Under the Influence (with Jo Piazza) - November 13, 2025


Guns & Gossip: My So Called Life Rewatch Episode Three

Topics
Rewatch My So Called Life With Me Can Instagram Ever Be Safe for Teens?

Episode Stats


Length

45 minutes

Words per minute

182.13

Word count

8,271

Sentence count

303

Harmful content

Misogyny

8

sentences flagged

Toxicity

24

sentences flagged

Hate speech

13

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 hey y'all joe here and you are listening to under the influence we are back with our second episode
00:00:11.280 re-watching my so-called life and because we just ended up covering episodes one and two
00:00:16.240 today we are talking about episode three guns and gossip which oh my god like does it does it still
00:00:23.700 have to be so relevant right now. I mean, my God. To break this episode down, I am joined by
00:00:31.580 Jennifer Armstrong, who's one of my favorite pop culture historians. She's the author of
00:00:36.400 Seinfeldia, When Women Invented Television, and Sex in the City and Us. Jennifer's critiques are
00:00:42.540 freaking amazing. She has this magical ability to make us see our favorite shows not just as
00:00:47.460 entertainment, but as reflections of who we are, what we value, and how we've changed over time.
00:00:53.700 Which is really what these episodes are about. It's about the nostalgia of going back to the
00:00:57.880 mid-90s and also thinking about how that time shaped us. This episode is a real barn burner.
00:01:03.300 I mean, it does so many different things. We've got rumors about Angela having not just sex, 0.65
00:01:09.340 but complete sex with Jordan Catalano. Somebody brings a gun to school. And 0.99
00:01:14.600 Ricky's story arc truly catches on fire. Let's get into it.
00:01:23.700 Were you a My So-Called Life fan when it was on?
00:01:29.620 I believe I was somewhat, but I don't have as strong a memory of this as I do of 90210.
00:01:37.240 So I think it was like, because I was a little bit older, so it was like, not as much.
00:01:42.640 You know how it's always, it usually speaks most to you when they're a little older than you.
00:01:46.720 Totally.
00:01:47.080 You know, and though I will say, and I'm sure we'll get into it more like my so-called life is unbelievably realistic and so different from 90210. But I still sort of like remember the awe of seeing 90210 for the first time, whereas this was more like, oh, this just seems like this quiet show about this regular girl, which it is. That's what's so cool about it. But at the time, maybe it maybe there's a reason we often have these like sparkly 30 year olds playing teens because they're they inspire awe.
00:02:15.700 They inspire so much awe. And I will tell you, look, I was a 90210 girl because they were older. So I mean, I was born in 80. I'm 45 now. Angela Chase was exactly the same age as I was. And that's not sexy, right?
00:02:30.840 Oh, no, no, no. It's not. It's not as sexy. It's not as sexy, as you said, as watching 30 year olds do ridiculous things in the state.
00:02:39.720 I guess I kind of do get it. It's like, you know, we don't there.
00:02:43.520 There's a reason this thing wasn't like taking the culture absolutely by storm at the time, because it's just apparently we just like our teens sexy and not really teen.
00:02:53.280 And not teenagers at all. My high school boyfriend was super obsessed with Beverly Hills 90210.
00:02:59.820 out he drove a maroon mustang convertible he had dylan mckay's exact haircut i'm not going to post
00:03:06.300 that for people because that's not cool to him but it was the same as dylan and brandon okay
00:03:12.040 and i thought it was the hunkiest i mean i had a i had their pictures on my walls my boyfriend also
00:03:21.160 had that haircut in high school um it just it was like ubiquitous it was like as soon as this hit
00:03:27.940 like everyone wanted to be 90210. So iconic. So iconic. And in fact, my high school superlative
00:03:33.620 was most likely to be Brenda Walsh. I don't know what that means. I don't know what that means
00:03:37.940 either. That's crazy. But I guess congrats. So yeah, we need to do a 90210 rewatch. For sure.
00:03:45.360 For sure. You haven't written a book on 90210. I feel like you've written a book on like every
00:03:48.720 show that I love. So I just have to double check. Not. No, I think it would be interesting,
00:03:53.620 but I won't get into the weeds on this. You know, these books are at least partially based on like
00:03:57.680 interviews with the people behind them. And I think that would be quite the feat to wrangle.
00:04:04.520 It really would. Although I think Jenny Garth would be into it. She's very accessible these 0.93
00:04:09.420 days. Yes. And I don't know if you watched that weird 90210 revisit. Of course I did.
00:04:16.000 That was truly one of my favorite things that's happened of the past decade in pop culture. Like
00:04:20.640 it was so bananas that I could not get enough. And it was so bad. It was so bad. Like it was
00:04:26.600 not good but it was just so watchable nonetheless i know it truly was so okay back to my so-called
00:04:33.660 life although again you'll come back and we'll we'll dig in dig into the bev uh it is about a
00:04:40.540 normal girl and i think that that was it also felt like a little bit of an antidote to 90210
00:04:47.160 for sure because she was so much more accessible to me i'm like oh like i'm not a rich kid and i
00:04:53.280 do live in the suburbs of Pennsylvania her life is actually more like mine than those people so I
00:05:00.380 did I did love it but and we said this when I was talking about the first two episodes I actually
00:05:06.360 think I got more into it when the reruns were on MTV when they were on death all the time correct
00:05:11.260 me too that's exactly my memory as well and I've revisited a couple times since then just as a
00:05:19.740 television critic and expert. And I kind of feel like it just it gets better with age. And I don't
00:05:25.620 know if that's my age or if it's a sensibility that we've come to in television that now we
00:05:30.720 really admire. But I think back then it was like hard to break through when you had those splashier
00:05:36.780 teens elsewhere. Truth. And in fact, I would almost compare my so-called life to like 30
00:05:43.480 something except for 14 year olds no it's no there was we don't do this vibe and i wish i could tell
00:05:49.980 you what it is it's the 30 something vibe it's like they put a 30 something filter on these shows
00:05:55.200 and they just become that and i remember this being such i guess it makes sense 30 something
00:05:59.460 was a sensation this was kind of almost its own genre back then and i always liked it it's kind
00:06:04.880 of the sort of cozy semi-realistic still a little gauzy drama like take i mean takes on some subject
00:06:13.460 but at the same time it just it felt a little homier instead of glitzy right yes when and
00:06:22.700 anytime I rewatch it especially I think it strikes me more it's like I guess it makes me nostalgic
00:06:27.600 and it really like you said even though these exact things didn't happen to me it always makes
00:06:32.340 me think about my own high school time granted it was also in the 90s so there you go um and it
00:06:38.140 really feels I'm just like it just immediately evokes that time for me. And I guess 90210 does
00:06:44.420 in its own way. But this feels like I'm watching my own life somehow, which I clearly they were
00:06:49.480 going for, which clearly they were going for. And I think I got to say, to me, it feels like it
00:06:55.300 holds up. It's still enjoyable to me. How did a rewatch feel for you? Oh, I every time I'm telling
00:07:02.200 you, I don't know if I just forget and then remember again how good it was or if I genuinely
00:07:07.240 feel every time I watch it like it gets better to me because honestly I was like almost screaming
00:07:13.320 at times this time because I was just like I'm mad that this is so good I just think and really
00:07:18.940 of course I mean I'm not even a parent and yet like so identified with the parents now right
00:07:24.600 oh my god that stuff is incredible like I don't think I understood that I don't think I understood
00:07:30.260 how well done no I thought the parents were so boring right it was always like oh god can we
00:07:36.100 fast forward through this part but the mom stuff especially i mean both really in the first couple
00:07:42.320 episodes is so so good and real and is you know the way they're sort of like part of her sort of
00:07:50.060 system of life but also not is so interesting and that talk that mom has with her about like
00:07:58.080 are you having sex with jordan my god i know all right we have to recap what the episode is about
00:08:03.120 really quickly and I found this episode really interesting to re-watch I've watched re-watched 0.97
00:08:11.200 the pilot a few times and I don't know if I've re-watched this one as much as I have the other
00:08:16.220 ones because the gun stuff really punched me in the gut because we live with gun violence
00:08:22.540 every day it's right now right yeah and we talk we talk about it as if it's a new thing
00:08:29.160 but this is a whole episode about a gunshot going off in school and like all of the repercussions
00:08:38.180 of that and i'm like oh my gosh i mean of course of course this was still a thing back then i mean
00:08:43.340 and also there's the famous gun episode of 90210 right so they weren't that's isn't it interesting
00:08:48.400 though because i have the same feeling of like as if we never spoke of guns in schools before
00:08:53.360 Columbine. When Columbine seems like it was more inevitable, it was like now that I'm sort of
00:09:00.540 rewatching this, you know, these snippets of pop culture history, I'm like, this was clearly on
00:09:04.880 everyone's minds. So I think it built to Columbine. But that feels like such a flashpoint test that
00:09:10.580 we forget that we ever talked about it before. Yeah, exactly. Exactly. And so we open in a
00:09:15.980 classroom where the kids are watching this video of President Kennedy's inaugural speech. Angela
00:09:20.700 chases voiceovers i said this i said this in the last episode but i'm like all of her voiceovers
00:09:25.880 could be the lyrics of a taylor swift song oh it's that's she is she's so taylor swift this
00:09:31.500 is really true she is so taylor swift and so she's just like oh this big thing happened when
00:09:37.520 president kennedy was assassinated nothing big ever happens to me also very i was like wow that
00:09:45.980 is such a nostalgic 90s sentiment we would never no one alive now well it's also you know as a 90s
00:09:54.420 baby someone that was you know 14 and 94 then here comes 9-11 we would never get a break after
00:10:01.680 that and so literally never get a break you would never ever say now like oh i wish something big
00:10:07.460 like an assassination would happen that's such i mean and it's not it's not wrong that they said
00:10:11.560 that it's like such a it's exactly the state of mind then it's exactly the state of mind of 1994
00:10:16.960 absolutely absolutely and so you know this this is cuing us up to be like something big is
00:10:23.920 happening to you girl right something big and something big is happening to the whole school
00:10:29.780 and then also to angela so the whole school is that you know they're a gunshot goes off and you
00:10:36.780 know all of a sudden everyone is being questioned and it sends ripples throughout the whole school
00:10:41.260 But then for Angela, personally, people are gossiping that her and Jordan Catalano had sex and not just sex, but complete sex. 0.63
00:10:51.980 There's so much going on in this episode. 0.89
00:10:55.080 This episode is wild.
00:10:57.040 I was like, this is a barn burner.
00:11:00.000 I mean, my God, there's so much.
00:11:02.200 And there's some other episodes of the show that I remember being particularly boring, like the Christmas one.
00:11:08.440 Good sentiment, but boring.
00:11:09.980 Whereas this, I was like, how is there like a gunshot? 1.00
00:11:14.880 You know, we're kind of starting to deal with the gay stuff. 0.96
00:11:17.740 We start to deal with the gay stuff, with Ricky's being queer and the bisexuality is finally coming to a forefront. 0.82
00:11:25.740 I mean, we saw it in the first couple episodes where Angela's mom is like, why is he wearing eyeliner? 0.99
00:11:34.040 And I'm like, just wait until you meet J.D. Vance, girl.
00:11:37.300 I loved it because it is all accurate to the time. And, you know, it's like and she's Angela's answer is like, well, he's bisexual. She's like, bisexual. Why are you talking about this stuff? Right. What word did you just say, my friend?
00:11:51.500 Yeah. But that's how it was then.
00:11:54.620 It's so accurate. It's so, so accurate for the time. And I actually, I got to say, the way that Ricky's storyline unfolds in the show.
00:12:04.820 Yes.
00:12:05.180 I mean, it's actually so well done and so beautiful. And one of the first times, truly, that we saw a bisexual teenager on television.
00:12:13.480 Yes, it really. I actually I did a big cover story in the late 2000s for Entertainment Weekly that was gay teens on TV that had to do with Glee.
00:12:26.460 And we looked at the entire history and I ended up talking to Wilson Cruz, who plays Ricky.
00:12:31.700 And he's a real like, you know, it's hard to say first first because there's always somebody who's going to be like, well, actually, there was this other one first.
00:12:39.800 but in terms of just like it really was a huge watershed moment um for this this was not we did 0.99
00:12:47.580 not maybe we had some gay teens on like soap operas because they were always doing stuff first
00:12:52.040 sure but this is really new at a time network tv yeah exactly exactly and when we had you know we
00:13:00.760 really were still mostly watching network tell you know you didn't have a ton of options somebody
00:13:04.580 was watching it that now these numbers the ratings numbers seem good for the show at the time it was
00:13:10.000 not considered a success but like enough people were watching that this was important oh my god
00:13:14.280 totally all right let's take a quick break and then we're gonna get into the sex stuff yes
00:13:21.040 okay we are back i'm still looking up those ratings numbers but
00:13:32.900 because we started out talking about Beverly Hills 90210, I do want to say that I think sex
00:13:39.100 on My So-Called Life is handled very differently. It's, I mean, it's all a piece of each of their
00:13:45.060 aesthetics, right? I mean, my God, 90210 was obsessed with, like, the virginity.
00:13:53.020 Obsessed with virginity. That whole plot line.
00:13:57.140 the whole she's gonna lose her virginity at the prom and i gotta tell you it made me think i'm
00:14:03.620 like should i lose my virginity at the prom and just i just the whole idea i think a whole book
00:14:09.920 could be written on the storylines of virginity in television since the beginning of television
00:14:15.960 absolutely there's absolutely no doubt about it and this like i had to re-watch recently the donna
00:14:22.340 loses her virginity scene um for being on a a different podcast and my god the like mellow
00:14:31.400 drama and the sort of like you know what i mean like the sort of glamorization almost and i don't
00:14:36.820 mean i mean glamorize losing your virginity but you know like i i guess it is glamorization it's
00:14:43.500 like almost this weird thing of like well you probably shouldn't lose your virginity but if
00:14:47.160 you are going to you should totally have like white candles totally and if you don't it's a
00:14:52.140 massive failure and go to the this fancy hotel yeah yeah exactly and i mean i i mean i think
00:14:58.780 this is this episode with sex is so great i am very i'm like a big fan of you know pro-sex
00:15:05.360 kind of content i would loved the show sex education that was on until like last year
00:15:09.940 such a leap forward from the stuff that we're talking about and you know the frankness with
00:15:16.600 which this is handled many girls have been through some version of this which is like a rumor that's
00:15:23.780 not true really about your sex life i went through something exactly like this you know that i had
00:15:31.260 like french kissed a boy i think and maybe maybe some above the belt petting and then there were
00:15:39.980 rumors going around school that that we had sex i was called a slut meanwhile i'm like in middle 0.88
00:15:44.600 school. Like eighth grade, right? I don't even know. I don't even know what any of this means 0.64
00:15:51.580 per se. I'm being called all of these names. And it was just it was a feeding frenzy. It was so
00:15:57.680 fun for people. Yeah. And I think we see that in this episode. Exactly. Like how the gossip
00:16:04.900 becomes currency in Angela's school. Yeah. And I'm struck all the time watching this show by
00:16:11.700 There's something really unique about, and I'm getting back to this, this ties back to what we're talking about. There's something really unique about the social structures here. This is not your typical like teen movie of the 80s where somebody is trying to jump from like a dork to the popular kids by Cook or Crook.
00:16:29.680 Yes, that is a whole, whole other genre. Right. This is like very much more normal and subtle. We're not she's not really she's not popular. She's not unpopular. She's so normal. She's so normal that it's almost painful.
00:16:43.780 She's so which I guess is, again, the kind of the point she's right in the middle and she kind of like makes minor waves in her life by essentially switching friends in the pilot from this sort of dorkier, nerdier, smart girl to, you know, Rayanne, who, again, she's just fun, but she's not she's not popular.
00:17:04.140 she's not this she's not and they're not really worried about their popularity status and you
00:17:08.540 can't really tell where jordan is on that ladder they're not this school is much more normal in
00:17:14.460 my opinion this was kind of my experience is like we did not have these incredibly you know enforced
00:17:21.500 strata like some same like when we look at a lot of the 80s or 90s teen dramas it's like here's
00:17:28.000 the popular table right or or if you look at the mean girls world which you're very familiar with
00:17:33.200 It was very much this hierarchy of who is cool.
00:17:37.000 And in Angela's school, it's like, I can't tell.
00:17:40.360 Like, there seem to be the alternative cool kids, the kids who drink, the kids who don't.
00:17:45.760 And it doesn't seem like the yearbook kids are uncool per se or unpopular.
00:17:51.720 They're just a different, different crew.
00:17:55.000 That's right.
00:17:55.400 And I mean, this for and again, like sometimes my friends will make fun of me when I talk.
00:17:59.900 They're always like, well, then you were popular.
00:18:01.620 um because I'm like no no no I I was like kind of the yearbook girl you know we didn't it wasn't
00:18:08.200 yearbook in my case it was the newspaper um but like I feel like I really relate to this where
00:18:14.400 it's yeah you just kind of like are doing some things that you like I was on newspaper but I was
00:18:18.740 also a cheerleader but cheerleaders weren't that cool at my school um and it just you know being
00:18:24.420 kind of in that middle where that's not her main anxiety her main anxiety more comes from first her
00:18:30.360 longing for jordan catalano and then her whatever this you know her anxiety over on we oh my god
00:18:39.300 if if anyone my god if anyone has just perfected on way is it one we're on way on we i just said
00:18:46.980 it weird i don't know why because i was laughing oh no i could be wrong i could no it's on we
00:18:50.820 um no it's like that's exactly in the way i mean and frank is obviously very you know serious but
00:18:59.300 I think it's an interesting that they bring in Anne Frank, like comes up repeatedly.
00:19:05.480 And I think that's so interesting because it's another sort of like we all know it's another touchstone where we're like, oh, she's she's kind of a smart kid, really, Angela.
00:19:14.640 But like, that's not the highlight here.
00:19:16.600 But I don't think she's in remedial classes.
00:19:20.440 Well, exactly.
00:19:21.200 Exactly. 1.00
00:19:21.660 She's a smart girl.
00:19:23.360 She likes being smart, too, but she doesn't know if she wants that to be her whole personality.
00:19:27.520 I mean, everything is about her trying to figure out what her personality is.
00:19:31.580 That's right. And I really that's what I liked about it is this is about social change.
00:19:36.060 You know, she's changing her social status, sort of, but I don't like the word status there. 0.94
00:19:40.920 She's trying to change her group. And she says it in the pilot, something about like, you know, like I can't remember how she says it.
00:19:47.160 But she basically says, like, she can't believe how much drama there's been over the fact that she, like, decided to pick different a different friend, a different best friend when she hadn't really given it a lot of thought previously.
00:19:59.980 And then in hindsight, as an adult, you look back and you're like, that was the defining moment of my life.
00:20:04.440 Yep. No, it's that is true.
00:20:06.400 And this reminds me a little bit of it's hard to talk about the show without going back to 90210 or forward to Freaks and Geeks.
00:20:12.980 Yes. And Freaks and Geeks is very, very similar.
00:20:15.880 And it's another reason I loved that show was like in both cases, I really related to this because like I changed schools in my sophomore year.
00:20:23.980 So I had to make all new friends and I made choices so quickly that ended up kind of it did really define the rest of my high school time. 0.97
00:20:32.020 And in my case, I hung out with a bunch of jerks and I was fine with it. 0.97
00:20:35.420 But, you know, it's so it is so hard to just like decide, oh, you know what? 0.98
00:20:39.900 This isn't my best friend anymore.
00:20:41.140 Now it's this person and it can cause ripples no matter who you are.
00:20:45.760 at that age. And it's so interesting how this that really did. I think that's the point of
00:20:51.460 the show is it kind of did change her life. It completely changed her life. It's funny for me
00:20:55.480 because I switched from public school to all girls Catholic school for high school for ninth
00:21:01.320 grade. And because I was kind of a junior high delinquent and I was I was already like not full
00:21:08.980 ran, but much closer to ran in in in some ways. Or I wanted to be the Angela that already hung out
00:21:14.820 with rayon yeah maybe like that's the thing right yeah and so i get to the all girls catholic school 0.55
00:21:19.940 and i had to make all new friends but i was like holy shit i am cool as all out compared to these 0.99
00:21:26.600 bitches um i say that i say that lovingly because i'm still friends with most of them right i'm like 0.99
00:21:31.120 oh no i know how to do this that it's that's the thing is like if you change schools one thing i 0.96
00:21:37.440 like i always had boyfriends from other schools and that gave me this like crazy mystique because
00:21:42.580 they didn't know yeah like people have like people would be like oh we got to go to the basketball
00:21:47.220 game to like see jenny's boyfriend yeah like i had a public school boyfriend right and it's like
00:21:52.980 whoa and he was and he was a little bit older and he was also from my camp i'm just like check check
00:21:57.440 check and he's got this convertible mustang oh yeah yeah just yeah like even though he was the
00:22:03.840 dorkiest human on the planet well that's the that's what's funny too is i was just thinking
00:22:07.860 of how, like, I had this whole cachet at my own, you know, at my own school, and then 0.96
00:22:15.540 it, you know, then, like, but he was not particularly cool at his school, but it didn't
00:22:22.000 matter. They don't know. It didn't matter. They don't know. Exactly. Exactly. Well, which is
00:22:26.620 interesting because this episode really dives into what creates social status. And so Raeann
00:22:33.460 starts saying to angela hey i know you're kind of upset about this rumor but this could be good for
00:22:39.620 you that's right and i think that that's really interesting and i think that's really interesting
00:22:47.140 to me as someone who thinks about personal branding and influencers all the time of like
00:22:53.760 the idea that's embedded in this show about high schoolers about projecting the kind of thing even
00:23:00.640 if it's not true that might increase your status in the world yeah and i don't know about you but
00:23:06.920 i feel like she's sort of she's sort of starting to figure it out for real by the end of this episode
00:23:12.720 that this has happened to her like and then the weird i mean the way that it flips the power
00:23:19.080 dynamic when he's like has this kind of creepy proposal like well we might as well do it anyway
00:23:25.120 um which i laughed at as an adult because i was just like he's not wrong i mean why not just get 0.87
00:23:31.160 it over like points have been made i'm just saying but but also jordan is so dumb oh my god it's i
00:23:39.020 am obsessed with this too like when you re-watch it as an adult because i do remember the impression 0.95
00:23:43.440 that he made on me when i was younger it was intense i was in love with him yeah like he's
00:23:48.160 stunning he's stunning and he's so like a specific type of kid who totally went to your school
00:23:53.860 yeah he did yeah every like every school has this kind of dumb really hot guy where you're like i
00:24:02.280 think he might actually be mostly nice but you haven't had to try at anything and maybe you
00:24:08.340 never will stunning and like the detail i feel like you will appreciate this more than most as
00:24:14.520 like a novelist the detail that he has to he keeps putting eye drops in his eyes oh yes oh my god
00:24:21.180 and and also i still like worship always the passage where she i think it's the first episode
00:24:27.720 where she talks about him leaning oh my god thank you for bringing it up because i think about it
00:24:31.440 all the time how she's just like i just like the way he leans i was like god it's if only i could
00:24:37.380 be so self-aware at that age that that's why i liked a guy that's why i know i know totally
00:24:43.080 yeah i mean he is he is like stunning and an enigma the way that you know a senior old boy 0.97
00:24:50.580 can be but but but watching as a and as an adult you're like you're so dumb yeah like everything 1.00
00:24:58.260 that comes out of your mouth is literally from stupid town oh my god isn't it wait oh i know 0.99
00:25:05.780 we're not supposed to be talking about the first episode but the first episode the first words he 0.99
00:25:10.220 ever says to her is something like it doesn't feel like friday yep yep and then she goes it's
00:25:16.440 thursday and he was like really and that's like their whole conversation that is their entire
00:25:21.480 first conversation and then she's just swooning i just swooning it's like this but it's so
00:25:29.520 relatable because it's it's clearly like that thing that you're just not in control because
00:25:34.860 you're just so hormonal at that time i know i know i'm not saying it doesn't go on well into
00:25:39.860 your 30s either but i mean i would i was i was catalanoing well into my 20s yeah i i i think i
00:25:48.100 was too actually i think that's actually true that especially it's just like for certain times in
00:25:52.360 your life but you know better you kind of know you're doing it when you're doing it later you
00:25:56.200 start it like starts to like tickle the back of your brain and you're like oh yeah say that but
00:26:03.220 yeah no i mean if every every word that comes out of his mouth i'm like it would be best if you
00:26:07.620 didn't speak oh it's and that's what's brilliant is like this show is not trying to hide any of
00:26:13.240 this not at all not at all because as we know Jared Leto is a wonderful actor right we learned
00:26:18.460 this much later like he had to overcome this overcome this but like the writers did his
00:26:23.360 dialogue on purpose yeah it's not him and he's it's just he's so good and we hadn't seen him
00:26:28.180 before that this is what you and also it just feels right it just feels like a guy who looks
00:26:32.600 like that exactly well it is you know it's interesting I've been thinking about the
00:26:36.660 different haircuts of the moon in these shows because you did have the brandon and dylan but
00:26:43.460 then you had the catalano dicaprio those are very similar yeah it's really really true and i'm
00:26:49.640 thinking too while we're talking about him of the difference between him and you know the guys on
00:26:54.420 90210 in terms of personality like of the character like those guys are complete fantasies
00:27:00.160 you know because brandon's like smart and also basically sensitive like he has some
00:27:05.540 faux pas moments but like he's the school newspaper guy who for some reason looks like that
00:27:10.380 school newspaper is always like the smart serious guy right right exactly he's gonna grow up and 0.67
00:27:16.340 like win a pulitzer instantaneously so but then like dylan is one of the most ridiculous and i
00:27:23.080 remember just like dying for him but i love him but oh my god he read it like the beats yep he
00:27:30.100 read the beat poets his mom was living up in um oh my god where was she the peacock the place with
00:27:36.380 the peacocks right out of la right where my my like really rich friend has a house now uh that
00:27:42.140 i'd never that i'd only heard about because iris mckay lived there yes exactly yeah they were they
00:27:47.960 were a different like class of heartthrob i think i mean that one was that one's going full old
00:27:53.980 school like rebel with they were they did not pull any punches on the rebel without a cause of
00:27:57.900 that all but it is sort of like that the literary bad boy is oddly prevalent in the lineage of
00:28:04.600 teenship oh my gosh it's so so is um i do want to say that i found the ratings okay during its
00:28:12.080 original run it was averaging 10 million viewers a week holy crap that's high right like as a person
00:28:18.300 who talks about tv a lot can you like kind of put that in perspective yeah that's that would be very
00:28:22.940 I actually was guessing more like five. And even so, that would be respectable numbers for a show now. By the same token, you know, we had 40 to 80 million watching something like Seinfeld.
00:28:36.520 Right. Right. Exactly.
00:28:37.960 you know so that's what that's what we were dealing with back then is like this show was
00:28:42.680 considered quite a failure um i mean it was our everybody understood that like the critics loved
00:28:47.440 it but no one watched it was sort of the way that it would have been described and it was even on
00:28:51.880 there was a weird like artsy channel that used to do this um programming block called brilliant
00:28:57.460 but canceled and remember that show do you remember that i loved it and this was like
00:29:03.680 the prime example you know one season and out yeah but then it's it's also classic because it
00:29:10.400 reminds me so much of freaks and geeks in like every possible way and then among the ways is
00:29:15.640 this fact that the this cast is just sort of stacked in retrospect but like we didn't know
00:29:23.040 we didn't know but it truly truly is yeah this is the show that gave us claire danes
00:29:28.340 and she's so good here she's amazing she's really always she's already there like that's what's so
00:29:35.840 interesting to watch is like the only reason i think the show probably worked was it's her
00:29:41.380 it's her yeah yeah a hundred percent the rest of the cast is wonderful the writing is very good
00:29:47.260 yeah she carried this show like we were talking about the angst right it's just like it's all
00:29:52.780 over her face all the time and i just and she has to but she has to be this like relatable
00:29:59.180 she can't be too bratty even though she's totally acting bratty but that's bratty i mean i've acted
00:30:05.680 the exact same like exact same way i always think about my god like i don't know how my parents
00:30:12.100 tolerated me no i no idea all right let's take one more quick quick break and when we get back
00:30:16.820 I want to talk about Ricky.
00:30:22.400 Chew on this bold question from Dentine Gum.
00:30:25.920 Is it ever okay to compliment a millennial on their skinny jeans in 2026?
00:30:35.300 Dentine, chew bold.
00:30:41.140 Okay, we are back.
00:30:42.980 So you got to talk to Wilson Cruz about Ricky's character.
00:30:45.760 what did he have to say um you know he this was this was probably 10 years ago and um he just was
00:30:55.480 so proud of this like he was one of the people it was actually really easy to get him on the phone
00:30:59.820 and i remember kind of like doing a dramatic lead about him you know um as the as the like poster
00:31:07.220 boy for this whole concept of gay teens on tv because it really was this you know important
00:31:13.460 moment um you would see later we all we kind of all but consider this standard issue for a teen
00:31:21.160 show at this point that of course you're going to have at least one gay character right probably
00:31:25.180 more and the fact that we would also probably even acknowledge there are multiple ways to be queer
00:31:30.760 right um back then this was a really big deal and i think you know he it's like this happens with a
00:31:37.660 lot of actors who end up playing these important roles which is they kind of just become that
00:31:42.780 you know what I mean so I think it was not super easy for him to sort of get out from under it and
00:31:47.800 then he eventually um really embraced it and I know he has continued to be you know outspoken
00:31:55.440 in addition to by the way he has worked a bunch of you know woke up his IMDb oh I did I did he
00:32:00.740 is a working actor he is a working actor not an easy thing to be yeah you know and I've seen him
00:32:07.860 play gay characters a lot um the good news is we need a lot more of them now and i think it he 1.00
00:32:14.720 really became one of these people who i've seen this it reminds me a lot of um jonathan i cannot
00:32:23.200 think of his last name uh the guy from from mean girls who was not playing a gay character then
00:32:29.900 he played aaron samuels but he has kind of gone on to be the guy in the hallmark movies um and so
00:32:37.920 i think a lot of them from this time end up going through this struggle of like first resisting it
00:32:42.720 or kind of being like oh god now i'm just playing this one guy all the time to kind of really
00:32:47.100 embracing it and realizing i mean most of them have gotten letters and letters and letters and
00:32:52.020 messages saying you know seeing you on tv saved my life so it was really that important then
00:32:57.520 Yeah. Yeah. And and still important. I mean, more important now than ever before.
00:33:04.580 Yeah. That's the other thing about it, isn't it? It's like we sort of almost started to take this stuff for granted.
00:33:09.620 I think we did. I think we genuinely did. And that's that's what the rewatch brought back for me.
00:33:15.820 Yes. That we had started to take this for granted. And now I don't think we can take it for granted and we have to continue to work hard.
00:33:22.440 yes exactly and this just reminded me just talking about this reminded me of this funny thing that
00:33:29.120 it's not funny funny um that happened when i did that piece like i said again that was what like
00:33:33.860 10 or 15 years ago the gay teens on tv thing but um you know i talked to the trevor project i talked
00:33:40.000 to all these people and then when it came out there was some person somewhere whose reaction
00:33:45.300 online was like they or i got a message saying like um complaining that i hadn't quote told the
00:33:50.920 other side and it was like so baffled it was like almost I had to take a beat and be like what are
00:33:55.400 they oh they wanted me to talk to an anti-gay person oh who doesn't think this is good and
00:34:02.080 it's so funny that like in that moment I was so was being so liberal I was being such a liberal
00:34:10.640 media New Yorker that like I was like what do they mean the other side oh oh like I would call up 0.86
00:34:18.820 a bigoted person you would call up a bigot yeah and i'd be like do you hate that there are gay
00:34:25.180 teens on tv please tell me why and that's just to me like suddenly doesn't like that doesn't
00:34:31.660 sound like a crazy story to me that doesn't sound from the current moment from in this in this day
00:34:36.820 and age yeah like i do i i get requests like that too when i talk about trad wives and things like
00:34:45.180 that they're like well why aren't you presenting the conservative point of view i'm like i called
00:34:49.420 them no one wants to talk to me yeah can you even imagine i mean what even would that look like and
00:34:54.360 i'm not gonna start a problem you know what i mean i'm not gonna like call up the anti-gay people
00:34:59.060 and be like would you like to protest this right nice progress that we've had oh my god but no it
00:35:07.240 is it is just such a stark reminder again that like and the show is now i mean so it was 94 i
00:35:13.740 can't do math I'm like 30 years old yeah 30 years old yeah uh and yet we're still going through so
00:35:19.740 many of the same things and Ricky's arc with the gun is that people immediately suspect him
00:35:25.960 for really no reason other than they think there's something a little different
00:35:30.240 about him that they're like you're making me uncomfortable I can't pinpoint why or I don't
00:35:36.120 want to say why out loud and so maybe you're the one that did this bad thing yeah and I think I
00:35:43.260 I actually wondered if you sort of, quote, couldn't get away with some of what goes on here now, which is to say his super interesting point of view on this in the end is that he wants people to think he had the gun because they would be afraid of him.
00:36:00.620 Right. Right. Because he is in such a precarious position.
00:36:04.240 and he he is afraid every day he is he is scared every day that just by being him he could be in
00:36:12.500 danger and he is not wrong i thought i was like wow i truly believe that like someone would twist
00:36:18.660 that into a problem now um but i think right i think they do such a good job with it so i was
00:36:24.640 like a that's i i was really struck this is this is us talking as writers here to some extent but
00:36:30.960 Like, I was really struck by the fact that we essentially had two incredibly subtle, huge twists on what you expect in this episode.
00:36:38.980 And this was one of them. 0.77
00:36:39.960 And the other was, you know, Jordan coming to her and being like, maybe we should just have sex.
00:36:44.420 And her being like, no, both were so interesting because they just weren't what you thought was going to happen.
00:36:50.820 And I haven't seen it done.
00:36:52.960 And both were so make it so much more interesting.
00:36:55.840 Right. Where I went like, oh, he wants people to know or to think.
00:37:00.060 To think so. Yeah.
00:37:00.960 because then he's safer so brilliant and this is also they're they're so subtle with like the way
00:37:07.020 they start seeding in his queerness oh yeah right because they never they don't say i mean they said
00:37:13.280 the bisexual thing so i guess they say stuff but like it's not some big like he's gonna come out
00:37:18.120 moment or whatever it's just there and we and we never see him coming out right thing because when
00:37:24.160 we saw gay characters on television up until this point there was typically a coming out
00:37:29.940 Yep. What year did Ellen come out literally out of the closet? I mean, that's a good question. I can ask. Oh, my God. Ninety seven. So this is before that. So this is pre Ellen. Yeah. And that that's actually huge. It really it really, really is. That's such a good marking point for this, because, yeah, after that, you'll start to get even something I think related is that it occurred to me only recently that like Clueless, for instance, which is 1.00
00:37:59.820 99 has a gay character but they actually don't really totally say it no they don't no they do
00:38:06.520 not um i re-watched it because it's great you know not that long ago and it was the first time i
00:38:11.320 totally clocked that they were i was like oh they're doing this they sort of like started this
00:38:17.520 to some extent in movies that you know the girl's gonna have a gay best friend right but it really
00:38:22.680 it's i guess i clocked away they right i i clocked it because of mean girls because i was like what
00:38:28.720 am I going to say about this character who is truly gay you know and was a really big deal at
00:38:35.480 the time and I realized like well clueless did this but they didn't you know what year was mean
00:38:41.100 girls mean girls is 2004 okay so full 10 years after full 10 years later yeah it's really it's
00:38:49.360 so I don't know it's very interesting to see the evolution of certain you know all this stuff keeps
00:38:55.020 coming up in i mean mean girls wasn't doing gun violence which is probably for the best
00:38:59.280 um best in that situation but you know a lot of the shows end up
00:39:05.780 treading the same basic themes which makes sense and it's interesting to sort of like
00:39:11.680 then you can you can chart them by these you know by how these shows handle it and then there's also
00:39:18.080 like two axes of teen shows like we've been talking about there's the like glitzy rich ones
00:39:24.020 and there's the grounded regular ones and the normies yeah and they're really very very different
00:39:30.760 and this is obviously in the grounded regulars along with like freaks and geeks and you know
00:39:36.440 one of my favorites Degrassi the next generation um you know those are they they handle all the
00:39:42.860 same issues but like well I don't think freaks and geeks did good pilots either if they were on
00:39:48.380 longer um but you know i think that's it's so interesting to see how they handle these things
00:39:54.200 and this one just really seems like it was ahead of its time i don't know what i would have made
00:39:57.880 of this back when i originally watched it yeah no i mean i don't i actually like i said i don't
00:40:04.180 really remember watching this episode the way that i remember watching other ones which is
00:40:09.460 which is very interesting to me am i having a total mental block did was there a gay character
00:40:14.960 on 90210 in the bed i'm sure somewhere i don't really remember there was probably at least like
00:40:21.760 a kid who was like maybe this there for a little bit maybe you know how they would off like a lot
00:40:27.020 of shows would do this they'd they'd have like a token a token kid on yeah it'd be like my cousin
00:40:32.320 is visiting and then they'd be like oh my god he's gay and then he could leave and then he can leave
00:40:38.020 and it's not not a cool storyline would i just yeah i don't know if that's something that the
00:40:42.240 90210-iverse really dug into a lot. I mean, it was a lot more virginity, although they had the
00:40:50.020 Scott episode with the gun. Right, right. You know, I just feel like I would remember if there
00:40:56.100 were a prominent gay storyline. Yeah. But we should be wrong. This is a thing that I have
00:41:03.020 not read. Oh, you know what? There was this is so classic there. I believe there was one kid
00:41:07.880 who was a quote friend of dylan who quote worked at a youth center okay yes it's very just like
00:41:15.060 classic you know i mean where they just sort of like we like we just said you know it's this
00:41:22.180 scrappy kid from the wrong side of the tracks and he brings up an issue and we can talk about it and
00:41:27.560 then it's over and then we're done and then we're done talking about it right focus on brenda's 0.94
00:41:30.880 virginity again right right if we're if anyone was going to be pregnant it was going to be like 0.80
00:41:35.140 a cousin visiting and that's totally so we don't have to see it let's not see it no right no that
00:41:40.420 is not that's not how we're gonna do this show um yeah no i just i i love ricky's storyline i
00:41:46.700 think wilson cruz plays plays him so well so well and i i i do think that this is one of ricky's
00:41:55.540 best episodes to be honest i think yeah i totally agree there's i do feel like at times and it's
00:42:00.700 just because it's because of the time and like no one had been this was so groundbreaking i feel
00:42:05.180 like at times it can get a little heavy-handed later later on oh yeah yeah yeah you know the
00:42:10.620 christmas episode was yeah i don't i don't know what that that felt like i don't know what they
00:42:15.820 were doing it's so funny that it was it's burned deeply into my brain um sometimes somebody just
00:42:22.880 wants to do something and they're gonna do it and it doesn't even really match the rest of the show
00:42:28.900 I think that way about every bottle episode of every television show.
00:42:32.080 Yeah.
00:42:33.380 Yeah.
00:42:34.000 It's just like somebody got to be in their bonnet about something.
00:42:36.700 And I think in this case, it's well-intentioned.
00:42:38.800 I feel like it's like homeless youth and stuff.
00:42:42.700 Which was actually well-trod territory.
00:42:46.780 Yeah.
00:42:47.260 If you want to bring up DiCaprio again.
00:42:50.000 Yes.
00:42:50.400 Throwing pains.
00:42:51.160 That's everyone's favorite.
00:42:53.280 Everyone's favorite homeless youth.
00:42:56.800 Leonardo DiCaprio.
00:42:57.800 Everyone.
00:42:58.340 I mean, I would I would actually say that it's kind of a tie between Ricky and and what was DiCaprio's name on growing?
00:43:05.780 I do not remember. I can totally remember him and his cute little face.
00:43:09.600 So cute with his little face.
00:43:10.720 Oh, my God. He looked like a little angel.
00:43:13.060 He's a little angel.
00:43:14.680 Little angel doing all over the sea verse.
00:43:17.400 That what that's like when those shows would do this stuff.
00:43:20.940 That's a whole other very special episode.
00:43:22.900 Yeah.
00:43:23.500 Like my so-called life felt like a very special episode in every episode.
00:43:28.340 Whereas like you would only get it once in a while on Growing Pains or Mr. Belvedere.
00:43:32.480 Right. And they'd be they were even more guilty of what we're talking about, which is that token guest character.
00:43:38.140 Who you never see again.
00:43:39.440 You would you cannot believe how many people can visit you who have very heavy problems.
00:43:43.600 Serious. Who will overdose on heroin while they're visiting your house.
00:43:47.660 While they happen to visit you. But sometimes like the Beach Boys come by.
00:43:52.560 Exactly. And that's a different kind of special episode.
00:43:54.800 Right. It's like they all meet, they all both have heroin addict visitors and meet famous people in their living room.
00:44:02.100 Exactly. I think that is a great place for us to go up, Mike. You're coming back for the Christmas episode.
00:44:06.920 All right.
00:44:07.720 Obviously. Thank you so much for being here. I loved having you.
00:44:11.220 You are such a wealth of knowledge about TV and movies and all the things I want to talk about all the time.
00:44:16.980 I love it. It's great to talk to you.
00:44:24.800 Thank you.
00:44:54.800 Thank you.