00:00:00.000Hello and welcome to Vulgar History, a feminist women's history comedy podcast. My name is0.73
00:00:15.020Anne Foster and this week's episode was a long time coming when you think about it.
00:00:19.760So we're talking today about my girl, Claire Claremont, who is best known as the kind of
00:00:26.520third wheel stepsister of Mary Shelley. And she's been mentioned on this podcast twice before. So
00:00:32.760when I did the Mary Shelley episode, Claire Claremont kind of like stormed on the scene
00:00:36.800and kind of stole my heart. And then also I did an interview a bit ago with Heather Redmond,
00:00:42.700who wrote a book called Death and the Sisters, which is about Mary Shelley and Claire Claremont
00:00:47.520solving a murder mystery. And then for people who are paid members of the Patreon, I've also in the
00:00:52.880past done a so this asshole episode about one of Claire's paramours, but we'll talk more about that
00:00:59.180in a second. Anyway, there's so much more to her story than just she was Mary Shelley's stepsister0.61
00:01:04.300and she was there that summer in Geneva when Frankenstein was written. And I lost my mind
00:01:09.600when I saw, this was like six months ago when I first heard, just saw the title that Leslie
00:01:15.600McDowell was writing a book called Claremont. And I thought to myself, oh, wouldn't it be great if
00:01:19.580that's about Claire Claremont, but I was also like mitigating expectations. Like I'm sure it's not,
00:01:23.940I'm sure it's just a book called that. I'm sure that's the name of a street or something,
00:01:27.240but no, it is a book about Claire Claremont. It's, I think the first novel, just telling
00:01:35.080Claire's story and really examining who she is as a person. And Leslie McDowell, I invited her
00:01:41.220on the podcast again. I'm going to say like six months ago, I was like, hi, you've written this
00:01:44.880book about Claire Claremont. I love her. Please come be on my podcast when your book is published
00:01:48.400a really long time from now. And she's like, of course. So anyway, finally, the time is here.
00:01:52.860The book has just come out in the UK. It is called Claremont and you should be able to get
00:01:58.400this wherever you are in the UK. If you're not in the UK, from what I can tell, you can pre-order it
00:02:04.300to get it in North America and other places as well. I think it's coming out maybe in the fall,
00:02:09.080but there are ways if you're in North America that you can order books from the UK if you
00:02:15.000poke around a little bit. Anyway, this book exists. I'm so happy that Claire is finally
00:02:20.440the main character for once. And so for this podcast, Leslie joined me just to talk about
00:02:27.220Claire and how she came to write this book. And we like, this is a true vulgar history episode.
00:02:32.460Like we're going from beginning to end of the whole story of Claire Claremont. There's so much
00:02:36.140I didn't know until I started prepping for this. Cause again, it's just kind of, one gets the
00:02:40.620impression that she ran away with Mary Shelley and Percy Shelley. And she was there that summer
00:02:45.600in Geneva. She had a baby. And then it's kind of like she, I don't know, like I didn't know until
00:02:50.320getting ready for this episode slash reading Leslie's novel that I learned all the cool
00:02:54.440stuff that Claire did and how she really was an icon for a kind of independent woman living on
00:03:00.920her own that I think was very unusual for the like Regions era when she lived. It's still unusual
00:03:06.540today. Anyway, I'm so happy to present to you this interview with Leslie McDowell about the
00:03:13.760one, the only, Claire Claremont. Oh, and also, trigger warning, Lord Byron.
00:03:25.100So I'm joined today by Leslie McDowell, author of the new book,
00:03:29.680Claremont, which is about Claire Claremont. Leslie, my first question, well, first of all,
00:03:35.480welcome. Thank you. And my first question for you is when did you first become interested in
00:03:43.300Clare Claremont? Do you remember? Oh gosh, yes. It goes back about 25 years ago. I think I was
00:03:52.740reviewing a book for a Glasgow newspaper based in Glasgow in Scotland. It was a newspaper called
00:03:59.320The Herald. I was reviewing this new publication that was out, which was newly found or newly
00:04:05.460discovered story by mary shelley called maurice or the fisher's caught and the introduction was
00:04:12.760quite lengthy by a woman called claire tomlin a biographer in the uk and she talks about
00:04:19.980mary obviously in the shelley's and also about claire now i knew about claire vaguely from
00:04:27.580when i was a student studying shelley and byron and stuff you know you sort of pass her as you
00:04:33.160go through all these the literary stuff but for some reason and I knew she'd had Byron's child
00:04:37.400but I for some reason I just thought she'd toddled off and died you know afterwards in the way that1.00
00:04:42.860women do I think it's that thing of you know if you're used to like 19th century literature like1.00
00:04:47.800you know Madame Bovary and Anna Karenina you know women who transgress in some way usually0.66
00:04:54.040sexual transgressions usually you know end up dead and she didn't there was this afterlife she
00:05:00.320went to Russia to become a governess and she lived in Paris and I thought oh this is really
00:05:03.400interesting and it was just one of those things you start to I started to look a little bit more
00:05:07.680I found out that she had journals I found there were volumes of letters it just got more and more
00:05:13.180interesting when I read the biography the last biography was written in 1992 and I read that
00:05:18.880and that was just that it was just mind-blowing I just thought how do I not know more about this
00:05:22.600woman she's amazing so that was when I first had the idea about writing about her in fiction but I
00:05:27.560just didn't know how to do it. I wasn't experienced enough at all, really. So that was my first
00:05:33.620attempt. No, what you just said, it really resonates with me because I think I was the
00:05:38.240same when I was even reading about Mary Shelley. Like if that was the first thing I was researching
00:05:42.100for this podcast and you come across Claire and I'm just like, oh wow, what a fascinating,
00:05:46.280interesting person. But because it's focused on Mary Shelley, I never really read about what
00:05:50.220Claire did next. And I think like you, I just kind of assumed like, well, that was it. She had
00:05:55.320this sort of exciting few years when she was a teenager and then, but her life continues on.
00:06:01.500And so I'm excited to talk to you. So what we're going to do is we're going to just kind of
00:06:06.340talk through her life. And I just wanted to say, I have your book here with me.
00:06:10.600So the dedication of the book is for every Claire Claremont who fears her story will be forgotten.
00:06:18.420And I found that so moving because I think that's part of what really strikes me about her story is
00:06:23.640that she was there her name comes up almost as a footnote and all these other people's stories but
00:06:29.320to her she was the main character and she deserves to be the main character yeah I think one of the
00:06:36.140things that's quite disturbing I think about about that notion being forgotten is that she
00:06:40.780she had to kind of do it herself while she was alive she wanted to you know have a career she
00:06:46.600wanted to teach she wanted to earn her own money but people could know that she was connected with
00:06:51.720the Shelley's and Byron because it was just too scandalous so when after Byron's death in
00:06:57.080particular in 1824 when people started producing memoirs and biographies of Byron
00:07:01.840Mary and Claire together both had to do quite a lot of work to say to mainly their friends who
00:07:08.000were writing these books and say to them please just leave Claire out of it you can't you can't
00:07:12.500include Claire so to a certain extent she was actually forced into colluding in her own forgetting
00:07:17.960as it were which I which she really struggled with and she she had a terrible time over it
00:07:23.380because it's obviously it's a double-edged thing you know having to sit there and read these
00:07:27.520accounts of people you were with and they're not they're not accurate and there's nothing you can
00:07:32.960say you can't you can't say anything about it at all I think I think she really struggled with that
00:07:37.780for a long time right up right up until her death really I mean she meets a couple of biographers
00:07:44.380later in Florence when she's living in Florence towards the end of her life the late 70s
00:07:49.180and she she starts to kind of tell them some things and and unburden herself to them but of
00:07:56.320course by then she's she's also playing some games I think a little bit and she's thinking very much
00:08:00.660about what she wants the world to know about her if anyone is going to know anything just lost the
00:08:08.200train of thought of what you originally asked me I'm wittering on this is fine that's what the
00:08:12.100podcast is like but so we're gonna look at at claire's life beginning to end um and i will say
00:08:17.820like your your novel i don't think this is going to be first of all this is not going to be spoilers
00:08:22.220for your book because it's a fact that anybody can find and your book really plays around with
00:08:27.800time and place and what so we're just going to kind of like hit the facts because people
00:08:32.580like me and like you initially are just kind of like well she was there that summer mary shelley
00:08:37.240wrote Frankenstein and that's kind of it. So, yeah, but, and we could spend the whole podcast
00:08:43.000talking about this. Can you explain her parental and step parents situation? Her, where did she
00:08:51.940come from and what was her family? It's so complicated. Yeah. It's really interesting
00:08:56.400because some details we've only just discovered in the last few years. So her mother was a woman
00:09:00.600called Mary Jane Vile, who already had an illegitimate child by someone, we don't know
00:09:08.560who, a little boy called Charles, when she becomes pregnant with Claire. And this Claire is born in
00:09:16.2201798. Like I said, we only found out recently who her real father was. Claire throughout her life
00:09:23.220believed her father to be some kind of possibly Swiss gentleman. She liked the idea that he was
00:09:29.680European and her mother I think probably told her a variety of stories but the truth is her father
00:09:36.020was a man called Sir John Lethbridge who I think was a baron or the son of a baron and Mary Jade
00:09:42.860Vile kind of ran her own pub and when she gets pregnant with Claire she's not like a child she's
00:09:50.900in her late 20s I think she's pushing 30 when she gives birth to Claire and she actually spends some0.99
00:09:56.180time just after Claire's birth in a debtor's prison as well. So presumably through the pregnancy
00:10:02.480stuff she wasn't able to work and there was no financial support and that's how she ends up in
00:10:07.160debtor's prison. So it looks as though we don't have any definite information about this but it
00:10:11.140looks as though Claire started life really in debtor's prison. Mary Jane Vallott gets out of
00:10:15.960debtor's prison and on behalf of a local curate takes on her case and together they write to Sir
00:10:23.960John Lethbridge. And Sir John Lethbridge actually does give financial support on a monthly basis
00:10:31.760to Mary Jane for Clare's upkeep. That is something we knew nothing about. I don't think Clare knew
00:10:39.060anything about it either. So fast forward six months, six months after Mary Jane gets out of
00:10:44.520prison, she winds up in London and she just happens to be living a couple of doors along
00:10:48.640from William Godwin. William Godwin, famous radical philosopher whose wife Mary Wollstonecraft
00:10:55.760has recently passed away. It's only about I think 18 months to two years after her death when she
00:11:04.240was giving birth to her daughter Mary Godwin. William Godwin is left then with two small
00:11:11.400children. He has Mary Wollstonecraft's first daughter, Fanny Emily, who she had with Gilbert
00:11:18.340Emily, and his own child with Mary Wollstonecraft, little Mary Godwin. So he's got two daughters to
00:11:25.060look after. And I think probably he needed a wife and Mary Jane Vile needed a husband. So the two
00:11:33.140households came together. They got married. To all intents and purposes, it was a good marriage.
00:11:38.700they have a little boy called William. I just wanted to point out so just now that William is
00:11:43.340on the scene as well so it's a household of five children? Yes. And each of them has different
00:11:50.640parents? Yes. Combination? Yes. And we think that that's quite I think unusual and remarkable and
00:11:57.940all this but actually probably it wasn't that unusual given the high rates of women's deaths
00:12:04.820in childbirth. There were a lot of mixed households, really, I think. So yeah, so Claire
00:12:10.440and Mary basically grow up together. When Mary's about 14, she's sent north to Scotland.
00:12:16.860It looks as though she's not getting on with her stepmother, Mary Jane. Mary Jane was clearly
00:12:21.460quite a force of nature because at this point, Mary Jane is also running a children's bookshop
00:12:26.920and she's publishing children's books as well. And she is the only bookseller and publisher
00:12:31.540in London who is a woman at this time so she's she's quite clearly um quite quite a quite figure0.91
00:12:38.560they don't get on so so Mary sent north to live with the Baxters in Scotland and I did write um0.84
00:12:45.020a novel back in 2013 about Isabel Baxter who Mary befriends when she's she's living up there in
00:12:54.740in Dundee in Broughty Ferry so Claire's in the household just with with Fanny and William
00:13:00.380and Charles until Mary comes back when she's 16 now by this point Shelley young radical poet
00:13:09.300who thinks Godwin is wonderful has been visiting the household I think Claire and Shelley actually
00:13:14.560meet first so when Mary returns Shelley comes to visit and it's pretty much instant the chemistry
00:13:23.480between them. Shelley is married, of course, though, to a woman called Harriet. So you fast
00:13:29.140forward, not very long after this, Mary and Shelley decide to run off to the continent
00:13:36.120and they take Claire with them because Claire's got a real facility for languages and also
00:13:41.540Shelley's quite keen on her. Can we talk about Claire's, sorry, just the, in terms of the
00:13:46.700facility for languages, just when I was reading a bit about Claire to prepare to talk to you about
00:13:50.520this? Because she was given a level of education that I think Mary wasn't. Claire was taught in0.95
00:13:57.520a different, a better school or something like that. Their education is slightly different. Yes.
00:14:02.700Like I said, Mary sent north and Claire remains in London. But I think also, I think Claire just
00:14:12.320has a natural facility for languages anyway. It's not something that Mary's quite so interested in.
00:14:19.280So, yes, I think there's probably I think there's probably a lot of homeschooling going on as well, because it was all so much of it was probably, I think, directed by Godwin because he believed girls and boys like Wilson Craft did should have an equal education.
00:14:35.640oh and speaking of the um godwin's beliefs can we talk about free love for a minute because that
00:14:43.740really affects both mary and claire's decisions throughout their lives the way that they were
00:14:49.340raised in this radical household yeah i mean i think the the free love influence i think more
00:14:54.340comes from shelly than anything i mean certainly with them claire i think really imbibes mary
00:15:02.080Wollstonecraft's philosophies about women's independence and women working for themselves
00:15:08.460and earning their own money and you shouldn't have to be married in order to be you know
00:15:12.820financially secure and all of this kind of stuff um Shelley of course takes it all a step further
00:15:19.020Shelley's really the proponent of free love as in we should all have multiple partners if we want
00:15:25.120and nobody sticks to one person and all that kind of thing and that's really kind of when later when
00:15:31.380they come back from the continent and he's kind of pushing mary towards his friend hog he wants
00:15:36.860her to sleep with him so that there's no there's no possession there's no nobody's clinging on to
00:15:42.360one other person the problem you have with shelley is a lot of his philosophies are quite contradictory
00:15:48.080you know on the one hand he he was also at this time trying to disinherit himself because he's
00:15:54.340the son of a baronet sir timothy shelley and he doesn't want to he doesn't believe in inherited
00:15:58.840wealth. So he's trying legally to disinherit himself so he doesn't inherit the house
00:16:03.760from his father. But at the same time, he depends on his father's money to be able to pay for things
00:16:11.880because Shelley isn't going to get a job, is he? He's got no interest in doing that.
00:16:17.080So you've got the same thing, I think, with the sort of free love philosophy as well, where,
00:16:22.000you know, they run off to the continent, Shelley, Mary and Clare. Then they come back after a few
00:16:27.360months and when he lands when they land back at Dover they've got no money to get back to London
00:16:33.320so he writes to Harriet and asks Harriet his wife the wife he has abandoned to pay for them to come
00:16:40.520back which she does thinking that Shelley is coming back to her only when Shelley meets her he
00:16:47.000says no that's not what I'm thinking at all I'm thinking a lovely big commune where we all live
00:16:51.840together it'll all be lovely and and Harriet's just like are you kidding me Harriet's pregnant
00:16:56.800with her second child by Shelley. So it's, and now Mary, of course, is pregnant too. So it's,0.73
00:17:03.020yeah, free love indeed, which turns out to be rather expensive.
00:17:08.580Good point. Great point. So there is sort of this trio, actually just side note. I don't know if you
00:17:15.920saw the Mary Shelley movie from a few years ago where Elle Fanning was playing Mary Shelley.
00:17:21.960Yeah. So the two recently, like within the last couple of months, the actress Belle Powley,
00:17:26.640who played Claire and the actor Douglas Booth who played Shelley they just got married in real life
00:17:31.100they met on that movie and fell in love I was like actually this is beautiful I know
00:17:35.760it's amazing isn't it yeah they're in and they're a lovely couple they are they seem like a lovely
00:17:42.740couple and I mentioned that to my friend and she saw the movie as well and she's like yeah those
00:17:46.360two had real chemistry in that movie it was almost distracting but the Claire Shelley Mary so you
00:17:54.480you talk about this in your book, which is again, a novel, but Claire and Mary are so similar in age
00:18:00.000and they're raised together and they've quite opposite personalities, but then they're both,
00:18:04.800it's like the three of them, Mary, Claire and Shelley are together. And it's always been a
00:18:09.580sort of like, what was that situation? What was Claire's role in this relationship? And I don't
00:18:16.000know how much we could ever really know, but it sort of taints both of the girls really by having
00:18:22.160run off with this man as teenagers, does it? Oh, yeah. I mean, it's you're talking about this is
00:18:26.580the Regency era. This is, you know, Jane Austen. You know, they run off the year after the publication
00:18:33.220of Pride and Prejudice. I mean, they are both doing Lydia Bennett. When they're doing this,
00:18:38.940they're ruining the reputations. And it's interesting that it's Claire's mother, Mary
00:18:42.860Jane, who runs after them. I mean, she, she, you know, William Godwin, the father is at home just
00:18:48.240going oh my god what are we going to do mary jane actually gets in a coach goes to the coast and
00:18:53.980then gets a boat across to france herself and chases after him and she does get hold of claire
00:18:59.460and tries to persuade her to come back but you know claire's 16 and having the time of her life
00:19:03.960she's just like no i'm having a huge adventure absolutely not and so when you sort of fast
00:19:09.400forward two years later when claire's 18 or 17 just before she meets byron she and shelly and
00:19:17.440mary have been living together on and off uh sometimes it breaks down when mary and claire
00:19:23.800fall out and mary's like i've had enough she needs to leave me alone and and also of course this is
00:19:29.240the period when mary goes through the loss of her first child as well and there's a sense that
00:19:35.320perhaps claire doesn't quite understand or or certainly a sense from mary of needing i think
00:19:42.640probably quiet and calm and peace around her and Shelley doesn't really know quite how to handle it
00:19:48.420so he finds it easier to just you know let's go off for a big walk with Claire and leave Mary to
00:19:53.000it so there's a kind of there's lots of tensions going on I think between all three of them at this
00:19:59.300point just before Claire meets meets Byron and Claire does go off and live for a while and in
00:20:07.380lionmouth she goes off on sort of little jaunts just when when mary's really had enough so byron
00:20:14.220enters the story how did they meet each other well as far as we know and and there's there's
00:20:21.820lots of different um stories about this but as far as we can tell it comes through claire writing
00:20:29.760to byron and asking for an audition and because he's one of the directors on the drury lane
00:20:35.980theatre and she wants to come and audition for him because she has a she does have a remarkable
00:20:40.920singing voice he just ignores the first couple of letters but she's quite persistent and she
00:20:45.520keeps writing and all we know is that eventually he says yes and ta-da it seems to have happened
00:20:53.660from there the question mark over it and you see this in biographies really from oh I would say
00:21:00.920about the the 1990s onwards in particular this sense of Claire being the one who came up with
00:21:09.780this idea and really ran with it and really pushed it and you'll see lots and lots of phrases in lots
00:21:16.280of biographies about her you know laying siege to Byron and you know all these kind of battle
00:21:23.040metaphors and stuff and really kind of blaming her as well it's a way I think of later on when
00:21:29.660subsequent things when they don't work out it's like it's her own fault she pushed for this she
00:21:34.060pushed for this and it's interesting because William Graham who is a young journalist who
00:21:39.420goes to visit Claire towards the ends of her life in Florence records that Claire told him that it
00:21:48.280was Shelley's idea that she write to Byron in the first place because Shelley wanted to meet Byron
00:21:53.140that Shelley was Byron mad and Shelley's biographer Richard Holmes is probably written I think one of
00:21:59.480the best biographies ever written, Shelley, The Pursuit. It's astonishing. The amount of detail
00:22:03.980he gets hold of is incredible. He also thinks that it's a bit of a put up job that Shelley
00:22:11.260encourages Claire. It's Shelley's idea and he encourages Claire to write to Byron to try and
00:22:16.780hook him. So she's, I mean, he's really kind of using Claire as bait to try and hook this,
00:22:22.040this poet. And we know also that Mary knew about it as well, because Claire takes Mary to meet
00:22:28.260Byron after the first couple of meetings. So it kind of complicates the picture. It means that
00:22:33.320it's not quite so clear that it was Claire who was chasing Byron, but she was kind of pushed
00:22:38.700towards him. That's the kind of version that I've kind of gone with, I think, in the novel.
00:22:43.780Not to absolve Claire of Blame, but just, I think, to balance it out a little bit better.
00:22:50.980Yeah, because I think I've come across the interpretation that she saw Shelley,
00:22:56.300like mary was with shelly so she wanted to be also with a great celebrity a great literary
00:23:02.820figure as well and so she just harassed byron into meeting with her but it's more nuanced than
00:23:09.460just that even if that maybe was like part unconsciously what she was thinking yeah there's
00:23:15.080this this idea that she um she wanted um to outdo mary she wanted to to get someone even more
00:23:21.600glamorous and and it still seems quite odd though because Byron was such a star at this time he was
00:23:29.060such a literary star um and she's nobody she she has you know no connections the the thing that
00:23:36.440probably would have interested him the most is her connection to William Godwin because Byron was a
00:23:40.620big fan of of Godwin's but yeah it is it is all quite strange it is all quite shrouded in sort of
00:23:47.560claim and and counterclaim and it depends on who you kind of want to go with I think and certainly
00:23:53.740for for fans of Byron I think Claire is is always going to be a sticking point for them because of
00:24:02.600how he treats her and I think it kind of absolves Byron a lot if you can blame Claire for it in the
00:24:10.580first place if you can say well look and that's what Byron says Byron's Byron's clearly trying
00:24:15.480to absolve himself much later on because that's what he says oh you know this this girl who comes
00:24:21.100you know traipsing after me traveling all these hundreds of miles you know to unphilosophize me
00:24:26.880he says he doesn't want to be blamed for what's happening either. So how do they all get to
00:24:33.460Geneva for that famous summer? Well of course Byron has separated from his wife Lady Annabella
00:24:42.220And it's quite shocking because, of course, this is an age when divorce isn't supposed to happen.
00:24:47.740And there's all sorts of rumours about exactly why his wife is separating from him from him.
00:24:56.560And then there's the rumours of sodomy and all sorts of things coming out.
00:25:01.200And Byron is really forced into exile.
00:25:03.520He has to leave the country because they're really gunning for him.
00:25:07.660So he's very angry and he's leaving in a big huff.
00:25:10.120Shelley has been talking for quite some time about you know whether should he should he go
00:25:15.280and live in Europe should he stay in England he can't decide what to do because he's getting
00:25:19.040annoyed by creditors he's also um he's lost some chancery suit as well he's constantly preoccupied
00:25:25.900with money and money situations and so he's in a bad temper as well and I think in the midst of all
00:25:31.900of this just before Byron leaves this seems to have been when well we know this is when Claire
00:25:37.940spends the night with Byron we don't know how often it happens we don't know how many
00:25:42.120times they they see each other but we know that obviously this is this is when she
00:25:46.960conceives she doesn't know that necessarily so Byron goes off to Geneva in May and Claire decides
00:25:56.780or says to him you know we'll come with you we're going to come to we're going to come to and she
00:26:00.640suggests it to to Mary and Shelley who are all for it they're just like yes let's let's do that
00:26:05.620let's go and so they actually I think they actually reach Geneva before Byron does and
00:26:12.400they take one house and Byron takes the other Byron takes the bigger house of course and then
00:26:17.440the Shelleys move again and they have this little cottage that's nearer Villa Diodati because Byron
00:26:22.840has all this money Byron is so rich this is the other thing he's not just a literary star he's a
00:26:27.560rich handsome you know dreadful man who's doing very very well in one respect and so they have
00:26:37.540this little cottage sort of down by the down by the water and it's Claire who introduces Byron
00:26:43.160and Shelley which I always think is quite a fascinating thing really that that she's and I
00:26:49.680and I have this in the novel quite a few times about her being positioned between them because
00:26:53.220she is the one who brings them together on the pier at the edge of the lake. And that's the first
00:26:58.800time that they meet each other. And I do think that's partly, it's not just the fact that it's
00:27:04.640a few nights later, the storms are happening because of the volcano in Indonesia, causing
00:27:10.420all sorts of upset with the weather in the Villa Diodati, the whole group of them telling ghost
00:27:15.680stories, all of this kind of stuff. It's not just because of Frankenstein that that summer matters,
00:27:21.180But it's been blown up so much because, of course, Byron Shelley, these two genius poets coming together and meeting and discussing things.
00:27:30.540And that's really what kind of pushes Claire out of the picture in terms of literary biography, because she isn't a literary genius.
00:27:40.320Mary and Byron and Shelley are the literary geniuses and Claire isn't.
00:27:44.780for all her for all her talents for all her intelligence and her education she isn't one of
00:27:51.320them isn't there a quote I'm not gonna ask you to recite the quote but I'm sure you've come across it
00:27:57.080where she said something about you know what why don't you write also Claire and she was like in
00:28:01.640my family you either need to be a genius or don't even bother because it's not just like Mary and
00:28:08.140Shelly and Byron who she's spending her time with but also her father and then also Mary's mother
00:28:12.540And then her mother, Mary Jane, is this publisher.
00:28:15.360Like there's such a high level of achievement.
00:28:17.260So I can see that that would be very daunting.
00:28:41.680So I don't think she's intimidated by genius necessarily.
00:28:45.860And she's very supportive of it as well.
00:28:47.380And she's always supportive of Mary's genius throughout her life.
00:28:49.920And she refers to it as genius, which we know is a word that's nearly always applied to men.
00:28:55.400And, you know, it's the old, you know, men have genius, women have talent kind of thing.
00:28:59.660And she's very forceful about Mary's genius.
00:29:03.140So I don't think she was necessarily intimidated by it.
00:29:05.800yes that there is that quote of her saying you know if you can't think of something you know
00:29:09.920that by its nature is the most original thing ever then just don't bother but she was she was
00:29:16.240clever and she could appreciate literature properly and she could hold her own I think
00:29:22.060in conversations there's never any sense that she doesn't really kind of know what to say or that0.97
00:29:28.820she's saying something stupid or foolish I don't think yeah and I think that's also sort of an0.89
00:29:34.940impression that one might get about Claire Claremont just from the way she's often talked0.98
00:29:40.240about just a little bit or she's kind of a small role documentaries or films or things like that
00:29:45.320she's just kind of Mary's like silly sister it's kind of like Lydia Bennett put into
00:29:49.240this summer in Geneva where it's like no she actually is like very intelligent and like you
00:29:54.100said she has this facility for languages and stuff like she can yeah she can keep up yeah and she I
00:29:59.680mean she wrote she tried to write as well she wrote um a short story called the pole and she0.70
00:30:04.800she was starting work on on a short story called the idiot which we don't really have
00:30:09.300i don't think we've got anything left of that so she was thinking about writing too but primarily
00:30:14.940she was kind of in training to be a teacher she wanted to teach and and teach music so she was
00:30:21.860thinking in in terms of a of a career she wasn't trying to ensnare byron and she didn't want to
00:30:29.360get married. All of that was very genuine. She really took on a lot of Shelley and principles
00:30:35.580early on that she really didn't abandon. She stuck with them, which I think is really interesting
00:30:41.620because that's really kind of what sees her through, I think, the tragedies to come as things
00:30:46.900just kind of implode, really. Well, let's talk about that implosion, which part of that is what
00:30:55.160happens with her child, with Byron. And actually, sorry, pause. I want to talk about names for a
00:31:01.300second because we've been calling her Claire all along, but her name was Jane. And then she chose
00:31:05.580to change her name to Claire, which one of her middle names is Clara. So it didn't come out of
00:31:09.860nowhere. And her surname was Claremont, but that was a surname her mother, Mary Jane had invented
00:31:17.540because. Yes. Right. Yeah. So there's just a lot of name. And in your book, you play around with
00:31:23.700this what she's called at different times so I just wanted to talk about that for a second
00:31:26.900yeah I think I think the naming thing is really interesting because yeah she she lives by the
00:31:32.960name Claire Claremont by this point and both those names are invented her her first name is an
00:31:39.680invention and so is her surname although she doesn't know her surname is an invention she
00:31:44.060thinks claremont is a real man who fathered her um so i i do think the the question of names is
00:31:53.960is really interesting particularly for women because they lose their names on on marrying
00:32:00.920because then she has a child the shot she has with byron is a daughter who initially
00:32:06.300she calls Elba which is a play on her nickname that so Lord Byron is LB and people call him
00:32:15.220LB like LB for a Lord Byron so then she calls the daughter Elba presumably is kind of an ode to him
00:32:21.580and he's like no let's change this child's name to Allegra actually so names are just changing
00:32:28.460names are changing and there's a lot of status in a name as well I mean it's interesting that
00:32:34.580Byron chooses the name Allegra which is much more classical those kinds of classical names have more
00:32:40.120status because one thing he does do he does he does acknowledge Allegra as his own he doesn't
00:32:45.660try and pretend I mean apart from that there is that quote where he says you know is the brat
00:32:50.800mine he writes to to one of his friends and he just says well you know I I know it is and it's
00:32:56.180so much as one can know these things but he does he does take on board that the child is this little
00:33:02.140girl is his so he is very conscious of himself as a Byron and that his daughter is a Byron as well
00:33:09.820she is Allegra Byron he doesn't he doesn't deny her his name and I know I mean these days we
00:33:16.820sort of think well that's how big of them that was great but uh in those days I think that was
00:33:21.680probably quite important and but it does feed into why Claire is ready and willing to hand her
00:33:28.880daughter over to this man. I have had a couple of people ask me when she finds out that she's
00:33:34.920pregnant to Byron, why is she so willing to give her child up? Especially when you think that her1.00
00:33:41.180mother managed with two children. She wasn't married, although her mother did end up in1.00
00:33:47.060debtors prison, so maybe didn't manage quite so well. It wasn't easy. She's 18 years old and she
00:33:51.980has nothing. She really has nothing. The best contact in the world she has is William Godwin,0.84
00:33:56.680her stepfather, who is broke. He is perpetually broke. So there's no money at her back. The only
00:34:02.680kind of support she's got is from Shelley. Shelley, at this point, is currently supporting two women,0.99
00:34:08.180Mary and Harriet. His two children by Harriet. He's got a child with Mary. He's supporting Claire
00:34:13.800as well. And his big fear, if Claire kept the child, was that his father would hear about this
00:34:22.500And everybody would just assume that Claire's child was Shelley's by Claire, that this would be the final straw and his father really would cut off all financial support.
00:34:35.680So even though he like wanted to be cut off from his father, he didn't want to be cut off from his father's money.
00:34:42.040Yeah. Like I said, this is the contradiction with him, you know, wanting to be disinherited.
00:34:46.760I don't want to inherit the title. I don't want to inherit this grand mansion field place, blah, blah, blah. But yes, could you please still give me my money so that I, like I said, so I don't have to get a job. So it's, he's still got quite a lot of money. I mean, it's not like he's impoverished or anything like that, but it would, it would cause problems.
00:35:08.020there's also it's interesting much later on a few years down the line when I don't mean to jump
00:35:14.320ahead I'm hoping I'm not doing that too much but when Claire is begging Byron to let her see her
00:35:20.980child and she says she comes up with this scheme to Shelly and saying look why don't we rescue her
00:35:26.500she's in a convent why don't we go and rescue her and Shelly's horrified she's like no what if
00:35:31.140Byron challenges me to a duel I might die and you're just kind of like you know Byron's too
00:35:40.260too big and strong and and rich and and even Mary Mary says the same thing she says is this what you
00:35:46.640want you seriously Claire do you want Shelley to to fight Byron and and he'll die and in any case
00:35:55.200Byron she said would like he has all the money all these resources he would just hunt down you0.90
00:35:59.680and your child and take her back anyway so there's no point so yes it's she has nothing she is not in
00:36:06.120a position of power and she's she goes very quickly I think from being in a position of
00:36:11.800she's an 18 year old girl with all these plus points you know she's attractive she's intelligent
00:36:17.400she's mixing with these sort of literary geniuses and then suddenly it's really kind of all taken0.94
00:36:23.560away because she's, the truth of the matter is that she's a penniless 18 year old single mother
00:36:29.880and you have nothing. You really do have nothing. Yeah. And that's the thing. That's where I kind
00:36:36.360of, one might understand why her mother went to try and bring her home age 16, because what her
00:36:43.440mother went through being the, being the single mother, being a debtor's person, she could,
00:36:47.680she could see a long view of where Claire was headed. Whereas Claire was just in the moment,0.92
00:36:53.280having so much fun I know and I do think it's such a shame that her mother didn't tell her the truth
00:36:59.580about her origins and tell the truth about her past because she might have been able to advise
00:37:04.800her daughter Claire didn't tell her mother about the child that she had with with Byron and you
00:37:12.040just kind of think her mother would have been a good person to have had by her side and to have0.64
00:37:17.540fought for her now she might not have I mean Mary Jane Vile might have taken the opposite line she
00:37:22.420might have said yeah absolutely you have to give your child over to Byron there's no point in even
00:37:26.980fighting it just do it and don't think twice about it but you you can't help feeling she kind of
00:37:33.660she actually kind of needed a stronger support I think behind her certainly if she was going to
00:37:39.600take on on somebody like Byron and she did that's a remarkable thing she actually did take him on
00:37:45.980I mean her letters to him after she's handed Allegra over to him are are astonishing you know
00:37:52.980she she really fights for her well I was just thinking you know if she had someone she had
00:37:57.360that own strength in herself to be fighting for her daughter but if she had someone in her corner
00:38:00.960besides these like though it just you know re taking the story and putting the emphasis on
00:38:07.200Claire in the background Shelly and Mary are just kind of these flakes like they don't know any
00:38:11.700better than she does what to do like they're all just kind of 20 year old doing the best they can
00:38:17.000but they don't know what they're doing they have skills but their skills are not to live life well
00:38:23.360and now we're just going to take a break for a word from our sponsors
00:38:27.580the war is over and both sides lost kingdoms were reduced to cinders and armies scattered
00:39:48.060Be awed by our incredible guests from familiar shows like Oxventure and No Rolls Barred.
00:39:56.000Search realms of peril and glory to find out more.
00:39:59.460Ever get to the end of a podcast episode and think, now what?
00:40:06.600Well, instead of scrolling through a million choices, try Something You Should Know.
00:40:11.360I'm the host, Mike Carruthers, and every episode is packed with fascinating, useful, and surprising things you'll actually use in your life.
00:40:19.620From human behavior, relationships, health, science, and everyday mysteries.
00:40:25.180So while you're already in your podcast app, just search for Something You Should Know