Witches of Scotland - February 12, 2022


EPIOSODE 52 DR MIRANDA CORCORAN

Topics
EPISODE 51 PROFESSOR MARION GIBSON EPISODE 53 - PARDONING THE WITCHES OF CATALONIA

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 7 minutes

Words per minute

181.8

Word count

12,301

Sentence count

161

Harmful content

Misogyny

17

sentences flagged

Toxicity

15

sentences flagged

Hate speech

19

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.200 Hi, I'm Clare Mitchell, QC. Welcome to the Witches of Scotland podcast.
00:00:05.220 I'm a lawyer who specialises in miscarriage of justice cases,
00:00:08.740 and we're bringing you this podcast because we want to tell you 0.61
00:00:11.560 about the women who were accused, prosecuted, convicted,
00:00:15.740 and ultimately executed as witches in Scotland.
00:00:18.800 I'm Zoe Vendetotsi, and I'm a writer who's always had an interest in the witches,
00:00:23.040 and I feel that this dark mark against Scotland needs a reckoning.
00:00:26.480 The campaign Witches of Scotland wants three things.
00:00:29.600 Firstly, a pardon for all those convicted of witchcraft.
00:00:33.120 Secondly, an apology for all those who were accused as witches.
00:00:37.420 And finally, a national monument in recognition of all those who were affected by this terrible miscarriage of justice.
00:00:44.420 Over the forthcoming weeks, we'll be talking to a whole host of experts about the history and the modern day connections to the witches of Scotland.
00:00:53.000 Hello and welcome to the Witches of Scotland podcast.
00:00:56.060 this week we are on episode 52 which is i'm just gonna say it again remarkable that's as many weeks
00:01:04.880 as there is in a year if you chose to listen to one of our recordings every week we'll see you
00:01:12.080 through an entire year i mean at what point do we say enough is enough when we run out of guests
00:01:21.020 it's amazing there are so many experts that have covered all the aspects that we could possibly
00:01:27.100 think of to do witchcraft and we've got a huge list of people still to interview so i think this
00:01:32.220 could just keep going forever and ever frankly yeah well i hope for both of our sanity that
00:01:37.920 there is a natural end to this story yes yes at some stage but not but no no but it's still
00:01:46.200 keeping up the level of interest though the level of interest growing i mean the number of people
00:01:51.200 dear podcast listeners is growing so please tell your pals your neighbors anyone that we are uh
00:02:00.040 what are we we're an interesting yeah we're we're certainly we're certainly here we're here we're
00:02:09.160 a podcast we're here deal with it that's yeah i'm not going to talk about the quality the quality of
00:02:15.460 The guess is very good.
00:02:16.940 I mean, our chat beforehand, slightly less.
00:02:20.300 That's less quality.
00:02:21.640 Less quality, slightly less marvellous.
00:02:24.980 No, not really.
00:02:26.460 No, maybe we should get David to cut that out.
00:02:28.920 We should big ourselves up.
00:02:30.540 Sorry.
00:02:33.200 That was David just saying, can you just stop this
00:02:35.700 and get to the bit where you ask me about the news?
00:02:38.480 Exactly.
00:02:39.160 The news, you say, Claire, the news.
00:02:41.560 What do you mean by the news?
00:02:42.780 Do you mean what is happening this week in the news with relevance to which adjacent issues?
00:02:48.180 That's exactly what I mean. I'm not even going to try and repeat that.
00:02:52.400 What's been happening in the news, Claire?
00:02:54.780 Lots has been happening in the news, Zoe.
00:02:57.000 But I think you know what's been happening in the news.
00:03:00.420 Oh, yes, I do. I do know what's been happening in the news.
00:03:03.540 And it's a strange story, but maybe not entirely surprising.
00:03:07.260 Surprising that it's still happening.
00:03:09.500 And I can't believe I'm actually about to tell you this.
00:03:12.200 there is a pastor in Tennessee, in America, who has very recently burned a whole bunch of books
00:03:19.440 that he thinks are demonic. So there's a pastor called Greg Locke, who is described as being
00:03:25.460 controversial, I'll say. He's been burning these books because he's trying to fight
00:03:30.460 quote, demonic influences. And I think this is really, it's not funny at all. It's obviously
00:03:36.480 totally not funny and this guy is a pro-Trump conspiracy theorist so which tells you probably
00:03:42.200 everything you really need to know but he said we will be in our continued series on deliverance
00:03:48.160 from demons we have stuff coming in from all over that we will be burning we're not playing games
00:03:53.520 witchcraft and accursed things must go and so he then said in a sermon that was before it that he
00:04:00.400 was fighting the quote Freemason devils and that quote I ain't gonna be suiciding myself no time
00:04:07.360 soon I ain't messing with witches no more I ain't messing with witchcraft I ain't messing with
00:04:12.620 demons I'll call all of them out in the name of Jesus Christ which he did in front of an audience
00:04:18.260 and then in it this is the part that I think is hilarious he thinks that all these books are
00:04:24.020 really terrible he thinks that they're under attack from demons he then live streamed the
00:04:28.940 burning of the books on Facebook right now I'm just going to make a point here if you're burning
00:04:33.860 books that you think are dangerous for children do you not understand that if they have access
00:04:39.360 the internet they can read and look at anything at all anything anything at all and you have no
00:04:46.140 control over that it's just really bizarre and also the psychology of saying oh we're going to
00:04:51.600 burn books they're so bad they're so dangerous we're going to burn them I mean I can't think
00:04:56.500 of anything that's more likely to get children reading books i would hope so i hope that children
00:05:01.780 in that area are now passing around copies of banned books that they've become like a no joke
00:05:07.420 intended hot topic that they want to pass around so there are pictures there apparently of the
00:05:13.260 different books that have been burned including fahrenheit 451 which is just bizarre and the
00:05:19.300 origin of the species i just think it's really bizarre and also harry potter and twilight you
00:05:26.460 know if i was street twilight i'm sure i would immediately seek how to become a vampire it's
00:05:30.740 just really really strange i mean obviously it is serious because it really speaks to a really
00:05:35.460 intense fear of freedom of expression and a really intense fear of what would be thought of as being
00:05:41.800 liberal kind of ideas there is an ongoing issue at the moment in america and i don't know if this
00:05:46.680 in other countries are just particularly an American thing but the American Library Association
00:05:51.020 the ALA said that there's been what's described as an unprecedented rise in requests for book bans
00:05:57.320 so at moment 330 books are being challenged as objectionable that was in the autumn of 2021
00:06:05.680 and a year before it was 156 books which is still to my mind 156 books too many and there's one
00:06:13.360 particular woman called deborah caldwell stone who said that in her 20 years with the ala i can't
00:06:19.920 recall a time when we had multiple challenges coming in on a daily basis and she's the director
00:06:24.860 of the american library association's office for intellectual freedom it's bizarre i don't
00:06:29.860 understand i don't understand how anybody that knows anything about adolescence would think
00:06:33.760 that by saying to them you can't do this thing that it's not going to make them want to really 0.61
00:06:38.940 really do this thing it's bizarre i just think it's stupid it's also incredibly worrying that 0.94
00:06:44.400 we're being told again that the devil and demonic forces is amongst us because that only goes in one 0.95
00:06:50.280 direction and the direction it goes in is eventually blaming people for being in cahoots
00:06:55.780 with the devil and we find ourselves once again with which i mean you know jokes aside it highlights
00:07:02.160 why it's so important that we do the campaign you know it highlights why we need to keep talking
00:07:07.540 about the fact that you can't blame humans for when you have misfortune in some way you can't
00:07:13.480 superimpose this religious supernatural idea on society and large and try and find somebody to
00:07:18.820 pin the blame on it's a really really dangerous route to go down and in fact this week I watched
00:07:24.960 the film I am not a witch which came out several years ago but was a pick for one of the artists
00:07:29.980 that's got a show on at the DCA in Dundee so the Dundee Contemporary Arts has got a cinema as part
00:07:35.520 of the building there and occasionally they have the artists that have got stuff on in the galleries
00:07:40.540 they choose you know films that they think people should watch so I went along and saw I am not a
00:07:45.740 witch and it was it's an amazing film actually it's meant to be as a satire partly on tourism
00:07:52.680 and part of the idea is that there's this bunch of witches and again that's in inverted commas
00:07:58.000 who live in a witch camp and people pay it seems from the film to go along and view the witches as
00:08:04.680 if they're in a zoo you know it's it's really bizarre but a really great film and it's a little
00:08:09.360 girl an eight-year-old girl who's just sort of turned up in the village who's accused of being
00:08:13.720 a witch and ends up touring with this government official picking out who's guilty in crimes so
00:08:19.080 she acts like the judge and the rest of the witches in the camp are old ladies and they all
00:08:24.920 have this ribbon that they're attached to that's on a big spool because the theory is that the
00:08:30.180 witches can fly as far as the uk so they have to be tethered to these ribbons to stop them from
00:08:35.960 going and doing their witch business and the one hand is kind of funny like the idea of that is
00:08:40.600 kind of funny and there is like definitely sort of like a deadpan humor that goes in the film
00:08:44.420 but on the other hand it just made me think really very clearly about that wee girl that
00:08:49.940 months and months ago we talked about with um lee igway who runs advocacy for alleged witches
00:08:55.360 and there's that wee girl that was accused in her primary school i think she was maybe like
00:08:59.300 six seven eight of being a witch and was chucked out of that school you know there is a real issue
00:09:04.780 with that so if we are talking about in america where you know it's like the epitome of like the
00:09:11.160 modern the cutting edge of things where they're literally burning books because this pastor says
00:09:16.520 he's so scared about demonic forces i would argue that i don't think he's scared demonic forces at
00:09:22.120 all and this is how he makes his money he makes his money by drawing in the crowds who are presumably
00:09:26.480 all tithing or donating or whatever to him and he probably lives in a McMansion and if that's not
00:09:33.060 true I'm happy to discuss it with him on air that'd be very interesting but I think that's just a
00:09:38.300 money-making thing and it's a calculated horrible horrible thing but I think what you're saying
00:09:43.200 Claire is true the natural progression from book burning is to blaming and then there's a human
00:09:47.760 cost I think. Yeah it's really really scary I mean looking up on what you said about I am a witch
00:09:54.600 i really really i'm looking forward to going to see it i hope i will be able to get to see it 0.95
00:09:58.960 but it's so sad that there actually are women and it is mostly women still alive these days
00:10:05.100 living that life and leo egway has to deal with accusations of witchcraft that he has to go and
00:10:12.840 try and persuade the authorities to intervene and to try and prosecute people who are causing
00:10:18.560 alarm and fear and injury to people by calling them witches so it's scary when a country which
00:10:27.000 you would think would have a better view on freedom of speech would allow for books to be
00:10:35.700 read as widely as possible and not for this sort of crazy spectacle I think you're right Zoe there's
00:10:43.980 something about it that you do wonder whether or not it's just to bring in the crowds 100%
00:10:48.400 And, you know, the fact he's live streaming it on Facebook,
00:10:50.800 I mean, that to me is somebody that knows very well
00:10:53.400 what they're doing to get clicks and to get sponsors or whatever
00:10:56.500 and to get money from people that think they're buying into heaven.
00:11:00.080 Yeah, it works because here we are talking about it annoyingly.
00:11:03.960 Yeah, we're talking about it, but very much in a slagging him off sort of a way.
00:11:07.320 I mean, you know, I've got absolutely no respect for that situation at all. 0.96
00:11:10.420 I think it's pathetic. 0.98
00:11:11.680 If you burn a book, I mean, come on. 0.97
00:11:13.320 You might disagree with the content of the book,
00:11:15.260 but let it be there so that other people can disagree
00:11:17.220 with the content of the book.
00:11:18.400 It's such a visceral thing, burning, you know, that we talk about on the podcast.
00:11:22.980 It's a real atavistic, a really base level, the burning of it, the getting rid of it, the erasing it.
00:11:29.800 It's like there's plenty more here, mate.
00:11:31.400 I think he had the temerity as well of drawing a line, a parallel with himself, 0.60
00:11:36.180 that it was like he was fighting the Nazism of demon-y people, demons, demon lovers, demon worshippers.
00:11:42.920 And you're kind of like, dude, you realise that the Nazis burned books. 0.59
00:11:45.840 that was like one of their their things that they did just like I don't want to do a big swear here
00:11:50.960 but I'm thinking lots of swear words keep that rage contained Zoe remember I'm reining it in
00:11:55.800 I'm reining it in about this anyway so that's the first piece of news Claire I believe you have
00:12:03.680 something else on the news agenda yes there's something else in the news agenda now I don't
00:12:08.360 know those of us that follow on Twitter may already have seen that on International Women's Day
00:12:14.380 Laura Graham who is trained as a lawyer and as an artist she is having an event in Edinburgh. Now
00:12:21.980 Laura Graham if those of you want to go back and remember Laura Graham was in episode 40 and we
00:12:27.980 spoke to her about her work involved in the witchcraft trials. So what she has decided to do
00:12:34.460 is on International Women's Day this year she has decided to have an event. Now the event is
00:12:42.240 very early in the morning it's described as the reclaiming of agnes experience and it's at 5 30
00:12:50.100 a.m on march the 8th that's international women's day on calton hill in edinburgh and what she's
00:12:57.900 doing is her project is called exonerate agnes and she is on twitter and you can find her on twitter
00:13:07.100 out at Exonery Agnes you can find her there and we are retweeting what they have tweeted so you
00:13:13.420 can have a look at that and essentially the idea of it is and we're going to actually ask her to
00:13:19.500 come on and speak about it in our next podcast but the idea is that on the days and weeks leading up
00:13:27.660 to the 8th of March Exonery Agnes tweets out the allegations that were made against Agnes and what
00:13:36.340 it was that she was accused of so it's really good if you follow her on twitter you'll be able
00:13:42.640 to see the allegations that have been made out against her when we come to it we thought it
00:13:47.560 might be a good idea if we just gave you some background information in relation to agnes as
00:13:51.940 well so she's the woman today that we're going to remember as i'm really quite excited about it
00:13:57.400 despite the fact that it's a very early start but it's it's a really exciting thing because
00:14:02.280 International Women's Day you know this year that marks two years since we started the campaign
00:14:06.800 and it'll be such an interesting you know to use the word visceral again twice in one podcast
00:14:11.920 it'll be absolutely fascinating to see the spectacle and I think it'll be really moving
00:14:16.620 that Laura's going to put this together and I know that her work that we've discussed before
00:14:21.200 in that other podcast that you mentioned is really incredibly moving and again it just makes
00:14:25.700 the reality of what happened to these people just really present and I think it's going to be a
00:14:31.060 really amazing thing to go and see so i would really encourage people to engage with that and
00:14:34.580 if you are in edinburgh or you feel like traveling to edinburgh it'd be really cool and it'd be nice
00:14:39.080 to meet you because of course we're going to be there alongside laura so it would be really great
00:14:43.360 to meet people if they're coming down to it i should also say that we will try and get laura
00:14:49.000 on to have a word about it and to let us know about it and if you go on to eventbrite and look
00:14:54.120 up exonerate agnes you should be able to get tickets for it as well so give that a look and
00:14:59.460 hopefully we'll speak to her soon about it too but it's free isn't it it's a free event it's just
00:15:05.120 yeah it's just to register i think for numbers particularly absolutely yeah yeah yeah so claire
00:15:10.800 can you tell us a bit about agnes samson okay well agnes samson was a woman who lived in nether
00:15:17.060 keith she was considered at the time to have healing powers and it said that she acted as
00:15:22.820 a midwife. Now she became involved in the witchcraft accusations at the time of James VI. 0.94
00:15:32.700 James VI had returned from Copenhagen after marrying Anne of Denmark as we've spoken about
00:15:37.900 before and he was quite fixated on the idea that the crossings had been so bad because the weather
00:15:44.640 had been turned by witches in order to try and foil him in his return. So when these women were
00:15:52.060 arrested. They were obviously tortured in terms of sleep deprivation, and women confessed to
00:15:58.120 having been guilty of raising storms that threatened the voyage. And there was all sorts
00:16:03.720 of lurids and stories that they sent devils to climb up the keel of the ship. The story of the
00:16:10.020 arrest and the trial and the confession of Agnes Sampson, the reason that we know so much about it
00:16:14.880 was that there was a printed pamphlet printed in London in 1591 called News from Scotland and I
00:16:23.700 would tell anyone that's interested to go and google that there's a Wikipedia page on it called
00:16:28.740 News from Scotland. News is spelt N-E-W-E-S, Newses from Scotland and that provided some contemporary
00:16:36.300 information and trial records so it's a really rich source of information. So Agnes Sampson was
00:16:42.740 accused by Gillis Duncan and was arrested along with others she was questioned regarding her role
00:16:48.240 in the storm raising she was put to torture we believe that that torture was probably sleep
00:16:53.600 deprivation and she confessed a part of her body was shaved we don't know if it was her head
00:16:59.220 but that it was said that she had a witch's mark on her and the proceedings took place in 1591
00:17:07.320 I'll not read out all the news from Scotland but it's definitely worth going and reading the accusations that were made against her and what Agnes was said to have said.
00:17:20.520 Effectively she was said to have confessed to witchcraft.
00:17:24.180 Now, one of the interesting things about the exoneree Agnes project is that what they are doing every day is that they are revealing part of the accusations that were made against Agnes.
00:17:39.340 I'll not go through them in detail, obviously, it's best if you follow on Twitter, because every day you'll see various accusations that were made.
00:17:46.900 but I'll just pick one or two. For example, it was said that Agnes had foreknowledge that a man
00:17:53.540 was a dead man. So obviously she'd refer to someone as being dead when it wouldn't have
00:18:00.020 been commonly known that that person was dead and it was said that that's why she was a witch.
00:18:06.240 It was also said that Agnes worked as a folk healer, that she employed people and there were
00:18:12.100 accusations against her in relation to that healing it was also said for example that Agnes
00:18:18.660 was charged with healing a man so it said that she'd healed the person it was by witchcraft
00:18:24.360 but we don't know any further details of that but that was one of the things she was said to have
00:18:29.740 done so what happened as a result of that and as a result of her confessing to that was that she
00:18:39.020 was in fact questioned by King James himself. He apparently and interestingly was sceptical
00:18:45.180 of the material that she had given in her confession but it was said that she told him
00:18:52.360 things about a conversation that he and Anne had had on their wedding night and that persuaded him
00:18:59.720 that she indeed was a witch. So on the 27th of January 1591 the charges of witchcraft against her
00:19:08.740 were drawn up into 53 different accusations or what's called articles of ditty. She was convicted
00:19:17.320 of those offences. She was taken to the scaffold in Castle Hill where she was strangled and then
00:19:24.000 burnt at the stake. So we remember Agnes Sampson as a woman who was accused of things she couldn't
00:19:31.620 possibly have done, who was convicted as a witch and paid the ultimate burden. We remember Agnes
00:19:38.620 samson today as a woman not a witch that's sad it's a sad story but i think it will be really
00:19:44.980 great to go along to the event on international women's day the 8th of march in edinburgh
00:19:49.600 that laura grame's putting together i think that will be a really interesting way of going along
00:19:54.160 and marking her in particular but the witch hunts and the people that were caught up in it more
00:19:59.060 broadly yeah she's i suppose on every woman in terms of the witchcraft act she could have been
00:20:05.220 any one of the thousands of people that were accused but it just so happens we have more
00:20:09.520 information about her great okay so today's episode of the podcast we are really excited
00:20:17.180 to be speaking to somebody who again we've met on twitter and has posted some really interesting
00:20:23.040 stuff that we think sort of broadens out the conversation generally about the witch hunts
00:20:27.120 so today we're going to be talking to dr miranda corcoran who's a lecturer in 21st century
00:20:33.560 Literature at University College Cork. Her research interests include Cold War literature,
00:20:39.300 genre fiction, popular fiction, sci-fi, horror and the gothic. Dr Corkin has recently just
00:20:44.440 released a book called Witchcraft and Adolescence in American Popular Culture. So without any
00:20:49.920 further ado, we'd like to welcome Miranda to the podcast.
00:21:03.560 our podcast it's really great to have you here we met met's the wrong word but on twitter
00:21:09.880 and I saw what your research area was and I thought this woman sounds like she has got some
00:21:16.120 interesting ideas that our podcast listeners would definitely love so we're really really
00:21:21.440 glad that you agreed to come on so thank you so much oh thank you and thank you so much for having
00:21:25.440 me this is really exciting and I'm so happy to be a part of your podcast and your broader project
00:21:31.420 as well so it's very exciting thank you. That's brilliant so if we could first of all start do
00:21:36.680 you mind just telling our listeners what your area is? So I work broadly in the area of horror
00:21:44.060 the gothic and popular culture so I write a lot on horror as I said on science fiction texts
00:21:53.100 I do a lot on witchcraft in popular culture which is obviously why I'm here I also do some teaching
00:22:01.180 on witchcraft as well I currently run a seminar in my department called witchcraft in the American
00:22:07.120 popular imagination so while I'm interested in obviously witchcraft as a historical phenomenon
00:22:14.960 and witchcraft sort of more broadly as a cultural phenomenon my main interest is in how it manifests
00:22:22.580 in in the media in film television and in popular fiction that's so fascinating I thought when we
00:22:30.100 thought about bringing you on or asking you on I thought about all the different representations
00:22:35.640 of witches that I had to start off with and I don't know whether or not Zoe you'd have been
00:22:40.820 the same but my first witch in popular culture was Tabitha oh yeah yeah from Bewitched oh I love
00:22:47.400 Bewitched she was such a cool witch though she was she was like a really cool kind of benign
00:22:52.880 positive cutesy sort of witch for the most part wasn't she she was I'm always fascinated by her
00:22:58.480 because when I was a kid I was obsessed with Bewitched so that was probably a good indication
00:23:02.980 of where my life would go but they used to show repeats of it on on Channel 4 the British Channel
00:23:08.940 4 early in the mornings when I was a kid and I was just amazed by it because Samantha wasn't some
00:23:15.480 you know sorceress living in an enchanted castle in some fantasy world like in Disney she was just
00:23:22.280 an ordinary woman who had all of this power and I was absolutely amazed by her and I think as I
00:23:28.680 got older obviously I think as with many people I did find myself being a little bit troubled by
00:23:33.520 some of the patriarchal connotations of the series in that obviously Samantha is this massively 0.96
00:23:38.840 powerful woman but she has to rein in her powers and sort of suppress her culture in order to keep
00:23:44.860 her very boring husband Darren happy but now that I've gotten a bit older again and have thought a
00:23:50.340 bit more about it I'm sometimes really impressed by some of the subversive elements of that show
00:23:55.960 and even though you know Samantha's forbidden to use her powers she still does and she gets sometimes
00:24:01.700 she gets away with it and sometimes she doesn't and she uses them in very subversive ways and her
00:24:07.500 mother Indora is a very powerful matriarch so the show actually plays with gender in some really
00:24:12.720 unexpected ways but I absolutely love Bewitched. Yeah Indora was in fact my favorite because she 0.96
00:24:18.500 would always come in as the mother-in-law to go now come on here's how we should be using our powers
00:24:24.160 and I loved her. Yeah and she was just so strong and so confident and men in the witch community 0.99
00:24:29.500 in Bewitched were almost non-existent they didn't have any real power they didn't have any real 0.53
00:24:35.740 strength it was always the women who were powerful in that community which I think is a really 0.99
00:24:39.980 interesting parallel to the middle-class suburban America that Samantha inhabits with Darren.
00:24:46.500 What's really interesting is each generation has its own witch icon, I suppose. And has that been going on for as long as we've had media?
00:24:59.240 I think so. So my focus in my research is very much on witchcraft and adolescence, but I think witches as a whole are such malleable figures that they can be adapted in so many different ways.
00:25:12.680 There's a great quote from Margaret Adler in her book, Drawing Down the Moon, where she researches neo-pagan witchcraft in America.
00:25:21.300 And in that book, she says that the witch has the ability to roam between a myriad of different forms and roam she does. 0.63
00:25:29.240 And I really like that because it sums up just how malleable the witch figure is. The witch as a archetype has so many different functions and can fulfill so many different roles.
00:25:42.440 So obviously you have witchcraft in the sense of neo-pagan witchcraft as a religion. There's historical witchcraft as in the history of the witch trials and witchcraft practices around the world. There are media witches where you can get witches who are good, witches who are evil, witches who are ambiguous.
00:26:00.900 And because the archetype of the witch is so ancient and so all encompassing, the witch as a figure can be put to any use. So it's really interesting to see how witches are adopted by different generations or by different groups for their own ends.
00:26:18.100 and yeah I think every generation does seem to have to have their own witch figures I know when
00:26:23.500 I was a teenager it was probably Sabrina the teenage witch from the 90s sitcom or maybe Willow
00:26:29.020 from Buffy the Vampire Slayer and they were really interesting witches but they were very much for
00:26:33.700 the most part good witches but I've noticed amongst my students the witches that they really
00:26:39.340 like are witches like the girls from American Horror Story Coven or Thomason from The Witch
00:26:44.620 who are much more ambiguous in their morality and in their behavior so it's really interesting to
00:26:49.860 see those shifts it's really interesting I wonder if that's because just absolute pop psychology
00:26:54.920 here I'm 46 so when I was growing up definitely would be bewitched because I was thinking earlier
00:27:00.920 that bewitched ran alongside for me I dream of genie now she's not a witch in that obviously
00:27:04.940 she's a genie but there's very very similar sort of an idea it's just the idea of a magical woman
00:27:10.680 in the home which I think really really formed me in different ways and I know it probably
00:27:15.200 if I was to research it I wouldn't sort of so crassly put them together because they're not
00:27:19.500 the same sort of thing but the idea of a magical having magical powers was quite interesting to me
00:27:24.500 and then I got into Sabrina so that would be sort of towards my sort of middle to late teens that
00:27:30.660 she was out and I definitely was from that because she was so ordinary in many ways she had the same
00:27:35.220 sort of worries and concerns and then I watched probably Practical Magic maybe after that so that 0.99
00:27:40.800 kind of a natural romantic slightly sexy move of witches at that point they weren't like evil they
00:27:48.440 were absolutely like a kind of a good kind of benign probably for the most part sort of an idea
00:27:53.660 and maybe something as a teen girl you'd gravitate towards that because you feel fairly powerless
00:27:58.180 generally so you have this kind of dream that if only I could you know do something magical does
00:28:04.060 your research bear that out that that's why teens are so drawn to witches? It does. I mean, so my
00:28:10.020 research initially begins in the period just after the Second World War, where witch figures are
00:28:17.100 mostly written and explored by adults. So I look, for example, at Marianne L. Starkey's The Devil
00:28:24.560 in Massachusetts, which is a study of the Salem witch trials, and was one of the most influential
00:28:29.940 studies of the Salem witch trials in the post-war period. It was published in 1949 and it was a huge
00:28:35.720 influence on Arthur Miller's The Crucible. So I begin with those texts where you have adults
00:28:40.900 engaging with the figure of the teen witch and mostly what I argue is that adults engage with
00:28:46.380 the figure of the teen witch in some ways as a means of figuring out exactly what this new
00:28:52.240 cultural phenomenon of the teenage girl is and what she means and how she functions. But after
00:28:57.860 that, once you get into the 50s and 60s, you get more books that are either written for teenage
00:29:03.140 girls or books that are adopted by teenage girls. So I look, for example, at The Witch of Blackbird
00:29:10.260 Pond, which was a popular young adult novel from the late 1950s. And I look at the early Sabrina
00:29:15.360 comics, and I very much explore how those works present their young witches as these points of
00:29:22.760 identification for teenage girls, these sort of almost ideal figures. The main character in The
00:29:29.680 Witch of Blackbird Pond, even though she's not actually a witch, it's a historical novel set in
00:29:34.360 New England. She's an accused witch, but she's presented as this very brave, very strong, very
00:29:39.420 idealistic figure. So she's very much an ideal projection of the self for teen girls. In the
00:29:45.200 early Sabrina comics, obviously there's a lot of comedy in them, but Sabrina is primarily presented 0.95
00:29:51.000 as this very glamorous figure whose powers allow her to have the latest fashions and the latest
00:29:56.200 gadgets and they make her very popular so they're very much presented as ideal figures and teenage
00:30:01.820 girls can sort of map their own burgeoning identities onto these ideal figurations of
00:30:08.520 teen girlhood that are sort of accentuated via their association with witchcraft particularly
00:30:14.340 in the case of Sabrina where her powers allow her to you know live out this ideal consumer fantasy
00:30:19.740 but I also look at some texts some witch figures that are a little bit more subversive
00:30:24.400 and allow teenage girls to explore some of their darker fantasies and their darker feelings
00:30:29.460 so I look at Shirley Jackson's We Have Always Lived in the Castle where the protagonist isn't
00:30:35.680 really a witch in that she doesn't actually have magical powers but she does engage in all of these
00:30:40.620 strange rituals she has a cat who basically acts like her familiar so she is a witch figure if not
00:30:47.500 actually a magical witch so I look at that and I look at Stephen King's Carrie as well who as I'm
00:30:53.060 sure you you know she's not again a traditional witch but throughout the novel she's constantly
00:30:58.200 aligned with the figure of the witch and I look at how those characters who are quite murderous
00:31:03.540 and quite violent and quite subversive how they allow teenage girls to explore some of their
00:31:09.560 darker impulses so a lot of my a lot of the work in my book does look at how the witch
00:31:15.240 as a figure by virtue of her other worldliness by virtue of her sort of liminal status or by virtue
00:31:22.480 of her magical abilities how she's allowed to do things that ordinary teenage girls might not be
00:31:27.620 able to and it gives them a space to explore who they are what their desires are whether those are
00:31:33.420 you know good or bad I think that really sort of shores up the idea that we have that we've 0.99
00:31:38.340 encountered a lot during the campaign particularly of people lots of people lots of women primarily
00:31:43.960 really identifying with the idea of the witch as being the subversive woman that's too powerful
00:31:49.080 to exist or you know that this sort of idea which i think is really really interesting
00:31:53.860 psychologically now i am a huge consumer of pop culture i've always been a big tv watcher so i've
00:32:01.520 got no issue with that whatsoever like 100 i love it i love the sort of the fictional representations
00:32:06.300 of witches and things are super interesting but it concerns me that our cultural input with that
00:32:12.900 and output with that obscures then the historical fact absolutely of those accused of being witches
00:32:18.640 you know that they're not they're not the same things and they can exist quite happily together
00:32:22.960 the historical truth and the representations as long as we understand that they're not that's not
00:32:28.480 the same things yes absolutely and that's something I've been very careful especially
00:32:32.880 in the introduction to my own book to separate out the sort of cultural function of the witch
00:32:37.860 from the actual individuals who were accused of witchcraft. I mean, even in the early modern
00:32:45.440 period, when people were being accused and tortured and executed for witchcraft, the witch
00:32:50.200 also served a sort of cultural purpose in terms of, you know, being used as a symbol or a concept
00:32:57.060 in debates about religion or the role of women and so on. And this is something that, for example,
00:33:02.120 Stuart Clark talks about in his book, Thinking with Demons. So witches have always had a sort
00:33:06.980 of conceptual function as well as their sort of real world or the real world reality of witch
00:33:13.400 trials and torture and executions. And I have very much been trying to separate those things out in
00:33:19.740 the introduction to my book. I think so many of our ideas, as you said, are very much obscured by
00:33:26.520 cultural representations and the various cultural work people have done, various groups have done
00:33:32.160 with the figure of the witch so for example second wave feminism made very heavy use of the figure of
00:33:38.600 the witch from groups like the women's international terrorist conspiracy from hell they were a radical
00:33:44.940 feminist group in the u.s in the 1960s so it's an acronym which women's international terrorist
00:33:50.340 conspiracy from hell why have we never heard of this oh it's really interesting so i was i was
00:33:55.760 trying to keep them away from you they used to dress up as witches and they would do things like
00:34:03.780 hex the New York Stock Exchange while dressed as witches or once they ran through like a bridal
00:34:09.020 fair um dressed as witches and like they were a really interesting group and their performances
00:34:13.720 were like disruptive and really fascinating but there's also like a massive issue with how second
00:34:19.360 wave feminism has treated the figure of the witch you know if you think of people like you know
00:34:24.120 Ernrich and English for example or Mary Daly people like that who have this very sort of
00:34:30.280 romanticized view of the witch and who essentially turn the witch trials and the European witch hunts
00:34:38.640 and the North American witch hunts as well into a sort of you know gynocide and a sort of targeted
00:34:43.440 attack on women they've you know inflated the numbers of women executed for witchcraft into
00:34:49.700 the millions or they often describe women who are executed as being you know midwives and healers
00:34:55.780 and these wise women and a lot of these ideas are older a lot of them come from people like
00:35:00.540 Jules Michelet and Matilda Jocelyn Gage but they've been really influential in terms of how
00:35:07.720 we as a culture view witchcraft and you still see that in the you know we are the granddaughters of
00:35:13.320 the witches you couldn't burn meme it's like it's really really pervasive and in a way it is
00:35:18.920 fascinating to me how our understanding of witches is so colored by the use that various
00:35:26.700 political groups various producers of literary and popular culture have made of them and it
00:35:32.280 seems like that almost functions as an intermediary or in some cases almost like a roadblock that's
00:35:37.560 kind of preventing us from you know exploring the actual and far more complex history of the witch
00:35:44.080 trials so I'm very clear in my own work that what I'm doing is I'm looking at the cultural
00:35:48.780 representations of witchcraft and the cultural representations of the witch as opposed to the
00:35:54.340 actual history because there's enough material there to work with you know with the real life
00:36:00.380 historical facts there's no need for people to exaggerate it in any way exactly as it was yeah
00:36:06.440 exactly and it's you know and also fascinating enough as it was as well as a reflection of you
00:36:12.280 know the power dynamics of the early modern period gender roles it's you know it's really
00:36:17.340 interesting as it is but people I think again it kind of comes back to that point I was making
00:36:22.340 earlier that the witch is so malleable and the archetype is so broad in some ways that people
00:36:27.860 will make whatever use they can of the witch and in some ways that's interesting it's created some
00:36:33.060 really fascinating works of art and some really fascinating pieces of literature and film but on
00:36:38.620 the other hand sometimes it does result in some very inaccurate perceptions of witchcraft and the
00:36:44.620 witch trials being sort of absorbed into popular culture and being described as reality when in
00:36:52.220 fact they come out of quite often first and second wave feminism and their use of the witch as an
00:36:57.700 archetype as opposed to you know actual historical women who were accused of a very specific crime.
00:37:03.100 you're absolutely right about the block issue because one of the things that we had when we
00:37:09.020 started I mean we started an international women's day 2020 with the campaign and one of the
00:37:14.340 difficulties that we had was at the start getting people to understand what we were talking about
00:37:20.920 because people actually just they treated it as as fun I think we were getting phoned by
00:37:25.940 journalists that wanted to do you know a silly piece or they they're trying to pardon witches
00:37:33.020 and then when you actually spoke to people and said what we're talking about is thousands of
00:37:37.660 people that suffered the most brutal miscarriage of justice in Scotland it was a high percentage
00:37:43.280 of women than it is elsewhere in Europe was 84 percent our experts tell us were women
00:37:47.900 and when we actually told them the story they were really receptive to it but there's and it's not
00:37:54.280 surprising there are layer upon layer of cultural ideas that we have about witches which make it
00:38:01.220 okay to treat them as a joke so when we're talking about the actual history of people
00:38:06.460 they're like well that's jokes I mean we had a good article in a newspaper recently really
00:38:11.840 positive article about the campaign about it's what we wanted out of it about why we wanted it
00:38:17.540 about the modern resonances with violence against women about modern resonances with other people
00:38:23.640 in the world who's still accused of witchcraft and the article was brilliant but the picture
00:38:28.180 they put beside it was a woman with a green face and a pointy hat oh no just you're just it was
00:38:35.500 obviously like someone just phoned the pictures desk was like we need a photo of a witch give us
00:38:39.900 a witch yeah it's it's irritating but it's not something that I would have thought greatly about
00:38:45.780 before getting involved in this campaign I have noticed little improvements though I've noticed
00:38:50.380 more now when articles come out that they have witches generally in quotation marks so they're
00:38:56.580 getting the message that they weren't actually witches which I think is really interesting I'm
00:39:01.060 not taking complete credit for that with the campaign but I do feel like that's had something
00:39:04.720 to do with that that there is an understanding now that they weren't actually witches which
00:39:09.660 seems to be to be the most obvious thing that you could draw from the story but a lot of people still
00:39:14.900 struggle with it you know I sort of didn't get into an argument with somebody on Twitter obviously
00:39:19.140 that would be foolish but I did say to somebody on Twitter that you know it doesn't matter what
00:39:23.880 else they were you know they might have been murderers they might have been you know robbers 0.98
00:39:28.960 you know they could have killed their children whatever if it was for witchcraft that they
00:39:32.860 would accuse and executed that's not factual that's you know so there's no point in obscuring
00:39:38.380 about going well some of them were criminals so what like that that's not the point that we're
00:39:42.920 making they still weren't witches exactly absolutely and I do remember a couple of years
00:39:48.280 ago before the pandemic I went to Salem which was kind of the fulfillment of a childhood dream for
00:39:56.140 me because I've been obsessed with Salem ever since I was I was very young but I do remember
00:40:00.480 I took a very good like very historically rigorous guided walking tour and someone did ask at the end
00:40:06.540 you know were they actually witches so I think that idea is still pervasive and I think sometimes
00:40:15.020 I think it kind of comes from two places in the sense that there is an element of ignorance but
00:40:19.620 then again there is also the massive cultural impact of again second wave feminism and the
00:40:26.280 use they've made of witchcraft and the way they did frame accused witches as healers as well as
00:40:31.740 kind of works like you know obviously you've Margaret Murray's work and the the whole idea
00:40:35.540 of the witch cult and a lot of that I think has seeped into popular culture as well so that
00:40:40.320 sometimes people do assume that even if, you know, people accused of witchcraft in the early modern
00:40:45.880 period, even if they weren't flying around on broomsticks, and even if they weren't green-faced
00:40:50.380 cackling hags, maybe they were part of one of these, you know, pre-Christian witch cults. So
00:40:55.240 I think it's just fascinating how all of these ideas have sort of percolated within the culture,
00:41:01.720 and it leads so many people to still view individuals accused of witchcraft as witches
00:41:07.300 of some degree even though obviously they weren't this very week we've had news that a pastor in
00:41:14.380 America who's described as a far-right pastor called Greg Locke has been suggesting has not 0.90
00:41:21.420 only been suggesting but has held a book burning event to burn evil garbage like young adult fantasy 0.62
00:41:27.020 books including books on witchcraft like Harry Potter and stuff like that that seems to me to be
00:41:34.080 the oddest thing that you can possibly do to draw attention to this as some kind of realistic magic
00:41:41.040 it seems really really weird yeah absolutely especially since so many of those books are
00:41:46.300 like high fantasy as well I mean they're not even they're not even grounded in reality
00:41:52.200 it seems even in some ways more extreme than you know the satanic panic of the 1980s
00:41:57.580 and the early 90s when people were concerned that teenagers were engaging in witchcraft and
00:42:02.260 satanism that that seemed at least somewhat more grounded though it was awful and the you know the
00:42:09.160 results of that you know led to so many people being imprisoned and having their lives ruined
00:42:13.700 for again for nothing but it seemed at least somewhat grounded whereas the books that are
00:42:20.600 being attacked in this context are high fantasy very much otherworldly kind of books which is
00:42:27.420 you know strange in many ways it just reminds me of the fact now i must have been reading an
00:42:32.020 article about this it mentioned something to do with zoophilia but the idea of the obsession at
00:42:37.980 the time and in the confessions of having sex with animals i presume that's that's what it is
00:42:42.640 the whole idea that the that satan was animalistic and and so on like it just always just makes me
00:42:48.540 think that these pastors are just they're having really big repressed sexual feelings and their
00:42:54.600 whole burning is just because they just can't deal with those feelings and they can't name whatever
00:42:58.760 it is it's going on inside their own minds there's a real parallel between that and the way that
00:43:03.600 confessions were extracted during the witch trials the witch hunts in Scotland particularly
00:43:09.360 the subjugation of the women and of them being stripped and the whole sexual dynamic I just
00:43:14.560 always think with those pastors dudes just relax explore your sexuality it's okay we support you
00:43:21.980 it's modern it's cool you don't need to burn young adult books also I think it's very bizarre that
00:43:27.980 they think that's going to make one iota of difference to what these young people sort of
00:43:31.500 consume because they can get the internet so what difference does it make because they could go on
00:43:37.180 they can log on to tiktok or instagram or whatever and see far more than the printed page where they
00:43:44.180 have to use their imagination you know i just think it's totally bizarre it is and it's clearly
00:43:48.120 very symbolic as well i mean it's all about the show and the spectacle of burning something
00:43:53.460 publicly it's not about actually destroying the books or making sure that young people aren't
00:43:58.960 accessing them it's this it's this big show and this kind of reaffirmation of the other adults
00:44:04.380 yeah exactly exactly and for the media as well yeah yeah it's just is there any reason or thing
00:44:12.120 that you have researched on as to why witches at the moment have had an absolute explosion in
00:44:19.780 popular culture you know Instagram, TikTok they're everywhere and modern day witches people
00:44:26.100 identifying as witches do you think that's as a result of the 50s and 60s and 70s that's why
00:44:32.640 it is happening now? I think some of it has to do with I mean firstly the internet and the kind of
00:44:39.560 ease of access to knowledge about these things I know that a lot of scholars of witchcraft and
00:44:45.100 scholars of teen witchcraft in particular talk about the emergence of the internet in the
00:44:49.600 1990s and the witchcraft related chat rooms and you know websites that helped a lot of young people
00:44:55.600 connect and become interested in witchcraft and I know it's something that Peg Alloy for example
00:45:00.440 in the U.S. writes extensively about so it is something you see in the 90s but I think it's
00:45:05.260 becoming at least partially more pervasive because again of things like TikTok and Instagram and
00:45:11.420 having access to these sorts of things and access to information about witchcraft. Last year I had
00:45:17.960 some students do an excellent project for me as part of my witchcraft seminar that was all about
00:45:22.560 witchcraft on social media and how teenagers and young women use social media to connect,
00:45:29.000 to share information about spells and rituals and Wiccan and neo-pagan beliefs. So I think a lot of
00:45:35.700 it has to do with the increased accessibility of information, but I think that part of it also has
00:45:41.200 to do with just the current political climate as well, and particularly the political climate during
00:45:47.200 the Trump era and the Trump presidency. I do remember reading a lot of articles during those
00:45:53.900 years about groups that had gotten together to hex Trump or hex Brett Kavanaugh or some other
00:46:00.060 very misogynistic politician. So there was a great deal of visibility there. That radical feminist
00:46:05.760 group that I mentioned, which the Women's International Terrorist Conspiracy from Hell, 0.98
00:46:10.220 they reformed under the Trump presidency. So I think some of it was sort of based on that sort
00:46:16.120 second wave idea that second wave feminist idea of the witch as a powerful woman and feminist icon 0.61
00:46:22.420 or a victim of patriarchal violence and I think a lot of women at that time as things like
00:46:27.960 reproductive rights were being eroded sort of identified with that the other thing I noticed
00:46:34.340 and I think it was kind of the thing that encouraged me to write my book was the explosion
00:46:38.680 of witches in popular culture as well during the 2010s so the 2010s gave us things I mean obviously
00:46:45.200 there have always been witches and teen witches in popular culture, but the 2010s had a really
00:46:50.200 high concentration of them. So it gave us things like The Witch, American Horror Story, Coven,
00:46:56.460 The Chilling Adventures of Sabrina, which was initially a comic and then a television series.
00:47:01.660 So there was this real explosion of very morally ambiguous witches in the media, witches who
00:47:07.400 weren't evil or heroic, but sort of more complex figures. And often these witches had to deal with
00:47:14.340 things like agency, consent, sexual violence. And I think a lot of that ties into the Me Too
00:47:22.700 movement as well. And these kinds of questions about, again, about consent and about rape culture.
00:47:27.640 And a lot of the teen witch texts from the 2010s are very much interested in young women who use
00:47:35.500 witchcraft as a means to explore their own agency and make their own choices about their lives and
00:47:40.820 their bodies so I think a lot of it has to do with the political climate as well as you know
00:47:45.120 obviously the internet and social media. That's utterly fascinating and something I hadn't really
00:47:49.860 considered in that way before. Why do you think it is that it's a way for young women to test out
00:47:59.020 their theories in the world or consider their position in the world? Why do you think that we 0.97
00:48:03.360 have to do that in the context of a witch idea rather than just having ordinary icons is it about
00:48:13.340 the witch that draws us to it I mean I think a lot of it has to do with how girls and women are
00:48:21.160 framed or treated in the world in that women are and especially young women and you know teenage
00:48:28.000 girls are not allowed to explore their sexuality are not allowed to explore their own agency or
00:48:35.580 their own sort of darker desires or their own sort of more socially unacceptable you know socially 0.66
00:48:41.480 unacceptable in air quotes impulses and I think fantasy figures like the witch sort of give them
00:48:47.560 a safe arena in which to explore some of their more complex feelings about themselves and about
00:48:54.100 their bodies and about growing up and the kind of transformations inherent in that. And I think
00:49:01.040 that because the witch is so often associated with a certain kind of set of key magical abilities,
00:49:07.160 things like flight and transformation, things that often kind of center around the body and
00:49:13.080 how it moves and how it kind of transforms from one state to the other. There are lots of parallels
00:49:18.520 between the experience of puberty and growing up and the figure of the witch. So I think the witch 0.87
00:49:24.500 is kind of useful in that sense. And also, of course, the witch is generally in fiction,
00:49:29.780 powerful. And I think that power is appealing to young women, especially in this kind of more
00:49:36.240 ambiguous incarnation that we're seeing now in the 2010s, where they can use their power for good,
00:49:41.920 or they can use their power for evil, or they can use their power to be selfish, which, again, 0.98
00:49:46.720 is something that women often aren't allowed to be like one thing that always strikes me in the
00:49:52.280 witch and I've had loads of debates with people about the ending of the 2015 film the witch whether
00:49:57.180 it's empowering or whether she's just signed herself over to be you know the servant of the
00:50:02.240 devil and serve another man one thing I always point out one thing that always interests me
00:50:07.060 is that the thing that makes her say yes I will sign your book you know yes I will become a witch 0.96
00:50:14.060 and serve you as, you know, the devil. The thing that makes her do that isn't really the fact that 0.74
00:50:19.440 her entire family is dead or that she's on her own. It's the fact that the devil says to her,
00:50:24.680 you know, wouldst thou like the taste of butter? Wouldst thou like pretty dresses to travel the
00:50:29.300 world? And I know some of that comes from a real case of witchcraft possession in the 17th century,
00:50:34.460 the case of Elizabeth Knapp. But the fact that she agrees to become a witch and serve the devil
00:50:40.600 because he offers her nice things i think it's really appealing she's allowed to be selfish and
00:50:45.980 to want things and desire things and that's often something that we just don't let teenage girls do
00:50:50.920 i don't know if either of the two of you saw at the weekend on twitter someone had taken
00:50:55.620 screenshots of all the t-shirts for young women in a high street store and it was like optimistic
00:51:02.940 be joyful happy and it was just it was constant direction be a good girl you know keep your
00:51:10.360 chin up and serve the Lord you know it was a bit it was yeah toxic positivity I think is what is
00:51:16.280 what they're calling it online now and I think there is a lot of that you know for young women
00:51:22.200 that sense that you have to be optimistic you have to smile I know there's been a lot of online
00:51:27.340 discourse about men telling young women to smile and that it's it's almost become a meme you know
00:51:32.020 that you'd be prettier if you smile think but I think there is an expectation especially for young
00:51:37.740 women to be polite and pleasant and yielding and accommodating and I think some of these darker 0.83
00:51:44.820 kind of 2010s which is they allow girls to defy that and they can be violent and they can be 0.73
00:51:51.520 messy and they can be dark and they can be selfish and it's this conceptual space where they can play
00:51:56.780 out those darker things that teenage girls aren't supposed to want or do. I think there definitely
00:52:02.480 needs to be a dark and messy t-shirt totally buy that yeah yeah same it's much more accurate with
00:52:09.460 the teen girl experience it's not like a nice and pleasant situation to be a teen girl i work in a
00:52:16.420 secondary school i've got a teen daughter and i remember vividly what it's like to be a teen it's
00:52:21.740 hideous oh yeah i think sort of the battleground of being a teen explains partly why we gravitate
00:52:27.640 towards the idea of having magical powers you know I hadn't thought about Carrie as being
00:52:33.000 like a witch you know I hadn't hadn't really made that connection but actually that's really
00:52:37.860 really perfect you know I really like that yeah it's it's in the book I don't think they really
00:52:43.060 touch on it there's a bit in the film where her mother calls her a witch because of her powers
00:52:47.920 but there's a lot of it in the book where Carrie there's a bit where Carrie's lying in bed and she
00:52:52.160 fantasizes about being a witch and like riding through the town and souring milk and overturning
00:52:57.300 butter turns and all of this stuff and again there's like a pleasure in that there's a pleasure
00:53:02.180 in destruction and violence which again teenage girls aren't associated with you know teenage 0.97
00:53:07.340 girls aren't supposed to be violent or just or um destructive they might be on the receiving end of
00:53:12.460 those impulses but they're not supposed to be that and like you're right you could not pay me
00:53:17.220 to be a teenager again it was awful and it was messy and i was insecure and like my body felt
00:53:24.960 uncomfortable like you never feel right in your body as when you're a teenage girl and I'm sure
00:53:30.380 like there's definitely a parallel for boys as well but like certainly as a teenage girl your
00:53:35.160 body just feels like this surface that's erupting and I think that's probably one of why there are
00:53:39.800 so many horror films centered around teenage girls I mean obviously you have Carrie but even
00:53:44.140 things like Jennifer's Body and Ginger Snaps there are all these films that associate adolescent
00:53:49.700 girlhood with monstrosity and with transformation and with horror because in many ways it is really
00:53:56.820 horrible it's sort of adjacent to poltergeist stories to the idea that that's teen girls and
00:54:02.740 it's this excess of energy that you know that then sort of seeps out in other ways it's so
00:54:08.140 fascinating it's really been great speaking to you you're just you're it's wonderful and we'll
00:54:13.120 put links up to things that people can go and find your writing and you mentioned what's your
00:54:18.300 book called so my book is called teen witches witchcraft and adolescence in american popular
00:54:23.980 culture and it looks at everything from spiritualism and how that's connected to
00:54:29.240 teenage girls because it was founded by the fox sisters who were teenage girls right up to things
00:54:34.500 like american horror story and the witch i was listening to a podcast about the foxes today
00:54:39.400 well they were mentioned in one about the great psychic fraud one that i'm listening to at the
00:54:43.920 moment and they were talking about that and i was just thinking about the idea of poltergeists and
00:54:48.260 I'm a secondary I'm a high school teacher I was talking to my kids today my third years who are
00:54:52.900 like sort of 14 15 about fear we're doing Macbeth so I was talking to them about when Macbeth sort
00:54:58.280 of loses the plot and he imagines Banco's ghost and we were talking about whether that's real and
00:55:03.140 what your brain does when you're under stress and I just think it's so fascinating as a writer and
00:55:07.980 English teacher I just think it's amazing that we can construct these stories that help to kind of
00:55:12.820 get through those difficult patches and I definitely think that the connection that many
00:55:17.620 young girls feel with witch stories with representations of fictional witches just to
00:55:23.140 be super super clear about it it's really helpful I think in some ways you know learn to accommodate
00:55:29.840 the burden of being a woman it's actually really important as you say Zoe not only to treat these
00:55:34.660 things as differently but to point out also we love witch stories I mean so hopefully
00:55:39.440 to me recently oh well you can't ban what's it called zoom on the broom no room on the broom
00:55:46.560 broom on the broom it was it was a child's book about yeah it's a great book oh yeah yeah i'm
00:55:53.140 definitely not into the business of banning or even burning books never which is but we just
00:55:59.320 all we want is restore these people to their proper place in history and make it clear that
00:56:06.640 whatever ideas we have now and however we use the witch as a construct it didn't actually apply to
00:56:12.920 these people i'm so glad we've managed to make it to the end without actually bursting into flames
00:56:17.360 at the idea of we are the granddaughters of the witch oh yeah that's a pet peeve of mine as well
00:56:24.840 just because it's it's very simplistic and it ties into i think what is a very problematic
00:56:33.720 romanticization of the witch trials and a distortion of the witch trials that you get
00:56:40.020 I say second wave feminism but you see it in like Matilda Jocelyn Gage's work as well at the end of
00:56:44.740 the 19th century and it's very much a distortion of reality and a romanticization of something that
00:56:51.300 was not only brutal and violent but also really complicated like in like there are parts of the
00:56:58.740 world where the majority of like Scandinavia and Russia for example where the majority of accused
00:57:03.860 witches were men like it's witch trials are such a complex phenomenon that it's very reductive
00:57:10.100 to position witches as these heroic victims of patriarchal violence you know it's it's so
00:57:18.060 simplistic one of the things that we've mentioned as well is well what what does that say for the
00:57:22.400 women that were burned like are they lesser like to me it's in the same sort of ballpark as people 0.98
00:57:28.320 that die of cancer like that they didn't fight hard enough that stupid idea we've got about 0.99
00:57:33.300 you're battling you know I just think it's just baloney I just think it's total nonsense and like 1.00
00:57:37.620 we said before there's enough there's enough there to work with you know there's so much and I hate 0.98
00:57:42.460 the idea that it's romanticized where we have this idea that they were nubile redheads that were 0.51
00:57:48.880 that were going you know get lost to the man and that's what happened you know it just doesn't
00:57:53.020 such an enormous disservice absolutely to like the calm and also like the complex personalities
00:57:59.120 of people who were accused of witchcraft I mean my interest is very much American pop culture so I
00:58:05.400 you know I look a fair bit at Salem because it's had such an influence on American pop culture
00:58:09.560 but like if you look at the variety of people accused of witchcraft in Salem you have people
00:58:14.940 including you know a former town minister a disgruntled beggar woman some teenage girls
00:58:21.960 some children you know it was such a variety of people that to reduce them all to these you know
00:58:28.860 adult quite sexualized and sexually liberated women who were you know maybe closely associated
00:58:36.080 with nature and healing like that reduces a really complex story to like one type of person
00:58:41.920 but Salem's just such a perfectly American setup it's like it's already it's been written as a
00:58:47.620 script that you could have all these different actresses playing all the different parts it's
00:58:52.060 so fascinating I think what's particularly amazing is that the story of the witchcraft trials were
00:58:58.040 people who absolutely had no agency and that was part of the problem that was part of the problem 0.93
00:59:04.220 they were people without any agency they were without any power they were people who were easy
00:59:09.340 to pick on and blame your ills on and it's so funny how we now transform that in the 21st century to
00:59:16.280 something which allows young people women to explore their lives and to gain power from it
00:59:23.160 It's such a reversal from what the actual story was.
00:59:26.100 It just absolutely fascinates.
00:59:27.580 It is.
00:59:28.200 And I guess it's just an example of how an idea can evolve over time as well.
00:59:34.160 The idea that if in the early modern period,
00:59:36.720 O'Wich was someone who was stripped of all agency
00:59:39.600 and all opportunities to determine the course of their life
00:59:42.920 by being imprisoned and being tortured and maybe executed,
00:59:47.100 and that evolved over the course of like four or five centuries
00:59:50.080 into someone who is basically the epitome of agency 1.00
00:59:54.200 and strength and feminine power.
00:59:56.440 It's really fascinating to see that evolution.
01:00:00.340 Now, just finally, can we ask you,
01:00:02.320 and you don't have to agree with us,
01:00:03.860 we ask this often,
01:00:05.700 whether or not you think that our idea,
01:00:08.420 our campaign for the pardon, the apology,
01:00:11.200 and the National Memorial,
01:00:12.920 for it, against it, neutral on it?
01:00:15.020 I'm for it.
01:00:15.820 It is something you see in Salem, by the way, 0.59
01:00:18.180 like the descendants of rebecca nurse who was an elderly woman executed for witchcraft during the
01:00:23.320 salem witch trials they got a monument to her in the 19th century yeah yeah and hold that up as an
01:00:30.420 example of better practice than scholars and also then obviously over the course of the 20th century
01:00:36.080 other witches were pardoned some of them only very very recently and there is a very you know
01:00:40.960 a very beautiful monument to those executed for witchcraft in the middle of salem so i mean i'm
01:00:46.500 absolutely in favor of of pardoning people who you know still I guess bear the stigma of being
01:00:54.560 executed for a crime that like not only did they not commit but they couldn't possibly have
01:00:59.160 committed exactly well thank you so much we really really appreciate you coming to speak to us oh
01:01:04.260 thank you absolutely fascinating thank you thanks so much for having me
01:01:16.500 So thanks for joining us for this week's episode. It's been fantastic. I love the discussion about cultural stories about witches. I think it's really fascinating. And I love the idea that they're such a big part of our culture.
01:01:29.820 And I know we've mentioned this already in the chat with Miranda, but we're not wanting to ban witches generally. We just want to make sure the people that were accused of being witches are recognised as not being witches.
01:01:41.060 and women aren't called witches as a derogatory term if people identify and reclaim the term
01:01:47.760 witch and are using that to describe themselves that's all good but not to be used as a term of
01:01:54.300 abuse against women yeah for sure for sure so I would say what we normally say every episode which
01:02:01.140 is please do get in touch with us on our social media we love to chat to people and you know as
01:02:05.480 I've already mentioned that's where we find a lot of our guests because either it's people that are
01:02:09.440 already using twitter that are really interesting or it's people that get in touch with us to say
01:02:13.140 hey do you know about this person that's an expert on this particular facet so thanks for getting in
01:02:17.740 touch those people that do already but please keep it coming it's nice so we can chat to you on
01:02:21.820 twitter that's the best chatty one to do we've also got a page on facebook that's not private
01:02:27.780 or anything it's just a page that you can like and then you get lots of information from us about
01:02:32.400 anything that's coming up that's you know of interest and then also there's instagram which
01:02:36.920 is pretty popular i'm going to keep mentioning the tiktok even though we haven't really done
01:02:41.000 one tiktok and i think so we should do another tiktok on international women's day the thing
01:02:46.360 is though claire i'm not sure that the raccoons are going to be trained for that time i mean
01:02:51.920 they're showing promise you know they're taking they're taking their time but i think it'll be
01:02:57.420 worth it ultimately i'm a lot skeptical of that because the last time we discussed things it was
01:03:04.160 in fact ravens you said you were training oh no i'm training ravens and raccoons of course yeah
01:03:09.680 i've got both going on i've got other animals too that i'm training i can't talk about that though
01:03:13.920 because that's um governmental but the raccoons and the ravens i've got quite a serious work
01:03:19.940 schedule with them yeah yeah the raccoons are not learning phrases presumably but the ravens are
01:03:26.960 that what the raccoons do is the raccoons come up with the phrases and then type them out on
01:03:31.780 miniature typewriters that I've commissioned with their tiny little hands I read them out to the
01:03:37.080 ravens the ravens then do the phrase so that's how it works Claire I mean it's pretty obvious
01:03:42.940 and this is ridiculous like I'm I'm sliding into this awful sort of mid midlife sort of senility
01:03:49.560 where I'm actually living through these imaginary troops of animals listen it's fantastic to imagine 0.91
01:03:57.360 that you have you know some ravens that you're teaching to smash the patriarchy with their tiny
01:04:03.180 tiny little raven beaks there is the guy on twitter who we follow who is an expert on corvids
01:04:10.300 who i would like to get on the show if i could just think of a good angle to tie in with witches
01:04:15.780 and it will come to me eventually something will happen where i'll be like aha now we can ask him
01:04:20.800 let us know through twitter if you'd be interested in just an episode on corvids with an expert
01:04:28.560 ladies and gentlemen do not encourage this type of behavior it's bad enough you can already see
01:04:34.740 so cool they're so cool lives in a world an imaginary world of ravens and raccoons don't
01:04:42.140 encourage it i'm sorry so just going back to being an adult again i would just like to remind people
01:04:48.280 as well that we've got merchandise and we've got the buy me a coffee thing that goes towards david
01:04:53.360 our poor beleaguered hard-working podcast engineer who obviously was only going to do six and was
01:05:00.640 motivated initially by shame at how poor our initial episode was and he's still here after 52
01:05:07.760 episodes i feel really bad i just want to make it really clear that we don't have david chained up
01:05:13.320 in a basement full of ravens and raccoons working away on different podcasts he has got a tether
01:05:20.680 we let him out into the garden only joking
01:05:24.160 now david's been co-opted into my imagination and the thing is that i've not even met david
01:05:33.420 you've not no no he's heard a lot of your man that poor poor man that's a shame but anyway we
01:05:41.860 have got the merchandise that's available so please do buy some of it for for david and his escape
01:05:47.720 fund oh god right okay is there anything else we need to say at this stage other than i'm really
01:05:55.440 sorry and i'm just going to go and have a lie down now there's nothing else we need to say except we
01:06:00.080 look forward to speaking to you again in a couple of weeks and that will be our last podcast before
01:06:05.340 international women's days oh hang on there is one thing i want to say um it's not a silly thing
01:06:10.900 this time it's serious we've just done a whole bunch of really interesting interviews that are
01:06:15.460 going to be going out in media sources that are international we've spoken recently to I think
01:06:20.220 two or three French outlets we've spoken to one that is an international news agency that's got
01:06:27.880 something like 155 clients worldwide so that might go up with them and also we've got an interview
01:06:33.640 lined up next week i think with german press agency and an international magazine and i don't
01:06:41.000 think we can say anything about what we're doing today but it's a cool thing that's coming up that
01:06:44.200 when we are able to tell you about it you're going to get into it that's the worst when people do
01:06:48.600 that but that was a that's a genuine one i can't tell you about it instead of people on twitter
01:06:52.500 they go i've got the most exciting news but i can't tell you what it is what is it you've got
01:06:57.300 a cinnamon danish for your tea tonight that totally would be exciting news we've managed
01:07:02.560 to get cake in there somehow Zoe
01:07:04.120 Oh my god, all the tropes of a middle aged
01:07:06.560 woman, it's really sad 0.99
01:07:07.840 Can I just inform you Zoe that the usual tropes
01:07:10.520 of a middle aged woman are not raccoons and 0.71
01:07:12.560 ravens, just FYI 1.00
01:07:14.080 Well it just depends on the circles you're moving
01:07:16.700 Bye
01:07:18.340 Bye 1.00
01:07:19.420 If you'd like to learn more about the Witches 1.00
01:07:22.740 of Scotland, please subscribe
01:07:24.380 wherever you get your podcasts
01:07:25.880 Sign up for our mailing list
01:07:27.980 at www.witchesofscotland.com
01:07:32.020 to keep updated with the campaign.
01:07:34.580 On that site, you'll be able to find how to link with us
01:07:37.280 on Twitter, Facebook and Instagram.