Vulgar History - September 06, 2023


Author Interview: Jenni Nuttall (Mother Tongue: The Surprising History of Women’s Words)

Topics
Real Estate Boss Bitch of the Tudor Era, Bess of Hardwick Mary Queen of Scots: Bonus: Mary's Besties, The Four Marys

Episode Stats


Harmful content

Misogyny

21

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

9

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 Hello and welcome to Vulgar History of Feminist Women's History Comedy Podcast. My name is
00:00:16.520 Anne Foster. And today, because we are in our academic era lately, I'm talking with
00:00:23.340 Dr. Jenny Nuttall, who is the author of Mother Tongue, The Surprising History of Women's
00:00:28.200 words. We're talking about linguistics. We're talking about feminism. We're talking about the
00:00:33.620 meaning of words. And it was so fascinating, this conversation I had with her. And her book is so
00:00:39.120 timely in interesting and fun ways, but in also kind of like sorts of ways. Because like we're
00:00:44.720 living in an era where conservative politicians are really mad about like pronouns and inclusive
00:00:50.520 language. And books like this one really show like every word was just invented by someone at
00:00:56.720 sometime. Like words, they have meaning and they have significance, but to be like, how dare language
00:01:01.560 change? It's like, it's always changing. It was such a fun conversation. I'll just let you know
00:01:06.540 a bit about Jenny. So Dr. Jenny Nuttall is an academic who has been teaching and researching
00:01:11.540 medieval literature at the University of Oxford for the last 20 years, and who has thus had a lot
00:01:17.240 of practice at making old words interesting. She has a doctor of philosophy from Oxford and
00:01:22.900 completed the University of East Anglia's Master's in Creative Writing. Mother Tongue is her first
00:01:28.420 book for the general reader. I had such a good time talking with her. This book really, I don't
00:01:33.320 know, the stuff that is in this book connects with what we've been talking about all along on this
00:01:36.880 podcast. It really, as I mentioned, has a lot to do with some really, really annoying things that
00:01:44.920 are happening lately with conservative politicians in multiple countries. Anyway, I really hope you
00:01:49.480 enjoy this interview with Dr. Jenny Nuttall. So I'm joined today by Jenny Nuttall. Thank you
00:02:01.540 so much for joining me. Thanks. It's great to be asked to talk to you and your listeners.
00:02:06.200 Yeah. So when I first saw what your book was about, so my book, it's a, it's feminist history,
00:02:12.620 basically, and I'm, I'm always interested in language and words. And so your book is exactly
00:02:17.420 the sort of thing we like to talk about. Actually, can you first just explain how do you describe
00:02:22.580 your book to other people? What's it about? So it's a history of women's words in English,
00:02:31.220 and particularly the kind of early history of women's words starting out in Old English and
00:02:38.400 medieval English into the 16th, 17th, 18th century. And I suppose that might then prompt
00:02:44.540 the question, what do you mean by women's words? And I don't necessarily mean the words that women
00:02:52.260 are using about themselves. I mean, I mean, sets of vocabulary that are being used to talk about 0.97
00:02:58.040 parts of women's lives and experiences. And to partly to kind of find out what's going on in
00:03:06.540 the early stages of that language, which words that we've got coming all the way from
00:03:10.680 the deep past of English to now and which words have got lost and just to kind of look at sets
00:03:17.860 of vocabulary for women's bodies, the work they do, things like menstruation and pregnancy and
00:03:27.240 words for different stages of women's lives. So yeah, just a kind of reaching back into the past
00:03:36.200 for each of those sets of vocabulary to kind of see what's there and why.
00:03:41.620 There are a number of words that you talk about in your book that I think have particular
00:03:47.280 resonances for this podcast and phrases that come up here. And one of them is you talk about
00:03:53.120 the different words and how it's developed in the English language to talk about breasts.
00:03:57.900 And you say in your book, the tit is the least worst of memory words. That's in your opinion.
00:04:04.280 can you talk about the development of the word just the words that mean breasts how
00:04:10.300 how that word has developed in English language yeah and it's it's interesting I mean the book
00:04:16.140 is full of kind of subjective opinions like that it's me kind of looking at language from my
00:04:21.600 position in language of as a speaker of a certain kind of British English who grew up in a certain
00:04:26.740 sort of culture, kind of testing out words. In Old English, you have words like reos,
00:04:33.980 obviously, and tit, these words that come through into modern English. But I was sort
00:04:39.720 of interested particularly in how changing ideas of register kind of join in. So if you
00:04:46.340 might say, if you're going to the doctor, you know, I had a problem with my breast.
00:04:50.280 But some of these words end up with a more kind of formal sense.
00:04:55.680 And I'm interested in finding out a set of kind of synonyms.
00:05:00.380 And if you reach into the past, you can get those synonyms.
00:05:02.760 So you have braeost and tit.
00:05:04.740 You have a word like pap, which starts, even though we might think of that as a word for baby food, it starts off as a word for the breast.
00:05:13.380 And that's where the connection with kind of baby's eating comes in.
00:05:17.580 And then you get, you have to name parts of the breast, the forward tit, the pap head.
00:05:24.500 And eventually, in the 16th century, you get nipple coming in.
00:05:28.520 So it's just sort of, I think, reaching back into the past allows you to kind of play around with choices as well.
00:05:35.060 What if we'd ended up with that one and not this word?
00:05:38.200 And tit, particularly in my kind of British English, is a good sort of plain spoken.
00:05:43.780 and you might say it's as cold as a witch's tit
00:05:46.860 if you were trying to explain how kind of freezing cold it was one morning.
00:05:49.820 So I was interested that that word is there back in the past.
00:05:53.780 It's not just a kind of slang word.
00:05:55.740 And it's part of this phase of English
00:05:57.980 where you often have several synonyms of kind of vaguely similar registers.
00:06:02.920 You don't quite get that stratification of kind of polite words
00:06:06.820 and impolite words that you get later on. 0.56
00:06:10.480 Well, and talking about female body parts as well,
00:06:12.540 You have a whole chapter that's about kind of female reproductive body parts and the words used for them.
00:06:19.040 But even just the word vagina was very interesting to me how you talk about just the various medical textbooks mostly written by men and which terms ended up kind of catching on and which didn't.
00:06:30.620 Like the word vagina, well, you could describe it has to do with a sword and a sheath, right?
00:06:35.280 Yeah, it's used in Latin treaties describing some of the new findings of anatomical dissection when that kind of gets going in a big way in the 16th century.
00:06:48.600 And it's just in there really as an analogy, you know, this body parts to describe it.
00:06:55.120 So if you're an anatomist for your readers, you will want to describe for your readers who haven't kind of been there and seen a dead body, but will want to kind of, I mean, they will know it in their own lives.
00:07:04.200 but you're trying to kind of describe it and it vagina yeah it's just that word for sheath or
00:07:09.000 scabbard of a sword and it's to describe a kind of reciprocal function you know as as a sword goes
00:07:15.380 into a scabbard and it's not really presented even as a new technical term I don't think but
00:07:20.780 but somehow it has gets kind of pulled out and becomes the standard term and before that things
00:07:28.680 things have been a bit vaguer in a way so you have wound gates or kind of ports or or wickets
00:07:36.020 but it's interesting that to me that it's it's very sexist that idea of it that it that it what
00:07:41.940 vagina is is is the thing in relation to the male and anatomy but but that's quite a late idea and
00:07:49.120 it's a quite it's quite an accidental idea which is not to say that the whole history of these
00:07:53.520 textbooks isn't full of kind of misogyny but often often you can kind of find surprises in
00:08:00.840 the histories of these words and every time I kind of thought I knew something when I was setting
00:08:06.380 off to research each chapter I would suddenly think oh that's that's a much stranger story
00:08:12.060 than I thought it was and then behind that there were there were other words and it can make you
00:08:17.120 you know which are we describing whose perspective are we describing this body part from and and the
00:08:23.520 the 16th century writers who are interested in opening up discussions of childbirth and pregnancy
00:08:30.540 and kind of communicating that to women readers in English are using a different set of words
00:08:35.440 they're they're not using vagina to start off with they're talking about kind of gates
00:08:39.300 and doorways and passages it's still metaphorical but it's a different set of metaphors
00:08:46.060 can you talk about the thing with nymphs in regards to female anatomy yeah I mean in that
00:08:53.520 That's coming out of, you know, classical Greek medical treatises and that writing as it's kind of being translated into different languages are coming across.
00:09:03.960 But it's one of the, again, it's a little bit hazy.
00:09:07.540 Some of these male writers are not very good at kind of accurate descriptions of that part of women's anatomy.
00:09:13.860 And, you know, like as we do these days with technical terms, people kind of muddle things up and overlap things.
00:09:19.540 But yeah, an early alternative name for what we would call the labia is nymph.
00:09:29.100 And it's where later on that idea of kind of nymphomania comes from.
00:09:33.320 But that's a much later coinage.
00:09:35.580 And here it's just part of, again, this slightly kind of flowery,
00:09:40.560 rather I wasn't expecting the language of Renaissance anatomists to be quite so wonderful.
00:09:45.040 lot and particularly those the English writers who are taking these Latin findings and kind of
00:09:50.300 bringing them across into English for a kind of popular audience and they yeah they labia lip
00:09:56.700 because it looks like you know there is a comparison there with the lips of the mouse or
00:10:00.600 actually the edges of a wound which perhaps seems a bit more of a kind of sexist idea but even though
00:10:06.940 nymphs is is rather flowering it's explained in this lovely way that just like nymphs in
00:10:13.060 mythology guard fountains. Here are the kind of nymphs down by your waterworks. That might be
00:10:19.060 a way to say it. But again, isn't it nice to have these sets of alternatives to kind of play around
00:10:26.320 with that come out of these kind of early Englishes? Well, and then some, I think that
00:10:32.080 was one of the many examples in your book, but when you learn about what the words used to mean
00:10:35.860 and you look at some of these old writings, you talk a lot about Geoffrey Chaucer and the
00:10:41.020 canterbury tales or even some shakespeare sonnets you're like oh this is like a lot more sexual
00:10:45.020 than i had realized just because you see a word like nymphs you're like okay nymphs but then to
00:10:50.540 them it had this very specific connotation that makes it like actually extremely sexual
00:10:54.880 where to us it seems more like oh that's sort of a metaphor he's doing yeah and kind of wings and
00:11:00.360 then the you know because they're very good at using this it's not very sort of super accurate
00:11:06.980 But there is a kind of lovely metaphorical language for all this stuff.
00:11:11.900 And again, it's not quite as sort of misogynist or sexist.
00:11:17.540 There are strands of that kind of thinking all the way through the periods I'm interested in.
00:11:22.040 But there are also much more appreciative descriptions of kind of women's body parts.
00:11:29.360 you know in in these uh anatomical treatises and in uh there's a wonderful text called the
00:11:35.420 woman's book written in the in the middle of the 16th century to talk to readers about pregnancy
00:11:41.200 and gestation and then yes in in the kind of the the punning literary text if you if you
00:11:47.740 understand this early set of vocabulary you can see that that the past isn't simply ashamed at
00:11:54.860 at all. I mean, they are called, they are sometimes called parts that are to do with
00:11:59.520 shame, but not always. They always have a kind of a multifaceted identity. And you can find that
00:12:05.200 if you look at different words. And what I found really interesting about your book as well is
00:12:10.560 that every time you're looking at one of these words and how it's used, it explains sort of how
00:12:15.700 that was seen in society, like what it means to history. So as an example, so like use of the
00:12:22.700 word hysterical you talk about where that comes from and I had sort of I'd heard before about
00:12:27.460 the sort of idea of the wandering womb and stuff but you you sort of dive into that and like where
00:12:32.960 did the word come from can you talk about that a bit yeah it's yeah the words as ways to write
00:12:38.900 almost kind of paragraph by paragraph little kind of mini it's not structured like something like
00:12:44.980 Raymond Williams's keywords say where you have kind of separate chapters but but each time I
00:12:49.560 got to a word I wanted to unpack it and yeah there's there's another example of something 0.97
00:12:57.020 that perhaps feminist history might hold up and say look isn't hasn't the history of the word
00:13:02.720 hysteria been been such a kind of long history of sexism and that's true but it but it's slightly
00:13:09.660 more complicated than that so we we don't get hysterical in English until the beginning of the
00:13:17.900 the 17th century and we don't get hysteria in English till midway through the 18th century
00:13:24.260 and that's because that diagnosis and the kind of groups of symptoms and the ways of thinking
00:13:32.580 that fit around those words change change quite a lot so Plato might suggest that the womb is
00:13:40.820 wandering but even early on medical writers and writers who know they're an athlete going no
00:13:45.740 that's completely impossible we can see it kind of tethered by ligaments what are you talking about
00:13:50.440 so there's a kind of complicated story there and is is the thing that people are describing early
00:13:57.260 on something that gets called the suffocation of the mother so a more physical idea that things
00:14:04.620 can go wrong with the womb and make the rest of you feel very unwell and you know i can think of
00:14:10.740 various modern complaints where that might seem a perfectly kind of reasonable idea and it it
00:14:15.460 doesn't necessarily always have quite the kind of misogynist connections with the idea that women
00:14:23.720 are kind of crazy and their wombs are wandering around that those come and go in history so in the
00:14:30.760 17th and 18th century people are able to say oh the the thing we call melancholic or on kind of
00:14:38.060 these nerve disorders in men is it is it's the same thing in women but we give it a different
00:14:43.640 name and that there's a much um more nuanced understanding of of these terms and then it's
00:14:49.580 it's only quite late on um one of the scholars calls it a kind of great forgetting the eclipsing
00:14:56.840 of that more complicated history in the 19th century where you get a bit more of that that
00:15:02.640 familiar cliche of the kind of hysterical woman and it all comes together but but I was so
00:15:08.960 interested that you can't even you would think hysteria would be the easiest word to trace back
00:15:15.420 as an as a wooden idea deep deep into kind of the history of medicine and and it isn't you know and
00:15:22.260 I one of the things I wanted to do a little bit in the book as well as writing a very feminist book 0.60
00:15:28.480 that was kind of standing up for women in the past 1.00
00:15:32.000 and kind of highlighting sex in the past.
00:15:33.640 But I also wanted to make the feminist history really accurate 0.74
00:15:37.420 and really nuanced to say, look, you know, 0.98
00:15:39.900 there are all those ideas we kind of grow up with as baby feminists,
00:15:43.780 but they're always generally a kind of simplified version
00:15:47.480 of a more interesting narrative.
00:15:52.560 And the first use of hysterical in English is used to say
00:15:56.740 that a woman might be hysterical might not therefore be a witch or influenced by witchcraft
00:16:02.500 so that you know it's it's there as a kind of useful medical medical idea no don't don't
00:16:08.500 don't decide she's a witch actually she may have this kind of long held diagnosis of of the
00:16:14.400 suffocation of the mother and we might call that hysterical and then it comes into english so the
00:16:18.560 i was interested in sort of balancing up moments in the past where you have a kind of more enlightened
00:16:24.360 way of thinking about things versus our sense of the kind of sexism of the past. And that's all
00:16:30.560 there in the history of hysteria. And it's really interesting too, in so many of the words you talk
00:16:36.880 about in your book and how it really made me think about the power of words. Like we're seeing it so
00:16:42.540 strongly these days right now with people getting upset about pronouns or describing people as a
00:16:48.740 woman or describing as like people who menstruate and people like the power and just the way that
00:16:53.800 words reflect a societal view I guess it's more clear to me now because of some of these debates
00:17:00.240 than maybe it would have been a couple of years ago and you do mention that in your book it's a
00:17:03.700 history of women's words but you do talk about the the use of the word woman versus the use of the
00:17:08.300 word like people with a uterus and things like that can you expand upon how you talk about that
00:17:12.580 in the book yeah I mean I mentioned it just at the end and I think it was it was one of sort of
00:17:19.080 watching those debates play out was one of the several things came together in the writing of
00:17:25.720 this book but I was sort of suddenly more conscious of the vocabularies that were being
00:17:32.500 kind of changed or replaced to do with things like menstruation or pregnancy and it made me
00:17:38.240 interested in all of those words it's something I'm still kind of working my way through as an
00:17:46.440 idea that the kind of balance between including and acknowledging and i talk about this in the
00:17:53.800 introduction a little bit that there'll be people who who wouldn't categorize themselves as women
00:17:58.400 but will need and use a lot of the kind of sets of vocabulary i'm interested in the book so that's
00:18:04.340 exactly right but it is interesting to see the the kind of unintended perhaps consequence of that
00:18:12.160 which is to see a word like woman disappearing out not not not in a kind of it's not that we
00:18:17.660 can't say it anymore but in certain types of public health messaging or a certain way of
00:18:22.720 writing a journal as well as something that the words was like women and women and girls might
00:18:28.280 might be sort of circumvented kind of written out somehow and that that's quite significant in a way
00:18:35.740 so so i was interested in not really trying to solve those questions but thinking about the
00:18:42.040 As you say, the kind of the way in which culture and language interact with each other and how even those usage choices there reflect these kind of tricky, tricky balances that we're trying to do.
00:18:58.940 You know, I could see both at the same time. Women's all sorts of issues relating to women and their lives and experiences are being represented and articulated at the same time as we're sort of changing or needing also to do something else at the same time with that language.
00:19:19.800 So it's a kind of interesting space to be thinking about. But I think what I'm really doing, if I'm honest, is kind of retreating to the past and saying, right, you know, there's all this going on, but let's go back and kind of see what's nearer the source, the origins of English. Yeah, so it just sort of frames the book, I think.
00:19:41.860 Well, no, exactly. And it's more, you use it in the book as an example of how words have power, how words interact with a society. Your book is very much, as you described it at the beginning of this interview, how were things about women written in the past.
00:19:55.980 But another weird way, and I say weird, just kind of unexpected, but also kind of distressing that some of this terminology is interacting with our current world, as you do mention in the book about the U.S. Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe versus Wade, which is using some, to me, quite obscure language about menstruation and about fetal development. Can you talk about that for a bit?
00:20:21.860 And now we're just going to take a break for a word from our sponsors.
00:20:25.980 Welcome to the Realms of Peril and Glory.
00:20:31.600 Explore the mechanically magical vistas of Vale,
00:20:35.300 the paranormal mysteries of liminal London,
00:20:39.560 and the cyberpunk chaos of Cyborg.
00:20:44.860 Be awed by our incredible guests from familiar shows like Oxventure and No Rolls Barred.
00:20:52.260 Search Realms of Peril and Glory to find out more.
00:20:55.980 The war is over and both sides lost.
00:21:03.080 Kingdoms were reduced to cinders and armies scattered like bones in the dust.
00:21:08.080 Now the survivors claw to what's left of a broken world, praying the darkness chooses someone else tonight.
00:21:15.960 But in the shadow dark, the darkness always wins.
00:21:20.300 This is old school adventuring at its most cruel.
00:21:23.760 Your torch ticks down in real time.
00:21:25.980 and when that flame dies, something else rises to finish the job.
00:21:29.680 This is a brutal rules-light nightmare with a story that emerges organically
00:21:34.580 based on the decisions that the characters make.
00:21:37.240 This is what it felt like to play RPGs in the 80s, and man, it is so good to be back.
00:21:41.880 Join the Glass Cannon podcast as we plunge into the shadow dark
00:21:44.980 every Thursday night at 8 p.m. Eastern on youtube.com slash the glass cannon
00:21:49.300 with the podcast version dropping the next day.
00:21:52.560 See what everybody's talking about and join us in the dark.
00:21:59.440 I'm Mandy.
00:22:00.540 And I'm Melissa.
00:22:01.340 And this is Moms and Mysteries. 0.80
00:22:03.100 We're two Florida moms obsessed with true crime.
00:22:05.640 From infamous cases like Ellen Greenberg to shocking Florida stories like the Dan Markell killing.
00:22:10.740 With 55 million downloads, we bring you new deep dives every Tuesday and Thursday.
00:22:15.120 Listen to Moms and Mysteries on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:22:19.460 welcome to mick unplugged the number one podcast for self-improvement and modern leadership
00:22:25.580 i'm mick hunt your host and i'm here to challenge your why and fuel your because this is where
00:22:33.240 leaders entrepreneurs and go-getters come to level up each week i bring you unfiltered
00:22:38.860 conversations game-changing strategies and the kind of motivation that transforms lives and
00:22:44.340 legacies i've learned from legends like les brown damon john and robert irvine and now i'm bringing
00:22:51.180 their lessons along with mine straight to you from modern leadership tips to creating unstoppable
00:22:57.720 momentum this is the podcast that redefines what's possible hit play subscribe and join the millions
00:23:05.720 who've made mick unplug their go-to source for growth and greatness because your next breakthrough
00:23:11.560 is just one episode away. This is Mick Unplugged, the voice and face of modern
00:23:17.620 leadership, entrepreneur, and self-improvement. Let's get started.
00:23:29.880 And we're back. Yeah, I was, again, it's one of those patterns where
00:23:35.880 things become much more kind of fixed and regulated later on in the story and going
00:23:42.780 earlier on in history and earlier on in language lets you see a kind of picture where more
00:23:50.320 uncertainty is possible so some of the debates the legal debates that have been going on with
00:23:57.600 the courts as far as I understand it go go back to kind of precedence and one of the issues there
00:24:04.300 is what does, say, a 17th or 18th century writer
00:24:10.700 mean by quickening, say,
00:24:13.400 the moment where the baby moves in the womb?
00:24:16.560 What do they mean by misprision?
00:24:19.380 What do they mean by fairly kind of
00:24:20.700 how are they positioning abortion?
00:24:24.200 And again, a bit like the history of hysteria
00:24:27.240 where it's quite easy to get the kind of
00:24:29.420 wrong end of the stick and simplify history.
00:24:32.520 telling the story of of the the early history of how which kinds of abortion are prosecuted and
00:24:40.060 why and when is is took an awful lot of research it's not a kind of hugely heavily footnoted book
00:24:47.800 but there's a lot going on under the surface I read I read and read for each of these chapters
00:24:51.700 to try and kind of get the story straight and and the the earliest prosecutions have to do with
00:24:58.240 people women pregnant women being injured and and having what we might think of as a
00:25:04.120 miscarriage and there's quite a long then it's recognized that that that doesn't really
00:25:11.720 work because it's very difficult to to kind of know the the legal personhood status of the kind
00:25:19.220 of fetus in the womb and the what you see is that there's an understanding this is very much a kind
00:25:24.220 of woman-centered knowledge as it were you know this is before our world of kind of scans and
00:25:31.260 dates and everything the kind of the the moment of quickening is something that you know sort of
00:25:36.320 inside out and that the the law and society is is not so easily going to be able to kind of
00:25:43.420 intervene in and kind of make pronouncements about and that there's a real um caution and
00:25:50.520 And recognition of doubt in some of the other writings about, you know, when can we say this is a crime and when can we say the fetus has a soul?
00:26:00.980 And so it's so interesting to see some of the kind of legal debate, which appears to be so certain that the past agrees with you on something where it's a much more complicated story, even coming down to kind of what does that writer mean by that word?
00:26:20.520 I think. Yeah, it's I think it's so useful and so important to have a book like yours that looks
00:26:26.540 that explains how the same word has meant different things through the years. So for
00:26:31.480 somebody today to see that word and be like, well, for sure it means this, where people in all
00:26:36.660 different cultures and contexts were using it in different ways. So it's language is so fluid. And
00:26:42.420 I think that's important for people to recognize. Yeah. And that's sort of underpinning some of the
00:26:48.220 arguments that people are having today i keep wanting to kind of do the most simple kind of
00:26:54.520 linguistics maybe a lecture and say there's this thing called polysemy we recognize that one word
00:27:00.120 can have several related meanings um but but then you need to look usage and context and trying
00:27:06.780 and kind of work out which is going on and it might be that i was quite keen not this is not
00:27:13.240 simply a book of kind of definitions of things because because defining the idea that words have
00:27:17.920 a kind of that either history or semantics will give you a kind of core central stable meaning
00:27:24.980 that's not how it works it's it's always as you say a kind of different different parts of society
00:27:31.100 using words slightly differently and kind of contested meanings and even this very weird
00:27:35.620 thing that language does which is to have kind of you know you can think of a word like wench
00:27:40.700 which can mean both both it can be used to straightforwardly for a young woman of a certain
00:27:47.240 type of social status but then also has a pejorative meaning and the two kind of sit
00:27:53.100 alongside and even when you're reading Shakespeare you're thinking okay they do relate to each
00:27:58.940 other it's not accidental that they have a kind of related meaning but it but there will always
00:28:04.620 be a sense of kind of negotiation through meaning yeah certainly even where we keep words to do with
00:28:11.080 abortion words to do with miscarriage separate now as we absolutely should and that those are
00:28:16.800 much more overlapping and intertwined and complicated in the past. And again, it makes
00:28:21.420 the legal history of this somewhere where you can't just jump back in and kind of grab a phrase
00:28:27.140 and say that's what that means. Yeah. And I was just going to say that's part of why it just
00:28:32.780 seems preposterous to me to be making a legal decision now saying, well, in 1642, they said
00:28:38.820 this, where it's like, well, a lot of context has changed since then. Yes. And bad scholarship
00:28:46.540 to i think she's carla spivak if i'm named like she's written a very good article about the kind
00:28:51.480 of complexity of the early history of of there's been you know some really good history research
00:28:57.320 and it and it it's really sort of the worst kind of cherry picking to kind of cite hail or someone
00:29:03.540 like that without kind of looking at you know because those legal writings are are sort of
00:29:09.740 processing that the sort of stuff i'm particularly interested in the kind of medieval early early
00:29:15.480 modern history of some of the ideas. They're just looking at kind of descriptions of cases in law
00:29:20.980 books and thinking, what does that mean? How should we understand it? Well, and even a definition,
00:29:28.540 this one also, after I read your book, I was talking to my friend and I kept giving my friend
00:29:32.220 examples. I'm like, did you know this? And did you know this? It was a sort of book where I just
00:29:35.520 enjoyed learning so many facts. But one that I found interesting, I was hoping you can talk about
00:29:39.200 is the word husband and how it relates to the word housewife and how those interact with each other.
00:29:45.480 Yeah. And even now, I don't think that the sort of connotations of housewife and the connotations of husband,
00:29:53.040 which you can see are kind of related. Obviously, we have husband and wife.
00:29:57.360 And yeah, I mean, coming back in origin to the sort of, in most circumstances, the two people,
00:30:04.840 the man and the woman who are running the domestic economy of a house, some kind of,
00:30:10.820 whether that's a kind of little house or a kind of bigger unit,
00:30:13.400 but that kind of domestic family unit.
00:30:17.240 So we would recognise a word like husbandry.
00:30:21.140 There's that funny phrase, animal husbandry,
00:30:23.540 which means the kind of looking after of farm animals very well. 0.98
00:30:28.540 And that word husbandry and housewifery, the thing that housewives do,
00:30:34.620 so the weef, the hoose, the bondman, the kind of retained worker
00:30:39.200 who's living in a house not not the kind of equal status and they don't mean the same thing but they
00:30:44.420 mean the kind of the related activities this has to do with the running of the household but but
00:30:50.100 more in the sense of the the kind of economic functioning as it were getting the stuff you need
00:30:55.400 to live and run it running a house on it's funny then the housewifery eventually becomes
00:31:02.900 reduced to you know cleaning and cooking and these these more domestic things but it it used
00:31:10.200 to have a much broader meaning a kind of equivalent to husbandry to do with the kind of
00:31:15.400 the the skill and knowledge and and how a you know social power needed to kind of not just
00:31:23.820 generally a household it might be a very small household of two but but as everyone will know
00:31:28.480 you know earlier on in history kind of bigger households with servants with children you know
00:31:34.760 to run those things and you you even find men in the pastor letters those medieval letters sort of
00:31:40.680 saying oh if you get a really good deal on some complicated sort of wood bargaining interaction
00:31:47.820 are you're being great housewife they say to one another because it's got these kind of
00:31:52.660 connotations of of being part of a kind of a system of kind of finance and economy and without
00:32:01.480 the kind of the separate spheres obviously comes along a lot later and kind of starts to push these
00:32:08.680 words in different directions but yeah you can think of husbandry and house for free who's one
00:32:14.260 who's wife is the the the kind of pair at the start well and that's that's so fascinating to
00:32:21.100 me i'd never heard any of that until i read your book and just the current contacts there's people
00:32:25.940 who you know who want you know quote unquote a return to the role of the housewife or a traditional
00:32:31.340 housewife and it's like well if we were doing that then if we're actually going back to the
00:32:36.380 traditional housewife than what you were just saying it's like household management it's yeah
00:32:39.860 yeah and maybe a bit closer to the sort of trad wives who are monetizing the business you know
00:32:45.760 who are making a lot of money out of it because the idea you know that that's what all of this 1.00
00:32:49.820 early language acknowledges that there's a lot of kind of um economy even even even economy goes
00:32:56.700 back to the idea of a kind of household in the greek and these these house whiffer is marjorie
00:33:04.180 kemp that wonderful medieval mystic and traveler writes in her book about at the start about how
00:33:10.940 she's going to try a new house whiffery a kind of new house whiffery and you think oh i wonder what
00:33:16.420 what that is and it involves a mill and a horse and an employee and all sorts of things so so 0.97
00:33:23.680 housewifery yeah i'd you know the the trad wives gang need to kind of somehow recognize that the 1.00
00:33:32.000 housewives are that you do see the beat i mean there are certainly kind of gender segregated 0.98
00:33:38.680 employments and within household kind of gender segregated tasks but but there is definitely a
00:33:45.880 kind of recognition of the importance of things like kind of bargaining money management supplies
00:33:52.080 all of those those things no they're certainly not decorative these are kind of limited in what
00:33:58.700 they do caxton has a lovely dialogue showing people how to kind of do certain kinds of public
00:34:04.520 speaking and one of the the examples is is a housewife in a market out in public kind of
00:34:11.500 bandying with all the stallholders and kind of getting the best deal it's that's a house
00:34:16.740 actually is a kind of larger than life person beyond in history i like uh and just as a as a
00:34:23.560 final question um just because the name of this podcast is vulgar history and i did choose it
00:34:29.380 because of the several meanings of the word vulgar can you you do you mentioned in your book i was
00:34:36.300 really excited that he talked about english um as a as the vulgar tongue can you explain that
00:34:41.860 meaning of the word yeah and it comes to the idea that the sort of the the tongue of the common
00:34:48.140 people vulgus and that it's it's there in that idea the word vernacular too that this is the
00:34:55.720 the language that most people speak in a nation but not necessarily the language earlier on in
00:35:03.720 in English as history, of education or of science,
00:35:07.440 of knowledge, of law, things like that, 1.00
00:35:09.840 and often associated with women, 1.00
00:35:13.020 partly because they're excluded in a patriarchal society
00:35:19.100 from some of those spheres in which other languages,
00:35:21.460 Latin and French, are used.
00:35:23.480 But the vulgar tongue is the language of the home and education, 0.93
00:35:28.800 your kind of first language, 0.86
00:35:31.500 which you know often women are understood as the kind of first teachers of your language as you 0.53
00:35:39.100 grow up as a child and even when we get to the point of the first dictionaries being created for 0.72
00:35:46.140 for english on it on its own they say in their prefaces you know these might be useful for women
00:35:53.280 who who will need to get a spin sometimes it's a bit of a kind of marketing spin because because
00:35:58.940 then you don't have to say, and actually we know all the chaps whose Latin and French is not very
00:36:02.940 good at the moment might find, oh, haven't got the kind of levels and education needed to kind
00:36:09.580 of decode some of these words. But I was interested, yeah, you know, that question,
00:36:16.840 feminist linguistics, you know, are we sort of excluded from this language despite ourselves
00:36:22.740 somehow is is is it always going to be the kind of the oppressor's language somehow not quite if 0.99
00:36:30.180 you go back in the past it's had lots of associations with women in terms of teaching
00:36:36.680 english and good speech and bad speech you know the gossipy speech and kind of uncontrolled speech 0.98
00:36:44.160 and speech outside of of institutions and establishments but also a kind of a speech that
00:36:51.220 Because it's outside of those things, this is what I found so much as I was writing, is so kind of wild and unruly and surprising, kind of thinks on its feet.
00:37:01.040 So, yeah, I like the idea of the, it is a kind of, I wanted to have both, the history of the kind of language that men use about women, but where I could find it, I wanted to find that kind of vulgar history.
00:37:15.400 There's not much straight from the horse's mouth, but there are ways to kind of get back to it.
00:37:22.040 When, say, in the Renaissance, physicians are writing for women, you start to kind of find some of these words that are not formal.
00:37:31.340 What Le Guin calls the father's language, not the father's language, but what she calls the mother tongue.
00:37:38.700 And that's why the book kind of has that name in a way, because I liked all those things coming together.
00:37:43.780 and also just in the sense of you know the writing for the common people or the general public the
00:37:50.120 book I think is very much written for an everyday audience you don't need to be a historian of
00:37:55.360 linguistics to enjoy your book and I assume that was your intention because that's how it comes
00:37:59.660 across yeah and it's I mean it's written much more in the voice I kind of teach it that was
00:38:07.080 really fun so to try and be funny and to try and explain things and and I was I yeah I wanted it
00:38:14.020 was kind of interesting to write because I wanted to explain a lot and I didn't you know as we've
00:38:19.680 been talking about with hysteria or I didn't or which you know the history of witchcraft say I
00:38:25.180 didn't just want to kind of give the kind of easy well-known version I mean I wanted it to be as
00:38:30.060 as kind of up-to-date and scholarly in its knowledge but in its tone and its writing I
00:38:36.880 wanted it to be like you know midway through a tutorial in Oxford when I've kind of lost the
00:38:42.740 plot a bit and I'm just kind of talking about the stuff I'm interested in and I'm I'm from rather
00:38:47.680 kind of humble common background really and I just talk in the in the kind of words that seem
00:38:52.580 kind of clearest and most expressive and I make a lot of jokes when I teach and it was it was so
00:38:59.340 wonderful to to have the opportunity to to write a book like this and um and have editors and and
00:39:07.380 and presses that were could see the value of that that kind of balance between the the very kind of
00:39:13.720 accurate informed stuff that's going on in there but but expressed in a way that that hopefully
00:39:20.520 was was just really kind of joyful and clear and kind of easy to get in and out of i think
00:39:27.280 I'm sure anyone listening to this can hear your passion and your joy for talking about this subject matter. And I think it's great when someone is, when someone is so, finds so much delight in talking about a subject to, to read a book that person has written just makes it more fun to read because it's, you're not just, you can tell how much fun you had putting this together.
00:39:46.200 Yes. Yes. Even in the middle of a global pandemic in quite trying circumstances. But yeah, the book is, and I didn't, I mean, you must feel this, this too, that you don't want to kind of simply scold the past and tell the past off for being not as progressive as we are.
00:40:05.720 I wanted to, you know, because I teach this really ancient, you know, old English, medieval English, students pitch up thinking, oh, no, what?
00:40:15.620 But, you know, I wanted to kind of to show how much fun you could have with it.
00:40:20.880 Definitely. And yeah, and I like the idea, you know, people have said that to me, this sort of book that you're reading and then you're kind of annoying the person next to you.
00:40:29.460 Like, can I can I just tell you this thing that I just read?
00:40:33.340 No, exactly. I have one of my co-workers, I get a ride home from work some days with her and I
00:40:38.060 spent the whole commute just being like, and this? And did you know the history of the word husband?
00:40:41.940 And did you know the history of the word vagina? I was just like this, like I couldn't stop telling 0.77
00:40:45.320 her all these fun facts. So yeah, it's that sort of book, definitely. So when this podcast comes
00:40:50.760 out, the book will have just been published, I believe in North America, as well as, is it already
00:40:56.240 out in the UK or is it coming out everywhere all at the same time? No, it's already been out. So I
00:41:00.980 have two different publishers it's come out with virago that great feminist press and it came out
00:41:06.980 in at the end of may in the the uk but yeah viking in the states at the end of august i've ended up
00:41:12.840 with sort of two different dates but it's quite nice it spreads the fun well it keeps it going
00:41:18.500 for you so you can keep talking about it with different people so i wanted to ask so if listeners
00:41:22.880 are interested in you and your work do you have any i don't know do you have a website or are you
00:41:29.180 on social media or anything where people can just see what you're doing? Yes, I'm on Twitter.
00:41:36.060 I didn't get the memo that you should have a really easy to explain Twitter handle. I was
00:41:40.580 just kind of somewhere else when that happened. So you can search for my name, but my Twitter
00:41:44.700 handle is Stylisticien, which is just impossible. It's kind of she who studies stylistics in
00:41:51.360 French. And I have a website, but the website is rather, before I started doing this, I was
00:41:57.980 writing lots about kind of medieval poetry in its form so the website is is mostly that but i think
00:42:03.100 the dying wastelands of twitter are currently the best place to find me and maybe
00:42:07.720 if it just falls over completely that's what's interesting about recording these a bit earlier
00:42:15.000 like if twitter still exists when this episode comes out that's where you'll be but it's good
00:42:20.320 i'll put all the links to to your website and everything in the show notes so people can
00:42:24.160 can track you down as well. Thank you so much for taking the time to talk to me about this.
00:42:29.480 Like, as I said, when I heard about your book, I thought, oh, that sounds interesting. And then I
00:42:33.320 read your book and I thought, oh, I really hope I get a chance to talk to Jenny about this because
00:42:37.240 it just sounds like exactly the sort of thing that I think the listeners are so interested in.
00:42:41.720 So I really appreciate you taking the time to talk to me.
00:42:44.720 Well, thank you so much. It's been wonderful to talk.
00:42:46.800 so again this wonderful book now available in north america and also other places i assume
00:42:57.600 is called mother tongue and the surprising history of women's words by jenny
00:43:01.720 nuttle and my name is ann foster and this is vulgar history feminist women's history
00:43:07.060 comedy podcast sometimes i do interviews with authors like this sometimes it's just me talking
00:43:13.300 sometimes it's me with a special guest you never know what you're gonna get with this podcast and
00:43:17.940 that's how it is gonna always be so you know get on board that's what i'm doing anyway so you can
00:43:24.480 keep up with me in this podcast at like god knows social media like what is even happening i am most
00:43:32.000 active on instagram at vulgar history pod that's where you can find me but if you're using another
00:43:37.040 social media thing like threads or blue sky or whatever like whatever like look at vulgar history
00:43:43.280 I'm probably there and if I start seeing there's a lot of people there to interact with maybe I'll
00:43:47.400 start being there more but at this point Instagram is where you can find me mostly and you can also
00:43:53.280 get in touch with me I'm always excited if you have a book to recommend an author you think you'd
00:43:57.180 like me to talk to or just honestly a book you think I'd like to read you can reach out to me
00:44:00.840 in my dms or also if you go to vulgarhistory.com there's a contact form there or you can also
00:44:06.420 email me at vulgarhistorypod at gmail.com I have merch available two different places if you're in
00:44:11.900 the US. What tends to work best is if you go to vulgarhistory.com slash store, or if you're
00:44:17.740 outside the US, shipping is better if you use the Redbubble store, which is vulgarhistory.redbubble.com.
00:44:23.880 You know, in many places, we're getting ready for back to school season, which I personally think
00:44:28.340 is a good time to get a sticker or a t-shirt that says scholarly and rambling, which is a thing that
00:44:33.920 I was once accused of being. And you can get that at the merch store. Anyway, you can also support
00:44:38.020 the podcast on patreon so if you go to patreon.com slash ann foster writer and if you just give like
00:44:44.600 donate some money every month then you get different levels of bonus stuff so if you join
00:44:49.820 the patreon for at least one dollar a month and you get early ad free access to all the episodes
00:44:53.740 including older episodes and if you pledge at least five dollars or more a month then you get
00:44:58.120 access to the ad free episodes as well as bonus episodes you can hear my episodes of so this 0.94
00:45:03.120 asshole where i just read men for filth the horrible men from history we also have vulgar 0.53
00:45:08.280 peace theater which are like three hour long episodes i do with my friends lana and allison 0.98
00:45:12.520 where we talk about costume dramas and most recently in terms of patreon there's also a
00:45:16.440 discord so for everyone who joins at the five dollars or more level at patreon uh you get to
00:45:21.100 join our the vulgar history salon which is a discord which is basically just like a big group
00:45:25.980 chat lately and i don't know if it'll finish by the time you have this episode but uh one of our
00:45:30.740 patreon members miguel has been running a sim that's like what if some of the greatest heroines
00:45:37.040 of vulgar history were playing the tv reality show survivor and who would win and it's just
00:45:42.040 been a really fun time anyway so you get access to all that if you join the patreon patreon.com
00:45:47.600 and foster writer i do want to mention that if and when i get to 500 members of the patreon i
00:45:52.500 will do a so this asshole episode on john knox but because that'll emotionally take a lot out
00:45:57.680 of me you know i need to be persuaded anyway i think that's everything next week you're going
00:46:01.780 to be back with a finale of the mary queen of scott season and i'll give you an update of what
00:46:06.300 to expect next from this podcast so that's all coming up next week and until then everybody 0.93
00:46:11.860 keep your pants on and your tits out vulgar history is hosted written and researched by 0.96
00:46:18.680 ann foster and edited by christina lumagi 0.99
00:46:27.680 Legendary stories, awe-inspiring sound, and endless adventure.
00:46:36.000 Welcome to the Realms of Peril and Glory.
00:46:42.100 Explore the mechanically magical vistas of Vale,
00:46:46.920 the paranormal mysteries of Liminal London,
00:46:52.240 and the cyberpunk chaos of Cyborg.
00:46:57.680 Fall in love with our core cast
00:47:01.940 Or be awed by our incredible guests
00:47:04.940 From familiar shows like Oxventure 0.99
00:47:07.820 Three Black Halflings 1.00
00:47:09.460 And No Rolls Barred 1.00
00:47:11.600 Ignite your imagination
00:47:14.780 And discover the Realms of Peril and Glory today
00:47:18.540 Go to RealmsPod.com
00:47:20.560 Or search Realms of Peril and Glory
00:47:23.000 Wherever you listen to podcasts
00:47:25.540 Welcome to Mick Unplugged, the number one podcast for self-improvement and modern leadership.
00:47:35.680 I'm Mick Hunt, your host, and I'm here to challenge your why and fuel your because.
00:47:41.900 This is where leaders, entrepreneurs, and go-getters come to level up.
00:47:46.040 Each week, I bring you unfiltered conversations, game-changing strategies,
00:47:50.740 and the kind of motivation that transforms lives and legacies.
00:47:54.060 I've learned from legends like Les Brown, Damon John, and Robert Irvine.
00:47:58.860 And now I'm bringing their lessons along with mine straight to you.
00:48:03.940 From modern leadership tips to creating unstoppable momentum,
00:48:08.180 this is the podcast that redefines what's possible.
00:48:11.900 Hit play, subscribe, and join the millions who've made Mick Unplug their go-to source for growth and greatness.
00:48:19.320 Because your next breakthrough is just one episode away.
00:48:23.040 This is Mick Unplugged, the voice and face of modern leadership, entrepreneur, and self-improvement.
00:48:30.020 Let's get started.
00:48:39.340 The world of Sonic the Hedgehog has been thrust into a not-so-dark, not-so-stormy, hard-boiled detective story that probably nobody saw coming.
00:48:52.000 Follow Sonic and the Intrepid Chaotic's detective agency as they take on their biggest case yet.
00:48:58.000 This high-flying, action-packed adventure will take them across the world,
00:49:03.000 fighting for every clue they can find.
00:49:06.000 It's one heck of a tale.
00:49:08.000 Which is good, because this story might be the only thing that can save their lives.
00:49:16.000 Well, if that's all, I can just dispose of you.
00:49:19.000 Wait, what?
00:49:21.000 All will be revealed in Sonic the Hedgehog presents The Chaotix Case Files.
00:49:30.400 Listen now, wherever you get your podcasts.