00:00:53.240and I've spent my life exploring how other people survive what should have destroyed them.
00:00:58.760I'm Elizabeth Smart, and these are The Survivor Files.
00:01:02.380Every week, I'm with survivors who live through the unthinkable, abducted, stalked, controlled, and nearly silenced.
00:01:09.920These are stories about what it takes to make it out alive.
00:01:13.740Listen to The Survivor Files with Elizabeth Smart on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:01:21.360If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
00:01:27.100Pro Society is a weekly podcast that's part book club, part group chat for anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:01:35.740Each week, we're connecting the dots between books, the internet, and pop culture with your favorite writers, book talk creators, and plenty of overthought opinions.
00:08:27.500Grok doesn't do anything that humans do not tell Grok to do or program Grok to do.
00:08:34.420Humans like Elon Musk built Grok and run it as a commercial service, making it available for other humans to use and do things with.
00:08:41.600And right now, those other humans are using Grok to undress women and girls to create sexualized images of children, i.e. what we call crimes, criminal behavior.
00:09:27.700pay credit visit bell.ca for details and to check availability bell connection is everything run a
00:09:33.760business and not thinking about podcasting think again more americans listen to podcasts than ad
00:09:39.260supported streaming music from spotify and pandora and as the number one podcaster iheart's twice as
00:09:44.660large as the next two combined so whatever your customers listen to they'll hear your message
00:09:49.080plus only iheart can extend your message to audiences across broadcast radio think podcasting
00:09:54.400can help your business? Think iHeart. Streaming, radio, and podcasting. Let us show you at
00:09:59.720iHeartAdvertising.com. That's iHeartAdvertising.com. If your bookshelf and your For You page are
00:10:05.940equally important to your personality, welcome home. This is Prose Society, the weekly podcast
00:10:12.800that's part book club, part group chat for thought daughters, pop culture obsessives,
00:10:17.280and anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:10:22.200I'm Eli Rallo, and every week we're connecting the dots between books, the internet, and the conversations everyone can't stop having.
00:10:29.300I'm going to have to look up this story. I'm obsessed. I'm obsessed.
00:10:32.900From best-selling authors and your favorite book talk creators to the latest pop culture moments, nothing is off the table.
00:10:38.840It's like if you can hide some real messages inside compelling characters, then that is a Trojan horse.
00:10:46.300Whether you're looking for literary deep dives, smart pop culture conversations, or a community of readers who love to think a little too much, you're in the right place.
00:10:55.900Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:12:16.540So this has really hit a fever pitch right now this week, but it's not really new, especially on X.
00:12:22.860So I want to back up a little bit and talk about sort of how we got to this moment.
00:12:26.620We've done a few episodes about AI-generated sexualized images that took off on X.
00:12:32.060It happened to teen Marvel star Sochal Gomez.
00:12:35.620Gomez was targeted with deep fake images that also flooded X.
00:12:38.980When this happened, she was only 17, so she was a minor.
00:12:41.780And she's spoken about this publicly. She was essentially told there was nothing that could be done, that she just needed to make peace with it, make whatever emotional peace with it that she could because nothing could be done about it.
00:12:53.820Also, folks might remember that in January 2024, AI generated images of Taylor Swift that originated on the platform Telegram, where Telegram had been running a channel that was kind of like a marketplace for celebrity deepfakes, where users would request and trade deepfake images of celebrities.
00:13:12.740Images of Taylor Swift were created on that Telegram marketplace.
00:13:16.540And then those images made their way to X, where they really took off.
00:13:20.540telegram is sort of like a smaller niche alternative space and so you know it was they
00:13:26.040were being traded there but when they hit x which is arguably a more mainstream online space
00:13:31.480that's when they really took off back when this happened in my opinion x did not really handle
00:13:37.960this well which i think we can understand as a precursor for what's happening today
00:13:41.840they initially tried to manage it by just blocking people from being able to search
00:13:46.920Taylor Swift's name. However, when you put quote marks around Taylor Swift's name, it's you were
00:13:52.800able to search her just fine. So that didn't even really work. And notably, that solution doesn't
00:13:59.140offer any kind of protection to a woman who's not named Taylor Swift, right? Like that is a that that
00:14:04.580it didn't work. But even let's say that it did work for the sake of argument. The only person
00:14:09.400that that would conceivably even work for is Taylor Swift. So certainly not any kind of a
00:14:14.260meaningful solution to this like deep problem. But the Taylor Swift situation was notable because
00:14:20.400back then these images would typically originate elsewhere like a more niche alternative platform
00:14:25.960and then make their way to X where they would enjoy more reach and visibility. Grok essentially
00:14:32.300allowed anybody to use natural language to do whatever they wanted to images of women and girls
00:14:38.080on X. So you've got the introduction of Grok, plus, as friend of the podcast Kat Tenmarge points out
00:14:45.300in her deeply researched, deeply reported media outlet Spitfire News, which everybody should be
00:14:50.640reading, Musk also dissolved Twitter's trust and safety counsel when he took over at Twitter,
00:14:56.420right? He fired 80 percent of the engineers who work on issues regarding child exploitation. So
00:15:02.040again, that is a kind of very specific choice that has led us to the moment that we're in now.
00:15:07.640And yet none of this stopped X from rolling out what it called spicy mode on Grok's mobile video generator, which basically includes a feature to produce sexual content.
00:15:19.700So, you know, think about that for a minute, because you've got a platform where the majority of people who work on sexual exploitation issues have been fired.
00:15:27.860You've got an issue already with users generating and spreading non-consensual AI generated images on your platform.
00:15:35.620You're not really doing a good job of dealing with it.
00:15:38.700And against that backdrop, you say, you know what we're going to do?
00:15:43.040We're going to double down on adult content generation where folks can make adult content right on our platform.
00:15:50.280I guess I just have to say, like, it's not it's not none of this is surprising.
00:15:54.040This is like very predictable. And it's not like any of this came out of nowhere or just happened in a vacuum.
00:15:59.920Right. These are very deliberate and I would argue decisions with very foreseeable results from Elon Musk.
00:16:08.040And that is what's led us to this moment where we're at right now.
00:16:11.260Yeah. All of those decisions add up to a very consistent picture of not prioritizing doing anything about this kind of content and in fact liking it and thinking it's cool.
00:16:22.540I mean, I'm glad that you put it that way because we can't talk about what's happening without talking about what we know about Elon Musk, who is someone who, in my opinion, has made it clear that this is the kind of thing that he likes. He likes sexualized content.
00:16:39.340There was a whole flurry of reporting about the way that he was publicly engaging with anime adult content on the platform, right? So, you know, there's nothing wrong with enjoying adult content, don't we all? But I think it needs to be said that Elon Musk is somebody who is totally fine with publicly engaging with content like this on the platform that he runs, and he is the key decision maker on that platform.
00:17:06.540So like that's unusual. And I want to highlight that because I just don't think that we need to pretend like this is not who Elon Musk is and this is not what Elon Musk is about.
00:17:15.820Elon Musk has long been a toxic decision maker. And I think had a lot of people in power, people in media, other folks in tech, had they not kind of framed this and treated this as, oh, a brilliant genius with a few acceptable quirks and rather talked about it like they probably should have, which is chaotic, volatile leadership decisions that are bad for business.
00:17:40.280Had they seen Elon Musk's public behavior that way, we genuinely might not be in the situation that we're in now where, you know, sexualized images of children are flooding a mainstream social media platform, which I think, you know, this is not the Twilight Zone, but I think most people would agree is not great.
00:17:58.660Yeah, you know, you mentioned earlier that, you know, lots of people, many people enjoy adult content in other contexts. The thing that's so unacceptable about the situation is that Elon wants to have it both ways with X, that it's like the public town square where ideas are debated, or at least that's what he says, and also a place for adult content.
00:18:25.040Like, you can't have both. Like, even pornography enthusiasts, I think for the most part, agree that, like, it shouldn't be out in the public square where children are. Like, there should be some separation there.
00:18:38.700Yes. And there's nothing wrong with consensual adult content, but you can't have a platform where just by engaging there, you might be setting yourself up to be sexualized against your consent in this way. Right. So like a town square doesn't work. If when I post there, somebody could say, put her in a bikini and that's totally normalized and fine. I'm not going to feel comfortable or safe showing up to that town square.
00:19:06.800So you've got a town square where people cannot equally speak up, equally show up. And so, again, I always say this. This is not just a tech issue or a gender issue or a sex crimes issue. It's all of those things. But it's also a speech issue and a democracy issue.
00:19:22.000If we were to take Elon Musk, liar that he is, let's just take him at his word and say he wants to build a town square where people can safely show up, all people can safely show up and engage in a marketplace of ideas.
00:19:33.840If when I walk into that marketplace of ideas, people can strip me naked without my consent, I am not able to safely and equally and equitably show up.
00:19:41.380And so it really, as we increasingly use platforms like this to engage in things like civic engagement, discourse around politics and social issues and democracy, if we cannot all equally show up, we've got a big problem.
00:19:54.200Totally. And if they continue entertaining the idea that it's supposed to be like a town square where people can talk about things, if people are supposed to be exchanging ideas, sort of a foundational principle I think that everyone agrees is important for that to be effective is some sense of mutual respect with people exchanging the ideas and listening to each other even if they don't disagree.
00:20:20.080and that's just like not even there's no shred of that on x it's just like a place where
00:20:25.480absolute disrespect is normalized and like who who would want to go there i continue to be baffled
00:20:31.820that like so many people continue to be there yeah i i'm with you i sort of get it because
00:20:40.440you know twitter was the platform that i had built up the majority of my sort of whatever
00:20:45.700you want to call it impact voice before i had a podcast and i i get you know being like i don't
00:20:51.580want to i don't want to lose that i don't want to lose the communities that i've built here the
00:20:54.700voices i've built here whatever i totally get that however i can only speak for myself personally
00:20:59.320the community that i built on twitter before elon musk took over and again not that pre-musk twitter
00:21:06.340was all peaches and cream i had issues with that too but that was largely like black voices black
00:21:11.380folks if you if you are somebody who was at all like minoritized if you are a woman a person of0.98
00:21:17.060color a queer lgbtq it is uniquely awful to show up on twitter and so i had to one day say the0.85
00:21:24.180people that i care about the voices that i care about they're not really showing up on twitter
00:21:27.440either so what am i clinging to right so i i on the one hand i get it like people who and also i
00:21:32.580think independent journalists like the the thing that twitter had over other social media platforms
00:21:39.320before musk took over was that that's where a lot of journalists and decision makers and editors
00:21:44.280hung out there was a time we did a podcast about it episode about it we'll put it in the show notes
00:21:48.100there was a time where just by having one just by getting like retweeted by lena dunham or something
00:21:54.000you could get a book deal right and so i understand that it was this place where
00:21:58.780power was built political power was built there you know you you had like black lives matter and
00:22:05.620And me, too, really taking off on the platform. I get all of that. But I think for me, I've had to kind of make peace with the fact that that's that's gone and probably not coming back.
00:22:16.480And so why would I want to subject myself to exactly the kind of disrespect that you just described to sort of enjoy like a facade of what once was right at a certain point?
00:22:27.460You have to just let it go. And I get that people, their temperatures may vary on this, but I personally have let it go.
00:22:34.740Yeah, I hear you. Okay, so getting back to this issue at hand, what do we know about the content on X and particularly this problem of non-consensual sexualized images?
00:22:50.600So the scope of the issue with AI-generated non-consensual sexualized images on X has
00:22:56.620gotten way worse. Friend of the podcast Kat Tenbarge reported this past summer about how
00:23:01.660users had been using Grok to use AI to make it look like women had semen on their faces.
00:23:07.540Just really awful stuff. Quick side note, we will put it in the show notes. Y'all should really
00:23:12.880read Kat's piece at her outlet Spitfire News called How Grok's Sexual Abuse Hit a Tipping
00:23:18.280point. One of the things that she puts really well is just describing what it is like to have to
00:23:24.160search for and confirm the absolute worst content on social media platforms. She describes it as
00:23:30.860being half journalist, half the internet's garbage collector, which I really, really identify with.
00:23:37.140So really shout out to people who have been working to help us understand the scope of this
00:23:42.700issue. And that work has gotten a lot worse because of all the things we've talked about on
00:23:45.780the show, you know, less transparency from platforms, less back end information. But people
00:23:51.160are still doing this work and it's not pleasant work. So shout out to the people and the researchers
00:23:57.420and the journalists who have gotten us this information. But when it comes to what we know
00:24:02.400about this content on the platform right now, CopyLeaks, which is a content analysis firm,
00:24:07.880reported that on December 31st, ex-users were generating roughly one non-consensual sexualized
00:24:14.400image per minute. That is wild to me. According to Bloomberg, during a 24-hour analysis of the
00:24:22.600images Grok's account posted to X, the chatbot generated 6,700 every hour that were identified
00:24:29.260as being sexually suggestive or nudifying. This is according to Genevieve Oh, a social media and
00:24:34.860deepfake researcher. The other top five websites for such content averaged 79 new undressing images
00:24:41.700per hour in the 24-hour period from January 5th to January 6th, O found. So we don't have to
00:24:48.320pretend that X is the only game in town when it comes to this kind of content. But as you can see
00:24:53.300from that information that Genevieve O pointed out, the problem is much bigger on X as compared
00:24:59.140to other platforms. And I know that we've been talking a lot about celebrities in this conversation,
00:25:05.120but just to be super clear, it is not just celebrities. It is also regular people and
00:25:10.680children who are not public figures who have just posted their images to x that this is happening
00:25:15.880to that's right and as we were doing research for this episode uh the guardian spoke to phd
00:25:21.500researcher at dublin's trinity college ai accountability lab nana and wachuku uh whose
00:25:27.380research investigated the types of requests that users were submitting to grok so we looked into
00:25:32.060that research a little bit uh really interesting important stuff i'm so glad that there are people
00:25:37.140like her out in the world producing this research
00:27:59.500Like it is you get what I'm saying, right? That like the fact that people are like comfortable having public conversation about what they're doing to these women and girls non-consensually, I think is is unique and telling.
00:28:12.040Oh, 100%. I mean, I think that's a big part of the appeal for them and for Elon as well, right? It's like the rudest, most juvenile assholes have forced their way to the grownups table and are reveling in their like fart jokes and like gross sexual jokes that like aren't even funny are just like rude and crass.
00:28:42.040And the fact that they are like normalizing this and like asserting that it is now acceptable, I think is a big part of the appeal for for Elon and team.0.98
00:28:56.160Yes, that's exactly what I was getting at. Let's not forget that Elon Musk is the same person who said that he wanted to start a university called the Texas Institute of Technology and Science, a.k.a. tits.
00:29:10.420it's just the worst it's not even a good joke it's not even it's it's like when you were a kid0.98
00:29:16.960and you would put boobs into the calculator and turn it upside down and then show it to the person
00:29:21.100next to you and i feel like i don't know if you were anything like me i feel like when people
00:29:25.320would do that even in like seventh grade the person that you were showing that to would be
00:29:29.440like really yeah it was like it never got a laugh it was kind of funny in like third grade that you
00:29:36.480could make your calculator say boobs but like by seventh grade come on uh yes yeah so but that's
00:29:45.120like i think that's a lot of the people who are really using x and not just like random accounts
00:29:49.500several posts in the trove that uh that noachaku showed to the guardian uh had received tens of
00:29:58.480thousands of impressions that came from premium blue check accounts so you know premium accounts
00:30:04.780that people pay for on X with more than 500 followers
00:30:07.280and 5 million impressions over three months
00:33:10.540more about this in a moment, but the fact
00:33:12.580that these platforms aren't doing anything to meaningfully address this i hate that in the
00:33:17.880absence of them actually doing anything what people keep saying is like don't post your pictures don't
00:33:23.100post your pictures and that just it doesn't work yeah it's a real conundrum because i totally get
00:33:29.820what you're saying you don't want to it kind of feels like giving in being like oh well i guess
00:33:34.640we just like won't post anything uh but then at the same time it's not safe to post there
00:33:40.280I do think it's worth pointing out that like, you know, sometimes it's convenient for us to talk about like social media platforms because there's a lot of stuff that they all get wrong in common.
00:33:52.940This does seem to be like a particular problem of X or certainly it's not exclusive to X, but like the scale and magnitude and demonstrated lack of concern put X in a category by itself.
00:34:07.780That is absolutely correct. And really, it's nothing new for X. It's just the culmination of all the bad decision making that from Musk that I described earlier. But X has just long been a platform where illegal child sexual assault material content flourishes.
00:34:23.040There is a fantastic piece by one of my favorite journalists, Samantha Cole at 404 Media, called Grok's AI Sexual Abuse Didn't Come Out of Nowhere, where Cole writes,
00:34:31.800This is the culmination of years and years of rampant abuse on the platform. Reporting from the National Center for Missing and Exploited Children, the official organization social media platforms report to when they find instances of child abuse material, which then reports to relevant authorities, shows that Twitter, and eventually X, has become one of the leading hosts of CSAM every year for the last year.
00:34:53.040last seven years. In 2019, the platform reported 45,726 instances of abuse to the cyber tip line.
00:35:00.420In 2020, it was 65,062. In 2024, it was 686,176. These numbers should be considered with the
00:35:10.880caveat that these platforms voluntarily report to the cyber tip line. And more reports also mean
00:35:16.400stronger moderation systems can catch more child sexual abuse material when it appears.
00:35:20.920But the scale of the problem is still apparent. Jack Dorsey's Twitter was a moderation clown show much of the time. But moderation on Elon Musk's X, especially against abusive imagery, is a total failure.
00:35:34.060So I think that speaks to exactly what you were just describing. I don't want to make it seem like X is the only problematic platform here because it's definitely not. And we've talked quite a bit about Facebook and all the ways that they have knowingly abused women and children.
00:35:48.860However, the size and the scale and the scope of the problem is much worse on X.
00:35:55.620And I would argue that the way that it's publicly handled by leadership is much worse on X.
00:36:00.900Like, y'all know one of my biggest, like, life enemies is Adam Mosseri, who runs Instagram.
00:36:31.080It was like when this story started breaking and people started complaining about it, he posted a toaster in a bikini, just like totally making fun of the situation.
00:36:41.760Yeah, I think that's totally part of the conversation.
00:36:43.860So you have Elon Musk joking about it.
00:36:46.320Per indicator, Musk has shared at least 30 posts celebrating Grok and talking about how great Grok is while this has been going on between January 7th and January 8th.
00:36:56.440He has not appeared to express remorse himself for what's been going down, right?
00:37:01.200So, like, he's been joking about it and then talking about how great Grok is and how happy he is with Grok while this is happening against this backdrop.
00:37:10.100And so, I'm sorry, even the ghouls who run Facebook would have the sense to be like, let's not post jokes about it, right?
00:37:18.600Let's not talk about how great of a job we're doing.
00:37:20.940They do a little bit of that, but not the way that Elon Musk is doing.
00:37:23.700even even those ghouls would have the the insight not to do this yeah it's you really can't conclude
00:37:32.140anything other than like he likes it and he thinks it's cool and he sees this as grok doing what it's
00:37:40.000supposed to do so one question that i've seen presented a lot is is this like how is this
00:37:45.340allowed which is the question that i started this this whole conversation with when i was thinking
00:37:49.560you about it. Like, how is this allowed? Yes. And I think that like really fits into the broader
00:37:54.000category of like, what the hell? How is this allowed? How is this going on? And it's just
00:37:58.480like an acceptable thing. Like, what the hell? So so please, Bridget, how in the world is this0.82
00:38:03.260allowed? I wish I had the answers. I'll tell you what I know. So this kind of content pretty
00:38:09.420blatantly violates XOX's own policies, which prohibit sharing illegal content such as child
00:38:15.560sexual abuse material. But as Wired points out, it could also violate Apple's App Store and
00:38:21.980Google's App Store guidelines. Wired writes, Apple and Google both explicitly ban apps containing
00:38:27.620child sexual abuse material, which is illegal to host and distribute in many countries. The tech
00:38:32.380giants also forbid apps that contain pornographic material or facilitate harassment. The Apple App
00:38:37.760Store says it does not allow overtly sexual or pornographic material, as well as defamatory,
00:38:42.600discriminatory, or mean-spirited content, especially if the app is likely to humiliate,
00:38:47.780intimidate, or harm a targeted individual or group. The Google Play Store bans apps that
00:38:52.400container promote content associated with sexually predatory behavior or distribute
00:38:57.280non-consensual sexual content, as well as programs that contain and facilitate threats,
00:39:02.760harassment, or bullying. So when I read that, I say, oh, well, Grok, especially the standalone app,
00:39:09.800is clearly, as the research that you just laid out
00:44:17.280okay so the big question that i had going into this was i understand it's against x's own policies
00:44:30.020it seems to be against google and apple's policies as well isn't this against the law like genuinely
00:44:36.220isn't this like a legal behavior i mean my understanding was that yeah child sexual
00:44:41.900abuse material is illegal you're it's illegal to make it it's illegal to distribute it it's illegal
00:44:47.240to have it to possess it so like what the hell so big warning caveat neither of us are lawyers
00:44:55.540however the framing that makes sense to me is that this is as you said criminal behavior in my
00:45:03.060opinion this is a criminal enterprise and elon musk is benefiting from that criminal enterprise
00:45:10.140So the same way that if any other kind of illegal enterprise, even if I were not making drugs, but I was I bought my house with illegal drug money, I would be complicit in an illegal enterprise per the government.
00:45:24.400Right. And so we are reaching out to an attorney who has been on the show before, who specializes in cybercrime.
00:45:30.320Stand out to Carrie Goldberg. We love her, friend of the show. But again, I'm no lawyer, but this seems like a criminal enterprise to me. And I don't understand why Elon Musk is not facing consequences for this.
00:45:43.560enough abuse which is an anti-child sexual abuse organization has documented that 45 states in the
00:45:50.440united states have enacted laws that criminalized ai generated or computer edited child sexual abuse
00:45:56.220material while five states and notably my own state or my own jurisdiction where i live my own
00:46:02.660jurisdiction dc have not as of august 2025 and so if you are listening to this in most states in the
00:46:12.360country if you were doing what these people are using x to do you would be you would have legal
00:46:19.360trouble and if you were financially benefiting from that you would have legal trouble so i do
00:46:24.420not understand like genuinely i do not understand how this is not something where elon musk would
00:46:30.000face legal consequences because he has been financially benefiting from the trade and
00:46:37.160creation of child sexual abuse material i genuinely like i have no idea i don't either
00:46:42.780i have seen a lot of people talking about this and a lot of analogies being used and i think
00:46:48.540analogies can often be helpful but they can also be kind of dangerous in like making things seem
00:46:54.540more similar than they are one analogy in particular that i've seen is people comparing it
00:46:58.600to guns and being like oh well if a gun shoots somebody is it the manufacturer's responsibility
00:47:05.580something aside the ethical responsibilities there we have the second amendment in this
00:47:10.200country that puts guns in their own category so i find that analogy to be like really unhelpful
00:47:18.460in trying to make sense of like how this is legal yeah as far as i know there's no right to bear
00:47:28.020child sexual assault material in this country so as far as i know no i think uh you know
00:47:34.620Madison wanted to put it in, but Jefferson was like, nah.
00:47:40.160Another question I've seen is what about the Take It Down Act?
00:47:44.200So folks might remember that Donald Trump signed the Take It Down Act into law,
00:47:48.860which makes it illegal to knowingly host or share non-consensual sexualized images.
00:47:52.880And even though there has been some, you know, mounting legal conversation,
00:47:58.960the thing there is that companies do not have to respond until a victim reports it.
00:48:04.120Right. And so if nobody reports it, the company doesn't have to do anything. And so that if you're if you're wondering, like, wasn't that signed into law? Why is that law not being triggered? That's why. Because companies don't have to do anything until somebody speaks out and reports it.
00:48:18.100Uh, that's useful. Thank you. Um, so what has the response from X been? I mean, we talked about
00:48:28.100Elon sort of joking about it. Has there been any other sort of response from whoever is running the
00:48:35.140show at X? Well, I like, that was like a deep seated sigh. I am loathe to say this. So again,
00:48:46.400you might have seen headlines about how grok is apologizing for and taking responsibility for this
00:48:55.180this was the statement that grok generated quote i deeply regret an incident on december 28th 2025
00:49:01.540where i generated and shared an ai image of two young girls estimated ages 12 and 16
00:49:06.420in sexualized attire based on a user's prompt it was a failure in safeguards and i'm sorry for any
00:49:12.180harm caused. Well, again, Grok is not sentient. And setting it up like a non-sentient piece of
00:49:18.240technology could take the blame for something. One, it makes me feel like I'm smoking crack.
00:49:24.920Two, it just lets the humans responsible off the hook because the humans, as we said,
00:49:30.380are doing nothing. Elon Musk is laughing about it and celebrating how great Grok is and how great
00:49:36.820grok's features are while this is going on and elon musk notably has not shared any kind of
00:49:44.040remorse himself about what's happening as far as i know as of recording and so i just really
00:49:50.040reject anything that that would even suggest that like grok can't take responsibility because grok's
00:49:56.960not human grok's not sentient elon musk is the person that runs twitter we have elon musk has
00:50:02.060expressed no remorse yeah i love the efforts to like keep the responsibility on the humans and not
00:50:10.820pretend that this piece of software that was built by humans run by humans is constantly
00:50:17.700being tweets by humans uh somehow it should be the the target of blame here right like the
00:50:26.140Accountability goes to the humans who are running it and making money off of it.
00:50:32.040Yes, exactly. And mind you, we talked about this on the show a while back.
00:50:38.240Elon Musk is the same man who in 2024, when Google's Gemini chatbot was making kind of biased outputs.0.58
00:50:46.640Remember, if you asked it to generate, I think, Alexander Hamilton, it would make it black.
00:50:51.460And remember that whole conversation?0.84
00:52:35.980And I do want to point out that response that she got from X, Legacy Media Lies, because I've seen this a lot lately, and it drives me up the damn wall that, like, she reached out with a specific concern about a specific issue.
00:52:49.740looking for a comment and she just gets back like vague boilerplate that kind of sort of invokes
00:52:57.180conspiracy uh that does not address it at all and i feel like we're seeing more of that and i
00:53:06.380really hate it so much and i also hate how they in a lot of cases media outlets will let them
00:53:15.620get away with it also not for nothing kat tenbarge is not legacy media kat tenbarge runs her own
00:53:22.580independent news outlet called spitfire news so not only is it a wild response to send it don't
00:53:28.900even apply it don't even make sense no it don't be like if i reached out for a comment and they're
00:53:32.540like nbc sucks it's like well i don't work for nbc so that's a non sequitur yeah it has nothing
00:53:38.400to do with anything other than like conspiracy smokescreen the truth is unknowable and also0.96
00:53:45.860probably somewhere in the middle yes okay so we've been talking about this for a while here
00:53:52.180we're pretty worked up what's gonna happen next here we we gotta we gotta get this under control
00:53:59.980what's gonna happen at this point not clear uh if i'm being honest i don't think the united states
00:54:06.720is going to do much of anything at all.
00:54:08.160We have not really heard a lot of anything
00:54:10.740from anybody with political power to do anything.
00:58:40.200But these kinds of AI services are pricey. They're expensive. And so one of my questions is, I wonder if, like, maybe X had been mulling a decision like this over for a while as a way to cut costs associated with Grok.
00:58:55.440This is just my theory. I don't have any, you know, this is just speculation. But I wonder if they had already been thinking about this and they were like, oh, we can just say that we're doing it as a fix to this AI sexualized images problem.
00:59:07.160But really, we were thinking about doing this as a cost-cutting solution all along.
01:04:47.420And I completely agree with Samantha Cole that I think all of this is really coming from the same place.0.94
01:04:53.240A desire to live in a world where women exist primarily to be consumed, controlled, and stripped of whatever agency we have managed to claim over our own bodies and lives.0.99
01:05:04.580And I think until we confront that reality, Samantha Cole is exactly right, that I don't think any amount of technical safeguards alone, even though we should be advocating for them, is going to fix that problem.0.98
01:05:19.520Got a story about an interesting thing in tech or just want to say hi?
01:05:22.640you can reach us at hello at tangody.com you can also find transcripts for today's episode at
01:05:27.420tangody.com there are no girls on the internet was created by me Bridget Todd it's a production
01:05:32.100of iHeartRadio and Unbossed Creative Jonathan Strickland is our executive producer Tari Harrison
01:05:36.840is our producer and sound engineer Michael Amato is our contributing producer I'm your host Bridget
01:05:41.780Todd if you want to help us grow rate and review us on Apple Podcasts for more podcasts from iHeartRadio
01:05:48.080check out the iHeartRadio app Apple Podcasts or wherever you get your podcasts