00:00:30.000Hello, and welcome to Vulgar History, a feminist women's history comedy podcast. This is the0.96
00:00:48.440Mary Queen of Scots series part I've lost track. I want to say eight, perhaps. But anyway,
00:00:56.680my name is Anne Foster. I'm joined by Alison Epstein. Alison, welcome.
00:01:01.240Thank you. I also don't know what part we're on, but we'll figure that out before it posts.
00:01:05.480Yeah, absolutely. We will. There's a part in all my notes where I'm like previously on. And at this
00:01:09.700point, I think I wrote just kind of like listen to all the episodes. Previously, a lot.
00:01:17.180A lot. A lot. A Douglas. And also a lot. This is in fact part eight. We are American Scots part
00:01:25.280eight. And yes, what I wanted to mention, I've said this before, but it becomes increasingly
00:01:29.580unhinged to me that I ever thought I was going to tell this story in four hour long episodes.
00:01:34.520That's hilarious. That is wild. That is adorable and hilarious. I think my plan had been to do in
00:01:40.260one episode, like the murder of Rizzio, the murder of Darnley, and also running away with
00:01:44.720Bothwell. I thought that's a cool 45 minutes, 60 minutes. And you spent an hour and 15 minutes on
00:01:50.720who is rizzio what's his deal yeah absolutely absolutely i did three episodes before she even
00:01:56.140married darling and then what we're talking about today like spoiler for how many episodes there's
00:02:01.040going to be i thought this was gonna like the contents of the next this and the next two
00:02:05.340episodes i thought it was gonna be another cool 45 minutes and you were the one who was like okay
00:02:10.720and like, I admire your, your ambition here, but I would book five hours.
00:02:19.360Yeah. And that is how long it will take is my guess. So I wanted to say, first of all,
00:02:25.080before I forget my references for this. So it's been interesting. I read so much Mary
00:02:29.640Green Scott's stuff. So many biographies of this person who the other thing, the other
00:02:34.760irony. Well, okay. I'm going to say two things. First of all, um, sometimes people, when I post
00:02:40.220an episode, people send me messages. And I'm like, I guess that like quoting something and
00:02:44.720like a laughing emoji. And I'm like, perhaps that is something I said. I don't remember what I've
00:02:52.040said before, especially in these extremely long episodes, these Mary Queen of Scots episodes.
00:02:57.040So I might be repeating myself, but whatever. Also, I was like Mary Queen of Scots season.
00:03:02.080I've been holding off and doing it for a while. And I'm like, you know what? I'm just going to do
00:03:04.820it. And this will be kind of straightforward because this is a story I know pretty well.
00:03:08.900And that's the thing. If I had just done this without any new research, it would have been for 45 minute episodes. But as I started reading actual books, I was just like, oh, shit, there's like so much stuff I did not know. Like I knew more than some people about Mary Queen of Scots. And now I know more than many people.
00:03:27.340Yeah, there's so many things I truly did not know. And this part that we're talking about,
00:03:33.600this post-Loc Levin era is the part I think I knew the least about. And that is because I think
00:03:40.200in a lot of books and also in movies and TV shows, although this was not Rain's fault,
00:03:45.700they were canceled. This part of her whole life often gets glossed over. Like a lot of things
00:03:50.640kind of go from like her being arrested in the first place. And then it's like time passes and
00:03:55.300then it's her death like spoiler she does die not in this episode not next episode this part
00:04:00.980just gets skipped over a lot because whenever people are telling her story it's always like
00:04:04.020darnley rizzio like that's like bothwell like that's the story that people often retell
00:04:09.080but this is i would say no less interesting it's just a different kind of interesting
00:04:13.660because we're getting into some spy shit allison what are your feelings about mary queen of spy0.99
00:04:20.280shit this is how i know mary best as mary queen of spy shit she is love of my life schemer of0.98
00:04:27.320schemes i'm very very excited to talk about this part and it's my favorite part of the story not0.98
00:04:33.660because mary is winning a lot but because she's up against some absolutely incredible odds that
00:04:39.680no like human being has the wherewithal to win against she's in a very hard spot at this time
00:04:46.480in the story every day of her life she wakes up and goes how can I scheme my way out of this one
00:04:52.260never gives up never surrenders she's a legend very excited to get into it it's really it's
00:04:59.540very exciting it's just it's a different vibe she's in England now and like the vibe in Scotland
00:05:05.680was just like groups of men getting together signing paperwork doing chaotic mass murders
00:05:11.920and then not thinking about the consequences.
00:05:15.520England is like, let's write some letters
00:05:18.480and be very like passive aggressive with each other
00:24:56.240So he was not there, but they were, they were like allowed to hang out in the house based on this story.0.96
00:25:00.840But pretty, for all the reasons you just said, the people in Workington were pretty much right away like, this is fucking Mary Queen of Scots.0.93
00:25:07.340Like this, this is clearly Mary Queen of Scots.0.97
00:25:11.940So the deputy governor of Cumberland arrived with 400 men to be like, hey, Mary Queen of Scots.
00:39:19.400So meanwhile, so Mary Seaton is there, and she's doing amazing work with wigs. So if you'll recall, Mary shaved her head. So Mary Seaton, I love that she like, she fled Scotland. No outfits, but all of the wigs. Like the first episode of Schitt's Creek when Moira is packing up all of her wigs. So Mary arrived with wigs and like no outfit.0.99
00:39:41.140Anyway, so Mary Seaton was just like styling the wigs. The wigs are all different hair colors. Letizia's dad wrote in one letter, like, I don't even know what color hair she has naturally every day. It's a new thing. Some great wig action happening. Mary Seaton is just at this level of personal dresser that I find really delightful.1.00
00:40:01.800anyway mary kept you know defending herself and letizia's dad was like went to elizabeth and was
00:40:09.500like maybe we should let her return to scott like mary's persuasiveness is considerable but
00:40:15.300letizia's dad seems like he was like kind of a pushover so he went to elizabeth and was like
00:40:20.020hey let's just let her go back to scott and elizabeth is like uh no like what are you no
00:40:24.900it was not that yeah yeah so all right so elizabeth wrote to mary being like you can't go
00:40:32.700back to scotland like stop asking to go back to scotland anyway mary wrote back to like these
00:40:36.920letters exist this is how we know so she wrote back to elizabeth being like like come on and
00:40:40.840elizabeth did not change her mind so anyway but elizabeth did agree to one thing mary wanted which
00:40:45.960was that she summoned hollywood icon jimmy stewart to london to testify about the whole
00:40:50.560Darnley murder situation as like a witness slash accuser. At the same time, Mary was moved further,
00:40:56.780like where Carlow Castle was, was like close-ish to the Scottish border. And so her supporters
00:41:02.280could come get her. She was good at riding a horse. So she was moved to somewhere a bit more0.97
00:41:06.720into England, further away from Scotland. She's moved to Bolton Castle in Wensleydale in Yorkshire,
00:41:12.080the home of Lord Scrope. But Mr. Latisse is still like her babysitter.
00:41:17.240So this place was also more fortress than cozy home.
00:41:21.700Mr. Latisse said it had the highest walls of any house he had ever seen.
00:51:44.040Kingdoms were reduced to cinders and armies scattered like bones in the dust.
00:51:49.000Now the survivors claw to what's left of a broken world, praying the darkness chooses someone else tonight.
00:51:56.920But in the shadow dark, the darkness always wins.
00:52:01.200This is old school adventuring at its most cruel.
00:52:04.700Your torch ticks down in real time, and when that flame dies, something else rises to finish the job.
00:52:10.600This is a brutal rules light nightmare with a story that emerges organically based on the decisions that the characters make.
00:52:18.120This is what it felt like to play RPGs in the 80s, and man, it is so good to be back.
00:52:22.920Join the Glass Cannon podcast as we plunge into the shadow dark every Thursday night at 8 p.m. Eastern on youtube.com slash the glass cannon with the podcast version dropping the next day.
00:52:33.600See what everybody's talking about and join us in the dark.
00:52:41.000Welcome to the realms of peril and glory.
00:52:45.360Explore the mechanically magical vistas of Vale
00:52:49.340The paranormal mysteries of liminal London
00:53:45.360Ever get to the end of a podcast episode and think, now what?
00:53:50.420Well, instead of scrolling through a million choices, try Something You Should Know.
00:53:54.840I'm the host, Mike Carruthers, and every episode is packed with fascinating, useful, and surprising things you'll actually use in your life.
00:54:03.460From human behavior, relationships, health, science, and everyday mysteries.
00:54:08.380So while you're already in your podcast app, just search for Something You Should Know and listen to an episode right now.
00:54:28.660I know there's some people that you're going to remember, and there's some people because of their nicknames being memorable, and one of those people is coming.
00:54:35.120but george buchanan he was in like part two of this series he was an old man friend of hollywood
00:54:42.080icon jimmy stewart who hollywood jimmy stewart hired him when mary first came to scotland to
00:54:46.760be like her tutor and he co-wrote some masks with david rizzio okay anyway so he's just kind of this
00:54:53.840old guy who appeared briefly so he's always been loyal to hollywood icon jimmy stewart he was also
00:55:00.360pals with Cecil because I guess just if you're an old man with a beard you just all are friends
00:55:06.780how many people of your generation are even still alive I don't know so he said to work writing a
00:55:11.800document one might call it a pamphlet claiming that Mary was this femme fatale she was 100%
00:55:18.860behind the Darnley murder she'd been having an affair with Bothwell since her son was born1.00
00:55:23.400everyone was always really careful about that to be to be like James was legitimate but Mary was a0.92
00:55:27.880whore but but in that one month the son was conceived she wasn't so this pamphlet got into0.92
00:55:34.380weird detail like weird detail about her sexual habits with bothwell like literally saying that0.93
00:55:40.420he was her backdoor lover like literally he wrote she allowed bothwell to abuse her body at the back
00:55:47.500door pro is a phrase he wrote in this pamphlet and so he also recast darnley from being this0.90
00:55:55.520darnly ineffectual but being darnly to being this saintly victim who is ill-treated by his1.00
00:56:02.180cheating slut of a wife oh for fuck's sake yeah it's just like fan fiction it's like erotic fan1.00
00:56:08.300fiction at least with fan fiction you have like some loyalty to the original character this is1.00
00:56:13.520just like no it's just fake and so what he was this is an oc named darnly come on guys yeah so
00:56:19.440he wrote this document i think just to be kind of like hey i'm i was in scotland and here's what i
00:56:24.000saw almost like can you use this in this inquiry but there was no witness statements in it there's
00:56:29.100no reports of like who how he knew any of this stuff so Kate Williams wrote in her book there
00:56:33.760was no way Cecil would persuade Elizabeth let alone a panel of judges with this ludicrous piece
00:56:38.400of creative writing so this is like Hollywood egg on Jimmy Stewart he's like I got you here's how
00:56:44.920like first of all he's like hey guess what the casket letters and it's like bro those this isn't
00:56:49.640anything he's like what about this erotic fan fiction can this be evidence like what are you
00:56:55.280what do you think evidence means well how are they supposed to know evidence sometimes means
00:57:00.380draw an elaborate picture with a naked man no one knows what evidence is well and i want to say i
00:57:07.000don't know if cecil appreciated that as much as we did either anyway so speaking of the casket
00:57:13.300letters so this erotic fan fiction not going to work so cecil asked hollywood og and jimmy stewart
00:57:17.800Like, do you have anything else to offer as evidence?
00:57:20.900And he was like, well, I do have these forged casket letters we made up a couple of years ago.
01:12:04.240It's damp and gross. So her new supervisor was George Talbot, Earl of Shrewsbury. He had recently
01:12:12.000taken a wife whose name is Bess of Hardwick. Bess of Hardwick. Bess of Hardwick is going to get her
01:12:18.980own episode later on. So we're going to talk about all this stuff, but just like, no, Bess of Hardwick
01:12:23.680is a very interesting person herself. I just yell the names of fool people when they show up. I'm0.98
01:12:28.280like, I don't know enough about her to tell the story, but I'm just like, I know Bess of Hardwick0.99
01:12:31.320kicks ass. Oh, no, she's great. Yeah. She was maybe, I think she's the wealthiest woman in0.99
01:12:36.460england not named elizabeth the first said her name was best so she was named elizabeth she was
01:12:41.900named elizabeth okay elizabeth the first was not her name her name was best of hardwick and so0.93
01:12:46.440she'd made her fortune through a series of good marriages and real estate like kind of flipping0.95
01:12:51.980houses sort of but which i know you're really into that stuff yeah so she's just like building1.00
01:12:59.880houses flipping houses so that's why they own this shitty castle because i think they were
01:13:04.100gonna flip it yeah it's not like they live there because they were like extremely rich people with0.91
01:13:10.040lots of properties but it's just like this is their property that's the furthest away from0.95
01:13:13.520the catholic supporters it's on a marsh they're like that one like you want us to live there
01:13:18.140with her this like castle in a swamp okay so anyway she and george talbot had recently just
01:13:25.460gotten married later in life they were both in their 40s this was like they had been married
01:13:29.400before they both had children from before they owned several properties as a couple tutbury was
01:13:34.100the worst one. Obviously, I'm going to call her husband Mr. Bess of Hardwick because she's the
01:13:39.120main person in this relationship as far as I'm concerned. So they had been chosen because they
01:13:43.920were rich, because Mary had to be kept in her queenly style and Elizabeth wasn't going to pay
01:13:50.100for that. Someone else had to. But also Elizabeth trusted them. So Bess of Hardwick, I believe I1.00
01:13:55.820mentioned several seasons ago in the Jane Grey season, she was caught up in the Lady Catherine0.66
01:14:01.020Grey secret sexy marriage situation in some capacity and so she was out of favor with Elizabeth
01:14:06.140so I think at this point this was a way that it's like best you kind of owe me from like the Lady
01:14:10.740Catherine Grey situation so do me a favor and you'll be back in my good books and she's like
01:14:14.600at this shitty house in the swamp fine yeah so being trusted was also key they had to follow
01:14:20.080Elizabeth's directions and report everything back to her and to Cecil also in terms of wealth so0.90
01:14:26.460Mr. Bess of Hardwick was the highest ranking peer in the realm after T-Dog. So he was wealthy and
01:14:33.260also influential and important. So keeping Mary in the state in which she was accustomed was really
01:14:38.580expensive. So it costs somewhere around 4,000 pounds a year, which I put into a currency
01:14:45.280calculator, which is about $1.7 million in today, or 1.7 million pounds, which is like 2.1 million.
01:14:51.760Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Per year, just to like keep Mary living like she wanted to live. And this
01:14:56.460These are details I did not know about how Mary was living, but I have these details now.
01:15:00.660So this money went to pay for her 50 servants, her 10 horses, each with groom,0.98
01:15:05.000all the food required for her household, which was, she expected two courses at every meal,
01:15:10.340both with a selection of 16 dishes from which she could choose.
01:15:14.060She wanted her own wine along with bread, salad, and fruit.
01:15:16.720So just every meal, it's like, okay, here's your 16 options.
01:15:20.860And they had to, and she wouldn't eat them all.
01:15:22.900Like she just, you couldn't be like, here's what you get today.
01:15:25.900That was surprising when you said it out loud. And then it clicked one more click in my brain. And I was like, I bet you Elizabeth was doing like 58 choices and six courses. Like, that's just how royal he was. And she's like, no, I'm still queen. You still better serve me the way that you would have served anybody else's power.
01:15:44.760yeah so she was getting like so this is this is why it's 2.1 million dollars her ladies were1.00
01:15:51.380allowed nine dishes per course um her secretaries got six or seven and eight for the gentlemen
01:15:56.420she lived like her court was second only to elizabeth's like it was like you just said like
01:16:02.680it's she's living like literally the queen that she is and best and mr best are paying for it
01:16:09.360so mr best kept asking elizabeth to chip in more like the english treasury covered a bit but never
01:16:14.640enough to cover everything. It's kind of like when people are like, oh, yeah, you send like
01:16:18.900$500 in child support every month. And it's like, but the child costs $5,000 a month. It's like,
01:16:23.840yeah, but get this $500. So Mary refused to pay for anything herself because she was being kept0.99
01:16:29.700against her will. Fair enough. Yeah. At Tutbury, the swamp mansion, she was allowed outside only
01:16:36.740under strict supervision. She was not allowed too far from the house for security concerns.
01:16:41.420But again, her entourage was allowed into town, and this is how she was secretly sending messages back and forth.
01:16:47.440She was closely guarded, watched by armed guards under her window,
01:16:50.600who followed her closely when she went out riding or hunting.
01:16:53.320And I guess they all had to be paid as well.
01:16:55.060She was not permitted to exercise outside of the gates or to talk to people Mr. Best had not approved.
01:17:00.420Mr. Best had a son called Gilbert, who appears every now and then.
01:31:06.660Gruesomely, like very gruesomely, like dragged through the streets, vivisected to the point that people were like, Elizabeth, like maybe not.
01:31:14.700The vibes are a bit like her older sister, Mary, Bloody Mary the First.
01:31:19.000And it's kind of like this is a bit much.
01:31:21.440We didn't love this the last time this happened.
01:32:43.460okay there's this happens in like two or three of the john wick movies there's a part where like
01:32:49.540this call goes out it's just like hey there's a bounty in john wick's head seven billion dollars
01:32:53.820and then suddenly every assassin in the world is going after him simultaneously it's like that
01:32:59.080it's like wait so everyone in paris is an assassin and has like everyone in this everyone in this
01:33:03.860cafe is an assassin they all just got this beeper on their pager okay exactly so it's like that
01:33:08.800Yeah, exactly that. So except, again, Tudor era. So Elizabeth demanded Mary be relocated somewhere even more obscure. So she was sent to Coventry Castle. But this again, okay, so I don't know a lot about castles in England, but it seems like there's an awful lot of abandoned ones.
02:11:20.740And I'm Melissa, and we're the hosts of Moms and Mysteries, the true crime podcast with over 55 million downloads.
02:11:26.720We're two Florida moms who are obsessed with mysteries.
02:11:29.820Each week, we do deep dives into fascinating true crime stories.
02:11:33.480We cover everything from infamous cases like Casey Anthony to the bizarre and complex crimes right here in our home state, like the shocking murder of FSU professor Dan Markell.
02:11:43.120We bring you the facts, but with warmth and width, you'd only get from two friends who have been hooked on mysteries since childhood.
02:11:49.320Join us for new episodes of Moms and Mysteries every Tuesday and Thursday.
02:11:52.960Listen to Moms and Mysteries on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.