00:00:00.200Hi, I'm Clare Mitchell, QC. Welcome to the Witches of Scotland podcast.
00:00:05.200I'm a lawyer who specialises in miscarriage of justice cases,
00:00:08.740and we're bringing you this podcast because we want to tell you about the women who were accused,
00:00:13.800prosecuted, convicted, and ultimately executed as witches in Scotland.
00:00:18.780I'm Zoe Vendetotsi, and I'm a writer who's always had an interest in the witches,
00:00:23.040and I feel that this dark mark against Scotland needs a reckoning.
00:00:26.500The campaign Witches of Scotland wants three things.
00:00:29.600Firstly, a pardon for all those convicted of witchcraft.
00:00:33.240Secondly, an apology for all those who were accused as witches.
00:00:37.420And finally, a national monument in recognition of all those who were affected by this terrible miscarriage of justice.
00:00:44.420Over the forthcoming weeks, we'll be talking to a whole host of experts about the history and the modern day connections to the witches of Scotland.
00:00:53.980Hello and welcome to the Witches of Scotland podcast.
00:00:56.980we're delighted to tell you that this week's episode is in fact our 30th episode which is
00:01:02.420very exciting and strange because i think when claire and i first started we thought there'd
00:01:06.160maybe be six this is 30 of six we should just start marking them you know this is 30 of six
00:01:12.180this is 31 of six oh why so i mean there's obviously enough material and this week is
00:01:19.140is definitely a fantastic one we've got a really interesting independent scholar that's going to
00:01:23.880be talking to us but more of that later. I think first of all Claire we're going to do a roundup
00:01:28.140of this week's news. Sure that makes it sound much more newsy than we are. Listeners contact us all
00:01:35.820the time sending us stuff and we're absolutely delighted. We do try and keep a list and a wee
00:01:40.880note of who's contacted us for what reason and through the various podcasts we will hopefully
00:01:46.420give people mentions and discuss what they're contacting with us. Last week as you'll remember
00:01:51.900we spoke for a bit about women in public, particularly women politicians, being called
00:01:59.240witches and witch analogies being used about them. And I think we touched upon that last week.
00:02:06.180And we were contacted by one of our listeners from Australia, Teagan, who says that she has
00:02:11.540been really enjoying the podcast and she wants to flag up an example of the former Prime Minister
00:02:17.320of Australia, Julia Gillard, and wanted to add her to the list of the people who had suffered
00:02:23.240from misogynistic hate, in particular the issue of witchcraft or using terminology of being a witch.
00:02:32.460And Teagan tells us that in 2011, when Julia Gillard was the Prime Minister, the leader of
00:02:37.880the opposition, Tony Abbott, attended a protest against her and addressed the crowd by standing
00:13:51.660So, yeah, so I couldn't leave it when I came home.0.91
00:13:55.080And I think 10 years later, I'm still here.
00:13:57.260well we're really glad because you're going to be our wealth of information and you've done all
00:14:05.680the hard work and we're here to benefit from that and reach the rewards of it while we talk to you
00:14:11.600about it well it's so nice to be able to share it because part of the reason I sort of put my books
00:14:17.540and things away was because there seemed like what's the end game to this there's no I mean
00:14:23.840And while I was always thinking of it being such an injustice to these people and that there should be something up in the town saying, you know, these people were just people.
00:14:34.220There is a private memorial on the very edge of Forferloch in a place called Murie now.
00:14:41.480That's one of the places where the accused were said to have gathered.
00:14:46.000And people who own the land there have put up a beautiful memorial.
00:14:50.580And that does say on it they were just people.
00:14:53.100and so but there's nothing there should be something in the centre of town I mean you'll
00:14:59.220have found this I'm sure there's so much in the records about the people who prosecuted
00:15:04.420you know the great and the good are all talked about but these people who have been subjects
00:15:11.040of a huge miscarriage of justice there's no memorial to them so your project your petition
00:15:18.960for gaining a pardon that's what sparked up my interest again because I was like oh my goodness
00:15:25.720someone's doing something about this um oh yeah it's it's been it's been uh it's brilliant and
00:15:33.200it's great to see the progress you've made because it's so important we think so yeah well you know
00:15:41.360in covid times as well it's really struck me the last time I was researching the comparison I made
00:15:48.160a long time ago was with george bush and his axis of evil so you're either with us or against us
00:15:54.660and that's exactly what james the sixth said about the witches and then in covid times where people
00:16:02.880are very keen to shout at someone in the supermarket who may not have a mask on there
00:16:10.200may be a justified reason for that or to maybe snitch on a neighbor who's you know things like
00:16:15.620that you think this still underlies what goes on in our society you know the veneer of civilization
00:16:22.660is very thin and you see during times of crisis like this that people will pick out a neighbor
00:16:31.840people will gossip about that you know so it's this has never gone away what caused these
00:16:38.080accusations still is there in our society I think Zoe has spoken before and I've never lived in a
00:16:46.420small village but Zoe has spoken before about village life haven't you and that sort of way
00:16:52.480of the dynamic of small groups of people the village that I live in isn't particularly tiny
00:16:57.820and it's really just a suburb of Dundee to be honest but when I was a little girl it was much
00:17:02.620more like a village you know and now because we're so sort of international and global
00:17:06.860ordinarily you don't really notice that but I think I like you're saying Judith during lockdown
00:17:12.260because it was the people that lived there had to stay there you became much more aware of even just
00:17:18.300in really benign ways going out for a walk you see the same faces so you start to think oh are
00:17:24.120they married to them or are they friends with that person or is that their kids or you know
00:17:29.120do you know I mean you see the same people all the time you do start to really notice things so I think0.80
00:17:33.700in the in the days of the witch trials i think it would have been very easy for a very kind of
00:17:39.740gossipy chatty keeping an eye on everybody else all the time mentality to arise i can see why it
00:17:46.240happened you know obviously it's not it's not pleasant but you can see why that happens with
00:17:50.300psychology of humans and forfer is strange in a way because all of the surnames that you recognize
00:17:57.920from the accused all these surnames are still found in Forfar I think the gene pool here is
00:18:04.040really quite small and I don't say that to be offensive but people in Forfar who are Forfarians
00:18:11.140the older people all remember you know oh yeah that's such and such her granny was married on
00:18:19.820to and they'll give you the history of that family and if they had money or you know there's
00:18:25.360they still know all these family connections so that's quite fascinating as well.
00:18:33.260So what happened in Forfer? Okay as we all know Cromwell invaded Scotland in 1651-52
00:18:40.800and he set up a very structured, well I mean he was basically all about control wasn't he? So
00:18:48.420troops were stationed in towns and cities all over Scotland and Forfer was one of those.
00:18:55.160So while the troops were here, there weren't any witch trials.
00:18:58.880Cromwell seemed to be, or his troops and his commissioners,
00:19:09.960Unfortunately for Farfur, there was a scuffle and the fire broke out,
00:19:14.120and all of our records prior to 1661 have been destroyed.
00:19:20.400So I think that Cromwell's troops probably didn't really keep very many
00:19:24.000or they destroyed them when they left but they'd also set fire to the charter chest which had
00:19:28.560everything in it and that's all gone but as soon as they left there was a power vacuum they had
00:19:35.140such a tight hold on the community and society in general and then they just stopped and left one
00:19:40.740night and you know the presbyterian church filled that void that power vacuum they they swept in
00:19:49.020And they thought to themselves, this is a great opportunity to finally structure our godly society, our city on the hill.
00:19:58.300You know, we are going to start from scratch.
00:20:01.820And so witch trials didn't tend to break out if you didn't have a zealous minister.
00:20:08.060And unfortunately, in 1658, we had a very zealous minister called Alexander Robertson.
00:20:18.000and he seemed to be very much in favour of witch trials and whipping up hysteria.
00:20:25.420Ministers would quell these things before they became informal accusations and things
00:20:30.120if they thought that it was just nonsense, if someone was just a gossip.
00:20:34.620But there seemed to be a push and warfare from the actual community as well
00:20:40.220and the minister was zealous and there was this whole idea of creating this godly society.
00:20:46.720So that meant anyone who didn't conform with that plan, they seemed to just want rid of.
00:20:54.660And so Alexander Robertson was the minister here from 1658, and then he died in 1662, and the witch trials just stopped.
00:21:05.100He was the shortest serving minister in the 17th and 18th century.
00:21:08.400And I think if you believe in divine retribution, he popped his clogs and did the community a favour because that's, along with the Privy Council refusing to allow torture anymore in order to obtain a confession in 1662, he also died.
00:21:26.260So after that was a mopping up process, just of the ones who were left in prison.
00:21:31.360But that's how it started. It started when Cromwell's troops left.
00:21:35.100there is an idea that there's possibly accusations made while Cromwell's troops were here but nothing
00:21:41.400was ever done about it so there was a pile of people in the community that the community had
00:21:46.960suspicions about so when the troops left and the presbyterian church took hold it was almost like
00:21:53.920a bomb had gone off they were dealing with a backlog of witches exactly yeah yeah they're among
00:22:00.780us. Do records exist where it identifies the different accused? Oh, yes. A woman in our
00:22:08.420archives, Angus Archives, called Fiona Sharlaw has done some amazing work. She has dug up a lot
00:22:14.640of records. I've dug up a lot from Privy Council records, which are mostly online now. Brian
00:22:21.380Lovac, he has a list of accused as well. So there are records because there are some confessions.
00:22:29.320I say confessions I hate saying that word um there are some we always put inverted commas
00:22:35.040around it which is exactly isn't any good when you're in a podcast I wanted to do that
00:22:40.040every time we say confessions just in your mind put those we and every time I write them in notes
00:22:44.720I put that down too okay so luckily we have some confessions we have in them the accused will name
00:22:53.480lots of other people and so there's a good list of we've got 42 at the moment you know the four
00:23:00.020four 42 there's obviously way more than that but that's until archives and things open again
00:23:06.480that's what I think we're at we're pretty certain that 11 of them were killed and then some were
00:23:11.940freed and banished one which is fascinating and I don't know of this anywhere else apart from the
00:23:20.740the lady who died in Fife is we have a witch who was buried and that's fascinating because
00:23:29.340the body has never been found and the remains have never been found and there's been lots of
00:23:35.280work done in the area that she she was buried when they were putting railway sidings and stuff like
00:23:41.380that they found other stuff like neolithic boats and stuff but they didn't find the body so that
00:23:48.460body's still there. What was her name? Her name was Gerzel Simpson. And it's really quite tragic
00:23:55.360because it's thought she must have been really quite young, under 18 anyway, because her parents
00:24:02.260were sent for to bury her. So that meant she wasn't married. She didn't have her own family,
00:24:09.100just her parents. So she is interesting because she was the first one we have a record of. A
00:24:14.840commission was sent to the Privy Council for her, but we don't know if it just didn't arrive back in
00:24:21.000time or the authorities and forfer weren't fully aware of what you do when you find a witch. So
00:24:27.580she was subject to the usual torture and the records of this are found in the treasurer's
00:24:34.220accounts. That's another fascinating thing that I can talk about later, but she was imprisoned
00:24:38.120in the tall booth and she was tortured and the commission was sent for. But it seems to me that
00:24:45.240before that arrived back, she was either the subject of a lynch mob or they just decided that
00:24:52.380the way you get rid of a witch is you hang her from the tall booth. Then you cut her down and1.00
00:25:00.400bury her in the local playfield. So that was what happened to poor Garzell Simpson. It's thought
00:25:07.940that they weren't very savvy when it came to witch trials at that point so that was a practice run
00:25:13.120almost but her body was kept for quite a long time before it was buried because they had to send for
00:25:19.460the parents I'm not entirely sure where the parents were they came and the town paid for her to be
00:25:26.300buried in the local playfield and that's where she will still lie to this day. Somewhere in there
00:25:31.440that people go every day walk over she still lies and the reason you know about her is not because0.89
00:25:38.140of her own story told but because she turns up in the columns and the treasurer's accounts yeah
00:25:45.260there are no there are very few presbytery records on any of this you know researchers always talk
00:25:51.340about this so you know somewhere someone along the line decided that maybe it doesn't look very
00:25:56.660good for us as a church if we've done this to all these people so we'll just ditch all these records0.95
00:26:01.420but it's always about the money you know it's the economy is stupid so if you look for treasurer's0.53
00:26:08.400accounts you can find incredible things in there you can find payments for well for example for0.96
00:26:15.040Gerzel Simpson it was eight pounds of candles she was kept awake and watched so they needed eight
00:26:21.040pounds of candles for that for a few days you'll find things like Fortford didn't have its own
00:26:25.840executioner. So it had to send to either Perth or Montrose. So that had to be paid for. That's
00:26:33.020all documented. Instruments of torture, when John Kincaid arrived in town, they had to be paid for.
00:26:40.280So they're in the treasurer's accounts. So now who was John Kincaid? Don't get me
00:26:45.140starters on him. John Kincaid was from Trenent and he's known as a famous witch pricker. I said
00:26:52.900that very carefully um so he he earned himself a reputation of being able to prick witches or the
00:27:02.960accused find areas where they didn't feel pain and that then proved that they were a witch now we
00:27:10.740know that people like Kincaid used retractable needles they also if they're pricking someone
00:27:16.420who's been tortured say they're wearing a boot or something like that you know so they're in
00:27:20.760extreme agony somewhere else and you poke them in the back with a needle they're not going to feel
00:27:25.100that they're not going to react now hang on judith can i just clarify when you're saying say they're
00:27:30.500wearing a boot you're not meaning just a boot no no you're meaning the boot that is the torture
00:27:36.500device yes for those that aren't familiar with that can i ask you to do the horrible job of
00:27:42.400explaining what the boot did please certainly there's two types there's a spanish boot which
00:27:47.880is a metal type which the feet were put in the legs lower half of the legs were put in
00:27:53.000and that could be heated up or um stakes could be put into it and hammered between the legs
00:28:01.080to to crush the shin bones and basically once you'd been in the boot you would never be able
00:28:07.280to walk again so but the one that seems to be used most in scotland is the wooden version which
00:28:15.540was basically sort of four planks of wood placed around each leg and there were spikes in them
00:28:23.380facing inwards and if someone placed a stake in between that and hammered it well you could
00:28:31.080imagine the pain and they say that the maximum number of strikes it took in order to gain a
00:28:38.200confession was three you would say anything anything to make it stop absolutely and they
00:28:44.680only do this stuff after you've been kept awake and without water and you're hallucinating and
00:28:52.320at that point you pretty much see anything anyway and then they'll introduce something like the boot
00:28:56.760and things like that they didn't tend to mention in treasurer's accounts because it was so common
00:29:02.260place to use these it was you know it wasn't really talked about they would have these in
00:29:08.300their armory so to speak so you'd have things like the boot you'd have the scolds bridle we've all
00:29:13.780seen the scold bridle that goes over the head and usually we'd have something that went in your mouth
00:29:18.860to keep your tongue down or they weren't usually as gentle as that when it came to witchcraft they'd
00:29:25.680have spikes in them as well and that might be attached to a wall and you might be standing up
00:29:30.820and so if you fell asleep and you pressure went down with your head you know the the spikes would
00:29:38.320go through the roof of your mouth and through your tongue they put them in stocks there's in
00:29:43.220the treasurer's account for Forfer, they used stocks. Now, these stocks wouldn't have been
00:29:49.060used outside because they didn't want the witches to curse people that were going past.
00:29:53.460So these stocks would have been used inside the tall booth so that they couldn't lie down or sit
00:29:58.260comfortably. Or what else did they use? Thrown by a rope. That's a very common form of torture.
00:30:03.740And that was basically just, you know, you were strangled, then the strangulation was eased and
00:30:07.880strangled again and eased and then you've got things like periwinks which were thumb screws
00:30:13.560and you had things for crushing hands and oh I don't know how how many do you want and was this
00:30:20.580it beggars this particular to forfer or was this from your in your knowledge was this across
00:30:26.600Scotland because we were on the impression that quite often Scotland didn't wasn't necessarily
00:30:31.740as brutal physically maybe as other places were because Scotland relied quite heavily
00:30:37.320on the sort of the mental torture of keeping awake but no I think that's because that's
00:30:43.440possibly the only kind of torture that we can find written down the thought is that you would
00:30:50.420mention that possibly in treasurer's accounts or something because you're having to pay for
00:30:54.580the men to watch them so in the forfeit they had six districts so that meant that each district
00:31:00.500provided a man to take shifts of watching and waking. So that had to be paid for. Candles had
00:31:08.680to be paid for. Tobacco had to be paid for for the men that were there, because you've got to
00:31:12.980keep them comfortable. So all these things had to be paid for, whereas if you had these instruments
00:31:18.640of torture anyway, which we know existed because a lot of them are still in museums and things today,
00:31:24.040that didn't have to be paid for. So that wasn't mentioned in terms of gaining a confession.
00:31:30.040I would think if it had been mentioned anywhere, that will have disappeared in the presbytery
00:31:34.800documents. I don't know if it would have been mentioned that they'd done that. I mean, I think
00:31:39.740it's still in some Privy Council records that they'll mention about certain types of torture
00:31:44.300that were used on people. But no, it is thought that these were so commonplace and Scotland was
00:31:49.060much, much more brutal than England. So they seem to really like their torture here.
00:31:55.040I've said this before my Scottish history is absolutely appalling and if I wasn't doing
00:32:01.660homeschooling with my youngest who's in first year I still wouldn't know anything today we
00:32:06.900did Robert the Bruce knew nothing about him we've done recently Bannockburn knew nothing about that
00:32:12.640I was listening to the rugby was was on in the background last weekend and they were singing
00:32:18.300Flower of Scotland and I went oh King Edward's army I know what that means now like I know nothing
00:32:24.280no nothing and I did I did history up to sixth year level and you know it was either going to
00:32:29.260be history or English at university you know I know I know about American things yes about the
00:32:34.560second world war but that you see this much earlier period of Scottish history no clue whatsoever
00:32:39.840yes I'm not surprised that Scotland was more brutal than England with my new newfound first
00:32:45.940year history knowledge I think with torture what the reason why it was thought that Scotland was0.93
00:32:53.780better was because we did less dooking of women oh okay and also what happened was the privy council
00:33:01.160said that it didn't approve of torture but the difficulty is what it described torture as
00:33:08.680didn't yes many of the things that you've described so this is exactly one of my points as well is
00:33:15.860define torture yeah you know they didn't think waking and watching someone was torture
00:33:21.560you know whereas we all know now that's probably one of the first things that you know the cia
00:33:26.960might use or something like that but they didn't think that that was torture and what astounds me
00:33:31.940is and going through the treasurer's accounts it really astounded me because someone is writing
00:33:37.520that down in minute detail and what is going through their mind where they are writing down
00:33:43.540oh we need x number of pounds to to pay for the rope that has to be a certain length long
00:33:51.180to hang this person oh we're we're paying for pins two pins to torture elspeth rind or katherine porter
00:34:01.980they're they're right and it's it says two pins for the torture of for the pricking of sorry and0.98
00:34:09.340you think these are godly men you know these are not stupid men the people that were on the0.64
00:34:15.680commissions were actually some of the best minds in the country they were up to date with the most0.78
00:34:22.280intellectual thoughts it was them they were the ones doing it and you think how could they well
00:34:31.040you know you know that the reason that they could justify it was they they no longer saw the accused
00:34:36.840person as a person they dehumanized them so I guess that's how they justified it yeah they
00:34:42.300weren't doing it I think when we spoke to Julian Goodyear he said well the thing is that what they
00:34:49.200were doing was God's work they were driving the devil out of the community so they felt righteous
00:34:54.800in what they were doing it was that mindset that that meant that despite and Zoe's always it says
00:35:02.100this despite the fact that these people were in league with the devil they were poor they were
00:35:07.080vulnerable if they were ill the devil wasn't healing them they were getting nothing from this
00:35:11.840apparently so even though it would appear to anyone thinking how on earth are they benefiting
00:35:18.800from being involved with the devil i read an article about this recently that outlined those
00:35:23.900things too that it wasn't what's known as a faustian pact so it wasn't like in you know the
00:35:28.780idea that you sold your soul to the devil for riches or fame or power or sexual magnus or
00:35:33.840whatever that's right it was for pure badness which again is so scottish yes scottish it's like
00:35:40.960it's not even for any sort of gain it's just because I'm bad I'm just a bad person yes other0.96
00:35:47.200people to be as fucking miserable as I am sorry David I'm so glad you swore because I've been0.80
00:35:51.780trying not to swear the whole time it's all right we've done it now sorry sorry listeners that0.99
00:35:57.680I have to rein myself in Claire will tell you I'm a prolific swearer when I'm not
00:36:03.400me too so the the thinking then was that you actually you just became you just you just got
00:36:09.880in league with the devil just out of badness so you just want to be a person that brought
00:36:14.480misfortune and sadness and pain to other people but no actual gain to yourself which is just0.99
00:36:19.840punishing to me in a farfer it was obviously uh not a ruse but it was a way of rounding up catholics0.76
00:36:26.800so the presbyterians the staunch presbyterian in them would have thought that they were0.70
00:36:33.160getting rid of catholicism they were wiping that out from their godly society because to them
00:36:39.420it's this whole idea of renaissance dualism and you're either good or you're bad or you're with
00:36:45.660us or you're against us if you don't believe in the protestant god the presbyterian god
00:36:50.960then that means and you're a catholic that means you believe in the devil because catholic is the
00:36:56.260antichrist yeah yes so they were they were clearly rooting out a bit of catholicism
00:37:03.120the women on forfer they seemed to have a great time to be honest to you
00:37:08.320obviously they didn't when they got caught but they were
00:37:12.400fourth at the time was it had a population of a thousand
00:37:15.900which was a reasonable size of town in the sort of 1660s but obviously tiny by
00:37:22.920our standards sorry that kind of does put 42 into
00:37:26.980perspective though 42 and that's 42 that we know of yeah i
00:37:31.480think it works out as 4.2 percent of the population
00:37:34.320And I think during the national hunt, one of you will remind me, is it 0.48% of the population or something that was killed?
00:37:44.220What we know is that in Scotland, between the 16th and 18th century, there was about 1 million people in the country and 4,000 were accused.
00:37:55.060So I don't know how that would work out as a percentage.
00:37:57.760but i i completely forget when we're talking about the numbers of people every time and we
00:38:03.980talk about villages that they're involved with i was thinking of for for now and thinking yes
00:38:10.180people in that i wasn't thinking of how small it would have been then yeah that is so we were way
00:38:17.400above the national average and that was only in a two-year period you know probably 18 months
00:38:24.800and and that's incredible that must have been terrifying to live at that time and for wow yeah
00:38:32.060and you see so many of the surnames are similar so you know that they were family members you know
00:38:38.560if one person was accused then the daughter would be the probably accused as well or the sister
00:38:43.060or the cousin and the witch the witch trials here are full of the name guthrie and guthrie
00:38:48.480is a local name guthrie is just along the road from forfer and that's where the surname originates
00:38:53.520from. So people on the commission, we have Guthrie's on the commission, Thomas Guthrie,
00:38:58.260Gideon Guthrie. We have two Guthrie's sisters from Montrose who came to Forfer to be accused
00:39:06.280and, well, to be tortured. We don't know why they came from Montrose. We think that probably
00:39:09.960Montrose didn't have, it didn't accuse many people. So they probably, because Forfer was
00:39:15.800in the middle of this stuff and they had all the torture equipment and they had all the people who
00:39:19.700knew how to do it. Let's just send them to Forfer. But it might be because they were related to Helen
00:39:25.520Guthrie, which is the main sort of subject when you talk about the Forfer Witch Trials. So they
00:39:31.200may all be related. Tell us then about Helen Guthrie. What is her story that she's the centre
00:39:36.820focus of the Forfer Witch Trials? Well, Helen Guthrie is interested for a number of reasons.
00:39:42.080she accused 30 of the 42 but she didn't do it in one stage I mean when I talk about accused this
00:39:50.460is another thing I think about because we know that the confessions were formalized and they
00:39:55.640were contrived so we know these weren't the words of the people that were confessing and I wonder
00:40:02.120if the same is true about the accused I mean did they just nod their head you know was this a
00:40:08.020person that was maybe suffering from some forms of psychosis or delusion or due to all the sleep
00:40:15.180deprivation and then the pain and did someone say a name which is you know someone in the church
00:40:22.520would quite like to clear up let's include them were they there to person nods head that's the
00:40:29.740equivalent of an accusation we don't know so helen guthrie accused 30 and it was over an 18 month
00:40:36.920period. So even though a commission was sent to have her executed once she'd confessed,
00:40:42.780she played, you could maybe call it a clever game, in that Helen Guthrie's 13-year-old daughter was
00:40:49.800accused with her. So she was arrested in 1661, along with her mum. She was 13 at the time.
00:40:58.480She's described as being very small, because the devil describes her as being such a little lass.
00:41:04.860and she's imprisoned in the tall booth