00:00:00.000hello and welcome to vulgar history feminist women's history comedy podcast my name is anne
00:00:14.360foster and it's pride month it's june this is the time when we we celebrate the history and the
00:00:21.100current status of and the future of all the 2s lgbtqia plus community and so with that in mind
00:00:29.100we're having another queer history episode, another trans history episode. And today for
00:00:34.860a third time, our special guest is Kit Hamm, who has been on the show. Initially, Kit's first
00:00:41.040episode is talking about their book, Before We Were Trans, A New History of Gender, which is
00:00:48.180such a good book. And actually, that is one of the references I use for today's episode, because
00:00:51.700one of the people profiled in Kit's book is the person we're talking about today, the public
00:00:55.920universal friend. Kit also returned when we did an episode about Elagabalus, the horny teenage
00:01:02.880trans Roman emperor, who, side note, in that episode, I forgot to ask Kit to help with scoring0.52
00:01:10.380Elagabalus on the Scandaliciousness scale. So we did record that as well. And so that episode is0.89
00:01:16.220being re-released. If you go back, if you want to scroll back, you can hear how we scored Elagabalus
00:01:20.300in the Scandaliciousness scale or also on the scoring. It's just its own special episode on
00:01:24.740Patreon as well. But anyway, a third time. And I was thinking in the episode, I said,
00:01:29.260it's a record-breaking third time. And I think it is. So in terms of guests on this show,
00:01:34.740Ms. Hepburn is here. I mean, she's the most frequent guest star on the podcast. That is
00:01:39.760my cat who may hear purring directly next to the microphone right now. But also, so for the podcast,
00:01:45.320Gina Berry has been on twice, although we have recorded a third episode. It's just,
00:01:49.220you haven't heard it yet. So Kit is the first three-time returning guest. Now, some of the
00:01:56.180other people who've been on the podcast before, Alison Epstein and Lana Wood Johnson, I consider
00:02:00.260honorary co-hosts rather than guests of the podcast. Anyway, Kit, I just, every time I encounter
00:02:07.260something in trans history, I'm just like, I wonder if Kit's written about this. Like,
00:02:11.120I wonder if Kit can come on the podcast because I just love talking with them. That's why I keep
00:02:14.780having him back on the show. And Public Universal Friend, I think, is such a fascinating person.
00:02:19.640And I'm so glad that Kit joined us to talk us through this story of American history.
00:02:25.100You know, Kit is a British person, me as a Canadian person. We're both kind of objective
00:02:29.720outsiders to the world of American history. But Public Universal Friend, quite a saga as we get
00:02:36.000into it. Some similarities to the story of Elagabalus, just in terms of sort of like an
00:02:40.700audacious person from trans history, whose spirituality is a very important part of their
00:02:47.140life. Anyway, I do want to mention that other than Kit's book, Before We Were Trans, the other
00:02:52.640major reference that I was looking at for this episode was an essay from the encyclopedia
00:02:58.380Women in World History, which was written by Amanda Carson Banks in 2002. Anyway,
00:03:05.300happy pride. Let's talk about The Public Universal Friend.
00:03:10.700so i'm joined by kit ham welcome kit hi thank you for having me this is a record-breaking
00:03:21.120third appearance on this podcast because i keep i can't not have you on it's a total delight to
00:03:26.880be here is that genuinely a record am i like a recurring guest type record you are now officially
00:03:33.140a recurring guest there's there's only a few people who've been on three times i think two
00:03:39.460people and you're the second so but yeah and it's I want to let the listeners know as well
00:03:45.100um and you I guess too so I've been doing this podcast now for four years and people have heard
00:03:51.080me do episodes about queer history and about trans history and I've been learning both of
00:03:56.140those things more about them on air with guests like you as people listen to me so just so people
00:04:02.020know when I encounter a story where I'm like oh wait a minute I think this is a bit of trans
00:04:05.540history i'm always like kit what do you take for this person if you study this person um like i
00:04:11.300messaged you when i did the het shepset episode recently just to clarify like how do i talk about
00:04:15.520this so i appreciate you being behind the scenes kind of my go-to expert oh no anytime like it's
00:04:21.660really great to be able to talk about as we were saying off air the complicated figures from trans
00:04:27.880history the people who aren't just like our inspiring ancestors but are actually bonkers0.99
00:04:32.640in various ways. Exactly. And so for people who perhaps haven't heard your previous episodes
00:04:39.120with me, where we've talked about this, but I do want to just clarify it again. Can you explain
00:04:43.460the way you do in your book and that you have on other episodes? Trans history in general,
00:04:48.220it's not just the history of people who make one transition and stick with it. It's very expansive.
00:04:55.800Yeah, exactly. I think it's really important that we distinguish between trans people in history,
00:05:00.620which is basically people who've said that they were trans using that terminology, because
00:05:04.520obviously terminology and the way we think about gender changes so much between times and cultures.
00:05:08.720So distinguishing between trans people in history and trans history, which is the history that
00:05:14.260shows us that gender has never been something that's tied to the body, has never been something
00:05:18.520that's fixed or stable. And when we look at it that way, we find that there is so much history
00:05:26.420that shows us the messiness and the complexness of gender. And I think that this story that we're
00:05:31.560talking about today is a really, really good example of that. It might not be a trans person1.00
00:05:36.880in history, but it's absolutely trans history in the way that it shows us that gender has always0.58
00:05:42.140been something we can mess with. This is such a fascinating one, too. I'm not going to keep
00:05:48.240teasing everybody. We're going to get into the story. But first, how do you suggest, and I mean,
00:05:54.120a hundred people could suggest a hundred different ways to approach this but like this story like
00:05:59.260i'm assuming they them pronouns because that's they they specifically did that in their life
00:06:06.280after a certain point yeah i'm gonna use they them pronouns to talk about this person and it might be
00:06:12.760that it would probably be also appropriate to use she her for the point before they transformed and
00:06:19.800And I use the word transformed really advisedly because the narrative, the way this person understands themselves is having been a woman who then died and was reborn as a genderless spirit in a human body.
00:06:33.820So maybe we go from she, her to they, them, but they, them would also be an appropriate way to capture all of that massive complexity.
00:06:43.360Well, and that's also where I was thinking about, you know, because there's the whole thing about like, do you use, you know, like dead names and stuff?
00:06:48.560and i'm like well this person was this person and then became a new person very consciously so it's
00:06:54.320not like they said i was never jemima it's like no i was and then i stopped it so it's already
00:07:00.160it's complicated yeah and arguably dead name is a really appropriate term to use for this because
00:07:06.020literally identifies as dying and then coming back to life as a different gender and then also okay
00:07:13.740so we're going to talk about the situation so that's what i'll do i'll start so jemima wilkerson
00:07:18.380Wilkinson was born November 29th, 1752 in Cumberland, Rhode Island. So this is exactly
00:07:24.620the time period all the episodes are so far in this series. We're talking about people who were
00:07:28.700born in the 18th century, pre-American revolution, pre all the revolutions, but already the world is
00:07:36.640just from like the slave trade and other trade, like there's so much international stuff going
00:07:43.080on. People are moving from country to country. So it's already sort of a world that's kind of
00:07:47.800influx is what what she is born into so this is another ongoing recurring thing in this series is
00:07:55.600massive families so jemima is the eighth of 12 children of amy whipple and jeremiah wilkinson
00:08:03.460and they were actually the fourth generation of the family to live in america which is interesting
00:08:07.740because i think of like oh america is still a pretty new country but four generations in so
00:08:12.740they've been there a while. So just some notable connections. So their great-grandfather had been
00:08:19.500in the army of Charles I, emigrating around 1650. And then father was a cousin of Stephen Hopkins,
00:08:26.980one of the signers of the Declaration of Independence, which doesn't necessarily mean
00:08:30.980this is like, wow, look at these connections. It just means it was a small world. And a lot
00:08:36.000of people signed the Declaration of Independence. So the mom died when Jemima was around 12 years
00:08:41.960old giving birth to the 12 child another recurring motif in this series kit it's just people these0.53
00:08:48.720women having so many children and then inevitably dying giving birth to one of them it's just like
00:08:53.620oh yeah just imagine being pregnant for that much of your life and then dying in childbirth is
00:08:59.760having been pregnant once i plan to never do that again no matter like never mind 12 times that's0.97
00:09:05.200ridiculous. It's women who spent their entire adult married life just being pregnant and1.00
00:09:13.180breastfeeding and being pregnant and breastfeeding. So this is a Quaker family. You know about0.97
00:09:17.720Quakerism. Is that an expected thing in Quakerism? Or do you know, historically, was it to just have1.00
00:09:24.580like be fruitful and multiply and like just have lots of kids? Was that a thing?
00:09:28.880um it's probably just more of a kind of settler colonial thing at this time than it is primarily
00:09:36.080a quaker thing um so yeah i grew up in um in a loosely quaker family was raised to quaker until
00:09:42.700my um family left our local meeting house um but not particularly religious reasons just like
00:09:49.460interpersonal ones but um it's not a religion that's big on be fruitful and multiply it's much
00:09:54.880more about it's kind of i mean i like to think of it as one of the overall one of the most kind of
00:10:02.020humane branches of mainstream christianity um in that um there's a big emphasis on god's light
00:10:09.580being in everybody um on the valid validity of other religions they say the lamps are different
00:10:14.340but the lights are the same which is really nice and on pacifism which i know is something we're
00:10:18.920going to come on to um and so i think what's really going on with those 12 kids is the settler
00:10:24.320colonial context in North America and the desire to really populate that land and outcompete the
00:10:30.060Native Americans. I think that's what Amy is kind of being pressured towards from that angle.
00:10:37.180Yeah, no, absolutely. And that's certainly something that we see a lot in most colonial
00:10:42.740settler societies. It's just like we need to have as many white children as possible just to have1.00
00:10:47.060more population so the society of friends is that aka quaker is that are those interchangeable0.91
00:10:56.240or do you know exactly yeah they call themselves the society of friends other people call them
00:11:00.540quakers they kind of reclaim that label later on but um initially yeah they're the society of
00:11:06.060to themselves and so the quaker i'm just i didn't warn you i was going to be diving into quakerism
00:11:12.840with you but i was like oh moves up just because i saw in your book that you were raised quaker
00:11:16.440so were they religiously persecuted in england is that part of why they came to america
00:11:22.400yes absolutely so um there was a big exodus of um non-conformist religion um to um to america
00:11:32.220from england um there was i mean yes essentially non-conformist religion was really cracked down
00:11:38.900on particularly um following the restoration of charles ii there oh i can read you some facts
00:11:45.580that i've just looked up now and you can edit out me um i'm gonna know about it yeah yeah we'll just
00:11:50.560we'll take out everything i'll be like tell me about this and you can just say some facts yeah
00:11:53.620yeah yeah so the quaker act 1662 was an act explicitly aimed at persecuting the quakers
00:12:00.860and there was very little tolerance of what was called non-conformist religion in england in that
00:12:06.480period and so there was an exodus um of anyone who wasn't a kind of mainstream protestant during the
00:12:15.120mid to um late 17th century which i know is when um the wilkinson family come over so that's sort
00:12:23.200of like i've been learning i've never read up on the american revolution before i started doing
00:12:27.560this series but now i understand the kind of the northern colonies were founded by religious
00:12:33.880refugees and the southern american colonies were kind of like plantation business people
00:12:41.160yeah absolutely and so that's a really important cultural distinction partly in the way that they
00:12:48.340understand themselves and partly in the way they understand sort of the point of the usa although
00:12:54.660you know the point of the um colonies that they're establishing you know are they primarily to
00:13:00.200exploit the land to work the land and to exploit the enslaved people and make as much kind of
00:13:05.020money and productivity as possible? Or are they to found a society that's more religiously pure0.78
00:13:12.780and more religiously exemplary than England that they left behind was? And so the northern colonies0.86
00:13:18.980have that idea of we need to be the religious exemplars that we want to see in the world and
00:13:26.820we want everyone else to follow. And that's where a lot of that conflict comes from, really,
00:13:31.520is those different kind of concepts and understandings of what they think that
00:13:34.880country is even for. Yeah. And that was something I didn't realize till I started reading about this
00:13:39.120was that whole North and South thing that I hear about more in the context of the American Civil
00:13:43.760War started early. It was just kind of like there was already the North and the South were settled
00:13:48.400completely differently so mid 1770s so jemima wilkinson is in her early 20s and switched there's
00:14:00.480a lot of um leaving of the group by various people so jemima left the society of friends aka the
00:14:09.740quakers to attend meetings with the new light baptists which is another group um and so the
00:14:16.800Society of Friends disowned them because of this, which I mean, fair, like you left the group. So
00:14:23.620you kind of disowned them first. Yeah. Yeah. You can't fire me. I quit. So at around the same time,
00:14:30.460Jemima's sister Patience was dismissed from the Society of Friends as well for having an
00:14:35.600illegitimate child. And two of the, because there were 12 siblings. And so at this point,
00:14:40.620four of the siblings have been dismissed. Two of the brothers are dismissed because they went off
00:14:44.800to train for military service and this is around the time that the um american revolution was
00:14:50.880kicking off and lots of people were signing up for military service so just i would presume
00:14:57.820for a family where religion was so important that the roots of the family had fled persecution to
00:15:05.440come here to found this colony to to have four children disowned from the society of friends
00:15:10.620it's probably very traumatic, very stressful for everybody.
00:38:57.960so the friend was like other quakers called for the abolition of slavery persuaded followers who
00:39:04.420held who like were enslavers to free the enslaved people um several members of the congregation were
00:39:10.740black um and they acted as witnesses for many mission papers so i think that's the papers that
00:39:16.740were freeing some people from bondage um this is all this whole section i'm getting this all from
00:39:23.520this reference thank god that they have the public library women in world history i'm always excited
00:39:28.620when somebody i'm researching has one of these essays because they're all really well researched
00:39:31.640by academics but this is where they're just kind of getting into the friend preached humility and
00:39:37.140hospitality towards everyone kept religious meetings open to the public housed and fed
00:39:41.460visitors including those who came out of only out of curiosity and indigenous people which is a
00:39:47.700strange way to phrase that um the preacher generally had a cordial relationship with
00:39:53.440indigenous people and they had few personal possessions mostly given by followers and
00:39:58.200never held any real property except in trust um and then we get into so the friend preached
00:40:07.280sexual abstinence and disfavored marriage but did not see celibacy as mandatory and
00:40:12.680accepted marriage as preferable to breaking abstinence outside of wedlock
00:40:17.700what what's that do quakers think that or is this like we're getting some of the friends personal
00:40:24.940ideas this is an early quaker thing it's not so much great thing now because obviously you know
00:40:30.780things have evolved um but yeah it is um it is an early quaker thing and i guess it's part of
00:40:39.520the emphasis on kind of plain dress um and abstinence from things like alcohol and tobacco
00:40:46.320um which again were kind of early Quaker preoccupations um it's part of the abstinence
00:40:52.340from um pleasures of the body um but I think I mean this is if we're thinking about um
00:40:58.020situations in which um women could be liberated as a result of the friends preaching this is one
00:41:04.480of them right if you don't marry and you don't have sex you're not going to be pregnant for your
00:41:08.800entire adult life and then die giving birth to your 12th child right that's actually quite an
00:41:12.640opportunity for lots of people yeah so the speaking of women so the preacher the friend
00:41:18.100also said women should obey god rather than men and the most committed followers included roughly
00:41:24.960four dozen unmarried women known as the faithful sisterhood who took on leading roles of the sort
00:41:30.760that were often reserved for men the portion of households headed by women in the the society
00:41:37.000so what is it like there's the friend and their followers are considered a society
00:41:41.760yeah society of universal friends um are the is the name of their followers
00:41:47.080different from the society of friends which is aka quakers yeah right so the portion of0.95
00:41:53.240households held by women in the society settlements was 20 and that's much higher
00:41:57.520than in surrounding areas so this is what you mentioned earlier like kind of the feminist
00:42:02.220angle like women this is a difference between general quakerism and what the friend was
00:42:08.200preaching there's more opportunities for women right yeah exactly um particularly the idea that
00:42:14.620women should obey god rather than men you know that hasn't really at this time made it into
00:42:19.620the kind of mainstream quakerism despite their emphasis on non-hierarchical worship and yeah
00:42:26.680as i said particularly that opportunity to embrace not marrying um is something that
00:42:34.860it is a really a great way out of kind of compulsory heterosexuality and compulsory
00:42:40.380pregnancy um for women who want that at the time yeah there's gonna be like again i'm doing this
00:42:45.780whole series of a kind of people in the 18th century and there are several instances of women
00:42:49.860who got married because that was kind of the only thing you could do and then when the husband dies0.97
00:42:55.920leaving you with debt like that's you're fucked like there's nothing you can do because you're0.88
00:43:01.260a woman and maybe you have all these children and you can't own property so the what the friend0.99
00:43:07.200was offering i can see where that would appeal to people who wanted something other so due to
00:43:11.860the rising antagonism you're talking about you know the crowds what did you say attack them with
00:43:17.460bats or yeah stones and brick bats um in philadelphia there's a real religious objection
00:43:26.300to the idea that the friend is setting themselves up as a kind of religious exemplar and particularly
00:43:32.240as we said as we mentioned those comparisons with jesus this person coming around with a
00:43:37.320band of followers saying i was resurrected that's a little concerning to a lot of christians at the
00:43:45.140time well and considering too in these areas like rhode island and connecticut like these are
00:43:50.320the areas that were founded by people fleeing religious persecution in england so these are
00:43:54.620people whatever fourth generation people religion is so important to them like they take it so
00:44:00.520seriously and so literally that this would be seen as really a threat um and so uh 1783 they
00:44:08.380transferred the headquarters to philadelphia which is where their only published work that they
00:44:13.800actually wrote appeared the universal friends advice to those of the same religious society
00:44:20.000recommended to be read in their public meetings um however philadelphia was only slightly less
00:44:25.540intolerant and so in 1785 they returned to new england and then met sarah and abraham richards
00:44:33.120so they had an unhappy marriage sarah met the society of friends as a widow and then with the
00:44:40.840infant daughter took up residence with the friend and sarah also adopted the same look the same
00:44:46.600androgynous robes look apparently the same dress and mannerisms as did a few other close female
00:44:53.320friends and came to be called sarah friend so this is another where you're like cult or religion
00:45:00.240like the fact that the followers started dressing like using the same mannerisms which you see in
00:45:05.660fandoms i guess you know if someone's again a fan of taylor swift not that i'm calling that a cult
00:45:11.020but people would swifties like they quote her a lot i think they would do the same dances as her
00:45:16.980it's like you maybe cut your hair like her you dress like her because that's who you idolize
00:45:20.320but here them dressing like the friend and adopting the mannerisms just does it's a little
00:45:26.960culty to me is how it sounds but sarah friend became a high up person in this group um they
00:45:35.260were entrusted with holding the society's property and trust and was sent to be sort of a backup
00:45:39.880preacher in one part of the country when the friend was in another and maybe that's like
00:45:43.680maybe that's why you want kind of doppelgangers so you can have lookalikes so you can do more
00:45:50.940speaking engagements i don't know it's a good strategy i could do with some of them
00:45:55.960so sarah friend had a large part in planning and building the house in which she and the friend
00:46:01.480lived in the town of jerusalem and when she died in 1793 left her child to the friend's care
00:46:07.300so sarah friend an example of followers so there's a lot of detail in here we don't necessarily need
00:46:17.160to get to but the friend was meeting with some influential people of the time so we're in 1794
00:46:22.540it's like post post american revolution like that ended 10 years ago but there's still people are
00:46:27.740trying to figure out what is this new american country gonna be like how is it gonna work with
00:46:34.680like the indigenous people and the colonists and like inventing this new country and how is it
00:46:39.600going to be so the iroquois were involved in producing this treaty and the friend gave a
00:46:47.500speech to u.s government officials and iroquois chiefs about the importance of peace and love
00:46:52.180which the iroquois liked so i don't i don't know bringing the public universal friend i don't know
00:46:57.380how i think there's i don't want to say that the other people writing these treaties were more
00:47:02.480suitable for doing that because these treaties were all terrible and shitty but i also think
00:47:06.080the public universal friend is a wild person to involve in these sorts of discussions because i0.53
00:47:11.380don't see them as having really both feet in reality yeah they have zero expertise in actually
00:47:18.100negotiating humane treaties um i don't know what's going on there i yeah for some reason
00:47:25.760But part of this was when I was looking through this, I was trying to see this whole series and finding connections between all the people, like some of those unexpected connections between people who you wouldn't think can connect back to each other.
00:47:38.140So this is where the friend is involved with some of the great thinkers of the time, just because I think they were just a celebrity the same way that, you know, like the White House might invite some poets or something.
00:47:50.100It's like, well, you're just kind of a notable person of the time.
00:47:52.440so 1788 they decided to try a different climate for preaching and purchased a large parcel of
00:47:57.900land in yates county near seneca lake in western new york state within two years it was ready
00:48:03.900enough that the rest of the universal friends set out to join it making it the largest non-native
00:48:07.680community in western new york one might say like a cult might do uh-huh well do you know when you0.51
00:48:15.660said cult earlier i was like this is the cultiest thing they do is create their own like cult
00:48:20.380compound yes this is the part where i'm just like i i can't see how this is nautical okay but then
00:48:26.600there's drama about land purchasing because i think partially because the public universal friend
00:48:32.760is not concerned with like the laws of society and this is kind of like here's what i want to do
00:48:40.180they're not a human right they're a spirit in a human body laws aren't for those
00:48:45.280paperwork. That's not a thing for spirits to do. So anyway, I'm not going to get into all
00:48:54.840these details, but the town became known as the Friends Settlement. There was a whole issue about
00:49:00.700kind of like who owns this land, who is going to pay for this land, a whole thing about finance
00:49:07.560years. More and more settlers kept coming and that drove prices higher. It was sort of like a
00:49:14.620bit of a fire festival situation if you know what that is just kind of like people were coming and
00:49:19.760there was not the infrastructure there to support a community because of course not because public
00:49:24.100universal friend isn't like creating the infrastructure to have an actual functioning
00:49:29.140society they're just like vibing with yeah god messages it's just like yeah but where are we
00:49:35.300what's the water source friends like do you know anything about plumbing friends can you build
00:49:42.060houses yeah no yeah so it didn't so there but there's other people in the group and maybe they
00:49:47.900have some skills so at one point one person acquired a large area of land in canada um
00:49:54.540but oh sarah friend still on the scene so she persuaded the friend not to move to canada so
00:50:00.980i was like oh is this going to be canadian content no anyways they were just trying to find other
00:50:06.900places to build their place um eventually so the new town that they settled in was along a creek
00:50:13.540that emptied into the crooked lake cuba lake the new town which the universal friends began there
00:50:19.380came to be called jerusalem which is really the name of the towns that a lot of christians found
00:50:24.700in various places to be like this is that's just what there's so many places in america called
00:50:29.940Salem and things because it's just like religious people see this as kind of like this is it's like
00:50:36.860Jerusalem anyway so this enterprise did better I guess I guess there were some helpful people
00:50:41.840with actual skills prospered in agriculture and lumbering by 1800 had increased to about 260
00:50:47.060members but as it prospered there's issues about like well who's where's this money going and again
00:50:56.000the friend is not a financier the friend is just really not concerned with worldly matters
00:51:02.740apparently the friend developed a penchant for requesting gifts and personal effects from
00:51:09.140members by saying the friend hath need of these things this is what celebrity does to you i guess
00:51:15.020yeah um and then assigned degrading forms of punishment for various infractions of the society
00:51:21.280rules so because earlier it had said that um the friend had very few personal possessions and stuff
00:51:27.640it's like yeah but they had all these things that were other people's possessions that they
00:51:32.700came to possess so people were becoming disillusioned not everybody but some people
00:51:39.800so in the fall of 1799 some followers led attempts several attempts to arrest the friend for blasphemy
00:51:46.400uh which was probably more to do with disagreements over land ownership and power and this is it's a
00:51:55.180familiar situation i think where people have all the best intentions in the world or spiritual
00:52:02.640intentions or something but once you get a bunch of people having to live day to day like you're
00:52:07.340gonna get into some fights and some hurt feelings and things you can't just be like everyone love
00:52:13.780each other like this kind of hippie commune eventually that's not going to work um an
00:52:20.780officer tried to seize the friend while riding on the horse but the friend a skilled horse rider
00:52:26.020escaped i like that moment that's in a movie that'll be a big scene oh yeah0.90
00:52:33.420not to mention uh an officer and assistant later tried to arrest the friend at home but the women
00:52:40.960of the host drove the men off and tore their clothes another exciting sequence in the film
00:52:45.540a third attempt was carefully planned by a posse of 30 men who surrounded the home after midnight
00:52:50.900broke the door down with an axe and intended intended to carry the friend off in an ox cart
00:52:55.900but a doctor who had come with the posse found that the friend was in too poor a state of health
00:53:01.500to be moved so okay um they made a deal that the friend would appear before in ontario the
00:53:10.860to ontario america um county court in june 1800 anyway eventually the friend appeared before the
00:53:19.040court it ruled that no indictable offense had been committed and the judge in fact invited
00:53:23.780the preacher to give a sermon to those in attendance so um like i it's like there's
00:53:32.080some details in here you hadn't encountered before and i just kind of knew the vague outline
00:53:35.680that this person existed but i didn't realize that there was all this drama yeah i so i knew
00:53:42.360i knew about the mobs in philadelphia i didn't know about the repeated attempts to actually
00:53:47.820enter their cult compound slash um you know society um and actually seize them um this
00:53:57.160this detail was new to me and it's really striking the amount of planning and the amount of anger
00:54:05.100of motivation that really has to go into that you know that's not just opportunistic oh this
00:54:10.040person's down the road let's go and throw some stones because it'll be fun that's really people
00:54:14.360sitting and plotting and thinking we need to get rid of this person and 30 of us are going to turn
00:54:18.560it with pitchforks you know that's quite a lot but then i love the turn that found not guilty
00:54:25.940and the judge is like and please i would love to hear you give one of your sermons like so there's
00:54:31.700just as many fans as there are enemies seems like still so having set aside 12 000 acres of the
00:54:40.860colony's property which again like to go back to something we talked at the very beginning is just
00:54:45.940like these are white people quote-unquote buying land that belongs to the indigenous people of the
00:54:55.480area. Like this is not just an open field that no one's ever lived on before. So as much as the
00:55:03.260friend is like, everybody has their special light and spirit inside of them and all humans are
00:55:07.600special. It's kind of like, yeah, but also 12,000 acres of this are going to be turned into my
00:55:12.760personal use now. So, um, they had an estate built on the furthest corner of the property
01:02:03.120Public Universal Friend, I don't know if that's an inspiring person.
01:02:05.740um but it's an interesting person and I think what I'm learning about trans history as I go
01:02:14.320through these episodes um and learning from you and from other scholars is just kind of
01:02:18.340looking backwards at somebody lived their life in a certain way and then sometime in the 20th
01:02:23.820century somebody came along to be like well actually this is what it is and here's how it's
01:02:28.700actually a woman and here's why that's inspiring and then in kind of the 21st century someone
01:02:33.580comes along to be like is it that like the way that each generation sort of reinterprets the
01:02:39.540stories and so I try to as much as possible look back at like who was the person actually
01:02:44.620not how were they reinterpreted or people again this story is so it's different in the sense that
01:02:52.040the public universal friend very clearly said who they were so for people saying like here's what I
01:02:56.500think was actually going on in their head it's like we know what was going on in this person's
01:03:01.120actually because they made their whole life just telling the story of who they were and why they
01:03:06.460were but this is the sort of reason why i love having you on the show and having other scholars
01:03:11.600on the show because i i want to be able to describe this well for listeners who are maybe
01:03:18.600new to trans history or new to this way of thinking about narratives yeah sure and i think
01:03:24.060you know like i was saying it's really important to say that is none of this is about saying that
01:03:30.160you can't understand this as a really inspiring piece of feminist history although as i say the
01:03:36.520extent to which you might want to be inspired by this particular example is you know maybe up for
01:03:41.720debate um but there's um you know even if we think about it as someone doing things that most people
01:03:48.040assigned female at birth couldn't do there's no one saying that you can't find that important
01:03:51.980but it's also i think equally important particularly in a climate where trans history is so often
01:03:58.220erased and where the claim that trans people are new is being used politically and really
01:04:02.840meaningful and harmful ways it is also important to say that what is going on here is an example
01:04:09.200of people being able to understand the concept of a genderless person or a genderless spirit
01:04:14.740in the 18th century and that's pretty cool yeah yeah exactly and as you said also and in a
01:04:23.060christian religious context yeah yeah so that's i really appreciate being able to like the
01:04:30.920scholarship that exists so i can have episodes like this talking about interesting people from
01:04:34.460trans history on this podcast and on the podcast i do try to focus on weird stories or people who
01:04:41.620are living sort of audacious scandalous lives which is exactly what this is so i don't i never0.78
01:04:47.160want anyone to feel like i'm taking away from women's history by talking about trans history0.70
01:04:52.520I think it's all it's all one thing it's just history of just one doesn't have to negate the
01:04:59.460other basically absolutely yeah it can be women's history and trans history and it can be history
01:05:04.880of gender not limiting us and gender not being something that we can't change and mold into
01:05:10.540what we want it to be and that's liberating for everyone right and I think this story too just in
01:05:15.900the context of trans history it's another interesting example of the trans history
01:05:20.720comprises all kinds of different gender experiences including that of people who
01:05:26.500die and are reborn as god incarnate in a genderless form exactly you know like in the acronym the
01:05:37.080lgbtqia plus this is the plus yeah there's a lot under that plus and you know some of it is
01:05:44.660resurrection yeah yeah exactly the plus contains a lot and so at the end of most of my episodes
01:05:52.500although i forgot to do this last time i had you on the show i like to um score the people who talk
01:05:58.940about in a variety of categories um just sort of as a way to wrap things up but also as a way to
01:06:03.100sort of just compare people to each other and a way to um there's certain historical characteristics
01:06:08.800that are celebrated in traditional conventional mainstream patriarchal history and on my show
01:06:14.600I want to celebrate other things to, to give a really high score to people who may not on other
01:06:19.860people's scales. And so if you would indulge me. So for public universal friend, we're going to
01:06:25.040go through these four categories, which I have forewarned you about. And the first category is
01:06:30.740scandalousness. In the context of this, it means how scandalous were they to the world in which
01:06:38.720they lived? Because there's sometimes when you look at the history of, I don't know, let's say
01:06:43.500like ancient rome which we're gonna look at later but that's a world where it's like oh did you kill
01:06:49.720your father and then poison your grandmother and then marry your sister it's like okay that's just
01:06:55.120kind of what we do so like to add that scandalous but in their era it wouldn't be so we're looking
01:07:00.480at how scandalous was this person considering their time and place um and public universal friend
01:07:06.100i mean as attested by the angry mobs i think was seen as pretty scandalous yeah you don't get
01:07:13.500stones and brickbats thrown at you you don't get 30 people showing up at your house with an ox
01:07:18.020cart if you're not pretty high on the scandaliciousness score i think yeah so on a scale
01:07:23.880of zero to ten i'm just thinking so certainly the reaction that they had so the and part of it too
01:07:31.280is not just did things happen to them that were scandalous but how much were they actively doing
01:07:36.260things that people found scandalous and their whole deal like the whole like i'm gonna be a0.96
01:07:42.700quaker type person but i'm also going to be a celebrity which is so against like the quakers
01:07:47.560i think would be like 10 out of 10 this person is horrific oh yeah and then to the quakers themselves0.99
01:07:54.460so i think it's a pretty high score and then in society in general like the whole the gender1.00
01:07:58.960presentation stuff i think people are kind of freaked out by that the people from other
01:08:03.100denominations who were startled by the like does this person think they're jesus that is
01:08:07.960i'm tempted to say 10 out of 10 for scandalousness honestly i was gonna go for 9 or 10 yeah i mean
01:08:14.560like yeah like you say that you don't get much more scandalous than we are scared this person
01:08:19.740literally thinks they're jesus in a pretty fundamentalist christian community yeah i mean
01:08:25.280i don't even know the only thing that would be maybe more scandalous would be like this person
01:08:29.560says they're satan but i don't know so let's say let's say 9.5 the next category is the scheminess
01:08:37.180and in this show we that's a positive people with a scheme and a plan um how much are they sort of
01:08:44.900like they see what's going on and they can kind of roll with the punches and move along with it
01:08:50.540and this is interesting to me to think about because the public universal friend i don't know
01:08:55.620how much they had a scheme and a plan and how much they were just kind of like just vibing just yeah
01:09:03.200you said vibing earlier didn't you i mean on like if you if you take the conspiracy theory route of
01:09:09.000like all of this is a scheme be reborn as a genderless person gain incredible celebrity
01:09:15.880be able to demand any gifts you want by saying the friend has need of these things if you see
01:09:21.040that as like an actual plan that's incredibly schemey i'm not sure it was an actual plan i
01:09:26.600think this person was just kind of going with the flow a bit so i would maybe go lower on that
01:09:33.200But if we decide that everything was actually planned, then it would be much higher.
01:09:39.380I don't think it was actually planned.
01:09:42.100My interpretation of this just seems like eventually they did get followers and, you know, a beautiful house and anything from anybody that they wanted.
01:09:50.320But I think if it had been a real grift scheme, there would have been more like money making stuff going on.
01:09:56.400and there wasn't really like it's just kind of the followers came and then that brought with a
01:10:01.180drama about property taxes and whatever but i think the friend was just kind of like here's
01:10:05.180what i want to do be a preacher so i feel like the scheminess is is low but that's part of what
01:10:12.180makes it interesting because like they cause so much chaos without really scheming just yeah
01:10:18.980without really meaning to and like you know there was i think there was some opportunism and
01:10:24.760materialism behind it but there was also like some sincere religious belief that they genuinely had
01:10:30.260been reborn and had a vision of god and things so yeah i'd go i'd go maybe like three or four there
01:10:36.320i think i'm gonna say four um because i do want to especially part i'm gonna go up from a three
01:10:44.040two or four because of that part where they republish that other person's book yes
01:10:48.640the plagiarism well i just thought more people would read it if it had my name on it
01:10:55.280okay so significance and this can be there's this story has a lot of resonances so there's
01:11:03.380stuff like in terms of just american history significance um like the first american to
01:11:08.180found a religious order the but then there's also stuff like significance to trans history