00:00:00.000Hey all, Joey here and you are listening to Under the Influence.
00:00:10.540Now just in case anyone wanted a reason to feel old today, or older perhaps, I want to
00:00:19.140tell you that the television show My So-Called Life premiered 30 years ago.
00:00:26.16030 freaking years, my friends, 30 years since Angela Chase said she just likes the way that
00:00:32.540Jordan Catalano leans. Just likes how he leans. Yeah. I was exactly the same age as the character
00:00:39.800of Angela Chase in that show back in 1994. And I freaking loved it. I loved it when it first ran.
00:00:46.080I loved it when it was in reruns constantly on MTV. It's one of the first shows I remember
00:00:51.540watching and being like, oh, oh, this, this is like my life. Wow. Wow. I went back and rewatched
00:01:00.680the pilot, and then I ended up binging the entire series. And I posted about it on social media,
00:01:07.220and a lot of you said, hey, what if we did a whole podcast rewatching my so-called life?
00:01:12.320To which I replied, I've got a podcast. Let's just do it here.
00:01:15.840Today, I'm joined by Emily and Esme from the podcast Stuck in Stony Brook to revisit this perfect one-season wonder.
00:01:24.580Come back with me. Come back to 1994, a time before texting, a time with lots of flannel, and a time when watching a boy lean against a locker could change your life.
00:01:35.760guys I feel like I got into a DeLorean and time traveled back to 1995 after watching
00:01:50.840re-watching the premiere of my so-called life it definitely it definitely has that effect
00:01:57.200it does so many things I just I thought we were going to talk about the first two episodes today
00:02:05.460and we might, but I have so many thoughts on the show generally and on episode one
00:02:12.140that I just, I don't know if we're going to get to episode two.
00:02:16.280Yeah, that's fair. There's a lot. There's a lot to say.
00:02:18.820There is a lot to say. Now, I want to set the scene a little bit.
00:02:22.420My So-Called Life premiered in 1994. It ran until 1995. There were 19 episodes.
00:02:29.040I was the exact same age as Angela Chase was in the show.
00:02:34.320Where were you guys in time when this show came out?
00:07:47.520And that's why I think it is so seared into our collective memories because of those MTV reruns.
00:07:53.620Like we didn't just see it once the way.
00:07:55.600Like, I mean, I did see a lot of episodes of 90210 only once until they started rerunning much, much later.
00:08:02.800But this felt more visceral because it was on MTV all the time.
00:08:07.980I did read in an article that it took them two years to do the first run because they would only pick it up like six or five episodes at a time.
00:08:17.280So even from the get go, it wasn't like a full season of episodes that they agreed to, which is really interesting to thinking about that.
00:08:23.940like the fight for that time slot or whatever exactly exactly and i gotta say i do think that
00:08:31.900some of that reticence was because it was a show that was so focused on the inner life of a young
00:08:37.620woman absolutely absolutely you've got these tv execs who you know then and now still mostly old
00:08:46.340dudes who are like i don't get it i don't i don't get it uh and so i do think that that was
00:08:53.020some of the issue with it. And some parents were concerned about it because of its very
00:09:00.100honest depictions of alcohol use, drug use, sex. A lot of parents were disturbed by that
00:09:08.620in the 90s. Another thing to note about this show was that it was one of the first shows
00:09:16.260to fully champion an openly queer character.
00:09:45.780Yes. Yes. And so that is it. So we've got let's do our cast of characters here. OK, we've got Angela Chase. She is Claire Danes. This is Claire Danes breakout role. And frankly, watching it now, you're like, this is still Claire Danes today. She ugly cries in exactly the same way, to be honest. OK, so we've got Claire Danes. She's playing Angela Chase.
00:10:06.000She's a 15-year-old girl living in the suburbs around Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
00:10:10.540And, you know, her whole life, she's kind of been this, like, good girl.
00:21:37.580I thought also, too, the, like, Patty as a parent is linked to Patty as a wife in an interesting way, right?
00:21:45.620Like she and I thought the discussion of the dad like kind of anticipates some of the contemporary discussions around like male loneliness or whatever, like crisis of masculinity, this idea that he is resentful in some way because of her success and because of the way that the typical balance of power is kind of skewed.
00:22:06.360But then Patty's also like mad at herself when she acts like a typical mom, but she does have that instinct, right? Like, oh, this kid is trouble, but like, I don't want to be like my parents. I don't want to do things the old fashioned way. I don't want to be only a mom and not also like a woman who's successful and whatever.
00:22:24.800So I thought that that was actually really nicely rendered and like a very thoughtful treatment of like what's difficult and lonely for her about her self-understanding, self-concept as a mom, but also as a wife.
00:22:40.860And I think you're so right that we see kind of the prelude to the male loneliness epidemic.
00:22:48.460Or dare I say that the male loneliness epidemic has always been, has always been.
00:22:53.220And now we're just finally paying attention to it, to be honest.
00:22:58.080Like, I don't think men ever, like, traveled with big groups of bro friends and, like, called up their friends and talked about their emotions.
00:23:05.900No, but when they all had a wife at home, they would go to the bar after work or they would be on their bowling team.0.89
00:23:14.500when the woman's job was to do everything in the house, they had more of an external social life0.61
00:23:22.600in third stasis. But that's been gone a long time. That was already gone in the 90s.0.95
00:23:26.980It was. It was. But you're very, very right that, you know, the rise of women both in the
00:23:32.400workforce and then the rise of women as the breadwinner, which you know that I'm fascinated0.99
00:23:37.320about uh has given men less time to or less perceived time to essentially just fuck off0.99
00:23:46.780yeah fuck around fuck around yeah exactly um i mean god bless god bless but that it is the0.99
00:23:57.220relationship between angela and her father is very interesting because she loves him she idolizes him0.99
00:24:01.980but she also feels sorry for him she's like he just wanted to be a chef and then he couldn't0.99
00:24:06.820because of my mom it's her fault it's her fault stupid babies yeah how do you get patty gets0.99
00:24:13.020blamed for everything but that was also very true and i related to it so hard because i blamed my0.99
00:24:19.580own mother for literally everything when i was 15 years old right so like all of it rings true0.96
00:24:26.480as a 15 and i did like i said i time traveled in a delorean to this time um i felt like a goddamn0.52
00:24:32.84015 year old again i really did i'm gonna after i after i take a shower i'm gonna put on some
00:24:37.180flannel today yeah and some doc martens because everything old is new again too it's a great day
00:24:43.780for it here in new york city i don't know about where you are but yeah no this feels like a nice
00:24:48.780day for some flannel and some doc martens absolutely absolutely uh and the fashion the
00:24:53.760fashion is so top-notch it truly is perfect it's perfect we all wanted all of angela's clothes or
00:24:59.760If you didn't want Angela's clothes, you wanted Raeann's clothes.
00:28:52.800And then that's when the teacher asks Angela to talk after class.
00:28:57.400And Angela has also the same thoughts that I had about teachers when I was 15.
00:29:01.060like it's so embarrassing to watch them eat and to see their bra straps yeah the bra strap one
00:29:06.700sent me I was like oh my god are kids this brutal yes but then I had some flashbacks and I was like
00:29:14.380oh no you were worse I think oh we were worse we were worse and then I'm looking at that teacher
00:29:18.480I'm like that core underpaid teacher it was just she's just trying she's just trying so hard she
00:29:22.700wants to make sure this student isn't falling behind she agrees that Rayanne Graff is a bad
00:29:26.960influence yeah i um there's a couple really good ones in in episode two as well so uh at the very
00:29:36.000beginning after i've been kissed three times angela is talking about not wanting to throw
00:29:39.900herself at jordan and rayanne says people throwing themselves at people is like the basis of
00:29:44.240civilization it is which i don't know what you think about that as a political scientist emily
00:29:50.680but i think it's not too far off i mean some people i think that's the basic the basis of
00:29:56.480like the realism paradigm and international relation. It's Hobbes. It's Machiavelli,
00:30:06.360arguably. Yeah, I think there's there's roots there. Wait, can I can we go back to Anne Frank
00:30:11.540for one second? Yeah, of course we can. Yeah. Is the idea of being stuck in an attic for three
00:30:15.980years with your crush something that you think is like appealing or does that sound terrible
00:30:22.740to you personally i mean i think if you're stuck in an attic with jordan catalano for more than
00:30:27.820two hours you finally realize how dumb he is yeah it's true he would not be your crush for very much
00:30:33.200longer no he sure would not okay that would that's ending real quick three years is so excessive for0.97
00:30:39.680that to be like lucky hi the 15 year like here's where i'll come in with the like development
00:30:45.520knowledge like a 15 year old doesn't really know what three years is like like like seventh grade
00:30:50.360is a million years away from from 10th grade she's not thinking about she's just like all the
00:30:54.960time i need because i can't make this happen right now because i can't make this happen right now
00:30:59.560but she does make this happen at the end of the episode because jordan finally notices her
00:31:06.560and i want to talk about that because i again when i was 15 i was like this totally makes sense and0.89
00:31:13.340back if i if i go through my memory i'm like oh yeah you were doing this shit when you were 150.96
00:31:17.260years old. I'm horrified now as a mother. Horrified. She tells her mom that she's going to sleep at0.99
00:31:22.740Raeann's. Her mom is upset about it because she doesn't know Raeann's mom. And the truth is,
00:31:28.220Raeann's mom's not even going to be there. And they're also not sleeping there. They're going
00:31:32.400to a club that some guy named Tino is going to get them into. Tino's the best. And a great name.
00:31:38.380Tino is the best, okay? Like, Tino is the ubiquitous, like, well, Tino's going to be there.
00:31:42.780Tino knows how to do this and it is such a classic world without phones because Tino never shows and
00:31:51.600they have no way to contact Tino right and I actually love this scene because it shows the
00:31:59.360boredom but like the beautiful boredom of not having phones so they're waiting for Tino to
00:32:05.480show up they can't get in the club because they're children yeah and they're drinking out of a whiskey
00:32:11.140bottle, too. Like, they're slugging down whiskey. And Angela and Rayanne get drunk and alone. And
00:32:18.680we're with Ricky, just sitting in this alley, just talking because they got nothing else to do
00:32:23.180and nowhere else to go. And I loved it. Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. I mean, and I think this
00:32:30.220is a parallel with the Babysitter's Club, too. A lot of the things they get into, they would never
00:32:33.720get into if there was the internet and phones. It's, you know, all of these things happen in a
00:32:39.180world where that those things don't exist so you have to I love the phrase you use beautiful boredom
00:32:45.220you have to just figure something out and the only people you have to entertain you are your friends
00:32:49.940and you just sit there and chat that's the thing like they're not looking at instagrams or tiktoks
00:32:54.820they're just they're chatting about who has prettier ankles to be honest and yes yes that
00:33:01.040that exquisite boredom is just so delightful it truly is so then they try to get into the club0.70
00:33:07.000And these like, oh, gross old older guys come out who are probably like in college. Right. And they're disgusting. They're so disgusting. And Rayanne is like, we should go off with them in their car. And I'm like, oh, my God. Oh, my God. Oh, my God. I'm like, I want to die.0.97
00:33:22.920as i'm watching this it's terrifying uh and angela doesn't know what to do she's hesitating
00:33:29.380ricky's like it's okay you can go i don't want to be trouble and the guy assaults rayann right
00:33:34.540there in the parking lot like sexually assaults her in the parking lot and the police end up
00:33:39.340intervening and rayann and angela get taken home in a cop car yeah and angela's excited by the
00:33:46.660whole thing because this is the moment this is something is happening like she that is what she
00:33:51.060said she's like something is finally happening in my life and jordan sees her get put in the cop car
00:33:56.000and is like i know that girl and now she is cool i know she's cool and all of this made so much
00:34:05.580sense to me as a 15 year old girl i was also really struck by the less the like nostalgia
00:34:12.240for beautiful boredom but like the specificity of being in trouble because nobody knows where you
00:34:18.500are like that was so pre-cell phone and such a like my experience of being a teenager getting
00:34:25.660in trouble like the biggest trouble you can ever be in is to not be where you said you were going
00:34:32.120to be and for your parent to not be able to find you that's like the the pinnacle of that
00:34:38.780pinnacle of trouble absolutely absolutely and but also it made me think about how much overkill
00:34:46.220like how much like excessive information we have in our lives and good example you know be my five
00:34:54.000year old was at a play date with another little five year old and their mom yesterday uh and a
00:35:00.340play date like 10 blocks away and the mom texted me updates like every 10 minutes like oh i'm gonna
00:35:06.720i'm gonna warm them up with some hot chocolate now we're getting on the bus soon we're on the
00:35:10.200bus now and i'm like i don't need to know any of this right no thank you no no no thank you of
00:35:14.580course, I'm going to look at it because I'm like, oh, I should now I should respond when I desperately
00:35:18.740want to not be on my phone. Right. Like I'm trying to be off my phone more often. And yet I'm like,
00:35:23.620I don't need real time updates. Go have a play date with my kid. Like it's insane to me how much
00:35:30.380information we have about them all the time right now that I do not actually want. Yeah. Yeah. That's
00:35:35.700fascinating, too, because you can imagine it starts as like a politeness thing like, oh, I don't want
00:35:42.000you, the parent who's in absence, thinking that I'm like being sketchy or being rude or being
00:35:46.940weird. And then it just becomes this like, you know, excess proliferation of something that
00:35:51.880probably nobody really wants to be doing in the first place. She probably doesn't want to be
00:35:55.400doing it either. Nope. No one wants this. Nobody wants this. Now, all right. My last question for
00:36:03.760you. Did this pilot make you want to keep watching the show? Emily. Yes. I'm very excited
00:36:11.680to get to hang up not to hang up but to after i hang up go watch episode three actually um episode
00:36:19.080two like sent me to the parents like ballroom dancing the the like metaphor of like science
00:36:26.860experiment as like a way to think about sociality i was like this show is so good yeah yeah there
00:36:33.660were like 13 metaphors in episode two well all right you you guys clearly want to talk about
00:36:38.700episode two let's do let's do episode two right now give me a recap of episode two okay in episode
00:36:44.640two um there's a controversy in school that's like we have to figure out this science project
00:36:51.780and they have to be in pairs and so angela gets paired with her awkward neighbor um i just forgot
00:36:56.960his name brian krakow yeah i also can i talk about brian krakow for a second because i thought he was
00:37:03.000just like the nerdiest nerd of nerd town when i was 15 years old and watching him now i'm like
00:37:07.260he is the cutest he's look he's so cute he is cute as a button he's so smart he's so funny
00:37:13.680i'm like i'm watching it as a mom i'm like you should date brian cracker uh-huh yeah which
00:37:18.580patty agrees with you yeah she does yeah because patty patty has a lot of common sense
00:37:23.120and then like the the parent plot is that patty and graham are both separately kind of like oh
00:37:30.060our marriage isn't as sexy as it used to be and patty's like maybe she's talking to her friend
00:37:35.380And her friend's like, this is going to sound silly, but you should do a ballroom dancing class.
00:37:38.700And then she floats it to the dad and he's like, that sounds really lame.0.76
00:37:43.060But then he's talking to his younger brother, who's kind of like a playboy.
00:37:46.460And the brother is like, you guys' marriage seems solid.
00:37:49.900And then he, of course, doesn't, you know, persuade him otherwise, but then goes back inside and is like, we should maybe we should check out that class.
00:37:57.000And so much of the episode is them in the class.
00:38:00.400It's like 20 full minutes of a 43 minute episode.
00:38:03.860they're like in a ballroom dancing club i know doing very badly doing very badly which i found
00:38:09.680so cringe even as an adult okay like i'm enjoying the adult storyline so much more now but i found
00:38:15.300this very very cringe then and now yeah yeah yeah okay i had one question uh when they're doing the
00:38:23.160heart vivisection the teacher says students who are opposed can opt out was that uh like a thing
00:38:32.240in the 90s or was that like a precursor to kind of the the sort of like trigger warning practice
00:38:38.480or like do they have to do that now do kids have to do dissection still and what's the like
00:38:43.780practice on some sort of opposition to it so i think i'm the only one with teenagers in the house
00:38:50.720i have no idea they do do do them now and they do have to have uh you know a real reason to not do
00:39:00.760which in Berkeley California you can imagine a number of kids do so if they do then they have
00:39:06.660to do an alternate assignment and this was exactly the same in the 90s because you know we're in you
00:39:11.820know we're just post save the whales save the rainforest the animal rights like PETA's getting
00:39:16.240big so there were definitely kids in my school that were like I'm opposed to you know and then
00:39:21.160you'd have but they would always the biology teacher would always make the alternate assignment
00:39:24.080really hard so it was like there was a disincentive to not do the dissection that's so crazy because
00:39:29.880i remember like opting out of sex ed was the easiest thing in the world but i don't remember
00:39:34.460any biology teacher ever being like you can opt out of this dissection if you want so i was like
00:39:39.280whoa yeah pittsburgh is so yeah well i do think i will say i think that there we're seeing the
00:39:47.000start of a lot of progressive things in this um you know in episode one where ryan gets assaulted
00:39:53.780by the guys in the parking lot and angela comes home in the police car and brian crack i was like
00:39:58.240what happens and angela kind of starts telling him he's like you mean like sexual assault
00:40:01.460so like they're starting with this language and but and when they use it it's almost like they're
00:40:06.780testing the waters with it yeah trying to see what they can say what commentary they can make
00:40:14.960how it works in the world it's yeah it's it's it's it's really well and i think that the scenes
00:40:20.720in school are so well done. I mean, the show was really a precursor, I think, to shows like The
00:40:28.660O.C. and Gossip Girl. For sure. Even more so than Beverly Hills 90210 was. Yeah, I really think this
00:40:37.540is in a separate category because there was nothing that was realistic that really felt
00:40:43.360like high school fells. Like you said, 90210 was aspirational and we knew that they were phonies.
00:40:49.660You know, we knew there were grownups. We knew there were grownups in kids clothes. Well, and and OC and Gossip Girl were also both very aspirational, like, you know, rich people, big houses. Yeah. All the things. Right. But at the same time, I do think that they had a little bit more real teen drama than, you know, the adults play acting as children in Beverly Hills, 90210.
00:41:12.700Absolutely. Yeah. I also read both of those as a little bit more self-consciously social satire. So like there's really real parts and then there's super exaggerated parts for the purpose of kind of like offering a critique.
00:41:25.500yes yes exactly well and also so my so-called life is truly you know one of the last shows
00:41:34.560one of the last teen shows without cell phones and and not social media because
00:41:40.320i was seeing gossip girl didn't have social media but they had texting and texting was such a big
00:41:44.020part of it and blogs were such a big part of it so i my so-called life also feels like the first
00:41:49.300show that is truly offline or like the first of these these teens i mean it feels like the last
00:41:54.620of these teen shows that is truly offline yeah yeah well and i think they even had cell phones
00:41:59.700on 90210 because they were rich kids right so exactly they had some cell phones but nobody in
00:42:05.440this pittsburgh suburb is going to have cell phones no exactly so you can't get a hold of
00:42:09.140anyone um it is surprising i think a couple people on the show probably have beepers i had a beeper
00:42:13.640in 95 very cool very i was pretty cool guys i was i didn't get a beeper till college joe so