00:02:23.400Hello, and welcome to Vulgar History, a feminist women's history comedy podcast.
00:02:34.340My name is Anne Foster, and this is a super special episode. Today, I got to talk with
00:02:39.500Vanessa Wilkie, who is the author of a new book, which is called A Woman of Influence,
00:02:44.900The Spectacular Rise of Alice Spencer in Tudor, England. And why this caught my attention when I
00:02:50.640saw this book announced a while ago is because Alice Spencer is a woman who I've talked about
00:02:55.500on the podcast in the episode from the Lady Jane Grey season about Anne Stanley, the Countess of
00:03:01.040Castlehaven. And so because we refer to that a few times in this interview, I just wanted to kind of
00:03:05.920recap what happened in that episode, if it's been a while since you listened to it, or if you haven't
00:03:10.060listened to that episode yet. So Alice Spencer's daughter, Anne Stanley, married this piece of
00:03:15.240shit called Mervyn Tuchet, the Earl of Castlehaven. And he was a sexual predator and a horrific1.00
00:03:23.360person. And then for various sort of complicated reasons, but eventually it became apparent that0.99
00:03:31.160he had arranged the sexual assault of Anne Stanley, his wife, and he'd also been arranging the
00:03:37.620ongoing sexual assault of his stepdaughter, Anne Stanley's daughter, Elizabeth. And it all went to
00:03:42.940court. Mervyn was put on trial as were two male servants who were implicated in all this awful
00:03:49.400stuff. And part of what happened at the trial was that Anne Stanley herself, and this was
00:03:54.960unprecedented at the time, she testified against her husband in a rape trial, which was the first
00:04:00.300time that happened in England. Anyway, so just so you know, if you want to learn more about that,
00:04:07.380like you can read, there's a whole section on that in this book, A Woman of Influence,
00:04:10.820But also you could just like listen back to that episode about Ann Stanley from a while ago. So it's called the Castle Haven trial. And that sort of looms large in the story of Alice Spencer, because she was the matriarch. She was the Kris Jenner of this family. And so she was behind the scenes, kind of trying to figure things out, trying to maintain the family's prestige and reputation throughout this trial.
00:04:34.760So I just wanted to recap that because we are going to mention it several times in the
00:05:14.720I was really intrigued when I first saw that your book was coming out because I was like,
00:05:18.480Alice Spencer, I know. I know that name. Can you explain who Alice Spencer was and why maybe the
00:05:23.660listeners of this podcast might know that name? Well, the listeners of your podcast,
00:05:28.740thanks to your podcast, have learned many names of women in the past,
00:05:32.600But they probably know Alice Spencer as Alice Edgerton, who was the mother of Anne, the Countess of Castlehaven, which is how I first met Alice, too, was through the Castlehaven trial.
00:05:45.440And we're going to get to the Castlehaven trials.
00:05:47.580So that was an episode I did a while back in the Jane Grey season, Anne Stanley, the Countess of Castlehaven.
00:05:53.280But before we get to that part of her story, actually, can you explain to Alice Spencer her beginnings, her quasi-humble beginnings?
00:06:05.020Sure. So Alice was born at Althorpe, which today is quite famous. It's the palatial estate of the Spencer family.
00:06:17.420But at the time in the 1560s, Alice was born in 1560, it was a sheep farm and a much smaller
00:16:12.660They perform in Queen Elizabeth's court. And then he starts to move on to sponsoring a troupe of players, which are, you know, actors and playwrights.
00:16:22.380And we know that, you know, Shakespeare comes out of that that circle.
00:16:27.540So they were not certainly the only family to do this.
00:16:31.980Probably their other most famous peers would be like the Earl of Leicester.
00:16:36.840Robert Dudley has a troop of players, Lester's Men. And so there's Stranger's Men and Lester's
00:16:42.320Men. And there's all these different theater companies that are traveling around performing
00:16:46.140in private homes and then also performing for Queen Elizabeth in the court.
00:16:51.040And then she, again, like I'm trying to go sort of sequentially, but later in her life,
00:16:54.700like she notably like throws these parties that are masks that are plays and she's like acting
00:17:00.940in them herself. Like it's very, yeah, she's very into that.
00:17:04.320Yeah, I think she probably we don't we don't know exactly. There's not great records. And there's a couple. It gets confusing because they're all named Elizabeth. And they're all, you know, and it gets confusing because there's multiple countesses of Darby at the same time, like her mother in law. She becomes the Dowager countess. Alice becomes a Dowager countess of Darby. And then her sister-in-law is also the countess of Darby. So we don't always know which which countess they're talking about when there's lists of players.
00:17:31.500But we do know that certainly later in life, Alice was sponsoring these entertainments, but mostly it was probably her children and grandchildren that were performing in them.
00:17:40.880And so she also, the length of her life, you know, she starts off in this, correct me if I'm wrong, but like Elizabeth is the queen, right? When she is kicking things off. And then it leads to eventually James is the king and Anne of Denmark, his wife, and like Anne of Denmark is so much into theater as well.
00:17:59.940So we see, we see that as a commonality.
00:18:03.400Yeah. And then, you know, and actually there are other literary scholars that have, have
00:18:09.160written this. It didn't come, I put it in my book, but it didn't come for me. That there's an idea
00:18:15.100when Anne of Denmark comes, makes the move down to London once James ascends to the throne after
00:18:20.640Queen Elizabeth's death, that she actually meets Ben Johnson at Althorpe at an entertainment that
00:18:27.800Alice hosted. So, you know, Alice is not just a patroness of theater, but she's also like making
00:18:34.580these connections between now the new queen of England and the playwrights and poets that she's
00:18:41.200been, she and her husbands have been supporting and working with for years. I love that side of
00:18:48.180your book and of her story that kind of, I love these, anyone who's sort of just coloring in
00:18:54.140the spaces between it's like well this is the king and this is the queen and this is Shakespeare
00:18:57.860but it's like but what if there was a person who was kind of like also there kind of connecting
00:19:02.120them and I like that sort of side story but you mentioned there's not like it's not clear if she's
00:19:06.820acting in these plays or who is where there are so many records of her is she um sued a lot of
00:19:12.880people she had a lot of court records can you talk about that that side of things yeah and this
00:19:19.520is a place where she's so well documented because she was so litigious, but also when
00:19:26.620we situate her within the existing scholarship, it turns out, you know, this was a really
00:19:32.020common thing. Women in this period, I should say elite women in this period, were quite0.82
00:19:38.980litigious. And so we see this massive influx in lawsuits that are kind of spearheaded by
00:19:45.280women. Of course, Alice's first encounter with that is after Ferdinando dies, she enters into0.74
00:19:52.320this massive inheritance suit against her brother-in-law because Ferdinando's will leaves
00:19:58.620a lot to Alice and to her daughters and leaves very little to his brother who inherits the title
00:20:05.020and the primary estate. So they just go at it in multiple court systems, multiple lawsuits for
00:20:13.72013 years until it settled. And this is the point at which she marries the lawyer, right?
00:20:20.720Yes. Yes. She marries her second husband is Thomas Edgerton, who at the time was the keeper of the
00:20:28.700great seal for Queen Elizabeth. And then when King James ascends to the throne, he gets promoted to
00:20:36.400Lord Chancellor. So he's the head of the chancery courts in England, which is very much to Alice's
00:20:42.940advantage. And it was sort of, she's in this sort of situation where even though, so she's married
00:20:48.200to Ferdinando, Ferdinando dies, asterisk, was he poisoned by Jesuits? I talked about that in my
00:20:53.460previous episode and you talked about it in your book a little bit. Seemingly he was, because he
00:20:58.260was a threat to, as a potential heir to, he was like the only man on the entire family tree who
00:21:03.660was potentially an heir to the throne. Everyone else was women. And he was Catholic, right? Or no,0.99
00:21:08.560he was not Catholic. He was not Catholic. I don't believe he was Catholic. His father was. And I
00:21:16.240think that his father and the county where they lived was kind of known for being a safe haven
00:21:24.640for Catholics in Protestant Elizabethan reform. Again, the North has always been kind of different
00:21:30.660than the South there. But I think there's no real record to say that he was Catholic,
00:21:37.060But he wasn't as, he probably wasn't as staunchly Protestant as he should have been in Queen Elizabeth's eyes.
00:21:46.140So it gave the impression, you know, it's kind of one of those things where it kind of doesn't matter what the truth was.
00:21:52.120What matters is what people thought about him.
00:21:55.140And he was, enough Catholics thought that he would at least be, if he wasn't Catholic himself, he would at least be sympathetic to them.
00:22:03.260And so they thought he would be a supporter of, of theirs.
00:22:08.060Yeah. I mean, we, we all know there was not a King Ferdinando of England that,
00:22:12.700that did not occur. Yeah. So he, Ferdinando died, she marries the lawyer.
00:22:17.560And what I was just going to say before it was this is a period of time where
00:22:20.480like she needed to marry again. It's not just like, okay, I'm a wealthy widow.
00:22:23.440Everything's great. It's like, no, in this culture,
00:22:25.300like she needed a powerful husband. Right.0.99
00:22:28.160Well, she, she kind of waited though. She, she weighed,
00:22:31.280She didn't want a husband right away because by marrying someone right away, she would be giving up a lot of her own legal rights.
00:22:37.720As a widow, she did hold a lot of, England at this time allowed widows more rights than other places did.
00:22:45.400So she didn't need a husband for a long time.
00:22:48.000She really didn't want to give up control over her daughter's marriages, which she would have if she had gotten married too soon.
00:22:55.100So that was part of what makes Alice so fascinating is she understood the laws and knew when it was the right time for her to get married and when it was the wrong time for her to get married.
00:23:06.340So she waited six years for the first six years of her lawsuit against her brother-in-law.1.00
00:23:11.060She purposefully didn't remarry so that she could maintain control of the wardships of her daughters.1.00
00:23:17.520And then once she secured the husband she wanted for them, then she remarried because that was like part of her legal strategy.1.00
00:23:25.100of who to marry and when to marry. This is part of what's so fascinating about her. And
00:23:30.780I'm guessing is probably part of what drew you to want to study more about her and write about her
00:23:35.520is she was just so savvy. She was so smart. She was. And I, you know, she's so excessively
00:23:43.680well-documented compared to many other women in the period. So it just begs the question of how
00:23:48.520many other women were out there like her that we just don't know about because they didn't survive
00:23:53.360and the records don't survive. We certainly see that her sister, Anne, it's confusing because her0.94
00:24:00.980daughter's Anne and her sister's Anne, but Anne Spencer, let's say, she also seems to have had
00:24:07.740this same kind of shrewdness when it came to strategizing her own marriages after her first
00:24:13.560marriage. She marries two other times after her first marriage, and she also picks very specific0.81
00:24:19.700people at very specific moments where it can help stabilize her, but she waits a little
00:26:00.180Kingdoms were reduced to cinders and armies scattered like bones in the dust.
00:26:05.180Now the survivors claw to what's left of a broken world,
00:26:09.800praying the darkness chooses someone else tonight.
00:26:12.660But in the Shadow Dark, the darkness always wins.
00:26:17.400This is old-school adventuring at its most cruel.
00:26:20.860Your torch ticks down in real time, and when that flame dies, something else rises to finish the job.
00:26:26.780This is a brutal rules-light nightmare with a story that emerges organically based on the decisions that the characters make.
00:26:34.320This is what it felt like to play RPGs in the 80s, and man, it is so good to be back.
00:26:38.980Join the Glass Cannon podcast as we plunge into the shadow dark every Thursday night at 8 p.m. Eastern on youtube.com slash the glass cannon with the podcast version dropping the next day.
00:26:49.760See what everybody's talking about and join us in the dark.
00:26:57.020Welcome to the realms of peril and glory.
00:27:02.420Explore the mechanically magical vistas of Vale,
00:27:06.080the paranormal mysteries of liminal London,
00:40:12.360Which is interesting, because like you were saying, like, there's so much documented, there's so much evidence of what she did and who she was. So it's, I'm glad that you put it together. Yeah.
00:40:22.300It's spread out. Thank you. It took a long time. You know, it's, it's, um, these records that I
00:40:35.380but they're in a lot of different libraries and repositories. And so I think one of the reasons
00:40:39.860why it's really, um, an obstacle to books like this being written is you just, you need a lot
00:40:46.200of, you know, I was a graduate student when I started this work. So I had fellowships and I
00:40:49.940had time. I mean, my job was to do this research. And it just it took years to piece it all
00:40:55.240together. So it's not that it can't be done. It's just that it takes time. And that means it takes
00:41:01.420fellowship money and research leave and things like that to be able to do it.
00:41:06.180That's so interesting. Like even I was just picturing that you were able to go and I don't
00:41:09.460know into some library. And it's like, well, here's the book of every court case that ever
00:41:12.480happened. And Ella Spencer is on page three and 45. And no, it's like all different places. Yeah.
00:41:19.040Yeah, it's all different places. And it's mostly like unpublished manuscript material. So it's digging through archives. I mean, they're processed and they're described. And, you know, a lot of people work to make this material as discoverable as possible.
00:41:33.220But then, you know, a lot of these manuscripts, you know, they're written in a secretary hand.
00:41:39.500It's not the same kind of handwriting that we use today.
00:41:42.280So before I could read any of them, I spent a couple, like about a year studying how to read.
00:41:56.140So there are a couple barriers to access.
00:41:59.200but you know with study and with the help of librarians and archivists and curators then it's
00:42:06.660possible to do so we've already talked about the parallels with like I think it's unavoidable like
00:42:13.080with the Kardashian-Jenner family but other other connections like your book coming out I mean
00:42:18.180today or you know whatever day it comes out whenever this podcast comes out but like coming
00:42:22.320out in the year 2023 um what are the parallels that you see at this point between her life and
00:42:28.420story in today's society? Well, I mean, certainly we today still live in a culture of patriarchy
00:42:38.320and white supremacy. And Alice lived in a culture of patriarchy and white supremacy.
00:42:45.140There's a lot that feels familiar about the 16th and 17th century, because that's how patriarchy
00:42:51.060and white supremacy work, is that stranglehold on power. But I think Alice's story and the
00:42:58.400story of her daughters also show different ways that people maintain the people who on paper
00:43:04.080wouldn't have any power right but you know 17th century england is an excessively patriarchal
00:43:10.600hostile environment but alice lives and her family rises and i think we see that happening today too
00:43:17.920that you know when we look closely we understand the ways that resistance movements are the ways
00:43:22.920that well the academic term for it is conjugated identities right that um alice's gender should1.00
00:43:30.260have relegated her to a spot where she didn't have any power but her class and her race allowed
00:43:36.580her to have power and she harnessed that in different ways and we see that today too like
00:43:41.840people who one aspect of their identity would relegate them to a place of less power in society
00:43:47.760but other aspects of their identity embolden people and give them more power and you harness
00:43:53.240those channels. So I think we can kind of look and see that Alice and her family is a good example
00:43:59.140of how people use conjugated identities in complicated ways. And we see that happening
00:44:03.240today too. And this is not about your book, but I'm just really curious. Can you tell me about
00:44:09.500where you work, the Huntington Library in California?
00:44:15.180Yeah. So I am a senior creator of medieval manuscripts in British history at the Huntington
00:44:21.760Library Art Museum of Botanical Gardens in California, just outside of Los Angeles.
00:44:28.300And it's one of the largest independent research libraries in North America.
00:44:33.000Our founder loved libraries and he bought up entire family archives and gigantic libraries
00:44:39.320And that's why a lot of this material is actually in California, because the Edgerton family papers and the Hastings family papers are in.
00:44:47.280He purchased them at the beginning of the 20th century.
00:44:50.520A lot of English families in the end of the 19th century and beginning of the 20th century started selling their libraries to raise money to pay for their estates and pay taxes on their lands.
00:45:02.400And if you're faced with the choice of, do I sell my land and my estate or do I sell my library, I sell the library. So a lot of material actually circulated around the world at that point. And that's how our library was founded.
00:45:18.840So we have an enormous research library in lots of different areas and fields and then botanical gardens and an art museum.
00:45:28.740It was like, I just saw it in your email signature, I think.
00:45:31.860And I was like, OK, you know, the medieval manuscripts.
00:45:34.440And then I'm like, wait, in California, what are British medieval manuscripts doing in California?
00:47:39.340And I get to talk to so many different audiences that are similar academics and some are, you know, lifelong learners and lovers of history and lovers of art.
00:47:48.280And so I just decided that I wanted to write a book for those audiences instead that's informed by all of this fellowship, that helps bring these archives and bring these stories and bring these histories to a wider audience.
00:48:01.260And it feels like such a privilege to be able to share these stories with so many different people.
00:48:07.840Well, and I would imagine that things like the Princess Diana connection, like people, it gives people a bit of a, and also that it's Tudor England, like, so it's a relatively obscure story. But I think there's some footholds that like the average history fan would be like, okay, Elthorpe. Yeah, for sure.
00:48:25.160yeah yeah I mean once you start talking about like I know conjugated identities and the
00:48:30.000chancery courts and all of this stuff it gets it feels like there's a barrier like well I don't
00:48:36.000know what that means I don't know what that is but all of those things that you just touched upon
00:48:40.660is exactly right like all of those are pathways into this story and one of my one of the things
00:48:46.100I'm really devoted to as a historian and as a curator is I want to make this this subject as
00:48:53.080approachable as possible. And I think it's so much, there are so many ways into it. But oftentimes
00:48:58.560it's like, no, you have to go to university and you have to study all of these things. And that's
00:49:03.240a valuable thing to do, certainly. But we can learn so much from the humanities without sitting
00:49:08.360in a lecture hall. Like history is all around us. You don't just learn history in an academic
00:49:13.900lecture hall. And my final question for you is whimsical, but I need to know. Which do you think
00:49:20.880is a better name? Gray Bridges or Ferdinando Stanley? Oh my gosh, I should have been prepared
00:49:27.860for this question. I haven't listened to your earlier. Gosh, Gray Bridges is a pretty great
00:49:35.460name. It's an outstanding name. When I was reading your book, I was just like, I forgot about Gray
00:49:41.120Bridges. Like what? Surrounded by all these people who are just Robert and Edward is just like, oh,
00:49:46.900okay like Ferdinando Stanley Gray Bridges like yeah I know Ferdinando is definitely you know
00:49:55.820catchy but the Lord Strange really works too like that's the hook for Ferdinando I think but Gray
00:50:01.520Bridges just sounds like a soap opera character or something or like a folk singer like I want
00:50:08.260to create all these alter egos for for Gray Bridges absolutely absolutely yeah and the thing
00:50:13.680with Ferdinando Lord Strange I I think I took a screen capture of that I was reading your book
00:50:17.700just as an e-book and where you just mentioned that he had it was like Lord Strange's tumblers
00:50:22.320like his acrobat team I'm just like really really Ferdinando like Lord Strange's tumblers like
00:50:27.500yeah it just I mean I don't even need to make this stuff up it's the historical record just
00:50:33.400gives us so much to play with like Ferdinando had a great name and was also kind of a weirdo
00:50:38.500and I respect that about him definitely but great I think he was uh you know there's so much
00:50:44.580less material survives for him than other people like Robert Dudley for example um but I think
00:50:51.820Ferdinando is a kind of a cool poster child for the English Renaissance like he seemed to have a
00:50:58.780I don't know I think he would have been a cool a cool Renaissance guy like interested in all
00:51:03.460these different things, had this very unusual position in the English realm. He seemed like
00:51:12.000someone that might be quite interesting to know. Yeah. And I think in terms of rank and stuff,
00:51:17.040like obviously like that marriage elevated Alice to a certain level, but I think she also lucked
00:51:21.100out that she had kind of maybe a cool husband, like Fernando is a good choice. Yes. And I think
00:51:25.640they definitely had a fondness for each other, which is, you know, that's kind of the cherry
00:51:29.900on top that's not why these people got married certainly it you know if you liked each other
00:51:36.180that's a bonus um and I think that they definitely liked each other which is it's nice to know that
00:51:41.820you know so much of Alice's life was just kind of cutthroat and partially in large part because
00:51:47.180she was so cutthroat but it it softened her when I started to think about her when I rewrote the
00:51:51.920the book from my dissertation um to the book and I started to think about her as a younger woman
00:51:57.440And it made, it humanized her for me too, to think about her in her twenties and having this,
00:52:02.360how scary it would be to marry someone that you didn't really know and what it must've been like
00:52:07.120for her. If it turns out they actually did care for each other. I'm happy that Alice had some
00:52:11.420love early in her life. Yeah. And that's the thing too, like your book, it's, there's so many,
00:52:15.520it covers a really wide period of time and there's a lot of people in it, but
00:52:18.780the Castlehaven stuff is just like, Oh my God. But like, there's, there's delightful things
00:52:24.560also in your book yes yeah it the castle haven child loomed large like i like even because as
00:52:31.780you said like you kind of start with that and you know that that's what's what they're headed for
00:52:35.980and you you wish they could still avert it um but they don't so writing the book um chronologically
00:52:42.440like this you know i felt like oh god i'm just like it's like the titanic like watching the
00:52:47.660movie titanic like you just you know where you're headed and you don't want to get there
00:52:51.160um but it's nice when it's nice when nice things happen for a little while it's nice you know
00:52:56.620titanic like jack and rose have their connection and that's like a really sweet love story
00:53:01.040and then the iceberg hits but like before the iceberg hits there's like lots of interesting
00:53:05.840stuff happening too yeah yeah that was that's funny that was the other thing i was just like
00:53:10.380how can i describe my experience of reading this book because i'm just like i know this
00:53:14.200horrible thing is going to happen but i was just hoping like but maybe it won't
00:53:18.940yeah maybe they won't hit the iceberg oh they will that's and that's not really the i guess
00:53:25.320the point of writing history is it's the how you get there and why it happens that's that's
00:53:31.940interesting so even writing this book as much as i wish i could have stopped it halfway through
00:53:36.480because it's you know the iceberg is looming out there um it's it helps understand what it was
00:53:43.640like to hit the iceberg when you know what the path was that got you there exactly exactly and
00:53:48.520And then your book continues on past the trial as well to see what,
00:53:52.160because everyone kept living except for the people who were executed.