00:26:49.560Not as fun as what the British were providing.0.66
00:26:52.160So Benedict Arnold wanted to try to be like, let's try and make everybody get along.
00:26:56.240But also I want to meet some hot young teens.
00:26:58.800And so he hosted a ball, like a big event, the social event of the season.
00:27:03.820He's like, great, we're going to invite all of the hot young everybody to this party.
00:27:07.760And then he was told like, turns out that the American people are not hot.
00:27:11.780If you want hot people, you need to invite some loyalist British types, like the Shippen Sisters.
00:27:17.500And so eventually they were invited as well, just because there wasn't enough.0.87
00:27:20.580Like the it girls about town were all on the loyalist side, not on the Patriot side. And so he, I don't know if this is where they met, but he hosted and or attended many events. And you know, Peggy was at every party. And by the end of this summer, they were courting. She was a teenager and he was 37. And that is what is happening.
00:27:41.900she is i believe at this point like 17 18 years old and he was escorting her to dinners receptions
00:27:49.200and the theater he was at one point challenged for dating a teenage loyalist and benedict arnold
00:27:55.540was like come at me you wish you were dating her she's the hottest girl in town and she's mine
00:28:00.940and i feel like to peggy she was just like he is a war hero he's the governor like i could not aim
00:28:07.120any higher, this is the best boyfriend I could find. So he also, with his leg injury, he used a
00:28:14.180white jewel encrusted cane. So he had this injury, but he was kind of like, oh no, my injury makes
00:28:20.340me even more cool and interesting. And all of Philadelphia, like the city, the city is a
00:28:26.120character in this story. The city of Philadelphia is the fifth girl in Sex and the City. All of
00:28:30.220Philadelphia, which again is a character, were intrigued by the courtship of this military hero
00:28:35.520and this hot young teen, Belle. One woman wrote to a friend, I must tell you that Cupid has given
00:28:41.520our little general a more mortal wound than all the hosts of Britons could. So he was smitten
00:28:47.020by Peggy Shippen, but like everyone who met her was. Her vibe in that way is similar to Nomi Malone
00:28:53.100in the movie Showgirls. So by September, like they met that summer. And then by that September,
00:28:58.520Benedict Arnold was asking her father permission to marry her. He was like, dear Mr. Shippen,
00:29:03.320I am not a gold digger, even though I do have numerous debts and like living a lavish lifestyle.
00:29:08.900But he's also like, I know that I am on team George W and you're allegedly a loyalist,
00:29:13.860but you know what? That shouldn't stand in the way of a love story between
00:29:17.440a 37 year old man and your teenage daughter. He also wrote a love letter to Peggy, which exists
00:29:23.060that we can still see. And it was literally a copy paste of a love letter he'd written to a
00:29:27.680previous woman. He was also trying to woo. So he had templates he was using anyway. So he wrote
00:29:32.920these letters. He requested this via letters. Peggy and her dad didn't, neither of them replied
00:29:37.760right away. I feel like they were like step and step here. They were just trying to figure out
00:29:41.140what to do. And so why wouldn't the dad want Peggy to marry this guy? So one issue was Benedict
00:29:47.520Arnold's social status. He was formerly an apothecary and the shipments were like fancy
00:29:53.140rich people. Also he was 37 and she was 17. And then also he was a widowed father of three
00:30:01.160sons who his sister in Connecticut was caring for. And so the issue is like, are these three sons
00:30:07.800going to come and join their household? Do we want that? But on the pro side, Peggy's dad knew
00:30:13.300that if she married Benedict Arnold, this could maybe be good for his career ambitions because
00:30:18.780Benedict Arnold was like the governor. But then the other perhaps biggest issue is the fact that
00:30:24.000Benedict Arnold was an asshole. So he was mean to his subordinates. This whole thing happened where1.00
00:30:33.340he part-owned this ship that arrived with goods that he was bringing into town so that he could
00:30:39.720sell for profit. And he put these goods in a government-owned warehouse and asked the army
00:30:44.580to transport it for him. Using government equipment for private purposes was illegal.
00:30:49.800so he did that he also did this thing where there's this woman who wanted to pass through
00:30:56.740so new york at this point new york state was british occupied and so it was patriots couldn't0.95
00:31:03.740really get in there but he like made an illegal passport so this woman could get in there to do
00:31:08.040spy work he got in trouble for that as well these three things really sank his whole reputation like
00:31:14.860he was mean to the people he worked for. He used government stuff to like store his weird
00:31:19.960West Indies goods. And he made a passport for this spy. And so his enemies took this to the
00:31:25.320newspapers, which were the pamphlets of the era. Someone filed a complaint against him to the
00:31:31.140Supreme Executive Council, which is a body of jurisprudence that is in this story a lot.
00:31:38.780And it just sounds like if you watch that season of American Horror Story in New Orleans,
00:31:44.580where it was all about witches and they're like, who's going to be the next supreme witch? Like,
00:31:48.540I just picture this council of, you know, Emma Roberts and people. Anyway, so a complaint was
00:31:55.560filed against him to the Supreme Executive Council and Benedict Arnold was like, I'm all too happy to
00:31:59.700answer for these actions to A, Congress or B, George W. Those are the only people I'm accountable
00:32:04.840to. I do not recognize you, Supreme Executive Council and Emma Roberts. So this drama was
00:32:09.640happening literally at the same time that he was wooing his teenage girlfriend. Around the same
00:32:14.460time, one of Peggy's sisters, her oldest sister Betsy was being married and Betsy was nervous
00:32:19.200about the wedding night. And then Peggy was like, oh my God, I'm also worried about like what sex
00:32:23.440is. Allegedly, she took a solemn oath to never have sex, which she then retracted very soon0.70
00:32:28.400afterwards. But just a detail I wanted to share. Eventually, Peggy convinced her father to agree
00:32:34.380that she could marry Benedict Arnold by doing some tactics that she was known to do, which
00:32:40.060includes weeping, taking to her bed, throwing a fit, refusing to eat or drink, and just being
00:32:47.060kind of a hysterical nightmare tantrum child. And when she did that, her father gave her what
00:32:53.520she wanted. And in this case, that was marriage to Benedict Arnold. So Benedict Arnold. So the
00:32:59.700supreme executive council was still like full of haterade for him he went to judge w for advice
00:33:07.860like he wanted to go ask for advice from his bro george w but on route i guess he's like on his
00:33:13.340in his carriage or on his horse then some other guy comes up on a horse to give him i'm picturing
00:33:17.480like a scroll but it's probably more like a sealed letter but it was a proclamation from the supreme
00:33:21.780executive council accusing him now also of military misconduct and they had timed like
00:33:28.700charging him with this to coincide with when he was leaving. He was leaving Philadelphia to go
00:33:32.460find George W. So then they gave him this paper at the same time to make it look like he had
00:33:37.420defected to the British. The Supreme Executive Council just really hated this guy. And I've
00:33:42.080got to say, I don't blame them. He sucked. But anyway, the charges he was filed for were basically1.00
00:33:47.740those three things I said before. There's eight charges total, but it's like storing your stuff
00:33:51.900in the warehouse, giving that woman the passport, and being mean to your support nets, effectively.1.00
00:33:56.760But Peggy and the Shippans were on Benedict Arnold's team.0.71
00:34:00.360They thought that this was an example of the Supreme Executive Council.0.98
00:58:53.680Fall in love with our core cast, or be awed by our incredible guests from familiar shows like Oxventure, Three Black Halflings, and No Rolls Barred.
00:59:06.180Ignite your imagination and discover the Realms of Peril and Glory today.
00:59:13.040Go to RealmsPod.com or search Realms of Peril and Glory wherever you listen to podcasts.
00:59:24.200You've watched them from the outside your whole life.