and things have been done about it. And
00:38:55.900 people like Helena can fight back. And I think that's quite important.
00:38:59.460 Yeah, we can. We can fight back. I want to open up the floor. Reid, do you want to jump in and start?
00:39:06.200 Yes, thank you very much. I am a 30-year PhD student at the University of Georgia,
00:39:12.040 and I am studying the history of witch trials. But my dissertation topic, which is related to
00:39:18.620 this, is why women are leaving Christianity right now in America in mass to practice witchcraft. 0.98
00:39:25.900 And I am working on a project right now. I have discovered a woman in the Atlanta Journal-Constitution, a ghost story about a woman who was tried in an illegal trial for witchcraft. 0.96
00:39:37.960 She was kidnapped and taken to a plantation and was tried and let go. She was tortured.
00:39:45.040 But she was able to secure a warrant from, I find this ironic, a Presbyterian minister.
00:39:51.700 the ghost story says that she won in court but was never paid because her accuser fled for the
00:39:58.680 frontier which at the time was alabama that sounds really interesting that's so i found that's really
00:40:04.560 interesting why is i stumbled upon it in this ghost story but i've been to the archives in
00:40:12.040 south carolina and what i found out is that she was a widow and was given a bunch of land and the
00:40:19.100 two people who testified against her that we have record of were her son and her grandson.
00:40:24.340 And six months after this trial, there is a land record of her deeding 100 acres to her grandson.
00:40:30.840 So you can imagine what shape that ghost story has, can't you? Yeah. Oh, that's very interesting.
00:40:35.520 Oh, I would encourage you to write about it. Obviously, you know, if this is something that
00:40:39.520 you're studying already, please tell the world about it. That's great. And you know, I'm at the
00:40:43.960 University of Exeter right in in in southwest England you know if you look out for for 1.00
00:40:48.820 opportunities there by all means think about coming there you know we do a lot of witchcraft
00:40:54.840 and magic stuff at the university in terms of its history and its literature so there's yeah
00:41:00.500 there's lots of ongoing stuff to talk about I'm sure but that's fascinating and I think one of
00:41:05.880 the things you're talking about there is the way that stories live on so you know you may not always
00:41:12.280 know exactly what happened historically in the past but the fact that somebody has cared enough
00:41:16.400 to make a story about it is really important and I also you know I write about witchcraft in
00:41:22.180 literature everything from Macbeth to the Harry Potter books I've written about you know the ways
00:41:27.360 that witches are remembered in modern society so I think that's really interesting it's a really
00:41:32.280 good field of research and there's an awful lot to say about it and if you found a case that
00:41:36.300 nobody else is writing about wow tell everybody we'll make sure that you can find each other for
00:41:41.320 sure and reed's research is so exciting we always love to get to hear updates from them i also while
00:41:48.560 we have you for like two more minutes there's two other things in the chat i want to make sure
00:41:52.540 to draw your attention to one is a question from sarah they're asking and i think this is such a
00:41:58.640 fair question the numbers vary so widely in how many people were persecuted during the witch hunts
00:42:05.920 those numbers are kind of all over the map and so sarah's wondering how many people were accused
00:42:10.760 How many people were killed?
00:42:12.040 What do we really know about that these days?
00:42:14.040 We don't know is the kind of big answer because of lack of survival of records.
00:42:20.660 So in some places, you know, record survival is excellent and that's where you find the
00:42:24.340 best evidence.
00:42:25.380 But in some places, everything before, say, like where I live, all the criminal trial
00:42:29.600 records before 1670 are gone.
00:42:31.760 So we have no idea whether people were prosecuted as witches here or not.
00:42:36.300 I very, very strongly suspect that they were.
00:42:38.820 I'd be hugely surprised if they weren't, but we don't know who they are. We never will know who
00:42:42.700 they are. So that's a really important thing to say to start with. There's been lots of contentious
00:42:47.240 figures chucked about over the decades. And people have said, oh, it's millions. I don't
00:42:52.380 think it is millions of people who were accused and executed. What historians have come to a
00:42:58.100 consensus that we talk about is something like 60 to 70,000, something like that. So it's tens
00:43:04.720 of thousands, which is a terrible thing. You know, people being killed for something that they have
00:43:10.280 not done. And that many people being put on trial and killed for that is a terrible thing. It's not
00:43:16.180 the big figure, but it's still a huge figure. But we all recognise that there may be more that we
00:43:21.440 just don't know about and never will know about. And obviously, there's a lot of the world still
00:43:25.800 unexplored by historians who focused on the witch trials. You know, we focused on Europe, we focused
00:43:31.540 a little bit on north america a little bit on other places some in south america some in in
00:43:37.000 the eastern europe the kind of peripheries of the heartland of the witch trials if you like
00:43:41.800 but there's just so much more to find this is why i'm so pleased to hear that some of you are
00:43:46.680 conducting your own research because there's still so much to say so i yeah i don't have a
00:43:52.560 have a nice neat figure which i'm sure you didn't expect me to anyway but i would say tens of
00:43:58.040 thousands. That sort of figure is probably what we're looking at. It's interesting to think about
00:44:02.160 the times you describe a witch hunter as an anxious young man, one who easily imagined
00:44:07.940 himself a victim despite his many social advantages. Yeah, that sounds like Matthew 0.51
00:44:12.700 Hopkins, the witch finder general, doesn't it? Yeah, it was. And what a great description in 0.88
00:44:17.640 so many of these cases is people who feel victimized, who truly saw themselves as victimized
00:44:22.760 by something in in their social dynamic and often even though they had more social power than the
00:44:29.180 people around them they were still in a position of feeling destabilized and scared and often that
00:44:37.560 has to do with what's happening in these gaps between rich and poor I think like people are
00:44:41.660 just feeling scared and uprooted and not having the the access to resources they had previously but
00:44:47.360 yes I mean the world's a scary place people people are scared and sometimes it doesn't
00:44:52.760 matter who they are how much power it might look like to other people they have or they might
00:44:57.660 actually have we do tend to to go around really anxious about things don't we and one of the
00:45:03.640 things that we have to try and avoid doing is projecting that anxiety onto other people and
00:45:07.620 saying oh well it's all her fault there you go that explains it but you can understand and I
00:45:12.920 I do understand how people might have come to be accusers of witchcraft and how of witches and how they might still do that.
00:45:22.440 I've always had quite a bit of sympathy with the accusers because often their stories are just heart rending.
00:45:27.360 You know, you look back to 16th, 17th century England and you think people are wrestling with all sorts of civil war going on.
00:45:35.320 There's massive religious instability. There's plague. Some people are starving.
00:45:39.280 how can they not feel anxious all the time and then if within their family you know they tell
00:45:45.380 you this terrible story about how their child died or their farm went to rack and ruin you think oh
00:45:51.020 you know you poor soul naturally enough you would want to try to find an explanation for that and 0.80
00:45:57.340 the one that your society offered to you was aha it's witchcraft so of course you would go along
00:46:02.520 with that wouldn't you i think it's really important to have sympathy and an empathy for
00:46:07.600 the accusers too because they are also living in a very difficult situation yeah do you want to
00:46:13.820 extrapolate that and apply that to today maybe I mean it's very difficult isn't it to yeah yes I
00:46:21.320 mean I feel you know I feel enraged in in the same way that that lots of people do when false
00:46:26.980 accusations are made or somebody is victimized or I see people being killed for what I what I think
00:46:34.200 you know is a crime they couldn't possibly have committed yes you know i feel rage and panic and
00:46:39.240 and sadness just the same as anybody else but i think it's probably better from the point of view
00:46:45.820 of intervention to step back a bit to try to feel a bit more concerned for why they're saying what
00:46:53.120 they're saying um they may be saying it because they're evil people but it might be better and
00:46:59.200 healthier for everybody to look at what are the social forces that cause them to think this what
00:47:03.640 are the cultural forces that have pushed them to believe this particular thing. I do feel like we
00:47:09.640 have more in common than divides us, really. It's hard to hold that line sometimes, but
00:47:15.420 it feels like it might be the better one historically. And as a historian, I'm always
00:47:19.740 trying to look at the long view. So I can see the same kind of impulses across history. But the one
00:47:25.360 that I always try and come back to is, well, you know, we're all just people. We're all sharing
00:47:30.400 our history together maybe there's more that we can do to come together and stop doing this stuff
00:47:35.140 to each other thank you so much for that grounding in the long view it's a pleasure
00:47:39.600 it's a pleasure I do feel that we can learn from history although as I say I sometimes fear that
00:47:47.200 we really don't well here's to the long view here's to listening in the archives walking in
00:47:54.620 the feet of people, the tired, trotting feet, trudging through mud of the people who have been
00:48:00.380 violated and accused to really feel each other's stories. Thank you so much to our coven for being
00:48:07.180 here, all of the wise folks who are here. Thank you to Reed and to Sarah and to Jane who messaged
00:48:17.000 me that it was so profound reading your work in school and she wrote a book and she wants to send
00:48:23.080 it to you, which I'll send to your publisher, if that's all right, called Witch Fulfillment.
00:48:27.140 It sounds awesome.
00:48:28.040 Quite all right.
00:48:28.840 Yes.
00:48:29.460 I'm so pleased that you're so excited by it.
00:48:31.960 I certainly find it a really, really exciting topic and it just continues to inspire me.
00:48:37.260 So I'm so pleased.
00:48:39.140 Yeah.
00:48:39.400 Thank you so much for being here.
00:48:41.540 I, you know, I love talking to people about witches.
00:48:44.360 It's just such a pleasure.
00:48:46.920 I hope we have successfully communicated how impacted we all have been by your work in
00:48:51.660 our various academic settings and your thinking and the enormous labor of research to give us
00:48:55.740 back those people's stories so yes you certainly have yeah yes and i do feel inspired when when
00:49:00.700 readers respond that way because i just think well great these are great stories let's you know let's
00:49:05.800 tell them and tell more tell more right read at the end of these things marion we often say 0.98
00:49:14.620 Blessing fucking B. 0.97
00:49:44.620 books or audio books. Find out more at missingwitches.com. 0.99