00:00:30.000hello and welcome to vulgar history of feminist women's history comedy podcast my name is am
00:00:46.320foster and today i'm going to be sharing with you a conversation i had with author helen king
00:00:51.020about her new book immaculate forms a history of the female body in four parts so just to give you
00:00:57.840an idea of what this book is like. It's a very readable book for just a general audience. It's
00:01:02.600not an academic book at all. Dr. Jennifer Gunter, author of The Vagina Bible, says,
00:01:07.860never has medical history been more entertaining. And I absolutely concur this book. It's really
00:01:14.020readable. It's really interesting. And what Helen does in this book is that she goes through four
00:01:20.840body parts. Each sort of chapter is about either breasts, clitoris, hymen, and womb, and just kind
00:01:28.600of talks about through history, how they've been put, treated in artwork, how they've been treated
00:01:33.300in medical knowledge. Do people believe in these body parts? It's really, it's such an interesting
00:01:40.620approach to the whole topic. And we're going to go in this interview, we're going to go body part
00:01:44.300by body part. And I do want to emphasize too, that in this book, so Helen King, she talks about
00:01:50.080gender um the the gender binary a lot in this book because she's bringing up so many examples
00:01:56.400of non-binary people um throughout history and how they're treated uh people so like breasts
00:02:04.020clitters hymen and womb and what makes somebody a woman and what makes somebody not a woman and
00:02:09.520it's in a really sort of open i think um very trans inclusive sort of way and i hope that
00:02:16.040comes across in our discussion as well i do want to just let you know a bit about helen and where
00:02:20.540she's coming from and who she is so she's a professor emerita of classical studies at the
00:02:25.420open university she's an elected member of the general synod of the church of england where she
00:02:30.320is vice chair of together which campaigns on a range of discrimination issues including
00:02:34.520discrimination on the grounds of gender or sexuality she's published extensively on the
00:02:39.940history of women's health and it's been talking to her too you'll hear this but in doing the
00:02:44.280research she learned so many things that she hadn't known before just by going through these
00:02:49.060body parts i think it's so interesting and actually one other thing i just want to mention
00:02:53.040is i recently saw the new movie version of nosferatu and there's a part in that where
00:02:58.680lily rose depp's character is she's suffering from possession by a vampire but the the sort of
00:03:06.860dim-witted male doctors are just like oh i think there's a problem with her womb tighten up her0.74
00:03:11.700corset more, the womb, hold the womb in place and stuff. So I do want to say, we don't talk0.94
00:03:16.480about it in the podcast, but in the book, Helen absolutely gets into the whole concept of
00:03:20.100the wandering womb and things like that. So anyway, without further ado, I hope you enjoyed
00:03:27.000this conversation between myself and Helen King, author of Immaculate Forms, A History of the
00:03:31.760female body in four parts. So today we are joined by Helen King, author of Immaculate Forms,
00:03:43.680a history of the female body in four parts. Welcome, Helen. Thank you. Lovely to be here.
00:03:49.160I'm really delighted to have you here. I think that this book is going to be of great interest
00:03:53.340to my listeners. Can you explain initially just the premise of your book? Sure. So I was trying
00:04:00.960to write a book which was a history of women's bodies, mostly in Western Europe, but going beyond
00:04:04.820where necessary. And I was trying to think, how do you do that? Where do you start? What counts
00:04:09.480as a woman's body? And of course, that's the big question. What is actually a woman? How much is
00:04:14.320it our bodies? How much does that define us? And I thought the way to do this was to pick four body
00:04:19.820parts. So the ones that sort of come up most in discussions of what a proper woman should look1.00
00:04:25.000like and be like so breasts clitoris hymen and womb and that also takes me from the outside of0.74
00:04:31.020the body from what is visible i mean even if you haven't got your breasts on display you know you0.94
00:04:36.460can enlarge you can show them with clothing you can sort of play them down you can play them up
00:04:41.000you can actually see some shape there whereas when you get to clitoris hymen womb you don't
00:04:47.680know what's going on there so from outside to inside from visible to invisible and that also
00:04:53.880means going from sort of what you can find out about through experience to what you really can
00:05:00.580only guess is going on inside the body like what is happening deep inside the body in the womb what
00:05:06.220does it look like what does it do what's it all about so inside from outside to inside and from
00:05:12.100visible to invisible and from sort of factual ish to imaginary and can you explain i mean you're
00:05:20.120talking about, just the book is described, it's going from classical Greece to the modern age,
00:05:24.620but the historical time periods and things you're talking about, it's everything. You're just
00:05:31.240looking at all different history. Yeah. So my own background is in ancient Greek stuff,
00:05:35.980classics. So Hippocratic medicine, the medicine of ancient Greece. But I've been studying a lot
00:05:41.040more than that ever since I really started doing research academically. So the point is that
00:05:46.400ancient Greek medicine is used up to pretty well the 19th century as a basis for what the body is
00:05:54.700about. Modern modernity is quite recent, if that makes sense. The same sorts of beliefs that,
00:06:01.360for example, a woman's body only has a finite amount of blood in it. And if you use up your
00:06:07.540blood by thinking, using your brain, you haven't got enough left to make babies out of. That sort0.91
00:06:14.160of belief goes back to the ancient Greeks and it was still around in the 19th century. So it was
00:06:20.680used as an argument against women having higher education. If you used your brain too much, the1.00
00:06:25.140race would die out. And this, what I was thinking of, just because there's so many things I want to
00:06:29.840talk to you about your book, we can go body part by body part. And so starting with the breasts,
00:06:35.860which I was just explaining to you before we recorded on this podcast, we talk about being0.98
00:06:39.800tits out as the ultimate compliment. And that's for any gender, you know, being tits out. It's1.00
00:06:46.260just a person who's just being audacious and doing their own thing. And so I was excited to
00:06:51.140have a whole chapter just about tits. It was the first one I wrote because I'd never really done0.69
00:06:56.980anything on the history of breasts before. And I thought, you know, I'm going to start with
00:07:00.700something I don't know too much about because that'll be interesting for me to write. And I
00:07:04.220won't get sort of overwhelmed by knowing too much. And I was just in shock the whole way through the
00:07:09.180chapter actually there was so much more historically than i'd ever imagined well and so and what i
00:07:14.920appreciate about your book i appreciate a lot about your book is with all the body parts you're
00:07:18.740talking about in one context there's a maternal thing like a procreative content but then there's
00:07:24.620also sort of philosophical but breasts especially like there's you talk about the breastfeeding
00:07:30.420versus just breasts as objects breasts as sexuality and so you're talking about both sides
00:07:36.620Yeah, that whole sexual versus maternal thing. I think what really brought that out for me when I was researching the chapter was the very recent discussions of human breast milk ice cream and the sort of shock horror.
00:07:49.860How could you possibly versus, well, actually, we've all either used breast milk as children or we've used substitutes for it. What's the big deal about breast milk? And yet it really freaks people out.
00:08:06.620to think of breast milk ice cream. So that was a modern example, which I found quite illuminating.
00:08:13.160Well, and in this chapter, and as well as in other chapters, but you, I appreciate it in your book,
00:08:17.520you also, you're talking about like a trans person's experience or talking about top surgery,
00:08:23.840the removal of the breast and how that can help, but also even people who aren't trans,
00:08:27.840like a cis man who might have excessive breast tissue. And so just talking about the breast is
00:08:34.140not just as a it's a very expansive discussion i thought that was also interesting as well
00:08:39.240well thank you for saying that because it was something again which i found surprising i i
00:08:43.760hadn't realized quite how much breast tissue is something found in people of any sex so yeah
00:08:51.380you've got the situation where somebody a man who's identified as male from birth could end
00:08:59.440up with breast cancer and men don't take that seriously they don't think about breast cancer
00:09:05.060they think it's a woman's disease well actually breast tissue exists in anybody and then the thing
00:09:10.520about accessory breasts which to me always sounds a lot like a handbag or something like taking your0.65
00:09:16.820purse out you know accessory accessory breasts where you can have a breast breast tissue that
00:09:22.300grows even on your leg and that can happen in people whatever sex they identify as and it can1.00
00:09:29.040even produce milk. And finding examples of that from the past, but also examples in modern medical
00:09:35.580literature, was one of those sort of shock horror moments in my breast chapter. I had no idea that
00:09:42.900breasts are actually not that much of a girly thing. In terms of getting your tits out, I was1.00
00:09:48.760really in a state of overexcitement when I found people literally doing that, including a man.0.99
00:09:53.380there was a guy in the early modern period who was 1665 who we're told in medical texts
00:10:01.500had so much milk in his breasts and this is someone assigned male at birth as far as we can
00:10:07.840see but who had maybe some sort of condition where breast milk develops even in the breasts
00:10:14.460of someone who's supposedly male and he would actually get drunk at parties and squirt milk
00:10:20.140at people as a sort of party trick now again what does that do to our ideas of breasts as the thing
00:10:26.300that's really really female clearly it's not as simple as that i'm hoping to be able to control
00:10:31.380myself and go body part by body part but every single chapter has examples like that where it's
00:10:35.980just like this book really illustrates how what is a man what is a woman like there's so much like
00:10:43.820it's not like bodies are born people are born with a combination of parts or whatever like it's
00:10:50.140It's not straightforward at all. I left this book being like, I don't even know what a woman is
00:10:55.180anymore. I don't know. I have to say, I get to a similar stage myself. Yeah, exactly that. So1.00
00:11:01.920things like how do you name parts? We will come to that later on. But how do you name them? What
00:11:07.260is female organ? What is a male organ? Do you have different words if it's in a man or in a woman?1.00
00:11:13.200So the breasts thing even, you know, do you talk about in English slang, you know, tits and boobs
00:11:18.520are those words which suggest one more than the other.
00:11:23.220You talk about men who have a lot of breast tissue, obvious breast tissue now, sometimes0.94
00:15:53.760But 1559 is supposed to be the big moment.
00:15:56.000And then it sort of goes quiet again. And then somewhere in the 19th century, you get a much bigger discussion of the clitoris in anatomical texts, saying it's not tiny at all. It's actually quite extensive. And the little tiny rosebuddy thing is not the whole of it.
00:16:14.120and then that gets forgotten again and medical textbooks in the early 20th century
00:16:19.660just leave it out it's not labeled it's not mentioned it's just not there and then it
00:16:25.700comes back again big time in the 1990s when it was rediscovered you know it keeps being
00:16:31.860rediscovered but this time by a female anatomist and at that point it starts to go into the sort
00:16:39.140of consciousness of what we have now of what the clitoris looks like the sort of wishbone shape
00:16:43.920the extending below the surface, not just a small dot on the body. So it sort of comes and goes in
00:16:52.060a way that shows that, again, medical history is not linear. Discovery just doesn't go in one
00:16:57.200direction. Well, and you mentioned, I think I just have this picture I took of the page,
00:17:02.780but you're talking about Cleopatra, I think it's from this chapter. And just talking about how she
00:17:08.440was, we've talked about this enough, I've done a whole Cleopatra episode about how she is,1.00
00:17:12.740people think oh she was this wildly sexual woman where it's like she was i mean she had these two
00:17:19.320monogamous relationships but anyway but just sort of talking about you wrote here um ancient greek0.88
00:17:27.140and roman writers contrasted her behavior with that of a proper wife holding her up as a warning
00:17:31.040to women of how not to behave the sexualization of cleopatra continues even today with the0.66
00:17:35.860marketing of clitoral jewelry yeah including the cleopatra clip it's absolutely extraordinary
00:17:42.120isn't it? So yeah, there's all sorts of use of that, the name of Cleopatra, to sell sex products,0.91
00:17:48.400basically, because she's still seen as this sex-crazed woman. I mean, if you actually read0.90
00:17:53.020her in the ancient texts, they talk more about her ability to learn different foreign languages
00:17:57.520as one of her main characteristics. It's not about her sexuality, it's about her brain.0.64
00:18:02.520But that's the sort of typical problem that women have always had, isn't it, really,0.71
00:18:06.540being defined like that. But the story is that she was just completely overwhelmed by her
00:18:11.260clitoris, that she had to sleep with vast numbers of men in a brothel in order to try and get any0.98
00:18:17.780satisfaction at all. That's actually a modern-ish story, 17th century story, that has then been
00:18:25.200used to argue that the historic, real Queen Cleopatra was somehow the discoverer of the
00:18:33.500vibrator, and that she had this vibrator filled with bees. And the more you think about that,
00:18:39.840the more disturbing it is uh right and also you know apart from the fact you would you want to0.99
00:18:46.500use a sex toy full of bees or you know what if the lid came off or something but actually0.96
00:18:52.220vibration wise that seems quite subtle to me yeah we'll stop going into detail your listeners can0.99
00:18:59.840work that one out but yeah so yeah cleopatra is used to to sell things now and she's always been
00:19:07.440seen as this you know paragon of over sexuality yet originally in the earliest sources that's
00:19:15.480really not what it's about as you say two monogamous relationships big deal yeah exactly
00:19:20.600and then also in the clitoris chapter too you you again like talk about um trans uh surgeries and
00:19:28.720how how the clitoris can be how that i don't know can you describe that i don't know how to describe
00:19:34.640Well, partly it's that very interesting question about what do you think about the clitoris and0.90
00:19:39.820the penis? Is the clitoris a small penis? And some of the language used for it historically1.00
00:19:45.960has suggested that. It's the lady penis. What if you reverse that and say the penis is the1.00
00:19:50.960large clitoris? Whoa, the whole thing has just shifted, hasn't it? And because, yes,0.99
00:19:57.020there are clearly analogies between the two as organs that are capable of erection and so on,
00:20:02.960and organs associated obviously with pleasure, then you can also say that some of the research
00:20:09.160that's been done on surgery on trans people has actually helped us to understand how the
00:20:17.020clitoris works. So if you think about the sorts of surgery you can do to make the clitoris bigger,0.83
00:20:25.140if you cut to release it from the hood slightly, it looks more like a penis.0.97
00:20:31.360But in the process of that, people have also discovered a lot more nerve endings that they didn't know that existed.
00:20:38.900So it's quite an interesting thing that surgery for trans people, if that's what they choose to have, has actually affected the way we understand the tissue down there.0.62
00:20:49.580And now for a quick advertising break.
00:20:52.280Before you knew what a stock was, you traded snacks, cards, turns.
00:20:57.460That instinct to trade didn't disappear.
00:21:50.580and armies scattered like bones in the dust.
00:21:53.740Now the survivors claw to what's left of a broken world, praying the darkness chooses someone else tonight.
00:22:01.660But in the shadow dark, the darkness always wins.
00:22:05.960This is old school adventuring at its most cruel.
00:22:09.420Your torch ticks down in real time, and when that flame dies, something else rises to finish the job.
00:22:15.340This is a brutal rules light nightmare with a story that emerges organically based on the decisions that the characters make.
00:22:22.840This is what it felt like to play RPGs in the 80s, and man, it is so good to be back.
00:22:27.660Join the Glass Cannon podcast as we plunge into the shadow dark every Thursday night at 8 p.m. Eastern on YouTube.com slash the Glass Cannon with the podcast version dropping the next day.
00:22:38.340See what everybody's talking about and join us in the dark.
00:23:07.960You know, in the tits chapter, there's lots of shock horror, but this is just kind of like, oh, God, the genital mutilation that happens in some cultures.
00:23:17.560Yeah, so that was something I knew a bit about before I started writing the book. But you find out so much more when you start researching it. I was really surprised at how much of this is being carried out now, particularly things like labiaplasty, as opposed to clitoridectomy, that these things are available in private medicine, people choose to have it.
00:23:37.660But then you start to get very interesting questions about how we judge other people historically or now. So if someone is from a culture where, you know, you need to look like this in order to be accepted as a proper woman and they don't look like this, is it OK to say, well, yeah, have the surgery?
00:23:56.880Once you start looking at that, as well as thinking about the dangers of playing with0.96
00:24:02.440different bits of your body and what could possibly go wrong, you also start to ask questions
00:24:07.560about how we judge people from other cultures in the past or in the present who choose to do
00:24:13.300things to their body. Because in a sense, we all modify our bodies anyway, whether that's in
00:24:18.900clothing or hairstyles or plastic surgery, obviously. How far do you go and how far is it
00:24:26.160legitimate to go and how far do you say well actually no that person shouldn't be doing that1.00
00:24:31.240they've been brainwashed into it by their culture and that's really complicated because the female
00:24:38.540genital mutilation range you know includes full clitoridectomy if you're removing the clitoris
00:24:46.900but we now know it goes on further in the body than just the bit that's visible
00:24:52.160pleasure can still be possible after clitoridectomy but there are so many things that
00:24:58.860can go wrong in clitoridectomy risks of infection and bleeding and so on it still seems to me to be
00:25:04.600something we should be saying no don't do that but then that brings in all those cultural differences
00:25:10.960I know in my own part of the world I mean Oxford there is a anti-clitoridectomy movement
00:25:17.800which is basically trying to say to communities where it's normal,
00:25:22.760don't do it because these are the risks to health on the women who have it done.
00:25:27.860So rather than saying, we're not in your culture,0.60
00:25:33.080to say, think about the implications of this thing you do
00:25:36.380and fight it within your culture rather than because we say you should.
00:25:41.860So very interesting ethical issues which these body modifications can bring up.
00:25:47.800Well, that just makes me think too, I guess it's more of an external thing, but in terms of the way that I read your book, and I was just like, I don't even know what gender is anymore. But you, I've seen people who, who are explaining, like, you know, men getting a hair transplant, like that's gender confirmation, or a woman getting larger breast implants, that's gender confirmation, like people who, so the broad spectrum of like somebody who is like a non-binary person or a trans person getting gender confirmation surgery, versus like a
00:26:17.800cis person who just wants to look more feminine or wants to look more masculine like it's just
00:26:22.380like well then why is one frowned upon you know by some people and one is plotted it's just it's
00:26:28.280odd yes it is odd and it's something which we really don't seem to have worked out in terms
00:26:33.760of the the ethics of this the sorts of choices people have or don't have about their own bodies
00:26:39.160and how they present their bodies and just what is a woman anyway listeners this book this book
00:26:46.260will blow your minds um your next your next chapter is about the hymen and that was very
00:26:51.840interesting so do we believe in the hymen big question um one of the reviews of my book has
00:26:58.260said we're still not really clear if helen king believes in the hymen or not no that's because
00:27:01.520helen king doesn't know if she believes in the hymen or not i mean i really don't know i don't
00:27:05.980think i have one but who knows um if it's a stretchy sort of membrane and if some people
00:27:11.900stretch more easily than others, then you might not necessarily know you have it. There is
00:27:17.220something where the hymen is called imperforate hymen, where the hymen has no gaps in it and you
00:27:25.020can't have a period because the blood just builds up behind it. So in some cases, there clearly is
00:27:30.080some sort of membrane that's really powerful and actually blocks the exit. But does that mean every
00:27:36.400woman has some sort of membrane. It's really not clear to me. But it's clearly something that's
00:27:42.220been fetishised over history, that you've somehow got to have it, and you've got to be able to prove
00:27:48.200you have it. Well, how do you prove you have it? So one of the moments for me in that chapter was
00:27:53.320finding out that as far back as Augustine, so late Roman Empire, we had people saying,
00:27:59.640well, the trouble is if you inspect to try and find the hymen, in the process of inspecting for
00:28:04.640it you probably destroy it so that's crazy isn't it you know you destroy the thing while you're
00:28:10.720looking for it well and i've come across just in my research for various podcast episodes you know
00:28:15.800when these sort of appalling situations to imagine you know people who have to prove their virginity
00:28:21.340in a court of law or something where it's just like oh my god but then even back then like you
00:28:25.980hear about people who would switch places with a servant girl or they would try and fake it but
00:28:31.380like shove something up inside of you to make it look like and people still do that now you were
00:28:35.400talking in your book can you talk about people who have yeah sure i find it quite extraordinary
00:28:41.100that this is still going on so again if you go online you can find all sorts of websites that
00:28:45.440claim to restore your virginity uh this could be sort of jokey like they'll give you a certificate
00:28:50.060that says i'm a virgin um right that's really going to help isn't it but also uh there's a
00:28:55.840long history of people doing things to create the effect of bleeding, so inserting something0.84
00:29:02.600red, berries, juice, into the vagina before sex so something will come out, or more rather
00:29:10.440more dramatic things like inserting something that will actually make you bleed so that0.94
00:29:16.680you produce the effect at first intercourse.
00:29:24.700But then you've got cultures where they could insert a small piece of raw meat up there so that someone inspecting you will think, oh, yeah, there's some sort of barrier when there isn't.0.74
00:29:34.600But this whole sort of inspecting, why can't you just believe a woman when she tells you about her sexual history?
00:29:40.460What sort of relationship is it if you don't believe her?
00:29:45.840But the sorts of tests people have done historically for virginity, all sorts of things.
00:29:51.560So even things like thinking about whether a particular strange musical sound comes out of a cave when a virgin enters it, really quite freaky things.
00:30:05.900How do you prove it, particularly when there's this awareness that by trying to prove it, you may well destroy it?
00:30:15.540If it's not a hymen, then what is virginity?
00:30:19.520why do you need a physical marker of it? Why can't a woman just say, I've never done this before,1.00
00:30:26.220or I did do this before? Now, again, we get onto judging other cultures. So if you are from a1.00
00:30:31.220culture where virginity is critical and where you will be disgraced and your family disgraced
00:30:36.720if you're not a virgin at marriage, then you can see why people have a strong motivation
00:30:40.740to do something, even something so extreme as having some sort of surgery that will then
00:30:48.140be broken at the point where the man enters the woman. You can see why people would do that in
00:30:53.280order to preserve their reputation. And it's disturbing that that is still a cultural thing.
00:30:59.580I have a friend who is an obstetrician and she treats a lot of newcomers, like people not from0.97
00:31:06.760North America, just in her practice. And she has been asked more than once to write a certificate
00:31:11.960of virginity for one of her patients. And she said, that is not a thing I can do.
00:31:20.720No, absolutely not. That's amazing. Some of the historical things are far less dramatic. So
00:31:28.200there's all sorts of remedies for astringence, things that will tighten you in some way.
00:31:34.000But then the problem with that is they're also associated with sex workers. So sex workers
00:31:39.540trying to simulate it's the first time by using some sort of constrictive medicine on those parts
00:31:47.720of the body. So that gets tricky, too, because it sort of equates virginity with sex work, and that's
00:31:55.220rather odd. And just sort of putting a small amount of blood into you, animal blood, a small
00:32:03.440pouch of animal blood, which will then break, it's very bizarre that we're so obsessed with
00:32:08.840that historically and yes the fact we're still worrying about it is even more bizarre yeah of
00:32:14.820all the the chapters in your book like this is this is a thing that we don't even know if it
00:32:19.100exists you know the breast exists clitoris exists womb exists but this whole chapter is just kind
00:32:24.740of it's all cultural like it's all cultural yeah i think that's right i mean don't of course don't
00:32:29.600forget that sometimes people said the clitoris didn't exist so there was yeah there was a 16th
00:32:34.660century line that said it's not real it's just a sort of freak of nature if you have one don't
00:32:40.480worry about it you know it's just weird but just that most women don't so to say it's not even a
00:32:46.220normal part of the body but then with the clitoris it's not but with the hymen supposedly it is but
00:32:51.580actually it clearly isn't so yeah that the there's an interesting link there between the two parts
00:32:57.780and then the final part that you look at in your book is the womb yeah so wombs is what i knew
00:33:04.600most about before I started writing the book. But I still found out things I didn't know when
00:33:09.400I was reading about this. There's a theme throughout the book on religion and how
00:33:14.420religion works with medicine. By religion, I'm mostly meaning Christianity here, though not
00:33:18.880exclusively. Medicine and religion have worked together through Western culture to argue for
00:33:24.120what a woman's body should and shouldn't be like. So some of the Virgin Mary stuff in the womb1.00
00:33:29.440chapter I found very surprising. So is Mary just a container? Is her womb just a sort of bag
00:33:37.940into which Jesus is placed? Because she doesn't have sex, there are representations of her0.94
00:33:45.420conceiving through the ear, so literally through the ear, or is that just a metaphor for hearing
00:33:51.980the word of God and obeying it? Very unclear. And there are even things where she sort of,
00:33:57.400she looks, she sees, and she somehow conceives through the eyes. Completely weird to us.
00:34:04.760But then when she's got Jesus in her womb, does he then somehow transmit his holy qualities to
00:34:13.220her body? Or is she chosen because she's specially holy? And then somehow, even though her body isn't
00:34:20.380contributing because he's being put in her womb, she's somehow contributing morally? But then I
00:34:27.120gets worse and worse. So the big thing here for me is because Mary's blood makes milk,
00:34:33.320that sort of basic ancient Greek how bodies work that went on for many, many centuries,
00:34:38.360your menstrual blood becomes your breast milk. It gets diverted and it's the same fluid. It just
00:34:43.960moves to a different place. So Mary's body, her menstrual blood somehow is becoming milk.
00:34:51.760lots of representations historically of Jesus being fed with her milk
00:34:56.040so the milk jutting out at him, it's back to the breast chapter
00:34:59.300milk actually coming out of her breasts into his mouth
00:35:02.580and then Jesus' death, Jesus' shedding of blood0.94
00:35:07.940is what is supposed to put us right with God
00:35:10.480and we take that blood in the Eucharist, in the Holy Communion
00:35:16.040the bread and the wine, the wine somehow becomes his blood
00:35:20.460So that's Mary's blood, isn't it? It's Mary's blood that became milk, that went into Jesus, that came out of Jesus' blood, that the believer then takes.
00:35:31.160Now, that to me was a mind-blowing moment, and I'm still having my mind blown by it.
00:35:37.760It's saying something very different about Mary and making her very, very important, not just a container.0.99
00:35:45.660But it's the typical problem with looking at female bodies, isn't it?
00:35:50.460At what point do you say, do you value them and say, this is really important, this fluid, this body part is critical?
00:35:56.400At what point do you say, well, actually, it doesn't really matter.0.65
00:36:57.520Because there are people, again, this is back to what you were saying
00:36:59.920about the binary and how the binary just doesn't work.
00:37:03.400In the binary, you argue that women have wombs, men don't.
00:37:07.300But if you find real bodies, and this was something that became apparent really in the 19th century when post-mortems were carried out more, you will sometimes find someone who appears to be female on the outside, breasts, female bone structure and so on.
00:37:28.580Do you say, well, that wasn't a woman at all?
00:37:30.780Or do you say, well, actually, it's how you present?
00:37:34.400That's how she lived, so she's a woman.
00:37:36.120what do you do and the womb used to be the big thing that made it absolutely definitive
00:37:42.180that you were a woman now not only um are alternatives to wombs happening so um the idea
00:37:52.080of actually having a system whereby women can produce a baby and then it's brought up outside0.77
00:37:59.980the baby outside the body even when they're really really tiny that is another possibility0.95
00:38:04.800but also if you don't have a womb and you have everything else that we think of as female
00:38:12.540you can still be a woman and if that's the case with people in terms of how they're born they're
00:38:18.440born without a womb why can't we say you can be defined as female if you were assigned male at
00:38:25.700birth why not well i think that's that's what i finished reading your book and i was just like
00:38:30.640well, I don't know what anything means anymore. What is, what is fact? What is truth? It's such
00:38:35.980an eyeopening book. Um, and I think just you, the number of examples you have exactly like that of
00:38:41.360just, does anatomy equate to sex or to gender? And it can't because there's so much differentiation
00:38:49.060and often you don't know until someone dies and you do a post-mortem and you're like, oh,
00:38:52.240that's what was inside them. Okay. Like how do people, I think it's such an important book,
00:38:57.460especially with all these conversations going on right now in the UK and in the US
00:39:01.360about gender and the binary like you bring countless examples of why it can't be a binary
00:39:09.780it's not it never has been exactly it's that point it never has been that this is not new
00:39:16.020we tend to think the discussions we have at the moment about gender and sex are somehow a dreadful
00:39:21.000new thing that's just come and before everything was really simple people knew what they were
00:39:25.140They didn't. Not only do we know that people lived as the sex they weren't born as, so they chose to dress and to live in a sex other than the one they were assigned at birth, but also we know that bodies didn't match and they didn't match the outside to the inside.
00:39:42.400And so for my book, which is going from the outside to the inside, it's kind of relevant to say, well, actually, outsides and insides can simply not match.
00:39:52.640Fact. You know, this is fact. This is not some gender critical, weird thing that's happening now.
00:39:58.800This is actually how bodies are. They don't fit.0.77
00:40:02.260These things like when I talk about the size that a penis has to be at birth in order to0.99
00:40:08.660be defined as a penis and to make you into a boy, I find that quite extraordinary that0.97
00:40:13.0201.7 centimetres is the current number that makes you one side or the other of the binary.0.98