There Are No Girls on the Internet - December 17, 2022


Elon Musk’s very weird night on Twitter- STUFF MOM NEVER TOLD YOU

Cuties Movie QAnon Controversy Explains Our Current Moment Part One: Why Trump Targeted Two Black Election Workers

Episode Stats


Length

1 hour and 7 minutes

Words per minute

178.93

Word count

12,094

Sentence count

695

Harmful content

Misogyny

2

sentences flagged

Toxicity

15

sentences flagged

Hate speech

10

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.000 This is an iHeart Podcast.
00:00:02.640 Guaranteed human.
00:00:04.520 Run a business and not thinking about podcasting?
00:00:06.820 Think again.
00:00:07.440 More Americans listen to podcasts,
00:00:08.980 then add supported streaming music from Spotify and Pandora.
00:00:11.600 And as the number one podcaster,
00:00:13.240 iHeart's twice as large as the next two combined.
00:00:15.720 Learn how podcasting can help your business.
00:00:17.540 Call 844-844-iHeart.
00:00:19.800 If your bookshelf and your For You page
00:00:21.760 are equally important to your personality,
00:00:24.000 welcome home.
00:00:25.580 Pro Society is a weekly podcast
00:00:27.460 that's part book club, part group chat
00:00:29.380 for anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island
00:00:31.760 deserve the same level of discourse.
00:00:33.880 Each week, we're connecting the dots
00:00:35.260 between books, the internet, and pop culture
00:00:37.380 with your favorite writers, book talk creators,
00:00:39.860 and plenty of overthought opinions.
00:00:42.120 Yeah, I'm obsessed, I'm obsessed.
00:00:43.940 Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app,
00:00:46.620 Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:00:50.340 With Dash Pass by DoorDash, there's no delivery fee.
00:00:54.280 Is that your way of telling me you want a burrito?
00:00:57.300 Does it look like I want a burrito?
00:00:59.380 It looks like you're a blanket burrito.
00:01:01.280 Who wants a burrito?
00:01:03.420 You get me.
00:01:05.140 Order without the drama.
00:01:06.180 Get no delivery fee with DashPass.
00:01:08.060 Eligible orders only.
00:01:09.020 Other fees and terms apply.
00:01:14.100 There Are No Girls on the Internet is a production of iHeartRadio and Unbossed Creative.
00:01:22.200 I'm Bridget Todd, and this is There Are No Girls on the Internet.
00:01:24.900 It has been a really weird time on Twitter lately.
00:01:31.300 So last night, Twitter's new owner, Elon Musk,
00:01:34.120 suspended journalists from big-name publications like CNN and The New York Times
00:01:38.760 for doing pretty straightforward reporting about the banning of a Twitter account
00:01:43.300 that tracked Elon Musk's personal jet using publicly available FAA data.
00:01:48.720 Then, Musk joined a Twitter Spaces, which is basically Twitter's audio chat function,
00:01:53.180 to talk about this. And when BuzzFeed's tech reporter, Katie Notopoulos, grilled him about it
00:01:59.260 and started really asking him some questions about his moderation inconsistencies, Elon
00:02:04.200 abruptly left the spaces. And then spaces was basically shut down for everyone globally.
00:02:11.420 Now, Elon said this was just a glitch, but I don't know. That timing just seems awful suspicious to
00:02:18.880 me. You know, when Elon first bought Twitter, he went on and on about how he wanted to make it this
00:02:24.160 haven for free speech, even going so far as saying that he had not banned the Twitter account that
00:02:29.860 tweets about the location of his private jet. That is until he did ban that account. And I think if
00:02:35.900 reporters and journalists are going to be retaliated against for doing pretty straightforward
00:02:40.260 reporting about him, it sends a pretty clear signal about what he actually thinks about
00:02:44.740 protecting speech. And this all comes as Musk is also banning links to the Twitter alternative
00:02:50.060 Mastodon and flagging any links to Mastodon as containing malware. Honestly, it was wild.
00:02:56.400 So given all of this, I thought it might make sense to remember how we got here.
00:03:00.500 So I joined my friends Annie and Samantha over at the podcast Stuff Mom Never Told You
00:03:04.860 to talk through the origin stories of Elon Musk buying Twitter. And I'm curious,
00:03:09.820 are you going to stay on Twitter? Were you never on Twitter? Are you looking for alternatives?
00:03:13.980 I'm definitely shopping around where I might wind up.
00:03:16.880 Who knows?
00:03:17.680 So let me know if you have platforms that you're liking or want to talk through any of them.
00:03:27.440 Hey, this is Annie.
00:03:28.680 And Samantha.
00:03:29.400 And welcome to Staff on Never Told You, a production of iHeartRadio.
00:03:31.580 and today we are once again thrilled to be joined by the fabulous fantastic bridget todd welcome
00:03:47.900 bridget we're always so happy to have you thank you for having me i'm so happy to be back here
00:03:52.660 and happy happy late thanksgiving yes to you too okay so bridget samantha and i the topic you
00:04:00.320 brought today, we're very excited you brought it because we have a lot of questions, but also we've
00:04:05.680 been meaning to talk about it, but we were hopeful that you would talk about it because I feel like
00:04:12.300 you have a lot more knowledge and expertise in this arena. So I'm so excited that this is what
00:04:20.280 we're talking about today, which is Twitter. Yeah. And you know what, the last time you were on,
00:04:25.760 we actually talked about the fact that it was the beginning of the end kind of had been that
00:04:30.300 moment, because at that moment, we knew that Elon Musk was coming on. We're like, oh, no, here we go.
00:04:36.580 So definitely, as we were watching this, I feel like it was just yesterday that we mentioned this.
00:04:42.480 So I'm sure you've got so much more in-depth information from the beginning of to today.
00:04:48.220 Yeah, I mean, it's so weird. And just to level set, like, it does feel like we're in a little
00:04:54.860 bit of unprecedented waters. You know, I have a lot of expertise when it comes to technology
00:04:59.500 and platforms and how they run and how they're moderated.
00:05:02.780 But this has never really happened before.
00:05:04.880 Since I have been working in the internet spaces,
00:05:07.840 I have never seen a billionaire
00:05:09.500 buy one of our largest digital communications platforms
00:05:12.680 and change the culture pretty much single-handedly overnight.
00:05:17.280 So I am going to try to bring whatever expertise I have
00:05:22.060 and answer whatever questions folks have.
00:05:23.740 But I don't know a lot
00:05:25.320 because this is just like a very new, weird experience.
00:05:28.000 It's I am learning right alongside all of y'all and figuring out what's happening in real time.
00:05:33.460 So it's kind of exciting, kind of interesting, but also TBD.
00:05:39.620 Yeah, which I guess we should say we're recording this on November 28th because things are changing rapidly.
00:05:46.180 Things are changing rapidly.
00:05:47.360 A lot has happened, as you said, Samantha, since Elon Musk came on board.
00:05:52.600 So, yeah, we'll see.
00:05:55.540 I think there's a lot more to come.
00:05:57.820 Yeah, well, that's a great place to start.
00:05:59.700 You know, just the rapid changing of the situation.
00:06:03.160 I initially started putting together an outline a couple of, I think, like last week.
00:06:07.180 And mostly all that stuff that I wrote is now, has now been changed.
00:06:12.400 So hopefully this will be not totally out of date by the time folks hear it.
00:06:16.940 I have to ask before we even start, like, have you sensed that your relationship with Twitter has changed since Elon Musk took over?
00:06:23.420 Yeah, I would say so.
00:06:25.120 So because one of the biggest things that I've experienced with Twitter since Elon Musk has been either kind of a sense of uncertainty or confusion where people will contact me and be like, I'm not sure what's going on.
00:06:43.420 So you can find me on this other social platform or whatever.
00:06:45.960 and then I have had several experiences
00:06:50.300 where I went to check on something
00:06:53.600 somebody on Twitter is doing that I follow
00:06:57.340 and their account is not there anymore
00:06:59.640 or it's deactivated
00:07:00.680 and kind of just a general
00:07:02.820 like I'm not sure if this is coming from
00:07:05.260 who I think this is coming from I guess
00:07:07.080 like a loss of trust
00:07:10.320 like I'm not sure what is going on
00:07:14.340 if I can trust anything that is happening.
00:07:17.440 Right.
00:07:18.040 I mean, essentially, I think that's the biggest thing
00:07:20.640 is I don't know if this is a real account to someone at all.
00:07:24.300 The amount of ads I've been getting have gotten up,
00:07:26.800 it's the same three ads,
00:07:28.200 but I'm like, oh my God, it is constantly there,
00:07:30.840 which we all know why.
00:07:32.360 But, and I mean, like, because they're losing so much money.
00:07:34.760 But I think one of the big things is like,
00:07:36.840 I will see parody accounts,
00:07:38.680 which because of the verification system
00:07:40.360 has completely gone out the window
00:07:42.300 that I don't know if it's real.
00:07:43.680 I think there was one at one point that I was like, oh, that one is real.
00:07:46.640 Oh, that's real?
00:07:47.560 Ooh, like that's kind of one of those moments, as well as the amount of misinformation has
00:07:52.480 grown to me.
00:07:53.320 At least I knew if it was coming from this specific account or type of account, what
00:07:57.600 was happening.
00:07:58.340 Now I don't know.
00:07:59.480 I'm like, okay, wait, did that actually happen?
00:08:01.820 And I don't know anymore if it's real or not.
00:08:04.080 Like so many things that were aimed specifically at Elon Musk.
00:08:07.220 I'm like, is that real?
00:08:08.640 Is that really happening?
00:08:09.380 Did he do these things?
00:08:10.540 Or are people saying this in order to fear monger or make it even bigger? 0.65
00:08:14.620 And then he comes back and say, just kidding, that didn't happen.
00:08:17.240 Like, I don't know at this point who to trust and who not to trust.
00:08:21.220 Of course, on our Stuff Mom Never Told You account, the followers just dropped because so many people have left.
00:08:27.380 I'm assuming maybe they just all were bots.
00:08:29.400 I don't know.
00:08:31.000 But the amount of people that had left has increased in the fact that has impacted our numbers for a while.
00:08:38.620 Not that we don't do too much because I am still fearful of writing anything on any of the social media accounts at all.
00:08:46.080 But it's interesting to see how that is fluctuating as well.
00:08:50.680 The people who I, again, trusted losing their verification because they didn't pay for it.
00:08:54.520 So therefore, I don't know if that's them anymore.
00:08:56.600 There's so much like I don't quite know what's reality, what's fake.
00:09:02.000 And then the amount of disinformation and people that I'm trying, like have been banned or back on that I'm like, oh, God, why?
00:09:06.880 So it's really sad because Twitter has been something that I use to let me know what's going on.
00:09:11.280 It's faster than any other news platforms and seeing the truth of what's actually happening, whether it's information about wrongful deaths or protests around the country or around the world.
00:09:23.180 So there's a lot that I'm like, ah, I'm kind of lost, but also at the same time entertained because it's going in flames.
00:09:30.220 Yes, a thousand times yes.
00:09:31.960 So I have seen all the things that y'all have seen and felt and sensed.
00:09:35.780 I have also seen and felt incensed.
00:09:37.840 And for folks listening,
00:09:39.660 even if you're someone who doesn't use Twitter,
00:09:42.320 like the majority of Americans,
00:09:43.820 or like will never use Twitter,
00:09:45.440 not a social media person,
00:09:47.180 I am confident that I can help you see
00:09:50.140 why this is a big deal for all of us,
00:09:52.560 not just folks who are on Twitter,
00:09:53.860 because I do think that a lot of the reporting on this
00:09:55.960 is like, oh, well, this matters because it's Twitter
00:09:59.560 and everybody uses Twitter.
00:10:00.760 Not so, right?
00:10:01.720 Like when you compare Twitter
00:10:03.300 to other social media platforms like Facebook,
00:10:05.780 only a small amount of Americans are on Twitter actively,
00:10:10.480 and even less Americans actually tweet and participate there.
00:10:14.500 So we're talking about a small amount of folks.
00:10:16.900 However, the reason why this actually, like, kind of matters
00:10:20.720 is because the people who are active on Twitter are kind of like,
00:10:24.360 I guess you could sort of call them, like, the tastemakers, right?
00:10:26.840 Like, journalists, researchers, activists, organizers,
00:10:30.620 There's people who are really able to shape conversation and shape our public discourse
00:10:36.600 and sort of have an influence on what becomes part of our public kind of conversation, right?
00:10:41.820 And so, Samantha, exactly like what you were saying, when people need quick, up-to-date,
00:10:47.360 hopefully somewhat reliable information, they're not going to Instagram.
00:10:51.360 They're not going to Tumblr.
00:10:52.680 They're not going to Snapchat or TikTok.
00:10:55.180 They're going to Twitter.
00:10:56.140 You know, there's a reason why when there's a, you know, mass shooting on a campus, people can follow updates quickly on Twitter.
00:11:03.880 And so Twitter is not just this place where public discourse is shaped.
00:11:08.360 It is also a place where you just go to get easy, quick access to hopefully reliable information about stuff happening near you.
00:11:15.580 And so you can sort of get a sense of why this is a platform where these kind of power struggles happen, right?
00:11:22.960 Like, it's not surprising that, like, a person like Donald Trump, Twitter was his platform du jour because you can have such outsized influence in getting a message out there quickly and effectively.
00:11:33.880 And I just don't think that we have another social media platform that mimics that so effectively.
00:11:38.480 Like, Facebook moves a little bit slower, even though more people are there.
00:11:42.000 Instagram, the timeline moves in such an algorithmic way that you only—it's like, if I posted something that was really important, it's not even a guarantee that everybody who follows me would see it, right?
00:11:51.120 And so Twitter is such a fast-moving platform,
00:11:53.520 and I think it's one of the reasons
00:11:54.760 why we're seeing it spring up as a battleground
00:11:58.380 in this, like, highly polarized kind of culture war.
00:12:08.560 Hey, I'm Ruby Carr, the host of the podcast Encore.
00:12:11.960 Check out our brand-new episodes featuring music
00:12:14.700 from the show that everyone is reheating as we speak,
00:12:18.180 Heated Rivalry.
00:12:19.280 Join me as I go behind the songs that brought Shane and Elia together.
00:12:23.340 I'll tell you the stories of Feist, My Moon, My Man, Wolf Parades, I'll Believe in Anything,
00:12:27.880 and Tattoos, All the Things She Said, and how they all became a part of this global phenomenon.
00:12:33.340 Stream Encore on iHeartRadio, Crave, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:12:38.580 Run a business and not thinking about podcasting?
00:12:41.680 Think again.
00:12:42.680 More Americans listen to podcasts than ad-supported streaming music from Spotify and Pandora.
00:12:47.100 And as the number one podcaster, iHeart's twice as large as the next two combined.
00:12:51.780 So whatever your customers listen to, they'll hear your message.
00:12:54.800 Plus, only iHeart can extend your message to audiences across broadcast radio.
00:12:59.120 Think podcasting can help your business?
00:13:01.060 Think iHeart.
00:13:02.120 Streaming, radio, and podcasting.
00:13:04.300 Let us show you at iHeartAdvertising.com.
00:13:06.860 That's iHeartAdvertising.com.
00:13:09.300 When I was 14 years old, I was kidnapped and held captive for nine months.
00:13:15.160 I survived, and I've spent my life exploring how other people survive what should have destroyed them.
00:13:21.540 I'm Elizabeth Smart, and these are the Survivor Files.
00:13:25.240 I just remember this low, taunting voice next to my ear saying, shut up, don't say anything.
00:13:33.340 Every week, I'm with survivors who live through the unthinkable.
00:13:37.560 I knew if he woke up, without a doubt, he was going to hurt me.
00:13:42.340 I started feeling that there was someone at the end of my bed, and I just started screaming.
00:13:49.860 They are abducted, stalked, controlled, and nearly silenced.
00:13:53.820 But these aren't stories about what's taken from them.
00:13:57.280 They're stories about what it takes to make it out alive.
00:14:00.920 Listen to The Survivor Files with Elizabeth Smart on the iHeartRadio app,
00:14:05.680 Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:14:12.340 I'm really glad that you're here to make this case because we recently, it was recently
00:14:20.020 Thanksgiving and I went home and a lot of people were kind of, you know, laughing about
00:14:23.620 Elon Musk and Twitter.
00:14:25.120 And there are definitely some funny aspects of it, but they were all like, well, I hate
00:14:28.260 Twitter, so I'm not sad to see it go.
00:14:29.580 And I was like, well, I have a lot of problems with Twitter too, but it's important.
00:14:33.780 It does matter.
00:14:34.900 And it is a shame like that we're seeing this happen.
00:14:37.660 And there have been things, examples of stuff that took off on Twitter and then fundamentally changed our public discourse, whether you use it or not.
00:14:51.160 Totally, right? And so this is the drum I will always beat.
00:14:54.680 Even if you are not someone who is actively using Twitter, you have felt the cultural impact of movements and conversations that started on Twitter.
00:15:02.220 You know, if you think about the way that people who traditionally have not necessarily had a lot of access to power and influence, they can use Twitter to build up that power and that voice and that influence.
00:15:13.660 I could give you a million different examples of concrete changes that we're all aware of and probably all felt directly that started on Twitter.
00:15:20.860 You know, it's not surprising to me that Twitter has been used as this way to really hold power structures accountable.
00:15:26.960 When Tarana Burke started the Me Too movement, you know, she had this movement that she had started for black and brown women and girls who were survivors of sexual violence.
00:15:38.000 And when actor Alyssa Milano tweeted about it on Twitter using the hashtag Me Too, that's when it really took off, right?
00:15:44.880 And so you see the power that, you know, generating conversations on the platform can have.
00:15:50.880 If not for Twitter, I don't know that we would have the Me Too movement the way that it was.
00:15:55.520 I don't know that, you know, all of these different powerful abusers would be eventually held to account and that we would be having a national conversation about things like gender and sexual violence.
00:16:05.460 You know, another great example is a friend of mine, April Rain, she tweeted about how white the Oscars nominees were and tweeted, Oscars so white, it completely took off.
00:16:15.440 People were tweeting things like, Oscars so white, it touches my hair without asking. Oscars so white, it, you know, da-da-da-da-da.
00:16:24.440 And because of that conversation, it fundamentally changed how the Oscars were that year. Spike Lee won an Oscar and he said that he doesn't think it would ever have happened without that campaign, which started as a tweet, a hashtag on Twitter. Look at the way that it was instrumental during Arab Spring, right?
00:16:42.960 And so, like, there are so many ways and times where, particularly outside of the U.S., Twitter has been used to document, you know, abuse of power and hold that power to account.
00:16:53.880 And I think even if you're not on Twitter, you have probably felt or seen the impact of some kind of movement that was started on Twitter.
00:17:01.540 You know, and as you're talking about these movements, which are so huge, I had to go back to the original idea of like our lingo changed completely with what is now the hashtag as well, because that actually originated in 2007, according to one of the resources that I looked at on Twitter.
00:17:19.700 Like it literally changed how we looked at so much of our conversations online.
00:17:25.760 It brought up a way for us to pass messages and bring up big issues with what I would have known as pound sign, which the millennials don't know what that is.
00:17:36.280 And that's fine.
00:17:36.840 I'm fine with it.
00:17:37.480 I'm okay with it.
00:17:38.800 But like that in itself has begun a new conversation.
00:17:42.560 The zeitgeist in itself had changed because of things like that on Twitter.
00:17:46.260 And it's such a big, significant thing that we don't often think about in knowing that before 2007, that didn't exist.
00:17:52.540 And what a powerful tool it is on across all social media.
00:17:56.340 Oh, my God, Sam, this is my, you're, I will keep my comments as brief as I can.
00:18:01.400 This is like my favorite topic.
00:18:04.080 The way that things that originated on different social media platforms, in this case, Twitter, have changed, fundamentally changed the way that we communicate digitally is fascinating to me.
00:18:13.060 I remember when hashtags were first rolled out and previously there wasn't really an easy way
00:18:19.040 to quickly figure out what everybody was saying on a particular topic. And I still remember I
00:18:23.580 was working as a social media manager at the time when the conversation was like, oh, well,
00:18:27.380 should we use hashtags on Facebook? Like, does it work that way? And, you know, people still use
00:18:31.960 hashtags. If you go to TikTok, like one of the biggest, fastest growing platforms out there,
00:18:37.000 when you scroll down to the bottom of a TikTok, people tend to include hashtags. And so it's
00:18:40.520 interesting how this mode of, this particular mode of digital communication did not just stay
00:18:46.240 on Twitter, how it really shaped other platforms as well. And I think has become a pivotal way in
00:18:52.640 terms of like how we just think about the way that discourse works online. I think before the
00:18:56.980 hashtag, we didn't think about it as like, I should be able to pull up a hashtag and get a sense of
00:19:01.740 like the diversity of thought and conversation on any one topic. And now that is kind of integral
00:19:06.420 to the way that we understand communication online.
00:19:09.220 This is something I could nerd out on for hours.
00:19:11.240 It's probably not interesting to anybody but me,
00:19:13.740 but I find it fascinating.
00:19:15.660 I love it.
00:19:15.860 I found it fascinating.
00:19:17.060 To be fair, again, I was late in coming to social media.
00:19:19.940 I still am late in understanding social media
00:19:21.980 to a certain extent.
00:19:23.260 So when I first started, I was like,
00:19:24.500 what are these hashtags?
00:19:25.400 I'm just going to write sentences on there.
00:19:26.840 And it made no sense.
00:19:28.480 But I'm like, that makes it blue.
00:19:30.180 Like, you can click on it.
00:19:31.280 I'm going to do it.
00:19:32.120 Which is a whole different conversation.
00:19:33.960 I'm like, look, technology.
00:19:36.420 which is, again, how I react to most things.
00:19:39.640 But going back to where we started,
00:19:41.520 because finding something that's coming to this point,
00:19:43.880 which seems apocalyptic for a social media brand,
00:19:46.780 but one of the oldest one that has been out there
00:19:49.340 that still stood the test of time outside of Facebook,
00:19:52.580 it's interesting to see what is happening
00:19:55.300 because it does feel like we have lived this extension of a life
00:19:58.840 of a creation of something completely different.
00:20:02.100 So with all that, how did we get here?
00:20:04.580 How did this happen?
00:20:06.420 Great question. So this is something, again, that I wish I saw more of in the reporting.
00:20:11.520 People kind of gloss over it, and I think it's actually a really big part of the story,
00:20:17.460 and it's important to not just gloss over it, which is that, you know,
00:20:20.980 Musk's decision to buy Twitter, per his own statements, was rooted in transphobia.
00:20:29.040 He'd been talking about buying Twitter for a while, and in 2018, Twitter added intentionally
00:20:34.320 misgendering people to their list of prohibited behavior on the platform. So you can't, as a
00:20:39.880 means of trying to harm someone, you cannot misgender them. So in the right wing, I guess
00:20:47.680 you'll call it a parody site. Even that doesn't seem quite correct, but we'll call it a parody
00:20:53.460 website for the sake of conversation. The Babylon Bee, they violated this rule when they tweeted a
00:20:58.920 transphobic joke, in scare quotes, that Dr. Rachel Levine, who is the first openly trans
00:21:05.460 four-star officer in the military and currently the assistant secretary for health in the U.S.
00:21:10.300 Department of Health and Human Services, they made a crack on Twitter that she had been named,
00:21:15.540 quote, man of the year, right? And so a lot of the report, first of all, it's wild to me how like
00:21:22.200 that level of humor has not evolved since that movie, Ace Ventura, Pet Detective. Like we're
00:21:28.120 still in 1992. Like, oh my God, like, get a new joke, people. It is so tired. But a lot of people
00:21:37.160 reported that the Babylon Bee was banned from Twitter for this tweet, but that technically is
00:21:41.940 not correct. Twitter said that the Babylon Bee could have their account back in 12 hours, but
00:21:48.080 that that countdown could not start until they deleted that particular tweet. They refused to
00:21:52.980 delete that tweet so they were unable to tweet so they weren't technically banned they kind of
00:21:58.100 decided like we are not we are going to die on this hill of this tweet and if we can't tweet
00:22:02.620 that's fine so at this time musk was already the biggest shareholder of twitter and he had been
00:22:07.460 invited to join its board of directors um in april elon offered to buy twitter and he said that it
00:22:12.180 was specifically that babylon b situation that prompted him to do so that like that was the
00:22:18.080 final straw watching the Babylon Bee not be able to tweet because they refuse to delete this joke.
00:22:23.880 The Babylon Bee confirmed this to the Washington Times saying, we have had some communication with
00:22:28.500 Musk. He wanted to confirm that we had in fact been suspended from Twitter. He reached out to
00:22:33.100 us before he publicly asked his followers if they think Twitter rigorously adheres to the principle
00:22:37.760 of free expression. He even mused on that call that he might need to buy Twitter. So it's, to me,
00:22:43.260 it's like pretty disappointing and also very important that Elon Musk's, you know, tenure at
00:22:49.940 Twitter really starts with his desire to protect transphobic jokes, in scare quotes, as protected
00:22:58.580 speech and free speech on the platform. I think that's terribly disappointing. And I think it's
00:23:03.020 related to the ways that we're seeing him, you know, at the rain at Twitter right now.
00:23:07.280 That's so disappointing because from what I do understand, he does have a trans child. And in
00:23:12.800 like obviously the relationship is not good they disowned musk as their our parental figure but it
00:23:19.340 seems like just an attack on them if i were if i were them i would think this as well but it's just
00:23:25.600 so disappointing to know that you could really care so little of your own child that you're
00:23:32.940 willing to go into 44 billion dollars in debt to go for this yes it is i mean the this is a weird
00:23:41.320 aside, but, like, I actually spend a lot of time thinking about Elon Musk's, like, personal
00:23:45.880 motivations. I obviously don't know Elon Musk, so I can't, like, it's all speculation, but
00:23:50.920 I do think there's something about it. Like, I can't imagine having a trans child and going out
00:24:00.520 of my way and spending a lot of money to protect, like, transphobic rhetoric. I cannot imagine it.
00:24:07.040 It's difficult for me to put myself in that position, I guess I'll say. I also think that
00:24:10.620 it really reflects the ways that particularly trans people have unfortunately kind of become
00:24:18.380 this like, like just the existence of trans people trying to live their lives has become this like
00:24:24.880 flashpoint. On the one hand, it is surprising to me that he would double down on this having a
00:24:29.880 trans child. On the other hand, I do see the ways that just like the existence of trans people
00:24:34.580 trying to live their lives has become this incredibly like politicized hot button issue.
00:24:39.180 It certainly should not be. But on the other hand, it's not terribly surprising to me that his bid at Twitter starts with that transphobia, that that's where it that that's where it begins.
00:24:50.200 Right.
00:24:50.880 It makes me want to have him fail, but that's just me.
00:24:54.840 But, you know, with that, it's kind of odd that he also continues to talk about free speech.
00:25:01.280 I think it's really, really almost ironic.
00:25:04.140 He talks about free speech, and several of the people that I've seen banned are the people that said something about him.
00:25:09.340 Not necessarily anything completely offhand.
00:25:12.820 It was just like, hey, he did this, and this is a bad thing, and he's like, banned them.
00:25:17.180 Exactly.
00:25:17.620 Okay, so let's get into this because Elon Musk, he has called himself a free speech absolutist.
00:25:23.940 He says in a TED Talk, like, free speech is the ability for someone you don't like to say something you don't like, right?
00:25:31.240 And so you might be thinking, oh, well, he would probably be working to foster a climate of open discourse and discussion at Twitter now that he's in charge.
00:25:40.100 But you would be wrong if you thought that, right?
00:25:42.300 Because that's not what the vibe has been so far.
00:25:44.780 And so, first of all, I have to say, like, obviously, when we talk about free speech, really what we are talking about is whether governments can punish people or prevent people from saying what they want to say.
00:25:56.200 Right. And so the conversation around free speech has gotten so muddled about like, oh, well, this is censorship.
00:26:01.980 It's like, oh, not really. But and there are absolutely free speech issues happening in the United States right now.
00:26:07.620 Like when you look at like anti-CRT bills or like don't say gay legislation, like we are in a climate where free expression is under attack specifically from government.
00:26:19.260 So like that needs to be clear. But for the sake of conversation, let's talk about free speech as sort of generally fostering a climate of open discourse and debate.
00:26:28.840 If we use that definition of free speech, you might be thinking, like, has Elon Musk worked to create that kind of environment since taking over?
00:26:38.060 Also, no, he has not done that.
00:26:40.980 First, he got started by overseeing a mass exodus of staff at Twitter.
00:26:45.480 Some employees resigned, which I totally get.
00:26:48.240 Like, I would have been out the door.
00:26:50.260 Honestly, there's not a lot of jobs that if I was offered three months pay to not do it, that I would keep doing it.
00:26:55.960 It's not a lot of jobs where that would be the case for me.
00:26:57.780 So I would totally have been on the resignation train, so I totally get that.
00:27:01.820 And some workers were fired.
00:27:03.360 And specifically, they were fired for things that they said about Elon Musk.
00:27:07.760 Engineer Eric Froenhofer was fired very publicly for going against Musk.
00:27:11.900 And it happened right on Twitter.
00:27:13.700 Eric worked on Twitter's apps for Android.
00:27:16.580 And after Musk tweeted that Twitter for Android had been really slow, the engineer retweeted
00:27:22.320 Musk saying that Musk, his technical understanding of Twitter's app was wrong.
00:27:27.780 which I can kind of buy because Elon Musk is famously not an engineer.
00:27:32.000 So perhaps might not totally know what he's talking about
00:27:34.360 when talking to an actual engineer who works on the thing that he is criticizing.
00:27:38.840 And so Musk replied and asked this engineer to elaborate before writing,
00:27:43.640 Twitter is super slow on Android.
00:27:45.340 What have you done to fix that?
00:27:46.580 They kind of go back and forth.
00:27:47.780 And then somebody else comes in and is like,
00:27:50.020 hey, engineer, why didn't you raise these issues privately with your boss?
00:27:53.960 And the engineer replies, maybe he should ask questions privately.
00:27:57.400 maybe use Slack or email. Elon then weighs in and says, oh, that engineer has been fired.
00:28:03.520 So I find this like very interesting because a lot of people said like, oh, if you publicly
00:28:09.400 disagree with your boss, you know, you can like pretty much anywhere, you would probably be fired.
00:28:15.260 And I guess that's a fair point. Like in most workplaces, you can't like get on Twitter and
00:28:21.480 call out your boss. Totally get that. But I think the larger point is like, it seems directly at
00:28:27.940 odds with somebody who has called himself a free speech absolutist. And I also think that that
00:28:32.680 engineer has a really good point. Like, why is it that Elon, as the boss, is allowed to publicly
00:28:38.540 misrepresent his work on Twitter? And that the staffer, he is the one who has to stay quiet and
00:28:44.800 only set the record straight in private. Like, if Elon Musk made it public by tweeting
00:28:51.340 about it? Why is it that when his boss publicly, I think, cramps on his work, he is not able to
00:28:57.560 publicly reply? I kind of totally get why he did this, even if for most people they might think
00:29:02.240 like, oh, that's clearly a fireable offense. Yes. Yes. Agreed. And also there's been a lot of
00:29:09.300 stories that like even privately that might not have protected him. Exactly. So even if this
00:29:15.400 engineer had brought it up privately via Slack or email, he probably, I think, probably still
00:29:20.620 would have been fired because it's not just staff who have publicly gone against Musk who have been
00:29:24.640 terminated. ABC reported that dozens of other staffers said that they were fired for raising
00:29:29.620 criticisms on internal Slack messages or email. And that kind of tracks with the kind of climate
00:29:34.980 that Musk has run at his other companies. I don't know how he's been able to dub himself as
00:29:39.500 a free speech warrior because the record of the climate at his other organizations just does not
00:29:46.740 reflect that. Like at SpaceX, for instance, former staff filed an unfair labor practice charge with
00:29:52.100 the National Labor Relations Board saying that they were retaliated against for writing and
00:29:56.740 organizing a letter that was critical of the company when Musk had been accused of sexual
00:30:01.140 harassment. And so they wrote this letter saying Elon Musk's behavior, the sexual harassment,
00:30:06.840 his like crass jokes on Twitter is making us look bad and it needs to stop. And they say,
00:30:11.780 and they went to the NLRB saying this,
00:30:14.820 that they were unfairly retaliated against for that.
00:30:17.600 And so, I don't know, I have a hard time
00:30:20.180 believing that Elon Musk is this champion for free speech
00:30:23.900 when those are the kinds of climates
00:30:25.960 that he has fostered at his organizations.
00:30:27.720 There's so much to all of that,
00:30:29.360 including the fact when we often hear people
00:30:31.660 complaining about free speech, especially today,
00:30:34.720 as you were talking about the anti-CRT stuff,
00:30:37.580 as well as so many other things, don't say gay bills,
00:30:40.560 that it seems very much coming from the conservative side
00:30:45.580 because they feel like since they think
00:30:48.040 they don't have the same privileges they did two years ago,
00:30:50.440 that they are now being imposed on
00:30:52.640 and therefore no longer having free speech.
00:30:54.720 And we also know that in Tesla, 0.85
00:30:56.300 there was a lawsuit where many black employees
00:30:59.800 talked about the racism within that company,
00:31:03.380 including him,
00:31:05.160 including being called the N-word and all of that.
00:31:07.340 And I'm thinking that's what he's talking about
00:31:09.040 when there's limiting free speech like okay white people you are now allowed to say that here
00:31:14.040 because that's free speech and not real not not like crediting the fact that that's you know like
00:31:19.580 it's racist that's not an issue of free speech that's about racism but that's what i'm seeing
00:31:24.760 as a pattern as well as the fact that the people who have been defending musk like the dude was
00:31:29.160 like hey dude don't be saying this to your boss are absolutely to the level like how close in
00:31:34.220 ratio are we to the incel link here oh you i have so much to say about this i have so much to say
00:31:42.040 about this so one i hadn't really thought about this before but you really put you really laid
00:31:48.420 this out nicely i do think that the way that people talk about content moderation on a platform
00:31:53.780 like twitter does kind of connect to conversations about like oh because i can't say what i used to
00:32:03.020 be able to say 20 years ago without repercussions. Therefore, I am being censored. Therefore,
00:32:09.500 the only way to protect free speech is to allow specifically racist or transphobic
00:32:18.100 content on these platforms. I hadn't really thought about it in that direct of a line,
00:32:23.160 but I think that you're absolutely on to something that the reason why so many people,
00:32:27.120 when they talk about free speech, free speech, they're not talking about the free speech rights
00:32:32.720 of like, you know, Palestinian activists or, you know, sex workers or any of the other
00:32:38.700 marginalized people who we know actually are the recipients of crackdowns on their speech. 0.70
00:32:45.260 They're talking about the right to say the N-word.
00:32:47.600 And to your point about Tesla, I would implore folks to read up on this because some of the
00:32:53.420 allegations are, it's not just like, oh, this person made off-color jokes.
00:32:59.520 that allegations, some of which are against Musk himself
00:33:03.220 and the kind of climate that he ran, are sickening, right?
00:33:05.960 Like one of them that sticks in my mind
00:33:07.440 is that at the Tesla factory,
00:33:09.020 one of the lawsuits alleges that
00:33:11.320 when Elon Musk would come do a tour of the factories,
00:33:16.120 that staffers knew that Elon Musk
00:33:18.840 had a problem with seeing black staffers on the floor.
00:33:23.440 And so on days when he was coming, 0.91
00:33:25.620 they would have the black staffers like essentially hide 0.83
00:33:29.060 because that they knew that like it would be a better walkthrough for musk if musk did not see 0.95
00:33:35.380 black and brown faces on his floor so like it's not just like oh someone made a joke i didn't like
00:33:40.300 that would be bad enough it's some some of the allegations are really deep and really i think
00:33:46.820 reflect a a real just a deeply culture and it's so interesting because i read this i i can't verify
00:33:54.900 if this is an accurate thing or not,
00:33:56.700 but I read this thing where someone was like,
00:33:59.580 oh, I used to work at SpaceX
00:34:01.180 and everybody knew that part of the deal
00:34:03.760 when you worked for Elon Musk
00:34:05.180 was so much management went into
00:34:08.780 managing Elon Musk specifically.
00:34:12.160 And so they would have all of these
00:34:13.280 like different window dressings
00:34:15.120 so that when Elon Musk was there,
00:34:17.020 he could feel certain kinds of ways.
00:34:18.840 And so they would have,
00:34:19.680 like he talked about how they would have
00:34:20.900 a computer run code in a way
00:34:23.060 that looks like the Matrix
00:34:24.080 So that Elon Musk, who is famously not an engineer, would think that really cool, super special tech stuff was happening, even though it was just farce, right?
00:34:32.680 And so I think some of the allegations coming out of other Elon Musk-run companies are so deeply troubling.
00:34:40.300 And I think that these are companies that have an infrastructure to manage these particular ways that Musk has.
00:34:49.120 Twitter is not a company that has that.
00:34:50.740 And so it's interesting to think, like, what will the vibe at Twitter be like when so much of the staff has been gutted and it's not a company that has been built to manage Elon Musk's quirks?
00:35:02.600 Yeah, that's I've heard that, too. And that's so sad that that's like people's mental energy is we got to keep this guy calm and here's how we'll do it.
00:35:13.000 hey i'm ruby carr the host of the podcast encore check out our brand new episodes featuring music
00:35:25.920 from the show that everyone is reheating as we speak heated rivalry join me as i go behind the
00:35:32.200 songs that brought shane and ilia together i'll tell you the stories of vice my moon my man
00:35:37.100 wolf parades i'll believe in anything and tattoos all the things she said and how they all became
00:35:42.400 a part of this global phenomenon.
00:35:44.580 Stream Encore on iHeartRadio,
00:35:46.560 Crave, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:35:49.840 Run a business and not thinking about podcasting?
00:35:52.920 Think again.
00:35:53.900 More Americans listen to podcasts
00:35:55.360 than ad-supported streaming music
00:35:56.940 from Spotify and Pandora.
00:35:58.440 And as the number one podcaster,
00:36:00.260 iHeart's twice as large as the next two combined.
00:36:02.700 So whatever your customers listen to,
00:36:04.300 they'll hear your message.
00:36:05.700 Plus, only iHeart can extend your message
00:36:07.600 to audiences across broadcast radio.
00:36:09.520 Think podcasting can help your business?
00:36:11.440 Think iHeart. Streaming, radio, and podcasting.
00:36:14.920 Call 844-844-IHEART to get started.
00:36:18.080 That's 844-844-IHEART.
00:36:20.520 If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
00:36:26.440 This is Prose Society, the weekly podcast that's part book club, part group chat for thought daughters,
00:36:32.860 pop culture obsessives, and anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:36:38.880 I'm Eli Rallo, and every week we're connecting the dots between books,
00:36:42.620 the internet, and the conversations everyone can't stop having.
00:36:46.020 I'm going to have to look up this story.
00:36:47.920 I'm obsessed.
00:36:48.700 I'm obsessed.
00:36:49.440 From best-selling authors and your favorite book talk creators
00:36:52.240 to the latest pop culture moments, nothing is off the table.
00:36:55.580 It's like if you can hide some real messages inside compelling characters,
00:37:01.560 then that is a Trojan horse.
00:37:03.420 Whether you're looking for literary deep dives, smart pop culture conversations,
00:37:07.060 or a community of readers who love to think a little too much,
00:37:10.980 you're in the right place.
00:37:12.640 Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app,
00:37:15.600 Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:37:18.560 See you between the pages.
00:37:26.120 I think as we're discussing,
00:37:30.680 he and a lot of people on the right, very conservative people,
00:37:33.600 would have you believe that this sort of hard right free speech, in quotes,
00:37:40.620 like they're being policed more, they're getting more, they're being more censored.
00:37:45.240 They are very much the victims in this conversation.
00:37:48.360 But that isn't the case, is it?
00:37:51.400 It is not the case.
00:37:52.440 And this is something that I think really points to the kind of ship
00:37:54.940 that Musk is going to be running at Twitter,
00:37:56.860 is that he gets on Twitter and repeats this thoroughly debunked claim
00:38:01.760 that Twitter has been, quote,
00:38:03.920 censoring the right more than the left.
00:38:06.460 And there is an entire body of research debunking this.
00:38:09.700 Like, I could do a whole episode
00:38:11.040 digging into some of the studies
00:38:12.560 that have come out about this.
00:38:13.540 It's fascinating to me,
00:38:14.580 but I'll just run through a couple.
00:38:15.900 So researchers from MIT, Yale,
00:38:18.140 and the University of Exeter
00:38:19.160 published a study that found that
00:38:20.760 while right-leaning accounts are banned more frequently,
00:38:23.320 it is not because of anti-right-wing bias,
00:38:25.660 but rather, as the researchers put it,
00:38:27.560 they found that users' misinformation sharing
00:38:29.660 was as predictive of suspension as was their political orientation.
00:38:34.320 Thus, the observation that Republicans were more likely to be suspended
00:38:36.920 than Democrats provides no support for the claim
00:38:38.860 that Twitter showed political bias in its suspension practices.
00:38:41.960 Instead, the observed asymmetry could be explained entirely
00:38:44.680 by the tendency of Republicans to share more misinformation.
00:38:47.540 And so basically, this idea that when they were looking at misinformation
00:38:50.640 and who was banned more for spreading it,
00:38:53.640 Republicans or right-leaning accounts were banned more,
00:38:56.500 but because those were the accounts that were more likely
00:38:59.080 to be spreading misinformation in the first place.
00:39:01.100 And this is actually backed up
00:39:02.700 by Twitter's own in-house research team.
00:39:05.320 In the pre-Musk days after Trump was banned on Twitter,
00:39:08.400 the Twitter internal team was facing a lot of criticism
00:39:11.800 that they were censoring the right.
00:39:13.240 So they put together a team to look into it.
00:39:15.220 And the internal research team at Twitter
00:39:17.080 found that folks on the right
00:39:18.720 are actually amplified on Twitter more often globally.
00:39:22.440 From the report,
00:39:23.240 our results reveal a remarkably consistent trend.
00:39:26.260 In six out of the seven countries studied,
00:39:27.820 The mainstream political right enjoys higher algorithmic amplification than the mainstream political left.
00:39:33.300 You can read this report on their website.
00:39:34.960 It's 27 pages long.
00:39:36.760 And so this idea that people on the right have been censored by Twitter or are, you know, getting a raw deal, it is just not borne out by the facts or the, you know, the research that's been done.
00:39:50.820 And I also think that it really speaks to this like wider misconception about social media more generally, that there is no real body of academic study or academic thought with regards to social media and that everything that we know about it is either anecdotal or like unknowable.
00:40:08.580 So people can just say whatever and be like, oh, yeah, you know how people on the right are censored on social media platforms and not really have it challenged.
00:40:18.220 And so I think that it really speaks to this, I don't know, I think it's a holdover from a time when people just saw social media as the internet and not the real world, and thus it was not really worthy of serious examination.
00:40:33.060 But there's entire schools of research and bodies of evidence about social media platforms, and all of them say the same thing, that people on the right are not being censored or cracked down on or anything like that.
00:40:47.500 And that if anybody tells you that they are, maybe that's their, maybe they feel that way.
00:40:51.780 Maybe that's their anecdotal evidence, but they're not.
00:40:54.300 And also like even beyond Twitter, people say the same thing about Facebook when in reality, you know, Mark Zuckerberg was personally intervening to keep people like Alex Jones on the platform and personally meeting with right wing leaders.
00:41:07.860 And so it's not going both ways.
00:41:09.860 And so, yeah, I think that Musk repeating this claim really shows how easy it is to, like, stoke this victim complex.
00:41:17.820 Like, of course, I am the one being victimized here.
00:41:21.300 What else could be happening?
00:41:22.620 I'm not excited about what's coming up because there's conversations about how Facebook is prepping for the next election, presidential election, and they are way too excited for the return of Donald Trump.
00:41:33.680 And I hate things.
00:41:35.860 But, you know, I find it interesting, too, because even with the COVID misinformation, it took forever for them to even recognize the misinformation and even talking about, OK, how are we going to do that without banning everybody because they didn't want to?
00:41:50.040 And so first they put the little warning things to all of it.
00:41:52.820 And you're like, it took a lot for a person to be banned.
00:41:55.620 It took a lot to even have any of that warning to be put on there because we went through a full year, I feel like, of so much misinformation, so many bad advices about how you can treat yourself to get rid of COVID.
00:42:08.000 It was, I felt like an ongoing battle and it still kind of is.
00:42:11.800 And it's kind of ironic that they were like, they absolutely hate us when there were so much fight to be put up from the people, especially scientists, to be like, can you please control this?
00:42:22.220 Because this is really bad for the health of our nation.
00:42:25.620 Totally. And what's so interesting about that is that something that people say a lot, like low-meaning people will say a lot, is like, you remember in the early days of COVID, we didn't know about masks.
00:42:35.420 Like it was like we were getting a lot of, like for a while it was like, oh, only medical professionals need them or only this.
00:42:39.800 And so like, and then eventually it was like, oh, it's masks. We all need masks.
00:42:42.800 People will, I think kind of understandably, conflate medical professionals getting more familiar with how the virus worked and all of that, which is confusing, right?
00:42:54.400 Like, it's like having one day having someone be like, oh, you don't need to wear a mask.
00:42:57.760 And the next day having to be like, oh, wear a mask.
00:42:59.220 Like, I can understand why people are confused and why that looks like, you know, like, oh, so why is that?
00:43:06.220 Why is that not misinformation?
00:43:07.760 You know, and it's like there's a difference between medical professionals, you know, getting more up to date on a novel virus and people who are spreading clearly, provably false information.
00:43:20.940 And I think that unfortunately with COVID, because it was like a new virus, it created a climate that really made it easy to conflate those things.
00:43:28.880 And so I think it made it easy to not challenge provable, demonstrable lies about COVID and lies about COVID that were intentional.
00:43:37.880 So like disinformation spread with malicious intent by bad actors.
00:43:41.840 I think that the climate of having a novel virus where people were still getting up to date on what was going on with it made it easy to not crack down on it.
00:43:50.220 And I think it's just like a reality of the way that inaccurate information on social media works is that there's always going to be that grain of truth.
00:43:58.460 It's like, oh, well, why is this not misinformation?
00:44:00.840 And I can understand why people raise that.
00:44:03.500 But I think it like did us a real disservice to cracking down on things that we know are just provably incorrect statements.
00:44:12.560 Does that make sense?
00:44:13.140 I feel like I'm kind of rambling, but hopefully you'll know what I mean.
00:44:16.460 I mean, that virus, we didn't know.
00:44:18.620 No one knew.
00:44:19.140 No one knew where it came from, what to do, how to handle it.
00:44:22.200 And I got, like, that definitely was.
00:44:24.320 We definitely were told, don't wear masks.
00:44:26.140 Please don't buy these masks because we're running out.
00:44:28.060 That's a whole different conversation. 0.99
00:44:29.380 But to, like, everybody wear a damn mask, please, for the love of all things. 0.98
00:44:33.980 And then having to be like, hey, they learn new things because they're researching new things. 0.99
00:44:40.380 And then also, like, political stuff.
00:44:42.580 But, like, yeah, that makes perfect sense that things would change.
00:44:45.340 And, of course, the naysayers would be like, do you remember this?
00:44:48.360 They're lying because they didn't say this the first time around.
00:44:50.620 It's like, this is what it means to learn and to research and to grow.
00:44:53.780 But there was a whole lot of stuff.
00:44:56.220 Yeah, and I think that's one of the things that makes me really sad about what's happening to Twitter,
00:45:00.340 as we were talking about at the beginning,
00:45:02.040 because there was a tweet that went viral a couple weeks ago from a reporter that was like,
00:45:08.940 you know, World War III could be breaking out,
00:45:10.580 and here I am not sure what is reality on Twitter anymore,
00:45:13.340 because it is such a big source for news.
00:45:15.800 And that whole thing with COVID, it did get really messy.
00:45:19.020 And it was an example of an interesting and kind of like terrifying example, I guess, of like how does this platform manage this information, perhaps misinformation or disinformation, when, you know, the scientists are researching and it is changing.
00:45:39.140 And I think because it gets so, a lot of it gets convoluted and there's so many like bad faith conversations that can happen on platforms like that, that it is, it's just like one of the, it's an interesting case study to see how Twitter kind of did deal with that and how long it took.
00:46:00.100 And I think that's another thing that's really upsetting about this is, as you alluded to, Samantha, it felt like we were making progress and it was so hard fought.
00:46:10.500 And now we're seeing like a reversal of all of these things that were, it felt like, oh, this is a step forward.
00:46:19.860 It's going to be a platform where a lot of this misinformation won't be as prevalent.
00:46:24.760 It will still be there, but not as prevalent, but it's getting reversed.
00:46:29.080 It's upsetting.
00:46:30.160 I mean, I, not to get too personal,
00:46:32.360 but like in my day job,
00:46:34.600 I do a lot of work trying to make platforms safer.
00:46:38.420 And, you know, I've met with the team at Twitter many times.
00:46:41.840 I don't know who's still there,
00:46:43.020 but like to advise them to be like,
00:46:46.420 oh, here are steps that you could take
00:46:48.300 to make the platform more hospitable
00:46:50.420 for marginalized people, women, people of color, whatever.
00:46:52.820 And so it does feel like a lot of the work
00:46:55.880 that I have done personally,
00:46:57.260 personally done in the last few years is now being erased. So it's a little bit like, oh,
00:47:03.620 well, glad I spent the last three years on this. But Musk reinstated a bunch of previously suspended
00:47:09.460 or banned accounts that had been kicked off the platform for things like spreading COVID
00:47:12.960 misinformation or harassment. And he signaled that he's planning on doing more of that in the
00:47:17.620 following week. So some of the folks who have been welcomed back to the platform include the
00:47:21.220 Babylon Bee, who you were talking about earlier, Jordan Peterson, who was banned after repeatedly
00:47:26.480 deadnaming the actor Elliot Page and misgendering Elliot Page. Kanye West, whose account was locked
00:47:32.280 after numerous anti-Semitic comments. Andrew Tate, who is, if you don't know who he is,
00:47:37.840 he's like a, I don't even know what you would call him, like a men's rights kind of misogynistic
00:47:43.860 influencer slash coach. Andrew Tate was banned from pretty much all platforms for saying things
00:47:50.380 like women need to be held accountable if they are raped. Marjorie Taylor Greene's personal
00:47:55.040 account, not her official account, was banned for spreading COVID misinformation. And of course,
00:48:01.000 Donald Trump. You may recall that Donald Trump was banned after using Twitter to foment insurrection,
00:48:07.920 which is a weird thing to say. Since having his account reinstated, Trump has actually not tweeted
00:48:13.100 and he has signaled that he is perhaps not going to be returning to Twitter, even though he can,
00:48:17.620 he has his account back, saying instead that he's going to stay on his own social media platform
00:48:22.660 that he owns called Truth Social.
00:48:24.820 I've heard that there might be
00:48:26.240 some kind of like contractual obligation there
00:48:29.860 that Trump might be contractually obligated
00:48:32.200 to only tweet on Truth Social,
00:48:35.200 but I actually don't know the incident.
00:48:36.680 That's why I can't really speak to it personally.
00:48:38.420 So all these people who had to leave the platform
00:48:44.280 for things like,
00:48:46.420 I would say that are like fairly serious offenses.
00:48:48.700 Listen, nobody is permanently suspended from Twitter for a one-time offense unless it is something egregious, right?
00:48:57.460 And so I can speak from personal experience.
00:49:00.400 Marjorie Taylor Greene had numerous warnings, and this was like a consistent thing with her, right?
00:49:05.600 Kanye West is the same.
00:49:06.600 It doesn't just come out of the blue unless you're doing something really egregious.
00:49:11.100 And so these are the people that Elon Musk is going to be welcoming back.
00:49:14.400 And he says that he's declaring amnesty next week for banned accounts.
00:49:17.420 But at the same time, he is also cracking down on accounts that are, you know, associated with, like, lefty politics as well.
00:49:26.340 So, for instance, Chad Loder, the founder of the cybersecurity specialty company called Habituate, his account was banned from the site after he used Twitter on November 23rd to warn users about an alleged data breach on Twitter.
00:49:39.140 Loader is known for, like, researching and reporting on right-wing extremism,
00:49:43.220 including unmasking a Proud Boy member who attacked a police officer during the insurrection.
00:49:47.980 And that report was actually cited by the Department of Justice.
00:49:50.300 So, like, a fairly, you know, known person who writes about things like cybersecurity and how to be safe on Twitter
00:49:57.840 and right-wing extremism was one of the first accounts banned while Musk was talking about this amnesty
00:50:04.980 and, you know, having Twitter be this place for free speech.
00:50:09.540 Interestingly enough, when Sam Harris asked Elon Musk about bringing back Alex Jones,
00:50:13.580 who you might remember made up egregious lies about babies who died in Sandy Hook
00:50:18.420 and the parents who grieved them, you know, said that they were paid actors and all of that,
00:50:23.040 Elon Musk tweeted,
00:50:24.680 My firstborn child died in my arms. I felt his last heartbeat.
00:50:28.420 I have no mercy for anyone who would use the deaths of children for gain, politics, or fame.
00:50:33.420 And I actually think that that was one of the more transparent, honest statements from Musk about how he sees his role in moderation, right?
00:50:42.620 Like, he can personally identify with the pain of losing a child because Elon Musk, unfortunately, has lost a child.
00:50:49.740 And so it allows him to have a sense of how painful it would be to be a grieving parent grieving that loss and then also be harassed and called a liar on top of that.
00:50:58.380 And so he's going to make those moderation decisions based on that lived experience.
00:51:02.600 It's interesting because I think it totally puts to rest that Elon Musk is like a free speech absolutist because it reveals what's pretty obvious, that these decisions are just made up by him based on like what he does or doesn't like, which is fine.
00:51:15.300 But I also think that like because he can personally identify with losing a child, he is going to moderate from that lived personal experience.
00:51:24.940 But what about experiences that Elon Musk has not personally had, right? So like the experience of somebody like Elliot Page or somebody like Dr. Rachel Levine, who was just a trans person trying to live their life, or the experience of being like a woman of color on a platform like Twitter, who we know are more harassed than our counterparts, right?
00:51:43.100 Or what about being a person with disabilities
00:51:44.900 who relies on the platform to build community, right?
00:51:47.840 Like, because Elon Musk has no personal lived experience
00:51:51.360 with those marginalized identities,
00:51:53.160 it seems like he really can't see those perspectives
00:51:56.000 as real as his own perspective.
00:51:59.340 And it really, it reminds me so much
00:52:00.580 of this like classic George Carlin joke
00:52:02.860 that I've gotten so much mileage out of in my life. 0.99
00:52:05.780 Have you ever noticed that other people's stuff is shit 1.00
00:52:08.640 and your shit is stuff, right? 1.00
00:52:10.200 He can only see his lived experience as real, and everybody else's is just theoretical or trivial or doesn't really matter. 1.00
00:52:19.760 And I don't think that platforms like Twitter should be moderated based on a white billionaire, what is within the scope of his personal lived experience, because there's so many lived experiences out there that he has no idea of.
00:52:35.240 I mean, not everybody gets the experience having people on your staff to make you feel comfortable, including, like, avoiding the color orange, I guess.
00:52:44.960 That's a whole different level of experience.
00:52:47.320 And, you know, not to dedicate the fact that he did lose a child and that was heartful.
00:52:52.500 Like, his wife, ex-wife, came back and was like, dude, you didn't hold that child.
00:52:56.760 I held that child.
00:52:57.640 I held that child. 1.00
00:52:58.020 You were a jerk through this entire process. 1.00
00:53:00.420 And now who's using the death of a child for publicity? 1.00
00:53:04.940 That's interesting. I mean, I'm glad he's acknowledging that's a bad thing. So I guess
00:53:10.080 half a point for that. But it's quite interesting that even that he couldn't be truly honest about
00:53:15.260 and he couldn't actually see beyond his own like, I'm going to make myself look really big by doing
00:53:19.580 this when in actuality, again, his motive in buying this is hurtful for one child and then
00:53:25.760 to lie about that specific thing against the wife who apparently had a lot of issues with
00:53:31.260 Elon Musk in general
00:53:32.820 and to literally dismiss her experiences.
00:53:36.360 There's so many things to this man
00:53:38.040 that I'm just like,
00:53:38.780 what is wrong with you 1.00
00:53:40.120 other than you are a narcissistic sociopath 1.00
00:53:42.300 and I don't know what else to say 1.00
00:53:43.640 except for, oh my God,
00:53:45.400 you're ruining this.
00:53:46.860 Totally.
00:53:47.280 So if anybody out there,
00:53:48.480 like, if you want to read
00:53:50.320 a heartbreaking account of a divorce
00:53:52.820 where you're like,
00:53:54.240 that man is awful,
00:53:56.020 look into Elon Musk's divorce.
00:53:59.560 I read it.
00:54:00.180 It like...
00:54:01.260 haunts me the things that were alleged that happened in that divorce haunts me um so yes
00:54:09.980 yes to all of that and i think like the kind of person who like requires their staffers to do so
00:54:16.960 much labor and energy to have the workplace be to their liking in this in these like really
00:54:25.140 particular ways is the kind of person who sees themselves as the main character of life and
00:54:30.460 doesn't even really question that like i think that's really what's going on here i think that
00:54:33.380 people like elon musk you know i don't know him this is my opinion i think it's hard for them
00:54:39.080 to see other people's perspectives as real and so the kind of person who requires staffers to
00:54:45.600 go around making computers look super cool and sciencey so that he you know gets warm fuzzies
00:54:50.900 and doesn't even see that that is what's is what's happening isn't even able to see that labor so he
00:54:57.320 just thinks like, wow, my company is so great. And he doesn't see the like 20 frustrated staffers.
00:55:02.200 I've been the staffer who has to go out of my way and do a lot of emotional labor to accommodate
00:55:06.940 a person in power who will never even see that labor, doesn't even know that labor has happened.
00:55:11.080 And it's really hard. And it speaks to this perspective of really not being able to see
00:55:16.340 other people. Everybody else is just a side character to your main character, I guess,
00:55:23.060 is how I'll play it. Yeah.
00:55:27.320 We'll be right back.
00:55:57.320 Win to win.
00:55:58.400 Cameron Wickham.
00:55:59.500 Stream the new single, Kingdom of Fear.
00:56:01.480 Available now.
00:56:05.860 Run a business and not thinking about podcasting?
00:56:09.040 Think again.
00:56:10.040 More Americans listen to podcasts than ad-supported streaming music from Spotify and Pandora.
00:56:14.740 And as the number one podcaster, iHeart's twice as large as the next two combined.
00:56:18.800 So whatever your customers listen to, they'll hear your message.
00:56:22.160 Plus, only iHeart can extend your message to audiences across broadcast radio.
00:56:26.060 Think podcasting can help your business?
00:56:28.440 Think iHeart.
00:56:29.440 Streaming, radio, and podcasting.
00:56:31.660 Let us show you at iHeartAdvertising.com.
00:56:34.240 That's iHeartAdvertising.com.
00:56:36.600 If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
00:56:42.540 This is Prose Society, the weekly podcast that's part book club, part group chat for thought daughters,
00:56:48.960 pop culture obsessives, and anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
00:56:55.000 I'm Eli Rallo, and every week we're connecting the dots between books, the internet, and the conversations everyone can't stop having.
00:57:02.100 I'm going to have to look up this story. I'm obsessed. I'm obsessed.
00:57:05.600 From best-selling authors and your favorite book talk creators to the latest pop culture moments, nothing is off the table.
00:57:11.640 It's like if you can hide some real messages inside compelling characters, then that is a Trojan horse.
00:57:19.160 Whether you're looking for literary deep dives, smart pop culture conversations, or a community of readers who love to think a little too much, you're in the right place.
00:57:28.720 Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
00:57:34.660 See you between the pages.
00:57:35.840 You always do such an excellent job of pointing this out, Bridget.
00:57:46.520 But people forget sometimes that technology is not without bias
00:57:51.440 because somebody programmed it, somebody's moderating it.
00:57:54.920 So I think with Elon Musk, without this team of people,
00:57:58.900 with all of these changes and his kind of declaration that,
00:58:04.740 oh, well, I'm going to make it somehow less biased.
00:58:08.140 Like, that's just false.
00:58:09.520 That's just such a lie.
00:58:13.980 And I know we've been talking about this throughout,
00:58:17.580 but what for, you know, everybody who's listening,
00:58:20.120 who's like, oh, well, you know, I don't really use Twitter.
00:58:22.260 I always kind of didn't like it or whatever.
00:58:24.240 What do we stand to lose?
00:58:25.660 Why does this matter?
00:58:27.220 Yeah, I'm so glad that you asked
00:58:28.400 because you might be thinking, okay, I get it.
00:58:30.920 But why do I care?
00:58:32.500 I don't work at Twitter.
00:58:33.580 I'll never work at Twitter.
00:58:34.360 I don't use it.
00:58:34.900 Why do I care?
00:58:35.800 Well, first is the most basic, you know, just Twitter as a place to get quick information,
00:58:41.100 like we were talking about earlier.
00:58:42.640 You know, it has functioned in this way for a long time.
00:58:45.940 You know, when Joe Biden needed to announce the specifics of, like, student loan debt
00:58:50.340 relief, he didn't go to Reddit or Tumblr or Instagram.
00:58:53.740 Twitter is how you get information out quickly.
00:58:55.780 And so, like, when there's an emergency, Twitter is how you get information out about it.
00:59:00.720 Like, I have a friend who works for the State Department.
00:59:02.700 It's Twitter that is being used right now
00:59:05.140 to get important information out to Americans
00:59:08.380 who are traveling to the World Cup, for instance, right?
00:59:11.020 And so if the platform is going to be full of bots
00:59:13.120 and hate speech and accounts
00:59:14.360 and personning other people and bad actors,
00:59:16.680 that whole thing breaks down.
00:59:18.120 Like, think about it.
00:59:18.900 If there was an emergency in your neighborhood right now
00:59:23.480 and you wanted up-to-date, real-time information about it,
00:59:26.500 we don't really have a place to really get that
00:59:28.480 other than Twitter.
00:59:29.280 And I think it really goes to show
00:59:30.460 that we need better public interest communications platforms.
00:59:34.200 But when there's been emergencies in my neighborhood,
00:59:37.160 I'm looking at Twitter to see who is talking about it
00:59:40.080 and what is developing quickly.
00:59:42.180 And so that's just the most basic reason
00:59:45.520 why folks should care.
00:59:46.500 But it's also more than that.
00:59:48.440 Earlier, I was talking about the massive influence
00:59:51.000 that Twitter has and sort of how it's been used
00:59:52.960 to drive progress.
00:59:54.060 I could give you so many examples of the way
00:59:56.060 that Twitter has been used to push conversations forward
00:59:59.140 to get us someplace better.
01:00:00.160 You know, if not for Twitter, we wouldn't have movements like Me Too, you know, which was not just something happening on Twitter.
01:00:06.000 It shifted our entire culture and our entire, you know, the progress of our culture, I would say.
01:00:11.800 For instance, you'll have probably heard of Shanquilla Robinson, who was a 25-year-old Black woman from North Carolina who traveled to Mexico on vacation with a group of people and ended up dead.
01:00:22.620 The people that she traveled with tried to say that it was alcohol poisoning.
01:00:26.080 But later, a video emerged of one of them getting into a pretty brutal physical altercation with her.
01:00:32.480 Now, there's actual movement in the case.
01:00:35.080 And her mother says that it's because of Black Twitter.
01:00:38.000 She says that if not for Black folks tweeting about it, raising the alarm about it, generating awareness about it,
01:00:43.220 she said that she was having a really hard time getting any kind of national attention on the story of her daughter's death.
01:00:49.100 And so she actually says it was Twitter that did that.
01:00:51.360 And so in that case, this rapper, Amina Cain, shared Shanquilla's photo on Twitter on November 9th.
01:00:58.320 Her message went viral.
01:00:59.420 It got almost 20,000 retweets and then later spread to other social media platforms and got so much more attention to her death.
01:01:06.420 And Sherry Williams, who is a professor of race, media, and communication at American University, she put it really well in this interview with NBC News.
01:01:13.180 She says,
01:01:13.540 Black folks know that mainstream news media
01:01:16.240 has a history of completely ignoring our stories.
01:01:18.900 So we've been using these tools
01:01:20.100 to amplify our stories ourselves.
01:01:21.860 And it works.
01:01:22.700 We see this cycle of mainstream news media
01:01:24.840 basically following the chatter 0.88
01:01:26.600 on Black social media like Twitter. 0.96
01:01:28.800 And so it really goes to show 0.97
01:01:30.120 the real world impact
01:01:32.220 that platforms like Twitter can have.
01:01:34.780 Twitter was not perfect.
01:01:36.040 It is not perfect.
01:01:37.060 I have had my issues with it.
01:01:38.220 But we lose so much
01:01:41.080 if we don't have platforms like Twitter
01:01:43.740 Marginalized communities lose so much
01:01:45.480 and our ability to push that culture forward
01:01:47.980 and have those conversations
01:01:49.260 that get us someplace better.
01:01:51.520 There is so much at stake
01:01:53.120 if we do not have social media
01:01:55.520 and digital communications platforms
01:01:57.100 where those kinds of conversations can happen.
01:01:59.740 Yes.
01:02:00.580 Yes, yes, yes.
01:02:01.660 I totally agree.
01:02:02.840 And I think that that's one thing
01:02:05.360 that kind of gives me anxiety
01:02:06.660 is when I hear people like,
01:02:07.980 well, I didn't like Twitter.
01:02:08.800 I'm like, but that can be a very privileged thing
01:02:11.120 to just be like, oh, it goes away.
01:02:12.600 because there are people in other countries
01:02:13.760 that use it to organize and to communicate.
01:02:15.820 It's a very powerful tool,
01:02:17.880 especially if you're kind of isolated
01:02:19.540 and maybe you don't have a lot of people
01:02:22.780 in your community or where you grew up
01:02:25.180 to talk to, to share ideas with.
01:02:28.020 It's important.
01:02:29.260 It's really, really important.
01:02:32.340 So I'm glad you brought this today.
01:02:35.600 I'm glad that you brought these points
01:02:37.760 because I just feel like there is so much at stake
01:02:41.260 And a lot of it's getting kind of lost in the chaos of what's happening with Twitter and why it matters is getting lost in all this chaos.
01:02:51.880 So thank you, as always, Bridget.
01:02:54.700 Oh, of course.
01:02:55.560 And if folks listening, like, if you have questions about Twitter alternatives, like, let's chat.
01:03:02.200 I have questions.
01:03:03.360 What should we do?
01:03:04.580 So that's a great question.
01:03:06.180 I have, I guess I, the platforms that I see people going to are Hive and Mastodon.
01:03:15.980 I'm still trying to figure them all out.
01:03:18.240 They all have their issues, but yeah, people have been talking about moving to Hive, Mastodon, Post, all of these different platforms all have their issues.
01:03:26.900 Like there's been big conversations about the funding structure and the moderation structure.
01:03:31.900 So I will be trying them all out myself, and I'm happy to report back and let y'all know, like, what worked, what didn't work, what's a flop, what's a bop.
01:03:40.500 I'll let y'all know, TBD.
01:03:42.400 That's amazing.
01:03:43.220 Yes, please.
01:03:44.240 Yeah, please let us know, because, like, Mastodon seems super confusing and very specific.
01:03:48.700 Hive may not be ready for the mass movement, is what I'm reading.
01:03:53.180 But, and then also, I know Discord is a thing, which I've been told that we should have one.
01:03:57.920 So, Bridget, let's have, Annie, let's have a Discord for us.
01:04:01.100 of Smithy plus Bridget
01:04:03.060 and then having like
01:04:04.100 questionnaires with the people
01:04:05.280 and then deciding
01:04:06.120 where to go maybe.
01:04:07.400 Oh my gosh.
01:04:07.980 I love this.
01:04:08.980 Yes.
01:04:09.360 So I actually,
01:04:10.300 even before Twitter
01:04:11.320 was bought by Musk,
01:04:12.000 I've always loved Discord.
01:04:13.460 Okay.
01:04:13.860 It's super fun.
01:04:15.620 Yeah, let's have a Discord channel
01:04:16.700 where we can like
01:04:17.260 cash all this out.
01:04:18.940 Let's do it.
01:04:19.480 Oh my gosh.
01:04:20.500 Yes, let us do it.
01:04:21.720 Get online, y'all.
01:04:23.040 Is that a saying?
01:04:24.080 Is that a saying?
01:04:24.540 Did I do this right?
01:04:25.740 Let's make it a saying.
01:04:27.220 Get online, y'all.
01:04:28.220 I'm going to do it.
01:04:31.100 I'm fine.
01:04:32.320 I'm fine.
01:04:34.200 We are the coolest, obviously.
01:04:37.480 This reminds me of the Britney Spears interview where she's like,
01:04:40.380 everyone's talking about the emails.
01:04:44.240 Yeah, that's about right.
01:04:45.920 I'll take it. 0.93
01:04:46.900 Like Britney Spears.
01:04:47.860 That's me.
01:04:48.680 Yes, yes.
01:04:50.560 Well, Bridget, the actual coolest.
01:04:53.340 Where can the listeners find you?
01:04:55.660 You can find me on Instagram at BridgetMarieNDC.
01:04:58.680 You can find me.
01:04:59.380 I still have a Twitter account, but tweeting a lot less these days at Bridget Marie.
01:05:03.180 You can listen to me on my podcast, There Are No Girls on the Internet.
01:05:06.720 And my new limited series with Cool Zone Media called Internet Hate Machine,
01:05:10.680 where we dive into all the ways that the internet can be a not-so-fun place for women and people of color. 0.69
01:05:17.100 Yes, super important to this conversation. 0.71
01:05:19.600 And definitely, listeners, go check it out if you haven't already.
01:05:24.240 Thank you again, Bridget, for being here.
01:05:26.080 Always a delight.
01:05:26.740 and thank you listeners for listening
01:05:29.680 if you would like to contact us you can
01:05:31.680 or email us Stephanie and MomStuff at iHeartMedia
01:05:33.580 you can find us on Twitter at MomStuffPodcast
01:05:36.380 or on Instagram at StephonNeverToldYou
01:05:38.180 thanks as always to our super producer Christina
01:05:40.280 thank you and thanks to you for listening
01:05:42.280 StephonNeverToldYou's production of iHeartRadio
01:05:44.080 for more podcasts on iHeartRadio you can check out the iHeartRadio app
01:05:46.660 Apple Podcasts or wherever you listen to your favorite shows
01:05:56.740 I survived nine months in captivity and I've spent my life exploring how other people survive
01:06:06.900 what should have destroyed them. I'm Elizabeth Smart and these are the Survivor Files. Every
01:06:12.920 week I'm with survivors who live through the unthinkable, abducted, stalked, controlled,
01:06:18.320 and nearly silenced. These are stories about what it takes to make it out alive.
01:06:23.500 Listen to The Survivor Files with Elizabeth Smart on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:06:31.880 If your bookshelf and your For You page are equally important to your personality, welcome home.
01:06:37.660 Pro Society is a weekly podcast that's part book club, part group chat for anyone who thinks Pride and Prejudice and Love Island deserve the same level of discourse.
01:06:45.960 Each week, we're connecting the dots between books, the internet, and pop culture
01:06:49.440 with your favorite writers, book talk creators, and plenty of overthought opinions.
01:06:54.200 Yeah, I'm obsessed. I'm obsessed.
01:06:55.980 Listen to Pro Society on the iHeartRadio app, Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:07:01.920 Hey, it's Nora Jones, and my podcast, Playing Along, is back with more of my favorite musicians.
01:07:06.760 Check out my newest episode with Phineas.
01:07:09.560 So I went home and I asked Billie if she wanted to sing it.
01:07:12.400 she immediately made it her own thing.
01:07:24.540 So come hang out with us in the studio and listen to Playing Along on the iHeart Radio app,
01:07:29.140 Apple Podcasts, or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:07:32.100 This is an iHeart Podcast.
01:07:34.720 Guaranteed human.