00:00:00.000Hello, and welcome to the Vulgar History Podcast. My name is Anne Foster, and this is a feminist1.00
00:00:17.400women's history comedy podcast. And today is the season two finale. So this is the ninth
00:00:24.640episode in our series looking at women leaders in history and the men who whined about them.
00:00:30.300And there has been a lot of leading. There's been a lot of whining. There's been a lot of
00:00:35.020patriarchy getting in the way. There's been a lot of just women who probably could have done1.00
00:00:39.440a lot more stuff if they hadn't had to spend so much time swatting away all these1.00
00:00:44.400people who kept bothering them. So last week's episode on Queen Anne, I had been sort of like,
00:00:51.680it was a moving target what was going to be the last episode of this season which like to clarify
00:00:57.300not the last episode forever just the last episode of this little pocket of things and I had been
00:01:03.100going chronologically and then just as I was working on the Queen Anne one then uh you know
00:01:09.100you might not know but um there's a pandemic going on in the world and that got me looking at all
00:01:16.260the stuff about pandemics in general. And then that got me thinking about, so I was doing the
00:01:22.520pandemic special episodes of this podcast. And so I was thinking about the different pandemic
00:01:28.200stories that I wanted to share on those short podcasts. And one of them involves Joanna of
00:01:32.560Naples. So I was like, oh, let me just like, because I remember there's this thing and we're
00:01:36.020going to get to it in this podcast, obviously, where some interesting plague related things
00:01:40.420happen around her. And that got me, so I was like looking back to see like, okay,
00:01:45.360what was her deal just so I could sort of get a grip on it for myself so that I could explain it
00:01:49.440to other people and then as I was sort of making up a little document script of like what you need
00:01:56.480to know to understand the plague part of her story I realized like oh this is going to be
00:01:59.780much longer than a little 15 minute mini episode because there's so much stuff even just to get
00:02:06.200you to the point where the plague stuff happens and then so much stuff happens after the plague
00:02:10.020stuff. So here we are with this sort of extra non-chronological story of Joanna of Naples here
00:02:19.100at the tail end of this season of Vulgar History. So Joanna, I'm just thinking if you want to do
00:02:25.100like a Fast and the Furious slash Star Wars thing to listen to the podcasts in order, I believe
00:02:32.720Joanna of Naples sequentially comes between Empress Matilda and Isabella the first so you
00:02:40.260could just like if you're not listening to these as they come out you could slot that back slot
00:02:45.560Joanna back in in between those two people so I also wanted to mention there's so many wonderful
00:02:51.700other podcasts that I've been listening to and I've been doing a lot of podcast listening
00:02:56.000lately what with pandemic etc and there's a really there's so much support and lifting each
00:03:03.400other up and wonderfulness in the history podcast online community and one of the the most welcoming
00:03:09.300and nicest podcasts is the what's her name podcast which you should all subscribe to as well they've
00:03:15.060got so many episodes i listen to them for research and also for fun and so they tweeted a couple of
00:03:21.940days ago on april 20th so they were sharing this article that's basically about like why are women0.61
00:03:28.200such good leaders during covet 19 which is the same sort of stuff that people are like wow you0.90
00:03:32.720know look at these countries that are doing well with this pandemic they have female leaders female
00:03:36.300leaders are better than men leaders and there's so much about that that's just um overly simplistic
00:03:42.700and also whatever anyway what's your name podcast succinctly um explain this the best that i saw
00:03:49.080So what they said is in their tweet. So when leadership is accessible to more people, you have a better chance at finding good leaders. And there have been impressive women leaders for millennia. We just don't talk about them. Maybe we should start. See, number one, hashtag learn history.
00:04:06.760And this is really what I was thinking about when I was preparing this season of this podcast as well, which is sort of the overly simplistic sort of paternalizing thing of being like, oh, women are inherently nicer or kinder or better or whatever.
00:04:20.460It's like so much is just how people are socialized and what they've been allowed to do.
00:04:25.220And there have been more male leaders than not male leaders in most of world history, to the point that when there are women leaders, their gender often becomes an issue, as we have looked at in these past eight episodes.
00:04:41.560So if there was parody, if there was an equal amount of leaders of every gender throughout all of history, there would be, I think, I can't say why there wouldn't be, an equal amount of good and bad people of all different genders.
00:04:53.280But women have more pressure put on them to be amazing when they get to these leadership roles.0.87
00:04:59.400And every single woman we've looked at this season ascended to a leadership role basically by either being born into it or marrying into it.1.00
00:05:09.580They're sort of women who, even if that annoyed people around them, they were the heirs to whatever kingdom.1.00
00:05:16.080And so they ended up being in charge and some of them did amazing things and some of them weren't able to do amazing things.
00:05:20.360And it's not it's not that women are better leaders than men.
00:05:24.380It's just they haven't had as much chance to be good or to be terrible or whatever.
00:05:29.680Anyway, so today we're looking at the story of Joanna of Naples, who reigned for 30 years.
00:05:34.260One of the longest reigns we've looked at of anyone this season.
00:05:37.340and it's a story based around a lot of geographical history that with which I am
00:05:43.200much more familiar now than I was a week ago but which I don't know nearly as well as I know the
00:05:49.240history of Britain or Scotland or England or anyway so but Joanna so she was the queen of
00:05:56.820Naples Jerusalem and Sicily which if you're like wait are those three places next to each other
00:06:03.320on a map and they're not really, but don't worry about it because we're not going to be getting
00:06:08.100into the geography that much. You just need to kind of know, basically we're looking at like
00:06:12.260Italy before Italy was Italy when it was just a bunch of sort of city states slash kingdoms.
00:06:18.280That's sort of where she was based out of, sort of between Italy and France. So Naples, 1326.
00:06:25.260Joanna was born and she was the eldest daughter of Charles, the Duke of Calabria and Marie of0.72
00:06:30.560Valois. They had had other daughters as well, but she was the first to survive infancy. She had an
00:06:36.360older sister, Louise, who died that same year, and a brother, Charles, who was born one year
00:06:40.980later, but he only lived for eight days. She wound up having one surviving sibling, who was
00:06:45.920younger sister, called Maria, who was actually born just after her father had died. So her father
00:06:51.220died when Joanna was two. Maria was then born, and she was a baby, and she's going to be sort of
00:06:55.920like a best supporting actress queen in the story, because Maria's life was also pretty volatile.
00:07:03.000So what this meant, though, is that Joanna being the granddaughter of a king who's called
00:07:08.180Robert the Wise. So Robert the Wise is her grandfather. Because Joanna's father had died,
00:07:14.120that means Joanna is now the heir to inherit Naples. So basically, the agreement said that
00:07:22.100his female ancestors or female descendants would be who would inherit the throne if there weren't
00:07:27.200any men around. And also the rule said that a female monarch had to marry and she should allow0.97
00:07:33.620her husband to rule. So although there are male relatives here and there, Robert was really0.63
00:07:40.560wanted to stay with that plan. So to have Joanna and then after her, Maria as his heir. So he had
00:07:46.820even a public ceremony when Joanna was four years old and Maria was two years old, I guess,
00:07:52.900where he just publicly said, like, hey, guess what? This is what's happening. My heir is going
00:07:57.060to be Joanna and then her children. And if for some reason she has no children, then my heir
00:08:01.360will be Maria and then her children. Some relatives weren't super excited about this,
00:08:06.020i.e. the relatives who thought that they should be his heirs instead of these little baby girls.
00:08:10.320some of the relatives include philip of toronto not toronto like ontario canada but i think it's
00:08:18.920pronounced taranto it's like toronto but with a's this word's going to come up i should really
00:08:23.980decide on a pronunciation and his wife catherine of valois refused to support the whole joanna
00:08:29.680being the heir thing so they refused to even go to this ceremony the pope tried to intercede
00:08:35.740There's a lot of Pope action in the story. And the Pope was like, Philip and Catherine, you need to go and go to this thing.
00:08:43.160Philip refused, and he only sent a deputy to pay homage to Joanna on his behalf, because he just really didn't think that she should be the heir.
00:08:51.940Not just because she was a girl, but because he thought that he should be the heir, I guess.
00:08:56.780So one year later, Joanna, age five, Maria, age three, Joanna's, their mother died.
00:09:03.820Joanna and Maria now orphans, parents, all dead.
00:09:07.980But their grandfather, Robert the Wise, is who's been sort of raising them.
00:09:12.180And so his wife, Joanna and Maria's step-grandmother, is called Sancia of Mallorca, and she assumed responsibility for their education.
00:09:20.660And Queen Sancia lived like a nun, although the Pope had refused to annul her marriage to King Robert.
00:09:26.120just so you kind of know what kind of religious thing is happening here and she became a huge
00:09:32.940influence on joanna and maria's life she really took charge of their education and raising them
00:09:37.960and she did a great job from what we see what they're able to do when they grow up later even
00:09:42.520the things were going pretty well in terms of like medieval naples so there was this um robert
00:09:50.960the wise the grandfather he had this long time enemy which was hungary the country of hungary
00:09:59.260it all has to do with like who is going to be king and who's going to inherit from where
00:10:03.320um robert was actually the younger brother so in terms of like hungary what happened is that
00:10:11.380there's three sons no there's two sons so robert's father died um robert's older brother died so
00:10:19.940technically his older brother's son should have become the next king of hungary but instead
00:10:24.600robert no king of naples oh my god i'm so sorry this is just like what you need to know is that
00:10:32.720hungary and naples were at war and everyone was related to everyone let's just like leave it at
00:10:39.040that for now because that's not what we're talking about we're talking about joanna but what happened
00:10:42.840is that so joanna little tiny girl to try and stave off a possible hungarian invasion it was
00:10:49.580decided that she would get married to one of these Hungarian princes, who's also maybe her cousin or
00:10:54.540something. I'm not sure. So the one who was chosen was Andrew. So her cousin, Andrew, the Hungarian.
00:11:03.080And then the stipulation of their betrothal was that Andrew's heirs would rule Naples,
00:11:08.240but he himself would only ever serve as Joanna's consort. So he wouldn't be king,
00:11:12.920even though he was going to be married to her and she was going to one day become
00:11:15.660the queen. And then Andrew, who's also just like a little baby at the time, was sent to Naples to
00:11:21.460grow up there. But people were very xenophobic against the Hungarians because of the whole
00:11:28.340being at war with each other situation. So he was never really accepted. So he remained in Naples
00:11:34.740after this little baby wedding when they were like six and four years old or something like that.
00:11:39.820But what it meant is that even though they were married, like they were little baby children,
00:11:42.680and it's not like okay no act like husband and wife but it just meant like they're married so
00:11:46.640like no question about that but like they're waiting until Joanna gets to be 12 or whatever
00:11:51.160for them to consummate and to start like living like men and wives so effectively Andrew just
00:11:55.680came to live with Joanna and Maria and their other cousins and he was just like this sort of like1.00
00:11:59.440pesky annoying Hungarian new sibling on the scene so they're just like all children growing up0.91
00:12:06.040together two of them happened to be married to each other whatever so king robert died in 13430.99
00:12:13.400age 67 after ruling for 34 years as king of naples joanna age 16 was now officially his heir
00:12:20.680and it was not a great time to be taking over as queen of naples because um there had been a series
00:12:29.400of famines due to the weather got really bad and then crop yields were bad so like things have been
00:12:35.560pretty great when king robert was around partially because he was called robert the wise like he made
00:12:39.360some good decisions but also because just like he lucked into some good weather and trade situations
00:12:44.300so joanna is a teenager the country's like not doing great also a lot of people are like she's
00:12:50.440female that's gross we don't like that and also she's 16 so it's just kind of like not it was
00:12:57.680precarious not the best of times for her to be taking over um two days after so he died she
00:13:04.760becomes queen two days later and then her husband andrew who is now 15 was knighted officially and
00:13:11.380the marriage was consummated in accordance with the late king's witches so the king he had wished
00:13:17.680in his will i don't know that they would consummate their marriage upon his death whatever so they
00:13:22.380hated each other like joanna hated andrew andrew hated her slash everybody um they basically lived
00:13:29.320apart they only met with each other if there's like an important dinner where they both had to
00:13:32.700be but otherwise they went to separate churches they visited separate places and joanna forbade
00:13:38.060him from entering her bedroom without her permission um andrew there's the whole thing
00:13:43.520where she's the queen but he's just like her guy um he doesn't get to be the king and so that
00:13:48.800extended to um she controlled his allowance and his spendings andrew was not happy with any of
00:13:57.200this he thought that he should be king he was mad that everybody was mean to him for being hungarian
00:14:02.000which is like fair enough shitty uh joanna eventually became pregnant and that made andrew
00:14:08.060even more want to become king and it's totally if you know this story i haven't done on the podcast
00:14:12.160but i bet a lot of you know the story it's very mary queen of scots slash darnley about it where
00:14:17.660like she's having the baby with this guy that she hates he wants to be the king she won't let him0.98
00:14:22.860that makes him mad so he started making threats towards her um she just mocked him openly in front0.96
00:14:29.080of everybody. He bullied and insulted everybody and was just sort of sucky husband to her. And0.97
00:14:35.940she was, you know, not a great wife to him, but that wasn't the point of her life to be a great
00:14:41.260wife to him. She was a queen. So screw him, basically. So September 18th, 1345, Andrew
00:14:46.980comes home after partying with his guys. Joanna is asleep in bed. And then a servant came to the
00:14:54.280door saying like oh my god we have there's these papers you need to sign out here not in your room
00:15:00.020so he ran out of the room and then he was seized by a group of men who uh strung a rope around his
00:15:06.140neck uh dangled him over the railing and some men down below were like pulling on his ankles from
00:15:12.760below and he basically was murdered and the thing about it is that joanna was in the bedroom and i
00:15:21.860guess he when andrew tried to like run back in the bedroom he found that the bedroom was locked
00:15:26.040from the inside so like was joanna complicit in this murder plot did she just see like oh man
00:15:32.060someone's killing andrew i'm just gonna like lock my door now or was she like a bunch of men yelling
00:15:36.720i'm just gonna lock my door now but so she didn't help him not that she should have i don't know
00:15:43.780so at this point she's six months pregnant 19 years old and queen of naples and also a widow
00:15:50.100slash the prime suspect in her husband's murder so people like they do now with everybody and0.97
00:15:58.300it's just bullshit they're just like oh she's like not sad enough or not in the right way0.98
00:16:04.240or whatever but she uh people were already prone to not want to like her because she was0.98
00:16:10.760a young queen and the whole like who is an ally of who the whole like hungarian question they're
00:16:17.180just like oh this is great like this she looks bad in all of this so let's just like spread some0.99
00:16:21.320rumors like that she was having affairs like that she was responsible for killing him and then the0.99
00:16:26.820thing is that also she had spent ever since she knew him um she had been like openly mocking him0.89
00:16:32.760hating him so it's like would she kill her husband it's like you know she she probably would have
00:16:37.660killed her husband um sorry um things were not in terms of like public relations not looking great
00:16:44.740for her a man was arrested in connection to the murders um but they cut out his tongue so then he
00:16:52.740couldn't say if anyone had put him up to it or whatever and had he even been involved at all i
00:16:57.860don't know it's all pretty sketchy um the hungarians aka andrew's family were like uh who
00:17:04.640killed him so they demanded the pope do a an inquiry into it because the pope used to do
00:17:09.700stuff like that i guess and the pope was like i'm on it but then he was like some other pope things
00:17:14.940to do and he sort of like didn't take it on right away andrew the dead teenage husband so he had an
00:17:22.040older brother called louis who louis who is now the king of hungary and he's called louis the
00:17:27.920hungarian and he's a supporting actor in the story he's gonna show up a lot he began to talk about
00:17:33.620invading naples because the whole thing where the hungarians thought that they should be the king of
00:17:37.680naples etc so things were doing pretty bad internationally um between all these different
00:17:44.580places joanna's still pregnant um so she gave birth on christmas day december 25th 1345 to a son
00:17:52.200which was like great excellent news for all the usual like everyone's just like okay there's a boy
00:17:58.400like it's not just this teenage queen girl like we've got a boy there's going to be a man king
00:18:03.820everything's great she named the child charles martel and started thinking about getting a new
00:18:11.580husband for herself for both just like protection reasons because she had been educated really well
00:18:17.180but she was not like a warrior she needed somebody who had like an army and knew how to do stuff um0.99
00:18:22.700she just did all the reasons that she needed to find a new husband for her and her little baby
00:18:27.840so the guy that she wanted to marry was her cousin called luis of taranto so um there's luis the
00:18:37.600hungarian who is her enemy and then now there's her new husband luis of taranto um there had been
00:18:45.860speculation that the two of them were involved for a while he's like super hot attractive looking
00:18:50.660gorgeous and he was also a cousin who hung out with them when they were kids and they were all
00:18:54.740making fun of andrew back then he was sort of like the big the cool guy who was there with them
00:18:59.920she got married to him really quickly which also sort of like is this like a mary queen of scots
00:19:05.900scenario where you're just like is she or her emotions getting away with her was she forced0.90
00:19:10.680into this but also she's forced into it in the sense of like the hungarians were going to invade
00:19:15.160and she needed this alliance pretty much so they got married but they didn't get the papal
00:19:23.660dispensation because again the pope at this time one of his other jobs when he's not infestating
00:19:27.340murders is giving people permission to get married because they are cousins but whatever
00:19:32.940everyone gets married when they're cousins but anyway the thing here is that they didn't even
00:19:36.020wait for him to give the dispensation they just like got married and this whole sequence of events
00:19:40.760the whole like did she kill andrew she got quickie married to this guy didn't get the pope's
00:19:45.080permission made everybody in her kingdom just suddenly not like her very much at all meanwhile
00:19:51.940in our B plot, Joanna's younger sister, Maria's life was a nightmare. So shortly after the
00:20:00.320grandfather had died and Joanna became the queen, Maria was abducted by a woman named Agnes of
00:20:07.040Perigord, who is the widow of John Duke of Dorazzo because she wanted Maria to marry her son,
00:20:15.200charles of durazzo and that is what happened so maria was 14 years old or almost 14 she's like
00:20:22.24013 almost 14 charles of durazzo was 20 and they were forced into marriage and the marriage was
00:20:29.300consummated by force and so it's like this it's happened they've got married the end uh this
00:20:35.840the secret marriage which maria doesn't seem to have been consenting to but this infuriated joanna0.71
00:20:42.440she didn't like that Maria got married without her permission. Joanna sent letters to the Pope0.84
00:20:45.820demanding the annulment of the marriage. Again, she and her BFF, the Pope, just like, Pope is busy
00:20:50.820doing stuff. The Pope, who is called Clement VI, refused to annul the marriage. And at this point,
00:20:57.960Joanna was just like, okay, you are dead to me. Like, my sister no longer. And slash, you're now
00:21:04.640my enemies the Durazzo entire family and then years go by I believe we so five years later0.98
00:21:13.400it's a little montage moment so her enemy Louis of Hungary is just like hacking and slashing his
00:21:20.480way across the Italian countryside conquering towns and villages and Joanna and her squad need
00:21:26.260to figure out what to do side note people from Naples are called Neapolitans that is what they
00:21:32.380are called and the word neapolitan to me and perhaps to you makes me think of ice cream so
00:21:38.460i'm going to not use the word neapolitan very much because i i'm just going to say the people
00:21:44.160of naples because the neapolitan it just i just picture little ice cream cones and it just is
00:21:49.580distracting so people are just like making alliances breaking lenses and by people i mean
00:21:55.460like all these dudes the durazos the taranto brothers so at one point joanna is in a castle
00:22:03.820under siege she's by now pregnant with her husband's baby she fled her castle in the middle
00:22:09.520of the night to try and get to avignon avignon avignon which is where the pope lived to just
00:22:17.080like have a sit down with the pope and like hash things out so she fled the castle under darkest
00:22:21.960night um pregnant in medieval times just like this is like empress matilda level like there0.80
00:22:28.000wasn't like she wore white and also a snowy but just like this is this gets her high score points
00:22:33.880in terms of just like bravery uh her husband lewis of toronto um heard that she had fled and so he
00:22:40.660decided to go to avignon as well unfortunately in order to escape she had to leave her son charles
00:22:46.240martel behind because she couldn't escape with him it was too dangerous and she didn't think he
00:22:49.900would survive a journey so his uncle the hungarians sent charles martel off to hungary to be raised
00:22:59.020by those relatives but charles martel unfortunately died age two um while joanna and her husband lewis
00:23:07.420of toronto were off headed to the pope to just like straighten things out her sister maria and
00:23:13.380her husband charles of durazzo were like oh they're out of town amazing um why don't we just
00:23:18.620like seize power so charles maria's husband seized power but he was captured and beheaded by the
00:23:24.740hungarians only days later his period of power lasted less than a week and now maria was a 19
00:23:30.860year old widow just like her older sister had been before so joanna is headed towards avignon after
00:23:36.920this great escape um and coming just like parallel with her if you picture like on america's next
00:23:43.340top model they have the airplane with the little faces so here we've got like joanna heading one
00:23:46.800way of a little face and the other way it's just like a death skeleton because the black death
00:23:51.200um the bubonic plague was also headed parallel to her to avignon um so the black plague which
00:23:58.140we discussed in some of the pandemic special episodes um which you can listen to if you want
00:24:03.780to hear about how that all progresses it's a pretty awful disease and it kills you really
00:24:08.740quickly and horrifically so the black death had arrived in sicily the previous fall in a fleet of
00:24:17.640genoese vessels so just like how it happened in that little english town where it's just like
00:24:22.960trade is how it was spreading anyway um so what happened is this ship went into port in sicily
00:24:30.100sailors were like all they all had plague and they like stumbled down the gangplank and into
00:24:35.060the city and then they like spread they between them the fleas and the rats just the plague
00:24:39.880toppled this whole city by the spring of 1348 which is when the story takes place currently
00:24:45.120it had spread to the rest of italy and beyond so everybody if you remember there was the whole
00:24:50.800famine scenario where people were the crops weren't growing so there's already famine
00:24:55.000their bodies were weak so they're even more susceptible to die of plague
00:24:58.840some cities like Florence the death rate was like 90 percent so small villages just like
00:25:06.120ended like there's no one left of them they're like not a village anymore because people were
00:25:10.940dying and or fleeing so people died super quickly like apparently you could be healthy at sunrise
00:25:18.820and dead by sunset but sometimes it was longer and it was incredibly painful and debilitating
00:25:24.120so there were so many dead bodies that the cities didn't have enough room to bury them
00:25:30.820in avignon where the pope lived he consecrated the river because the whole thing about like you want
00:25:36.500to be buried and like consecrated ground but there wasn't enough ground to consecrate it and there
00:25:40.400wasn't time to like bury everybody so he just consecrated the river so every day hundreds of
00:25:45.660stinging corpses choked the river and slowly floated downstream to the open sea um so it's
00:25:51.540just like a river of dead bodies so then so this is pretty gruesome um joanna comes to avon y'all
00:26:02.820everything's pretty awful and gross but that's where the pope is and she needs to talk to the
00:26:07.480pope so that's what she's doing so on march 15 1348 she arrived with great fanfare so she had
00:26:15.200the whole squad with her she had the bishop of florence the chancellor of provence 18 cardinals
00:26:21.340Next came Joanna, dressed in a golden crimson robe, her blonde hair gleaming in the morning sun.
00:26:27.760Her robe had sort of like fleur-de-lis on it because that was to remind everybody that she's descended from the king of France, which she was.0.99
00:26:35.020Presumably, she would have been riding sidesaddle.
00:26:37.800So just sort of like this gorgeous moment of her just like coming through town.
00:26:41.220Her husband Louis was there looking super hot.
00:26:44.380The colorful parade was the first bright spot Avignon had seen in months.
00:33:04.260But Maria, not having this, and Joanna and her husband were like, we're not having this either.
00:33:11.020So what happened is, so when the ship was coming into port with Maria and this new, oh, sorry, and this marriage had also been consummated by force.0.69
00:33:23.080Louis, Joanna's husband, armed himself and accompanied by a small party of warriors, boarded the vessel and stabbed Hugh repeatedly with his sword before throwing the corpse of the victim into the sea.
00:33:34.680He was the one who kidnapped Maria, the father of the husband.