00:00:00.160Hi, I'm Clare Mitchell QC. Welcome to the Witches of Scotland podcast.
00:00:05.220I'm a lawyer who specialises in miscarriage of justice cases and we're bringing you this podcast
00:00:10.120because we want to tell you about the women who were accused, prosecuted, convicted
00:00:15.240and ultimately executed as witches in Scotland.
00:00:18.780I'm Zoe Vendetotsi and I'm a writer who's always had an interest in the witches
00:00:22.780and I feel that this dark mark against Scotland needs a reckoning.
00:00:26.500The campaign Witches of Scotland wants three things.
00:00:29.600Firstly, a pardon for all those convicted of witchcraft.
00:00:33.240Secondly, an apology for all those who were accused as witches.
00:00:37.420And finally, a national monument in recognition of all those who were affected by this terrible miscarriage of justice.
00:00:44.420Over the forthcoming weeks, we'll be talking to a whole host of experts about the history and the modern day connections to the witches of Scotland.
00:00:54.300Hello and welcome to the Witches of Scotland podcast.
00:00:56.860this week we're on episode 33 before we get down to talking to our fantastic guest this week
00:01:02.880claire i was thinking you and i had a conversation about this about how it is that you come up with
00:01:09.040the list of names each week how it is that you do your research and i was thinking because we
00:01:14.380know lots of listeners are doing their own research and are either proper historians or
00:01:19.740are kind of citizen historians or they're researching their own family it's always
00:01:24.240useful i think to share different research tools if they don't know about them already then it might
00:01:29.180be helpful to them so i was thinking could you tell us what it is that you use to do your research
00:01:34.260into the witches names please i think a lot of people who independently research these things
00:01:39.720have actually gone far beyond what i do an example a recent example is judith gorman who is
00:01:45.880researching the forfer women killed as witches and she has done a lot more work actually going
00:01:52.080to archives actually going to records because of the pandemic i've kind of been stuck using what
00:01:58.300sources i can from the internet obviously but my first and original source was the source book of
00:02:05.160scottish witchcraft that's a book written by christina larner christopher highbury and hugh
00:02:11.040mclaughlin and published by the grimsey press now that's the big book you and i first started
00:02:17.120working together you gifted me a copy of the big book it's massive i guess big you know size of
00:02:23.160size of thing which i think gives an idea of how much info is in it i did and sadly that contained
00:02:28.880all the names of the people who at that time when those researchers were being done
00:02:34.580those researchers had found this book which was i think published in 70 originally
00:02:42.360that's right yeah it was published in 1977 and the book you can buy is in its original form
00:02:50.700but it's been updated a little but with a preface to the print in 2005 by Hugh McLaughlin
00:02:58.920one of the writers and he explains that for almost 30 years the source book of Scottish
00:03:04.720witchcraft had been the most authoritative reference book on Scottish witchcraft and
00:03:09.440been invaluable to specialist scholars and of interest to the general reader but provides much
00:03:14.880more than a series of list of the names and addresses of the long dead witches. He points
00:03:20.400out that before that time the only book on the matter had been a 1938 book which George F Black,
00:03:29.280a Scotsman who was in charge of the New York Public Library had published and that was called
00:03:34.800a calendar of cases of witchcraft in scotland 1510 to 1727 so that's really interesting that
00:03:43.740in the 30s a scotsman was in charge of the new york public library and obviously had an interest
00:03:50.400in seeing scotland's history being recorded so obviously since that time of the 70s we've moved
00:03:57.540on greatly with technology and we have got the internet stuff which we refer to every week which
00:04:03.700is the database and the interactive map which references Larner as well as other documents
00:04:10.580but what I thought was really interesting when speaking with Judith before is that they're
00:04:15.500uncovering more people that aren't mentioned in the book the source book and aren't mentioned
00:04:22.760elsewhere and of course that's because the people that compiled the source book only had a finite
00:04:27.820amount of money to do their work so that they went to the primary places where they would find
00:04:35.580information like the court records, Privy Council records but they didn't obviously go to every
00:04:43.200small place and look individually at all those records. If you like we were kind of looking at
00:04:49.140the centralised records and our guest today is in fact going to tell us that in her area
00:04:55.760there were nine people killed as witches total and some of those don't appear in the survey of
00:05:04.000scottish witchcraft or the book so they've uncovered by their investigations more people
00:05:09.540and i just think how important the work is that people are doing listeners are doing
00:05:14.820by checking these archives and uncovering these people themselves and i just think it's it's
00:05:22.940great and fascinating work to be able to do that sort of archive stuff but i was wee i wanted to
00:05:28.080be an archaeologist i always wanted to lots of really really old books and strangely i do read
00:05:33.440lots of really old books i don't do any of the exciting indiana jones stuff well i've got quite
00:05:39.020a lot of my garden that needs dug out at the moment so if you want to practice your archaeological
00:05:42.800skills i will gift you that there was not a beat you were right in there seeing how you could turn
00:05:49.700my want to dig to your advantage it's because every week where we record i sit at a bedroom
00:05:56.360window and at the upstairs of our house and i can look out onto my garden and each week i look out
00:06:00.980and i just go oh my god it looks so bad so i'm just always every single week i'm like with one
00:06:06.620hand up to my eye almost so i don't have to look at how bad my garden looks well i'm giving a hard
00:06:11.900pass on that i think i'll just if you change your mind let me know okay might might come to you so
00:06:17.880the other thing we wanted to talk about as well is that we're having a bit of a change to how
00:06:21.820we're going to be putting out the podcast which is because we have got like a few different
00:06:28.460projects that we can't really speak about just now this is this is so funny this is like people
00:06:32.640do us on twitter all the time they go i've got some big personal news but i can't share it we
00:06:36.980are like that now we've got some big news but we can't share it so because of that we are going to
00:06:42.100go down to every two weeks for an episode to come out and we'll be doing that quite soon won't we
00:06:47.360Claire? Yes I think as of next week we will be going down to fortnightly we're doing quite a
00:06:53.920lot of work we're trying to liaise with as many groups as we can political groups and we're doing
00:06:59.760a lot of work behind the scenes to ensure that when the petition hits the new justice committee
00:07:05.420whenever that is formed we will be able to try and persuade as many people as possible to be in
00:07:11.120support of it so we're working our way behind the scenes and we thought that whilst we're doing this
00:07:16.560we would drop down to another period we still have i mean i think i counted 15 different people
00:07:21.860at the moment that we're hoping to have on that we've we've spoken to the list just keeps growing
00:07:28.100so it's not for want of people that we've got to speak to but it's just for want of time and having
00:07:33.160to focus on other matters to make sure that the petition and all that goes with it has the best
00:07:39.580chance of working yeah and it's not bad considering when you and i first talked about this you had in
00:07:46.160mind sort of maybe six to ten episodes it wasn't that basis that it was sold to my brother if he
00:07:51.900would just sound engineer these six to twelve episodes yes now what i think is really professional
00:07:57.940about what you did there was you were able to introduce your brother david mitchell our sound
00:08:02.620engineer who is available for other projects if you'd like to oh yes very good he takes the sow's
00:08:08.880ear of our raw recordings and makes them into it i mean it's maybe like a low sort of satin
00:08:15.440polyester purse that he comes up with i'm not saying it's silk it's not silk but that's not
00:08:21.500his fault that's our fault no it's much improved it's taking some quite raw raw material and
00:08:27.240making it a little bit more finessed so that's good but he is available for that and we've said
00:08:31.220this before but i just want to reiterate this thank you so much david because we don't pay him
00:08:36.060because we don't get any money for doing the podcast this is all just love which is delightful
00:08:39.980but um we have now started selling very snazzy merchandise claire i saw you raise your which
00:08:46.240is a scotland mug there very nice so if you have a look on the website there's a link to
00:08:51.700the merchandise that's there and there's some quite snazzy stuff and we've got people around
00:08:55.920the world who've been buying things so there's hoodies t-shirts bags i think mugs one of our
00:09:02.460listeners leslie is in nova scotia and i was so tickled when she said it had been there you know
00:09:09.460To think something of Witches of Scotland
00:18:35.460So witchcraft has been known in Shetland certainly since Norse times.
00:18:40.320And I kind of look at witchcraft and divide it into two distinct categories.
00:18:45.140So you have like the accepted witches is what I'm calling them and the unaccepted witches.
00:18:50.240And the accepted witches are generally people within the community, usually older women, maybe spinsters that live alone, that rely on the goodwill of the community.
00:19:02.080They rely on charity and help from their neighbours.
00:19:05.160and it's believed that they might have certain powers that they can cure an alien animal or
00:19:12.840they can cure an alien child but on the same hand they can use their power to take away the
00:19:19.560profit from the buyer so they can stop your cow from milking they can transform sometimes into
00:19:26.780an animal there's stories of witches in Shetland who have transformed into a bird and they've gone
00:19:33.840to sea like many miles out to sea and they're able to see the mine that are at the whalen for
00:19:39.440instance and they can tell their families when to expect them home so there's a story of one
00:19:45.500witch who told the mother that her son would be home the following week and they'd been at sea
00:19:51.640for months and months at the whalen and she even knew how many like how much of a catch they had
00:19:56.760on board the boat so those are the kind of accepted witches within Shetland's folklore or history
00:20:03.560and then you have unaccepted witches and those are the ones who for some reason are punished
00:20:09.760through law and they're executed and they're burned at the stake so treated very differently
00:20:16.080but in most cases their actions are the same and so we're thinking about why they're treated
00:20:23.020differently and I have found some evidence as to why they're treated differently but
00:20:28.200again it seems that a lot of it has to do with the time that they were living so when they were
00:20:34.220alive. So it was just their luck that at the time they were alive and the idea of them being a witch
00:20:42.600was being attributed to them that was a dangerous time and that was when they became the unaccepted
00:20:49.160witches. Were the people identifying themselves as witches? Good question I'm actually I'm not
00:20:57.520sure in the stories that we have in the folklore some of the women i suppose inadvertently are
00:21:04.940referring to themselves as witches because people will go to them and they will seek their help so
00:21:11.080these women will go and try and help an animal that's sickly or or whatever but whether they
00:21:18.380refer to themselves directly as witches i couldn't say i suspect not your unaccepted sort of category
00:21:26.640witches were they dobbed in by other people in the community was it because other other people
00:21:31.280made an accusation of them as being witches that sort of got the ball rolling yeah certainly in the
00:21:39.2201616 trial that's the one that we have like the most evidence for where that there was a case of
00:21:45.200three women that were tried and they were dobbed in by their neighbours some of the accusations
00:21:50.980against them they name other people that they had bewitched or that they had done ill against so
00:21:56.960that they are being accused by neighbours certainly. So 1616 you've got the three of them
00:22:05.020and is that the biggest which trial in Shetland do you think the three of them that you know about
00:22:10.620at the one time? That's the biggest one that we have any real evidence of that yeah that I've
00:22:16.800found and there were more than three that were actually tried on that day but there was three
00:22:22.040that were executed on that day so five people went to trial yeah it was four or five on on that day
00:22:29.740but it was the three of them that were executed were the executions done similarly to how they
00:22:36.580were in mainland scotland you know was it hanging and then burning of the body or was it different
00:22:41.720in some way yeah they were they were strangled here and then they were burnt so the three in
00:22:48.3201616 it says that they were all indicted and accused for modern witches sorceress and deceivers
00:22:55.440of the people they were sentenced to be taken to the place of execution above bury and worry it
00:23:01.720which is strangled at the stake and brunt in ashes so this exact same so strangulation and then
00:23:09.460burning yeah do we know the names of those women before i'm presuming it's women we do so firstly
00:23:16.540we have catherine john stother and so this is the north patronymics in the names uh and we've got
00:23:23.080jonathan uh dinez or that's maybe dennis and we've got barbara thomas dother or scored
00:23:30.120as she's sometimes known those were the three in 1616 do you know anything else about them you
00:23:36.440know like whether they were widows or single or is it just purely their names yeah we know we know
00:23:42.960a bit about them so Catherine Johnstother she was married so she was married to a man called Thomas
00:23:49.780Kirkness and Jonka was married to a man called Peter Kettle or Ketil I'm not sure so we we do
00:24:00.560we know a little bit about them and I think that Barbara Scord or Thomas Dother the third witch
00:24:05.580She was a widow and one of the things that she was tried for was her daughter had been obviously caught in a man and she was evidently not very happy about this as a mother.
00:24:19.020And one of the things that was reported to the court was that she had gripped his member in her hand.0.51
00:39:41.700about the consequences of my thoughts sometimes and that it's good sometimes to not speak and to
00:39:49.820have a moment of thinking before you speak and I struggle with that sometimes but I'm still I still
00:39:56.000feel quite compelled that I want to go and have a look. I suppose that's the whole thing about it
00:40:00.820that we speak about that these things are fascinating and compelling and we want to see
00:40:06.860them and we want to know about them at the same time we want to acknowledge the terrible parts
00:40:12.480i think i would come back and i would say that when we're thinking about the human remains the
00:40:20.420ashes that are on display and we think about the maybe human remains of someone that that wasn't
00:40:28.000killed through a miscarriage of justice when we're thinking about those human remains that
00:40:33.060means that somebody whether it's an archaeologist or a farmer digging has disturbed a grave but with
00:40:39.580the ashes weren't they were not given a proper grave they were not given that dignity and death
00:40:47.260that's true no there's nothing which i mean you're you're campaigning to have them have a memorial
00:40:52.480made so there's no memorial to these women and men but in having the ashes and having the display
00:41:00.040that tells us that these women were unfairly accused and tried
00:41:06.060then we are memorialising them in some way
00:41:09.560we're giving them a bit of their dignity back
00:41:12.380and we're having the conversations and we're remembering them
00:41:15.260Actually I take that on board, that is true
00:41:18.240because without that display we wouldn't be having this conversation
00:41:23.040even if it is controversial we wouldn't be discussing it
00:41:27.440So I suppose, and we've spoken about this with Lilith Aidy, that we've got because that she has a resting place, as it were, I won't call it a grave, but because there were actual parts of her that were kept and recovered and things people could go and see, people have a connection with it.
00:41:46.040And I suppose if there is anything that holds a connection to these times, then it's good.
00:41:51.820I think, though, there's something that just makes me think it would be better to have those ashes put somewhere
00:41:57.580and then perhaps a photograph of them put up explaining that's what happened.
00:42:04.300Maybe if they were in kind of an urn, if they were in an enclosed dinner so that they weren't visible, so that you weren't...
00:42:10.340Yeah, there's almost something about it.
00:42:12.720And maybe I personally think that when you die, that your body's finished.
00:42:18.080It's not that I have a particular care over burials or graves or something.
00:42:23.980It's maybe the way that they're being held, because if they were in an urn, bizarrely, I would think, oh, well, that's appropriate.
00:42:32.280But it's only another vessel. Isn't it strange how your person...
00:42:36.540I wonder if it's just your, it's your heritage, Claire, your Irish heritage that would have a great respect for, I know you're not a Catholic, but like the way that you were brought up with that, maybe.
00:42:49.800Yeah, well, that we would have proper weeks and all that sort of stuff.
00:47:05.020I mean, it seems quite frankly that he was very, very lucky
00:47:07.740right up until the point that he stops being lucky
00:47:10.080when someone says, you're not lucky, you're a wizard.
00:47:13.360Exactly, yeah. And the Reverend John Brand, who came to Shetland in 1701 and spoke about the people that he encountered and our strange superstitions and all of that, he commented on Logie.
00:47:28.020And he said that he was able to fish in this manner by agency of evil spirits with whom he was in compact and covenant.
00:47:34.500oh and so do you think it was as a result of a minister coming to the island that he was
00:47:43.440called a wizard no i i don't think so because john brand came to shetland he was writing in 1701 and
00:47:52.620we we believe that the last witches were executed here in 1700 this is a story that john brand
00:48:01.320has been told and it's interesting because Brand writes about how he actually says that in 1701
00:48:09.100I do not hear of any such appearances the devil makes in these isles. The Brunies, fairies and
00:48:15.360other evil spirits that haunted and were familiar in our houses were dismissed and flayed at the0.87
00:48:20.900breaking of our reformation. So he goes on to say how he doesn't encounter much witchcraft and
00:48:26.360devilry here but later on and this is what I found interesting he tells a story that a minister
00:48:32.040another minister has told him in which an eagle was seen to take away a cockerel and luckily a
00:48:39.940charmer was nearby who took out a string from his pocket tied it in nine knots and whispered some
00:48:46.280inutterable words and then the eagle as if by magic dropped the cockerel where it was then
00:48:53.040retrieved by a boat and brought back to safety so the very things that people are being tried
00:48:59.120and executed for are also seen to be a positive in that the cockerel survived it's you know it's
00:49:06.300just madness yeah and there doesn't seem to be any sensible line that you can draw between
00:49:12.100witchcraft and charming in that regard it just doesn't make any sense so sorry i very much
00:49:20.000interrupted you earlier on if you want to name the names of the people that you have done your
00:49:27.400researches on and found out were executed as witches on Shetland. Yeah so the names of the
00:49:33.780witches who were executed in Shetland are Helen Stewart and her daughter is mentioned in that
00:49:43.020trial, Catherine Jones-Dotter, Jonka Dennis, Barbara Thomas-Dotter, Marion Pardin or Peebles
00:49:53.480and Luggy, our wizard, who his name was Andrew Stevenson and Barbara Tullock and Ellen King.
00:50:05.080So those are the nine people. Well thank you so much Laurie for all your researches
00:50:12.400as we mentioned before we know that you're going to do your own podcast and do deep dives into
00:50:19.580each one of them and tell as much as we can so please do let us know when you're going to do
00:50:25.220that so we can let everyone know that listens to our podcast because I'm sure that they would
00:50:29.900be fascinated to to join in and with yours that's fantastic and thank you so much for having me and
00:50:37.460just congratulations on all your fantastic work i honestly i think what you are doing
00:50:43.500it's just long overdue so hats off to you for doing it and i hope that you have every success
00:50:51.460that's really kind we'll definitely be up to visit you in shetland as soon as we can
00:50:55.480start traveling we've got a round the world plan now i'll take you to the gallo hills
00:51:01.720and as i'm not fond of flying we'll have to get there by slow boat
00:51:07.880claire i'm telling you if we have to go on a boat i'll have to take valium or something i'll
00:51:12.040be conked out i can't cope with that with boat journeys so actually i could be a perfect
00:51:16.120traveling companion for you on the boat i'll need more of valium to get on the tiny plane to shetland
00:51:21.460oh no no no really which is worse oh no i prefer the boat well whatever way we get there we really
00:51:30.400look forward to see in the future and we hope you stay in contact and keep us updated if you've got
00:51:35.560any new information um if you find any new stories that you want to share with us please do stay in
00:51:40.940contact so we can talk to you i will and there's there's actually one more story that i i think i
00:51:47.500should share with you and it's when earlier on i spoke about accepted witches and there's one story
00:51:54.360which i found fascinating and it was a story from the island of fetler and in that story
00:51:59.820and there was a woman who asked for a passage on a boat
00:52:03.720and she wanted to be brought to Fettler
00:52:06.080but the men had just got this new boat1.00
00:52:08.820and it was bad luck to take a woman, especially in a new boat
00:52:12.020so they refused her passage and she cursed them0.99
00:55:03.180got the website so please do get in touch
00:55:05.360let us know if you are listening and if you're enjoying it and please also tell people that
00:55:09.920don't use social media because there'll be lots of people that don't use twitter and so on
00:55:13.660who might still enjoy the podcasts so please do share because obviously the more people that know
00:55:18.620about the campaign i think the higher chance we have of success yeah can i say the discussions
00:55:23.860on instagram are really surprising because i usually think of instagram as just a photo
00:55:28.780and every week that we have a podcast i put up a photo of what it's about and then say hey it's
00:55:35.020this week's podcast and last week I put it up about the question whether or not a national
00:55:40.500memorial should go hand in hand or should be a museum of witchcraft trials and the responses
00:55:47.120on Instagram were huge there's a huge number of people writing we think it's a great idea there
00:55:54.040were no no negatives in fact I've not come across anyone that doesn't think it's a good idea I mean
00:56:00.220I suppose to borrow a religious phrase you are preaching to the converted if you're asking people
00:56:05.380who are listening to the Scotland podcast whether or not they think that would be a good idea but
00:56:11.360we just have so many people on Instagram getting in contact and seeing how good an idea it was
00:56:16.820that they thought I mean we have people saying yes yes yes let's educate the museum's a great
00:56:23.260idea here are a few examples we have Handsome Healing saying yes a museum would be amazing
00:56:29.280We have Noel Harrison reminding us of the memorial in Vardo in Norway and asking us whether or not we've interviewed Professor Viv-Helene Willemson yet.
00:56:40.300And in fact, we did speak with her at the International Women's Day event.
00:56:45.660Again, that might be a good idea to approach her to see if she'll speak to us about that.
00:56:50.560Other people saying a museum would be amazing.
00:56:53.600Quite a few people saying there needs to be both.
00:56:55.860There needs to be a national memorial and a museum.
00:56:58.220and a leslie a listener in america leslie saying yes a museum in america we have the salem witch
00:57:03.800museum which she recently featured it's a great educational tool some other people saying that
00:57:09.260they love the idea so i'm just really really surprised that instagram which i thought was
00:57:14.160just more really about photos people were really really engaging in that way so yeah if you're
00:57:19.240following us on twitter or facebook nip over onto instagram because it's quite a lively conversation
00:57:25.220going on yeah no it's good and it's great you can see people kind of coming together that are
00:57:29.300like-minded and it's nice and it's people all over the world as well we've got sort of regular
00:57:33.880contributors to the different things like say on Facebook and on Twitter and it's really nice
00:57:37.820on Instagram there's a lot of modern day witches following us they really get the difference
00:57:42.680between the people that were killed as witches and what they do in the modern day as well which
00:57:47.700I think is really really good to see that they're so supportive of what happened to those people