Vulgar History - February 23, 2022


Author Interview: Shelley Puhak (The Dark Queens: The Bloody Rivalry That Forged the Medieval World)

Movie Discussion: Shakespeare In Love (1998) International, part 1: The Disabled Woman Who Ruled Ancient Kashmir

Episode Stats


Harmful content

Misogyny

16

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 Before you knew what a stock was, you traded snacks, cards, turns.
00:00:05.080 That instinct to trade didn't disappear. It just grew up.
00:00:08.520 With no minimums, no monthly fees, and 100 free trades,
00:00:11.940 TD Easy Trade taps into that instinct.
00:00:14.260 Because you are made to trade, and TD Easy Trade is made to help. 0.99
00:00:30.000 Hello, and welcome to Vulgar History, a feminist women's history comedy podcast.
00:00:40.420 My name is Anne Foster, and this is a super special episode.
00:00:44.200 It's a very special episode.
00:00:45.580 I'm sharing an interview with author Shelley Puhack, the author of the book The Dark Queens,
00:00:51.180 a joint biography of Fredegand and Brunhild, who you'll know from the super special episodes
00:00:56.540 from last summer.
00:00:57.400 and I was able to do those episodes because I was fortunate enough to get a pre-publication
00:01:02.140 advanced reader copy of this book so I can attest that it's so good. It was really exciting to talk
00:01:07.600 to Shelley all about everything Fredegind and Brunhild and how she wrote the book so please
00:01:13.020 enjoy. Okay so I'm joined by Shelley Puhak. Welcome Shelley. I'm so excited to talk to you.
00:01:21.380 Thank you. I'm really excited to be here. So you have a book coming out that's about
00:01:26.400 well at least one person who the listening audience are very familiar with but it's equally
00:01:32.100 about someone else can you tell like just introduce your book just in case somebody
00:01:36.180 doesn't know who you are and what your book is yes so my book is the dark queens and the subtitle
00:01:40.980 is the bloody rivalry that forged the medieval world and it is the long suppressed history of
00:01:46.440 two early medieval queens fredegund who you and your listeners are very familiar with and her
00:01:51.500 arch nemesis, Brunhild. And so correct me if I'm wrong, but your previous books have been poetry,
00:01:59.960 right? That you've published? So how did you wind up writing this very specific history book about
00:02:08.960 these two obscure figures? That's a great question. So I do write some nonfiction,
00:02:14.920 mainly articles and essays, but this is my nonfiction debut. And when I stumbled across
00:02:21.520 these queen stories, I was actually working on a completely different project. And as part of that
00:02:26.480 project, I was participating in this thing called a genographic project, which is like trying to
00:02:32.340 trace deep ancestry. So it's not necessarily like ancestry.com, but it was trying to work out who
00:02:37.100 your earliest genetic maternal ancestors were. And I was oddly enough linked to this Viking queen
00:02:45.780 named Estrid, and then to her mother, who's the semi-legendary Sigrid the Hottie, who I think you
00:02:51.920 and your listeners, if you are not familiar with her story, will be very excited about. So all you
00:02:57.480 really need to know about Sigrid is that the king of Norway slaps her across the face during marriage
00:03:02.340 negotiations. Sigrid tells him he'll be sorry. She spends the next decade organizing a multinational
00:03:08.500 alliance. She ambushes him at sea. She forces him to commit suicide by jumping into the icy
00:03:14.400 waters while she watches and waves from her own boat. So I thought that was the story, which is
00:03:20.460 pretty cool, that I was going to be writing. And then in the course of that, I come across a source
00:03:27.120 that makes this like offhand mention that if you think the grudge match between Sigrid and the
00:03:32.400 King of Norway is bad you should really look at the grudge match between Queen Brunhild and Queen
00:03:38.560 Fredegund and I had never heard of either of these queens but clearly immediately I am very curious
00:03:44.240 and at the same time as I describe in the opening of my book I also happened to buy one of those
00:03:49.680 Viking hats at a costume store for a Halloween party it was one of those like giant plastic
00:03:55.160 horned helmets with the blonde braids glued on. I must've had Vikings on the brain because of
00:04:01.260 Sigur the Hottie, but I also knew like this helmet was linked in some way to a woman in an
00:04:07.400 opera named Brunhild. And then I realized there was a connection to the story of Freda Gunn and
00:04:13.040 Brunhild and I was hooked and I kind of fell down the research rabbit hole and this book resulted.
00:04:18.360 Okay. The research rabbit hole is a big thing that I'm really curious about because, okay,
00:04:22.880 my listeners know but just to recap i somebody mentioned to me oh you should do an episode about
00:04:28.580 fred again and then i just like googled it i found the wikipedia page i'm like whoa this is
00:04:32.900 interesting and then i was like i wish that there was a biography of her and then i came across one
00:04:38.860 of your articles um and at the bottom the article said like she's writing a book about about this
00:04:43.540 i'm like oh my god like what perfect timing so like there wasn't a book about this until your
00:04:48.580 book so like the research like you are kind of the first person to like delve this deep into it so
00:04:54.800 what how did you find the information you found so as you well know is the case with probably
00:05:02.140 every historical woman that you have done any episode on basically all we know about them is
00:05:07.780 through some man so I had to sift through all that figure out who each man was what his agenda was
00:05:13.900 what could he possibly realistically know and not know and how much um credence to give to his
00:05:19.480 account and the bibliography in this book is quite ridiculous I think it's like 20 pages so there's
00:05:26.000 a lot but I'll like I'm happy to share some of my favorite highlights of uh these these men and
00:05:32.720 the queen's lives so can I ask one question first so like when you do this research was
00:05:36.720 were you looking at primary source documents like yeah written like I don't is Frankish a
00:05:42.580 written language like it's all in latin okay so they were writing in latin and then luckily my
00:05:48.880 latin is quite terrible i had to uh in many cases rely on a translator but luckily a lot of these
00:05:54.400 have already been translated for me but a lot of times i went back to the original latin and then
00:06:00.240 kind of double checked because there were some really interesting things where there were words
00:06:04.340 that particularly like when it applied to fredega where you're like is she mad is she scared is she
00:06:08.980 upset. And the shade of meaning of that word could really change something, particularly when it came
00:06:13.820 to things like a pregnancy, a miscarriage, the loss of a child, and certain motivations that men
00:06:19.980 had said, oh, well, clearly, they were feeling x, y, or z. And then you went back and said, well,
00:06:24.340 actually, it seems more likely, given all the other evidence that this was what was really
00:06:29.280 happening. So primary sources, but also a lot of secondary scholarship, there are a very committed
00:06:35.520 group of scholars that specialize in Merovingian history. And I was lucky to get to talk and
00:06:42.040 interact with a lot of them. And there's one in particular who has done a lot of work on
00:06:47.220 Merovingian women named E.T. Daly, who I can give a little shout out to. So if people are really
00:06:51.980 interested in scholarship on this era, that's a good person's work to check out. So were you in
00:07:00.180 France? Like where are these documents housed? Are we able to do it digitally or?
00:07:06.800 So I did actually do a lot of traveling. This was pre-pandemic. So this was in 2019,
00:07:12.600 right before everything shut down. I had no idea how lucky I was, but most of these have,
00:07:18.720 they are digitized. So you can look at the manuscripts online. And then a lot of them
00:07:23.400 that have been translated are in academic libraries. So it is possible to get a copy.
00:07:29.640 I was really lucky to have some kindly librarians sort of bend over backwards to get me these
00:07:36.020 really obscure texts through interlibrary loans that were like very convoluted, but
00:07:41.620 I was extraordinarily like fortunate that way.
00:07:45.360 I think you're going to say, before I ask the question, like what some of your favorite
00:07:49.120 sources were.
00:07:50.200 So what, out of the like 20 pages of references, like what were the ones that you're most excited
00:07:55.800 about or were most interesting?
00:07:57.260 i think we get most of our dialogue from a guy named gregory of tor he's kind of a fun source
00:08:06.780 because he really hates women in power but he's brunhild's ally and he's really embarrassed that
00:08:11.920 brunhild helped to get him his job as bishop so he actually like never mentions that she gets him
00:08:16.520 his job and we only find this out by a mention from one of his friends and you go oh okay
00:08:21.200 but he really goes after Fredegun though she basically enrages him and he is very uh we could
00:08:28.440 say a very anti-Fredegun source but he is also an eyewitness so particularly for things like
00:08:34.980 weather events or what happened in what order we can definitely count on him and he actually
00:08:39.520 goes on trial for slandering Fredegun and you know has his life hanging in the balance and has
00:08:46.440 to pull in some friends and flatter her. So it is pretty interesting that he's actually involved in
00:08:52.120 it. He has this friend named Fortunatus, who's a court poet who makes his living writing poems for
00:08:58.900 rich people. So he's friends with basically anyone who's anyone in the Frankish kingdoms on both
00:09:05.100 sides. But he writes poems for both Brunhild and for Fredegann. And what's really interesting is
00:09:10.000 obviously they're biased, but you get a sense of how these women want to be seen. And one thing I
00:09:15.320 found really interesting was even well before Fredegun was regent, the poem he writes about
00:09:21.420 her, it talks about her brains, just how smart she is. And that's not really typical for the
00:09:26.340 time period. It's just, she's shrewd. She's great at making decisions. And it also says that she
00:09:31.620 shares in the rule with the king. It's really interesting that publicly they're going out
00:09:36.900 saying the king needs this woman to help him rule. And that's okay. Everyone's all right with 0.95
00:09:41.700 that so I found that a little surprising and interesting and then there are some oh go ahead
00:09:47.440 no no you go ahead there are some letters written by Brunhild and her son that are a lot of fun like
00:09:55.460 there's one of these where the Byzantine emperor sends a message to Brunhild's son and she writes
00:09:59.560 back really sternly and she basically slaps him down and says I'm the one you need to be dealing
00:10:05.140 with and he does deal with her from then on so it is great to get these little glimpses of their
00:10:11.680 personalities. And then there's a lot of more boring and bureaucratic things like church records
00:10:16.140 and church councils and historical chronicles. But those would probably be my favorite.
00:10:23.340 I'm so excited just thinking that you got to read an actual letter Brunhilde wrote. That's
00:10:27.380 so exciting. Yeah. She's very imperious and she refers to herself in the royal we.
00:10:32.980 So we have counseled war or we have decided this or that. It's kind of fun.
00:10:38.560 so I was just gonna ask before um you mentioned in the Gregory of Tours that he talked about
00:10:44.820 weather events and things so the weather was wild right yes like there it was just like what like
00:10:53.940 describe the like the weather of the like the story it's just like there's all these people
00:10:58.900 making you know assassination attempts and like wars and whatever but it's like and also guess
00:11:02.800 what? It's like raining for like 10 years or something. Like what was going on? Yeah. Well,
00:11:08.540 we have, they're both born right after this horrific climate change and it's two degrees,
00:11:15.760 except in our case, we're worried about it becoming two degrees warmer. In their case,
00:11:19.280 it went two degrees colder and that disrupts everything. So we have 18 months of darkness,
00:11:25.240 there's snow in the summer. This is the entire world, right? And then it seems like it takes
00:11:31.400 a while for things to get back up to speed and then there's another volcanic eruption and we
00:11:36.160 have more famine and on top of that we have bubonic plague and then it seems like the world
00:11:42.980 rebounds by just there's a lot of rain there's just a ton of rain it's a really wet damp period
00:11:49.540 and you can imagine that doesn't bode well for everyone's health as in there's just constant
00:11:55.380 flooding everybody's getting dysentery from the flood water there's you know just cold and damp
00:12:01.140 a lot of mold it's it's really awful mud mud everywhere right yeah so just as that is like the
00:12:09.400 the backdrop for everything that's happening like it's just like it feels like a movie honestly
00:12:15.100 it's just like everything simultaneous like it's giving me a game of thrones right where it's just
00:12:20.020 like well it's been winter for 20 years and everyone's kind of losing their mind yeah so
00:12:27.240 just that dysentery you mentioned so that was just like in going through like just reading the book
00:12:33.020 um it's just like and then and then this child died of dysentery and then she like managed to
00:12:38.080 get pregnant again and then that child died of dysentery and it's just like oh my god it just
00:12:42.060 it's like unrelenting like the the debt it seemed to be a lot of children dying
00:12:46.920 yes and I think unrelenting is a great adjective for it it's just one thing after another I don't
00:12:55.980 know how people managed to endure. It's quite overwhelming. And the thing that's so interesting
00:13:03.120 is that there was this knowledge that you should really boil water and you should only drink clean
00:13:08.700 water. And there were some aqueducts, Roman aqueducts that were still functioning. So there
00:13:14.620 was this knowledge, but somehow it wasn't always translating into practice. There was just so much
00:13:19.160 chaos in terms of being able to repair infrastructure that they couldn't keep up.
00:13:25.560 So that's the other frustrating thing of if people weren't completely ignorant as to why this was happening, but they just couldn't stop it from happening. And I think that's even more frustrating must be to live through.
00:13:35.320 well yeah if you're just like constantly dealing with like climate-based disasters it's like yeah
00:13:41.540 there's not time to really do the like next level city building structuring type stuff there's a part
00:13:48.200 now I'm just like I read this like a bit ago but what was this there's part of it and I think it
00:13:53.640 was Brunhild or no maybe it's Fred again there was a part where like it was something about there
00:13:59.640 was a child was sick and they were like yeah we should like we should all separate everybody and
00:14:04.260 they're like, no, let's all go in church altogether and stay awake for like 72 hours
00:14:07.780 altogether. What was that? Can you tell that? That's Keith Guntram who, and it's to deal with
00:14:12.480 the plague and he decides, so some people are saying having basically rudimentary travel
00:14:18.920 restrictions, like we really shouldn't travel. We should stay apart. And they're understanding
00:14:22.780 that it's how it spreads. So even Gregory of Tor, who's very superstitious, sort of credulous man
00:14:29.280 who believes that like you know stars and comets are comets are causing people to drop dead but he
00:14:35.460 understands oh a ship comes into port somebody on the ship has the plague the next thing you know
00:14:40.000 the people who did business with that man have the plague and then his family has the plague and then
00:14:45.500 their neighbors have the plague so they were understanding how it spread and a lot of people
00:14:49.580 are saying we should not have fares we should not get together but king guntram's like i need a win
00:14:56.040 so I'm going to make everybody come together for several days and we're all going to be packed in
00:15:01.820 and we're just going to pray and have these processions and all these people drop dead
00:15:06.740 but not seeing the connection and then there's this great cure where they decide that
00:15:13.320 some woman takes a bit of thread or maybe it's embroidery from his cape and puts it
00:15:19.460 in some water and has her child drink it and that cures him so people are starting to think
00:15:25.700 that if they can just get pieces of royal cloaks and soak them in water that that will cure the
00:15:32.340 plague so scary it's so like this story especially but i guess lately anytime i'm reading about
00:15:42.180 somebody living through any sort of pandemic i'm just like i relate but it's so yeah because i
00:15:48.360 think there's this really and i think this comes across really well in your book um there's a sense
00:15:53.220 like you sort of spoke to it that people think like oh people in those like early medieval period 1.00
00:15:57.620 like well they were just a bunch of dum-dums like they didn't know what they were doing like they 0.99
00:16:01.880 were just kind of like in this you know the dark ages sort of thing where it's like no like even 0.99
00:16:06.880 if they didn't know like germ theory like they could figure out like a ship comes and then that's
00:16:11.300 where the plague comes from like they were smart I liked reading about how they were making decisions 0.96
00:16:16.480 that are similar to decisions people would be making today like they're not just like fools 0.95
00:16:21.220 who are just like everything's witchcraft or whatever it's like they're like I don't know
00:16:27.580 did you find like relatable things that people were doing when you were researching it like
00:16:32.820 decisions that surprised you that felt like modern yeah I mean I think even Fredegund
00:16:38.380 has this one decision where she wants to get rid of one of her her stepson her only surviving
00:16:43.200 stepson who's in the way between her her sons and and the throne and so she sends him to an area
00:16:49.520 that's having an outbreak comes up with an excuse because she clearly there's some understanding as
00:16:54.440 you say maybe not of germ theory but like this area more people are dying I'm going to send him
00:16:59.940 here in the hopes that that he will die which is diabolical but also seems like something somebody
00:17:07.260 could pull off today right and I think even just some of the decisions that both queens make
00:17:13.900 surrounding pregnancy, early childhood of their children, even the degree of their grief seems
00:17:22.680 really modern. When you hear of Fredegund being just devastated and she's sobbing publicly,
00:17:31.280 particularly given what we know of her sort of imperious temperament, the fact that she's just
00:17:36.680 that broken and fortunatus, this court poet has to make these poems to say, please stop crying and
00:17:42.420 there's going to be another son and you're going to get to snuggle him. And the fact that they
00:17:45.440 would use a word about like, talk about snuggling and cuddling children, even if it's a stretch,
00:17:51.940 it still gives you a sense of how close people were or expected to be to their children and how
00:17:59.600 devastated they were when they died so much more frequently than what we have to endure.
00:18:05.100 And that felt very modern too. Yeah. I think there's sort of this,
00:18:10.340 there's a lot of there was so much more child death in history than there is now for various
00:18:16.760 reasons so I think there's sort of like a flippancy that not just historians but just like people who
00:18:21.520 read it but they're like oh yeah everyone had 12 children because they knew like five of them would
00:18:24.300 die and whatever it's like oh another child died like on we go but it's like no like it was it of
00:18:28.680 course people were upset when their children died like it's not just like well there goes another
00:18:33.200 one I guess we'll just have another baby yeah and I'm even thinking of things like postpartum
00:18:38.020 depression, that it seems pretty clear based on the evidence that Fredigan has a really bad
00:18:42.800 bout of that. And they describe it, even though they don't use the sort of terms that we would.
00:18:49.100 But there are things like that, that seem really moderate. I also think there's this
00:18:53.960 great interlude where we get to this rebellion in a convent, but there's that description of both
00:19:02.000 surgery, where men are having surgery on their testicles based on some procedure they saw done 0.74
00:19:08.740 in Byzantium. So you're saying, okay, so people are able to transport medical knowledge across
00:19:15.000 these distances and copy. And at least in this case, this person survives. We don't know how
00:19:19.580 many people survive, but we have at least a few people where it's successful. So they're
00:19:22.980 performing some sort of basic rudimentary successful surgery. But also there are a lot
00:19:27.300 of cases of people who are biologically sexed as male, but are living as women. There's the graves 0.55
00:19:34.900 that have been found. There's this one particular case of this person who was born a man, but lives
00:19:42.400 as a woman in a convent. And so that's also, I think their sense of gender surprised me often,
00:19:50.740 that it was a little more fluid than we might expect, or we typically think it was black or
00:19:56.100 white and that they did have some gray area as well yeah it was um not an era that I've ever
00:20:03.900 read about before this like I've read about you know like the Romans and I've read about
00:20:08.080 I don't know like my historical knowledge until I read your book was kind of like
00:20:11.620 Romans Egyptians and it jumps forward to like the renaissance like what happened in Europe in the
00:20:18.160 middle and I guess it's is it because there's just less sources that people know not as much
00:20:23.080 about this time period? Or was it just because they were wiped out? And then, well, I guess I
00:20:28.520 know like Charlemagne came in and then like, you know, about that, but the stuff that happened
00:20:32.120 before did they, was it suppressed? I think it's twofold. So there's been this estimate that of
00:20:39.400 the sources that survive, there are probably less than 1% of what was produced, but because so little 1.00
00:20:45.640 survived, it became really easy for the next dynasty to say, these people were idiots. They 1.00
00:20:50.780 didn't produce a lot of information and look how smart we are in comparison to them. So there was
00:20:55.260 a bit of a public relations campaign on the part of Charlemagne and his dynasty. But also the
00:21:00.660 Merovingians made a bad decision, they didn't know it at the time, to use papyrus for a lot of their
00:21:07.440 records. And papyrus can survive for, you know, thousands and thousands of years in the dry
00:21:13.140 climate of Egypt. But once you get it into the damp and the cold of Europe, it does not last nearly as
00:21:20.000 long. So a lot of what has survived just happened to be on parchment. And there was a shortage,
00:21:25.700 a papyrus shortage. And there were these issues with trade. So people switched to parchment. And
00:21:30.660 so it just happened that everybody who wrote on parchment, those records survived and all the
00:21:36.000 records that have been written on papyrus didn't. And that's just kind of the luck of the draw. So
00:21:40.540 some of that accounts for the lack of sources. And then also there was a lot of purposeful
00:21:44.800 suppression as well which leads me to something that I still find it very I wouldn't say enraging
00:21:52.440 but just like so annoying which is that after the death of both women that it was kind of like she
00:21:58.260 was the king's mother at the end like the fact that it's Fredigan's tomb right that's just like
00:22:02.940 wife mother and it's like oh my god she did so much like it was her like immediately like upon
00:22:10.880 the death of both women like what they did was kind of hidden away like sort of like we don't 0.84
00:22:16.140 we kind of don't want people to know that like women did stuff so let's just like not let anyone
00:22:21.580 know what happened absolutely and you know something that really surprised me is i assume
00:22:28.700 that brunhild and fredigan were exceptions to the rule and i was really surprised to find out that
00:22:33.560 there were actually quite a few female political leaders in the sixth century so if your listeners
00:22:38.260 are interested, we have a queen in Lombard, Italy. There's a regent, Sophia, for the Byzantine Empire.
00:22:46.680 Japan's being ruled by an empress, Suiko. There's a Mayan queen, I think her name's Yal-Iknol.
00:22:54.500 And so we have all these women that happen to be ruling at the same time. And then we also have
00:22:59.640 women that are powerful abbesses and business owners and women who are entangled in political
00:23:05.920 plots, and we have nuns in armed rebellions. So given how few sources survive, I think we only
00:23:12.220 know the half of it. But it's really surprising that there were so many women in such a chaotic 0.82
00:23:17.960 era that were thriving, not just surviving and getting by, but actually thriving and ruling.
00:23:24.720 And then that sort of stuff is so interesting to me, too, because there's such a sort of like,
00:23:31.200 i don't know the common way that history is taught in general it's kind of like you know
00:23:38.220 women weren't able to do anything and then suddenly like the 1960s birth control pill
00:23:42.880 women could have jobs now where it's like no it's not been like an upward trajectory and like women
00:23:47.460 get more and more rights it's like there were places like this where that was not so much of
00:23:52.080 an issue and then that was suppressed and then this other place like it's i love reading with
00:23:57.920 these little pockets of time to learn that like it's not history is not a straight line of just 0.98
00:24:03.420 like things are just always getting better which is so false but especially in terms of women's
00:24:09.340 rights that's so fascinating I've just been reading about a woman in um 10th century Kashmir 0.96
00:24:15.740 and how she was like anyway which was really interesting like she ruled it was chaotic there 1.00
00:24:22.920 and then she came in with like very ruthless successful style and then she like brought
00:24:28.960 stability for 40 years to this region fascinating wow yeah no I know so it's like it's not new 0.91
00:24:35.800 the idea of like women could be leaders but you just don't hear about it yeah yeah I wanted to 0.84
00:24:42.800 ask you just one final question which is what influence do you think the Fredigan and Brunhild
00:24:52.120 had on history or just like, well, I guess more on a micro level, like the development of Western
00:24:59.460 Europe? Like what do you think their era, what's the significance of it? So I think there probably
00:25:08.000 are three key ways that they influence Western Europe. So the first and probably the most obvious
00:25:16.580 is one provides the air and the other the land that shapes Europe for the next few centuries.
00:25:20.620 So Fredagon is the one through who, you know, her blood flows through all the subsequent Merovingian kings. And I say that just because there were some questions about her son's legitimacy. These might have been the usual slurs, but because we have no DNA, we can't prove paternity. So she's the only one we can really be certain of.
00:25:40.000 and anyone who follows is her descendant and there are even people alive today they call
00:25:48.540 themselves the order of the Merovingian dynasty who claim to be descended from Fredegund so they
00:25:52.720 trace their lineage back through a woman named Bertha Broadfoot who is Charlemagne's mother
00:25:57.460 who may have been part of the Merovingian royal family kind of tangentially so there is that sort
00:26:04.900 of intriguing bit that if it's not for Fredegund we don't have the rest of the dynasty and then
00:26:11.720 obviously Brunhild and Fredegund to an extent provide the land so when Fredegund's son Clothar
00:26:17.780 II deposes her he's getting a ready-made empire he's moving in she's already united the bulk of
00:26:23.480 Western Europe you know for him we know that they have an outside influence on future queens so
00:26:31.820 there are women who try to follow in their footsteps or take lessons from them and we know
00:26:36.400 are aware of their example so there's women who try to become regents themselves or they adopt
00:26:41.700 some of their survival tactics and there's even a great case this queen adelaide of morienne who
00:26:47.860 has a matching sarcophagus made like her so her and fredigan have matching or matchy matchy even
00:26:54.640 after death. So we know that a lot of royal French women read their stories, are aware of
00:27:03.140 their legacy, and we can assume there's some influence there. But I think the most important
00:27:08.400 is that the backlash to their reigns reverberates, and it really impacts Europe for centuries.
00:27:15.420 I would argue that it sets the world back in a lot of ways. Both of these women seem to foresee
00:27:22.200 the wisdom of there being a single heir model they're both trying to consolidate it behind a 0.73
00:27:28.340 single male heir as opposed to keep dividing it up as we know that that probably would have worked
00:27:34.800 out a little bit better and prevented you know some wars if that had worked but we also know
00:27:41.900 that like when Brunhild is betrayed by the people who work for her and Clothar II Fredegund's son
00:27:49.300 moves in he basically dooms the whole dynasty because he makes has to make some concessions
00:27:53.920 so in order to get what he wants and part of that is he limits the king's power and he agrees to
00:28:00.320 split the frankish empires into three so it basically does away with the dream of like a
00:28:05.600 unified empire like rome and it leads to the fragmented nation states that we see then for the
00:28:11.840 next you know thousand years so there's that there's kind of two models of government where
00:28:17.380 we could have this sort of Roman empire with these sort of semi-autonomous provinces, or we could have
00:28:24.400 these sort of fragmented kingdoms that are always going to be jockeying for position and a lot of
00:28:29.780 infighting. So they also, both of them stand up to the church at a time when the church is
00:28:36.000 consolidating power and it's growing increasingly misogynistic and more fundamentalist. So
00:28:42.760 they're on the losing side of that. But unfortunately, the way the church reacts to
00:28:47.800 both of them influences women for centuries. So we have to keep in mind that about a generation
00:28:54.960 before them, women are still serving as deacons. So they're actually participating in mass. That
00:28:59.000 has to be outlawed. Priests are still getting married. Things are a lot more in flux, and
00:29:04.020 there's two denominations of Christianity, and it's kind of not clear which one's going to win
00:29:08.240 out, whether it's going to be the more tolerant branch, or if it's going to be what eventually
00:29:13.420 becomes Catholicism. We know Fredigan seems to be what I'd say a flexible Christian. There's some
00:29:20.560 potentially some pagan influences there. And Brunhild is certainly was raised in a more
00:29:26.500 tolerant Christian background. She's very tolerant of Jews in her kingdom. And she is like
00:29:32.020 smacked down by the Pope for that. So we know that they have this more cosmopolitan worldview,
00:29:37.440 maybe not because they're nice people, but just out of sheer necessity that they have to work with
00:29:41.480 whoever will have them. But we also see like Fredegun clearly assassinating bishops and
00:29:46.680 Brunhilde brings a rape case against another bishop and sticks up to some particularly
00:29:54.040 fundamentalist monks and kicks them out of her kingdom. So they unfortunately don't win out, 0.90
00:30:00.520 but I think they're part of that struggle where it could have gone either way. And the fact that
00:30:04.860 it goes against them we essentially pay the price so i actually have a question for you if that's
00:30:12.180 okay please yes um or maybe two so you are clearly team fredigan by the way i love your um that's so
00:30:21.020 fredigan merch oh thank you i just ordered a tote no oh uh i love it okay but i also i'm like really
00:30:27.660 curious what caught your imagination other than maybe the red hair okay that is a factor but um
00:30:36.120 so I think it was honestly because I had asked my listeners I was just like what are some
00:30:40.980 interesting stories like what are some lessons and one of the listeners said Fred again and I'm
00:30:44.680 like well who's that and I googled it so I honestly I read about Fred again first so that's I came to
00:30:50.200 this all from a Fred again lens so I was just like who's Fred again and then excuse me Brunhild
00:30:55.580 I'm like oh that's Fredigan's enemy like that was how I didn't make the choice after seeing
00:31:02.340 them both and assessing it was just kind of like I came to it from a Fredigan point of view
00:31:06.860 and from her point of view Brunhild is the enemy and that was just kind of where I came to it from
00:31:12.120 but Brunhild I think I do think one day I might do a Brunhild episode just like flip it around to
00:31:17.620 be like from her point of view what was happening but I don't know also Fredigan feels kind of like
00:31:22.040 the underdog to me a bit and the way that she kept trying to assassinate Brunhild and it kept
00:31:27.740 not working was like made me like her more it was like charming and then the fact like her
00:31:34.620 the fact that her military victories were so stylish like the the the walking forest it's like
00:31:41.700 that was her it's just I don't know so it's Fred again has a sort of I think because she wasn't as
00:31:49.480 my sense is not as powerful as Brunhild so she was like scrappier and also the fact that she came
00:31:56.080 from being like an enslaved person to being so powerful where Brunhild kind of had the she was
00:32:02.260 like more groomed for it so yeah so I think it's the underdog quality I appreciate and also just
00:32:07.300 her her flair her flair do you have a favorite Fred again story I love so many things about
00:32:13.740 Fred again um when I was getting ready for this interview I was just like remember this remember
00:32:18.200 when she did this and I was just like oh she did so many cool things I was like looking at
00:32:21.400 my notes from when I was doing the episode I love the walking trees I love um I love that
00:32:27.800 she kind of invented putting poison on blades that was iconic but I mean the part where god
00:32:37.080 I forgot what it even was but when somebody had said that she had maybe committed adultery and
00:32:41.440 then it's like well she could have 12 witnesses speak for her and she brought in 300 and they
00:32:46.860 were like all like bishops and like the most important people like I think that's that's the
00:32:53.220 most iconic Fredigan moment for me I think the 300 character witnesses yes excellent although I do
00:32:59.760 like I like one of her military victories I forget the details exactly but it's where she got all of
00:33:05.920 her army to like cut their hair so they would look like the other people yes the Bretons when she's
00:33:10.640 uh so she wants to go against Guntram but she doesn't want to be seen to do so so she's like
00:33:16.380 yeah these the bretons are fighting against you so we're just going to pretend we're bretons
00:33:21.140 yeah well and where hair was so important to the like culturally but she's like what if i just like
00:33:26.560 cut off everyone's hair and then yeah so just like i'm not someone who's into reading about like
00:33:32.000 battle history but fredigan every time she did one it was something cool like that
00:33:36.180 it made me interested in it yeah yeah that's very cool i love hearing that she is quite a character
00:33:44.180 and what's so fascinating about both of these women is they never seem to have internalized
00:33:49.440 the misogyny that's all around them like there's doesn't seem to be a lot of self-doubt there
00:33:54.080 might have been but we don't see it but they were like why not why can't I yeah yeah I'm just as
00:33:59.860 good as the rest of you if not better here I go well and I think I appreciate that too I love
00:34:06.080 like not just like as a woman reading about women but just like as a person like I love reading
00:34:09.760 about somebody who's just like that confident and outside the box and like who sees who's in this
00:34:15.400 like pit of vipers environment where like anyone could betray you at any point but the way that
00:34:20.520 they're both kind of like always one step ahead of that is like gratifying to read where they're
00:34:25.580 sort of they are in ostensibly powerful roles but they could so easily be brought down and the fact
00:34:33.160 they weren't was very um not inspirational but just like satisfying to read I think
00:34:41.040 I think my favorite Fredigan story has to do with Sigivert's assassination but I just find it
00:34:48.780 amazing that first she has this severe postpartum depression she basically seems like she might be
00:34:53.940 borderline you know psychotic like she's cobitose and she somehow is able to snap out of that which
00:35:00.700 in and of itself right everyone else around her is completely freaking out they're under siege
00:35:07.640 they assume they're about ready to die and none of the military advisors or her own husband can
00:35:12.580 figure a way out of it and she doesn't just recover she's able to keep a cool head and she's able to
00:35:18.240 come up with an innovative idea for an assassination and then convince two boys to go on a suicide
00:35:23.420 mission for her. I just can't imagine the, the wherewithal, especially on days when I can't
00:35:30.320 get my grocery list together. And she was able to pull all of that off in such a short period of
00:35:35.760 time. It's just stunning. I love that. I love that story too. I love just the image of just like
00:35:41.680 everyone being chaotic around her. And she's just like pulls herself, even just momentarily to be
00:35:46.520 like, okay, like clearly you can't do anything without me. Like, here's what we're going to do.
00:35:51.220 like we're good and then she can just like go back into her coma or whatever like 0.72
00:35:55.280 like the yeah just the constant really smart things she did and because you're more um
00:36:02.760 objective about all of this than I am what's your what's a Brunhilde
00:36:05.720 iconic moment that you really like I really I do like when Brunhilde goes after the church
00:36:15.000 occasionally. I also love that she cooperates. I didn't know this story, but Pope Gregory the
00:36:21.380 Great happens to be somewhat progressive in that he's willing to work with women because nobody
00:36:27.000 else seems to really want to work with him. And I love part of this idea that Bede erases from his
00:36:33.400 history, but that Pope Gregory the Great thanks her and says, you're the reason that Britain is
00:36:38.780 Christianized and that she's the one funding his missionary movement to send the monks over to
00:36:44.620 Canterbury in the little kingdom of Kent and essentially convert all of those people so
00:36:52.100 that's that was just something that I find really interesting that that's like an outsized influence
00:36:57.020 that we don't know about that's kind of been erased I love her letters particularly
00:37:04.480 there's a few where she there's one in particular where her grandson is being held hostage by the
00:37:12.140 Byzantines and they're trying to get her to go to war in order to get him back and she writes these
00:37:18.180 letters to the Byzantine Empress saying essentially part of her plays on her pity like oh feel bad for
00:37:25.080 me my I miss my grandson and he's my only link to my dead daughter and I'm just so sad but then a
00:37:31.260 minute later there's that steal and like it would be very unfortunate if something were to happen
00:37:35.240 to your, you know, to your son, who's about the same age as my grandson. So you might want to
00:37:42.340 keep that in mind and how she's able to kind of veer back and forth. So anytime I think that she
00:37:46.080 maybe has lost the plot and she's genuinely upset, and then you realize, nope, she's thought this all
00:37:51.700 out ahead of time. I also really love about Bernhilde, how she builds these networks with
00:37:59.160 other women. So as much as we have the two of them fighting against one another, there was some part 0.99
00:38:04.960 of it that was kind of charming for me to realize that it wasn't necessarily personal because I
00:38:10.400 think it can be really easy to get caught up in the catfight aspect of it as opposed to which I
00:38:16.760 like that you focused on them as political rivals of just somebody's got to win and we've got to do
00:38:22.560 this but I really like how there's this treaty that she negotiates and she makes sure throughout 0.98
00:38:30.060 the treaty to basically guard the rights of all these other women. So, you know, she, it's called 1.00
00:38:37.100 the Treaty of Andalot. And we know there's cooperation between her, another one of her
00:38:40.700 daughters, her daughter-in-law, as well as Guntram's own daughter. And a third of that treaty
00:38:45.440 just has to do with women. Like Brune Hope gets legal protection for herself. For all these other 1.00
00:38:49.740 women, it says we're financially independent. You can't force us into a convent. We can keep our
00:38:53.980 property. We can dispose of it as we wish. So I really like that about her. And I also love the
00:39:00.040 moment where Brunhild and Fredegund have to have this short-lived alliance so there's this time
00:39:04.760 when Fredegund basically has to grudgingly symbolically adopt Brunhild's son and I just
00:39:10.680 love to imagine the behind the scenes of that for both of them because you know there had to be some
00:39:17.800 sort of gritting of the teeth and getting on with it but I also like that that really shows
00:39:22.120 their very practical sides and how in some ways they're more similar than they are different.
00:39:26.760 I love what you said about um like the the rights and stuff that Brunhild was codifying for women
00:39:35.160 and stuff because I do one does find in stories where women take power especially in ones where
00:39:41.280 they're like the regent but technically the like child boy is the king a lot of times like oh I'm 1.00
00:39:46.720 just like a lot of times they like separate from their gender I think out of survival but they 0.51
00:39:51.720 really don't stand up for other women because they know that that wouldn't be popular I'm I 1.00
00:39:56.820 can't think of a specific example but there's certainly women who have been in power but they 0.98
00:40:01.320 really rule I would say Elizabeth the first um but they really rule like men frankly right because 0.75
00:40:08.220 that's kind of what they have to do it's like the way that they can get respect is by being like oh
00:40:12.780 I'm not really a woman like I look like a woman but I'm not really a woman I'm not going to like
00:40:16.140 give like women rights. So I respect that Brunhilde and Fredegand didn't, well, like you were saying, 0.93
00:40:23.640 the cultural context of the time, it's like that misogyny of religion was not super influential
00:40:30.520 at that point. So they were able to have a bit more leeway, I guess, than what future generations
00:40:36.260 had to deal with. Yeah. Yeah. It's kind of interesting too, to think about how there's
00:40:43.400 this horrific climate change and this pandemic. And those are very bad things, but they also
00:40:49.200 open up a lot of opportunities for women. And I think that that's just something that I am trying
00:40:55.180 to keep in mind because people are more willing to try something unconventional. I mean, there is
00:41:00.900 a shortage a lot of times of able leaders. We know a lot of the men just keep dying,
00:41:06.100 but there is this sense of, you know what, things are kind of going to hell in a handbasket. Why not?
00:41:10.480 why not try this? And so there is, I think, a little bit of hope to be found in that even just
00:41:16.840 in our own time too, that sometimes really extreme circumstances can push us to think out of the box
00:41:23.600 and to maybe allow people who've been marginalized to come to the forefront and to contribute to
00:41:29.620 greater degree. Your book comes out on February 22nd. It does, yes. And are you going to, well,
00:41:39.220 this is just a curious question of my own like you're going to be doing I assume like lots of
00:41:43.220 other interviews and like you're going to be I know that as far as it's a mix of things right
00:41:49.440 now being virtual and being in person I know that there is a virtual event on the 27th I believe
00:41:57.780 it's February 27th DC's Politics and Prose but it's a free virtual event for anyone who would
00:42:03.560 like to join. And I know there are some in-person events and a mix of virtual events, but anyone
00:42:09.720 who's interested can certainly check out my website. It's shellypuhack.com. And that's
00:42:15.220 shelly with an E-Y-P-U-H-A-K.com. And there's an events page and I am updating that as more and
00:42:21.560 more things get on the schedule. So thank you. And thank you so much for your support of the book. I
00:42:26.240 was so grateful to stumble across this podcast and to hear of your love of all things Fredagon.
00:42:32.120 done. And I'm very excited to get my tote. Really? I mean, that's honestly, this is like a beautiful
00:42:37.180 first full circle moment. Cause I just like found your book, did this podcast and now you have the
00:42:41.460 tote. It's like, I don't know. It's a circle of life. It's beautiful. So good luck with all of
00:42:46.460 your promotion. And I'm so excited for when the book comes out. And I know like listeners have
00:42:51.000 been telling me like, they're excited to get the book. So you'll get a little vulgar history,
00:42:56.420 little bump of purchases, I hope. Well, thank you. That's so gratifying. It's excellent.
00:43:00.660 thank you so much thank you for having me i really appreciated chatting with you
00:43:05.760 so as we said in the episode you can get a copy of the dark queens all over the place there are
00:43:13.740 links in at shelly's website shellypuhak.com and i've got the link in the show notes as well
00:43:18.900 and also check out her website to learn about all of the online events she has coming up because
00:43:23.580 obviously as you just listen to she's a delightful person to listen to she has so much to say about
00:43:29.200 this book and about these queens and i'm so happy that i got to share this interview with all of you
00:43:35.700 um regular episodes of vulgar history are going to start next week uh season five is going to start 0.96
00:43:42.040 on march 2nd so stay tuned for that and until then keep your mask on and your tits out take care 0.98
00:43:59.200 Chew on this bold question from Dentine Gum. 0.99
00:44:07.640 Is it ever okay to compliment a millennial
00:44:10.340 on their skinny jeans in 2026?
00:44:16.920 Dentine, chew bold.
00:44:19.240 Before you knew what a stock was,
00:44:21.140 you traded snacks, cards, turns.
00:44:24.220 That instinct to trade didn't disappear.
00:44:26.260 It just grew up.
00:44:27.500 With no minimums, no monthly fees, and 100 free trades,
00:44:31.160 TD Easy Trade taps into that instinct.
00:44:33.180 Because you are made to trade, and TD Easy Trade is made to help.
00:44:38.800 The war is over, and both sides lost.
00:44:43.100 Kingdoms were reduced to cinders, and armies scattered like bones in the dust.
00:44:48.520 Now the survivors claw to what's left of a broken world,
00:44:52.780 praying the darkness chooses someone else tonight.
00:44:55.620 but in the shadow dark the darkness always wins this is old school adventuring at its most cruel
00:45:03.580 your torch ticks down in real time and when that flame dies something else rises to finish the job
00:45:09.640 this is a brutal rules light nightmare with a story that emerges organically based on the
00:45:15.640 decisions that the characters make this is what it felt like to play rpgs in the 80s and man
00:45:20.320 it is so good to be back join the glass cannon podcast as we plunge into the shadow dark
00:45:25.040 every Thursday night at 8 p.m. Eastern
00:45:27.080 on youtube.com slash the glass cannon
00:45:29.360 with the podcast version dropping the next day.
00:45:32.740 See what everybody's talking about
00:45:34.040 and join us in the dark.