Vulgar History - March 27, 2024


Latin American Nightmare Woman, La Quintrala

Topics
Margaret of Scotland Saved A Book And Became A Saint The First Female Egyptian Pharaoh, Hatshepsut

Episode Stats


Harmful content

Misogyny

144

sentences flagged

Toxicity

37

sentences flagged

Hate speech

141

sentences flagged


Transcript

Transcript generated with Whisper (turbo).
Misogyny classifications generated with MilaNLProc/bert-base-uncased-ear-misogyny .
Toxicity classifications generated with s-nlp/roberta_toxicity_classifier .
Hate speech classifications generated with facebook/roberta-hate-speech-dynabench-r4-target .
Topics generated with Qwen2.5-3B-Instruct.
00:00:00.000 hello and welcome to vulgar history a feminist women's history comedy podcast
00:00:14.860 my name is ann foster and this week we are talking about la quintralla who that is how
00:00:21.160 she's known that's kind of the name the name by which she's best known in chile for that is where
00:00:27.340 this story takes place. Her real name is Catalina de los Rios y Liesberger. And how did she become
00:00:34.860 La Quintrala is what we're going to talk about in this episode. It's kind of like there's the
00:00:40.180 real person who lived, and then there's the monster, La Quintrala. And that is what her
00:00:47.000 real story is maybe somewhere in the middle of those two things. And so this is a listener
00:00:51.680 suggestion. Javi is the name of the person who suggested this. I believe Javi is a listener
00:00:56.600 they're from chile and a while back i had said on the podcast i really was hoping to find some more
00:01:03.100 suggestions of people from south america from central america from the western hemisphere it's
00:01:09.600 i haven't talked about a lot of them on the show and i'm really eager to learn about them and find
00:01:12.960 people who could be suitable for vulgar history episode and so javi sent me information about
00:01:18.200 la quinchalla i was like oh man this sounds so interesting and just from what i was first finding
00:01:22.220 The vibes I was getting were really Elizabeth Bathory coded, where it's like, this was this
00:01:28.160 woman and she killed thousands of people and isn't this terrible, but there was kind of like not a
00:01:34.140 lot of evidence that that is what a real person who actually lived in the world did. And so I was
00:01:41.120 poking around a bit more, hoping to find a bit more information. And what I found was a paper
00:01:45.620 from 2019 from a journal called History Compass, and the author is Maria Marsili. And so I looked
00:01:52.780 up to see Maria and if she would be someone who'd be interested in coming on the show,
00:01:56.880 and she was very enthusiastic about it. So Maria is an associate professor in the history department
00:02:01.620 at John Carroll University in Ohio, and she grew up in Chile, and she's always had an interest in
00:02:07.660 La Quintralla. We talk about in this episode how she remembers hearing about it as a child and
00:02:12.640 kind of what how what her journey has been like if anyone knows about the real person and also
00:02:18.380 the monster it's really Maria so I was so happy that she came to to join me on the podcast to
00:02:24.380 help explain the story kind of the myth and the legend and the real person and just to situate
00:02:30.580 this in the context of other episodes we've done on the podcast so Catalina aka La Quintralla she
00:02:37.580 was born in 1604 in Chile. And so that's about a hundred years after Malinzin, a.k.a. La Malinche,
00:02:45.740 was born in what is now Mexico. So this is when Catalina La Quinchala was born. This is about
00:02:54.020 a hundred years into Spanish people colonizing South America region. So that's the colony has 0.92
00:03:04.320 been there for a while. It's got its own identity as we're going to talk about. This is also around
00:03:09.740 the same time. So La Quintralla, born in 1604. Catalina de Arauso, who we did a podcast on a 0.65
00:03:16.220 while back, who was a Spanish person who came over to kind of terrorize around where did Catalina go? 1.00
00:03:25.580 Peru. And anyway, so Catalina was kind of in this colonial era as well. So if you remember that it 0.65
00:03:32.600 was a bit of a, the closest thing I can think of to compare it to is like the American Wild West.
00:03:39.100 It's just kind of these colonies were just doing their own thing, not necessarily representing
00:03:44.380 Spain, which is what they had been founded to do, but really just kind of enriching the wealthy
00:03:50.480 elites, subjugating the local indigenous people. And that's kind of the world that La Quintralla 0.99
00:03:56.720 came from. So I was so delighted to have Maria come on to help explain the story that she's
00:04:03.380 so knowledgeable about and so passionate about. So please enjoy this discussion with Maria Marsili.
00:04:13.980 So I'm so happy today to be joined by Maria Marsili, who is here to talk about
00:04:19.620 one of her main, a person you said that is one of your fascinations. So I'm happy to have you
00:04:25.320 here welcome maria thank you thank you and for the invitation i really appreciate this and i
00:04:31.560 really appreciate the opportunity to talk about this this topic of my research so first of all
00:04:38.940 can we can you set the scene for everybody we're talking about so it's chile it's the
00:04:45.320 the early 1600s is when she was born and so what was the situation there how long had it been
00:04:51.620 colonized who had colonized it what was going on yeah let me let me try to dissect the question
00:04:59.500 into two areas so one is the the actual facts the historical facts which are very much said
00:05:07.040 in chile 17th century the complement to that situation is chile 19th century which is when
00:05:17.420 And the father of Chilean historiography, a guy named Benjamín Vicuña-Maquena, created the icon for Chilean audiences.
00:05:26.860 So there are two separate, yet intertwined situations that we need to figure out in order to see how the icon of the monster was created.
00:05:39.460 Exactly. That's how I wanted to talk about it.
00:05:41.300 There's who is the person and then who is the monster?
00:05:45.340 What's the myth and what is, what do we actually know?
00:05:48.220 Yeah.
00:05:48.700 Correct.
00:05:49.100 And if we do have time, we might, I would like also to touch on the role of monstrosity.
00:05:56.840 Why monsters are important and what specific elements of the political agenda in 19th century Chile,
00:06:04.880 these monsters serve.
00:06:07.000 So let us start with the colonial situation first.
00:06:09.420 So the historical person who is going to give the basis to the monster, we know who she was. 0.73
00:06:17.540 Her name was Doña Catalina de los Rios Felisberger.
00:06:21.720 She lived between 1605 and 1665 in central Chile.
00:06:27.360 And she was a wealthy lady of the Chilean colonial elite.
00:06:32.880 She was part of a very extended clan in the colony,
00:06:39.000 which was the Lisberger clan,
00:06:41.560 which was a family clan that had German origins,
00:06:44.760 and that's part of why this topic is so interesting.
00:06:50.500 Something that we need to keep in mind here is that at this time,
00:06:54.400 well, industrial societies,
00:06:57.600 people go through life in their family clans.
00:07:00.660 So what mattered, your center of affiliation was your clan, your extended family.
00:07:07.040 Not so much the local government, the national government, or even the king, which was a distant figure in this remote colony.
00:07:17.220 What mattered in the life of individuals was who your father was, who your uncle was, who your mother was,
00:07:24.760 and what kind of connections could your family, extended family, build in order to ensure that you survive in this situation.
00:07:33.700 So you go through life being the daughter of, the husband of, the wife of.
00:07:40.700 And what matters is what can you do in order to make sure that your clan, as a clan, as an extended family, survives.
00:07:48.060 So that's the sort of social environment.
00:07:51.300 As per the economic environment, we are talking about a remote Chile, central Chile, in the 17th century,
00:07:58.780 which is a remote province of the Spanish Empire that is a war, constant war against the natives. 0.80
00:08:08.240 This is the ultimate frontier of Dubai, right?
00:08:12.500 So there is a little bit south of Santiago, it's war territory.
00:08:19.260 And this territory is controlled by the natives who, for lack of a term, many ways to call them,
00:08:27.040 but for lack of a better name, we can give them the collective noun of Mapuches.
00:08:33.620 So the Mapuches are in control of pretty much southern Chile.
00:08:36.680 And this tiny colony is trying to survive with assistance from the central government, from the king in Spain.
00:08:45.640 But in constant war against these natives who resist colonization, resist Christianization, evangelization, you name it. 0.94
00:08:55.160 These natives epitomize everything that is, quote-unquote, pagan, everything that is bad, everything that is backward, and they oppose the expansion of the bad. 0.88
00:09:06.680 So in this situation of constant war, we have in the cities or the main city in the colony, which is Santiago, where Doña Catalina lived, we have the creation of an elite that builds its identity on the situation of war. 0.93
00:09:26.540 how good you are in advancing the interests of the Spanish Empire,
00:09:31.100 how many natives have you killed,
00:09:34.320 and how loyal you are to the cause of the empire.
00:09:41.080 So in this situation, this kind of society does not recognize itself 1.00
00:09:48.460 because it's not in their best interest as a mixed-race society. 1.00
00:09:53.540 It is you are Hispanic, Catholic, white, Christian, loyal subject to the king, or at least this is what you say, or you are native, bad, pagan, backward, savage. 0.98
00:10:06.760 So in that dichotomy, that dichotomy is what we need to use to understand Chilean society at the time and the milieu in which Doña Catalina, the real Doña Catalina lived. 0.94
00:10:20.460 This is also a very, in modern terms, we would call it a corrupt society.
00:10:27.840 The royal administration, particularly in these remote locations, was subject to all forms of engaging in all kinds of corruption.
00:10:38.160 So all kinds of favors and agreements that were not part of the duties, of the administrative duties of these authorities, were the norm.
00:10:47.020 and all these clans competed
00:10:49.620 to get a
00:10:51.760 favorable treatment in the eyes
00:10:54.320 of these administrators
00:10:55.560 and the Lisberger family
00:10:57.680 of which Doña Catalina was a member
00:11:00.300 was no exception
00:11:01.760 so everybody was, all families
00:11:03.920 all extended families are doing exactly the same
00:11:06.360 as her family
00:11:08.500 is doing and what she is doing
00:11:10.220 as part of this
00:11:11.760 competitive landscape
00:11:13.820 so I guess
00:11:16.160 that depicts the kind of situation in colonial Chile in the 17th century.
00:11:23.340 Something that is important, I believe,
00:11:25.500 and I'm trying to emphasize it in my own research,
00:11:28.580 is that in this kind of society,
00:11:31.140 and other historians have said it better than me,
00:11:34.840 in this kind of society,
00:11:37.980 race mixing, although race mixing is happening,
00:11:42.060 And historians do agree that race mixing happened since day one, since the first Europeans arrived.
00:11:48.420 Race mixing is, however, not recognized.
00:11:52.180 Again, because of the situation at war, you are either a native, a pagan, a bad person, or a Catholic, European, quite good person.
00:12:02.280 But the in-betweenness of race mixing is not recognized.
00:12:08.420 It's not something that people want to talk about or even see.
00:12:13.960 So I guess that describes the situation in colonial times.
00:12:17.760 Let us quickly move to mid of the 19th century, which is when the monster, the icon of the monster is created.
00:12:25.920 And we know exactly who created it.
00:12:28.320 This Benjamin Vicuña McKenna, who is recognized and celebrated as the founding father of Chilean historiography, he created the monster.
00:12:37.020 and the process by which he created the monster
00:12:40.060 is also fascinating
00:12:41.260 so he presented
00:12:43.900 Doña Catalina
00:12:45.760 as
00:12:47.040 La Gintrada right away
00:12:49.520 in
00:12:50.500 1877
00:12:52.780 specifically
00:12:54.040 and he was a very prolific
00:12:57.180 historian, journalist
00:12:59.620 novelist
00:13:00.940 he wrote amazingly
00:13:03.700 well
00:13:04.100 so
00:13:05.280 in the 19th century
00:13:09.340 these newly independent countries
00:13:11.040 are trying to create an identity
00:13:13.160 for themselves, a national identity
00:13:15.100 and in the process
00:13:17.420 and this is also a fascinating
00:13:19.600 topic, in the process
00:13:20.840 of doing so
00:13:22.460 the written word
00:13:24.840 is fundamental
00:13:26.220 so intellectuals writing
00:13:28.500 intellectuals creating
00:13:30.260 stories
00:13:31.500 that would serve as a sort of
00:13:35.280 platform in which everybody can identify themselves, in this case, as Chileans, is
00:13:40.680 fundamental. So this is exactly what Vicuña Machina is doing. He is feeding his audience
00:13:46.840 with stories that are somehow grounded in coloniality, but serve as an instrument of
00:13:53.340 education of these newly independent citizens, particularly male citizens, because those
00:14:02.220 are the men are those who run the government, right? 1.00
00:14:05.940 So he creates this monster, this monstrous woman, 0.99
00:14:11.340 and he's very open. 0.93
00:14:13.740 He starts the narrative.
00:14:16.120 He introduces first the monster of La Quintralla
00:14:19.840 to Chilean audiences in a very specific way,
00:14:24.140 which is, I think the word in English is foliatin.
00:14:27.760 is the kind of serialized stories that appear in newspapers.
00:14:33.260 So not the news itself, but the appendix
00:14:36.460 that are sort of mini stories like soap operas of the time
00:14:41.980 that are included in each day of the newspaper.
00:14:46.360 Sorry, there's something happening on your screen.
00:14:50.100 It's, okay, listeners, we were being haunted by La Quintralla.
00:14:55.820 But now we're back.
00:14:57.020 So you were talking about in the historian, the historian and the creation of the Chilean national identity, which somehow involved inventing this monster narrative.
00:15:09.740 He, I will say, Benjamín Vicuña McKenna introduced the monster via a very specific tool of mass media communication, which was a newspaper to begin with.
00:15:23.620 But within the newspaper, the section called Foyetín, which is a serialized narrative, you know, included at the end of each edition.
00:15:33.020 And this idea is important because this kind of serialized, serial deliveries added to the newspaper, they have a very specific targeted audience, which is first of all women and second, young readers.
00:15:51.960 So young, inexperienced readers, and women who are inexperienced readers by definitions in the 19th century, would be the main readers of this first delivery of the monster.
00:16:07.380 And Lakintralla is an immediate success.
00:16:11.220 And people keep asking more details about this monster to the author.
00:16:17.620 So the author, at the end of the same year, at the end of 1877, he puts out a book.
00:16:25.780 And if you notice the switch to the audience, books are the kind of readings that educated men would engage.
00:16:36.020 So he switches from uneducated audiences who love it to educated audiences, men, which is fascinating in itself.
00:16:46.360 So he publishes a book with the title of Lisberger and Plakindrala, which is basically a genealogy of the Lisberger clan that depicts the sort of Baroque environment that was 17th century Chilean society.
00:17:06.080 The Leisberger clan was, they were well known at the time or later on, this clan, you said that the family was so important and this was one of the prominent families.
00:17:16.320 Yes, it was one of the most prominent families in the colonial society.
00:17:22.580 And Vicuña McKenna being a member of the Chilean elite in the 19th century, somehow connected by her voice to these stories.
00:17:33.980 He knew about this. So he is in his in his narrative. He basically says openly that it's very basically that his depiction of the monster is basically based on hearsay, fault tales and stories that he heard as a child.
00:17:52.460 He's very open about that.
00:17:54.060 Yet he engages, because he's talking to an educated audience now in the book,
00:17:59.860 he engages the best he can, archival documentation to demonstrate
00:18:04.240 all the evil activities of Doña Catalina, a.k.a. La Quintrada.
00:18:10.980 So he's saying that these are stories, so he'd heard the stories before.
00:18:14.860 He wasn't inventing them.
00:18:16.260 He was just sharing a story that already invented, that existed.
00:18:20.180 Yeah, but because his audience is an educated audience now, he needs to somehow put some validity in the form of documentation.
00:18:32.440 And he's very explicit about this as well. The guy was a masterful writer. He's very explicit about that.
00:18:39.560 He says, you know what, I know I should be showing to you documentation about all the crimes committed by this woman. 1.00
00:18:47.340 But there is no documentation. Guess why? Because her clan was so connected to the high spheres of the law in the colony that they covered up all her crimes. 1.00
00:19:03.420 So the notion of corruption of the judicial colonial system
00:19:07.780 comes very prominently in Vikunyamakena's writing. 0.93
00:19:12.080 So he says basically, yeah, believe me, she committed all these crimes,
00:19:15.780 but I cannot show you documentation because all these crimes were covered up 0.94
00:19:20.820 by the judges who were basically bought by the Lisberger clan,
00:19:27.480 which is a very convenient way for historians to say, yeah, believe me, believe me,
00:19:31.740 There should be documentation, but there is none because of the corruption of the system.
00:19:36.800 The truth was that the system was corrupt.
00:19:40.860 The colonial administration in Chile was extremely corrupt.
00:19:46.080 And there is a historian who makes a very good point about this.
00:19:51.020 It's the notion of co-optation.
00:19:53.160 The colony of Chile, during colonial times, was very well known for exercising the process of co-optation of authorities coming from Spain to rule the colony.
00:20:07.980 And there were, I mean, new administrators coming to the colony were warned very explicitly about how keenly this local elite is going to try to get you to be part of their business.
00:20:27.680 So this summer, for instance, I was doing my own research, trying to find some form of documentation about all the alleged crimes that Vicuña Maquina said Doña Catalina committed.
00:20:41.060 And I found instead a lot of crimes committed by the clan, by the Lisperger clan, of which Doña Catalina was an active member, a prominent member.
00:20:51.720 And the crimes, all the crimes that this family committed were very much geared towards co-optation of the local authorities, the administrators sent by the count.
00:21:05.220 So we can talk about that, or we can go into the alleged crimes of Lagintralla.
00:21:13.320 I think what would be good for the listeners right now is to explain the monster,
00:21:19.780 to explain what the crimes are this is where when I first started just doing a little bit of reading
00:21:26.760 about her the everything you just said about how there's no proof seemed so confusing to me because
00:21:33.840 I was reading she did this she did this she did this but there's no actual she was never put taken
00:21:40.920 to prison for any of these things so I thought well did she do these things I love that you're
00:21:46.780 Like even today, you're trying to find evidence and it's hard to find.
00:21:50.960 So yes, explain the monster.
00:21:53.320 And also, I guess both just how little children hear the story probably still today.
00:22:00.560 Like what is the story that people know?
00:22:02.820 Okay, so today La Quintralla is this kind of an evil ghost that is kind of the boogeyman.
00:22:10.780 I was born and raised in Chile, so I was threatening myself with Lagintralla. 0.99
00:22:16.920 So Maria, if you don't eat your veggies, Lagintralla is going to come after you 1.00
00:22:20.520 because she is the encapsulation of all the kind of punishment 1.00
00:22:25.520 that you can receive if you commit a transgression.
00:22:29.620 And the notion of transgression is kind of very neat in this whole story as well. 0.98
00:22:36.600 So, like in Trala, it's the kind of encapsulation of all that can be wrong with a woman. 0.93
00:22:44.620 So, it's an encapsulation of sexual transgression, proclivity to commit violent acts, greed. 0.99
00:22:53.620 Greed because it's supposedly this woman did commit all these crimes just out of pure the fact that she was back to the ball.
00:23:04.880 I think I started my piece with the story of a middle-aged architect in Chile who, in 2014, I want to say, was found guilty of paying a sicario to kill somebody, her ex, her former husband.
00:23:23.680 And she was arrested and put the trial, found guilty.
00:23:27.480 And right away, Chilean newspapers nicknamed her La Guintrana.
00:23:31.300 so it's the bad woman who commits violent crimes and that do the best that's the best to get away 0.87
00:23:40.480 with it so the notion of impunity committing crimes because you're bad because you're greedy
00:23:45.820 because you're sexually unrestrained and try to and do the best to try to get away with it
00:23:51.540 it's also part of it's an important component of the monster i personally think that the notion
00:23:58.540 of impunity runs very deep in the collective imagination of Chilean society, even today.
00:24:05.760 The notion that somebody can be bad, bad, bad, commit horrible things and yet get away
00:24:10.780 with it is, I'm thinking about Pinochet's dictatorship, for instance, it's very prominent
00:24:17.540 into the collective imagination of what can happen in Chile.
00:24:22.940 And like Intrala fits into that profile to the team.
00:24:25.640 And so on top of that, she is also the ghost of La Quintralla is supposed to be one of the many manifestations of the devil itself.
00:24:38.400 And so practitioners of black magic, for instance, to use the ghost of La Quintralla to give power to the rituals that they are performing.
00:24:47.460 So it's kind of an omnipresent presence in Chilean pop culture, popular culture today.
00:24:57.760 That is the today, the monster, the ghost today.
00:25:02.180 In Vicuña McKenna's narrative, the crimes that Doña Catalina committed, but of which there are no proof,
00:25:11.340 documental proof, were severed.
00:25:13.620 So according to him, let me see, I have the list of the bad things that she probably, that she was said to have done.
00:25:20.800 She poisoned her father when she was a teenager.
00:25:27.640 And the reason why she poisoned her father, Cedicuna McKenna, it was because she was reaching teenage years. 0.99
00:25:34.540 Her hormones were running wild and her father wanted to sexually constrain her. 0.94
00:25:40.940 And so in response, she killed the father. 0.81
00:25:44.760 After that, she goes on to have many, many, many, many lovers. 1.00
00:25:50.060 And so she basically sleeps with whichever man she wants to sleep with and gets away with it because she kills them after having sex with her. 1.00
00:26:01.580 So as a way to protect her reputation, she basically kills all her lovers. 1.00
00:26:07.160 Another crime that she committed was, and it's probably the only transgression that so far I found documentation for. And according to Viguita Makena, she killed by torture hundreds of her workers in her landed estate. 1.00
00:26:28.120 Can we talk about, so the workers, so like enslaved people, are these Africans or are these... 0.99
00:26:35.120 There are Mapuches. So there are Mapuches who live in this European control area of the colony, but they're also African slaves. 0.94
00:26:50.820 So that's the workforce that the landed elite has at its disposal in Chile. 0.88
00:26:57.600 And Doña Catalina had a number of workers as well. 1.00
00:27:01.800 So, according to Vicuña McKenna, she tortured.
00:27:07.700 The notion of killing by torture is also a component in Chilean imagination, by the way. 0.90
00:27:15.440 So, according to Vicuña McKenna, because of her own sadism, she killed them by torturing them endlessly.
00:27:27.940 And she killed many, many, many, many, according to Vicuña McKenna. 0.84
00:27:31.800 And she got, of course, that was against the law, but she was brought to trial, but she got away with it because of all the influences of the Lisperger clan.
00:27:44.880 So this actually did occur? She did?
00:27:47.820 That's a good question.
00:27:49.620 Okay, we'll get to that. Yeah.
00:27:51.660 The other crime, of course, was a spiritual crime. Oh, that's my God, I'm sorry. 0.67
00:27:57.180 The only one, the other crime was a spiritual transgression in which she, of course, was a witch. 0.76
00:28:04.940 And she had, she practiced, she combined in her practice the historian.
00:28:12.220 And this is kind of interesting, native witchcraft with African witchcraft.
00:28:17.820 and in that mixing also she had made a pact with the dead 0.55
00:28:24.480 which made her a very powerful witch in the colony 0.63
00:28:28.620 so she was definitely a force to fear 0.84
00:28:31.600 and I think that's the least of all the crimes that she was supposed to have committed
00:28:36.100 I have a question about just because one of the examples that I heard
00:28:40.680 I first heard of La Quintualla because a listener from Chile
00:28:46.180 suggested that this could be a good episode and it is and the story that she told me that she's 0.98
00:28:52.860 heard is that la quinchala she was torturing one of her her workers in a room where there was a 0.97
00:28:59.960 giant as you know you're nodding a statue of jesus and then she had this statue removed or
00:29:07.120 something yeah can you relate that story that that's another that's another story that's 0.95
00:29:12.440 promoted by Vicuña Machuera, she was torturing one of her workers and when in the process 0.99
00:29:22.980 she looks, she was of course, she had the appearance of being a very Catholic lady, so the appearance
00:29:30.060 of piety was important in the whole Chilean society. So she had a crucifix attached to
00:29:36.600 one of her her walls and when she was structuring this the worker she looked at the crucifix and
00:29:44.920 she saw says the story goes the story goes she sees the face of jesus right looking at her um
00:29:53.720 with horror but because of what she was doing so she stops punishing the worker and she turns to
00:30:01.180 the crucifix and she grabs the crucifix and throws the crucifix out of her house and she says and
00:30:09.380 this is this is very important uh get away from here talking to jesus of course and she says
00:30:16.460 because i don't want men looking at me with a weird face in my house or something like that
00:30:23.480 no quiero hombres que me miren con mala cara en mi casa
00:30:26.180 something like that
00:30:27.180 so it's a clear statement
00:30:30.460 right this is my house
00:30:32.120 I do in my house what I want
00:30:33.860 I'm the master of my own private sphere
00:30:36.340 religion has no business here
00:30:39.020 and Jesus has no business here 1.00
00:30:40.940 so I proceed to throw you away
00:30:42.940 it's a clear representation
00:30:45.960 that she has turned totally and completely
00:30:48.200 to the dark side
00:30:49.500 right
00:30:49.960 So, yeah, that's a good point.
00:30:53.840 I was forgetting the story of the crucifix.
00:30:57.300 But the story goes that the crucifix was picked up by the Augustinians,
00:31:01.560 and they put it in a church, and then there's a big earthquake that comes,
00:31:08.400 and everything is destroyed back for the world that it calls the crucifix.
00:31:12.160 So it's a clear representation that the crucifix indeed had been blessed by God,
00:31:18.100 and that
00:31:19.220 made the point even clearer that 0.95
00:31:22.260 Lachintralla was evil
00:31:23.600 because the crucifix is
00:31:26.080 protected by God in a big earthquake
00:31:28.300 and while Lachintralla had thrown
00:31:30.220 it away out of her house
00:31:31.760 so that's an important
00:31:33.700 and thanks to your
00:31:35.820 reader for making that
00:31:37.360 bringing that point up
00:31:38.880 and she mentioned that too
00:31:40.960 she said men aren't going to look 0.69
00:31:43.580 at me like that in my own house
00:31:45.720 Yeah. So it's. Yeah. So these stories, I can see why when they were serialized first, I think the readers every week would be excited to hear what new terrible thing did this person do if everything is so extreme.
00:32:03.380 Yeah, well, let me go back a little bit to the story of the workers, because that's the only direct piece of documentation so far that I found in archives that clarifies the bond.
00:32:20.400 So there was a legal investigation because not hundreds, but 40 workers had died of illness, of a plague in the landed state of Doña Catalina.
00:32:38.060 And there was an investigation because it was, of course, against the law to punish your workers or to mistreat your workers.
00:32:46.020 Although labor laws were very loosely enforced in colonial Chile.
00:32:51.640 So we're talking about 40 people who apparently died out of malnutrition or illness during that particular winter.
00:33:02.700 There was an investigation, but there was the judge following the investigation did not find any conclusive evidence that it was the personal flaw of Doña Catalina. 0.93
00:33:17.600 To which Vicuña McKenna would argue, you see, there's a whole system of corruption protecting her and her family. 0.90
00:33:27.240 So that's the reason why we don't have evidence.
00:33:29.220 so you're saying you've done these investigations to try and find evidence
00:33:35.860 one way or the other about what she did but what do we know about the real person
00:33:44.520 uh what do we know about the real person and that's another component and probably the 0.93
00:33:52.060 one of the main points in my own research what do we know about her we know that she
00:33:59.200 was a wealthy lady that she married only once and she her husband died very very early into the 0.98
00:34:10.660 marriage and she remained a widow which was kind of not the norm yeah women were supposed to marry 1.00
00:34:19.540 and stay and if the husband died they were supposed to marry again because women needed to be 0.98
00:34:25.180 under the control or the protection of a maid, right? 0.97
00:34:29.700 Contrary to that, she is a widow. 0.95
00:34:31.880 She remained a widow for a long time.
00:34:35.120 It has been said that she was a very beautiful lady
00:34:39.420 and that she, in her complexion, 0.90
00:34:46.480 it was clear that she was mixed race.
00:34:48.760 and as in having sort of native features in her face and skin,
00:34:56.100 yet have red hair, which was extremely uncommon, 0.58
00:35:01.100 extremely uncommon in the Spanish Empire in general,
00:35:04.780 and specifically in this remote colony.
00:35:08.420 So that the mixing, that talks deeply about race mixing, right?
00:35:13.360 About her condition of, and the word in Spanish is mestizo,
00:35:17.280 as somebody who has mixed heritage and she was a wealthy independent resourceful
00:35:26.300 widow who happened to be a mixed race woman and vicuña marquina is very intentional about this 0.81
00:35:36.940 he says quite open that like intrala was evil first of all because she was a woman 0.71
00:35:43.300 because she was a woman in power,
00:35:46.340 which was one of the horrors that the colonial system allowed. 1.00
00:35:50.520 The colonial system allowed women to be in power, 1.00
00:35:54.260 which was true. 1.00
00:35:55.180 Historically, we know that the Spanish Empire 1.00
00:35:57.460 allowed women to be in power, 1.00
00:35:59.540 to have power over their economic decisions, 0.99
00:36:03.680 about their domestic sphere,
00:36:05.460 and to exercise economic agency. 1.00
00:36:08.960 Women could do that, 1.00
00:36:10.680 even if they didn't have a husband. 1.00
00:36:13.300 you know, next to them. 1.00
00:36:15.980 So Nagintola is evil 1.00
00:36:17.500 because she's a woman, 1.00
00:36:18.980 because she's wealthy, 1.00
00:36:20.460 because she has power, 1.00
00:36:21.860 because she exercises agency,
00:36:24.780 because she's independent.
00:36:27.900 But most importantly, 1.00
00:36:29.460 she's evil because she's mixed race. 1.00
00:36:34.120 So it's the condition of being a mestiza 1.00
00:36:36.080 that makes her particularly bad. 1.00
00:36:39.360 that exacerbates her evilness, which is true. 0.62
00:36:47.220 She, in her clan, we have German origins on her two sides, 0.99
00:36:54.060 on her maternal and paternal side, by the way.
00:36:57.320 And we have certainly Mapuche origins,
00:37:02.160 and that's another interesting element in her.
00:37:04.460 she was the granddaughter of a cacica.
00:37:10.940 A cacica is a native chiefs in central Chile.
00:37:17.940 And we have the name of this cacica, Doña Aguida Flores,
00:37:23.380 who was the daughter of, and listen to this,
00:37:28.380 this is native elite as good as it gets.
00:37:31.260 So Doña Catalina's grandmother was the daughter of an Inca-appointed chief in the area
00:37:40.140 at the time when the first Spaniards arrived.
00:37:43.180 So this daughter of the native leader marries a German guy
00:37:50.980 who happens to be Bartolomé Blumen, who later his name to Flores.
00:37:57.980 So we have on one side already German roots, Germans mixing with natives.
00:38:05.460 On the other side of her family, we also have German, and there is the Lisberger.
00:38:11.860 That is the Lisberger element of the family.
00:38:14.980 And in that case, we're talking about Peter Lisberger, who was a page to Charles V.
00:38:23.640 So we are talking about Germans ranking very high in the colonial administration that then are sent to the frontier of the empire to, again, preserve Spanish control there. 0.73
00:38:37.720 And in the process, they get mixed with the local elite.
00:38:42.160 So in there, and of course, there is the Spanish component, also on another venue that runs in her plan.
00:38:50.280 so that combination of spanish native and german heritage says vicuña maquina is what makes it 0.91
00:38:59.560 specifically evil and because it's mestizaje right it's race mixing as good as it gets 0.58
00:39:06.620 and race mixing is something that was not supposed to happen was not meant to happen 0.56
00:39:12.260 in a colony that was constantly at war 0.96
00:39:15.840 and that put in one side the bad native
00:39:21.100 and the good Spaniard or the good European.
00:39:24.360 So the crossing, the in-betweenness 0.96
00:39:26.700 is what makes her particularly bad, particularly evil.
00:39:33.300 So is that partially when he was writing it,
00:39:36.340 McKenna, sort of these were things
00:39:40.080 that his readers would already be suspicious about so he knew that if he says it's a independent 1.00
00:39:46.760 woman mixed race he knew that the readers would think oh of course she's evil of course she has 1.00
00:39:53.920 to be bad yeah yeah because it's this because they mixed race in chile even today i'm talking 1.00
00:40:04.760 today almost everybody is mixed race almost like in any other part of latin america almost
00:40:11.380 everybody's mixed race but chileans i would presume because of the situation of war that
00:40:21.720 marks so deeply colonial times in chile in chilean society there is the idea that chileans are
00:40:29.960 quieter than everybody else in Latin America, which is of course not true. But not only that,
00:40:36.500 but the Chilean, and there are several articles and studies in the 20th century that talk about
00:40:44.080 how the Chilean quote-unquote race is the most homogeneous race everywhere that you can possibly
00:40:52.260 find anywhere in the entire planet, which of course is an exaggeration. But the idea that
00:40:58.540 Chilean society is more European than any other society in Latin America, maybe with the exception of Argentinians.
00:41:08.740 It runs very deep into the way in which Chileans still today identify, recognize themselves to be like. 0.61
00:41:17.660 So by making this monster in the 19th century, remember the 19th century is a period when historians,
00:41:25.460 particularly historians, are sort of laying the foundations of national identities in these newly independent countries.
00:41:34.220 When a historian picks, grabs the notion of mestizaje and adds into the creation of this monster that he offers to his readers as a lesson,
00:41:45.600 because she serves as a monster to educate Pequena Maquena's audiences, they would recognize, oh yeah, mestizaje was so bad.
00:41:55.460 It never happened. It was horror, but when it did happen, look what it did to people, particularly to women, who were allowed to run without control in the colonial times.
00:42:09.120 So that is a mistake that we should not repeat in the organization of this newly independent republic.
00:42:15.400 So that is the educational angle. I think Vicuña Maquina intended to use when she adds the notion of Doña Catalina Beina Mestiza, which I find fascinating.
00:42:29.620 well and as you said there is there is so much race mixing but to say to use her as a warning 0.99
00:42:37.040 or to show this is why you shouldn't do it because your child will be a monster like she was 1.00
00:42:41.600 although i have no proof that she was a monster she was yeah that's a good point she she was
00:42:48.220 it doesn't matter in that sense when we think in those terms evidence is irrelevant right 0.98
00:42:54.380 because she is a monster for what she is and therefore as a monster she had to have committed
00:43:03.340 bad crimes because she's a monster right so it's a catch-22 so i have a list of what i think
00:43:14.540 is what vicuña mckenna wanted to um to teach his his 19th century audiences
00:43:22.060 Remember, in the book, he's addressing now males, men, educated men,
00:43:26.640 who is the political elite that is going to run the country
00:43:32.960 during the 19th century and much of the 20th century. 0.99
00:43:36.160 So this is, I would say, that this is what Vikunyamagina wanted
00:43:40.400 to instruct his audience about.
00:43:43.520 First of all, he wanted to teach them about all the bad things
00:43:50.300 or the dangers of colonial past.
00:43:54.020 Remember, these new independent countries
00:43:58.280 want to put away, put aside the colonial past.
00:44:02.780 And so all the dangers,
00:44:04.640 all the corruption of the colonial past
00:44:07.460 is something that should not be replicated
00:44:09.960 in the new governance.
00:44:12.780 They needed, in creating the monster, 1.00
00:44:15.920 Vicuña McKenna was also trying to educate women and girls of the proper way. I mean, 1.00
00:44:23.320 how a woman should behave in this new society, which is basically, among other things, to
00:44:29.560 be the mothers of the importance of women in this newly independent society. It's not 0.98
00:44:36.860 to be political agents, it's not to be economic agents, it's to have children, to be confined
00:44:43.220 to the domestic sphere, have children,
00:44:45.580 and educate those children, particularly their boys,
00:44:49.640 into the proper ways of being a citizen. 0.98
00:44:53.860 So mothers of male citizens is the kind of target 1.00
00:44:58.620 that we need to emphasize in young girls. 0.99
00:45:01.680 Another component is that in characterizing natives as evil, 1.00
00:45:07.620 because Black Interala is evil also because she was a part-native, 0.99
00:45:13.220 the interactivizing natives as evil, as backward. 0.92
00:45:18.300 Bicuña Maguena makes clear the point that in the 19th century, 0.91
00:45:22.160 what the Chilean government needs to do is basically eradicate all native people.
00:45:28.720 Remember, in the 19th century, the war against the Mapuches is still going on.
00:45:33.400 And some political scientists, and I would say that it's still going on,
00:45:38.080 write that the war of Arauco, the war against the Mapuches has not finished.
00:45:43.220 So the solution that the political leader was proposing in the 19th century,
00:45:48.800 of which Vicuña McKenna was part of, he was also a politician, 0.89
00:45:53.340 was to basically commit genocide and kill all natives 0.94
00:45:59.260 and open those lands for European immigrants. 0.97
00:46:03.380 So Chile was engaged in a policy of immigration, clear immigration. 0.55
00:46:09.120 What kind of immigrants do we want to bring to this Mapuche lands 0.86
00:46:13.420 where we need to bring white Catholic Europeans? 0.92
00:46:18.080 That was very clear. 0.95
00:46:19.400 And Vicuña Macuena was very active in that.
00:46:21.560 He openly called for the genocide, for the killing of natives.
00:46:27.240 Another element that the most served Vicuña Macuena to educate his audiences
00:46:33.600 was the negation of race mixing. 0.70
00:46:38.460 The natives are separated from the whites. 0.61
00:46:43.000 There was no race-mixing.
00:46:44.740 Chilean society is not the result of mestizaje in any shape, way, or form.
00:46:54.200 I think an important point here also is that, which is another fascinating angle,
00:47:00.880 and it's what monsters are there for.
00:47:03.260 Why do we need monsters?
00:47:04.720 I teach a class on monstrosity and students, my students get it most of the time, I think, or I would like to think.
00:47:14.180 We need monsters because monsters are constantly telling us the limits of what we are not.
00:47:24.660 And so as a society, and I'm using Cohen, of course, here, as a society, we need to have a monster.
00:47:33.660 constantly, you know, presented to us
00:47:37.180 as a reminder of what we are
00:47:40.160 because we are not like that.
00:47:43.460 So it shows the limits of social possibilities.
00:47:47.780 If you transgress,
00:47:49.640 if you surpass that limit,
00:47:53.260 you become a monster
00:47:54.660 and you are something that you should not be. 0.99
00:47:57.540 So the monster shows us
00:48:00.540 the limits of possibilities.
00:48:03.660 that a society should keep.
00:48:06.920 And that's why we need monsters so badly.
00:48:09.500 And that's why we like monsters so much, right?
00:48:12.800 And that's why Vicuña Maguena's audiences
00:48:14.640 were fascinated by this, you know,
00:48:17.460 gothic monster because this is what
00:48:19.280 La Quintralla, the icon,
00:48:22.040 was a gothic monster
00:48:23.600 who commits all sorts of crimes. 0.91
00:48:26.960 And in so doing, 0.98
00:48:28.720 the monster shows 19th century Chileans 0.80
00:48:32.040 what you should not be and what happens to you when you transgress, you trespass, 0.97
00:48:39.120 these kinds of limits of social ability, which I think is the ultimate tool of
00:48:45.180 lagging through as an icon as it was created.
00:48:48.500 That's so interesting what you said, everything you said, but we need monsters
00:48:54.260 as a cautionary tale to show if you transgress, if you go beyond, this is what
00:49:01.500 happens you become oh here's your cat not a monster very adorable so it's interesting to me
00:49:10.580 because just on this podcast I've I've been looking at women from history in all different
00:49:17.460 countries and often you do I have found a widow or a landowner who's a woman not necessarily
00:49:24.820 becomes a monster as happens with Catalina but that scene is so suspicious and so strange and
00:49:32.260 people in the time were almost frightened of a woman having this power so do you know in her
00:49:41.000 as much as you can know in her life was before she became the monster 0.99
00:49:46.580 was she uh a scandalous figure in in chile did people think right this is this is weird she 0.97
00:49:55.500 shouldn't be she should have married why is she a widow why does a widow have a landowner 1.00
00:50:00.280 correct maybe not so much in colonial society we don't know how many rich widows were around 1.00
00:50:08.920 colonial society, we need to presume that there were not that many. Maybe there were. We know 1.00
00:50:16.520 very little about women in power during colonial times, as we know very little about women in power
00:50:24.040 in pre-colonial times. So the fact that, for instance, her maternal grandmother was a very
00:50:33.080 prominent native chief on her own rights, indicates that in pre-colonial times, pre-Columbian
00:50:40.100 times in this specific region, but probably in most of Latin America today, there were 0.99
00:50:46.260 women in power.
00:50:47.860 And we know that the case for the Peruvian Viceroyalty, for instance, during the process
00:50:51.700 of the conquest itself, we know about female native chiefs who sided with Pizarro's troops.
00:50:58.720 So the option to be a woman and to have political power and to control men was open in colonial times.
00:51:07.940 We know that colonial times, excuse me, pre-Colombian times, we know that in colonial times that option was also available.
00:51:17.500 That a woman was allowed to, for instance, keep control of her own dowry according to the Spanish law.
00:51:26.040 So, for instance, if at the time when women married during colonial Spanish administration,
00:51:33.580 there was a dowry that went from the father of the woman to the bride, right?
00:51:39.500 One of the reasons for divorce, for instance, and probably the only reason for divorce,
00:51:45.060 was if as the wife realizes that the husband, who is supposed to be the one who administers the dowry,
00:51:52.760 and it's allowing the dowry to lose some value,
00:51:57.700 that's a reason for divorce 1.00
00:51:59.300 because the dowry is property of the woman. 1.00
00:52:03.100 It's administered by the husband,
00:52:05.360 but property of the woman. 0.91
00:52:07.020 And the woman is the owner of that source of wealth at all times. 0.99
00:52:11.660 So that indicates that a certain degree of economic agency 0.92
00:52:17.540 was allowed during colonial times to women. 0.60
00:52:22.760 So, under that perspective, a widow, when a woman becomes a widow, according to Spanish law, she can run her own business.
00:52:33.060 So, Doña Catalina, in that sense, being a rich widow, maybe was not so exceptional as if Cunha Maquina wanted it to appear.
00:52:43.400 It probably sounded exceptional to his readers in the 19th century because a lot had changed in Chilean society.
00:52:50.280 but maybe it was not as weird
00:52:54.020 as hard to find in colonial times
00:52:57.460 as the historian wants us to believe.
00:53:01.100 As per the decision of witchcraft
00:53:03.880 it is sort of also textbook, right?
00:53:06.960 Who are the witches? 1.00
00:53:08.460 Witches are by definition all women 0.99
00:53:11.680 that is women who have passed their reproductive life 0.98
00:53:17.140 and that's a component there of patriarchalism
00:53:20.080 working as good as it gets so when you reach a certain time in your life when you no longer can 1.00
00:53:26.300 have children you uh you sort of fall into the weird category right witches are also women who
00:53:35.300 live i'm talking about the the sort of traditional view of the witch there are women who live 0.93
00:53:41.680 in the borders of towns or in the woods let us say so therefore they don't share the social space
00:53:49.240 with everybody else and therefore they are all or they cannot only have children that we are
00:53:56.600 they live outside society they live without the control of a man therefore they have to be doing
00:54:03.320 something wrong and doña Catalina fits into that profile with the aggravation that she doesn't live
00:54:11.340 outside society she doesn't live in the borders of colonial society she lives in the center
00:54:16.360 of colonial society and her own plan is very powerful. 0.95
00:54:20.720 The Lisbethers are very powerful in colonial Chile. 0.97
00:54:24.560 So in a way, she was the perfect candidate, right? 1.00
00:54:28.220 For Vicuña Macena to pick her and turn her into the monster 0.99
00:54:32.740 that would serve to educate his audiences in the 19th century.
00:54:39.400 Do you think when he said that these were stories he heard
00:54:44.360 and now he's sharing them with other people,
00:54:46.360 do you think that's true do you think there was the legend of the monster before he wrote these
00:54:51.820 stories yeah probably I think it's the kind of stories that you tell children because
00:54:58.740 Mikunia Makena says in his the introduction to his book he's very open and he says that these
00:55:05.660 are stories that I heard from the servants in my own house when I was eating with them in the
00:55:13.660 kitchen so he's he's very open about that there was a this was a fault is circulating in chile
00:55:20.300 for a long long time that he picked and he had some historical components and he presented as
00:55:29.760 an educational tool for his audiences something that is important to keep in mind here i think
00:55:35.520 is that the story is fundamental.
00:55:40.680 When you have a good story,
00:55:42.820 you have a good story.
00:55:44.680 And you can keep your audiences captive.
00:55:47.620 And Vikunyamakena knew that
00:55:48.960 he was a magnificent writer.
00:55:51.520 And Vikunyamakena knew that.
00:55:52.860 So he had the perfect story.
00:55:54.400 The story would fascinate his readers.
00:55:59.480 So yeah, keep telling that story.
00:56:01.740 that's interesting the angle that um he said the servants that that's where he heard the story
00:56:08.940 because then there's an element of um the oral storytelling you often find in um in a lot of
00:56:17.360 north american indigenous cultures south american like societies where there's not necessarily a
00:56:24.860 written record but these oral stories and so i could see if there was a horrible a specifically
00:56:31.620 notable
00:56:33.060 wealthy person
00:56:36.660 who is mistreating their workers
00:56:39.000 those workers would
00:56:40.360 tell other workers, they would tell their children
00:56:42.880 so I can see that that's how the
00:56:44.820 story, even if she's outside
00:56:46.400 that would make sense why it's outside 0.96
00:56:48.220 of the bounds of justice
00:56:50.820 Yeah, the fact
00:56:53.080 that the story of the 0.98
00:56:54.860 monster that Begunya Makena picks
00:56:56.840 as a child 0.90
00:56:58.100 it comes from the servants
00:57:00.060 right so it comes from the popular classes in which oral communication is what matters most
00:57:08.800 culturally so in in that sense the whole story might be encapsulated as the transition from
00:57:17.500 an oral story into the written communication which is in itself also it's a fascinating
00:57:25.060 process how societies transition from communicating mostly orally into into degree into writing right
00:57:34.460 where information when you you transmit information orally people can add it's like the telephone
00:57:42.740 game you can add people can add details and but when you put it in writing the process became
00:57:50.780 more normalized you can yes certainly you can add more details to a piece of written
00:57:57.660 information but there is documentation of who's adding while in the process of orally transmitting
00:58:05.180 information you don't know who's adding you don't know who's putting extra something extra
00:58:10.780 and so the notion of ownership of information is very fast in order in societies that
00:58:18.540 that transmit information orally versus societies
00:58:22.820 that transmit information in written.
00:58:27.100 So, yeah, that's a fascinating element.
00:58:30.140 Thank you, Anjou, you gave me something to think about.
00:58:32.480 Well, and then also just from what I've been reading about this story
00:58:36.380 and the way that it's shared, there's been telenovelas.
00:58:40.120 I think there's been movies, which I would imagine, again,
00:58:44.340 the same way that this story you know was coming out in the in the newspaper just a little piece
00:58:49.980 at a time and people are so invested i can see it's such a good story like of course you'd want
00:58:56.000 to i'm sure it would be very exciting as a telenovela and they were to my knowledge they
00:59:01.460 have been two telenovelas uh on like in general maybe there is a third one i don't know i'm going
00:59:08.300 to chile in april so i'll check on that the first one that i that i know as a telenovela was during
00:59:15.040 dictatorship uh was produced and put out during dictatorship and some some um political scientists 1.00
00:59:23.120 made a point that like by pinochet dictatorship putting the story of this sadistic woman out for
00:59:31.820 mass consumption was a way to sort of distract the attention of the crimes being committed
00:59:38.500 at that specific time by the government and safely projected them into the past.
00:59:45.700 So, which is, yeah, this is a very good strategy to deviate attention, right?
00:59:51.320 And at the same time, to normalize crimes.
00:59:53.600 um the second the second story came out in the i want to say 2010 also the novela but in that
01:00:04.840 case it emphasized more the um it was a late show so it emphasized more the sexual component
01:00:12.320 of La Kindrala, 0.98
01:00:14.740 who was meant for more adult audiences.
01:00:19.440 That was done in 2010
01:00:23.120 for the Bicentennial Celebration of Independence.
01:00:27.440 And in that case, there was a historian
01:00:29.720 running the show, Kuros, finally.
01:00:33.420 And the name of the historian was Manuel Vicuña,
01:00:36.680 who's a very good, very, very good Chilean historian
01:00:39.460 who happened to be a descendant of Benjamín Vicuña Maquena.
01:00:43.680 And in that episode, Manuel Vicuña makes a very clear point
01:00:49.400 about the condition of Doña Catalina as a mestiza woman. 1.00
01:00:54.420 So, kudos.
01:00:57.020 I think in that case, the historian is putting the attention,
01:01:01.780 is placing his attention in the right areas.
01:01:04.260 But we need to add ethnicity and the mixed ethnicity of the character into the whole deconstruction of the icon first, but also to think that maybe race mixing was not that uncommon.
01:01:22.180 And we know, demographic historians do know, they have made the point that race mixing was not that uncommon at all. And it happened since day one. Yet, the Chilean colonial society refused to accept it and recognize themselves as mestizos.
01:01:44.420 and the way at the very beginning of this conversation we were describing
01:01:49.340 the the culture was so much this is the colonial the the european pathlic people and then here's
01:01:58.760 the the mapuche the incas the indigenous people were so separate that's how they how the europeans
01:02:06.820 wanted it to seem but that was never the case there was always the mixing oh yeah there are
01:02:14.140 in the case of the Peruvian Viceroyalty there are monumental works on the notion of mestizaje.
01:02:21.500 Because probably Peru, and we're jumping to Peru, but that's fine, probably because the Viceroyalty
01:02:28.380 of Peru, of which Chile was a province, was immensely rich and immensely important
01:02:35.500 geopolitically for the Spanish Empire. We have far more documentation about
01:02:43.340 this race mixing in in the case of peru and we do know and there is no reason to think that chile
01:02:50.380 was different we do know that spaniards mixed and married or not married uh very prominent incan
01:03:00.140 daughters of incan administrators uh so the alliance at the at the at the level of the leads
01:03:06.620 was a governmental policy since day one.
01:03:11.380 So there's a first generation of mixed race people 1.00
01:03:14.820 who are a novelty, right? 1.00
01:03:18.060 And among them, for instance, Inca Garcilaso de la Vega
01:03:21.240 is the prominent writer of Spanish Golden Age.
01:03:27.180 It's a fundamental, it's a novelty
01:03:30.220 because he's one of the first mestizos. 0.90
01:03:32.620 But after that first generation, 0.99
01:03:34.680 when everybody, all the Spaniards 0.99
01:03:37.560 were having children with native 1.00
01:03:39.680 ladies, mestizos 0.99
01:03:41.800 were not novelty anymore 1.00
01:03:43.580 mestizos were the norm
01:03:44.820 and in the case of Peruvian history
01:03:47.680 it has been documented very clearly
01:03:49.560 how mestizaje
01:03:50.800 was the norm
01:03:52.520 now if that happened
01:03:54.680 in the center of
01:03:57.540 Spanish administration there is no reason
01:03:59.500 not to think that it was also happening
01:04:01.660 and we know it was also happening
01:04:03.120 in the remote areas of the Peruvian bisexuality, right? 0.61
01:04:09.240 Like in the case of Chile. 0.55
01:04:11.620 What is different in the case of Chile is the situation of war.
01:04:16.240 And that makes a whole difference.
01:04:19.940 Because, as you said, war places these two parties
01:04:24.900 as completely separated from each other,
01:04:27.380 constantly cleaning each other at odds.
01:04:30.240 There is no way to solve this problem.
01:04:32.620 And as a matter of fact, the war against the Mapoches was not sorted out.
01:04:37.400 It was not solved during the 19th century and during the 20th century. 0.98
01:04:43.140 And as I said, there is reason to believe that the war still goes on against Mapoche people. 0.78
01:04:49.140 So in a society that separates these two elements, these two fundamentally different players, 0.97
01:05:00.280 it is the sort of the sitting ground to think that there is no mixing right because those two
01:05:07.060 enemies they're not mixed and they're so radically different from each other well the truth is that
01:05:15.340 race mixing and cultural exchanges and the cultural in-betweenness happens in all kinds
01:05:23.120 of situations, war included, right?
01:05:27.120 So wars are also a powerful situation
01:05:31.120 in which cultural exchanges can take place. 0.92
01:05:35.100 And biology, I mean, race mixing does 0.88
01:05:39.140 take place. We do know that. But it was 0.98
01:05:43.080 important, I would say, for colonial Chileans not to recognize it.
01:05:46.940 And for 19th century intellectuals like Bicuña Macena to negate 0.98
01:05:51.240 that openly and make of that race mixing a component of monstrosity right as though they're
01:05:58.840 saying you know race mixing it happened once and it led to this monster and that's it yeah and 0.95
01:06:07.520 that's it we should not allow it to happen because look at the one time it happened 0.99
01:06:11.840 look at what happened and yeah and on top of that she was a woman look what happened 0.97
01:06:18.200 particularly to women, to the female, right? 0.85
01:06:21.920 What was the hypocritical situation of this whole speech
01:06:26.540 is that at the same time that mestizaje
01:06:29.540 and the targeting of natives as inherently backward,
01:06:36.300 mean, bad, not able to be civilized,
01:06:40.400 is happening among intellectuals.
01:06:44.080 Some of these intellectuals, like Igunya Makena himself,
01:06:46.400 who happen to be politicians are advocating for the genocide of native people, which they
01:06:55.440 cynically call the pacification of Araucanía, which was a very well crafted campaign to 0.93
01:07:06.320 basically kill these people, kill any Mapuche that you could find, any native that you could 1.00
01:07:12.160 find sort of to open this this huge piece of the of chile to business to agrarian business 0.98
01:07:21.440 and so this is what is at the stake basically in in the political agenda of vicuña mackenna
01:07:27.760 and now we're just going to take a break for a word from our sponsors
01:07:31.840 the war is over and both sides lost kingdoms were reduced to cinders and armies scattered like
01:07:40.960 bones in the dust. Now the survivors claw to what's left of a broken world, praying the darkness
01:07:48.140 chooses someone else tonight. But in the shadow dark, the darkness always wins. This is old-school
01:07:55.500 adventuring at its most cruel. Your torch ticks down in real time, and when that flame dies,
01:08:01.660 something else rises to finish the job. This is a brutal rules-light nightmare with a story that
01:08:07.080 emerges organically based on the decisions that the characters make this is what it felt like to
01:08:12.280 play rpgs in the 80s and man it is so good to be back join the glass canon podcast as we plunge
01:08:18.140 into the shadow dark every thursday night at 8 p.m eastern on youtube.com slash the glass canon
01:08:23.380 with the podcast version dropping the next day see what everybody's talking about and join us
01:08:29.160 in the dark
01:08:30.760 Welcome
01:08:34.720 to the realms of peril
01:08:37.300 and glory
01:08:38.520 Explore the mechanically magical
01:08:41.320 vistas of Vale
01:08:42.500 The paranormal mysteries
01:08:45.440 of liminal London
01:08:46.640 And the cyberpunk
01:08:49.360 chaos of Cyborg
01:08:51.600 Be awed
01:08:53.340 by our incredible guests
01:08:54.780 from familiar shows like Oxventure
01:08:57.640 and no roles barred search realms of peril and glory to find out more
01:09:03.660 goodbye kyle did the sound of those words call to you like pavlov's dog
01:09:10.360 then you might enjoy our podcast turtle time every week you can join me riley hamilton and
01:09:15.900 my co-host amy scarlotta as we cover the most pressing bravo news and dig into the new episodes
01:09:21.400 to answer important questions like who the hell is adrian maloof in this world
01:09:25.580 Listen to Turtle Time on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts.
01:09:31.200 New episodes every Wednesday and Friday.
01:09:35.000 The world of Sonic the Hedgehog has been thrust into a not-so-dark, not-so-stormy, hard-boiled detective story that probably nobody saw coming.
01:09:47.220 Follow Sonic and the Intrepid Chaotix Detective Agency as they take on their biggest case yet.
01:09:53.480 This high-flying, action-packed adventure will take them across the world, fighting for every quill they can fight.
01:10:01.620 It's one heck of a tale.
01:10:04.280 Which is good, because this story might be the only thing that can save their lives.
01:10:11.880 Well, if that's all, I can just dispose of you.
01:10:14.880 Wait, what?
01:10:19.240 All will be revealed in...
01:10:21.880 Sonic the Hedgehog presents The Chaotix Case Files.
01:10:25.960 Listen now, wherever you get your podcasts.
01:10:28.660 The chaotix are on the case.
01:10:34.580 And we're back.
01:10:36.300 So of the information that we know about Catalina, the actual person,
01:10:42.920 I think you said she was, at one point,
01:10:46.620 charges were brought up for the death of 40 of her workers.
01:10:50.480 so that that did actually happen she was investigated for that and that's it
01:10:57.660 it was horrible certainly certainly was a horrible thing to happen but if we look at these
01:11:07.220 40 workers who who died in the hands or because of the misadministration of of that specific 0.91
01:11:15.520 If we look at these numbers in the sort of overall context of the agrarian violence that was pervasive in colonial Chile and still in modern Chile, agrarian society is extremely violent.
01:11:31.040 if we looked in which corporal punishment was the norm was allowed and there was this huge
01:11:40.720 gap between those who are in were in power i mean that is the owners of the land and those who were
01:11:46.700 not those that is the workers violence was corporal punishment violence killings were the norm
01:11:55.220 And almost everybody in the landed elite of colonial Chile did engage in this kind of activities.
01:12:03.980 Vicuña Maguena picked the case of Doña Catalina because of her profiles very nicely to his purposes.
01:12:14.900 But workers died all the time, at all times, during colonial Chile.
01:12:20.540 in the agrarian side
01:12:23.400 in the country side
01:12:25.780 of the colony
01:12:26.460 I was so happy
01:12:29.760 when I found your paper
01:12:31.880 that I read about La Kinchala
01:12:33.800 because when I started reading
01:12:35.880 about her, there's so much written about
01:12:37.800 the myth and the monster
01:12:39.840 when I found your paper
01:12:41.760 I was trying to find
01:12:42.700 anything that was actual
01:12:45.560 historical information
01:12:47.280 but it seems like
01:12:50.540 At the very beginning of our conversation, you made the distinction.
01:12:54.000 There's the Catalina, there's the woman, and then there's the monster.
01:12:57.340 And the monster, there's so much more written about.
01:13:03.600 Again, when you have a good story, you have a good story.
01:13:08.900 And Vicuña Marguena, God, he had a very good story.
01:13:13.680 That's part of his genius, I would say, as a writer.
01:13:17.220 i guess i guess to a certain extent all historians we do know that as historians right when you have
01:13:23.900 a good story you you know it because your audience wants to know more about that
01:13:29.640 so happens that most of us is modern historians we do pay attention to our sources and we do pay
01:13:38.720 attention to questioning our sources with a green or sort of that that's what we do by training
01:13:43.880 But that kind of restrictions were not part of the way in which Vicuña McKenna understood his role as historian.
01:13:53.980 In his mind, like in the minds of intellectuals at the time, history was to serve as an educational tool.
01:14:04.580 So notions from the past, stories from the past, information from the past was to serve as a way to educate.
01:14:12.080 The role of the historians, of historians, because I was very clear about that, is to educate people.
01:14:19.280 And you educate people using a good story, not using abundant information.
01:14:26.760 I don't, I was just imagining if you or anyone publishing academic papers now said, there's no evidence for this, but just trust me, it happened like he was able to do.
01:14:38.680 you would not go very fast into this profession if you do that yeah but that's so i'm also curious
01:14:45.860 to know you mentioned being told as a girl you know if you don't do this la quinchala will come
01:14:51.640 do you remember um any other examples of as a child just what you heard about la quinchala
01:14:59.520 So I grew up in the northern provinces of Chile, and the north is very native.
01:15:10.320 So there is a strong native influence in what is nowadays northern Chile.
01:15:14.460 But in this case, not Mapuche natives, but Aymara natives.
01:15:22.120 So spiritual alternative practices, for lack of a better word, are very prominent in Native societies.
01:15:32.180 And those practices borrow from Catholicism as well as from Native traditions.
01:15:37.220 So there is a mixing also there.
01:15:40.280 And I recall that, for instance, women who have a reputation of being a witch or healers would claim as a sort of publicity to their services that, yeah, yeah, I use the goals of La Quintrada to potentiate, to enhance my power.
01:16:04.200 So trust me, I'm better than everybody else, just pay for my services because I work with
01:16:10.860 like Entrada, you know, which is fascinating in itself how people of Aymara origins practicing
01:16:19.500 healing, which incorporates elements of Catholicism, at the same time are borrowing from this
01:16:27.120 collectively constructed monster surely without knowing the origins but it it i guess at that
01:16:34.660 point when you have a good story as i said it doesn't matter by what kind of information people
01:16:39.360 do not care in this case that non-specialists let's say would not care about what what are
01:16:45.900 the sources of information but i would think too just la quinchalla being the most sounds like
01:16:52.060 the most famous monster in Chilean history so of course that's and if I can harness that and I
01:17:00.100 keep it under control look at me what kind of spiritual services I'm offering right and just 0.97
01:17:06.100 the people everyone would know what you're talking about because that's the most famous 0.98
01:17:10.120 I find it so interesting that that this is the most famous monster in Chilean culture and it
01:17:18.840 is based on a real woman but there's such a such a strange path from her and who she was
01:17:26.020 McKenna like really popularizing this story and now it seems like and didn't you say part of why
01:17:31.580 he did that was Chile was developing its own independent culture and so he wanted to have
01:17:38.200 figures that everybody could unite around yeah it's called the foundational narratives
01:17:46.760 So the idea is that, well, this is the notion by Benedict Anderson.
01:17:55.480 His book came when I started grad school, which is some time ago.
01:18:00.120 And the idea that nations, modern nations, as nation states in the 19th century of after colonial period, nations are created, nations are invented.
01:18:13.040 There has to be some form of speech, of discourse that is created, that would create this notion of affiliation.
01:18:24.380 So, oh, we are Chileans because this is what we share.
01:18:28.520 We are Peruvians because this is what we share.
01:18:31.280 And, you know, you name it, multiply it around Latin America.
01:18:35.860 So the 19th century is the sort of fertile ground
01:18:40.060 for the creation, and intellectuals do that.
01:18:44.000 Intellectuals from the local bourgeoisie, by the way,
01:18:46.640 they do that, they create these stories
01:18:49.980 that would be the foundational fiction
01:18:53.440 of who Chileans are, what makes Chileans common,
01:18:59.020 what would make you recognize each other as Chileans.
01:19:03.480 And so the creation of these foundational fictions
01:19:06.220 are fundamental to create this notion of connectivity.
01:19:11.960 Think about this.
01:19:13.020 I mean, these are countries that are being created,
01:19:15.600 nation states that are being created, 0.98
01:19:19.000 putting together people very different from each other
01:19:22.200 and that were kept into those separate labels
01:19:28.020 by the colonial administration, right?
01:19:30.920 And the Spanish Empire recognized the natives and the Spaniards as separate groups, legally separated.
01:19:40.480 The Spanish administration did not recognize itself the category of mixed race, although everybody was mixed race.
01:19:46.600 so when the new countries
01:19:49.320 sort of try to
01:19:50.640 organize these newly independent
01:19:53.640 republics, they need to
01:19:55.500 they need to come up with something
01:19:57.640 with a story
01:19:58.340 that creates reality
01:20:00.980 and this is exactly
01:20:03.840 what foundational fictions like
01:20:05.460 in Tralat, they create a reality
01:20:08.020 a common past
01:20:09.100 that would serve people
01:20:11.980 to identify
01:20:13.420 themselves as part of a group
01:20:16.600 Is the main way that La Quinchalla or Catalina is remembered now is through the storytelling or is there any sort of building or memorial?
01:20:29.960 Is there any sort of place people go or is it, does she stay alive through these stories mostly?
01:20:36.080 I think it's just the stories.
01:20:37.520 i don't know about a grave or a sort of a place that can you know commemorate or this was the
01:20:46.720 this this is where the physical doña catalina can be found i i believe that there is none
01:20:53.300 so most of what we know about here is pastoral stories and which are collective creations as
01:21:01.180 well in which it's again the marvelous side of oral communication right so everybody adds something
01:21:09.860 in the compound it becomes something that we can all identify as horrible as bad as something that
01:21:18.480 we don't want to be is again it's the monster becomes the most the collectively constructed
01:21:23.460 monster that shows us the limits of who we are and what we should not become which is which is
01:21:31.140 a fascinating process in which storytelling precedes social reality that i love that whole
01:21:39.340 angle of it and i love you teach a course about monsters that sounds wonderful do you have
01:21:46.560 any other just in terms of like beginning to wrap up our discussion were there any other
01:21:52.800 things you wanted to share about the story of la kinchala i guess la kinchala the story of la
01:21:59.860 can also be placed in a larger narrative, per se,
01:22:06.100 which is something that I'm interested in studying,
01:22:11.680 is the notion, the category of those who are in between.
01:22:16.920 In societies that cast each other as separate,
01:22:21.200 as composed by separate groups that are at war against them,
01:22:24.100 they're so different from each other.
01:22:25.620 Spaniards and Natives are supposedly so different from each other. 1.00
01:22:29.860 in these societies the creation of the the positioning of some individuals as in between
01:22:36.020 are a fundamental and are fascinating in itself and a fascinating topic in itself so
01:22:41.860 from the her position of being in between being a woman who clearly shares some cultural traits
01:22:48.580 with natives with Spaniards and with Germans in that in that situation like Intrala can be placed
01:22:55.380 into the context of those agents of go-betweenness in colonial society,
01:23:04.820 in the situation of colonialities.
01:23:06.660 And from that viewpoint, for instance, an interesting reflection can be elicited
01:23:14.500 where we place like in Trala, vis-a-vis, for instance, with Lama Lynch,
01:23:18.740 in the case of the Mexican, or in the case of the United States,
01:23:23.140 with the case of Sagayawea, right? 1.00
01:23:27.160 So those women who can navigate to different cultures 1.00
01:23:31.240 and act as translators. 1.00
01:23:33.800 But like Doña Catarina was not a translator, right? 0.99
01:23:37.020 But these other women were. 0.91
01:23:39.100 And in that sense, also we can add men
01:23:41.140 into the, as agents of in-betweenness, right?
01:23:44.760 I'm thinking about, for instance,
01:23:46.640 in the case of Yucatan, Gonzalo Guerrero,
01:23:48.640 the the the spanish soldier who ended up uh becoming maya and he he rose to the rank of
01:23:57.400 mayan general and fought against the spanias so i think in the studies of cultural encounters
01:24:06.040 that are that are also that in essence the story of imperial expansion the notion that i think
01:24:15.840 there is a very important niche of research when we think about those who were neither here not there
01:24:23.040 and and what does it tell us about a personal agency what does it tell us about the possibilities
01:24:32.320 the porosity of these two cultures that allow for this kind of exchanges to take place and
01:24:37.520 be encapsulated in one single individual and why that single individual ends up being
01:24:45.840 Normally, in all these stories, this person who is in between ends up being dead, meets a bad end.
01:24:57.520 And there is a reason for that.
01:24:58.860 There is a reason for that.
01:25:00.140 Because the person who is in between is extremely dangerous for everybody else.
01:25:06.620 So we know what happened to La Malinche, for instance.
01:25:10.640 We know what happened to the case of Guerrero.
01:25:13.020 So the fact that those people who are in between are either killed, they meet a bad end, or they are monsters, it's an important component of how we should be thinking about cultural encounters in a situation of coloniality.
01:25:34.100 i guess i do just want to clarify as well that catalina the person as far as i have read she
01:25:42.940 she lived to she was not put to death she did not die tragically young she just lived sort of an
01:25:50.860 average lifespan her 60 something yeah yeah there was nothing so the monstrousness
01:25:59.580 is really about how allegedly she lived her life
01:26:04.880 and then she has this long afterlife as the monster,
01:26:08.540 but she doesn't have the same sort of tragic end
01:26:12.300 as like La Malinche, for instance.
01:26:13.920 That's a good point.
01:26:15.500 Yeah, yeah, that's true.
01:26:16.880 She dies of all age at 60-something in her own house.
01:26:22.520 So she was not punished for her crimes,
01:26:26.800 for her in-betweenness by human law.
01:26:30.300 But in Vicuña McKenna's narrative,
01:26:32.480 her soul is the one who is being punished in hell
01:26:37.600 because her soul went to hell. 0.99
01:26:40.500 And that's where she made eternal punishment.
01:26:44.580 So in the afterlife, 1.00
01:26:46.640 Vicuña McKenna makes her pay 0.94
01:26:48.720 for her alleged crimes when she was alive.
01:26:53.220 That's so interesting. 1.00
01:26:54.020 that yeah so she and that's why she is this monster she's this ghost doing scary things to 1.00
01:27:01.360 to frighten children haunting people's computers she's in hell that was her ultimate punishment
01:27:08.380 for all the crimes that she committed exactly so yeah so that really does line up with what
01:27:14.040 you're saying if you're not people like again like la malinche who we did i did do an episode
01:27:19.080 about her a bit ago but she died very young um and so that could be seen as sort of her punishment
01:27:25.540 for for being in between and then even somebody like la kinshala who lived longer she's punished
01:27:33.100 eternally in this other way this is also interesting i had sent you a list of um
01:27:40.940 at the end of all my episodes where i profile a woman i have these categories yeah i score and
01:27:47.000 i'm very interested because this is a tricky one because the real life person we don't know a lot
01:27:52.360 about so we might be scoring partially the monster i'm not sure yeah so the first category um is how
01:28:03.340 scandalous was this person so we i think we could think about catalina herself in her life she was 0.97
01:28:11.280 put she was charged with a crime so seemingly she had some enemies and her being a widow who
01:28:19.200 didn't remarry who was a landowner on a scale of zero to ten how scandalous do you think
01:28:25.260 she was i think it's pretty low yeah i would say it's pretty low the real one the real the real 1.00
01:28:31.420 one yeah um and the reason for that is because she was not doing anything out of the norm anything
01:28:39.340 Anything that any other woman in the social situation in this kind of society would be doing for her land. 1.00
01:28:52.000 So she was also bribing authorities.
01:28:54.800 She was also litigating.
01:28:57.400 And there is some documents that I found about that.
01:28:59.420 She also has some problems with a local religious order because of borders of the landed state.
01:29:07.000 she was not doing anything else 0.67
01:29:10.560 that any other woman
01:29:13.220 in this, of her position
01:29:15.200 in this society
01:29:16.320 would have been doing 0.60
01:29:17.940 the die 0.70
01:29:21.020 the death of these workers
01:29:23.080 again, yes, it was horrible
01:29:25.600 but in the context of the violence
01:29:28.780 of the society
01:29:29.860 it was nothing
01:29:32.420 out of the norm
01:29:33.480 she was peaked
01:29:35.380 by the historians for that. 1.00
01:29:38.300 And she was probably big 1.00
01:29:39.960 because of the political power 1.00
01:29:43.500 of the colonial society.
01:29:47.380 The Lisbethers, her clan,
01:29:49.400 are very important.
01:29:50.960 And therefore, they have many enemies.
01:29:53.920 So there is some of the alleged crimes 0.70
01:29:57.460 of the Lisbethers women,
01:29:59.260 for instance, you know,
01:30:00.560 her mother and her grandmother
01:30:02.480 also have been accused
01:30:04.500 of being, of having killed men, of being witches.
01:30:09.180 So the witchcraft runs in the family, says Nicuña Maguena.
01:30:14.480 But her mother and her grandmother had also been accused
01:30:18.300 of committing crimes by political rivals of the clan.
01:30:23.740 So the sense is that in this kind of very litigious society 0.51
01:30:28.580 where competition for very reduced resources is the norm, 1.00
01:30:34.500 it's very easy.
01:30:36.020 It's easier to become women of the clan
01:30:38.580 than to go openly against the men of the clan. 1.00
01:30:42.160 Oh, that's such a good point. 0.99
01:30:44.300 I was wondering why the women would be chosen,
01:30:46.880 but you're right.
01:30:47.660 It would be maybe less dangerous
01:30:50.200 to go against the women and the men. 0.93
01:30:52.000 Of course, of course. 0.78
01:30:54.580 So in that sort of the real Doña Catalina,
01:30:58.160 I don't think she was out of the norm at all.
01:31:00.780 yeah i i would suggest on a scale of zero to ten i would give her a one and that's just because
01:31:08.700 everybody was kind of scandalous i think everyone was the same yeah yeah yeah and even things like
01:31:15.760 yeah the the death of 40 workers is a lot of people but i i kept thinking and i'm glad you
01:31:23.020 just said that about the men versus women but i'm sure group i'm sure there were men who were doing
01:31:29.360 this sort of who are treating the workers the same way and they they do not become the monsters
01:31:34.640 okay yeah because in Vikunyamakena's creation she's a monster and another historian put it 0.99
01:31:44.220 in better terms that I did in my paper but she's a monster because she's a woman with power 1.00
01:31:51.960 and therefore out of the power of men. 0.97
01:31:57.760 So, I mean, that's kind of important
01:32:00.320 in the creation of the monster. 0.97
01:32:03.500 She is so bad. 0.79
01:32:06.600 Not only because she has power, 1.00
01:32:10.580 but because she exercises that power 1.00
01:32:12.960 out of men's control. 1.00
01:32:16.300 She's not controlled by a husband. 1.00
01:32:17.860 She's not controlled by the church.
01:32:19.560 She's not controlled by the local authorities.
01:32:21.960 And that's what makes her, in Vicuña McKenna's imagination, the real monster. 0.87
01:32:26.640 That's the ultimate crime. 1.00
01:32:29.080 I think we'll just skip ahead to one of the other categories in my little scale, is sexism. 0.99
01:32:37.340 How much did sexism shape her life and her story?
01:32:41.100 And I think that's a 10 out of 10. 0.88
01:32:42.560 That's a 10 out of 10, definitely.
01:32:44.160 Yeah, absolutely. 0.98
01:32:46.140 that's um everything you just said the reason she was chosen by mckenna to be the monster 0.99
01:32:53.340 was partially because of the mixed race but largely because of she's a woman and look what 0.78
01:32:59.180 she did and the way you described her monstrosity is to show here's a woman doing all these things 0.97
01:33:04.660 and that's why women shouldn't do these things correct yeah and that shows how rotten colonial 0.85
01:33:12.100 times where right because look what the colonial administration allowed to happen this is a mistake
01:33:18.800 that we as newly independent citizens of Chile should not allow to happen the next category
01:33:27.560 so it's the scheminess was she a person with schemes and plans and again not knowing that 0.94
01:33:35.420 much about the real Catalina but it sounds like she was effective as a landowner she didn't need 1.00
01:33:40.300 to find a husband you said she had what did you say that she had these legal disputes about land 0.84
01:33:46.220 and territory so she was she wasn't passive she was active and so in terms like her schemes weren't 0.99
01:33:56.180 necessarily to to have sex with men and then kill them and then murder thousands of people but in 1.00
01:34:02.600 terms of the schemes to be an effective landowner i would give her a 10 there okay 0.99
01:34:10.200 she is effective she is effective uh as a person as an individual and also as a member of this clan
01:34:19.800 remember she she as everybody else in the society went through life as a member of a collectivity
01:34:27.120 um and her clan was extremely rich extremely powerful very successfully successful politically
01:34:34.480 speaking very successfully in co-opting uh colonial authorities and she was certainly
01:34:41.520 a part of the game she was she was a member right of of this successful group of individuals
01:34:48.260 personally I would say that she was very competent
01:34:59.600 and she had a lot of agency
01:35:01.440 but also because her clan was successful
01:35:06.080 so it's very hard
01:35:08.580 it's artificial to separate the individual
01:35:11.660 from the individual's success
01:35:14.320 from the collective success
01:35:16.300 political economic success
01:35:18.720 of her own extended family
01:35:20.640 the final category and this is
01:35:24.540 I'm also curious what you're going to say is
01:35:26.760 the significance
01:35:27.920 and
01:35:30.520 I think
01:35:32.660 the significance of La Quintralla
01:35:34.120 to Chilean culture
01:35:36.520 seems 10 out of 10
01:35:38.920 it's a 10 out of 10
01:35:40.320 if I could do more
01:35:41.740 yeah definitely
01:35:44.400 definitely it's very high there
01:35:46.300 Could not be more.
01:35:47.920 Yeah, which is also interesting that in the culture, 0.98
01:35:52.820 this figure is, it's a female figure who is monstrous,
01:35:56.300 but it seems like she's one of the most famous cultural figure.
01:36:03.740 Which says a lot about Chilean society, right?
01:36:08.740 And that's actually a question I had.
01:36:11.500 One of my listeners who's in Peru had been to Chile,
01:36:15.980 And he was impressed. And I think he said, sort of pleased to see that there was a lot of feminists, there was a lot of women being celebrated in Chilean culture and society. That was his impression. Is that something that you would also recognize?
01:36:34.620 I think the election of President Bachelet, Michelle Bachelet, twice, marked a threshold in there, as in Chileans recognizing women and following women in a position of authority.
01:36:52.740 So I think Chilean society has made a lot of advances in putting and selecting and implementing female leadership.
01:37:05.680 So, yes, I would agree with your viewer in that regard.
01:37:09.880 Also, but however, I would give credits also to Peru. 1.00
01:37:14.800 I think female leadership, questionable as it can be at times, 0.99
01:37:20.400 is also gaining grounds in Peruvian society. 0.97
01:37:24.900 Another element that we need to keep in mind 0.99
01:37:26.780 is that economic agency and leadership for women 0.87
01:37:32.360 is a variable that is culturally connected. 0.99
01:37:39.840 So in native groups, for instance,
01:37:42.920 which are, in the case of Peru,
01:37:45.720 there is a good size of Peruvian population
01:37:49.520 is of Native origins and Native communities are very important in Peru.
01:37:54.080 We do know that Native women do exercise more agency
01:38:00.000 than we are bound to recognize from an outside perspective. 0.99
01:38:06.120 That Native women do run businesses, 1.00
01:38:09.840 they make their political agents in their communities,
01:38:13.040 and that is something that also we need to keep in mind. 0.78
01:38:15.740 uh women uh in in Mapuche in Mapuche societies women do have a leadership it's it's it's not
01:38:26.400 out of the norm to see a woman in a position of leadership this all is somebody I'm in Canada
01:38:33.080 so learning anything about Chilean history Peruvian history it's all it's nothing I was
01:38:38.560 ever taught in school this is all brand new to me and I really appreciate hearing this sort of
01:38:45.000 background about the development of the society and even as the indigenous people have been
01:38:52.300 the victims of ongoing the wars and the the genocide there's still
01:38:59.500 this influence of the the women you know perhaps that's part of why in Chilean or in Peruvian 0.90
01:39:06.720 society there is that influence because you said like the race mixing and the culture mixing you
01:39:12.840 can't fully separate them yeah yeah my mentor in grad school put it very nicely her name was
01:39:20.920 so she said that in colonial society in latin america basically everybody was sleeping with
01:39:28.180 everybody and when you're having children in common uh when when you have this kind of intimate
01:39:35.700 connections with somebody who is from a different culture you cannot disaggregate cultural mestizaje
01:39:44.320 from biological mestizaje it's it's impossible and i think she was right definitely right
01:39:50.840 as much as the the europeans would like to say this is what it's like everything there's a
01:39:58.060 strict division that's what they wrote that's what they recorded but what we see and through
01:40:03.580 the oral storytelling we see that's not true that's just what they wanted to say do you have
01:40:09.780 any any final thoughts about this about Catalina or La Quintralla or this discussion uh I would
01:40:19.580 my my summit as I told you I went this past summer to the dark eyes in city and thanks to
01:40:27.820 support from my institution
01:40:29.900 from John Carroll University
01:40:31.320 and one of the
01:40:33.940 things that I discovered
01:40:35.720 in the archives when I was following
01:40:37.860 the Lisberger clan
01:40:39.140 was all the bad things 1.00
01:40:42.120 that many Lisbergers 1.00
01:40:44.400 were doing 1.00
01:40:45.720 the kind of crimes that 1.00
01:40:47.660 men of the Lisberger 0.99
01:40:49.680 clan
01:40:50.180 were committing
01:40:53.060 which are
01:40:54.980 pretty bad
01:40:57.200 Right, but Vicuña Machina did not pick on them for all the reasons that we are commenting.
01:41:03.700 And so, for instance, there was a case that really struck me, in which, I have it here,
01:41:09.660 one of the uncles of Catalina on the maternal side, the Lisberger, he basically, with the assistance
01:41:22.820 of the entire clan 0.94
01:41:24.220 he basically raped 0.98
01:41:26.500 the very young daughter of 0.99
01:41:28.620 the new judge
01:41:29.940 Oidor, who had been
01:41:32.640 sent to the colony of Chile
01:41:34.140 to put legal order, right
01:41:36.320 so this guy with the assistance
01:41:38.640 of everybody in the clan
01:41:40.460 basically 0.99
01:41:42.420 raped this 0.99
01:41:43.880 14 year old girl 1.00
01:41:45.580 who
01:41:47.120 from the description of the situation seems that
01:41:50.380 she had some
01:41:52.820 learning needs um at the age of 14 so this this this young girl is great but this 40 something
01:42:01.300 year old man um and he does it so as to get her pregnant so as to be forced to marry her
01:42:11.420 because this is what he wants to happen because if he marries the daughter of this prominent judge
01:42:18.300 and the person who decides on legal cases right this judge would be bound to favor any kind of
01:42:28.880 crime to overlook any kind of crime that his own plan would be committing from now on and this is
01:42:36.100 the uncle of doña catalina and doña catalina herself would have been according to the cuña
01:42:43.380 I cannot benefit from this same Oidor, sort of looking somewhere else, right, at the time
01:42:50.340 when she's accused of killing these 40 workers. 0.55
01:42:54.720 So that demonstrates that, like probably any other extended family in colonial Chile, 0.97
01:43:01.040 the Lisbethers were pretty terrible, pretty terrible people. 1.00
01:43:05.820 And so in this context of this plan of monsters, let us say, Doña Catalina, 1.00
01:43:12.500 was probably not doing anything out of the norm.
01:43:17.060 So the concepts of what is right, what is wrong,
01:43:20.660 are very culturally connected, right?
01:43:24.240 So for Vicuña Makena, all these actions are horrible
01:43:27.860 and are the clear encapsulation of why the colonial system is so bad.
01:43:32.820 But for people living in this situation, this is everyday life.
01:43:37.460 This is what everybody did.
01:43:38.960 and probably
01:43:41.180 if this guy
01:43:42.900 did not take the initiative
01:43:44.720 with this young girl
01:43:47.020 another guy of another clan
01:43:48.920 would have tried
01:43:50.200 so yeah
01:43:52.320 I guess that is something
01:43:54.900 that we need to
01:43:56.960 keep in perspective when we're
01:43:59.060 talking about bad people
01:44:00.700 using the lens
01:44:03.340 of another time to evaluate
01:44:05.300 to judge those actions
01:44:06.920 it's true if
01:44:08.440 and i've seen that i'm thinking about things like ancient egypt cleopatra things like that where if
01:44:15.320 you're not trying if you're not being trying to murder your own family member then they're going
01:44:21.920 to murder you so it's it's different to judge somebody for doing a thing when that's that's
01:44:29.280 what the culture was if you didn't do that then you would probably just be murdered 1.00
01:44:32.340 so it's in the context of that but it's just but as you said the the mixed race and the 0.99
01:44:39.160 that she was a woman that's why she out of this whole clan of monsters and every other clan
01:44:45.780 probably was monsters too she became the one as though she's the the emblem of all of these people
01:44:56.540 when really everybody was kind of terrible correct yeah thank you so much for taking
01:45:04.500 this time with me today yeah I was I'm so excited I was so excited to find your paper at first and
01:45:10.820 then I love to talk to somebody who is so interested in the in the topic I immensely
01:45:18.520 enjoy our conversation. Thank you. If you're interested in reading the paper that Maria
01:45:29.900 wrote, that is how I found her and was able to come and get her to come on the podcast. I'll put
01:45:34.520 a link to that in the show notes. It was in an academic journal called History Compass. If you're
01:45:39.600 at a university, you can probably access that, but because universities have ways to access academic
01:45:45.920 papers it's just really interesting and i was really appreciative of the work that she was
01:45:51.500 sharing that paper and that she shared on this episode as well today just about what what was
01:45:57.360 the real story of the real catalina as far as we know what was it like in chile at this time
01:46:02.420 and the monster of la quintralla and kind of how did that how did that all come to be
01:46:08.460 so thank you so much for listening to vulgar history i have a couple announcements which
01:46:15.480 is what I like to do at the end of the episode. I hope everyone, you know what? I don't. Everyone,
01:46:20.440 God bless. Do what you want to do. But if you want to listen to some announcements at the end
01:46:26.520 of the episode, that's when I do them. So if you're curious about La Quintrella and where she
01:46:32.420 scored on the Fredegund Memorial Scandalicious Scale as compared to other people who we've done
01:46:37.580 on the podcast, the full scale is actually posted on the website vulgarhistory.com. There's a thing
01:46:43.040 at the very top of that page that says scores. So you can just kind of compare where, where people
01:46:50.520 go. Actually, I'm curious because La Quintralla is there with a 31, Elizabeth Bathory 29. Just 0.73
01:46:57.920 the two stories, I'd see them relating in my mind as just kind of women who really lived and whose 0.98
01:47:04.200 stories then developed into that of a serial killer monster. And what does that have to do
01:47:10.300 with the real person who lived debatable. Anyway, if you kind of want to see just where your fave
01:47:15.500 compares, just vulgarhistory.com. And then the scores are there as well. And I want to make sure
01:47:24.300 that the things I'm saying are true for the day when this episode actually comes out for you.
01:47:29.660 So you're listening to this and it is March 27th, 2024, or whatever day you're listening to this
01:47:37.200 in the future or the past question mark anyway yeah so it's just coming towards the end of march
01:47:43.160 so we are still i'm still going to be posting an open thread to talk about the tower which is this
01:47:49.680 month's book club book vulgar history book club um it's not a i'm not going to do a book club every
01:47:55.720 month but just when there's a book i'm really passionate about that's really vulgar history
01:47:58.840 coded i'll be doing a book club and so this week we'll be having our a wrap-up discussion about
01:48:04.420 that book. If you've had a chance to read it, you can share your thoughts on Patreon or also on
01:48:09.500 Instagram. I post a post on the grid every Wednesday. Also, I think I've mentioned this
01:48:15.700 on the podcast, but I should mention it again because I'm not good at remembering what to
01:48:19.460 mention. So I also have started a sub stack newsletter, which is free. And I consider it
01:48:26.660 a companion to this podcast. So it's not like I post a podcast and then I do a sub stack about
01:48:31.360 the same person. I've been sharing some of my other writing on the sub stack about people who
01:48:35.900 I haven't talked about on the podcast before and who I don't know if I ever will talk about on the
01:48:40.460 podcast, but they're people who I have researched in the past. And currently I'm doing the wives
01:48:46.000 of Henry VIII. So in a series called Tudor, I hardly knew her. And this week on the sub stack,
01:48:54.640 I'm talking about Catherine Howard, which is like, she's maybe my favorite of the wives just 0.84
01:49:01.540 because she's kind of the most scandalous and also kind of the most trashy. And that's the 1.00
01:49:07.540 sort of person I like best, but it's also one of the saddest stories. Anyway, if you want to follow
01:49:12.720 that, which again is free and which again is optional, it's really running parallel to the
01:49:20.500 podcast you know like it's called vulgar history a la carte but it's telling different stories than
01:49:25.140 what i'm doing on the podcast and it's because in this kind of um post twitter world you know
01:49:31.620 i'm just trying to figure out what makes sense for me and what what sort of online presence
01:49:38.780 just feels the most comfortable and natural and i've i was a writer before i was a podcaster
01:49:43.420 and i really like sharing my writing and i like doing writing and so yeah anyway it's vulgar
01:49:50.400 history.substack.com, but there is a little link in the show notes for that as well. If you also
01:49:56.980 want to keep up with me and what I'm doing, and if you're just like, I need more and foster voice
01:50:01.600 in my ears, there's all kinds of bonus episodes on Patreon. So that's where you can get early
01:50:07.220 ad free access to all of the episodes, um, you know, upcoming episodes and also past episodes.
01:50:12.800 So if you pledge at least $1 a month, you get the early ad free access and you don't have to
01:50:17.180 listen to that on patreon there's you can once you subscribe there you can hook that up to your
01:50:21.980 spotify or to apple podcasts or wherever you're listening to your podcast so you can get that ad
01:50:27.120 free early access that's for one dollar or more a month if you pledge at least five dollars or more
01:50:33.420 a month you also get the bonus episodes which is vulgar peace theater which is where i talk about
01:50:38.180 costume dramas with people you know from the podcast alison epstein and lana wood johnson
01:50:44.840 the most recent episode was a little contentious. We talked about a movie called
01:50:50.480 The Brotherhood of the Wolf, which I chose. And anyway, Alison and Lana thought differently
01:50:59.580 about it from me. And we had a whole conversation. Those episodes are all like three hours long. So
01:51:04.220 if you really want to have some more Ann Foster voice in your ears, that's where you can.
01:51:07.920 So pledge at least five dollars or more, five dollars or more on Patreon to get access to
01:51:13.300 vulgar peace theater or if you just want to listen to it to that episode you can always just purchase
01:51:17.980 the newest episodes of vulgar peace theater on patreon as well for just five dollars and you 0.97
01:51:22.200 have it then you own it um also on patreon recently i did um so this asshole john knox
01:51:28.520 which is an hour and 15 minutes of me trying to be as fair as i possibly can about john knox
01:51:35.800 and i read a whole biography about him i have i've learned lots of things about him it includes
01:51:42.140 the beard origin story which is actually kind of interesting when he how he decided to grow an
01:51:47.620 incredibly long beard and it's because he's in cosplay as his favorite preacher um anyway if
01:51:53.820 you want to listen to that that's also available for the five dollars a month on patreon or you
01:51:58.380 can just buy it for five dollars on patreon and i will also mention our brand partner common era
01:52:06.260 jewelry so this is a hundred percent woman-owned business who makes beautiful pieces of jewelry
01:52:12.660 with women from history and or mythology on them so this is uh this includes some people
01:52:19.560 we've talked about on the podcast some people who we're going to be talking about on the podcast
01:52:24.180 um in fact one of the people that you can get on a necklace is a person we'll be talking about
01:52:31.060 next week on the podcast so people we've talked about before she has got beautiful pieces the
01:52:35.860 Boudica, Cleopatra, Agrippina. There's a beautiful Anne Boleyn necklace. I have that one. There's
01:52:41.000 also some mythology like Medusa. I bought that one as well. Sappho, lots of different people.
01:52:48.220 And also you could just look at her website, the Difficult Women Collection and try to guess who
01:52:52.240 next week's subject is going to be for. She's on a necklace that I, after I researched this person,
01:52:57.700 I also bought that necklace because I became obsessed. Anyway, so if you want to get 15%
01:53:04.020 off of a purchase from Common Era, go to commonera.com slash vulgar and or use code vulgar
01:53:12.500 at checkout. That's 15% off anything from Common Era at commonera.com slash vulgar or use code
01:53:19.960 vulgar at checkout. If you want to buy Vulgar History merchandise, that's at vulgarhistory.com
01:53:25.860 slash store. That's best for Americans. Actually recently, I just, oh no, I'll tell you. And if 1.00
01:53:32.720 you're outside the U S the more international friendly shop with better shipping is vulgar
01:53:37.440 history.redbubble.com. And I recently just added a classic design back to the collection, because
01:53:44.000 if you are following the latest British Royal family drama, or if you just follow the British
01:53:50.520 Royal family in general, or if you just like excellence on Tik TOK, um, you might know Amanda
01:53:56.080 Mata. She does Mata of Fact is her name on TikTok. And she does really smart, really like 1.00
01:54:02.700 intersectional feminist discussions of what's going on with the royal family, which lately has
01:54:07.840 been absolute chaos. Anyway, she's also a friend of the podcast. And one of her recent TikToks,
01:54:13.040 she was wearing one of our older merch designs, which is the Masarinettes, which was sort of an
01:54:18.340 astrology inspired design that I put out the week, the five weeks we were doing the Hortense
01:54:24.620 Mancini episodes. Anyway, because Amanda wore that, I was like, that was a good design. And also
01:54:29.820 because maybe you want to dress like her. I relaunched that design. And so it's back in
01:54:34.820 both of the merch stores. If you want to get the Mazarinettes. And also speaking of, you know what,
01:54:40.280 not even my merch store, but somebody else's merch store. There's a thing that I say on this podcast
01:54:45.520 that I started saying uncontrollably, because what I do is I listen to, I listen to all kinds
01:54:50.440 of different podcasts including the double love the svh sweet valley high podcast which is hosted
01:54:57.340 by two amazing um women in ireland and they are the ones who started saying herman my pills and
01:55:05.320 then i had been binging the whole all their episodes and i started i didn't start talking
01:55:09.860 with an irish accent although i was close to it there was an episode of this podcast where i used
01:55:14.360 the word lads um but they just said herman my pills and it's a thing that they say when it
01:55:20.440 you know just when somebody's being shocked by something scandalous that somebody is doing
01:55:24.960 they started saying it so i started saying it on this podcast because when you listen to enough
01:55:30.600 episodes of a podcast you kind of start thinking in their words anyway it's a thing that i started
01:55:35.460 saying inspired by them and they the double love podcast they've just put out some new merch
01:55:40.220 including a sticker that says Herman, my pills. And so I have to give a plug to there.
01:55:46.120 They have a red bubble store as well, which is at, um, I think it's just double love pod
01:55:52.060 dot red bubble.com, but I'll put a link to the Herman, my pill sticker for sure in the show
01:55:56.380 notes, because I know I've ordered one. And also you can get in touch with me. I mentioned that
01:56:01.960 this episode's topic was suggested by Javi who heard my plea for suggestions of people from
01:56:09.140 different countries in the world. If you have a suggestion of a person that you'd like to see
01:56:12.840 on the podcast or any other things you want to share with me, there's a form to contact me at
01:56:18.480 vulgarhistory.com. You can also email me at vulgarhistorypod at gmail.com. I'm also on
01:56:23.460 Instagram at vulgarhistorypod, where you can also send me a DM if you want. Transcripts of recent
01:56:30.300 episodes are available at vulgarhistory.com. Thank you to Aveline Malik for providing these
01:56:35.040 transcripts. And finally, next week, we'll be back with one of the women from the Common Era
01:56:41.000 Difficult Women collection. It's going to be a long episode. It's one of my favorite episodes
01:56:48.960 because it features one of my favorite returning guests. Anyway, so stay tuned for that next week.
01:56:56.320 It's going to be a super special extra long episode, much like this was a super special
01:57:00.860 extra long, extra. Anyway, until next time, my friends, keep your pants on and your tits out. 1.00
01:57:09.100 Vulgar History is hosted, written, and researched by Anne Foster and edited by Christina Lumagi. 0.98
01:57:23.200 Legendary stories, awe-inspiring sound, and endless adventure. Welcome to the
01:57:30.840 realms of peril and glory explore the mechanically magical vistas of vale
01:57:41.080 the paranormal mysteries of liminal london and the cyberpunk chaos of cyborg
01:57:52.760 fall in love with our core cast or be awed by our incredible guests from familiar shows like
01:58:00.040 Tickox Venture, Three Black Halflings, and No Rolls Barred.
01:58:06.300 Ignite your imagination and discover the Realms of Peril and Glory today.
01:58:11.820 Go to RealmsPod.com or search Realms of Peril and Glory wherever you listen to podcasts.
01:58:18.960 Do you love Disney? Do you love Top Ten lists?
01:58:25.380 Then you're going to love our podcast, Disney Countdown.
01:58:27.960 Hi, I'm Megan the Magical Millennial.
01:58:30.040 And Biscuits, I'm Jeremy, a.k.a. Jarendel, and we are the hosts of the hit Disney podcast, Disney Countdown.
01:58:36.100 On every episode of our fun and family-friendly show, we count down our top ten lists of all things Disney.
01:58:41.720 The parks, the movies, the music, the food, the lore.
01:58:46.080 There is nothing we don't cover on our show. Right, Jeremy?
01:58:48.960 Ooh, girl, you know we are famous for rabbit holes, Disney-themed games, and fun facts you didn't know you needed, but you definitely need in your life.
01:58:56.040 So if you are looking for a healthy dose of Disney magic, check out Disney Countdown wherever you get your podcasts.
01:59:02.640 You've watched them from the outside your whole life.
01:59:05.760 On TV, on stage, on the cover.
01:59:08.260 The success that always looks like it happened to someone on a different planet.
01:59:12.660 But what if it didn't?
01:59:14.340 I'm Evelyn, and I've spent over 25 years in entertainment, producing for some of the biggest names in Hollywood.
01:59:20.060 And here's what I learned.
01:59:21.100 The distance between you and them, it's a lot shorter than anyone's letting on.
01:59:26.040 On my podcast, Reppin', I sit down with the people you've been watching and I ask them
01:59:31.020 who they actually are, not the brand, the person, where they started, what it costs
01:59:36.840 them, what almost broke them, their grit, their courage, their resilience, and the lessons
01:59:42.960 they've learned.
01:59:43.860 It's all yours for the taking.
01:59:46.840 Reppin', wherever you listen.