There Are No Girls on the Internet - November 30, 2022


Part Two: The Online & Real Life Harassment of Marginalized Elected Officials

How extremists are taking over small town governments: Bedrock USA Elon Musk’s “Twitter Files” is a whole lot of nothing.

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 7 minutes

Words per minute

176.41

Word count

11,913

Sentence count

786

Harmful content

Misogyny

59

sentences flagged

Toxicity

130

sentences flagged

Hate speech

56

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 This is an iHeart Podcast.
00:00:02.580 Guaranteed human.
00:00:04.520 Run a business and not thinking about podcasting?
00:00:06.820 Think again.
00:00:07.440 More Americans listen to podcasts than ad-supported streaming music from Spotify and Pandora.
00:00:11.620 And as the number one podcaster, iHeart's twice as large as the next two combined.
00:00:15.720 Learn how podcasting can help your business.
00:00:17.540 Call 844-844-iHeart.
00:00:19.920 I survived nine months in captivity,
00:00:23.080 and I've spent my life exploring how other people survive what should have destroyed them.
00:00:28.600 I'm Elizabeth Smart, and these are The Survivor Files.
00:00:32.200 Every week, I'm with survivors who live through the unthinkable, abducted, stalked, controlled, and nearly silenced.
00:00:39.740 These are stories about what it takes to make it out alive.
00:00:43.580 Listen to The Survivor Files with Elizabeth Smart on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:00:51.200 If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
00:00:56.920 Pro Society is a weekly podcast that's part book club, part group chat for anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:01:05.580 Each week, we're connecting the dots between books, the internet, and pop culture with your favorite writers, book talk creators, and plenty of overthought opinions.
00:01:13.820 Yeah, I'm obsessed. I'm obsessed.
00:01:15.600 Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:01:22.200 Welcome back to another episode of Internet Hate Machine.
00:01:25.640 So this is the final installment of our two-part episode with Francesca Fiorentini,
00:01:30.620 where we look at the ways that harassment online keeps women, particularly women of color and
00:01:35.580 Black women, from being able to run for and hold public office safely, and how that impacts our
00:01:40.880 democracy more broadly. So in our last episode, we talked about some national leaders like Kamala 1.00
00:01:45.780 Harris. And in this episode, we're zeroing in to look at some specific women in local public
00:01:51.000 offices and the harassment and abuse that they faced just for trying to do their jobs.
00:01:56.100 So, you know, we're talking about Harris, but I want to make it clear that when it comes 0.73
00:02:00.000 to women who are running for public office, it is not always like flashy candidates with
00:02:04.300 well-funded campaigns who are like running for a presidential administration. 0.58
00:02:07.800 We're often talking about women running for like local offices, like school boards in 0.99
00:02:12.040 their community or county commissioners.
00:02:13.900 So I want to talk about a few examples of what I mean.
00:02:16.580 The first is Tammy Sawyer.
00:02:17.760 will actually hopefully hear from Tammy Sawyer
00:02:20.120 in her own words later in the season.
00:02:21.700 But I want to talk about her time
00:02:24.440 as an elected official in Memphis Dynasty. 1.00
00:02:26.140 So Tammy Sawyer got her start in activism.
00:02:29.140 She felt called to public service
00:02:30.500 watching the acquittal of George Zimmerman
00:02:32.460 during the murder of Trayvon Martin
00:02:33.740 and the grand jury decision not to try Darren Wilson
00:02:36.420 through the death of Mike Brown.
00:02:37.760 She became a pretty like visible figure
00:02:39.760 in the movement for Black Lives.
00:02:41.380 In 2015, she organized a vigil in honor of Tamir Rice
00:02:44.460 at the Health Sciences Park in Memphis.
00:02:46.480 If you've ever been there in the last few years, you know that it had a statue of Confederate General and Ku Klux Klan Grand Wizard Nathan Bedford Forrest, the namesake for the movie Forrest Gump.
00:02:58.100 Fun fact.
00:02:59.500 In 2017, Tammy Sawyer organized the hashtag Take Em Down 901 movement, which led to the statue being removed.
00:03:07.620 In 2018 of August, she was elected to Shelby County Commissioner for District 7 in Memphis.
00:03:12.360 So she was this, like, visible figure in the movement for Black Lives, but that thing that elevated her to the public stage also made her a huge target for white supremacists.
00:03:23.380 Things came to a head in June when she was doing a press conference at this park during the actual removal of the monument.
00:03:29.380 So here's a little bit of, like, weird backstory.
00:03:31.800 Through this, like, very weird compromise, the group Sons of Confederate Veterans were responsible for hiring and overseeing the construction project to remove this Confederate statue.
00:03:43.440 It sounds like they never wanted this statue to be removed in the first place, and the team that they put together and hired to remove it seemed to reflect that, right?
00:03:51.820 This team that they had was obviously not thrilled that these statues were coming down, to say the least.
00:03:56.400 Yeah, that's an interesting contractor.
00:03:58.640 Yeah, like—
00:03:59.900 Tons of the Confederate veterans, like Confederate statue enthusiasts, you know.
00:04:07.740 I don't fully get it.
00:04:09.640 No.
00:04:10.820 Is there no one else who can take down the statues?
00:04:13.260 It's just the same people who put them up are also the people who take them down?
00:04:17.040 That's the compromise.
00:04:18.720 It has to be fair.
00:04:19.980 So the crew hired to take down these monuments.
00:04:22.700 They ended up putting Confederate flags all over the job site.
00:04:26.800 It sounds like they intentionally covered this, like, Black Lives Matter mural with bricks while working. 0.99
00:04:32.200 Just, like, petty shit, right? 1.00
00:04:33.960 Just, like, petty stunt shit. 1.00
00:04:35.220 That's how they were doing this for whatever reason. 1.00
00:04:37.420 I don't fully get, like, why or how this happened, but petty stunt shit. 0.98
00:04:42.920 So a member of that crew hired to remove the monument is a man named George K. Rack Johnson, 0.98
00:04:47.800 who is the founding member of a group called Confederate 901,
00:04:51.040 who has a history of, like, showing up in places where Confederate monuments are being taken down.
00:04:56.540 They were the group, if you remember, like, the group that was protesting a Confederate monument being taken down on Ole Miss, that was them.
00:05:03.780 I found this very interesting.
00:05:05.260 A piece in the Clarion Ledger says that the group is mostly white, shocker, but they do have a Black member who led one of their marches in Memphis.
00:05:14.980 So, like, yay for inclusion.
00:05:18.600 Something else to know about this guy is that in addition to being a founding member of this Confederate group, he loves Facebook Live.
00:05:26.060 And here's what he had to say about his own presence in Pittsburgh, North Carolina, on Facebook Live.
00:05:31.820 Today, I was like, I want to go to Chapel Hill.
00:05:34.060 I want to go to Pittsburgh.
00:05:35.180 I want to go to where they've already removed the monuments, you know?
00:05:39.460 And honestly, yeah, I was looking to stir the pot. 0.97
00:05:45.200 But hey, they've been stirring the pot for a long damn time.
00:05:48.660 And I'm about ready to make my own batch of stew, you know? 0.97
00:05:51.580 Ugh.
00:05:52.440 All right.
00:05:53.060 So, that's him.
00:05:55.520 Get a ring light, my guy.
00:05:58.260 I know.
00:05:58.620 What are you doing?
00:05:59.220 Get a ring light. 0.86
00:06:00.120 You want to eat people?
00:06:01.700 Yeah, that's literally what you're saying.
00:06:03.600 What?
00:06:04.680 That was my understanding as well.
00:06:08.060 Yeah, it's a very weird, gross analogy, and I don't like it at all.
00:06:13.200 And so this is a person who is hired to be part of the construction crew to take down this monument,
00:06:18.740 but to do it in the stuntiest way possible in Memphis,
00:06:22.160 where Tammy Sawyer has, like, led this campaign to remove these monuments. 0.96
00:06:26.080 And while Tammy is trying to hold a press conference at this park,
00:06:29.860 Johnson stands behind her, marching back and forth, holding a Confederate flag.
00:06:34.340 He uses racist insults toward her.
00:06:36.700 He sings the Confederate anthem, Dixie, as he's trying to speak.
00:06:40.220 My God.
00:06:41.260 Here's a little clip of what it sounded like
00:06:43.040 outside the Health and Sciences Park in Memphis that day.
00:06:48.020 So when they put all of this on social media,
00:06:50.920 and continue to threaten my life.
00:06:53.300 I didn't threaten your life.
00:06:55.380 When they continue to do all this 1.00
00:06:57.380 and say they're going to beat my ass 0.99
00:06:59.060 if you have it on record 1.00
00:07:00.960 and they wave their racist confederate
00:07:03.380 symbols behind you.
00:07:05.260 Remember.
00:07:07.000 Okay?
00:07:08.360 I came out here to give y'all a statement
00:07:10.160 and say that this was a powerful moment.
00:07:12.340 I was going to connect it to Cosa.
00:07:13.700 I was going to connect it to Memphis Massacre.
00:07:16.660 You know who else has been called a communist?
00:07:18.860 They called Martin Luther King a communist.
00:07:20.920 They called the Black Panthers Communists.
00:07:27.680 James Baldwin was called a Communist.
00:07:30.160 James Weldon Johnson was called a Communist.
00:07:33.060 Muhammad Ali was called a Communist.
00:07:38.420 Make sure you get a picture of the man who just threatened my life.
00:07:41.600 The man who just said he was going to lay hands on me.
00:07:44.600 And then make sure you go down there when they arrest me.
00:07:50.920 And remember that I do this by myself.
00:07:53.120 No one comes with me.
00:07:54.880 No.
00:07:55.760 No security. 0.99
00:07:56.840 All these cowards stand behind me. 0.99
00:07:57.720 So sad. 1.00
00:08:00.540 Coward. 1.00
00:08:01.740 That's what these people are. 1.00
00:08:02.800 They're cowards. 1.00
00:08:03.380 Yeah, I'm a coward. 1.00
00:08:04.180 Say, all right, you're fine. 1.00
00:08:05.420 So, you said you were going to beat my ass. 1.00
00:08:07.300 I'm right here. 1.00
00:08:07.840 Hide behind the fence. 1.00
00:08:08.660 Come beat my ass. 1.00
00:08:09.380 If he was a man, he'd be like, if he was a man, what'd I say? 1.00
00:08:11.920 I'm more a man than you are.
00:08:13.780 Well, I'm more of a gentleman than you are.
00:08:14.980 Oh, yes, Tammy.
00:08:16.060 Yes, Tammy.
00:08:17.560 Remember that. 1.00
00:08:20.920 Audrey Lorde once said, they will kill you and say you like me. 0.97
00:08:26.500 I'm not going to let him kill me.
00:08:28.560 But if he does, you know who to go find, right?
00:08:31.560 Y'all know where to start.
00:08:36.280 So that's really where things kind of come to a head.
00:08:39.680 And honestly, it's hard to watch that because I really feel for Tammy in that video. 0.77
00:08:45.620 You know, she's just trying to do her job. 0.86
00:08:47.820 She obviously has to respond in this moment with, like, grace because it's happening in public.
00:08:54.040 And you don't want to give these people any fodder to be like, oh, she deserved it. 1.00
00:08:59.320 You know, you can't really respond the way that you might want to because of all the negative stereotypes that women deal with that we talked about earlier.
00:09:07.480 And, yeah, I just, I really feel for her.
00:09:10.320 Like, I feel like it's palpable to see that she's dealing with this alone.
00:09:14.280 and and like tammy tammy was actually on my podcast habituation room a while ago before this
00:09:20.860 and she's the most lovely person like she's so wonderful and and just like warm and thoughtful
00:09:30.020 and fierce and you can and clearly it comes across but it is just funny that like yeah the
00:09:37.220 confederacy has been reduced to a sad man on a random tuesday with nothing to do with a tiny
00:09:43.900 little flag and his little you know
00:09:45.960 his air pods 0.99
00:09:47.080 listening to whatever the fuck he's listening 1.00
00:09:49.640 to waving his flag behind a woman 1.00
00:09:52.020 doing a press conference like
00:09:53.580 Robert E. Lee would be so proud of
00:09:55.940 you sir oh god
00:09:57.380 like keep the 1.00
00:09:59.160 flame alive you idiot 1.00
00:10:01.600 like you want to lose again 1.00
00:10:03.240 you fucking lost the civil war bitch 1.00
00:10:05.620 like I'm sorry I'm just like 1.00
00:10:06.960 you can't get over the fact that you 1.00
00:10:09.580 goddamn lost and you want a stupid monument 1.00
00:10:11.740 to your loser ass you know 1.00
00:10:13.840 Civil War hero? Shut the fuck up. 1.00
00:10:16.660 Fun fact, the show The Golden Girls lasted longer than the Confederacy, 1.00
00:10:20.240 so maybe we should have monuments to that, you know? 0.86
00:10:21.980 Yes, we should.
00:10:23.880 Sophia deserves her own monument.
00:10:26.420 I, as an Italian woman, believe Sophia is our queen.
00:10:33.180 No, yeah, that is, it's just so sad.
00:10:35.860 It is.
00:10:36.440 And so after this interaction, Sawyer filed charges against him
00:10:40.260 and said that, you know, he threatened her.
00:10:41.760 During the investigation, it is revealed that that same man, after she filed those charges, went on Facebook Live and read her address out loud.
00:10:51.040 Here is a little bit about how she explains what went down after the incident we just heard.
00:10:56.800 Because he went on Facebook Live with a friend and offered out my address and actually emailed out my address to people telling them to send me cotton and other gifts and show me who was in charge in this country and, you know, threatening that after January 24th after court that Memphis and me were going to face a reckoning.
00:11:21.160 Because of those actions that came to light this weekend, the judge was forced to allow the case to continue.
00:11:29.320 But the judge is also from Dyer County, and he did not want the case to continue.
00:11:36.160 And he lectured Mr. Johnson and told him, you have a great lawyer.
00:11:40.300 You know, why did you open your mouth?
00:11:42.280 You know, don't ruin a good thing.
00:11:43.960 He told him, son, don't ruin a good thing.
00:11:46.680 And so I already see where this is going.
00:11:49.740 Wow. That is incredible that that was what was discussed. And so so what? Nothing left for you here?
00:11:59.320 I was in court, and when I attempted to speak, the judge told me that I don't address him.
00:12:04.280 I could talk to the DA.
00:12:05.760 This is the same DA that never called me, interviewed me.
00:12:08.940 And actually today, when the case was continued to be set for trial in March, I said, I'll now have to look at this case.
00:12:16.500 I have to be honest.
00:12:17.560 I hadn't looked at it because I just knew it was going to be dismissed.
00:12:21.040 So this is a six-month-old situation that went viral that was covered on your show and many others.
00:12:26.220 and the DA is telling me he's never looked at the file
00:12:29.440 and now he's going to have to look at it.
00:12:31.880 There's still a motion to dismiss from the defense
00:12:34.340 that'll be heard on March 31st.
00:12:36.120 So yeah, you can sort of get a sense that like
00:12:39.240 it doesn't sound like anybody whose job it is 1.00
00:12:43.200 to give a shit, gives a shit. 1.00
00:12:45.760 She's an elected official. 1.00
00:12:47.720 I believe she's still currently the commissioner, 0.63
00:12:51.060 Shelby County commissioner.
00:12:52.180 No, she was at that point, but no longer,
00:12:54.200 she's not like today.
00:12:55.600 Right. Yeah. So she at that point, she was still an elected official. And this is how they were treating a pretty clear like like problem, you know, and also keep in mind, she was a county commissioner. Right. It's not like she had a well-funded security detail or like endless funds to dedicate to the kinds of like security that someone would need in a situation like this.
00:13:17.880 You know, after this man made a show of having her address and a clear intent to cause her harm.
00:13:24.120 And so Tammy had to fundraise for her own security.
00:13:26.540 I should say, full disclosure, I do work for a organization that did help her fundraise for her security details.
00:13:31.520 So, like, I should add that.
00:13:33.040 It only makes us like you more, Bridget.
00:13:35.180 Okay, good.
00:13:37.240 I don't want someone to, like, find that and be like, wait a minute, conflict of interest.
00:13:40.520 I mean, I love Tammy and I admire her work so much.
00:13:44.480 And, like, you know, it is what it is.
00:13:46.980 I can't believe you would cover this story.
00:13:49.420 That is, wow.
00:13:51.260 I thought you had integrity.
00:13:53.300 I mean, yeah, it's like, you know, we saw what happened and it just felt like nobody had her back, right?
00:13:58.900 Like, she shouldn't have to, it shouldn't be this barrier and this cost that just she alone has to shoulder.
00:14:06.540 It's not like county commissioners, this like lucrative, cushy thing. 0.67
00:14:09.580 Like, she shouldn't have to just, like, shell out to have to have security because some Confederate maniac has a bee in its bonnet. 0.72
00:14:17.980 Like, I thought it was completely unacceptable.
00:14:20.800 Yes, and it's indicative of the fact that most people who run for elected office and who get elected are themselves wealthy. 0.63
00:14:28.660 And they're usually white dudes.
00:14:30.720 And they have generational wealth or they're independently wealthy, whatever the case may be.
00:14:35.740 And they can afford a security detail. 0.65
00:14:37.720 But again, as you've discussed and laid out, mostly when you are a white man in office, you do not face those kinds of threats the way women and women of color do. 0.61
00:14:48.060 And it goes from, I mean, from Tammy to AOC on, you know, on a federal level, I guess, or in Congress, you know, AOC saying we need security. 0.60
00:14:57.940 And this is after January 6th, right?
00:15:01.060 This is like we need better security in and around the Capitol.
00:15:04.880 And it seems like that's only reserved for people who like the speaker or who people who just privately funded themselves.
00:15:13.240 And who's got the money for that?
00:15:15.740 I mean, this is ostensibly these should be public servants.
00:15:18.800 And this is the mint.
00:15:20.220 Just the least we could do for them.
00:15:22.680 Exactly.
00:15:23.080 And if we're saying we want to have a representative democracy where lots of different folks from lots of different backgrounds can be public servants, that should include people who, I'm sorry, can't afford a private security detail.
00:15:36.180 It shouldn't just be for wealthy people.
00:15:37.360 And I feel like we are creating a situation where the only people who can reasonably and safely hold public office are people who have independent wealth to pay the astronomical costs that are involved with security and online and offline security.
00:15:53.280 And so I think it's a real problem.
00:15:55.600 And, you know, I should say, like, with the Tammy Sawyer situation, the charges were eventually dropped against the person who was harassing her.
00:16:02.900 You know, it sounds like Tammy felt like this case was not handled seriously.
00:16:06.140 Right.
00:16:06.540 She talks about how the judge was, like, really palling it up with the defendant who she says was harassing her.
00:16:13.340 And when the judge was like, oh, you know, don't go on Facebook Live, it wasn't because he wanted Tammy to feel safe.
00:16:21.080 It was because he didn't want that guy to make his case that much harder to have him be dismissed.
00:16:27.300 And so when the charges were dismissed, Tammy wrote on Facebook, she said that even though the judge called his actions pathetic, he could not identify a reasonable level of fear on her part. 0.99
00:16:38.320 And so I would actually argue that that like weird—I know, it's so fucked up. 0.76
00:16:44.020 And like, I think that weird vibe, that tightrope of like, I have to show public grace kind of creates this impossible situation where it's like, oh, well, you can handle it. 0.99
00:16:53.900 Like, you're a black woman.
00:16:55.740 It's just like part of showing up and being a visible black woman.
00:16:58.440 You're not afraid, whatever, whatever.
00:17:00.440 And I think that's part of it.
00:17:01.940 It's this impossible situation that we face.
00:17:04.080 You're used to it.
00:17:05.300 No, imagine if she had freaked out in that video.
00:17:08.420 Imagine if she'd gotten angry, right? 0.90
00:17:11.020 It would have been used against her.
00:17:12.340 The dude would have used it to file charges against her, right?
00:17:19.440 And you know that would have flown.
00:17:21.060 He would have loved that.
00:17:22.840 He would have loved that.
00:17:23.900 He was just waiting for her to go off on him, and she didn't.
00:17:27.040 She had to keep her cool, which is asked of marginalized people all the time because when you raise your voice, somehow that is – that's a threat.
00:17:36.660 But, yeah, I think – the other thing I was going to say, and this is a terrible comparison, but when it comes to the justice system, it's just right there for the taking.
00:17:44.820 Like, you know that rape victims are – their cases are not taken seriously often if they don't, quote, unquote, fight back.
00:17:52.140 Mm-hmm.
00:17:52.640 Right. So and in this case, oh, she wasn't afraid. She wasn't afraid because she didn't raise her voice or she didn't run. She wasn't physically running at the time. So therefore, there was no fear. Like, what are you talking about? This is all about surviving.
00:18:08.060 And it just, I mean, you bring up such a good point about the ways that we've really just failed survivors and made survivors walk a really impossible tightrope in public. 0.99
00:18:22.200 And it's just really fucked up. 0.98
00:18:25.060 And, yeah, it makes me very sad. 0.99
00:18:27.640 Totally.
00:18:28.260 And today, Tammy Sawyer is no longer in public office. 0.77
00:18:30.940 She is pursuing a PhD.
00:18:32.380 And don't get me wrong, like, she is still doing great things.
00:18:34.820 Like, we will hear her.
00:18:36.360 I am so sure we're going to hear her name again, like, just because she's no longer in public office.
00:18:41.360 I don't think this is, like, the end of her road by any margin.
00:18:45.260 But I do think that we should acknowledge this, like, added burden that she was forced to carry because of her identity.
00:18:51.540 You know, pursuing charges against somebody who gave out her address and encouraged people to harass her.
00:18:57.460 And it's like, we, rather than taking the time to really reflect on that or acknowledge that, we just move on.
00:19:05.020 We're just like, oh, yeah, like it just it just feels like a footnote as opposed to something that is a real marker of our democracy and how unwell our democratic system is right now.
00:19:15.840 It's also it reminds me of like she was working with Black Voters Matter when I had her on.
00:19:20.640 So she also has done incredible activism.
00:19:23.020 And you're totally right.
00:19:24.160 We'll continue to do so.
00:19:25.140 It reminds me of like women in comedy, you know, where it's like a lot of male bookers will be like, well, look, I would put more women on my show, but like, well, they're not any good women. 0.53
00:19:36.260 I don't know any female comics. 0.96
00:19:37.980 It's like, number one, you're blind and there are tons of amazing women, female comics. 0.97
00:19:44.140 But also it's like, yeah, look at the industry writ large.
00:19:48.400 Like look at the culture of comedy in a lot of ways.
00:19:51.580 We don't have HR.
00:19:52.280 there's not it's like a not a safe space specifically for women and for women of color 1.00
00:19:58.060 the comedy space just isn't you know right like and and it's the same thing with elected office 1.00
00:20:03.500 it's just like well you know we we love to have like some kind of quota or have like more women
00:20:08.880 in office but just they don't run and and i think republicans are so guilty of that too you know
00:20:13.580 because it's like they have what like three female senators it just it's like the lowest in in
00:20:20.660 internationally i think the u.s congress is one of the least representative bodies when it comes 0.98
00:20:27.940 to gender and so and like and it's just like well we we'd support them if they would run for office
00:20:35.660 no they run for office they just get torn down i mean i'm also thinking of someone like katie hill
00:20:40.880 in california right like they get torn the fuck apart so yeah yeah and it's funny that you i mean 0.96
00:20:48.340 not funny but what katie hill went through was a sex crime like she was the victim of a sex crime 0.97
00:20:54.480 by a an ex-romantic partner who was like a like harassing her and yet it's like we just allow 0.93
00:21:03.880 we just have a really fucked up culture when it comes to women i guess i'll just say that like 0.97
00:21:08.820 all i can really say 0.99
00:21:10.700 run a business and not thinking about podcasting think again more americans listen to
00:21:18.260 podcast than ad-supported streaming music from spotify and pandora and as the number one podcaster
00:21:23.520 iheart's twice as large as the next two combined so whatever your customers listen to they'll hear
00:21:28.360 your message plus only iheart can extend your message to audiences across broadcast radio
00:21:33.340 think podcasting can help your business think iheart streaming radio and podcasting let us show
00:21:39.440 you at iheartadvertising.com that's iheartadvertising.com when i was 14 years old i was
00:21:46.560 kidnapped and held captive for nine months i survived and i've spent my life exploring how
00:21:52.700 other people survive what should have destroyed them i'm elizabeth smart and these are the
00:21:58.520 survivor files i just remember this low taunting voice next to my ear saying shut up don't say
00:22:06.720 anything every week i'm with survivors who live through the unthinkable i knew if he woke up
00:22:14.200 Without a doubt, he was going to hurt me.
00:22:16.940 I started feeling that there was someone at the end of my bed, and I just started screaming.
00:22:24.560 They are abducted, stalked, controlled, and nearly silenced.
00:22:28.460 But these aren't stories about what's taken from them.
00:22:31.920 They're stories about what it takes to make it out alive.
00:22:35.540 Listen to The Survivor Files with Elizabeth Smart on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:22:43.300 If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
00:22:50.200 This is Prose Society, the weekly podcast that's part book club, part group chat for thought daughters,
00:22:56.340 pop culture obsessives, and anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:23:02.380 I'm Eli Rallo, and every week we're connecting the dots between books, the internet, and the conversations everyone can't stop having.
00:23:09.500 I'm going to have to look up this story. I'm obsessed, so obsessed.
00:23:12.640 From best-selling authors and your favorite book talk creators to the latest pop culture moments, nothing is off the table.
00:23:19.040 It's like if you can hide some real messages inside compelling characters, then that is a Trojan horse.
00:23:26.940 Whether you're looking for literary deep dives, smart pop culture conversations, or a community of readers who love to think a little too much, you're in the right place.
00:23:36.120 Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:23:42.140 See you between the pages. 0.56
00:23:47.860 So I want to talk about one more elected official and her experience in public office, Kia Morris. 0.91
00:23:54.300 She made history in 2014 as Vermont's only black woman lawmaker.
00:23:58.420 Her husband, James, grew up in Bennington, Vermont, and she went to college in Chicago but relocated back to Vermont to become a lawmaker.
00:24:04.700 Her career was very short-lived because it was completely derailed by online harassment and violent threats by self-proclaimed white nationalist Max Misch.
00:24:14.660 Misch was kind of known as like a violent—
00:24:17.160 Wait, wait, wait. His name is Max Misch?
00:24:19.200 Max Misch. 1.00
00:24:23.220 Dude, white nationalists have the dumbest names. 1.00
00:24:27.040 They really do. They really do. 1.00
00:24:29.500 Max Misch. Misch Misch.
00:24:31.120 i don't know i'm just like that is the stupid anyway sorry it's like a mickey mouse name 1.00
00:24:37.600 that's a made-up it's so stupid so he's kind of like no like a known violent asshole uh side note 0.99
00:24:44.620 he looks exactly like whatever you're thinking that he looks like based on the behavior i'm 1.00
00:24:49.600 about to describe i can tell you that you're right whatever you're thinking yes that's what
00:24:53.200 he looks like very red faced super red face you got it you got it
00:24:58.500 so mish he pled guilty to both first degree aggravated domestic assault and disorderly
00:25:07.540 conduct as a hate crime so he has this like he doesn't have a great like he's like a known
00:25:12.860 shithead i guess so he's been through a lot is what you're saying yes he's just a real victim
00:25:18.060 You know, and so Kia, when she supports a gun safety bill, she starts to experience animosity from gun rights advocates in Vermont because of her support of this legislation. 0.97
00:25:30.240 Now, many legislators in the governor were targeted with like angry mail and messages over this this law.
00:25:36.940 But the kind of content that she gets is very different because she's a black woman and the only black woman in the legislature.
00:25:43.160 So, you know, she's not just getting like, oh, we didn't like that you support this bill.
00:25:47.320 She's getting frightening, horrific, racist messages, particularly from Max Misch.
00:25:53.100 Max starts sending her these, like, racist memes on Twitter and elsewhere about her support for the bill.
00:25:59.380 Kia says that she gets an uptick in the intensity of this kind of harassment after a columnist for the white supremacist website, the InfoStormer, posts about her re-election and starts tagging, like, residents in it.
00:26:10.820 The InfoStormer. Sorry, I had to give that a moment.
00:26:14.260 I know. I feel like it's like we stormed the truth.
00:26:18.620 They're like putting a bunch of words into like an A.I. generator or something.
00:26:23.200 And it's like InfoStormer. That's going to be it.
00:26:25.460 Like you mean DailyStormer? No, we're like a breakaway of the DailyStormer.
00:26:30.300 Who even is that?
00:26:33.480 Exactly. InfoStormer.
00:26:35.180 It's so ridiculous. 0.79
00:26:35.940 And so in a 10-page report published by the Vermont Attorney General's Office, 0.89
00:26:42.360 It outlines almost 50 instances of threatening behavior where her or her family or her neighbors called the police.
00:26:49.360 And so first it's like.
00:26:50.180 In Vermont?
00:26:51.200 In Vermont.
00:26:51.880 You guys.
00:26:53.460 And it's funny because you think of Vermont as like a progressive state. 1.00
00:26:57.380 But, you know, it's like this shit happens, you know. 0.99
00:27:02.760 It's not just Bernie building a fire endlessly and the coat factory. 1.00
00:27:08.220 Or like wearing mittens.
00:27:10.400 Exactly.
00:27:10.840 It's Vermont.
00:27:11.940 It's more than mittens.
00:27:13.860 That should be their slogan.
00:27:15.120 Yeah.
00:27:16.140 I mean, that's what Max Misch wants.
00:27:18.000 Like, these guys must be so mad that Bernie, like, put them on the map as, like, as progressives.
00:27:23.240 The governor of Vermont is a Republican.
00:27:25.600 Yeah, it's one of those states, right?
00:27:27.520 It's one of those sort of, like, it's kind of a Max Misch state, you know? 0.85
00:27:31.900 It's a Misch-Misch. 0.96
00:27:32.300 It's a Misch-Misch state, yeah. 0.94
00:27:33.680 It's a Max Misch of ideology. 0.97
00:27:35.940 Their governor is, I think it's Phil Scott, and he's, like, this is, like, his fourth time.
00:27:41.720 Right. And it was the one issue that Sanders, like Clinton was to the left of Sanders on because there's so many gun enthusiasts in Vermont.
00:27:51.480 Yeah. And Sanders was, I mean, I think now that's like, I mean, how many mass shootings has there been since 2016? Right.
00:27:56.760 So even now, I don't think he can hold that line, but it's been the sort of one gray area where he was like, had to appease the gun folks in his state.
00:28:06.580 Yeah, I get it. I mean, like, honestly, researching this episode, I get it.
00:28:10.480 I was like, oh, I don't think I realized how fervent gun ideology is.
00:28:15.220 Like, I live in D.C., so, like, there's gun crimes here, but, like, individuals don't have the same kind of connection to it.
00:28:23.920 And when I was researching this episode, I was like, oh, wow, like, I forget how different it is in different states that, like, it's a real issue.
00:28:31.540 Right.
00:28:32.640 They're all arming up for the imagined crime, whereas, like, D.C. actually has a little bit of it.
00:28:38.640 Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. 0.98
00:28:39.680 So the kinds of messages that she's getting from Max Mish are just racist, garbage, you know, go back to Africa, it's the only place that you'll be safe, that kind of thing, right? 0.64
00:28:49.680 And so in August of 2016, she files a complaint with the FBI where she says that this guy and his associates are harassing her on Twitter. 0.83
00:28:56.700 But as online harassment often works, it doesn't just stay online, it bleeds from Twitter and Facebook into her offline life.
00:29:03.220 On election day, she's doing a campaign event at a polling place, and she sees this guy, Max, there staring at her and weirding her out.
00:29:12.220 Then somebody breaks into her home.
00:29:14.360 They stole about 100 of her husband's neckties and littered them across a cemetery in her home, which is very weird.
00:29:20.640 It's like a very weird thing.
00:29:23.140 So can you imagine them getting together and being like, so what should we do?
00:29:26.440 Should we put a horse in her bed, like in Godfather?
00:29:31.480 No, no, no, no. I saw this one thing on the Lifetime channel. We're going to do the neckties.
00:29:38.660 The necktie thing.
00:29:40.160 Pete, I don't know if we should do the necktie thing. No, trust me. We're going to do the necktie thing. It'll be crazy. We just put a little necktie on every single gravestone.
00:29:50.080 It's such a weird, specific way to fuck with somebody. 1.00
00:29:55.600 Yes. 1.00
00:29:56.420 So bizarre.
00:29:57.880 You know, it's like a snowman, but of headstones.
00:30:01.880 Right.
00:30:02.780 You know, we're going to get the corncob pipe and the carrot nose and then one of their neckties. 1.00
00:30:08.040 It'll freak her out. 0.85
00:30:09.740 I mean, probably mission accomplished.
00:30:12.120 Yeah, she was completely freaked out. 0.72
00:30:13.940 Also, her home was vandalized with paintballs.
00:30:17.260 But then we're going to bake her a pie.
00:30:18.740 So one hot piping apple pie. 1.00
00:30:23.040 yeah a lot of mixed signals from these harassers yes yes a house nearby that has a ton of her like 0.99
00:30:30.620 campaign paraphernalia on their windows gets a racist mailer shoved under the door and then
00:30:36.460 her babysitter reports that a man in a car outside of her home is recording their house so like just
00:30:41.980 like weird like weird scary shit that maybe does not like i kind of see whoever's doing this it
00:30:47.940 kind of seems like they're trying to operate on like a level of like it's enough to freak you out 0.74
00:30:53.360 but not enough to be like you know the kind of crime that the police would take seriously like
00:30:59.240 I feel like they're they're really walking the line of like it has to be scary but not scary
00:31:03.260 enough that like somebody in power would take this seriously but that's sort of the the tricky
00:31:07.940 thing with harassment generally right and with like crimes whether they be I mean especially
00:31:12.300 sexual crimes but like is that gray area and it's the sort of you know I know it's overused but
00:31:17.820 that microaggression but this is obviously much more than that like the micro the stalking right
00:31:23.920 the harassing and harassment it's like well did he enter with a gun did he like no buddy there's
00:31:30.580 a car outside uh someone's filming me and it's just like and of course um cops uh not the most
00:31:37.340 empathetic not the best at dealing with some of these the warning signs which by the way is really
00:31:43.440 just hey do you have a history of dv yeah then you should have someone tailing you at all times 0.99
00:31:49.040 because likely you're gonna do some other shit to somebody else and you probably shouldn't have a 0.92
00:31:53.880 gun and you definitely shouldn't have a gun like just some common sense like yeah if you've been 0.97
00:32:00.500 threatening your domestic partner maybe let's not get a gun in the mix like just you know uh so the
00:32:07.300 police it sounds like don't really do anything like they don't she when when they when somebody
00:32:11.920 breaks into her house they don't like take fingerprints or whatever she gets a restraining
00:32:15.700 order against him but it only lasts for one year after the restraining order expires max mish
00:32:21.040 contacts her again on social media writing on twitter you will never silence me every time you
00:32:26.360 attend a political rally at the four corners or another local venue and i'm aware of the event
00:32:30.180 i will troll the hell out of you and other subversives there maybe i'll bring a friend
00:32:35.000 or three with me to stop pushing social justice on your nearly entirely white constituency in 1.00
00:32:41.220 beddington vermont go back to chicago if you want to engage in social justice warrior bullshit 0.96
00:32:45.340 we will continue to fight against you and your efforts to make our town and state 1.00
00:32:48.440 look more like your mongrel son so pretty fucked up like not good and so i understand why she was 0.98
00:32:57.380 like terrified and unnerved but unfortunately the attorney general declines to press charges 0.95
00:33:03.000 against this guy explaining that in this case the online communications that were sent to miss
00:33:07.400 Morris by Max Misch and others were clearly racist and offensive. However, the First Amendment does
00:33:12.740 not make speech sanctionable merely because it is objectionable. The question here is whether
00:33:16.860 the messages and context were communicating a serious expression of intent to harm Miss Morris
00:33:20.680 or her family. Yeah. It sounds like. Yes. Sorry, I didn't mean to interrupt. Yes. Yes. Yes. The fact
00:33:28.260 that a number of the messages were directed at her as in her role as an elected official raises
00:33:32.580 the issue of whether they were intended to express political opposition through the use of hyperbole
00:33:37.040 and insult as noted in the case above therefore there appears to be insufficient evidence to 0.98
00:33:42.340 pursue criminal charges under vermont law oh that's such bullshit i mean that's such bullshit 0.97
00:33:48.520 that because that's that's basically like well it's open season you know and here we are in a 0.99
00:33:53.340 moment where it's like oh my god someone protested outside of brett kavanaugh's home like how dare
00:33:58.940 you you know what we really need to beef up security on um white men in power like or the
00:34:04.680 supreme court is just being targeted like no these are the stories that happen all the time on a local
00:34:10.020 level people have been harassed for decades and we don't hear it gabby gifford's god has to get
00:34:15.780 shot in the head and we still don't have security details for elected officials i mean it's just how
00:34:22.560 many more instances do you need and that's was so perfect it's like okay we we know who we choose 0.99
00:34:27.480 to protect we know when people raise the alarm it's when fucking ted cruz gets trolled a yankees 0.59
00:34:32.860 game and then it's like oh my god yeah and it creates this like really obviously false frustrating 0.91
00:34:39.580 both sides narrative of like oh they both sides do it and it's like well someone writing in chalk
00:34:45.600 outside of brett kavanaugh's home is different than like breaking into nancy pelosi's home and
00:34:49.320 hitting her husband on the head with a hammer it's like those are not analogous so like let's
00:34:53.140 not pretend that they are like i hate this vibe of like i think that political violence and threats
00:34:59.640 against elected officials as, like, a should-be-a-nonpartisan issue.
00:35:03.420 But I hate this vibe that, like, we have to be completely disingenuous 0.96
00:35:07.760 about which side is doing it in a way that is, like, much more fucking scary. 0.96
00:35:12.500 Yes. 0.94
00:35:13.440 So, case closed.
00:35:14.760 They're not going to press any charges against this guy.
00:35:16.920 There's a press conference where the DA is announcing
00:35:19.400 that he does not intend to press charges against Max Misch.
00:35:22.100 After the DA speaks about freedom of speech,
00:35:24.700 Kia gets up to the podium to speak.
00:35:26.180 And guess who comes in? Max Misch.
00:35:28.980 He's wearing a Pepe the Frog shirt, and you can hear everyone's reaction when he enters.
00:35:58.980 So I'm happy to take other questions other than that.
00:36:11.300 With that, I'm going to conclude the press conference unless there are
00:36:28.840 Other questions?
00:36:30.860 I'd like to say something, please.
00:36:32.320 Hold on one second.
00:36:34.080 As a political opponent who was accused of being a Nazi myself,
00:36:37.720 I think we're hearing one side of the story.
00:36:40.040 Oh, my God.
00:36:41.200 So this is failed lawmaker Kevin Hoyt.
00:36:44.060 Kaya's politics, and I was called the Nazis.
00:36:46.820 I was called the white supremacists.
00:36:48.240 You probably are, my guy.
00:36:49.880 Obviously, racism exists in Vermont State.
00:36:52.780 It's like hate, right?
00:36:54.240 It's like all these things.
00:36:55.860 It's crazy.
00:36:56.440 We don't want these things, but they're part of our fabric of society.
00:36:59.940 I question to what degree, though. 0.99
00:37:02.200 I call bullshit on Miss Morris. 0.98
00:37:04.200 I think I'm a friend of mine. 0.99
00:37:06.500 Okay, so you kind of get the idea.
00:37:08.400 Wow.
00:37:08.540 Also, FYI, Kevin Hoyt is like, if folks are interested, he's his own weird guy who folks, you can look him up if you're interested.
00:37:18.420 But it's so funny that he's like, I was also unfairly called a Nazi, and I think we should let him speak.
00:37:22.960 It is just wild, right? 0.56
00:37:24.680 But, like, complete pandemonium, onlookers use their jackets to try to block Mish.
00:37:29.900 It's this big dramatic scene, but not to Max Mish.
00:37:33.640 To him, it is all a big joke.
00:37:35.420 He told the free press, I am a troll. 0.56
00:37:37.620 I like it.
00:37:38.360 I like this.
00:37:39.140 Like, it's just funny to him.
00:37:40.900 And so I would love to play a little clip of him responding to the free press.
00:37:45.680 Because I can.
00:37:47.160 Yes, you can.
00:37:48.660 Absolutely.
00:37:49.220 That doesn't explain why you do it.
00:37:50.460 But that's why we were holding up our coats so that people of color don't have to see that hate and we're surrounding you and we don't like it. It's vile. It's vile. Yes, you have the right to put the shirt on, but I have the right to tell you that it's hateful, it's cruel, and it's vile.
00:38:11.460 I see. I mean, you can cry about all you want. I'm not crying. I'm pissed.
00:38:18.460 it's max are you intentionally being provocative that's what people are yes why why are you being
00:38:25.420 provocative i like trolling people it's fun i'm so over that concept and look how much attention
00:38:31.520 he's getting for doing it so he's clearly just someone who likes to like like this is a joke
00:38:38.520 to him i don't think that he's any of this is serious to him i think it's just a joke
00:38:42.520 oh my god if mommy issues pepe shirt i'm like oh just just like mom issues in a person you know
00:38:50.020 like um it's because i want attention because i didn't get enough as a child and no one will
00:38:55.460 play with me and one time they ditched me in the sandbox for like the volleyball court and i didn't
00:39:00.100 know how to play volleyball and uh you know it's just like it's like oh my god go to therapy bro
00:39:05.940 go to therapy people like again what is it what will it take and I think that's the woman who's
00:39:12.940 like yes I have the right to also you know stand in front of you and call you hateful she was
00:39:17.880 excellent and then she points out that the media is going to the provocateur and saying which is
00:39:24.820 just a really funny statement I mean I don't know disrespect to local news but like or the free
00:39:30.140 press but like it is very funny to be like are you being intentionally provocative like yeah 0.74
00:39:37.400 like what is the other answer to that no in my heart of hearts i do believe that white people
00:39:43.380 are a superior race like huh interesting expound on that you know like what what's the other answer 0.98
00:39:50.000 yes he's being provocative on purpose does it has to do with his fucked up ideology doesn't even 0.97
00:39:55.780 matter yeah and asking him about that with a camera with a bunch of camera crews in his face 0.98
00:40:01.760 like sir are you intentionally being provocative are we like it's like you're providing the answer
00:40:05.960 is clearly yes and you are providing him the exact thing that a provocateur wants a platform yeah
00:40:11.340 and this is and i think it's important to remember 24 i believe 2014 or maybe 15 but kind of when
00:40:17.960 the media was lending a platform to people like richard spencer people like these sort of you
00:40:25.540 You know, Nazis in suits or sort of, you know, and and on on the cusp of the election of Donald Trump, effectively saying maybe we need to listen to Nazis a little bit more.
00:40:38.140 And now that they've made their message a little more couth and digestible, you know, hey, they're not hateful.
00:40:43.500 They just believe we should live in separate communities for people of color and white people.
00:40:48.680 There's nothing hateful about that.
00:40:50.040 Like, I mean, just the mind trick that I think white nationalists pulled on the media and the media in turn pulled on us.
00:40:58.000 We're seeing that in a microcosm in this example that you that you brought up.
00:41:03.340 Yeah, it infuriates me.
00:41:06.320 And I will never forget this. 0.67
00:41:08.060 And I like the publication for the most part, but, like, there's a Mother Jones piece where it's like, oh, the dapper white supremacists walking through town.
00:41:17.660 Like, I feel like it's, like, burned into my memory of, like, what are we doing?
00:41:22.820 What are we normalizing?
00:41:24.120 What are we glamorizing?
00:41:25.120 What are we giving a platform?
00:41:26.260 And the thing that fucks with me is I worry that we learned nothing.
00:41:31.440 I worry that when I when I look at like how the media is covering somebody like Ron DeSantis, for instance, I worry that we have learned nothing. 0.99
00:41:39.460 The media has learned nothing about what kind of hateful bullshit ideology they will amplify and normalize despite the fact that he's like criminalizing trans youth and shit and like putting, you know, putting immigrants on buses and just like rewriting history books. 0.99
00:41:58.680 It infuriates me. The way that this kind of like horse race kind of political coverage is going, I see us poised to do the same thing again, where I see these memes about like, Ron DeSantis is tall or like things like that, where I'm like, yeah, he's also like a hate monger. Can we talk about that? 0.99
00:42:15.180 Right. They're just so desperate to move on from Trump, even though they're not. I think there's just this. I mean, that's like our political system is such, especially and the media is like following the political system is so reliant on the idea that there are two rational actors.
00:42:31.920 Obviously, we have all of two parties in this country.
00:42:34.620 Yay.
00:42:35.200 And they're both rational and they're both great and we can level with them.
00:42:38.340 And, you know, it's a balance of powers.
00:42:40.000 And it's like, no, it's not. 1.00
00:42:41.220 It's bullshit. 0.99
00:42:42.580 One side doesn't believe in a balance of powers. 1.00
00:42:44.700 They believe in authoritarianism.
00:42:46.020 But, yeah, you're absolutely right.
00:42:48.260 I'm because it's exactly that.
00:42:50.980 Ron DeSantis is the buttoned up Donald Trump and Richard Spencer is the buttoned up David Duke.
00:42:58.780 Right.
00:42:58.880 And so as long as he's not openly saying he's a member of the KKK, it's all good. 0.52
00:43:04.800 And even though people held Hitler in his little, you know, like, hotel speech when Trump won, that's fine because he's in a suit and he's got a nice haircut.
00:43:13.740 Yeah, I—God, I want us to be better.
00:43:16.320 We deserve a better—we deserve better media that can, like, tell a better version of these stories that isn't so harmful.
00:43:23.740 Like, I'm exhausted because I know we're not going to get it.
00:43:27.200 Yeah.
00:43:27.680 And also, there's enough on the Democratic side. 0.68
00:43:29.520 Like, there's enough in—we got a lot of, like, conservative Dems.
00:43:32.860 There's tons of drama on this side. 0.99
00:43:35.280 Talk about those folks.
00:43:36.600 But anyway, I digress.
00:43:41.400 Run a business and not thinking about podcasting?
00:43:44.420 Think again.
00:43:45.400 More Americans listen to podcasts than ad-supported streaming music from Spotify and Pandora.
00:43:49.700 And as the number one podcaster, iHeart's twice as large as the next two combined.
00:43:53.960 So whatever your customers listen to, they'll hear your message.
00:43:57.240 Plus, only iHeart can extend your message to audiences across broadcast radio.
00:44:01.440 Think podcasting can help your business?
00:44:03.340 Think iHeart.
00:44:04.360 Streaming, radio, and podcasting.
00:44:06.440 Call 844-844-iHeart to get started.
00:44:09.580 That's 844-844-iHeart.
00:44:12.040 If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
00:44:17.960 This is Prose Society, the weekly podcast that's part book club,
00:44:22.340 part group chat for thought daughters, pop culture obsessives,
00:44:25.740 and anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:44:30.420 I'm Eli Rallo, and every week we're connecting the dots between books,
00:44:34.120 the internet, and the conversations everyone can't stop having.
00:44:37.380 I'm going to have to look up this story. I'm obsessed, so obsessed.
00:44:41.120 From best-selling authors and your favorite book talk creators to the latest pop culture moments,
00:44:45.980 nothing is off the table.
00:44:47.080 It's like if you can hide some real messages inside compelling characters, then that is a Trojan horse.
00:44:54.980 Whether you're looking for literary deep dives, smart pop culture conversations, or a community of readers who love to think a little too much, you're in the right place.
00:45:04.140 Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:45:10.080 See you between the pages.
00:45:11.260 When I was 14 years old, I was kidnapped and held captive for nine months.
00:45:18.060 I survived, and I've spent my life exploring how other people survive what should have destroyed them.
00:45:24.420 I'm Elizabeth Smart, and these are the Survivor Files.
00:45:28.120 I just remember this low, taunting voice next to my ear saying, 0.99
00:45:33.540 Shut up. Don't say anything. 0.99
00:45:36.300 Every week, I'm with survivors who live through the unthinkable.
00:45:40.740 I knew if he woke up, without a doubt, he was going to hurt me.
00:45:45.280 I started feeling that there was someone at the end of my bed, and I just started screaming.
00:45:52.740 They are abducted, stalked, controlled, and nearly silenced.
00:45:56.700 But these aren't stories about what's taken from them.
00:46:00.140 They're stories about what it takes to make it out alive.
00:46:03.280 Listen to The Survivor Files with Elizabeth Smart on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:46:16.340 So while all of this was happening to Kia, her husband James was in very poor health and he had to have open heart surgery.
00:46:22.920 So I know like this had to be stressful for her.
00:46:25.580 And so perhaps not surprisingly, 10 days after she won the Democratic nomination for a third term as state representative, she announced that she was dropping her campaign and packed up and left town shortly thereafter for her family's safety.
00:46:40.380 This is really sad.
00:46:41.500 Like, she talks about how her son, who at the time was seven, saw the threats that she got, like, saw them and, like, understood them and had questions about them and was so scared that he tried to build a panic room in their home out of his closet.
00:46:58.440 And so, like, it is scary and sad.
00:47:02.100 And after she left town, Mish was quoted as saying, I won.
00:47:06.420 I did it. 1.00
00:47:07.080 so yeah just a real piece of shit good for you asshole i hope it's given you know he's still 1.00
00:47:15.260 unhappy isn't that crazy i think he's still unhappy he's still insufferable that's for sure 1.00
00:47:23.040 this is this is the threat of equality this is what i mean i love it like you you want social 0.56
00:47:29.120 justice like what are you talking about this is a predominantly white state a predominantly white
00:47:35.560 electorate predominantly white you know uh whatever state body like in no way is she trying 0.98
00:47:43.680 again by her mere existence her mere existence and the threat the the supposed threat of one day 0.88
00:47:52.260 there could be equality one day there could be two kia morrises oh my god like all of two black 1.00
00:47:58.780 women in their legislature yep and and then it'll be all over i mean we'll still have the power 1.00
00:48:04.500 white dudes, but it'll feel like we don't because someone's going to quote Audre Lorde to us. 1.00
00:48:13.820 Or what? Or like someone's going to like want to create a program for black youth in our state.
00:48:20.760 Like, Christ. So this story does not end there, because if you're thinking, wow, it sounds like
00:48:28.160 officials didn't do a great job of taking the situation seriously or investigating it,
00:48:32.440 you would be right. After Kia left office, she filed a complaint with Vermont's Human Rights
00:48:37.560 Commission in 2019 alleging discrimination by the police department and the town of Bennington.
00:48:42.700 An investigation found that the Bennington police chief failed to disclose relevant information
00:48:46.900 about her harasser to her, including his possession of high-capacity firearms and
00:48:51.900 details of an interview that they did with his ex-wife where she expressed concern for Kia's
00:48:57.140 safety. The investigator recommended that the commission find reasonable grounds that the
00:49:01.820 town of beddington discriminated against her on the basis of race and color and the town had to
00:49:06.400 publicly apologize and agreed to pay her 137 000 so yeah they didn't properly investigate it they
00:49:12.480 withheld information that frankly she should have been informed of and they just like didn't take it
00:49:18.280 seriously and yeah when online threats of an online abuse are not taken seriously by people
00:49:23.760 with power dangerous things can happen it can get really really scary and honestly like i am grateful
00:49:30.200 that it didn't come to like actual physical violence
00:49:35.640 that like, you know, it didn't wind up like that,
00:49:38.820 but it so easily could have.
00:49:41.040 Oh, obviously.
00:49:42.120 And it's like, and I mean,
00:49:43.720 essentially she was paid to kind of go away, you know?
00:49:47.220 Yeah.
00:49:47.440 Yeah, there's a settlement.
00:49:48.860 I would argue it's very low,
00:49:50.840 but it's just like, well,
00:49:52.400 that's the cost of doing business 1.00
00:49:54.200 and attempting to be a black woman 1.00
00:49:56.620 in the state legislature. 1.00
00:49:59.120 Like...
00:50:00.200 Or in leadership. Bye. Like, anyway, sorry. It's and I think it's also interesting because you see, again, there's like it's a white people problem. Like I'm reminded of W. Kamau Bell's like, you know, come get your boy when it comes to Trump. And it's in terms of what happened to Kia. It's like it's not a Kia problem. It's a everybody else problem. And you see like, you know, some of the white officials or police officers, folks around.
00:50:25.960 And I think it's like, you know, you guys are the ones who have a lot of work to do. It's a you all problem. It's not a Kia problem. So how is this systemic? And yeah. And also, when are we going to get to the idea that once everyone is liberated, once there is equality, that will mean, or once the most marginalized are liberated, it will mean liberty and equality and freedom for everybody. 0.51
00:50:53.680 Sorry.
00:50:54.240 I've got to practice that part before I run for president.
00:50:57.720 Yeah, I mean, I would vote for you tomorrow.
00:51:00.140 Me too.
00:51:01.120 Thanks.
00:51:01.760 Thanks.
00:51:02.920 Hell yeah.
00:51:04.280 So these stories are obviously heartbreaking, but I also think they show the true cost to all of us of what happens when things like online harassment and abuse just go unchecked.
00:51:15.140 And we know this.
00:51:16.820 This kind of harassment keeps marginalized people from running for office. 0.99
00:51:19.920 You know, I'm sad to say that I think a lot of people will hear about the experiences of women like this, and they'll be like, oh, well, that is just the cost of being a public figure. Deal with it. But we deserve a political landscape where, like, this is not just the cost of wanting to serve your community, especially when that cost is so much higher for the most marginalized among us. 0.99
00:51:38.100 absolutely i mean i think that i think with the latest midterms the fact that like young people
00:51:43.840 came out in droves and that you had you know the squad growing with a lot of young folks and 0.96
00:51:49.360 specifically young people of color we will stop normalizing this kind of crap and because there 0.99
00:51:56.260 will be just more of it because there will be more women in office there will be more people 1.00
00:52:00.260 of color in office which is a good thing but then this is the crap that comes along with it and so 0.99
00:52:04.520 it's like not to mention the fact that younger generations are god i mean from middle school 0.97
00:52:10.200 dealing with online harassment from peers from randos like it's just gone are the days of random
00:52:17.340 aol chats and uh me logging in being like i am blonde sexy lady hello sorry i'm just talking
00:52:26.220 about how i was on the internet as a kid that's how i was too i was like yes that's how i was too
00:52:31.660 Right, right. And you're like, now it's like, oh, no, there's consequences and everyone's using their real name and like people are stalking you and what? Not that that wasn't happening then. But so I feel like especially since young folks are also more Internet savvy and online harassment savvy and experience it, we will arrive at a point, Bridget, and you will be vindicated in all of your work in this show and everything that you've been sounding the alarm on.
00:53:00.100 And I know we will be vindicated, but it's just going to take a while.
00:53:04.440 It's going to give us like a decade, which is too long. 0.98
00:53:08.200 But I feel like we will arrive in another point where this shit is just not as normalized. 0.99
00:53:13.880 Yeah, I actually agree with you. 0.99
00:53:15.400 I think that like, you know, we've seen historic numbers of young folks, women, people of color running for office in this last cycle. 0.62
00:53:22.820 And I just think that we are different. 0.55
00:53:25.760 I don't I don't I don't think that we're going to tolerate this.
00:53:27.980 And I think that we are going to hold people with power, whether it's legislators or policymakers or tech leaders, we're going to force them to, you know, do what they can to create a situation where this isn't the norm.
00:53:43.120 Because this is not a functional democracy.
00:53:47.540 This is not a healthy democracy when this is how the political landscape and the media landscape that people are trying to compete in.
00:53:54.520 It's just not healthy.
00:53:55.460 It's not a functional democracy.
00:53:56.740 And I think young people are smart enough to see that.
00:54:00.260 Totally. And as and our Senate and our Congress are old.
00:54:03.700 I mean, you guys remember you remember when Zuckerberg testified like a few years ago.
00:54:08.280 And it's like you got senators being like, oh, Mr. Zuckerberg, what is the fight stand for in Wi-Fi?
00:54:16.660 Because I think why is wireless.
00:54:20.100 Well, what is the fight?
00:54:21.340 You know, just like, you're like, Mr. Zuckerberg, could I?
00:54:24.780 What is my password? 0.99
00:54:26.740 to my Amazon account, like the most Luddite ass Senate. Right. And that's going to change. 0.98
00:54:35.460 And I think when that change, as we slowly change it, yes, we will hopefully have more protections.
00:54:41.680 Yeah, it's so frustrating to watch those hearings where it's like the people who are in charge of
00:54:45.840 making our policies around technology. Like, I forget who what lawmaker it was, but was like,
00:54:50.040 will you commit to ending Finsta? And what the fuck are you talking about? Like, what are you 0.99
00:54:55.900 saying, sir? Like, what are you
00:54:57.820 saying? And these are the people, like,
00:55:00.380 I mean, it also starts
00:55:01.860 with getting, like, more young people
00:55:03.920 in office, because, like,
00:55:05.940 we just, I mean... Yeah. I was just
00:55:07.860 going to say, and surrounding them, too, you know?
00:55:10.520 Absolutely. Like, supporting,
00:55:11.880 like, get an aide, you know? Ask the staffers.
00:55:14.380 10% of Senate
00:55:15.700 is made up of men named John.
00:55:19.460 That's, like,
00:55:20.080 a real thing. Like, spelled two
00:55:21.900 different ways, but 10% of Senate
00:55:23.920 are John.
00:55:25.900 Yeah. It's a solid name when you're born in 1929.
00:55:31.580 Yeah, when you're a white guy who watched the moon landing, yeah.
00:55:38.840 And so, you know, when it comes to these kinds of attacks and harassment that we're seeing, something I think is really interesting and telling is that it seems like the goal of these attacks is to really destroy marginalized candidates, their resolve, and to get them to internalize this abuse that is directed at them.
00:55:55.800 This is from the folks who did the study at the Center for Democracy and Technology that they wanted that these candidates felt very strongly that the point of this kind of harassment was to just get them to internalize and accept the oppression that they face as women and women of color and just drop out of politics.
00:56:13.400 And so you see that that has an incredibly like silencing effect, you know, and unfortunately, and the research bears this out that these kinds of threats do keep women from running for office or just sort of engaging in public life in general or civic life because they're smart enough to see the way that other women are treated. 0.78
00:56:31.140 They see the way that law enforcement and media really do nothing or make it worse. 0.98
00:56:35.280 And they're like, no fucking thanks. 0.97
00:56:37.020 I don't want to deal with it. 0.98
00:56:38.020 You know, just this afternoon, Nancy Pelosi announced that she's ending her career in politics on the heels of that horrific hammer attack against her husband, who not only was attacked after being attacked, elected officials and like political figures like and Elon Musk spread homophobic conspiracy theories about the attack, joked about it.
00:56:56.500 And part of me is like, I can understand why she's just like, I'm out, you know, when a woman runs for office or is a public figure and she is attacked, it is never just her. It is her partner. It is her kids. It is her parents. It is her community. And I can understand why women are just like, you know, the cost is just too high. I don't want to put myself or my family at risk to run for public office. And so I'm not going to do it or I'm going to check out of it. I can understand that.
00:57:22.200 And so I think if women can't run for public office safely, then we will never have a truly representative democracy or a functional democracy in general. 0.50
00:57:32.480 You know, the author of that report said a lack of representation means that we lose the important insights and solutions to public policy problems that women of color will bring.
00:57:41.360 We will all suffer. We all suffer if everyone does not have a seat at the table.
00:57:45.740 And I could not agree more. Like, it is not just about the women who are attacked and targeted.
00:57:50.720 all of us lose out when we don't even have a shot at a landscape where people can safely
00:57:56.920 serve their public through running for office. Absolutely. I mean, look, I'm not the biggest
00:58:01.920 fan of Pelosi, but I do respect the hell out of her. And what I will say with people like her
00:58:06.480 and also people like Clinton, I wish they would do what Monica Lewinsky has done. And I think
00:58:12.320 that's part and parcel of the fact that Monica Lewinsky is a little younger, but like taking
00:58:15.680 her the public um the scrutiny the harassment what she was put through and using it to actually 0.92
00:58:23.540 try and change the culture and i think that hillary and nancy pelosi come from more of a
00:58:29.420 generation that's like you gotta like go you know basically shut up and get along and like um like
00:58:36.180 whatever it is like get along to go along i'm really terrible with any kind of idioms today
00:58:40.340 but you guys know what I mean like we right and and it's like it's like no I don't think I think
00:58:46.860 we're done with that and I think that young women and all people are done with the like no you have
00:58:51.560 to shut up in order to appease these systems and halls of power it's like no you don't and and so
00:58:57.660 I hope that Nancy Pelosi in her because she's not going to rest this woman's never going to rest 0.95
00:59:01.920 until she's dead like she's going to keep on working and I hope she uses you know um her time 0.98
00:59:08.400 to try and not cut the ladder from out underneath her, 0.98
00:59:11.720 but help young women also accelerate and succeed in politics as well. 1.00
00:59:16.480 She hasn't got a great track record with that, going to be real.
00:59:20.020 She jumped on a little bit of the anti-squad, anti-Ilhan Omar,
00:59:24.240 you know, calling Ilhan Omar anti-Semitic when she totally was not being anti-Semitic.
00:59:29.800 So, Nancy, you know, I hope you do better.
00:59:33.420 Thank you for your service.
00:59:35.060 I agree with you.
00:59:35.820 Like, Monica Lewinsky, she's my white whale podcast guest because I think the way that she has turned something that was, like, meant to silence her and belittle her, she turned it into a platform.
00:59:49.500 And she really changed the conversation about online shaming and online harassment and online bullying.
00:59:55.740 And I respect the hell out of it.
00:59:57.920 Monica, if you're listening, please call me.
00:59:59.780 You're my white whale guest.
01:00:01.780 She did that TED Talk about the price of shame.
01:00:05.060 That's right.
01:00:05.820 And she has a really good – she's in a really good documentary called 15 Minutes of Shame on HBO Max, which everyone should watch, all about online shaming.
01:00:14.220 But, yeah, I agree.
01:00:15.640 I hope that this becomes the kind of situation where women are not expected to suffer in silence and have a kind of, like, poised face because, you know, it doesn't serve anybody.
01:00:28.740 And it's funny because in an interview I listened to with Kia, she was asked, she said that so many people were like, you should just ignore this.
01:00:36.420 You shouldn't stoop to their level.
01:00:37.760 You should just ignore it.
01:00:38.760 And I'm so glad that she didn't ignore it because it started a conversation about what is and is not acceptable in discourse.
01:00:45.900 And, you know, if you ignore it, it just festers and gets more empowered.
01:00:49.820 And so the advice of just saying like, oh, rise above, you know, go high, don't go low, ignore it, you're too good to respond.
01:00:55.980 I don't think that advice is really serving anybody, particularly if you're marginalized or you're like a young person who's coming up on this like online next generation.
01:01:05.420 Yes, absolutely. And I think it's why a lot of people who are harassed incessantly often post those DMs or that harassment or the, you know, air the voicemails that, you know, people like AOC or Ilhan Omar get or Pramila Jayapal, who I believe was threatened as well.
01:01:23.220 Yeah.
01:01:23.440 And it's like, yeah, more folks need to understand this is a daily occurrence before we actually, like, take it seriously. And whether or not Pepe Le Maximich understands it, I mean, he's not getting paid by anybody, but he's absolutely part and parcel of this system designed to, like, yeah, keep women and people of color out of any kind of decision making process over their lives. 0.99
01:01:50.360 Exactly. And I'm so glad that you put it that way because this was my whole intention behind this podcast is that it's so easy to think that when someone is being targeted in this way, it's individual and certainly it has individual impacts, of course, but it's also institutional. It's also systems. It's also, you know, power structures that enable it or, you know, amplify it or profit off of it. Right.
01:02:15.820 And so we need to start picking apart and calling out all of the systems that make this kind of harassment a viable thing for people to do and break those systems and say, we're not going to tolerate this.
01:02:27.120 If you want to engage in this kind of discourse, we're not going to amplify it.
01:02:30.220 We're not going to incentivize it.
01:02:31.160 You're not going to be able to build a platform off of it.
01:02:32.840 And it's not going to be effective.
01:02:34.580 You're going to pay $200 for that DM.
01:02:37.580 Yes.
01:02:38.600 Honestly, I would accept some, like, harassing DMs if I got $200 every time.
01:02:43.660 Yeah, yeah, yeah.
01:02:44.240 Okay, yeah.
01:02:44.800 You got to give me 500 bucks.
01:02:46.820 But yeah, say whatever you need to say to me.
01:02:48.680 SJW, cool, whatever.
01:02:51.020 Ka-ching! 0.99
01:02:52.300 Exactly. 0.98
01:02:52.940 It's like a cameo, but for hate.
01:02:55.260 Yes.
01:02:55.620 Ooh, you need to pitch this to some venture capitalists, Fran.
01:03:00.300 But that's the whole thing.
01:03:01.400 The irony is exactly what you're saying, which is these platforms already pay for—
01:03:07.400 they get that stuff for free.
01:03:09.140 Yeah.
01:03:09.500 They're the ones making money off of the hate.
01:03:11.800 It's going into their pocket.
01:03:13.040 And it's like, I would say, I mean, like, I would argue that marginalized people, we are absorbing the hate to make tech leaders more money.
01:03:22.900 And we need to break that system.
01:03:23.720 It's the externality of capitalism.
01:03:25.940 And that's the thing.
01:03:26.580 What if Google was like, listen, Bridget, if you get trolled, I'll give you $200 every time, like every, like, hateful tweet.
01:03:35.140 That I might, I'd be like, that's, that'd be a good solution.
01:03:38.960 And it would certainly incentivize them to, you know, fix the problem, which is all we're asking for. And I guess this is my, like, overall point. You know, we, especially in the Democratic Party, we love our slogans like, support Black women. Yes, trust Black women. Like, I have a trust Black women shirt. And I am all on board for, like, championing the leadership of Black women.
01:03:59.620 But we can't just say, you know, support black women without also being honest about the unfair racist, sexist attacks and harassment that they will they will probably face when they get into these leadership roles that we like are vocally supporting them for. 0.94
01:04:12.520 And so we need to be creating the conditions so that those women that we love to champion also have a chance at an equal playing field, that we're not just setting them up to be knocked down, to have to like, you know, abandon their office and leave town because of harassment and threats and garbage. 0.97
01:04:29.620 Amen. And we didn't even talk about Ketanji Brown-Jackson, but my mind went to her as well.
01:04:36.200 Yes. Coming soon. Coming soon. Great example. Coming soon.
01:04:40.820 Good, good, good. Awesome.
01:04:41.780 That is all I have, Fran. There is no one else that I would rather have dug into all this with than you.
01:04:49.380 And I appreciate you taking the time after you've, you know, had so much going on.
01:04:54.800 So much going on. Babies, probably. It's been two hours.
01:04:57.920 Time to feed yet again. 0.99
01:05:00.320 I'm going to go soak my aching nipples, guys. 0.99
01:05:04.580 That's your show. 1.00
01:05:06.900 TMI.
01:05:08.260 Deal with it. 1.00
01:05:09.560 We need to support women much more.
01:05:12.940 But yeah, Bridget, this has been awesome.
01:05:15.220 And I mean, awful, but also like people like you are like, oh, yeah, there's hope.
01:05:21.000 There is hope.
01:05:21.600 You make me feel very hopeful.
01:05:22.920 And where can folks follow you and what you're up to?
01:05:25.620 Yeah, dude. Follow me on all things at Franny Fio, F-R-A-N-I-F-I-O. 0.87
01:05:30.560 And then The Bituation Room is a podcast.
01:05:32.760 It's also a live stream every Tuesday, 1 p.m. Pacific, 4 p.m. Eastern on YouTube and Twitch.
01:05:38.240 Yay.
01:05:42.740 Internet Hate Machine is a production of Cool Zone Media.
01:05:45.840 For more podcasts from Cool Zone Media, check out our website, coolzonemedia.com.
01:05:49.940 Or find us on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:05:55.620 I survived nine months in captivity, and I've spent my life exploring how other people survive
01:06:03.220 what should have destroyed them. I'm Elizabeth Smart, and these are The Survivor Files.
01:06:08.820 Every week, I'm with survivors who live through the unthinkable, abducted, stalked, controlled,
01:06:14.640 and nearly silenced. These are stories about what it takes to make it out alive.
01:06:19.820 Listen to The Survivor Files with Elizabeth Smart on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:06:28.200 If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
01:06:33.980 Pro Society is a weekly podcast that's part book club, part group chat for anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
01:06:42.280 Each week, we're connecting the dots between books, the internet, and pop culture
01:06:45.760 with your favorite writers, book talk creators, and plenty of overthought opinions.
01:06:50.540 Yeah, I'm obsessed. I'm obsessed.
01:06:52.300 Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts. 0.97
01:06:58.340 Why do some women yearn for Shakira's black hair to make a comeback? 1.00
01:07:02.800 And whatever happened to the power couple of my dreams, Mariah Carey and Luis Miguel?
01:07:09.140 I'm Maria Garcia.
01:07:10.140 You may remember me from my podcast, Anything for Selena, or My Divo.
01:07:15.000 And now I'm back to unpack more stories from the present and the past.
01:07:19.800 Listen to Muy Excited with Maria Garcia on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:07:27.940 This is an iHeart Podcast.
01:07:30.840 Guaranteed human.