Under the Influence (with Jo Piazza) - June 04, 2026


Royals Were the Original Reality Television Stars

Topics
What Killed the Girl Power Movement? Sunday Nice Things: Family Money

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

161.96

Word count

6,657

Sentence count

255

Harmful content

Misogyny

24

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 Hey y'all, Jo here and you are listening to Under the Influence.
00:00:09.500 Do you love a story about female friendship and ambitious women defying all expectations 0.92
00:00:14.120 society sets in them? Well then the Parisian heist is for you, my friend. I promise you're
00:00:19.440 never going to look at a Van Gogh painting the same way. Grab your copy of the Parisian
00:00:22.940 heist today for you and five of your favorite people. Okay, now on to today's episode. Today
00:00:28.940 I'm talking with another historical fiction author that I just love so much, and I have so
00:00:33.640 much respect for her. Melanie Benjamin is a New York Times bestselling author. I adore every story
00:00:38.880 that she writes, whether it's about Truman Capote's swans, the Mitford sisters, or one of the many
00:00:44.080 women in history who has been reduced to a footnote, much like Joe Van Gogh. We don't let
00:00:49.540 women be footnotes here on Under the Influence. We sure don't. We write entire books about them. 1.00
00:00:55.720 Melanie's latest book is The Windsor Affair, and it's about the story that rocked the world
00:01:00.640 almost 100 years ago when the king of England abdicated his throne for Wallace Simpson.
00:01:05.440 And we're going to get into all of that backstory, but what I want to talk about first is why are we
00:01:09.140 so obsessed with royals? And I think it's pretty simple, to be honest. I think it's because royals
00:01:13.760 in general were the world's first celebrities and first influencers. Because long before there
00:01:19.600 were Kardashians, reality stars, or trad wives. There were kings, queens, princesses, and princesses
00:01:25.320 living their lives in a very public way. We only wear white wedding dresses because of Queen
00:01:30.860 Victoria. I mean, that's bananas to me. People copied what they wore, they followed their
00:01:36.200 romances, they obsessed over their scandals, and they constantly argued about which family
00:01:40.700 members were villains and which were the victims. All the way back to Greek mythology, the Arthurian
00:01:46.100 Legends, and then Shakespeare's Time, Royal Families have been the original reality shows
00:01:50.120 and the original influencer ecosystems. So Melanie and I are going to talk about all of that. And
00:01:56.440 then we're also going to talk about the very juicy details of the Windsor Affair and how it compares
00:02:00.460 to the scandals of the Royal Family today. Hello, Melanie. How are you doing? Oh, I'm great today.
00:02:13.120 Thank you for having me, Jo. I'm so excited.
00:02:16.320 I'm so excited that you're here. Before we even dive into more of the history,
00:02:21.060 why do you think that we're so obsessed with royals?
00:02:25.080 We don't have that kind of built-in resentment that many British might have or built-in reverence for it.
00:02:33.120 Right, right. We get to look at them just as, like, characters, right? Like, as celebrities.
00:02:37.840 And there's celebrity, and then there's history behind the celebrity, right?
00:02:42.080 you know this permanent which makes it which maybe maybe even makes it feel less trashy right
00:02:46.220 but it's like history making and has attracted viewers from the time of shakespeare oh i mean
00:02:56.440 you know shakespeare's whole entire thing was basically the british royal family for such a
00:03:01.040 long or other royal families for such a long other royal families yeah well unpack that a little bit
00:03:05.680 for me, actually, because I just watched Hamnet on the plane last night. And, you know, that's
00:03:12.100 obviously Denmark. But I was thinking about how so much of what Shakespeare wrote was based on
00:03:21.560 royal family shenanigans and almost like watching The Crown today. Yeah, it is. And, you know,
00:03:29.240 there's that somebody called my book real housewives of you know of great britain right you
00:03:36.700 know i mean there is that thing too that it is a reality show i guess it was probably the first
00:03:42.540 reality show you could say you know yes yeah i think the royal the royal the royals were
00:03:47.880 yeah two things right there one the first reality show and also two the first influencers because
00:03:55.360 people looked to what they were doing to then you know how they should dress how they should
00:04:01.140 act i think about queen victoria's wedding dress all the time all the time influence
00:04:05.120 of streams we got from because of queen victoria and british elbert i mean the influence is there
00:04:10.340 and um the influence still is there every time kate wears something you know from zara or whatever
00:04:16.080 sells out immediately um every you know megan mark i don't think megan markle is as much of a
00:04:21.420 fashion influencer as kate yeah i don't know i mean i think i don't i don't think she sells out
00:04:29.460 as much as kate but i think i think people are still looking looking at her fashion for sure
00:04:35.360 she's like deliberately chosen this very minimalistic almost boring personal clothing 0.98
00:04:43.400 style yeah but she but megan was also an early influencer she had one of the first celebrity
00:04:48.880 see her thing is more lifestyle you know is what i'm saying versus fashion is is kind of what i'm
00:04:54.960 saying um i'm not i'm not denying her influence in the world but i think it's more and it's in
00:05:00.320 a different arena than sure what did she wear because she's also not out in public as much
00:05:05.800 as kate right so the opportunity for her to make an impact in the style world is not as much there
00:05:12.240 But yes, yes, they were their original influencers.
00:05:15.780 I am not a massive Royals watcher.
00:05:19.380 And yet this story, the story of Wallace Simpson, like I've been obsessed with it since I first heard it maybe 25 years ago.
00:05:30.920 And I assume everyone knows it.
00:05:32.700 But sometimes I find out that people don't.
00:05:34.200 And I'm like, oh, my God, let me tell you this.
00:05:36.300 And now I can just hand them your book, which is just going to be a lot easier than me having to launch into the whole epic story.
00:05:43.960 For our readers who are not familiar, can you talk a little bit about the affair that literally rocked the entire world?
00:05:51.020 Yeah. So this happened 90 years ago now.
00:05:55.100 90 years ago.
00:05:56.560 It really is.
00:05:57.100 yeah saying um and it happened uh king the then prince of wales david as he was known to by his
00:06:05.340 family um who was who was going to be king when his father king george v kicked off which was
00:06:11.400 going to be any any day now he fell in love with a married american woman named wallace simpson
00:06:17.180 and now he was known to love americans and fall in love with married ladies quite a bit
00:06:23.420 He was bucking tradition. He was not settling down. He was not marrying a royal princess and having children the way he should have been doing by this time. He's in his 30s. Glamorous, dashing, all the girls wanted him. And then this American woman, Wallace Simpson, waves her hand and he comes running. And at first, everyone was like, OK, well, this is just going to be another one of his affairs because he did that a lot. Right.
00:06:48.120 Everyone expected that he would either keep her on the side or just dump her like he'd done the others and marry suitably and settle down.
00:06:55.520 He did not.
00:06:56.500 He fell completely, crazily, obsessively in love with Wallace Simpson and decided to abdicate the throne once he became king for the woman I love.
00:07:07.280 Because the government would not let him marry a divorced American woman at this time.
00:07:12.700 But the monarch has always been the head of the Church of England.
00:07:17.680 And in 1936, the Church of England was very conservative and very much against divorce.
00:07:24.120 Well, yeah, of course.
00:07:26.380 But also, I mean, this is kind of, and correct me if I'm wrong, but very similar to there was no way that Charles was going to get to marry Camilla, even if she got divorced, when they had been in love for so long.
00:07:38.260 And he had to marry Diana.
00:07:40.660 Yeah, I think.
00:07:41.960 He married Diana.
00:07:43.140 So by the time Charles and Diana got married, though, I think they had started to loosen up divorce because Princess Margaret had already been divorced by the time Charles and Diana married.
00:07:57.060 So when this is why famously Princess Margaret Margaret was not allowed to marry her true love, Peter Townsend, because he was divorced.
00:08:04.620 but when margaret married tony armstrong jones and their marriage was hell and finally the queen
00:08:11.600 allowed divorce in the royal family but uh i think charles was not going to be allowed to
00:08:17.120 marry camilla because i think it was more about the virgin thing with him you know what i mean
00:08:21.020 i think that they were didn't think that i mean obviously camilla got married so
00:08:25.920 you know she was not available at the time but i think she was just more of a worldly woman and
00:08:32.000 They didn't think she was a proper royal bride the way the virginal young Diana was.
00:08:37.800 But then, obviously, later on, you know, divorce just hit the royal family, you know.
00:08:43.380 Anne and Charles and Andrew and Fergie.
00:08:46.700 I mean, it's just, so it's now more acceptable.
00:08:50.000 But back in 1936, it was not. 0.80
00:08:52.340 And this was an American to boot.
00:08:55.060 And she was older. 0.72
00:08:56.920 And so there wasn't, you know, it was just she was wrong in every way.
00:09:00.380 but he gave up the throne he abdicated um and sent them into this lifelong exile
00:09:06.400 of a really shallow lifestyle and she was forever yoked to him because she couldn't leave
00:09:14.020 the man who had given up the throne of england for her you know you that's an impossible position
00:09:19.100 so you can literally you can you can never leave you can never leave the man who gives up the
00:09:23.600 throne of england for you like you're stuck forever she knew it a lot of people look at them
00:09:29.300 as this amazing iconic love story and that is definitely how the american press of the time
00:09:36.100 depicted it uh but it i think you know what i'm exploring is you know that it wasn't and that um
00:09:44.040 i don't think she ever really wanted to be married to him even as she probably got her eyes a little
00:09:50.920 her head turned a bit by his promise of, I will not be crowned without you by my side. So I think
00:09:56.480 there was a part of her that started to buy into this narrative that maybe I can be queen, but I
00:10:01.160 think she was always the more practical, realistic one in that couple. And then on the other side of
00:10:06.420 the coin, you had his younger brother, Bertie, who was a Duke of York and his wife, Elizabeth
00:10:14.040 Bo's Lion. When David abdicated, Bertie became king. He was never supposed to be king. He wasn't
00:10:22.920 raised to be king. He and his wife and their two little girls, Elizabeth and Margaret, they lived
00:10:28.680 a very happy life kind of on the back bench of royalty. And then they were thrust into the role
00:10:34.420 of king and queen of England. And I think for the betterment of history, you know, for sure,
00:10:39.500 it was a good thing that happened but it wasn't what they sought but elizabeth i think knew very
00:10:45.540 early on she would be a very good queen and she could rise to the occasion but she hated wallace
00:10:50.540 then the rivalry between the two women is my book and it was a juicy epic historical
00:10:58.100 lifelong feud i mean it actually is royal mean girls right and i want and i want to dig 0.71
00:11:05.360 dig into that feud. But first, let's take a really quick break.
00:11:16.280 Okay, we're back. I do think that so much of this, you know, mythology around it has been so
00:11:24.800 focused on, isn't this romantic? He gave up a throne for her. And it's like, it's such a male
00:11:31.980 centric narrative instead of, you know, what did she give up? You know, was was this the happy
00:11:39.100 ending, you know, that they made it out to be? And who was she to begin with? Right. Yeah. I did
00:11:47.840 try to bring her backstory to light in this because I think I very much informed her actions.
00:11:53.640 I mean, most people, most British people, I will say, who were not part of the circle of the
00:12:00.560 then prince of wales they saw her as an american social climber a schemer um someone who was 0.62
00:12:09.440 predatory uh taking away their king from them you know they she went she had to leave the country 0.96
00:12:17.340 when the british press finally broke down their kind of silence around this and what people don't
00:12:25.220 understand is for months before the abdication the foreign press knew what was going on and was
00:12:31.280 posting articles and photographs of the king of england with this american divorcee but the
00:12:37.720 british press was not they were protecting their king um and then finally when the scandal broke
00:12:44.340 she had to leave the country they were so angry with her but i think wallace um there is some
00:12:51.280 sympathy to be found she was born in baltimore her parents both of them were from fine old
00:12:57.220 southern baltimore families society but her mother married a younger son and um they didn't
00:13:03.540 have much money and her father died when she was just a baby and so for the rest of her young life
00:13:09.680 she and her mother were very dependent on her uncle soul uncle uncle solomon to give them
00:13:15.180 money and lodging and when he was very not generous in that way and her mother tried various
00:13:22.920 ways to support her in walls but always she had to go back in bed for money to go to a private 0.96
00:13:27.840 school like everyone else in their society money to have a debutante ball like you know her cousins 1.00
00:13:33.080 had had she was constantly relying on men to to give her stability and um you know and a place 1.00
00:13:43.120 society which she was really born into and then she married her first husband was alcoholic and 0.96
00:13:48.680 abusive um and she couldn't get divorced for a very long time because her family wouldn't accept
00:13:54.140 it and wouldn't give her the money to do it and then she finally did and then she married another
00:13:58.560 man ernest simpson who could give her a little bit more i mean so i think the story of wallace
00:14:03.440 is the story of a woman who he lives in a time when she can't get these things herself right
00:14:09.780 And of course, I mean, it's a it's a it's a woman. Yeah, it's a woman who, like so many women then couldn't have agency or success or sometimes even purpose without yoking herself to a man or even getting out of an abusive marriage without, you know, without her uncle, you know, who ultimately refused to give her the money and refused to give his blessing.
00:14:33.500 And she had to, you know, to years and years to extricate herself from that because of the men in her life refusing to do it.
00:14:41.180 It was just, you know, so I think we have to know that a lot of people compare Wallace Simpson with Meghan Markle.
00:14:48.040 I was just going to bring it up. I was just going to bring it up.
00:14:50.260 OK, you know, Meghan was a successful entrepreneur and an actress. 1.00
00:14:56.420 And she did not need men to give her things in the way that Wallace Simpson did.
00:15:01.260 You know, so I think some of the comparisons you can't avoid, but I think you have to understand there are big differences, too.
00:15:08.700 Oh, absolutely. Absolutely. And I mean, I say this all the time. I'm actually a big Meghan Markle fan. I think she's great. And I actually love their love story. I truly do.
00:15:18.220 But are there similarities, even though we're talking about, you know, two completely different time periods, in how the British press treated the two of them?
00:15:27.500 um well they're the racial component with megan you cannot ignore you know that is such the big
00:15:33.160 thing because she's not you know harry is not king he's not he wasn't going to abdicate the
00:15:38.260 throne for megan you know he he he is um he's a i think he's very much like his uncle though to a
00:15:45.820 great great great uncle and so um i do think there's a there's a thing in my book where
00:15:51.380 queen mary says that it's the windsor women who are the strong ones it's the windsor men are weak
00:15:57.660 and are either made or broken by whom they marry and i think that's all very true which i love
00:16:04.880 you love it so much yeah i mean you see that you can see that in all the generations of windsor men
00:16:09.220 including charles um and i think harry you know look megan markle was never going to be queen
00:16:16.320 I mean, she never wanted to be queen.
00:16:18.280 I never think she wanted that.
00:16:20.320 But she did want to, I want to say there's an American thing, right?
00:16:25.280 An American energy, an American, you know, questioning and seeking.
00:16:30.200 And, you know, why can't we change things that the British are not comfortable with,
00:16:33.840 especially in the royal family?
00:16:35.300 And I think in that way, Meghan and Wallace are probably similar, right?
00:16:39.340 But it's just, Meghan didn't need Harry to give her the riches and the jewels,
00:16:43.540 You know, the way that Wallace needed a protector, a rich husband, you know, in a way.
00:16:51.640 So I do think that Harry and Meghan, I have to believe theirs is a true love story in a way.
00:16:59.360 I want to think it is. I don't know why I want to think it is, but I do. I do. I really do.
00:17:05.520 I don't think Harry really wants to be a member of the royal family.
00:17:08.600 I mean, it obviously was born that way, but I think he, it was completely wounded by his mother's death, you know, devastated and broken.
00:17:17.620 And here comes, here comes a strong woman to kind of like provide that figure to him.
00:17:22.660 And I truly think that was part of the appeal of Wallace as well, you know, and even Bertie with Elizabeth, both of those, the older Windsors.
00:17:32.700 now i'm going back to talk about the david and birdie um in the 1930s they they they needed a
00:17:39.920 mother's love and they didn't have it their mother was not particularly maternal didn't like babies
00:17:45.680 they had a very uh horrible nanny when they were very very tiny like from infancy to like three or 0.99
00:17:52.540 four who physically abused birdie at least almost to the point of starving him to death because she
00:18:00.260 favored david and then she would pinch david whenever he was in the presence of his parents
00:18:05.660 to make him scream so he would come running to her and there are allegations she sexually abused
00:18:10.580 the young princess and finally another nanny finally told queen mary what was going on and
00:18:16.580 they finally got rid of her but i i think you cannot discount their abusive you know very
00:18:23.200 hard young childhood and i think they both sought mother figures and found them and i yeah there's
00:18:30.920 a parallel there with harry you know yeah no that makes that makes so much sense i want to switch
00:18:37.120 tracks really quick um just to to ask you a question and again this you know and then whenever
00:18:43.900 there's any kind of drama in the royal family it has the chance to change history you know we would
00:18:51.160 not have had queen elizabeth ii have the abdication if 1936 not happened you know so it's not just
00:18:59.880 brothers against brothers the way it is still today in that case brothers against brothers
00:19:05.640 altered the the the line of secession yeah yeah and that's such an interesting point i mean that
00:19:13.540 one just kind of like smacked me in the face these dramas do have the ability to completely
00:19:19.500 changed history had we not had Queen Elizabeth on the throne. I mean, can you think of the
00:19:23.880 alternate history? Now, that's a novel that could be written. Right? I mean, everyone would have
00:19:29.240 accepted Wallace Simpson had he just kept her on the side as a side piece, right? I mean, it was
00:19:34.480 like, that was expected of kings back then, right? His grandfather, Edward VII, had famously, you know,
00:19:41.940 had mistresses all over the place, but married a suitable person. And then even after he abdicated
00:19:48.300 and then Elizabeth Bozelyan and her husband Bertie became King George VI and Queen Elizabeth,
00:19:55.420 there was still an expectation they might have children. And had they had another, more children,
00:20:02.180 other than Elizabeth and Margaret, and had they had a little boy, he would have been king,
00:20:07.080 not Elizabeth II. Because at the time, it was very much based on gender. Now it's not. They
00:20:14.080 changed the rules but back then you know had her parents had another child and that child been a
00:20:20.020 boy king queen elizabeth would not act on the throne so i also i also think a lot about the
00:20:27.000 history of world war ii would have been completely different had king edward the eighth and queen
00:20:34.980 wallace been on the throne you know i think right that would the outcome would have been different
00:20:40.680 and um you know you kind of think thank god for the abdication in that case because i truly
00:20:46.800 truly don't know that germany might have been defeated had there been a king edward the eighth
00:20:53.040 and queen wallace on the throne of england i don't think so oh why why do you think that
00:20:57.960 well because we know now they uh they well so the stain of wallace and edward beyond the
00:21:06.740 abdication, which so many British could never forgive him for, right? I mean, what's the point
00:21:11.260 of divine right if you can just chuck it all if it doesn't suit you, right? But he and Wallace
00:21:17.560 met with Hitler in, I think it was 1937 or 38, before the war. They admired Hitler. They were
00:21:27.020 on the record of saying Great Britain is on the wrong side of this. They need to side with Germany. 0.99
00:21:36.740 and part of that was the memories of world war one um which david um who became you know the
00:21:46.300 former king who became the duke of windsor he witnessed he wasn't he wasn't in battle the way
00:21:52.160 birdie was but he they wouldn't let him but he witnessed the horrors of war so i think part of
00:21:57.360 it was that but then during the war uh the germans the nazis famously had a plan drawn up we know
00:22:05.760 this. There are files now. If Britain was defeated to set up, you know, Wallace and David to be back
00:22:17.500 on the throne, and they would be puppet king and queen. And in fact, they were hoping David would,
00:22:23.620 you know, knowing of this plan, would actively then try to get his brother basically to surrender.
00:22:31.420 We don't know 100% for sure if Wallace and David said yes to this plan. Pretty sure they knew of it. And David did say on the record he thought it was okay for the Germans to blitz London, resulting in the death of, you know, millions of his former subjects, if it meant Britain would surrender to Germany and end the war.
00:22:56.960 so this we know and uh you contrast that to the king and queen on the throne during world war ii
00:23:06.280 george and elizabeth they they became the faiths of british resilience and you know they they
00:23:12.640 visited every bombed outside and buckingham palace actually was bombed when they were in it
00:23:17.580 they they i think the war made them as monarchs and forever like solidified them as the most like
00:23:26.440 beloved monarchs ever, right? And defied Hitler. And so you can't help but say, well, thank God
00:23:34.480 the others abdicated. Who knows what history would have been like?
00:23:40.080 That's a book I would also read. Okay, let's take a quick break. And when we get back,
00:23:44.420 I want to dig more into this real housewives of the UK and the royal family in this time period.
00:23:56.440 Okay, we're back.
00:24:03.360 So I think that the feud between these two women is much more interesting. 0.58
00:24:08.940 And not because I love a feud between women.
00:24:11.780 I think that the press creates feuds between women all the time.
00:24:14.820 But because this was, you know, this was an actual feud, but it also tells us so much about who these two women were.
00:24:23.600 Just give us a taste of what of what created this feud and and then how this feud actually impacted history.
00:24:31.240 Well, Wallace was always that woman. 1.00
00:24:35.100 Elizabeth refused to speak her name and Wallace nicknamed Elizabeth Cookie.
00:24:40.180 This was an era of extreme that she made.
00:24:45.260 And Wallace took it to an art form, I think.
00:24:48.680 They loathed one another.
00:24:50.840 I think initially when they first met Elizabeth, I mean, Elizabeth met her probably before she was David's mistress because Elizabeth was close to David's mistress at the time, another American, but she was married into British gentry.
00:25:08.300 She was a lady, Thelma Furness, and was never going to, she was never going to marry David.
00:25:14.000 She didn't have that aspiration.
00:25:15.660 Whereas once it kind of became evident that Wallace wasn't going to say no, that David wanted to marry her, that's when the feud became real.
00:25:26.300 And David really broke protocol and inserted Wallace, this at the time still married, divorced woman.
00:25:34.160 He just kind of shoved her down the throats of his family, taking her to court when it really wasn't appropriate, presenting her at court and just every, you know, entertaining with her, ensconcing her as the hostess of his private home, the Port Belvedere, just throwing her in their fate in a way he had not really done with previous mistresses.
00:25:55.140 So I think that is what started it. The royals were very traditional. Queen Mary and King George were appalled by their son's behavior. They saw him getting more reckless with Wallace, more blatant, more reluctant to do his job.
00:26:12.440 and and the entire royal family then very much took a dislike towards wallace but elizabeth i
00:26:20.020 think was the most affected because she could see that if this continued down this path suddenly her
00:26:27.400 cozy little domestic life is going to be upended and her husband who was not a strong man at that
00:26:34.520 point was going to be king and she was horrified by this and also felt betrayed by david's behavior
00:26:40.880 so she immediately and she you know she was american wallace was american and the opposite
00:26:45.980 of elizabeth in every way wallace was divorced she was stylish she was thin she to the point 0.90
00:26:50.700 of anorexia she as david was too she wore you know fashionable fashionable clothes she danced 0.97
00:26:56.360 at nightclubs till dawn and elizabeth was the english rose you know the mother of two adorable
00:27:01.840 little girls wearing her chintzes her flounces and enjoying her scones with tees and and and
00:27:09.940 just, you know, so they were immediately, they were so different. But yet what I found as I was
00:27:16.780 writing the book is they were so similar in many ways. Both strong women married to weaker men,
00:27:23.360 both really smart, really ambitious. But Elizabeth kind of cloaked her ambition in a little more, 0.98
00:27:30.520 I'm going to say, quote unquote, acceptable, traditional way versus Wallace being a little
00:27:35.400 bit more blatant about it. So they just took this instant dislike to each other and they saw each
00:27:40.780 other as rivals and they saw each other as enemies because Wallace saw Elizabeth as perhaps the
00:27:46.520 strongest person opposing her from taking the throne. And she accused Elizabeth, I think, of
00:27:54.380 spying on her and David, which I think Elizabeth probably did. She thought Elizabeth manipulated
00:28:01.820 the press in Elizabeth's favor. And I think Elizabeth probably did. Versus Elizabeth looking 0.67
00:28:09.040 at Wallace and seeing her as this divorced American who is going to take away their beloved 1.00
00:28:14.940 king or turn his head or make him do things that he shouldn't. And there might have been some 0.51
00:28:20.680 jealousy there. Maybe Elizabeth had a little crush on David when she was younger. Kind of right about 0.74
00:28:25.680 that i think she might she might have so they were just they just they were like two different
00:28:31.540 rivals at court they each had their own team your team was you were team elizabeth yeah and i mean
00:28:39.540 again i don't want to keep comparing this to megan and kate and i don't know if there's a necessarily
00:28:46.680 a comparison in real life but i think there is a comparison again in how the media likes to
00:28:54.060 portray and then also caricature women and put women in boxes you know Kate she's a mother she's
00:29:01.840 very elegant she's she's a princess even though she was a commoner uh and then you know Megan
00:29:08.480 she's an actress she's edgy right like and that's that's not even getting into the racial component 1.00
00:29:14.220 of it but you know in the press these two women have been pitted against one another but then also
00:29:20.360 just completely separated into like what kind of woman are you yeah yeah and this it's very again
00:29:28.060 i think this is where the strongest parallels are to wallace and ozbeth elizabeth boselyan and
00:29:34.620 pate middleton represent i think that more traditional the more i want to say again
00:29:41.780 quote unquote acceptable feminine strong but cloaked in femininity woman that is more acceptable
00:29:49.640 to those who want their royals to continue to be very traditional, right? You know, the mothers,
00:30:00.360 you know, with the beautiful family and their fashions are very similar too, I think. You know,
00:30:06.740 they're not cutting edge. They're not going to, you know, going to be wearing the hottest designer
00:30:11.600 labels um and then you have wallace and megan who american lots of energy divorced which again to 0.91
00:30:19.940 some people means something um kate was never divorced um women who were a little bit more
00:30:25.880 cutting edge more modern more more of their time you know and wallace wore all these crazy
00:30:32.620 schiaparelli and chanel um you know cutting edge fashions versus elizabeth who just was never going
00:30:41.540 to rock a boat in that way and i see that with kate today as well and um so yeah i mean i think 0.62
00:30:47.240 you can't deny they're all strong women that the americans are just a little bit 0.54
00:30:55.000 more modern and naked louder louder yeah the americans tend to be right look and i think 1.00
00:31:03.640 that's an asset in a lot of ways right you know versus then you've got third the the women who 1.00
00:31:10.000 are going to not rock the boat traditionally, who are not going to push, are not going to
00:31:17.120 question, they're going to do the job and they're going to do it very, very well, but
00:31:21.020 they're going to, they're not going to upend the monarchy and try to modernize it, which
00:31:26.260 I think was a great fear about Meghan in a lot of ways, too.
00:31:30.400 So, yeah, those, again, similarities.
00:31:33.500 Again, yes.
00:31:34.080 I mean, just what is old is new again and history repeats itself.
00:31:38.740 And this is not to disparage any of the women. I think they're all strong. I think they're all swell. But it's just that it's just interesting that 90 years later, the public opinion still veers.
00:31:57.060 and again this is manipulated by the press coverage veers toward the more traditional feminine
00:32:05.820 thing versus the strong woman girl boss thing yeah no no exactly and again even even as we're
00:32:17.340 talking about this we're also in so many ways still talking in archetypes right it's like we
00:32:25.460 men can be anything, any number of things. In fact, most men are, I think a lot of men are often
00:32:33.640 weaker than women and less competent than women. And yet they just never get categorized the way
00:32:41.820 that women do. No, we're still there. We're still there. In some ways, things have changed. But I 1.00
00:32:49.340 mean, I'll really honestly, when you when you look at the press coverage of these poor women that
00:32:54.040 we're talking about right now, it's then it's not changed at all. It's not changed at all. And so
00:33:00.480 that actually takes me right into my next question for you. How did you research this book? And so,
00:33:06.120 I mean, did you read all of the press from this time? Were there any people that you that might
00:33:11.440 not have been alive at the time, but they're experts in this? Like, who could you talk to?
00:33:16.060 And also, that sounds like so much fun. And I am a huge Anglophile. Okay, I love
00:33:21.720 British history I've you know I'm obsessed with I loved the crown except for the last season
00:33:28.100 uh you know um so I know this history like you know I'd read there's a there's a wonderful
00:33:37.180 biography of Queen Mary who was the mother of these two kings um that I'd read a hundred years
00:33:43.380 ago I mean my bookshelves are full of British history I love it so this was not new news to me
00:33:49.580 None of it was. So I tended to write novels, historical novels that are set in a time period
00:33:57.640 or about historical era that I do know quite a lot about. So I'm kind of starting on a higher
00:34:04.400 level. I'm not having to start from scratch. I hadn't read any biographies of these two women.
00:34:12.020 I mean, you know, the crown does touch on the abdication more of its aftermath, much focusing, you know, solely on David, not Wallace. 0.97
00:34:22.860 And a lot of that is true.
00:34:24.320 You know, the bitter resentment that the royal family had toward him forever.
00:34:28.040 And Elizabeth blaming him and Wallace for the premature death of her husband, Bertie, in 1952.
00:34:36.140 Wasn't that 52, 53, something like that?
00:34:38.140 um so but i did read then i found several biographies of the women and i found it
00:34:44.320 fascinating because depending which biography you're reading wallace is either the jezebel
00:34:50.040 of all time or the most romantic victim of you know the establishment or elizabeth is the saint
00:34:59.640 of all time or a master manipulator i mean it's so funny they're either saints or sinners depending
00:35:05.680 on which book you read so i thought that was to me that's like oh that's where i wanted to write
00:35:10.000 the book because they both have these different these two different kinds of of faces and so
00:35:18.560 which one was the real one and i think as always the truth is somewhere in the middle but i think
00:35:23.560 neither of them were saints and neither of them were entirely sinners uh of course because we're
00:35:30.560 not just one thing, but again, you know, everyone wants to, you know, you know, and look, I admit
00:35:36.340 even part of the publicity of my novel is Team Wallace or Team Elizabeth. I mean, we all love a
00:35:41.340 juicy feud, right? And I think you want to. So we're kind of like asking that question in the
00:35:46.840 publicity of this book. But but like I said, the truth is somewhere in between. There was a British
00:35:53.260 a pbs miniseries back in the 70s the king and mrs simpson i think it was and it's a very delicious
00:36:02.100 you know dramatization of the abdication basically that elizabeth is hardly in it it's all wallace
00:36:09.780 and and david uh so that was to me i think you know elizabeth kind of is never really the main
00:36:16.160 player in any of these dramatizations of this particular thing that happened and i think she
00:36:23.120 she really was the leading player she and wallace were the leading players of this and and responsible
00:36:28.080 for everything so i uh wanted to bring that up so then went to london but that was just mainly fun
00:36:33.920 because i love to go to london but i know right i mean i went to i went to paris for parisian heist
00:36:39.160 twice and i went to paris for mysteries of the ritz yeah so much fun to be able to travel for
00:36:45.080 research uh well i i also i love that book so much and i'm actually i think i'm i'm gonna do a
00:36:51.340 giveaway of that one with Parisian Heist. I want to try to couple it up with other books that I
00:36:57.040 love that are set in Paris. There are a lot of good ones. Yeah, there is a lot of good ones.
00:37:01.840 That is something that is to come for our audience. I shalt be giving away many Parisian books.
00:37:08.900 But any excuse to go to Paris. I love Paris. Any excuse to go to Paris.
00:37:13.800 I don't talk to people when I'm researching my novels. Okay. Yeah, tell me more. Tell me why.
00:37:18.820 I don't want anyone else's opinion or take to influence mine.
00:37:25.180 I'm very guarded in that way.
00:37:28.140 And one of the things that is weird about me is that I don't do as much research as you think I do.
00:37:38.040 Because if I over-research something, if I truly read every single thing written about these people,
00:37:45.420 everything written by these people every newsletter whatever it somehow stifles my imagination
00:37:51.400 and my imagination is my greatest strength because what i am doing is trying to you know
00:38:01.860 make these people real and help us understand what they might have been thinking behind the scenes
00:38:08.020 of the things that we know we know they did these things but what were they thinking when they did
00:38:12.840 what was the reasoning that went up to what were they feeling what was the emotion how did it impact
00:38:17.080 their daily life that's the stuff that a biographer cannot do that a nautilus can and so i i find that
00:38:25.340 i have to just kind of i have to find a really sweet spot in the research where i have enough
00:38:30.720 to know what i'm doing what happened you know when did these things happen and actually the
00:38:35.700 timeline of the abdication and everything was like you know i had to write it out also i gotta tell
00:38:41.520 my mother loves this book because she is a real nerd okay and she is completely obsessed with it
00:38:47.660 i cannot say enough about it uh will you tell everyone where they can find you yeah just go
00:38:52.560 to my website melaniebenjamin.com that's the easiest place i have you know some events for it
00:38:57.200 i'm always happy to meet with book clubs if you know your club wants me to zoom in just there's
00:39:03.080 a place on my website for book clubs and we're also giving away some goodies for two book clubs
00:39:08.440 who are choosing any of my novels there's a whole lot of background about the book that
00:39:14.280 it's just like a little little extra juicy stuff um and also to kind of maybe help you
00:39:19.740 keep these characters straighter there's a little bit more backstory about
00:39:22.860 the monarchy from victorian victoria's time on um that's on the the website um i'm on substack
00:39:30.720 follow me there the reluctant extrovert uh and i also have a podcast i do my friend edward
00:39:36.240 kelsey moore called who the hell are we where we talk about books and movies but yeah yeah so you
00:39:41.680 can my website is the place to go for all information all the things all the things
00:39:46.400 i loved talking to you my mom is going to be so jealous uh this was this was wonderful i hope you
00:39:51.360 come back for the next one
00:40:06.240 Thank you.
00:40:36.240 Thank you.