00:02:14.340Trans women? And if these women were justifiably angry about not having been included in the
00:02:19.900movement, would that brand of feminism make room for that anger? Ten years ago, writer Mickey
00:02:26.060Kendall had had enough. She started the hashtag Solidarity is for White Women on Twitter,0.87
00:02:31.520and it took off in a way that's almost kind of hard to imagine here in 2023.0.95
00:02:36.240Solidarity is for White Women was meant to pull back the curtain and expose the ways that white
00:02:40.440feminism had left so many Black and brown women to fend for ourselves. In exposing this,
00:02:46.560Mickey Kendall changed the face of online feminism. But it didn't necessarily make her well-liked by1.00
00:02:52.060the people she was calling out. But for Mickey, if being liked by everyone is the cost of being
00:02:57.900able to speak her truth, then it's not worth it. I was the most unpopular, popular girl in feminism.1.00
00:03:10.440i know how that sounds but it was like i was the mean black girl of sixth grade
00:03:16.240and it was hilarious to me because i have a life offline and i have friends and things like that
00:03:21.800but the things that i could say to make people mad that were perfectly innocuous everyone wanted
00:03:29.620me to know relatively regularly of that like rbg shirt whatever kind of end of feminism1.00
00:03:36.560that I was never going to write for Jezebel that I was killing my career or whatever everyone1.00
00:03:41.680didn't know these things and the whole time I worked for the federal government like I had a
00:03:45.000regular job so I wasn't sure what career I was killing right by saying things and then I had
00:03:53.880all of these black and brown and all of these other people who were fine who we got along great
00:03:57.700um but there was like a small core group of predominantly white not entirely
00:04:02.780a predominantly white feminist who really wanted me to know that I was mean to them at regular1.00
00:04:08.820intervals. And I understood the performance on display. And then I just was like, well,0.84
00:04:15.940I guess you're going to get your feelings hurt today, sis. You'll be all right.
00:04:19.540In 2013, NPR does a piece about the hashtag Mickey created. They include responses from
00:04:24.980prominent online feminists, including a white feminist Kendall specifically called out for
00:04:30.060failing to show up for Black women. Now, the piece was a response to something that she created,0.99
00:04:34.760but they didn't even include her. There was pushback, so much so that NPR was forced to
00:04:40.180address the oversight, saying, Kendall kicked it off, and we should have asked Kendall to
00:04:45.240participate from the beginning. That was our mistake. NPR eventually invites Kendall to
00:04:50.140participate in the conversation, where she writes, this is a conversation after conflict,
00:04:55.160because sometimes the political is personal.
00:04:58.660Now, there's really no way to engage with conflict as a Black woman publicly1.00
00:05:02.580without the stigma of angry or mean clinging to you wherever you go like smoke.0.97
00:05:08.780A year later, Mickey is back at NPR as part of a feminist roundtable1.00
00:05:13.080in the wake of a piece examining whether online feminism is too toxic, too mean.
00:05:18.300And in fact, a big part of the piece examines whether Mickey herself is mean or not.0.98
00:05:25.160One of the questions that comes up is basically, Mickey, do you think that you're a bully? And your answer is spot on. You're basically like, you know, can people feel however they're going to feel about the things I have to say and the frustrations that I have? Sure.
00:05:39.940But we're also at a time when people are being duxed, trans people are being threatened. Your answer almost kind of feels like looking into this crystal ball of horrible things to come where we have people who are, you know, losing their rights, being threatened, being killed.
00:05:57.140And there's always going to be this subsection of people who are like, are they being nice enough about it, though, when they talk about it?
00:06:03.500so funny story that that round table happens uh basically because the internet bullied npr
00:06:11.520and not even that i bullied npr the internet bullies npr right so there's that
00:06:16.900and then because npr was going to have that round table about me without me if that makes sense0.98
00:06:24.440and there's been several things already and I was astonished at how just stupid the complaints0.89
00:06:34.920were and like listen I'm never going to tell you I'm a nice person right I actually explicitly0.98
00:06:39.100tell people if I had a brand it would be affable asshole right but also it took absolutely nothing
00:06:47.760in an era of doxing, of harassment, to hurt the feelings of some of these people.0.92
00:06:54.020And I do mean saying, well, no, you're wrong.0.77
00:16:31.760Solidarity is for white women, she tweeted.
00:16:34.500And it was like she had broken something open.
00:16:37.400What started as Mickey's response to the movement overlooking Black women became a rallying cry, exposing all the tensions and fractures in feminist spaces online.
00:16:46.520Do you think if you tweeted, solidarity is for white women today in 2023, it would take off the way that it did back in 2013?
00:16:54.460I think in theory it could, but in execution what will happen is that Twitter will suppress the hashtag.
00:17:01.580um because the other reason i think solidified when happens is that it is at the beginning of
00:17:07.660the concept of hashtags as calls as calls as a call to action so twitter didn't know what to do
00:17:14.880with me right most of the viral hashtag phenomenon hadn't started yet i'm not saying i actually
00:17:20.940started it but i'm one of the very early ones where that happened organically and twitter didn't
00:17:27.320know what it had either twitter was still figuring itself out right like if you were on twitter in
00:17:32.2202009 you remember a very different twitter than twitter of today right when the hashtag happened
00:17:40.420it was still kind of like the wild wild west in terms of the algorithm because twitter was still
00:17:44.580trying to figure out how to make the algorithm work for advertising revenue for all of these
00:17:49.500things it was still mostly third-party clients making twitter even a usable experience right
00:17:55.980Twitter had to buy everybody that made Twitter possible to use.
00:18:00.780When you first started it, did you create it thinking this is going to like crack things open?
00:27:18.020Mickey did the work of exposing existing tensions and fractures that exist in our movement.
00:27:22.820But in order to heal tensions, there has to be reflection, honesty, and accountability, which just didn't really happen.
00:27:31.940So these tensions were left to be exploited by bad actors, like the ones behind the end Father's Day hoax to inflame tensions in feminist online spaces that would take place just a year later.
00:27:43.100Something that we have talked about quite a bit on this podcast is sort of what came immediately after things like the disinformation troll campaign hashtag and Father's Day.
00:27:55.300And I think something that solidarity is for white women exposed is the reality and the rawness of these tensions between black women, black feminists and white feminists.
00:28:09.320And I think that bad actors, trolls, extremists, whatever you want to call it, people who are interested in using social media spaces to cause confusion and chaos, I think the movement's lack of really taking accountability, really examining what happened, really figuring out how we navigate around each other and with each other.
00:28:32.620I think that you're right. There was, there was broadly not no interest in really doing that and having those conversations. And thus, I think that bad actors know like, okay, well, this is a tension that exists. It's a tension that is being kind of danced around, you know, everyone feels it, but no one's really, people aren't really talking about it openly because they don't want to.
00:28:53.740We can go in and exploit it. We can go in and seize it and inflame it, and it might be effective because no one's really naming it. No one's really talking about it. Nobody's really interested in taking accountability for their part in it.
00:29:06.020Do you ever think that the lack of interest in real accountability and looking backward and taking stock just leaves these communities online vulnerable to people who will step in and exploit and talk about it, just not in the way that maybe it's going to be helpful?
00:29:23.540Oh, I think it absolutely. It's one of those things with just how we got all those feminists talking to like Mila Yiannopoulos and engaging sort of disingenuously with the idea that Megyn Kelly was, you know, not necessarily racist, right?
00:29:47.240Because everyone started to kind of go, well, you know, people can be swayed, people can be wooed. And I wonder often about the people who at that point kept saying we have to reach out to the other side because the other side was very clearly, very cogently planning to sow discord, very much trying to widen rifts.
00:30:13.260And also using those conversations, those educational conversations to boost their own platforms, right? Because when you think back to 2013, really all the way up to 2016, and actually even before 2013, a lot of those, well, I want to talk to a white nationalist, a person who identifies as a white separatist, whatever.
00:30:38.820You remember all of those news stories, all of the, like, inside the mind of a Klansman kind of news stories, right, for a while.
00:30:49.760Nobody had ever given them a platform.
00:32:49.920But Mickey reminds us that our communities are resilient and that we'll always find a way.
00:32:55.320How do you see the state that Twitter is in and sort of social media more broadly,
00:33:00.420How do you see that impacting marginalized communities' ability to build up power and build up a voice?
00:33:07.180I think in some ways, and this is going to sound real strange, but the existence of TikTok and all the competing other sites will help, you know, Mastodon, all of these things, will help marginalized communities find a place to rebuild the networks that they had on Twitter for some levels.
00:33:29.420levels of of rebuild here um but only because twitter was already not particularly usable for
00:33:37.440community anymore once all eyes were on twitter it seemed like all the time remember that like
00:33:42.540weird period of time where anything you tweeted could wind up on your television screen that
00:33:46.980night as news or in an article yeah that was a wild time right people already started to kind
00:33:55.060of migrate away from Twitter, right? Twitter's popularity as a social media app was on a decline.
00:34:00.660People were just abandoning their Twitter accounts, whatever, and moving to Discord and all these other
00:34:05.200places. And so I think it will make it more difficult to kick off an initial group, but also
00:34:12.860in some ways now it is easier to have those conversations without necessarily as much
00:34:18.840trolling. This weird split where like, yes, the loss of Twitter is a big deal, but also Twitter
00:34:53.360Like, I definitely felt that when it came to being part of Black Twitter for a while, where you definitely feel like these people over here are doing something distinct of their own, and let's lurk at it.
00:35:04.180It kind of, in a lot of ways, you wanted to be having these insular conversations, but the feeling that they were happening in a bit of a fishbowl digitally.
00:35:12.640And that, I think, that level of surveillance culture is not something I'm going to miss, right?
00:35:19.540i i had already twitter for me had been rendered largely unusable for like socializing with
00:35:26.400friends kinds of things a while before this because and not even in a major way but in a
00:35:32.700no matter what there was always someone who had thoughts feelings opinions right and it's like
00:35:38.740the api is being altered to prevent a lot of third-party clients i know like today someone
00:35:45.240was saying that one of the things that made Twitter usable for visually impaired users,
00:37:19.360I saw in your piece for MIT Tech Review, I think that you, I can't remember exactly how you put it, but you had it, like, it's not a platform to live one's life.
00:37:28.380You know, it's like, it's not a place where you're necessarily going to look for a connection.
00:37:33.340And it sounded like even in your personal life that Twitter just wasn't it for you anymore,
00:37:39.380that like you just weren't interested.
00:37:41.240I think that you described it when you do show up there, it feels like it's out of habit
00:37:46.340It's not like you're going there looking for connection.0.99
00:37:49.460Oh, yeah, because I can tell you a really stupid story about how I got done with using0.93
00:37:56.640Twitter socially I was talking to a friend of mine and we were talking about um a workout routine0.98
00:38:04.020that we had both tried and someone briefly tried to turn that into like pro um like a fat phobic
00:38:15.980oh this is really fat phobic having this conversation in public and we had said
00:38:21.940nothing about anyone's bodies not even really our own other than the usual uh
00:38:26.640Yeah, I tried blah, blah, blah. It was really rough, kind of. You know how you talk about things. And I couldn't figure out how we got there. And then there's this entire conversation happening in my mentions about whether or not this conversation with my friend about a workout we had both tried was really about something else.
00:38:46.960And I thought, I have hit the point where we are reading into things.
00:38:51.720I always wondered how that would feel.
00:39:02.860And as more things move to the group chat, I have a hustling, bustling series of group chats going on.
00:39:12.100I don't necessarily think to go to Twitter in the same way in my personal life anymore.
00:39:18.980I don't even necessarily react to everything on Twitter because sometimes news stories pass by
00:39:25.220or someone tweeting something passes by. And in my brain, I think this does not pass the smell test.
00:39:31.820But it's not worth getting into it with people who are buying in on the spot to whatever is being said
00:39:37.220because they're going to find out in a few minutes or a few hours that they were wrong
00:39:41.520And they're going to want to erase all of their tweets about this, all of their engagement with this, you know, and I don't even need to jump in and participate.
00:39:53.020I can have this conversation with people who actually have a conversation.
00:39:56.740Oh, this is something I have absolutely felt.
00:39:58.940The story that you told about the workout with your friend, I have this theory that we've reached a point where we have visibility into too many conversations between strangers, where people are just injecting and projecting a lot of their own stuff onto the conversations of strangers in ways that if you did it in real life,
00:40:25.980If you were in a cafeteria and two people were talking about a workout they had done, and I walked up to their table and sat down and said, this conversation is fatphobic, and maybe it's actually about something else altogether, you would think that was the weirdest thing in the world.
00:40:39.180And I think that we've, I do think that we've hit a point where these platforms cease to
00:40:44.000be useful when they, when they are, when they feel this way, because, because it's just
00:40:47.940not, it's not a, an enjoy, it's not a way to connect with people that feels enjoyable.
00:40:53.060That level of surveillance, every little thing that you say, feeling like someone's
00:40:57.380going to take it the wrong way or project their own, their own stuff onto it.
00:41:02.240Well, and this is the thing, because I definitely started to feel like at a certain point,
00:41:09.180Is this about what I said, or am I just where you put your feelings?
00:41:18.200And I think a lot of it is just where they put their feelings, right?
00:41:23.400And if that's the case, I don't need to be here for this.
00:41:27.780And I think that, and then I think about how many of my friends who, like I have a friend who pointed out to me one day, I tweeted something she said because I thought it was funny.
00:41:36.420And she says, I know you didn't mean any harm, but can you not retweet me?
00:41:39.980Because I always end up with all of this crap in my mentions.
00:41:43.660And I was, you know, very apologetic, offered to tweet.0.75
00:41:45.880And she was like, no, no, no, it's not like it's your fault.
00:41:47.740I just know your level of visibility is too much for me.
00:41:54.980And I hadn't, I, you know, like the frog in boiling water, I had gotten used to it.
00:41:59.740But I hadn't thought about what it feels like to kind of be thrust into this level of thing.
00:42:05.820And even though I will still occasionally retweet people or whatever, or quote tweet them, I try to be more judicious. I'm not always successful. I don't always think about impact, but I try to be more judicious when I do do it because there's this point in the hypervisibility where I don't want people to be having a conversation about the things they didn't say.
00:42:25.280um i want to talk about the things they did say or i have a thought about what they said kind of
00:42:32.660and i don't know where we go on twitter with that like i don't see a way to salvage that part
00:42:40.080at this point you know the way that you put that of like am i just a place where you put your
00:42:44.720feelings i'm not super visible on on any social media platform but i do wonder if that has
00:42:50.820something to do with you being a Black woman, that you, something about the way that you show
00:42:56.960up online for folks as a Black woman means that you are the place where a lot of their feelings0.85
00:43:03.320go. That whether it's feelings of anger or wanting to call somebody out or wanting to show you
00:43:09.860something so that you have a publicly angry reaction, and that feels a certain way for them,
00:43:13.700where you kind of aren't a real person. You're just this abstraction online for them to
00:43:20.700project whatever they want onto you do you ever feel that oh absolutely it's one of those things
00:43:26.820first of all i had to tell people to stop sending me things for me to respond to right like for a
00:43:31.120while there people would tag me in their arguments with random people i don't know you i don't know
00:43:35.780them i'm not joining into the middle of a conversation whatever but also it started to feel
00:43:43.360like i am not a person oh god so many people to go um because and this is another sort of silly
00:43:53.120story someone was mad about something i had said apparently they started tweeting about it at
00:43:59.000around 3 a.m my time okay somewhere in the following four hours they had worked themselves
00:44:07.180up to the point that you know i was avoiding them i was ignoring them how dare i was i you know a0.53
00:44:12.820coward, blah, blah, blah. And I get up, I get my kids out the door to school. And I used to for a
00:44:18.780while on my way to work, I would, you know, fart around on Twitter on the way in. And I log on and
00:44:25.020I'm like, what is this? Because I was asleep. It is 7 a.m., right? What the heck are you doing?
00:44:36.360What is wrong with you kind of thing? And this person who had spun themselves into a frenzy in
00:44:41.820the middle of the night says i completely forgot the difference in time zones you weren't ignoring
00:44:49.220me i'm sorry and ends up deleting probably like 40 tweets but also i had never responded to you
00:44:54.900and you had never thought about the fact that i wasn't awake just because you were it didn't even
00:45:02.080occur to you person whose name i i won't say that i was a person with a life and responsibilities
00:45:08.200right like had not even crossed their mind i have a joke i tell friends there are no sick days
00:45:14.340on the internet and yet in real life people take off work so how do we expect people to
00:45:22.080be available 24 7 online it makes no sense and yet that is how everyone is operating sometimes
00:45:28.940oh yeah i've seen people get very for lack of a way of putting it get very in their feelings
00:47:24.300may or may not really be paying attention
00:47:26.720to the reality that you are a whole person.
00:47:29.540One of the things that always sticks out to me is this idea that because you like someone, they can never be wrong. They absolutely can be wrong. Did that make sense outside of my head?
00:47:41.980It made so much sense. And the vibe of because I like this person, I am team them for life. If they say anything wrong, it must be right. I don't think there's a that's got to be one of the most dangerous, toxic vibes that we have where I see it play out all the time.
00:48:02.680And, like, these are people, they're not going to, just because somebody had a great take or wrote a great piece on one thing doesn't mean that you should blindly sign up for their takes on everything and, like, be invested in them never being wrong, you know?
00:48:16.800It's like, I don't know how we got to such a weird place when it comes to relationships and how they function online.
00:48:22.740I think part of what's happened, unfortunately, and I'm seeing this even more on TikTok, is that the entertainment people get, right, let's call it like the skits you see on TikTok, the storytelling, whatever, on Twitter, all of these things that have happened over and over again on various platforms, makes people feel like this stuff is there for them.
00:48:48.240it is not necessarily that this person is doing something to entertain themselves that you happen
00:48:55.000to like it has become oh this performance is for me this article this writing this whatever is for
00:49:01.240me and therefore everything here is about me for me and i don't have to have any sense of boundaries
00:49:09.120or limits or really grasp that this was just someone making a thing that was in their head
00:49:15.420Right? We feel an ownership stake in the things we are fans of.
00:49:21.820I was a fan of Twitter 10 years ago, as much as I criticized it.
00:49:25.580And that ownership stake Mickey describes?
00:49:28.540Well, as I watch the platform that I once loved become something else entirely, I feel that too.
00:49:36.100In a piece for MIT Tech Review, Mickey looks back on a career that she's built in part on Twitter and what the future of platforms holds.
00:49:44.100Twitter's importance five years ago cannot be overstated, she writes.
00:49:47.640But now, as we look at the possibility of a future without Twitter,
00:49:51.440will anything really change for the average person who uses the internet but doesn't live on it?
00:49:56.920Setting the scene for where we are and where we go next.
00:50:00.320Like, I've seen so many people, myself included, writing about how much Twitter sucks now that Elon Musk has taken over, blah, blah, blah.
00:50:08.140But in your MIT tech review piece, you kind of pick up on something else.0.96
00:50:11.660Yeah, Elon Musk sucks and Twitter sucks because of him and all of that. But really, do you think that something there's sort of a larger cultural shift happening that is actually being mirrored via our use of technology?
00:50:27.040That it's not just about Elon Musk being like sucking and ruining Twitter. Something else is happening where folks are just not that invested in showing up on platforms like Twitter.
00:50:37.380Maybe they're spending more time on platforms like TikTok. Maybe they're less interested in social media as we all get older. Do you think something is happening more broadly in culture and that we're just experiencing that through technology and our relationship to it?
00:50:51.240I think what's happening is that for a lot of people,
00:50:56.280A, as we are getting older, the earlier social media users,
00:51:00.000but also for a lot of people who grew up with social media,
00:51:02.980and I was having this conversation with a college student last night,
00:52:15.820And maybe you have some things that are public,
00:52:18.140But you don't let everyone see what you're doing. You don't have your business in everyone's eyeballs because you don't want everyone else's business in your eyeballs.
00:52:29.640I think that we are also going to see the rise of those kids who were the early mommy blogger content, right? Like parent blog content kids. They're almost adults now. Some of them are legally adults.
00:52:44.360i think for a lot of them the financial impact of having been content for 20 years but not
00:52:52.600necessarily being paid for being that content and having that experience shape their future
00:52:58.520means we're going to see a lot of people in in court in federal court very soon right because
00:53:05.060for all that we have said about the most successful of them the kids who were memes whatever those
00:53:10.140kids have grown up and yet when you google their names it's the meme it's the mommy blog content
00:53:15.700it's the pictures of them with a poopy diaper on their head or whatever that comes up and mom and
00:53:22.440dad or grandpa grandpa our guardians whoever they made the money they got the checks but the kids
00:53:28.560get consequences i don't foresee those kids being interested in social media and i think they will be
00:53:34.040part of a growing number of people who are just like we should not know this much about each other
00:53:39.500about total strangers. I think people will still use social media to some degree, but I think the
00:53:43.760way we use it is going to change again. So you think that we should really be letting the younger
00:53:48.080generation take the lead. Where do you see them leading us? Yeah, I think they will have some
00:53:55.560form. I think that they're going to like kind of reinvent private social media, right? Whether it
00:54:00.340will be Snapchat or something else, but I think they're going to reinvent that kind of thing.
00:54:04.360um where they'll want to be able to talk to their friends but i don't know that they're
00:54:09.220going to want to be able to talk to their friends in a way the general public can see
00:54:13.320because i'll be honest not being able to like
00:54:17.020lock individual tweets was always a weird thing about twitter
00:54:20.920it always invited a certain level of harassment and and just unpleasant context because twitter
00:54:31.720definitely knew, right, way before we got to any of the conversations. Twitter definitely knew
00:54:36.640about 4chan and on Reddit and all of those things, right? And we're seeing people who post on Reddit
00:54:41.800say, oh man, this stuff is going all over. These things are going viral. I'm sure some of that is
00:54:47.820intentional. I just don't know that we really need to see everything with your face attached.
00:54:54.140yeah I I hate being perceived on social media I'm every time I like have a few glasses of wine and
00:55:02.260spent and like actually do some tweeting when I wake up the next day and I see like oh you've got
00:55:07.260five replies I'm like oh no why did I do this to myself I hate it so much and I mean I think
00:55:13.880the answer unfortunately is um it used to be fun it used to be great to like hang out and talk to
00:55:21.560your friends and sometimes you slip up and you forget that the way social media functions has
00:55:26.300also changed right like we've changed but also now you have people who get online and they're
00:55:32.660looking for a fight and they don't care who it's with and it doesn't have to be on a particular
00:55:36.480topic it's not something they feel passionately about it's something that they just want someplace
00:55:42.700to argue right and a lot of times like we call it sea lining right the guys that just want a good
00:55:47.500debate and then won't go away what else do you do but decide okay well people have perceived me
00:55:56.040this person won't leave me alone or these people or whatever sure you meet the conversations you
00:56:01.920do all of these things but at a certain point where's the payoff for you in getting online in
00:56:08.000the first place right i don't know if it wasn't still related to like my books my work my whatever
00:56:15.560I don't know if I, right now, if I were coming into social media now, right, like I was 24
00:56:21.320years old or whatever, and my job didn't require it, I'm not sure how much I'd use it.
00:56:26.380Well, I guess this leads me to kind of my awkward final question, which is,
00:56:30.580where can folks keep in touch with you?
00:56:33.660After all this, it feels weird to be like, oh, should they tweet at you?
00:56:37.280But where can folks, like, what are you up to next?
00:56:39.860And where can folks keep in touch with all your work?