Under the Influence (with Jo Piazza) - September 15, 2026


The Lone Liberal on Fox News Wrote the Book on Disagreeing Better

Topics
How Can We Save Child Stars ? Would You Buy Sydney Sweeney's Underwear? And a New Royal Tell-All Can a Chatbot Love You Back?

Episode Stats


Length

43 minutes

Words per minute

181.7

Word count

7,964

Sentence count

367

Harmful content

Misogyny

14

sentences flagged

Toxicity

29

sentences flagged

Hate speech

6

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 Hey y'all, Jo here, and you are listening to Under the Influence.
00:00:09.700 So today we are talking to someone that I think has one of the weirdest jobs in American
00:00:13.920 media. 0.98
00:00:15.420 Jessica Tarlov is the lone liberal on Fox News' The Five, which means that five days 1.00
00:00:21.220 a week she sits at a table and argues in front of millions of people who mostly do not agree 1.00
00:00:26.560 with her.
00:00:28.040 I actually think this makes for great television.
00:00:30.000 It also makes Jessica the perfect person to write a book called I Disagree, Winning Arguments Without Losing Friends.
00:00:39.360 Jessica gets asked the same question a lot from people from both parties. 0.99
00:00:43.620 How does she do this job without losing her freaking mind?
00:00:47.520 This book gives some of the answers, and I think it's a really great read for a lot of us right now who truly believe that civil discourse has ended up in the dumpster fire of American media and social media.
00:00:58.200 And we really all need to figure out a way to just freaking talk to each other again.
00:01:03.700 I love this conversation with Jessica.
00:01:05.540 I am convinced that if we went out for a spicy margarita, we would be very good friends.
00:01:10.340 I also think that this book, I Disagree, would make an awesome book club pick with some of
00:01:15.000 the people that you actually disagree with.
00:01:18.320 Because we have to figure out how to disagree better.
00:01:20.140 We have to figure out how to talk better.
00:01:21.700 We have to all figure out how to live in this crazy world together.
00:01:24.860 And I think this book is a really great first step.
00:01:28.200 hey jessica how you doing i'm great how are you i'm good i'm good i mean there are a thousand
00:01:40.400 things that i want to talk to you about i mean we could go in so many different directions i love
00:01:48.800 your new book i disagree winning arguments without losing friends and this truly is the ultimate how
00:01:56.240 to guide for navigating. I mean, what I think is just that we have kind of an undercurrent of
00:02:02.820 conflict in our lives, in our society, in our culture right now, all the time. And this is a
00:02:08.520 how to guide to do it with grace, which is something that you learned very well on Fox
00:02:14.800 News's The Five as the lone liberal voice on a panel dominated by conservatives. Talk to me about
00:02:21.220 how this book came about. Yeah, so it's kind of a two-part story. So there have been folks in my
00:02:28.860 life or people who reach out through social media or send emails for as long as I've been at Fox,
00:02:35.040 but really the last five-ish years when I've been co-hosting the five who say, I don't know how you
00:02:41.480 do it. And this is Democrats and Republicans, you know, people who love Jesse Waters and Greg
00:02:47.980 Gutfeld and people who hate them, who just say, I don't I don't know how you make it through this
00:02:53.240 and stay composed and keep it all intact. So I was hearing that from a wide variety of people for
00:03:00.540 a long time. And then after the 2024 election, I had this kind of come to Jesus moment. I'd already
00:03:09.300 accepted the election results. And I mean, obviously, I'd accepted them. I'm a good liberal
00:03:13.380 And I don't deny elections. I just mean, I had already started bathing in the results and thinking about what it meant, you know, in terms of Democrats' media strategy, how we would appeal to working class people, you know, how to rebuild the coalition that we'd had for so long.
00:03:29.240 And I went to Columbia to their journalism school to talk to some students, and I was floored by the questions that they were asking me.
00:03:39.260 You know, the caricature of these left-leaning Wokistan folks didn't fit at all.
00:03:46.000 And they really wanted to talk about how you can maintain your values and your sanity in this current environment and how to better express themselves, especially when their back is up against a wall, whether they're outnumbered or they're just, you know, dealing with someone with a very harsh or specific, I don't know the exact term for it, but, you know, a pointed point of view.
00:04:08.920 And that made me feel sure that I should write I disagree and that there would be a use for it and that it would actually cut across party lines, which is something that's really important to me as someone who, you know, spends my days in a conservative media environment.
00:04:27.700 Well, I think it's something that should be important to all of us right now, because the truth is we're not all going to disagree. Our country's more fractured than ever. And we have to figure out a way to live here together. We have to figure out a way to, like I said, argue with grace, to disagree with grace. But what is even what is even the starting point for that?
00:04:49.240 Well, I don't want to be the person who every question you ask me, I just come back with a, there's a two-parted answer to that, Jo.
00:04:55.300 You are more than welcome to. You know what? I love a two-parter. Okay.
00:04:59.440 Okay. This is my two-part series on how do you even start.
00:05:02.960 So I think that there's the facts part of it. And if you've watched The Five or seen clips of me flying around on social media, you'll notice that I'm very heavy on data and statistics and citing my sources. And I reveal myself to be the dork that I am. I had a career as a researcher and pollster before I went into media full time.
00:05:27.880 So the first part, I think, is building a data-based worldview. And then that imbues you with a certain level of confidence to be able to defend it in any venue.
00:05:37.660 But the second piece of it, I think, is what is really hard at this moment for people because it relates directly to the hard work of forging relationships and connective tissue with people that you struggle with and who see the world differently from you.
00:05:58.600 And this is something obviously we know about families being torn apart, you know, people not being able to talk about what they think and their work environments. Basically, ideology is siloing ourselves and then adding the algorithm to it, which I know is something you talk about all the time.
00:06:14.560 like there's a good chance that you could just live in your own with your own people off to the
00:06:20.940 sides for the rest of time so there has to be that desire and then a set of skills as well that go
00:06:27.120 along with it which i i talk about in the book for you to be able to actually have decent interactions
00:06:33.640 with people who you have the most vehement disagreements with and it's really hard and you
00:06:38.780 have had some of those disagreements in the public square on television. And I think for the most
00:06:45.160 part, you have absolutely kept your cool. Not everybody keeps their cool on that show. It
00:06:51.360 wouldn't make for good television. If it did, what were some of the hardest moments for you?
00:06:55.780 I mean, this is many years of heartbreak sometimes. Hardest moments for me, the day the
00:07:02.300 Dobbs decision came down was one of the most difficult days to be doing TV, where you kind of
00:07:08.300 just want to crawl into a ball and process, you know, 50 years of having a right, getting rolled
00:07:14.280 back and the implications of that. Not so much for me because I live in New York and I have means.
00:07:21.860 And so I'm always going to have access to quality health care, even if I had to travel for it.
00:07:27.760 But what this means for the most vulnerable amongst us, the women living in conservative
00:07:33.100 states, especially women who earn less and women of color. And so that was really tough for me to
00:07:39.260 gather myself personally and then to also hone in on what it is that I wanted to represent that day.
00:07:48.140 You know, you only get 90 seconds, maybe two minutes at best to be able to talk. And so what
00:07:55.480 was going to be the most meaningful? Do you want to go all data? Do you want to go personal
00:08:02.180 anecdote? What stories do you want to amplify? You know, how do you make this not hyperbolic
00:08:08.880 and hysterical while also meeting the moment and making it clear that this will lead to,
00:08:15.260 which it has, things like women bleeding out and waiting in ERs for care and governments going
00:08:23.160 after doctors who provide reproductive health care and the kind of abject terror that we've seen 0.56
00:08:28.640 women in conservative states, especially the 13 that have trigger laws having to live in.
00:08:33.640 So that was a very tough day for me. And I will say my colleagues really made space for me to
00:08:40.180 get my feelings out and to get my points out. And I used a lot of data in my answer as well.
00:08:46.060 So I remember that being very emotionally tough, especially as the only person on the panel who
00:08:51.280 is pro-choice and talking to folks who are pro-life for religious reasons, it also is
00:08:59.200 different. And you have to factor that into how you approach the conversation and what kind of
00:09:05.160 headway you might ever be able to make, honestly, because of how deeply held those beliefs are.
00:09:11.400 Another instance that was really tough was right after Charlie Kirk was murdered. And
00:09:17.280 And I got into a huge dust up with one of my colleagues that day that was exceptionally tough, where it kind of just halts you.
00:09:26.780 We're sitting, so I won't say like in your steps because I was, you know, sitting down.
00:09:30.040 But it really jars you and you take a step back and you think, my God, this actually isn't the time for a debate about the facts on the ground, like who commits more political violence, the right or the left.
00:09:43.040 The answer is clear based on the data and it's the right.
00:09:45.900 But what do you do when you're having a tough conversation with someone who is so personally attached to the issue? You know, someone who is so close to, in this case, Charlie Kirk, who was needlessly assassinated. And how do you make room for people who matter in your life to get their feelings out and almost to live grieve, I would say.
00:10:12.100 And it led me to, and if you, for those of you listening, get the book and read it, and I hope that you will. I, at the end of each chapter, have a set of tips. I have little tips boxes all over the place because I wanted the book to also be able to be used as kind of a business book.
00:10:27.820 And one of the tips that I think is really important for people is to understand the value of listening and sometimes being silent.
00:10:37.600 And I think our culture promotes this feeling that it is always better to have a response.
00:10:43.180 And the faster you can calculate your response, the better.
00:10:45.940 And you want to have a great comeback or a zinger, whatever you want to call it.
00:10:49.000 And sometimes the best thing that you can do for yourself and for the people that you're dialoguing with is to actually just sit back and process what they're saying and take that to heart. So that day definitely taught me that lesson.
00:11:02.840 Let's take a quick break. And when we get back, I want to talk about the value of taking a step back, of being quiet, not forever, literally just for a beat in our world where it is too loud right now, can also be an advantage for women who do start most disagreements from a disadvantage.
00:11:24.500 okay we are back you talk a lot about the unique tightrope that women are walking when we are
00:11:37.100 let's say when we're just talking but also when we happen to just breathing and existing yes just 0.80
00:11:42.540 being a person with a vagina in the world it's rough out there yeah it's not easy we you know 0.99
00:11:49.100 we get told we're too aggressive, we're dismissed as a bitch. So I think taking a beat is, I mean, 1.00
00:11:55.540 it's good for everybody, but also good for women to think about how do we want to show up in this
00:12:01.100 moment? Talk to me a little bit about that. Yeah. So this is something that I had to learn the hard 0.98
00:12:07.540 way as someone who would self-describe as a Tracy Flick kind of character in life. I always prided
00:12:13.940 myself and almost couldn't control myself from having a quick retort, even when it really hurt
00:12:21.080 me, frankly, to respond in that way. And you get this kind of know-it-all reputation, a little bit
00:12:26.760 of a Doogie Howser, right? And I didn't love it, but I also felt like I couldn't stop myself.
00:12:34.360 And as I got older, and especially as I became a mother, I have a four and a half and a two and a
00:12:39.340 half year old. I have learned a lot about the beauty of silence and not just like when they
00:12:43.300 go to sleep and everything is peaceful. How important it is to make space for these little
00:12:50.520 people who you love more than anything to get it out, right? Whether it's a temper tantrum or in a
00:12:56.660 conversation and they're puzzling through how they can get their words out. And I think that
00:13:02.360 carries over to us even in adulthood where making space for people to work it out for themselves
00:13:10.860 is a gift that you're giving them, but it's also a gift that you're giving yourself. And the kind
00:13:16.520 of rule or tip that I use in the book or how I explain it is to regulate before you respond.
00:13:22.880 So it's not only giving yourself the opportunity to recalibrate and really process. In giving them
00:13:30.000 that space, sometimes they will hang themselves out to dry. You ever notice that when you're
00:13:35.160 having a conversation or an argument with somebody and they're getting progressively
00:13:41.000 crazier and crazier with the stuff that you're saying and you just think act well i'm gonna i'm
00:13:45.920 gonna let this go yeah i think you're you're gonna yeah you you don't you you've got this
00:13:51.000 you keep going you keep going right and it's gonna get crazier and crazier and then at a certain
00:13:56.820 point and it's not everybody but a lot of people realize how insane they sound by you letting it
00:14:04.240 just hang out there. So I'm a very big fan of letting people actually deal with their own
00:14:10.860 content because too often they're moving much too fast to actually process what it is that's
00:14:18.540 flying out of their mouth, how little of it is grounded in the real world and how immature they
00:14:24.080 can seem. Like I'm 42 years old. I don't want to argue or disagree like I did as a 20 something.
00:14:30.660 I've learned a lot of things since that.
00:14:32.740 So buying yourself that space serves a number of purposes.
00:14:36.740 And I also, you know, in the workplace, and obviously Fox is my workplace, big corporation.
00:14:43.320 And it's not a normal work environment for sure being on TV, but we're colleagues just
00:14:49.840 the same and have all the folks that work on the shows and layers of executives down
00:14:53.780 to janitors.
00:14:54.580 You know, we've got all the trappings of normal stuff.
00:14:58.180 And so I am very aware of the difficulties out there for women showing up in workplaces, even though this is one that has rewarded me like I got this huge promotion at eight months pregnant, which never happens, especially, you know, in a profession where your physical appearance matters a lot.
00:15:17.840 And I was a boat, to say the least.
00:15:20.840 But looking at all of the data and, you know, organizations like Deloitte do incredible work into this space.
00:15:29.160 And, you know, what adjectives are used to describe women?
00:15:32.980 What are the barriers to entry? 1.00
00:15:35.720 How we even manage our time when we're on corporate retreats?
00:15:40.200 You know, like, do you pretend you want to take a golf lesson just to get in the cart and hang out with the guys?
00:15:45.320 Or do you spend that time doing something else?
00:15:48.840 And so I really wanted to make that a central piece of this book because in today's environment, and you know this as, you know, someone who is a creator in all sorts of ways, like podcast and author and have a social media presence and all of these things that I feel like there's a little bit of a falsehood that's been told to people, especially women, like you can go your own way, right?
00:16:14.440 Like you just get out there and you do your thing. And we all report to someone in one way or another. And we all face a lot of these challenges. And I really wanted that to be front and center in I Disagree in the book.
00:16:29.660 Yeah. And you really you really did it. And you and I come from a very similar generation that we were we were told to lean in.
00:16:37.900 We were told that if we leaned in, if we did this, we could have it all. 0.99
00:16:42.300 And I think a lot of that was absolute bullshit. 0.99
00:16:46.360 The world is not set up for women to have it all. 1.00
00:16:49.160 Certainly not all at once. Corporate culture definitely is not. 0.88
00:16:52.500 And it's created this kind of binary between you're either a boss, babe, or you're a trad wife.
00:16:58.880 which is, I mean, obviously I think a lot about Tradwives because I wrote the original Tradwife
00:17:03.540 thriller and I've been reporting on them for so many, so many years. But the fact is most of us
00:17:09.600 are somewhere in the middle. Most of us know we can't have it all, all of the time or all at once.
00:17:15.000 And you kind of take a machete to this premise that women can effortlessly have it all. I really 0.94
00:17:21.380 think Sheryl Sandberg did a whole generation of women of real disservice. Well, not only in the 0.80
00:17:27.900 Lenin sense, but in the Facebook sense. Right. Also in perpetuating the worst thing to happen
00:17:34.380 to media in the history of media. Yes. All of that as well. Not great. But yes, the the rah-rah,
00:17:41.680 we can have it all. And it was so much bigger than like Anne-Marie Slaughter talking about
00:17:48.820 what you just said, the timing of when you can have it. Right. Or Michelle Obama in her memoir.
00:17:56.380 writing about crying in the parking lot on her lunch break outside of Chipotle,
00:18:02.600 realizing she has to get one of her kids another costume
00:18:05.980 and still make it back in time for her to do her very high-octane important career 0.93
00:18:11.800 and support a husband who is away all the time.
00:18:14.660 And you're like, I can't believe I bought this.
00:18:20.000 And how how much I wanted to feel a part of something that ended up being such a fallacy.
00:18:27.080 And that's not that there aren't incredible women who have done all these things like have a great and loving marriage, have kids who succeed and are rock stars, have these insane careers and travel the world and like all of the good stuff.
00:18:42.260 But you can't point to anyone that was definitely juggling all that at the same time.
00:18:47.040 And people, they don't talk about their failures enough and they don't talk about how hard it is. And I realized this more and more around the times that I was pregnant, especially having friends that were struggling with that process and, you know, issues of infertility and what going through the IVF process is like I only I froze my eggs and we didn't end up using them.
00:19:10.160 But I had like a little inkling of how fucking hard it is to build a family for some people.
00:19:18.080 And then these breezy presentations that the big accounts versus the micro influencers that people actually feel like they have a connection to were just selling you this horrible bill of goods. 0.79
00:19:28.400 And it's so detrimental.
00:19:30.460 It's so detrimental.
00:19:31.200 And it wasn't even just influencers.
00:19:32.920 I mean, it was really just this culture at large that was all like, yeah, you can't.
00:19:37.220 Yeah.
00:19:37.800 If you're not doing it all, you're failing at it all.
00:19:40.920 And I drop balls all the time. 0.99
00:19:43.100 I am failing at one thing or another, whether it's, you know, being a crappy wife or, you 0.99
00:19:48.820 know, trying trying to be a good enough mother. 0.65
00:19:51.300 My kids.
00:19:52.520 I also I have a six year old, a two and a half year old and a nine year old.
00:19:56.360 And yeah, I mean, they take up all of my energy to the extent that, yeah, I'm kind of a crappy, 0.98
00:20:01.340 crappy wife a lot. 0.97
00:20:02.920 lately. Because I could drop a husband ball. I could drop a husband ball. There's nothing he 1.00
00:20:07.340 can really do about it. Well, I mean, I guess he could divorce you, but. Yeah, but he's not going
00:20:12.480 to. That's what I tell my husband, too. I'm like, we're too tired to get divorced. It's too expensive
00:20:17.740 to get divorced. Let's just take a nap and hold hands and it's going to be fine. Yeah. Yeah,
00:20:24.000 exactly. Like, I mean, I'll be a good wife again someday. So why bother divorcing me? That seems
00:20:30.500 like a lot of work. I'm so with you. I mean, I feel badly, but I presume they feel similarly if
00:20:37.000 men were the ones who weren't at their office jobs and were sitting around doing a podcast in
00:20:42.700 the middle of the afternoon. So it is one of our privileges. It is one of our privileges.
00:20:48.380 You have a pretty good story, though, about meeting your husband. I want to hear it.
00:20:52.600 Yeah. Sometimes you just take a flyer on the guy in the elevator at midnight,
00:20:56.840 which is not safe and if someone does this and then it goes badly I feel like I'm going to be
00:21:01.800 responsible for it but I had been living with my now ex-boyfriend in this apartment building in
00:21:09.600 Union Square in New York City and we split up and a couple months later I started dating and
00:21:15.220 came home from a disappointing date and got in the elevator to go home and there was a tall guy
00:21:22.160 in the elevator who I'd never seen before and I asked him what floor and he said five and I said
00:21:26.580 know I live on five and I was five a and he was five B and in he worked fast like in the ride
00:21:32.500 going up he said like oh do you want to have a drink and I was like you're crazy like you don't
00:21:36.880 go into a stranger's apartment and he made a compelling case including we're on security
00:21:41.280 cameras and I just moved in here and it would be really silly of me to do anything on tour to you
00:21:47.360 which looking back it's actually not that compelling of a case and clearly I just wanted
00:21:52.620 to live a little dangerously after having a bad breakup with the guy I thought I was going to
00:21:55.820 Mary and I went home and texted a bunch of people if I disappear I'm in 5b you know send help and
00:22:04.200 went in there and we hung out for an hour and talked a lot about Jamaica and music and we made
00:22:11.020 out and then I went home he said obviously you know you can stay I was like I'm not doing that
00:22:17.080 as if I hadn't already crossed lines you're like I am already living dangerously my friend yes
00:22:21.680 already living dangerously. I cannot be naked on top of it in the stranger's house.
00:22:27.120 Not yet. Not yet. No, maybe tomorrow, man, maybe tomorrow. And I went home. And then when I woke 0.99
00:22:32.580 up in the morning, I had a note under my door that said, nice meeting you. Solid makeout. I
00:22:37.900 hope this is the right apartment. And it was signed, Brian. And I wrote back and then he
00:22:42.360 sent his number. And the next week it was COVID. And we're an arranged marriage by the Wuhan lab.
00:22:47.380 yeah you were that wasn't that was actually an arranged marriage sure i mean i'm so i'm actually
00:22:52.160 so glad you went because your covid would have gone a totally different direction can you imagine
00:22:56.520 i was even thinking about that and we joked about it because we both had online dating accounts
00:23:01.000 that you know then you were already married so you don't know how weird it was but there were
00:23:06.420 all of these people who had been like on one date making deals like you'll be the only person that i
00:23:13.020 see and then people are obviously fucking up those deals and getting people sick and so we would have
00:23:19.580 days where we'd be in our separate apartments and see each other like active on bumble or whatever
00:23:24.460 you know just having fun because you're locked in and a once in a generation pandemic but yeah
00:23:30.860 there were really no other options and we both don't know in the nicest possible way because
00:23:35.700 we're very happy i promise we don't think if it had been normal dating conditions that we would
00:23:40.820 have ended up married with kids. So very, one of the silver linings of COVID is definitely
00:23:46.780 my husband. But you also never know. That's the thing. I met my husband because we were on a 10
00:23:54.340 day eco cruise in the Galapagos and there was no wifi on that boat. We were both journalists on
00:24:01.120 assignment. He was not my type at all. And then we made out on the last day on the boat and I was
00:24:07.440 like okay all right let's why not you but I'm like have we not been at sea that maybe this never if
00:24:15.100 had I met you in a bar I absolutely do not think it would have happened there you go and the wi-fi
00:24:21.000 part I think matters a lot because you probably would have like doom scrolled instead of made out
00:24:24.820 with the cute journalist man totally because I was a workaholic and I would have been back in
00:24:29.480 my room filing like 19 stories that's awesome yeah that's a great adventure me cute I love it
00:24:36.320 Well, I mean, and I also I love an elevator meet cute.
00:24:39.040 I really do.
00:24:40.220 Big fan.
00:24:42.060 All right.
00:24:42.260 Let's take one more break.
00:24:44.500 And then I want to talk a little bit about podcasting because I can talk about podcasting all day and how great I think it is and also how terrible in some ways it is and how it's also completely changing the media landscape.
00:24:56.760 So, all right.
00:24:57.760 Just one more break.
00:25:06.320 okay we are back you also have a podcast you do what you do nine jobs like me we all do nine jobs
00:25:11.860 we do and it's raging moderates with with scott galloway what do you think of the podcast
00:25:18.940 landscape right now because i think i think it's bananas i love podcasts i've been doing them for
00:25:25.060 10 years but i also think now all of a sudden we have all these talk shows which is that a podcast
00:25:30.440 i don't know is the amy polo show really a podcast or a celebrity talk show like what what do you
00:25:34.820 think about the podcast ecosystem right now? Well, I think it's cool that you're actually an OG
00:25:39.900 in it because I am a recent addition to the space and got super lucky to be able to do it with
00:25:48.580 someone well-established in the space because I think that there is such an enormous barrier to
00:25:54.220 entry right now, especially if you want to get advertisers and if you want to get any sort of
00:25:59.760 fan base and that or like make a living off of it you know i say this i say this all the time
00:26:05.680 yeah yeah yeah people are gonna start a podcast i'm like don't do that not now no no no no no
00:26:11.140 unless you have a good partner right or someone who's kind of a known quantity in the space which
00:26:16.520 is what i had with scott you're right about the talk shows and i thought about this i had you
00:26:21.080 know adam friedland i do yeah yeah yeah so i had adam on raging moderates maybe like a year ago
00:26:28.280 And I remember like what it what a big deal it is to introduce him as talk show host Adam Friedland. And he's kind of making fun of like doing a parody of old school talk shows when you watch his show and what the set is like and they do the clapping and and whatever else.
00:26:45.860 But it did get me thinking about the fact that a lot of these actually are talk shows masquerading as podcasts. And it's just the medium that we're all playing in right now. And frankly, like everything, you should have no expectation that you are not going to have to be audio and video for anything that you do now.
00:27:05.340 I'm not saying you need to be like in super glam constantly. Like I don't always have HD makeup and, you know, fake eyelashes on. That's usually for actual TV. But I think that that transition has really changed the space and moved us away from, I think, a lot of what pioneering podcasting was, which was this opportunity for, in some cases, like two, three hour conversations where people could feel comfortable.
00:27:35.340 unencumbered, sharing their deepest, darkest thoughts, right, or their expertise. So I think
00:27:40.980 it has changed a lot. I mean, the algorithm and what it takes to get into people's for you pages
00:27:48.900 is nauseating to me. And I, I feel pain every time I catch myself thinking about it, like,
00:27:57.660 oh my God, we did this great episode, but I need to get in a mention of Canada because Raging
00:28:02.720 moderates listeners are obsessed with Canada which is a new thing that we didn't know and I love
00:28:07.400 Mark Carney and like it's interesting but you know what it's like where you think I just put
00:28:13.420 all of this work into this incredible episode or had this guest that I am dying for people to hear
00:28:20.940 from but their name isn't big enough for it to break through and so what am I gonna do like how
00:28:27.840 am I going to juice this to make sure that I get into people's feeds? Yeah, because you have to
00:28:33.080 break into this crazy attention cycle, which is shorter than ever. The algorithm controls it.
00:28:39.680 It's bananas. I'm doing more and more video. I'm doing a little less now, honestly, total,
00:28:45.360 total honesty, because I'm leaving for Morocco and Paris next week and I don't want to edit that 0.98
00:28:49.560 shit. OK, I respect that. Yeah. September isn't going to have any. And you know what? That's 0.99
00:28:55.700 going to be fine. I have I mean, I have I have so many loyal listeners because I've been doing it
00:28:59.420 for 10 years. Right. And so I do have listeners who are still listening to the podcast, getting
00:29:04.620 new listeners. You need the videos, which is insane. And then, you know, sell it. Now you're
00:29:09.780 about to sell some books. And that's a whole different ballgame of people's feeds. That's
00:29:15.020 bananas. I was even I was listening to like some more recent episodes of yours and, you know,
00:29:20.920 where you're trying to hawk books and all the time like all the time it's like a 24 hour a day job
00:29:26.900 and for people it's funny and i sense and obviously i don't really know you we're only
00:29:31.200 30 minutes and five seconds deep but i feel like we're pretty we're similar in a lot of ways just
00:29:38.020 yeah i feel that i feel this too i feel this too yeah great so we can talk about that offline too
00:29:42.660 maybe the cocktail but there are a lot of people i think like us in the space who present like
00:29:50.520 extroverts, but are actually introverted. And I wanted that to be also a major theme of the book
00:29:56.620 so people understood how difficult it is for people who do these things that feel so big and
00:30:02.900 scary and intimidating, like what's actually going on inside of them, right? And like what you have
00:30:07.640 to battle through to be able to get there. And selling your book is one of the biggest hurdles
00:30:12.640 I have ever approached. And I'm only like halfway through it. It is daunting to the max. I cannot
00:30:19.800 believe the shamelessness that is required of you and like what publishers also tell you like well 0.99
00:30:24.700 why don't you just do this and i'm like because i have a fucking conscience and i cannot do that 0.90
00:30:29.660 yeah and like it's disrespectful and they're not bad people like that's just how you sell books 0.86
00:30:34.960 now and like i also i don't want to make this into like a book publishing conversation but
00:30:39.040 please like we can always have a book publishing conversation but did you know i mean you're what
00:30:44.640 you 13 books at this point yeah yeah it's yeah so I don't know if it was the same because I've
00:30:52.600 heard that the culture has shifted a lot in this but I had this assumption that getting people to
00:30:57.320 pre-order a book would be easy because they're obsessed with you like I have people literally
00:31:02.760 you know tweeting every day oh my god you do the lord's work like I would tattoo your face on my 0.97
00:31:07.640 ass like whatever and I'm like just pre-order my book then like I don't know why it's so hard for 0.99
00:31:12.420 you to do this thing. And they just do not want to. No, they do not. No, they do not. I will tell 0.88
00:31:17.380 you, selling books is harder than selling anything else. I could sell like a thousand candles,
00:31:22.460 okay? For some reason, I could link a candle on my Instagram and a thousand people are going to
00:31:26.720 buy it. And I'm like, why don't you buy this book? Also, you've loved my past books. And it's still
00:31:31.560 impossible. Pre-orders are also, it's a weird thing. The publishing industry counts them. They
00:31:36.380 love them so much. And that said, an actual consumer doesn't want to pre-order a fucking 0.99
00:31:40.780 buck they want to get the book when it can come tomorrow okay like they just don't want to do it 0.97
00:31:44.140 and so yeah the whole thing is absolutely bananas you just have to and again this is shameless
00:31:49.520 you keep saying it all the time you talk about it all the time and then the 56th time that someone
00:31:56.680 hears about it like you know what i meant to i meant to order that book okay cool cool yeah that's
00:32:03.520 and don't feel bad about it because honestly they're only going to see this mentioned like
00:32:06.920 once in a while. So just shout about it from the rooftops. I think your book. So I've been talking
00:32:11.860 to a lot of women recently who have who have nonfiction books that I think would be great 1.00
00:32:17.120 for book clubs. Like I don't want book clubs just reading strangers. I've got a lot of opinions on 0.68
00:32:20.920 strangers. I think it's a flawed book. I think book clubs should be reading books like yours.
00:32:25.420 I just had Bobby Brown on the show. Yeah. We talked about her memoir, Still Bobby. It's great.
00:32:30.620 I want book clubs chewing on real stories from real women who've lived in the world and gone through some shit, which strangers is in a way. 0.97
00:32:39.940 But I think that there's the book clubs are reading four books right now.
00:32:43.060 And I'm pushing books, books like yours, for for book club picks, because I think that this gives us a lot, a lot to chew on, a lot to talk about and a lot to explore as women in the world right now.
00:32:54.060 But this loops back quite elegantly to how we started this conversation about the polarization, because people are so hesitant to put a like a recommendation on something that could offend even a small cadre of quote unquote fans of theirs.
00:33:14.740 Right. So there's like I, you know, my book has a lot of lessons for you, no matter your politics. Right. But I am a partisan person and I'm most closely associated with politics and for making arguments on behalf of a liberal perspective, whether you think Democratic Party or liberal perspective, whatever it is.
00:33:36.540 And you see the terror in these groups of getting those angry emails, right?
00:33:43.560 That you're like cutting out the point of view of 81 million Americans if you do this.
00:33:49.240 And it goes both ways.
00:33:50.200 I'm not talking about this.
00:33:50.900 And listen, I am very blessed.
00:33:52.340 I have a lot of people who love this book and think like you that it is something that we should be talking about in these kinds of forums, right?
00:34:03.060 especially for women coming up in a workplace, et cetera.
00:34:06.700 But it's crazy how controversial people who I think are pretty neutral actually are in
00:34:15.360 this fraught universe, which is why you have book clubs with these four books, essentially,
00:34:21.060 or maybe like someone throws in like a YA book once in a while.
00:34:25.800 But then, I mean, that's not for everybody.
00:34:27.480 It's not particularly for me either.
00:34:29.000 So I'd rather, you know, like read Wedding People or whatever.
00:34:33.060 Totally. Totally. Yeah. I mean, I had to get over that. You know, I published a book. I published a novel, We Are Not Like Them, which was about social justice. It was about the police shooting of a black boy in Philadelphia and the newscaster covering it and her best friend who was the wife of the cop who killed the kid.
00:34:48.960 And before that book came out, my co-author and I were like, we're getting canceled.
00:34:53.720 Like, no matter what we do, someone is going to cancel us.
00:34:58.300 And I think I've just gotten a lot thicker skin, which also makes me a lot happier now.
00:35:02.500 And you have to have it being on TV, especially being on Fox.
00:35:06.200 I'm being like, I'm not going to make everybody happy.
00:35:08.380 I cannot make everybody happy.
00:35:10.200 And I'm just going to do my best to put as much good into the world as I possibly can.
00:35:15.340 And to, you know, put the things that I think are actually going to help women out there. 0.99
00:35:20.060 And if I don't make people happy, fuck it. 0.99
00:35:22.660 I don't I don't care anymore. 1.00
00:35:24.080 But it took me so long, so long to get there.
00:35:26.900 But I feel I feel very optimistic about your book, especially for me.
00:35:30.820 This is the book that you gift well before Thanksgiving so that people know how to disagree
00:35:35.780 properly at the Thanksgiving table.
00:35:38.760 It's like a pre Thanksgiving gift that you send to your relatives.
00:35:41.320 That was my alternate title was surviving Thanksgiving. And I wanted that's why I included in that appendix that I have like 10 tips for your table where I go through 10 hot button issues and talk about how I've argued those positions.
00:35:58.680 So, like, I have seen your Uncle Frank before. I have talked to him about abortion. I have talked to him about immigration. I have talked to him about Trump's corruption. Like, I got you, girl. Or boy. Whoever is reading it.
00:36:11.140 Or boy. Yep. So I wanted that to be a piece of it. But I also wanted the overall tone of the book to be cognizant of the fact that I work in a very specific kind of space and that I think it's important to be there and to be modeling a type of civil and civic discourse that is missing in a lot of places.
00:36:35.640 And, you know, I've gotten pushback like, oh, well, you get, you know, disrespected this way or that way. 0.98
00:36:40.200 I'm like, sure, shit happens for sure. 0.95
00:36:42.700 But like if I keep my side of the street clean, I feel really good about that. 0.99
00:36:48.460 And that's what we teach our kids, right?
00:36:51.100 Like it's okay to get upset.
00:36:53.000 And if you need to tattle on someone, I was a big tattletale.
00:36:55.920 I totally get it.
00:36:57.040 But like I don't want you name calling back.
00:37:00.720 And that's the type of politics that I practice.
00:37:03.480 and I really I wanted that to be a big current and I disagree so that conservative fans of the
00:37:10.880 five would also find value in this book and to see it as a warm depiction of a show that they're
00:37:19.140 so connected to yeah because you're sharing your stories and your perspective in it which I think
00:37:25.340 is what makes it different too you're coming at it from a human place I think the five comes at a
00:37:30.960 lot of things from a very human place I like the fact that there are disagreements on air I love
00:37:36.100 the fact that you are there okay like we need more shows where we're seeing people actually disagree
00:37:43.140 with civility because we're certainly not seeing it on social media on social media we're seeing
00:37:47.680 cancellation after cancellation 100 but I think it's it's inherently a a higher brow take or more
00:37:56.760 of an enlightened take to feel the way that you do. And I'm assuming some things about your
00:38:02.180 politics, you know, based on a lot of information that I've already seen about the types of policies
00:38:07.500 that you support and how you think the country could be made better. Not everyone sees it that
00:38:12.720 way. And not everyone thinks that we should, quote unquote, legitimize each other, depending
00:38:17.800 on which side of the fence you're on. And I think we are so past legitimizing or platforming or any
00:38:24.900 of it like we're in a world where candace owens makes a bajillion dollars and nick flentes does
00:38:29.800 and hassan piker does like they don't need you and i think the sooner that we really grasp that
00:38:36.680 and live in that space the better off we're going to be like that's part of the podcasting world but
00:38:43.200 just the way social media works in general like you the gatekeepers are dead essentially the
00:38:50.500 gatekeepers are dead that would be a great name for another book maybe yourself maybe number 14
00:38:55.400 no you could do it you're better at this than me i'm done i know that's what everyone says after
00:38:59.480 one book but i'm like what would i even write about next you never know it's but it's very
00:39:04.020 similar to when you have babies and you have the baby and you go through the birth and the awful
00:39:08.880 newborn stage and you're like i would never do this again this is terrible and then you have a
00:39:12.460 two-year-old and you're like i think i could probably do it again yeah yes totally i definitely
00:39:17.280 feel that way i i have like we're not gonna have another one but i am in the sad that i'm not gonna
00:39:22.060 have a baby again phase when i look at my two and a half year old and i'm like are you actually a
00:39:26.760 middle child but no she's she's that's what i did that's what i did i looked at my i looked at my
00:39:31.380 two and a half year old i'm like oh now you're the middle child and then we just then we got
00:39:35.340 very drunk at nilton john concert and made another baby and this is what happens like i get it that
00:39:41.420 you didn't do it at the concert but like if not at the concert no no i get it after the concert
00:39:45.980 uh-huh but did you dj the event with elton john music or is that a weird thing to ask you no it's
00:39:54.120 i don't i have there's no weird questions with joe piazza no we were we actually went to the
00:39:58.020 elton john concert we went to an elton john concert in north dakota in fargo north dakota
00:40:01.960 with a bunch of friends and drank drank everything went back to the hotel and made a baby and then
00:40:06.320 yeah we put the elton john on rock okay good and we made another baby made another baby and
00:40:10.700 rocking it in there cool rock it in there and we and then we named her eliza john
00:40:14.580 that's so cute i know can i tell you something weird about elton john please do and i hope that
00:40:21.220 this is right because my husband would kill me or he would have lied to me no he was right okay
00:40:29.780 so my husband was his last name is mckenna so i didn't change my last name so my kids are mckenna's
00:40:35.560 and I'm a Tarlov and he really loved the name Reggie and he thought Reggie McKenna was like
00:40:41.660 the sickest name and it is a really good name if you're gonna have like someone going to the NFL
00:40:46.360 draft and I was like it just yeah and then we found out it was a girl and he was like trying
00:40:51.900 to make the case still and I'm all for funky names and I was supposed to be named Teddy Tarlov and so
00:40:56.940 my younger daughter is Teddy Tarlov McKenna so I totally get it and she's not like Theodora or
00:41:03.100 anything. But he was making the case and making the case. And so Reggie became this like flashpoint
00:41:08.320 issue for us. And he was like, you just have the wrong idea about who's actually named Reggie and
00:41:14.020 life or Reginald, which is the main name that folks have who go by Reggie. And he told me that
00:41:20.060 Elton John's real name is Reginald, which is true. Reginald Kenneth Dwight is his name. Did you know
00:41:25.620 that wow no no i did not know that and those three names separately are also names that you
00:41:33.280 wouldn't normally think like naming your kid dwight naming your kid kenneth naming your kid
00:41:38.560 reginald wow that's that's really good trivia we are a family that loves trivia so i'm gonna throw
00:41:44.120 i'm throwing that one out there that is that is excellent so much fun i could talk to you all day
00:41:48.660 long but my kids are downstairs i can hear them now and that means i have to be a mother at some
00:41:52.740 point fly you tell me thank you will you tell everyone where they can find this wonderful book
00:41:58.580 of yours it's probably it's everywhere books are sold you can literally just get it today get it
00:42:02.080 tomorrow buy it for nine people you disagree with and then maybe you guys can have have a great
00:42:07.560 argument at melton john concert make a third baby yeah i would love to do that but not really on the
00:42:13.580 third baby part we can't handle it but yes where books are sold and i'm all over social media at
00:42:19.800 Jessica Tarla and it's easy to find it there. And I hope that you all love it and mostly that
00:42:26.240 it benefits you and that you feel braver and better equipped to have tough conversations
00:42:31.220 because you read it. Love it.
00:42:49.800 Thank you.
00:43:19.800 Thank you.