00:00:00.000Hello, welcome to Vulgar History, a feminist women's history comedy podcast. My name is0.97
00:00:16.600Anne Foster and today we have a very special guest who is Daphne Palmer Janikopoulos, author
00:00:22.820of a book that just came out called The Pirate's Wife, The Remarkable True Story of Sarah Kidd.
00:00:27.920And so she is going to join me to help share the story of Sarah Kidd, who is married to the famous pirate Captain Kidd, who you might have heard about.
00:00:36.800It's a really interesting story. And I hope you enjoy this talk with Daphne Palmer Janikopoulos.
00:00:43.140OK, so I'm joined today by Daphne Palmer Janikopoulos, author of The Pirate's Wife, The Remarkable True Story of Sarah Kidd.
00:00:52.940Thank you. It's a pleasure to be here.
00:00:55.720Yeah, I think I'm really excited to get to learn more about your book and also about Sarah Kidd.
00:01:02.260But my first question is how like this is a whole book just about Sarah Kidd, who is the wife of Captain Kidd.
00:01:10.040We're going to talk about that. How did you come across enough information to write a whole book about her?
00:01:15.040Well, I first got interested in pirates when I wrote a freelance piece for the New York Times Museum special section about the Witta Pirate Museum in Provincetown.
00:01:29.040And when I saw the artifacts of the pirates, I realized that they had lives and connections on land.
00:01:36.620And the legend of the captain of the Witta pirate ship, Sam Bellamy, had a love interest, Maria Hallett.
00:01:45.040And that told me that pirates might have families and communities.
00:01:48.900And I hadn't thought about that before.
00:01:51.260So in the course of writing my first book, The Pirate Next Door,
00:01:55.420the untold story of 18th century pirates' wives, families, and communities,
00:02:01.940I learned about Sarah Kidd, and I knew that she would be worth a deeper look.
00:02:08.040And so what sorts of resources did you have to learn about her?0.97
00:02:12.280I used a variety of sources because women left little record of their affairs.0.93
00:02:18.500Most women, including Sarah, were illiterate because men owned all the property and exercised most of the legal rights at the time.0.98
00:02:28.620And history was written by men for men.
00:02:31.220In order to explore Sarah's life, I read a lot of contextual history of pirates and of the time period, which gave me the broad scope of the economic, political and social conditions under which she lived in.
00:02:48.400And I was able to find some important primary sources of Sarah's that she left.
00:02:54.080And, for example, her petition to the governor of Massachusetts, Lord Belmont, and asking him to give her back her seized property.
00:03:08.080And she left a will and a number of other things.
00:03:11.400There was a lot of land transactions and genealogical information.
00:03:17.240Many of the ancient sources that I relied on were handwritten, and I transcribed them to make them easier to work with.
00:03:24.540I also visited the archives in the places where Sarah and Captain Kidd had lived.
00:03:29.920Those were in New York and Boston and Rhode Island.
00:03:33.600And I walked the surroundings where she had been to get a greater sense of her world at the time.
00:03:40.700I also found some really great resources at the National Archives in London, among the
00:03:46.640Admiralty Papers, and at the Library of Congress in Washington.
00:03:51.580And Captain Kidd also left statements, recorded statements, that gave evidence of their relationship.
00:03:59.740So can you contextualize, if we're just kind of starting at the very beginning of the story,
00:04:06.140So Sarah, it starts with she's a young teenager and she immigrates over.
00:04:10.980So what was the what was the reason her family came over to the United States?
00:04:15.480She was 14 years old when she came from England to New York with her father and two brothers.
00:04:24.000The reason they came was to get a fresh start, to get a fresh start in the new world and opportunities.
00:04:30.960Her father was a mariner and he owned it, owned transatlantic vessels.
00:04:36.140So trade was booming in Manhattan, and he came for those economic advantages.
00:04:45.160Sorry, and can you just contextualize for the listeners, what year is this?
00:14:52.260So for five years, he was home, except when he went on his trips to Antigua to deliver
00:15:02.420goods for his merchant shipping business.
00:15:06.520But then after five years, he really got the itch to have a dream job, and that is to get back into serious privateering, and he wanted to be sponsored by the monarch. That was his dream job.
00:15:23.140And so what happens next? So he starts traveling more effectively, like he's away more often?
00:15:31.100So he promises Sarah that he will he will be back very soon, but he wanted the opportunity to see if he could get this dream job with the King of England and investors.
00:15:47.120So he he he tells Sarah, I'll be back by Christmas.
00:15:53.440And he brings with him Sarah's younger brother, Samuel Jr., who.
00:16:01.100Those two have a very special relationship.
00:16:03.800Kidd is more like a big brother or an uncle to him.
00:16:07.980He mentors him and teaches him the way of being a sailor.
00:16:13.260And so he brings him with him, Samuel Jr., to London, where Captain Kidd tries and succeeds at getting this privateering job.
00:16:24.480So he's gone for almost a year and he comes back and he tells Sarah that he's got this great opportunity and he promises her it's a one year gig.
00:16:39.680It's a one year job. He'll be back. And this is this is an opportunity of a lifetime.
00:16:47.780so he does go and she lets him go and uh they spend time together every minute before he leaves
00:16:56.380and um he uh when he sets out on his voyage it's just supposed to be for one year that's what his
00:17:04.220contract says but while he's at sea for a year he doesn't find any prizes to capture
00:17:11.480so he stays an extra year and then he stays an extra year and it's three years now and his men
00:17:19.760are are really unhappy because they have no money to pay to earn they they've earned no money and
00:17:28.420they have no money to send back to their family so things are difficult after three years and
00:17:35.260And the ship that he was given, a brand new ship called the Adventure Galley, is now leaking and in bad repair.
00:17:43.040And the men are mutinous and the conditions on board are terrible.
00:17:46.620So it's a very difficult time for Captain Kidd.
00:17:51.640And his men insist that they just take any prize that they can because they are now desperate.
00:17:59.660And that's where he breaks his contract and captures ships that are not just French ships.
00:18:26.360And they use Captain Kidd as a scapegoat.
00:18:29.660In the meantime, Captain Kidd comes back after three years to get Sarah.
00:18:37.360He is now a wanted man, and he comes back to get Sarah so that together they can plot how he can try to get pardoned from Lord Belmont, who is the governor of New York and Massachusetts.
00:18:54.300But Lord Belmont also is he wears two hats.
00:18:59.280He's not only the governor appointed by the king, whose mission, by the way, is to stamp out piracy in the colonies, but he is also a private investor in Captain Kidd's privateering voyage.
00:19:13.220And he has a lot to gain if Captain Kidd is successful in carrying out the mission of capturing French ships.
00:19:50.120He doesn't go into Manhattan because he knows he'll be captured.
00:19:53.780And he has her taken by ship with their children to Block Island, where he's arranged for her to stay safely with some friends of his until he can get to Block Island, which is a small island in Long Island Sound, where he will come and get her and they will be reunited after three years.
00:20:16.040So this is where what I find really compelling, and I'm sure this is part of what led you to write the book, is the fact that, like you were saying, you know, pirates had people at home.
00:20:25.400They had loved ones, they had families. But the fact that he and she, like that they're so drawn to each other, despite all of these circumstances, he's finding ways, even though it's complicated, to reunite with her because they were so in love.
00:21:47.000She put herself in harm's way because of her devotion.
00:21:51.180She absolutely believed in him and he needed her too.
00:21:54.940He absolutely relied on her skill as street savvy
00:22:00.900and her support and her commitment to keeping their family together.
00:22:06.680And that's just, when I think of pirates, I don't think of that side of things. I don't
00:22:11.280think of them being a devoted, like you just said, devoted to the family, devoted to the wife. I
00:22:16.100think that's such an interesting and unexpected thing for me to learn. So how did their reunion
00:22:22.820go on Block Island? Well, it went very well. He came for her. Before she arrived there,
00:22:33.520when she was in transit, Captain Kidd dropped off cannon and ammunition on the front lawn of
00:22:42.420his friend's house and pointed the cannon towards the harbor, which was a signal to anyone,
00:22:50.120any of the authorities, don't mess with my wife and family. So he made arrangements to protect her
00:22:58.340and his daughters. And he did come for her. She rode on his pirate ship, she and their daughters
00:23:10.420and their maid. And she invited her friends that she was staying with. They were all on the pirate
00:23:17.160ship sailing around um long island sound for a couple of days not just having fun they although
00:23:26.580when they reunited captain kid had made arrangements to have a feast of uh as a form of
00:23:33.560reunion celebration of um sheep uh he had spices he had rum spices to cook the sheep and um so they
00:23:45.680They had they had a festive reunion and then they got down to business on how how he was going to try to secure a pardon with the governor,
00:23:58.020who is now has moved from Manhattan to Boston to check out things in that colony.
00:24:05.160So I like thinking that they were reunited.
00:24:09.040Obviously, they were very devoted to each other, very in love.
00:24:12.940But also she was helping him strategize, presumably, to figure out based on what she knew from having been living there for so long.
00:24:21.060Maybe she would know who her friends were, who she could maybe contact, who she could petition to maybe find support for him.
00:24:29.200Do you think that was part of their strategy?
00:24:31.680Yes. I think she applied her natural instincts of nurturing and protecting. And I think that was her strongest suit. While they were on his boat, which is called the St. Antonio, he received a letter via a messenger from the governor saying, if you are as innocent as you say, come to Boston and you will be pardoned.
00:25:00.580Well, together they read that and it just didn't ring quite true that he wouldn't put in writing a more committed, a stronger commitment for Captain Kidd.
00:25:16.080So I think what she contributed to him was her womanly instincts of, wait a minute, let's make sure that we're more secure, more safe.
00:25:28.420let's write back and buy more time until we can get a clearer sense of really what's going on
00:25:37.180with with things but he relied on her for that absolutely he did her and that's where
00:25:45.560I think a lot of the the strength of your book as well is you found these primary sources and
00:25:51.020you're looking at the events that happened and then kind of deducing what Sarah's role would
00:25:56.900have been in these events given that we don't have her writings we don't have her diaries so
00:26:02.660we know that she and he were on the ship together you just said they um you know they were suspicious
00:26:09.680of this of this letter so then what happened next so they go to they sail they're very suspicious
00:26:18.840And Captain Kidd has a ship full of treasure.
00:26:23.300So he goes to Gardner's Island, which is in Long Island Sound.
00:26:28.720So he is in Long Island Sound, picture this, at Block Island.
00:28:39.860So Captain Kidd buries it on Gardner's Island.
00:28:45.060They offload all the treasure on there.
00:28:48.000And then they return to Boston, and the ship is now empty of any treasure.
00:28:53.820So Captain Kidd arrives and after a couple of days trying to get a meeting with the governor, he is finally granted a meeting and he is asking for a pardon.
00:29:06.780And the governor doesn't trust him and arrests him and puts him in prison there in Boston.
00:29:14.320and he's chained with 16 pound weights
00:37:39.480And she sends two petitions to the governor.
00:37:45.640One of them is politely demanding that the governor return her personal belongings that
00:37:51.860were seized because it's all she has to live on.
00:37:56.940And they were returned to her, which is really interesting.
00:38:01.960So she did get her silver back and her money back.
00:38:07.940The second petition she sent, she sent three petitions while kid was in prison. First one was give me my stuff back, which they did. The second one was, let me go visit my husband. He's in need of his wife's affection. And the governor did not grant that.
00:38:28.260And then the third one was, we're now into the dead of winter in Boston.
00:38:34.920And of course, there's no heat in this.
00:40:09.440the treasure that was dug up from Gardner's Island
00:40:12.440is put on a ship. His ship, the San Antonio, is taken also. And these all go back, go across the
00:40:24.120Atlantic to London. In addition, Kidd's men, who were his crew, are arrested and taken with him
00:40:33.040to London. So he is there imprisoned again in solitary confinement for over a year awaiting
00:40:42.700trial. And that goes, I think, somewhat famously very badly for him. It does. And at this point,
00:40:51.340he is starting to go mad because he is physically so worn down and so emotionally worn down from
00:41:01.640being in solitary confinement in chains in Boston for almost a year, and then in London
00:41:10.100in the same conditions for another year. So the man's spirit is just depleted. He does manage to
00:41:21.820write some amazing letters defending himself but you also see from his handwriting and from what
00:41:32.880he writes that he is now a desperate desperate man pleading for his life and by the way his
00:41:41.580his one his evidence is gone missing conveniently so there it's very difficult for him to defend
00:41:51.500himself. He also was given lawyers, but not enough legal representation. So it was really unfair
00:42:00.340the conditions under which he was tried. He really had no chance. The ending was
00:42:08.360predetermined. This was a trial that the people, his enemies, wanted him to be found guilty.
00:42:15.300Yes. Yes. The trial documents are very, very interesting, but they're also, I found them hard to read. Hard to read meaning it was just so sad to hear it all going on. But that's because I really thought Captain Kidd was a decent man. I didn't think he was, how they made him out to be is like this monster. I didn't see him that way.
00:42:43.360he was um he was tried not only for piracy he was tried for murder too and what happened there was
00:42:51.940that on the third year when the men were in desperate desperate situations and they were
00:43:01.100very very mutinous and one of his crew members who is the gunner meaning he ran the the cannon
00:43:09.640mouthed off to Captain Kidd. And a captain of a ship just cannot have disrespect and insolence
00:43:19.140among his crew members. And in the 17th century, what captains did to their crews on a good day
00:43:28.520may not have been the best of things. Some of the punishment was very harsh.
00:43:35.280Anyway, so this gunner mouths off to Captain Kidd and Captain Kidd gets angry because,
00:43:42.060of course, he's in straits also desperate to try to save his ship that's leaking and
00:43:49.540to capture prizes, to appease his men and his investors and the king in England.
00:43:57.020And so the gunner who mouths off, Captain Kidd hits him with a wooden bucket on the head and the guy dies the next day.
00:44:06.480So that then he's accused of being a murderer, but it wasn't premeditated.
00:44:11.700It was an act of of anger and disciplining the insolent crew member.
00:44:20.460So Captain Kidd is now tried for murder and piracy, and he was found guilty of murder.
00:44:32.240Once you have one conviction, there's no way you're going to get out of that one.
00:44:37.280So he was tried for murder, and then he was found guilty of piracy also.
00:44:44.420And where was Sarah while all this trial was happening in England?
00:44:49.900She had left Boston when he was put on a ship to go to London,
00:44:55.120And she returned home to New York, to her home.
00:44:59.480She lived on the corner of Pearl Street and Hanover Street in the Hanover Square area of Manhattan, which is now the financial district of Manhattan.
00:45:13.440So she returned to her home there waiting, thinking that he would be found not guilty.
00:45:20.700and at the same time hoping that he would be pardoned because the king issued a proclamation
00:45:28.280pardoning pirates. He was trying to rid the seas of pirates and this happened a couple of times
00:45:36.160that the king issued pardons and this pardon Sarah was really hopeful would apply to Captain
00:45:44.920kid but the king specifically named the captain kid would not be in the broad pardon of pirates
00:45:54.140and so he was found guilty and was put to death right yes he was hanged on the river thames
00:46:04.180and his body was left in chains for years as a as a reminder to anyone who would think of turning
00:46:13.800pirate to let them know it was a terrible idea. And so this, where does this leave Sarah other
00:46:21.800than devastated? Um, but she's again, widowed, still quite young. What does, what does she do?
00:46:31.500Well, she waits. It takes several weeks for her to learn that Captain Kidd's
00:46:36.200been found guilty and that he's been executed. And when she gets the news,
00:46:44.360the authorities in New York come and confiscate everything from her. So she loses her home,
00:46:51.580her properties, and all her personal belongings. And she's destitute and she's a social outcast.
00:47:00.160With, I mean, this is part of what I find so compelling about your book and just this story
00:47:05.720is the the way her fortunes just like things are good and then they're terrible and then they're
00:47:10.940good again like just the swings that she is dealing with so she's again destitute but she
00:47:17.560she's a resilient person certainly and so how what does she do so she mourns captain kid for
00:47:25.720two years and she has got to figure out what to do and she does what she needs to do0.95
00:47:33.820And she remarries. And with the help of her father, she remarries an East Jersey merchant named Christopher Rouspe.
00:47:45.080And with the help of her father, she's able to offer a dowry, which is some property that she had.
00:47:54.740What was in Captain Kidd's name, as all property was, it was in the man's name.
00:47:59.920And she has her father take the property and give it to Christopher Rouspe.
00:50:46.460And I really wanted to set history straight to bring her into the light, to give her credit where credit was due.
00:50:57.260And I think details like you mentioned on this podcast, but also in the book, like the fact that they were friends, like they knew each other, they became quite good friends before they even got married, like while she was still married to her second husband.
00:51:09.420The fact that got married, what was it, two days after that husband passed away, like it speaks to, I think often when I think of people in this era, you think about arranged marriages or you think about people who maybe are forced into it or something.
00:51:23.720But these were two people who really liked each other, got married and just had this really strong partnership.
00:51:29.900And I think that's also that's also worth bringing to the forefront.
00:52:03.000Her mother, we don't know when her mother passed away.
00:52:07.760there's no primary sources to inform when Sarah lost her. But Sarah went through all of these
00:52:17.880tragedies alone, and she just had to keep figuring it out. And I think her ability to recover from
00:52:26.620tragedies and to reinvent herself and to keep figuring it out, but she also did it within the
00:52:34.100strictures of 17th and 18th century society, which were very limited on women. They had no0.85
00:52:41.540legal identity. They were all based, their whole being was based on a man, through a man.0.98
00:52:48.680But Sarah was able to navigate herself through the limitations to create a life for herself,
00:52:58.260which in the end was very successful. And she restored herself. She died. Her will shows that
00:53:06.360she had all her properties. She had five children that survived to adulthood. And that in itself
00:53:13.980is amazing because so many women died in childbirth. So Sarah not only was physically0.92
00:53:20.740strong living to the age of 74, she was physically strong surviving childbirth and surviving
00:53:27.880five pregnancies and her children lived to adulthood. I mean, she's an amazing woman
00:53:35.860with a character that is really worth bringing to the forefront of empowering women who have
00:53:46.620tragedies, but you can pick yourself up and keep going, which is what Sarah Kidd did.
00:53:54.420And I think just the fact that her character comes through so strongly, despite not having her diaries, despite not like just the evidence that you were able to find, it really, it's enough to put together.
00:54:10.600We can see what kind of a person she was just based on the evidence that was left behind.
00:54:14.240Like that was how strong her character was, that it's that it comes through just from.
01:04:07.980And her son and grandson are buried there.
01:04:11.460And her offspring and the future generations continued to use Trinity Church until the 1800s.
01:04:24.100So her significance, I would say, is on her family, and she passed on her sense of values, family values.
01:04:34.620She was very religious, very, very religious attending this Anglican church, Trinity Church.
01:04:42.140So the significance, I would give her a 10 for her immediate family.
01:04:47.580And now that this book has brought her into the light, I think it's a book of empowerment for men and women that they can see how relationships can work together.
01:05:01.200and um so i think that she is a 10 um in history and then the final category is i describe it as
01:05:11.760the sexism bonus it's kind of for women who could have done more if not for the state of women in
01:05:18.660the world to give them some more points if they need them i think certainly like the fact that1.00
01:05:23.900she couldn't own her own property you know she couldn't have her own money would have gotten in1.00
01:05:29.140her way. But I would argue that she did very well for herself considering how few rights women had.1.00
01:05:36.560She found ways around that, like by finding a new husband, by finding ways to leverage her power.0.96
01:05:43.240So I'm not sure how much more she could have done. I don't know. It's a complicated thing
01:05:48.900to think of with her because she was successful, like you were saying, within her own life,
01:05:54.440within her family, within that world. I'm not sure what more she could have done if she had
01:06:00.080been able to own her own property, things like that. That's right. I agree with you. I think0.97
01:06:05.780that's, that's very clear understanding of the situation. If it was sexism, it was just that she1.00
01:06:13.020had the limitations. It was called femme covert. It was that she married women, couldn't own0.99
01:06:20.600property and their standing was through their husband and they had no legal rights so the1.00
01:06:26.260sexism was that men controlled women she was the property of her husband so that sexism part would1.00
01:06:34.060have been a 10 but but you're absolutely right she she she managed to work around around it and0.55
01:06:43.460was very successful so she didn't really let the sexism bother her too much she worked with it0.98
01:06:50.600Yeah, she found ways around it. You know, it would have been like if after her second husband died, if she was destitute and was never able to pull herself out of it, then that would have been like, oh, because of women's place in the world. But she found ways to continuously do that. So I think I would give her a low score for that just because that didn't get in her way. I'll give her, I don't know, a two, maybe.1.00
01:07:13.600I agree with you. I think that's a, I think two is perfect.
01:07:17.040Yeah. So that gives her a total of 27, which I'm going to say is on the scale of people who are on this podcast, it's a lot of people fall in that range because that's why I have the four categories. Some people score high in some and lower in some. It's rare for somebody to score high in everything. But I love that you've brought her to the forefront. I love that you wrote this biography of her.
01:07:42.360So The Pirate's Wife, the remarkable true story of Sarah Kidd.
01:18:36.600We want to tell you about a podcast we love.
01:18:39.400It's called Rebel Girls, formerly known as Good Night Stories for Rebel Girls.
01:18:43.860It's about real-life women who are changing the world with their courage, creativity, and big, bold ideas.
01:18:50.820Want to know how Taylor Swift became a superstar or hear how Simone Biles became the greatest athlete of all time?
01:18:58.760From immersive stories to heartfelt interviews to super smart advice, Rebel Girls brings you stories that will get you fired up to become your best self.
01:19:08.540There are over 400 episodes for you to explore with new episodes every week.
01:19:12.640So check it out. Listen to Rebel Girls wherever you get your podcasts and find us on YouTube dot com slash Rebel Girls.