Under the Influence (with Jo Piazza) - June 25, 2024


Let's Take Back Masculinity From the Douchebags!

Sunday Nice Things: You Probably Think This Story's About You Stop Giving All the F*cks AND What to Read Right Now

Episode Stats


Length

42 minutes

Words per minute

156.26

Word count

6,630

Sentence count

440

Harmful content

Misogyny

18

sentences flagged

Toxicity

8

sentences flagged

Hate speech

8

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
00:00:00.140 I want to date with Rawls, Carty says.
00:00:03.400 Rawls? Rucka asks.
00:00:05.540 This is the love story of real-hinged couple Carty and Rucka.
00:00:09.620 Written and read by me, Nicola Dynan.
00:00:12.380 Listen to the free audiobook now.
00:00:16.960 Before you knew what a stock was, you traded snacks, cards, turns.
00:00:22.740 You knew what something was worth because you felt it.
00:00:26.160 That instinct to trade didn't disappear.
00:00:28.880 It just grew up.
00:00:30.400 TD Easy Trade taps into that instinct
00:00:32.380 so you can build something real for the future
00:00:34.880 with no minimums, no monthly fees, and 100 free trades.
00:00:39.200 You already got this because you are made to trade.
00:00:43.360 And TD Easy Trade is made to help.
00:00:45.840 Download it now.
00:00:53.480 Hello, party people.
00:00:55.720 I don't know why I just said that.
00:00:57.520 It just, it came out. It may be because this week I've just done something that I do not
00:01:04.360 recommend at all, at all to anyone. You should not do what I just did. But I listened to about
00:01:10.540 six hours of the Joe Rogan show straight, straight through. I just put it on as like my
00:01:16.220 ambient noise while I was cleaning my house and my toilet and doing other things that I don't
00:01:23.160 enjoy doing. Why did I do this? Did I do this to get myself into a massive rage? No, no, I did it.
00:01:32.520 I did it for work. I did it out of curiosity. I am intensely curious about why this man is so popular.
00:01:40.660 I'm going to admit something kind of embarrassing. I used to be a Joe Rogan fan. Newsradio,
00:01:47.100 the sitcom, was one of my favorite shows to watch reruns of in college in like the mid-afternoon 0.99
00:01:55.020 time after classes, like after economics class, when you're just going to like crack open a Zima 0.94
00:02:00.180 and watch some dumb TV. That was my jam. And Joe Rogan was right there. He was the hot dumb guy. 0.93
00:02:06.360 He's definitely not hot anymore. And now he has a lot of influence. So things are different. 1.00
00:02:10.720 But listening to the show and, you know, then absorbing the whole ecosystem of the Joe Rogan
00:02:18.920 universe, which, again, terrifying, terrifying, it made me think a lot about something I've been
00:02:25.780 been talking about lately, which is what is masculinity? What is masculinity? What is
00:02:33.180 femininity? And how are certain people co-opting those things? Because at its heart, masculinity 0.98
00:02:40.260 just means pertaining to the characteristics of a man. That's it. That's it. But our culture has
00:02:50.120 created a very particular way of being masculine. It ascribes things like dominant, strong,
00:02:58.560 powerful, fierce to the masculine. And I'm so curious if we could flip that narrative. I think
00:03:05.300 about it all the time as the mom of a boy, what if we assigned other characteristics to masculine?
00:03:11.820 Things like caring and nurturing, warm, kind, supportive, and respectful. All good things.
00:03:18.800 All wonderful things. Joyful, playful, emotional. What if we thought of these as male traits?
00:03:29.840 And maybe you already do, but I don't think that most of our culture does. In fact,
00:03:34.240 after listening to so much Joe Rogan, I know that most of our culture does not. I know things now.
00:03:41.420 I know things that I will never unknow. Here to talk to me about all of it today is someone else
00:03:47.620 who has been thinking about masculinity and femininity for a very, very long time.
00:03:55.740 Catherine Connors is the former head of content for Disney Interactive, and she used to call 0.99
00:04:00.600 herself a princess hacker. Because part of her job was figuring out what characteristics a Disney 0.99
00:04:08.400 princess should have. What characteristics are distinctly princess-like? Are those feminine? 0.99
00:04:15.860 Are those masculine? And does any of this matter at all? Catherine's also the creator of the blog
00:04:22.700 herbadmother.com. And like I said, she thinks a lot about all of these things. One of the reasons
00:04:31.340 is that she is the mom of a girl who used to love princesses and fairy tales, but now loves dirt
00:04:36.680 bikes, cheerleading and hockey. And she also has a boy who loves princesses and fairy tales. And
00:04:42.760 Catherine believes in the power of fairy tales. She believes in the power of storytelling to flip
00:04:49.280 the narratives that we've traditionally been told about what is masculine and what is feminine.
00:04:54.780 This conversation is so fun. It's so much more fun than Joe Rogan. I mean, it was a real palate
00:05:00.300 cleanser for me. Like I said, don't do it. I do these things so you don't have to. Here's Catherine.
00:05:07.380 Can you tell me who you are and what you do? Oh my gosh, who am I? You're starting with the
00:05:14.520 existential question. I am a writer and an entrepreneur. I do want to ask you a couple
00:05:22.960 questions about femininity to start because, you know, one of the things that we see so much on
00:05:30.140 social media now these days is the idea of what is feminine and what is masculine. And I feel
00:05:39.180 Those words are being co-opted in a very specific way, really, to keep women in a role out of the workforce and to say that feminine equals soft and submissive and masculine equals strong and powerful.
00:06:00.600 What are your thoughts on this?
00:06:02.160 I love this question. And I know you've done a lot of investigation into trad wives and that whole dynamic and, you know, and a lot of conventional sort of stereotypes of women, you know, and, you know, how their character tends to be represented.
00:06:20.900 Look, femininity and masculinity are made up things, right? They just are. They're social constructs. That's not to say that they are conventional understandings of masculinity and femininity, which are very squishy. They can encompass a lot of things.
00:06:39.160 You know, they they've tended to track to social rules and ways of really sort of constructing experience, you know, for for different groups in society, women and girls on the one hand and boys and men on the other.
00:06:55.620 But but but they are they're just stories. Right.
00:06:58.820 You know, they've been convenient stories for us and, you know, they've been convenient stories across, you know, many, if not most cultures and most of history.
00:07:09.160 in order to, you know, to really, you know, ensure, you know, a kind of predictable social
00:07:15.300 order that serves certain, you know, political, social and economic ends, like the, you know,
00:07:20.260 the family and the household. So there's nothing, there's nothing really in anything biological,
00:07:28.080 you know, that tells us that women need to be soft and compliant. I've had conversations with
00:07:34.480 people, you know, usually with men on the other side of this discussion of like, aren't these,
00:07:39.160 aren't we just conforming to natural roles? And it's like, well, female violence is an extremely 1.00
00:07:46.640 natural thing in the natural world. If we want to get really, really, really into it, it's stuff 0.99
00:07:51.540 we don't like to think about. But there's nothing in the natural world that pushes us into any kind
00:07:58.020 of natural softness. And there's also the fact that so many of the postures and performances
00:08:06.820 that we code as feminine. This is one of the things that my co-author Amy Stanton and I talk
00:08:11.580 about in The Feminine Revolution. Many of those things are just twists of the lens, right? There 0.95
00:08:17.620 are some things that we characterize or code as feminine that if you just twist the lens slightly,
00:08:21.780 you can see the masculine version and see how it's celebrated in masculinity. They're just
00:08:27.380 frameworks that we put upon the world. And they're frameworks that, to your question,
00:08:33.000 for the most part, really serve to limit us. And what are some of those things that if we
00:08:38.640 twist the lens, we can see it the other way? Well, you know, vanity, for one, right? You know,
00:08:44.900 there is the, you know, the trope of vain women, and certainly this is a trope that gets applied 0.99
00:08:49.080 to teenage girls all the time, right? You know, just really obsessed with appearances and that 1.00
00:08:54.620 sort of thing. But it's like, you know, look at the peacock, right? The peacock is male.
00:08:58.500 And, you know, and we see that trope played out, you know, in masculinity. I mean, it's like with like weightlifting and bodybuilding and posturing and, you know, like the cars and all of the aspects of masculine performance that are celebrated and supported, you know, in the culture, right?
00:09:20.080 We love our culture, love seeing men peacock, right? And show off. Another is forms of social
00:09:27.860 communication. We have stereotypes of women being gossips, right? But gossip is just a form of 1.00
00:09:35.920 social communication. It's a form of information sharing. And we don't call it gossip when men
00:09:40.540 share intel with each other and talk with each other. No, we call it networking.
00:09:45.920 We call it networking. Exactly. You know, we've just we've put language and stereotypes onto
00:09:52.260 things. And we code them as feminine or masculine determined, you know, usually on the basis of do
00:09:59.380 we see do we want to portray something as weak or silly or ineffectual on the one hand? Or do we 0.64
00:10:04.820 want to see it as strong or powerful on the other? Right, right. And yeah, the, you know, the former
00:10:10.800 is what we tend to code as feminine in our culture. And we're continuing to do it on social 0.99
00:10:16.600 media. That's the thing, you know, I look at social media, and my hope is that it can be
00:10:21.200 a next generation of reframing what it means to be feminine, what it means to be masculine. And
00:10:28.160 it's just more and more, it seems to be falling back on these old tropes. And that sucks. 0.99
00:10:34.400 It does. I mean, I think it's a backlash, frankly, against the, you know, the shifts of the kind that 0.98
00:10:40.640 you're describing having been working their magic over what is in the, over the course of human
00:10:47.160 history, this is a really short amount of time, right? The consumer has not been around for very
00:10:52.320 long at all. And it was in fact, the thing that, that, that drew me out of academia. And the reason
00:10:57.100 I started writing about motherhood was because I became really, really interested. This is like
00:11:01.620 late 2005, early 2006. And the, you know, influencer was not a term yet. Blogging was
00:11:09.640 barely acknowledged. But this is this is sort of the first instance that you could see of what we
00:11:15.320 would now call sort of lifestyle content creation. It was in the form of weren't even they weren't
00:11:20.900 even called mom blogs at the time, right? There wasn't even a name for them. But it was it was
00:11:26.580 an early instance of women and some men writing very, very honestly about private life. And,
00:11:33.360 you know, I had been a scholar of storytelling in the context of political philosophy. And I had
00:11:38.420 been, you know, my thesis over my academic career had been that, you know, that the stories that we
00:11:43.420 tell sort of are what put women and girls into the private sphere. And, you know, it's the stories
00:11:49.440 we tell that determine who gets to participate in the public sphere. And, you know, guess what,
00:11:54.140 You know, women and girls have largely been excluded across most of history and in most cultures. And my argument was that storytelling had everything to do with that. When that first wave of online private storytelling emerged, I became really, really interested in how that was potentially going to challenge the way that we thought about motherhood.
00:12:13.700 Now, of course, I fell down the rabbit hole and just became a mom blogger myself and just loved doing it. And so I, you know, sort of ate my own dog food to an extreme degree, such that, you know, I ended up leaving academia and just writing. But at the time, it seemed obvious to me that, oh, like, this is going to change how we think about the tropes and stereotypes of motherhood. And it did, right? You know, there was a period of time in which a lot of the content was what we would now consider sort of countercultural.
00:12:40.040 I mean, my own blog was Her Bad Mother. You know, there was, you know, Deuce, obviously, Heather Armstrong, and Rebecca Wolfe, Girls Gone Child, and Liz Gumbiner, Mom 101, and Kristen Chase, Motherhood Uncensored, all of which were focused on like counter narratives. And we started to see this in other forms of lifestyle content, right? You know, in fashion, influencing gender identity, and the ways in which we talk about all sorts of things, sexuality, and mental illness, and mental wellness, and all these things.
00:13:08.700 So what I think that we're seeing now is a cultural pushback to that, right?
00:13:15.960 It's been, you know, for the first time in human history, we had this like widely accessible
00:13:21.080 communications technology that allowed anybody to like fly their freak flag and assert their
00:13:28.360 own identity.
00:13:29.420 And a big piece of what I think is happening now is that we're just, we're starting to
00:13:33.880 see the cultural discomfort with that really rear its ugly head and try to reassert, you know,
00:13:40.440 more traditional narratives to restore order. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. I mean,
00:13:46.160 I was talking about how, how I want to define masculinity the other day with my son, you know,
00:13:55.440 I'm raising a boy human, and I want him to see male role models that are positive and supportive.
00:14:05.700 And the words that I would love to attach to masculine are supportive, loving, caring, also strong, because I want to attach strong to everyone and powerful to everyone.
00:14:23.320 um and then some someone messaged me and said also playful i would love to attach the word
00:14:28.700 playful because i i would i would like to see men having more joy in their lives and that was a
00:14:36.720 really fun one for me um i'd love to hear your thoughts about like what can we what can we be
00:14:44.000 attaching to masculine how can we play with redefining these ideas um because they are being
00:14:51.520 redefined for us in a cohort on the internet that is very powerful, that is getting a lot of
00:14:57.960 attention. Okay, let's take a quick break here. And then we're going to talk about how to take
00:15:03.520 back the words masculine and feminine, the same way that Donna Martin took back graduation
00:15:09.300 in Beverly Hills 90210.
00:15:11.140 Transcription by CastingWords
00:15:41.140 The audiobook's out now. Give it a listen.
00:16:11.140 made to trade. And TDEZ Trade is made to help. Download it now.
00:16:21.680 And we're back. We've been talking about how masculine and feminine have been co-opted
00:16:26.340 and redefined in what I think are very toxic ways. And how can we take those words back?
00:16:32.580 How can we choose our own definitions for what is masculine and what is feminine?
00:16:37.960 There are times when I talk about femininity, depending on the audience, when I say that,
00:16:44.380 you know, in some respects, we could say that some of the most important work now is about
00:16:48.680 how we reframe masculinity, right? Feminine gonna feminine, you know, and part of...
00:16:53.800 Feminine gonna feminine. 1.00
00:16:54.960 Yeah. Feminine gonna feminine. And, you know, a big part of the gains of the various waves of 1.00
00:17:00.260 feminism were that, you know, we're sort of affording cultural, political, and economic 1.00
00:17:05.400 space for women to define for themselves who they want to be. And for some women, it's to, 1.00
00:17:09.700 you know, to embrace traditional femininity. And we want to keep space for that as long as it 0.99
00:17:15.980 doesn't become culturally dominant and oppressive. Men in many respects, you know, even though
00:17:22.080 the stereotypes around masculinity are much more positive, you know, they're arguably as
00:17:27.280 oppressive. And I think that's part of what we're seeing emerge now is this, you know, this movement
00:17:34.880 to kind of reclaim it and assert the power of it in the face of all these much more diverse and
00:17:42.620 diffuse identities. So asking the question of like, how can we expand that for men and especially
00:17:51.000 for boys? I have a son. So I've thought about this for a long time. I think that playful is
00:17:58.100 a fantastic one, but playful in the sense of what you just described as joy, you know, and
00:18:04.240 enthusiasm and imagination. You know, there's a reason why, you know, the story of Peter Pan is
00:18:10.460 so compelling, right? It's an assertion of the power of playfulness and joy, specifically for
00:18:22.520 boys, right? You know, it's Peter Pan and the Lost Boys or, you know, boys on an island that
00:18:27.320 get to sort of live out this play environment. Wendy, the tragedy of Wendy is that she has to
00:18:33.820 come in and sort of be the mother and then return to the real world. But I raise it to say it's like
00:18:40.260 we have reference points for the playful boy, right? And in fact, most of children's literature
00:18:45.760 that has not been about princesses has been about the adventuring, curious boy. And there are ways
00:18:51.820 in which that's sort of been turned in some, you know, borderline toxic ways, right? It gives
00:18:58.180 approval to someone like Elon Musk, who can just be sort of eccentric and chaotic and willful and
00:19:04.340 petulant, you know, and have approval for it. But what it's missing is that strain of joy that you
00:19:12.500 described, right? You know, what would it look like? And for boys to be able to tap into the
00:19:19.360 glorious, whimsical expansiveness of their imaginations. My son loved princesses more
00:19:25.500 than my daughter did when they were younger. And it was one of the big things that influenced
00:19:30.760 a lot of my work on Princess at Disney was appreciating that there's something really
00:19:36.600 spectacular and wonderful and beautiful about these stories and even the things that we dismiss
00:19:42.820 about them. And noticing how a boy responded to it. He also loved My Little Pony.
00:19:49.360 which is another conversation.
00:19:50.140 Yes, but why not?
00:19:51.180 Why not?
00:19:52.420 It's color, it's sparkle, it's glittering.
00:19:54.980 It's fun, it's delightful.
00:19:57.080 Exactly.
00:20:00.000 Let's back up for one hot second
00:20:01.900 because we didn't, I introduced you,
00:20:05.240 but we didn't properly introduce you.
00:20:06.860 Talk to me a little bit about the work you did
00:20:08.140 with Princesses with Disney.
00:20:10.260 Yeah, so I came into the Walt Disney Company
00:20:14.820 on an acquisition.
00:20:16.160 I was editor-in-chief of a media company
00:20:18.560 called Babbel, which was acquired by Disney, and we became the digital arm. So I became head of
00:20:24.480 content for Disney Interactive and had responsibility over its digital platforms and portfolios and
00:20:32.160 that sort of thing. What I also, though, endeavored to do from my first minute on the lot in the
00:20:42.040 of campus was ask what we were going to do about Princess. It was, you know, sort of one of the
00:20:49.440 things that was an interesting point in the, you know, in the Babel acquisition, I think we're far
00:20:55.060 enough along past it, you know, that I can say this, I'm well beyond my NDAs. You know, and we're
00:21:01.020 also, we're all in a safe space here. It's a safe space. Just, just everyone in the world is listening
00:21:07.000 right now. Everyone in the world is listening. It was 13 years ago now. But one of the points
00:21:12.360 of conversation we had was, you know, because there are a number of storytellers in the Babel
00:21:16.580 ecosystem that wrote critically about Princess. I had written critically about Princess. I delivered
00:21:21.860 lectures as an academic on the Princess Industrial Complex. So we wanted to make sure that we were
00:21:27.760 coming into an environment that was going to be friendly to constructive criticism, you know,
00:21:31.980 healthy discourse, you know, we were after all the discourse, we were in charge of the company's,
00:21:38.600 you know, women and family strategy for the internet, right? Like you couldn't,
00:21:42.940 Peggy Ornstein had just written Cinderella ate my daughter, right?
00:21:46.420 Love me some Peggy. We had it. Yeah, we had her on a couple months ago.
00:21:50.000 Yeah, Peggy's amazing. That book was amazing. It was just at the moment that GoldieBlox was
00:21:54.840 emerging. And so like, this was a real question. And so you know, when I, you know, one of the
00:22:00.500 things I, you know, I took upon was like asking, so what are we going to do? Like, can we, can we
00:22:04.800 talk about princess, right? Can we have a conversation about how we're engaging women
00:22:08.660 and girls around these stories, you know? And so, you know, I, you know, I, I led co-led, I had
00:22:16.380 conspirators and collaborators, you know, and an initiative within the company to, you know,
00:22:20.680 to, to think critically about, you know, women and girls strategy broadly, you know, and in
00:22:26.540 particular, how to think about, you know, what's the best way to be framing princess for a new
00:22:30.580 generation of girls and women. And it was amazing work. It was frustrating work. It was fascinating
00:22:38.520 work. It was challenging work for me in part because, you know, I, you know, as I said,
00:22:44.560 I had spent a long time as a scholar and then as a mom blogger being super critical, right,
00:22:51.000 of the princess industrial complex and a lot of the stuff. And I found myself in a situation where
00:22:55.700 the the right strategy wasn't to continue to be critical it was to be like okay like let's like
00:23:01.580 let's take serious our role at Disney as the stewards of fairy tale and think about what it
00:23:05.960 means to like to really embrace where the culture is going and do it in a way that is constructive
00:23:12.260 and and that honors the legacy of fairy tale and again as I said you know the the personal side of
00:23:19.140 that for me was having a you know a young daughter and especially a young son who were just in that
00:23:24.700 moment of really, really, really, really falling in love with princesses and superheroes and space
00:23:31.840 cowboys and all those things. And having that influence of how their imaginations, you know,
00:23:38.640 were engaged by these stories became a became a core part of the work.
00:23:42.740 Yeah, yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. And I just look, there's a lot that I like about princess
00:23:49.320 princess play for, for, for my girls. Um, they love, I love, I love anything where kids put on
00:23:55.760 costumes. I'm just like, right. I love anything where kids put on costumes and makeup stories
00:24:02.920 and expand their imagination and their worlds. Like that's awesome. Uh, and I also like that
00:24:10.020 for boys. Yes, exactly. Exactly. Exactly. Exactly. And that becomes like, that really
00:24:16.700 becomes the hinge right is that yes there's you know we can we can be critical about many
00:24:23.420 many elements of how historically in pop culture sort of princesses have been framed for girls
00:24:29.800 but that core element of the expansive horizon that's provided by imaginative play you know the
00:24:36.960 magic of dress up the magic of like having just being like responding to like glitter and sparkle
00:24:44.680 and magic wands and all of these amazing, fantastical fairyland things, when you open
00:24:52.160 up that sphere and welcome boys into it, that's, I think, when you get the sort of radical
00:24:57.640 opportunity for change because boys do love it. I mean, our own research at Disney showed that
00:25:02.020 boys like that kind of play, right? My son loved that kind of play. And, you know, when you open
00:25:08.400 up the narrative opportunities in those stories, the social emotional learning opportunities in
00:25:13.640 the stories and say, look, these are really stories about kindness. These are stories about
00:25:19.200 sort of leaning on your fellow creature, you know, woodland animal or dwarf or, you know,
00:25:24.600 anything. Yeah. Donkey. There's Donkey. No, that's Pixar. That's a different, right?
00:25:28.860 Right, right, right. Whatever. Whatever. They all blend to me these days.
00:25:33.900 I mean, for children, they all form a landscape. I mean, my daughter, you know, in the years that I
00:25:43.640 who she called Dr. Mrs. Space Ranger Princess, and she blended a Buzz Lightyear costume with
00:25:51.160 a Cinderella costume, and she would go out, we lived in New York at the time, and she would go
00:25:56.540 out onto the roof deck, and she would jump from the tables in the Buzz Lightyear wings and the
00:26:03.280 Cinderella dress and rain boots, and declare herself a Space Ranger Princess, who was also
00:26:08.720 scientist, right? Who was also a mom and had a family, right? And it was that mashup that was
00:26:15.660 just spectacular, right? It's like, you know, take these stories and live in them and inhabit them
00:26:21.600 and let your imagination be expanded. Like, grownups should be doing more of that, right?
00:26:27.480 Yes, absolutely. Absolutely. And I really like including boys in this. Again, this goes back to
00:26:36.100 the definition of what is masculine, what is feminine. And in terms of, I want you to have
00:26:44.660 the roles, to be able to enjoy the kinds of things that girls get to enjoy in that role
00:26:50.080 playing and the play and the whimsy, you know, for so long in many of these, we talk a lot about
00:26:59.300 how the princesses were, you know, I find like their roles are challenging, right? In the
00:27:04.820 the submission and things like that. But for the men, I think they're equally as toxic. I mean,
00:27:11.180 my God, Prince Eric is dumb as bricks. And I don't think Prince Charming speaks. 1.00
00:27:19.180 And then we have these male roles, but then they're also expected to be the savior. And
00:27:24.080 that is a lot of pressure. And so, yes, transforming these things and also just
00:27:30.120 having these conversations when we're watching these movies um i do i do like the frozen franchise
00:27:38.800 because it is the the girls saving themselves and each other and protecting each other uh and
00:27:44.880 there's also a great dude in it who is just along for the adventure but i think that we can do more
00:27:50.980 now we've done we've done a lot for girls i think we can be doing more for boys to create these role
00:27:57.300 models for them that are the supportive, whimsical, delightful, fun-to-inhabit characters.
00:28:04.540 I think that's exactly right, right? And the fun-to-inhabit characters and also the characters
00:28:09.840 that get to be, I hate using this word because it's so loaded in our culture, heroic in different
00:28:18.060 ways, right? We have such a narrow understanding of what a hero is. And arguably, I actually did
00:28:25.700 this exercise when i was at disney when it was a as a sort of it was a rhetorical exercise but it
00:28:29.920 was really fun for me as a writer i took a handful of the fairy tales and i gender flipped them
00:28:35.000 completely right so i've got i actually have like my favorite is a gender flip version of snow white
00:28:41.020 that i called pale jack and literally just took like the the um the the gram version of the stare
00:28:47.680 the the brothers gram version of the fairy tales and just swapped out the gender and i was trying
00:28:52.660 to make a point about how there's nothing in these stories that that we have to be obsessive
00:28:59.120 about the sort of femininity or masculinity about and what's interesting when you do that is that
00:29:03.600 you start to see oh that becomes a really a boy Snow White is a really interesting character to
00:29:08.040 play with a boy Cinderella is an interesting character to play with if you don't try to turn
00:29:12.980 them into a fairy tale Luke Skywalker right or Iron Man when you actually like really honor
00:29:20.660 And you can really see some of the like really interesting threads in older versions of these stories. And these stories go back way beyond the brothers Graham and Hans Christian Andersen. And there are Chinese versions and African versions and ancient Greek versions.
00:29:34.620 But you can start to see how what some of these many of these stories are doing is saying, oh, the superpowers of a Snow White or a Cinderella were being brave. Right. We're being kind. We're being, you know, both Snow White and Cinderella build community for themselves with creatures and beings that everybody else is ignoring. Right.
00:29:57.180 you know they create safe havens for themselves Snow White in particular creates a whole community 0.78
00:30:01.640 with dwarves right in order to kind of affect her own self-rescue initially the prince as to your 0.79
00:30:07.700 point just sort of comes in at the end and is an afterthought right oh my god I never thought that
00:30:12.740 Snow White's village is her dwarves like we're all searching for a village and community and she gets
00:30:17.400 her dwarves yeah she gets her village they make a home together right it's like they make a home 0.99
00:30:23.400 together home together and she builds this beautiful happy life for a while in the forest
00:30:29.140 with these like funky little dwarves funky little supportive dudes yeah and she's kind to them and
00:30:37.420 they're kind to her and she wins them over and it's like you know if you think about like what
00:30:41.940 happens if a boy goes into that environment a boy has to rescue himself from a toxic family
00:30:46.300 right or a toxic yes and he finds this little community of magical beings and um it's like
00:30:54.140 you know what i'm gonna i'm gonna help you you help me right and not on the level of i'm gonna
00:30:59.040 defend you and i'm gonna carry a sword but a level of like i'm gonna care for you and you're gonna
00:31:03.380 care for me right and let's look at how powerful that is about how that's what rescues you from
00:31:08.900 the dark forest, right? Yes. Yes. Absolutely. Absolutely. Time for a quick break. Be right back.
00:31:20.480 You want to impress them on a first date, but also play it cool. So what do you do? I'm Rufy Thorpe,
00:31:28.280 and I wrote and read a real love story about a hinge couple that navigated exactly that.
00:31:32.980 Listen to the free audiobook now.
00:32:02.980 is made to help. Download it now. What am I missing? What else should I be asking you about
00:32:12.120 the masculine and the feminine? Oh, gosh. Well, one of the things that is on my mind a lot,
00:32:18.060 because I went through, last year was a super tough year for me. I kind of like
00:32:21.580 lost everything. I lost my mom. My mom died on Mother's Day last year. My cat died six hours
00:32:29.040 before my mom did. I wasn't, I was in the hospital in Canada with her. So I missed that. I lost my
00:32:34.440 job. I lost my house. I lost my sister in a different sense. She didn't die, but she like
00:32:40.620 absented herself into the world. I lost my stepfather. I lost a lot of, like it was a lot
00:32:47.080 of things. It was an earthquake of a year and, and there was a lot of grief and there was a lot
00:32:54.000 of emotional processing. And one of this, I'm, I'm looping this back to masculinity promise.
00:32:58.060 Yeah, you are. Yeah, of course you are. There are two elements of it, right? One was that it was, I was very, very grateful for the space as a woman, as a mother, as a daughter, as a putative caregiver, the space that I was afforded for my loss and for my grief, right? That I feel like men don't get as much.
00:33:20.080 And I was very aware in conversations that I had with male friends about how these were trickier conversations for them, complicated relationships with their own mothers, complicated relationships to grief, living in a culture where men still, you know, aren't supposed to outwardly show emotion.
00:33:38.720 i was really really really grateful for the you know that you know the meme the feminine urge
00:33:44.100 right to xyz i i felt very grateful for the feminine permission to indulge the feminine urge
00:33:50.980 to cry a lot to mourn a lot to engage in ritual and this is where you know i you know i mentioned
00:33:56.800 one of the things i'm working on you know narratively right now is uh is an intersection
00:34:01.160 of loss and grief and magic and woo one of the things that was a big saving thing for me was
00:34:05.860 that open space to like, spiritually explore ways of getting comfortable, right, with the emotional
00:34:13.540 storm that I was weathering that it's like, it's, it's okay, especially for like a middle aged
00:34:18.940 woman living in Los Angeles. It's like, grab your crystals, girl, right? That's fine. Right? It's
00:34:24.560 like, do your moon rituals, like embrace woo. And that was really, really, really, really,
00:34:29.580 really a big part has been continues to be a big part of my healing process. But it's something
00:34:34.660 that is this is one of the things that's certainly super coded feminine right now in certainly an 1.00
00:34:39.960 internet culture and one of the things that's made fun of and that sort of thing it's like the ladies 1.00
00:34:44.760 with their crystals and their astrology and you know there's you know the witch witch fluencers 0.93
00:34:50.280 and witch talk and all this which waiter witch fluencers a thing totally oh shut your mouth
00:34:56.380 totally maybe a longer conversation um yeah like it's you know it's a whole thing but it's super 1.00
00:35:03.840 feminine. And there are really, really interesting male, masculine, you know, presences in that
00:35:11.860 space. And what's interesting to me about them is that they like they're conflating masculine or
00:35:16.500 they're exploding, disrupting, let's say masculinity in a different way, a way that's
00:35:20.760 really interesting by embracing this like hyper feminized space. And I've thought a lot about how
00:35:28.800 it's like, look, you know, this is one of the things this goes to what we were saying about
00:35:31.680 boys and fairy tales men get locked out of magic right men get excluded from that now they have
00:35:39.440 there's various like there's obviously iron john and heroes journeys and all that sort of thing
00:35:44.940 men you know men have their own paths and joe rogan will go on and on about you know all the
00:35:49.820 insights from psychedelic journeys but that like but but they're cut off from magic magic i think
00:35:54.560 Right. Right. Kind of folkloric, whimsical, fairyland magic. Right. You know, the, you know, real interesting, powerful magic that helps us navigate emotional storms. It's, it's so hyper feminized. And there's a part of me that wants to construct, like deconstruct that critically.
00:36:18.540 But there's a part of me that just feels wild gratitude that to have all this cultural space to explore emotions and spirituality in that way.
00:36:30.480 Now, I can also go on very critically about the divine feminine, but there's something very, very powerful about the cultural moment that we're in that is creating so much space for different forms of emotional and spiritual exploration that I feel sad for men to be cut off from.
00:36:49.160 And where I would wish to see, like, really some sort of gentler integration of masculine and feminine around that of having it be less gendered than it is. I say that at the same time as I'm like, you know, one of the things I'm grateful for, it's like, you know, it's like grown up princess play in some respects, right?
00:37:10.360 You know, I'm grateful for the feminization of it in some respects, but I also am like really, really aware of how the gender coding with magic in the current cultural moment makes it kind of exclusive.
00:37:25.440 Right, right. Well, I think that gender coding makes too many things exclusive, right? 0.56
00:37:30.060 Yes, totally, totally, totally, totally. Especially things that have to do with how we move emotionally in our world, right? It's, you know, the, you know, the masculine public sphere has so often, especially in the West, especially, you know, in the, you know, the, the capitalist patriarchal West.
00:37:50.340 is framed as the space of reason and order, right? It's framed as the space of, and we know that it's
00:38:00.800 not that, right? We know that that's a lie, but it does put a cultural expectation on anyone who
00:38:06.960 is embracing that sort of masculine space that it's like, that is the space of reason and science
00:38:12.560 and order. And it's not a space in which you get messy and cry, right? It's not a space in which
00:38:19.560 you pursue whimsical joy, right? It is not a space in which you are soft, right? It is not a space
00:38:26.740 in which you hug trees, right? It's a more closed space to the landscape of our emotions and our
00:38:36.640 imagination. And that's where I think the oppressive character of gender stereotypes
00:38:43.700 just really does us all a disservice, but it's one of the ways in which it really does harm men and
00:38:48.320 boys. Absolutely. Absolutely. That is all we've got for today, mostly because I have to go to the
00:38:54.340 gym. I loved this conversation. We're going to have you on again because you are a Renaissance
00:39:00.900 human. I don't like to say Renaissance woman or man, a Renaissance human. We can talk about all
00:39:05.440 of the things. And next up, we're going to talk about AI, which is going to be delightful and
00:39:09.820 also terrifying in a way for me. I'm scared. I'm scared of AI. Yeah. I mean, we'll save it for the
00:39:17.000 next conversation. But it's a terrifying, exhilarating, beautiful and horrible moment
00:39:23.220 that we're in. And it's a fascinating one to explore. Yeah, we are. Tell everyone where
00:39:29.120 they can find you and support you on the interwebs. On the interwebs, I am on Instagram
00:39:37.160 and threads as at her bad mother, H-E-R-B-A-D mother. I am, where else am I? I'm no longer on 1.00
00:39:47.440 X, thankfully. Oh, me neither. I haven't been on X in forever. I had my identity stolen on X and
00:39:53.880 then I gave up. I thought you did. Yeah. It's a terrible place. It's a terrible name. Everything
00:39:58.280 about it is awful. Yeah. And I was just like, I'm not, this is not important enough to me to fight.
00:40:03.640 So I'm just going to abandon it, delete it, and go away.
00:40:06.400 And I just launched a sub stack, which is Holy Doodle Bug.
00:40:11.900 Holy Doodle Bug.
00:40:13.300 I love it.
00:40:14.800 I love it.
00:40:15.440 Everyone follow the Holy Doodle Bug.
00:40:17.880 Wonderful.
00:40:18.540 Thank you so much for being on here today.
00:40:20.440 I loved this.
00:40:21.800 I love this too, Jo.
00:40:22.760 Thank you for having me on.
00:40:25.640 And that is all we have for today.
00:40:27.820 Lots to think about, my friends.
00:40:30.400 I feel so much better.
00:40:31.560 Joe Rogan is gone.
00:40:32.760 he's gone from my brain in such a wonderful way. If you love this show, please leave us a review.
00:40:40.260 It actually really helps. You can do it in all of the review places. If you love me,
00:40:46.460 order The Sicilian Inheritance. Seriously, it really is the best book of the summer.
00:40:51.120 The other day, I actually stopped by a reader's birthday party. She emailed me and was like,
00:40:57.060 will you come to my birthday party? And I said, hell yes. And we had some delicious Negroni
00:41:02.560 and we laughed and we wore funny hats in a restaurant and everyone, everyone stared at us
00:41:08.460 and we didn't care. Nope, nope. Because that is the vibe of the Sicilian inheritance. We got big
00:41:14.560 Sicilian energy and we don't give an F what the world thinks of us. We're awesome. You're awesome.
00:41:21.640 Go do something nice for yourself. You deserve it.
00:41:32.560 Transcription by CastingWords
00:42:02.560 I didn't like what you said, Odin pauses, about the future.
00:42:16.740 This is the love story of real hinge couple Odin and Edward,
00:42:21.060 written and read by me, Curtis Garner.
00:42:23.800 Listen to the free audiobook now.