00:00:00.000Hello, all. Jo here, and you're listening to Under the Influence. I'm so happy you're
00:00:09.000with me today. We're going to have some fun. Now, we've been talking a lot about trad wives
00:00:15.080on social media and a lot about the new Secret Lives of Mormon Wives TV show. One of the
00:00:23.000things that I can't say enough and that I do sometimes become a broken record about
00:00:28.440is that it is very hard to hear real, raw, honest, unfiltered stories from women.0.95
00:00:39.080We see images of trad wives. We see images of their quote-unquote domestic bliss.0.91
00:00:45.440And we think it looks beautiful. And more importantly, young women looking at this
00:00:50.280content on social media think that it looks beautiful. And I'm not being a conspiracy
00:00:54.460theorists when I say that some of these young women who are getting a lot of their culture0.99
00:00:59.100from TikTok and Instagram, they are making choices based off what they see. They're making choices0.92
00:01:05.640based off this beautiful imagery of tradwives and domestic bliss. And the fact is, a man is never a0.82
00:01:14.480plan. That's why I think it's incredibly important for us to continue telling the stories of real
00:01:20.720women who have escaped from trad wife situations, like the incredible Tia Lovings, who have
00:01:26.320said, no, this is not what I want for myself, and this is not what I want for my children.
00:01:32.080Today's guest DM'd me to tell me that she was a former OG trad wife.
00:01:39.120She was just 16 when she was on her own and when she fell in with the Mormon church, and
00:01:44.920she got married incredibly young, at 18. Her husband was so controlling, so controlling,
00:01:52.560that he wouldn't even buy her a Kindle so she could read a book. She asked if she could go to
00:01:58.020college, get some work experience. He didn't want her to do either of those things. He took the
00:02:05.780church's teachings to believe that he had complete ownership over her. And when she chose to leave
00:02:13.100him, it was hard. It was really hard. She had no money. She had no work experience. And she had to
00:02:21.980build a completely new life for herself. Now, as many, many millions of people are watching The
00:02:29.520Secret Lives of Mormon Wives, I want you to know that this is the actual reality.
00:02:36.480hi i'm christianne when i was 16 my parents got a divorce we lived out here in the hill
00:02:51.000country of texas and i went to high school with probably like 100 people in my class
00:02:56.760and my mom and dad volatile relationship super unstable um i was fighting they ended up
00:03:05.280separating and I went with my dad to San Antonio which is a big city outside of the hill country
00:03:11.260um so I ended up kind of on my own at 16 my dad and mom were going through all of this turmoil
00:03:18.860I was an only child at one point he basically said you know I'm done racing you you're kind
00:03:25.060of on your own um I was working trying to go to school um kind of just getting into a lot of
00:03:32.780trouble. And I mean, it's really hard to be an adult, right? When you're 16. It's hard to be an
00:03:40.180adult when you're 44. Yeah. So I cannot imagine how hard it is to be an adult at 16. So I kind
00:03:47.560of decided, well, I guess what's the point of school? Like I wasn't ever a really good student.
00:03:54.720I didn't have, my parents were working both of them 40 hours a week. They worked like 45 minutes
00:04:00.440from town. So I didn't have a lot of supervision. I had already been skipping school a lot. And at
00:04:04.780that point, I mean, I'm probably 17 by now and I just stopped going to high school. There was like
00:04:10.5804,000 kids in this new school. I was overwhelmed. I wasn't doing well. I didn't have any parental
00:04:15.860audits. Nobody was telling me to go to school. So it stopped. My dad kind of was getting in
00:04:20.500trouble, I would assume. So he went up to the school and unenrolled me. Oh, wow. Okay. So he's
00:04:26.640just like fine it's done we're done with this for you you should probably get your gd and i was like
00:04:30.780okay i guess so i guess let's have a waitressing um kind of waitressing overnight it was odd like
00:04:38.740i was there's like diners out here called gyms and i would work from 6 p.m or sometimes 3 p.m
00:04:45.540to like 6 in the morning and so there really wasn't a way for me to even go to school i was
00:04:50.220so tired just to make money to like have gas in my car and shampoo and soap and all the things
00:04:55.300um so i finally just he kept bugging me about the gd thing and kind of guilting me into feeling like
00:05:02.620i was kind of worthless because i didn't have some kind of education so i went and took the test i
00:05:07.980passed thank goodness which actually gave me some hope that i wasn't like not so hard you know right
00:05:14.940right yeah of course yeah so then i i don't know i had always kind of befriended older people so i
00:05:23.500friends with like our neighbor we lived in like a trailer park not a great situation either
00:05:27.500um but she was an lbn and she was like you should go to school to be like a medical assistant or an
00:05:33.780lbn so i looked into it um my dad wasn't nice enough to sign on a loan i went to school to be
00:05:42.060a medical assistant and that's where i was introduced to the church i was you know getting
00:05:47.400to the mormon church so i'm an xlds called latter-day saint um to the outside world it's
00:05:55.280known as the mormon church but it was during that time that i was introduced to kind of a
00:05:59.680different way of living okay yeah yeah and so how did you get involved with the mormon church like
00:06:05.180what what was the what was the first first thing that happened to you yeah so i was in school to
00:06:10.920be a medical assistant i was still working like two jobs i was waitressing in the evenings
00:06:15.220was going to school but i was getting into trouble i mean like nobody was telling me it was trouble
00:06:22.860right i didn't know right of course yeah but like something inside me was like this isn't the way to
00:06:26.480live like drinking smoking running around with certain crowds of people things like that i mean
00:06:33.960something in me knew like there's a better way out there right like you i could see like people
00:06:41.060lived in nice houses and had nice cars and had nice lives we just didn't and i just i knew there
00:06:46.080was something else out there so i'm going to school with this girl she's a teenage mom you know she
00:06:51.700introduced me to this boy and he was mormon and i didn't even know how it came out throughout the
00:07:00.720night but we had like a really fun time not drinking not smoking not doing anything to get
00:07:06.540you in trouble you know um and i was intrigued i was like well he had he then he invited me to a
00:07:14.500party at like the bishop's house his bishop's house he was telling me that he was in he was
00:07:21.340in the military but he was home for a month on leave and kind of telling you about his church
00:07:25.900and how it's a college ward so when you're in the lds church you kind of go to church in your area
00:07:32.900or like with your group of your age group of people so the college ward was nearly local
00:07:37.600university and people who were like 18 to late 20s that's where they would go to church to be
00:07:43.720with their peers and go to church with their parents like say you're away from home or you
00:07:49.500don't have a family or things like that right you go to church with your peers so you could
00:07:53.020pretty much meet a me okay yeah my feeling from being in it but like that wasn't the feeling it
00:08:02.740got right off the bat it was just like well this is really neat i can hang out with other people
00:08:06.240my age who have fun and don't drink um so that kind of just rolled into me i was i mean i thought
00:08:13.580it was the best things in flight spread i really did these people had so much fun they were healthy
00:08:18.920and shiny and the bishops were nice and they were usually so that people kind of in charge who would
00:08:26.200lead the group were older people whose kids were like our age or out of the house and it was like
00:08:31.640having parents so it was very appealing to me i can see that i can totally see that so so what
00:08:38.620happens next so are you mated do you find a mate yes so i was actually pretty interested it's like
00:08:47.500really strange i was pretty interested in that boy who was in the military but like he had to go
00:08:53.620back um so i i was just his family kind of took me in during that time like i would have family
00:09:00.800there's a thing in the church called family home evening usually like on a monday and you spend the
00:09:05.820evening having dinner and games and just family time reading the scriptures and praying and i was
00:09:11.720spending that month of family home evenings with his family um he had a brother who actually ended
00:09:18.980up baptizing me into the church that summer i was just completely smitten because the family was just
00:09:25.120so different from what i was used to so i started going to church regularly being very involved
00:09:31.900and that's where i met john and my husband so i was with a group of girls that i had made friends
00:09:39.320with in the church already baptized already super into it studying my scriptures uh really just
00:09:46.080ready to dedicate my whole life to this better way of living this cleaner way of living that's
00:09:51.160shiny and not like where i came from so you guys get married how old were you i would be 18 all
00:09:58.140right i'm gonna stop us now let's take a really quick break and when when we get back i want to
00:10:03.040hear about your engagement and when you started having kids and when you realized that you were
00:10:10.600were becoming sort of a trad wife right when you emailed me you described yourself as an og trad
00:10:15.400wife yeah okay and we're back you are a baby your baby pants right now and you're you're0.94
00:10:31.400you're engaged tell me about what happens next so our vision was ridiculous like walmart ring0.53
00:10:37.620um but in the church it's like it's a big deal to get engaged everybody knew
00:10:45.120every like i think it was like sunday and then by the end of church on sunday we were being called
00:10:51.020to the bishop's office we'd probably been engaged like a couple of days he sat us down and he asked
00:10:56.660us if we were having sex we said no he said good and basically said we don't believe in short
00:11:03.800engagements that leads to premarital sex that's a sin you should get married as soon as possible0.54
00:11:10.600i'm okay great you're you're 18 i'm 18 i'm susceptible i come from a bad life and a bad
00:11:17.660family i just became baptized and i'm thinking this is a bishop um he knows better than i do
00:11:25.880and he knows what god wants right so um we started planning for our wedding and we were married
00:11:32.580within probably two or three weeks after that wow okay okay yeah i mean this is the fast track
00:11:40.980for sure and so what was married life like for you you described yourself as as we said in your
00:11:48.060email as an og trad wife yeah and i understand every single step you've taken so far you had
00:11:55.020no real parental figures the church felt safe as human beings we are desperate for safety and
00:12:01.200security so i am completely completely with you i get it yeah so what happens next so
00:12:09.260i had never met his family john was from el paso i'm from san antonio it's like eight hours apart
00:12:16.600it's like a whole nother world texas is huge um so we go to el paso to get married we get married
00:12:23.840by his grandpa in the backyard i meet his older sister and she hands me a little pamphlet um from
00:12:30.600one of the prophets in the church had written and it's like a little story about john and mary and
00:12:37.660like i read i read it and it basically kind of was like the first glimpse into what i had gotten
00:12:46.080myself into um the little story was basically like as a woman your job is to have the home
00:12:55.540clean take care of the children um if your husband is upset you should do everything you
00:13:01.700can to comfort him not take it personally um turn the other cheek if something happens with
00:13:09.640your husband it was like a setup for being dominated kind of like by a man for the rest
00:13:19.180of your life it was kind of surreal i kind of shoved it under the rug and over the years there
00:13:24.120was like a lot of things like that but I was so dedicated to the church because it made sense in
00:13:32.560a way and I just it was like being freaked out over and over again that I kind of just
00:13:38.280pushed under the rug right right and a book like that I mean so when I was researching
00:13:43.200my my book how to be married I remember finding a book like that you know how to please your
00:13:49.160husband how to keep a house how to greet him when he comes home and it was and it was from 1942
00:13:53.960I think this book was probably during the 80s.
00:13:57.880Yeah, right. And still being used today. So make no mistake, there are communities and religions out there who are still saying this is a woman's highest job and a woman's highest role, right?
00:18:34.400and i love hearing these details my heart breaks hearing these details but you know again when we
00:18:41.220see the trad wife fantasy what we're not seeing is the level of control that goes down to i don't
00:18:50.420want you to read yeah um and then goes goes even further to i don't want you to go back to school
00:18:57.080to do something that you think will better yourself make you feel good about yourself
00:19:02.920and that is a level of submission that no one should go through not not men not women not
00:19:10.340children um it is a complete stripping of agency yeah definitely and you know
00:19:16.240on some level when you're for me being in a church I felt like I was doing the right thing
00:19:23.660though I was being a mother with being a homemaker that was like revered in the church
00:19:29.240like you're a good homemaker there was almost like a competition among women of like how good
00:19:33.860of a homemaker could you be how clean can you get your health let's swap recipes let's swap0.99
00:19:38.160baking recipes and how well am i raising my children on organic food that i've cooked myself
00:19:45.940i can see where the trad wife on instagram can look beautiful because it did look beautiful
00:19:55.320from the outside. Of course it does. Of course it does. And because it strips the labor and you
00:20:02.500don't see this submission. And that's what I think we have to be talking about because it is
00:20:09.260essentially cosplaying these beautiful lives. Let's take one more quick break here. When we
00:20:14.080get back, I want to talk about the end of this marriage and what life was it like for you when
00:20:19.720you came out of it with no work experience and no money yeah we are back so christine
00:20:33.820talk to me about how your marriage your first marriage ended so
00:20:38.660john so we're along the way after we had our second son he started to fall away from the church
00:20:49.500He didn't want to go with me anymore. He didn't want to participate. He didn't want to go to the priesthood meetings. He wanted to start drinking and, like, have more fun. I don't know what it was that he was exactly getting lost from the faith, but I was so deep in the faith that I was deeply upset by this.
00:21:15.440i gave him a hard time about it and he didn't like that so he started buying me books um
00:21:23.320about how the mormon faith was a lie oh okay so he he was very manipulative and like always wanting
00:21:31.680to get his way you know if it was the church that was helping him to keep me under his thumb he was
00:21:37.140using that and now it you know he didn't want to be a part of that anymore he didn't believe in it
00:21:41.960So now he wanted me to not believe it.