Under the Influence (with Jo Piazza) - July 29, 2025


Gwyneth Paltrow: First Influencer or MAHA Godmother? With Amy Odell

Topics
Sunday Nice Things: LEAD Can Plastic Surgery Keep Up With AI?

Episode Stats


Length

41 minutes

Words per minute

182.74

Word count

7,590

Sentence count

283

Harmful content

Misogyny

21

sentences flagged

Toxicity

7

sentences flagged

Hate speech

7

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 Hey y'all, Jo here, and you are listening to Under the Influence. A bombshell new memoir
00:00:12.540 of Gwyneth Paltrow is hitting shelves today, and I am completely obsessed with it. Now,
00:00:19.120 I gotta say, I truly consider Gwynny to be one of the world's first-er influencers. In
00:00:28.460 my opinion, she was definitely, definitely one of the first A-list celebrities to embrace social
00:00:34.760 media and digital culture in a very real way. No matter what you think about her and opinions
00:00:41.860 about Gwen, be strong. Okay, you either love her or hate her. I don't actually know anyone
00:00:47.700 who has an in-between about her. But no matter how you feel, you gotta give her credit for
00:00:54.920 building a lot of things, some of them good, some of them not so good. And we're going to get into
00:01:01.080 all of it today, including how a lot of people, including the author of this biography, Amy O'Dell,
00:01:08.540 truly believe that Gwyneth paved the way for the Maha movement and that she could definitely
00:01:15.420 do more to stop it. This book has so much going on. I mean, it gets into the friendship breakup 0.99
00:01:22.540 between Gwyneth and Madonna. It also dives deep into Gwyneth's relationships. Brad Pitt and Ben
00:01:31.300 Affleck, apparently Ben Affleck, is very skilled in the bedroom. Or maybe it's just skilled in a
00:01:36.820 way that Gwyneth enjoyed, because according to this book, she likes something that I don't think
00:01:43.060 any woman likes. And I'm not going to say what the actual act is. I will say that it rhymes
00:01:50.880 with sea-hagging. Sit with that for a second. Sit with that, and the image will never leave
00:02:00.440 your mind. It will not. Ben Affleck and Gwyneth Paltrow friends, sea-hagging. So I want to get
00:02:08.160 into it. I want to get into it. You probably know Amy O'Dell from her back row substack,
00:02:12.760 from her incredible biography of Anna Wintour. She's just a badass journalist in the best of 0.95
00:02:20.760 both the old school and the new school ways. And reading her is a joy, as is talking to
00:02:27.520 her, which I got to do this weekend. I was desperate to have her on the pod the day the
00:02:31.700 book came out. But we're both busy women, busy working moms, and yet we squeezed it
00:02:36.880 in in the middle of playdates and dinner and birthday parties and all of the stuff. Because
00:02:42.600 women, women get shit done. Here's Amy. Hello, my dear. How you doing? I'm great. How are you? 1.00
00:02:54.180 I'm good. I'm good. I don't even know where to start this interview because there's there's like
00:03:00.020 so many entry points into Gwyneth Paltrow and your new book is juicy, but not just juicy. It's
00:03:08.860 also smart because you're charting a woman's career. And I think anytime that you're looking
00:03:15.320 at the career path of someone as ambitious as Gwyneth Paltrow, much as you did Anna Wintour,
00:03:23.100 it's complicated and it is fascinating. So I don't know what to go after first,
00:03:27.120 the juicy bits, the career bits, or just ask you what you think of the astronomer commercial.
00:03:33.580 Yeah, I was going to say astronomer. Obviously, I had to look at that basically all day Saturday
00:03:37.660 and uh which was the day after it it launched because i think she launched it on friday 1.00
00:03:42.900 yeah um and of course everyone was sending it to me i mean look she's a cultural um influencer for
00:03:49.540 sure uh i think there are a few celebrities who have had the longevity that she has she's been in 0.80
00:03:54.860 public eye for 30 years um and i think that that video is kind of an example of why she knows how
00:04:02.040 to create a media moment for herself um anyway but i do think that uh you know a lot of people
00:04:09.460 ask me was that a do you think that was a response to your book like trying to draw attention away
00:04:13.460 from the book i don't know truthfully what i do what i would feel certain guessing is that she
00:04:21.380 was paid for it i don't know how much yes people have been asking me to guess how much because you
00:04:29.320 know like celebrity celebrity inc celebrity money stuff like was long my forte and i so i know i
00:04:37.600 loved that project yeah yeah i was i mean oh wait what would you guess because i have a guess
00:04:43.480 i guessed five million oh i was gonna guess one okay no i guessed five i guessed five they feel
00:04:50.840 like someone like her could come in because it was a full-blown commercial it wasn't just a reel
00:04:56.860 or a post and so it feels like commercial sponsorship level to me okay the reason I'm
00:05:04.520 guessing a million is because it was just a video it looked like she may have even shot it herself
00:05:10.160 do you know what I mean oh 100% I think she may have shot it in her house yeah yeah it didn't look
00:05:15.300 like a day she would have had to spend in the studio so that's probably why I'm guessing a
00:05:19.280 million but I do know I mean I know the value of some of her other like endorsement and like 0.82
00:05:25.200 public appearance work. So she went to the Saudi Film Festival. I think it's the Red Sea
00:05:29.920 International Film Festival. Very controversial for celebrities to be going to this and getting
00:05:34.840 paid for it because of the killing of Jamal Khashoggi. But then Hollywood, I guess, decided
00:05:43.140 people had bills to pay. This is how it was described to me. People had bills to pay and
00:05:47.900 they were just going to go and get their check. She got one point six million for going to that
00:05:51.860 for showing up and yeah and she um well she may have spoken forgive me i don't i don't remember
00:05:59.160 off the top of my head but she uh she also was paid 250 000 for appearing at the skims
00:06:05.140 swarovski party in 2023 around holiday time with kim kardashian and that was part of a bigger
00:06:11.360 1.25 million dollar deal she had with swarovski to wear their pieces uh like a certain number of
00:06:19.820 times and um my understanding is that a lot of her money a lot of her income comes from these
00:06:25.180 endorsement deals so they're important to her um and that one had the bonus the astronomer one i
00:06:30.380 mean had the bonus of creating this viral moment for her where everyone was talking about her for
00:06:34.980 a day yeah yeah so i mean people are still talking about it people brought it up to me today
00:06:39.140 at my at my book event there because i was i did a sub stack on the cold play cheating thing and
00:06:44.660 how it's just the one thing no one can get enough of and they're like wait a second did you see the
00:06:48.700 one of the paltrow thing and i'm like yeah we've all i mean the world has seen it now
00:06:51.780 how do you not see it i mean maybe five million is off but i also thought because they're so
00:06:56.500 desperate that i'm like maybe we're so desperate that maybe they're she's just like she could
00:07:03.140 probably name anything and they'd be like okay this this could be the one thing and it is because
00:07:08.340 no one had heard of astronomer before this yeah i mean who still really knows what they do like
00:07:13.060 i think a lot of people know that she was in the video but i don't know how many people watched it
00:07:16.900 and, like, listen to what she said about the company.
00:07:19.160 No, no, no, no.
00:07:20.040 I don't think I'm a real astronomer, and I don't know her.
00:07:24.240 I mean, one person told me I interviewed so many people to write the book,
00:07:27.760 more than 220, and one person told me that one person who worked with her
00:07:32.100 closely said they got the sense that she didn't know who she was
00:07:35.480 if people weren't writing about her.
00:07:36.820 So there's something about her that, like, I don't know.
00:07:40.900 It's like she needs that in a way.
00:07:44.520 Mm-hmm.
00:07:44.760 that's real I mean that's really interesting that's a great line too that she doesn't know
00:07:50.160 who she is if people aren't writing about her because that would seem to belie an intense
00:07:57.000 insecurity in a way and for someone who you feel like should be one of the most secure women on
00:08:03.640 the planet yeah well I think um you know people told me that she has confidence like crazy
00:08:12.640 confidence, or at least she did as a child. And that was thanks to her parents, Bruce Paltrow
00:08:17.560 and Blythe Danner. Bruce was a famous producer known for shows like St. Elsewhere. Blythe Danner 0.96
00:08:23.040 is one of the greatest actresses probably of all time. Highly respected, came up in the theater. 0.92
00:08:30.100 People probably know her more recently for movies like Meet the Parents. But really,
00:08:33.860 when she was coming up in the theater, was viewed as, at least by some people, as better than Meryl
00:08:38.000 street um so i love you some life she's a national treasure is what she is she's an amazing actress i
00:08:45.580 mean as is gwyneth and so her parents just gave her the supreme confidence like you need to make
00:08:51.020 it but also in interviewing so many people about the entertainment industry and acting and the
00:08:55.100 theater and all of it um they told me that uh actors are on that stage because they need the
00:09:02.160 applause. So there is that. There is that. There's that. So more than 200 interviews. I don't think
00:09:13.700 that people who are outside of the world of journalism, which you and I have been in the
00:09:17.820 trenches of for so long now, understand how much work goes into a book like this. You've been
00:09:25.060 working on it for more than three years, right? It's about three years. Yeah. Three years. Yeah.
00:09:30.500 and 200 interviews. Talk to me about the kinds of people you were seeking out to try to get to the
00:09:37.000 truth of who Gwyneth Galtrow is, because that's what that's what you did in the Anna book as well.
00:09:41.820 Like you come away from that. And like I said earlier, with some juicy tidbits, but also feeling
00:09:46.660 like, you know, this human. And I think the same is true with Gwyneth. Who are you approaching to
00:09:52.280 talk to for things like this yeah well thank you for saying that um the i talked to people from
00:10:00.560 the entertainment world from the film she worked on many many people who worked at goop um friends
00:10:07.760 um a whole whole range of people people who worked on brand deals with her um yeah uh directors
00:10:17.480 members, crew members of kind of all ranks and stripes on various films because she's been in a
00:10:24.200 lot of movies. Yeah. And, you know, I will say that the thing that surprised me the most is that
00:10:30.360 the Gwyneth that we've seen on talk shows and social media videos, maybe I should say now,
00:10:35.460 it's just not the same Gwyneth that a lot of people saw. Like she can be cold, she can be icy,
00:10:40.320 She can be aloof. Some people compared her to Anna Wintour, kind of like as, you know,
00:10:48.040 just saying that she's kind of like a busy editor in chief, like when she's at Goop running her
00:10:52.440 business. And people may think that she doesn't really run her business, but she does. She is the
00:10:57.340 CEO. You know, they might walk into her office. She's looking down at her computer doing something 0.99
00:11:02.320 and the attitude is kind of what do you want? Say what you need and then I'll give you an answer
00:11:05.680 and you can get out of here and be on your way. I'm not saying that in a negative way and just,
00:11:10.140 you know, to sort of describe what she's like. So I thought that that was fascinating that,
00:11:14.780 you know, she has this insanely powerful charisma and she really turns it on when she needs it. 0.97
00:11:22.940 And it might be off the rest of the time. Yeah. But I think that that is probably 0.99
00:11:29.060 fairly true for a lot of powerful people too, right? Like we are all different people when
00:11:35.680 we're public facing. I know that I'm someone different when I'm doing a book event and I'm
00:11:39.840 meeting people. And like, I'm not going to Gwyneth Paltrow, but then I'm also a different
00:11:44.020 person when I'm managing staff to create podcasts and things like that. So I wonder if we would
00:11:51.200 question this kind of switch in personality if we were talking about a man.
00:11:57.100 People bring that up. I mean, I do think so. I've read many biographies of men in the course of
00:12:01.540 sort of becoming a biographer. And they do point, they just point out all facets of their personality.
00:12:06.540 if you write a biography like that should be the point to like get a a really uh like a 360 degree
00:12:12.940 view of a person not just a superficial view that you get from reading a glossy magazine profile of
00:12:18.100 which so so many as you know have been written about Gwyneth so that was the goal but if you
00:12:22.980 read about men I mean I think that their coldness and their aloofness and their breastness is also
00:12:26.800 pointed out yeah yeah I think men are men are just kind of sometimes allowed to be cold and
00:12:32.300 aloof more than like I feel like it may be less of a thing I mean with Anna first people told me
00:12:37.600 that they thought that a lot of this sort of I don't know attention that her personality got
00:12:42.040 was kind of sexist and that that seemed maybe a bit more true with Anna than with Gwyneth I do
00:12:47.840 think the sexist coverage that Gwyneth has received was really concentrated in the period
00:12:52.200 after she won her Oscar when people really turned on her because the coverage was very positive and
00:12:58.020 glowing. And she was on the up and up. She did her first leading role in a film was for Emma in
00:13:03.540 1996. And then Shakespeare in Love came out in late 1998. And she won the Oscar at 26 years old
00:13:08.980 in 1999. And it was only after that point that the attention kind of curdled and the press really
00:13:15.200 turned on her in a way that read to me as very otsy. We know that was not a great time for the
00:13:20.520 treatment of women in the media and just very sexist, I think. Very sexist. Why do you think
00:13:27.400 that was why do you think that shakespeare in love which by the way i re-watched it recently
00:13:31.060 and i enjoyed it i really did it like it was it was worth a re-watch it was a fun movie everyone
00:13:37.520 in the movie is adorable i don't know if it should have won the oscar but i do know for a fact
00:13:41.560 because this is a whole chapter in celebrity inc that harvey weinstein's off oscar campaign for
00:13:47.480 that movie was legendary and so you know movies win academy awards because studios spend a lot
00:13:54.960 of money to buy Academy Awards. I still think she was great in it. She was great in it. I mean,
00:13:59.780 there is the ongoing debate till this day among a certain set of people about how, or maybe not
00:14:04.820 a debate, but a belief that Cape Linshot should have won. Yeah, fair. But I think that there is
00:14:09.720 an argument every year that someone else should have won something. Why do you think the tide
00:14:13.420 turned on her after 99? Well, basically what happened was she got a lot of really positive
00:14:19.520 press she got a lot of um good commentary in the media about her acting i mean there were a few
00:14:24.880 things that she did in the 90s that people said you know this she was not good one of them actually
00:14:30.900 she was in the seagull and a summer stock theater production at williamstown theater festival which
00:14:36.440 she had grown up going to with her parents uh playing nina which her mom had played brilliantly
00:14:41.900 so like an impossible act to follow she did this part she didn't get good marks for that um
00:14:47.960 but generally even though a lot of the movies she did were frankly kind of mediocre she got good
00:14:53.080 marks and people people would say well she was like a good part of this movie so she does shakespeare
00:14:58.320 in love she's great in that it's a great film everybody loves it she wins the oscar so there
00:15:03.660 was a there was an article that was written up around the time that she won the oscar
00:15:07.340 um about how she was wearing this that she was wearing the pink ralph lauren dress and she
00:15:14.100 accessorized only with a diamond choker like a thin diamond band around her neck and her father
00:15:20.660 I guess what happened is he looked over at her during the award ceremony because she went with
00:15:24.920 her parents Bruce and Blythe and he thinks she's so beautiful and I'm so proud of her I'm gonna buy
00:15:30.200 her that necklace and then Gwyneth said to a well Gwyneth I guess the the way it was relayed it was
00:15:37.480 like a Harry Winston official so she had borrowed the necklace from Harry Winston and someone from
00:15:41.580 harry winston told the new york times that gwyneth said my daddy's buying me the necklace
00:15:46.360 and that really triggered people and so in many of the screeds that were written about her were
00:15:52.860 like right after she won it was glowing it was like oh my god she's so talented she's so beautiful
00:15:57.140 she's inhuman like that's the that's the level of praise she was getting there's nowhere for it to
00:16:01.560 go but down in that time period and this story about the necklace was was cited in many many
00:16:07.520 of these stories just to show like how privileged she was it was almost like a reaction to
00:16:12.980 to money to all the things people react to today well and also not and knocking someone off a
00:16:20.940 pedestal because like you said when you reach this apex of a career there's nowhere to go but down
00:16:27.200 let's take a really quick break here and then i want to get into why the press has always been
00:16:33.840 so into knocking women off 1.00
00:16:35.860 of a pedestal. 0.98
00:16:43.680 Hungry now.
00:16:46.920 Now.
00:16:49.080 What about
00:16:50.020 now? Whenever
00:16:51.740 it hits you, wherever you are,
00:16:54.060 grab an O'Henry bar
00:16:55.720 to satisfy your hunger.
00:16:57.860 With its delicious combination of
00:16:59.820 big, crunchy, salty peanuts
00:17:01.560 covered in creamy caramel and
00:17:03.760 chewy fudge with a chocolatey coating. Swing by a gas station and get an O'Henry today.
00:17:09.300 O'Hungry O'Henry.
00:17:15.720 All right, we're back. I've got so much to say about this.
00:17:19.280 You know, I've, I've, like, dissected so much of how the tabloid media has re, has reacted to
00:17:26.260 women generally, and also women in the late 90s, early 2000s, and ripping women to shreds was an
00:17:31.440 industry at the time and finding ways to pick them apart it didn't help that Gwyneth was then 0.94
00:17:38.380 also having some of the most high profile relationships in Hollywood at this point I
00:17:44.720 mean she was there are some stars who can stay out of the press and who actively do stay out of
00:17:50.660 the press I need I name them all the time when people are like oh but you know all celebrities
00:17:56.400 are going to be covered I'm like can you name me Matt Damon's children and everyone's like no
00:18:01.240 Actually, I'm like, but you can tell me Ben Affleck's.
00:18:03.400 And they're like, yes, I can.
00:18:04.980 I'm like, they came up at the same time, same level of stardom.
00:18:08.480 And one of them decided to get engaged to Jennifer Lopez.
00:18:12.460 Twice.
00:18:15.500 So some people, some people, and some people court the press.
00:18:18.260 I mean, do you think that Gwyneth was courting press?
00:18:21.280 Yeah, I do.
00:18:22.460 And I don't know that she is aware of how she was courting the press because she had these high profile relationships. 0.99
00:18:30.360 I mean, and interviewing so many people in Hollywood and the entertainment world about her.
00:18:35.360 And I would say, why did she become so special?
00:18:37.240 Like, why did she become so famous?
00:18:38.320 And a number of them did say, well, she had she was dating Brad Pitt and Ben Affleck and all these famous guys.
00:18:45.300 That's not to denigrate her talent, but it does make her an object of tabloid fascination.
00:18:52.260 You know, going from Brad Pitt to Ben Affleck.
00:18:55.520 It's like people want to read about that.
00:18:57.600 Yeah.
00:18:57.780 Yeah.
00:18:58.060 yeah and uh you know there was an interesting comment i found in an old article about her
00:19:05.160 where you know she would often say like i'm not as so after she dated brad pitt she decided she
00:19:10.240 didn't want her relationships to be public anymore because she and brad were very public
00:19:14.120 they were going on red carpets together they were at the golden globes together he wins an award
00:19:18.060 and he goes up on the stage to accept it and he calls her his angel like it was very much out
00:19:23.200 there in the public sphere, making them very, very famous. Right. So she decided after that
00:19:31.260 relationship, she and Ben were not going to be seen together on a red carpet. They weren't going
00:19:35.100 to talk about their relationship. That said, when she was on sets, like filming Shakespeare in Love,
00:19:39.560 like everyone knew they were an item, like they were canoodling and people were walking in on
00:19:43.260 that. They weren't really hiding it. But she said something, I believe it was around this time where
00:19:50.260 she was like you know we're not it may have been when she was dating chris martin but she basically
00:19:54.360 said you know we're not putting our relationship out there i'm not putting myself out there to be
00:19:58.220 a tabloid person but i looked back at what she had done like in the few months around that comment
00:20:05.860 and she had gone to like a magazine party a movie premiere like a charity event like she had been
00:20:10.520 going all these things so i don't i think it's like a self-awareness there like i don't know that
00:20:16.980 she was aware of the ways in which she was putting herself out there and obviously her
00:20:20.560 self-awareness can at times be quite lacking which is why she's so polarizing it's true it's true and
00:20:26.260 i mean it is hard for me to believe that she wasn't at least somewhat self-aware again i have
00:20:30.900 no idea but the kinds of events that you're talking about are tabloid fodder i know that's
00:20:35.980 because i ran tabloid magazines and i ran the daily news gossip column right like i knew i know
00:20:41.940 when celebrities show up at these charity events and movie premieres they're doing it for one
00:20:45.860 reason and one reason only especially if it's not their project it's to be seen and to be asked
00:20:50.660 questions and to get attention so as and also as someone who grew up with famous parents she knows
00:20:58.960 the ecosystem so much better than someone who like just got off the plane from iowa and stepped
00:21:05.740 into hollywood stardom like yesterday right exactly exactly yes she's not i mean one comparison
00:21:12.280 that I sort of had in my head as I was writing is like Brad Pitt. Like he grew up in Missouri
00:21:17.260 in a religious Southern Baptist family. And then he decides to drive out to LA and try to make it
00:21:25.260 like coming from nothing. That's not her. Like her parents were successful from the time she
00:21:29.980 was born. I mean, she was nursing as a baby on a movie set with Blythe when she was 12 days old
00:21:35.440 and was the milieu that she stayed in her whole life. And she had this sort of glamorous by
00:21:42.160 coastal childhood going from LA to New York. When she entered seventh grade, her parents
00:21:47.080 enrolled her in Spence, which is a very elite Upper East Side private school. So that exposed
00:21:51.460 her to high society. Like Grecian princesses were there and they would do for their senior project. 0.99
00:21:57.280 Like one person told me an interview with their Aunt Elizabeth. Well, who's Aunt Elizabeth? Queen
00:22:02.100 Elizabeth, the Queen of England. That's the million. And like girls who were super, super
00:22:08.640 rich and kind of like not impressed by her and that actually seemed to really affect her for a
00:22:14.100 long time because she saw all the success in hollywood she was engaged to brad pitt like
00:22:17.820 she was so famous and they acted i mean whether or not they were but they just they acted like
00:22:22.460 they didn't care and maybe it was jealousy maybe maybe they did care but they they never acted all
00:22:28.400 that impressed but these girls are you know among the richest people in the world probably yeah yeah 0.99
00:22:33.500 and also royalty adjacent royalty yeah or literal royalty yeah which is interesting 0.95
00:22:41.120 because in a way Gwyneth created her own version of celebrity royalty I mean she doesn't then
00:22:47.640 after Brad Pitt and Ben Affleck she doesn't just go marry you know average joe she marries one of
00:22:53.640 the biggest rock stars in the world again choices yeah so the genesis of that relationship with
00:23:02.380 chris martin i was told so her spence friends it close with some of them uh from the time they were
00:23:08.940 in seventh grade and they were starting to settle down she would go to their weddings um and uh
00:23:16.600 well actually she didn't go to one friend's wedding i was told specifically to hurt that
00:23:20.620 friend but anyway she would she would go to their weddings they were settling down having children
00:23:26.140 and she wanted that too and her father had died bruce paltrow died suddenly when she was 30
00:23:32.340 they were taking a trip for her 30th birthday through italy together he had been diagnosed
00:23:37.740 with throat cancer never really fully recovered fell ill and died and she was there alone with him
00:23:42.300 which is a you know a horrible tragedy horrible and she's grieving the loss of her father she's
00:23:49.400 living in london and she goes to see a coldplay concert and they end up meeting her and chris
00:23:55.300 martin end up meeting and he encounters her at this very tender moment in her life when she's
00:24:00.880 grieving her father and he is there for her and they their relationship you know was born in that
00:24:06.520 moment and you know her friends told me like they never really seemed like they totally had chemistry
00:24:12.800 um they seemed quite different uh but one of the one of the friends said there's got to be
00:24:20.740 something about a rock star who adores you i am curious how self-aware she was that conscious
00:24:27.280 uncoupling was going to turn into such a media sensation that it is something we can all still
00:24:34.100 quote from and that I say and it is funny that like I mentioned conscious uncoupling like you
00:24:40.200 know regularly enough that in like in normal life about different things I'm like oh I'm like this
00:24:45.320 friendship is conscious uncoupling like in a humorous way almost as much as I read referenced
00:24:50.700 another Gwyneth movie which I think people reference a lot who haven't even seen it sliding
00:24:55.300 doors yeah that's true i hear people see sliding doors moment all the time and i'm like have you
00:25:02.200 seen the movie and they're like no no yeah i was over i swear to god i was on a train and i was
00:25:08.980 overhearing people talking about it and one person said sliding doors moment and another person was
00:25:12.960 like what are you talking about and they're like you haven't seen that um anyway uh yeah just a
00:25:20.320 She didn't even choose that subject line. One of her editors picked that subject line, which was obviously very triggering to people.
00:25:30.420 I think what was interesting about that moment, too, is that she chose to make that announcement through Goop.
00:25:36.540 And I think speaking of the astronomer thing, that was obviously calculated, I think, right?
00:25:41.680 Like, sure, it helps her control the message, but on your own platform, which is a foreshadowing of media, because at that time, celebrities on social media was 2014.
00:25:50.320 probably not all of them were there yet they were coming around actors in particular were
00:25:54.600 really slow to get on social media as you surely remember yeah um you know and in this way i think
00:25:59.700 she's one of the original influencers like in 2008 she's saying i'm gonna start a newsletter
00:26:03.480 and like celebrities are afraid of the internet um so she sends it out through goop and that's
00:26:10.120 just a really interesting sort of merging of her private and professional life in a way and
00:26:16.580 And people said to me over and over again, Goop is all about Gwyneth.
00:26:21.020 It's all about her.
00:26:23.180 And that's an early example of it.
00:26:25.560 So, you know, making a very personal statement, like not giving it to AP, putting it on your own website where you're going to capitalize on the traffic.
00:26:34.440 I'm sure she captured she was trying to build her newsletter.
00:26:36.700 She probably got a bunch of new signups.
00:26:38.520 Oh, I'm sure she did.
00:26:40.120 That the site crashed.
00:26:41.280 And I think what triggered the public about it, in addition to those two words, conscious uncoupling, she ran an article on Goop by one of her gurus, Dr. Sadegi, who was blathering on and on about what it meant.
00:26:55.180 And it was sort of like, you know, wellness wasn't as big of a thing, but it was coming up.
00:26:59.800 But the way he talked about it, I think, was really off-putting to journalists who trade in facts and the truth.
00:27:06.060 mm-hmm yeah i mean wellness gurus like you said were not what well wellness gurus are today
00:27:13.600 right and so like actual grimalists were like what who is this quack that is talking about
00:27:18.620 these things yeah and he this guy dr sadagi he didn't even come up with it it eventually came
00:27:24.920 out or probably quickly came out that someone else came up with conscious uncoupling and they
00:27:29.900 never credited her they never credited her i've had i've interviewed her i've talked to her before
00:27:35.140 yes yes it is a it is a woman therapist and like yeah she was never credited yeah so i think that's
00:27:40.980 a shame and she's not like a wellnessy type right no no i think i think she was a marriage therapist
00:27:46.080 yeah this wellness spin on it and i mean i will say that like conscious uncoupling i think a lot
00:27:52.920 of people have been negative negatively affected by divorce unfortunately and have seen divorce
00:27:57.940 really destroy families so i think that the you know the ethos of it and their intention was
00:28:02.240 really great. And from what I understand, they really did it. Like they really consciously
00:28:06.940 uncoupled. And the whole idea behind it was, was to protect their children so that they could all
00:28:11.980 be a family and they could be together with their children without hating each other, which is
00:28:17.680 great. Which is great, which is actually great. I mean, I remember reading the conscious uncoupling
00:28:23.160 thing and I'm like, this is the dumbest name for something that's awesome. Yeah, that's a really 0.89
00:28:28.480 great way of looking at it. I like this is how all divorces should be. But also this name is so dumb.
00:28:34.040 Goop became famous for that gift guide. Do you remember? Ridiculous but awesome. 0.99
00:28:37.560 Ridiculous but awesome. It's like that. Exactly. Like I feel like she knew really well 0.99
00:28:41.480 how to push boundaries to push this business forward in that she knew that she was the story
00:28:47.600 at that point, which is why I do think she was very self-aware or at least, you know, self-aware
00:28:51.940 enough because she was this early influencer. She knows how to create a viral moment. She had 0.99
00:28:58.180 really good instincts about using her image to start her own brand instead of using her image
00:29:02.580 to promote other brands like Estee Lauder, American Express. There were many that she was
00:29:07.860 endorsing in the 2000s when it was sort of considered tawdry for actors to do that. Now
00:29:12.660 that's obviously totally changed. Every actor is getting paid to plug something and aspires to get
00:29:18.400 paid to plug something out yeah so she was early on I think my analysis of her polarizing-ness
00:29:28.320 and her commentary and the quotes are fairly memorable like I can't pretend to be someone
00:29:33.980 who makes $25,000 a year I'd rather smoke crack than eat cheese from a can like these kinds of
00:29:39.860 quotes I think that what happened oh when she said something about the mommy wars she said
00:29:44.720 something about how she liked running goop or like didn't want to do as many films when she
00:29:48.760 had her kids because it was people didn't know how hard it was for her to go film a movie you
00:29:54.400 know and like when you have an office job it's like easier right and then columnists had a field
00:29:59.080 day like you know writing like hilarious retorts and stuff like that anyway so I think when she
00:30:04.240 made comments like that that was like kind of her privilege coming through like she was trying to
00:30:09.280 get on the level of average people she's never had an average life in any sort of way so she can't do
00:30:14.400 it. And people pick up on that and react very strongly. People do react really strongly. And
00:30:20.880 yet there's nothing average about goop. And I want to get into that after our last break.
00:30:33.980 Okay, we are back. I remember walking into the goop store in LA because I had an event at that
00:30:39.800 diesel bookstore that's right there next to the group store and like I mean I'm used to being 0.90
00:30:44.680 like in fancy stores and going to fancy parties right from when I was covering them but like I
00:30:49.740 felt like I could touch nothing in this store and everything was so freaking expensive it was
00:30:55.980 insanity and I remember like looking at one dress and like thinking about trying it on
00:31:00.380 and the the saleswoman was like oh my gosh it is 70% off and it is never going to be this cheap
00:31:06.860 again. And so I considered it for a moment and 70% off was still $2,000. And so really, I feel
00:31:13.440 like goop is a thing. Even when I go on it now, you know, she's advertising the laser pro for
00:31:21.040 six grand and a slide for $600. It's all aspirational, but like to the level that a lot
00:31:28.240 of it will never be attainable. But then she has like some lower brow stuff that she throws out 0.69
00:31:33.900 there and then people gobble that up yeah what is the laser pro the laser pro appears to be
00:31:41.660 like a red light near infrared clinic grade laser um that she is selling on goop for six grand
00:31:50.220 right now yeah yeah you can use it on your on your face for as little as three minutes
00:31:57.400 and apparently it's as good as as a facelift so i mean look and i think we all look at gwyneth
00:32:05.460 and we're like i would look like that when i'm 52 looked into the research on infrared i looked
00:32:10.380 into so many of the different things that grew promoted like the wellness fads that's really
00:32:13.940 like kind of like the second half of the book you know yeah yeah and so many of them some of them
00:32:19.440 are just going to be expensive they're not going to do anything bad for you some of them are actually
00:32:22.800 going to harm you and maybe kill you which ones are going to harm you and maybe kill you like
00:32:26.580 that can be our mic drop moment we can we can end oh she talked about getting stung by bees 1.00
00:32:33.320 uh yes i remember this and i had friends who had lyme disease who who wanted to do this
00:32:39.840 well it can kill you people have died doing that so don't do that i think what they do is they
00:32:45.800 inject bee venom if i'm not mistaken it's not like they put the bees on you and they sting you but um
00:32:51.540 uh gerard butler did it and had like a very bad anaphylactic reaction like you can do it and not
00:32:56.740 have any bad reaction and then all of a sudden get terrible anaphylaxis and die um and uh vaginal
00:33:04.660 steaming uh what is the vaginal steaming is that what it sounds like like putting a steamer on
00:33:10.400 your vajay to get wrinkles out you sit on some steam oh no like you're thrown with a hole in it
00:33:18.180 and steam comes up as i am and it came up on goop in the context of a spa the tican spa in santa
00:33:26.140 monica and she got this treatment and she really liked it so they promoted it on goop and then that
00:33:32.940 was one of the early things where people went completely bananas um however i found a study
00:33:37.900 written up in a journal about a woman i believe she was in canada who did this and sustained like 0.96
00:33:43.100 severe burns to her cervix yeah no that's i'm not i'm not gonna put steam anywhere near my vagina 0.85
00:33:49.480 i'm just not that's where i'm drawing the line yeah maybe that spa i don't know maybe they are
00:33:55.960 really careful but i don't know i mean doctors don't recommend it anyway there's kind of no
00:33:59.540 reason to to take on the risk as i understand it on interviewing medical experts uh and then coffee
00:34:06.280 enemas are also yeah also really dangerous and she was she was made fun of a lot like colbert
00:34:12.600 did a really hilarious bit about the implantorama coffee enema but that's really really dangerous
00:34:19.160 that is not something you should do so but an infrared light mask like it's going to cost you
00:34:24.180 a lot of money i don't think it's going to actually give you a surgical looking facelift 0.99
00:34:27.740 right right exactly but the more extreme i guess the the more extreme fads that she promotes or
00:34:35.060 the more extreme gurus that she promotes the concern of experts is that people will you know
00:34:41.500 drink celery juice instead of going to see their doctor if they have something suspicious going on
00:34:46.260 with them. Do you know what I mean? Which is fair. Which does happen. Until it's too late. And this
00:34:52.140 does happen. There are stories, many stories out there about patients who do this. I mean,
00:34:57.000 talking anecdotally with doctors that I have encountered, you know, they many have stories
00:35:03.080 about, you know, patients who have cancer that they could cure and then they, you know, they
00:35:07.420 don't want to get surgery or do chemo or whatever they go off and get a vitamin drip and then they
00:35:11.720 then they come back and it's no longer able to be cured so there are some serious consequences to
00:35:17.560 to the the wellness industry in general i mean it's a 6.3 trillion dollar industry
00:35:22.540 pharmaceutical industry is much smaller it's 1.6 or 1.7 trillion yeah yeah well i mean this leads
00:35:29.620 into what what actually really is my last question now but you know we've seen the rise of hashtag
00:35:34.720 Maha in the past year and a half, two years, right? But it feels like Gwyneth was the root
00:35:43.040 of a lot of these things. I mean, a lot of the Maha on my feed now are doing and promoting the 0.66
00:35:47.980 coffee enemas and all the stuff. I mean, in a way, did you pave the way for this to be very
00:35:53.560 acceptable to talk about things that are very questionable medically? That's what I argue in
00:35:59.140 the book. I think so. I really think so. I think that she did a couple of things for the wellness
00:36:04.500 industry that were really influential and important. One, she sowed a distrust of Western
00:36:10.640 medicine and established science and trained experts. You see RFK Jr. doing the same thing
00:36:17.080 as the Secretary of Health and Human Services, casting doubt on things as long proven as vaccines,
00:36:22.580 unfortunately. And we see what's happened with measles. They were believed to be eradicated in
00:36:26.620 2000. And now it's so bad that you basically can't take your infant on a plane or many doctors advise
00:36:32.400 that you not until they get their first shot. So that's very unfortunate. I'm not saying Gwyneth
00:36:37.480 is anti-vax, but I do think that the distrust of science really snowballs. And one expert I
00:36:42.800 interviewed said facts aren't profitable. And I think that's really important to think about
00:36:47.780 because the stuff that you're talking about, coffee enemas, all the stuff that we see on
00:36:50.940 social media, you know, it's we know conspiracy theories really travel. We know that misinformation
00:36:57.580 spreads sensationalist things really spread very well on social media yep the other thing she did
00:37:04.280 for the wellness industry that i think is really important is she um she gave it this luxurious
00:37:10.940 aesthetic yes yes she she created a world a wellness world that people want to be a part of
00:37:18.360 and it's that incredible taste that she has that we see at the in group health conferences that
00:37:24.260 she's been holding for a while um we see just looking at her this perfectionism this gorgeous
00:37:30.200 taste that she has her homes her offices she gave this you know luxurious aspirational look and vibe 0.87
00:37:38.060 to wellness and people would are willing to pay a lot of money to be a part of that yeah yeah and 0.94
00:37:44.960 then also to create their own image based off it she did she made wellness very sexy very aspirational
00:37:53.220 And we know that influencers who can position themselves aspirationally are the ones who who do the best and who end up going the most viral.
00:38:01.800 So, yeah, I mean, I think that that is a really, really strong argument for I don't think it was. 0.57
00:38:07.960 I mean, obviously, she can't see in the future and see us going down this slippery slope of Maha that we have seen. 0.84
00:38:15.120 But yeah, but I will say she hasn't done anything to dispel it. 0.80
00:38:19.040 true you know when people ask her about rfk jr in interviews she says she says stuff like
00:38:24.920 his ideas are interesting do you know what i mean and they both drink raw dairy products which
00:38:30.640 you should not do all that's going to do is increase your risk of acquiring a foodborne
00:38:34.420 illness which you do not want and if you have little kids at your house you especially don't
00:38:37.780 want to risk having that that in your house anyway um so yeah she doesn't really dispel it
00:38:47.300 which is a shame. You know, I interviewed Dr. Jen Gunter, who is a prolific OBGYN who writes
00:38:55.480 quite often now about health misinformation and women. Oh, yeah. Dr. Jen is great. She is someone
00:38:59.800 that I want everyone following on all of the platforms. Probably a lot of your listeners
00:39:03.140 follow her and read her. I do. She's fantastic. She gets the good word out there. But she said
00:39:09.220 to me, you know, imagine if Gwyneth Paltrow had been out there talking about abortion access.
00:39:12.700 And I think that's really powerful.
00:39:17.200 That's really powerful. Yeah. And reproductive rights. I mean, there are a lot of things that she could be doing for good. And it is a choice. It's a choice to not speak out about certain things as it is a choice to promote certain things. I think they're both equally weighted.
00:39:34.040 Well, I love this book so much. I have already gifted it to a ton of my friends. They're so excited. I've had people come up to me at signings. Actually, I meant to email this to you the other day, but I got distracted by the astronomer thing. A woman was like, I'm packing my beach bag. I'm going to the beach next week. And I've got yours. But I'm just waiting for this new Gwyneth biography to come out. And I was like, oh, girl, you are in for a treat. And also listen to the Influence on Tuesday.
00:40:04.040 that's awesome yeah so they have their non-fiction and their fiction yeah exactly exactly so yes um
00:40:10.640 people are so psyched as they should be and then you don't need anything else you are the best will
00:40:15.340 you tell everyone where they can find you on the interwebs yes you can find me on substack i'm amy
00:40:20.820 odell.substack.com you can find me on instagram it's i-n-s-t-a-m-y-o-d-e-l-l and i'm on tiktok
00:40:30.120 as Amy O'Dell writer, but I'm I don't know. I'm sort of a fairweather TikToker. Maybe I'll scoot
00:40:36.000 on over there now that my book is done and I have more time to make videos. Yeah, sure, sure. I keep
00:40:40.440 saying I'll do it every day and I wake up and I never do it. So, so much work. So much work.
00:40:46.120 Oh, all right. Goodbye, my friend. Bye.
00:41:00.120 We'll see you next time.
00:41:30.120 You