00:00:00.040Hi, everyone. Before we get into today's episode, I just wanted to acknowledge that I know there's a lot of listeners in the United States.
00:00:06.960A lot of messed up things are happening right now, and so I just wanted to share some ways you can help.
00:00:12.580So right now in the United States, the U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement, known as ICE, has been overseeing a mass deportation campaign
00:00:19.260affecting hundreds of thousands of people through detentions, confinements, and expulsions.
00:00:23.860Their stated goal is to arrest 3,000 people per day.
00:00:26.240To attain this number, people are being taken from public places like churches, schools, and hospitals.
00:00:31.320The people being targeted are predominantly from a Hispanic background.
00:00:34.920Families are being separated, and people are living in fear.
00:00:37.820This is a horrific campaign affecting people all across America.
00:00:41.380I want to highlight some organizations working to help those being affected.
00:00:44.860Today, I want to highlight CHURLA, the Coalition for Humane Immigrant Rights in Los Angeles.
00:00:50.140This is one of the largest and most effective advocates for immigrant rights,
00:00:53.340organizing, educating, and defending immigrants and refugees in the streets, in the courts,
00:00:57.680and in the halls of power. Their work includes helping with legal fees for migrants, and lately
00:01:02.060they have also been helping with fees for those arrested during anti-ICE protests. You can donate
00:01:07.460to support their work at chirla.org. That's C-H-I-R-L-A dot O-R-G. Enjoy today's episode.1.00
00:01:23.340Hello, and welcome to Vulgar History, a feminist women's history comedy podcast.
00:01:31.700My name is Anne Foster, and this is part two of a duet of episodes.
00:01:37.500Our voices are so melodic, you'd think we were trained in ancient Rome.
00:01:41.060Last time we were talking about what was ancient Rome like, especially for women living there.
00:01:45.380And that was really setting the stage for this part two, which is where we're talking about one specific woman from the Roman era,
00:01:51.240and her name is Livia and my guest is Gina. Welcome back, Jean Barry. Thank you. So we're
00:01:59.380talking about Livia and before we get into explaining her whole deal, I need to, long-time
00:02:06.720listeners of the show will know that about a year ago, I got really obsessed with this 1976 British
00:02:12.920miniseries called I, Claudius. Have you ever watched it? I have not because I haven't been
00:02:18.120able to find it so the couple of places i looked i couldn't find it but it's absolutely on my list
00:02:23.740of must see i believe it is on acorn tv app but um so i watched that and i was like wow this is so
00:02:31.240good and i loved it was just so like messy and trashy but like all the actors in it are like the
00:02:37.280finest shakespearean actors so it's kind of like downton abbey in that way where you're like oh
00:02:41.900this is just like a messy soap opera but the acting is so good you're like this feels like
00:02:46.320Shakespeare or something where it's like, no, this is just like people, these are ridiculous
00:02:50.120pot twists. Anyway, in that show, so I, Claudius, the miniseries, it's from 1976 and it's based on
00:02:56.460a 1934 novel by Robert Graves, also called I, Claudius. And you'll understand why I'm explaining
00:03:04.620this in a second, because this all sets up what the modern understanding of who Livia is,
00:03:09.660comes from. So in 1934, Robert Graves was like a penniless author and he's like,
00:03:14.620I need to get rich quick. I need to write a book really quickly. And I need to, it needs to sell
00:03:18.660a gazillion copies. I know he could like read Latin. He's like, I'm going to translate these
00:03:23.160old sources and I'm going to write a history of ancient Rome, but I'm going to include all the
00:03:26.720messiest, sexiest, like most debaucherous rumors and I'll make it seem like that's true. And so
00:03:32.720this was his like salacious novel he was writing just to make money. And he made it as salacious
00:03:38.060as possible to make as much money as possible, which he did. But then to the surprise of, I think
00:03:42.740him it became accepted as kind of like wow this is what ancient rome was like it's a really pop
00:03:47.260it became a popular book and then 1976 this mini series came out it was the bridgerton of its time
00:03:53.220everybody in every country was watching i claudius and it really like and since then people like
00:03:59.980teachers show it in their history classes and in their latin classes and the book i claudius
00:04:05.820and then the miniseries that claudius presents livia as this like straight up serial killer
00:04:12.320murderess but her performance in the miniseries is by this welsh actress called shan phillips and
00:04:19.480it's amazing i think she won the bafta for it like she's so good at this character so when you
00:04:24.100and i decided to talk about livia i was like amazing i love this murderous um badass killer
00:04:31.260And then I started reading and I was like, oh no, yet again, the sources, the sources, it's Cleopatra all over again.
00:17:20.980So, A New History of Rome's Imperial Women.
00:17:23.420So it's like a group biography of various different women from Roman history. And what I appreciated about it is that it's looking, the way that I try to do history, it's like from the woman in, like using them as the focal point and then kind of the men are in the background.
00:17:37.580So I got some good information here about just the trajectory of like the writing about Livia through to I, Claudius, through like kind of how she developed, the reputation she developed.
00:17:48.320And a lot of that is from a writer from ancient Roman times called Tacitus, who another writer described as like he hated women the way that most people hate wasps.
00:19:10.620Which caused the vast majority of everything that we are currently taught about Roman history
00:19:18.900is it really does start at that point when Julius Caesar is killed.
00:19:23.960We obviously know things that happened before then, but the height of what is taught about ancient Rome takes place at the time that he's killed on the Senate floor, because that's when basically all hell broke loose in Rome.
00:19:37.540And that's when everything started to shift for everyone.
00:19:42.160And where this eventually ends is that Octavian, a.k.a. Augustus, ends up taking over.
00:19:48.220And this is where Rome shifts from a republic to an empire.
00:19:52.700So instead of having these kind of three guys, the consuls leading it, you have one guy and then his heir and then it becomes like he becomes a king, like it becomes a dynasty instead of just like an elected position anymore. So that like that's a major shift in Roman history. And this is like Livia.
00:20:08.700so it's she's 14 years old and julie caesar is killed and that's around the same time that she
00:20:14.500is married to her first husband because as we said last time like 40 year old men marrying 14
00:20:20.900year old girls that's what rome is all about yeah um but also i think it's just like she was such a
00:20:25.960valuable wife she was because she brought so much family history so much stature so much class with0.95
00:20:34.100her that, I mean, I would assume she probably had quite a few suitors. So the fact that Tiberius
00:20:41.960won out because it was ultimately her father's choice on who she married. So I've always wondered
00:20:48.340what did Tiberius bring to the table where he won because he could not have been her only suitor.
00:20:53.320It's just not possible. I think, and I do want to clarify for everybody that ancient Rome,
00:20:58.420and this drives me crazy has like three names everybody has the same names so yes her husband
00:21:06.260is named Tiberius that is also the name of her son she's going to later on have um so Tiberius
00:21:12.940one is the dad we can call him Tiberius Nero oh my gosh wait so no her I think her dad oh no sorry
00:21:20.500her dad is not called Tiberius her husband is called Tiberius there's a lot of repeated names
00:21:26.040Anyway, so it's just like in the wake of the assassination of Julius Caesar, she, a 15-year-old girl, is married to this guy.
00:21:32.360So her father at that time sided with the assassins.
00:21:38.320Like he sided with killing Julius Caesar.
00:21:41.200But then as like the politics kind of played out, it's kind of like that's not the side that he should have sided with.
00:21:47.140And then the whole family has to flee.
00:21:50.680So the reason why they had to flee was because they were unprescripted.
00:21:54.800And what it was is Octavian and Antony and Lepidus, I believe, was the other guy that was part of the newly created council.
00:22:07.440They decided that they needed money to fight the war that was coming up, that they knew was coming up, to chase down and kill the killers of Julius Caesar.
00:22:20.900And so what they did was the rich noblemen that sided with the killers, they had their wealth taken from them and they were killed.
00:22:35.680And the family was basically thrown into poverty and their family name was Dirt and so on and so forth.
00:22:44.760And what happened was Livia's father was one of them that was very popular, very wealthy.
00:22:52.340He sided in with the killers, but they didn't kill him.
00:26:51.540So just like, Gina, you're a mother, like, imagine being on the run with an infant for a year.
00:26:58.160Like, I can't because I think I barely survived that first year with both of them.
00:27:03.020No, I mean, just like emotionally, physically, everything like so on top of that to just be like on the run for your life.
00:27:08.980I mean, and think about this as well. A lot of women in her position, they probably would have abandoned the child and went off to to survive on their own because it's it's a lot easier to survive without a child.1.00
00:27:23.220It's not easier to survive without another person, period. But to have a small child like that, an infant like that, I kudos to her that she didn't abandon the kid because a lot of women in a position would have.0.82
00:27:35.160Well, and in her sort of like wealthy position too,0.79
00:27:37.880like ordinarily she would have a lot of assistance,
00:27:39.960like if she was not on the run for a year,
00:27:42.620like she would have had like all these household servants,
00:27:44.120but because she didn't want to be identified as who she was
00:27:46.800and who her father was and who her husband was,
00:27:49.060she had to travel with just one servant.
00:27:50.560So she wouldn't look like she was as important as she was.
00:47:18.320So when people are just looking back at this era with retrospect, they're like, okay, so how do we, how can we blame a woman for these awful emperors?0.99
01:03:53.280like living in that city where like there was raised to the ground.
01:03:56.140Like she knows what happens when a civil war breaks out and Octavian was
01:04:01.860emperor for long enough that kind of stability came back in,
01:04:05.600but she knew how easily it could all be upended again.
01:04:10.180If there wasn't a strong person at the head of the empire and Tiberius was1.00
01:04:14.320just like a bitch and like didn't listen to her,0.99
01:04:18.420even though she was the smartest person in the room she had all this life experience she knew1.00
01:04:24.040personally the damage it can cause when there's not a good when things are chaotic and he's just
01:04:30.360like meh no but i also think some of her driving force was um her her lineage her her family name
01:04:38.420because they held that in such high regard everyone did if you were part of any of those
01:04:44.800families that was like the end-all be-all of stature within society and i think that in a way
01:04:53.220she was trying to protect the lineage of the family as well with some of the things that she
01:04:58.960probably did all of those years because she didn't want to see her family line she didn't
01:05:06.780want to see the julians or the claudians or the jerseys just die out like that right like it's
01:05:11.880personal to her like saving rome is like her family like rome is her family yes yeah exactly
01:05:18.360like rome is her so tiberius threatened that like to the core he threatened that and so i don't blame
01:05:25.640her one bit if she tried to step in and keep that from happening i'm gonna reduce just listeners but
01:05:32.440also gina some highlights of tiberius being the worst so he avoided private meetings with her
01:05:38.320refused to listen to her advice and responded furiously when the Senate proposed to honor him
01:05:43.680with the title son of Livia. He also warned her to keep out of matters unbecoming to a woman.
01:05:53.800He resented. So she did, you mentioned before that she was like not a frigid person. She was
01:05:58.360like, she did a lot of charitable work. Like she did outreach stuff. Like she was like
01:06:02.660Princess Diana-esque in that way. So at one point there had been a fire near the temple of Vesta
01:06:08.100and she directed rescue operations she's in her 70s she's like going to the site of this temple
01:06:13.840that's kind of in her honor and like directing firefighters anyway he was really mad that she
01:06:20.740did that and then eventually he removed her entirely from public life and then in the final
01:06:27.320three years of her life he only saw her once she felt ill with whatever she's 86 years old in
01:06:33.440ancient Rome and he refused to come back from Capri to even visit her and then when she died
01:06:40.440he took so long leaving Capri they were I don't know maybe you know about this but like the funeral
01:06:45.380processes and stuff but they kind of kept the body out so he could come and visit but he took
01:06:49.780so long to visit that the body started to rot so that they had to like put the body away so she
01:06:55.400didn't she was denied a proper funeral and had to be hastily buried in defiance of tradition
01:07:00.440because her son was the worst he definitely was and there was probably i mean there could have
01:07:08.880been an actual mental illness there we don't know because they didn't they didn't know about that
01:07:14.440back then but like you had mentioned he had some seriously deep-rooted ptsd and obviously there
01:07:22.440was something not right in his bloodline because you ended up with claudius well claudius was
01:07:28.740those weren't his children they were in his bloodline oh i guess you're right yeah and so
01:07:36.300it's just like i i i want to give him slight benefit of the doubt that he might have been
01:07:43.480battling some mental illness in there because i don't think ptsd would turn you into that big of0.99
01:07:48.760an asshole it could but i want to say there was something else working in there but i think he0.99
01:07:56.920also really was jealous of her because absolutely from the get-go when octavian met her and decided0.99
01:08:06.700i want that person there she clearly was always gonna rank high with him and his mind and his
01:08:13.780hearts just always rank high with him tiberius i would assume probably wasn't hugged enough as a
01:08:23.180child i guess i mean honestly look at all the drama that was happening and i think he really
01:08:27.800grew up to have jealousy of her if anyone had anything to do with drusus dying i would say
01:08:34.040it was him because she clearly loved the hell out of drusus and for all we know tiberius could
01:08:39.800have had something done to him and then be like okay say he fell off a horse you know i wouldn't
01:08:44.560put that past his brother yeah i think the tiberius thing like you mentioned the bloodline
01:08:48.920and stuff you're right i can't keep track of the bloodline of who's related to who everyone's
01:08:53.200related to everyone in this family or they adopted somebody and then suddenly that's in their bloodline
01:08:57.360as well but yeah like the fact that you have like octavian who is like he was i will give him the
01:09:03.540credit of saying he was a successful emperor for 50 years during an extremely contentious time0.88
01:09:09.080was he like a nightmare asshole chaotic tyrant who was the worst yes but he was a good at being0.96
01:09:17.700emperor for the time he was the emperor tiberius disaster like caligula complete disaster nero0.99
01:09:25.080disaster and this is like this is why you don't have this is why maybe rome was better off with
01:09:30.700elected leaders instead of the heir because like four in a row like the heir of the previous
01:09:36.920emperor was like not suited for the role but think about the inbreeding because you have
01:09:44.680this person who's a cousin or this one was a sister of this person but now we're marrying
01:09:51.720the brother of this you had it was a very roundabout way but you had quite a bit of
01:09:57.620inbreeding going on there and it's like the only trait that like passed through the inbreeding was
01:10:03.660like being a terrible emperor was like coded into their dna because i mean in the podcast we did
01:10:11.200about um hat all of the the male heirs that her father had whoever they they didn't really survive
01:10:23.300the one tetlos what was the third second third her her um stepson he his mother was part of the
01:10:33.440harem his mother brought in some new dna yes she wasn't of royal blood you look at at um tut and
01:10:40.960his sister. They didn't have any surviving children. They were brother and sister. That
01:10:47.000wasn't going to work. History shows inbreeding really is just not going to work. And I think
01:10:53.500some of those people were just too closely related because they wanted to try to keep
01:10:57.520everything in the Julian family. They wanted to keep everything in the Julian family.
01:11:00.740Exactly. You're like, this family is so important. Yeah. Because even I think Livia's first husband
01:11:05.900was he was a Claudian as well like which means Tiberius was the product of some level of incest
01:11:13.180as well and Drusus is yeah and that's the we see this over again like in ancient Egypt we see that
01:11:18.300but then also you get into that with like the Habsburgs and like European history like when
01:11:22.380the family lineage is so important everyone marries within the family eventually like
01:11:27.080this does not work out eventually everyone becomes infertile and you have to switch to
01:11:31.200another family anyway. And I think that that might have played a part in that succession of
01:11:36.300really terrible leaders. I think they've really had some not so great things happen and look in
01:11:42.460their DNA. That's the risk you get like in any of the history that I look at where it's a dynasty
01:11:47.480where it's just like, who's going to be the next monarch? Oh, it's the son of the guy. Like,
01:11:52.220and you never know if that's going to be a good king or a bad king. And more than often,
01:11:57.520it's a bad game so like maybe this isn't a good system of like pretending that one family is like
01:12:04.600pure and godly because then we just get stuck with like the worst yep i'm not trying to make
01:12:12.960it for for tiberius because he was a jerk but there might have been other things at play that0.95
01:12:18.580i mean obviously genetics just weren't something they thought about back then all they thought0.99
01:12:22.160about was keeping things pure i mean it even happens within like dogs the purebred dogs yeah
01:12:27.280they have the most medical issues it just that doesn't work yeah no exactly when it's just
01:12:34.780eventually what's the one it's like they like their face is so short they can't breathe properly
01:12:39.960like some of those dog breeds yeah tiberius is kind of that but um you just call it dog breed
01:12:46.340purebred overly purebred but yeah i mean that's the thing and on the podcast too like when i
01:12:53.820encounter somebody where it's just like i try to have empathy for people but at the same time it's
01:12:57.200Like, there's lots of people with lots of health conditions and lots of mental health conditions who would have been a much better emperor than Tiberius.0.99
01:13:03.120Like, ultimately, he was a shitty person.0.97
01:13:05.700And maybe that was exacerbated by some of these other things.0.99
01:13:09.080You know, another thing that contributes to that is the lifestyle that you live.
01:13:14.120If you're always kind of told you're special, you're treated like you're special.
01:37:01.700Transcripts of this podcast are available at vulgarhistory.com by Aveline Malek.
01:37:06.140You can get early ad-free episodes of Vulgar History by becoming a paid member of our Patreon
01:37:10.760for as low as $1 a month at patreon.com slash Anne Foster Writer.
01:37:15.200Vulgar History Merchandise is available at vulgarhistory.com slash store for Americans and for everyone else at vulgarhistory.redbubble.com.
01:37:24.400Follow us on social media at vulgarhistorypod and get in touch with me via email at vulgarhistorypod at gmail.com.
01:37:34.600Legendary stories, awe-inspiring sound, and endless adventure.
01:37:40.460Welcome to the realms of peril and glory.
01:37:45.200Explore the mechanically magical vistas of Vale
01:37:50.420The paranormal mysteries of liminal London